Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

GameMakers

GameMakers artwork

The Gaming Industry Isn't in a Downturn. It's Losing Its Moat.

Feb 17, 202614 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

I told you last week that the gaming industry is losing its moat. Now here’s the data. The GDC 2026 State of the Industry report surveyed over 2,300 game professionals. It’s the most comprehensive snapshot we get of what’s actually happening inside this industry. The report presents data without a thesis - that’s its job. My job is different. I’ve been developing an argument about where this industry is headed, and the GDC data confirms it almost point by point. Here’s the argument: the gaming industry’s historical moats - capital, talent, technology - are all collapsing at the same time. Not slowly. Not theoretically. Right now. Three moats. Let’s go. 1. The Money Moat For decades, you needed money to make games. Real money. Publisher advances. Venture rounds. Platform deals. The development cycle was long, expensive, and required capital just to get in the room. That’s ending. Not slowly. Not theoretically. But it’s not over yet - and the studios that recognize they’re in the middle of this shift, not past it, are the ones with the advantage. 35% of developers say self-funding is their primary source of funding. For solo devs, it’s 86%. Publishing deals? 20%. VC and private investment? 5% each. Crowdfunding, seed rounds, bank loans, accelerators - all at 1% or below. Platform-based funding sits at 2%. Read those numbers again. The entire infrastructure of game financing - publishers, platform deals, VC - accounts for less than half of how games get funded. Most developers are funding themselves. And it’s not by choice. The money isn’t just expensive - it’s gone. “We attempted to secure venture capital... and got 0 bites and a lot of: ‘Wow, if you had pitched this 2 years ago, you’d already be funded.’” - Director (Game Design), California “There’s basically no funding at our scale: we’re too expensive for indie, too small for AA/AAA. Award-winning studio, ‘Triple I,’ prestige and history, but there’s a gap.” - Senior Employee (Game Programming), Virginia “Platform deals have dried up (Game Pass, PS+ etc.), which used to be a great way to finance indie games.” - C-Level (Independent Studio 5+ Years), California The “Triple-I” squeeze is real. Studios too big to bootstrap but too small for AAA publishing deals are getting crushed. The funding infrastructure wasn’t designed for a world where the cost of building dropped faster than everything else. But here’s the thing. If building games is cheap, why does anyone need money at all? » Distribution. « When the GDC report asked what matters most when choosing a platform, audience reach was #1 at 78%. Discoverability: 43%. Top marketing methods? Social media (65%), streamers (39%), paid advertising (31%). The money you used to spend building the game? You’re about to spend it making anyone notice it exists. I wrote about this last week - when anyone can build an app, and nobody has patience, you get a billion apps and seconds to prove yours matters. The moat didn’t vanish. It moved. 2. The People Moat You used to need a big team. Dozens of artists, engineers, designers, QA testers, producers, and PMs to coordinate them all. Scale was the price of entry. Not anymore. 77% of newer indie studios have fewer than 20 employees. 11% of respondents at newer studios work entirely alone. Across the full survey, 8% identify as solo developers - and they’re shipping real products, not hobby projects. I wrote about this in September - The Great Western Game Development Divergence. The breakout hits on Steam and PC aren’t coming from 200-person studios. They’re coming from teams of 1 to 20. Lethal Company. Schedule 1. Project Zomboid. The GDC data confirms that pattern at scale. Meanwhile, the big teams are bleeding out. 28% of respondents have been laid off in the past two years. In the US, it’s 33% - one in three. And it’s getting worse: 17% laid off in the past 12 months, up from 11% the year before. For AAA specifically, 19% personally laid off in the past year - more than double the prior period. Of those laid off, 48% still haven’t found another job. For people laid off 1-2 years ago, 36% are still looking for work. The “course correction” everyone hoped for didn’t arrive. The jobs aren’t coming back. The companies say it’s “restructuring” (43%), “budget cuts” (38%), and “market conditions” (38%). The people who got fired have a different take: “Executives who have never actually worked as a dev are pulling up the boards on their ships, throwing people overboard, and expecting these scuttled ghost ships to keep making them infinite money.” - Former Senior Employee (Game Design), New York And the pipeline is breaking too. 74% of game dev students are worried about their future job prospects. 87% of educators expect a negative impact on placement. “Most of my students will not have a career in game development.”* - Educator (Computer Science), Michigan “There aren’t any jobs. Everyone’s getting fired. It’s fucked.” - Student (Game Design), California The people moat used to mean you needed a hundred skilled professionals to ship a competitive game. Now you need five. Maybe one. The human cost of that transition is enormous - but the structural reality is clear. 3. The Technology Moat This is the one nobody wants to talk about. For decades, proprietary technology was one of the hardest moats to cross. Custom engines, institutional knowledge, and toolchains built over multiple product cycles. id Tech, Frostbite, Rockstar’s RAGE - these weren’t just tools, they were competitive weapons. That era is ending. Unreal Engine now sits at 42%, surpassing Unity (30%) for the first time. Godot is gaining traction with newer indie studios at 11%. Proprietary engines have dropped to 19%, with almost all of that in AAA. The tools to build a competitive game are available to anyone with a laptop. But the real disruption isn’t which engine you use. It’s what’s happening to the people using them. 52% of game workers think AI is having a negative impact on the industry - up from 30% last year and 18% the year before. Visual artists: 64% negative. Designers: 63%. Programmers: 59%. And executives? 19% say it’s positive. The open-ended responses capture what the percentages can’t: “AI is theft. I have to use it, otherwise I’m gonna get fired.” - Senior Employee (Visual and Technical Arts), Ukraine Read that again. A person who believes the technology is morally wrong uses it anyway because the alternative is unemployment. That’s not adoption. That’s capitulation. And it’s everywhere: “I guess I’m hypocritical about it. I’m outspokenly against AI, but then do use ChatGPT as a sounding board for some of my marketing ideas.”* - Manager (Marketing/PR), Canada “I don’t tell anyone how I use AI, for fear of backlash.” - Contributor (Game Design), California Meanwhile, on the other end: “We are intentionally working on a platform that will put all game devs out of work and allow kids to prompt and direct their own content.” - Senior Employee (Machine Learning Ops), New Mexico The technology moat isn’t collapsing from outside. People in the industry know it’s collapsing. Some are accelerating it. Most feel powerless to stop it. That’s what makes this one different from the money moat or the people moat. Those are structural shifts you can adapt to. The technology moat’s collapse comes with an identity crisis. When your tools can be replicated by anyone, what makes you you? The Moats Didn’t Vanish. They Moved. The money moat shifted from development to distribution. You don’t need $50M to build a game anymore. But you might need it to make anyone notice. The people moat shifted from team size to taste and speed. Small teams win because they move fast and build with their audience, not for them. The technology moat didn’t shift - it’s shattering. Everyone has the same tools. Everyone has access to AI. The industry hates it and uses it anyway. Studios still defending the old moats - raising money to build big teams using proprietary tech - are optimizing for a world that no longer exists. The new advantages… Get full access to GameMakers at www.gamemakers.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Last month, I joined a panel about where the game industry is headed. The conversation was good, but there was one thing I didn't say out loud. I didn't say it because quite frankly, I wasn't sure. There wasn't any data yet to back up my hypothesis. But now I have the numbers. 2,300 people responded to the GDC State of the Industry Survey. Developers, artists, producers, students, CEOs, and what they said when you put it together tells a story that

changes how you

SPEAKER_00think about this industry. The gaming industry isn't in a downturn. It's losing its moat. And most people just don't see it yet. Last week, I wrote about four trends that will define gaming 2026. The noise problem, small teams eating giants, the nobody codes anymore reality, and why the industry is losing its protective advantages. Today, we're going deep on that last one, because I promised you the data from the GDC report,

SPEAKER_00and the data is... Well, it's something. We're going section by section through what I'm calling the three moats. What's collapsing, where the advantage is moving, and why the studios that understand this will survive. And the ones that don't, won't. So let's get into it. First up, the money moat. For decades, you needed money to make games, real money, publisher advances, venture rounds, platform deals. The development cycle was long,

expensive, and required capital just to get in the room.

SPEAKER_00This is a world that has been dramatically changing, and I believe... will soon be over. According to the GDC report, 35% of developers are now self-funding their games, not 10%, not 15%. More than one in three. And for solo developers, 86% are self-funded. Why? Because the money isn't there anymore. I want to read you something from the report. This is from a senior producer in the Netherlands.

SPEAKER_00Quote, we attempted to secure venture capital and innovation loans and got zero bytes and a lot of, wow, if you had pitched this two years ago, you'd already be funded. That's not one person's story. That is the story. Platform deals, those life-saving advances from Sony or Microsoft are nearly gone. The mid-tier is being hollowed out. If you're a AAA studio, too expensive. For indie, too small. For AAA, you're in no man's land.

SPEAKER_00Here's what one American studio founder had to say. Quote, there's basically no funding at our scale. Award-winning studio, triple-I, prestige in history, but there's a gap. So you're thinking, okay, capital requirements collapsing. That's good for indies, right? Yeah, except for one thing. The money you save on building the game, you're about to spend it making anyone notice it exists. Last week, I wrote about attention compression, how TikTok trained people to evaluate a game in 16 seconds.

SPEAKER_00That 16 seconds. It's not just a TikTok problem. It's a distribution problem in a world of infinite content. If dev costs are collapsing and more games are shipping, which they are, and AI is accelerating both production and marketing, which it is, then the scarce resource isn't capital, it's attention. And attention isn't free. The money moat didn't vanish, it moved. You don't need 50 million to build a game anymore,

SPEAKER_00but you might need 50 million to make anyone care. Second moat, people. For years, the advantage was headcount. Big teams meant big games. You needed 200 people, 300 people, 600 people to ship something competitive. The expertise lived in expensive senior engineers. The institutional knowledge took years to build. Not anymore. The GDC data here is stark. 77% of newer indie studios have fewer than 20 people.

SPEAKER_00Solo developers are at 8%. And these aren't hobbyists. These are people shipping commercial games, building audiences, finding success. Meanwhile, 28% of developers have been laid off in the past two years. Of those who lost their jobs, 48% are still unemployed. That's not a downturn. That's a restructuring. And here's where it gets uncomfortable. The education pipeline? Breaking.

SPEAKER_00I want to read you three quotes. First, an educator in the UK, quote, most of my students will not have a career in games development, end quote. Second, another educator, quote, there are hardly any junior level positions. It doesn't make sense to invest time and effort into training people for jobs that don't exist, end quote. Third, a student in the U.S. There aren't any jobs. Everyone's getting fired. It's fucked.

SPEAKER_00End quote. That's 87% of educators expecting negative impacts on student placement. 87%. So the workforce is bifurcating. Small teams can ship. Big teams are shedding people. And the pipeline that used to feed the industry with fresh talent, it's drying up. But here's the twist. AI is compressing the experience curve too. You don't need 20 years of shader programming to get a lighting engine working.

AI handles the early work, the brainstorming, the prototyping, the first draft.

SPEAKER_0081% of developers use it for research and ideation. But when it comes to the final product, the thing the player actually touches, only 5% are using AI there. The gap between AI as a thinking partner and AI as a shipping tool is enormous. You just need someone who knows what good looks like. The report shows 36% of developers are already using AI at work for prototyping, for coding, for art generation. So the people moat,

SPEAKER_00the idea that you needed a big, experienced team to compete, that's eroding from two sides. Smaller teams are viable, and AI is making experience less scarce. Okay, third moat, technology. Engines used to be emote. Proprietary tech used to matter. Having your own render or physics system was a competitive advantage. It took years to build, millions to maintain, and it kept smaller competitors out.

SPEAKER_00Those days are ending. Look at the engine data from the GDC report. For the first time, Unreal Engine has surpassed Unity in market share, 42% versus 30%. But here's what's actually happening. It's not about which engine wins. It's that engines don't differentiate anymore. Only 19% of developers are still on proprietary engines. That number keeps dropping. And then there's AI. I told you last week, in Silicon Valley, nobody codes anymore.

SPEAKER_00Here's what the survey actually shows. 36% of developers are using AI tools at work right now. That's more than one in three. 47% for coding and programming, 35% for prototyping. But here's the split that matters. Executives are at 47% adoption. Individual contributors, 29%. The people making decisions are betting on AI. The people doing the work

SPEAKER_00are terrified of it or not allowed to use it. And here's the best quote of the entire report. This is from a senior employee in Ukraine working in visual and technical arts. Quote, AI is theft. I have to use it. Otherwise, I'm going to get fired. End quote. That single sentence, that is the entire industry right now. The moat isn't just gone, the people inside know it's gone. And they're using the thing that destroyed it because if they

don't, someone else will.

SPEAKER_00That's not a fringe opinion. When GDC asked developers whether AI is good or bad for the industry, 52%, the majority said it's bad. But 36% are using it anyway. The technology emote didn't just collapse. The industry is actively participating in its own disruption. Even the people who hate it are using it. Even the people who see exactly what's happening can't stop it. That's not an adoption curve.

SPEAKER_00That's a black hole with opt-in participation. And that tension, hating something you can't stop using, that's what a transition feels like from the inside. Nobody in 2011 loved free-to-play either. Developers called it exploitative. Journalists call it the death of real games. And then it became the entire industry. We're in that same window right now. So here's a question nobody's asking. If all three moats are collapsing, money, people, technology,

SPEAKER_00Who actually wins? Not the people pretending AI doesn't exist or doesn't matter. And not the people pretending AI can do everything. Both of those groups lose. The winners are in the middle. They're in the transition. Let me show you what I mean. The GDC data tells a very specific story about where AI works and where it doesn't. Right now, today, 81% of developers use AI for research and brainstorming.

SPEAKER_00That's the back office thinking work. But only 5% use it for player-facing features. 5%. That gap between AI as a thinking tool and AI as a shipping tool, that's the entire game right now. The studios that understand that gap, that have mapped exactly where AI's usefulness drops off and have kept human judgment on everything past that line, they're building an advantage that compounds every month. Think about what compounding means here.

SPEAKER_00Every month you spend learning where AI fits in your pipeline, and more importantly, where it doesn't, you're building institutional knowledge. You're developing workflows. You're training your team to work with AI's limitations instead of pretending they don't exist. And that knowledge doesn't reset. It stacks. When I say AI or bust, this is what I mean. I don't mean AI does everything. I mean, if you're not actively learning where the edges are, you're falling behind people who are,

SPEAKER_00and you won't know how far behind until it's too late. But here's the part that creates urgency. Look at the sentiment trajectory. In 2024, 18% of game workers said AI was having a negative impact. Last year, 30%. This year, 52%. The industry is waking up. Adoption is accelerating. The tools are improving. The window where understanding AI's limitations gives you a competitive advantage,

SPEAKER_00that window is compressing. In two years, this will be table stakes. Right now, it's still a moat. That's the transition trap. The studio that wait for AI to be ready will find that by the time it is. The early movers have two years of compounded learning they can never catch up to. And the studios that go all in on AI without understanding its limits will ship products that feel hollow because right now, AI can help you think,

SPEAKER_00but it can't help you feel. And there are fundamental limitations to applying AI to game development. So the winners are the ones in the middle, operating in the gap. That's where the advantage lives, at least for now. So let me bring it back to where we started, because I think the story is written by the data. The gaming industry isn't in a downturn. It's in a transition. The three moats that define who could make games,

SPEAKER_00capital, experience, talent, and proprietary technology are all collapsing at the same time. That's not a recession. That's a restructuring. And the moats aren't vanishing. They're moving. The new moat isn't how much money you raised or how long your team has been shipping. It's how well you understand the gap. between what AI can do today and what it can't, between back office tool and shipping tool, between 81% and 5%.

SPEAKER_00That gap is your window, but it won't stay this wide. So if you're running a studio right now or building one, ask yourself, do you know where your AI line is? Because that's your moat for now. Next week, I'm going deeper on each of these three motes, what specifically is replacing them, and what the new playbook looks like for studios that want to be on the right side of this. If you're not subscribed to GameMakers, now's the time. Thanks for listening.

SPEAKER_00I'll catch you next week.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Your Discord Is Lying to You. Watch What Players Build.

    Oct 22, 202654 minAudio

    I like to think about game development as product velocity, and velocity is a vector. It has a magnitude, which is how fast you build, and a direction, which is whether you’re building the right thing. AI is pushing the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. PR for Gaming Studios

    Sep 1, 202651 minAudio

    Kalie Moore ran the prompts across ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity. What came back turns game discoverability into a PR problem, and she gave me the playbook she uses to fix it. When I ask people in games what PR is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Paradox of AI ROI

    Aug 28, 202659 minAudio

    The story is that AI isn’t paying off, that the ROI just isn’t there, that the org charts and the earnings calls are still waiting for the productivity spike. Harsh Savergaonkar and I are pretty extreme vibe coders....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Most Important Number in Unity’s D2C Launch Is Zero

    Jul 14, 202643 minAudio

    In 2002, Electronic Arts banned ICQ - the office chat app - and put a single internet terminal in the center of the building. A programmer named Steve Ganem responded with what he calls “civil disobedience”: he built...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. So This Is How The Metaverse Dies

    Jun 23, 202650 minAudio

    Here’s the top of the Fortnite metaverse, as of June 20, 2026, during a Saturday night at around 8 pm EDT: (Source: fortnite.gg) #1. Battle Royale: 549.3k concurrent players. #2. A battle royale variant: 97.7k #3....

    Credit the people on this episode