Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Folklore Forensics

Folklore Forensics artwork

The Hansel & Gretel Witch-Killing : The Crime Behind the Fairy Tale

Sep 22, 202632 minAudio

Two starving children walked out of a forest carrying a dead woman's food, money, and wedding ring. The story says they escaped a witch. The evidence is much less certain. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. This week, Folklore Forensics reopens one of the most famous cases in European folklore. Two children are abandoned in a German forest. Days later, they emerge barefoot and burned, carrying food, silver, and a dead woman's wedding ring. Behind them is an isolated cottage, a cold oven, and the body of the woman they claim intended to eat them. But the surviving evidence complicates the fairy tale. Was the woman in the woods really a predator? Did two terrified children kill her in self-defense? Or did famine, abandonment, and desperation turn a violent encounter into a story about an evil witch? Through folklore, fairy tales, history, witness testimony, and forensic reconstruction, we investigate the possible crime behind Hansel and Gretel, and ask why a starving community might have needed the witch to be guilty. Folklore Forensics reopens myths, legends, and folklore as historical criminal cases. Listener discretion is advised. Written and hosted by Danielle Christmas and produced by Audio Ellis. Follow / subscribe for weekly storytelling investigations. Follow the show on Instagram @folkloreforensics Case suggestions and research inquiries: folkloreforensicspod@gmail.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00At dawn, in the bitter depths of a famine winter, Jacob Reiner found the children above the mill path outside Linkirk. They were standing at the forest edge where the frozen timber of the Robinwald gave way to the village track. The boy was carrying a heavy burlap sack that dragged through the crust of snow. The girl had severe weeping burns across both palms, and the sour reek of charred wood and scorched wool clung to their torn smocks. They were barefoot, emaciated, and shaking violently in the cold.

SPEAKER_00When Reiner asked where they had been and what had happened to the old woman living alone at the isolated forest holding of Askenbrook, the boy stated plainly that she was dead inside her burned bake house. The girl said nothing at all. Inside the sack was enough food to feed a family for weeks: smoked bacon, flour, 20 silver coins, and a woman's silver gilt ring wrapped neatly in a scrap of linen. In a district where families were starving, it was an impossible amount of wealth.

SPEAKER_00By nightfall, the village had already begun turning the morning's discovery into a story of miraculous survival. The children had been stolen by a witch. They had suffered in a dark wood. They had destroyed a monster and escaped. But the earliest administrative record preserves a simpler, far more disturbing scene. Two desperate children emerging from the woods with the life savings of an isolated woman who was no longer alive to dispute their account.

SPEAKER_00Folklore would eventually give us a house made of bread, a woman who ate children, and an oven where danger was cleanly answered. But before it became a fairy tale, it was a crime scene. And the only witnesses were the children who walked away with the silver. I'm Danielle Christmas, and this is Folklore Forensics.

SPEAKER_00Two children, a brother and sister, are taken deep into a forest by parents who can no longer feed them and left there. They wander hungry and afraid until they find a cottage built in the version we all grew up with, from bread and cake and sugar paned windows, an impossible edible house in the middle of starvation. An old woman invites them in. She feeds them. And then she reveals herself as something else entirely.

SPEAKER_00A woman who fattens children in order to eat them. The boy is caged. The girl is put to work. And in the story's most famous act of reversal, it is the girl, small, frightened, presumed powerless, who pushes the woman into her own oven and ends her. The children escape with treasure. They find their way home. The story ends as fairy tales do, with a door closing on the horror behind them. What's interesting if you trace this story across the many regional versions collected from oral tradition in the German countryside, is how much of it changes and how much doesn't.

SPEAKER_00The names shift, sometimes it's a stepmother urging the abandonment, sometimes a birth mother driven to it by hunger. Sometimes there's a bird that leads them further into the woods instead of home. The house is sometimes bread, sometimes cake, sometimes simply sweet. These are the decorative details, the parts a story picks up and sets down again as it travels from one telling to the next, one household to the next, shaped by whoever is telling it and why.

SPEAKER_00But three things almost never change. Two children abandoned because there isn't enough food, a woman alone living deep in the forest, and an oven at the center of the story where the danger is finally answered. That kind of consistency is what makes an investigator take a folk tale seriously as evidence rather than dismissing it as invention. When the decoration changes but the frame holds, something underneath it usually did happen, not necessarily the way the story tells it, but something real enough that a community felt compelled to keep explaining it to itself, generation after generation.

SPEAKER_00What this story can't tell us, because it was never built to, is what actually happened inside that cottage before the oven door closed. It can't tell us whether the woman who died there was a predator interrupted mid-crime, or a solitary woman who caught two children stealing from her failing food stores and paid for it with her life. It can't tell us whether which was a word invented to describe something monstrous or a word too frightened children reached for because it was the only shape available to explain what they had done and survived.

SPEAKER_00The known story gives us a beginning, a house, and an ending. It does not give us a crime scene. So let's go back, back before the oven, back before the cottage made of bread and sugar, back before the children entered the forest, back to a winter when hunger began changing the rules people lived by. To understand what happened in that forest, you have to understand what hunger does to the geography of a village.

SPEAKER_00The winter in question fell during a prolonged subsistence crisis in the forested inland districts of central Germany. An unseasonable frost in late May blackened the rye before it could head, followed by months of unrelenting rain that rotted the winter spelt in the ground. By midwinter, communal grain stores in the village of Lindkirk were exhausted and barley prices had climbed beyond the reach of day laborers. And Lindkirk's survival became a physical degradation.

SPEAKER_00Families stripped the inner bark from birch trees to grind into meal, boiled turnip pairings and dried elderberry stems and steeped leather scraps in salt water. In the parish memorandum book kept by Pastor Ambrosius Kell, burials climbed from a seasonal average of four or five to more than forty. Kell noted that he had ceased ringing the funeral bell because the sound demoralized the living and because the church wardens could no longer spare tallow for the bell ringer's lantern.

SPEAKER_00In a village stripped to that bone, the young and the landless were the first to feel the margins close. Parish records from the district show that child abandonment during severe famines was an open, desperate practice tolerated through communal silence. A struggling household did not announce its intentions. A father walked his children past the pasture gates into the timber of the Robinwald, telling them to search for windfall pine nuts or wait until he returned. If the children died of exposure, the forest took the blame.

SPEAKER_00If they survived, the household had fewer mouths to feed. That was the world that produced Hans and Margareta Vogler. Hans was ten years old. His sister Margareta, recorded in Pastor Kell's later notes under the diminutive Gretchen, was around eight. Their father, Nicol Vogler, was a saw pit laborer whose work had vanished with the frost. His first wife had died two winters earlier of a lung rot, and his second wife, 24-year-old Barbara, had buried an infant of her own before the ground thawed.

SPEAKER_00In the folklore, the stepmother is pure theatrical venom. But the surviving record points to a simpler, colder reality. The household was out of food. According to a brief statement collected later from a neighbor, Elsa Hummel, the Voglers had sold their copper kettle, spinning wheel, and blankets by December. By mid-January, their chimney had stayed cold for three days. Barbara had half a loaf of moldering bran bread left, a husband coughing blood, and two children she could no longer feed.

SPEAKER_00The decision to take Hans and Margareta into the Robinwald was the end point of that exhaustion. The children remembered their father leading them past the high ridge, giving each a piece of hard rye crust and telling them to wait beside a felled fir while he notched timber deeper in the woods. He hung an axe handle from a dead branch so the wind would knock it against the trunk, a hollow clack, clack that sounded like the steady swing of work. They waited until dusk.

SPEAKER_00When the wind dropped and the sound stopped, the forest was empty. Hans and Margareta wandered for two days along the frozen course of the Schwarzwasser brook, sleeping under limestone overhangs and eating fur needles and frozen lichen. On the third morning they broke through scrub pine into a clearing called Oskinbrook. Oskinbrook was an isolated holding consisting of an oak and daub dwelling, a timber store shed, and a detached stone bake house with a domed masonry oven.

SPEAKER_00And suspended from linden cords beneath the eaves of the main house hung rows of dried provisions, apple rings, plaited rye biscuits, twists of pork fat, and round honey cakes baked hard as tile. The later folk tale transformed this into walls of bread and windows of sugar, but in isolated forest homesteads, hanging preserved food beneath a thatch overhang was standard practice to keep winter provisions dry and out of reach of rodents. To two starving children stumbling from the timber, it was a house made of food.

SPEAKER_00The woman who lived at Oskinbrook was Agatha Brenner. A widow in her early 60s, Brenner had lived alone at the holding for twelve years following the death of her husband, a lime burner. In Linkirk's parish letters, she was largely an absence. She paid her modest ground rent in beeswax and dried herbs, rarely attended church, and maintained an orchard, bee scaps, and a sheltered garden plot. In ordinary years, the village treated her with cautious respect as a healer who set bones and traded honey for salt.

SPEAKER_00But during a famine, self-sufficiency looked unnatural. While village families starved, Brenner's storehouse held dried legumes in sealed jars, grain banked in dry ashes, and rendered lard. When the children reached her eaves and began tearing down the frozen cakes, the noise drew Brenner to the threshold. What followed in that doorway is where the record fractures. In the children's account, Brenner was a predator. She welcomed them with warm milk, dried fruit, and fried cakes, gave them straw beds by the hearth, and revealed her intentions the following morning.

SPEAKER_00According to Pastor Kell's deposition, the children claimed Brenner locked Hans inside an unheated lean to shed to fatten him on grain mash, while Margarita was set to hauling water and stoking the bakehouse oven. Every morning, the woman demanded Hans thrust a finger through a knothole to test his weight, and every morning the boy tricked her failing eyesight by holding out a dry chicken bone. It's an iconic image, but it is also the point where trauma, folklore, and defense blur together.

SPEAKER_00Consider the domestic reality. An elderly widow living alone finds two starving feral children tearing food from her roof. She brings them in and feeds them. Within 48 hours, she realizes that two extra mouths will exhaust her winter stores before the thaw. Under those conditions, locking a panicked 10-year-old boy in a pantry shed may not have been preparation for slaughter, but a desperate measure to protect the remaining grain from being raided. Setting Margareta to hull water was the ordinary labor expected of any child taken into a rural homestead.

SPEAKER_00And an old woman with cataracts feeling a child's outstretched hand through a plank slit in the dim morning light was not grating meat. She was checking whether a freezing boy in an unheated outbuilding was still alive. Whatever occurred over those four days, the climax came at the bakehouse. The stone outbuilding housed a heaven masonry bread oven that required hours of furring with beechwood until the brick floor was white hot, at which point the embers were raked and the loaves slid inside.

SPEAKER_00According to the children, Brennard ordered Margareta to crawl onto the wooden peel inside the oven to check the heat. The girl feigned ignorance, and when the old woman leaned forward to demonstrate, Margareta gave a desperate shove, dropped the iron bar into the latch, and fled. That was the children's testimony. The physical scene recorded days later told a more chaotic picture. When Jacob Reiner and the men from Linkirk reached Oskinbrook, the bake house was cold.

SPEAKER_00The heavy iron door was barred, and inside the ashlight Agatha Brenner's remains. Inside the main house, furniture was overturned. A three-legged stool splintered against the wall, an iron ash shovel lying near the threshold, and a shattered crock of dried beans spilled across the floor. Margarita Vogler's hands bore another piece of evidence. When Reiner found her on the path, her palms and forearms were covered in severe second degree burns, injuries consistent with direct, frantic contact with hot irons or glowing coals.

SPEAKER_00And across Hans Vogler's shoulder was a sack. Inside were two loaves of rye bread, a slab of fat back, a tin box containing thirty-two silver gross skin and four copper fennings, and a silver gilt wedding band. The children had not simply fled. They had searched the dwelling, emptied the larder, found the woman's hidden money, and walked out carrying everything of value the holding possessed. When they emerged from the trees, Linkirk didn't investigate whether an old woman had been robbed and killed by two desperate children.

SPEAKER_00They saw Margarita's burned skin, Hans's hollow frame, and heard Pastor Kell declare that the Lord had preserved two lambs from a demon of the forest. In a winter, when half the parish had contemplated abandoning their own children, the story of a cannibalistic witch was far easier to carry than the truth. For the village of Lindkirk, the case should have ended the morning Jacob Reiner brought the children down from the forest. The children were back.

SPEAKER_00The dead woman was buried in unhallowed ground outside the churchyard. Pastor Ambrosius Kell had already entered the incident into his parish memorandum as a miraculous deliverance, a testament to Christian innocence preserved against a forest demon. In a community exhausted by months of starvation, there was an overwhelming desire to seal the story, distribute the dead woman's confiscated larder among the poorest households, and look away. Looking away was easy. Looking closer meant asking questions no one in Linkirk wanted to answer.

SPEAKER_00The formal record of what happened at Oskinbrook exists only because of a magistrate named Syriacus Lenz. Lenz arrived in the district in late March when the snow had turned to gray slush and the territorial bailiff ordered an administrative audit of all irregular deaths that had occurred during the famine winter. Lens was an imperial civil investigator. Over 12 days, he convened a court of inquiry in the parish tithe barn, taking sworn depositions from every person who had handled the scene, the children or the dead woman's property.

SPEAKER_00The surviving bundle of seven depositions he assembled is the closest we will ever get to an adversarial examination of the case. And from the first deposition, the coherent story of heroic survival begins to unravel. Lenz started with Jacob Reiner, the sorrier who had first intercepted the children. Reiner's initial report to the pastor had emphasized the children's pitiful state, their torn smocks and shivering limbs. But under Lenz's questioning, Reiner added details that sat uncomfortably beside the image of two helpless victims fleeing in blind terror.

SPEAKER_00He noted that Hans, despite his emaciation, was watchful and composed. When Reiner offered to carry the sack, the boy refused to surrender it, stating plainly that he had bread, bacon, and silver. Most telling was the silver gilt wedding band. It had not been swept up in a panicked rush from a tabletop. It was wrapped carefully in a clean scrap of linen and tucked into the bottom of the tin box. A child running for his life from a cannibal doesn't pause to wrap an old woman's keepsake in linen before fleeing into the snow.

SPEAKER_00The testimony of the second witness, Elsa Hummel, challenged the narrative from the opposite direction. Hummel was one of the few villagers who had traded regularly with Agatha Brennard before the famine. When Zlenz asked whether Agatha had ever exhibited cruelty or threatened children, Hummel hesitated. She testified that Agatha was sharp-tongued and guarded her property, but she had never known her to harm anyone. When Hummel's second son had been sick with the croup three summers earlier, Agatha had walked two miles to bring her dried colt's foot in time without asking for payment.

SPEAKER_00Then Hummel offered the court a rumor. Six years before the famine, a swineherd's daughter had vanished near the western ridge of the Robinwald, and villagers had whispered that the woman at Oskinbrook had taken her. Lynch checked the parish rolls of the neighboring district. He found the girl's name immediately. Her body had been recovered from a mill race four miles south three days after her disappearance, and the coroner had ruled it an accidental drowning. The rumor had not existed when the girl died.

SPEAKER_00It had been manufactured in hindsight to give the community's fear of an isolated woman an ancient, plausible pedigree. When Lens turned to the children, the discrepancies deepened. Pastor Ambrosius Kell had questioned Hans and Margareta four separate times before the magistrate arrived. In Kell's earliest notes, Hans' account was chaotic. He spoke of an old woman who shouted at them for stealing her dried apples, a dark shed with an iron bolt, and a fire that got out of hand in the bakehouse.

SPEAKER_00There was no mention of a cage. There was no mention of a chicken bone. There was no mention of the woman intending to eat them. Those details appeared only in the third and fourth depositions, after Pastor Kell had spent days praying with the children and asking whether the woman had displayed the abominable hungers of the forest. By the time Syriacus Lenz interviewed Hans, the boy had adopted the pastor's vocabulary, describing the fattening stall and the oven trap with practiced fluency.

SPEAKER_00Margareta's interview told a very different story. The eight-year-old girl was sullen, frightened, and barely audible. When Lens asked her to describe the cage where her brother was kept, she couldn't answer. When he asked about the chicken bones, she began to weep and said Hans had told her not to talk about the shed. When asked how the fire started, she held out her bandaged hands and gave the magistrate a single sentence that Lens entered verbatim into the ledger. The woman was screaming and the iron was hot, and Hans told me to hold the bar.

SPEAKER_00That is not the testimony of a clever child outsmarting a witch. That's the testimony of a terrified younger sibling who participated in a violent struggle at the direction of her brother. And then Lenz's record reveals the most glaring contradiction in the inquiry. The crime the court chose not to investigate. On the fifth day, Nicol Vogler appeared before the court. He was not brought in chains or questioned under caution for leading his children into the timber and abandoning them to die.

SPEAKER_00Instead, Mr. Vogler appeared as a petitioner, demanding that the silver and bacon his children had carried out of the forest be released from administrative custody and returned to his household. Lenz recorded no charges. He noted simply that the father had acted, quote, under the grievous extremity of the common dearth, and awarded 12 silver to the Vogler household to prevent further parish dependency. The legal system had no difficulty imagining an isolated woman as a monster who deserved to burn in her own oven.

SPEAKER_00But it couldn't afford to prosecute a father for abandonment, because prosecuting Nicol Vogler meant indicting half the starving families in the district who had contemplated the same desperate act. When we assemble the depositions, the physical evidence supports a violent encounter, severe burns, a fatal fire, and the systematic looting of an isolated holding. What it can't establish is the intent behind them. Did Agatha Brenner attempt to slaughter the children, or did she lock a feral boy in a pantry to protect her dwindling grain before a struggle at the oven turned fatal?

SPEAKER_00Did the children break in, panic when Confronted and trap the homeowner inside? Or did Brenner collapse while firing her oven, leaving two starving children to plunder the holding and invent a monster to explain the coins in their hands? Syriacis Lenz never chose between these possibilities. On the final page of his memorandum, he recorded only that the woman was dead, the property dispersed, and the famine lifting. He closed the file and returned to the district seat.

SPEAKER_00The case remains open because every surviving voice had a reason to distort what happened. The children needed to justify a killing. The father needed to conceal an abandonment. The pastor needed a demon to prove divine grace. And the village needed a witch so they would never have to look at what they had done to survive. So where does the investigation ultimately land? The strongest reconstruction is also the least comfortable.

SPEAKER_00A winter of catastrophic famine pushed an impoverished woodcutter and his family past the breaking point. Two children were led into the Robinwald and deliberately abandoned. Wandering through deep snow, they reached Oskinbrook, an isolated holding where a solitary widow had managed through years of thrift and forest knowledge to preserve enough grain, lard, and dried fruit to outlast the season. What followed was not a fairy tale. It was an encounter governed by panic, starvation, and mutual terror.

SPEAKER_00Whether Agatha Brenner locked a starving boy in a pantry shed to protect the food keeping her alive, or whether two feral children broke into her bake house and were met with an iron ash shovel, the confrontation ended in violence. An oven door shut, a fire caught, an older woman died inside her own hearth, and two children walked back out of the woods carrying what she left behind. The surviving evidence doesn't support the candy walls, the fattening stall, or the bone held through the bars, but it does suggest that the folklore was anchored to an event the valley could neither fully confront nor entirely forget.

SPEAKER_00Two abandoned children, a winter forest, an isolated dwelling with dried food hanging from its eaves, a masonry oven, a violent death, a sack of silver and a wrapped wedding band. And yet, when I finished reviewing the deposition Syriacus Lens left behind, I realized that the forensic reconstruction of the big house wasn't the part of the file that stayed with me. The question that kept pulling me back was wider than Askenbrook.

SPEAKER_00I keep returning to that sack of 32 silver and that gilt ring wrapped in its scrap of clean linen. In the fairy tale we inherited, that sack is called treasure, the storybook proof that virtue is rewarded and that innocent children will always triumph over evil. But stripped of that romantic gloss, it's something much heavier. It's the material proof of a practical, desperate transaction. Two children trembling with shock, with Margarita's hands raw and blistering from the hot iron, took the time to open a dead woman's tin chest and take what could be spent before they ran.

SPEAKER_00It's tempting to look at that detail and ask what kind of children could do such a thing. But that question misses the reality of the famine. Hans and Margareta were not calculating thieves. They were children who had learned in the most brutal way imaginable that the world does not feed you simply because you are young. They took the silver because hunger had taught them that survival is unsentimental. The real discomfort of this case doesn't lie in what two traumatized children did in a smoke-filled bakehouse.

SPEAKER_00It lies in what happened when they brought that sack back to Lindkirk. Because responsibility in this record refuses to stay contained inside the forest. If Agatha Brenner was a victim, who made her one? The two starving children who fought her for bread? Or the father who tied an axe handle to a tree and left his son and daughter to freeze in the timber? What about Nickel Vogler who walked into the parish tithe barn not in chains for abandoning his children, but as a petitioner demanding the court hand over the dead widow's silver so his household could buy grain?

SPEAKER_00What about Pastor Kell, who heard Hans describe a chaotic fire and deliberately fed the boy theological language about cages, cannibalism, and forest demons until the child's testimony mirrored the expectations of the pulpit? And what about Magistrate Lenz and the territorial court who dismissed child abandonment as the common misfortune of a hard winter, took their administrative cut of the dead woman's estate and closed the file. The closer you look at Lindkirk, the more impossible it becomes to find a single villain.

SPEAKER_00Famine is not an individual crime, it's an institutional collapse. It corrodes families, dissolves neighborly obligation, and forces ordinary people to make peace with choices they could never justify in daylight. And that is why the community needed the witch. Because monsters offer clarity. Monsters give collective guilt a single convenient face. If Agatha Brenner was an unnatural demon who lured children into the woods to eat them, then Nickel Vogler was not a father who abandoned his children.

SPEAKER_00He was an unfortunate victim of a dark season. If the old woman was a monster, then the village of Linkirk had not failed its most vulnerable. It had been miraculously delivered from evil. The legend didn't survive because generations of children believed in gingerbread roofs. It survived because it offered an entire community moral absolution. It took a catastrophe of social failure, abandoned orphans, neglected elders, communal cowardice, and violent theft, and transformed it into a clean, simple story about an evil woman in the woods.

SPEAKER_00And perhaps that is the enduring question this case leaves behind. Not whether Hans and Margareta acted in self-defense, but who gets to remain innocent when an entire community survives by looking away? When starvation strips away every moral luxury, survival itself becomes a kind of complicity. The children survived by taking a dead woman's food. The father survived by claiming his children's spoils. The pastor survived by creating a demon to preach against.

SPEAKER_00And the village survived by turning their solitary neighbor into a fiend so they would never have to examine their own silence. Long after the historical record falls quiet, those stories often become the only evidence that an unbearable winter ever happened. And sometimes memory survives in forms even quieter than folklore. Sometimes it lingers in the domestic habits we pass down without thinking, in the bread we bake, the eaves we adorn, in the ancient rituals meant to keep the hunger at the forest's edge from finding its way back inside.

SPEAKER_00Three generations after the smoke stopped rising above that cottage, a school teacher in a nearby village began collecting stories from the oldest residents of the district, worried that the old tellings were dying out along with the people who remembered them firsthand. Among the fragments she gathered, recipes, weather rhymes, half-remembered songs, was a small, specific custom still practiced by a handful of households well into her own lifetime. Every winter, on the shortest days of the year, certain families in that district baked small loaves shaped like houses.

SPEAKER_00Modest things, unglazed plain bread rather than anything resembling cake or sugar. Children were given the task of hanging them, one at each corner of the house, along the outer eaves. The same gesture, unmistakably, that the old custom of feeding the eaves against hunger had always required. The teacher asked one old woman why the loaves were shaped that way, specifically like houses, and not simply left as ordinary bread. The woman didn't have a folklore's answer for her.

SPEAKER_00She only said that it was how her grandmother had always shaped them, and that her grandmother had told her once, without much explanation, that a house made of bread was safer than a house made of anything else. Because hunger, she'd said, could never bring itself to burn the thing it needed most. The teacher wrote the line down and moved on to the next household. Somewhere in that district, if the custom survived long enough, a child too young to know why is still shaping dough into the corners of a roof, pressing a small window into the side with her thumb, and setting it out along the eaves before the snow comes.

SPEAKER_00Folklore Forensics is written and hosted by me and produced by Audio Ellis. You can find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Follow Folklore Forensics on Instagram at Folklore Forensics. Future case suggestions can be sent to Folklore Forensics Pod at gmail.com. Next week, Lilith. Dozens of medieval Jewish communities, hundreds of infants dead in their cradles, and the surviving fragments of testimony that may explain why.

SPEAKER_00How did generations of grieving families come to lay their sorrow at the feet of a single biblical woman? Until then, remember, you may have heard the story. Perhaps it's time to hear the case.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Isobel Gowdie Confessions: The Scottish Witch Who Vanished from History

    Nov 17, 202631 minAudio

    Four confessions. A woman who claimed to fly, transform into a hare, and feast with the Queen of Fairies. And a historical record that ends before revealing her fate. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. In 1662,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Pendle Witch Trials: The Child Who Sent Her Family to the Gallows

    Nov 10, 202630 minAudio

    Lancaster Castle. August 1612. A nine-year-old girl is lifted onto a table before a crowded courtroom. Her name is Jennet Device. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. Standing before the judges, Jennet accuses her...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Black Annis Mystery: The Child-Stealing Hag of English Folklore

    Nov 3, 202628 minAudio

    In the hills outside Leicester, children were disappearing. The villagers knew who was responsible. Black Annis. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. According to English folklore, she was a blue-faced hag with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Rusalka Haunting: The Deadly Secret Beneath a Slavic Legend

    Oct 27, 202634 minAudio

    A young man disappears from a riverboat after dark. His lantern is still warm. His coat remains folded on the bench. And in the bottom of the boat, investigators discover a woman's carved horn comb. The villagers...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Cerridwen Manhunt: The Stolen Wisdom and Deadly Chase of Welsh Mythology

    Oct 20, 202637 minAudio

    A servant boy stole three drops of divine wisdom from a Welsh sorceress. She hunted him across land, water, and sky and when she finally caught him, she swallowed him whole. You've heard the story. Now hear the case....

    Credit the people on this episode