Here’s a contradiction worth sitting with. Earlier this year, Epic Games - the studio that spent five years and north of $100 million breaking the platforms’ 30% tax - quietly cut the value of V-Bucks by 20% to, in its own words, “pay the bills.” The company that won the fee war still had to raise prices on its own players, amid layoffs, in the same news cycle. The reflex was to call it a betrayal. I think that misses the point entirely. Epic’s fight was real, and every developer benefits from how it ended: Google settled at 20%, Apple cut fees in China, and link-outs are finally on the table. The more useful reaction isn’t outrage - it’s the question almost nobody asked. If the biggest winner in the West, with its own store and its own engine, still can’t escape the squeeze, what chance does anyone else have? The V-Bucks cut was never an Epic story. It was a margin story, and the entire industry is living in it. This piece is about where margin actually comes from once content is infinite and attention is finite - because it isn’t the fee percentage, and it isn’t even distribution the way most studios picture it. It’s the player relationship. And a sprawling, nearly invisible economy of community-run game servers has spent fifteen years quietly proving exactly what that relationship is worth in dollars. To get a real number, I sat down with Liam Wiltshire, GM of Tebex - the company sitting on the most underreported figure in our business. The math is brutal, and it’s first-principles simple On one side of the equation: player attention is finite, and the competition for it isn’t just other games anymore. It’s TikTok, YouTube, Netflix - everything with a screen. I’ve written about attention compression before: players now evaluate a game in roughly 16 seconds. On the other side: supply is exploding. iOS App Store submissions jumped over 60% year-over-year this past December, after three years of basically flat growth. Why? AI is collapsing the cost of building software toward zero. People who couldn’t ship apps are shipping apps, and games are next. Infinite shelf. Finite attention. When supply explodes and attention doesn’t, two things happen mechanically: the cost of acquiring a player goes up, and your pricing power goes down. That’s margin compression. That’s the V-Bucks story, the layoff story, the whole story of the industry right now. So ask the first-principles question: in that world, what’s actually scarce? Not content - AI just made content abundant. The obvious next answer is distribution. But getting on the shelf isn’t distribution. Steam will list you. The App Store will host you. Getting a player to walk down your aisle is distribution, and that’s the most expensive it has ever been. Here’s the move most people miss: a player relationship is distribution. A player who knows you, trusts you, and comes back without being paid to come back - that’s not a brand metric. That’s a distribution channel you own instead of rent. Every other channel - paid UA, store featuring, the algorithm - you rent by the impression, and the rent is going up. The player relationship is the only channel whose cost goes down the stronger it gets. And here’s how you know that’s true: watch what the platforms refuse to give up. They’ll negotiate the percentage. Google lowered its headline fee - then introduced a charge for steering and quietly moved chargeback costs onto developers. Valve is in federal court right now facing a certified class action of some 32,000 developers over rules that stop you from selling your own game cheaper elsewhere; their position is that no such written policy exists, while the emails in evidence suggest otherwise. The platforms will give you margin before they give you the relationship. The login, the payment method, the purchase history - that’s the part they keep, because they’ve understood for fifteen years what most studios are only starting to see. The relationship is the moat. Which is exactly what I wanted to put a number on. Tebex sits on the data to do it. 🎧 Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or Anchor The shadow games industry While everyone argued about percentages, somebody already solved this - not in theory, but in production, at scale, for fifteen years. Just not anywhere the industry press ever looks. There’s a Minecraft server called Hypixel that holds the Guinness World Record for concurrent players and is closing in on year 15. Microsoft doesn’t run it; a community does. There are FiveM role-play servers - the multiplayer layer on top of GTA V - where players have held the same job, in the same city, with the same friends, for years. Thai communities. Portuguese economy servers. German servers. No publisher pays for the hardware. No platform processes the payments. The people who run these worlds own the entire player relationship, and players pay them directly, happily. In a brutal attention economy, these communities have held people for a decade-plus. And the company that built the payment rails underneath this world - a company most people in this industry couldn’t have named six months ago - has processed $1.5 billion in lifetime payments. These days that includes direct-to-consumer for studios you’ve heard of: Rockstar, Take-Two, Hytale, FiveM. So what’s the whole UGC server economy worth? Honest answer: nobody knows. No earnings call reports it. No analyst covers it. The best window anyone has is one company’s books - and through that one window, a billion and a half dollars. The market is big enough that the number should exist, and it doesn’t. That’s how deep in the shadows this thing runs. That company is Tebex. It was started by a 16-year-old named Lee McNeil in his childhood bedroom in Nottingham, England, with £20 - the price of a domain name. (More on that story in a minute, because it’s worth it.) What Minecraft kids know that billion-dollar studios don’t Why should you care what Minecraft kids and GTA roleplayers are doing? Because their data tells you what a real player relationship is worth in dollars. Three numbers from Liam stopped me cold. 1. Trust is worth 50-227% more spend. When a purchase goes through a creator code - a streamer the player actually trusts - average spend jumps from $24 to $41. In Rust, from $18 to $60, a 227% lift. And before you call it a promo effect: 84% of players only ever use one code. One. That’s not a coupon. That’s loyalty. 2. How players pay reveals how much they’ll spend. The same player, buying the same content, spends 50-70% more with buy-now-pay-later than with a card. Tebex controlled for this with cohort analysis - same users, card vs. BNPL - and the lift held. Crypto showed the same pattern, running as high as ~150% more in parts of LATAM. Players are budgeting entertainment like an investment, spreading the cost of a game across the months they expect to play it. 3. Players are fixing a checkout nobody designed for them. On desktop games - Minecraft, Rust, Ark - 35% of purchases happen on a phone. Players keep one screen in the game and buy on the other, optimizing their own flow because no one built one for them. Put it together and the conclusion writes itself: in a world of infinite entertainment, players pay more - meaningfully, measurably more - when they trust who they’re paying. The relationship isn’t a soft metric. It’s the margin you’ve been looking for. “Every purchase a gamer makes these days is a CapEx decision. They’re choosing to invest their time and their money, and they want to know they’re going to get a return - enjoyment, entertainment - that justifies it.” - Liam Wiltshire “Is the 30% dead?” Yes - with a giant asterisk Liam’s read on the fee wars is more sober than the headlines. Yes, studios now have alternatives. But the platforms aren’t giving up margin; they’re relocating it. Google drops the headline fee, then adds a steering fee and pushes chargeback risk onto developers. Steam may permit link-outs - but the same anti-steering mechanics that govern mobile a… Get full access to GameMakers at www.gamemakers.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01A few weeks ago, Epic Games cut the value of V-Bucks by 20%. Same dollar, 20% less currency. And the reason they gave was simple and honest. They needed to pay the bills. Now, a lot of people jumped on that, called it a betrayal. Here's a company that fought the 30% tax, turning around and raising prices on players. I want to push back on that because I think it misses the entire point.
Tim Sweeney took a principled stance that nobody else in the industry was willing to take. Epic spent five years and north of $100 million fighting Apple and Google.
SPEAKER_01An unpopular fight. A lonely fight. And every developer watching or listening to this benefits from how it ended. Google at 20%, fee cuts in China, and link outs, the right to put a link inside your own game that sends players to your own checkout, is actually on the table for the first time. So you don't get to dunk on the one company that actually went
to war for you.
SPEAKER_01But you should ask the question almost nobody is asking. Epic, the company that won that war, the company with the biggest game in the West, its own store, its own engine, if that company still has to cut V-Bucks value to pay the bills, what does that tell you about everybody else? That's today's episode. Because a V-Bucks move isn't an Epic story.
SPEAKER_01It's a margin story. The entire games industry has a profitability problem, and it's about to get much, much worse. Let me lay out the math from first principles. On one side of the equation, player attention is finite, and the competition for it is not just other games anymore. It's TikTok, it's YouTube, Netflix, it's streaming, it's everything with a screen.
SPEAKER_01I've talked about attention compression on this channel before. Players now evaluate a game in roughly 16 seconds. 16 seconds to earn the next minute. On the other side of the equation is supply. iOS App Store submissions jumped over 60% year over year in December, after three years of basically no growth. Why? because AI is collapsing the cost of building software towards zero.
SPEAKER_01People who could not ship apps are shipping apps, and games are next. I've been deep in this personally, and I'm telling you, the flood has already started. We are heading into an era where entertainment supply is functionally infinite. Infinite shelf, finite attention. When supply explodes and attention does not, two things happen mechanically.
SPEAKER_01The cost of acquiring player goes up and your pricing power goes down. That's margin compression. That's the V-Buck story. That's the layoff story. That is the story of the industry right now. So ask the first principle question. In that world, what's actually scarce? Not content. AI just made content abundant. Now the obvious next answer is distribution.
SPEAKER_01And in one sense, distribution has never been more abundant. Shelf space is infinite. Steam will list you. The App Store will host you. Anyone can publish. But getting on the shelf is not distribution. Getting a player to walk down your aisle is distribution. And that is the most expensive it has ever been. And it gets more expensive with every game that ships. Discovery is a choke point.
SPEAKER_01So yes, distribution is what's scarce. And here's a move most people miss. A player relationship is distribution. A player who knows who you are, trusts you, and comes back without being paid to come back That's not a brand metric. That's a distribution channel. One you own instead of rent. Every other channel, paid UA, store featuring, the platform algorithm,
SPEAKER_01you rent by the impression and the rent is going up. The player relationship is the only distribution channel whose cost goes down the stronger it gets. The scarce asset is the player relationship because the player relationship is owned distribution. And here's how you know that's true. Watch what the platforms refuse to give up.
SPEAKER_01They'll negotiate the percentage. Google settled Apple cut fees in China. But look at the fine print. Google lowers the headline fee and introduces a charge for steering. A fee for telling your own player your own webshop exists while chargeback costs quietly move onto developers. And Steam? Valve is in federal court right now. A certified class action of some 32,000 developers over rules
that stop you from
SPEAKER_01selling your own game cheaper anywhere else. Their position? No such written policy exists. The emails in evidence, however, suggest otherwise. That's not me speculating. It's in the court record. The platforms will give you margin before they give you the relationship. The login, the payment method, the purchase history, the refund, that's the part they keep.
Because they've understood for 15 years what most studios are only starting to see.
SPEAKER_01The relationship is the moat. Now last week I interviewed a guy who said it better than I can. The real story isn't the 30%. It's that regulations are quietly changing who owns the player relationship. Who owns the player relationship? In an attention economy, that's a whole game. And it's why what I'm about to tell you next is I think
SPEAKER_01One of the most underreported stories in our industry. Because while everyone argued about percentages, somebody already solved this. Not in theory, in production. At scale for 15 years. Just not anywhere the industry press ever looks. It's something of a shadow games industry. There is a Minecraft server, not a game, a server called Hypixel that holds the Guinness World Record
for concurrent players
SPEAKER_01and is closing in on year 15 of operation. Microsoft doesn't run it. A community does. There are 5M roleplay servers, the multiplayer layer on top of GTA 5, where players have held the same job in the same city with the same friends for years. Thai communities, Portuguese economy servers, German servers. No publisher pays for the hardware.
SPEAKER_01No platform processes the payments. The people who run these worlds own the entire player relationship. And the players pay them directly. Happily. In a brutal attention economy, these communities have held people for a decade plus. And here's the number that made me sit up. The company that built the payment rails for this world,
a company most people in this industry could not have named six months ago,
SPEAKER_01but this company has processed $1.5 billion in lifetime payments. Now, precision matters. That's their total volume. These days, it includes direct-to-consumer for studios you have heard of, Rockstar, Take-Two, Hytale. And they're not the only payments company serving game servers. So what's the UGC server economy worth in total? Honest answer, nobody knows.
SPEAKER_01No earnings call reports it. No analyst covers it. The best window anyone has into this market is one company's books and through that one window, a billion and a half dollars. This market is big enough that the number should exist and it doesn't. That's how deep in the shadows this thing runs. And that company started by a 16-year-old in his childhood
bedroom in Nottingham,
SPEAKER_01England with 20 pounds, the price of the domain name.
SPEAKER_00and we'll get to that story because I think it's worth it. Now, why should you care what Minecraft kids and GTA role players are doing? Because their data tells you what a real player relationship is worth in dollars.
SPEAKER_01Three numbers. Number one, when a purchase goes through a creator code, a streamer the player actually trusts average spend goes from $24 to $41. In Rust, from $18 to $60, a 227% lift. And before you say promo effect, 84% of players only ever use one code. One, that's not a coupon. That's loyalty.
SPEAKER_01Number two, the same player buying the same content spends 50% to 70% more with buy now, pay later than with a card. Players are budgeting entertainment like an investment. Now, the guest you're about to hear calls every player purchase a CapEx decision. And once you hear it framed in that way, you can't unhear it. Number three, on desktop games, desktop, 35% of purchases happen on a phone.
SPEAKER_01Players keep one screen in the game and buy on the other. Players are optimizing their own checkout flow because nobody designed one for them. Put those numbers together and the conclusion writes itself. In a world of infinite entertainment, players pay more, meaningfully, measurably more when they trust who they're paying. The relationship isn't a soft metric.
SPEAKER_01It's a margin you've been looking for. The industry spent 15 years engineering pressure. The data says we should have been engineering trust. So here are the three questions I couldn't shake. If even the winner of the fee war is squeezed, where does margin actually come from? When AI makes content infinite, what's the asset that appreciates?
SPEAKER_01and what do a million Minecraft kids know about player relationship that billion-dollar studios still don't? To get the answers, I spoke with Liam Wiltshire. Liam is a GM of TEDx. They power direct-to-consumer payments for Rockstar, Take-Two, Hytale, and 5M, and they're the company behind that $1.5 billion. Liam joined when it was two kids and a kitchen table and he's been there for a decade.
SPEAKER_01We get into the merchant of record model, what Brazil can teach you about checkout, how Hytale launched off steam and secured two years of runway from pre-orders alone, and what happened the day a 16-year-old's side project started making money in his parents' house. Our discussion with Liam Wiltshire, GM of Tebex, starting
SPEAKER_01I think while a lot of people in the industry, me included, we have a kind of a very simplistic understanding of D2C, what people mean by D2C. There's a lot of focus in terms of mobile web shops, for example. But in fact, it's a more complicated and dynamic landscape that I think most people are aware of. Number of headlines, for example, Epic just slashed V-Bucks per dollar by 20% to quote-unquote pay the bills while there were layoffs happening as well.
SPEAKER_01Apple cut fees in China. Google settled with Epic at 20%. Fortnite is back on the Play Store. Hytale, who you work with, have launched with 0% server commission, and we can go into more about what these kind of UGC servers are all about, but From your perspective, what's going on in the industry today?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I think this is really important because we see Epic changing V-Books because they needed to increase their margins and pay the bills. But on the flip side, studios such as Hypixel Studios, when they launched Hytale, foregoing the opportunity to produce additional revenue because they felt that was the wrong approach to take. And for a lot of that, I think you could say, well, how can those two things be true at the same time? What we see and what we need to recognize from this is that
players have a much
SPEAKER_00bigger say now, maybe more than ever, about how they are spending their time and their money. We've recognized that spending power across the world has gone down, right? Like everybody's kind of quality of life and cost of living has gone up, but salaries haven't kept up. Everyone is making a lot more intentional choices about how they spend both their time and their money. The reaction to some of these things being actually the winners right now are the ones that are recognizing that and the ones that are respecting
the players. And that's the thing we're going to continue to see this year is the studios and the games that are going to win are the ones that are actually treating players as almost an equal partner in this whole situation and are trying to find a way that
SPEAKER_00works for both sides fairly.
SPEAKER_01I think that's an interesting point that you're mentioning, Liam, because it does seem that with the way that the world economy is going and with what's happening with AI where there's so much supply now in terms of, well, not just because of AI, but because of just in terms of all the things that games are competing with, that it sounds like what you're saying is that players are going to be more discerning. And if a company wants to actually be more successful in terms of generating more revenue, it's got to link Yeah, I think partly it is just treating players with
SPEAKER_00I don't want to say more respect because that's unaffected. We all know that our players who play our games pay the bills, right? This is the end result. If we don't have players, we're not going to get very far. It's recognising that today's player has a level of sophistication around they're making capital expenditure decisions. And that capex is both time and money, as we talked about. But it's not just a, oh, well, they're playing this game. Of course, they're going to make a purchase. Players are making a real conscious decision Decision on like is this worth am I going to get enjoyment am I
going to get a return on this investment of time and money playing game and that's the same whether it's a purchase or whether it's watching ads ads are a time investment just the same as buying a battle pass is monetary investment right and so I think lesson number one is recognize that is the reality you know games that still and we've all
SPEAKER_00seen it we've seen these monetization kind of cycles and mechanics that that even when you look at them, they feel a little bit like this is a little bit icky. It's a little bit, you know, pulling the wool over the player's eyes. Players are far too savvy for that. They will sniff that out immediately. So that's kind of number one is even without talking to the players, just understand they have a level of sophistication. Gamers today have a level of sophistication. That's not going to wash. But second of all, like owning the relationship with your community is We are moving and one of the things with D2C is very much this
whole concept of
SPEAKER_00It's not just about kind of saving fees and all that stuff. It puts you, rather than being a gatekeeper between you and your player base, you have direct contacts and direct relationships with your player base and you can build those meaningful relationships. And then that can expand into Discord or forums or just how players are playing. You give people options on how they want to spend. Certain players might prefer cosmetics, certain players might prefer kind of level skips, whatever that might be, and give them the options and understand what players are
choosing to buy and give
SPEAKER_00them that option. Don't try and force something down their throats that isn't the thing that they want.
SPEAKER_01The other headline that we talked about is like the app store fees. And certainly if you think about the game studio, it has this relationship with the customer, but sitting in between them is that app store And it's at least on the mobile side, they've been taking 30%. And there's been a lot of pushback against that. Now, with what we saw in terms of Google to 20%, Apple to 25% in China, and we were seeing stuff happening in the EU, would you say that dead is a 30% dead? And where do you,
from your perspective, where do you see that kind of heading towards?
SPEAKER_00I mean, it makes a great headline, doesn't it? You know, it's the big thing that you can put up. 30% is dead. It's going to get clicks. I think it is true, like, with a massive asterisk. And what I mean by that is I think what studios and indie devs have recognized is that there are alternatives. Now, whether that is... through fee reductions in app stores, meaning that more money is being passed on. A cynic might argue that Google's changed now to start passing the cost of chargebacks onto developers is maybe a way to take some of that back.
SPEAKER_00I can't say that it is, but there is certainly a cynical viewpoint that you could take the timing of those two things. You know, maybe there's a relation, maybe there's not. But I think we are going to see different ways where these platforms still want to make their margins. They will find other ways to do that, whether that's leveraging data in different ways, whether that's, like I said, passing on certain risks that maybe they previously absorbed onto the developers. So I think, is 30% dead from a platform perspective?
SPEAKER_00Yes, to a point, but no in other ways. But I think the bigger thing is that what it has done is many more app developers certainly and game developers, mobile developers, PC game developers have recognized is there is an alternative. There's another way they can do this that isn't necessarily going to be a replacement for those distribution channels, but certainly as a supplementary route will give them a much more significant cut of that revenue than maybe they've received in the past.
SPEAKER_01I actually have a quote from you here. I don't know if I have this quote right, but I think you've publicly said something along the lines of that the real story isn't this 30%. It's that regulations are quietly changing who owns the player relationship. And so I was wondering if you can go into that into a little bit more depth, because it's certainly like you can make the argument that from a game studio perspective, the stronger the relationship with their customers and players, that is what is actually putting pressure on the app stores to reduce their fees.
But it'd be great to get a better characterization of what you meant by that. Gaming in some ways is a little bit behind in some ways when it comes to like
SPEAKER_00culture and popular culture and media and that sort of thing. What I mean by that is if you think about movie stars or music artists, media artists, whatever, any of these other sorts of We talk about these individuals and these bands having fans and sometimes even super fans. You have, I'm too old to understand, half of this, Swifties and they have their names and they're almost like their lore within these different groups, right? And you have these massive fans of actors and art musicians and
all of these things.
SPEAKER_00But we don't tend to talk about fan bases within gaming. And I think a lot of the reason for that is because there has always been this kind of artificial divide. You never felt truly connected with the developer of a game or with the studio that developed a game or whatever it might be. So whether it's an indie or a larger studio, there was never that kind of connection. And so one of the things that we really advocate for with D2C is using that as your opportunity to to build that connection and have that real kind of those touch
points almost expose yourself a little bit more to your player base convert them from being players to being fans that are proud to support your game it's it is a unique opportunity having those direct purchasing points and having that direct interface
SPEAKER_00so yes absolutely will you save fees using DTC most certainly you will But is that the key moral of the story? Less certainly in our opinion, but using that as an opportunity to create a long term fans of your game and your studio that want to buy the games that you play or support other things that you want to do is super, super valuable. And in our opinion, certainly in some ways more important than the fee savings in the short term. Yeah, I actually think that's a very critical point that you're
making, Liam, because
SPEAKER_01To the point that we actually touched upon, attention economy, there's going to be so many entertainment options in that if there are like no switching costs, people will just go wherever, right? And just getting a user, acquiring that user is so difficult. So to the point that you're making, sure, maybe you could save a little bit of money on your App Store fees, but more importantly, If you can help game studios develop a stronger relationship or bond with their audience, that is just so much more valuable than just saving that whatever 5,
SPEAKER_0110, whatever percentage that you save on the App Store fees. And so I actually wanted to, before we move forward into a little bit more detail, I was hoping you could actually help characterize the market. Because again, I think one of the things I mentioned is that for some of us, I'm in the mobile gaming industry. When I think about D2C, the thing that just comes to mind is, oh, a web shop. Oh, you saved some fees. But the landscape is actually much bigger, right? It's not just mobile. It's mobile. It's web.
SPEAKER_01It's PC. And I'd love for you to help characterize this UGC server space, which I think a lot of people don't know a lot about.
SPEAKER_00There's way more similarities than we recognize. And the reason for that, and again, this is another one of those examples of where we can learn from the wider kind of e-commerce industry. There are things, practices that have been in e-commerce for a long time that only now we're starting to see come across to gaming. So, for example, yeah, I'll take UGC. So UGC and game servers was Tebex's genesis. Happy to talk about that a bit more later. But that's where we started. We started doing monetization for Minecraft servers and Garry's
Mod servers and Rust. And then we went into mods and all these things way before we got into working with
SPEAKER_00studios and helping them grow their player relationships through D2C. But a lot of what we learned there, for example, is very... similar to what we see in mobile. The average transaction value is often the same. The kind of short life cycles of some of these experiences. It's not like a PC game where you might play for how many hours of gameplay there is. Apart from like Hypixel, you know, largest Minecraft server, Guinness World Record holder for a number of concurrent players.
SPEAKER_00They have lots of minigames. So they have Hide and Seek and they have Skyblock and they have all these different types of gameplay. They are In terms of the cycle and the mechanics, much more akin to a mobile game, short sessions, snappy activity, you play something for three minutes and then that's it, you move on to the next level or whatever it might be, than traditional PC gaming. So there's a lot of overlaps and a lot of things that we can learn around how to share value between gameplay sessions. It's not like a DLC on PC where you know you're buying
SPEAKER_00hours of additional content. When you're making that investment decision, as we talked about for a game server or mobile, it's like, is this value going to carry on to my next play session or is it one and done? Because if it's one and done, the ROI calculation in my head, and I might not think of it in that way, but that is the calculation we're doing, is much lesser. But those lessons apply both. And then likewise, we see PC as these that you're selling premium games, AA, AAA, whatever. But A lot of the logic behind microtransactions in PC games,
SPEAKER_00and there's a lot of views on that, positive and negative, take a lot of lessons from the smaller transaction value, the immediate payback that we see in some of the design patterns in mobile and UGC game servers as well. So I think there's a lot of ways you can leverage the same ideas and the same techniques across these different things. But fundamentally, yes. The key difference that we do see is a lot of it is to do with, I guess,
game session length.
SPEAKER_00So are we talking short, sharp mechanics, short, sharp cycles of This is a three-minute kind of set piece almost, or is it a sprawling five-hour adventure? And, you know, how you leverage the player's attention and the right time to strike. You know, we talk in marketing around you want to have the right message to the right person at the right moment. And what that right message and that right moment is going to be very different for someone who's dedicated 20, 30, 40, 50 hours to a game versus someone who might be playing in short
five-minute
SPEAKER_00sessions. So that's kind of the big difference is when the right moment is. But in terms of like a D to C perspective, in terms of a monetization perspective, The same concepts, like I said, that right message at the right moment is exactly the same. A lot of things that we're seeing around the massive impact in influencers and social proof applies across all, whether it's console, whether it's mobile, whether it's console or PC. That is applying in the same way. A lot of the same kind of ways to build that loyalty and that
kind of sense of fandom
SPEAKER_00apply across the mall. So I think there's a lot more similarities than people give it credit for.
SPEAKER_01Right. So it sounds like the similarities you're talking about are like some lessons you learn from buying patterns that you see from players. But in terms of if we were to just try to explain to our audience what payments looks like or what the service looks like from a D2C perspective on the different platforms, I think mobile is simple to understand, right? There's like a web shop that takes you to a web browser experience. On PC, there's Steam. So where does the TebX or the D2C kind of solution sit with a game developer that
SPEAKER_01might have a Steam game and paying fees to Steam? Where does a D2C kind of payment solution come in.
SPEAKER_00Sure. And actually, again, I think it's becoming less and less different because most gamers these days are cross-platform. You don't have very many, I only play on PC or I only play on mobile or I only play on console. Yet people do a little bit of everything. So where a few years ago, absolutely, the concept of going to a standalone web shop for a desktop game would have been very alien, 100%. But I think, you know, we are seeing less and less now that's the case.
SPEAKER_00Certainly for live service games, having a web-based presence that you're, again, the people that know your game, the people that know you, they see it in Discord, whatever else, is absolutely... And I also think kind of the other side for selling the games themselves, because, you know, Hytale, which is a launch that we were involved in, is a great example. Didn't go live on Steam at all. Only launched via their website. But players again when you build this sense of fandom players are then prepared to sacrifice a little bit of convenience you know I'm from an age
where I remember when my games were all on a big stack of floppy disks and then I thought it was the best thing ever when my games were in a cd wallet but I had this whole stack of cd wallets and you'd pull a cd out to find it was scratched and you couldn't play it
SPEAKER_00and all the I remember all that but steam is brilliant. You know, it has this amazing library management that players absolutely love. But, and trying to ask someone to give up that convenience without having that existing relationship is definitely tough. But you build that relationship and you go like, hey, we're going to release our next game direct on our web store. You know, that's the place that you're going to buy it. You know, it's really going to support us. It's going to help us out. And those players that are proud to support your game, well, absolutely then go.
SPEAKER_00Actually, you know what? I love this studio. I love this title. I want to support them as much as I can. I'm okay with having that extra launcher on my desktop. I'm okay with it coming via a different channel.
SPEAKER_01Right. So on the PC side, it looked like a separate launcher and a D2C solution would essentially be very similar to the mobile side where it's like where you guys would be powering The web shop and handling the transactions and things like that. And we can go into a little more details because I do think that another thing that would be useful is for some of the folks in the audience to understand what is the value that they're getting from TEDx, right? Like they may not understand things like merchant of record, chargebacks, fraud, all that kind of stuff.
SPEAKER_01But just to kind of close the loop in terms of the platforms, so mobile, web shops, PC, like launcher and kind of web store, web, I assume that would also look somewhat similar in terms of like having a web shop that you guys would also power. Is that correct?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, in some ways, web is almost the most native, right? So I still think back to some of the classic games, the classic web games that I played as a kid. like Neopets and then just as I got out of Neopets like Club Penguin came along and all those things and a lot of those games still exist which is amazing but obviously in that sense there is a reality right now that if you download a game via the Google or the Apple App Store or you buy a game via Steam or you receive a game via Steam there are restrictions in those platforms about
promoting external
SPEAKER_00payments or external web shops from within the game Obviously, you now can with the new steering rules on Google, but they charge you for that. And again, that's another way that 30% isn't really dead because the steering thing comes back in. So with web games, web native games, you remove that hurdle of it needing to be outside of the game. You can literally have almost the classic in-app purchase experience where it's like, hey, I'm going to buy this directly from the game. I'm going to click that button and the checkout pops up and you go and make your payment and you get on with your gameplay.
SPEAKER_00Interestingly, and this is related, that whole concept of being quote-unquote distracted from the game, players are very good at solving themselves. So we see a lot, even with our UGC game server space, where most of those are desktop. Most of them are like Minecraft, Rust, Ark, those sorts of games, right? And yet, even on those, 35% of purchases are made on mobile devices. So players are actually using the webshop on their phone so
they don't have to
SPEAKER_00leave the gaming experience. And that is something that we find super interesting and something that, you know, certainly for desktop games more broadly, we talk a lot about actually, you know, Optimizing your purchase experience for mobile even if it's a desktop game because players can you know I see my kids do my kids will have three devices at the same time they'll be playing they'll be playing something on the PC or on the console they'll have YouTube on their phone they'll have something going off of having a phone call on their watch whatever it is and I find it incredible the ability to multitask in that way I find incredible but we see a lot of it
and a lot of the data the growth in mobile payments even on desktop based games really is evidence
SPEAKER_00of that I'm going to stay plugged into the game while multitasking my purchase on a second device. I was hoping you could also talk a little bit more about like the steering rules, right?
SPEAKER_01So on mobile, there are a set of regulations about how you can inform and try to drive some of your players to your web shop. For PC Steam, how is that different? And then what you were saying on web is like, it's so native and direct. There's no real, like you can do whatever you want. But can you talk more about like on the PC Steam side? How do you effectively drive more of your player base to your own web shop?
SPEAKER_00I guess that's a very timely question. Obviously, I'm sure we all saw the news in the last few days with the current case and the statements that are being made that no, Steam doesn't have an anti-steering policy. But then there being evidence of emails and things that suggest they do. So, you know, it's a little bit unclear right now. Like we've got statements that say they don't have one. There is evidence that suggests they do. And indeed, in their terms, it suggests they do. So in many ways, in that sense, the mechanics are very similar to,
SPEAKER_00I guess, traditional mobile mechanics. It's very much a case of we are going to build this relationship. And this is one of those things that I say about learning from, you know, learning from other e-commerce. So you make that first kind of, you know, and I'm going to use mobile as an example for a second, then I'll go back to Steve. But, you know, we talked about the fact that Google are now going to charge a steering fee. If you steer out to a third-party payment, they're going to charge a fee. I kind of like that as a mobile...
SPEAKER_00If I was a mobile developer, I would be okay with that as long as I see it as a cost of initial acquisition. So what I mean by that is... This is something that I've seen. If you buy things from, say, back in the day from eBay, and you'd buy something from eBay, particularly if it's like a new item rather than an actual second-hand item, and you'd often get it lovely packaged in a box, and you get a little card that would say, hey, I'm so grateful for your purchase, but actually, next time you purchase, come straight to my store. This is where all the best deals are. And that same mechanic, certainly on mobile,
SPEAKER_00works really well, where it's like, actually, pay the extra 5% for the steering the first time. No problem. But when they make that purchase... Send them a follow up going look we are so grateful for your purchase we're so grateful that you've supported our game the next time check out our webshop And we're starting to see with this suggestion that actually linkouts are potentially going to be permitted on Steam, certainly from kind of what the quotes that we're seeing in the media now, so we see if that turns into reality. I think that same mechanic will become very, very powerful in PC gaming as well,
SPEAKER_00where it's like, okay, you link out the first time, and if there's a fee attached, you consider that an initial cost of acquisition, you build that into your business plan, cool. You then promote from that purchase, that's how you then set up the, hey, Visit the webshop next time Start to build that connection
SPEAKER_01Right, and that's an interesting way of thinking about it as the platforms are kind of like your acquisition channel. And then from there, if you are able to, to the point that you made earlier, develop a strong relationship with the player, then you can own that player relationship going forward, have better economics going forward. And so when you're modeling your P&L or your business case for a game, that's something that you should consider because there will be some conversion where those players don't need to keep paying those app store fees over and over again.
SPEAKER_00So just to jump in on that, that is also a really big mindset shift as well, because the story for the longest time, and we still have these conversations with studios today, it's like, how can I maximize the one time spent? There is still a lot of a mindset that it's like, how can I get them to spend the most right now? And actually, that's when that kind of initial cost of acquisition model started. struggles a little bit because if they're only going to buy once, you've paid that extra 5% and you're never going to make it back.
SPEAKER_00The whole focus, exactly as you rightly said, is actually I don't mind if that first purchase is only $5. If I can then get them to come back and build that relationship and build that fandom that we talked about and they come back and make 20 $10 purchases over the next year that I don't have to pay that acquisition cost on and goes directly via my web shop and I'm only paying maybe 3-7% or whatever that might be depending on the payment method and all those things, that initial acquisition cost suddenly becomes the best
business decision you've
SPEAKER_00ever made.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so going back to our framework, so we've talked about mobile, and I think that's probably the most well-interested, at least by the audience that watches GameMakers. But then web is relatively straightforward. We've talked about PC Steam. In terms of the console space, I mean, the way that my simple understanding is it's a very tightly controlled walled garden. Does DTC fit in the console space as well, or does it not apply? It absolutely does It's more challenging But with all these
things It takes the
SPEAKER_00brave individual To take the first step, right? So, and the example is of that. So, our parent company, we're part of Overwolf. We have been for the last four and a half years, which has been amazing. And obviously, they are leaders and we lead in so many areas about UGC, not just game servers, but mods and the wider creator economy. ARX 5 Ascended was the first game that allowed third-party mods on console.
SPEAKER_00Everyone said it would never happen. Everyone was like, no, these Sony and Microsoft are never going to allow this to happen. And without giving too much away, it was hard work. It took a lot of conversations and a lot of building trust. That's a lot of it. Those are very important brands. They're very meaningful brands. They have a lot of impact. And the last thing, completely understandably... that Sony or Microsoft want is for their brand to suddenly be kind of dirtied in some way because these things are cropping up and illegal
content or whatever that
SPEAKER_00might be. Absolutely makes sense. But it takes somebody who is prepared to put in that time and effort to change that paradigm. And we're now seeing other games that are following up with modding, following that kind of template of high trust, moderation, enforcing the rules, all these things that we started alongside Studio Wildcard and their team in ASA, we're now seeing starting to replicate in other games. And that's incredible.
SPEAKER_00And so actually DTC can be very similar. The most obvious example being Roblox. Of course, you can buy Robux in-game, but any Robux that you buy on the web, you can also use in your own console with that same user. And indeed, Roblox are very open about the fact that if you buy on web, you get more bang for your buck, as it were. You know, you get more value for that same purchase. That is a model that there are other games that do very similarly. And as such, would we even want to remove the consoles and the console
platforms from that
SPEAKER_00conversation? No, because there is a level of trust and certain players will always have more trust in, I'm going to buy it directly from here or it's more convenient, whatever. Absolutely. I would say to any game developer, you absolutely you know having a smaller percentage of a purchase is still better than having no purchase at all right but again you build that relationship and for those players that understand that they want to support what you're doing and they want to make sure you get the biggest level of kind of leg up and the biggest level
of support that you can having that third party option so actually you can buy our virtual currency direct from our store and use it in game on console is absolutely
SPEAKER_00a valuable play
SPEAKER_01Speaking now, maybe talking about servers in UGC, which is where you guys have operated for a long time and where you have a lot of expertise, but probably I would suspect the least understood by our audience. First, could you help characterize what is in terms of like whether it's Minecraft servers or what is 5M Rust? Maybe you could speak a little bit more about Hytale since you guys work with them. And so on the server-based D2C side, could you kind of characterize, first explain that market a little bit and then characterize how you guys fit in?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. That'd be great. So as I mentioned, game servers and UGC was our genesis. That will always be a really big part of our DNA. We are so thrilled to be able to work with the likes of Roxara and Wildcard and all of these guys, but actually supporting small indie creators running their game servers, building mods is something we will always love to be a part of. And the reason it is so important and the reason it is actually super relevant is that a lot of these servers, in some ways, I like to say it's kind of like the original Roblox.
SPEAKER_00So Minecraft servers have always had different experiences. You can join 50 different Minecraft servers and they're all run like Microsoft don't run these servers. They're all run by the community, by different groups and different people and different organizations. But you can join any of a number of different servers and have a very different experience. You have economy servers where the whole thing is about increasing your net worth through doing activities or mining or whatever that might be. You have minigame servers where, again,
SPEAKER_00much more like that mobile experience where it's short, sharp, you get in, you play a couple of rounds of hide and seek or whatever it might be, and you get out again. You have other experiences where it's role-play type experiences where you live out a kind of virtual life. And these different experiences completely change the value proposition of the game for the player. Because it's no longer about just kind of punching trees and mining for gold and emeralds and whatever it is. It's no longer about just playing the story through and you get
to the end of the
SPEAKER_00story and you go, okay, well, what's next? It is a complete universe of different experiences and different worlds and different gameplay mechanics and all of these things. So... The way that works, as I said, is very rarely do the studios and the publishers have much to do with running these servers. There will be guidelines. There will be things that you can and can't do on these servers. There'll be rules about you can't. Clearly illegal content, obviously, but also other things to protect the brand.
SPEAKER_00So they have that kind of side of things, but they don't get involved in the management of these servers. They're not providing infrastructure. They're not providing CPU runtime or anything like that. That is what done by the community. And some of these servers have been going for years and years. Hypixel is, I think, closing in on 15 years now. Again, I said world record holder. Some of the 5M roleplay servers, which is the multiplayer layer on top of GTA V, again, they've been going for many years. There are storylines within some of these roleplay servers where people have gone
literally from graduated through jobs and they almost treat it like a second life
SPEAKER_00in many ways. And so... because of that because there is no kind of Other than providing the software, there's no operational support from the studios. These servers historically ran into a lot of challenges because you have to pay for the hardware. Like I said, that hardware is not coming from the studio. It's not like a game, like a matchmaking type game, like Rocket League or whatever, where these servers are spun up by the game and by the publisher. You have to run these servers. If you're producing custom gameplay,
either you have to build it yourself or you have to pay a developer who can do so. If your game grows to a certain scale and you need kind of moderation and support
SPEAKER_00and all these things, all that stuff costs money. And so that historically was a big challenge for a lot of these servers. They wanted to grow. They wanted to be able to create these unique experiences. Some of them might be geographic. You might have Portuguese-speaking servers or Korean-speaking servers or French-speaking servers or whatever. Some of them might be unique gameplay. And to do that, you have to generate revenue. the very earliest servers used to do this through kind of donations and yes there
might be like some reward for it but it was very I don't want to say black market because that makes it sound wrong but there was like no automated way for this to happen it was like you would send some money to a PayPal account and when that person got an opportunity to do it you might get the rewarding game but that might take two days by which point maybe you've got word that you've not received it you
SPEAKER_00might then open a dispute whatever it might be. So that was the very first version. And that was the problem that Tebex tried to solve. So we were like, hey, if we provide that kind of layer, so we provide the webshop interface and we provide the integration into the game so that the minute that purchase happens, The reward that you get is immediately fulfilled in game. And honestly, that was the genesis of Tebex. Back then, we didn't actually process the payments. We had integrations with all these different things, but we just provide the integration.
You had to plug in your API keys and you had to have the agreements with PayPal or
SPEAKER_00Stripe or Molly or whoever it might be. You had to deal with sales tax, all these things. We didn't touch any of that. We just had this webshop solution and this integration into the game. But that whole thing of actually making the creator's life easier really was the thing that kept us going. It was the thing that we got up to do. It's the thing we still get up to do today. And so we very quickly started to realize we started in Minecraft and then we started supporting other games because we saw these exact same challenges in games like Garrismod and Rust and ASE at the time and games like that.
SPEAKER_00So we started supporting other games. We then recognized that actually as these servers continue to grow, People were running into different challenges. They were like, well, I don't know how to deal with sales tax. I might be based in France, but if I sell items into certain US states, one purchase is enough to trigger a tax audit. Server owners, the thing they do is produce brilliant experiences. The thing they do is produce these communities that love what they do and want to play together and want to enjoy these experiences together. That's what they do best.
SPEAKER_00They're not accountants. They're not tax experts. They're not fraud experts. And so we recognize that actually that is the way we could help these communities continue to thrive by, as I used to term it back in the day, dealing with the crappy business stuff. So we dealt with all the tax, we dealt with all the risk and the frauds and the global payments and all of these things, and let them do what they did best, which was producing these brilliant experiences. And yeah, so that's how Tebex fits in. We basically free up K1min8r GameMakers
SPEAKER_00So that's what they can spend their time doing, not worrying about tax returns in Ohio or whatever.
SPEAKER_01And so to some degree, the way that you're describing it, your business is trying to make the life of the developer from a DTC perspective easier and maybe even the player's experience easier. One of the things I read is that with Hytale in particular, that you were able to enable a single click purchase experience because you had Could you explain that? And then the other thing that I didn't understand is that something along the lines that Hytale launched with 0% server commission for two years.
Could you kind of go into the detail about how you enable that single-click purchase experience?
SPEAKER_01And then how is Hytale able to have this 0% server commission? If you could explain, that'd be great.
SPEAKER_00No, absolutely. So I guess the first thing is, and this is the great thing about, I guess, a network effect of a merchant of record like Tebex, because we will see players... Sorry to pause you, but could you explain that concept as well for our audience?
SPEAKER_01What is a merchant of record? Because a lot of payments companies talk about that. Just for our audience, if you can explain, what is a merchant of record?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So a merchant of record is when a company such as Tebex takes the full selling responsibility for a piece of content. So what that means is, and the way Tebex does it, is if you as a, say you've produced a game and you want to sell copies of that game, rather than you selling it to the player directly, you say, hey Tebex, I've got this game. I would like you to sell it to players instead of me. We will buy copies of that game from you at a price that we agree,
SPEAKER_00which is much less than, say, our margin is much less than the 30% or whatever from Steam or Google or Apple or whatever. And we will then sell it to the customer. Now, you are still involved in that whole process. The web store is branded as your game. It's not like they're buying from the Tebex game store or whatever else. They are buying from the Hytale game store in Hytale's experience or the Dawn of Ages store or whatever it might be. They still have that connection to you. But the principle in the transaction is Tebex.
SPEAKER_00Tebex is the one that has the contract with the player. And the benefits as a studio or as a game developer for that is that Tebex as the principle is responsible for the sales tax. So if there is sales tax to collect and pay in Singapore or Texas or Ohio or somewhere in the EU or Australia or wherever else in the world. We cover sales tax in 120 odd jurisdictions these days. That is Tebex's responsibility. If there is risk and fraud,
that should be the merchant records responsibility.
SPEAKER_00We can talk about that a little bit more. I have quite strong opinions on that. But certainly for Tebex, that is our responsibility. If there is a chargeback for a sale that we've made, we made the sale. We will cover the cost of defending that chargeback. We pay any penalties If we can't win that chargeback And then we have to return the money to the customer We will return that money to the customer As a studio, you will never pay a cent Like you keep the money So if that $5 purchase If we might lose on a purchase that has a chargeback We might lose $20 But you will keep
SPEAKER_00that $5 It's as simple as that We handle the first level of support. So if someone has a billing type inquiry, like, hey, I don't recognize this transaction, or I made this purchase, but I've not received the content, any of those sorts of things, rather than you suddenly having to hire support agents to handle these queries, we handle that for you. Now, clearly, if it comes to game specific things, it will eventually get to a point where it's outside of our kind of area of expertise, and we would have to escalate at that point. But a lot of that, the majority of that kind of fairly...
SPEAKER_00Straightforward billing type inquiries, delivery inquiries, compatibility inquiries, those sorts of things we deal with for everyone that uses Tebex as a merchant of record. We handle the challenge of global payments. Gaming is wonderfully global. You can be playing with players from literally anywhere on the globe and that's amazing. But not everyone makes payments the way that maybe I might do or you might do. I very much, I use my points card for basically everything because we're trying to maximize the
SPEAKER_00points. And I get that. But lots of players in even European countries, the Netherlands, for example, most online payments are made using Ideal. For Tebex specifically, it's about 70% of all Purchases of content from players in the Netherlands use a local payment method called Ideal. They don't use cards. They don't use PayPal. Likewise, in Germany, actually paying with cards is quite rare. Local wallets and account-to-account payment methods reign supreme. Other countries have local card rails like Rupay in India.
SPEAKER_00Pix in Brazil is a brilliant story where five years ago, most even online purchases in Brazil were made using cash over the counter. You would make your purchase online and you'd get this little receipt called a boleto. You would take that to a local convenience store and you would hand it to the cashier and they'd scan it and they'd be like, all right, you need to pay a hundred reais or whatever it is. And you'd pay your money over the counter. They would then transfer that's been paid and they'd send the money off to the central agent and all of this stuff. And that was wild. But that was still five years ago.
That is how the majority of Brazilian online, quote unquote, payments were made. PIX was a central bank kind of exercise to create a true online account to account
SPEAKER_00payment method. So that when you make a purchase using PIX, it immediately comes out of your bank account and goes into the retailer's bank account. And literally in the space of five years, boletos have basically disappeared. TEDx now, on a given month, is like less than 0.2% of all Brazilian purchases use a boleto now. The vast majority of picks. But if you don't know that, if you're not au fait with the purchasing habits of Brazil, if you're not au fait with the purchasing habits of Japan or Korea or Germany or
SPEAKER_00the Netherlands or wherever, how are you supposed to do that? It's impossible, right? So handling all these things, this is the stuff that Merchant Records do. This is why it's not just about understanding gaming, but we bringing experts from the world of payments, companies like Trainline in the UK and ASOS. And like our head of fraud came from a gambling company because actually fraud in gambling is even worse than fraud in video gaming. And we bring together these true experts in their fields so that you can focus on
producing kick-ass content and amazing games and we will handle the rest of it and you can sleep much better at night knowing that your merchant record has it
SPEAKER_00covered.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I can totally see the value in that. It's hard enough to get a successful game, but then to have to understand all of those geographically specific payment issues and options and all that kind of stuff, certainly I think there's a lot of value in that. And maybe I can ask you one last question related to the platforms and the landscape. And then I would like to talk more about specific payment innovations, which were new to me and I think the audience would be very interested in. But one last question in terms of the platforms is the notion of cross-platform,
right? And so we've seen there are certainly a number of games that are maybe increasingly
SPEAKER_01where the trends are going, but certainly a number of games are cross-platform. In those scenarios, What happens? How should game studios think about payments from a cross-platform perspective? Where do you guys fit in? And how should students be thinking about DTC in a cross-platform scenario? I love cross platform games because again if you're trying to build that connection we as a species we are increasingly on the go we're not sat in one place all the time we travel for work or we we commute every day we fly to a
foreign country we've not got a massive gaming rig with us you know or for myself when I'm playing
SPEAKER_00games in the evening Maybe I don't want to go through a bunch of driver updates again, so I will just turn the Xbox on because it's easier. Like, that's the reality. And so having a game that I know I can pick up on any of those devices, having a game that I know I can continue exactly where I left off, I'm going to get not the same experience because then you're sacrificing somewhere, but a level of consistency so I feel comfortable. I talked about my kids and how they work on multiple devices. their gaming experience is very much the same.
They play these games where they'll pick up and they'll be playing a game on their
SPEAKER_00phone and then they'll be playing it on a console, then they'll be playing it on the PC. But they can instinctively pick up any of these devices and there is enough about the experience that is consistent that they, even if it's the first time they've played it in that particular format, they can just pick it up and run with it. And I think that from a gameplay perspective is super important and we're seeing more and more of that like trying to build these kind of consistent design patterns but it's the same with your payments because the habit is and this is that
whole thing that we talked about earlier where the default mentality is well the playbook for mobile must be different from the playbook for console must be different from the playbook for PC and actually if I'm playing across all of those and I've built that
SPEAKER_00connection with you as a studio or you as a developer I want I don't want to buy something on mobile and it not be available on PC when I switch over there I don't want to buy something on PC and it not be available on console So that actually having that consistency and having a cross play session benefits. So not something that you're buying and the minute your play session is over, that's it, you've lost it. Something that the next time you log on, you still have that benefit. The next time you log on after that, you still have that benefit. That is like taking these things we're already seeing from a game design
SPEAKER_00perspective, but applying it to your payment design. And this is like an important lesson that your payment design shouldn't be something you add on as an afterthought. You know, it is part of your gaming experience, how someone Support your game, be that through when they buy the game first of all, be that through in-game purchases, microtransactions, battle passes, whatever it is, that should be thought about as part of your core game design, not a, oh, how are we going to monetize, put something on top after the fact.
SPEAKER_01And so that's like, I think we can, just shifting gears from kind of the platforms and landscape and maybe getting a little bit more tactical now. I have been reading and hearing about certain alternative payment options like BNPL, for example, and crypto, and also hearing more about creator codes. So maybe we could take each of those in turn, but just getting a little bit more tactical here. Let's start with creator codes. Could you talk about
SPEAKER_01How do Creator Codes fit into some of these games? And actually, I've got a few stats. Let me try to pull this up. And it'd be great. And I think this was data from you guys, actually. So one, transactions using a Creator Code is growing. So it's grown from 5.2% to 6.9% in two years. Revenue share is now 9.6%. Average spend with a code is 70% higher to $41 instead of $24. In Rust, I think you guys have said that there's a 227% lift, $60 instead of $18. And in Minecraft, 16% of all transactions use a code with an over 100% spend
lift.
SPEAKER_01So could you help us understand like Why is this happening? Can you talk to us about creator codes? And then how should game studios think about creator codes and integrating that within their payment experience?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So first of all, I love creator codes. Anybody who will listen, I will say you absolutely should have an influencer kind of strategy. You should be leveraging creator codes. I could do an entire six hours on creator codes, I think. So just be warned. Ultimately, the way we see it and the way we've seen it being used is creator codes are the ultimate in social validation. So we talked at the very beginning, and I'm going to go back to that very first point I made, that every purchase that a gamer makes these days is a capex decision.
They are choosing to invest their money, which we've already talked about. Everybody has less money at the moment due to all the things that are going on. They're investing their time, and they want to know, we're going to get a return through
SPEAKER_00Enjoyment, entertainment, whatever, that justifies that capex. And so having a source of validation of proof is so, so valuable. Being able to see the gameplay and being able to experience someone that you trust. Much like we talked about this concept of fandom. Many players have, whether it's streamers or YouTubers, that they watch over and over again. I hear the same voices coming out of some of my children's devices every single day
SPEAKER_00or what it feels like. I'm sure it isn't, but it does feel like it. So do I. I have certain Arc, Arc Ascender, Arc Evolved streamers that I watch and YouTubers that I watch a lot. And there is a level of trust. You build that kind of fandom for some of these content creators. And so if they are playing a game and you get to see them play it. You get to understand what are the, what is the gameplay like? Is this something I'm likely to enjoy? And at the end of it, they're saying, hey, you can really support me. You can help my channel grow by using this creative code at checkout.
They have done the work of going, actually, yes, I think this is worth that investment. I think this is worth me investing my time and my money to try this game out and to
SPEAKER_00make this purchase. But on top of that, I now want to also support, because I am a fan, I want to support this streamer or this YouTuber. And so by doing this, you get that double value. So as a player, I'm actually almost getting double the return because I'm supporting someone that I have a real affinity for and I'm getting entertainment and enjoyment from this game that maybe I wouldn't have known about otherwise. So I think creator codes in that sense, that's the way it should be thought about is it is the ultimate kind of social proof, social validation.
SPEAKER_00It does lead that additional trust, that additional confidence that yes, this is a purchase that I feel comfortable making. naturally leads to a higher spend. If you've got two options, it's like, okay, I can buy this bundle or I can, you know, there's 40 bucks or I can buy this bundle, there's 25 bucks. If you've got uncertainty, you're going to hedge your bets. You're going to go for the smaller bundle. And the mindset might be, well, if I really enjoy it, I'll come back and buy the bigger bundle. We all know that doesn't always happen. I do. Like I will always... Every single day I'll be like, right, I'm going to come back to that.
SPEAKER_00I will definitely go do the dishes in 20 minutes. I'm just going to get this email done first and the dishes will still be there when I go to bed. And it happens in our lives every single day. So absolutely, you know, giving them that confidence to be like, actually, I don't need to hedge my bets. I can go in. I can make this purchase. I get, like I said, that feel good factor. I'm supporting this creator. I get to enjoy this great new game that I've discovered. It is absolutely a double positive. It's one of those rare occasions where the sum of the parts is
much greater than the whole.
SPEAKER_01Right. And so to the point, like even at the beginning of our conversation that you had mentioned was the criticality of having a player relationships. And it's these these influencers and creators that do have that relationship. And to your point, when a player is purchasing in your game, one, there's the trust aspect where there may be influencers that the players are watching over and over. They trust that person and they want to support that person. And so it sounds like in just looking at some of the data,
it does seem like that is actually driving monetization in the sense that I think another one of the stats that I saw is that over half of the people that use
SPEAKER_01creator codes will use it on that very first purchase, for example. And so how do you How do you recommend to game studios that they incorporate that more strongly within their games? Is it just establishing these relationships with creators and letting them know what's available? What is your recommendation on how to leverage this? Because it seems like it works if you can get that influencer to promote your game.
SPEAKER_00And that is, you know, I think there's two approaches here. There is the, what I kind of call the quote-unquote agency approach. There are platforms out there that maintain kind of rosters of influencers that are looking for those kind of opportunities. Now, my concern with those is that, does it always come across as authentic? You know, if I've got a creator that one day is playing K1min8r GameMakers
A great example of this is James Turner He's a well-known predominantly Sims YouTuber but he then does things with other kind of life sim style games he's done things with Crafton's Enzoi and so you know that is that natural thing because if he's playing a game that is within his wheelhouse it is a life sim and he is enthusing about it and sometimes he will compare it be like oh well kind
of in if I was playing the sins it'd be this but actually this is the mechanic here and actually
SPEAKER_00you know what I prefer this that is social validation through the roof. As a viewer, he's playing a game that fits into this category that I know and respect his opinion on. It is a category that I enjoy myself. He is enthusing about this game that sits within this category. I need to check that game out. And so definitely like, yes, going down the agency route absolutely can work and in some ways is easier because it is,
SPEAKER_00you know, you're not trying to pitch to the streamer almost that they should do this thing. It's, you know, it's more a case. These are people that are looking for these opportunities. But kind of the real, like the highest levels of social validation do tend to come from building, again, is that our word, relationships with the streamers and the YouTubers that are within this genre of game, this style of gameplay that they're already known for.
SPEAKER_01Right. And a couple of their interesting data points that I saw, one is that 84% of players just use one creator code. So to the point that you were talking about earlier, These players do have that relationship and loyalty to a specific influencer. But the other thing is that Hytale hit 20% of pre-launch purchases via creative code, which is, if I understand correctly, three times your platform average.
And so maybe you could talk to us about what did Hypixel do specifically to make
SPEAKER_01creator codes work at their launch. And maybe it's some of the things that you've already mentioned, but was there anything specific that they did
SPEAKER_00So there's kind of two parts to that. So the first of all, again, it's exactly what we already talked about is they found, or not found, they built relationships with YouTubers and streamers that were massive in Minecraft, were massive in kind of rust, in these kind of communities that have very similar sentiments. Modding, multiplayer servers, block game in Minecraft's case. They found, built these relationships with these YouTubers and streamers that Their audiences were already going to be interested in what
they were selling, effectively.
SPEAKER_00Because that's what these streamers and influencers are doing, right? It's very different. If I watched a creator that produced Minecraft content, and it was always kind of quite child-friendly and whatever else, and suddenly they're doing a one-time video on Dead by Daylight, incidentally an absolutely cracking game, but if I know this creator for their Minecraft content, there's always going to be that little question going, well, why are they suddenly doing a one-time video on Dead by Daylight? There's a jarring there.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't seem completely legit. It doesn't make sense. There's a friction there. Whereas if you find players that this is their natural habitat, Minecraft, multiplayer servers, modding, that sort of community... the their fans the viewers that watch them are going to be receptive to this new game they just need to be drawn attention to it and they need somebody that they trust to be saying look I know this style of game and I think this is great that's
like that is what the viewers are asking for to have that social validation so
SPEAKER_00that's kind of the one element is is Absolutely, you know, finding the relevant streamers that their audience base is going to trust their opinion within this play style, this genre, whatever you want to call it. The second item is also finding kind of influencers, let's call them, that are doing multi-platform kind of activations. So it's not just about the video, but they're putting their code on Twitter or they're putting their code on, you know, Josh Kim k1min8r GameMakers
SPEAKER_00K1min8r an influencer or a streamer, YouTuber that's only announcing it in-game, then they're missing out on a big opportunity and so are you as a studio or as a developer.
SPEAKER_01Okay. And I've got two more questions just to go a little bit deeper in terms of creator codes. And the first was that I found it interesting that there also seems to be like this kind of geographic differentiation, right? Where Romania has a very high creator code adoption rate, I think over 13%. Norway, Denmark, Sweden also are relatively high. U.S. not as high. And could you speak to some of these regional differences and how should game studios be thinking about this?
Is there any way that they should factor in some of these regional differences in
SPEAKER_01terms of creator code adoptions?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, in many ways, I think it's actually funnily very similar to some of the approaches and why we see some of the smaller kind of geographic game servers do very well. And the reason for that is that typically speaking, and I am making some generalizations here and I do apologize in advance for these generalizations, but YouTubers and streamers that are trying to attract a global audience. So they're doing all their stuff in English. They are, you know, they're covering everything in English.
They're trying to keep it fairly kind of high level because they want to appeal to
SPEAKER_00a broad church. That the level of trust and social validation you're going to build there still exists and people still use those codes, but there's going to be a less level of uplift. whereas if you do a some of the greatest game servers for example are actually kind of language specific ones so it might be a German language server or a Portuguese language server or you know or there's a there's a Thai 5M community that does incredibly well and that's because they are targeting and
tailoring the experience to that specific community they're not trying to appeal to everyone and my and I
SPEAKER_00will be honest this is a hypothesis I don't have data to to back this up But taking those learnings that we know are true in game servers, my hypothesis has always been that the same applies, that if you've got locally targeted influencers that maybe aren't known in the US, aren't known in the wider kind of internet, as it were, but are well known in a particular region or by particular language speakers, and they're speaking in their language. It's like, I'm telling you about Hytale in Portuguese for my Portuguese
audience. immediately that level of trust that level of validation is going to be a few notches higher than if it was just hey I'm telling the world whoever you are and everyone's mum and aunt and dog and cat and everyone else how great this thing is so like I said entirely a hypothesis I don't have any data to back that up but I
SPEAKER_00would say having a healthy mix of local influences um And that's something that a merchant record can certainly help with and help introduce you to some of these people that they know and they've got relationships with as well. But yeah, absolutely being able to introduce you to these kind of local YouTubers and streamers is definitely should be part of your strategy.
SPEAKER_01And so last question on creator codes is like speaking a little bit more practically, let's say I'm trying to set something up. I want to offer an influencer some kind of commission split to that creator and whether it's discount to the player. What are some of the industry benchmarks or standards and how should you come up with some of these splits? How do you think about that?
SPEAKER_00That is the million dollar question, isn't it? I hate to say it depends, but it really does. And what I mean by that is to a degree, it depends on the average transaction size and all of these things. So if you've got a large game that's AAA pricing, you've got a game that's going to be selling for 40, 50, 60 bucks, maybe even 100 soon, you know. Watch this space.
SPEAKER_00But you have one of these games, you have kind of high purchase value. A streamer knows that even if 1% of their viewers go and use their creator code, on a smaller percentage, like maybe a 5% of that purchase, that's still a significant source of revenue. On the flip side, if you are selling in-game content, and this is one thing for say like mobile or even game servers, the average spend on in-game purchases for UGC game servers is
lower than the price
SPEAKER_00of a AAA game by some margin. You have to, if the percentage is still that kind of 5%, you have to convert a lot more of your viewers into buyers Kevin K1min8r GameMakers
SPEAKER_00versus the kind of fee that is, or the cut that is often shared. But like I said, as a rule of thumb, we tend to see in the majority cases between, like I said, 5% and 15% is the standard that we tend to see.
SPEAKER_01And the other thing that might be surprising to a lot of people, certainly was surprising to me, was this notion of alternative payments through BNPL and crypto. And I've got some data points here, but let me actually have you speak about that. What is going on with BNPL and crypto? Because I think that the typical game studio is probably not aware of just how powerful Buy Now, Pay Later. And for our audience, there actually have been huge companies that have been built
just on this concept.
SPEAKER_01And as we talked about during the beginning of our conversation, we are in a world now where the economy is getting a little bit harder for some folks. And so having these kind of alternative payments, can you speak to the impact of those? And how do you view it? How popular are these alternative payment forms on your platform?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I'll start by saying, actually, it is something that kind of crept up on us a little bit. So, you know, one of the things that we're always doing clearly is looking at, as we talked about again, how do different players, whether that's geographically, by age, by socioeconomic kind of status, whatever it might be, how do different types of players want to buy and want to spend? That is something we have an entire team that's dedicated to that. It's literally what they do all day is like comb the world for
payment methods that
SPEAKER_00are becoming popular in Vietnam or Chile or whatever it might be. By now, PayLage and crypto payments are things that we added a number of years ago. Just more of a, we knew there was going to be some interest, but honestly, when we integrated them, we didn't know what the interest was going to be. In some ways, and I often say internally, one of my greatest Not greatest regrets, that's overstating it But one of the regrets that I've always had is I wish we had integrated crypto payments earlier Because for years, I used to be head of payments So I totally,
SPEAKER_00this blame sits squarely on my shoulders And for years, we looked at crypto and I was like, I don't see it making sense Like, if you're holding Bitcoin, you're probably holding it because you think it's going to go up in value You're not going to spend it, you know And I never saw it as more than a kind of a niche thing And then eventually I was like, yeah, maybe I'm wrong. I was checking my own, have I just got a preconceived notion that's wrong here? So we went, you know, we're going to try it. We added it to the platform. We genuinely didn't know what the uptake was going to be like.
SPEAKER_00It could have been completely nothing. It could have been crazy. It could have been in between. And very similar to BNPL. We knew that it was growing in popularity. We knew that certain regions of the world, it was picking up traction. We didn't know. Tim K1min8r GameMakers
SPEAKER_00in some regions is double. The average transaction value is double for someone using Buy Not Pay Later. For crypto, again, very similarly, and actually in certain regions, I think it's LATAM, it's more, it's about 150%. It's over double the average spend. And we see that, we thought, okay, maybe it's a quirk in the data. Maybe it's a, is it just that these are quite sophisticated buyers? Because if you're holding crypto, you're probably quite sophisticated. You probably know what you're doing. You know your way around a computer. So is it just that they're more sophisticated and they spend more anyway? So we then started doing cohort analysis and we were like, well, hold on.
SPEAKER_00Maybe it's not. Maybe, you know, let's look at just players that have used crypto. made a card transaction and we would look at their average spend on card transactions and their average spend on crypto and yes the difference isn't quite as big they did typically spend a bit more but it was still like 70% higher than their non-crypto spend and Buy Now Pay Later very similarly was depending on the region, whether it was US or Europe or kind of Australia or New Zealand, interestingly, you know, anywhere between 50% and 70% uplift on what that same cohort
spent if they were
SPEAKER_00using a card. So yeah, we found that super fascinating. We actually wrote a white paper on this or co-authored a white paper last year with NewZoo related to this. So that's well worth checking out. It's a good read. But yeah, absolutely, like anybody who isn't considering crypto, isn't considering buy now, pay later, BNPL, honestly is missing a trick at this point.
SPEAKER_01Got it. And in terms of the kinds of players, you mentioned that the average spend is roughly similar. But would you characterize it that way? So these are just like, from at least a payments perspective, they're going to act like a typical spender in your game. It's just that K1min8r GameMakers
I think they're two slightly different cohorts I will start by saying I think although the data is very similar across the two I think they are slightly different cohorts BMPL kind of uses from the data that we've seen and kind of some of the investigations that we've done it does tend to be a you know again it comes
SPEAKER_00back to the thing that we've talked about that you know people still need entertainment people still need leisure Just because spending money is having to be stretched further, people are having to budget more carefully, that doesn't mean we can K1min8r GameMakers
SPEAKER_00But it allows them to budget that spend. So if they know they're going to buy this new game, they're going to play it for the next two months, three months. So actually, splitting the cost over that time that they're going to be playing this game absolutely makes sense. Because that's literally what they're doing. They are spreading the cost over the time that they're playing that game. So for Buy and Pay Later, I think that is very much the case and the data that we've seen definitely reflects that.
SPEAKER_00For crypto, I think you're spot on. I think it is the fact that not everywhere except crypto, spending crypto isn't necessarily easy. And so when you see an opportunity to spend it on something that you enjoy and something that you see the value in, it absolutely makes sense. And You're probably going to be incentivized into spending, if you have it available, spending a bit more because it's not the money that you're using to buy your groceries. It's not the money you're using to pay rent. It's not the money you're using to put fuel in your car or
charge your car or
SPEAKER_00whatever it might be. It is this kind of separate pool of resource that you have that is more discretionary by its very nature.
SPEAKER_01Got it. And maybe I'll ask you one more question around BNPL and crypto, which was some data I saw about There being a surge in January of this year with the Hytale launch, but a lot of it was attributed to BNPL and crypto. So could you explain that for our audience? Why would that support lead to kind of this surge in Hytale?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and again, I think it's exactly that first thing that I pointed to where Hytale is such a great story. It's a story worthy of Hollywood, if you ask me. Maybe that's just me. But yeah, it was started out of a UGC server. Like this is that thing that it brings this whole thing full up. Hytale was born out of Hypixel Studios, which was born out of them running the Hypixel Minecraft server. That is what gave them the money to start this whole project. a number of years ago. Obviously it got acquired and it went through some different kind of rebuilds and rewrites and it was going to launch and then it was delayed and
then it was going to launch again and then it was delayed and this kind of ebb and flow definitely
SPEAKER_00happened. And then kind of the redemption arc almost where the studio was shut down, Riot sort of said, look, we're closing the studio, this game's not going to be released. And for the original founders to acquire it back, and obviously we worked very closely with those guys, I am pretty sure some of the actual founder, Simon, who reacquired this, didn't sleep for about two weeks straight, I swear. It's like he seemed to be on constantly to get this game ready. And the dedication and the passion that went into it was honestly incredible. It was incredible to win this.
SPEAKER_00It's incredible to have a tiny, like our parts play in it is tiny. Like, let's be real. We try and leverage and make that business stuff easier. But those guys are the heroes. Getting it from the point that they acquired it to getting ready in a few months is honestly like an incredible, incredible achievement. was very much clear because at the very beginning, you know, Hytale said, right, we're going to have three different tiers. So you've got the basic game and you'll get access to the game, but there's different benefits to the different tiers.
SPEAKER_00There's the basic game. Anyone who wants to play by the basic tier, absolutely, we are so appreciative of everybody's support. And then there was the mid-tier, offered a bit more for people that wanted to support them a bit more and are able to do so. And then there was the Curse Breaker tier. And I love the name Curse Breaker because for so long, it's a bit like the whole X is going to happen before GTA 6 is released or whatever. Like it was this whole thing that Hytale is cursed. Every time these things happened and they got delayed and everything else. So to be able to say,
Simon, to be able to say, look, we're breaking the curse.
SPEAKER_00It is going live on this date. The curse is lifted. The curse is broken. and allowing the supporters in the community to be part of that is super, super, super, super powerful. But again, it's that thing that the curse breaks it, it is the most expensive. And if you know you're going to be playing this game for a long time, and again, the joy of games that have UGC at their core, the joy of games that recognize that actually allowing servers, allowing modding is what keeps a game relevant for decades. We are measuring the life cycle of some of these games in decades now.
SPEAKER_00Minecraft, Still super popular, well into its second decade. GTA V with 5M and roleplay servers, again, super relevant in a decade on. Knowing that I'm buying a game that I'm going to get value out of for years to come absolutely makes sense. Well, why I want to make the biggest kind of show of support that I can But I don't necessarily want to pay all that right now So actually splitting it over a couple of months When I know I'm going to get far more
than a couple of months of value out of it Totally makes sense So I think a lot of it is that It's very much that there's the opportunity to really support a game It was incredible
SPEAKER_00The pre-orders alone, as Simon announced on X The pre-orders alone secured the future of the studio for two years And then on top of that, obviously they then had kind of actual launch sales and all that, which completely gives them such a long life cycle for this game. But yeah, pre-orders alone secured the studio's future and secured the game's survival. And being able to do that, but as a player, maximizing the support I can give without unduly stressing my kind of finances
SPEAKER_00right now, being able to split it and budget for it over multiple months, it's kind of a no-brainer. in so many ways. And that's why there was such a big, you know, uplifting in the use of Buy Now Pay Later and crypto for the, you know, the kind of more discretionary spend argument that we talked about that we saw with Hytale.
SPEAKER_01Liam, in the interest of time, maybe there's one other aspect to payments that I'd love to ask you about. And if you have time, I'd love to hear a little bit more about your story, a little bit more about Tebex. But the last aspect around payments that I'd love to hear more about is this notion of payment optimization. And you've already touched upon, for example, when we think about geographical differences, there's a lot of local payment options. We've also talked about single-click checkouts. presumably you guys are working with so many different
platforms you've seen a lot of different kinds of checkout data so in theory you guys would have a lot of understanding of how players pay and you would be able to optimize that so could you speak to that like what are some of the things that you guys are doing to like optimize payments and how would that be beneficial to a game studio absolutely so I
SPEAKER_00think there there's kind of 3 different parts of this so you can almost see them as different levels there's like levels of optimisation a bit like as you progress through a game and the game gets progressively harder so the easy answer and anyone who's looking at payments whether that's in gaming whether that's in other areas absolutely this is the thing you have to understand first is how do players want to pay locally
SPEAKER_00And what I mean by that is, we talked about it at the beginning, that even within kind of Europe, there are certain countries where cards do not have the same penetration. And a lot of these players, like a lot of players in Germany, absolutely do have a credit card or a debit card. They will have a Visa card or a MasterCard or an Amex or whatever, but they don't want to use them. And the minute you throw any type of friction, and this is honestly, this is Payments 101, Any time you throw any level of friction, you are going to see drop-off.
SPEAKER_00And if they have to go, well, if I don't like, I feel uncomfortable using my card, which is very much kind of the thing that we see, you are going to lose a portion of that audience. And so that's number one is understanding like in Germany, what is, how do people think, how do people want to spend in Brazil? How do people think, how do people want to spend in Korea or Australia or wherever? How do people think? How do they want to spend? So that's your first layer, is understanding geographic nuances. The second one comes back to that thing that we've just talked about.
SPEAKER_00It comes back to, even within an individual player, how I choose to spend might vary depending on what I'm buying and how much I'm spending. For example, if I am making a large purchase, Even though it is actually slightly less convenient because I'm actually going to find my card or whatever else, I'm likely to use my points card because I go, actually, I'm making a $100 purchase or a ÂŁ100 purchase. I'm going to use my points card because I'm going to get some points.
SPEAKER_00If I'm making a $5 purchase, I'm probably going to go, well, it's not worth the effort to go and find my wallet, go and find my card. There's an option there that I know, account to account, open banking in Europe. Something that's happened over the last few years where I know straight from my PC, I can click that, my bank screen will come up, I can key my details, it sends the money, easy. I'm not going to get points on it, but it's convenient. So even as an individual, how I purchase and understanding that human psyche element almost on different
SPEAKER_00purchases have different payment styles is number two. Number three is very much Again, it is back to reducing friction, but in a different way. So trying to optimize for payment methods that hide the least amount of work. So we talked about it, like open banking is an example, but save payment methods. Now, when we talk about save payment methods, most people just think of saving cards. So that's a good example. You put card details in, you put save this card for next time. And we do that. And again, leveraging this network effect of Tebex.
SPEAKER_00We can, you know, see a player that's maybe bought on a Minecraft server and they choose to save their payment method. So now when they go to Hytale to buy Hytale or they go to a different Minecraft server or they go and buy, they join a 5M roleplay server. We already know who they are. We already know their payment details. They don't have to go through all that process again. They can go, oh, yeah, I recommend Tebex. I'm used to Tebex. I've done this before. They've got my details. Click, click, done. There's no keying anything. There's no going through authentication and any of that stuff,
SPEAKER_00they can literally just get straight back into playing. So that is super powerful as well is having that network effect and that third tier of saving, seeing players across the ecosystem. And it's something that if you're doing this kind of yourself, that's challenging because you only have your environment, your ecosystem of data. Whereas, like I said, we can have players in and coming back to the point we made earlier about a lot of Hytale players because they already played Minecraft. They had already made purchases, whether that was on a Hypixel server or somebody else's server,
SPEAKER_00they'd already made these purchases, saved their payment details so they could come straight in and be like, oh, this is great. This is TebEx. I know this flow. I've done this plenty of times before. My card's already saved. Click the button. Happy days. So that's kind of the third tier is, yeah, those three tiers, understand geography, understand that even within an individual player, how they behave will differ depending on context. And then third of all, giving players as many opportunities as possible to reduce friction, safe payment methods so that the next time they come back, it's a one-click process.
SPEAKER_01Right. I think maybe the most interesting point, at least for me, of what you just talked about is like this notion of the friction in payments to D to C and relative to the average transaction value, right? So one thing, one argument you can make is that By using Tebex or the know-how and the things that you guys can do to just reduce that friction, you can argue that you're going to be able to then allow a D2C
transaction to occur
SPEAKER_01at a lower average transaction value. So I thought that was a really interesting point. And I can totally see that happening from my own personal experience. I know like when I'm buying stuff online, whether it's shoes or, you know, a desk or whatever, and I can just use Google payments and just click rather than, oh, I got to put all this stuff in again. Then, yeah, it's definitely like, yeah, it feels like, OK, yeah, now I want to do it.
SPEAKER_00And the level of intent that you need definitely scales with like given price and spend and all these sorts of things right so yeah absolutely I mean you know I'm still of you know it's taken me a long time and you know it's kind of an aside but it's an amusing story and I think it does illustrate the point that Up until probably the last couple of years, I was still of a certain or I am of a certain generation where big purchases were laptop purchases. Like I would never buy flights from my phone. Like it seemed like the amount that I'm spending didn't compute
with me doing it on
SPEAKER_00this tiny mobile mobile device. Steve for a long time I know that is absolutely insane like I fully recognize this and yet up until probably the last couple of years like I had oh no this is a laptop purchase I need I need my actual like screen and keyboard to make this purchase versus this is a couple of a few dollars yeah absolutely I'll buy on my phone Now I have kind of seen the light in the last couple of years and now like I actually did buy flights from my phone to LA not that long ago
but you know it's that same concept that the higher the spend the more kind of intent that has to be from the player or the buyer's perspective and you know giving them the information
SPEAKER_00they need being very transparent is super important. But also, you know, making it easy. So when it is a lower, when they don't need to think as much, making it as easy as possible for them just to go, okay, cool. Yeah, I'm good with this. Let's get on and let's get back to playing and spend, as we like to say internally, spend as little time paying and as much time playing as possible. That is something that is absolutely super important.
SPEAKER_01And to that point, in terms of the trust factor, too, like if somebody's already paid with Tebex and if you're a relatively unknown studio and it's like, oh, do I trust this? Oh, wait, it's Tebex. OK, I've already paid there. So why not?
SPEAKER_00Exactly. A lot of we have those consistencies and standards across the board where it's like for things like subscriptions, you know, if you see Tebex and you're like, OK, I'm going to subscribe to this Battle Pass, you know that actually the experience, if you do need to cancel that subscription, it's like, you know, we will have the We have financial things. I might need to pause it for a month. I might need to cancel it for a couple of months because, you know, maybe there's been a medical bill, you know, whatever else it might be. You know, with Tebex, that's going to be dead straightforward. You're not going to be asked to jump through, you know, 50 hoops and make a phone call to a call center in the middle
of nowhere or
SPEAKER_00anything like that. You know the experience. You know what it's going to be. And then the next time you come back to renew that subscription, you've got that level of confidence that, hey, actually, I know that this is safe. I know I can trust this. And that in itself, I think, is a really valuable thing to build consistency and trust and confidence in your player base.
SPEAKER_01So Liam, I've had you for quite a long time. So I'll like end my D2C questions. But for me, I actually find some of the more personal stories and like the story behind the scenes of a business even more interesting. So if you have some time, I'd love to ask you a few more questions about TEDx and about you personally.
SPEAKER_00I did warn you I could talk about this for years.
SPEAKER_01Great. Awesome. So let's start with Tebex because I think this is a really fascinating story. And some of our audience might be familiar with Tebex, but maybe not so much about Lee McNeil, who founded Bycraft when he was 16 years old out of his, I guess his,
SPEAKER_00you know, parents house. His childhood bedroom. Yes. And so the business, I think, started with a ÂŁ20 investment or something like that.
SPEAKER_01Could you tell us the story? Like, how did this business kind of start?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I'm a little bit jealous. Like, I've always said this, and I said this very openly internally. Lee, you know, to start kind of Bycraft, what became Tebex, at the age of 16, with literally $20, I think it was $26 or ÂŁ20, to buy the domain. That was it. That was the starting money, was to buy the domain, and that was the whole thing. And to go from that to kind of where we are now is incredible. So yeah, he had always been involved in gaming. He saw this need, as we talked about, Minecraft was starting to take off.
SPEAKER_00And he saw this absolute need that these servers were popping up. And it was almost like this Wild West, as we said, you know, like how you supported a server would be you'd send money to a random PayPal address and maybe your reward would turn up, maybe it wouldn't. And obviously that wasn't going to be sustainable. Servers would be up one day, down the next They didn't have money to cover the hosting costs Whatever apps And so Lee started Bycraft as it was then To address that pain point To be like, look,
SPEAKER_00he could see that need was there And that's what he did So yeah, he started it with that initial money to buy the domain. And he told me the story about the fact that basically in those early days, every time someone subscribed to Tebex, he would run down the stairs and tell his parents, oh my God, like someone's just subscribed. Someone's just paid me 9.99 or whatever it was, 4.99 back then, I think. And I know, and I'm sure he won't mind me sharing the story. And his dad would look at him and be like, tomorrow it's going to be even more and one day you'll be a millionaire.
which is I mean so lovely like I love it and every time you know I've heard him tell this story many times and I love it and I've met his dad and he's absolutely exactly what he would say so I can verify the authenticity of that as well and so yeah so he started it he kind of did the original thing so the original code base the original version of Bycraft and TebX was built with his hands we didn't have AI to the degree we have now 16 years ago it wasn't a vibe coded thing it was like
SPEAKER_00every line of code painstakingly written And then I joined a few years later. He ran it himself and one childhood friend ran Bycraft for the first five years of its life, basically five, six years of its life. And that was incredible. And they got to a point where I was like, okay, we want to take this to the next level. I joined, and yeah, it's one of those interesting things.
SPEAKER_01Could you actually talk about that? So you have these two kids, two kids, I guess he's 16, operating for two years, so he's 18 years old. So what were you doing, and what was his pitch to you to get you to join him?
SPEAKER_00You know what? You're not the first person that's asked me, honestly. So yeah, definitely. So I think my family thought I was mad, honestly. So I mean... Yeah, I don't want to talk about myself. It's boring, but I will do slightly. You know, I came from a, you know, I've always been a gamer. And actually, when I joined like Biocraft, my kind of journey came full circle. But I'll talk about that in a second. So I was working at a digital agency doing kind of Magento websites back then. That was like the height of e-commerce at that point,
how times have changed.
SPEAKER_00And I was looking around, I was going, you know, I was thinking about whether it was time to make a move into something else. And someone that I knew was like, oh, there's this role at this company called Bycraft. And I was like, okay, so what do they do? And so she gave me the summary going, well, they're building kind of gaming, kind of game server kind of monetization and web shops and things. And I was like, okay, that's, it was kind of relevant to what I'd been doing with kind of Magento and stuff. And I was always you know like I said the reason I got into technology was to build a clan website for my the Unreal Tournament clan I was part of way back in in
the day so you know this whole thing kind of bringing it back full circle I kind of like the idea so yeah I spoke to Lee and you're right it's like even at that point so I had two children of my own or at that point and stepchildren so I have four kids and I was
SPEAKER_00talking to these these you know almost kids themselves. I feel terrible saying that because he is quite literally the smartest guy I think I've ever met, but they work. And I'm sat in this room going, what am I doing? But I really believed in what they were trying to build. You know, I really believe that actually supporting creators, UGC, game servers, mods, all of these things are going to be what creates long living games. I fully understood that. I fully bought into
this whole concept and so yeah I was like you know what I sat and I spoke to spoke to them for way more than I was supposed to I think we were booked in for an hour and two hours later we were still talking about this stuff and I was like you know what I need to get in on this like I love it this is the thing that I was meant to
SPEAKER_00be part of And so, yeah, I joined, I had a, I think the company I was at, I had a three months notice period. It was probably the longest three months of my life. Like a kid at Christmas, like I can't wait to get started. And yeah, and I joined actually to run the tech side of the business. As I said, my background, I learned to program, to build a matchmaking and clan website for an Unreal Tournament clan. So it was, like I said, it was almost like a homecoming in that sense. Joined to do the technology side of the business. There was still that, those days, We were all sat around Lee's kitchen table. Like every day,
my commute was traveling to his apartment to sit around his table as we built some
SPEAKER_00of this stuff out. Like that was the, that's how it was. And we continued to grow. And like I said, we moved from just doing Minecraft into doing other game servers. Then we moved into doing kind of the actual merchant record piece and handling the payments and the tax and offering. We've always offered chargeback insurance from day one. We've never taken money for chargebacks off of creators, you know, in the UGC space, in the game server space as well. And then we started having conversations with Overwatch. This happened over the course of a couple of years where their
view on these things
SPEAKER_00was very similar. It's like, you know, mods and overlay apps and creative content absolutely should become a profession. And, you know, our job and Oval's job was like, how can we strip away all the complexity so they can focus on that thing that they do, building these brilliant apps, building these brilliant mods, and we'll handle the rest of it. And so we started talking with the leadership team at Oval, and it was just so apparent that our view on these things was so tightly connected. We absolutely saw the progression of UGC as a career.
SPEAKER_00in very much the same way. And I think honestly, had we not joined forces, had we not been acquired by Overwolf, I think that would have been crazy. Like it wouldn't have made sense. It seemed like the most natural thing ever. And as with all M&As, it took a while. But yeah, that was over four years ago. We've continued to grow individually as Tebex since when we were acquired. We only had a headcount of eight still. We were still a very small company. We never took investment. We never took Debt, like everything that we did to grow, every cent that we spent was we made money,
SPEAKER_00we then used it to grow the business further. We made money, we used it to grow the business further. So, you know, we were a very small, very lean team of eight. Thankfully, with Oval support over the last four years, we've been able to grow. We've now got a headcount just within Tebex of just shy of 60 across payments and support and tech and partner success and operations and all of these things as well. So It's been an absolute kind of, in many ways, a joyride. I do still, and it sounds very cliche and I almost regret saying it,
SPEAKER_00but I genuinely wake up every morning excited to get started. The kids will go off to school and I'm like, right, I can't wait to jump in and do what we do. And it's something that I've thoroughly enjoyed for the last decade. I've been with Tebex now for a decade of my life. I love the fact that we help. developers from indie developers to individual creators to large studios support their teams. And people are putting money on the table, food on the table. People are paying mortgages and paying rent and all these
things because of what we
SPEAKER_00enable them to do. And that's kind of the most exciting thing about being part of TEDx, I suppose.
SPEAKER_01A couple more questions. So like going back to when you joined and, you know, obviously when you joined, it was not It was a much smaller scale. But for our audience, there was that exit, as you mentioned. I think it was reported as like $29 million exit. And you've grown to 60. So there's been a big success there. But when you were sitting there at that kitchen table, did you imagine it would have this kind of success? Like, what... What was in your mind in terms of what the potential of the
business was? And maybe the other question to ask along those lines is what was the inflection point that was able to turn the business into this much more highly scaled kind of
SPEAKER_01business?
SPEAKER_00Honestly, no. I have said this to Lee before, and I've been very, very, very honest with Lee. There were times kind of in some of the early days that even I mentioned and I joked about the fact that my family, as I said, when I joined Tebex, I already had four kids. And there was... There were times that I looked and went, what are you doing? Like, I don't mind disclosing this. When I first joined TebX, I took a pay cut from my role. I was incredibly, some might say, overpaid in the role I was in before. And then I joined TebX and I believed that much in what we were
doing that I took a
SPEAKER_00pay cut to join. But that doesn't mean in those early days, there weren't times that I sat there and went, I don't know if I've made the right choice. Like, did I honestly think we would get to the point that we didn't? I had faith and conviction that we would because I truly believed that what we were building was important. But in those days, the original Tebex and Bycraft model was a subscription model. We charged $9.99 a month, $14.99 a month, whatever it was. And that was it. The only way to scale was to get more people.
SPEAKER_00We We were investing in the success of these servers. We were providing guidance and making recommendations to make these creators grow their revenue and help them make more money. But what we were able to kind of get from that deal was only very, very small. And so that was very much the inflection point actually was recognizing in some ways our own value. Like I think, you know, as we and so many small startup businesses do this kind of almost
under underestimate their own value and the value that they're bringing and when we actually kind of
SPEAKER_00sat and recognized actually hang on like we are we're Helping these creators not have to hire huge numbers of people. They're not having to hire fraud analysis and support staff and all of this stuff. And we're dealing with global payments where we're increasing their revenue. Sometimes by enabling local payments in certain markets, we're unable to double the revenue that some of these servers were making by protecting them against chargebacks, by going, you know what, you're never going to pay a cent for chargebacks. We've got that covered. That is on us. We brought so much value that maybe we...
SPEAKER_00didn't fully realize that to start off with. And kind of the launch of the Tebex checkout project, the merchant record product, working with 5M as the launch partner for that was the point where we went, actually, we are like really like massively bringing value and we could sit there with complete confidence, complete kind of faith and say, look, we are going to take a cut of each transaction, but we are going to work damn hard to make sure we can justify it.
SPEAKER_00And that was the light bulb moment for me.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So very last question. You mentioned, it sounds like you're very optimistic and you thought that the relationship with Overwolf sounds like it was very good, but could you talk about that? So post-acquisition, how did things change for you personally for the business and then it sounded like you're able to to like get additional skill is that because of something to do with the overwolf network or how did they add value to to TEDx it's
a whole combination of things and I will try and keep this as short as I can I promise um but it is
SPEAKER_00absolutely a whole a whole combination of things so um day one um Not too much, changed in many ways early on. Tebex still ran Tebex operations. We still did everything we did from our team in the UK. Lee and I actually were together when the contracts were signed and it was all made official. We had a bottle of champagne that we had sat there for for many months where we were getting through all the due
diligence and all of this
SPEAKER_00stuff and all the usual things. And yeah, that was an amazing, amazing evening when, you know, finally the contracts were signed. It was all official. You know, we spoke to Ori, the CEO of Overwolf on the phone and we opened the champagne and, you know, we had a bit of a celebration. But the next day we were back to work. You know, we were still supporting thousands of game server owners. We, you know, these people were still relying on us to put food on the table, to make rent, to pay mortgages,
SPEAKER_00whatever else. So, you know, the next day we were back to work. And Overwolf has been fantastic to be part of that business group because we are still allowed to make, you know, a lot of our own decisions. We still decide how we sell, what we do, how we position, what we do, what vendors we're working with, what providers we're working with. they absolutely our HQ team provides so much support and one of the things that I loved was a lot of the operation stuff that I used to do I was able to give away my
role had changed from being kind of CTO when I first joined to being managing a lot of the operations kind of finance and HR and these sorts of things so you know when
SPEAKER_00we were when we were acquired by Overwolf being able to say to the HQ team, here you go, here's all this operation stuff I don't need to worry about anymore. That was an amazing experience. And so they were super supportive on that side of things. It's like, look, you tell us what you want to be doing. We will kind of deal with everything else. And that was amazing. And you know what? I'm not going to sit here and lie. Yes, being part of a well-known and well-respected brand such as Overwolf
clearly it opened some doors you know I'm not gonna sit here and pretend it doesn't you know there were certain meetings I'm not gonna name names but there were certain meetings that we had tried for years to get you know we would hound execs we would chase them down at Gamescom we would chase them down at GDC and it was always like oh you know maybe later yeah we'll get some time in speak to my you
SPEAKER_00know speak to my assistant whatever um You know, we get acquired. We are now part of the overall pack. We're part of this, this, you know, well-respected, well-known brand. And like the next day it's like, Hey, can we meet? And I'm like, we've, we've been trying to speak to you guys for like two years, but, but, you know, I get it. And it's that, it's that old adjutant. It's, you know, no one, no one ever got fired for buying IBM. And, you know, you go with a, a small eight person team based in Nottingham in the UK and, you There is a kind of level of risk.
SPEAKER_00If that all goes wrong, someone's going to look like an idiot. You go with a well-respected, well-established, well-known and respected brand such as Overwolf, you know you've got that level of safety and security. So absolutely, I always had absolute faith and I knew that we were doing things the right way. But having that, again, it's that social validation, it's that whole, there's that extra level of comfort and proof that being part of this amazing family that we are now part of brings.
SPEAKER_01All right, Liam. Well, you know, I think I've had your time for quite a while now, so appreciate all of the insights and, you know, kind of all of the description in terms of the industry. So for anyone who's interested in you personally, is there any way that they can get in touch with you or find out more about what you're doing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I'm always happy to chat, whether it's gaming, whether it's modding, whether it's payments. Best thing is finding me on LinkedIn. So I am just Liam Wiltshire on LinkedIn. Otherwise, reach out to the Tebex team, tebex.io. Absolutely always happy to talk payments, modding, and everything in between.
SPEAKER_01Great. So I will leave a link to your LinkedIn in the show notes. But thank you so much for your time, Liam, and for our audience. We will catch you next time. Thanks.
I like to think about game development as product velocity, and velocity is a vector. It has a magnitude, which is how fast you build, and a direction, which is whether you’re building the right thing. AI is pushing the...
Kalie Moore ran the prompts across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. What came back turns game discoverability into a PR problem, and she gave me the playbook she uses to fix it. When I ask people in games what PR is...
The story is that AI isn’t paying off, that the ROI just isn’t there, that the org charts and the earnings calls are still waiting for the productivity spike. Harsh Savergaonkar and I are pretty extreme vibe coders....
In 2002, Electronic Arts banned ICQ - the office chat app - and put a single internet terminal in the center of the building. A programmer named Steve Ganem responded with what he calls “civil disobedience”: he built...
Here’s the top of the Fortnite metaverse, as of June 20, 2026, during a Saturday night at around 8 pm EDT: (Source: fortnite.gg) #1. Battle Royale: 549.3k concurrent players. #2. A battle royale variant: 97.7k #3....