When someone helps rewrite your script, who owns the finished story? And what happens when the person financing your film wants to change it? Entertainment lawyer Joshua Lastine joins Damien Swaby on Filmmaking Conversations to explore the agreements behind creative work - and the disputes that can arise when expectations are left unwritten. Drawing on his experience across independent film, animation and talent deals, Joshua discusses when to involve a lawyer, what to look for beyond the headline fee, and how ownership disagreements can follow a project all the way into production. We also explore his cautious approach to fair use, the distinction between fair use and public domain, and the questions AI raises around authorship and copyright. Joshua shares his journey from Iowa to Hollywood, including work at Marvel Studios and time in the CAA mailroom.In this episode: Defining ownership, credit and responsibilities with creative collaborators. Understanding payment schedules, milestones and contract details. Securing rights and organising production paperwork. Negotiating creative control when someone else provides the money. Discussing clearance, fair use and the risks of relying on supposed shortcuts. Navigating AI tools and questions of human authorship. Building a career through relationships, adaptability and a love of film. https://lastineentertainmentlaw.com/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1You are listening to the IFH Podcast Network. For more amazing filmmaking and screenwriting podcasts, just go to ifhpodcastnetwork.com.
Speaker 2Today, I'm joined by entertainment lawyer Joshua Lastine. We talk about protecting your work, understanding contracts, and what happens when money and creative control collide. If you're making films or developing a project with others, there's plenty here to think about.
Speaker 1Hey, hey, Damien. I'm doing well. Thank you. Thank you so much for having me.
Speaker 3No, thank you so much for coming on. This podcast has had many great lawyers on, many people from different law firms, and it's so important for creatives, filmmakers especially, to understand what they're getting into and how the law and the legal side of things, to be exact, are so important. And we sometimes go ahead and make something that we like or we get involved in things we like without considering the legal aspects of things. So Thank you for coming on. I truly appreciate it.
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah. And thank your audience for having me. I know you've had a lot of entertainment lawyers on before, some of which I'm sure I've done business with, probably some of my colleagues and friends. And I think it's important to have a variety of entertainment lawyers on talking because it's really... there are so many different types of entertainment lawyers and we all do slightly, slightly different businesses. You know, I mean the prominent distinction be between, you know, litigators,
Speaker 1those who go to court, those who sue people, argue in front of a judge or jury, you know, those are very particular types of entertainment lawyers versus myself. And I think more aligned with probably some of your previous guests are transactional lawyers, you know, handling the, the, strictly the contracts, the, the, the financing deals, the option purchase acquisition agreements, crew deals above the line, below the line, you know, VFX and vendors, um, that that's more so
Speaker 1of what, what I handle, but like, you know, at, at any given studio, you, you know, your Warner brothers, your Disney, your Paramount, well, I guess Paramount is Warner brothers, but Within the confines of those larger corporations, every single department has their own set of entertainment lawyers. Some specialize in labor and guild issues, handling strictly the DGA, SAG, WGA, IATSE, Teamsters. Some handle strictly marketing and advertising legal issues. One of
Speaker 1my former bosses was responsible for drafting the fine print on sweepstakes and consumer products, invites to live action events, red carpet premieres and stuff. So it is pretty, I don't know, daunting and expansive, all of the different things various entertainment lawyers cover. I would consider myself more of a generalist. I run Lasting Entertainment Law. We're a small
Speaker 1boutique practice. We do a lot in indie film finance, indie film production. We handle deals for our animation studio clients and smaller actors, writers, directors, and producers. But there are many different types of entertainment lawyers out there. So it's good that you got a variety, I guess I would say.
Speaker 3Thank you thank you i really appreciate you saying that and i as i said it's great to have you on i'm looking at your website as i have done for the last couple of weeks or so you specialize your organization your firm in rights accusation right acquisitions development production deals branding commercial advertising deals talent deals and other contracts for new media social media and the internet 3.0 that's an amazing amount of stuff how do you have the time and Who are you usually working with on
Speaker 3such a range of things?
Speaker 1Oh, man. When you're a small law firm like ours, we only have three lawyers, about seven people in total in our roster. We have to stay flexible. We have to stay nimble in terms of the amount and scope of work that we handle. Coming out of the pandemic, after we launched our firm in 2021, animation deals. Were very popular. Netflix was doing a lot in the form of adult animation. That kind of died off for
Speaker 1a period of time when we went through the 2023 writers and actors strike. So we pivoted to podcast and new media and digital influencers and stuff. And now we're seeing kind of a cultural renaissance as it relates to indie films, in particular indie films like horror indie which is, you know, as a consumer, as a fan, as a fan boy, that's, you know, my favorite thing to work on, my favorite thing to consume. But, you know, it's just about, you know, being able to juggle all of these different hats.
Speaker 1And like I said, I'm more of a contract generalist. I handle all of this breadth and scope. But, you know, if there are particular issues, you know, like if somebody needs to sue somebody, if something like goes to litigation, that's something that I would outsource and you would recommend to another lawyer. Or, you know, like a larger scale merger and acquisition, like the Warner Brothers Paramount merger. That's not something my little law firm would be working on. That'd be something more like a Shepard Mullen or Manat Phelps or Loeb and Loeb or something. So just like, you know, kind of knowing, you know, again, what different
Speaker 1types of entertainment lawyers are out there. I handle a lot more smaller productions. Most of our films range in the $ 1. 5 million to $ 5 million mark. Our studio clients are making adult animation at a more moderate price point, more moderate price levels. So it took me a long time to kind of build the well-rounded skill set to handle all of these different things. When I was in
Speaker 1law school, I worked for American Idol. I did music licensing and unscripted content for Fremantle. I worked at Marvel Studios where I did animation deals. I did voiceover agreements, visual effects agreements for the main Avengers movies. Worked on Bradley Cooper and Vin Diesel's deal for the original Guardians of the Galaxy way, way, way back when. And graduated law school, went to CAA, went to Creative Artists Agency,
Speaker 1spent some time in the mailroom there. was outside counsel to Amazon Studios for a brief period of time when I was at another law firm. So just kind of building the skill sets to handle all of these different things. I'm 38, been running my own law firm now for six years. And we have to stay, again, nimble in these ever-changing times and how the entertainment industry you know, decides that it wants to reinvent itself every 18 months.
Speaker 1It seems like, um, you know, I, I don't think that that's exclusive to us as a law firm. I think that that's anyone trying to survive Hollywood in, in 2026 is, is like just refiguring things out every 18 months.
Speaker 3Considering the entertainment world basically changes every 18 months in many different ways. When should creators start thinking about rights ownership and legal protection? And what type of lawyer should he or she be thinking about working with?
Speaker 1Yeah, yeah. I mean, even though the, how do I say, the Hollywood mandate changes every 18 months, like what Hollywood is interested in as a subject matter might change every 18 months. The legal basics are like, the legal basics are how, you know, indie creators can protect themselves. That doesn't really change, right? And I guess the answer to that question is you can never start too early. Thinking about finding an entertainment lawyer, building relationships with an entertainment lawyer,
Speaker 1you know, entertainment lawyers, they're sometimes hard to contact. We have very busy schedules. We're not exactly always, you know, looking to expand our book of business. But, you know, when a client seems interested, when a client reaches out and makes that a concerted effort, you know, we do a lot of what I call hip pocketing where it's like, you know, I'll make introductions with people and then I'll say, Hey, you know, when, when the time's right, when the time comes, feel free to reach back out again. I don't think it's ever too soon to start having those conversations. And
Speaker 1I'll tell you, you know, a lot of the stuff on my desk right now that I'm, I'm doing cleanup work on are situations where, where creators have come in, Um, you know, and they've had, they've had friends help out creatively. They've had people do rewrites. Maybe they attached a director to a project that they were working on. And then that director did rewrites or they, they had a manager involved. And then that manager started at, you know, adding creative elements or creative contributions or reading the screenplay and making recommendations.
Speaker 1At that point, when you start inviting on a creative, creative collaborator, you're, you're already starting to mix, you know, business with pleasure, I guess I should say you're already starting to, to open up legal doors of liability. So, I mean, even before you start inviting people to opine on your work creatively, um, I think it's important to kind of like, at least start thinking about having an entertainment lawyer. Again, I have probably three deals on my
Speaker 1desk currently, where, you know, one of them, we're at the end of the rope. We finished completion on a short film project and the director had helped, you know, my creator client, the capital P producer, as I call it. they helped them do some writing services early on. And now they're asking for essentially, you know, co-creator status in the moon in the back. And my client's like, wait a minute, I created this thing. And, you know, and so now we're trying to walk back and undo, you know,
Speaker 1something that it should have been pretty clear from the get-go that if we're inviting you to creatively collaborate or to opine or give your opinion on stuff, Um, you're, you're a work for hire. You're not a, you're not a co-creator. Um, and then, and again, similarly, I've had where I've had that bite me in the butt most, the most recently is with managers actually with, with, with, with people who are supposed to be protecting their talent. Um, in the last, you know, six to nine months, I've had several projects where I've had managers from legacy past
Speaker 1come out of the woodwork. to say, hey, you know, I represented so-and-so writer client X number of years ago, and I did a pass at their screenplay, and I deserve a producer credit, and they promised me a producer fee, and this and that, the next thing. And it starts to create a chain of title issue for the entire production, especially if you're really far along in the production. So, you know, it it's never too soon to start building relationships. I mean, if you, if you're serious about your career in Hollywood in general, you should be constantly cultivating relationships with,
Speaker 1with just about everybody because you don't, you don't know who you're going to need in your Rolodex someday. But, but certainly, you know, if you're inviting people to creatively collaborate on a project and, Um, and, and if the, if the understanding is less than 50, 50, that I guess maybe that's where I caveat. If, if, if, if there's a basic understanding that I'm inviting somebody to, to creatively collaborate in, in the understanding is, is that we are co equal 50, 50 partners that that's maybe where
Speaker 1you can save some money and invite an attorney on later. But, but even still like that, that relationship needs to be memorialized. Um, it's just an easier conversation when everything is fair, 50, 50 equal partners.
Speaker 3So which parts of a contract deserve the closest attention beyond the headline fee?
Speaker 1Yeah. I mean, you know, it, I, when I work with my clients, I really feel like there's a division of labor. There's a, there's like a, a dual responsibility that, that has to take place because, you know, when, when you send a contract my way, I am very much analyzing it for legal issues, legal compliance, things that are going to bite you in the butt. Yes, I'm looking at the fee, but even that usually has already been hashed out and negotiated. I'm not so much interested in
Speaker 1how much you're getting paid. I'm more interested in when are you getting paid? How are you getting paid? What percentage is it upon signature? Do you have to deliver something on a milestone basis to get paid? like, like my job is to focus on the, on the, the nitty gritty and the meat and potatoes of the contract. What I'm less focused on and what I really need my clients to kind of step up and own responsibility is like, just in, just in some of the basic stuff, like, like what is your full legal name? Like, you know, if,
Speaker 1if you've, if you've only been going by, um, CJ, um, And that's what, you know, you sign your rep agreements are, but your full legal name is Carlos Jones or something like that. You know, that's information that I don't have that I need to know. And so, you know, what I usually do is, A, I try to make all my clients read their contracts because I want them to
Speaker 1at least ask me questions about things in there that they either disagree with or or don't think that they've agreed to i don't expect them to to catch things i don't expect them to know things but it's like where the clients are the closest to the conversations being had i'm being pulled in as a third party you know sort of fly on the wall you you know you client you've had 20 conversations with the producer and What did you guys talk about with respect to X, Y, Z and Zed? You know, I rely on my client
Speaker 1for a little bit of feedback and a little bit of guidance in that regard, as well as, again, you know, making sure that, you know, your names are spelled right and that is your legal name and it's the name of your company and your company is, you know, the information that you basically the information that you provided me needs to be accurate for me to do my job. Um, and so, you know, I, I, I would say the most important things from a client's perspective of reading the contract is, is, is reading it like less as a lawyer and more as a, more as a fact finder. Um,
Speaker 1so to speak, like, like my job is to make sure that the legal ins and outs and cupboards, your job is to look through it and say, Hey, this seems like something that we talked about. That is the exact opposite of what we talked about or. You know, this is you know, we agreed to five thousand, not four thousand or something. I'm only as good as the best information that you provide me with with that regard.
Speaker 3Can you give us an example of when a client found it difficult to ask you a question, but you were so happy that the client asked you the question anyway?
Speaker 1You know, maybe not a specific example, but again, I always encourage the dialogue and the feedback with my client. There are oftentimes, again, where the client has access to more information about the project than I have information to. So just being vocal and being cognitive and knowing that you can ask questions. I mean, I think that for some lawyers, some lawyers can come off as, as semi intimidating.
Speaker 1I try not to come off as intimidating to my clients. I know that's probably not that they might say otherwise, but, um, you know, just trying to keep that open door, open question policy as much as, as much as possible. Um, Yeah, that's important from the attorney-client perspective is just having that relationship and knowing that they can ask questions if they do have them.
Speaker 3And considering you have production agreements with crews, actors, writers, producers, visual effects teams, music licensing, and so many different departments and so many different people, typically, which ones are usually faster or take longer to do when you're working with independent companies and filmmakers.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah, for sure. So, so at the start of every production, prior to going into production prior to, to, to lights, camera action role, I'll usually provide my clients with what is known as a standard production packet. Um, it's a, it's a, it's a zip drive of documents, usually around five to seven documents, depending on what the production is and where they're filming. But they'll usually include things like standard filmed location agreements, non-filmed location agreements, post-filming
Speaker 1film releases, crew deal memos for employees, vendor service agreements for vendor providers, equipment rentals, maybe a materials release, background performer release, some sort of SAG standard terms and conditions. But all of those are, how do I say, template contracts that we provide production that the line producer and associate producers and production assistants on the ground, their job
Speaker 1is to go out and make sure that everyone signs the applicable paperwork, the NDAs, the policy, production code of conduct policy handbook. All of those template documents are I don't want to say non-negotiable, but in a way they're not negotiable. They're just, you know, you're an employee, you're a crew member, you're signed on to this production, sign it or go home, I guess. So to that end,
Speaker 1those contracts are relatively quick because that's the, you know, the kind of just standard onboarding stuff that you would have to sign just coming on to a production, right? And then, you know, the stuff that takes the longer time time is, is like the actor deals. And in particular, the schedule F actor deals, people being paid above 70, 80 K. I forget, I forget what schedule F is off the top of my head. I think it's like 80 K now. So performers being paid above 80 K, we call them schedule F performers under SAG. They're freely
Speaker 1bargained for players. Meaning we can, a lot of the, a lot of the basic terms of the SAG agreement don't apply and we're free to negotiate. Well, oftentimes too, though, if they're Schedule F performers, it means they're somebodies, right? It means that they're stars. It means that they're celebrities. And there might be way more terms above and beyond SAG that need to go into those deals. It's always my favorite to negotiate a really prestigious older actor, someone
Speaker 1who's been in the business for 50 plus years. It's always funny to get all of their asks because it's like they need three people on set at any time, one of them to help them read lines with, the other one to feed them lines, an earpiece, one of them to shine their shoes on Wednesday, whatever sort of crazy ask that actors might have. Those are always fun deals to negotiate. Probably the longest contracts that are the
Speaker 1most challenging contracts to negotiate that really do take months, if not longer, are larger, you know, film finance agreements, senior loan documents. There's a lot of due diligence required in senior loan documents, especially if you're putting up collateral as part of a senior loan, as part of a bank loan for either, you as well as rights acquisitions. Sometimes the deals for rights acquisitions, even just starting a project,
Speaker 1just acquiring a screenplay or acquiring a book to write a screenplay or something, option purchase agreements and rights acquisitions, those can take a while sometimes. So those are probably the longest deals that it takes to negotiate.
Speaker 3And when it comes to intellectual property, we've all heard and and seeing how Marvel uses that and many other film studios, but what is intellectual property rights and how did they develop with theme park rides and videos that go viral?
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. You know, so intellectual property is more like an umbrella term that, that really is a, it's a, it's a legal, it's a legal term of art umbrella term that describes a a property right that people have, a right of ownership that people have into the value of non-tangible, you can't call it goods, you can't call it services, right? It's just IP, it's intellectual property. So it's property that's value stems from the intangible creative or
Speaker 1human intellect-based nature of the property. And while that sounds really heady, in practice, it's pretty simple, right? Like, I own Spider-Man action figures. I collect action figures. I like Spider-Man as a character. I have a Spider-Man action figure collection. And, you know, one of those action figures might be worth $ 25. Maybe, like, the rarest high-up action figure that I have might be worth, like, $ 200, $ 300 or something at best. But that is representative of
Speaker 1the physical manifestation of the intellectual property IP, the action figure... but it's not representative of the value of Spider-Man as an intangible character, right? The value of Spider-Man as an intangible character is $ 20, $ 30 billion at this point. I don't even know. You probably can't even, you know, evaluate it at that, around $ 50 billion or something. The intellectual property really becomes how do you take something like a copyright and how do you exploit it across various medias
Speaker 1and mediums? Because the copyright of Spider-Man is a nebulous thing. What is the copyright of Spider-Man? Well, it's the, what has it been, 50, 60 years? I think he just had like a 60th anniversary or something like that. It's the 60 years of story and lore. that goes into building the copyright of Spider-Man. And then it's just a matter of who owns the copyright to, you're limited by your own imagination in terms of creative exploitation. If they
Speaker 1want to make, you know, they do, but you know, backpacks of Spider-Man or action figures of Spider-Man, movies, plays, theme parks, 3D rides, you know, all of that is exploitable under the ownership of a copyright. And so it's really about having an original idea, manifesting that somehow into
Speaker 1a work, either a painting, a script, a short story, whatever. You build the foundational layers of the IP, but it's how you exploit it that builds the franchise. Once I build a character, what am I going to put it in? Television, film, digital shorts, backpacks, t-shirts, video games, action figures. That's how you build a franchise. Spider-Man.
Speaker 3Why Spider-Man? I'm curious because I used to be a comic book fan myself.
Speaker 1Oh, I don't know. I don't know that he's even my favorite comic book hero or anything, but between him and Batman, I feel like those are the two most popular, at least individual, creative copyright franchises. The value of the character of Spider-Man as a whole is probably worth more than the entire rest of the Marvel catalog of characters, except for now maybe Iron Man has maybe broken away from that, but Yeah, it's interesting that the character of
Speaker 1Spider-Man in of himself is worth just about as much as all the other characters combined.
Speaker 3So if an independent filmmaker came to you and said, what types of intellectual property and content rights can you help us secure? And what legal agreements do you offer to support development, adaptation, financing and production? What type of answer would you be able to give?
Speaker 1Yeah, you know, again, intellectual property being an umbrella category, we don't do anything with patents. Patents are intellectual property that protect works of science, of creative technology, medicine, things of that nature. You know, there's a lot of patent exploitation in entertainment, you know, people who develop camera lenses and stuff. We don't handle any of that. We also don't handle anything with trademark or trademark registration. Trademark protects
Speaker 1brand goodwill as a component of intellectual property. We don't really do much with trademark either. What we pretty much exclusively handle is copyright law. And if you have an original work of authorship and you need help filing for copyright registration or If you're bringing on co-developers, co-writers, and you're wanting to maintain your creative ownership, your exclusive ownership of everything, we can help you do the contracts for those.
Speaker 1You find financiers, you find investors, you find people who want to give you money to help bring your idea to life. We'll help do the investment agreements. We'll help do the back-end participation for people who want to put their money, park their money into projects. Um, you know, when you're ready to go light rights, lights, camera in action, um, we're there to help with the, with the production paperwork, the, the templates, like I discussed and spoke about the, the location agreements, the above the line actor deals, the below
Speaker 1the line crew. Um, you know, we, we, we help secure the paperwork from, I guess, ideation or, or initial inception, um, of an idea to, to final credit roll.
Speaker 3So what would actually happen or what happens emotionally when a creator gives someone else the right to develop their story and suddenly the characters, events or themes they deeply identify with are being changed? How do you structure agreements to protect both the creator's creative voice and the production's need to evolve?
Speaker 1You know, it really depends. It really depends on the leverage of the creator. I mean, the more of a proven track record that creative has, the more the studio buyer is going to allow them to have a final say over their creative voice, or at least have some say over their creative voice. But if you're a smaller independent creator, they may not give that to you at least contractually. So it's a little bit of managing expectations.
Speaker 1You know, if you're an indie creator, it's going to be very hard for me to fight for those sort of like approval.
Speaker 4You're not, even if, even let me put it this way at the, even at the tippy top of the toppest of the top, it is very hard for, for someone to get an outright blanket approval, right.
Speaker 1Or a veto right over the person who's putting money in. He who has the money, he who the one who's putting the money down, he who, who pays the money usually has final say in approval over everything. Now, there are two components of that. There's the practical component of it, which is the interpersonal relationship between the creative and, and the buyer, you know, and that's a, that's an interpersonal dynamic. That's not something that is necessarily managed by the contract or it, you know, it lives outside the contract, but,
Speaker 1but taking that, that relationship into consideration, what's the relationship between the buyer or the studio and, or the developer and the original, the original creator and, how they treat you at the beginning of the relationship is going to be very indicative of how they're going to treat you throughout the entire time. So if they treat you at arm's length, and don't really want you in the room, they can, you can expect that that's how you're going to treat you from the outset, you know, at which point it starts to become a discussion of, well, to me,
Speaker 1to me, there's always a price. There's always a price. There's you know, yes, I've created this baby, but you give me the price. I'll give it to you. I'll walk it away. I'll walk away and you guys go do whatever you want with it. So, so a, like finding out that price and, and, and B, you know, I, I do try to convince or coach my clients not to be too precious about any of their darlings. I mean, you know, if, if you have your Magnus Opus, if
Speaker 1you have your, um, you know, what, what was it that, um, Oh, gosh. Now, now I'm blanking. Francis Coppola just did that, that that huge movie that he sunk all of his money into. You know, if you if you have your lifelong passion project, don't sell it for nickels. You know, don't give that one away. Put that one, you know, in a basket and save it for for later on in your career. But but oftentimes early in your career, it's more important
Speaker 1to just get W's under your belt. It's just it's more important to get wins. So I try not to coach my I try to coach my clients not to be too precious about any given project, because you're with any luck, you're going to have a very long career and you're going to have a lot of ideas. And I mean, I think it just came out. Um, not too long ago that like, it was like some very prestigious writer. I think it was like Steven Spielberg or something like that, who did a, did a, basically a page one rewrite on the, on the fugitive film. And, and,
Speaker 1or no, it was James Cameron, not Steven Spielberg. It was James Cameron. James Cameron was married to the, I think the director, um, of the film and ended up doing like an uncredited page one rewrite of the entire movie. And it's just like, you know, a lot of people will, will, will take, you know, deals to live to fight another day or deals to advance their career. And if it may not be the, that might not be the deal, but maybe the next one is. And so you have to be very strategic in that front. I mean, I
Speaker 1think Seth Rogen spent a large portion of his career just doing punch up writing on scripts, again, uncredited. He could have been very precious about his work and said, hey, I'm not going to do this because, you know, I'm Seth Rogen and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. But you, you, you play your cards, you play your cards smartly. And that's hopefully what I'm there to help you to guide you through on, on when, when to play your hand and what hand to play. Amazing.
Speaker 3I had no idea about that. Um, especially if someone at the level of Seth, um, yeah, that's a really interesting take to have on it. But in terms of documentary filmmakers, um, What should documentary filmmakers understand about fair use, clearance, and the limits of using other people's material?
Speaker 1It's a myth. No, I don't do so much unscripted and documentary work. I do, but I live a lot more in narrative land. And just by, you know, the nature of copyright law and fair use in general, fair use is very misunderstood in and its application is decided on a case-by-case basis. So it's very hard for anyone to take any case or any example of fair use
Speaker 1and say, ha ha, okay, so here's an instance of fair use over here. My case is similar, therefore it's a direct application. That's not really how it works. Fair use is applied given on a case-by-case basis on the very particular merits and fact patterns that it's being analyzed. And so, you know, I highly, highly, highly caution people against using fair use as their main legal defense. You know,
Speaker 1in my world, I advise my client to uh, delete footage, blur footage, or clear footage. Um, those are kind of the three options. There's, there's not a whole lot of fair use argument that I give my, my clients. Wow.
Speaker 3That's pretty interesting because I've heard a completely different answer to people that have different opinions on fair use or where they can use fair use. I'm sorry, where they can use footage, for example, or in terms of fair use or for how long in a scene they can use it or where it's placed.
Speaker 1The length thing is definitely, definitely a Hollywood myth, Hollywood fable. There is no like, oh, I only used it for three seconds. And in fact, there's a pretty famous Dimensions film case that the court ruled. There was like a three second that took place in the opening of a film and the court said, nope, no fair use. Um, and then on the flip side, you have a case like, uh, um, the, the two live crew case, um, with pretty woman where,
Speaker 1you know, that, that was just a very blatant, um, sampling of Roy Orbison's pretty woman song that, that two live crew essentially did a repurpose of, um, sold it to huge commercial success in the, in the Supreme court was like, Oh, parody fair use. And so, I, you know, E & O Insurance doesn't like fair use. I don't like fair use. If you're going to go out and hire Donaldson Califf and get Lisa Califf or one of them to write you a good opinion letter as to why you can use it and you give that to
Speaker 1your E & O Insurance carriers, then great. But I ain't writing you that letter.
Speaker 3Okay, fair enough. But one last bit on fair use. Let's take a character we both like, Spider-Man. Where does the boundary lie between inspiration, homage, parody? an infringement, and can fair use ever give a filmmaker the freedom to tell a story with a cultural icon without crossing the line on somebody else's rights?
Speaker 1Oh, it depends on how big your legal budget is, my friend.
Speaker 3I think I know the answer.
Speaker 1I think that a clever lawyer can argue around anything, right? I mean, the most chef's kiff's perfect example of this going on culturally right now is the Entourage, HBO, Jake Paul, Jeremy Piven, Adrian Guineer commercial. I don't know that you've seen this or are familiar with this or not, but essentially, you know, Jake Paul started a predictions market app, a gambling app, right? I think it's called Better or something like that. And he did this commercial and it stars
Speaker 1Jeremy Piven and Adrian Ganeer playing themselves. They call them by their names. Hey, Adrian. Hey, Jeremy. But, you know, the whole entire setup of the commercial couldn't be more blatantly Entourage. I mean... Jeremy Piven rolls up in a, in a very Ari gold suit. He's driving, you know, a convertible Lamborghini. He rolls up to a house party. There's tons of celebrities. He rushes out to Adrian. Adrian's out on a bow. He's like, Oh, I got this big offer for you. I mean like the whole thing
Speaker 1is just to the nth degree turned up, uh, uh, entourage, um, homage, I guess you would call it. Um, And, you know, Doug Ellman, creator of Entourage, he slammed it on social media and HBO fired a cease and desist saying, hey, you know, you're essentially using, you know, our characters and this is basically copyright infringement. And the lawyers for Jake Paul and his betting app, you know, they fired back
Speaker 1quite appropriately that HBO does not own Jeremy Piven as a person, nor do they own Adrian Ganeer as a person. nor can you have creative ownership over the idea of a backyard yacht party or inviting celebrities to an all-white party. These are non-original, non-creative elements that people just can't outright own. And so while HBO might not be happy with the commercial,
Speaker 1Jake Paul and the Better app, I'm sure, have hired... all of the best lawyers in the world to make sure that they filmed it in such a way that they could, that they would survive a cease and desist and, or HBO is not going to sue them, but you know, it is very apropos. So to, to, to answer your question, it depends on how deep your pockets are. Now there, there is a big difference to highlight to the, to the audience between fair use and public domain. Those are
Speaker 1not the same thing. Fair use is someone else owns a copyright and I have found a way that skirts copyright protection to use it fairly. If I'm using short snippets of YouTube videos in my educational class, I might have an argument for fair use. I'm not going to say I have fair use, but I might have an argument for fair use. Public domain... is when the copyright of a particular character or a particular idea, the copyright
Speaker 1itself has expired. So the the life of the author plus, uh, 95 years or at this point, that's the, that's the more newer standard, but, but any, anything published pre 1924 at this point, the copyright, um, um, the, the copyright protection on has probably expired and, So you do have characters like Mickey Mouse and Winnie the Pooh and Popeye, the Sailor Man, Betty Boop, all of them coming into
Speaker 1the public domain. Spider-Man will be in the public domain. I forget what year exactly, but it's not... not soon. I think it's like before 2050. So, you know, as, as those beloved characters become public domain, that's when you are seeing people, you know, there's a, there's a whole underground horror franchise about, you know, Mickey Mouse and Winnie the Pooh and Betty Boop and Popeye the Sailor Man, because,
Speaker 1because they're now allowed to kind of do that. They're allowed to differentiate them, those characters from the, from the previous versions.
Speaker 3So how can creators protect their content audience and income when working with platforms, brands, managers, or production partners?
Speaker 1Well, I mean, the, the, the first thing that you want to want to do is, is make sure that you get contracts around any sort of creative partner. I think that that's big, the biggest, um, death's kiss that creators run into. They'll invite people to collaborate with them, you know, on the, on the, on the artistic spirit, you know, Hey, we're all working on this together. And then they'll make a little bit of headway. They'll make a little bit of progress. And then all of a sudden it becomes knives out in terms of who owns what and what are everyone's rights and what their entitlements
Speaker 1are to, to this thing that they've, you know, now helped bring to life. So, so, you know, before inviting anyone to be a creative collaborator, a creative partner, having clearly defined expectations on what that means, Um, really I think is, is, you know, gotta be at the forefront of your mind before you, before you bring anyone on to help you punch up or revise or do notes
Speaker 1or whatever, um, you know, on your creative project.
Speaker 3Ideally, if an independent filmmaker approaches you or your firm and needs help, needs advice, need you to work for them. What does the ideal client look like?
Speaker 1Yeah, somebody who definitely knows that that they have to work just as hard as I do to make their creative vision happen. I'm only half of the equation. I wouldn't even call myself half of the equation because I'm really there, you know, to help with with with the with the legal paperwork. You're the creator. You're the star. You're the guy or girl who, you know, it's your idea. It's your baby. I'm just kind of along for the ride. And while I can, you know, do cool things with
Speaker 1a contract and while I can help protect you, I'm not the guy that moves your ball forward. You got to pick up your ball and run it into the end zone. I'm more like the blocker. Okay.
Speaker 3I like that. American football term. But for the Europeans listening, we're not as knowledgeable about it. And how can legal agreements and production paperwork protect your creative vision or protect the client's creative vision while allowing people to maintain control from the pre-production through final delivery?
Speaker 1You know, again, going back to just getting the contracts in early with your creative collaborators, you know, if you're... If you're the one paying people, if you're the one engaging people, if it's your project, you're going to want to retain creative control. We put that directly in the contract. It says, you know, in not so unclear terms, it says, you know, company or studio or producer, whoever it is, the one that's that's doing the buying, doing the engaging, the capital P producer, it's their creative vision. Um, so,
Speaker 1you know, any approval rights or consultation rights, anyone coming on board, that's going to help out on this project. Yeah. We're hiring you, um, to do, you know, creative services, but at the end of the day, you're, you're, you're a creative work for hire. Um, all of the, all of the work that you perform is, is a work made for hire in favor of the person paying you. So you, you have a voice in the room. but the final voice belongs to the person who's got the cash.
Speaker 3And clearly, like, everyone is human and mistakes are made, but which production documentation errors, such as incomplete releases, missing IP assignments, or improperly executed crew agreements, create the most downstream legal issues?
Speaker 1Well, again, I keep coming back to it, but not having an agreement at the outset with any sort of creative collaborators... That's got to be the biggest one that creates the down, the biggest long, long-term downstream effect. You know, I have clients that will, will run into issues where people will not properly sign things, the signature, maybe they typed it and it was, it's gotta be, it's gotta actually be a signature, either digital or physical. Like a lot of that stuff can be fixed in hindsight. But
Speaker 1the rights are the most important. And maintaining rights ownership throughout the entire process and having it very clear in writing that you are the one that owns everything from start to finish, that's the one thing that's very hard to go back and correct and fix.
Speaker 3And again, in an ever-changing world, for example, earlier you mentioned the Hollywood infrastructure in terms of what wants to be seen or what should be seen and something along those lines every 18 months. So what emerging legal risk and a production company is overlooking today, particularly around AI generated content and digital replicas, IP ownership and ever evolving rights.
Speaker 1Yeah, you literally just took the words out of my mouth. I was going to say that the biggest concern right now has to be with relation to AI and Maybe not in the way that everyone kind of thinks, but, you know, from a, from a creator studio perspective, the biggest thing to worry about with AI is that we don't really have a, a good grasp or understanding of the copyrights office position as it relates to AI contributions and how that impacts the copyright ability of work, you know?
Speaker 1I have clients that use AI tools to help generate creative works, and on the one end of the spectrum, the copyright office has said that works of creative authorship generated by AI absolutely do not qualify for copyright protection. Only works generated by creative human intellect qualify for protection, but that leaves this grand canyon-sized gap you know, hole
Speaker 1in the middle of, of, you know, what, what, what AI tools are not outward facing or not outward generating enough that you can use them and still have sufficient creative human expression. You know, um, I would argue something like spell check, for example, is, is something that's been around for 20 years, 30 years. And that's never been a question of whether or not you did you use spellcheck.
Speaker 1So does your screenplay not qualify for copyright protection? I think that would be a very extreme and harsh position for the copyright office to take. And I don't think that they would. But then that becomes a slippery slope question. How much AI is OK to use before it's not? And that's not something that I think the court is really ever going to give us clear guidance on. It's just going to be litigated into the ground. Um, raises a lot of questions about the use of copyright law,
Speaker 1at least as it relates to substantially similar copyright works. AI throws a lot of the, uh, uh, I don't know, a lot of the basic assumptions of copyright law kind of throws them out the window. And so, you know, yeah, even with my clients, the studio clients that I work with, we are constantly trying to revise our internal corporate policy
Speaker 1as it relates to using A.I., Because it's just so ubiquitous in people's life that you can't tell people not to use it because they're just going to use it anyway. But then on the flip side, we worry about, well, how much of it are they using it and for what purposes? And does that impact the copyright ability of the final product? I don't think there's a good answer. Yeah, that's true.
Speaker 3That's a very hard answer because I think AI is only as good as the person using it in terms of copyright law, maybe. And how long is someone prepared to use it can also impact how much they're using it clearly.
Speaker 1But if I'm a VFX wizard and I've been studying visual effects software design for 30 plus some years and I build an AI algorithm tool that helps streamline my VFX, processing. Is that, you know, is that the same thing as someone typing into AI? Draw me a picture of a Pikachu. Like, like it, there's just so it's a grand Canyon size room for nuance and discussion and, that i just it like i don't know it it's a big can of worms.
Speaker 3I mean with ai and evolving technology um today i've recently uh well sorry recently i heard that there was a australian tv show called neighbors that was very popular in the uk and it's being reproduced for vertical watchers on instagram um instagram story you'll be able to to watch it there's so many evolving changes and So much technology is out there now, the way films are financed. It's helping and produced and distributed and owned and everything
Speaker 3like that. So how do you think the role of being an entertainment lawyer will evolve in Hollywood due to the nature of things?
Speaker 1We always got to stand our toes. We always got to be in front of what's happening. You know, the moment the technology changes, my understanding of how things done has to change because... You know, it wasn't even, you know, before AI, a lot of the stuff that would have been, like, really complicated, back-of-the-house, sophisticated accounting practices can all now be pretty much easily figured out with AI. Like, you know,
Speaker 1there are just constant changes in the technology that force me to re-understand my understanding of things. Like AI, like, again, you know, How much AI are you using and what is it generating? We just constantly have to be on the know of how things are changing, both from a law perspective and a technology perspective.
Speaker 3And in your opinion, what separates lawyers who have long lasting careers from those who remain vulnerable from one deal to the next?
Speaker 1I think it's that interest. Um, I know a lot of entertainment lawyers who oddly enough are not interested in entertainment. They, they don't own TVs. They don't go to the movies. They, they prefer to spend their weekends hiking and being outdoor in nature and stuff like that, which I mean, Hey, who doesn't it? Right. Like we all like some, like us some nature. Um, but you know, for me and for a lot of people that I know that do this, um, for life, it's, it's more than just a nine to five job. Like we, we eat, live and breathe what
Speaker 1we do. And, you know, I'm going, I try to go to a movie in theaters, you know, once a week, if not once every other week, we try to walk, I try to, my wife and I try to watch everything that comes out. We try to be exposed to even things that I don't, wouldn't have normally wanted to watch just for the sake of, you know, being in the cultural know. And it really does impact how I do deals for me to say, well, you remember this show over here and they did something like this over this, well, this is what we're doing over here. And this contract
Speaker 1is like this. Remember this deal from way back when, you know, having that, that interest in that knowledge, um, I hope makes me a better entertainment lawyer. I think makes me an entertainment, better entertainment lawyer. Um, There's also people that think that, you know, the farther removed you are from all the craziness, you can have a more unbiased opinion. But I don't know.
Speaker 3Who knows?
Speaker 2Yeah.
Speaker 3But one last question. What would make a proud native son of Iowa head west with his BA in economics from the University of Northern Iowa? to take on Hollywood?
Speaker 1Oh man, you know, it's, it's what I always wanted to do. It's, it's everything that I, I wanted to be growing up as a kid ever since, you know, I, I saw my first, the first movie I ever saw in theaters was Jurassic Park, the original Jurassic Park in 1993. First movie I ever remember catching a glimpse on from the television screen was the, the 1990s television version of it. I remember Steven, uh, Steven seeing Tim Curry's eyes from, you know, the sewer, the clown. You know, I remember getting,
Speaker 1you know, the VHS Star Wars box 90s collection where they had, you know, all of the behind the scenes and interviews with Alan Ladd Jr. that was the head of business and legal affairs at Fox at the time. And he talked about, you know, the contracts and the deals and stuff. And, you know, Jerry Maguire came out when I was a kid and show me the money and, you know, right. And it, it just like, there was so much growing up as a kid that I could
Speaker 1point to that. I was just like, this was always the plan. You know, I used to hang out at family video, AKA blockbuster. Um, you know, uh, uh, entourage came out when i was in college and everyone was like that's what josh is gonna go do and i'm like yeah that's what i'm gonna go do and you know that's that's kind of what we did so.
Speaker 3Sounds great i've been to iowa as a first place in america i've been to so yeah i remember it well okay okay very different from some of the other that's what i like about america you can be in a one state and it feels like a completely different country to another state yep so much uh choice and different cultures and everything like that.
Speaker 1Yeah. Yeah. My wife is from Romania and that's what I often reminder is, is it's like the United States is a lot like Europe, but, but, but every state is like its own kind of little pseudo country there. There's a lot of differences between them and the geography is, is vast and wide.
Speaker 2Complete.
Speaker 3That's a great way to put it. I say that, um, myself, when I, when I speak to people in England, um, you know, the United States is literally like Europe. There's so much to offer and so much to see. Well, Joshua, thanks again for coming on. I really appreciate you taking the time to speak to me. I'm going to put the link to your website in the show notes. So everyone listening, if you need to speak to Joshua, you need to contact him or you're curious about his website and more of his work, please feel free to look at the website and I'm sure you'll see some great stuff.
Speaker 1Awesome. Awesome. Thank you, Damien.
Speaker 4Thank you.
Speaker 1Thank you, audience, for having me. I really appreciate it.
How do you bring someone’s most painful memories to the screen with honesty and care?Damien Swaby speaks with writer and director Saila Kariat about Jesus Land, her adaptation of Julia Scheeres’s memoir exploring...
Mike Gallant and Seled Calderon join Damien Swaby to discuss BACKPAY, an independent neo-noir crime thriller about financial desperation, family and the consequences of believing one bad decision can fix...
Documentary filmmaker Luchina Fisher joins Damien Swaby to discuss the people and experiences that shaped her work.Growing up in a military family took Luchina from Texas to Germany and North Carolina. She reflects on...
Filmmaker Katie Cokinos joins Damien Swaby to reflect on a career shaped by independent cinema, personal vision and the determination required to get unconventional films made. Katie recounts beginning her career at the...
Rob Hollocks has spent more than two decades on both sides of the film business - helping major studios sell some of the biggest films in the world, while ultimately pursuing his ambition to write, direct and produce...