Ben sits down with c-designer Christian Kudahl about the new standalone expansion for Magical Athlete. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support. Support the show here
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Freshly dug from the cold face of the board game world, we bring you. The Five Games for Doomsday Newsflash. So I'm delighted on this Newsflash to be joined by the most prolific game designer who's ever lived. I think at this point he's had more games than Riley Canizia published. This is Christian Koudal all the way from the sunny climes of Denmark. Christian, welcome to the show.
Speaker 2Thank you so much, Ben. Great to be here.
Speaker 1So we're here to talk about, I was browsing BGG the other day and I saw on the hotness the sequel to a game that came out recently, that didn't come out recently, that came out years ago, but there was a new reprint recently that was super, super popular called And now there's been a part two, and this is Magical Athlete. So first of all, what's your experience with Magical Athlete, the first game?
Speaker 2Oh, it's an interesting relationship. Actually, I never played the old one. So the old one, originally it was like a Japanese game that was brought over by Seaman, I think, like 20-ish years ago. And I never played that one, but it always had this sort of mythical status in the industry. You'd hear Tom Vassell or someone be like, oh, this is amazing, and reading about, okay, some kind of roll and move, what? And saw some videos of someone playing. So I had never played and I didn't really know what the rules was. And then eventually I was working
Speaker 2with CMYK on another game and they started talking about this magical athlete stuff. So it turned out they had gotten the rights for that, which is a whole long, complicated story on their own, how that happened, because the designer is a japanese guy who's not very easy to get a hold of um and so so they brought this new version together with richard also i think they got in touch with touch with richard just from him being super active on the btg forums entering well.
Speaker 1He'd he'd revamped the original design right.
Speaker 2Yes i mean so he worked with them for the for the first new release here taking some characters from the old one tweaking them but trying to stay true to the original vision um So we did that together with CMYK. And they knew they wanted to do more stuff for this game. And Richard and I have this kind of relationship where sometimes when he needs an extra set of hands or something, he calls me up and is like, hey, we're doing this project. This is something
Speaker 2you'd be interested in joining. And for me, this was a super interesting possibility. When we first talked about it, the game hadn't come out yet. So I didn't really know it was this huge hit, which, of course, now I think every game designer would be very happy to be on board with any kind of hit of this size. Back then, it was less clear it was the case. But when I got the game and started playing it, it also was one of my absolute favorite games of,
Speaker 2what was that, 2025, I think. I remember I got the box there at Essen 2025. hadn't really come out yet so walking around with that box people were yelling at me in the halls like where did you get that is that magical athlete um and so playing it a bunch and i was lucky enough it became one of my favorites and then we got to working together on the on the sequel box.
Speaker 1So then so then firstly my first question is because it has a different name in germany yes does it have a different name in denmark.
Speaker 2No i think it's just magical athlete in denmark.
Speaker 1And then secondly then, you know, you're a game designer and then when someone approaches you and says, you know, would you like to work on the sequel to this? When you're playing that game, you're not just playing it straightly as a gamer. You're thinking about it when you're playing it. What's the magic to Magical Athlete then? Why is it so good and why has it been so popular.
Speaker 2Do you think? It's a good question. I don't really know, but... There is some... I think they got some... Okay, so clearly it's very surprising because it uses this roll and move mechanism that everyone hates. So you take a game everyone hates and you make it look really weird and funny. I think it's just so clear that the game is stupid that it sort of disarms the people. It's like
Speaker 2you can't even criticize the game for being stupid because you can see on the cover that the game is trying to be stupid. um so somehow all serious gamers including myself we sort of lower our barrier when already when we open the box we see the figures and allow ourselves to have fun and maybe leave this analytical mindset a bit as you describe um feel i mean i will say i feel similar with the game like like flip seven that to i seen it very serious
Speaker 2gamers play and enjoy this game and it somehow puts them in the right state of mind of that they should not expect something very fair. They should just relax and expect something very fun, which I think is what Magical Athlete pulls off so well. I think CMYK also didn't, like the game was not a huge hit when it came out 20 years ago. So I think what they did really well is also sort of put the artwork on the game that shows you, okay, it's this kind of game.
Speaker 1So it's, it's really interesting when people think of Richard Garfield, they think of magic, obviously. And they think of the, the massive sort of the massive institution that is. And I, I think that may lead people to misinterpret what kind of a game designer Richard Garfield is. Richard Garfield is designed so many silly games with lots of randomness and lots of charms. King of Tokyo being a great example. Um, What is there of Richard in the first Magical Athlete,
Speaker 1do you see?
Speaker 2Oh, it's a good question. I mean, I think, as you say, it fits really well with the stuff that he loves. I know he was a big fan of the original. I think he at home had a million custom characters and was running big tournaments and stuff. So I think one thing he does really well is making fun abilities. And usually he's actually not the guy who's super concerned with like a balance or if any weird rule stuff can happen. Like when I work with him,
Speaker 2I'm someone who's much more concerned with those things. Although also trying to let myself relax that a bit and focus more on the fun. So having that game where it's allowed that things are not balanced, it's allowed that things are, that can be a weird situation where maybe you're not quite sure how it resolves, like sort of, being free from those chains allows the stuff he's good at to shine even more. So in a sense, it is actually the perfect match with the way Richard designs.
Speaker 1So looking at the first one then, do you have favorite characters?
Speaker 2Oh, yes, yes. I really like the party animal. That's like the one that draws everyone closer to himself, which is very thematic. And it also... mechanically works nice so he helps a bit the ones in the back he hinders a bit the ones in the front and then gets a boost on how many are on his space so he's like a very social character I think the mouth is also a favorite that's the one where if it lands on exactly one other character it eliminates them so it's like a big drama around that character with
Speaker 2every single role even though in the like you might say oh maybe it just kills everyone but usually it won't so in the grand scheme of things it works out but There's very high tension when playing with that character. Those two are certainly some of my favorites.
Speaker 1The Scoocher is the best. Mechanic, in terms of playing, it's the best. The Scoocher wins every time.
Speaker 2The Scoocher is pretty strong. I think if you speak in terms of power rankings, also the Lovable Loser is very strong. That's the one where if it stays behind, it can score extra points.
Speaker 1Yeah, so for the listeners, the Scoocher is you get to move one space if anyone's power activates.
Speaker 2Yeah. Even that one is like Okay, so what does it exactly mean that someone's power activates if they have like a passive power or something? So this is a game that very much embraces that kind of rule discussion that most games try and make sure that you never run into any weird situations.
Speaker 1And so Richard has spoken a lot about his inspirations for magic. And to some degree, they can be quite surprising. Cosmic Encounter was a big... was a big inspiration. And you see those... That game in particular really doesn't care about balance. It's really the antithesis of Euro design. Have you played that? Does playing something like that inform you going into a project like this?
Speaker 2I have to admit, I've never played Cosmic Encounter, although I've wanted to. I know about the game, so my understanding is in that game, you make all these... wacky special powers and then the group dynamic sort of helps balance it out so if everyone agrees that you have a strong character they're less likely to collaborate with you I mean maybe the thing is if you have that sort of system you need you need some way that it is actually balanced and the way it is in
Speaker 2Cosmic Encounter is by the player dynamics in Magical Athlete it's by the chance of the dice rolls and the chaos happening so even the Scooter will sometimes just not do very well If I look at my own games, other games like Mindbog, for example, also has some kind of wild special abilities. on the characters that are then mitigated by the Mindbug, the fact that the opponent can steal it. So I think, from a design perspective, there's something very strong about if you have a system that allows you to make all kinds of powers and not
Speaker 2worry so much about balance and stuff, and then the system ensures that it will be fine in the end, that's somehow a quite strong recipe.
Speaker 1So then let's talk about Magical Athlete 2. So going into the project, firstly, how much did you play the first one? And secondly, what was your intention with the second one?
Speaker 2I played the first one a lot because it's such a fun game to play with kids. It's an easy game to pull out. Normally, I sometimes have to play games for work, but this is a game that you end up playing much more than would even be needed just because it's such a fun game. In the beginning, there was sort of a grander vision for the second one, which was sort of an idea of having a very
Speaker 2big box with many more characters, maybe some sort of campaign-type elements were things we discussed and experimented a lot with. In the end, we went for something more straightforward, So Magical Athlete Second Wind is just a box like the first one, has two maps like the first one, 36 characters like the first one. So having something that sort of in its form looks a lot like what you already know, when you get it, you're sure how it works,
Speaker 2you won't need to learn anything else. In the end, we deemed that was the best way to go.
Speaker 1I mean, that makes much more sense to me.
Speaker 2It probably does.
Speaker 1Because I think there is a temptation. I think people think that sort of campaign games and stuff are really popular. And in fact, they're pretty niche. From what I've seen, the success of Magical Athlete is retail, is that it sells out in shops super quick. And it's to casually type players. So it's not... A big gloomhaven box with a campaign really defeats the object of what the game
Speaker 1is trying to do, right?
Speaker 2Yeah, I can see that the intention when we discussed campaign stuff was more if you could... Like, you would definitely not want to have the same group of people come together every time. People should be able to go in and out, and it gives some quite neat properties. I won't spoil it too much because I don't know if it's something that will ever end up happening, but... making something that is just like people know, where they immediately know what to do with it, that certainly has a lot of strength, especially with this audience that don't go to board game geek or don't want to learn
Speaker 2a lot of new stuff, but just want some fun new characters and maps.
Speaker 1So I have this theory, right? After The Sopranos, everything became sort of narrative television. Before that, you had things like The X-Files, which had a sort of overarching narrative, but it was basically each episode was self-contained. Monster of the Week. And then everything became an overarching narrative. And I think people are fucking bored of it, frankly. And I see this tendency within board games that everything... I mean,
Speaker 1you look at some Alexander Pfister games that are Euro games. The beauty of Euro games is they're these self-contained, brilliant designs. And they try to leverage a bloody campaign into them. And frankly, it doesn't work. So are you telling me that we can expect Magical Athlete Legacy coming in?
Speaker 2No, no, I'm definitely not. I mean, I would say it was something we had in thoughts. And yeah, no. So I can, yeah. I mean, I can't really say any of this kind of stuff.
Speaker 1Give me a scoop, Christian. Come on.
Speaker 2I don't have a scoop. I mean, I can tell you... I can tell you we're certainly working on more stuff and thinking about where the series can go. We see it as a series that can hopefully have a healthy life for a long time. But the second one was just announced, so there's nothing new to announce yet.
Speaker 1You're not going to forward me your private email correspondence?
Speaker 2Not this time again, because we misused it last time. So....
Speaker 1I just looked at the credits on BGG, and there are three designers credited. There's you, there's Richard Garfield, and there's the original designer from Japan. What input did the original designer have?
Speaker 2Nothing. I mean, he just, like, I've never spoken to him, so he just designed the original game, which is this, like, that is what makes the magic of this whole thing work. But he is, no, it's, so I have not, I have never talked to him.
Speaker 1And so then, what was the working process between you and Richard then?
Speaker 2I mean, for this one, when I came in, he had sort of brainstormed a big pool of characters. So there was a lot of testing and refining those. I made some new designs that came in there. In this box, there's also a handful of designs from the community. People were able to submit their own characters. So Team YK were great at vetting them and picking the ones that seemed promising. We tested them. We tweaked them. And so it's sort of a very iterative thing of playing a lot, tweaking,
Speaker 2being like, this sounds cool. OK, in this race, it actually didn't do anything. Is that OK? Should we change the trigger a little bit so it looks like a quite easy game to create that you just come up with a bunch of special powers and everything will be fun and chaotic but there is a bit of meticulousness to it of trying again and again different combinations of characters and are they impactful enough either yeah um that that sort of stuff to make sure things land in what we believe to be just the right place.
Speaker 1And so was your job more of an editor or were you also creating characters?
Speaker 2No, I was also creating a bunch of stuff. So it was a mix. I think I also wore a bit of a developer's cap of sort of tying together all the strings, but also bidding in with plenty of my own designs and for the new maps and stuff. So definitely also a designer.
Speaker 1And so then what is the criteria for a good designer? character in Magical Athlete?
Speaker 2It's a good question. And I think it's not the same criteria for every character. It's a bit like when you put together your diet that you want sort of a balanced diet. You want the things where you look at them and you're like, wow, that is crazy. But it's also fine to have some that are sort of slow and steady, giving little cool things every time. I'll say what I learned is... we try to have a
Speaker 2lot of the racers that care about other racers, which sounds dumb, but a lot of my initial designs were stuff like, okay, you go normally, but if you roll a one, then you go ten spaces or something, which can be fun and simple, but the game really shines when these characters really care about each other. So like, okay, because I passed him, now he trips, which triggers this other thing, so these two swap, and now this guy starts to turn front, so he's in fact eliminated. Having
Speaker 2these sort of comical chain reactions, I think, is where the game shines. And so it took a while for me to actually get into that groove of designing characters that play into this, and they're a bit like Lego bricks, that they can fit together in all kinds of ways.
Speaker 1And so then, how many characters do you think were created... in this initial run, and for this game, and then how many are in the box?
Speaker 2It's a good question. Maybe we... I mean, with the community ones, there were many, many hundreds. I don't know exactly, but many, many ones. Some were overlapping, and some would clearly not work, and a lot of them were okay, and a lot of them were really good. But if you think of the science, yeah, so maybe it's like 100, 250 between 100 and 150 characters that we actually tried playing around with on the board and then sort of whittled that down to this final set.
Speaker 1And so then, you know, you've designed a lot of games, but this might be the most high profile you've done so far.
Speaker 2It's the first time that a game that I co-designed is on the number one spot of the hotness, for example. This has never been the case for me before.
Speaker 1And so what is that like? Because you started with Mindbug and that enabled you, which is really successful and enabled you to go into the industry. And now I think you've been simmering away, designing lots of games. Because I know you, I see your name a lot on boxes. And now you're doing something that's Hollywood, that's box office, right? Have you noticed that?
Speaker 2What do you mean? If I've noticed that if people know my name?
Speaker 1Yeah, do people start knowing your name now and recognizing you as a designer?
Speaker 2Yes, it's, I think, I mean, I always go to Essen, like most of my year I spent sitting in my basement. typing away my little spreadsheets and uh testing stuff online or sometimes going out and testing but then i go to essen every year to the big speed fair and i've every year i find people know me a bit more i had one moment this year of we had a like i When new games come out, we often have these signing sessions. And sometimes it can be pretty
Speaker 2empty with a new game that doesn't have any fans yet.
Speaker 1Is that completely cringe? Do you feel terrible when that happens?
Speaker 2No, because I think I usually have a co-designer. So at least you're two people sitting there.
Speaker 1So you're sharing the shame together.
Speaker 2So if no one shows up, you just have a nice little talk. I think the better way to do those is to make them sort of demo sessions so like have the designer teach you the game and if you buy it you can get assigned or something this year there was a session for Agent Avenue which has been out for a few years also one of my games that did well and I had this experience of having to it's also a game that has become a lot more popular within the last year I had an experience of going to the booth and I had these halls are very full so I had a hard time
Speaker 2getting there there was like a long line for something it was the TCG hall some kind of promo or something but I had a hard time getting there. I was short on time. Then when I got there, I realized that this long line was to come to me and to get my signature on the box, which was extremely moving of game design. There's this hustle and bustle for many, many years. You work and work and try and fail and try and fail. And so seeing all these people that I have not I've not had that
Speaker 2experience before. A long line of people that were there to get my signature on their little box.
Speaker 1And so does that mean you're going to become a complete arsehole now?
Speaker 2Yes. I think that comes a bit later. I think you have like a honeymoon period where you're like enjoying it and then becoming a bit full of yourself later.
Speaker 1So there's going to come a point I'm going to send you a message asking for an interview, and you're just going to go, who are you?
Speaker 2Did you even win the Golden Geek thingy?
Speaker 1No, it's never going to happen, Christian. So, okay, we're 21 minutes into this, and we actually haven't properly discussed what the game is. So, Magical Athlete, second wind. How is it different from the first one?
Speaker 2It's... I think it's a little wilder. So there are two new maps. The first one has this kind of vanilla map where you just go along. And then there's like a crazy map. This one has kind of two crazy maps. One also has some whopping stuff where you're teleporting back and forth. And the other one is like one of my favorite things in the box. It's like a plain map, but there is a twist. So once you pass the halfway mark, you draw a little card.
Speaker 2They're made to look like the event cards from the old Monopoly games. And some kind of twist happens. And they can be quite wild stuff. So I think the fun and chaos is dialed up a little bit in the second box, which I think makes sense. People have already played the first one. You certainly don't want to make it sort of more vanilla. But it's a box. I think if you played the first one, you can easily imagine what this is. New characters, new maps. With the four, you can now play a race of four games,
Speaker 2each one on a different map, which I think is sort of really nice.
Speaker 1So then give us a rundown of some of your favorite characters in the new box.
Speaker 2Oh, it's a good question. There is Le Saboteur, which is a French saboteur character. It's just like whenever anyone else rolls a three, they move backwards instead of forwards. So you can really just mess with people a lot. Yeah. You have. Okay, one of my favorites is the stepdad. It's this walrus with a mustache. It felt like a stepdad really needed to have a mustache, which he boosts one of
Speaker 2the other players, and then he gets some points if they win. So he's there on the track on his own, but he's actually rooting for his stepkid. But somehow, I love the mechanics of that and the thematic tie-in. A lot of people also really like the hog rider. It's like a guy who's riding a pig, so he moves faster. So you actually put the piece inside this pig piece. But then if someone lands on his space, they can steal the pig from him. And now they are the ones getting that boost. So we tried also playing with
Speaker 2the physicality of the pieces. The first box has the legendary huge baby that takes up the entire space so no one else can stay there. And sort of trying to play around in physical ways is also something we always have in mind when working on new stuff.
Speaker 1And so then, is there a danger? I'm not saying Magic Athlete Second Wind is this, but is there a danger that you end up doing too much to the game and it loses its unique selling proposition, which is its simplicity?
Speaker 2Yes, maybe. I mean, it is a challenge to do these kind of long-running series. We don't know yet if it will be. I, of course, hope so. Like with Mindbug, we've done that for, we've done close to 10 boxes now. And so trying to come up with new stuff that stays simple, but it's still interesting. And it's not like something you've seen before. It does become harder and harder, but you also get better and better at sort of finding the fun little nooks and crannies of the design space.
Speaker 2So I think there definitely is a challenge, but it is also something we're looking at, looking at sort of the average text length that it doesn't grow too much measures like this. But if you have to do 20 boxes or something, then yes, it will be. I will say some games lend themselves better to being expanded than others. If I can use examples from my own catalog, like Mindbug, it has this sort of TCG DNA where you always want new monsters and that is just fun. Whereas a
Speaker 2game like Agent Avenue is much harder to expand because it's sort of a quite closed system If you put in a lot of new agents, it will be impossible to collect three code breakers anymore as you're watering down. And I think Magical Athlete is more on the side of that people are very hungry for new stuff for it. It doesn't feel like a neat, rounded experience. It feels like a crazy box that you want to make even crazier.
Speaker 1And so you're going to put a lot of those ideas into Magical Athlete Legacy then?
Speaker 2I don't... I don't... I'm not sure that's going to happen. But I think something new might... I think something new will probably come for the game at some point.
Speaker 1I love that because the listeners can't see Christian's face, but he's gone red because he's desperately trying to think, how do I answer this question without breaking my NDA? So I think it's fair to say there's more stuff for Magical Athlete in the future.
Speaker 2I don't have an NDA, actually. These guys, they are... for people they might think like okay what's this publisher CMYK they're probably some huge company in a building but it's mainly like three dudes that yeah so like these companies they're often very small behind the scenes.
Speaker 1And are you then very happy that you got the opportunity to work with Richard Garfield again but then work on this sort of big deal.
Speaker 2Yes yes I think for any designer it's you know I mean It's like if Tolkien is like, oh, do you want to make the third Lord of the Rings book? I already made the first two. They're pretty good. Do you want to try to make the third one? I'm like, yes, I want to do that. So yes, it's an amazing opportunity. There is something I've been thinking about lately. If this one becomes really popular, it could be my most successful game.
Speaker 2which is sort of an odd feeling, right? Like some of my other projects, like Mindbug or Agent Avenue, I've been sort of more spearheading. And this one, like with Mindbug, Marvin and I were working on that, and then Richard joined the team. Here, Richard was working on it, and then I joined the team. So it's kind of the opposite way around. And there is something interesting about if that ends up becoming the most successful thing I'm ever a part of. But I certainly won't complain if that's the case.
Speaker 1So then, when can we get hold of Magical Athlete Second Wind?
Speaker 2I believe it's available right now from ordering on the CMYK website. I think they just opened orders yesterday. So it's really new, but you can order it right now. They don't really do crowdfunding or pre-orders or that kind of stuff. They just release the game, boom, and then it's there. Everyone can order it. Eventually, it'll probably also show up on your Amazons or in your local game store or where you normally get games. But I think
Speaker 2right now you can just get it from their website. It supports them directly. So if you're a big fan of the game, it's also something worth considering. Excellent.
Speaker 1Well, Christy Koudal, shooting star of the board game design industry, thank you very much.
Speaker 2Thank you, Fred.
Speaker 1You can support the show by going to patreon.com forward slash 5G4D. Thank you for listening.
Ben talks to James Nathan Spencer and Alex Hague from CMYK about their adventures with Magical Athlete. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support....
To get the full episode go to https://www.patreon.com/c/5g4d and become a backer. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support. Support the show here
This week's guest is Joshua Buergel, the designer of Fox in the Forest. We talk about design, development, and the most overrated band of all time...but which games did he choose? Become a supporter of this podcast:...
This week's guest is the designer of Munchkin, Ogre, and GURPS, Steve Jackson. We talk about being raided by the government, designing a classic and renown...but which games did he choose? Become a supporter of this...
Ben and Uli are joined by Liz Davidson and Geoff Englestein for a live show from Essen Spiel 2026. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support. Support...