#360 - When 21-year-old Denise Amber Lee was abducted from her Florida home in January 2008, she fought to return to her husband and two young sons - even managing to call 911 from her captor’s phone. A passing motorist also called, reporting the car’s movements. But critical information never reached the officers searching for her. From DNA and a palm print to a heart-shaped ring, forensic evidence helped investigators piece together what happened to Denise. This week on Forensic Tales, we explore her fight to survive, the emergency response failures that cost her a chance at rescue, and her family’s work to change the 911 system. Content warning: Abduction, sexual violence, murder, and a distressing excerpt from a 911 call. Forensic Tales is a Rockefeller Audio production, written and produced by Courtney Fretwell. Support the show on Patreon (get early ad-free access to episodes, monthly bonus episodes & more): patreon.com/forensictales Website & Episode Sources: https://www.forensictales.com/denise-amber-lee Follow Forensic Tales: Instagram: @forensictales TikTok: @forensictales Facebook: Forensic Tales Contact: courtney@forensictales.com Our Sponsors: * Check out Sequencing and use my code sequencing.com/FORENSIC10 for a great deal: https://sequencing.com * Check out Vinted: https://www.vinted.com Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[SPEAKER_00]: Stopped at a red light, a driver hears muffled desperate screams coming from the green Camaro beside her. [SPEAKER_00]: She locks eyes with the man behind the wheel as a trapped woman's hand bangs against the window. [SPEAKER_00]: She dials 911 immediately. [SPEAKER_00]: Two police officers are patrolling that exact stretch of highway, but help never arrives. [SPEAKER_00]: This is forensic tales, episode 360, the kidnapping and murder of Denise Amberley.
[SPEAKER_00]: Welcome to Forensic Tales. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm your host, Courtney Fretwell. [SPEAKER_00]: If you enjoy deep dives into real cases and the science behind them, make sure you're subscribed so you never miss an episode. [SPEAKER_00]: And if you want even more content, including monthly full-length bonus episodes, and early ad-free access to over 350 episodes, you can join our community over on Patreon. [SPEAKER_00]: To learn more, visit patreon.com slash forensic tales. [SPEAKER_00]: Let's get a quick word from our sponsors.
[SPEAKER_00]: Most of us learn how to call 911 before we ever need to. [SPEAKER_00]: We're little kids learning our address, our parents' names, and what to do if something bad happens. [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe a parent shows us the buttons on the phone. [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe a firefighter visits our school and explains that if there's a fire, someone is hurt or we're in danger. [SPEAKER_00]: These are the three numbers we need to remember. [SPEAKER_00]: Nine, one, one. [SPEAKER_00]: And when you're a kid, there's something comforting about that.
[SPEAKER_00]: You don't have to know how to put out a fire or help someone who's unconscious. [SPEAKER_00]: You just have to get to a phone and tell someone what's happening. [SPEAKER_00]: Before 9-1-1, people often had to dial a local seven-digit number to reach police, fire, or emergency medical help. [SPEAKER_00]: That meant finding the right number while an emergency was already unfolding. [SPEAKER_00]: The idea behind 9-1-1 was to give people one short number they could remember.
[SPEAKER_00]: The first 9-1-1 call in the United States was placed in Haleyville, Alabama, in February 1968, and the service gradually spread to other communities. [SPEAKER_00]: three numbers could connect them to someone who could get help moving toward their door. [SPEAKER_00]: Of course, a lot has to happen after someone answers. [SPEAKER_00]: The person taking that call has to listen, ask questions, and make sense of what might be a terrifying confusing situation. [SPEAKER_00]: As callers, we don't see most of that.
[SPEAKER_00]: We hear a voice asking for our location. [SPEAKER_00]: We answer as best we can. [SPEAKER_00]: We stay on the line. [SPEAKER_00]: And we trust that somewhere beyond that conversation, someone is sending help. [SPEAKER_00]: For Denise Amberley, that trust was put to the test on January 17th, 2008. [SPEAKER_00]: That day, more than one person called 911 to get her help. [SPEAKER_00]: Denise herself even managed to make a call while she was being held captive. [SPEAKER_00]: But reaching someone on the other end of the phone wasn't enough.
[SPEAKER_00]: On a day when she desperately needed the system, she'd been taught to rely on that system failed her. [SPEAKER_00]: On Thursday, January 17, 2008, Nathan Lee was getting ready for another day at work. [SPEAKER_00]: At home, his wife, Denise, and their two little boys were still asleep. [SPEAKER_00]: 23-year-old Nathan and 21-year-old Denise were busy raising a two-year-old and a six-month-old baby. [SPEAKER_00]: Their morning started early, but for the moment the house was quiet.
[SPEAKER_00]: Denise stayed home with the boys while Nathan went to work. [SPEAKER_00]: It was the kind of morning that probably wouldn't stand out in your memory. [SPEAKER_00]: Getting dressed, getting out the door, thinking about whatever needed to get done that day. [SPEAKER_00]: For Nathan, there was no reason to think he wouldn't come home to Denise and the kids that afternoon. [SPEAKER_00]: Denise Amber Gough was born on August 6th, 1986 to parents Rick and Sue. [SPEAKER_00]: She was the eldest of three kids and spent most of her life in her near Inglewood, Florida, a coastal community between Sarasota and Fort Myers.
[SPEAKER_00]: She was a bright student who loved reading and learning math. [SPEAKER_00]: She met Nathan while she was still in high school, but was taking college classes at a local community college where he was a student. [SPEAKER_00]: Nathan would later say it was love at first sight for both of them. [SPEAKER_00]: They just knew from the moment they met that they wanted to spend the rest of their lives together. [SPEAKER_00]: Get married, have kids, buy a house with the white picket fence.
[SPEAKER_00]: I know it sounds cliche, but I mean, we really knew right away. [SPEAKER_00]: I mean, we were two peas and a pod. [SPEAKER_00]: We were as happy as you could be. [SPEAKER_00]: Nathan told reporters. [SPEAKER_00]: Their first Valentine's Day came just three weeks into their relationship. [SPEAKER_00]: And like any good boyfriend, Nathan bought Denise a gift, a $40 heart-shaped ring. [SPEAKER_00]: From that night on, she never took it off. [SPEAKER_00]: Even when he later gave her an engagement ring, that little heart stayed on her finger.
[SPEAKER_00]: It was still with her the day she was abducted. [SPEAKER_00]: And what began as a gift from the man she loved would become a piece of evidence linking her to the man who killed her. [SPEAKER_00]: In 2004, Denise graduated high school and on August 20th, 2005, she and Nathan got married at first United Methodist Church in Punta, Gordafloreta, just after her 19th birthday. [SPEAKER_00]: Then by 2006, their first son Noah was born, and then Adam was born in July of 2007.
[SPEAKER_00]: By the start of 2008, Denise and Nathan were busy juggling work and family life. [SPEAKER_00]: Denise stayed home with the boys, while Nathan reportedly worked up to three jobs to be able to provide for his family financially. [SPEAKER_00]: His main job was reading meters for Florida power and light, but his mother also recalled him stalking shelves at Windixie, playing trumpet with the Venice Symphony, and [SPEAKER_00]: They rented a small home in Northport, Florida, about 11 miles northwest of Engelwood.
[SPEAKER_00]: So they weren't far away from Denise's parents if she ever needed help with the boys, or if they just wanted to drive up and have dinner with them. [SPEAKER_00]: With two little boys and Nathan working multiple jobs, life was busy and money was tight. [SPEAKER_00]: But this was the life they were working so hard for. [SPEAKER_00]: A home together, a family, and a future they were still figuring out. [SPEAKER_00]: Nathan made a habit of talking to Denise over the phone at least a couple of times while he was at work.
[SPEAKER_00]: He liked to check in on both her and the boys to see how they were doing. [SPEAKER_00]: And January 17th, 2008 was no different. [SPEAKER_00]: At 11-21 that morning, they spoke over the phone for about five minutes. [SPEAKER_00]: They talked about how nice the weather was that morning. [SPEAKER_00]: And Nathan suggested she opened the windows to let in some fresh air. [SPEAKER_00]: After that, they hung up. [SPEAKER_00]: Nathan went back to work while Denise made a quick stop at the post office off Highway 41 at 145.
[SPEAKER_00]: Then returned home to cut their two-year-old son's hair on the back porch. [SPEAKER_00]: a few hours later, at around 330, Nathan got off work and immediately reached for his phone to call Denise, like he usually did. [SPEAKER_00]: But instead of hearing his wife's voice, he only heard the phone ringing. [SPEAKER_00]: Denise wasn't picking up. [SPEAKER_00]: Thinking maybe she was tied up with one of the kids, he drove straight home, but the drive was supposed to take about 25 minutes. [SPEAKER_00]: And during that time, he called Denise
[SPEAKER_00]: As soon as Nathan turned into his street, he said he knew something was wrong. [SPEAKER_00]: The windows to their house were closed, but Denise had specifically told him she opened them to let fresh air in. [SPEAKER_00]: When he got inside, he saw their two sons asleep together in the crib, which was unusual because they didn't normally sleep together. [SPEAKER_00]: And Denise was nowhere to be found. [SPEAKER_00]: He must have known then that something was terribly terribly wrong, because she would never have left the boys alone in the house even for a second.
[SPEAKER_00]: And his panic only grew after seeing her car keys, wallet, and cell phone sitting where she usually kept them. [SPEAKER_00]: So even if she had voluntarily gone out of the house for some reason, she didn't take anything with her. [SPEAKER_00]: At 329 that afternoon, Nathan did what he had been taught to do as a kid when something was wrong. [SPEAKER_00]: He called 911, becoming the first of five calls related to Denise Amber Lee's kidnapping that day. [SPEAKER_00]: He said, my kids are in the house, and I don't know where she is.
[SPEAKER_00]: His next call was to Denise's father, Rick, who was also a sergeant with the Charlotte County Sheriff's Office. [SPEAKER_00]: So if anyone knew what to do next, it would be him. [SPEAKER_00]: Earlier that day, Rick had called Denise to ask if she, Nathan and the kids wanted to come over for dinner. [SPEAKER_00]: So when Rick saw that his son-in-law was calling, he assumed it was about their dinner plans. [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe one of the boys wasn't feeling well and they had to reschedule, but Nathan wasn't calling about missed dinner plans.
[SPEAKER_00]: He called to let Rick know that Denise was missing, and he thought someone had kidnapped her from inside her very own home. [SPEAKER_00]: After hanging up, Rick immediately contacted the Sarasota Sheriff's Department, which covered the county Denise lived in. [SPEAKER_00]: He also called his own department in Charlotte County to let them know what was happening. [SPEAKER_00]: In many cases, people don't take missing adults seriously at first. [SPEAKER_00]: Some agencies even require a minimum amount of time before loved ones can file a missing person report.
[SPEAKER_00]: But because Denise's dad was a member of law enforcement, [SPEAKER_00]: The official search for her began quickly, and according to the Denise Amber Lee Foundation, it became one of the largest and most cooperative search efforts the region had ever seen. [SPEAKER_00]: Over 300 police officers joined the search. [SPEAKER_00]: About 15 minutes after Nathan called 911, the police arrived at the couple's house to get a statement from him. [SPEAKER_00]: They also began canvassing the neighborhood, looking for any potential witnesses.
[SPEAKER_00]: They knew someone had kidnapped Denise from her own home during the middle of the afternoon. [SPEAKER_00]: So someone from the area should have seen something, and that's when they heard from Jennifer Eckert, one of Denise and Nathan's neighbors. [SPEAKER_00]: She reported that earlier that day, sometime between one and two o'clock, she was watching television when she saw a green Camaro creeping up and down her road going very slowly. [SPEAKER_00]: She said the Camaro had a black car bra, which is a leather or vinyl casing across the front of the car that protects against impact from insects or rocks.
[SPEAKER_00]: She watched as the car circled the street about four or five times, driving directly in front of Denise and Nathan's house, almost as if it were surveilling it. [SPEAKER_00]: Initially, she thought the driver might be lost so she went outside to see if she could offer directions. [SPEAKER_00]: But right when she got outside, the car pulled directly into the leaves driveway. [SPEAKER_00]: She even made eye contact with the driver, but assumed he'd found the address he was looking for. [SPEAKER_00]: Maybe he was just a friend of Nathan or Denise.
[SPEAKER_00]: So Jennifer walked back into her house, not knowing she had very likely witnessed Denise's [SPEAKER_00]: 10 to 15 minutes later, Jennifer walked back outside and saw the green Camaro leave. [SPEAKER_00]: But she didn't see Denise. [SPEAKER_00]: And while no one knows exactly what happened, some reports say Denise might have been cutting her toddler's hair on the porch, or breastfeeding her younger son when her abductor attacked. [SPEAKER_00]: Nathan even told NBC News that she might have mistaken the kidnappers 1994 Green Camaro for his 1995 Green Dodge Avenger because the two cars looked pretty similar.
[SPEAKER_00]: So Denise may have unlocked the front door because she thought her husband was home. [SPEAKER_00]: But instead, the driver of the Green Camaro wasn't her husband. [SPEAKER_00]: It was her kidnapper. [SPEAKER_00]: By five o'clock that evening, the North Port Police Department issued a Beyond The Lookout for Denise and the Green Camaro. [SPEAKER_00]: But when the alert was issued, they had no idea it belonged to a man named Michael Lee King. [SPEAKER_00]: Michael King was born in 1971 and lived in Michigan for most of his life until his divorce in 2002.
[SPEAKER_00]: His ex-wife later described their relationship in a USA today article as troubled, calling him Meek and Deceitful. [SPEAKER_00]: Following the divorce, King decided he wanted a fresh start and moved to Florida. [SPEAKER_00]: He initially found work as a plumber, but that didn't last long. [SPEAKER_00]: Sometime in 2007, he just stopped showing up for work and eventually became unemployed. [SPEAKER_00]: But employment problems weren't his only issue. [SPEAKER_00]: He also had deeply personal and disturbing issues with women.
[SPEAKER_00]: At least one woman came forward saying that King had assaulted her. [SPEAKER_00]: She said that she had passed out drunk while at a gathering, and King took advantage of her state to assault her, and out of fear or shame, she never reported the incident to the police at the time. [SPEAKER_00]: Then there were the incidents of indecent exposure and harassment. [SPEAKER_00]: Several women said that he would regularly expose himself to them make unwanted sexual advances and was known to aggressively brag about fabricated or inappropriate sexual relationships.
[SPEAKER_00]: Some of these incidents even happened at work, leading to King's firing, and his fixation on women wasn't limited to adults. [SPEAKER_00]: Witnesses alleged that he frequently made highly inappropriate [SPEAKER_00]: Those accounts raised troubling questions about how King treated women and responded to their boundaries. [SPEAKER_00]: But there was another story from much earlier in his life that suggested a willingness to use fear and the threat of violence, even as a child.
[SPEAKER_00]: According to King's brother, he became so enraged one day that he started a chainsaw and chased family members around the house. [SPEAKER_00]: Fortunately, no one was injured or killed. [SPEAKER_00]: Around noon on January 17th, Michael King and his friend Robert Salvador went to a shooting range together just outside Northport. [SPEAKER_00]: When they arrived in the parking lot, King reached under the passenger seat of his 1994 Green Camaro and pulled out a 9mm semi-automatic pistol.
[SPEAKER_00]: But before exiting the car, Robert stopped his friend, saying he couldn't just walk into the shooting range without a case. [SPEAKER_00]: So before they headed inside, Robert let him borrow one of his cases. [SPEAKER_00]: About an hour later, they wrapped up at the shooting range and parted ways. [SPEAKER_00]: Robert ran some errands, then returned home just before 6pm. [SPEAKER_00]: But it's unclear exactly what Michael King did after leaving the shooting range. [SPEAKER_00]: Some reports say he might have stopped at the post office around the same time that Denise did that afternoon,
[SPEAKER_00]: but that claim hasn't been verified, and there's never been any evidence that Denise and King knew each other. [SPEAKER_00]: Sometime between 530 and 6 o'clock that evening, King unexpectedly showed up at his cousin Harold Muxlo's home. [SPEAKER_00]: He said his lawnmower was stuck in the front yard and needed some supplies like a flashlight, a gas can, and a shovel to get it out. [SPEAKER_00]: After Harold handed over the tools, King headed back to the Camaro. [SPEAKER_00]: But as Harold walked toward his house, he heard a woman yell from the car, call the cops.
[SPEAKER_00]: He immediately turned around and walked back down the driveway, asking his cousin what he was doing. [SPEAKER_00]: King then raised his head from beside the passenger side and said, nothing, don't worry about it. [SPEAKER_00]: At first, Harold started back toward the house, but then he turned around again and walked toward the street to get a better look. [SPEAKER_00]: This time, he saw King crawling over the Camaro's center console, pushing someone's head down in the backseat. [SPEAKER_00]: He also saw shoulder-length hair and part of a knee as king forced the person down.
[SPEAKER_00]: Then his bizarre cousin got behind the wheel and drove away. [SPEAKER_00]: Now before we go any further, when these details were released to the public, many people were angry with Harold Muxlow. [SPEAKER_00]: That's because he essentially saw Denise in his cousin's car, and he didn't do anything to immediately stop it or save her while there was still a chance. [SPEAKER_00]: He didn't confront his cousin, he didn't try to grab Denise from the car, he didn't call the police, he didn't really do anything.
[SPEAKER_00]: He knew his cousin had a lot of tumultuous relationships with women, so he just assumed they were having a fight, which wouldn't be totally out of character for him. [SPEAKER_00]: Of course, knowing what he knows now, he probably regrets not doing anything to save the woman in his cousin's car that day. [SPEAKER_00]: If he had done something, we probably wouldn't be talking about this case. [SPEAKER_00]: Of all the calls to 911 that day, the most disturbing one came from Denise herself, who called at 614 that evening.
[SPEAKER_00]: She had somehow managed to get a hold of her kidnapper's cell phone to call for help. [SPEAKER_00]: And for the next six and a half minutes, she begged for her life, saying, please, a total of 17 times. [SPEAKER_00]: While the call wasn't released until her kidnapper's trial, it would give everyone a chance to hear her fighting to survive. [SPEAKER_00]: As the operator asks her questions, she tries to answer while making it sound like she's still talking to her kidnapper. [SPEAKER_00]: She tells him her name.
[SPEAKER_00]: She talks about her husband and their children, pleading to see them again. [SPEAKER_00]: And listening to it, you know she's reached someone. [SPEAKER_00]: There's another person on the line, [SPEAKER_00]: But Denise can't tell them exactly where she is. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to play a short portion of that call, but I just want to warn you that it's very difficult to hear. [SPEAKER_00]: You'll hear Denise crying and pleading with the man holding her captive. [SPEAKER_00]: So if you'd rather skip this part, please do.
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm sorry, I'm just going to be right there, boy. [UNKNOWN]: No. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [UNKNOWN]: I'm just going to be right there. [UNKNOWN]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [UNKNOWN]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_00]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going to be right there. [SPEAKER_01]: I'm just going [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [SPEAKER_01]: Hello.
[UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [SPEAKER_00]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [SPEAKER_00]: Hello. [SPEAKER_00]: Hello. [SPEAKER_01]: Hello. [SPEAKER_01]: Hello. [SPEAKER_01]: Hello. [UNKNOWN]: Hello. [SPEAKER_00]: That was only about a minute of the entire call.
[SPEAKER_00]: But what's frustrating to hear is how many times the operator says, hello, like she doesn't quite realize the person on the other end of the phone is in trouble. [SPEAKER_00]: It's also frustrating how much of that call depends on Denise answering questions she can't safely answer. [SPEAKER_00]: At one point, the operator even asks whether the radio can be turned down, [SPEAKER_00]: Less than 10 minutes later, and about four hours after that green Camaro was seen outside Denise's house, someone made a third 911 call.
[SPEAKER_00]: This time it was Harold Muxlo's 17-year-old daughter Sabrina. [SPEAKER_00]: After King left Harold's house, he called his daughter to tell her what happened. [SPEAKER_00]: Unlike Harold, Sabrina knew the woman in King's car wasn't just a crazy girlfriend. [SPEAKER_00]: She was in danger. [SPEAKER_00]: She relayed almost everything her father had told her to the operator, saying that a woman was being held captive in her father's cousin's car. [SPEAKER_00]: At first, Sabrina was reluctant to tell the operator where her dad lived because she knew he wanted to remain anonymous throughout all of this.
[SPEAKER_00]: But eventually, Sabrina told the operator her father's address without giving his name, but she did provide his cousin's name, Michael King. [SPEAKER_00]: By this third call, the authorities were slowly starting to put the pieces together, that Denise had been abducted by Michael King, who drove a green Camaro. [SPEAKER_00]: With this information, every available police officer rushed to Michael King's home in Northport. [SPEAKER_00]: But by the time they arrived and broke through the front door, neither King nor Denise was there.
[SPEAKER_00]: Soon after, King's cousin Harold Muxlow went to his house. [SPEAKER_00]: Thinking his cousin's behavior about the lawnmower was suspicious, he decided to see if his story was true. [SPEAKER_00]: But when he got there, he didn't see a stuck lawnmower or any sign of King. [SPEAKER_00]: So at 650pm, he called 911 anonymously from a convenience store, saying that a woman was being
[SPEAKER_00]: At nearly the same exact time, a woman named Jane Koalski placed a fifth 911 call. [SPEAKER_00]: But unlike the other four calls made by Nathan Denise, Sabrina and Harold that went to the Sarasota County call center, Jane's call which was arguably the most important was picked up by the Charlotte County call center. [SPEAKER_00]: And she had something the other callers couldn't provide, a first hand account of where [SPEAKER_00]: Around 6.30 that evening, Jane was stopped at a traffic light on Highway 41 when she heard screaming from the Camaro beside her.
[SPEAKER_00]: The sound was so terrifying that Jane would later describe it as something she'd never heard before. [SPEAKER_00]: Jane looked over and made eye contact with King. [SPEAKER_00]: Then she watched him turn around and pushed down toward the backseat. [SPEAKER_00]: Moments later, a hand came up and started banging against the passenger side window. [SPEAKER_00]: Jane knew she needed to get the car's license plate. [SPEAKER_00]: When the light turned green, she held back, waiting for the Camaro to pull ahead so she could read it. [SPEAKER_00]: But King didn't move forward either.
[SPEAKER_00]: And when Jane slowly began to roll ahead, he switched lanes and pulled behind her. [SPEAKER_00]: Now she couldn't see his plate at all. [SPEAKER_00]: Realizing he wasn't going to pass her, Jane called 9-1-1. [SPEAKER_00]: She described the car, the screaming, and what she'd seen the driver doing. [SPEAKER_00]: But while she was talking to the dispatcher, King changed lanes again and turned left onto Toledo Blade Boulevard, heading toward Interstate 75. [SPEAKER_00]: But Jane couldn't get over in time to follow him because there was too much traffic.
[SPEAKER_00]: She tried to keep the Camaro in sight, but now it was getting away. [SPEAKER_00]: But remember, Jane was speaking to Charlotte County's 911 Center, while North Port Police in neighboring Sarasota County searched for Denise. [SPEAKER_00]: Her information needed to reach the officers who could intercept that Camaro. [SPEAKER_00]: Instead, the call-taker relayed the details verbally, and on a handwritten note to dispatchers inside the Charlotte County Center. [SPEAKER_00]: They failed to send that information out to deputies, and North Port Police weren't
[SPEAKER_00]: What makes this even more frustrating is that even if this call hadn't been connected to Denise Lee, it still should have been taken seriously. [SPEAKER_00]: A woman called 911, saying she was basically witnessing a kidnapping taking place right before her eyes. [SPEAKER_00]: So a call like that should have triggered an immediate major police dispatch. [SPEAKER_00]: To make things even worse, at least two patrol officers were on highway 41 at the time, the same road Jane and King were on, and it's very likely that King drove right past them with Denise trapped inside his car.
[SPEAKER_00]: But because 911 didn't relay the message properly, nothing was done. [SPEAKER_00]: In the weeks and months that followed, an internal investigation found that dispatchers had violated procedures. [SPEAKER_00]: Two Charlotte County dispatchers were suspended, required to undergo additional training and placed on probation for six months. [SPEAKER_00]: But neither was fired. [SPEAKER_00]: For Nathan, those consequences weren't enough. [SPEAKER_00]: He questioned why the dispatchers would get to keep their jobs after failing to pass along information that might have saved his wife.
[SPEAKER_00]: We're going to give them a second chance, he asked, Denise didn't get a second chance. [SPEAKER_00]: The last person to see Denise alive was Jane at 630. [SPEAKER_00]: By 7 o'clock, the police had set up roadblocks throughout Northport as a helicopter flew overhead, searching for the green Camaro. [SPEAKER_00]: They also obtained a search warrant for Michael King's residents. [SPEAKER_00]: The police had just about everything they needed. [SPEAKER_00]: They had Michael King's name. [SPEAKER_00]: They knew where he lived. [SPEAKER_00]: They even had his license plate number, but none of that could have prevented what happened next.
[SPEAKER_00]: By 930, PM, King was in police custody, but initially refused to tell them where Denise was, or if she was even still alive. [SPEAKER_00]: He had even come up with a crazy story that both he and Denise had been kidnapped together. [SPEAKER_00]: He said that he was blinded, and that's [SPEAKER_00]: About 90 minutes later, at 11 o'clock, he led the police to a wooded area in Northport, trying to convince them that that's where he and Denise had been kidnapped.
[SPEAKER_00]: And although they must have known King was lying, they spent the next several hours searching the area for Denise, but never found her. [SPEAKER_00]: At around 8 a.m. the next day, January 18th, Michael King was arrested on felony kidnapping charges and held without bond. [SPEAKER_00]: That allowed the police to search his car. [SPEAKER_00]: And what they found inside would give them forensic evidence to back up what the calls and witnesses were already telling them. [SPEAKER_00]: Denise had been in that car.
[SPEAKER_00]: Inside, a dirt-covered shovel sat in the backseat. [SPEAKER_00]: Later, Harold would confirm it was the same shovel he'd given his cousin the day before. [SPEAKER_00]: The police also found Denise's palm print on the driver's side window, along with several strands of her hair, and the heart-shaped ring Nathan had given her as a Valentine's Day gift that she wore every single day. [SPEAKER_00]: To me, it feels like Denise was leaving investigators a trail, doing everything she could to make sure that if she didn't survive, they would know who had taken her, helping solve her own murder, even as she fought to escape it.
[SPEAKER_00]: DNA and forensic testing also confirmed that the hair recovered from the outside of the [SPEAKER_00]: and the hair found in the backseat, matched her DNA to the exclusion of nine trillion other individuals. [SPEAKER_00]: There was also a sap-like substance found on the car that would eventually be linked back to her. [SPEAKER_00]: Something we'll talk about in just a few minutes.
[SPEAKER_00]: Investigators also found a blanket in the back seat, and forensic testing confirmed it contained blood that matched Denise's DNA to the exclusion of 9 trillion other individuals. [SPEAKER_00]: Blood found on the outside of the car also matched Denise. [SPEAKER_00]: Back inside Michael King's home, they found more forensic evidence linking him to Denise. [SPEAKER_00]: In the master bedroom, there were pillows, a winy, the poo blanket, and a wad of duct tape with hair stuck to it.
[SPEAKER_00]: Investigators found more tape with hair attached in a garbage bag in the kitchen pantry. [SPEAKER_00]: Testing linked the hairs on the tape in the garbage to Denise, and swabs from the ends of the tape in the bedroom, matched King's DNA. [SPEAKER_00]: The blanket also tested positive for blood and semen. [SPEAKER_00]: The Seaman matched King, and Denise couldn't be excluded as the source of the blood. [SPEAKER_00]: While forensic experts tested different pieces of evidence, the search for Denise continued.
[SPEAKER_00]: But it wouldn't last long. [SPEAKER_00]: On January 18, someone helping with the search, noticed disturbed ground near plantation Boulevard. [SPEAKER_00]: Nearby were two small piles of sand with what appeared to be blood in them, leading a crime scene technician to believe that someone had put the sand over blood already on the ground. [SPEAKER_00]: So the next morning, a forensic team began carefully digging. [SPEAKER_00]: As they removed the soil, they found marks consistent with a round nose shovel.
[SPEAKER_00]: Then just over three feet down, they found Denise's body. [SPEAKER_00]: She was lying on her side, curled into a fetal position with a visible gunshot wound. [SPEAKER_00]: A few hundred yards away, investigators recovered her shirt, and a pair of Nathan's box or shorts that she often wore. [SPEAKER_00]: The shorts contained sperm cells, and the DNA matched king. [SPEAKER_00]: Then a couple of days after Denise was found, investigators discovered a single nine-millimeter shell casing in the grass near her grave. [SPEAKER_00]: And remember, King had gone to the shooting range with his friend Robert Salvador on the morning Denise was abducted.
[SPEAKER_00]: Robert had seen King take a nine millimeter handgun from beneath the passenger seat of his Camaro. [SPEAKER_00]: And after their time at the range, the gun went back under that seat. [SPEAKER_00]: Robert later helped police find the spot where they'd been shooting. [SPEAKER_00]: and investigators collected 47 9 millimeter casings from that area and compared them with the one found near Denise's grave. [SPEAKER_00]: Three of the range casings had matching microscopic marks. [SPEAKER_00]: When a gun fires and ejects a casing, its metal parts can leave tiny marks on it.
[SPEAKER_00]: By comparing those marks, the analyst linked the casing near Denise's grave to the same firearm that had fired those three rounds at the range. [SPEAKER_00]: The gun itself was never recovered. [SPEAKER_00]: But the casing it left behind provided another forensic connection between Denise's burial site and King's activities that day. [SPEAKER_00]: Denise's autopsy revealed that she had died from a single gunshot wound to the head. [SPEAKER_00]: The wound was consistent with the gun being pressed against her skin when it was fired, and with a bullet from either a 9 mm or a 38 caliber weapon.
[SPEAKER_00]: The medical examiner also offered a possible explanation for the substance found on the Camaro's front protective cover. [SPEAKER_00]: The one investigators had initially thought looked like sap. [SPEAKER_00]: He believed it could have been fluid from Denise's eye, released by the gunshot. [SPEAKER_00]: Blood in her lungs showed that she had continued breathing for a period of time after she was shot. [SPEAKER_00]: There were also bruises around both wrists, consistent with being restrained, and struggling against those restraints. [SPEAKER_00]: Two pieces of duct tape were still caught in her hair.
[SPEAKER_00]: The autopsy revealed injuries indicating that Denise had been sexually assaulted while she was alive, and Seaman recovered from her body, matched Michael King's DNA. [SPEAKER_00]: Denise's body was released to her family on January 21st, and a few days later, they held her funeral at the same church where she and Nathan got married just four years earlier.
[SPEAKER_00]: his trial began in late August of 2009. [SPEAKER_00]: The prosecution built its case around the forensic evidence linking King to Denise. [SPEAKER_00]: While his defense attorneys tried to raise reasonable doubt by questioning whether that evidence had been contaminated or tampered with and suggesting that one of King's friends was responsible. [SPEAKER_00]: As with every criminal trial here in the states, the prosecution presented its case to the jury first. [SPEAKER_00]: But when it came time for the defense to present its case in chief, it called no witnesses.
[SPEAKER_00]: On August 28, 2009, after deliberating for two hours and five minutes, the jury found King guilty of kidnapping with intent to commit a felony, sexual battery, and first-degree murder. [SPEAKER_00]: The next step was to decide on King's punishment. [SPEAKER_00]: His defense attorneys argued that he shouldn't receive the death penalty because he had suffered a severe head injury as a child during a sledding accident. [SPEAKER_00]: A doctor testified that his frontal lobe had been severely damaged, which impacted his ability to make good decisions.
[SPEAKER_00]: It also led to his aggression and impulsivity. [SPEAKER_00]: Experts also testified about his alleged low intelligence and that he was on the border of having a learning disability. [SPEAKER_00]: But on September 4th, 2009, at 245 p.m., the jury handed down the recommended sentence of death in a unanimous vote. [SPEAKER_00]: Over the next several years, the courts heard multiple appeals, but they denied everyone. [SPEAKER_00]: And on February 13th, 2026, Florida's governor signed King's death warrant, setting his execution for March 17th.
[SPEAKER_00]: That evening, more than 18 years after Denise's murder, King was executed by lethal injection. [SPEAKER_00]: He was 54 years old and was pronounced dead at 6.13pm. [SPEAKER_00]: For his final meal, he had pizza, tater tots, ice cream, and soda. [SPEAKER_00]: His final statement was so quiet that witnesses could barely hear it. [SPEAKER_00]: In a statement relayed by the governor's office, King said he found religion in prison and tried to live according to his faith.
[SPEAKER_00]: He said that included, loving his own family, Denise's family, and the people carrying out his execution. [SPEAKER_00]: King's execution marked the end of his case. [SPEAKER_00]: But Denise's family had been working to change the system that failed her since shortly after her death. [SPEAKER_00]: In June 2008, Nathan established the Denise Amber Lee Foundation. [SPEAKER_00]: He wanted other families to be able to call 911 and trust that the information they gave would reach someone who could help.
[SPEAKER_00]: The Foundation's work focused on better training, clear procedures, improved technology, and reviewing calls to identify mistakes before they happened again. [SPEAKER_00]: Florida also made changes. [SPEAKER_00]: In April 2008, lawmakers unanimously passed the Denise Amberly Act, creating a voluntary certification program for 911 dispatchers. [SPEAKER_00]: It was a step forward, but training was still optional. [SPEAKER_00]: A state report published in early 2010,
[SPEAKER_00]: Confirmed that Florida still didn't require minimum training for its 9-1-1 call center staff. [SPEAKER_00]: So Nathan and Denise's father Rick kept pushing. [SPEAKER_00]: In 2010, Florida passed legislation establishing mandatory statewide certification with an October 2012 deadline. [SPEAKER_00]: Answering those emergency calls would now require meeting a state competency standard. [SPEAKER_00]: And Nathan's work extended well beyond Florida. [SPEAKER_00]: Through the foundation, he began traveling around the country, sharing Denise's story with the people answering emergency calls and dispatching help.
[SPEAKER_00]: Those recordings became part of an effort to help other 911 professionals recognize what went wrong and what they could do differently when someone else called in danger. [SPEAKER_00]: Nathan took some of the most painful moments of his life and used them to help prepare people for a call that might otherwise end the same way. [SPEAKER_00]: to share your thoughts on this week's story, follow forensic tales on social media. [SPEAKER_00]: And if you'd like to support this independent, one-woman podcast, you can join us on Patreon for as little as $3 a month.
[SPEAKER_00]: Patreon members receive new episodes early and ad-free, along with monthly full-length bonus episodes. [SPEAKER_00]: Your support directly helps fund the show's research, production, and editing. [SPEAKER_00]: You can learn more at patreon.com slash forensic tales. [SPEAKER_00]: forensic tales is a Rockefeller audio production. [SPEAKER_00]: The show is written and produced by me, Courtney Fretwell. [SPEAKER_00]: If you'd like to support the show and help fund research, production, and editing, you can do so with a small monthly contribution on Patreon.
[SPEAKER_00]: Patreon supporters get early access to add free episodes and exclusive bonus content. [SPEAKER_00]: You can learn more at patreon.com slash forensic tales. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you so much to this week's newest supporter, Peter R. And if you enjoy the show, leaving a positive rating or review really helps others discover it. [SPEAKER_00]: For a full list of sources used in this episode, visit forensictales.com. [SPEAKER_00]: Thank you for listening, and I'll see you next week.
[SPEAKER_00]: Until then, remember, not all stories have happy endings.
The Jordan Harbinger Show is a podcast with incredible guests, from experts speaking on major global topics, to more personal discussions on issues like navigating your career or romantic life. I have become a regular...
#359 - In August 1987, a freight train struck 16-year-old Don Henry and 17-year-old Kevin Ives as they lay motionless on railroad tracks in Arkansas. The medical examiner called it an accident, claiming marijuana had...
#358 - In December 2003, federal prosecutor Jonathan Luna was found dead in a Pennsylvania creek, far from his Baltimore office. He had suffered 36 stab wounds and drowned. Toll records and banking activity traced a...
#357 - When Sharon Causse was shot and killed inside her Las Vegas home in 2008, her husband, Thomas Randolph, claimed he had killed the intruder responsible. But the physical evidence raised questions about his story....
#356 - When 71-year-old Alan Abrahamson was found shot dead near his gated Florida community, the missing weapon pointed investigators toward murder. But unusual purchases, a puzzling timeline, and a digital trail...