Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

GameMakers

GameMakers artwork

So This Is How The Metaverse Dies

Jun 23, 202650 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Here’s the top of the Fortnite metaverse, as of June 20, 2026, during a Saturday night at around 8 pm EDT: (Source: fortnite.gg) #1. Battle Royale: 549.3k concurrent players. #2. A battle royale variant: 97.7k #3. Another battle royale variant: 43.7k #4. A Star Wars idle tycoon: 24.1k #5. Yet another battle royale variant: 21.1k #6. An arena shooter: 20.9k #7. LEGO Fortnite Odyssey: 17.2k #8. A brainrot tycoon: 16.8k #9. Another brainrot tycoon: 12.3k. #10. Save the World, the original co-op PvE mode that Fortnite started out as: 12.1k. #11. An arena shooter: 11.4k. #12. Another arena shooter: 11.3k. Combined, Epic’s own non-battle-royale games - LEGO Fortnite Odyssey and Save the World - reach only 55% of the idle tycoons’ combined playerbase. Battle Royale and its variants make up 85% of the top 12’s playerbase. Worth noting: Fortnite’s all-time concurrent peak was 14,343,880 players - recorded just 1.6 years ago. Current concurrent sits at 1,210,150. The platform that was supposed to become the metaverse is now running at 8.4% of its peak engagement. If this doesn’t seem like a metaverse to you… that’s because it isn’t. But this is what the Fortnite metaverse looks like in practice. This isn’t a discovery problem. It isn’t a tooling problem. And while the economics make it worse - as we’ll see - they aren’t the root either. It’s an audience problem. And that problem was decided before UEFN - Epic’s Unreal Editor for Fortnite - ever launched. Before the first island was built, before the first creator-economy policy was written, before the first developer saw a revenue-share agreement. What Epic is learning, slowly and expensively, is the most important lesson in platform strategy: You can’t turn a game into a platform just by adding tools. You can only build a platform if your players arrive wanting one. I. The Wrong Kind of Crowd Every platform that works - Roblox, Minecraft, Steam - has something in common that has nothing to do with technology or funding. Their users arrive to browse. Not because a single flagship game pulled them in. They arrive with exploration as their default mode. The platform is the product. Whatever they discover inside it is secondary. This is not how Fortnite’s audience works. Think of it like a shopping mall. (A modern one, not the social hubs that they used to be at their peak.) Epic built the most popular anchor store in the city - Fortnite Battle Royale, the store everyone comes for. Then they built out the rest: Rocket Racing in one unit, Festival in another, Ballistic down the corridor. The assumption was that foot traffic from the anchor would spill over. But people who come to this mall don’t come to browse. They come for the anchor store. They walk in, go straight to it, and leave the mall after they’re done playing. People don’t say “I’m going to browse Fortnite.” They say “I’m going to Fortnite Battle Royale.” Roblox isn’t a mall. It’s a bazaar. No anchor store. Players arrive to wander. That wandering is the product. This difference isn’t about quality or investment. It’s about why the person on the other side of the screen opened the game in the first place. And that “why” is the hardest thing in platform-building to change - because it was formed long before you decided to become a platform. Fortnite’s identity was locked in years ago: a battle royale shooter, polished to become one of the most successful games ever made. That identity shaped every player who ever logged in. It shaped what they expected to see, what they were willing to try, and - most importantly - what they would tolerate leaving the main mode for. There’s an obvious objection here: Fortnite’s audience has left battle royale before, in enormous numbers. The Travis Scott concert in 2020 drew 12.3 million concurrent players. Marshmello, Ariana Grande, the live Star Wars trailer premieres - Fortnite has repeatedly marched millions into experiences that aren’t shooters at all. But look at what those experiences share. They’re scheduled. They’re social. They last fifteen minutes. And they ask nothing of you but to show up and watch. They are the opposite of a destination you browse to. The concerts don’t disprove the thesis - they sharpen it. Fortnite’s audience will leave the main mode for a zero-commitment, time-boxed event, and then walk straight back. What it won’t do is treat the surrounding island as a place worth exploring on its own. An event is a detour. A platform needs players to make the detour the destination - and that is exactly the behavior Fortnite never taught them. The genre numbers on June 20, 2026, tell the story bluntly: Fortnite top 12 experiences: 5 genres. Based on the total concurrent player count of 1,210,150, over 58% of the player base is in Battle Royale and its variants. That means all of the non-battle royale games are fighting for that remaining player base of 499k. Outside the top 12, that’s a playerbase of 372k. Compare this to Roblox: 9 genres. With a concurrent player count of 10,713,176, the top 12 games make up just 32.7% of the playerbase - meaning there’s still 7.2 million players up for grabs outside the top 12. And notice how there’s no real genre dominance. Idle tycoons are popular, but not much more so than anything else. You might object that this comparison is rigged by scale. Roblox has 10.7 million concurrent players to Fortnite’s 1.2 million, and a near-two-decade head start on conditioning people to browse. Both are true. But scale is the symptom, not the rebuttal. Roblox didn’t become diverse because it got big - it got big because it was diverse from the start, with no anchor experience large enough to define what “playing Roblox” even meant. Normalize for size, and the shape holds: Fortnite funnels more than half its players into a single genre; Roblox spreads them across eight. Epic has more players than almost anyone else, and still can’t move them three feet to the left. Just imagine any other big-name game doing what Fortnite did, and you’ll quickly see how absurd this experiment was. Would you make shooters in Mario Kart? Play a social sim in Call of Duty? Browse for rhythm games in EA Sports FC? This is the fundamental tension at the heart of UEFN: when your platform is defined by one game, every other experience competes with that game for the same players. And the only way to win that competition is to be just as compelling as the game that brought players in the first place. II. Epic’s Failure to Expand Their Audience Fortnite built stores in their mall that weren’t as nice as the original store - and for an audience that only came for that store, almost nothing else was ever going to be enough. Nintendo players try unfamiliar genres because Nintendo spent decades establishing that anything with its name on it will be exceptional. The quality isn’t a bonus - it’s the mechanism by which trust is stored and withdrawn. Mario Kart succeeds because it is the best kart racer ever made, not because it sits next to Pokémon on a storefront. Valve achieved something even harder. Portal should not have worked. Valve’s audience was a shooter audience. Portal had no competitive multiplayer, no progression systems, no traditional combat - just physics puzzles narrated by a homicidal AI. But Valve shipped it in The Orange Box, which bundled it with Half-Life 2 and Team Fortress 2, forcing it on an audience that hadn’t asked for it. Because the trust was already there, the players followed. Portal became one of the most beloved games ever made not despite coming from a shooter company, but because Valve had banked enough goodwill that audiences were willing to go somewhere unfamiliar. That is what Epic needed from UEFN’s first-party slate. Instead, they produced Rocket Racing, Festival Battle Stage, and Ballistic. Rocket Racing competed against Forza and Rocket League without surpassing either. Festival Battle Stage stripped the fantasy structure that made Guitar Hero compelling and added a broken competitive mode where higher difficulty pla… Get full access to GameMakers at www.gamemakers.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Hey, Ted, thanks for joining. So you wrote a piece claiming that the metaverse is basically dead, not dying, but dead. And so for our audience, I was wondering if you could explain your thesis.

SPEAKER_01Whenever people think about the metaverse, people talk about, oh, meta, basically they renamed their entire company to be meta. basically saying we're focused on the metaverse. And then there's Epic with Fortnite. They try to do this whole transformation, making Fortnite into a metaverse, as they say. But then you kind of look at what's happening. Meta spent 80 billion trying to create a metaverse and no one really uses it.

SPEAKER_01And then Epic and, you know, barely get 25,000 players for their non-Battle Royale games. And to me, that just kind of just doesn't seem like there's really a metaverse. So that's why I made the bold claim that the metaverse is dead, or at least what companies have been trying to make.

SPEAKER_00And I think Tim Sweeney was trying to turn UEFN into the metaverse. But before we go further, I think it'd be useful to try to kind of describe what is the difference between the metaverse and a games platform. And what would you call Roblox as the nearest kind of competitive product to UEFN? So what's the difference and how would you describe Roblox and UEFN today?

SPEAKER_01Sure. So I would say a games platform is just a place where you can play games, a variety of different games and the platform is just a mechanism to deliver games. Meanwhile, what people seem to be calling the metaverse is it's kind of like an interconnected sort of virtual world, which to a certain extent, games platforms are, but there's that whole connected aspect of it. And honestly, in my mind, you can't really make the metaverse right now because

SPEAKER_01the amount of effort and technology that's required to connect all of these different experiences together and make it into one never-ending world. It's just impossible right now. So I think what these companies have been trying to do is, okay, let's start out by creating a games platform because that's the closest thing that we have right now to connect all these experiences.

SPEAKER_00Right. And then to some degree, Oh, sorry, sorry, Ted, just to clarify. So to some degree, what you're saying is like a games platform is basically a place that you can go to to play different games. And there might be account services, there might be some core services around that. But when you're talking about the metaverse, that that line between games platform to metaverse is one, not well defined, but it would have some level of interconnectedness. And whether that's commerce, whether that's social features, whether that's concerts and things like that, which Fortnite has done before,

SPEAKER_00that additional set of interconnectedness is what you would call the metaverse. But if it's just a place where you play games, that would just be a games platform. Is that how you're understanding it, Ted?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's correct.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01And to go back to what Roblox is, I would still kind of consider it a games platform right now and not really a metaverse.

SPEAKER_00And what would it take to get it to become a metaverse?

SPEAKER_01I think it's mostly just a level of connection, which is people or players just jump naturally between experience and to experience and then kind of use that as I don't want to say this because but it's essentially a second life you know which actually exists and is pitched as a metaverse and I think it's kind of just like the next level which is we don't just think of it as just like oh I'm just here to play

SPEAKER_01a certain game or a handful of games I actually just play like I do this for all my social interactions or virtual experiences.

SPEAKER_00Right. And that's sort of the kind of experience that Meta was going for, right? So to the point that you're talking about where it's almost like a virtual world that you would kind of exist and almost live in separate from the physical world would be another kind of vision of what the metaverse is. Although I think that it's been very difficult for Meta to pull off that vision.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_00Would you agree with that, Ted?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, for sure.

SPEAKER_00Okay. And so going back to the post that you wrote, because I thought it was quite interesting and a topic worthy of discussion, your last line in your post is, so this is how the metaverse dies with Star Wars tycoons. I actually love that line. So what exactly died and why is it important? Why does it matter? And what got you up to want to write about this topic?

SPEAKER_01I would say it's kind of like this kind of iteration of... the metaverse I think is kind of epic and meta have got proof that like the way that they've been trying to build out the metaverse it just doesn't work and the way I see it is okay what's the most popular games on Fortnite it's Battle Royale and then a Star Wars tycoon right and I just don't see that as a metaverse. It's just so far away from what they've been pitching as the metaverse.

SPEAKER_01When they first came out, they were just like, oh, look at all the different games that are on Fortnite now. It's like, oh, you can race your cars or play in a band or do all these different things. But when you actually look at the numbers, it's just, oh, people are just playing Battle Royale and playing these idle tycoons.

SPEAKER_00Right. And for our audience and for old guys like me, because I'm not in Roblox, I'm not in UFN very much, but I thought that was also quite interesting where, to your point, the vision of what was kind of marketed to the public, which was this expansive vision of commerce, of all these different kinds of social experiences, of a second world, if you believe in the meta vision. But what we actually got was these brain rot tycoons.

SPEAKER_00And so for our audience, and for me too, Could you explain, what is this thing that's actually taking the place of the metaverse in UAFN and in Roblox? What is a brain rot tycoon?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, sure. So I'll kind of start out by explaining what the tycoon is. Specifically, it's an idle tycoon. And basically, these are kind of just simple games where your whole entire purpose is gaining money and then using that money to get these Objects that generate more money and then the kind of goal is just keep making money and what we've seen now is brain rot characters have become super popular in Roblox

SPEAKER_01and Fortnite and basically what they are are just AI generated weird characters creatures and they've kind of just tied those together like just mashed those together so now you got an idol tycoon and then You got brain rods and now you got kind of almost have like the perfect sort of engagement platform where all these, you just get all these kids because they love brain rod characters. And then because these idle tycoons are just naturally addictive.

SPEAKER_01You just kind of just wait around and just wait until you can spend more money to make more money. And you can actually see like all these idle tycoons just have crazy engagement numbers and retention. So they promised us the metaverse, but instead we got Braidrot Tycoon.

SPEAKER_00And so many people who analyze these platforms and UEFN in particular have blamed a number of things on why they haven't been as successful. So bad discovery, bad tooling, not enough rev share. And you say that maybe you agree or disagree with that and it'd be good to hear what you think about that. But I think the argument that you make in your post is that's the wrong way to think about it.

SPEAKER_00So could you explain your reasoning and your rationale for why UFN in particular has not been able to achieve the success that they had hoped for?

SPEAKER_01All these things are good. And if you want to keep having your developers develop games, these become important, like making sure that they can generate enough income so that they can continue making games. But the problem is it's There's kind of like the root of the issue, which is you need kind of like the audience and player base that's actually willing to play all these different games. And so the problem that with UEFN is it's just so tied with Battle Royale.

SPEAKER_01And this is kind of like, this isn't necessarily unique to just Knight. You could actually try to do the same thing with any kind of popular game. So if you connected with FIFA and say, oh, we're making FIFA into the metaverse or like Call of Duty to metaverse. It's still just people play FIFA just for FIFA. They want to play football slash soccer and Call of Duty. They just want to go and play Call of Duty.

SPEAKER_00And sorry to, but maybe I could get you to expand on that a little bit, because I think one of the analogies that you made in your post is this comparison where you're saying Fortnite is a mall, Roblox is a bazaar. I think that kind of connects to what you're talking about. So could you explain that concept for our audience?

SPEAKER_01Yes. So this is the first one I'd clarify. I kind of realized that back in the old days, malls were kind of like a social hub where you just kind of like walk around and check out different stores. But When I say mall, I'm kind of thinking about the post-COVID world. To be honest, no one really goes to a mall unless you have something specifically you want to buy. Oh, there's some shirt that some store in a mall has, and I'm just going to go and buy that shirt. But then I'm not really there to just hang out and check out stuff.

SPEAKER_01I'm just going to go back in. And so for me, it's like Fortnite is a mall where, okay, they built out Battle Royale. It's a, it's don't get me wrong. It's a good store. Like a lot of people are playing it, but people are just there to go to that store. And then you still have all these different stores and you have festival and you have rocket racing, ballistic and whatever, but you kind of see no one's really trying to go to the stores and The difference with that and Robux is kind of more bizarre.

SPEAKER_01You're kind of there to, you don't necessarily have something that you're looking to purchase. You're just kind of there to just check out what's available and then you might go and see something interesting and then, oh, let me go. Kind of look at that, talk with the owner and whatnot, see what they have to offer. That's kind of what I wanted to kind of convey is the difference.

SPEAKER_00So I think there's kind of two interesting kind of points or theses that you had presented in your paper, which is one, the whole vision of a metaverse, we didn't quite get there. Instead, we have kind of a games platform, but even within a games platform, Fortnite is a mall. Roblox is a bazaar. They've been able to drive players more meaningfully towards other genres. And so Could you expand a little bit more into why you think that difference exists between

SPEAKER_00the ability for Roblox to potentially have more success in UEFN and to the point that you've already made, like it does seem people are going there for Fortnite, for Battle Royale. Maybe you could help characterize or help the audience understand, me too, to understand why is it that they have not been as successful as Roblox in terms of even as a games platform?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think it kind of stems from when you're building out a platform, you don't want any one game to sort of kind of take over, right? Because then you don't really have anyone left for like the other games on your platform. And so what I do remember, there's a quote in my article that comes from one of the guys at Roblox. And he basically just said, it was really tempting to try and build out a game. Minecraft was coming out and being popular. Temptation was there to build something like Minecraft to try and get people into the ecosystem.

SPEAKER_01But they kind of decided not to go with that. And I think Fortnite kind of proves why that's like, that was the correct decision. And so you see, okay, we've Yeah it makes sense from like a business perspective why you would kind of do that but now you're kind of seeing why this is a problem which is you built up this audience with expectations they just want to play battle royale and they've kind of dedicated their whole lives to battle royale so like Any hour that you spend outside of Battle Royale,

SPEAKER_01it's an hour you're not spending in Battle Royale. So now there's a sort of tension between the player and the platform, which is, do I want to engage more with the platform or do I want to keep playing this game?

SPEAKER_00Right. And maybe to push back on you a little bit, Ted, is basically one kind of data point that I thought was always interesting, which was the Travis Scott virtual concert inside of Fortnite, which was able to draw 12 million concurrent players. And so to some degree, when we talked about the metaverse being a more interconnected space, a space where people can share something, that was one example of potentially a metaverse type of experience.

SPEAKER_00And in terms of the, on the platform level, one example where there was kind of a popular experience that's not Battle Royale, And so how would you explain this or what do you think was going on with the Travis Scott sort of virtual concert experience that kind of defied the current inability of UEFN to turn into a metaverse and turn into a platform?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I'm Yeah, obviously it's a lot of people that watch this concert, myself included. I think actually the first time I downloaded Fortnite was because of the Travis concert, which is funny. But the thing I think is with sort of like these concert experiences is they're kind of low commitment. So you kind of watch this for 10 minutes and then you can kind of go back to doing whatever. and so it's it was almost kind of like a red herring they made this cool thing and it was enough to get people people playing Battle Royale to go check it out but

SPEAKER_01then you may watch it once or twice maybe even five times but you can't just keep watching it forever right so you end up right

SPEAKER_00so you're saying it was more of a novelty and maybe the draw was more Travis Scott than the actual experience or that kind of model itself yeah what you're saying okay And maybe one other question I could ask you is along the lines of, well, so I'd like to kind of hear your thoughts in terms of where do you think the potential opportunity that still exists? So one, do you think UFN is completely dead? Fortnite has changed identity before, right?

SPEAKER_00They were saved the world, then they pivoted over to Battle Royale. And if you look at Roblox, it just took them a really long time, nearly two decades to build Stank Joseph Kim k1min8r GameMakers

SPEAKER_01I think my main issue with where UEFN is right now is if they want to keep doing what they're doing right now it's honestly very difficult and that's because you basically need to just keep making good games which nowadays has just become so difficult and you have to kind of use that as a way, like a jumping off point to be like, okay, well, we got people,

SPEAKER_01we made these games that are interesting enough that, you know, even battle people came in and checked it out and maybe are just playing it now. And like you have like new audiences that have come in and, you know, now we have that player base that we can, that developers can cater to. Yeah. And honestly, I kind of see that's the only way to do it in its current state. Because it's just the problem is the pool of Battle Royale is just so difficult.

SPEAKER_01And I don't think any third-party developers are going to figure out like, oh, how do I get people off of Battle Royale? Because Epic's pouring so much of their resources into Battle Royale. It's like, how do you really compete with that?

SPEAKER_00Maybe we could shift gears a little bit here. We've kind of talked about, you know, the platform UFN on a high level. So I was thinking we can now go into a little bit more of the specifics and starting with like the first party slate. So you've got Rocket Racing, Festival Ballistic. What do you think of that slate and why are those things not as popular, right? Nintendo certainly does a great job with their first party slate and is very popular. What's missing?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. To me, they just kind of feel like MVPs. They kind of just threw them out there just as a proof, oh, we have different games now on our platform. But there's nothing that they really do particularly well or that makes them unique. Rocky Racing is literally just a generic racing game. That festival is just, it's like Guitar Hero or Rock Band, but without the coolness of those games. Ballistics literally just Counter-Strike or Valorant, but

SPEAKER_01They didn't really do anything other than, oh, you can play as Bugs Bunny or something like that. And when you're thinking about, oh, okay, when we're making a game, nowadays, you kind of have to either do something really well, better than what your competition does, which is actually, funnily enough, that's kind of what Fortnite did with Battle Royale is. They had PUBG and was a popular game, but it was paid and there's bugs and it was hard to get into. So then Fortnite just decided to come in and it was just like,

SPEAKER_01all right, let's just do our kind of take on Battle Royale. And then it turns out when you make your game free and you have interesting mechanics like building stuff, you can potentially start a cultural revolution with your game. And so there hasn't really just been that sort of moment with these other games. There's nothing that gets people from Forza to play Rocket Racing. Now there's a clone hero for a festival where they didn't get any of the Counter-Strike and Valorant players to play Ballistic.

SPEAKER_01So that's a key ingredient that's missing.

SPEAKER_00Right. But from a first party perspective, when we think of other companies with platforms like Valve with Steam, for example, and Valve was able to make a number of games across different genres, right? Portal being an example with no combat, no multiplayer, no progression, but it became a fairly beloved game. Why did that work for Valve if you were to hypothesize or speculate, whereas with Epic, it seems like it's kind of like Fortnite. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so like you said, Portal's one of the most beloved games. And it's just, you can play it even today and you'll still be like, oh, well, like going through portals is just so cool and so novel. But I think One of the differences is it's not like you had to download Half-Life to play Portal. It was packaged together, but it's not like one was going to rely on the other. So you can kind of get that sort of curiosity from the Half-Life players.

SPEAKER_01Oh, they just finished Half-Life. Let me check out this other little game that came with my bundle. And then once that kind of... happened. It was kind of like a snowballing effect where people were telling each other, it's like, oh, you got to check out this game. And it's even a good game for people that don't like Half-Life or don't like shooters. They were able to kind of get a new audience from that. And then kind of after doing that for a little bit longer, they were kind of able to cultivate this audience on Steam

SPEAKER_01where they're not necessarily tied to one particular game, although Certainly there are people that just play Dota all the time or Counter-Strike, but there's just kind of an audience there that's willing to go check out new games. And even if you're not into the shooters or games that Valve has made, there's still a bunch of other interesting games for you to play.

SPEAKER_00It is interesting how some companies are able to make successful products across different genres and have multiple hits, whereas some other companies aren't as successful. probably a bigger question for another podcast. But another thing that you talk about is the 40% engagement payout. And so I was wondering if you could talk about, what is that? Talk about payouts and maybe you could also compare the payouts of Roblox relative to Fortnite.

SPEAKER_00And how do you, you're an independent developer, how do you view that value of developing on UEFN versus Roblox?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so basically how the engagement payout works is So whatever purchases from the item shop that they have, all the skins and all of the cars and whatnot, so 40% of that is reserved to be able to pay out to the third-party developers. And the way they calculate that is it's based on engagement. So if your game gets more users, then you'll basically get more from that payout than the other games.

SPEAKER_01So to some degree, the algorithm is what's driving you. Yeah. And we'll probably get into this later, but the difference with that and Roblox is sort of more, is based around in-app purchases. So if someone buys something within your game, then you, yeah, I believe it's 20%, you end up getting 20% of a cut from that.

SPEAKER_00So it's a different model essentially. It's engagement versus transactions,

SPEAKER_01essentially, is the difference in the models between the two platforms.

SPEAKER_00Something that was very interesting was K-pop Demon Hunters. I'm as surprised as anyone popular that was on Netflix. I think one of the most successful shows ever. 537 million people, I think, was the statistic I read about how many people watched it, but the Fortnite islands built around it are basically empty. So how would you attribute that? Why have they not been able to be as popular?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So the main thing is it kind of starts from the developers. And so like you go as a developer, you kind of like think about, okay, I'm going to make something for UFN. What am I going to do? And because of the engagement model, you kind of go, okay, I don't want to make something super crazy or Super risky. So I'm going to just do what I've seen gets engagement and naturally that's just idle tycoons or little arena shooters or whatnot.

SPEAKER_01And then, so then you're like, okay, I got to make it kind of unique. Let me try throwing like K-pop demon hunters onto it. And then the Battle Royale people like kind of, maybe they do like K-pop demon hunters. So they kind of like go, go check it out. And then, but then they say, oh, it's just Idol Tekkens and like little shooters. So then they're like, okay, I'll try it for five minutes and then bounce. But then you have the actual, the larger K-pop Demon Hunter fan base. And that's a whole different audience, right? I believe it's a majority female, but then so you can kind of imagine like a female with one

SPEAKER_01if they're not already in Fortnite they would have to download like a 50 gigabyte game just to try out like these islands but then they get to the island and they're like oh it's just like an idle tycoon like no one's made like a cool like action arpeggio or something like that so then you're like all right I guess I'll just bounce

SPEAKER_00from what has been delivered may not be what players are looking for, and there could be something of an audience mismatch, especially to the point that you're making if a lot of the audience for K-pop Demon Hunter is female. So maybe we could now talk about some of the stuff that is working. You mentioned Star Wars made with Disney's Blessing. pretty big budgets, professional studios, and I think it had something like 26,000 players. Could you talk more about, what does that tell us about UEFN and what is actually working on them?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so like before, it just seems like whatever's made to maximize engagement gets all the players. Right now, it just seems to be idle tycoons. So now we have an officially sanctioned Star Wars idle tycoon. And don't get me wrong, it's actually very well designed and very, very polished. But if that's kind of the best that UFN has to offer,

SPEAKER_01then it's kind of a little like, all right. It just seems so far from what they're kind of promising with the metaphors.

SPEAKER_00So maybe we can go into a little bit more depth on that. To some degree, could you say, is that working then? Or like, maybe we didn't get the metaverse, but maybe we got a platform for idle tycoons. Would you consider that to be some kind of success on UEFN? Just not what Epic had imagined as being what would be successful on their platforms. And idle tycoons are also successful on Roblox as well. Maybe you could go into a little bit more depth on that.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I think it just kind of proves that, yeah, you kind of have no offense to idle Tekken. I used to work on an idle Tekken back in the day, but it is kind of more like easier to make than most games. And it just kind of proves, okay, people are still making games, but they're just kind of making the lower effort sort of games. Yeah, not seeing like a a Mario Kart or some other big God of War type game.

SPEAKER_01We just have idle tycoons. I guess it's fine, but if you think about how from a developer and player's perspective, it's not the most enticing way to get someone to develop for their platform or explore their platform.

SPEAKER_00Right, so kind of like one of the arguments you're making is, and we talked about this before, but one, they're easy to make, and two, the platforms are kind of optimized for those kinds of games that have that much engagement. But would you consider that maybe a problem also for Roblox, where if you optimize for that, if these idle tycoons are easy to make, that any game platform that does that would have idle tycoons as being the number one

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it kind of goes for all platforms. Roblox, yeah, has idle tech games. The mobile app store, there's tons of idle tech games. Like Steam too, there's a bunch of idle tech games. Literally one of the most popular games is a banana clicker, where you just click a banana and then numbers go up. But I think... The main difference is you see those idle tokens, but on Roblox, you don't just see idle tokens, like sort of like social life simulators, shooters, fighters.

SPEAKER_01There's still like a variety of games. Sure, they might be using sort of the idle mechanics, but it's still generally kind of like a more healthier sort of ecosystem.

SPEAKER_00And I like to actually go back and revisit this notion of the metaverse Back in 2020, I had an opportunity to interview Tim Sweeney, and one of the things that he told me is that nobody knows exactly what the metaverse will be six years later today. What do you think we know now? Are you of the opinion that it's just a dead concept, or how are you thinking about it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think just the way that these companies have sort of packaged the metaverse, I think it's just, at least in that sense, it's not what people are looking for. Yeah, there's Roblox and Minecraft, but other than that, all the other kind of attempts have failed. And so unless there's something you can provide more than what Roblox and Minecraft provides, I don't think there's really any significant sort of evolution of the metaverse.

SPEAKER_00Maybe in Tim Sweeney's defense, because I do think that Part of the way that I believe in, you know, I don't know Tim Sweeney, I just did that one interview with him and have heard him speak on occasion, but it does seem that one of the things that he thinks about are kind of like the environmental, the environment, like an ecosystem, developer ecosystems and things like that. And I think that one of the reasons why he was so focused on the metaverse is because he felt like if this concept of the metaverse took off, then you would have essentially

SPEAKER_00the ability for a single company to kind of control the metaverse and own all of the commercial aspects of what that thing was. And so while the metaverse itself did not kind of come into fruition as he probably had intended, and I know he was very serious about this because I had heard from some Epic employees shortly after 2020 that any initiative at Epic had to be related to the metaverse or it was not greenlit. Today, To your point, UEFN is kind of dominated by a single game.

SPEAKER_00So single game instead of a single company. And so do we have this kind of... And you kind of talked about it, but it does seem like there is this ecosystem problem within UEFN as well. Is that solvable?

SPEAKER_01It's... I think just the way it is right now is really difficult because yeah as we were talking about just Battle Royale just takes over so much of players time and interest that trying to get people to move away from that it's just I almost I'm not even sure that's really a solvable problem if you look at the numbers it's literally kind of like 50% of the 1 million of concurrent Fortnite players are there for Battle Royale

SPEAKER_01and now everyone else is kind of fighting for that other half and it's still kind of just like a small pocket if you compare it out to Roblox it's okay 450k players versus Roblox is what I think it's six six million if not six million it's like 9.44 million Roblox players okay and yeah it just kind of comes down to were you able to kind of build out this bigger audience.

SPEAKER_01So everyone kind of gets a nice share of the pie. Or is it still, I know you have good intentions, but your game is kind of just taking away all that opportunity. So from a developer's perspective, it's even worth it for me to even try like getting into your ecosystem.

SPEAKER_00Going back to 2020, one of the other things that Tim Sweeney did is he was very critical about Roblox only paying creators 20%. He also very famously fought the war for us, and that's something I'm very appreciative of him and Epic for doing, is fighting the 30% platform fees, for example. But to a developer, how much does it matter what the payout is relative to the size of the audience? Because Roblox will offer developers 6.6 million browsable players, UFN less than half a million.

SPEAKER_00So you as an independent developer, what matters more, the revenue split or just the size of the audience?

SPEAKER_01I'd say the size of the audience matters because you only kind of get the benefits of the better payout if the audience is big enough for it. I don't want to be like, I mean I'll be straight up it's like okay if I'm getting like even like a hundred percent of zero zero dollars like that's zero dollars like honestly right I will say yeah I will say to Tim's credit you know like he as far

SPEAKER_01as like you know in-app purchase monetization goes and like rev share when it comes to like you know Epic Game Store like he's doing the right thing like I see like okay if I'm gonna get like 100% of in-app purchase revenue, that does get my attention. But then when you look at the player base and you're like, oh man, I've got to compete against Battle, Royale, and Idle Tycoons, then it becomes like,

SPEAKER_01okay, is it really worth the risk for me to put in all this effort? just for a smaller piece of pie versus maybe I'll risk it on Roblox or Steam or any of the other platforms available.

SPEAKER_00And it's not just Epic. It's not just Tim Sweeney who had a strong belief in the potential for whether it's a games platform or a metaverse. Disney, for example, invested $1.5 billion into Epic as an equity stake explicitly to build games and entertainment universe on top of Fortnite. That was two years ago. And the main project is still not out. And what do you think? Will Disney's involvement, does that help?

SPEAKER_00Does that potentially help fix some of the audience problem? Or to the point that we talked about earlier related to K-pop Demon Hunters, is Disney just going to make an even bigger mistake than the sort of K-pop Demon Hunters example I have to kind of say that because good luck

SPEAKER_01because that's a lot of money that you're dealing with and yeah I think as we talked about before it's very easy for this to just become another K-pop Demon Hunters mistake where you have you made all these games but you don't get the Battle Royale people to go check it out you don't get Disney adults to go download and check it out if You really have to just make sure that your game is able to do that.

SPEAKER_01Otherwise, there's a lot of money to flush out the toilet, honestly.

SPEAKER_00And maybe one other question on this topic, which is when we talked about the different kind of visions of the metaverse, there's also, as of the time of this recording, June 12th, on June 15th, Horizon Worlds will shut down. And so what do you think happened there? Would you draw similarities to UEFN or is there a different reason for the inability of Horizon Worlds to gain a bigger audience and gain more traction?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think audience-wise, it's a little similar. You can kind of say, okay, I don't know off the top of my head how many Quest owners there are, but it's kind of like you already have this existing audience and you're kind of just trying to throw this sort of this platform to them and saying, okay, will you guys check this out? But I think kind of the difference is there wasn't any big sort of like game that was kind of tying, oh, I take that back a little bit. There was already a competitor's VR chat, right?

SPEAKER_01That has already kind of grabbed everyone's attention and they kind of didn't really do a good job of convincing people, oh, instead of being in VR chat, you should go check out Horizon Worlds. So it's kind of like a, it's a different It still stems from the same issue, but it's a little different where it's not a homegrown problem like with Fortnite. It's more just not understanding what the competition, what competition was out there and how do I actually get people away from that.

SPEAKER_00And now just talking about the future of UFN, in your post, you did lay out kind of two paths forward. And so can you walk us through how you see a potential improvement to UFN in the future? Walk us through your two options.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so the first option is just spin UEFN entirely from Fortnite Battle Royale. Just make it an entirely different game. And that sort of makes sure there's no influence between one and the other. You don't have that problem of, okay, we're just trying to get players from Battle Royale. We're just trying to build up a new audience. And then the second is kind of, honestly, throw in the towel. Just accept, yeah, this is what it is.

SPEAKER_01We just got a bunch of idle techians and we don't have to invest so much money into trying to make it something it's not. And then that just saves you time, resources. You don't have to worry about trying to make these big games to try and get people off of Battle Royale. You can just be like, all right, this is it. There's still kind of opportunities to do interesting things. One thing that we didn't really discuss was, okay, you can kind of use BeFenn as kind of like an incubator to the Epic Game Store.

SPEAKER_01But that still kind of comes off, that comes from spinning off BeFenn, just making its own things that developers have the opportunity to build out their own games and create an audience.

SPEAKER_00Okay. And let's say you were to try to take the other side of the arguments that you laid out in your post. What would UEFN have to show, let's say in the next 12 months or so for you to think, okay, I got it wrong in my essay. What would have to happen?

SPEAKER_01It honestly kind of comes down to player distribution. I'm going to have to I went over the top 12 games of Fortnite and Roblox. You basically need to have the same thing that Roblox has, which is there's no real game that dominates the others. Players are just kind of out there just playing a bunch of different games, and each of these games were able to cultivate an audience that isn't reliant on Battle Royale.

SPEAKER_00Okay. And I think one of the reasons why I thought it was great to talk to you is because you represent an actual data point, an independent developer making real world choices amongst these different platforms, whether it's UFN or Roblox or Steam or Discord activity. And I don't even know what's going on with Discord now. I think they've been retooling all their game stuff over and over again. But maybe walk us through how you think about these different platforms and what would it take How are you thinking about which platform you would want to build for?

SPEAKER_00And how do you actually... I think you have a checklist as well, but maybe you can go through that and walk us through how you think about these different platforms. What would it take to get you to build on one platform versus another?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, finally, you mentioned Discord just because actually back when I was an independent developer, my first game actually was released on the Discord game store. So it's actually a very... It's actually something that I know a lot about, which is Discord kind of came in. They're like, hey, bring us your games. We have such a big audience, right? I don't remember what the number is, but you can just imagine all the Discord users. But then the problem that happened,

SPEAKER_01which to be honest, one, they probably shouldn't have won with our game as a Discord exclusive, but two, you kind of realize that Just because you're a Discord user doesn't necessarily mean you're going to use the Discord game store. If anything, it's actually the same problem that Fortnite is having, which is Discord. Discord users are there to use Discord to talk with their friends and communities and whatnot. They're not necessarily there to buy games. And so I think what I've learned from that whole experience is

SPEAKER_01that understanding what is the actual customer behavior is there kind of proof that some They'll throw all these fancy numbers at you, but is there actual proof that people are willing to check out different games? I think it's just very important. And I can kind of say out of all those, if you're looking at all those platforms that you mentioned, they actually do have good audiences. It's just, you kind of have to For Roblox and Discord specifically, you have to kind of tailor the experience. So Roblox is primarily based off kids,

SPEAKER_01hence why brain rot stuff is popular and also those cutesy lo-fi graphics about being social. And I don't really know what the numbers are on those Discord activities, but I'm sure that's probably doing better than back when I was on the Discord store because who knows?

SPEAKER_00I don't want to... Tangent onto Discord, but I do think from a gameplay experience perspective, I thought the platform that they had is amazing, right? The ability to have, to be able to see all your friends and to play a game together. I thought that the potential for Discord was incredible. It's just, it's not surfaced. I remember playing a game with some folks from Discord who showed me the capabilities, but then I tried to go back and I'm like, okay, let me do that again. I'm like, Where do I even go?

SPEAKER_00I couldn't find him. So I think that might be more of a discovery UX issue. But anyway, that may be another topic for another time. But I did want to ask you one last question before I ask you maybe some questions more about you as well. But I think the biggest thing that's happening right now in not only games, but in society and the world is AI. And so one of the things that we're seeing is the ability to be able

SPEAKER_00to create content very easily. And so you'd have to imagine that with AI, that all of these platforms will get flooded by an enormous deluge of content. And so what do you think happens? How do you think that impacts these platforms? And how are you even thinking about it as an independent developer?

SPEAKER_01Honestly, it's so much more difficult to release a game. It's just the bar, the bar to entry is so low, but being able to succeed is just so high. I honestly think it just comes back to curation. There's just all these players are getting so much content thrown at them and now they're just, they have to kind of naturally become more pickier about what do they spend their time on. And that kind of means the quality bar has to get higher and that's just kind of difficult all around because it's just hard

SPEAKER_01and you understand too it's just so hard to make a good game nowadays right yeah I've been getting my butt kicked

SPEAKER_00for years okay yeah did you have any other thoughts on that sorry

SPEAKER_01and I'll be honest it's I don't especially if I'm thinking about it from a big company perspective I don't know how to really solve that other than either you're gonna have to spend a lot of money or you gotta have figure out how to do things more cheaper. And I'm guessing that's why a lot of these big companies are trying to go with AI and trying to see if they can make things cheaper, but we'll kind of see where it goes. But to end on the note, it's like, you just can't produce slop in a world of infinite slop.

SPEAKER_00Right. You have to distinguish yourself in some way. Okay. So maybe to close the conversation, I'd love to find out a little bit more about you, your story. So for our audience, it'd be great to learn a little bit more about you and also what interested you about this topic? Why did you wind up writing about UAFN, Metaverse, things like that? And yeah, it'd be great to hear more about your personal story.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, sure. Ted Park. I'm a product consultant and former indie game developer. I used to run my own little indie game studio right after I graduated college and one of the Interesting things was our game was like one of the first games on the Discord game store. So yeah, kind of platforms and thinking about what are the benefits of each different platform is just kind of something that stuck with me. This was kind of like a natural extension of that. And I still kind of remember back in,

SPEAKER_01I think it was GDC when they first announced UEFN and they kind of make that big announcement. I had a lot of hype around it. And so this is kind of like an opportunity for me to sort of, oh man, it's been, what, three years since that's happened? So I just, naturally, as I was playing Fortnite, I was like, honestly, I was just playing because I was like, should I make another Battle Pass article? And then I was like, you kind of see next to, while you're playing Battle Royale,

SPEAKER_01it's, oh, there's Brain Rod Tycoon, there's all these different icons. And you're like, huh, okay, that's kind of interesting. What is that actually, though? So I kind of just went down this rabbit hole and this was kind of the result.

SPEAKER_00Okay. And are you fully, did you give up on your dreams of being an independent developer or is that out for you or maybe you could talk about your transition into product consulting?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I'd say it's, it's a little on the back burner. Yeah. Maybe shouldn't have released on the discord game store, but No, no, but the reality is sometimes you make a game and for a variety of reasons it's...

SPEAKER_00But you also released on Steam as well, right? So Discord wasn't the only time.

SPEAKER_01Steam and also consoles. Even with that, sometimes you just don't make a game that's successful, to be frank, but you still have that sort of thought in your mind. Maybe I should get back into it at some point, but I don't... I think you should. I don't... But to be honest, at least right now, I don't think it's going to be on UEF. Unless I get an idea for... What platform would you go for?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So let's say you have an idea. So for you, what would be the platform that you would go for? Would it be Steam? Would it be mobile? Would it be something else? Web, maybe? Because it seems like web is becoming increasingly viable as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. For me, I kind of do value being able to try different things and not be confined by any particular sort of restrictions. So for me, Steam is probably the way to go. But yeah, Web is also an interesting thing to check out. It's pretty much 100% freedom, which has its caveats, but it is a cool idea.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Ted, thanks so much for the post. I thought it was a very interesting topic to explore. and I definitely appreciate your insights and your thoughts on that. And I guess we'll see how UFN does. I'm a fan of Tim Sweeney just because I think that a lot of the things that he's trying to do out of principle rather than just for commercial purposes is something that I think that our industry needs. But we'll see how it goes. And for our audience, we will catch you next time.

SPEAKER_00Thanks so much, Ted. Take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Your Discord Is Lying to You. Watch What Players Build.

    Oct 22, 202654 minAudio

    I like to think about game development as product velocity, and velocity is a vector. It has a magnitude, which is how fast you build, and a direction, which is whether you’re building the right thing. AI is pushing the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. PR for Gaming Studios

    Sep 1, 202651 minAudio

    Kalie Moore ran the prompts across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. What came back turns game discoverability into a PR problem, and she gave me the playbook she uses to fix it. When I ask people in games what PR is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Paradox of AI ROI

    Aug 28, 202659 minAudio

    The story is that AI isn’t paying off, that the ROI just isn’t there, that the org charts and the earnings calls are still waiting for the productivity spike. Harsh Savergaonkar and I are pretty extreme vibe coders....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Most Important Number in Unity’s D2C Launch Is Zero

    Jul 14, 202643 minAudio

    In 2002, Electronic Arts banned ICQ - the office chat app - and put a single internet terminal in the center of the building. A programmer named Steve Ganem responded with what he calls “civil disobedience”: he built...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 🎙️ The Most Valuable Asset in Games Isn't Your Game

    Jun 16, 20261 hr 58 minAudio

    Here’s a contradiction worth sitting with. Earlier this year, Epic Games - the studio that spent five years and north of $100 million breaking the platforms’ 30% tax - quietly cut the value of V-Bucks by 20% to, in its...

    Credit the people on this episode