Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Five Games for Doomsday

Five Games for Doomsday artwork

Battle Reprot - Medico(Sample)

Oct 15, 202621 minAudio

To listen to the rest of the show, go to patreon.com/5g4d and give your support. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support. Support the show here

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Battle Report with Ben and Steve.

Speaker 2So here we are, Ben and Steve.

Speaker 3We finally made it work, Ben.

Speaker 1What's that?

Speaker 3They said that we would never come back together again for Battle Report. They doubted us.

Speaker 1They doubted us and they wanted it secretly.

Speaker 2They wanted us to not do this.

Speaker 3To fail. They always want you to fail. They always want you to fail. What is it with them and wanting us to fail?

Speaker 1But you know what's great about you being a bloke?

Speaker 2What's that?

Speaker 1I mean, for the first six months of your... You've got no real sort of biological need to be close to the baby, have you?

Speaker 2I'm not really useful in this situation. No, exactly.

Speaker 3I carry stuff. I go out on errands. I basically do what I'm told, but there's no biological necessity.

Speaker 1No, I mean, you're not feeding the baby the milk from your body, are you?

Speaker 3No, no, no. I mean, eventually we'll be able to turn Samantha into like a milk factory and bottle it, and then I'll be able to feed the baby.

Speaker 1Are you going to sell her milk on the open market?

Speaker 2I didn't say that.

Speaker 3But now that you mention it.

Speaker 1I mean, factory implies production for sale, doesn't it? I did kind of imply it, didn't I?

Speaker 3I didn't come right out and say that I intend to sell on eBay the milk from my own wife. I tell you what, there's definitely a market for that, isn't there? People would buy it, wouldn't they? Do you think the discord dickheads would buy it?

Speaker 1Well, do you remember that woman? She was like an influencer. And she made hundreds of thousands of dollars selling her bathwater.

Speaker 3Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Who is that?

Speaker 1What's that? I can't remember.

Speaker 2People are going to be screaming about it.

Speaker 1I'll have to look on my mantelpiece.

Speaker 3Yeah, no, I totally know what you're talking about.

Speaker 1And then she also... Gwyneth Paltrow? No, it was an influencer. And she sold her farts as well. She bottled her farts and sold them. I totally know what you're talking about, yeah.

Speaker 3It's outrageous.

Speaker 1Anyway, so what are we playing today, Steve? On the subject of bodily excretia.

Speaker 3We are.

Speaker 1Excretia? That's what I said.

Speaker 3That's good. Excretia. That's the plural, you think?

Speaker 1I think it is, isn't it?

Speaker 3Of excretion?

Speaker 2Yeah, I think so.

Speaker 3Why would it be excretia? So let's... That would imply that the nominative singular is excretium. And then the plural would be excretia.

Speaker 1Well, I don't speak Latin because I'm not pretentious.

Speaker 3Yeah, I'm just saying. So it's actually an interesting attempt by you to sound erudite, or as some people might say, erudite.

Speaker 1Well, it says... The word excretia... is already a plural. I said, I wrote in, what's the plural of excretia? We were looking for the plural. And Google corrected me. That was a difficult sentence to get out of my mouth. The word excretia is already a plural noun. Originally, the neuter plural of the Latin word excretius.

Speaker 3Excretius.

Speaker 1That's what it says. And its plural form remains excretia. The singular form, the rare or technical singular form, is excretium.

Speaker 3Yeah, that should be, if it's a neuter noun, it should be excretium, not excretious. Yeah, so it's excretium, excretia.

Speaker 2Where does this excretious come from?

Speaker 3I don't fucking know.

Speaker 2Anyway, this is what I said.

Speaker 1Anyway, so, yes, so we're playing Medicos.

Speaker 3I'm dealing with a lot of excretia lately.

Speaker 1This probably isn't the first review of this game, but it's going to be one of the first because it's, Fucking hotness.

Speaker 2Hot off the presses.

Speaker 1So I was at work the other day, and I saw a delivery. Because I was thinking about getting this at Essen. Because it's the new Feld, and I like Steffen Feld. Probably in English.

Speaker 3This is the German version. But you couldn't wait to put your hot little phalanges on it.

Speaker 1Well, I get a fucking 20% discount, don't I?

Speaker 2That's not bad.

Speaker 1Yeah. I'm not going to fucking pay.

Speaker 2Is it like six euros?

Speaker 1What? The... The.

Speaker 2How much is a discount?

Speaker 360 euros.

Speaker 2That's 12 euros. That's 12 of your euros. 12 euro discount.

Speaker 112 euros.

Speaker 3What are you going to do with that 12 euros?

Speaker 1I've already spent it on booze, Steve. 12 euros. I discovered at the Spatey around the corner from me that used to be your favorite Spatey.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1They've got honick beer.

Speaker 2I think it still is my favorite Spatey.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 2It's not like I've discovered a Spatey that's better than that one in the meantime.

Speaker 1Because there isn't one. That's why.

Speaker 3I just don't get to go there as often.

Speaker 1Although the nice guy who was really pleasant is not working there anymore. And... I like that guy. He was very pleasant. His wife works there and she's a fucking living nightmare.

Speaker 3I mean, that's just like.

Speaker 1She is the most miserable fucking woman I've ever met in my life.

Speaker 2Spaty people, you know?

Speaker 3It's like... It's like drawing lots. Yeah. I mean, usually they're... Usually they're fairly unpleasant.

Speaker 1Anyway.

Speaker 3So, Steve.

Speaker 1Looking at the board... Mmm. It's... So, we were talking about this as I was setting up. And I was saying that I think the production of this is really great. And frankly... Frankly, I don't see why you would need more than this. So you've got lots of meeples. They're screen printed.

Speaker 3That's nice. I think that's the one improvement. Concession. Yeah, the one improvement to board game componentry over the years that I'm totally on board with. Yeah. Because it's very basic, very simple, and I think it actually adds quite a bit without detracting.

Speaker 1Right. And then you've got the resource counters are in their own particular shapes.

Speaker 3You've got eel, CSD. Very charming.

Speaker 1Flowers and water and that. And the rather suspicious... What are these? I don't know what they are. It says in the book. But the rather suspicious herb resources. Do you think they were laughing behind their hands when they made the marijuana-shaped... It is.

Speaker 3Yeah, it does have five... Shall I... What do you call these? Five lobes on the leaf?

Speaker 1Yeah. So these are called Heilmittel.

Speaker 2So healing stuff.

Speaker 3Healing herbs, yeah. Well, I mean, I would say some people regard marijuana as in the healing herb.

Speaker 1That's right. I'm just trying to see if they say what kind of herbs they are, because I definitely read them.

Speaker 2Just generic healing herbs, I assume.

Speaker 1No, I definitely read them, because when I was reading the rules....

Speaker 2This is great.

Speaker 3This is great while Ben looks in the rulebook and everyone is listening to what's happened.

Speaker 1Anyway, so yeah, and it's beautifully produced. And I frankly don't... The thing is, with the... Modern overproduction, it does two things. The player boards are a bit flimsy. Yeah.

Speaker 2It's like the one thing.

Speaker 1We can live with that.

Speaker 3I also like the double-layered boards that some games come.

Speaker 1With these days. Yeah, double-layered boards are also good. But the point is, I think with the overproduction, what it results in is it's not just massively more expensive, as we can see by the King's Gambit, which is currently on Kickstarter, but also it detracts from the play experience in many cases for me.

Speaker 3You're really leaning in lately.

Speaker 1The shit gets in the fucking way, Frank.

Speaker 3You've always had this opinion, but you're really leaning into it lately. Especially after you played Jerusalem.

Speaker 2The other day.

Speaker 1Well, I think it's something to do with writing my book.

Speaker 3You're writing a book?

Speaker 1I am.

Speaker 3When were you going to share this with me? With the world?

Speaker 1I was just going to announce it when it was published. Just like surprise, I've written a book? How long have you been working on it?

Speaker 3Oh, fucking ages.

Speaker 2When's it going to be done?

Speaker 1Well, this is interesting because we decided that I had to completely rewrite one of the chapters.

Speaker 3Which one?

Speaker 1The other day. It's about art in board games in the 21st century. Yeah, just use AI. I'm not using fucking AI.

Speaker 3It's about art in board games in the 21st century.

Speaker 1That would be highly ironic.

Speaker 2Exactly.

Speaker 1But the production of this is beautiful. The board is round and it's interesting looking and it's... It's not like a conventional board game board.

Speaker 3Dennis Lohausen.

Speaker 1Dennis Lohausen, yeah.

Speaker 3Maybe he's a newcomer to the board game illustrators.

Speaker 1Yeah, definitely a newcomer to the board game. Is he?

Speaker 2I don't know.

Speaker 1He's fucking done loads of shit. Has he done? So, his most famous games are probably Camel Up.

Speaker 2Okay.

Speaker 1Fields of Arla. Okay. A Feast for Odin.

Speaker 3A Feast for Odin? A Feast for Odin. Oh my God, my foot is in my mouth. Like he's done loads. This is me not paying attention.

Speaker 1Exactly. Anyway.

Speaker 3Because it looks so like whimsical and sort of like, you know. Stylistically, not avant-garde, but different. The thing is, I think there is a cynicism. Because Euro games became so prevalent in the sort of 2000s and 2010s, I think there is a cynicism has developed around something like Stefan Feld, that it's just another Euro game. But for me, they really are my gaming happy place. Well, he's a professional board game designer, and there aren't too many of those.

Speaker 3And by professional, I mean... Comes out with a new game practically every year. They're not all great, but they all work. They all work.

Speaker 2They're all relatively tight. They may not be to everybody's taste.

Speaker 3I think not all of his games have been to my taste. But by and large, I think I always have a good time with them. Even if I have quibbles. They're worth criticizing.

Speaker 2In that sense.

Speaker 1So I was writing this art chapter today. And I'm writing about the woman who did the original illustrations for Carcassonne. And I write that the human form has become so heavily politicized over the last 20 years that Carcassonne has decided to remove the people from the picture of Carcassonne. Now you just have a.

Speaker 3Landscape because you can't depict anyone.

Speaker 1I mean, you can depict people, but there will always be some fucking dickhead on the internet who will politicize an illustration. I think some are worth criticizing. I think the illustration from Mombasa is a is pushing the fucking limits.

Speaker 3Society is moving towards some weird, I don't know, it's not like a religious extreme, but it's like an extreme that has some of the hallmarks of religious extremism that sort of deny the, or like, how do I say, it is as if the character of people is Sacred and you can't depict it at all there where you.

Speaker 1Shouldn't so so I think I think it's a I think it's a failure of social media one of the failures of social media one of the failures of society with their relation to social media is that they take social media seriously.

Speaker 3Iconoclasm. Yeah.

Speaker 1So they take social media seriously. And the problem is with social media is that we have these thoughts in our head. When we see something, we have an instant thought about it that is often just a fucking massively overblown reaction. But pre-social media, pre-social media, that thought would come up, disappear. and would have no effect on the outside world. Whereas social media just allows us to fucking spew bullshit. And the fact that it's then rendered into

Speaker 1text offers it a gravitas that it doesn't need to have. And so people start to take it seriously.

Speaker 3But where board games are concerned, this is simply indicative of its success as an art form. You're the one who's always banging on about how board games are art form.

Speaker 1No, I think critique is wonderful. I think the instant reaction and spewage of ludicrous opinions based on fucking nothing is deeply destructive.

Speaker 2I think you've just described a lot of art criticism.

Speaker 1It's absolutely the reason why board games have pulled back from exploring themes that aren't that aren't socially but this is less.

Speaker 3About critique as such than a response to the market right.

Speaker 1Well yes because they are they are they are prone to market forces and so people are going to moan and the reaction is endless games about cats endless games about hills.

Speaker 3Well maybe it's not all art i mean i think if it's art then it's not It's not worried about offending.

Speaker 2It may even be trying to provoke.

Speaker 3And if it's a product, it does not want to offend at all.

Speaker 1Well, I think there are certain designers who try to make political points.

Speaker 2Or can you make a political point via mechanisms, I suppose? Yes, absolutely. I suppose in some ways you can, but I think it'd be.

Speaker 3Hard to make a political argument about every game and its mechanics.

Speaker 1Well, the thing is, I think... So Medico appeals to me because it's barber surgeons in the....

Speaker 3Medieval times it's totally seamless.

Speaker 1It's complete. I've played the game. It's completely seamless, but I am I am someone Who I am a medievalist? Mm-hmm. I like that sort of medieval World when you remove all the shit and the death drinking booze out of horns Yeah, and you're left with that sort of modern conception of medievalism right appeals to right and I think I think there was a there was a reaction to Because every Euro game that came out was a kind of medievalist game. And I have a theory about it in my book as to why that is.

Speaker 3Do we have to wait for the book to come out to find out what that theory is? But it's to do with German history fundamentally.

Speaker 1Oh, man. Let's not go there. But there was a massive reaction from North Americans primarily. And I think Eric Lang gave voice to this on social media extremely loudly.

Speaker 3This idea that... So North Americans, including Canadians.

Speaker 1North Americans.

Speaker 2But not Mexicans.

Speaker 1Yeah, sure. But they speak a different language. So Anglo... What's the word?

Speaker 3Anglo-Americans?

Speaker 1No. What's the word for speaking English? Anglophone North Americans, right? And Eric Lang came out and was... openly critical about why is every game set in Europe?

Speaker 3So not people from Quebec. They're excluded from the conversation.

Speaker 1So I can only talk about the Anglophone reaction because I don't speak French well enough to be able to comment.

Speaker 2Maybe there is the.

Speaker 1Same thing happening in the Francophone world and the, what's it called, Hispanophone? What's Spanish speaking?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Hispanophone world.

Speaker 2Why are you putting me on the spot like this?

Speaker 1Well, because your intelligence.

Speaker 2Lusophone would be Portuguese.

Speaker 1Yeah, exactly. See, you know the fucking Portuguese. Anyway, and so there was this, you know, reaction saying, how dare Europeans create games with European themes? Because we should all adopt American modes of behavior. And because, you know, the 21st century has been the American century. And, you know... I am drawn because my experience of history has been filtered through European lens.

Speaker 3Because I'm fucking European. I live in Northern Europe. The places I've been to apart.

Speaker 2From Reno are in Europe.

Speaker 3Therefore, why is it incumbent on us to be universally representative of all times, places and peoples?

Speaker 1Yeah. Why is it incumbent upon people producing stuff in Europe to be.

Speaker 3I mean, I like this medieval shit too.

Speaker 1Yeah, all I'm saying, and it's cozy. And there's a great chapter written by Isaac where he talks about Puerto Rico and things in the book that kind of reckons with kind of the misplaced Orientalism. I'm using the term Orientalism as a general term for those outside of Europe when you portray them. And making those kind of mistakes, making those kind of mistakes, in German game design, but one thing German game design does really well is create

Speaker 1a medievalist setting for their games that I find very appealing and I don't think should be disparaged.

Speaker 3So you are criticised if you set all your games in the Middle Ages because you're not being inclusive and you're criticised if you try to represent other times, places and peoples because now you're being Orientalist, for one thing. You're doing, yeah, Orientalist or it's a caricature.

Speaker 2So what are you left to do?

Speaker 3Like anthropomorphic creatures or fantasy scenarios, science fiction?

Speaker 1Removing the human, removing the human from the artwork is less likely to produce ire in the kind of people on the internet who have ire about those things.

Speaker 3I mean, traveling barbers in the Middle Ages sounds like someone said, we need to come up with a theme that is so boring, it's not even worth critiquing.

Speaker 1Yeah, but the point is, I... So, I am a defender of this kind of medievalism. I think it bears no relevance to historical reality, probably. But that's not the issue. I am a fan of it. It appeals to me.

Speaker 3Ooh, I like these.

Speaker 1I find it escapist. What do you call this? What is it?

Speaker 3The Staff of Asclepius or something? Yeah, it's the Staff of Asclepius. That's right.

Speaker 1And I find it appealing, and I think....

Speaker 2I think it needn't be disparaged. Like a banana.

Speaker 1Yeah. It needn't be disparaged. I find a lot of criticism often is targeted at things. So I think some of it's relevant and some of it's in keeping with what should be. I'm trying to think of a word.

Speaker 3I'm wondering to what extent, and this is not meant to be like an attack on your position, to what extent is it possible that It's a bit of a straw man argument. You're much more online than I am. Is this kind of discourse still going on?

Speaker 1Well, that's the thing.

Speaker 2It seems a bit stale at this point.

Speaker 1It probably isn't. It probably isn't anymore. Because the classic criticism was the stern-faced medieval man looking out of the Euro game. And a lot of people just said, oh, isn't this funny? And then some people, of course, said, introduced introduced ire into it which to me would just.

Speaker 3Create your own fucking shit if you're pissed off about it but you know i i look at this game i look at the box i look at the illustrations the art the components uh the designer and it's as if the last 15 years or so in board gaming didn't even happen.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 2It's like a game, I assume.

Speaker 1From a different age.

Speaker 2Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 1And the thing is.

Speaker 3Like Pegasus Spiele, it's like, you know, we're doing our thing as we've always done it, and I don't know what.

Speaker 2The rest of you people are talking about.

Speaker 1And the thing is, also in the book, I talk about how part of the reason for this kind of, on the face of it, bland theme is that these are mechanics-forward games. You don't want the theme to interfere with the mechanisms. You just want a blank, sort of bland world on which the mechanisms.

Speaker 3Can shine and distract, right?

Speaker 2It's Medico.

Speaker 3It's not Pax Medico, right? It's not trying to make a political statement. It's not trying to make.

Speaker 1A political statement. And I think it's interesting that what we've seen within board gaming is that Certain political statements are completely fine and others aren't, depending on how you jive with the current cultural majority.

Speaker 2But that's for a different.

Speaker 3So you've played this at four?

Speaker 1I played this at three. Three, okay.

Speaker 2So we're going to try it at two.

Speaker 1Yeah.

Speaker 3And I'm looking forward to it. I didn't really love Druids of Adora that much.

Speaker 1So after my first play, I would say it's a good, not a great Feld game.

Speaker 2Better than Druids of Adora?

Speaker 1I quite enjoyed Druids of Adora, so.

Speaker 3I didn't hate it, but.

Speaker 2I don't need to play it again.

Speaker 1I mean, I'm not entirely sure that this has the kind of legs that Trajan has either.

Speaker 3But it's a good game.

Speaker 2It's a solid game. Indeed.

Speaker 1Anyway, so with that kind of very unfocused, me moaning about, me subtweeting basically for 20 minutes.

Speaker 3I mean, the usual. Yeah, the usual.

Speaker 1Let's move on, shall we, Steve? Who do you think is going to win?

Speaker 3Well, you have the experience of having played this just once?

Speaker 2Just once.

Speaker 3Okay, so you're thoroughly familiar with the mechanisms, the strategies, the combos, how different, like, I don't know, player powers?

Speaker 2Are there player powers?

Speaker 1It's called Bethos, by the way, this is.

Speaker 3Yeah, the upgrades, you know. the sequence of play, how the game unfolds. So I'm up against that on your side. On my side, I'm barely going to listen to the teach. I've got a lot on my mind.

Speaker 2I'm exhausted. I'm probably going to have a baby crying in the background. So obviously the advantage is on my side.

Speaker 1You can listen to the rest of this show and hundreds of hours of bonus content, including convention reports, in-game bickering and loads more at patreon.com forward slash 5G4D.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. CMYK on Magical Athlete Second Wind

    Nov 20, 202652 minAudio

    Ben talks to James Nathan Spencer and Alex Hague from CMYK about their adventures with Magical Athlete. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Toy Battle - SAMPLE

    Nov 18, 202636 minAudio

    To get the full episode go to https://www.patreon.com/c/5g4d and become a backer. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support. Support the show here

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Joshua Buergel

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    This week's guest is Joshua Buergel, the designer of Fox in the Forest. We talk about design, development, and the most overrated band of all time...but which games did he choose? Become a supporter of this podcast:...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 5G4D News Flash - Christian Kudahl on Magical Athlete-Second Wind

    Nov 12, 202630 minAudio

    Ben sits down with c-designer Christian Kudahl about the new standalone expansion for Magical Athlete. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support....

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Steve Jackson

    Nov 2, 202648 minAudio

    This week's guest is the designer of Munchkin, Ogre, and GURPS, Steve Jackson. We talk about being raided by the government, designing a classic and renown...but which games did he choose? Become a supporter of this...

    Credit the people on this episode