Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Filmmaking Conversations Podcast with Damien Swaby

Filmmaking Conversations Podcast with Damien Swaby artwork

Ep 252: A Legal Architect’s Journey Through Hollywood, Integrity, and Innovation

Aug 11, 202552 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Episode Summary: Marc's career is anything but ordinary. Before becoming a powerhouse entertainment attorney at Fox Rothschild LLP, he studied film at the University of Pennsylvania and UCL, made three documentaries - including the Sundance Special Jury Award-winning After Innocence - and helped change legislation in multiple states. In this in-depth conversation, Marc opens up about how he navigated the worlds of law and filmmaking, and the lessons he’s learned from representing clients ranging from Hollywood legends like Joe Pesci to first-time filmmakers breaking out at Venice. What You’ll Learn in This Episode: 🎥 Breaking In - How a passion project about the wrongfully convicted became a Sundance hit and changed state laws. ⚖ Balancing Careers - Producing films while practicing law at major firms. ✍ Why Contracts Matter - The dangers of handshake deals and how to protect your creative work early. 🎯 Negotiation Tactics - Why respect, clear communication, and calm articulation win deals in a small industry. 🖥 Streaming’s Impact - How Netflix’s early spending spree changed the game, and why Apple’s theatrical push is both exciting and limited. 🌍 Global Deals - How to approach cross-border financing, tax credits, and presales in today’s market. 💡 Advice for Creatives - What young lawyers, filmmakers, and financiers must understand before jumping in. 🔍 Case Studies - Behind-the-scenes legal challenges on The Irishman, The Hunting Ground, The Eagle Huntress, Winter’s Bone, and The Kids Are All Right. Guest Bio: Marc is an entertainment attorney in the 40-member Entertainment & Sports Law Department at Fox Rothschild LLP. A filmmaker, his unique career has spanned Sundance premieres, award-winning documentaries, high-profile distribution deals, and complex cross-border financing arrangements. His clients include top-tier talent, rising stars, and independent financiers shaping the future of content. Key Links & Resources Mentioned: Fox Rothschild LLP - Entertainment Law After Innocence (Sundance Special Jury Award) Unraveled, The Irishman, Winter’s Bone, The Kids Are All Right The Hunting Ground, The Eagle Huntress, Dead Man’s Wire (Venice 2024) Use Promo Code "FILMMAKINGSWABY" for all my deals or just click the link: 25% Off More Labs https://www.morelabs.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off Strong Coffee Company https://strongcoffeecompany.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 15% Off Tussle https://www.tusslegear.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off Eric Javits https://ericjavits.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 25% Off Quantum Energy Square https://quantumsquares.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off Long Table https://longtablepancakes.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off HyperNatural https://hypernaturalstyle.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off wearplayground https://wearplayground.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 15% Off STAND+ https://www.standshoes.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 10% Off Molly Bz https://mollybz.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 41% Off Cozy Earth https://cozyearth.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You are listening to the IFH podcast Network. For more amazing filmmaking and screenwriting podcasts, just go to ifhpodcastnetwork dot com.

Speaker 2Mark H. Simon is not your typical attorney. A veteran transactional lawyer, an award winning three time feature documentary filmmaker, he has built a career at the intersection of legal position and creative vision. His journey is marked by unique duality, from producing the award winning documentary After Innocence, a film that exposed flaws in the justice system and earned him a spot at the Sundance Film Festival, to serving as a trusted advisor to some of Hollywood's biggest names. While

Speaker 2his work on landmark projects like Martin Scorsese is the irishman navigating the legal issues concerning the groundbreaking use of the aging technology is widely celebrated, his most vital and often own overlook contribution lies in his mastery of multifaceted complexities that power the entertainment industry. Here's the architect behind the deals, the one who understands that the creative vision is only as strong as its legal and financial framework. This isn't just about reviewing contracts. It's about structuring development, financing,

Speaker 2and production deals, as well as protecting intellectual property rights and forging the distribution deals that bring projects to life on the global stage. On this episode, we dive deep into his career and his philosophy on negotiation and the importance of integrity in a cutthroat industry. Yet really for an insider's look at the deals that shape the industry and the unseen machinery of the entertainment world and one

Speaker 2of its most respected arpentects, Mark, You've had such a dynamic career blending law and filmmaking. What drew you to entertainment law and how did your journey begin?

Speaker 1I would say I have an unorthodox path into the film and entertainment law crossover. When I went to law school, I had had some experience in the film business previously for the two years between college and law school, and I had studied film at the University of Pennsylvania and even in your hometown at UCL. I studied film and American history at UCL, which was a really really neat

Speaker 1experience to study it across the pond, but American filmmaking one card. In law school, I knew I was interested in entertainment and criminal law. What I knew was that criminal law felt very narrow to me and that the entertainment field felt very broad. In law school, I worked for the Innocence Project, which exonerates the wrongfully convicted with DN eight, which today still remains a big passion project of mine, and back when I was in law school,

Speaker 1there was very little attention about what happens to these individuals after they are exonerated. I was graduating law school, going to a law firm and decided that I wanted to make a documentary about what happens to the wrongfully convicted after they're exonerated. And five years later that film premiered at the Fundamn Film Festival. It was called After Innocent, It won a special Jury Award, It went on to be shortlisted for an OSCAR, and it changed legislation in

Speaker 1many states, bringing compensations for the wrongfully convicted. So that was my entry point to the fact that all of a sudden, I was an associate practicing entertainment law and having produced a documentary. And then from there the lawyers at my firm embraced the fact that I had made a film instead of you know, being confused and opposing the fact that this attorney was making a film invited

Speaker 1me to make an other because they weren't trying to get they were all trying to get their kids into preschool in Manhattan, which is also like London, quite competitive. Then the next thing you know, I'm a lawyer and I've made two documentaries, and then I made a third documentary, and then all of a sudden, I was an attorney in the entertainment business with quite a lot of experience both as a filmmaker and have a lawyer. And here we are some years later.

Speaker 2Amazing your first entry into the world of film, and you ended up with a Sundance Jury Award. I mean, who else has that? That's brilliant.

Speaker 1It was a fortunate experience. But I can tell you, in large part why it happened in to any of the young listeners.

Speaker 3It's the old hell.

Speaker 1That people tell you when you're passionate about something and you're laser focused and you put the time and effort into it, good thing happened. And for me, nothing else existed other than bringing attention to the wrongfully convicted. And you know, through hell or high water, as I say, I was going to get that film made, and that's a lot of what it was about. And you know, it was a privilege to bring attention to the heroic individuals.

Speaker 2So how did you balance doing that whilst being a lawyer.

Speaker 1Well, by the time we got to the third documentary, which I skipped for time, but very briefly, the law firm that I was at called Dryer LLP. The firm imploded because the head of the firm, the now infamous name Mark Dreyer, was involved in a PONDI scheme. He it was his own ponding team. Five days he was the biggest white collar criminal American history. For me, Off overtook him five days later. When that film came out,

Speaker 1it was called Unraveled. I owned the Mark under house arrest from the day he played guilty to the day he was sentenced. And I directed and produced that one. Like the second film. When it came out, you know, the press would day, so what is your next film? And I would say, I'm not making another film until I get a wife and a life in no particular order. That, Damien, is how I balanced that. I at the time did not have a family, did not have children, and my

Speaker 1life was my two brains. You know, one with the analytics side representing filmmakers, and the other was making films. But I consciously and intentionally after the third film hung up the filmmaker hat and now I just proudly represent the people in the industry and companies in the industry.

Speaker 2And why exactly is having a wife and having a family so important for you, especially at that stage in your life.

Speaker 1Oh well, there's the funny answer that has a bit of furiousness to it, and then there's the more profound answer, the funny answer that has a bit of seriousness to it for your filmmaker fans out there, And as I alluded to as it relates to my first film, after Innocence, when you're a filmmaker, you're all encompassed. Some people might say there's narcissistic tendency, and I recognized that in myself,

Speaker 1and I just thought I can't continue this. And also I wasn't willing or didn't believe that I was gonna take the foot that was on the legal side and step it over to the full filmmaking side and commit my life to that. So having that straddle and believing that I was a probably a better deal maker than I was a filmmaker that allowed that decision to occur. The more profound answer is that I felt at that

Speaker 1time it wasn't really the a balanced life, and that a balance life is giving yourself to others and family and children, and it's not all just about the work. And so that allows me to ease into the representation side of my career. And people sometimes say, do I miss it making the films? And I'm very comfortable in my representation life, and clients give me to give notes on Fizzle, to give notes on deckth to give notes

Speaker 1on and I'm very often involved in the creative process through them, and I get my fulfillment in that respect.

Speaker 2It's very great of you to say that, because a lot of the times filmmakers, especially ones who start out and have an incredible success, sorry, lose sight of family, friends, loved ones, potential wife and things like that. But you seem to be very level headed and were able to see the important things other than just filmmakings in life. You've all still worked at several top firms before landing at Fox. Roth styled what experiences along the way helped you shape your comment practice.

Speaker 1The Fox Orrock child I'm at a department that we have about forty entertainment attorneys, which are a rather large department. When I first started out, the entertainment attorney group that I was working with was fairly sparse, and it allowed me to have a lot of independence and entrepreneurial spirit to go out and build a practice that was positive. The negative was I did not have a wealth of mentors internally, like my associates coming up now have great mentorship.

Speaker 1It's very intentional. So ironically, my best takeaway in my early years was dealing with my quote unquote adversaries on the other side of the deals, learning from them, learning their style, learning how they approached things, and understanding if there was an area that they sensed or I actually admitted was a new area, a new issue, navigating with them the point so something like, well, I'm not familiar

Speaker 1with this issue or this argument that you're making. Can you articulate it for me? Can you explain to me of your thought process here? And so I would sum up my early years as my best mentors being the individuals that I was negotiating against.

Speaker 2That's a very interesting way to look at So what exactly were you learning? Can you tell us one or two things.

Speaker 1Certainly I would. I think a fundamental philosophical and conceptual conceptual point that I learned early that absolutely reflect my practice today is that this is a very small community and you're not going to win by I don't know what language we're allowed to use on this podcast, but you're not going to win in this progression being an asshole. You're going to winning this profession be respectful of your counterparts,

Speaker 1articulating the issues, explaining your perspective, and explaining why you think your perspective prevails over their perspective. I found that again dealing with those adversaries, it was the ones that approached things respectfully and had thought out their answers and weren't giving just urf throwways and becoming combatible. Those were the folks that I wanted to emulate as I grew in the business and today, whenever there's a frustrating negotiation

Speaker 1of frustrating deal point, I really really try, not always easy, but really try to win myself in and rather going to the anger mode, the short mode, the explosive mode, go to the articulation mode, and really try to explain why another perspective isn't the best answer. I just did that via email. I had to Snario where a counterpart was being very terse and short and essentially not looking

Speaker 1to embrace an issue that I was trying to put forth for my client and wouldn't park it out, wouldn't get on the phone, which is another thing that I had learned back in the day, the importance of conversation and communication, and so you know, rather than getting into an email loar, I just bullet pointed out why I thought their perspective is not accurate and why my perspective benefits both them. Up now, I haven't gotten their answer yet, so I'm curious to see if they come around to

Speaker 1my side of thinking, which I sincerely believe is a win win for both. So that'll be our equal conversation.

Speaker 2And for those on Familia, what does an entertainment lay actually do? And what I mean by that is a lot of people listening our waar, but most are creatives and they work in television and film or aspired to a cinematographers right as directors, actors and so forth. But what do you actually do in layman terms?

Speaker 1So first I'll give my tip to the creative out there. Very often I come across very different types and categories of filmmakers and creatives out there, from the inexperience to the legendary. I represent a broad spectrum. Often in the years, I've come across folks that say, you know, we just don't have the money. You know, we're just starting out, so we're just doing it on a handshake or on napkin, And I always say that is not good invest in

Speaker 1that opportunity cost Get a professional to look at that understanding between you and your partner, because if that thing that you guys are building together become successful, very often people with the best of intentions when they look back, they each have a different understanding of what they agreed to. So it doesn't have to be complicated. But you know, agents and lawyers can be very helpful. It's setting forth

Speaker 1and it can be a very basic term sheet one or two or three pages. What the intentions are of the parties, who owns the piece of property, who's going to make the decision making, how are the fees going to work, how is the back end going to work, all of the things, so you know, to your audience, I really really want to emphasize the importance of when something seems small, it's really still important to get it, to get it put down on paper and have an understanding. Now, in terms of what entertainment attorneys do and what I do,

Speaker 1it's a vast ecosystem, So I like break it down between category. So there's music entertainment attorneys and they're film and TV. Now I call it really content entertainment attorneys. I'm on the content side. So if you ask me a detailed question about the music industry and music royalties, I'm not going to be a lot of help. It's like I'm the orthopedist. Don't ask me about the the guycology question because I'm not expertise. So you have you

Speaker 1have music, and you have content. You have litigators, and you have transactional attorneys. The litigators are involved in dispute and or dispute resolution on the transactional side, like me a deal life. I'm in private practice, so I'm not working for a studio representing actors and content creators, writers, directors in helping them get their bills made, their projects sold. And there's also clear into attorneys. So for your documentarians out there, my firm, for example, we will pre clear

Speaker 1it's called pre publication will clear that documentary for fair use and for defamation and all of those issues. But you know, most to thinkly, I'm someone who helped navigate creatives while they're trying to develop their properties, buyant their properties, produce their properties, and then get their projects out into the world dire exploitation and marketing.

Speaker 2Could you walk us through a typical negotiation for a film or TV project.

Speaker 1Well, there's no typical. First is the cookie cutter independent model has an original idea, not based on IP. It's an original script they wrote, so they own it. And then they're going to go out and independently raise financing for their film. And they're going to do that maybe through equity. You know, people who are investing in their business, which happens to be the production of the film. And

Speaker 1sometimes there can be grants or fiscal sponsors to taking money that's not recouped bill. They've written their script, they raised their money, they're now ready to shoot. By the way, I wish it was this easier. Right in two minutes, they now have a movie. We will navigate the production. So everything as simple as the location and appearance releases and actor agreements. Do you know, the more for bigger films, the more complicated issues that involve lenders and completion guaring

Speaker 1toward and collection accounts. But at the end of the day, it's your your writer deals, your directing deals or actor deals or producing agreements. Everything helped produce it. As then once it's made and hopefully we're going to Thundance or we're going to can or we're going to Venef or even you know, a more modest festival, then that that the deal navigation, that the distribution navigation, and you know, we're in a very changing landscape of distribution. But it's helping to navigate those options that the filmmaker. I don't

Speaker 1let's not use the word options. TH's opportunities that the filmmaker has. Sometimes it's the golden goose. You know, you're at a big festival and some of the big buyers are interested in you. And sometimes it's far more modest. You're not at those big festivals, and you have to navigate a type of self release or a digital release or an educational release. And my team and I are able to help navigate those choices and make the best fields for the project, for the financiers and for the filmmaker.

Speaker 2And your client list includes everyone from Added Baldwin to Joe Pesky. How do you approach representing such a diverse group of personalities and needs.

Speaker 1Well, certainly referencing back to the early part of our conversation and the fact that I come from a filmmaking background, I have great respect and appreciation for the creative process for standing out on that ledge, for taking that risk, for coming up with that original idea, and having the real advocacy for that client, you know, whether it's a director, whether it's a writer. I have a client who I'm

Speaker 1going to owe him. I'm gonna say his name because it's a phenomenal story. I have a writer client named Austen Colodney whose first feature is going to venice this for fall. It's called dead Man's Wire and Gus van Zan directed it. Often prior to this film was literally cleaning cages at the La Zoo to make ends meet. So when you have a creative client that is doing all that he can to realize his creative vision and

Speaker 1then you know, working at the La Zoo, I don't know how you can't be passionate to represent them and get the best deal and be a strong advocate. So whether it's a celebrity or a legendary celebrity like Joe Peshi, or you know, it's an up and comer, it's like really in my DNA. And because I've made films, I just understand the difficulty and challenges and you know, to me, it's like a privilege to be in the represent representation game and help these individuals exceed, you know, in the

Speaker 1deal and professionally.

Speaker 2And you mentioned you've made films. What exactly inspired you to make documentaries like After Innocence.

Speaker 1After Innocence, It was certainly the individuals, you know, the stories of these heroes, I think alter just growing up and having an understanding of the Holocaust and people being imprisoned for something they didn't do and being able to survive that and have the perseverance and the persistence. It was just something as the young child, always resonated with me when I learned about the Holocaust, and I just

Speaker 1it was so unfathomed ball that people were put into these cancer and so you transition that to wrongful conviction in American prisons, and it's literally, you know, the unimaginable. There's been films and books about it, the people who languished for decades or a crime that they didn't commit, and sometimes the most enous crimes. I felt that it was my duty to bring a spotlight to these individual stories and help their journeys. So, you know, it was

Speaker 1less intellectual and more emotional for me to and and then there I was making a movie. And as I said earlier, it's that passion and that determination that pushes those doors open.

Speaker 2And you've worked on The Irishman, Winter's Bone and the Kids Up? All right, can you share the behind the scenes legal complexities or one or two of them at least involved in bringing those projects to life?

Speaker 1Sure? I think The Irishman is a good example because as your fans, hey remember, as your audience may remember, there's that daging technology that we make the actors you know, younger. And this was, you know, even though it was just a handful of years ago, this was before AI was taking over the conversation where you know, now a lot of my conversation and my research is about AI perspectively

Speaker 1and leaning into it. There, it was very protective because if we are giving access to Joe image and likeness or digital modification. I wanted to ensure the protection of that data. And that was one, you know, very very interesting issue on the documentary side, there's always thorny and

Speaker 1interesting issues there. I'm trying to think of what one lily interesting one would be. It's more of like a war story, but on the hunting ground that Kirby Dick directed that dealt with college campus assaults. It was released by CNN Films. At the time, we were having weekly calls with the Standard in Practice as group of CNN because you have a lot of pressure from the universities

Speaker 1about this film that's talking about, you know, assault on their campuses. So CNN was under a lot of pressure about how those stories were told, and the filmmakers were under a lot of pressure to tell their stories unfiltered, and so that was a very interesting process. Currently, I you know, I represent Sharmino be Chenoi, who the two time winning filmmaker from Pakithan who asked her documentary s

Speaker 1directed very successfully Miss Marvel and then got a lot of studio interest. And this has all been reported so I can talk about it, including from Lucasfilms and the film Brilliant for Paramount. So the other interesting part or another interesting component of my professional life is that crossover. You know, a filmmaker who crosses over from the documentary medium to the you know, big budget feature medium, and that's equally exciting.

Speaker 2Today, I could imagine there's not too many that I've spoken to that I've done that. So for you to work to someone like that must have been very, very exciting for you. I can certainly understand that. And the Eagle Huntress and the sentence above critically acclaimed what was your role in those and how do you support filmmakers beyond just contracts?

Speaker 1So the Eagle Hunter is an interesting one because I really packaged that project, which means that I literally saw that the sivil reel for it. The filmmaker Otto Bell came to me and he said, Hey, I think I have a project that's really interesting, you know, will you take a look, And he sent me the sizzle reel, which was this young teenage girl from Mongolia going to

Speaker 1capture her eagle and then to train it, the eagle to be a hunter, and she left the Eagle Hunter and it was the most captivating fizzle reel I had ever seen. And I told him and so I helped bring in the producing team, the executive producing team, and the financing. And I served in that project as an executive producer in addition to being a lawyer. So that you know that film was an extraordinary experience from at Sundance.

Speaker 1It was released by Sony Pictures Classics. You're hoping for an Oscar nomination, but we didn't make it, and that's how they pick. You crumbled sometimes, But that was another another good one.

Speaker 2And with the Ryanzol streamers and digital platforms, how entertainment deals evolved over the last.

Speaker 1Decade, Well they're still evolving, you know. On the positive side, I repworsent a lot of content creators for a company. This is a very American company, but it called Friday Beers and it's like, instead of college humor, it posts college humor. And the way that deal structure works is it's almost like old Hollywood. So the company engages their

Speaker 1their talent, both writers and on air and on camera talent in like employee and agreements like the way the old studios just and would work. And because of the rise of digital explication, it is short form content and it's very successful and the company's growing and my clients are getting a lot of acclaim and recognition, and then we their agent and the attorneys are able to over these individuals and the more traditional content and they're writing

Speaker 1for long form epathodic and for features, and they're getting branding opportunities. So you know, something like that certainly did not exist a decade ago, and it's exciting. And when I talk about my broad practice, that's another example. So you know, you go from a legendary Starlight Joe Keshi to you know, young creator that are really inventing it, doing it on their own on short form visual platforms, and the crossing over to traditional that's very interested. On

Speaker 1the from my perspective, the negative side, six years ago, like you know, right around right before the pandemic and then certainly through the pandemic, people were talking about the golden era of documentary and everything was great for independent cinema and Netflix came along and was paying huge amounts of money to the filmmakers and back ends were gone and people were looking the other way. And for me,

Speaker 1it was like the pied piper and everyone just following and going right off the pier. Because if we look in the very short period, I guess that's six years ago or seven years ago. Right right around then to now, theatrical has sort of collapsed and digital streamers are now paying traditional distributors a lot less money for that pay one window. You know, distributors used to rely on home video, and then it was the pay one video, the pay

Speaker 1one window, which is that cable or streaming platform that can pay a big license fee. Now those license fees are lower, and it's just one or two of the films that have to be a unicorn to get a big significant payment. And now Netflix, which was paying all of that money to capture the digital footprint, failed back and they're not paying these big amounts, and they're being far more selective and the content is far more moder rated.

Speaker 1It's like, it's general, it's for the middle, it's not taking big swings. So you know, it's concerning, and it has been concerning, and the pendulum hasn't swung back totally yet and right now everyone in our industry is trying to find their footing and waiting for the pendulum to switch and them are and you know, I'll stop there, but so digital streaming has completely changed the ecosystem.

Speaker 2Mark, how do you feel about Apple taking the transition from a streaming platform to going more towards theatrical in the future.

Speaker 1So right now, you know, we've talked about from the challenges in the marketplace and the collapse or the reduction in the theatrical marketplace. So as someone who is a professional in this business, and certainly please and happy to see Apple leaning into its theatrical business, you know, and it had at the myths and then it regrouped and

Speaker 1it came out with F one, which by all accounts is a significant success or Apple and it and it touches on Apple's vertical integration ambitions. It it reflects on apple broad footprint in terms of its brand. Right the film, this film shows Apple products in it's it The film utilizes Apple products to be got in terms of their cameras,

Speaker 1and the film feels sleek, if field on brand. And in so doing, they took a big swing because if it didn't work, this would not be good for their expansion plans. So I'm very happy to see it because it's putting it's putting energy into theatrical. But on the foot side, if you hear me being a little hesitant, it's because at the end of the day, this is

Speaker 1pushing forward what we're seeing in theatrical, which is the event sized theatrical, which is the imax theatrical. It's about the spectacle. It's not about dare I say, cinema. Now, there there can be some tailwinds that it has to be. Let's say, like, let's be not let's be optimistic. There has to be tailwinds for the larger cinematic community and filmmakers if if a tech company like Apple really leans

Speaker 1into the theatrical experience. But Apple is going to be opportunistic, right, They don't currently have their own distribution arm they're using third parties to release their film. That's not going to change over day, you know, overnight. But what I do like seeing is it's a tech company that's leaning into theatrical and making it important. And it's and you know, Netflix to me respectfully feel you know, it's like Walmart. You know, it's just like middle of the road. And

Speaker 1I think, you know, Apple is trying to need more like aname and market for you know, some tell me what that higher brand is and and we're seeing it in the visual, we're seeing it in the cinema and we're seeing it with their products. So it's the positive. It's definitely a positive, and I want to see more of it, But it doesn't change the landscape for independent film and independent filmmakers.

Speaker 2Can you tell us why do you think Apple have done there and why do you think Netflix is so lukem at the moment?

Speaker 1Well, you know, Apple's in an interest in position. If we kind of zoom out right, we have the legacy studios whose entire economic structure is based on storytelling. Right here. A legacy studio, all you do is make doled and content, and you have an entire ecosystem to do that which is built under studio and your sometimes your theme parks

Speaker 1and your theatrical and then you're putting it out into the world. You know, Netflix is not that it's not a legacy studio. It's its own sort of tech company. But it's in a very narrow path. It is a platform, and it's currently not trying to be anything more than a platform, and it's trying to appeal to the math. Is add this storytelling platform? Okay, Well, in the middle of those two things is Apple. And Apple is a

Speaker 1robust tech company that does a lot more than storyteller. Right, it's in the hardware business, it's in the service business. It has a lot of ways to be very successful and has done so. But at the end of the day, it's technological basis is also in a way storytelling. Music is storytelling, and then you know five or six years ago, Apple TV Plus is storytelling. But it doesn't have the

Speaker 1life that the Legacy Studios has, It doesn't have the library that Netflix has built in a short amount of time. So I think it's trying to find its footing by saying we are a tip, We're a very identity based brand. We are premium, we're slick, we are a higher class. So if it can then create opportunistic content that serve that brand, that serves that vertical integration that brings audiences

Speaker 1in to their streaming platform, then that's the success story. And at the end of the day, Tim Cooks talked about they're in the storytelling business, and right now we're in a culture of storytelling, aren't we. So Apple is leaning into that. I do think it's a positive. But this is working at a very high level. This is premium and I can I just hope that we will get tailwinds across the industry. But you know, at the end of the day, Apple not in the slate model.

Speaker 1You know, this is not going to be a volume business anytime scene. It's opportunistic, but it is driving people at the theaters. From an event heids perspective, Are.

Speaker 2There any major legal trends or issues that filmmakers should be paying attention to right now?

Speaker 1I mean, certainly, the conversation about around back end for the last few years has been significant, and we're seeing different approaches and we're seeing different changes to it. It's everything from a back end buyout, which can happen with the streamers, like most recently, I did a feature deal at Apple and they did, meaning there's a price, the back end pool will participate in it, and regardless of

Speaker 1the success or lack of success, that's how it's going to work for feature. There's a point system also even at Apple, which was not unique to Apple, but there's a point system where and it's more atcheing to episodic right now, where the back end is based on how long how many seasons the project stays on Apple, and then if it stays on a very long time, there's like another legacy pool and back ends at all of

Speaker 1the streamers are just everyone's trying to the reps, the deal makers on the filmmakers side are trying to push for something, and we're trying to find metric that makes sense that are not arbitrary. You know, when we had box office bonuses, that was very objectives. The film either reached that box office number or it did not. Now is it based on toscriber growth? Is it based on hours viewed? How long does a viewer have to watch?

Speaker 1With all of these issues and playing out, and you know, I'm always a believer in having mutual SIXCEPTH opportunities. You know, if a project does well, the creators should be incentivized to do their best work to make it a strong project, et cetera. And that over the last you know, five or six years, as eroded considerably and the theatrical markets are rooted considerably, and you know that is not a

Speaker 1positive trend.

Speaker 2Given so much brilliant and great advice on this podcast so far, it's amazing learning from you and hearing about your own stories as well. As a filmmaker. You've spoken at major law schools and universities. So what do you tell young lawyers or creatives trying to break into entertainment.

Speaker 1You know, I get those calls a lot, and I try to have them focused on, you know, a topic that we've brought up a few times on where their passion is. So sometimes get a call from someone in law school and they say they want to be an entertainment attorney, and I say on the music side or on the film side, and they say, you know that, Then the answer might be I'm not sure. I like number one. It doesn't work that way. If I go back to the orthopedics kind of college technology example, you

Speaker 1gotta pick one. You know, I'm going to be an obscutrician kind then an orthopedis So you gotta you have to be totally passionate about it. You have to understand the industry, read the trades, and listen to podcasts. You have to talk to people in the industry and really mess yourself in that space to become sort of an expert about it and really understand it. You know, that's where it begins. On the on the filmmaker's side. You

Speaker 1have to be doing it for the right reasons. You have to understand the challenges and it's about you know what separates the really good creators from the others, you know, from from the pack, so to speak. It's about that unique voice, it's about that unique approach, and it's about just like to be successful in any industry, it's about putting in the reps. So you have to be doing that work as a filmmaker, as a writer, as an actor.

Speaker 1You know, the great new thing is social media and the short form that is available now through social media. So if you're a creator, you can break in through these, you know, previously unconventional channels. That that's the positive and you can be your own entrepreneur. That's also a positive right. You can build a following audience on social media. At the very positive trendom, we're going to continue to see

Speaker 1how social media and workforum content and being your own boss and getting your own brand endorsements and building your own audience and building your own channel. How does that transition into more traditional and mainstream compat That will be super interesting.

Speaker 2And one of the trends that has happened throughout the history of film, I think, especially for some of the people listening to this podcast, is trying to get funded, trying to get a film funded as best as possible, But how do you approach working with finances who are new to the entertainment industry but bring capital from other industries.

Speaker 1Super interesting in that regard, and I believe this anecdote is emblematic of what's happening in the industry ten years ago, twelve years ago, eight years ago, I was focusing on representing a lot of independent financiers. But we just talked about how like netflicking in and everything was being shut up in the streamer took over to the independent film financing model really dissipated, and then all of.

Speaker 3A sudden in the last six to nine months, not even through intention, but through like incoming referrals and intri all of a sudden, I'm representing more independent financiers.

Speaker 1And why is that? I think that's because when one door shuts, meaning the streamers aren't just throwing money at content and acquiring, another door opens, and that that is a bit of a pendulum. And I think we're going back to an independent financing model and financiers are back, and when or growing back. It's not black and white, But when I speak to independent financiers first and foremost, again a similar theme that's come up in this podcast.

Speaker 1I talk about doing it for the right reasons, being passionate about it, wanting to support, wanting to support creators, if you're not there to support careers. And it depends like what is your financial capacity. You know, it's very hard to be a financier in this industry if you do not have significant capital. I mean, that's just the reality. If you have significant capital, we can be really strategic about what kind of projects you're going to make, how you're going to make them. One of the have a

Speaker 1client right now that's doing something really interesting, which is and this has been talked about over the last fall fifteen years and hasn't sixteen and the independent financing model for episodic television hind or screening, and we see in it coming ways where it hasn't ever really attached well. Now with Volume Capture VR, I have one client that is fully leaning into independently financing and producing an episodic serials and the licensing it to the different buyers all

Speaker 1over the world. So what's your level sophistication, what's your level of capacity, and how do you want to approach it? And depending on that, I talk about the ability to lose, right you have to have the wherewithal to lose the money. You can't go into this thinking that it's going to be a win win and that's going to all these sunshine and rainbows. But you can have a major impact right now, especially independent financiers can have a major, major impact because money fuel, you know, economic fuel is needed

Speaker 1to support creators. Right now. It is a tough time.

Speaker 2Incredibly tough, that's for sure. I can feel it. I am feeling that I should say sorry, but you're clearly a go to entertainment attorney for complex financing and distribution deals. When did you first start working on cross border transactions?

Speaker 1A long time ago? Because it's just the nature, you know, I mentioned Ermine, who's from Pakistan. We have several international clients, Scandinavia, Brazil, so it's just sort of a natural outgrowth as you grow your practice. And again it's a necessity you have to be able to as both as a funding theories a gillmaker. You need to be able to be expanse those and so you know, that's just a component of the business. And I go to can every year. I

Speaker 1go to Toronto, you know, to understand the international marketplace.

Speaker 2Was there a project early on that really tested your understanding of international finance and tax law.

Speaker 1Well, when it comes to tax law, I don't come to me. I have tax partners that I consult with on the international tact implications. In terms of the deals, you know, they're just they can be complex that they can also be straightforward. So I don't have a deal to you know, to reference and say, like, you know, here's a story that made it quite compelling. I would just point to several deals in Canada that take advantage of the Canadian tax credit. There's a client of mine,

Speaker 1Sonya O'Hara right now, who's in genre director, and you know, we're able to tap into territories in Canada where there's literally, in this case, a one million dollar grant that's non recoupable that bring production to Canada. You know, those opportunities aren't present in the United States. And again, it's just about being able to fitt and handle those deals and understand how they work, and having filmmakers be able to

Speaker 1lean into that.

Speaker 2And we've previously spoken about how things have changed in terms of distribution and the filmmaking industry as a whole. But in your experience, how important is pre sales in secure in finance today compared to ten or fifteen years ago.

Speaker 1We've ran on how the package is being put together. I would say now in the last year it's sort of reverted back to what it was fifteen years ago, where the models are prevalent again and they're necessary or put together film projects, Whereas in that period three years ago to eight years ago and everything is just being set up, and you know, Netflix and buyers are just throwing money at it to get films made. It became I really wouldn't have been I would not have wanted to be a foreign sales agent at that time. But

Speaker 1I feel like now that pendulum is swinging back to that model, you know, where you have a foreign sales agent, you get Askimich, you get a lender, then you get a little bit of equity, and then you have financed the gap and the pre sales.

Speaker 2Okay. And a lot of people listening to the podcast our producers early in their career. If you were advising a first time producer, for example, today, what's the one thing they must understand about cross border financing before they take a dollar or foreign investment.

Speaker 1They should be working with producers from the local region who understand what those regents have to offer and understand whether the region those foreign regions that they're looking at the crew that lends itself to the tax credit. In other words, if there's some very beneficial tax credit but that local area doesn't have the crew to support it, then all that tax credit savings is going to flying people and crew to that area, and that's not worth it.

Speaker 2Yes, that makes sense, because you're just bringing in people from abroad when you could what were the people there, and all the money going in a place where it might not be necessarily best spent in that In that way, and your job is very full, very very good. What's someone rewarding part of your job and what's the most misunderstood.

Speaker 1Currently, The most rewarding part is find you know, helping my clients find success on a deal and seeing a phenomenal project come to fruition. You know, there's no doubt about that, and it happens, and it's worrying, you know. The challenge is dealing with volume, number of emails and the time pressure on your multiple deals happening, and being response to being a lawyer is a sort of a

Speaker 1twenty four to seven job in terms of responsiveness and fielding.

Speaker 2Yeah, deal well, And one of the things that a lot of the filmmakers on this podcast also struggle with, and I'm imagining you may have heard this before, some of the technical and legal hurdles that happen when filmmakers are trying to make the documentaries or narrative films. So beyond the legal documents, there are often technical requirements for delivery, things like master files, QC reports and captioning. Do you find these technical details often cause delays? And if they do,

Speaker 2how much of a problem is it for you?

Speaker 1The day that, even though I've mentioned your films, which sets me apart for most attorney, I deal so little with technical delivery and try so hard not to keep up with technical advances and or delivery itself. Just I find that, you know, I just talked about the volumes, like I don't want to get into that and let the producer do it. And he said that, of course, if you're unable to deliver a film correctly, it's gonna set you back. So the young filmmakers out there, you

Speaker 1definitely have to your data and your content properly managed and stored it and organized, or you're gonna have a nightmare on the other end.

Speaker 2Too true, Too true, I can't disagree with that one nightmare at the other end. And lastly, if you had to sum up your philosophy on law and storytelling in one sentence, what would it be.

Speaker 1Oh, I had a law school professor who had this great little line factor. It was three p's, and I'm forgetting one of the piece, maybe your audience consoling. But it was practiced with passion, provision, and another P I'll say persistence. Practice with precision, passion, and persistence. I think got both law and creation right.

Speaker 2I like it, I really do. Mark, thanks so much for coming on the podcast. I really appreciate you taking the time to talk to me. I've learned a lot. I know the listeners have learned a lot too. And it's always amazing to talk to someone who's a filmmaker and an attorney, because genuinely, a lot of the times people don't think attorneys would make films or do make films. So it's a special kind of person that can do both. And I hope you would make a film again one day that we can all go and watch and see

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 298: Saila Kariat on Jesus Land: Adapting Trauma and Directing Juliette Lewis

    Nov 1, 202658 minAudio

    How do you bring someone’s most painful memories to the screen with honesty and care?Damien Swaby speaks with writer and director Saila Kariat about Jesus Land, her adaptation of Julia Scheeres’s memoir exploring...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 297: Joshua Lastine: Film Contracts, Copyright and Creative Ownership

    Oct 31, 202656 minAudio

    When someone helps rewrite your script, who owns the finished story? And what happens when the person financing your film wants to change it? Entertainment lawyer Joshua Lastine joins Damien Swaby on Filmmaking...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 296: Stop Waiting, Start Filming: Mike Gallant and Seled Calderon on BACKPAY

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    Mike Gallant and Seled Calderon join Damien Swaby to discuss BACKPAY, an independent neo-noir crime thriller about financial desperation, family and the consequences of believing one bad decision can fix...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 295: Emmy Award-Winning Filmmaker Luchina Fisher: The Stories We Carry

    Sep 18, 202657 minAudio

    Documentary filmmaker Luchina Fisher joins Damien Swaby to discuss the people and experiences that shaped her work.Growing up in a military family took Luchina from Texas to Germany and North Carolina. She reflects on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 294: Katie Cokinos: From Slacker to I Dream Too Much

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Filmmaker Katie Cokinos joins Damien Swaby to reflect on a career shaped by independent cinema, personal vision and the determination required to get unconventional films made. Katie recounts beginning her career at the...

    Credit the people on this episode