#355 - In 2015, healthy 60-year-old chiropractor Mary Yoder suddenly became violently ill and died less than 48 hours later. Toxicology revealed that she had been poisoned with colchicine, but identifying who gave it to her would divide her family and community for years. A suspicious letter, a bottle hidden inside her son’s Jeep, conflicting digital evidence, and touch DNA eventually led investigators to his ex-girlfriend, Katie Conley. But after two trials, a conviction, and its eventual reversal, one question remains: Who really poisoned Mary Yoder? Forensic Tales is a Rockefeller Audio production, written and produced by Courtney Fretwell. Support the show on Patreon (get early ad-free access to episodes, monthly bonus episodes & more): patreon.com/forensictales Website & Episode Sources: https://www.forensictales.com/mary-yoder Follow Forensic Tales: Instagram: @forensictales TikTok: @forensictales Facebook: Forensic Tales Contact: courtney@forensictales.com Our Sponsors: * Check out Sequencing and use my code sequencing.com/FORENSIC10 for a great deal: https://sequencing.com * Check out Vinted: https://www.vinted.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[SPEAKER_00]: Violent nausea strikes Dr. Mary Yoder so fiercely that all the color drains from her face. [SPEAKER_00]: She spends the night shivering in the bathroom, unaware that her lunch hit a deadly secret. [SPEAKER_00]: She actually swallowed enough agricultural poison to kill her 15 times over. [SPEAKER_00]: This is forensic tales, episode 355, the poisoning death of Mary Yoder.
[UNKNOWN]: Welcome to Forensic Tales. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm your host, Courtney Fretwell. [SPEAKER_00]: If you enjoy deep dives into real cases and the science behind them, make sure you're subscribed so you never miss an episode.
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you want even more content, including monthly full-length bonus episodes and early ad-free access to over 300 episodes, you can join our community over on Patreon. [SPEAKER_00]: To learn more, visit patreon.com slash forensic tales. [SPEAKER_00]: After covering a few international cases in honor of attending CrimeCon UK last week, we're back to a story from New York that is still generating a lot of attention even over a decade later. [SPEAKER_00]: We're headed to Utica, a small city in central New York located in the Mohawk Valley about an hour east of Syracuse.
[SPEAKER_00]: Once a booming manufacturing hub, Utica is now home to around 60,000 people and is known for its close-knit neighborhoods, long winters, and strong Italian-American roots. [SPEAKER_00]: But it's also remembered for something far darker. [SPEAKER_00]: Just a few miles outside the city is the village of Whitesboro. [SPEAKER_00]: That's where 60-year-old Dr. Mary Yoder and her husband, 68-year-old Bill, spent years building both their family
[SPEAKER_00]: They met in college in 1975, where they were both studying for a degree in chiropractic medicine, and although their relationship started as just roommates, they soon began dating and became inseparable. [SPEAKER_00]: After college, Bill and Mary got married and had three kids together, Leanna, Tamaran and Adam, and one of their shared interest over the years was health and wellness. [SPEAKER_00]: Bill had even published a book called The Happy Mind. [SPEAKER_00]: Seven principles to clear your head and lift your heart.
[SPEAKER_00]: And Mary ran a small supplement and vitamin business on the side. [SPEAKER_00]: After running their respective practices for decades, the two decided to start a joint chiropractic care center on Oriscani Boulevard in Whitesboro. [SPEAKER_00]: And it quickly grew into one of the most popular in the area with hundreds of loyal customers. [SPEAKER_00]: It felt more like a mom and pop business than a large corporation, which is likely why people kept coming back. [SPEAKER_00]: Mary and Bill treated patients while a small front office staff handled appointments, paperwork, and the practices day-to-day needs, and it wasn't just their business that was successful.
[SPEAKER_00]: By the summer of 2015, the Yoders had been married for nearly 40 years, and all three of their children had grown up and started their own lives. [SPEAKER_00]: Mary and Bill had built their home, raised their family, and devoted their careers to helping others live healthier lives. [SPEAKER_00]: But their own seemingly happy and healthy life together was about to come to a sudden and tragic end. [SPEAKER_00]: Monday, July 20th, 2015 started like any other day for Mary, and by all accounts, it was going to be a busy one with a full schedule of patients to see.
[SPEAKER_00]: Bill was up by 630 to head to the gym like he usually did while Mary showered and got ready for the clinic. [SPEAKER_00]: He kissed her goodbye, then Mary made the 15-minute drive to work. [SPEAKER_00]: Also working that day was the Yoters 22-year-old [SPEAKER_00]: Katie first became connected to the practice through the Yoda's son, Adam. [SPEAKER_00]: Adam had been helping his parents manage the office. [SPEAKER_00]: But when he decided to return to school full-time in 2014, he suggested they bring in his girlfriend, Katie, to help out and replace him.
[SPEAKER_00]: And by the summer of 2015, Adam was no longer working there. [SPEAKER_00]: And 22-year-old Katie had taken over as the practice's full-time office manager. [SPEAKER_00]: Although Mary and Bill had only met her a few times before she joined the business, she quickly earned their trust and became close to the family. [SPEAKER_00]: Sometime that year, Katie and Adam broke up, but Katie continued to work at his parents' office. [SPEAKER_00]: And everything seemed to be going well. [SPEAKER_00]: Katie got to keep her job and Mary and Bill appreciated the support in keeping the administrative side of the business running.
[SPEAKER_00]: But Katie's connection to the Yoder family was about to become far more complicated than anyone could have imagined. [SPEAKER_00]: Patience who saw Mary on the morning of Monday, July 20th, said she seemed completely normal. [SPEAKER_00]: She was happy, upbeat, and looking forward to working in her garden after work, like she usually did. [SPEAKER_00]: But when she returned from her lunch break, where she stopped by her sister's house to visit with her 93-year-old mother, everything about her changed.
[SPEAKER_00]: She had lost all the color in her face, and in-between patients, she was constantly running to the restroom to throw up. [SPEAKER_00]: Initially, Mary thought she had come down with a bad case of food poisoning. [SPEAKER_00]: Although even that idea seemed a little far-fetched, because she ate almost the same exact thing for lunch every day, protein powder that she mixed with almond milk. [SPEAKER_00]: So it would have been a little out of the ordinary to suddenly get food poisoning.
[SPEAKER_00]: But as the afternoon went on, Mary just kept getting sicker and sicker until she eventually asked Katie to cancel the rest of her patients that afternoon so she could go home. [SPEAKER_00]: She then called Bill saying she wasn't feeling well and was headed home. [SPEAKER_00]: As soon as she walked in the front door, Bill saw firsthand just how sick his wife really [SPEAKER_00]: Mary wasn't the kind of person who got sick often. [SPEAKER_00]: She had always been healthy and did her best to take care of herself.
[SPEAKER_00]: That's something the Yoders always had in common. [SPEAKER_00]: So when he saw her, he thought maybe she had caught some kind of severe stomach bug. [SPEAKER_00]: The kind that keeps you running to the toilet hoping you make it in time. [SPEAKER_00]: By 930 that night, Mary still felt terrible, so she told Bill to go upstairs, get some sleep, and she would stay on the couch. [SPEAKER_00]: If this was a stomach bug, she would probably feel better by the morning. [SPEAKER_00]: When Bill came downstairs the next morning to check on her, she was even worse.
[SPEAKER_00]: She said she had been in the bathroom all night long with relentless diarrhea and vomiting. [SPEAKER_00]: And whatever she had was only making her sicker. [SPEAKER_00]: So they decided to go to the emergency room. [SPEAKER_00]: When they arrived, the doctors and nurses performed every possible test on her, but everything came back negative. [SPEAKER_00]: They just couldn't figure out what was making her so sick. [SPEAKER_00]: And although she started feeling a little better, the doctors decided to keep her overnight for observation. [SPEAKER_00]: They wanted to give her fluids and told Bill he could go home and get some rest because they would keep an eye on her.
[SPEAKER_00]: But the next morning, July 22, around 530, Bill was woken by someone banging on his front door. [SPEAKER_00]: When he got up and answered, two state troopers met him and told him the hospital had been desperately trying to reach him. [SPEAKER_00]: On his way to the hospital, Bill called their three kids to break the news that their mom wasn't doing well and to make plans to come see her.
[SPEAKER_00]: And throughout the rest of the morning and early afternoon, Mary went into cardiac arrest seven times and at 254 that afternoon, she died with Bill in the kids by her side. [SPEAKER_00]: In less than 48 hours, she had gone from a seemingly healthy 60-year-old woman to dying from a mysterious illness that no one could explain. [SPEAKER_00]: While Mary's family grieved her sudden loss, doctors were desperately trying to figure out what could have caused her to go downhill so quickly.
[SPEAKER_00]: Her first symptoms had been nausea and diarrhea. [SPEAKER_00]: Nothing that would ordinarily be expected to lead to repeated cardiac arrest and death less than two days later. [SPEAKER_00]: So the following day, her body was taken to the medical examiner's office for an autopsy. [SPEAKER_00]: And that's where this story takes another unexpected turn. [SPEAKER_00]: One of the first things the pathologist saw was that many of Mary's organs had failed right before she died, including her lungs, which isn't something you typically see in an otherwise healthy adult.
[SPEAKER_00]: He also noticed their strange color, later telling law enforcement that they looked as if they had been subjected to aggressive rounds of chemotherapy. [SPEAKER_00]: But that didn't make any sense either because she wasn't being treated for any type of [SPEAKER_00]: with almost every other possibility taken off the table for her organs being so badly damaged, the pathologist then considered whether Mary had been poisoned. [SPEAKER_00]: But initially, she was only tested for commonly used poisons, like arsenic and cyanide, and all of those tests came back negative.
[SPEAKER_00]: But even with all the negative tests, the authorities weren't ready to throw in the towel and call this a natural death. [SPEAKER_00]: Mary's family tried to think of anything she could have accidentally consumed that might not show up on a traditional poison screening. [SPEAKER_00]: Everyone knew that she regularly took vitamins and nutritional supplements, and she spent a lot of time gardening, where she may have encountered fertilizers, pesticides, or other dangerous chemicals.
[SPEAKER_00]: Then, in October of 2015, the medical examiner consulted a poison control expert and described Mary's sudden gastrointestinal symptoms and rapid organ failure. [SPEAKER_00]: And as soon as this expert heard that, they thought the pattern sounded consistent with one very specific substance, [SPEAKER_00]: For many people, culture scene can be taken safely, but the dosage has to be extremely precise.
[SPEAKER_00]: That's because there's only a very small difference between an amount that can help someone and an amount that can kill them. [SPEAKER_00]: But besides treating out, it's also used in agriculture and plant breeding to change a plant's chromosomes. [SPEAKER_00]: So when Mary's samples were finally tested, investigators got their answer. [SPEAKER_00]: She had been poisoned with agricultural grade colcocene and reportedly had enough of it in her system to kill her 15 times over.
[SPEAKER_00]: This was no longer an unexplained death. [SPEAKER_00]: Someone had intentionally poisoned Mary. [SPEAKER_00]: Naturally, one of the first suspects was Bill. [SPEAKER_00]: Like we've talked about in so many previous episodes of the show, usually the husband or significant other is considered suspect number one until proven otherwise. [SPEAKER_00]: And this case was no different. [SPEAKER_00]: Although Mary and Bill seemed like the perfect happy couple on the outside, you never know what's actually going on behind closed doors.
[SPEAKER_00]: So the police first considered whether Bill could have intentionally poisoned his wife to death, but they couldn't find an obvious reason why he would want Mary dead. [SPEAKER_00]: There wasn't a large life insurance policy waiting for him. [SPEAKER_00]: There were no allegations of abuse. [SPEAKER_00]: They didn't find any of the telltale signs pointing to murder. [SPEAKER_00]: There was, however, one thing that raised some eyebrows, mine included. [SPEAKER_00]: Not long after Mary died, Bill began dating her sister Kathy.
[SPEAKER_00]: According to Bill, they first spent time alone together on July 30th, just eight days after Mary's death. [SPEAKER_00]: Kathy had also lost her husband a few years earlier, and Bill said they found comfort in their shared grief. [SPEAKER_00]: But over the next several weeks, that connection became romantic, and by September, they were openly in a relationship. [SPEAKER_00]: understandably, not everyone believed Bill's story about how exactly this relationship blossomed.
[SPEAKER_00]: Even some of Mary's other sisters claimed that he and Kathy had been spending time together before Mary died, raising the possibility that their relationship had started much earlier than they admitted, and if there was any truth to that, then that could certainly mean a motive for murder. [SPEAKER_00]: It's one of the oldest motives in the book, husband kills wife so he can be with his mistress instead of simply divorcing her. [SPEAKER_00]: But when detectives asked Bill to turn over his phone and computer, he cooperated.
[SPEAKER_00]: And after reviewing all his texts and emails with Kathy, they found nothing proving that the relationship had begun before Mary's death. [SPEAKER_00]: as strange, or at least incredibly fast, as the situation may have seemed, police had no evidence that Bill had killed his wife to be with her sister. [SPEAKER_00]: Then on November 23, 2015, the Sheriff's Department received an anonymous letter that pointed them in an entirely new direction.
[SPEAKER_00]: The letter pointed directly to Mary and Bill's oldest son, Adam as the killer. [SPEAKER_00]: A name you heard a little earlier in the episode. [SPEAKER_00]: The anonymous writer claimed that Adam had confessed to killing his mom, and had even explained how he did it. [SPEAKER_00]: He had gone to his parents' house and secretly mixed culture scene into the supplements Mary took every day. [SPEAKER_00]: The writer also offered a possible motive. [SPEAKER_00]: They claimed Adam was struggling financially, and angry that Mary essentially cut him off and wasn't giving him any more money.
[SPEAKER_00]: The letter even claimed that he resented hearing people speak so lovingly about his mom after she died. [SPEAKER_00]: But the most important part of the letter came at the very end. [SPEAKER_00]: The writer claimed the remaining culture scene was inside Adam's car. [SPEAKER_00]: As soon as this bizarre letter arrived on the detective's desk, they knew they had to bring Adam in to be questioned. [SPEAKER_00]: And that interview only made them more suspicious of him. [SPEAKER_00]: He admitted the letter was right, and that he was having a lot of financial issues at the time.
[SPEAKER_00]: That was also supported by some of Mary's sisters, who said she was starting to cut him off financially. [SPEAKER_00]: So detectives asked if he would let them search his car and when they did. [SPEAKER_00]: They found exactly what they were looking for. [SPEAKER_00]: A bottle of coleshasine under the front passenger seat. [SPEAKER_00]: Beside it was a crumpled receipt showing that the chemical had been ordered from a company called Art Chemicals Months Before Mary's Death, and the email address attached to that order appeared to also point directly back to Adam.
[SPEAKER_00]: Mr. Adam Yoder 1990 at gmail.com [SPEAKER_00]: At this point, the police felt pretty confident Adam had poisoned his mom, but when given the chance to confess, he completely denied it, saying he had nothing to do with it and was shocked by what they found inside his Jeep. [SPEAKER_00]: He said someone was trying to frame him. [SPEAKER_00]: Regarding the email address, Adam claimed it didn't belong to him and he wasn't the one who created it. [SPEAKER_00]: He also had an alibi.
[SPEAKER_00]: On the day of the suspected poisoning, he was in Long Island visiting his sister and he had been there for five days, so there was no way he could have done it. [SPEAKER_00]: So now the police had a problem. [SPEAKER_00]: The anonymous letter had told them exactly where to find the poison, and they had found it exactly where the writer said it would be. [SPEAKER_00]: It was almost too convenient. [SPEAKER_00]: If Adam was telling the truth, then someone hadn't just accused him of killing his mother.
[SPEAKER_00]: They had planted evidence in his car, and then carefully guided the police straight to it. [SPEAKER_00]: Investigators began looking more closely at the people in his life, including someone who knew both Adam and the Yoder family very well. [SPEAKER_00]: His 22-year-old ex-girlfriend, Katie Conley. [SPEAKER_00]: Another name you heard earlier in the episode, the family's office manager at the Chiropractor Business.
[SPEAKER_00]: Sparks flew when Katie and Adam first got together in 2011. [SPEAKER_00]: They went and did everything together. [SPEAKER_00]: They talked about getting married and having kids one day. [SPEAKER_00]: Everything seemed like a dream come true. [SPEAKER_00]: But somewhere along the way, the relationship started going south fairly quickly. [SPEAKER_00]: According to Adam, the two began arguing constantly, and their relationship became increasingly volatile. [SPEAKER_00]: At one point, Katie accused Adam of assaulting her, an allegation he denied, and claimed was false.
[SPEAKER_00]: After one of their break-ups, Adam began dating someone else. [SPEAKER_00]: But he said he ended that relationship and went back to Katie after she told him she had suffered an ectopic pregnancy and that the baby had been his. [SPEAKER_00]: But their reconciliation didn't last. [SPEAKER_00]: And Adam later suspected that Katie had cheated on him with his best friend. [SPEAKER_00]: So, they once again broke up, but even after her relationship with Adam ended, Katie remained close to Mary and continued working full-time at the Chiropractic Office.
[SPEAKER_00]: So if someone had wanted to frame Adam, investigators now had to consider the person who knew his family, his routines, and his car, and who may have had a very personal reason to be angry with him. [SPEAKER_00]: Initially, Katie denied knowing anything about Mary's murder and said she had no idea who wrote the anonymous letter. [SPEAKER_00]: But by her third interview on December 21st, 2015, and after agreeing to submit DNA samples, her story had changed.
[SPEAKER_00]: She admitted to writing the letter, but claimed she only did it because she was afraid of Adam, saying he had been abusive during their relationship. [SPEAKER_00]: But that's not all investigators uncovered about her and Adam. [SPEAKER_00]: They also learned that in April 2015, just a few months before Mary's death, Adam had also gotten really sick with many of the same symptoms after taking supplements Katie had given him. [SPEAKER_00]: She said she gave them to him to help him focus, but now he believes she was trying to poison him.
[SPEAKER_00]: None of this looked good for either Katie or Adam, Katie admitted to writing the anonymous letter, while the poison was found inside Adam's Jeep. [SPEAKER_00]: So to try to get to the bottom of this and decide who was lying and who was telling the truth, the police kept digging, and that's when they learned something else interesting about the email address used to purchase the culture scene. [SPEAKER_00]: On face value, the email address appears to implicate Adam as the purchaser. [SPEAKER_00]: However, the digital forensics suggest otherwise.
[SPEAKER_00]: Detectives learned that the Gmail account was created on September 19, 2014, on a computer Katie used for work. [SPEAKER_00]: But that's not the only place she accessed it. [SPEAKER_00]: The same email account was also found on her cell phone and home computer. [SPEAKER_00]: If there was any doubt that Adam might have created it, that was likely squashed when detectives learned that the password was Adam is gay.
[SPEAKER_00]: Investigators also found records of two cultucene purchases made through the computer KDUs.work. [SPEAKER_00]: because art chemicals required documentation explaining why the substance was being ordered. [SPEAKER_00]: The paperwork included Mary's and Adam's names and signatures. [SPEAKER_00]: Prosecutors would later argue that Katie had forged those signatures. [SPEAKER_00]: Then there were the pre-paid visa cards. [SPEAKER_00]: Both had been purchased in Adam's name, but surveillance footage reportedly showed Katie buying them.
[SPEAKER_00]: And the serial number from one of those cards matched the number printed on the art chemicals receipt. [SPEAKER_00]: But perhaps, the most damaging evidence came from the poison itself. [SPEAKER_00]: Remember the DNA sample Katie voluntarily gave investigators during her interviews. [SPEAKER_00]: When investigators tested the bottle, found inside Adam's Jeep and its cardboard wrapper, they excluded Adam as a contributor, but not Katie. [SPEAKER_00]: Her DNA was found on both the bottle and the packaging, where she was identified as the major contributor.
[SPEAKER_00]: So by this point, nearly every piece of forensic evidence that initially appeared to implicate [SPEAKER_00]: With all the evidence piling up, police arrested Katie Conley for Mary's murder in June of 2016. [SPEAKER_00]: But if you thought this was the end of the story, you'd be wrong. [SPEAKER_00]: This is only just the beginning. [SPEAKER_00]: Trying to figure out how to get the right mental health treatment for you can feel overwhelming. [SPEAKER_00]: Talk eye a tree helps you move from I know I need the
[SPEAKER_00]: and a clear personalized treatment plan. [SPEAKER_00]: It's a 100% online psychiatry practice that provides comprehensive evaluations, diagnoses, and ongoing medication management for conditions like ADHD, anxiety, depression, and more. [SPEAKER_00]: And because you continue with the same provider, you're not starting over each visit. [SPEAKER_00]: Your treatment can evolve with you so you're actually making progress over time. [SPEAKER_00]: More than 300,000 patients have already found high-quality psychiatric care.
[SPEAKER_00]: Head to talkiattree.com slash tails to complete the short assessment and get matched with an in-network psychiatrist in just a few minutes. [SPEAKER_00]: That's T-A-L-K-I-A-T-R-Y dot com slash tails to get matched in minutes. [SPEAKER_00]: talk ayatree.com slash tails. [SPEAKER_00]: She was charged with second degree murder, one count of second degree forgery, two counts of first degree falsifying business records, and two counts of larceny.
[SPEAKER_00]: The falsifying business records were forforging the signatures to purchase the poison, and the larceny charges were because she used fraudulent means and stolen identities to purchase it. [SPEAKER_00]: So her trial was set to begin in April of 2017. [SPEAKER_00]: When it came to motive, the authorities considered two possibilities. [SPEAKER_00]: Number one, [SPEAKER_00]: Katie had murdered her ex-boyfriend's mom to serve as a traumatic event that would eventually lead him to get back together with her.
[SPEAKER_00]: Or, number two, that it was revenge for their breakup. [SPEAKER_00]: She wanted to frame him and make everyone believe he was the one who did it, so he would go to prison for the rest of his life. [SPEAKER_00]: If she couldn't have him, then no one else could. [SPEAKER_00]: Whatever the motive may have been, their theory was that she had poisoned Mary's daily protein drink, which she may have had access to at the office where they worked together, and while Mary was with a patient.
[SPEAKER_00]: But Katie's lawyers pushed back on the prosecution's theory and motive, saying she had a good relationship with Mary and Bill and had no reason to want her dead, and in a slightly [SPEAKER_00]: Most of Mary's sisters believed the authorities arrested the wrong person. [SPEAKER_00]: They thought it had to be either Bill or Adam. [SPEAKER_00]: Katie's lawyers pointed toward Bill's relationship with Mary's sister Kathy, which they alleged began before her death, despite what they both said.
[SPEAKER_00]: They also claimed that Bill had recently inherited around $400,000 from his father and didn't want to share it with Mary. [SPEAKER_00]: According to their theory, he poisoned the cough drops and inhaler he brought with him to the hospital when Mary first got sick, shortly before her condition took a dramatic turn for the worse. [SPEAKER_00]: But even with the digital evidence linking Katie to the coltucine purchase and her DNA on the bottle and its packaging, the jury couldn't agree on whether she had killed Mary.
[SPEAKER_00]: Over the next few months, prosecutors prepped for round two. [SPEAKER_00]: But they wouldn't have to go into the second trial with all the same evidence they had in the first. [SPEAKER_00]: Sometime, before the start of Katie's second trial, Adam came forward with new, pretty shocking information. [SPEAKER_00]: He said that Katie had plugged her phone into his computer around the time of his mom's death, creating a backup. [SPEAKER_00]: And when investigators searched through the backup data, they discovered that Katie had made several searches for the deadliest poisons.
[SPEAKER_00]: But once again, her lawyers pushed back, saying that both Bill and Adam had much more motive to want Mary dead. [SPEAKER_00]: They also argued that Adam framed Katie not the other way around. [SPEAKER_00]: But they weren't the ones on trial for murder. [SPEAKER_00]: In fact, both Bill and Adam received full immunity when they testified before the grand jury, meaning they couldn't be prosecuted for anything connected to Mary's death that was covered by their testimony. [SPEAKER_00]: And the two of them testified against Katie at both of her trials.
[SPEAKER_00]: So in the end, only one person was on trial. [SPEAKER_00]: Katie. [SPEAKER_00]: At both trials, she faced second-degree murder. [SPEAKER_00]: That might sound strange, considering prosecutors believed the poisoning was intentional. [SPEAKER_00]: But New York reserves first-degree murder for killings involving certain specific aggravating circumstances. [SPEAKER_00]: At her second trial, however, the jury was also allowed to consider first-degree manslaughter as a lesser charge. [SPEAKER_00]: That would mean Katie intended to seriously injure Mary, but not necessarily kill her, and Mary died as a result.
[SPEAKER_00]: So if the jurors weren't convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that she meant to kill Mary, they could still find her guilty of causing her death intentionally in another sense. [SPEAKER_00]: Prosecutors argued at both trials that Katie's motive was tied to Adam, that she either wanted revenge after their turbulent breakup, or believed Mary's death would somehow bring them back together. [SPEAKER_00]: But her attorneys challenged that theory. [SPEAKER_00]: Among the evidence presented at her second trial, were messages in which Adam appeared to ask for her back, including one where he told her he missed her and was always thinking about her.
[SPEAKER_00]: There was also the fact that Katie was dating someone else at the time of Mary's death. [SPEAKER_00]: She also took a privately administered polygraph that reportedly found no signs of deception when she denied killing Mary. [SPEAKER_00]: But the jury didn't get to see those results. [SPEAKER_00]: Katie claimed that she wasn't working at the office when the culture scene was ordered from the computer at her usual workstation. [SPEAKER_00]: According to her supporters, the office payroll book might have helped confirm her schedule, but Bill said it had been lost.
[SPEAKER_00]: So there was no reliable way to verify whether she worked that day or who might have access to that computer. [SPEAKER_00]: Ultimately, after weighing all of the evidence, the jury acquitted her of murder, but convicted her of first degree manslaughter on November 6th, 2017. [SPEAKER_00]: That moment seemed to mark the end of the Yoder family's tragedy, but this dark and twisted story is still far from over.
[SPEAKER_00]: Two months later, Katie was sentenced to 23 years in prison for poisoning Mary Yoder that summer day in 2015, while they work together at the Chiropractor's office. [SPEAKER_00]: But even after two criminal trials and one conviction, Katie still maintains her innocence. [SPEAKER_00]: And she's not the only one. [SPEAKER_00]: Even three of Mary's sisters still believe that the system convicted the wrong person. [SPEAKER_00]: They continue to point the finger at Bill Yoder. [SPEAKER_00]: They believed that Mary wasn't deathly sick when they first arrived at the hospital.
[SPEAKER_00]: suggesting that's when Bill Poisoned her. [SPEAKER_00]: It also explains why he went home instead of staying with her overnight and why he was so hard to reach the next morning. [SPEAKER_00]: The police had to actually knock on his front door to let him know things had taken a turn for the worse. [SPEAKER_00]: And even then, they say he took an unusually long time to answer the door and get to the hospital to be with her. [SPEAKER_00]: Another thing that troubled them was how quickly Bill moved forward with cremating her remains. [SPEAKER_00]: Even though the toxicology results hadn't yet come back.
[SPEAKER_00]: Wouldn't you want to know what happened to her before destroying her remains? [SPEAKER_00]: At the time, Mary's eldest daughter Lyanna told her aunts that their mom was believed to have died from ascending colonjitis, a serious infection of the bile ducts. [SPEAKER_00]: But Lyanna hadn't made that explanation up. [SPEAKER_00]: She later said the medical examiner had mentioned it as a possible cause, based on Mary's inflamed gall bladder and elevated white blood cell count, and it was the best information
[SPEAKER_00]: About a month later, Mary's sister Janine spoke with the physician who had overseen Mary's care at the hospital. [SPEAKER_00]: And according to Janine, he told her that ascending colonjitis had never been confirmed, and that the medical staff had never seen anything quite like Mary's rapid decline. [SPEAKER_00]: Here's another part of the story that makes things even more interesting. [SPEAKER_00]: Throughout this episode, I've said that Mary had a protein shake for lunch, and that Katie had likely mixed the poison into it.
[SPEAKER_00]: But as the case unfolded, evidence emerged suggesting that might not have been what she ate at all. [SPEAKER_00]: According to Mary's hospital records, she told medical staff that she'd eaten a protein bar for lunch and grilled chicken for dinner the night before. [SPEAKER_00]: There was no mention of a protein shake. [SPEAKER_00]: That also directly conflicted with Bill's story. [SPEAKER_00]: He said Mary had consumed a protein shake and had an eaten dinner. [SPEAKER_00]: He also claimed she hated protein bars.
[SPEAKER_00]: But her sisters said the opposite, telling investigators that Mary ate them regularly. [SPEAKER_00]: to be completely fair, that discrepancy doesn't necessarily mean Bill was lying. [SPEAKER_00]: Mary could have eaten more than one thing. [SPEAKER_00]: Someone could have recorded the information incorrectly at the hospital, or memories could have become confused, but it certainly adds a layer of confusion as to exactly how Mary consumed the poison that ended her life.
[SPEAKER_00]: During the 1980s, Bill reportedly grew a particularly potent crop of marijuana using what Mary described to her sisters as a special process that chemically altered the seeds. [SPEAKER_00]: Years later after learning that culture scene could genetically alter plants, Mary's sisters began to wonder whether that was the chemical bill had used. [SPEAKER_00]: They couldn't prove it, and they hadn't known the chemicals name at the time. [SPEAKER_00]: But when Bill denied ever hearing of Coltcheseen, or knowing that it could be used on marijuana plants, they didn't believe him.
[SPEAKER_00]: So Katie's lawyers used that allegation to argue that Bill may have been familiar with commercial Coltcheseen long before Mary was poisoned. [SPEAKER_00]: But once again, to be completely fair to both sides, no physical evidence or records ever confirmed that the chemical he used in the 1980s was actually cultucine. [SPEAKER_00]: As for Katie's DNA on the packaging from inside Adams' car, [SPEAKER_00]: She offered an innocent explanation for that, as well.
[SPEAKER_00]: She claimed that Bill had once asked her to retrieve any packages addressed to Mary and bring them directly to him, supposedly because he had ordered Mary a birthday present and didn't want her to see it. [SPEAKER_00]: Katie said she followed his instructions without thinking anything of it. [SPEAKER_00]: If you recall from a little earlier in the episode, the culture scene order was placed on January 5, 2015, using Mary and Adam's names. [SPEAKER_00]: But Katie's lawyers believe that if she handled the package as part of her normal work duties, or because of Bill's request,
[SPEAKER_00]: That could explain why her DNA was found on it, but like so many other parts of this story, no independent evidence confirmed that Bill made the request or deliberately arranged for Katie to touch the package. [SPEAKER_00]: That now brings us to where the case stands today. [SPEAKER_00]: After her conviction at the second trial, Katie immediately launched several appeals, and in January 2025, one of those
[SPEAKER_00]: That month, a New York appellate court overturned her conviction. [SPEAKER_00]: The court found that her first trial attorney was ineffective, and failed to prevent her cell phone from becoming a primary source of evidence. [SPEAKER_00]: Melissa Swartz, Katie's appellate lawyer, told Dateline 2025 that the warrant for her cell phone was, quote, probably the most facially insufficient warrant I've ever come across. [SPEAKER_00]: They believed that was a warrant to take her phone and look in it," Swartz said, but what it needs to be is two separate warrants.
[SPEAKER_00]: One to take her phone and then one to actually search her phone. [SPEAKER_00]: So in February 2025, following the Appellate Court's decision, Katie was officially released from prison after spending seven years behind bars for a murder she says she didn't commit. [SPEAKER_00]: Katie hasn't spoken out publicly following her release, but her attorney told Dateline, we are making sure that the criminal justice system is working correctly. [SPEAKER_00]: That's important for people that commit crimes, and that's important for people who have been wrongfully convicted of committing crimes.
[SPEAKER_00]: The Yoder family also hasn't really spoken out publicly. [SPEAKER_00]: However, Adams, Sister Tamron, said in the documentary about the case Little Miss Innocent, I hope she never makes it out of prison. [SPEAKER_00]: I'd be okay if she made it to 22 years, and then got killed in there. [SPEAKER_00]: I'd be happy. [SPEAKER_00]: Although Katie Conley is free today, her story and Mary Yoder's murder still aren't done. [SPEAKER_00]: The O'Nida County District Attorney's office has filed three separate appeals to reopen the case.
[SPEAKER_00]: But in June, 2026, the Appellate Division denied the first appeal, leaving the two other appeals still open. [SPEAKER_00]: So as of the time this episode airs, it's unclear what Katie's future holds regarding Mary Yoda's death. [SPEAKER_00]: So who really killed Mary Yoder? [SPEAKER_00]: Was it Katie as prosecutors argued? [SPEAKER_00]: Was Bill overlooked too quickly? [SPEAKER_00]: Or could Adam have somehow been involved despite his alibi?
[SPEAKER_00]: The forensic evidence uncovered what killed Mary and connected Katie to the poison, but it couldn't tell investigators exactly when she touched it. [SPEAKER_00]: Why she touched it? [SPEAKER_00]: Or how the culture scene entered Mary's body. [SPEAKER_00]: And ultimately, this case is a reminder that forensic evidence can be incredibly powerful, but only when it's collected lawfully, interpreted carefully, and considered alongside every other piece of the story.
[SPEAKER_00]: More than a decade later, Mary's family remains divided, Katie's legal future remains uncertain, and the most important question of all still lingers, who poisoned Mary Yoder. [SPEAKER_00]: To share your thoughts on this week's story, follow forensic tales on social media. [SPEAKER_00]: And if you'd like to support this independent one-woman podcast, you can join us on Patreon for as little as $3 a month. [SPEAKER_00]: Patreon members receive new episodes early and add free, along with monthly full-length bonus episodes.
[SPEAKER_00]: Your support directly helps fund the show's research, production, and editing. [SPEAKER_00]: Forensic Tales is a Rockefeller audio production. [SPEAKER_00]: The show is written and produced by me, Courtney Fredwell. [SPEAKER_00]: If you'd like to support the show and help fund research, production, and editing, you can do so with a small monthly contribution on Patreon. [SPEAKER_00]: Patreon supporters get early access to ad-free episodes and exclusive bonus content. [SPEAKER_00]: You can learn more at patreon.com slash forensic tales.
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you so much to this week's newest supporter on Patreon and [SPEAKER_00]: And if you enjoy the show, leaving a positive rating or review really helps others discover it. [SPEAKER_00]: For a full list of sources used in this episode, visit forensictails.com. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for listening and I'll see you next week. [SPEAKER_00]: Until then, remember, not all stories have happy endings.
#360 - When 21-year-old Denise Amber Lee was abducted from her Florida home in January 2008, she fought to return to her husband and two young sons - even managing to call 911 from her captor’s phone. A passing motorist...
The Jordan Harbinger Show is a podcast with incredible guests, from experts speaking on major global topics, to more personal discussions on issues like navigating your career or romantic life. I have become a regular...
#359 - In August 1987, a freight train struck 16-year-old Don Henry and 17-year-old Kevin Ives as they lay motionless on railroad tracks in Arkansas. The medical examiner called it an accident, claiming marijuana had...
#358 - In December 2003, federal prosecutor Jonathan Luna was found dead in a Pennsylvania creek, far from his Baltimore office. He had suffered 36 stab wounds and drowned. Toll records and banking activity traced a...
#357 - When Sharon Causse was shot and killed inside her Las Vegas home in 2008, her husband, Thomas Randolph, claimed he had killed the intruder responsible. But the physical evidence raised questions about his story....