Ben sits down to talk to Christian Kudahl about his new partnership with Richard Garfield, Final Titan. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support. Support the show here
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1So I am delighted to have with me the hottest game designer north of Copenhagen. I'm here with Christian Koudle, designer of Mineberg, Cafa, Cotta, Sombrero, Agent Avenue and loads others. Christian, welcome to the show.
Speaker 2So much for him. That's quite an introduction.
Speaker 3Do you think you're punder if I'm actually north or south of Copenhagen.
Speaker 2I think I'm right around the same.
Speaker 1Well, let's just say you're a meter north, so our geographically accurate. So we're here to talk about current game found that's going on. And this is excuse me, I'm drinking a cup of tea. This is with so you.
Speaker 3You.
Speaker 1The thing is, you're a hot game designer now, so you decided that you get a new young game designer on board with you and sort of chewtor him through the game design process. So you've designed I don't know if any one listening to this has heard of the game designer Richard Garfield's, but you designed Final Titan with him first of all. So the listeners have an idea of what the game is. Tell us, tell us about Final Titan.
Speaker 2What is it?
Speaker 3Sure it's a bit of you know, one challenge with this game was that we always found it hard to explain so that it sounds fun, So I'll give it might try and we can see if it works out. So in the game, they're like a whole bunch of these creatures called Titans. They're like all sorts of stuff from mythology or fook tales or fiction row it might be. Then every person is drafting a team of three of them, and then you try to be the least one standing.
Speaker 2The final Titan, as in the title, and.
Speaker 3The way it works is by King of the Hill mechanisms. Someone is in the middle and now the other people have to decide who needs to go in and challenge you in the middle. So when you're up, you can either send one of your titans into fight, or you can sort of pay one card to skip to say ah, I'll.
Speaker 2Wait a bit. So this is reminiscent of the classical carcain.
Speaker 3No thanks, where you have like you don't really want to go in and fight, because if you try to be the less one standing, it's better that everyone else fights it out. So you can be like, I'll skip, and once you pay these cards, they go in a little stack and whoever goes in gets that stack.
Speaker 2So song will be like, Okay, what the hell.
Speaker 3I'll go in and fight this hydra even though it already has three heads and it's in its ultimate form or something.
Speaker 2And then the fight themselves. They are just rolling a die and seeing what happens. So there's like super little choice involved there. So it's it.
Speaker 3Shines on chaos and sort of exciting moments while stuff that can happen. It's a bit in the vein of something like a magical athlete of like a not a game of huge strategy, but a game of more crazy moments and stories to tell afterwards. So one is a bit more game where there's a bit more stuff going on, a bit more crazy things that can happen, and then a really big roster of characters.
Speaker 2Okay, I think that's it. So life strategy, high energy dice game.
Speaker 1So you worked with Richard Garfield before on mine Bug. I interviewed you and the co designer and mind Bug about about it when it came out a long time ago.
Speaker 2Now it's been a few yeares.
Speaker 1Yeah, you have less hair now, yes than you did then.
Speaker 2Yeah, And.
Speaker 1So I assume you got together with Richard through that project. But how did you come up with the project of deciding to do Final Titan together.
Speaker 3Yeah, it's it was. We often emailed it together and just discuss all kinds of stuff like what we like in games, and let this long thread of like it.
Speaker 2It's a pretty.
Speaker 3Fun school of games in sort of watching something crazy and exciting unfold and then having some way of interacting with it. If you don't have anywhere exacting with it, it's then people will discuss if it's actly given, not too neat, some way that the players can do something, But the main is actually watching the fun thing happen.
Speaker 2And we discussed a bit back and forth, and then I was sort of inspired and.
Speaker 3Made the initial prototype and showed it to Richard and he was When making games, often the initial prototype is not very good, but for this one it actually started up being pretty fun because the sort of spectacle was already there. And then so Richard he really liked that he was in Boss, so we decided to do together. And when he gets excited about something, he really puts us all into it, So I think he basically took over the project for like a few months to do
Speaker 3like a million different characters and mechanisms and stuff, sort of really exploring that space deeply. We also quite early got in touch with Nolabs. Marmon was also in one of those early play tests, and he was just like, I like it. Let's do it too, Let's get the band back together again, so to speak, like we did for and that was actually also of mine, like because I have gone so well for mind Buck.
Speaker 2So this was very early, but as a designers were flattering if someone wants to publish your game very early.
Speaker 3Of course, he also wanted to end up in its best possible home, so.
Speaker 2Discussed with Richard, like, okay, not lock. They did a great job with mine book.
Speaker 3They're also, especially back then there's still a kind of small company, so will they really have the muscle to lift this thing. Richard particularly had a strong vision wall. He really wanted there to be one hundred titles in the box, which is like, it's kind of a crazy number.
Speaker 2I think most companies.
Speaker 3During this game would put twenty thirty, maybe maybe thirty five because the game would be perfectly fine then. But he really didn't want to skim on anything. He and or like hit a certain price point or something you know, he just wanted the game to be as cool as it could be. So we were like, hey, not okay, we want it, but we really want to have one hundred times. And man was sort of crazy enough to be up for that and be like, yeah, sure will figure that out right.
Speaker 2You know, for a game like this, artwork cost is quite a big deal.
Speaker 3I don't know the exact numbers, but even one piece of art can easily cost a few hundred euros just for for any game. So when you want to do like hundred big, high quality detailed portraits, it's it's a big expenditure for a small company.
Speaker 2And so I think, without knowing the detailed finances, I think it has been a big bet for a lab. They really believed in this thing.
Speaker 1So how is it working with with Richard Garfield? Because you know he's a big name. He he doesn't have to design game. Frankly, I've I've seen how much magic the gathering cells. So he doesn't have to design game. What what does he bring to a project?
Speaker 2A lot of stuff. He's obviously super experienced.
Speaker 3And he's I think something I learn from him is like he's probably a bit more brave than me.
Speaker 2Of like shrying out crazy things.
Speaker 3I'm always like thinking about okay, but the simple like the German casual player who's buying this game, will they really be able.
Speaker 2To understand it?
Speaker 3And he's just he's not so concerned with okay, will this create a potentially in one percent of the cases a weird rules thing, or will be a bit counter onto it to He's just really focused on, like what is the maximum number of fun we can put into this box? So being a bit brave there and doing kind of crazy stuff. I think that's a lot of what he's brought into this that has made it so good.
Speaker 1And so what do you bring to the partnership.
Speaker 3It's a good question. Al it's a bit hard to say with yourself. I think I do it bring a bit of the other stuff, So like like trying to make sure we have a sort of solid rules foundation and the things that don't get too out of hand. Maybe our fact will only have to be ten pages and one hundred pages.
Speaker 2And sort of I think my onnest, the thing I'm good at is.
Speaker 3Trying to squeeze as much fun as possible out of very little extra rules overhead or new mechanisms introduced and stuff, So maybe I'm more.
Speaker 2Exploring sort of that end of the of the swimming pool, and.
Speaker 1It feels like it feels like a very it feels like a kind of mash up of King of Tokyo magic, and then when you mentioned one hundred Titans, this feels very cosmic encharacter. You know, a box, a box full of stuff, and everything's about variety. Do you see those inspirations and did you discuss games like that during the development of it?
Speaker 3Yes, I mean, interestingly, for me, the biggest inspiration when making the very first prototype was Magical Athlete, despite at that point I had never played Magical Athlete because it was like a twenty year old obscure game that I didn't know anyone who had, so just just based on my sort of rough understanding of that that, Okay, you get some characters and then you do the fun resolving thing. King of Tokoyo was actually not something I thought a lot about, but a lot of people have drawn comparison.
Speaker 3Also because Richard designed both, I think that one is a bit more family oriented. Final time, I would say, like, get to go a bit more wild and crazy, and sometimes.
Speaker 2Someone will do something that you feel like it shouldn't be allowed.
Speaker 3Was King of Tokyo is a bit more controlled, and with the special power cut it does get a bit wild, but that that's sort of where I see them.
Speaker 1And so then how was the design process? Because so anyone who knows me will corroborate this. I'm an asshole, which means I'm very difficult to work with. And if people take stuff I've done and try and change it, I get I throw my dummy out of the pram and I get very very angry. So I tend to work alone because I mean I can, I can have a fight in an empty room, but I work better with myself. How was the How was the design process
Speaker 1with Richard? Was there someone who took a leadership role or was it or was it a sort of equal partnership.
Speaker 3I feel like there's a lot to impact there. Maybe you should make an episode about yourself.
Speaker 1Yeah, maybe maybe I should get therapy.
Speaker 2There was some it was.
Speaker 3It would usually be someone who took chart, although it changed a bit who it was. So there would often be for a few months which it would be doing.
Speaker 2A ton of stuff with the game, and I'll let him run with it.
Speaker 3At some point he'll be like, Okay, now I don't have so much time the next few months. So he gives to me and I run with it, and we also work with nerd labut it's also a ton of development on on it, so for some time they would run with it. So we took a bit of terms while of course also play system together all of us. Richard's it's rare that he will sort of fight very hard for a specific thing, you know. I think we had it just one or two times in the game. Sorry,
Speaker 3in the process, I'm thinking of the stuff I thought really hard for. I think we are both kind of chill dudes who are like, Okay, if the players are enjoying this and not enjoying this, then okay, we can go with that thing just once in a while. You have sort of a very specific vision, so that the thing that didn't work, maybe it just needs a bit of tweaking in it. It doesn't actually get cut. Nerd Lab also had a big impact on how the game turned out to be, so they they pushed a lot
Speaker 3for the outside, like the slightly more advanced, slightly more nerdy direction, so that the characters became a bit more complex, you know, They had this idea that every character should have an ultimate attack, which like and which I knew, we were a bit more skeptical, like, sounds cool, but I'm not sure if there's design space for it. Like the ultimate attacks, we sort of have them already, but everyone would just kill the other person with the ultimate attack, so they weren't really personalized for the character, and that
Speaker 3served some nice That did some nice stuff gameplay wise, because once in a while someone else would be really charged up, so it's nice that everyone does have a little chance to just instant kill them.
Speaker 2But when we finally.
Speaker 3Were like, okay, let's try these ultimate attacks, it actually just worked super well. So I think Nolub also did a great job of making the game better, even when occasionally I was skeptical of the stuff they wanted to do. When we tried it usually turned out to work, but it didn't mean the game became a bit heavier. Then, for example, how I would have initially enditioned.
Speaker 1It and so on the way, then how how heavy easy it? Because you've been longlisted for the Spielders Yours agent Avenue was Spielders Yours, right.
Speaker 3Yeah, and mine book was long listed for the Kenneshpiel Kenshiel.
Speaker 1So sort of how heavy is it? And do you think you've got a chance? I mean, it doesn't sound like a spieled as yours game, but do you think you've got a chance for Kennishpiel when it's.
Speaker 3I mean from the weight, it would probably be more in the Kennishpield territory. I it's not your sort of super typical German game. But then again, if I look at the games that are in the Spield, I think they're also quite quite broad.
Speaker 1This.
Speaker 3Yeah, I had sort of expected and hoped Hustrick to be there, which is the game.
Speaker 2I also really like that one was long listed.
Speaker 3But it's also been in this family of you do something and then you watch a crazy spectacle unfold. So if it would be anywhere, it would probably be in the kidnus Field wave. It's it's a bit triggered with this game because I have also played it with children, so that like you just need that the person who owns the game knows the rules and people can play and kids can have fun and stuff even without knowing all the the ruse details. And so it's sort of the game where if the person who owns it knows
Speaker 3the stuff, then you're actually fine to play with anyone.
Speaker 1So one of the designers a cosmic encounter, and I'm paraphrasing here because he didn't use this word, and I can't remember the word he did use, but basically he said, Balances for pussies. And you know this is a game with one hundred characters in it. Yes, yes, and cosmic encounter. Part of the joy your cosmic encounter is that it isn't balanced. Sometimes you'll just get a broken combo and the game will just accelerate. Does Final Titan have this or have you brought your your boring, constricting European sensibilities
Speaker 1into it.
Speaker 2Ah, this is such a it's such an interesting topic. I think. I think I'm telling the country.
Speaker 3I think Balance is slightly underrated in that I think, what if people say they don't like Balance. I feel you can say if you disagree, but I feel what they actually say.
Speaker 2Is that they like stuff to be allowed to.
Speaker 3Be wild and weird and get closey sometimes to the game like this where you have like dice rolling all the time. It's it's huge on randomness. I think what you want from Balance is like you don't want, for example, to have one character who is always terrible, because then no one's going to pick that character and the game will be sort of less fun for it.
Speaker 2But you can have some that like.
Speaker 3Seven games out of eight they are quite bad, but then that eighth game they go crazy and kill everyone and win the whole game. In a sense, this is still sort of a kind of balance, so we have sort of a window we're trying to land within. There's some people on the nertlib team who are very good also on the software side, like they also make the mind block app. So they did some simulations of like running all these because it's a lot to test by hand, and there's big varieties. So even if you test the same matchup ten times, it's not clear you get a correct picture. So here they tested all of these hundred
Speaker 3times against each other a bunch of times. I know that the stats and helped us identify, Okay, this character is actually never really beating anyone that probably needs a bit of a buff, and so we did. What we like to see is when characters have very skewed matchups, so like, Okay, this character is really good against half the cast and really bad against half the cast for example, that's actually really healthy for the game, because the game is a lot about sort of going in at the right time, getting that good matchup. You say, Okay, this
Speaker 3guy who's really strong in the middle, but Mike, I hear, will actually have a distinct advantage, So this is the time I should be going in.
Speaker 2Or maybe I skip first and let everyone else skip and then I go in.
Speaker 3So there has to be some balance, although the players probably won't notice because, like from the reviews, are also father say, oh, this game is not balanced at all. And I think what they mean is just that that it gets to be wild and all, not necessarily that they lost, but just that sometimes one character is beating everyone.
Speaker 2But the thing they might not.
Speaker 3See is that the next time that character will not beat everyone. Tory, there was a prefer redly. So it's a little bit important, but not the most important.
Speaker 1So I'm looking at the game phane page, and I'm looking at the art, and it's there's a so the big debates around AI art and should you use it in all of that, and there's a there's a disclaimer on the nerd lab page that said this project project supports real artists something when you when you look at the when you look at the game now from that initial prototype that you you knocked together, how how exciting is it to see it in its sort of final form.
Speaker 2It's so much fun.
Speaker 3Actually, for this game in particular, the first prototype was like the I think the ugliest I've ever had because it had no artwork. It just basically had a few numbers written on the car. They will not even send her. So one of my biggest pleasures in the development process of game is seen the characters come to life. Because when you have just a spreadsheet, that's it. Okay, one when you roll this, there's two damage. When you rule this, there's three demons in a real.
Speaker 2And then seeing oh, it's this cool ninjaka.
Speaker 3Or something it like, you know, the really kid inside me who likes watching morning cartoons filled with action sometimes from Asian countries get very exciting.
Speaker 2About seeing these.
Speaker 3So for me, it's one of the biggest splasures of gaming sciences I've seen seeing characters come to life. In this game, we were lucky enough to have a big cast. I think it's like six different artists or maybe even more so. That's a big variety in sort of art and style. It's not something you normally see in the game, but this game with this kind of multiverse type theme, it seemed like a very cool fit that you could have some more comic book style artist or some realistic or dark artists, or doing very bright positive imagery.
Speaker 2I think this comes to really nicely.
Speaker 1So then to wrap up, then can you give us the vital statistics? How much does it cost? What kind of expansion stuff can you get? And also when can people actually have it on their tables? And I get the feeling that Christian is frantically googling the game fan page as I asked.
Speaker 3Question, I haven't it already because you so, as a just a bit behind the scenes as a game designer, we don't always know this stuff. It can be quite surprising, but especially during many different games, who are thinking more about the games or how they look or how they play, and less about this side.
Speaker 1You're an artist, dear, you don't want to get your hands dirty with money. You've gotta have an uncorrupted brain.
Speaker 3They are important too to be able to have this as a job. So the game is still in late pledge on Game found so you can go there. The sort of the stand up version is the challenge of the edition of thirty nine euros. Now I am looking at the game found page and you can go up to this the big version, the ultimate version that comes with two different expansions. That comes with one of them is mind Bag theme to bring a lot of the mind Back characters into this universe, and the other is
Speaker 3themed around guards that I use these special artifacts. That one, and this edition also has component upgrades and stuff.
Speaker 1And you get dice trays with dice and you.
Speaker 3Can't even there to see the sedule's inside. That one is eight nine euros. That's sort of the the big one. It comes out if everything goes like we hope, it will come out of esson screen where it will be for sale.
Speaker 2At some point. It should also be in your store.
Speaker 3I don't know exactly when it will be install It probably varies a lot with where you are and sort of what localizations partners pick up the.
Speaker 2Game for agent revenue.
Speaker 4I think it took about about one year from the release of Spiel before it came out in the States, So if you Understates and sounds interesting, you can consider checking out the game fant page.
Speaker 3I think some of the stuff like The a's a promo peck with a bunch of extra characters and stuff, so if you are a completionist, it's also the place where you can be sure to get.
Speaker 2All the stuff.
Speaker 1Excellent Well, Christian Koudal, Denmark's hottest designer, both in the way you look and the games you make. Frankly, frankly, I think you're ten times better than Aska Grana Rude. Oh, thank you very.
Speaker 2Much, sweet music to my Yes, thank you, Ben. Always a pleasure.
Ben talks to James Nathan Spencer and Alex Hague from CMYK about their adventures with Magical Athlete. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support....
To get the full episode go to https://www.patreon.com/c/5g4d and become a backer. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support. Support the show here
This week's guest is Joshua Buergel, the designer of Fox in the Forest. We talk about design, development, and the most overrated band of all time...but which games did he choose? Become a supporter of this podcast:...
Ben sits down with c-designer Christian Kudahl about the new standalone expansion for Magical Athlete. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/five-games-for-doomsday--5631121/support....
This week's guest is the designer of Munchkin, Ogre, and GURPS, Steve Jackson. We talk about being raided by the government, designing a classic and renown...but which games did he choose? Become a supporter of this...