The Pendle Witch Trials: The Child Who Sent Her Family to the Gallows
30 minAudio
Lancaster Castle. August 1612. A nine-year-old girl is lifted onto a table before a crowded courtroom. Her name is Jennet Device. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. Standing before the judges, Jennet accuses her own mother, brother, and neighbors of witchcraft, murder, and a conspiracy involving demonic spirits. Her testimony helps send members of her family to the gallows. The Pendle Witch Trials would become one of the most notorious witchcraft prosecutions in English history. Ten people were executed, and the surviving court account preserves an extraordinary record of accusations, confessions, neighborhood rivalries, and judicial fear. But what did Jennet Device actually witness? This week on Folklore Forensics, we reopen the Pendle Witch Trials of 1612, examining the evidence behind the prosecution of the Device and Chattox families, the mysterious gathering at Malkin Tower, and the legal machinery that turned suspicion into proof. Were the defendants members of a murderous conspiracy? Or did frightened witnesses and determined magistrates construct a criminal case out of poverty, folk beliefs, and neighborhood grudges? What happens when fear becomes evidence? Folklore Forensics reopens myths, legends, and folklore as historical criminal cases. Listener discretion is advised. Written and hosted by Danielle Christmas and produced by Audio Ellis. Follow / subscribe for weekly storytelling investigations. Follow the show on Instagram @folkloreforensics Case suggestions and research inquiries: folkloreforensicspod@gmail.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00On August 18th, 1612, inside the crowded courtroom of Lancaster Castle, a woman named Elizabeth Device was brought before the bar to face charges of witchcraft. When Elizabeth looked across the room and saw the star witness brought forward by the crown, she began to scream. Standing before the judges was her own nine-year-old daughter, Janet. Elizabeth shouted curses and wept aloud, throwing the court into such disorder that the presiding judge, Sir Edward Bromley, ordered the mother dragged out of the room so proceedings could continue.
SPEAKER_00With her mother gone, the nine-year-old was lifted onto a table in the center of the hall, placed in full view of the jury and magistrates. According to the account published the following year by court clerk Thomas Potts, Janet spoke with striking composure. She told the court that her mother kept a spirit in the shape of a brown dog called Ball. She testified that her brother James possessed a black dog and had fashioned clay figures to waste the flesh of neighbors. And she described a Good Friday gathering at her family's home, Malkin Tower, where neighbors allegedly plotted to blow up Lancaster Castle, murder the jailer, and rescue prisoners awaiting trial.
SPEAKER_00Under standard English practice, child testimony was rarely admitted in capital felony trials. But in this case, Janet's words became the prosecution's central pillar. Her testimony linked separate neighborhood disputes into an alleged criminal conspiracy, helping send her mother, her brother, and several neighbors to the gallows. The case had not begun in a courtroom with talk of gunpowder plots and demonic packs. It had started five months earlier on a muddy lane near Cone when a traveling peddler named John Law suffered a sudden collapse after a brief encounter with Janet's older sister Allison.
SPEAKER_00Between that road and the castle table, an everyday rural dispute transformed into one of the deadliest witch trials in English history. What did nine-year-old Janet Device actually witness? And how did a frightened community and a group of ambitious magistrates turn the words of a child into legal proof of a demonic conspiracy? I'm Danielle Christmas, and this is Folklore Forensics.
SPEAKER_00The popular narrative is vivid and dramatic. At its center stands Pendle Hill, a brooding whale-backed ridge that dominates the Lancashire landscape, often shrouded in cloud. Around this landmark, folklore placed a secret coven of witches, led by two elderly blind matriarchs locked in a decades-long feud. In the received legend, these women lived in crumbling stone ruins with sinister names like Mulkin Tower. They allegedly met on Good Friday for a forbidden feast of stolen mutton.
SPEAKER_00They made packs with demonic familiars, evil spirits believed to take animal form like black dogs. They crafted clay poppets or small handmade dolls studded with churchyard teeth to murder their enemies. And they plotted to blow up Lancaster Castle with gunpowder to free their imprisoned kin. At the climax of the story stands the ultimate family betrayal. A nine-year-old girl named Janet Device standing on a table in open court, pointing a finger at her mother, her brother, and her sister, sending her entire family to the gallows.
SPEAKER_00It's a story of terrifying supernatural malice. But that is the folklore. When we look past four centuries of romantic legends and popular retellings, what survives is something far more grounded, far more human, and far more unsettling. The historical record of the 1612 Lancashire trials is extraordinarily detailed. It's among the most thoroughly documented legal proceedings in early modern Europe. This is largely because the clerk of the court, Thomas Potts, published an official account of the trials in 1613 under the title The Wonderful Discovery of Witches in the County of Lancaster.
SPEAKER_00Potts wrote with a clear political goal, to celebrate the vigilance of the presiding judges and flatter King James I, whose interest in witchcraft helped shape the wider legal and religious climate of the time. Yet, because Potts included transcripts of depositions, formal sworn statements taken before trial, along with pretrial examinations and courtroom testimony, were left with a detailed window into how an isolated rural community turned on itself. When we examine those records not as an account of supernatural warfare, but as the documentary trail of a criminal investigation, the questions change entirely.
SPEAKER_00Twelve people were accused of capital felony, crimes carrying the death penalty. Ten were ultimately executed, nine at Lancaster, and Janet Preston at York. Elizabeth Southerns, known as Old Demdike, died in the dungeon awaiting trial, and one defendant was acquitted. But the question we have to answer is much darker. Why did an entire community choose to destroy these two marginalized households? And what mounting crisis of land, religion, and fear were they trying to explain away?
SPEAKER_00So let's go back. Back before the gallows were raised on the hill above Lancaster Castle, back before a nine-year-old child was lifted onto a table to condemn her own family. Back before Emile's stolen sheep at Malkin Tower was branded a criminal conspiracy, before a pedlar stumbled on a muddy lane and felt his body fail him. Back to a cold spring when two rival families were competing for survival in the shadow of Pendle Hill, and a local magistrate saw a chance to turn neighborhood gossip into evidence of a capital crime.
SPEAKER_00To reconstruct what happened in Pendle in the spring and summer of 1612, we have to begin with the land and the pressures bearing down upon the people who lived there. In the early 17th century, the forest of Pendle was not a dense woodland. It was a vast upland pasture district in northeast Lancashire, a landscape of damp peat bogs, steep valleys, and scattered stone farmsteads. It had formerly been a royal hunting forest, but under the Tudor monarchs, the land had been opened up, divided, and leased to private tenants.
SPEAKER_00This economic shift brought intense social strain. Rents were rising rapidly. Wealthier farmers were buying up land while poor cottagers and small tenants struggled just to survive. There were few churches, no resident noble families, and very little formal law enforcement. The community was physically isolated, economically insecure, and religiously suspect. Lancashire remained a stubborn stronghold of covert Roman Catholicism decades after the Protestant Reformation, a fact that made the central government in London view the entire region with a deep political anxiety.
SPEAKER_00In this precarious world, two impoverished families lived on the margins of village life, the Southerns Device family and the Whittle Redfern family. At the head of the first family was Elizabeth Southerns, an elderly woman in her eighties, widely known as Old Demdike. She lived at a remote cottage called Malkin Tower with her daughter Elizabeth Device and her three grandchildren, James, Alison, and the youngest nine-year-old Janet. At the head of the second family was Anne Whittle, known to everyone in the forest as Old Chaddock's.
SPEAKER_00She lived with her daughter Anne Redfern. Both Demdike and Chaddocks were elderly, widowed, and desperately poor. For at least 20 years before 1612, both women had occupied an accepted but dangerous place in the local economy. They were cunning folk, traditional healers and charmers who survived on small payments and begging. In a society without doctors or veterinary medicine, villagers routinely paid people like Demdike and Chaddock small sums of ale, milk, or oatmeal to bless their cattle, cure sick infants, locate lost property, or undo perceived curses.
SPEAKER_00It was a trade built entirely on reputation. To make a living, a cunning woman needed her neighbors to believe that her words had power. But in 17th century England, the line between helpful magic and harmful magic was razor thin. If people believed a woman had the power to heal a dying cow, they also believed she had the power to kill one. For years, the Devis and the Whittle Redferns had lived intense rivalry. They competed for the same charity and the same neighbor's business.
SPEAKER_00Around 1601, an incident deepened this professional rivalry into a bitter feud. The Devices accused Anne Redfern of breaking into Malkin Tower and stealing clothing, linen, and oatmeal. When James Device confronted Chaddocks, angry words were exchanged. Over the following years, whenever cattle died, beer spoiled, or children fell ill in the forest, each family blamed the other for practicing maleficium or harmful magic. This private friction remained manageable until late March 1612, when Allison Device met the peddler John Law on the road to Cone.
SPEAKER_00When John Law collapsed, his family didn't let the matter rest. His son, Abraham Law, brought Allison before Roger Noel, a wealthy local landowner and justice of the peace. Noel was operating under the 1604 Witchcraft Act, passed during the reign of King James I, which made harmful magic in dealings with spirits' capital crimes. On March 30th, Noel examined Elizabeth Device. In her recorded statement, the 18-year-old admitted that after quarreling with John Law, she had called upon a black dog to lame the peddler.
SPEAKER_00But Alison's testimony went beyond her own actions. She also directed Noel's attention toward her family's longtime rivals. Allison told the magistrate that her grandmother, Demdike, had long practiced witchcraft and claimed that old Chaddock's was far worse. She accused Chaddock of having caused the death of a local landowner named Robert Nutter years earlier and accused Anne Redfern of making clay figures to waste the flesh of her neighbors. Noel moved swiftly. Over the next few days, he brought in Demdike, Old Chaddock, and Anne Redfern for questioning.
SPEAKER_00Under examination, the women traded accusations. Chaddock's admitted to keeping a familiar spirit while Demdike described decades of folk charms and encounters with spirits. On April 2nd, 1612, Noel signed the commitment orders. Old Demdike, Old Chaddock's, Anne Redfern, and Alison Device were bound in chains and escorted 40 miles across the moors to the underground dungeons of Lancaster Castle. If the case had stopped there, it would have remained a localized witch prosecution.
SPEAKER_00But on Good Friday, April 10th, while the four women were held in prison, a gathering took place at Malkin Tower. Elizabeth Device met with family and neighbors at her home where they shared a meal of mutton. When word of this meeting reached Roger Knoll, the magistrate suspected an organized conspiracy. Knoll ordered swift arrests, taking Elizabeth Device, her son James, and several neighbors who had attended into custody. Among those arrested was Alice Nutter, a prosperous gentlewoman and the widow of a substantial landowner.
SPEAKER_00Her arrest transformed the case from a dispute among poor cottagers into an alleged conspiracy reaching across social classes. By the time the summer ascises approached, the suspects were held in the castle cells. Before the judges arrived, old Demdike died in the dungeon. In August 1612, the surviving prisoners were brought to trial before Sir Edward Bromley and Sir James Altham. The legal system of the era gave them no defense lawyers, no advance notice of the formal charges, and no opportunity to call witnesses on their own behalf.
SPEAKER_00To secure convictions for an invisible crime, the Crown introduced a catastrophic star witness, nine-year-old Janet Device. When Elizabeth DeVice was brought to the bar and saw her nine-year-old daughter preparing to testify, she screamed in anguish and cursed the girl until Judge Bromley ordered Elizabeth removed from the courtroom. Once her mother was gone, Janet was lifted onto a table before the jury. The child delivered sweeping accusations.
SPEAKER_00She named familiar spirits kept by her mother, accused her brother James of bewitching neighbors with clay figures, and testified that the guests at Malkin Tower had plotted to blow up Lancaster Castle, murder the jailer, and kill Roger Knoll. James Device, trembling and weakened from months in the dungeon, broke down and confessed to similar acts. Alice Nutter stood silent, maintaining her innocence. Anne Redfern refused to confess while Alice and Device wept openly.
SPEAKER_00On August 19th, 1612, the verdicts were delivered. Nine defendants at Lancaster were found guilty of felony by witchcraft and sentenced to hang alongside Janet Preston, who had been tried and condemned at York. Alice Gray was acquitted. The following day, on Gallows Hill overlooking Lancaster, the nine convicted prisoners were executed. The prosecution claimed total victory, a dangerous conspiracy dismantled by vigilant magistrates.
SPEAKER_00But when we test the evidence against the legal standards of the case, that official certainty begins to disintegrate. To test the evidence, let's turn to the foundation of the prosecution. The physical objects, the confessions, and the witness testimony brought before the court. After the first arrests, Magistrate Roger Knoll ordered a search of Malkin Tower. According to the surviving account, James Device led investigators to the hearth and uncovered two small clay figures and human teeth.
SPEAKER_00On the surface, this looked like tangible proof, but that certainty quickly falls apart under scrutiny. The surviving record provides no independent proof of where the objects came from, who made them, or how they were used. Traditional cunning folk often used clay, gathered herbs, or customary tokens in protective domestic rituals, but the prosecution treated these items exclusively as instruments of murder. Beyond what was reportedly found in the hearth, the crown produced no physical weapon, no poison, and no demonstrable mechanism that could have caused the deaths attributed to the defendants.
SPEAKER_00The real engine of the prosecution was never physical evidence. It was the way words changed categories as the investigation gathered speed. When John Law collapsed on the road near Cone, Alison DeVice didn't celebrate. She broke down in tears at his bedside, terrified that her angry words had somehow caused his stroke. In her own mind, she was expressing guilt and remorse for an emotional outburst that happened to coincide with a medical catastrophe.
SPEAKER_00Roger Knoll didn't treat Allison's distress as a private moral crisis. He treated it as a legal confession of capital murder. That confession then became a tool to interrogate her mother, her brother, and her grandmother. In turn, Allison was pushed to name her family's rival, Old Chaddox. Chaddox was arrested and her interrogation produced retaliatory claims against the Device family. Without a single new piece of physical proof, a young woman's tearful apology had been converted into evidence of an organized network.
SPEAKER_00It wasn't necessarily that anyone was consciously inventing lies. The structure of the inquiry transformed every scrap of neighborhood gossip, grief, and fear into formal proof of a conspiracy. Yet Alison wasn't the only one who admitted to impossible acts. Old Chaddocks confessed. James Device confessed to bewitching his neighbors. In early modern courts, confession was considered the queen of proofs. But those admissions were gathered after weeks and months of confinement in the dark, damp dungeons of Lancaster Castle.
SPEAKER_00When James Device appeared at the bar, court clerk Thomas Potts recorded that he was physically broken, trembling, and barely able to stand. While formal physical torture was illegal under English common law without a royal warrant, prolonged imprisonment, hunger, cold, and relentless interrogation exerted immense pressure. In a dark cellar, a confession becomes an act of physical collapse or a desperate hope for mercy rather than a statement of historical fact.
SPEAKER_00To the judges and jury, the case appeared formidable because several different voices seemed to tell the same story. Allison pointed to Chaddock, Chaddocks pointed to Demdike, James pointed to his mother, Janet pointed to everyone. On paper, it looked like independent confirmation coming from multiple angles. But in reality, the evidence was running in a tight, closed circle. All of these statements came from two impoverished feuding households and a handful of frightened neighbors living under the immediate shadow of the gallows.
SPEAKER_00The court wasn't hearing from detached observers. It was hearing accusations traded back and forth between bitter rivals trying to shift blame or extracted from family members desperate to survive. The magistrates heard an echo chamber, a small network of terrified people repeating and amplifying each other's words until rumor took on the weight of legal evidence. At the center of that echo chamber stood nine-year-old Janet Device.
SPEAKER_00Janet was the sole eyewitness used to place her mother, her brother, and her neighbors at the Malkin Tower meeting. But her position was profoundly isolated. She had seen her grandmother, her mother, and her sister carried away in irons, leaving her entirely dependent on the magistrates and neighbors investigating her family. While Thomas Potts recorded Janet's courtroom delivery in vivid detail, the surviving record preserves nothing of how she was questioned or prepared before taking the stand.
SPEAKER_00Growing up around her grandmother's hearth, Janet would have heard countless rural folktales of spirits, charms, and black dogs. Under repeated questioning by powerful adult authorities, those familiar stories were easily shaped into the precise demonic narrative the court was seeking. We have only the words that condemned her family. The private reality of how those words were formed remains out of reach. The same dynamic shaped the crown's central conspiracy claim, the Good Friday gathering at Mulkin Tower.
SPEAKER_00The prosecution argued that this gathering was an organized plot to blow up Lancaster Castle, murder the jailer, and liberate the prisoners. Yet the surviving record offers no evidence that the people gathered their possessed gunpowder, weapons, political allies, or any logistical plan to march 40 miles across rugged moors and storm a fortress. The gathering was far more likely an anxious meeting of family members sharing a meal in the midst of a sudden crisis, an unauthorized royal gathering magnified by judicial panic into treason.
SPEAKER_00That panic reached well beyond the device and Chaddock's families, drawing in Alice Nutter. Alice didn't fit the profile of the other defendants. She wasn't an impoverished village healer or a beggar living on the margins. She was a woman of wealth, land, and independent social standing. Unlike the other defendants, Alice didn't break under pressure. She gave no sensational confession. She named no familiar spirits, fashioned no clay poppets, and consistently maintained her innocence from the moment of her arrest to the foot of the gallows.
SPEAKER_00Virtually the only evidence against her was the claim that she had attended the Molkin Tower meeting, an allegation drawn primarily from the testimony of Janet and James Device. Why was a wealthy gentlewoman drawn into a net cast for impoverished village outcasts? Historians have pointed to several possibilities local boundary disputes over land, her family's covert Catholic sympathies in a fervently Protestant region, or long standing neighborhood grudges. The surviving record gives no definitive answer.
SPEAKER_00But what it reveals is striking. Once an investigation becomes convinced of a conspiracy, silence is treated with as much suspicion as a confession, and wealth offers no protection once fear takes over the legal process. Strip away the panic and the legal machinery, and the crown's theory of an organized murderous coven dissolves. What the historical record actually documents isn't a criminal conspiracy, but a tragic convergence, sudden medical misfortune, neighborhood rivalries, child testimony shaped by adult authority, and confessions exacted through prolonged imprisonment.
SPEAKER_00Under Roger Knoll and the Lancaster magistrates, suspicion was given the force of law, and fear was accepted as proof. When we step back from the depositions and trial transcripts, the contours of the Pendle case become clear. The historical record establishes that in 1612, ten people were convicted and executed for supernatural crimes that the surviving evidence can't independently verify. It establishes that their convictions rested on confessions made during imprisonment, the testimony of a nine-year-old child questioned behind closed doors, and the belief that sudden medical emergencies and traditional folk charms were deliberate acts of murder.
SPEAKER_00What remains unresolved and will remain unresolved forever are the private interior realities of the people involved. We can't know to what extent old ChadX or James Device believed in the magical powers they claimed to possess. We can't know whether Alice Snutter was targeted through local land disputes, religious prejudice, or circumstances the surviving record no longer preserves. And we can't know what went through the mind of nine-year-old Janet Device as she stood on that wooden table and watched her mother being led away to the gallows.
SPEAKER_00But the Pendle trial leaves us with a deeper, more enduring human question. What happens when fear becomes evidence? The tragedy of Pendle wasn't driven by obvious villains or corrupt judges acting in bad faith. Roger Knoll and Judge Bromley believed they were performing an urgent moral duty. They were educated religious men operating within the legal and intellectual framework of their time, standards endorsed by the king, the church, and the legal culture of their era. They genuinely believed that their community was under attack by invisible evil forces.
SPEAKER_00And that's precisely what makes the case so chilling. When a community is gripped by deep fear, the standard of proof doesn't just drop. It turns inside out. Suspicion stops being a hypothesis that must be tested. Instead, it becomes the lens through which every ordinary detail is reinterpreted as confirmation. In Pendle, a sudden stroke wasn't seen as a medical crisis. It was taken as proof of Alice and Device's malice.
SPEAKER_00A stolen sheep and a gathering of frightened relatives were not seen as signs of poverty and panic. They were treated as evidence of a criminal conspiracy. A child's stories about spirits and black dogs weren't treated as folklore. They became evidence for the crown of a demonic pact. Once fear enters the legal machinery of a society, the accused are trapped in a closed loop. If you confess, your confession validates the prosecution.
SPEAKER_00If you deny the charges, as Alice Nutter and Anne Redfern did, your silence is interpreted as the hardened defiance of the truly guilty. Family bonds collapse under the pressure of communal survival until a daughter condemns her mother and a sister points the finger at her brother. The people of Pendle didn't die because they were wicked. And they didn't die because their neighbors were unusually cruel. They died because fear had become an acceptable substitute for proof.
SPEAKER_00On July 28th, 2012, during the 400th anniversary of the trials, a new figure appeared in the Lancashire village of Roughly. Sculpted by local artist David Palmer from brass and steel, it was placed beside a narrow country road framed by dry stone walls and the green rise of the surrounding pasture. The sculpture depicts a woman in 17th-century dress, her face turned toward the high, sweeping ridge of Pendle Hill. Her name was Alice Nutter.
SPEAKER_00In the summer of 1612, the legal system stripped Alice of her land, her standing, and her life. In the surviving trial account, she was reduced to ink on paper, an alleged conspirator at Malkin Tower whose refusal to confess didn't save her. She was taken from this valley in irons, led across the moors to the damp dungeons of Lancaster Castle, and hanged on the hill overlooking the city. Four centuries later, she was brought back.
SPEAKER_00The statue doesn't resolve the unanswered questions of her arrest. It can't confirm whether her downfall began with local boundary disputes, religious suspicions over covert Catholic sympathies, or neighborhood grudges that left no trace in the depositions. It offers no formal exoneration and it can't undo the verdict rendered in an early modern courtroom. What it does do is shift the geography of the case. For centuries, the story of Pendle moved in only one direction, away from these quiet valleys along the road that carried the accused to imprisonment in the gallows.
SPEAKER_00But today, the metal catches the changing northern light beneath the shadow of the hill, anchoring the memory of the trials not to the castle where they died, but to the landscape where they lived. Alice Nutter is no longer merely an entry in a clerk's record of witchcraft. She's a woman remembered by name in the place where she lived. Once the road led only to Lancaster. Now it leads back to her.com.
SPEAKER_00Coming up on our season three finale next week, Isabel Gowdy. In 1662, in the Scottish parish of Aldern, Isabel Gowdy offered four of the most extraordinary witch confessions on record, weaving accounts of the devil, the queen of fairies, shape-shifting, folk charms, and secret gatherings. But with no surviving evidence of physical torture, the case confronts a haunting question. Why did Isabel Gowdy speak? And what truth was her testimony trying to preserve?
SPEAKER_00Following our season finale, folklore forensics will return in January with a new season investigating familiar fairy tales. Until then, remember, you may have heard the story. Perhaps it's time to hear the case.
Four confessions. A woman who claimed to fly, transform into a hare, and feast with the Queen of Fairies. And a historical record that ends before revealing her fate. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. In 1662,...
In the hills outside Leicester, children were disappearing. The villagers knew who was responsible. Black Annis. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. According to English folklore, she was a blue-faced hag with...
A young man disappears from a riverboat after dark. His lantern is still warm. His coat remains folded on the bench. And in the bottom of the boat, investigators discover a woman's carved horn comb. The villagers...
A servant boy stole three drops of divine wisdom from a Welsh sorceress. She hunted him across land, water, and sky and when she finally caught him, she swallowed him whole. You've heard the story. Now hear the case....
Morgan le Fay poisoned kings, kidnapped knights, stole Excalibur's scabbard, and plotted the destruction of Camelot. At least, that's what the prosecution says. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. Arthurian...