A nobleman with a blue-tinted beard. Four wives vanished. A locked chamber at the end of a corridor - and a final bride who opens the door. In this first investigation, Folklore Forensics revisits the story of Bluebeard as a cold case - reconstructing timelines, centering the victims, examining motive, and analyzing the evidence hidden within the folktale. Content warning: themes of domestic violence, murder, and disturbing imagery. Listener discretion advised. Folklore Forensics presents narrative reconstructions inspired by myth, legend, and historical context, examined through an investigative lens. Folklore Forensics reopens myths, legends, and folklore as historical criminal cases. Listener discretion is advised. Written and hosted by Danielle Christmas and produced by Audio Ellis. Follow / subscribe for weekly storytelling investigations. Follow the show on Instagram @folkloreforensics Case suggestions and research inquiries: folkloreforensicspod@gmail.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The key was still warm in her hand when Marie Catherine Deschamps pushed open the door to the chamber at the end of the east corridor. It was October 17, 1595. The chateau was silent except for the sound of her own breathing and the whisper of her silk skirts against the cold stone floor. Her husband, Charles Antoine Duray, had left a few days ago, traveling to Paris on business. He'd be gone for two weeks, maybe three, and he'd given her explicit instructions.
SPEAKER_00You may go anywhere in the chateau, my darling wife, he'd told her, pressing a ring of iron keys into her palm. Anywhere at all, except this one room. He'd pointed to the smallest key, tarnished and old. This chamber must remain locked. Do you understand? It is the only thing I ask of you. She'd promised, of course she'd promised, but that was before she'd found the letter hidden in his study, before she'd learned the names.
SPEAKER_00Marguerite, Jeanne, Elizabeth, Anne-Marie. Wives, four wives before her, all of them gone. The smell hit her first, copper and rod and something else, something sweet and terrible that made her stomach turn. The chamber was dark, lit only by the gray October light filtering through a single narrow window. And then she saw them. Hanging from hooks on the walls, four women, four bodies in various states of decay.
SPEAKER_00Their fine dresses, wedding dresses, she realized with horror, stained dark with blood, their faces frozen in final moments of terror. Marie Catherine's scream echoed through the chateau, with only her sister there to hear her.
SPEAKER_00So let me explain what we're doing here because this is a little different from your typical true crime podcast. We've all grown up with fairy tales, right? Folklore, legends, myths, stories that have been passed down for generations, stories we think of as fiction, as cautionary tales, as entertainment. But here's the thing that's always fascinated me. What if they weren't just stories? What if these tales, these dark, twisted narratives about monsters and murderers?
SPEAKER_00What if they were based on something real? What if they were the true crime cases of their time, passed down through oral tradition until they became legend? That's what folklore forensics is all about. Each episode, we're going to take a famous folk tale, myth, or legend and investigate it as if it were a real criminal case. We'll look at the evidence, examine the victims, profile the perpetrators, and try to understand not just what happened, but why these stories have survived for centuries.
SPEAKER_00And for our first case, I knew exactly where I wanted to start, with one of the most chilling tales in the folklore canon, the story of Bluebeard. Before we get started, I need to give you a content warning. This episode contains disturbing material. Listener discretion is advised. Now, if you're not familiar with the tale, here's the basic version. A wealthy nobleman with a strange blue-tinted beard marries a series of young women. Each wife mysteriously disappears.
SPEAKER_00When he marries again, he gives his new bride the keys to his castle, but forbids her from entering one particular room. Of course, curiosity gets the better of her, and she discovers the bodies of all his previous wives hanging in that forbidden chamber. It's a story that's been told and retold since it was first published by Charles Perot in 1697. But Perrault didn't invent this story. He was recording something that was already part of French folklore.
SPEAKER_00And the more I dug into this case, the more I became convinced that this wasn't just a cautionary tale about female curiosity or disobedience. This was a record of real crimes, serial murders that took place in 17th century France. So today we're going to investigate what I'm calling the Bluebeard serial killings, case file number 247. And I have to warn you, this one is dark. We're talking about a serial killer who used his wealth, his title, and the patriarchal structures of his time to prey on vulnerable women.
SPEAKER_00We're talking about at least four confirmed victims, possibly more, and we're talking about crimes that went undetected for years because of who he was and the power he held. But we're also going to talk about the women who survived him, the women who fought back, and the final victim who brought him to justice. So let's dive in. Our perpetrator's name was Charles Antoine De, born in 1561 in the Brittany region of France, specifically in the town of Tiffauges, about 50 miles south of Nantes.
SPEAKER_00And yes, before you ask, he was distantly related to the infamous Gilles de Rey, the 15th century nobleman who was executed for the serial murders of children. Charles Antoine came from old money. We're talking about a family that had held their titles since the 1300s. His father, Jean-Baptiste de Rey, was a baron who owned several chateaux throughout Brittany in Pays de la Loire. When Jean Baptiste died in 1585, Charles Antoine inherited everything the title, the estates, the wealth.
SPEAKER_00He was just 24 years old. By all accounts, Charles Antoine was an educated man. He'd studied at the University of Paris, spoke Latin and Italian in addition to French, collected books and art. He was known for hosting elaborate parties at his various estates. He was, on paper, an excellent match for any young woman of good family. But there was something off about him, something that made people uncomfortable. First, there was his appearance.
SPEAKER_00Multiple contemporary accounts describe his beard as having a strange blue-black tint to it. Some historians have suggested this was due to the lighting in his chateau or the way his very dark beard caught the light. Others have theorized he may have used some kind of dye or oil that gave his beard this unusual color. Whatever the cause, it earned him a nickname among the local population. Barb Ble, Bluebeard. But it wasn't just his appearance. There was something about his demeanor that people found unsettling, a coldness in his eyes, a way of looking at women that made them uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_00Several accounts from servants and visitors describe him as having dead eyes or a predatory gaze. And then there were the wives. Charles Antoine married for the first time in 1587, two years after inheriting his father's estate. His bride was Marguerite de Ponchateau, the 19-year-old daughter of a minor nobleman from Nantes. It was considered a good match, Marguerite's family was respectable, if not particularly wealthy, and Charles Antoine's title and fortune made him an attractive prospect.
SPEAKER_00The wedding took place in June of 1587 at the Chateau de Tiffauges, Charles Antoine's primary residence. By all accounts it was a lavish affair. But here's where things get strange. Within six months of the wedding, Marguerite had vanished. Charles Antoine's explanation? She died of a fever and been buried quickly to prevent contagion. He claimed to be devastated, he wore black for the appropriate mourning period, and then, less than a year after Marguerite's supposed death, he remarried.
SPEAKER_00His second wife was Jeanne de Brisac, 21 years old from a family of merchants in Angers who had recently been granted minor nobility. They married in April of 1589, and just like Marguerite, Jeanne disappeared within months. This time, Charles Antoine claimed she died in childbirth along with the baby. Again, he said the burial had been immediate and private due to the tragic circumstances. Are you getting chills yet? Because I am.
SPEAKER_00This is a pattern, right? This is textbook serial killer behavior. But here's the thing, in late 16th century France, no one was connecting these dots. Women died in childbirth all the time. Fevers were common and often fatal, and Charles Antoine Derey was a baron, a man of wealth and standing. Who was going to question his word? His third marriage took place in 1591 to Elizabeth Mercier, the eighteen year old daughter of a wealthy textile merchant from Tours. Elizabeth's family was thrilled with the match.
SPEAKER_00Their daughter was marrying into the nobility. The wedding was even more elaborate than the previous two, held at Charlantoine's chateau in Chamtous sur Loire. Elizabeth lasted longer than the others, almost a full year, but in the spring of 1592, she too disappeared. This time, Charles Antoine claimed she'd been thrown from a horse and killed instantly. Once again, the burial was private and immediate. Now, Elizabeth's father, Guillaume Mercier, was apparently suspicious.
SPEAKER_00There are records of him writing letters to local authorities demanding to see his daughter's grave, asking questions about the circumstances of her death. But Charles Antoine was a baron, and Guillaume was a merchant, even a wealthy one. The social hierarchy of the time meant that Guillaume's concerns were dismissed. Charles Antoine's word was considered beyond question. The fourth wife was Anne Marie Dubois, 20 years old from a family of minor nobility in Rennes. They married in 1593, and just like the others, Anne Marie vanished within months.
SPEAKER_00This time Charles Antoine claimed she'd taken ill with a wasting disease and died slowly over several weeks. He said he'd been so distraught watching her suffer that he'd had her buried immediately after her death, unable to bear the sight of her any longer. Four wives, four deaths, four quick private burials with no witnesses, no graves that family members could visit, no bodies that anyone outside of Charles Antoine's household ever saw. And then, in 1595, he married for the fifth time.
SPEAKER_00Before we go any further, I want to take a moment to talk about the victims, because that's what these women were. Victims, not characters in a fairy tale, not cautionary examples, but real people with real lives who were targeted, manipulated, and murdered. Let's start with Marguerite de Ponchateau. She was 19 when she married Charles Antoine. The youngest of four daughters, Marguerite had been educated at home by a governess. She could read and write, which was relatively uncommon for women of her class at the time.
SPEAKER_00She loved music. Several letters from her older sister mention Marguerite's skill at the pianoforte. Her family's estate was struggling financially, which is likely why they were so eager to marry her off to Charles Antoine. In the letters that survived from the period before her wedding, Marguerite sounds excited but nervous. She writes to her sister about the chateau, about Charles Antoine's wealth, about the life she's going to have. But there's also this undercurrent of anxiety. In one letter, dated May 1587, about a month before the wedding, she writes, quote, He's kind to me, but there is something in his manner that I cannot quite understand.
SPEAKER_00Perhaps it is only that he's so much older and more worldly than I. That letter breaks my heart, because you can hear it, that little voice of intuition telling her something is wrong. But she was 19 and her family needed this marriage, and she probably told herself that she was just being silly. Marguerite disappeared in December of 1587. She was twenty years old. She'd been married for six months. Jeanne de Brisac was twenty one when she became Charles Antoine's second wife.
SPEAKER_00Her family had only recently been granted their title. Her grandfather had been a successful merchant who'd purchased a minor lordship. Jeanne was the eldest of three children and by all accounts was known for her intelligence and wit. A family friend described her as having a sharp mind and sharper tongue, which I love. She sounds like someone who didn't suffer fools. But here's the thing, Jeanne's family was still establishing themselves in noble society. They were nouveau riche, looked down upon by the old aristocratic families.
SPEAKER_00Marrying Jeanne to an established baron like Charles Antoine was a way to legitimize their status, and Jeanne, despite her sharp mind, was in no position to refuse. There's a record of Jeanne writing to her mother shortly after the wedding in May of 1589. She mentions that Charles Antoine had been asking her questions about her family's finances, about her dowry, about what she might inherit. She writes, quote, He seems more interested in my father's leisures than in me. And then chillingly, there are rooms in this chateau that remain locked.
SPEAKER_00When I ask about them, he smiles and tells me not to worry about such things. Jeanne disappeared in October of 1589. She was twenty one years old. She'd been married for six months. Elizabeth Mercier was 18 when she married Charles Antoine in 1591. She was the only child of Guillaume and Marie Mercier, and by all accounts she was adored by her parents. Guillaume's letters to friends describe Elizabeth as gentle, kind, and devoted to her family.
SPEAKER_00She apparently loved De Paint and had a particular talent for botanical illustrations. Elizabeth's mother had died when she was young, and she'd been raised primarily by her father, which was unusual for the time. Guillaume had given her an education typically reserved for sons. She could read Latin, understood mathematics, and helped manage her father's business affairs. This made her an unusual bride for a nobleman, but Charles Antoine seemed charmed by her intelligence. Or so everyone thought.
SPEAKER_00Guillaume's letters after Elizabeth's disappearance are absolutely gutting. He writes to the local magistrate, to the bishop, to anyone who will listen. He demands to see his daughter's grave. He wants to know why he wasn't informed of her illness, why he wasn't called to her side before she died. He writes, quote, What father would not wish to comfort his dying child? What husband would deny him this right? But his questions went unanswered. Elizabeth disappeared in April of 1592.
SPEAKER_00She was nineteen years old. She'd been married for almost a year. She came from a family of minor nobility that had fallen on hard times. Her father had died when she was young, and her mother was desperate to see her daughters well married before the family's remaining resources ran out. Henri had two younger sisters, and there's a sense in the surviving letters that she felt responsible for them. If she married well, her husband might help arrange good matches for her sisters.
SPEAKER_00She was, in a way, sacrificing herself for her family's future. A letter from Hen Marie to her mother, dated August 1593, two months after her wedding, is particularly haunting. She writes, The chateau is beautiful but cold. Charles Antoine is often away on business, and when he is here, he spends much time in the East Wing where I am not permitted to go. He says these are his private chambers where he conducts his affairs. I do not question him as a good wife should not, but mother, I confess I am lonely here.
SPEAKER_00The servants are strange and silent. They will not meet my eyes. Aunt Marie disappeared in November of 1593. She was twenty years old. She'd been married for five months. Four women, four young women from respectable families, four women who were excited about their futures, who had hopes and dreams and talents and people who loved them. Four women who walked into Charles Antoine Dere's chateau and never walked out.
SPEAKER_00And the truly horrifying thing? No one stopped him. No one investigated. No one connected the pattern. Because he was a baron and they were just wives. So how did he do it? How did Charles-Antoine Duray get away with murdering four women without anyone stopping him? Let's talk about his methodology, because this is where the case gets really disturbing. First, the victim selection.
SPEAKER_00Charles Antoine was strategic about who he targeted. He didn't go after daughters of powerful noble families, families who might have the influence to demand investigations or challenge his authority. Instead, he targeted women from families who were either financially struggling, newly noble, or otherwise vulnerable. Families who would be grateful for the match, who wouldn't ask too many questions, who could be easily dismissed if they did raise concerns. Second, the isolation. Once these women married Charles Antoine, they were cut off from their families.
SPEAKER_00This was somewhat normal for the time. A woman was expected to leave her family and become part of her husband's household. But Charles Antoine took it to an extreme. His various chateaux were remote, located in rural areas of Brittany and Pays de la Loire. Visits from family members were discouraged. Letters were monitored. We know this because several of the letters that survive were clearly written under duress, with the women assuring their families that everything was fine when other evidence suggests it wasn't. Third, the household staff.
SPEAKER_00This is something that really struck me as I researched this case. Charles Antoine employed a small loyal staff at each of his chateau. The same servants appeared at multiple properties over the years, and these weren't local hires. He brought them with him from property to property, which suggests he specifically chose people who would be loyal to him, who wouldn't ask questions, who might even be complicit in his crimes. There are records of several servants who left Charles Antoine's employment and later gave testimony about the strange atmosphere in his households.
SPEAKER_00One former chambermaid, Claudette Moreau, testified that she was forbidden from entering the east wing of the Chateau de Tiffauges. She said that Charles Antoine kept the keys to that section of the chateau on his person at all times, and that she'd once seen him emerging from that wing with blood on his hands and clothing. When she'd asked if he was injured, he told her he'd been butchering a deer and dismissed her. But there was no deer. No venison appeared in the kitchens, no hide was sent to be tanned. Claudette said she knew something was wrong, but she was terrified of Charles Antoine.
SPEAKER_00She left his employment shortly after and never spoke of what she'd seen until years later after his arrest. Another servant, a groundskeeper named Michelle Fontaine, testified that he'd been ordered to dig several graves in the private cemetery on the Tifauge estate. Charles Antoine told him these were for family members who had died, but Michel said the graves were too small for adults. He thought perhaps they were for children, but no children were ever buried there. Instead, Charles Antoine filled the graves himself at night and forbade anyone from entering the cemetery.
SPEAKER_00So what was in those graves? We'll get to that. Now let's talk about the actual murders. Based on the forensic evidence that was eventually uncovered, and yes, they did have forensic analysis in the 17th century, just not too sophisticated, we can piece together Charles Antoine's method. He would wait until he'd been married for several months, long enough for the initial excitement of the wedding to fade, long enough for his new wife to settle into the household routine, long enough for her family to stop checking in quite so frequently.
SPEAKER_00And then he would plan a trip. Business in Paris or Nantes or Tours, something that would take him away from the chateau for a week or two. Before he left, he would give his wife the keys to the chateau, all of them. He would tell her she could go anywhere, explore anything, make herself at home, except for one room, one chamber in the east wing that must remain locked. And this is the psychological torture of it, because he knew, he absolutely knew, that by forbidding her from entering that room, he was making it irresistible.
SPEAKER_00He was counting on her curiosity. He was setting a trap. Wait, you might be thinking, why would he want her to enter the room? Why not just kill her without the whole elaborate setup? Because Charles Antoine Duray wasn't just a murderer, he was a sadist. He enjoyed the psychological torment. He enjoyed knowing that his wife would struggle with the temptation, would eventually give in, would discover the horror he'd created. And then he would return, unexpectedly, to find her in the forbidden chamber, confronted with the evidence of his previous crimes and paralyzed with terror.
SPEAKER_00That's when he would kill her. The forensic evidence suggests he used a blade, likely a sword or a large knife. The wounds on the bodies that were eventually recovered were consistent with a sharp weapon, and the blood spatter pattern suggested the victims had been standing when they were attacked. He would strike quickly, probably from behind, severing major arteries. Death would have been relatively quick, but not instantaneous. His victims would have had time to understand what was happening to them. I know this is graphic, but I think it's important to understand the reality of what these women experienced.
SPEAKER_00This wasn't a fairy tale for them. This was real violence, terror, and suffering. After the murder, Charles Antoine would hang the bodies in the forbidden chamber. He kept them there, preserved with salt and herbs, a technique that was known at the time for preserving meat and that would have slowed decomposition. He dressed them in their wedding gowns, he arranged them carefully like trophies. This is, plainly put, serial killer behavior. This is a man who was collecting his victims, who wanted to be able to revisit his crimes, who derived pleasure from seeing the evidence of what he'd done.
SPEAKER_00And then he would tell everyone that his wife had died of natural causes. He would arrange a quick private burial, but not of his wife's body. The graves that Michelle Fontaine dug, those were filled with weighted sacks or animal carcasses or nothing at all. They were props, stage dressing to support his story. And because he was a baron, because he had wealth and title and authority, no one questioned him, no one demanded to see the bodies, no one insisted on a proper funeral with witnesses.
SPEAKER_00He got away with it four times. But then he made a mistake. In March of 1595, Charles-Antoine Duray married for the fifth time. His bride was Marie Catherine Deschamps, the 22-year-old daughter of a minor nobleman from Vaughan. Marie Catherine's family was in financial difficulty. Her father had made some poor investments and was on the verge of losing his estate. Marrying Marie Catherine to a wealthy baron was seen as a way to save the family from ruin.
SPEAKER_00But Marie Catherine was different from Charles Antoine's previous victims in one crucial way. She had a sister that she was close with. She wrote to her sister constantly, and she insisted on visiting regularly despite Charles Antoine's obvious displeasure. This is important because Anne's presence, her refusal to let her sister be completely isolated, is probably what saved Marie Catherine's life.
SPEAKER_00The wedding took place in March of 1595. For the first few months, everything seemed fine. Marie Catherine's letters to Anne were cheerful, describing the chateau, the grounds, her new life as a baroness, but by summer the tone of the letters had changed. Marie Catherine wrote about feeling watched, about the strange silence of the servants, about the locked wing of the chateau that Charles Antoine forbade her from entering. In one letter, dated July 1595, Marie Catherine wrote, An, I must confess something troubles me.
SPEAKER_00I've learned that Charles Antoine was married before, not once, but four times. Four wives all dead. He says they died of illness or accident, but Anne, is it not strange? Four wives all young, all dead within months of their wedding. I asked him about them, and his face became cold. He told me to never speak of them again. I am frightened, sister. Ame was alarmed by this letter. She immediately began making inquiries, trying to learn more about Charles Antoine's previous wives.
SPEAKER_00She wrote to families in Nantes, Angers, Tours, and Rennes, asking if anyone knew of the women who had married Charles Antoine Duray. And what she discovered horrified her. She found Guillaume Mercier, Elizabeth's father, who told her about his daughter's disappearance and his unanswered questions. She found Anne Marie Dubois's mother, who said she'd never been allowed to see her daughter's grave. She found records of Marguerite de Ponchetteau and Jean de Brisac, both of whom who had vanished shortly after marrying Charles Antoine.
SPEAKER_00Anne realized her sister was in danger. She wrote to Marie Catherine, urging her to leave Charles Antoine to come home. But Marie Catherine wrote back saying she couldn't. She was married, she had duties, and besides, Charles Antoine had been kind to her. She had no proof that anything was wrong. She would seem foolish, hysterical. If this is frustrating to us, we can only imagine how Ahm felt. Because we can see what's happening. We can see the danger.
SPEAKER_00But Marie Catherine was trapped by the social conventions of her time. A wife couldn't just leave her husband. She had no legal rights, no independent income, and without proof of wrongdoing, she would be the one who was blamed and shamed. But Anne didn't give up. She continued to visit her sister regularly despite Charles Antoine's increasing hostility toward her. In an October of 1595, she was visiting the chateau when Charles Antoine announced he had to travel to Paris on business.
SPEAKER_00He would be gone for two weeks. Before he left, he gave Marie Catherine the keys to the chateau. Anne was there when he did it. She watched as he told Marie Catherine she could go anywhere, do anything. Explore the entire chateau to her heart's content, except for one room, one chamber in the east wing. That room must remain locked. Anne saw the look on Charlantoine's face as he said this.
SPEAKER_00She later testified that it was a look of anticipation, of cruel pleasure, and she knew in that moment that this was a test, a trap. After Charlantoine left, Anne begged Marie Catherine not to enter the forbidden chamber. But Marie Catherine was tormented by curiosity. What was in that room? Why was it forbidden? What was her husband hiding? For three days Marie Catherine resisted, but on the fourth day, October 17, 1595, she couldn't stand it anymore.
SPEAKER_00She had to know. Anne tried to stop her. She later testified that she physically tried to prevent her sister from unlocking the door, but Marie Catherine was determined. She took the small tarnished key from the ring, walked to the end of the East Corridor, and unlocked the forbidden chamber. The smell hit them first. Anne Marie described it as quote the stench of death and decay mixed with herbs and salt, a smell that made me wretch. The chamber was dark, lit only by a single narrow window, and hanging from hooks on the walls were four bodies, four women in wedding dresses and various states of decomposition.
SPEAKER_00Marie Catherine screamed. Anne caught her as she collapsed, and then Anne did something incredibly brave. She went into that chamber. She examined the bodies. She looked for anything that might identify them, any evidence that could be used to bring Charles Antoine to justice. She found jewelry on the bodies, rings, necklaces, brooches, she found scraps of letters in the pockets of their dresses, she found a ledger on a table in the corner of the room where Charles Antoine had apparently kept records of his murders, dates, names, details of how each woman had died.
SPEAKER_00Anne took the ledger, she took the jewelry, she took everything she could carry. And then she and Marie Catherine fled the chateau. They rode through the night to Nantes, where Anne went directly to the magistrate. She presented the evidence she'd gathered, she told him everything, and she demanded that Charles Antoine Dere be arrested for murder. But here's where things get complicated, because Charles Antoine was a baron, and Anne and Marie Catherine were just women.
SPEAKER_00The magistrate was reluctant to act on their testimony alone. He needed more evidence, he needed witnesses, he needed to be absolutely certain before he could move against a man of Charlantoine's status. So Anne did something even braver. She went back to the chateau. With the magistrate and a group of armed men, she returned to Tiffauge and she showed them the chamber. The magistrate's report, which still exists in the archives in Nantes, describes what they found.
SPEAKER_00Four bodies of women in states of advanced decay, quote, hanging from hooks affixed to the walls. The bodies were dressed in fine gowns, now stained with blood and corruption. The chamber reeked of death. Upon examination, we found evidence of violence upon the bodies, wounds consistent with blade weapons, severed arteries, signs of struggle. We also found a ledger containing detailed accounts of the murders written in the hand of Charles Antoine de Rey, Baron of Tiffauges. They had their evidence.
SPEAKER_00Now they just had to find Charles Antoine. The investigation into Charles Antoine de's crimes was remarkably thorough. The magistrate in Nantes, a man named Francois LeBlanc, took the case seriously. He understood that he was dealing with a serial murderer even if they didn't use that term in 1595. LeBlanc's first step was to secure the crime scene. He posted guards at the Chateau de Tiffauge to ensure that no evidence was disturbed.
SPEAKER_00He then brought in a physician, Dr. Henri Beaumont, to examine the bodies. Dr. Beaumont's report is fascinating from a forensic perspective. Remember, this is 1595. They didn't have modern forensic science, but they weren't completely ignorant either. Dr. Beaumont was able to determine several key facts. First, all four women had died from blood loss due to wounds from a sharp blade. The wounds were consistent across all four victims, suggesting the same weapon and the same perpetrator.
SPEAKER_00Second, based on the state of decomposition and the preservation methods used, Dr. Beaumont estimated that the first victim had been dead for approximately eight years, the second for six years, the third for three years, and the fourth for two years. These timelines matched up with the disappearances of Marguerite de Pontchateau, Jean de Brisac, Elizabeth Mercier, and Henry Dubois. Third, Dr. Beaumont noted that the bodies had been carefully preserved using salt and herbs, a technique that required knowledge and planning.
SPEAKER_00This wasn't a crime of passion. This was premeditated methodical murder. The bodies were identified through the jewelry they wore and through physical descriptions provided by family members. Guillaume Mercier identified his daughter Elizabeth by a distinctive ring she always wore, a gold band with a small ruby that had belonged to her mother. Henie Dubois's mother identified her daughter by a locket containing a miniature portrait of the family. Marguerite de Ponchateau's sister identified her by a pearl necklace that had been a wedding gift.
SPEAKER_00Jeanne de Brisac was identified by her clothing. Her wedding dress had been made from a distinctive fabric that her family's textile business had produced. Her father, who had been granted his title only a few years before her marriage, had been so proud that his daughter was marrying a baron that he'd had her dress made from the finest fabric his business could produce. Seeing that dress, stained with his daughter's blood, hanging in Charles Antoine's chamber of horrors, it's hard to imagine. While doctor Beaumont was examining the bodies, Magistrate LeBlanc was interviewing witnesses.
SPEAKER_00He spoke to four former servants who had worked at Charles Antoine's various chateaux. He spoke to neighbors, to merchants who had done business with Charles Antoine, to anyone who might have information about the Baron's activities. What emerged was a picture of a man who was charming in public, but cold and cruel in private. Multiple servants testified about the forbidden wing of the chateau, about Charles Antoine's violent temper, about the strange comings and goings at odd hours of the night. The chambermaid, Claudette Moreau, testified about seeing Charles Antoine with blood on his hands.
SPEAKER_00The groundskeeper, Michelle Fontaine, testified about the graves he'd been ordered to dig, graves that were never properly used. A cook named Margot Le Brun testified that she'd been ordered to prepare large quantities of salt and herbs, which Charles Antoine said were for preserving meat, but no meat ever appeared in the kitchens. LeBlanc also examined the ledger that Andechamp had taken from the Forbidden Chamber. This document was damning. In Charlanto Antoine's own handwriting, it contained detailed accounts of each murder.
SPEAKER_00Marguerite, december twelfth, fifteen eighty seven. She entered the chamber as I knew she would. The look on her face when she saw what I had prepared for her, such perfect terror. She tried to run, but I was faster. The blade was sharp. She died quickly, though not as quickly as she would have liked. Jean, october twenty third, fifteen eighty nine, more clever than the others, she suspected something was wrong. But curiosity overcame caution as it always does.
SPEAKER_00She fought harder than Marguerite. I had bruises on my arms from where she struck me. But in the end, she joined her predecessor on the wall. I realize that these entries are graphic and disturbing, but I think it's important to understand the level of depravity we're dealing with here. Charles Antoine didn't just kill these women. He enjoyed it. He documented it. He revisited his crimes through his writings and through the trophies he kept. The ledger also contained entries about Marie Catrine.
SPEAKER_00Charles Antoine had been planning her murder, writing about how he would do it, what he would say to her family afterward. He'd been anticipating the moment when he would enter the forbidden chamber and she would discover his secrets. But thanks to Anne's intervention, Marie Catherine survived. She was the one who got away. LeBlanc also investigated Charles Antoine's finances, and what he found was interesting. Charles Antoine had been living well beyond his means for years.
SPEAKER_00The elaborate weddings, the lavish parties, the maintenance of multiple chateau, all of it was expensive. And each time he married, he gained access to his wife's dowry. Each time a wife died, he kept the dowry in any property she'd brought. So in addition to being a serial killer, Charles Antoine was also a con man. He was marrying these women for their money, killing them, and then keeping their assets. It was a financial scheme as well as a murder spree. LeBlanc compiled all of this evidence, the bodies, the ledger, the witness testimonies, the financial records, into a comprehensive case file, and then he issued a warrant for Charles Antoine Duray's arrest.
SPEAKER_00But there was a problem. Charles Antoine had disappeared. Charles Antoine Duray was arrested on november third, fifteen ninety five in Paris. He'd been staying at a townhouse he owned in the Moray district, apparently believing that his title and connections would protect him. He was wrong. The arrest was carried out by the Prevot de Paris, essentially the chief of police, with a contingent of armed guards. According to the arrest report, Charles Antoine was shocked when they came for him.
SPEAKER_00He apparently believed that the word of the baron would outweigh any evidence against him. He demanded to know who had dared to accuse him. When he was told that his own ledger had been used as evidence, he reportedly went pale and silent. Charles Antoine was transported back to Nantes in chains. The trial began on november twentieth, fifteen ninety five in the Chateau de Duc de Bretagne, the seat of judicial authority in the region. The trial was a sensation. Nobility being tried for murder was rare enough, but a serial killer who had murdered multiple wives?
SPEAKER_00This was unprecedented. The courtroom was packed with spectators, including many members of the nobility who were both horrified and fascinated by the case. The prosecution was led by Magistrate Francois Leblanc, who presented the evidence methodically and thoroughly. He called Dr. Henri Beaumont to testify about the bodies and the cause of death. He called the former servants to testify about Charles Antoine's behavior in the forbidden chamber. He called Guillaume Mercier and the other family members to testify about their daughter's disappearances and Charles Antoine's suspicious behavior.
SPEAKER_00And then he called Hen Deschant to testify. Anne's testimony was powerful. She described finding the chamber, seeing the bodies, realizing that her sister had been moments away from becoming the fifth victim. She described Charles Antoine's behavior, the way he had set up the trap with the forbidden room, the anticipation in his eyes when he gave Marie Catherine the keys. The courtroom was silent as she spoke. Several people were reportedly weeping. Charles Antoine's defense was, shall we say, weak.
SPEAKER_00His attorney, a man named Claude Moreau, tried to argue that the evidence was circumstantial, that the bodies could have been anyone, that the ledger could have been forged, but it was a losing battle. The evidence was overwhelming. Charles Antoine himself was called to testify, and this is where things get really chilling because he didn't deny what he'd done. Instead, he tried to justify it. According to the trial transcript, Charles Antoine said, quote, these women were my wives.
SPEAKER_00They belonged to me. I had the right to do with them as I pleased. They disobeyed me. They entered the chamber I had forbidden them to enter. They brought their fate upon themselves. The prosecutor asked him about the ledger, about the detailed descriptions of the murders, about the pleasure he clearly took in documenting his crimes. Charles Antoine's response was, quote, a man is entitled to keep records of his property and its disposal. The courtroom erupted.
SPEAKER_00The judge had to call for order multiple times. Several people had to be removed from the courtroom for shouting at Charles Antoine. The prosecution then presented evidence of Charles Antoine's financial motives, the dowries he'd kept, the property he'd acquired through his marriages. They argued that he had married these women not out of love or even lust, but out of greed. He'd wanted their money, and once he had it, he'd killed them. Charles Antoine's attorney tried to argue that his client was insane, that no sane man would commit such crimes.
SPEAKER_00But the prosecution countered with evidence of Charles Antoine's careful planning, his methodical approach, his ability to maintain a public facade of respectability while committing atrocities in private. This wasn't insanity, this was calculated deliberate evil. The trial lasted for three days. On november twenty third, fifteen ninety five, the jury, composed of local nobles and magistrates, retired to deliberate. They returned less than two hours later with a verdict.
SPEAKER_00Guilty on all counts, four counts of murder, multiple counts of fraud, desecration of human remains, and a charge that was specific to the time period, crimes against the natural order and the laws of God and man. The judge, a man named Philippe Rousseau, delivered the sentence. He said, quote, Charles Antoine Duray, you've been found guilty of the most heinous crimes imaginable. You have murdered four innocent women, women who trusted you, who married you in good faith.
SPEAKER_00You have betrayed the sacred bonds of marriage. You have used your title and your privilege to prey upon the vulnerable. You have shown no remorse, no humanity, no recognition of the evil you have committed. Therefore, it is the judgment of this court that you be stripped of your title and your lands, that your property be forfeit to the crown, and that you be executed by beheading, the traditional method for nobility, though you have shown yourself unworthy of such consideration.
SPEAKER_00Charles Antoine was executed on december first, fifteen ninety five in the public square in Nantes. Thousands of people attended. The execution was carried out by the royal executioner, and by all accounts, Charles Antoine showed no remorse, even at the end. His last words were reportedly, quote, I regret. Nothing. His body was buried in an unmarked grave. His chateau were seized by the crown and eventually sold. His name was stricken from the family records, his relatives wanting nothing to do with him.
SPEAKER_00And the four women he murdered? They were finally given proper burials. Their families were able to mourn them, to say goodbye, to lay them to rest with dignity. So what happened after the trial? What became of the people involved in this case? Marie-Catherine Deschamps, the wife who survived, had her marriage to Charles-Antoine annulled by the church. She returned to her family's estate in Vans and never remarried. She lived quietly for the rest of her life, dying in 1642 at the age of 69.
SPEAKER_00In her will, she left a substantial sum of money to establish a home for women fleeing abusive marriages, a remarkably progressive act for the time. She married a few years after the trial and had three children. She died in 1638 at the age of 65. Guillaume Mercier, Elizabeth's father, was finally able to bury his daughter properly.
SPEAKER_00He attended Charles Antoine's execution and reportedly said afterward, quote, justice has been done, but it cannot bring back my child. He died two years later in 1597. His friends said he never recovered from the loss of his daughter. The families of the other victims, Marguerite de Pontchateau, Jean de Brisac, and Em Marie Dubois, were also able to bury their daughters and find some measure of closure. But the trauma of what had happened, the knowledge of how their daughters had died, haunted them for the rest of their lives.
SPEAKER_00As for Charles Antoine's estate, it was divided up and sold. The Chateau de Tiffauge, where the murders took place, was purchased by a merchant family who tore down the East Wing, the wing that had contained the Chamber of Horrors, and rebuilt it. They wanted to erase any trace of what had happened there. But the story didn't die. It couldn't die. The case was too shocking, too horrifying, too memorable. People talked about it. They told their children about it.
SPEAKER_00They warned their daughters about the dangers of marrying men they didn't know, about the importance of listening to their instincts, about the red flags they should watch for. And over time, the story evolved. It became a folk tale. The specific details, the names, the dates, the locations, were forgotten or changed. But the core of the story remained. A wealthy man with a blue-tinted beard who murdered his wives and kept their bodies in a locked room.
SPEAKER_00A curious wife who discovered his secrets, a brave sister who helped bring him to justice. By the time Charot published his version of the tale in 1697, more than a hundred years after the real events, it had become a fairy tale, a cautionary tale about female curiosity and disobedience. The focus had shifted away from the murderer and his crimes and onto the wife who disobeyed by entering the forbidden chamber. But despite Perra's lesson to young girls about the perils of disobedience, the real story isn't about a woman who was too curious.
SPEAKER_00It's about a serial killer who used his wealth and power to prey on vulnerable women. It's about a system that enabled him, but looked the other way, that valued his word over the lives of his victims. It's about Marguerite, who was 19 and loved music and was excited about her future. It's about Jean who was sharp and witty and didn't deserve to die. It's about Elizabeth who loved to paint and was adored by her father. It's about Homerie who sacrificed herself for her family's future.
SPEAKER_00These women weren't characters in a fairy tale. They were real people. They had lives and dreams and people who loved them. And they were murdered by a man who saw them as property, as objects to be used and discarded. But this story is also about Anne Deschamps, who refused to let her sister become another victim, who investigated, who gathered evidence, who risked her own life to bring a killer to justice. Anne is the real hero of this story, and her bravery should be remembered.
SPEAKER_00So when you hear the story of Bluebeard, I want you to remember the real story. Remember Marguerite, Jean, Elizabeth, and Anne Marie. Remember that they were real women who deserved better. And remember An Deschamps, who made sure their murderer faced justice. That concludes our first investigation, the Bluebeard serial killings. Keep listening for a brief case epilogue on the man most famous for setting this story to the page. When Charles Perrault published his sanitized version of these murders in 1697, just over a century after Charles Antoine's execution, he made one crucial change to the ending.
SPEAKER_00In his tale, the heroine's brothers arrived just in time to save her, bursting through the door as Bluebeard raises his sword. It's a dramatic rescue, the kind that makes for satisfying storytelling. But here's what's fascinating: that ending was almost universally rejected by the women who told this story to each other in the centuries that followed. In oral traditions across France, Germany, and England, the tale evolved differently. In these versions, the youngest wife saves herself.
SPEAKER_00She outsmarts Bluebeard, she discovers the chamber on her own terms, she orchestrates her own escape. Some versions have her setting fire to the castle with him inside. Others have her leading him into a trap. The women who pass this story down, generation to generation, refuse to let the heroine be passive. They understood something Perot didn't, or perhaps chose to ignore. This wasn't a story about waiting to be rescued.
SPEAKER_00It was a story about the courage it takes to open the forbidden door, to face the truth no matter how horrifying, and to fight back against the monsters who believe they're untouchable. That, perhaps more than anything, is why this tale has survived. Because every generation has needed to hear it. Next week we'll reopen another case, examining legends and lore through the lens of true crime. I'm Danielle Christmas, and you've been listening to Folklore Forensics.
SPEAKER_00Folklore Forensics is written and hosted by me and produced by Audio Ellis. The music is by The Soundlings and Josh Pan. You can find us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen to podcasts. Follow Folklore Forensics on Instagram at Folklore Forensics. Please send future case suggestions to Folklore Forensics Pod at gmail.com. Until next time, stay curious and always follow the evidence.
Four confessions. A woman who claimed to fly, transform into a hare, and feast with the Queen of Fairies. And a historical record that ends before revealing her fate. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. In 1662,...
Lancaster Castle. August 1612. A nine-year-old girl is lifted onto a table before a crowded courtroom. Her name is Jennet Device. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. Standing before the judges, Jennet accuses her...
In the hills outside Leicester, children were disappearing. The villagers knew who was responsible. Black Annis. You've heard the story. Now hear the case. According to English folklore, she was a blue-faced hag with...
A young man disappears from a riverboat after dark. His lantern is still warm. His coat remains folded on the bench. And in the bottom of the boat, investigators discover a woman's carved horn comb. The villagers...
A servant boy stole three drops of divine wisdom from a Welsh sorceress. She hunted him across land, water, and sky and when she finally caught him, she swallowed him whole. You've heard the story. Now hear the case....