Deep in Russian forests, in times of famine and social upheaval, children sent to gather food or seek help from distant relatives frequently vanished without trace. Local accounts attributed these disappearances to a cannibalistic witch living in a mobile dwelling. Modern forensic analysis suggests these cases may involve a combination of exposure deaths, predation by desperate hermits or outcasts, and the deliberate abandonment of children by families unable to feed them - with the Baba Yaga legend providing psychological cover for both perpetrators and survivors. Content warning: child harm, violence, and disturbing material. Listener discretion advised. Folklore Forensics reopens myths, legends, and folklore as historical criminal cases. Listener discretion is advised. Written and hosted by Danielle Christmas and produced by Audio Ellis. Follow / subscribe for weekly storytelling investigations. Follow the show on Instagram @folkloreforensics Case suggestions and research inquiries: folkloreforensicspod@gmail.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00In the winter of 1897, a woodcutter named Pyotr Volkov was making his way through the Bryansk forest in western Russia when he noticed something that made his blood run cold. It was late afternoon, that gray time of day when the winter sun barely manages to penetrate the dense canopy of birch and pine. Pyotr had been working since dawn, his axe biting into frozen timber, his breath forming clouds in the bitter air. He was taking a shortcut back to his village, following a deer path he'd used a hundred times before, when something caught his eye.
SPEAKER_00At first he thought they were birds, dark shapes hanging from the branches of a massive birch tree swaying slightly in the wind. But as he got closer, his steps slowing, his heart beginning to pound, he realized what he was actually looking at. Shoes, children's shoes, dozens of them. Small leather boots, their laces tied together and looped over branches. Felt velenky, those thick winter boots that every Russian child wore, hanging like strange fruit, crude bark sandals, the kind that the poorest families made when they couldn't afford anything else.
SPEAKER_00All of them strung up like macabre ornaments, creaking softly as they swayed in the frozen wind. Pyotr stood there, his axe hanging loose in his hand, staring up at this impossible sight. He counted them. Later he would tell the authorities he counted them three times, not believing his own eyes. Forty-seven pairs.
SPEAKER_00Pyotr would later tell authorities that he knew immediately something was wrong. Because in rural Russia during the 1890s, shoes weren't something you just threw away. They were precious. Families would pass them down from child to child, repair them until they literally fell apart, stuff them with straw to make them last one more winter. No one, and I mean no one, would abandon perfectly good children's shoes in the middle of a forest. Unless those children no longer needed them.
SPEAKER_00What Pyotr stumbled upon that day would lead investigators to one of the most disturbing serial murder cases in pre-revolutionary Russia. A case that would claim at least 43 victims, possibly many more. A case that locals were already whispering about, but not to the police. No, they were whispering to each other in hushed tones, using a name that had terrified Russian children for centuries. Baba Yaga.
SPEAKER_00Every week we take a famous folk tale, myth, or legend, and investigate it as if it were a real criminal case. We look at the evidence, examine the victims, profile the perpetrators, and try to understand not just what happened, but why these stories have survived for centuries. I'm your host, Danielle Christmas, and today we're wandering into the dark corners of Slavic storytelling. This is case file 117, the Russian Forest Murders. And before we get started, I need to give you a content warning.
SPEAKER_00This episode contains disturbing material. Listener discretion is advised. Before we proceed, I need to establish the context for what follows because this case is profoundly disturbing. We're examining child victims, we're examining cannibalism, and we're examining a period in Russian history that was catastrophic for rural communities. The 1890s in Russia were marked by widespread famine, poverty, and desperation that most of us today simply cannot fathom.
SPEAKER_00And I want to be clear about something from the outset. This episode will challenge some of our assumptions about folklore, because what we're going to discover is that sometimes, not always, but sometimes, the monsters in our stories are real. And sometimes the most terrifying element isn't the monster at all. It's what we as a society are willing to countenance when we're desperate. To understand this case, we must first understand the world in which these crimes occurred.
SPEAKER_00The 1890s in rural Russia were catastrophic. The Russian famine of 1891 through 1892 killed somewhere between 375,000 and 400,000 people, according to official records, though the true number was almost certainly higher. Crops failed across vast swaths of the empire. Grain prices became astronomical. The government's response was inadequate at best, criminally negligent at worst. And here's what we often fail to acknowledge about famine.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't simply end when the harvest returns. The social devastation continues for years afterward. Families fracture, communities are traumatized, and people commit acts, desperate, horrifying acts, that they would never contemplate under normal circumstances. In the rural villages surrounding the Bryansk Forest, which spans the border region between Russia and what is now Belarus and Ukraine, a disturbing pattern was emerging in the mid-1890s.
SPEAKER_00Children were disappearing. Now, child mortality was already tragically high during this period. Disease, malnutrition, accidents, these were commonplace. But what was happening in these villages was different. These weren't children dying at home. These were children who were last seen walking into the forest and never returning. The first documented case that we can definitively link to what would become known as the Baba Yaga murders was a seven-year-old girl named Katya Sokulova from the village of Suzemka.
SPEAKER_00This was in April of 1894. According to the case file, and yes, there are actually police records from this period, which is remarkable for rural Russia at that time, Katya was sent by her mother to gather mushrooms in the forest. She never returned. Her mother, Yelena Sokulova, reported her missing to the local village elder. But what's striking is this. She didn't seem frantic. The village elder's notes describe her as resigned and fatalistic. She kept repeating phrases like the forest took her and Baba Yaga must have been hungry.
SPEAKER_00At the time, the elder apparently accepted this as peasant superstition and pursued the matter no further. No search party was organized, no investigation was launched. Katya simply vanished from the record. And she wasn't alone. Over the next three years, at least 23 children disappeared from villages around the Bryantsk Forest under similar circumstances. I say at least because those are merely the ones that were officially reported. Given the chaos of the period and the fact that many families were transient, moving from village to village in search of work or sustenance, the actual number could be substantially higher.
SPEAKER_00The victims range in age from approximately five to twelve years old. They were both boys and girls, though girls slightly outnumbered boys, roughly a 60-40 distribution. Most came from the poorest families in their villages. And here's a detail that will become significant. Almost all of them were last seen being sent into the forest alone, usually to forage for food, gather firewood, or tend to livestock. The pattern was consistent. Child enters forest, child doesn't return, family reports them missing, but displays a strange passivity.
SPEAKER_00Local authorities do little to nothing, and the villagers whisper about Bobby Aga. For those unfamiliar with Slavic folklore, allow me to provide some context. Babbi Yaga is a witch figure who dwells in the forest in a hut that stands on chicken legs. She flies through the air in a mortar, the vessel used for grinding herbs, using the pestle to steer and a broom to sweep away her tracks. She possesses iron teeth, and depending on which version of the tail you encounter, she either aids lost children or devours them.
SPEAKER_00The devouring is what concerns us here. For centuries, Baba Yaga has served as a cautionary figure to keep children from wandering into the forest alone. Behave or Baba Yaga will snatch you. Don't venture into the deep woods or Baba Yaga will put you in her oven, that sort of thing. So when the children began disappearing into the forest in the 1890s, the folklore was already there, ready-made to explain it. It was almost convenient, and that's something worth examining more closely.
SPEAKER_00Let us return to Pyotr Volkov, our woodcutter from the opening. It's January 1897, the depths of winter, and Pyotr is in the Bryansk Forest pursuing his trade, cutting timber. He's approximately 15 kilometers or nine and a half miles from the nearest village, in a section of the forest that most people avoid because it's dense, difficult to navigate, and possessed of an unsettling atmosphere even without a serial killer in residence. Pyotr notices the shoes suspended from the tree, and he's immediately disturbed.
SPEAKER_00But he's also curious. So he begins looking around more carefully, and that's when he sees it. About fifty meters or fifty-five yards distant, partially concealed by snow and undergrowth, there's a structure. And when I read the description of this in the case files, I felt a chill. Because it's described as a quote, small wooden dwelling elevated on what appeared to be carved posts.
SPEAKER_00A hut on legs. Now obviously it wasn't literally on chicken legs, that's the folklore speaking, but it was elevated on wooden posts, probably to keep it off the frozen ground and away from wolves and other predators. The posts were carved and weathered, and in the snow and shadows one can absolutely understand how they might resemble legs to someone already primed by folklore to perceive them that way. Pyotr approaches the hut and he notices other things. There are bones scattered around the perimeter. Small bones.
SPEAKER_00He observed what appears to be a grinding stone, a large mortar and pestle, which would have been used for processing grain or herbs. There are strange symbols carved into the surrounding trees. And there's a smell. Even in the frozen winter air, there's a smell emanating from the hut that Pyotr later described as quote, the smell of death and rendered fat. Pyotr is not a foolish man. He's lived in these forests his entire life. He understands what he's looking at.
SPEAKER_00So he doesn't enter, he doesn't confront whoever might be inside. He very quietly retreats, marks the location in his mind, and runs back to the nearest village. He goes directly to the village of Krasny Rock and reports what he's found to the local constable, a man named Dmitry Orlov. And here's where fortune favors the investigation. Orlov actually takes his seriously. He's heard the rumors about missing children, he's heard the whispers about Baba Yaga, and unlike the village elders who dismissed earlier reports, Orlov suspects something real might be occurring.
SPEAKER_00Orlov organizes a group of six men, including Pyotr, and they return to the hut. They bring weapons, axes, hunting rifles, a pitchfork. They are taking no chances. They reach the clearing in the late afternoon. The hut remains, obviously. Smoke rises from a crude chimney. Someone is home. According to Orlov's official report, which is now housed in the State Archive of the Russian Federation of Moscow, yes, I've actually examined copies of these documents.
SPEAKER_00The men surrounded the hut and Orlov called out, identifying himself as a representative of the law and demanding that whoever was inside emerge. Nothing happened. He called out again, still nothing. So they made the decision to force entry. Two of the men climbed up to the door, remember the hut is elevated, and they broke it down. And what they found inside, I'm not gonna soften this. It was a charnel house.
SPEAKER_00The interior of the hut was small, perhaps three meters by four meters. There was a crude stove constructed of clay and stones, shelves lined the walls, and on those shelves were jars and containers filled with preserved meat. Human meat. There were also bones, numerous bones, small bones, clearly from children, some of them displaying cut marks consistent with butchering. Some had been cracked open, presumably to extract the marrow. In one corner there was a pile of children's clothing, shirts, dresses, pants, all small sizes, all worn and patched, all belonging to children who would never wear them again.
SPEAKER_00And in the center of the room, sitting on a low stool beside the stove, was the person they would come to know as Baba Yaga. Here's where we must separate folklore from reality. The person sitting in that hut wasn't some supernatural witch with iron teeth and a flying mortar. It was a woman, a real human woman, probably in her sixties or seventies, though malnutrition and harsh living made it difficult to determine her exact age. She was described in the police report as quote, extremely thin with long gray hair, missing most of her teeth and possessing a disturbing, vacant stare.
SPEAKER_00She didn't resist arrest, she didn't speak, she simply stared at the men with what Orlov described as, quote, the eyes of a wild animal, not hostile, but not quite human either. They took her into custody and brought her back to the village, where she was held in a root cellar that served as their makeshift jail. And when they returned to the hut to conduct a more thorough investigation, what they discovered was absolutely damning. Over several days in the area surrounding the hut, they found a burial site, or more accurately, a disposal site, shallow graves containing the remains of at least 18 children.
SPEAKER_00Some of the bodies were relatively intact, others had been processed, butchered for meat. They found tools, knives, a cleaver, a saw, all showing signs of use and crude attempts at cleaning. They found that mortar and pestle Pyotr had observed, which was used for grinding bones into meal, probably to make them easier to dispose of or possibly to consume. There's evidence that bone meal was being mixed into a kind of porridge. And they found something else that's crucial to understanding this case.
SPEAKER_00They found evidence that the woman wasn't always alone. There were multiple sets of clothing in different sizes. There were two different sleeping areas, and some of the tools and implements suggested that at least one other person, possibly more, had been living there at various times. This becomes significant because it raises the question, was this one person acting alone or was this a group? Were there multiple baby gaz operating in the forest? Was this some kind of survival community of desperate people who had turned to cannibalism?
SPEAKER_00We don't have definitive answers, but the evidence suggests it might have been both. Once word spread that someone had been arrested in connection with the disappearances, people began coming forward. And their testimonies paint a deeply disturbing picture. A farmer named Ivan Petrov from the village of Suzemka, where our first victim Katya was from, testified that he had seen a strange old woman in the forest on multiple occasions over the past few years. He described her as wearing layers of ragged clothing, carrying a large walking stick, and sometimes pulling a small wooden cart.
SPEAKER_00He said she would appear suddenly, almost silently, and that she had a way of watching people that made him profoundly uncomfortable. On one occasion, he witnessed her talking to a young boy who was tending goats near the forest edge. He said the woman was offering the boy something, he couldn't discern what, and the boy seemed hesitant but interested. Ivan shouted at the boy to get away from her, and the woman disappeared into the trees, quote, faster than someone her age should have been able to move. That boy, incidentally, was never reported missing.
SPEAKER_00He made it home safely. But Yvonne's testimony suggests that the woman was actively luring children, not simply waiting for them to stumble upon her hut. Another witness, a woman named Olga Mikhailova, testified that she had seen smoke rising from deep in the forest on multiple occasions, always from roughly the same area. She said everyone in the village knew that someone was living out there, but no one investigated because, quote, the forest was Baba Yaga's domain and you didn't enter Baba Yaga's domain unless you wanted to disappear.
SPEAKER_00Consider that for a moment. The villagers knew someone was out there. They knew children were disappearing, but the folklore was so powerful, the fear so ingrained, that no one took action. Or, and this is the darker possibility, perhaps some of them didn't want to take action. We'll return to that. The most chilling testimony came from a 12-year-old boy named Alexei Volkov, no relation to Pyotr the woodcutter. Alexi testified that two years earlier, when he was ten, he had gotten lost in the forest while searching for a lost calf.
SPEAKER_00He wandered for hours, growing increasingly frightened, until he saw smoke and followed it to a clearing. There was the hut on its posts, and there was the old woman. She called to him. She told him she had food that she could help him find his way home. She seemed kind, he said, grandmotherly even. He was about to approach when he heard a sound from inside the hut. A whimpering sound. A child crying. Something about that sound made Alexi run.
SPEAKER_00He didn't know why at the time. He simply knew he had to escape. He ran blindly through the forest until he found a path he recognized, and he made it home just before dark. He never told anyone about what he'd witnessed because he was afraid people would think he was fabricating the story or that he'd be punished for losing the calf. But when he heard about the arrest, he came forward. The investigators asked him if he could identify the woman they had in custody. They brought him to the root cellar, and the moment he saw her, he began shaking.
SPEAKER_00That's her, he said. That's Babi Aga. We must remember that this is 1897 in rural Russia. Forensic science as we understand it today essentially didn't exist, especially not in remote areas. There was no DNA testing, no fingerprint analysis, no sophisticated autopsy procedures, but the investigators did the best they could with the tools available to them. A doctor from the nearest town, a man named Dr. Leonid Sokolov, was brought in to examine the remains found at the site.
SPEAKER_00His report, which still exists in the archives, is both meticulous and deeply disturbing. The doctor confirmed that the remains were human and that they belonged to children ranging in age from approximately five to thirteen years old. He identified at least 18 distinct individuals based on skeletal remains, though he noted that the number could be higher because some remains were incomplete or had been destroyed. The cause of death for most victims couldn't be determined due to the condition of the remains, but the several skulls showed evidence of blunt force trauma.
SPEAKER_00The doctor theorized that the victims were likely killed quickly, a blow to the head before being butchered. And yes, they were definitely butchered. The cut marks on the bones were consistent with someone who understood how to process an animal carcass. The long bones had been split to access the marrow. The skulls had been opened to access the brain. The ribs showed evidence of having meat stripped from them. Dr. Sokolov also examined the preserved meat found in the hut. He confirmed it was human tissue, primarily muscle meat, preserved in salt and fat.
SPEAKER_00Some of it appeared to be relatively fresh, weeks old perhaps. Other jars contained meat that was clearly much older, possibly years old. There was also evidence of rendering, the process of melting down fat to create lard or tallow. There was a large pot in the hut that contained residue consistent with human fat. The doctor's conclusion was unambiguous. This was a case of systematic murder and cannibalism carried out over a period of at least three years, possibly much longer.
SPEAKER_00So who was this woman? Who was the real Baba Yaga? This is where the case becomes frustrating because we don't have as much information as one might hope. The woman refused to speak. She wouldn't provide her name, wouldn't answer questions, wouldn't explain herself. She simply sat in that root cellar staring at nothing, occasionally humming. The investigators tried everything. They brought in priests thinking perhaps she'd confess to her religious authority.
SPEAKER_00Nothing. They brought in women from the village thinking perhaps she'd be more comfortable speaking to other women. Still nothing. They even threatened her with torture. Which yes was still practiced in 1890s Russia, but she didn't react at all. It was as though she existed somewhere else entirely. So the investigators had to piece together her identity from other sources. They searched the hut more thoroughly and found a few personal items, a small icon of St. Nicholas, a wooden comb, and a tattered piece of paper that appeared to be a very old internal passport.
SPEAKER_00The passport was barely legible, but they were able to discern a name. Paulina Antonova. They began making inquiries in the surrounding villages. Did anyone know of Paulina Antonova? Did anyone remember a woman by that name? Eventually, they found someone who did. An elderly man in the village of Pochep, approximately 30 kilometers away, remembered a woman named Paulina who had lived in the village decades earlier. This would have been back in the 1850s or 60s.
SPEAKER_00She'd been married to a farmer named Anton Petrov, that's where the Antonova derived from, the feminine form of his patronymic. According to this man's recollection, Polina and Anton had several children, but they all died, some from disease, some from accidents. Then Anton died, probably in the late 1860s. After that, Polina became increasingly isolated and strange. She began talking to herself, claiming she could see spirits, that sort of thing. Eventually, she simply disappeared.
SPEAKER_00People assumed she had died or moved away. No one searched for her. If this was indeed the same woman and the age would be approximately correct, then she had been living in that forest for potentially 30 years or more, alone or mostly alone, surviving however she could. But here's the crucial point. The investigators didn't believe she had been killing children for 30 years. The physical evidence suggesting the murders had begun more recently, probably in the early to mid-1890s. So what changed?
SPEAKER_00Why did she begin killing? The most probable answer is the famine. Before the famine, she likely survived by foraging, perhaps doing some small-scale cultivation in the forest, possibly trading with villagers or stealing from them. But when the famine struck, those options vanished. The forest had less to forage. The villagers had nothing to trade and were guarding their resources more vigilantly. She was starving. And at some point, she made the decision to survive by any means necessary.
SPEAKER_00Let's consider Paulina as a person, because I think it's essential to understand that she wasn't born a monster. She was made into one by circumstances, by trauma, by a society that abandoned her. Based on what we know, Paulina was probably born sometime in the 1820s or 30s. She would have grown up as a serf, essentially enslaved, on some nobleman's estate. Life for serfs in Russia was brutal. They had no rights, no freedom, no prospects. They could be bought, sold, or beaten, or killed at their master's whim.
SPEAKER_00Serfdom was abolished in 1861, but that didn't magically improve life for former serfs. Most of them remained desperately poor, tied to the land struggling to survive. Paulina married, had children, and then lost everything. We don't know the specific details of how her children died, but child mortality in 19th century Russia was approximately 40 to 50 percent. It wasn't unusual for a woman to lose multiple children, but that doesn't make it any less traumatic. Then she lost her husband.
SPEAKER_00As a widow with no children and no means of support, her options were extremely limited. She could attempt to remarry, but who would want to marry an older woman with no dowry? She could try to live with relatives, but what if she had none or they couldn't afford to support her? She could beg, but there were many beggars and little charity to go around. Or she could disappear into the forest. Living in the forest would have been extraordinarily difficult, but it would have granted her a kind of freedom. No one to answer to, no one to judge her, just survival day by day.
SPEAKER_00And for years, perhaps decades, she managed it. She became a hermit, a forest dweller, someone who existed on the margins of society. But then the famine came and survival became impossible through conventional means. And at some point, we don't know exactly when or why, she crossed a line that most people never cross. She killed a child, and she consumed that child. I want to be careful here because it's easy to sensationalize this, to transform her into some kind of monster or demon, but the psychological reality is probably more complicated and more tragic.
SPEAKER_00There's a concept in extreme survival situations called survival cannibalism. It's when people resort to consuming human flesh, not because they desire to, but because it's literally the only way to remain alive. It's been documented in shipwrecks, plane crashes, sieges, and famines throughout history. The most famous example is probably the Donner Party in 1846-47, where American pioneers trapped in the Sierra Nevada Mountains resorted to cannibalism to survive. But there are numerous other examples, including several from Russian history.
SPEAKER_00During the Siege of Leningrad in World War II, there were documented cases of cannibalism. During the Soviet famine of 1932 through 33, there were reports of cannibalism in rural areas. The point is this when people are starving to death, when they're in a state of extreme desperation, they're capable of things that would be unthinkable under normal circumstances. I believe that's probably what happened with Polina. She was starving. She was alone. She was likely suffering from malnutrition-induced mental illness.
SPEAKER_00And at some point, the survival instinct overrode everything else. The first time was probably opportunistic. Perhaps she found a child who had died of exposure or gotten lost and died of starvation. Perhaps she told herself, if it was already dead, that she was simply using a resource that would otherwise go to waste. But then it became easier, and then it became a pattern. And then it became her primary means of survival. The fact that she actively lured children suggests that by the end, she had moved beyond pure survival cannibalism into something darker.
SPEAKER_00She was hunting. She had become a predator. But I don't believe she started that way. I believe that she was a victim of her circumstances who became a perpetrator out of desperation and then couldn't find her way back. Remember the evidence of multiple people living in the hut at various times? We need to examine that because it's one of the most disturbing aspects of this case. The investigators found clothing and personal items that clearly belonged to different people.
SPEAKER_00There were two distinct sleeping areas, and some of the witnesses reported seeing different people in the forest at different times, sometimes an old woman, sometimes a younger woman, once or twice a man. This led to a theory that there might have been multiple Babayaga's, multiple people living in the forest, possibly working together, possibly operating independently. One possibility is that Paulina wasn't alone. Perhaps she had a partner or partners. Perhaps other desperate people found their way to her hut and joined her in her survival strategy.
SPEAKER_00Perhaps there was an entire community of forest dwellers who had turned to cannibalism. Another possibility is that there were copycats. Once the legend of Baba Yaga began spreading, once people started whispering that there was a witch in the forest who devoured children, perhaps other people decided to use that legend as cover for their own crimes. Consider it. If you're a desperate person who's decided that cannibalism is your only option for survival, what better cover than a pre-existing legend? People are already afraid of Babi Yaga, they're already avoiding the forest, they're already explaining disappearances as Babi Yaga took them.
SPEAKER_00You can hide in plain sight. The investigators attempted to track down these other potential perpetrators, but they were never successful. The forest was vast, the population was transient, and record keeping was minimal. If there were other people involved, they either died, moved on, or successfully concealed their involvement. But here's what we do know. After Polino was arrested, the disappearances didn't completely cease. There were at least three more cases over the next two years that fit the same pattern.
SPEAKER_00Children sent into the forest, never returning, families resigned to their fate. This suggests that either there were copycats or the problem was larger than just one person. We need to discuss something profoundly difficult now. Something that the investigators at the time didn't want to acknowledge, but that becomes rather obvious when you examine the evidence with clear eyes. Some of these children were deliberately abandoned. I know that's a horrible thing to articulate.
SPEAKER_00I know it's difficult to hear, but the evidence is there. Remember how the families of missing children often seemed strangely passive, how they didn't organize search parties, didn't demand investigations, simply accepted that their child was gone. Remember how almost all the children were sent into the forest alone, often on errands that didn't really make sense? Sending a seven-year-old to gather mushrooms alone miles from home, sending a six-year-old to tend livestock in the deep forest. These weren't normal tasks for children that young.
SPEAKER_00And remember the social context: widespread famine, desperate poverty, families with more children than they could feed. The uncomfortable truth is that some of these families probably knew exactly what they were doing. They were using the legend of Baba Yaga as a means to abandon children they couldn't afford to keep. They would send a child into the forest knowing, or at least suspecting, that the child wouldn't return, and then they would tell themselves and everyone else that Baba Yaga took them. It wasn't their fault, it was the witch, it was the forest, it was fate.
SPEAKER_00The legend provided psychological cover. It allowed them to do something unthinkable, abandon their own children to die without having to fully acknowledge what they were doing. And here's the truly dark element. Paulina might have understood this. She might have known that some of these children were being deliberately sent to her. She might have seen herself as providing a service in a twisted way, taking children that no one wanted that would have died anyway. There's a note in the case file from one of the investigators, a man named Sergei Fyodorov, where he writes, quote, one must wonder if the true monster is the woman in the forest or the society that feeds her.
SPEAKER_00I think about that observation frequently. Because yes, Polina killed children. That's monstrous, that's unforgivable, but she was also a product of a system that abandoned her, that left her to starve, that gave her no options and no hope. And the families who sent their children into the forest, they were also products of that same system. They were desperate, starving, watching their children suffer, and they made an impossible choice. Who's the real monster in this story?
SPEAKER_00Is it the cannibal in the forest? Is it the parents who abandoned their children? Is it the society that created the conditions where these things could happen? I don't have an answer to that. I'm not certain there is one. Let's consider the broader picture because this case doesn't exist in isolation. Child abandonment during times of famine and hardship is not unique to 1890s Russia. It's occurred throughout history, across the globe. In medieval Europe, children were regularly abandoned at monasteries or left in the forest during famines.
SPEAKER_00In China, during periods of famine, there are documented cases of families selling children or leaving them to die. In Japan, there was a practice called mabiki, literally thinning, where families would kill or abandon infants they couldn't afford to raise. It's one of the darkest aspects of human history, but it's a real one. When resources are scarce and survival is uncertain, societies make brutal calculations about who gets to live and who doesn't. And folklore often reflects these dark realities.
SPEAKER_00Hansel and Gretel, the German fairy tale, is literally about parents abandoning their children in the forest during a famine. The witch who attempts to devour them is the monster in the story, but the parents who left them are treated as sympathetic figures who had no choice. Babby Aga's stories serve a similar function in Slavic culture. They're cautionary tales, certainly, but they're also a way of processing and explaining the reality of child abandonment and death. When a child disappeared in the forest, saying Babby Aga took them was easier than saying we sent them there to die or we couldn't afford to feed them anymore.
SPEAKER_00The legend made the unbearable bearable. And in this case, the legend became real. Or perhaps it was always real and we simply didn't want to see it. There is a Russian historian named Dr. Natalia Smirnova who has written extensively about this case. She argues that Polina wasn't an aberration, she was a symptom, a symptom of a society in crisis, a society that had broken down to the point where the most vulnerable people, children, the elderly, the disabled, were being sacrificed for the survival of others.
SPEAKER_00Dr. Smirnova writes, quote, The Babiaga case forces us to confront the reality that folklore is not merely entertainment or superstition. It is a mirror that reflects our deepest fears and our darkest truths. And sometimes that mirror shows us things we would rather not see. I believe she's correct. So what became of Polina Antonova, the woman who became Baba Yaga? She was never formally tried. The Russian legal system at the time was complicated, especially in rural areas, and there was considerable debate about whether she was mentally competent to stand trial.
SPEAKER_00Some officials argue that she was clearly insane and should be sent to an asylum. Others argued that she was a dangerous criminal who should be executed. Still others argued that she was a victim of circumstances and deserves some measure of mercy. In the end, the decision was made by the provincial governor, who ordered that she be held indefinitely in a secure facility. She was transferred to a monastery in the Bryansk region that had a wing for housing the mentally ill and criminally insane. She died there in 1899, just two years after her arrest.
SPEAKER_00The cause of death was listed as quote, general decline. Essentially, she simply wasted away. She never spoke, never explained herself, never showed any remorse or even acknowledgement of what she had done. The hut in the forest was burned. The burial site was blessed by a priest and marked with a simple wooden cross. The families of the victims were notified, though many of them didn't attend any kind of memorial service. And then, officially, the case was closed.
SPEAKER_00But unofficially, the story continued. The legend of Baba Yaga, which had been folklore, was now reinforced by a real case. Parents continued to use it to frighten children into obedience. Don't go into the forest or Baba Yaga will get you, now had a very real referent. And the disappearances didn't completely cease. As I mentioned earlier, there were at least three more cases in the following years that fit the same pattern. The authorities investigated, but they never found another perpetrator.
SPEAKER_00Either the person or people responsible were never caught, or the disappearances had other explanations that were never uncovered. By the early 1900s, the case had faded from official memory. The records were filed away in archives. The people who had been directly involved died or moved on. The villages around the Bryansk Forest continued their difficult existence, dealing with poverty, famine, revolution, and war. But the story survived. It was passed down through generations, becoming more legend than history, until it was almost impossible to separate the real case from the folklore.
SPEAKER_00In the 1990s, after the fall of the Soviet Union, Russian historians and criminologists started looking back at old cases with fresh eyes. The Baba Yaga case was one of them. Dr. Natalia Smirnova, who I mentioned earlier, led a team that went through the archived caste files, interviewed descendants of people involved in the case, and even conducted an archaeological survey of the site where the hut had stood. What they found was fascinating. The site was still identifiable. There were remnants of the foundation posts, some artifacts, and yes, human remains that had been missed in the original investigation.
SPEAKER_00Using modern forensic techniques, they were able to confirm that at least 43 individuals had been killed at that site, probably more. They also found evidence that supported the multiple perpetrator theory. There were artifacts from different time periods, suggesting that the site had been used by different people over a span of decades. There were also indications that the site might have been used for other purposes before it became a murder site, possibly as a legitimate hermit's dwelling or even a small shrine. Dr.
SPEAKER_00Smirnova's team also did something really interesting. They tracked down descendants of the families involved and conducted oral history interviews. And what they found was that the story had been passed down but with significant variations. Some families remembered it as a straightforward case of a serial killer. Others remembered it as a tragedy of desperation and survival. And some, and this is the part that really got to me, some families had stories about ancestors who had, quote, sent a child to Baba Yaga during the famine years.
SPEAKER_00One woman, whose great-great-grandmother had lived through the famine, told the researchers, quote, My babushka told me that her mother had eight children, and during the worst of the famine, three of them went to the forest. She said it like that, went to the forest, not died or disappeared, but went to the forest. And she said it was a mercy because they would have starved slowly at home, but in the forest, it was quick. Whether that was true or just a family story, we'll never know, but it speaks to the reality that these families were living with.
SPEAKER_00So here's what stays with me about this case. The Babya Ga disappearances sit in this really uncomfortable space where there's no clear villain, no satisfying resolution. Paulina Antonova killed at least 43 children. That's documented, that's real. But she was also starving, abandoned, probably mentally ill from years of isolation and trauma. And then there are the families. Some of them were genuinely searching for lost children. But others, the evidence suggests they knew exactly where their children were going.
SPEAKER_00They just couldn't say it out loud. Folklore gave them a way to not say it. The witch took them is easier to live with than we couldn't feed them. I'm not sure I can even imagine making that choice, but I also can't imagine the kind of desperation that would lead to it. What gets me is how the legend and the reality fed into each other. The folklore created a framework for something unspeakable to happen. And then the reality reinforced the folklore. It's this horrible, self-perpetuating cycle.
SPEAKER_00Dr. Smirnova told me something in one of our interviews that I keep thinking about. She said, quote, we want our monsters to be simple. We want them to be purely evil so we can feel purely good in opposition to them. But history doesn't give us that. History gives us complexity and context and circumstances that make us uncomfortable. And that's this case. It's deeply uncomfortable because there's no easy way to process it. That concludes case file number 117, The Russian Forest Murders, but the story doesn't end there.
SPEAKER_00Keep listening for a brief case epilogue on the afterlife of Baba Yaga. There's a detail about this case that I find both haunting and strangely beautiful in the way that only the darkest stories can be. In 2003, a Russian folklorist named Elena Dmitrievna was conducting field research in the villages around the Bryansk Forest, collecting oral histories and traditional tales. She was particularly interested in how the Babi Yaga legend had evolved over the past century.
SPEAKER_00What she discovered was unexpected. In several villages, there was a tradition that it emerged sometime in the early 20th century after the case, after Polina's death. On the winter solstice, the longest night of the year, families would gather in their homes and light candles in their windows. Not for celebration, but for remembrance. They called it lighting the forest. The tradition was to light one candle for each child who had gone to the forest during the famine years.
SPEAKER_00The candles would burn through the night, and in the morning, families would take the melted wax and bury it at the edge of the forest near the tree line. When Elena asked about the meaning of this ritual, an elderly woman told her, quote, We light the candles so the children can find their way home. Not their bodies, those are long gone, but their spirits. We light the ways so they know they weren't forgotten, so they know they were loved, even when love wasn't enough to save them. The tradition has largely died out now.
SPEAKER_00The villages have changed, the old people have passed away, and the younger generations have moved to cities. But Elena documented it, preserved it, ensured that this small act of remembrance wouldn't be entirely lost to time. And here's what strikes me about this. The same communities that may have participated in abandoning children, that may have used the legend of Babiaga as psychological cover for an unbearable choice, also created a ritual to honor those children, to acknowledge them, to say in the only way they could, we're sorry, we remember, you mattered.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't absolve anything, and it doesn't make the horror any less horrifying. But it does suggest something about the human capacity for both cruelty and compassion, often existing in the same hearts, the same communities, the same moment in history. The last recorded lighting the forest ceremony took place in 2007 in a village called Suzemka, the same village where Katya Sokolova, our first victim, had lived. Three elderly women gathered in one of their homes, lit 43 candles, one for each confirmed victim, and kept vigil through the night.
SPEAKER_00In the morning, they took the wax to the forest edge and buried it as their grandmothers had taught them. And then they went home. The forest, as always, kept its secrets. Next week we'll reopen another case, examining legends and lore through the lens of true crime. I'm Danielle Christmas, and you've been listening to Folklore Forensics. Folklore Forensics is written and hosted by me and produced by Audio Ellis. Lean music is by The Soundlings and Josh Pan.
SPEAKER_00You can find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Follow Folklore Forensics on Instagram at Folklore Forensics. Please send future case suggestions to Folklore Forensics Pod at gmail.com. Until next time, stay curious and always follow the evidence.
Four confessions. A woman who claimed to fly, transform into a hare, and feast with the Queen of Fairies. And a historical record that ends before revealing her fate. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. In 1662,...
Lancaster Castle. August 1612. A nine-year-old girl is lifted onto a table before a crowded courtroom. Her name is Jennet Device. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. Standing before the judges, Jennet accuses her...
In the hills outside Leicester, children were disappearing. The villagers knew who was responsible. Black Annis. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. According to English folklore, she was a blue-faced hag with...
A young man disappears from a riverboat after dark. His lantern is still warm. His coat remains folded on the bench. And in the bottom of the boat, investigators discover a woman's carved horn comb. The villagers...
A servant boy stole three drops of divine wisdom from a Welsh sorceress. She hunted him across land, water, and sky and when she finally caught him, she swallowed him whole. You've heard the story. Now hear the case....