Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Freight 360

Freight 360 artwork

Who Gets Judged When Freight Data Lies | Final Mile 157

Sep 15, 202616 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

πŸš› One rollover on a new authority - still bookable? ⚠️ MOTUS says suspended, paperwork says clean - who wins? ⏱️ Clean detention, customer won't pay - who eats it? Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click Here OperFi: Click Here QuikSkope - Get a Free Trial: Click Here DAT One - Brokers & Carriers: Click Here to get 10% off your first year! DAT Outgo Factoring for Carriers: Click Here AscendTMS: Click Here and use promo code RA-freight360! to get AscendTMS FREE for 90 days! Recommended Products: Click Here Freight Broker Basics Course: Click Here Join Our Facebook Group: Click Here Check out all of our content online: Click Here

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome back for another edition of the Final Mile. It's our listener QA session here on the Freight 360 podcast. These questions come from you guys. So our Facebook group is a big source for us seeing good questions on there. Same thing with YouTube, you know, comments on YouTube of a video usually spur up some good questions. But if you're brand new, check out all the other content. You can check out the sponsors in the description box to help support the channel.

SPEAKER_01And uh let's get into this one, Ben. Our first question this came from a uh a small owner operator carrier. So this guy said um it's an he's got a nine-month-old authority, and he rolled his truck when the load shifted. So the truck was totaled, no other vehicles were involved, there was no injuries. He's 62 years old, and he only had one prior accident at the age of 16, so fairly clean driving record. Would you he wants to know um for brokers, would you still book him?

SPEAKER_01Because he's running into issues with you know brokers that don't want to book his truck because basically he's got that one eyesore um crash incident with such a short authority. So I I feel like, and I wanted to kind of get your take on it from both sides. I feel like some brokers won't, and some brokers would, and it's probably very situational dependent. So if you just you know, the the ones that won't, I'll give you, you know, probably procedurally what they see is they're gonna look at the um safety um scores and percentiles and all those things online or through their carrier vetting platform.

SPEAKER_01And with such a short authority history and a big crash like that, with you know you know, basically they have nothing else to dilute that incident from their um how their safety looks, right? And then on the other side, you might have a brokerage that's like you know, hey, whatever, we're moving, um you know, low risk for damage and the price is right, they might roll with it. I'd have other questions too, though.

SPEAKER_01Like the load shifted, well, how did that happen? Like who loaded it, who secured it? Was there something did he swerve? You know, I I'd want to get more information, but I'm curious what would kind of what would sway you to use him and what would sway you against using it?

SPEAKER_00I think the nine-month thing probably hurts more than the safety rating for most of the bigger brokerages because they just have like a hard control of a year. Yeah. Um I think the safety rating is far less than the authority age. Because a lot of those are just like no budge rules. Like I think for sure when I was at TQL, I don't think I was able to ever book a truck less than a year. Again, long time ago, very different than now, but I'm guessing that's probably one of the things because I kind of really don't have as much of an issue with the safety rating.

SPEAKER_00Like if I was looking at it and I was talking to the carrier, like I would absolutely work with them. I would ask a few more questions, like, tell me a little bit about the load shifting thing. But if you've been driving from 16 to 62, and those are the only two incidences, like to me, like that's a pretty good track record.

SPEAKER_01Yep. Yeah, I mean, it could it could be too where like, you know, a smaller brokerage that gets to make their own decisions, right, has a personal relationship with the guy, right? They've loaded him before. Um, they find out, like, hey, you know, the the shipper improperly secured it and normal driving, he didn't do anything wrong. It just while going around a turn, something tipped over, and it, you know, center of center of balance, basically center of gravity, caused everything to topple over, and luckily no one got hurt.

SPEAKER_01Um, no other vehicles were involved. He'll probably say, like, yeah, it's kind of a one-off fluke, we're gonna use this guy again because he's he's been reliable, the the lane is good, um the price is right, etc. Whereas to your point, a larger company that has pretty black and white standards probably is gonna say, I don't even think about the authority length, like, he doesn't have a year authority, we just don't book those guys. Or um they could say, like, if they've had a crash recently, we're not gonna book this guy, or whatever, whatever the case might be.

SPEAKER_00So that's the other thing, too. The other thing that I think you can't really see is when was the rollover? Was it within the nine-month window? Because if you just look at the company, you're gonna see less than a year with that accident, which looks very bad. Because you what you can't tell or verify is what he also added, which is I've been driving since I'm 16. You can't see that when you look at the authority. You can't see that he's got a clean record from 16 to 62 if this theoretically happened in the past nine months.

SPEAKER_00So it really looks like a new driver with one terrible accident, not what it is, which is 50 some years or whatever of authority, which we talked about like in driver verification. And Dean and I did a deep dive when you were out, which is like you see company level. You do not see actual driving history for the people moving your freight, and you also don't see how safe they actually drive. You just see a company level. So you could see a company that looks terrible and has fired all those drivers and bought on great drivers, they still look terrible.

SPEAKER_00And vice versa. A company that looks great and has a bunch of drivers that are very likely to have an accident that they recently hired. None of that is visible to a brokerage.

SPEAKER_01Yep. You could have a driver to the point of the one-year requirement for a lot of companies. Like, let's say, you know, I've been working with a trucking company for three years, the same driver is hauling, you know, a certain load for me every week, and he decides I'm gonna go off on my own, get my own authority, become an owner operator, and you know, he wants to continue, you know, same truck, same driver, same lane, same shipment. But now because he gets his own authority, boom, he's flagged as you know, under under 12 months or whatever.

SPEAKER_01So um, those are the like kind of the exceptions that I've seen and made in the past is is usually if there's a personal relationship with and history with uh the driver who gets their their own new authority. So but interesting question. Um, I would tell if to answer the the driver directly, um, expect you to have change. Like you're gonna have brokers that won't work with you because they see that. That's just the reality behind it. So all right, next question. Um, MODIS, the new uh the wonderful new system that FMCSA has has rolled out.

SPEAKER_01Uh MODIS is showing legitimate carriers as suspended, uninsured, or inactive when there are none of those things, and the fix can take weeks. If a carrier's paperwork checks out, but the federal system says no, do you override it and book them, or is that a line that you can't cross? Um that's a great question. I'm just gonna tell you, like, my I would not. I would not until they get it the glitch fixed, because that is like the system of record. And even though it's a glitch, there was like, I think there were like 1200 carriers that were legitimate, authorized, had insurance, but for some reason the glitch showed them as like um a suspended registration or authority, whatever it was.

SPEAKER_01Um I'm sorry, Mr. or Mrs. Carrier, but I'm I'm not gonna personally cross that line because should something happen and there's a crash and there's a fatality, as we saw with Montgomery, the size of these lawsuits, the last thing I want is one more thing for a prosecution to throw in a case against me is that well, Modus said that they were suspended. Why'd you book them? And then you've got to defend, well, it was a glitch. You know, I I just I wouldn't cross that line.

SPEAKER_01Now, here's what I here's what I would do is that Can I ask you something?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Because I don't know this, because I've seen a couple of those, but I was able to go to Safer and look at the old system and see the discrepancy between the two. But I haven't seen one where it showed. I just haven't seen enough of them. I'm just curious if you have looked at any that show up like that, like personally and reviewed them and went to the old system and saw if they said the same thing.

SPEAKER_01Um have not. So I I don't know. I don't have anything for you on that one. But here's what I would do. And this kind of goes back to our last question about the authority age. So like when the glitch is fixed and it shows an active authority now, um, I'm not going to penalize that carrier for bad data historically. So if I see like you could see authority gap history on a lot of um carrier vetting platforms. So if I see that their current authority only shows active for a week because of the glitch that you know, if that still kind of shows there as like a um as a ding against them, um, I'm not gonna hold that against them.

SPEAKER_01But I'm not if the if the record the system of record, which is MODIS as of May 2026, if that is showing them as not authorized, unfortunately, I'm gonna say that's between them and MODIS to figure out. But I I'm the way that I'm seeing it in my system, I'm not gonna risk it. That's just my personal take on it. You got anything else on that one?

SPEAKER_00Not really, because like I don't actually know this. That's why I was asking. Like, I know that's the official system of record. But like, did they um I there's a word for it. Like when you roll back a system, something overlap. Yeah, that wasn't it. It's sundowning, like basically when something goes away. But like a lot of sunsetting, yeah. Yeah, sunsetting like they'll overlap, meaning like, hey, this is the new system of record, but while we transition, you can look at the old one for verification as we debug the new one.

SPEAKER_00And I don't actually know if that ever was disclosed to anybody.

SPEAKER_01Um, I believe at first, because we're I mean we're months later at this plan, but I believe at first there was a period when mod people like I know our team was would be we used both. So at one point, for like certain MODIS rolled out in phases, I believe. So like you'd see certain things in MODIS, but still have to go to Safer to see the rest. Whereas ultimately the goal is to have MODIS for everything. Um so I don't know for sure, but yeah, there was probably a period of time when you know you could reference the old one.

SPEAKER_01So um, interesting, interesting question. So um, all right. Next one, um okay, so this is a clean carrier was for a um delivery, or I don't know if it's pickup or delivery, but it was on time, had the tracking on, they were able to sign in and sign out, and were they notified before their free time for detention expired, and they still sat for five hours. Customer is refusing to pay detention. So, do you pay the carrier out of your own margin?

SPEAKER_01Do you push back on the shipper, or do you deny it and move on? Um, I have seen so I'm not gonna deny and move on. We'll just get that one out there because we can tell the carrier deserves detention here. So um, depending on the situation and depending on the customer relationship, it's probably gonna determine what I'm gonna do here. Um, but if a if a customer is truly wrong, I would I would probably just generalize this. I'd I'm gonna pay the carrier what they're due.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, because it's gonna work out with my customer and figure out as to why they're denying it. So was it because you know the carrier says they checked in and they checked out, but maybe they didn't do it in the right format or the right whatever? And I'll try to work some kind of exception for them. But I have seen customers that just flat out are like, nope, you can pay it. If you want to keep doing business with us, that's what you're gonna do. And they put you in a really bad spot. And those are customers that I I usually warn people about. Like, they're if they're gonna take advantage of you on a$200 detention or$100 detention, what are they gonna do when uh$50,000 claim arises or something like that?

SPEAKER_01Like those are those are situations where you definitely um you gotta be cautious. But the other thing too is certain customers have requirements of to get detention approved, you have to do X, Y, and Z exactly in the way that they prescribe it. So if there was maybe miscommunication, the the driver thinks, oh, I did everything right because this is how I'm used to doing it, but they didn't know that, oh, there's a special, you know, check-in and out form that the shipper or the receiver will provide at the gate when they come in, and it's gotta be signed by a certain authorized person on that form and submit it to an attention, right?

SPEAKER_01Those are the situations for you to figure out like where's the and it's a learning lesson too. Like, this is where if you talk to your customer, you're like, hey, like the you know, the driver definitely didn't know, and hey, it was my fault, I didn't let him know. Um, would you guys be able to make an exception to this? So I think if you go at it with a point of humility versus like you know, aggression, you might be able to get somewhere. But ultimately, like I'm not gonna screw a carrier over because a customer is deciding to be, you know, an a-hole.

SPEAKER_01So but there's probably a way to work through it. Do you ever deal with one of those where you're yeah you got a customer not wanting to pay?

SPEAKER_00Many of them, because I I mean, like, that's the glitter was going through my head. I'm like, yeah, I remember and definitely had a customer where like the carrier's tracking worked. The check-in and checkout time were on it, but it wasn't like initialed by an employee there. So the customer was like, Look, like, I need my employee's initials. I don't know that the driver actually didn't just do that himself. Yeah, they're like, hey, I'm like, makes a lot of sense. Talk to the driver, pay the carrier, learn from it, remind every driver next time. Hey, you checked in, great, make sure you get your check-in time initialed and your checkout time, otherwise they'll deny it.

SPEAKER_00Hey, no problem. Driver will do that. Like, they don't know that. It's your job to tell them. And it's certainly your job to pay them if they did what you told them to do and you didn't tell them something because you didn't ask your customer. Like that's on you, and you absolutely should do that, right? I totally agree. Good questions.

SPEAKER_01Keep sending them our way. Final thoughts, Ben.

SPEAKER_00Whether you believe you can or believe you can't, you're right. And until next time, go bills.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Factoring For Freight Startups (with Tom Croteau of OperFi) | Episode 364

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    We sit down with Tom Croteau, CEO and founder of OperFi, to discuss the ins and outs of freight factoring, how he built his company from the ground up, and why credit and cash flow are so important in transportation. We...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Fuel Surcharge, Dispatchers, and LTL | Final Mile 163

    Nov 17, 202616 minAudio

    β›½ Do brokers often keep the FSC from carriers? πŸ’Έ How much should an owner-operator pay for a dispatcher? πŸ“¦ Truckload brokers: what do you do when a regular customer wants LTL moved? Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. How Freight Broker Actually Find Shippers | Episode 363

    Nov 13, 202645 minAudio

    If prospecting feels like pushing a boulder uphill, the problem is usually your system, not your script. We cover why one call and one objection won’t win a shipper, how to pick a niche and target mid-sized shippers,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. A New Brokerage Can Win Carriers Without Credit | Final Mile 162

    Nov 10, 202621 minAudio

    πŸ›‘οΈ Do freight agents need general liability insurance? πŸ’° How can new brokers book loads without established credit? πŸš› How could H.R. 7261 impact brokers and carriers? Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click Here OperFi:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Protect Freight Broker Profits When Rates Shift | Episode 362

    Nov 6, 202647 minAudio

    Freight brokerage margins can make or break your business, especially when market conditions shift. We break down how to protect your profits, adjust pricing as carrier rates rise or fall, manage customer expectations,...

    Credit the people on this episode