Protect Freight Broker Profits When Rates Shift | Episode 362
47 minAudio
Freight brokerage margins can make or break your business, especially when market conditions shift. We break down how to protect your profits, adjust pricing as carrier rates rise or fall, manage customer expectations, and avoid costly mistakes that eat into your bottom line. Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click Here OperFi: Click Here QuikSkope - Get a Free Trial: Click Here DAT One - Brokers & Carriers: Click Here to get 10% off your first year! DAT Outgo Factoring for Carriers: Click Here AscendTMS: Click Here and use promo code RA-freight360! to get AscendTMS FREE for 90 days! Recommended Products: Click Here Freight Broker Basics Course: Click Here Join Our Facebook Group: Click Here Check out all of our content online: Click Here
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Today we're talking margin. We're talking what to do when the market changes, whether rates are going up or rates are going down, how to protect your profits as a freight broker, especially in a changing market. Ben, what are your thoughts? I feel like we we kind of covered a lot and um it's a really good financial lesson for brokers, but what's your what's your take on this one?
SPEAKER_02I thought it was a really good discussion because it really wasn't just margins. I mean, it was basically everything that like attributes to margins, right? Like, do you have the right customers? Are your customers willing to pay for the service you provide? Are you bringing in new customers? Is the market moving? Is it going up? Is it going down? Because margins isn't just how do you negotiate this load. It's what's going on in the market, what's going on with your customer, what's going on seasonally with the customer. And I think we really had a really good discussion on how all of those things basically contribute to margin and also mathematically or financially, how important margin is for you to actually have any type of success in this industry.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and definitely give it a listen all the way through. We we're we've got a lot of really good tips and advice in there for how to set yourself apart from being just a transactional relationship with your customer to truly becoming a partner with them, locking arms with them, becoming that extension of their, you know, their shipping up or their shipping operations and their um supply chain. So uh we've got some real world stories built in there. We talk about historical stuff and also what's going on currently. So, with all that said, let's hop right into it.
SPEAKER_00All right, welcome back for another episode of the Freight 360 podcast. This is episode 362, and we're gonna get into some discussion on margins today, and we're gonna go down some rabbit holes. But uh, if you're brand new here, make sure to check out all the other content. We've got the Freight Broker Basics course. If you're looking for an educational option, I know we've got a lot of students that go through that throughout the year. And we've got an entire searchable library on the website. A lot of our stuff is also on YouTube. Um, share us with your friends, subscribe to the newsletter, join the Facebook group, all the things.
SPEAKER_00And this episode is brought to you by Ascend TMS. So if you're looking for a new TMS option, check out Ascend. You can get 90 days for free of the entire pro version. No card required. You just need to have a referral code, which we do have um down in the description. Ben, what's going on in uh in Florida? It's like 80 degrees. It's gonna be 80 degrees here in Buffalo in November. So I'm curious what you guys are feeling. A lot of rain. It's dude, my mom has been spending me videos of flooding, like just wild.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. On top of that, my brand new roof apparently still is not keeping water out of my house. So that was all so pleasant surprise. Yikes. Crazy, man. It's like it's so dark outside, like it looks like it's like nine o'clock, eight o'clock outside.
unknownWow.
SPEAKER_02Past two days.
SPEAKER_00Well, daylight savings uh was this past weekend. So we're back to the uh at least up here where I live, like by the time my work day is over, it's dark. So it's very, very depressing. Um, and it only gets worse until I want to say like towards the end of the year. It's like 4 30, it'll be dark.
SPEAKER_02But I to this day, I still remember that my first sales job, we had like it was all in offices, which were pretty nice, but none of them had windows up in Pittsburgh, and basically the entire winter from like as soon as they turn the clock the clocks back until they turn them forward. Like you just don't see daylight until Saturday and Sunday. No sunlight other than Saturday and Sunday. Yeah, that's crazy.
SPEAKER_00Um let's see here. Sports Steelers looking good. They didn't know Bill's looking good. You gotta you're there's no more, let's see, no more undefeated teams in the NFL. Um Bills are number one in the AFC right now. I know it's a little early in the season, but um looking looking strong there. Unfortunately, for so I was at the Bills Ravens game over the weekend, and if you're a Ravens fan, it's gotta be tough. Um lose.
SPEAKER_00They lost their first and second string quarterbacks in the first half of the game. So Lamar Jackson went out on his first snap. It was his first game back, and then uh Huntley, who's the backup, um, also got injured in the first half. So they're they have a third stringer. Their emergency quarterback came in. So hate to see an injury like that, especially season enders for guys, but um it's unfortunately one of the negative parts of the of the sport.
SPEAKER_02So speaking of, did you hear they're launching a flag football league this year in 2027? Yeah. 33 teams. I believe it's gonna be in the Olympics. Yeah, correct.
SPEAKER_00I heard Yeah, they've been talking about they've been talking about that since like last year. You got like a handful of like I think like Jalen Hurts was one of the guys that was like big on promoting it. Um there's a bunch of like bigger names that are they're trying to like really put it put as the face of it. So they brought it in, like, you know, they they got rid of the um the Pro Bowl game that's the week before the Super Bowl. They got rid of that, and then they went to like a you know, like a con like uh basically like a skills contest.
SPEAKER_00So then they brought in flag football, I think, last year. Um but yeah, we'll see. It's interesting. Interesting so sports, yeah. The Brewers won the World Series first time in history. It was it's funny because I was in Florida last week when the World Series was going on, and um I was in on I was in Disney World, so like the Orlando-ish area, and um went to like a sports bar at a resort a couple times to get some food to go, and they had the games on, and there's a lot of people from Tampa because it's so close, and the Rays were who they were playing, and but yeah, it was a four to one um near sweep.
SPEAKER_00But uh yeah, congrats to Milwaukee and the Brewers there. So um all right. What do we got in the news?
SPEAKER_02I don't have other than the uh elections yesterday. I think the entire Congress and Senate moved to the Yeah, I mean that was that was of no surprise.
SPEAKER_00That's been kind of uh a somewhat common theme for a midterm. Um not always, but I don't think anyone was surprised with the flipping of the House or Senate. Um I was actually thinking about it, I was looking back at like how has how has a midterm election or election in general like impacted our industry? And I'm like, eh, like it I don't think it's gonna really do a whole lot. Like um, you know, we we're we're dealing with all kinds of other things.
SPEAKER_00Like, I don't think the midterm election is gonna have a big impact on us right now. I think the bit the biggest changes we've seen are on um ship demand to ship, which comes down to like consumer spending, which is impacted by inflation, and also carrier uh capacity, which a lot of it's come down to enforcement and stuff like that. So I think those things are pretty um they're pretty like I don't want to say set in stone, um, but they're we're pretty deep into the where both sides are at right now that I don't think you're gonna see a a swift change anytime soon.
SPEAKER_00So I think we'd all love inflation to go down, but that'd be nice.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I'm pretty far out in tinfoil hatland anymore in regards to like how the economy works and the global economy and who's running things. And I'm like, it's just the same person with two hands and two different puppets. I'm like it's they both do the exact same thing. I'm like, my cousins who've lived in DC forever, like, and I used to be like pretty politically active and like really involved. And I'm just like, the older I get, I'm like, do you know why they swing from party to party every two and four years? Because everyone gets sick of whoever's in power. And why? For the exact same reasons.
SPEAKER_02And it's just it's just literally the exact same thing. And then people just convince everyone to argue with each other to go get angry, to go watch more YouTube videos and click on Instagram so that they can get more traffic and make more money. And like it's all just a giant facade.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, agree. I actually I had an interesting conversation with somebody last week. Um, and a lot of it came down to like, you know, the it's it's interesting because historically geopolitics has had an impact on the market and on freight ultimately. So like typically war in the past has led to an increase in government spending, shipping demand, things like that. Whereas the kind of like micro war earlier this year that started has led to you know, ripple effects of higher gas prices and which is all part of inflation, which leads to less um consumer spending on other things, which then in turn leads to demand for shipping.
SPEAKER_00So he was kind of telling me, he's like, Man, I really think this whole this whole war is is taken down our industry. And I'm like, well, I think I think there's other other factors, but it was an interesting take that he had. So we'll see. We're gonna talk today about margins and what you personally can do with your freight business, whether you're an employee at a company or an agent or run your own brokerage. Um, because this stuff happens cyclically, whether it's related to the economy or regulation or seasonally, right?
SPEAKER_00So we'll see. We'll see. Um we get into it? Ready when you are. All right. So a a common theme, I a common theme I've seen lately, and I wanted to talk about this today because it's kind of an evergreen topic, because like I said, this stuff is cyclical, it happens all the time. Um, but a common theme lately is that we've seen certain, I would say, isolated either brokers or areas of the market where we're seeing margins that are degrading, they're thinning out, and it's come down to if I had to oversimplify it, I would say carrier rates have gone up and customers naturally don't ever want to pay more for your services.
SPEAKER_00And you've got some brokers that just kind of roll over and say, all right, you know, I'll I'll take a lesser margin, or in some cases a loss. And the justification is like, well, you know, I've got to come in with low rates to try and win their business and show my value. And it's like, yeah, but you know, margin is how you truly operate. Um, you know, it's it's one thing to say, like, I've got a you know, five million dollar book of business, if you're looking at your total revenue, but how profitable is that five million dollars?
SPEAKER_00Because take the carrier pay out of it, that'll leave your gross profit. That's what you have to pay your expenses, to pay your actually your sales number. Like that's your sales number. That's remembering when I came into the industry. Because they're like, yeah, we don't care what the sales revenue is. We don't we want to know what the brokerage net is because that's how you truly operate the business, right? Didn't you guys call it brokerage revenue when you were an employee?
SPEAKER_02Probably did. I and honestly, like I think they kind of use top line, but that's I always felt like that was more of like a marketing thing and more like like public relations than it was like actual, because it's like we are a six billion dollar company, we're gonna you know, cross the and I'm like, yeah, but like no, like that's just pass-through. And honestly, like that number you like pay interest on, or you lose interest carry. Like that's kind of an expense. But like your GP, your gross profit between what you charge your customer and pay your carriers, like that's actually your sales number, in my opinion.
SPEAKER_02Because and I think everyone wants to use like industry standards, like, oh, what's the industry? We'll just apply 15% or 12 and a half or whatever it is on what market on what year. And it's like brokerages are so wildly different in what that number actually is, that that's always my first question. I mean, I'm always curious about what the top line is because that definitely affects how you're financing the brokerage. But if you got a really big top line number and a really small percentage of gross profit, like you're probably not even making money. Like you're just going to work for free.
SPEAKER_02And to me, like they're very misunderstood, um, or I don't know, overgeneralized, I guess is a better way to put it, where people just want to compare it to other things, but like they're just so very different.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'll give I'll give you like some context. So one of the things that I typically review on a monthly basis with the brokers in our company is I look at their gross profit, which is that you know, number we're talking about here, and I also look at that margin percentage and how it correlates with you know how much work they're doing versus the the the juice that they're getting out of it. So to give you context, like I've I've had conversations with people even in the last few months where I'm like, I'm like, you're operating at six and a half, seven percent margin here, you know, and you know, we got a guy over here that's doing 19, 20%.
SPEAKER_00I'm like, it's it's taking you three times as much business to equal what he's doing over there. And they're like, well, you know, my customer doesn't want to pay more. I'm like, well, that's great, but you're you're not the one setting the rates, right? You you all your job is to present them with access to the market and give them options and let them decide. Your job is not to absorb in a spot market, at least we're talking here. Your job is not to absorb shifts in the market.
SPEAKER_00That is not, we're not, we don't set prices. The market is completely completely uh set independently from what our feelings are, right? And the and the shipper's feelings. It's a supply and demand relationship. So there's hard conversations to have for sure. They're not easy. Um, and if you can get ahead of them, that's why I recommend like follow the analytics, follow what the market's doing. If you want an easy way to do that, um, check out Dean Croak's weekly updates on DAT. We also include them in our newsletter every Tuesday.
SPEAKER_00So just subscribe to that. We put in the market overview, an overview of uh dry van market, reefer market, flatbed market. But when we're seeing rates tick up, you have to have that conversation with your customers. Like, look, the overall spot market is increasing. Here's why it's increasing. It comes down to fuel, it comes down to carriers exiting the market.
SPEAKER_00Um, so because of that, we've got choices to make, right? If if you are very adamant on service, expect our you know, available pricing of available carriers to go up. Um, if you're price sensitive, understand we're not gonna have rapid 15-minute trucks booked for you. We're gonna have to shop the market a lot longer because it's like finding a needle in the haystack to find that more you know economy priced carrier option for you, right?
SPEAKER_02Agreed. And I think like that's your best tool, right? The best tool is education and information because customers make assumptions and being able to explain that and articulate it really helps uh, I don't know, get that across. Because the other thing that I always I like really I hear as soon as a customer says it is like, well, your rates, right? I'm like, like these aren't my rates. Like these are the market rates, right? And like we'll always use that example of like, would you ever say that to like a stockbroker? Like, I want to buy 10 shares of Apple.
SPEAKER_02Oh my God, your rates are terrible. Like, no, like that's the price of Apple today, right now. If you want to buy at a lower price, I'll let you know when it gets there. But for now, this is what it costs. It's really no different in the freight brokerage market, but like customers like attach the number to like you as a person. Like you are just throwing this number out there, right? So being able to like explain that, I think, is like, again, to your point, really important. But the other thing, too, I think is very closely related with margin, is uh maybe your customer just isn't a brokerage customer.
SPEAKER_02Maybe they aren't willing to and don't get enough value out of service that like they're never gonna pay 15%. Yeah. And in those scenarios, like you just need to get on the phones and find the right fit customer. Because not every customer is a fit for a brokerage or for a volume. Maybe one or two loads a week. They need extra help, they need it last minute. They'll pay you to go bail them out of a scenario where one of their trucks couldn't show up for whatever reason, but maybe not running 15 loads a week where the other 12 are basically at$50 margins and you're not making any money and you're working 30 hours a week to make$1,500, right?
SPEAKER_02Like it's not just the margins, it's also the customer makeup. And it's also the demand for whatever that customer sells, right? Because sometimes that customer seasonality will pay a lot of money to a broker because their volume went up and they're a really good customer in the spring. But maybe the next three to four months, like people just don't buy that much of whatever they make, and they need cheaper trucks because they aren't selling as much product. So it's not just like the math to the truck, the math to the negotiation table. It's like, okay, like what else is going on with what this company actually produces, and what does the consumer demand look like for it this time of year?
SPEAKER_02Not just whenever.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that brings up an interesting question. So, like uh there's the whole idea of do you ever take a loss on a load for a customer? And if so, when when is that appropriate? Like, when should you absorb the increased cost of a truck versus pass it on to your shipper? So I think there's there's this we've talked about it in other content, but like if you're at fault as the broker, like and I don't even mean directly, but if it's if it's on you, meaning like if you booked a truck and that truck bails out and you got to rebook it on a Friday afternoon, um, you know, you may have to absorb that because you're the carrier that was, you know, kind of shit.
SPEAKER_00That's on you. Yeah. Yep. Um, but overall, if the market is just going up and the rates are going up, and I like how you said they're not my rates, they're the market rates. That's a really good um way to frame it there. But if the rates are going up, um you, you know, it you should be giving your customers some context. And I wouldn't just be giving handouts and you know, free discounts just because the market's changing. Because it's, you know, if it's a if it's a one-off day and you agree, like let's say, for example, you committed to book a truck for, you know, book a customer's load for next week, and in hindsight, you didn't realize that, like, oh, that's the day before a holiday.
SPEAKER_00Um, and you go to book it and you're like, crap, the market's a thousand dollars more expensive than what I had quoted my customer. Well, that's on you, right? You can you can take, you know, take the hit on that because you, you know, you gave your word to your customer that here's the rate and I'm gonna get it covered for you. But if the overall market's getting more expensive, I don't, but I don't think it's appropriate to just absorb that for your customer because it's ultimately like they're not just gonna absorb it, they're gonna tack those increased transportation costs onto their buyer, right? Whoever's buying their product.
SPEAKER_00And that's reality. It all ends up coming down to the the end consumer ultimately who pays more for it, right? We talked about that with inflation earlier.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I'll give you like this is a real real world example from like two or three weeks ago. Um, there was this brokerage where the call it like the customer rep, the one negotiating, right? Margins were literally non-existent on this customer. So like breakeven for flat Yeah, little bit of losses,$50 win here or there,$50 loss here, there, mostly breakeven, just flat, right? At like 15, 20 loads a week. Well, the that that brokerage brought a new account manager in for a couple of these accounts and they shifted some things around.
SPEAKER_02And the person they brought in was, you know, 15, 20 years experience. Um, they brought in to handle like some larger accounts, and this one smaller account, the broker gets put on. And I was listening literally to the call on both of it. What the other broker was saying basically, look, they just won't pay. They need to be at this rate. The customer needs to be here. And I remember even asking them back then, I was like, Well, what does need to be there? I'm like, you're charging two grand, you're paying two grand. I'm like, uh, if you literally just didn't go to work this week, what do you think that company would do?
SPEAKER_02And they went, what do you mean? I'm like, well, they would need another broker, right? I'm like, do you think another broker would charge them break-even? Well, probably not. I'm like, okay. So if you just step back, they'll pay 23 or 24, right? Well, yeah. Okay. So what does need to be there mean? Well, my customers are just telling me they need to be there. I'm like, no, no, you're just losing the negotiation. Because if you didn't go to work, they would pay what you should be charging them. So then the next person comes in and has a conversation.
SPEAKER_02Hey, listen, like, I know we've been running these at two grand or two grand a day, whatever. Um, I need to be at like 2350. I actually need to be at 24, but I think I can make a market twenty three fifty. Customer goes, look, I need to be at this number, I need to be at this number. Same song dance, right? And then the new brook goes, Well, okay, but like you watch the news, you do see that diesel has been up this much in the past three months, right? Oh, well, well, yeah, I I saw that. Well, you do realize that like the trucks have to pay for gas, and when gas goes up, whatever, 30% in the past three months.
SPEAKER_02What you were paying three months ago is probably not going to be the same rate as it is today because like that's literally how they move your freight, right? And the guy kind of laughed, but he's like, Oh, well, I I never really thought about that. He's like, Listen, like I think I can get you a 2350, but if you don't think that's a fair rate, then feel free to shop it on the market. Let me know what you get. Guy calls him back the next day, called a couple other brokers. They're a 2450, you can for 2350. It's almost always having that conversation and realizing just going like, well, if I didn't move this freight for that, is there another broker that would be willing to just run this freight for free?
SPEAKER_02Because most other companies aren't going to do it either. I mean, maybe they get a cheap truck here or there, but if you're 15, 20 loads a week at break-even, like they're going to pay more with some other company. Maybe not for a week, maybe not two weeks, but in the course of a month, they're going to come up to market, right? Like artificially starving your own business and your own book of business because you don't want to have a difficult conversation when ultimately you're going to have to at some point anyway.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'll give you, let's, I'll give you a fun analogy. We'll play with this one. So let's say me and you are hanging out. We're in uh we're in Boca down by you, and we're down at whatever that little Billsbacker lunch place is that I ate out on the uh is it an island? The the coastal one, you go over the bridge, it's on the left side. Anyway, we we wrap up lunch and we're like, hey, we're gonna go drive wherever, let's stop and get some gas. And you're filling up the pump, and um, you're like, man, it's four dollars a gallon for gas. And then I, you know, I step out, I walk into the gas station, I'm like, hey, he really needs it to be at$3.50 a gallon right now.
SPEAKER_00Like, is the gas station gonna give you gas at a loss? Like, it doesn't work that way. They don't set the prices, it doesn't work that way in anything. Yeah. So, you know, that's why, I mean, you might, again, you're gonna see a couple cents higher or lower here versus the competitor. And sometimes they can offset that because they make margin on what they're selling inside the store, or maybe they're also a car wash, or maybe you've got the the gas club where your bank account is connected to their card and they're not paying transaction fees. Like, there's all stuff like that. And the same happens with brokerages, right?
SPEAKER_00You have a little bit of flexibility on what's our overhead and you know, our ability to source better carriers, things like that. But overall, the market is what the market is, and fuel is what fuel is. It's just that's the reality of it.
SPEAKER_02So it's really interesting that you use that as an example because I had a client a few years ago that started a brokerage, but they owned a bunch of gas stations. And I'm just super curious. So I was asking, I'm like, I was always curious. I'm like, how do the margins look in that business? Like, I just asked a whole bunch of questions, just really curious how it looks. And I'm like, oh, fuel is basically so competitive that we undercut each other by a penny or two. We make almost zero profit on selling gas. All of our money is by driving foot traffic into our convenience store to buy things because everybody basically has to charge the same thing, and everybody undercuts everybody for the fuel for the fuel to get the foot traffic to get you to buy potato chips or whatever's in that convenience store.
SPEAKER_02And the funny thing was, I I like forgot about that. And I usually go um like nicotine, like Zen packs, right? Like I usually get them at this um at Walgreens because they're like, I don't know, I think they're like three bucks there. And I never really noticed because like did you just get in the habit of like picking them up there? And and I I ended up on the other side of town and I didn't want to drive there. This was like three days ago, so I stopped at the gas station and I picked them up, and they were literally twice as expensive. And I was like, I was like, are they really$30 for like three of these?
SPEAKER_02And I'm like, I like looked at the receipt because I'm like, that doesn't seem right. And when I got home, like, oh yeah, that's how they make money. It's not on gas. Walgreens makes money on prescriptions, that's why they sell you cheap stuff in the store in that place and makes money selling you when you go into it. And I'm like, it's anyway, not to go on like a tangent, but like to your point, like it wasn't like I was gonna be like, look, I need to be at 12 bucks on these. Like, can you do this at 12 bucks? Like he was just gonna sell them to me for 12 dollars.
SPEAKER_00The Boca Beach House, by the way, I had to look it up. That was the name of the uh the food spot. Um so let's flip the script here. When rates go down, right? Because this is it's cyclical, right? And if you take fuel out of it, because fuel's like one part of the equation, um, and it's kind of a fixed like it's a set in stone price that whether line haul rates are high or low, fuel is gonna be whatever fuel is. You could have thin line haul rates and high fuel, you could have um high line haul rates and cheaper fuel.
SPEAKER_00Um, but let's exclude fuel fuel here and look at like line haul in general, supply and demand. So let's say that that you know you go back when the market got flooded with carriers, the COVID money, the the whole spigot dried up, and all of a sudden you had a lesser demand to ship and a ton of carriers out there, and rates started to plummet, right? So, what do you do in that situation? How do you navigate it? And I'll I'll caution you when because this, you know, it feels like, man, that's never gonna happen right now, but it will.
SPEAKER_00It'll happen again. You'll see, you'll see rates ease down um and then back up again. I mean, this is a a cycle. Um, but we've seen it time and time again. Um, like we've always said, 18 to 24 months is a typical cycle for a freight market, which sounds like unbelievable right now when you think about it in the last like five, six years. But what happens when when rates go down is if you don't then give your customer the benefit of that, right? You risk losing business. So I've seen people that literally rates went down and out of nowhere they're like, man, I lost my customer.
SPEAKER_00And I'm like, well, what happened? They're like, well, someone else came in um cheaper. And I'm like, 40% cheaper. Yeah, and I'm like, have have you like changed your rates? And they're like, no, they've just been paying what they've been paying for you know last year. And I'm like, yeah, but rates have gone down, and like, yeah, you're you're living high off the hog for a little bit, and is was it worth it? Because you basically were taking advantage of your customer because they were uneducated on what's going on in the market. They're used to paying, you know, three bucks a mile, two bucks a mile, and now it's 220.
SPEAKER_02That's why they trust you. Exactly. Yeah, that's the trust they have, is that you're gonna give them the market insight.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that's why I think that the best relationships that shippers and brokers can have is when you kind of lock arms and you're like, we're in this together regardless of what goes on. We're gonna meet regularly, we're gonna discuss what's going on, we're gonna both be on the same page with what does capacity look like in our region with our equipment types that we're dealing with here? What does fuel look like? What are we projecting out in the future? What kinds of um external factors are going to impact it one way or another? Because at the end of the day, they've got a boss to report to, and they've got to be able to justify when they're spending more and be able to project to their boss when they can expect to pay less.
SPEAKER_00And ultimately, if service is the goal, right, you know, you've got to be able to lock arms and understand that price is going to fluctuate, you know, over and over and over, up and down. It's just it is what it is. So the thing, the two things that remind me as to why price is lower or why price is higher.
SPEAKER_02Correct. It reminds that saying uh what pigs get fat and hogs get slaughtered, right? Like you can eat and you can keep healthy margins. But when you're greedy and you push it too long, like you end up losing everything. And to be honest, like the other thing too, I would say is that like sometimes you need to lose the customer to get them back. And I'll give you like a whole other example, right? Was I had this customer, I'm sure I've talked on the show where I did a bunch of like steel shipments. Like the whole boat, it was like uh five loads a day for like three or four weeks every time a boat came in.
SPEAKER_02So basically the whole boat of steel would come into New Orleans and it went up to all the steel mills, and I'd manage like literally the whole thing because it was just too much work to be able to give it to multiple brokers because the confusion, figuring out what was going on which truck to which place. So I had like the whole contract for every single one. And my average margins that I negotiated were like right around 25. It was like 23 to 25, is pretty much where it stayed. But also, I was literally managing like the loading. So like there's manual labor that are Stevedors there.
SPEAKER_02They didn't actually know what to load on each truck. So like I had all these spreadsheets that were like these POs go to this truck, the next truck in line, these POs have to go on it. And if one got loaded wrong, it went to the wrong place. And then you had to re-deliver it, right? Or you had a missed delivery, and like you're literally having to reship it to another state. So like the cost of a mistake was high enough that it was worth paying for somebody to like oversee the whole thing. And I did it for like, I think like five or six months. And it was basically my whole book of business for that period of time. And I still have a really good relationship with this company and that person that was there.
SPEAKER_02And I remember um her coming back to me because her family owned the business. And she was like, listen, like the service has been great. We have literally not had any complaints. I would love to keep using you guys, but like I need to be able to cut my margins to have a little more profit on the next one. So we're gonna use another broker for the next month or the next one or two shipments and see how it goes. We'll let you know if we need help. Well, I mean, it definitely sucks because it was like almost my entire book of business because it was so much freight. And I'm running like, you know, six, seven loads a day for three or four weeks a month.
SPEAKER_02You're off for like four days and it starts again. And I'm like, I like literally fell down to zero. I'm like, okay, I had some other small prospects. I'm basically on the phone trying to backfill it. But then, like, I think three, four weeks into the next shipment, I get a phone call. Can you pick up the rest of this? I'm like, what's going on? Well, the first two weeks didn't go very well. We had about 20% of our loads get misdelivered that need picked up and sent somewhere else. They're sitting in a yard in the middle of Detroit. Half the stuff that was in Ohio needs to now go over to Michigan.
SPEAKER_02Can you like help us out of this? I'm like, yeah. So sometimes, like, when somebody says they need to be cheaper and they need to try out what cheap actually is, they actually come back. And then, to be honest, I probably made 35% on the rest of that shipment, but it was twice as much work to fix the problems from the other person. And like, that's why some of this business is cyclical. Like, you could have a customer for a year or two and just make really average 15, 16% margins. And then they get a new boss that comes in that has a new like directive of we're gonna slash, we're gonna slash our shipping costs.
SPEAKER_02We're gonna drive more profit the bottom line. And the shipping manager usually yells at that person and says, Yes, but our customers are gonna get mad, and pretty soon we're gonna lose customers. And this person goes, Nope, we're gonna be able to do this. They do it, they lose a bunch of customers. Three months later, into the next quarter, they come back to the brokers and they go, Hey, can you pick these lanes back up? Uh, didn't go so well. We're now struggling to go get the sales back up. And like that is part of the cyclical nature of business, is just like different seasonal decisions, different people come in, different COO, like this happens at huge companies, small companies, it happens everywhere.
SPEAKER_02That's why if you're not constantly filling the funnel of like more businesses and more prospects, like it's pretty much inevitable you're gonna lose a customer. And it might literally be no fault of your own. I mean, you could be doing everything perfect, yeah, and just somebody that you're not even talking to comes out of left field and then all of a sudden shoots and ladders, you're back to the bottom again.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've I've seen this actually recently with a customer where um the customer has a couple different peak seasons throughout the year. Um, so if you go back to two peak seasons ago, um there's a we had a lot of business coming our way. And then the most recent peak season, to your point, like somebody within the company, whether it was a new manager or a new boss or whoever, decided like, hey, we want to shop some rates around here. So we lost a portion of the business and they started bringing in other brokers to um you know price stuff out, to work on some of their lanes, et cetera.
SPEAKER_00And now come to this current upcoming peak season, the customer has then decided, yeah, we tried that. It wasn't a good idea. You're our number one, and we've got those other brokers as are basically in our bullpen for like stuff that you can't cover. And because again, no customer is ever going to say, I have one and one only broker, right? They've got to have a backup for unexpected business, fallout, and negotiating purposes.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like almost every shipment wants a they want they don't want any transportation provider to have more than like 10 or 15%. It's like kind of like industry standard. And like that's really high, especially for a larger company.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we had another one um last year that we did a lot of business for them. Um, it was a beverage company, and all of a sudden, like overnight, because they they would do um, I think it was either monthly or like every six weeks, they were doing like a mini bid, and they're like, um, we lost all the business overnight. And we're like, what happened? Like, TQL came in and just like undercut it. And very quickly, it was like, yeah, we we know it's gonna come back because the service or they're not gonna be able to uh you know hold true on their rates or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Um, and it did. Um, but I I mean I've seen it happen for a number, you know, a number of reasons like that, but um, that's why like I can't stress enough to have that strong relationship with your customer. Don't just be transactional. You've got to have a long-term uh play with them. And I always say, like, you should be an extension of your customer's supply chain, right? You are their logistician. Um, it's your job to make their job easier. And if all of a sudden, you know, they take business from you and give it to some new broker who's coming in with cheap rates, and then that uh that broker can't hold true and they kick it back, they've got to answer their boss.
SPEAKER_00Like, what happened? You promised me cost savings. Now we're not even our customers aren't getting their stuff delivered on time. So those are you gotta have those. Like, here's the here's what might happen if you go down this road. You got to have those conversations with them.
SPEAKER_02Well, and I think there's like two important takeaways from that, too, at least one, which is like for newer brokers, right? This is why it is hard to get a new customer. Because that person is trusting somebody they've never worked with. They're taking business from somebody that is already moving it, where it's at some acceptable level of service to give it to somebody new, that is a risk for that company. And you just saying you're cheaper, yes, sometimes gets you that load or two, but like you want to be really cautious because one, now you're the cheap option.
SPEAKER_02So when you try to raise your rates, they're like, well, I don't need you anymore. I'm gonna go back to the guy I've been using for years. And two, if you give them a cheap rate and you can't cover it, like you just wasted a whole bunch of time and effort to get to that point. Like, it's way better to be at least reasonable and fair with your rates and to work a little harder to get the freight than it is to throw cheap numbers at people to just get a load to just move it for the sake of moving.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, the whole it's the whole, like, when you talk about margins and numbers, like would you rather move five loads at 20%, or would you rather move 20 loads at 2%? Like, that's why that that margin, that margin means everything, right? Like you because like you could say, I've got uh, we'll go back like, hey, I got a$10 million book of business and it runs at 5% margin. Well, you're you're netting$500,000 in gross profit versus I've got a five million dollar book of business that operates at a 20% margin, you're operating a quarter of the size or half the size at double the profit.
SPEAKER_00Like that is that is the difference there. Um so yeah, that's that's that's big to look at. And I always think too, like you should you should take a look at not overall what are your profit numbers look like, but you you got you can look at the specific customer. Like I'll give you an example that I looked at um yesterday, actually. So I'm looking at one of our brokerage teams, and I'm you know, I'm talking with one of the guys that helps manage it, and like, man, like they they used to do like 20% consistently, and now they're at like 13.
SPEAKER_00Like, what's going on here? And then we we like take a take a deeper look in and we broke it down by like rep and specifically by like customer, and we found out that like one of the brokers uh in that group is at like 7% margin and is tanking the overall number. Like you've got one part of it that, yep, they're at like 19, 20, like very healthy, and then you got someone else just pulling them down. And I'm like, you look at the volume of business, and again, to my earlier point, like you've got one part of it doing twice the work for less profit compared to the other one.
SPEAKER_00Like, you've got to make some adjustments there because especially when you start handling a lot of volume, it takes up a lot of your time. It's gonna deal with you know more and more issues, and you're basically like not doing it for free, but you're you're doing it at a discount. Like you're putting out, you're doing extra work for less money, it just doesn't make any sense.
SPEAKER_02So the other the other thing too is that like mathematically, a loss hurts you more than a win, right? So when you lose money, it's actually not the equivalent of making money. And the the way I always just even in my head to remind myself of that is like in stock trading, like that's really true because like you make lots of bets, and the best traders are trying to get it like 55% wins, 45% losses. And if you read any of the biographies from any of the very like legendary traders, they all kind of have the same strategy, which is not look for wins, it's avoid losses, right?
SPEAKER_02It's to say no more and to be more patient, or every single one of them has the same trait. And if you look at like really good golfers, same thing. Like even Tiger Woods would say, like at his best stretch, like he was avoiding bogeys, not shooting for birdies. And that was really a strategy because if you have a hundred dollars and you lose 10%, you have 90, right? Well, if you make 10%, you have 10% of 90, which is$9. That only gets you to 99, right? So losing 10% is not made up by a 10% win on the next load.
SPEAKER_02Like you actually can make 11 or 12% on the win to make up for the 10% loss. So like I would argue that like even if you probably looked at that scenario, what you were just saying, I was like literally pictures on a spreadsheet. I'm like, oh, that's 7% has such a larger impact than the 19 on the positive side, which is why the blended margin comes down so much, which is why the profitability looks like a dumpster fire.
SPEAKER_00Well, the the last thing I'll add in too on this conversation is like the cost of capital, right? So when you whether you're cash flowing or you're factoring, this is a huge, huge important thing, okay? Because you have to remember, let's start with factoring first. So, factoring, um, you are paying a factoring company to fund your business, basically. They're gonna fund your receivables, your invoices, um, perhaps pay your carriers as well, and they're gonna charge you a percentage, like a rate, right?
SPEAKER_00We'll just for simple terms, let's call it 2%, just for this discussion. All right. That 2% is off of your revenue. It's not off your profit. So if you're operating at a 7% margin and you're factoring at 2%, you just drop down to essentially 5% margin before anything else, right? Whereas um if you look at 17% margin, well, 2% puts you down at 15%, right? Very different. If you look at someone who's cash flowing their business, well, if I have to um spend$200,000 of my money to cash flow this business and it's operating at 7%, um you know, and I'm only making X amount on it, like I might make my money might serve me better off in, you know, a you know, in the market or doing something else with it, right?
SPEAKER_00Or funding a different customer's business who's looking at growth and extending credit lines. So that's oftentimes like if you're if you're limited by the amount of cash you have available and you don't want to touch a line of credit and you don't want to use a factoring company, that's when you have to look at customer opportunities and which customers are are holding you back cash flow-wise, not to mention do they pay quickly or do they pay slowly? Um, those things all come in and can really tank your business and kind of sneak up on you too.
SPEAKER_02Here's another one, too. I saw this when rates fell. I don't know if it's probably a little after COVID, but brokerage 15, 12, 15% margins, probably a year after COVID, right? And they factored everything. Probably$20 million brokerage. And they were like, Can you come and take a look at this? I think our margins are going down. And I there's something wrong with factoring. I'm like, okay. So I go and look at the TMS and I'm like, well, the average margins were 12. Now they're like eight.
SPEAKER_02I'm like, well, what happened here? Same conversation, didn't have conversations with their customers, didn't keep rates up a little bit, and just basically caved, gave the customers whatever they asked for. They're like, yeah, we know the margins are down, but like our factoring money isn't coming in. And I'm like, well, what are your factoring rates? Uh 2%, 5% holdback. What's 2 plus 5? Uh 7. So if you're making 7 or 8% and factoring holds five and charges you two, you literally don't get any money from factoring.
SPEAKER_02You're just waiting for your customer to pay the bill to get your 1%. So they like literally couldn't even cash flow the business anymore. Because factoring only helps when you're making at least 10% or more, because most are going to hold 5%. Well, there's half, and they're going to charge you one to two. So you're only getting three on hand up front to be able to live on and pay your staff, even if you are factoring. And anything sub 10, basically, factoring starts to just not provide any time benefit back to the brokerage.
SPEAKER_02You still got to wait for your customer to pay the bill because they're holding your margin until the customer pays the bill anyway.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I talked with a guy recently that he got his own authority, and we were talking through like, and he decided, like, yeah, I don't want to have my own authority anymore. I want to go, I want to go work for somebody. And I was like, Oh, I was like, little tough to get carriers to work with you and factoring companies to approve you. He's like, no. He goes, Yeah, that's a that's an issue. He's like, but more importantly, he's like, I didn't realize how expensive it is to cash flow a business. He's like, and it's all coming out of my own pocket. I'm like, yeah. So well, good uh good discussion there.
SPEAKER_00Um let us know your thoughts or if you have questions about it. But you know, this this stuff's gonna happen. Um, it's rates are gonna go up, rates are gonna go down, fuel's gonna go up, fuel's gonna go down, um, capacity is gonna get tight, it's gonna get loose. I mean, this stuff, if you're gonna be in this career for the long haul, expect change to be the constant. As ironic as that sounds, but change is the constant, inevitable thing that you can expect. So um, final thoughts, man.
SPEAKER_02Whether you believe you can or believe you can't, you're right.
We sit down with Tom Croteau, CEO and founder of OperFi, to discuss the ins and outs of freight factoring, how he built his company from the ground up, and why credit and cash flow are so important in transportation. We...
⛽ Do brokers often keep the FSC from carriers? 💸 How much should an owner-operator pay for a dispatcher? 📦 Truckload brokers: what do you do when a regular customer wants LTL moved? Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click...
If prospecting feels like pushing a boulder uphill, the problem is usually your system, not your script. We cover why one call and one objection won’t win a shipper, how to pick a niche and target mid-sized shippers,...
🛡️ Do freight agents need general liability insurance? 💰 How can new brokers book loads without established credit? 🚛 How could H.R. 7261 impact brokers and carriers? Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click Here OperFi:...
🚢 How do I find carriers for port container moves? 🚛 Does Highway flag carriers for taking time off? 💰 Why do brokers pass lumper advance fees onto carriers? Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click Here OperFi: Click Here...