CH Robinson's planned $5.8B purchase of RXO kicks off this episode. We cover what consolidation really changes for brokers and shippers, and why AI keeps coming up in pricing and matching. Then we look at rising diesel costs and how internal silos at big shippers turn budget cuts into service failures. We close with a deep dive on noncompetes, non-solicits, and confidentiality clauses in freight brokerage, including real lawsuit stories and what to watch before you sign, hire, or quit. Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click Here OperFi: Click Here QuikSkope - Get a Free Trial: Click Here DAT One - Brokers & Carriers: Click Here to get 10% off your first year! DAT Outgo Factoring for Carriers: Click Here AscendTMS: Click Here and use promo code RA-freight360! to get AscendTMS FREE for 90 days! Recommended Products: Click Here Freight Broker Basics Course: Click Here Join Our Facebook Group: Click Here Check out all of our content online: Click Here
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00All right, we're talking legal stuff. We got some big news stories. Just wrapped up a pretty good episode there, Ben. We uh got a lot of news on the front end, but the the tail end or the the the back half of this episode is really good as far as digging down into the rabbit hole of non-competes, non-solicits, employment agreements, uh restrictive covenants, things like that. Um what are your thoughts?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I thought it was a really good episode. It's been a while since we've kind of dug into those things. We've had a few clients recently where these have come up more. You and I had spent some more time chatting with attorneys on a few of these things. And I think it's just really good education for anyone out there because anytime we even get this question, even when we do these classes for the TIA, is like you have kind of the legal side, but you also have the practical side, right? And for me, understanding both is super helpful, whether you're on the employee side or you own the business or your HR, because there are what the documents say, and there's also what happens when they're actually litigated, taken to court, and those things.
SPEAKER_01So I thought it was a really good refresher and conversation on a lot of the things that we've done content on over the years because they're super common in our industry.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. All right, well, strap in, let's hop into it. We've got a milestone, it is episode 360 of Freight 360. Ben, we did it. How do you feel?
SPEAKER_01I'm like, I always can't even remember how long we've been doing this show, but I'm like 360 episodes, 360 weeks.
SPEAKER_00Like a couple weeks off here and there.
SPEAKER_01It's a long time ago.
SPEAKER_00It's funny. I was actually uh just before we hopped in here, I was on YouTube and I saw a couple of newer people, the people that I know in the industry that are starting starting to like tease the idea of like being like content creators. And I'm like, we've been doing this for seven years now.
SPEAKER_01A little more than seven years. Because some of the old episodes aren't Freight 360, they were the Midnight Freight Brokers. Mnight Freight Brokers.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. But hey, it's good stuff, man. Milestone. What are you drinking there? Little protein shake. Oh, okay. Nice. Very cool. I've got my uh my local favorite here, Tim Hortons. If you're if you live anywhere remotely close to Canada, that's like the Dunkin' Donuts or Starbucks of our region. So shout out to Timmy Hose.
SPEAKER_01You gotta pour that into one of those free 360 coffee mugs we have, so you're not drinking all those microplastics in the styrofoam cups. Well, these are actually um oh, I guess the the top is inside plastic, but it's uh the paper cups are sprayed with plastic inside it. That's more how they're waterproof.
SPEAKER_00Oh. Very good. Um, well, hey, we're uh yeah, we're back with another uh episode here, but there's clearly 300 and some other episodes plus a bunch of final mile QA sessions and some short form content, and we've got a bunch of uh blogs. We haven't done blogs in a while. Um, but it's fine. We've got a ton of crap on our website. So feel free and check it out. Create360.net.
SPEAKER_00Share us with your friends, join the newsletter, join the Facebook group. You if you want some training, uh go to the website and you can check out the uh Freight Broker Basics course. We actually had a somebody commented on one of our videos um who's taking our course right now. So appreciate the uh the questions and the feedback. But uh yeah, that's what we're here for, and we we enjoy serving you guys. Um sports, the Bills dropped a big uh fat L to the New England Patriots.
SPEAKER_01So that's very successful, but whatever.
SPEAKER_00How'd the Patriots or not the Patriots, how'd the uh Steelers do this weekend?
SPEAKER_01I didn't even loss to the Browns by three did not look great.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so we yeah, all right, so we're we're we're sharing in some some uh sadness. All right, that sucks. Divisional loss to the Browns. I actually saw a really funny YouTube or Instagram reel or whatever it was. It was like NFL teams like deciding on their colors, and it was like the Bills. It was like blue and red, it's a good contrast, and then it was like um Pittsburgh, and it was like I think we should go with black and yellow because Tell me can make a song called Black and Yellow.
SPEAKER_00And then it was like Green Bay, yeah, yellow's cool. Let me add some green to it. And then it was like Cleveland Browns, poop. Literally just shit. I was like, all right, good. Love it. Yeah, good stuff, man. Um sports, uh, yeah, NFL's in full swing here. I think who's undefeated still? You've got Kansas City, took down the Raiders. Um, they were two undefeated teams.
SPEAKER_00And then sorry, NFC teams. I don't follow you as closely. Maybe Minnesota, I don't know. Um baseball is uh progressing along in the in the playoffs. The Red Sox got embarrassingly eliminated in two games last week. So I'm uh past that. Uh it's so funny. So last year I ordered a Red Sox playoff hoodie as soon as they were released, and it and they were eliminated by the Yankees in the first round last year, and my hoodie arrived after they were eliminated.
SPEAKER_00So then this year I ordered another playoff hoodie, and it actually arrived before the playoffs started, and the Red Sox played the Yankees again in the wild card. But the the irony is like the phrase this year on all the playoff hoodies is like I think it was like built for October or something like that, but they were eliminated on September 30th. So like they didn't even make it to October.
SPEAKER_01That reminds me of it, it was a funny story. So on I used to swim um in high school, and we got all these shirts made for this. Um, it was like a the chance, I don't know if it was like the summer or something. It was like a huge swimming tournament, right? So um all my buddies, we had shirts made that said second place is the first loser. This is so old. This is like it was on no fear shirts back in the 90s, right? So like a very long time ago. And we were like, oh, this is a great thing to get on all our shirts. So the whole team has these shirts that say second place is the first loser.
SPEAKER_01And we got second place in that tournament, and we all were wearing these shirts and had to literally go get the trophy for second place with those shirts on.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's great. That's hilarious. Um, NHL is started. Um, the Sabres they won their home opener over the weekend, and then they won last night. So they're uh two and one. They lost their season opener on the road. But um, and ironically, I know I'm wearing this uh the my Red Bull F1 hoodie. Max Verstappen on the Red Bull team actually did win his first race of the season over the weekend in my for any F1 fans out there.
SPEAKER_00So um anything else in sports? Is golf all like wrapped up for the year? I know you're like the big golf guy.
SPEAKER_01Uh I don't even know. I haven't had time to watch much sports at all recently, just been like busy with work and stuff. I don't even know if tennis is over. I've watched a little more tennis and golf this summer, but I have not been able to catch up on much sports related.
SPEAKER_00A lot of injuries in the NFL so far this year, though. Like uh you've got poor Jackson Dart for any Giants fans out there. Like this kid, like out for the season early on, got hurt last year. Caleb Williams for Chicago, out for a couple weeks. Um the Chiefs had like a dude break his foot in the most disturbing way last week or over the weekend. This guy catches what ends up being like the play that seals the game for the Chiefs.
SPEAKER_00Um Mahomes throws like a bomb down into the red zone in the red zone. This dude catches it, gets tackled, and his left foot just goes like sideways. Doesn't even know it yet. He stands up because he's got all this adrenaline, and his foot is sideways, and then he just falls down, and then he realizes like, oh shit, I have a broken foot. And I think Rashi Rice was hurt like earlier in the game, too. So um just seen a lot of injuries around the league. But anyway, news. You see the big news about uh the big acquisition that was announced this week.
SPEAKER_00Uh CH buying. I did read it and my mind just blanked. Yep. Yeah, that's a big one, man. Um let's see if I got it was in our newsletter yesterday, so I should be able to pull up and I'll just read this out. I always love, like I saw two newsletters today that came out with the news, and I'm like, hey, that was in ours yesterday. So that's a reminder for you guys. Make sure to subscribe to our newsletter because we put out a newsletter every Tuesday and Thursday. Um I'll read it for you here. So uh there's Dean's update.
SPEAKER_00Here we go. Freight brokerage world just got a lot more concentrated. That's kind of the theme of this year's uh acquisitions. But CH Robinson announced Monday, so that would be October 5th, it's buying RXO in a cash and stock deal valued at$5.8 billion, creating a combined company worth more than$25 billion. So, as you guys know, CH was already the largest brokerage in the country, and now it's getting even bigger. RXO shareholders get$30.25 per share, about$17.25 in cash, plus a slice of CH Robinson's stock, a 29% premium over Friday's close, and will own roughly 11% of the new company.
SPEAKER_00Both boards signed off unanimously. RXO's biggest shareholders are on board, and the deal is expected to close in the first half of 2027, pending regulatory and shareholder approval. C. H. Robinson is funding the cash portion with new debt and will fold RXO mostly into its North American surface transportation division. The pitch. Two big truckload brokerage and managed transportation shops get bigger and denser together while C.H. Robinson's global forwarding pairs up with RXO's expedited and last mile business.
SPEAKER_00The real headline number is$300 million in annual cost savings within two years, which CH Robinson says it'll squeeze out by running its lean AI playbook across RXO's operations. The translation for anyone on the RXO side, expect a heavy focus on productivity, shared services, and cutting what overlaps. CH Robinson also gets a much bigger pile of data to feed its AI pricing, matching, and procurement tools. Wall Street will get earnings accresion?
SPEAKER_00Is that a word? I don't know what I wrote. Within nine months of closing, but buybacks are on pause until the company pays its debts down to target levels, which it's aiming for by the end of 2028. Interesting here, the big AI piece here, like CH Robinson is like their um their big push is to go lean by leveraging AI and all their stuff. So like pricing models, things like that.
SPEAKER_00Um I know a lot of guys that have worked for CH Robinson. Like we'll have uh the guys from uh Quickscope and Togo on at some point this month talk about um Quickscope's second version coming out, and those guys uh they started at CH Robinson. So I've heard stories from years ago about how how uh they operate there. And I actually a buddy I used to hang out with back in college, spent some time at CH Robinson, but um curious like what these other big companies are doing AI-wise to get competitive, like the TQLs of the world, Coyote, CH, like what is it actually like on the inside using AI?
SPEAKER_00Um I'm curious, I don't know, just interested.
SPEAKER_01I've talked to those folk, everyone you mentioned very recently in the past couple weeks, and unrelated things, but also some ch related things, where I definitely went down the rabbit hole and asked a bunch of those questions, which I don't necessarily know like are proprietary. So I'm not just gonna like throw them out there. But like I did kind of dig into that because I was also very curious. Also, Tim Um from Ascend uh was talking about this, and he referenced a post from uh Eric Williams that I thought was pretty interesting.
SPEAKER_01It said, you know, initial thoughts on RXO acquisition, spoke to a few of the leaders there. No one knew this was coming. Seems rushed for a straight EBITDA arbitrage. Two, execution is what matters. Lots of relationships and account nuance to manage through here. Bigger as a broker doesn't necessarily mean more pricing power. Almost every broker has access to the same pool of carriers. There is no net new capacity coming in that is running at above average margins that can be consolidated and sold for cheaper.
SPEAKER_01This should actually benefit the mid-size brokers and other and other mega player options. Four, many shippers don't want one player to own very large percentages of their networks, but I would for sure agree with, right? Like they intentionally minimize the size to any vendor so that they have pricing leverage. Five, the market won't get a clean look at the financials of an AI-empowered brokerage until 2029 at the earliest.
SPEAKER_01Thinks that's probably good news for CH. Big winner, RXO shareholders, and this one was just for funsies. My guess is some of those lawsuits are magically solved. Interesting.
SPEAKER_00Also, I I looked it up. It's uh pronounced earnings accretion, and that is an increase in a company's earnings per share after a merger or acquisition. So there you go. Yeah. Well, yeah, it's uh it's interesting. CH has been in the news for a lot of different things, but yeah, those lawsuits. Um there you go. That's uh very you think about six hundred and four million dollars as kind of a drop in the bucket when you think about a$25 billion value.
SPEAKER_00Like very small drop in the bucket. So yes. All right. Well, uh, anything else in the news? Um diesel's expensive. Oh, interesting. I was talking to somebody the other day who I used to work with, and she's like, you know, how's things going for you guys at Pierce, you know, with the market and everything? Actually, I was talking to two different people that I used to work with at two different companies about the same thing. Just like, how's the market going? How how you guys like how's it impacting you all?
SPEAKER_00And I was talking about I'm like, you know, there's kind of like two different kinds of brokers. There's those that have good relationships with their customers, and customers are receptive to like rate increases and it's being passed on to their customers. And then there's those that are like, I can't ask for more money, and then they're taking like thin margins or losses because you know, cost of transportation has gone up because of capacity and fuel. Um and the the one the girl I was talking to, I was like, what does that conversation sound like for you if you ever have a customer that's like pushing back on rates?
SPEAKER_00And she's like, Well, she's like basically like it's not them, it's usually like their boss or like a meeting where like the cost of transportation comes up and they're talking about it, and that's where the pressure comes from. That like, hey, our costs are going up, what's going on? And she's like, like, tell your boss, like, you're not an idiot. I know you watch the news, I know you've seen it on TV, I know you see it when you fill up your gas in your car, like gas prices are way higher than they were six months ago.
SPEAKER_00Like, this is not like a magical like phenomenon, like this is a thing that's been happening since the end of February. So, um, and it's just having that like open conversation. Like we used to talk about years ago before like fuel came into the question. Like, if you go to your customer with analytics and data about why the price is what it is, whether it's because of capacity or market tightness or looseness or fuel or whatever, like giving context as to why a rate is what it is, doesn't only like help your customer understand, but like kind of gives you some like a little bit of credibility, right?
SPEAKER_00Like you actually have a pulse on what's going on in the market.
SPEAKER_01So it also does a third thing, which I would say is like you are also adding value to the relationship with your customer in a sense that now the person that is giving you the business has another way to explain it to their boss. Yes. Right? You're basically educating one person removed from the person you talk to, right? The more your point of contact can explain this in multiple ways, the less likely they are to get yelled at for pricing going up as if it's them not being good, effective, or caring about how they manage transportation.
SPEAKER_01Because uh one of the things that kind of surprised me, but maybe didn't surprise me, I always kind of go back and forth on this, is like when I was just as a broker working on the outside, right, with shippers. And then since we've been doing consulting for like we were talking about for like seven years now, like we get to go and also work with these large shippers from the shipper's point of view. So it's a for sure behind the curtain scene of the conversations that happen with these individuals. And like I can't tell you how many times I've been on calls with like a director of transportation, a director or executive of procurement, a CTO or a CFO, right?
SPEAKER_01Mostly the CFO, and they're all different departments. And when you're talking these companies that are multi-billion dollars, right, like it always kind of would surprise me that like a lot of them, I think, don't have an understanding of how those things work. Yeah. Because it and again, I don't want to go on like a huge tangent, but like all of our society is set up in silos, whether it's science, medicine, history, like I know this, I stay in my lane, you know this, you stay in your lane. But there's very little crossing the aisle to use a political term, to understand how your department affects mine and vice versa.
SPEAKER_01Because in some of these, right, one department is in charge of like the service level for transportation. How, how many of their loads are delivering and picking up on time? That's not always the transportation person. Like they have those numbers, but usually the person that is either complaining, they're never like bringing good news. It's always just the negative. Our loads aren't picking up on time as much as they used to. And then you've got a guy in another department that's staffing that's like, yeah, I had to hire more people at our warehouses because more of our trucks are showing up late for either pickup or delivery.
SPEAKER_01My costs are going up. And then in a whole other department, the person in charge of transportation is like, well, yeah, we tried to slash the transportation budget 20%. We hit our goal, but then all of our trucks are showing up late because we're paying them less. And that's kind of it's like if you push on one side of a balloon, like it gets bigger on the other end. You push down here, it gets bigger over there. And these things are all related, but they're managed by different departments. So oftentimes you just have somebody in a department that gets a directive and says, Well, my boss told me our numbers need to be cut by this no matter what.
SPEAKER_01Well, then the person on the ground's like getting yelled at because the loads aren't picking up on time because they're they're cutting rates. Well, what happens when you cut rates to a carrier, even on dedicated lanes? They have to make up for having less money. What do they do? Take more loads closer together. Why? To make up for getting paid less on the work they did for you. That means there's more likelihood that they don't get to your pickup on time because they literally had to run a load that delivers an hour and a half before they get to your facility. When you pay them a little more, they can deliver a load that is four hours before they pick up your load, wait a little bit, and your service goes up.
SPEAKER_01There's a direct correlation between what you pay and your service levels. You can't pay for what you get.
unknownCorrect.
SPEAKER_00Um, one last news thing. Did you hear about this new trucking bill that was introduced? Um the trucking safety and accountability act of 2026. So this was introduced by Brandon Gill. He's a uh uh congressman in Texas. He's like he's pretty popular on YouTube and Instagram. He's like a younger guy. I think he's in his 30s, but this one it's it's nicknamed the uh Baron's Law.
SPEAKER_00Um so this like does it deals with cabotage with uh chameleon carriers, um English language proficiency, like all the like the buzz things that we've talked about lately. So what this and it I it's so new that like he's I think he's just got like one co sponsor right now, but basically, um so it's got CDL applicants would uh need to be U.S. citizens, green card holders, or otherwise federally authorized.
SPEAKER_00Authorized to work as commercial drivers. Federal CDL records would flag whether uh driver qualifies. Drivers have to pass an FMCSA approved English English proficiency test to get or renew a license. Proven you can read road signs, handle spoken and emergency instructions, and fill out logs. It also goes after chameleon carriers. DOT could deny registration to carriers whose authority was revoked within the last three years, hiding any affiliation to try and dodge sanctions.
SPEAKER_00So like if you were basically to burn an MC and try to open up a new one, would cost you up to$25,000 in a year in prison.
SPEAKER_00And if you're a carrier that uses ineligible drivers, so like your non-domiciled, non-eligible drivers,$25,000 per offense and rising to$100K if someone is seriously hurt or killed in an accident. Foreign carriers doing illegal domestic runs, that's your cabotage. So like if a Canadian carrier tries to run a US to US load.
SPEAKER_01I know that we'd found in other episodes.
SPEAKER_00Yep. So cabotage could be a hundred thousand dollars per truck per day in fines if they if they're caught doing that. And states that do not cooperate would lose a 10% of federal highway funds. And then lastly, it would add um a G a GPS and geofencing pilot uh program at busy border crossings that would track violations, and uh DOT, Department of Homeland Security would all report back to Congress on whether the law is working.
SPEAKER_00So there's a lot in there, and because I think it's so heavy on immigration, it's probably gonna face some scrutiny um and not get as much bipartisan support as some of the things we talked about last week. Um, that was kind of a big, big one for the trucking industry to see that one um introduced. So Well, here's the thing that I'll update you in like three years on whether or not it passes. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01The one thing I do like about the proposal is we've constantly heard. I mean, we were talking about this last episode and you when you were on Capitol Hill. Was it like we need funding to enforce and do these things? Okay. Right? We've heard Leffler has been on our show and others have talked about like safety costs money, right? Like whether it's auditing the vehicle maintenance logs, whether it's making sure that equipment is safe on the road, whatever those things are, like there's a cost associated with them.
SPEAKER_01But you have criminals where we're not generating fees and fines from their illegal actions. And to me, like that is at least a very good way to generate income from people breaking the law and doing things that are creating literally fatalities, issues, and driving up insurance costs. That's who should be paying the bill. And that money should, in essence, be able to fund different programs that are making the road safer.
SPEAKER_01Like, yeah, to me, that's the loop that should work. Now, again, we could spend hours talking about whether money gets directly to that department, how it gets funneled, how they'll argue back and forth that money will be misappropriated. But at the end of the day, the people that should be paying to increase safety are the people violating the things and doing unthings, things that are unsafe, and that money should go directly back to the people that are trying to make things safer.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, agreed. Yeah, that's a good point. Very good point. All right. Uh let's get into some legal stuff. We're just talking about news and legal things, but we had this, I we were talking about it off-air uh last week about uh well, why don't you just kind of take it away?
SPEAKER_01What do you got for us on the uh we were chatting about a we had a client that was running into some things with like non-solicits, and and there's a lot of different agreements, and there's a lot of different states and a lot of different ways these are handled, but they're pretty common in free brokers. We have many episodes throughout the years on like how to negotiate a non-compete, a non-solicit, and some of the things that basically are also usually in those agreements, meaning like you also can't take intellectual property, meaning like if a company has a certain way of doing business or a certain technology, both can be considered intellectual property.
SPEAKER_01Me teaching you how to do something and you learning how the software is made or used are all kind of fall under that umbrella in one way or another, right? Those are usually in that agreement. And then usually you also have a restriction on you can't not just take intellectual property customers, but you also can't take other employees, whether it's a colleague or somebody that works for you, meaning like you can't just like gut a business. And these are very common in every industry for like really valid reasons. Like you like a company doesn't have any vested interest in being able to survive if the employees can just take everything they learn and use, go across the street and open up a McDonald's, for example.
SPEAKER_01Like they exist over there too, for the same reasons. And you could watch that whole movie with Ray Kroc because that actually happened in the McDonald's um story related to how that business came up. So these are just specific. They're not just specific to freight brokerage, but they're pretty common. And they're definitely states that literally won't uphold non-competes. But non-solicits usually are pretty defensible because like you're like stealing a customer. So those are also works made for hire.
SPEAKER_00You remember that one where like if you created something, so like for example, this podcast, right? This podcast started inside of a brokerage that I worked at before my current company, and that was one of the things like when I got when I got uh served for non-compete, non-solicit, like works made for hire, all the things. Like they they threw the the the book at me and the podcast was part of it. Like, hey, this was created inside our our walls under our roof, and you know, we work through it because you know legal battles go two ways, right?
SPEAKER_00Um, but that's that's a big thing. So like if you if you work at a brokerage and you created, let's say, like a TMS or some sort of software or an AI tool or whatever that you use to benefit the company, you can't leave in most cases and then take that product or platform with you if you have one of those employment clauses.
SPEAKER_01Two interesting things. The same thing happened to me. I was a 1099, you were a W-2, yours had to be worked through much longer. Mine was squashed in like two emails with our attorney because I wasn't, I did not have that agreement. The other thing I was using, I was explaining this to um someone else is like you you hear about these more with like inventions, like, oh, this guy works for this company, invented like the computer, a printer, a monitor, like the light bulb, like any of those things throughout history.
SPEAKER_01And you wonder, like, you'll see in the news, like, oh, this guy invents this super important thing that everybody used and ends up losing his job, being penniless, and taking nothing with him. Well, it's usually because of one of these agreements where the resources, the tools, and the things that person used to create this invention were all funded by that company, along with the people that helped that person invent it, along with the salary that person was compensated with to literally do this type of work for the benefit of the company.
SPEAKER_01So, and a lot of times you'll read an article that'll very much seem like this big bad company like did something really terrible, but not the other side of it, of like, well, companies also wouldn't fund any of these things if they aren't label able to later able to sell it, because most things that people invent or do also lose money. So, like if you're doing this a hundred times, 95 might literally just be losing money. The handful that actually work, the company needs to be able to sell to pay for all these people to keep doing it.
SPEAKER_01And then you read an article and it focuses on the one winner, they don't talk about any of the losers, and then all of a sudden it seems like these companies are just doing things terribly, right? So there's two sides to it. But what we were talking a lot about is like how these things kind of play out because you've had a lot more personal experience being involved in these things. And like, if you want to just kind of go through a couple of the stories that we were just chatting about, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I've so I have like two personally that I was involved in. Um, I had when I came to work for my current company, I was for lack of better legal terms, I'll just say I was sued because I don't know what the legal I don't know what the legal actual term was. But like they they tried to come after me for working for a competitor, and I had like um, hey, for I think it was like for one year, you can't go work for a competitor that operates, you know, in our space within 50 miles, blah, blah, blah.
SPEAKER_00And also, like, you can't solicit any old customers, any old employees, any old agents, you know, all the things. And you can't take anything with you that was created here. And naturally, like, I was going to work for a competitor. I was gonna try and take some of the business with me, and I was gonna take the podcast with me, like all the things. And like my my whole like defense was well, they're not within 50 miles because they're in a different state. And I counter-sued and said that you guys didn't pay my commission on this, so I'm gonna sue you for you know unpaid wages and commissions.
SPEAKER_00And my I think the attorney, we've we've used the same guy for a couple things, but like he he like he's like, dude, you're the best, he's like, You're the best candidate to like put a you know, a big SOP story together. He's like, You're a military guy that like whose wife is pregnant and is about to have a baby, and they're trying to like destroy your life and all these things, and like we can we can paint this nasty picture of them, and I'm like, wow, there really is two sides to every single like legal case.
SPEAKER_00So there is that one, um, which ended up working out, and a big part of it too is like the state that you're in. Like, the reality is most of these don't ever get to court, and most attorneys will argue to each other, like, hey, you know, this will never hold up in court because this jurisdiction is very friendly on the employee, not the employer. So you have like right-to-work states, and you have so like basically half the states in the US are more employee-friendly. Um and side note, if you ever wonder what a work or a right-to-work state is, it's actually um states that make it illegal for a company to force you to join a union if you want to work for the company, which New York is actually not a right-to-work state.
SPEAKER_00Um I worked at a grocery store growing up that forced you to join their union. I had to pay like seven bucks a week or something like that. It was super dumb. But um, but regardless, states that are right to work and have those laws tend to be more employee-friendly. And also, New York, even though it's not a right-to-work state, is typically more employee-friendly overall. Um, the other lawsuit that I was wrapped into was against TQL.
SPEAKER_00I never worked for TQL, but we hired a lot of people that came from TQL, and TQL is notorious for having very um strict, non-compete, non-solicitation, um, employee contract clauses, and more so importantly, enforcing them. Like they have an entire, I mean, you would know better than me, but like they have like in-house counsel that you know most smaller brokerages don't have. Um, that they like it's worth hiring these attorneys in-house just to be able to like you know, go after every every single employee once they're fired or quit or whatever.
SPEAKER_00But we had this this lawsuit, and I think it's still ongoing, like six years later, but basically, like for um, and they ended up hiring like an outside firm for it, but it was basically like you guys are targeting people that you know have non-competes, non-solicitation agreements, etc., and we're gonna come after you for damages, and it's like a seven-figure lawsuit.
SPEAKER_00I don't I don't think it's even still finally closed out yet, but like it's a real thing.
SPEAKER_01But that is the very big different, that is a very different scenario, the first and the second that I kind of want to like cover, right? One is knowing and willingly like taking customers and taking employees or coworkers to damage a business and doing it intentionally. The other story is this person wants to continue working in the industry and is in a far enough away place that it should not impact your business, right?
SPEAKER_01Like they seem very similar, but they're very different, right? Because the things that you and I were talking about is like in most of those ones related to like TQL, like the people that became agents that left the W-2 world, like most of those ended up settling. Like they literally paid out of their pocket to be able to make that go away, if I remember, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so one of the one of the guys, um Trevor, you I think you know who he is.
SPEAKER_01I definitely know Trevor.
SPEAKER_00But he was um he was a TQL guy, and he was part of it. He was forced to sit on the sidelines for six months or whatever, I forget the timeline, but like it actually like it happened. Like, yeah, because he had his own individual lawsuit with TQL. So like it's a real thing, and like they will like if a if a company wants to, and that you signed an agreement, like whoever wants to spend the time, energy, and oftentimes money, like that stuff will hold up most times, like it really will.
SPEAKER_00And like, so he literally had built this entire like we'll just call it a business. He was he had an agency, but he built this, like, this business and everything, and um he was forced to sit on the sidelines and do nothing related to the industry for six months or whatever, I forget how long it was. I think it was like half a year or something like that. But like, it's a real thing, and um or they can even double down and like you could you have to pay damages. So, like, oftentimes in your agreement, it'll say, like, you know, not just hey, you can't go work for a competitor for a year or you can't steal business for two years, but it'll say, like, if you do, uh, we we are entitled to recoup, you know, sometimes it's like 10% of all profits plus attorney's fees, etc.
SPEAKER_00So, like, dude, it you can you get yourself in a whirlwind of trouble um if you violate this stuff.
SPEAKER_01So that was one that you and I were talking with with this client was they had the ability to basically show damages, the dollar amount of the damages, the time frame in which these things occurred. And then I know like for sure there's always gonna be different legal opinions, but when you get to the damages part, right, like that's where it really is a lot different. Because when you have a very large company, like you said, like again, not picking on TQL, but just using them as an example because they happen to be involved in some of the stuff that you happen to be involved in, is it's worth it for them to spend the tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars to take these all the way to court when oftentimes the person defending themselves, like their their attorneys aren't just taking that on pro bono.
SPEAKER_01It's not like some attorney is gonna be like, hey, like, or in your case, whoever represented you was like, hey, we're just gonna do this for free. Because even if you win in court, sometimes you still have to pay your attorney fees. Like you might literally prevail after a year or two in court. And it is not always a given that the losing side pays the winning side's attorney fees. I've run into this in like real estate things where it's like, hey, the attorney's like, we would definitely win. It'll probably be 150 for you to fight this. The reason I won't take it pro bono, because I've asked them this in these scenarios over the years, I'm like, well, why wouldn't you take it in pro bono?
SPEAKER_01Like if you know it's 150 and you know, like with almost assured certainty, because of other cases you've tried and precedents and things you know that I don't, that you'll win, why wouldn't you take it? And they're like, well, because it's still a coin flip that the judge would make the losing side pay my bills. So if I do this, they basically have come back to me or real estate clients and said, are you guys willing to roll the dice on 150 grand? Because we'll win, but you still might have a hundred and fifty thousand dollar bill that's said and done. And if the judge says, hey, they're not required to pay my fees, like I have to bill you.
SPEAKER_01And I don't want to put you in this position where you think winning is the same as free legal counsel by way of winning. And those are very different things when you really get into these cases.
SPEAKER_00And the other thing too is like the company hiring somebody that has that non-compete, non-solicit. Like, so let's say, let's say, like, you know, you have a brokerage, Ben, and you know, you hired somebody and they're working for you, and they have all these restrictive covenants, and then they try to leave and go work for another decent sized brokerage, and they try to steal customers, and they try to steal employees, etc. Like the company hiring them is also gonna be at fault here, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So, like, normally what I've seen is when a um, and uh it's funny, like oftentimes as the employer, I I have received the cease and assist before the actual person that we hired did. So, like I remember years ago, hired a guy and like never mentioned anything about non-compete, non-solicit, anything like that. And then we get like an overnight letter from an attorney's office representing like the former employer.
SPEAKER_00I forget, it was some brokerage in Chicago, and they're like, Yeah, you're you know, you're named in this, like you guys apparently hired so-and-so, and here's his employment contract, and you can see right here in sections, blah, blah, blah, he's got a non-compete, non-solicit for X amount of time, and you guys are violating it. Here's a cease and assist. And then I call the dude, and he's like, he's like, I didn't get anything. And I was like, Well, do you have a non-compete? He's like, I don't know. And I'm like, Well, and then he got like the next day, like his came shortly afterward. But it's like both parties are at risk in these situations.
SPEAKER_01So this is why something that you and I've talked about over the years, but like you, this is something you literally do as an employer, right? And like, but I do, and like most larger companies do, but smaller companies don't necessarily think about this, right? But usually when you inside when you sign your paperwork to either be an agent or a W-2 employee at another brokerage, usually somewhere in that paperwork it says, I'm certifying that I'm under no prohibitive other agreements. I'm not currently employed by someone else, I have no conflict of interest, I have no withstanding or outstanding agreements related to intellectual property or anything that basically that business operates in, right?
SPEAKER_01So whether you've read all those or not, when you go work at a medium to larger company, like that's in there. And that's in there to protect the company from saying, hey, like we asked this candidate when we interviewed them. They said they weren't aware of any of those. But ignorance is not a defense in law. Like just not remembering you have one of those does not mean you're not still under that agreement. That's why an employer will literally ask you this and then have you sign it in writing. Because if they get a cease and desist later, that's exactly what the attorney is gonna request.
SPEAKER_01Did you ask this? Did you know this? Were you aware? Because that is the piece that, like you said, you do as an employer where you ask and you make sure this is true, or you will call previous positions, right? Like the references, right?
SPEAKER_00I'm gonna read that, I'm gonna read verbatim. Here, here's a uh here's a employment contract um from a company that I will read one of the sections on. Uh, this is not my current company, it's just one that I as soon as you mentioned that I wanted to pull it up because I know I had it. It states, and this is what this is what the the broker would be signing when they join this new company. It says Um uh this person uh further represents and warrants that neither it nor any of its employees are party to any non-compete or non-circumvention agreement or similar restrictive covenants with any other third party or restricted in a way to enter into this agreement and will indemnify this company harmless from and against any and all claims made against or losses incurred by the company as a result of this person's breach of this provision, including without limitation all attorney's fees, costs, disbursements, and settlements made related to the same.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, if you sign that and you know you have a non-compete non-solicit, now your company, right, not only can they just like fire you, but they can then sue you in addition. Like you're gonna get sued, and then your new employee or new employer can then sue you as well for any damages that they have to uh end up paying. So the reality is most of these never get to court because if the argument is strong enough, like Usually the person that's going to lose the argument is gonna bow out.
SPEAKER_00And that's usually in the best interest of every everybody, whether it's the employer or the employee. Like in my case, it was the employee or the employer that bowed out. But in a lot of cases, it's the employee that bows out. So like TQL, CH Robinson, you know, any any company that's got a strong case usually like just comes hard on the paperwork side and the scare tactic alone sends the message that like we don't want to go down this path, and you don't want to go down this path.
SPEAKER_00We know how this is gonna end, like let's just get this over and done with. So yeah. So I'm I'm actually curious. Do you think we had this conversation with with Trey many, many years ago, but do you think non-competes are good for our industry? Or do you like would you do you have a case for both sides of it? Non-solicit is one thing, right? Like non-solicits, I think, are are healthy and good in our in our industry. Um but just to go to work for somebody else.
SPEAKER_00Not if you're gonna steal anything, but just to work for somebody else.
SPEAKER_01I think here's the I I would say Okay, because there's a few different ways I want to answer it and I want to make this all make sense. Okay, so non-solicits, you should not be able to steal customers. I that's why they're pretty much upheld everywhere, but non-solicites.
SPEAKER_00What's mine's mine, what's yours is yours. Like we're not stealing from each other.
SPEAKER_01Now, there are certain businesses where like a time frame on a non-compete, I think, makes sense. And those are usually when you have equity or you own a company. And here's the reason why those I think make sense and they are different. Okay, so there's a famous story that Warren Buffett tells. He buys this furniture like franchise. I think it was in Omaha or Nebraska somewhere, right? And it was a pretty big furniture company. Think like Kmart that sold only.
SPEAKER_00Did he like buy it from some lady or something like that? Yes, like an old lady.
SPEAKER_01She's like literally 87 or 88 years old. This isn't like the 70s, right? And it is a large dollar amount, like 100 million dollars or something back then, right? So a large dollar amount buys the whole business. He's like, this is a great business. He does not include a non-compete because, well, the woman was, I think, like literally 89. She might have been 90 years old. Okay. Yeah. That woman, once she takes the 100 million dollars, he immediately, like a month later, buys the building. I think it was literally across the street. And she has all of the relationships with all of the furniture suppliers.
SPEAKER_01She still knows all of them. So she basically literally creates the exact same business under a new name across the street, like a month later. Inside of a year, he says in his biography, I had to buy her out a second time. So from that point forward, I at least put a time frame on you can't compete with me because I'm buying your business and the goodwill and equity, and part of that are your relationships. So you at least got to give me a head start before you come back and start to compete. So, like that's really where I think those make a lot of sense.
SPEAKER_01And there are like valid reasons why if I'm paying you for your business, you shouldn't be able to go and compete with me at least next week with the same inside information that I've literally purchased from you. So in that sense, I think that's why they exist. Now, the argument has been made in like our industry that like it's not the customers, but we're paying to hire, recruit, and train people. Then those people go and work for other companies and then they compete against us. So that's the justification for non-compete for a big company in freight brokerage.
SPEAKER_01But the thing that I think is bullshit is well, if you treated those employees better and you didn't treat it like a giant factory where you train, hire, and fire people because they're not up to an unrealistic standard, your employees wouldn't be needing to go to other companies. They clearly find enough value in them that they've continued on in their career. People wouldn't still have a job at a business, even it's across the street in freight brokerage, if they didn't provide value to that business. So, yes, you as a business owner have the ability to create a different standard for output and productivity for your employees, but you shouldn't be able to prevent said employees from continuing to work in the industry somewhere else because you just don't want them to, and you refuse to address that issue.
SPEAKER_01So, that to me, why like I think there's more of an argument against it than for it. And also, I spent more of my life on being under non-compete than having one. And it's always been the non-solicit part that I think is ridiculous, or no, that should be upheld where the non-compete probably shouldn't be there. Because if you had people willingly and able to go to different companies without all the legal costs and things, like you would have probably like an overall better on better industry.
SPEAKER_00That was, and that was the big argument that Trey made on our this is probably like four years ago. We had this conversation of like, there's so much talent in our industry, and non-competes oftentimes restrict companies from being innovative and having just good talent come in and make the industry overall more efficient and better. Um, again, non-solicitation, stealing business, stealing customers, stealing employees, different conversation. Um, non-competes, I think, have a place in certain industries, and ours, I don't really like it.
SPEAKER_00And here's an interesting one for you. So I'll say this too: like employees versus contractors, like an agent who's an 1099 should never exist, right? There's a guy right now that I met who has a he's a he's an agent for a company, and um when you're an agent, like you don't get a salary, you don't have any benefits, you're paying an extra um X amount percentage and self-employment tax because you're um you don't have an employer that's gonna pick up half the tab.
SPEAKER_00And this guy, he's considering switching companies, and he's like, I have to meet with my attorney because I, you know, I have this multi-year like exclusivity clause, like a non-compete clause with them. And I'm like, as a contractor, you have that? He's like, he's like, Yeah, you know, they made me sign it in order to receive the commission percentage that I have. And I'm like, Yeah, but you're 1099. Like you're an independent contractor, that shouldn't even hold up. He's like, Yeah, it probably won't. Like it should be like a a non-starter.
SPEAKER_00I'm like, I'm just shocked that like a company would even think that would ever hold up and would make somebody sign that. And I think the reason is it's more of a scare tactic for a 1099 than anything. Um it is, but I'll give you the counterpoint.
SPEAKER_01I'll give you a counterpoint. The counterpoint is really related to time, which now I can argue the other side. I'll argue it from a company's point of view. Okay, if you're going through training for a job and it's very intense and very expensive for the company, and say it takes six months, okay? So you come, you work for me, and I give you the best training in the industry, tools, know-how, practice, experience, all on my dime while you collect a salary. And then once you know how to do the job, you leave next week.
SPEAKER_01Okay, well, now that does create an issue for businesses that have a large expense in training, which is why like I do feel like I could argue the other side. And the reason I know that is like that's kind of common for coaching certifications in 1099 world, because the bulk of the training and the expense is on the company, even though the person's 1099. And usually the company, there's two ways to do it. If you want to go be a coach for some companies, and there's a lot of different ones, right?
SPEAKER_01Some you pay for the certification. Like you will literally pay this company 45 grand for three to six months to get certified in all of their training and practice to do this, then you can operate and then they either give you clients or you can get your own. No non-compete. Some of those companies will say, We will pay for your certification, but you basically have to stay with us for at least a year until we recoup the training costs.
SPEAKER_00Did you have an agreement like that with Southwestern?
SPEAKER_01I think I did. And I think that's why I was there for a little more than a year before we started coaching here, if I remembered, was there was something in there? Because that definitely was part of it. And I'm like, that to me, I agree with. Because it's also the same reason why if you some like I think nursing does this, they'll pay for you to go get another degree, but then you sign a contract that you will work at this hospital for at least two years so the company can get back their investment they pay in your education. And to me, like that is a very justifiable reason to have some time commitment that like the company's not saying we're firing you.
SPEAKER_01They're saying you have to work with us so we can get the value of what we put into our investment in you. Then if you just to go decide to leave the next week, then I should be able to prevent you from doing that in some way because like you broke your agreement. I did what my side said, paid, invested time, hired you, paid you, gave you benefits, and then you broke your end of it. To me, maybe there's a different agreement, and that's not a non-compete. It's just I would be able to personally go after you for breach of contract for doing it. But I think that's probably all into the same bucket of non-compete, which is why they seem like you can argue both sides of it, because depending on time, like they're very much because we've seen cases of both.
SPEAKER_01That's what I'm saying. Like we've literally had clients where like they've literally hired, recruited, brought somebody into their brokerage, trained them, invested their time, gave them customers, and as soon as that person learned the job, they left and tried to take everything. And like that to me is also super unethical. It's the same way as I think it's unethical to prevent people from like literally just going anywhere. But at the end of the day, non-solicit solicitations are not really a gray area. You are taking customers, you are doing that, or you're taking employees, or you're taking IP, those exist for a reason, and they typically end up playing out the way you thought, like you said, in court, where that agent ended up settling or getting sued or losing, and the business that took them also is still literally in court or has lost in most of those.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So all that to say, if you are uh we obviously if you're if you're the employee, we've kind of laid that out. But if you're an employer, you're running a brokerage, right? You definitely should consult with an attorney. Like um, employment attorneys are great. We you and I used one um both for personal cases, but also he helped us put together a lot of business documents for Frey 360. Uh, but use an attorney and and think about like what do you want to have as part of your employment agreements with your employees uh or your agents, if it's you know an agent-based company, but probably you know, way less restrictive in that case, but they will be able to help protect you, but it also if they're too restrictive, it might hurt you in the you know the the pool of candidates that are willing to come work for you.
SPEAKER_00So keep there's kind of two sides to it. So if you're if you're if you're hiring people that have no experience and they're getting trained up and all that, like you have a lot of leeway to have restrictive covenants in your employment agreements. Um, it's very difficult if you're trying to if your goal is to hire a very experienced, well-seasoned um broker to come to your company as an employee, W-2. It's gonna be very hard to get them to, you know, come bring their business with it, you know, with them and and grow it, and then tell them like, oh, you can't ever leave and go work somewhere else or take business with you.
SPEAKER_00Um they're gonna probably tell you to go town rock. So um yeah, good takeaways, you know. What else you got on this topic?
SPEAKER_01That's all I got, man.
SPEAKER_00All right. That's a good one. Good discussion. All right, Ben, final thoughts.
SPEAKER_01Whether you believe you can or believe you can't, you're right.
We sit down with Tom Croteau, CEO and founder of OperFi, to discuss the ins and outs of freight factoring, how he built his company from the ground up, and why credit and cash flow are so important in transportation. We...
⛽ Do brokers often keep the FSC from carriers? 💸 How much should an owner-operator pay for a dispatcher? 📦 Truckload brokers: what do you do when a regular customer wants LTL moved? Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click...
If prospecting feels like pushing a boulder uphill, the problem is usually your system, not your script. We cover why one call and one objection won’t win a shipper, how to pick a niche and target mid-sized shippers,...
🛡️ Do freight agents need general liability insurance? 💰 How can new brokers book loads without established credit? 🚛 How could H.R. 7261 impact brokers and carriers? Support Our Sponsors: Togo: Click Here OperFi:...
Freight brokerage margins can make or break your business, especially when market conditions shift. We break down how to protect your profits, adjust pricing as carrier rates rise or fall, manage customer expectations,...