Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Filmmaking Conversations Podcast with Damien Swaby

Filmmaking Conversations Podcast with Damien Swaby artwork

Ep 233: The Audience is the Strategy: Caitlin Boyle on Purpose-Driven Distribution

Apr 30, 202545 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Episode Summary: In this episode, Damien Swaby is joined by Caitlin Boyle, a pioneering force in strategic documentary distribution and the founder of Film Sprout. Caitlin discusses how filmmakers can move beyond traditional release models to build meaningful connections with audiences through grassroots campaigns, non-theatrical screenings, and community engagement. Drawing on over a decade of experience guiding social impact films, she shares insights into how intentional distribution strategies can amplify a film’s reach and deepen its impact. Whether you're an independent filmmaker, producer, or distributor, this conversation is essential listening. What We Cover in This Episode: Caitlin’s career journey from WNET to founding Film Sprout The limitations of conventional theatrical distribution How community screenings can drive deeper engagement and real-world change Designing a distribution strategy with purpose from pre-production Real case studies from Film Sprout’s work with impact-driven documentaries Tips for filmmakers on connecting with grassroots organizations and educational institutions Why audience-building should be treated as a creative discipline Guest Bio - Caitlin BoyleCaitlin Boyle is the founder of Film Sprout, a consultancy that has shaped the distribution strategies of hundreds of independent documentaries focused on social justice, education, health, and the environment. With over 15 years of experience building grassroots outreach campaigns, she’s a recognized leader in impact distribution and a frequent speaker at DOC NYC, Sundance, and Good Pitch. Resources & Mentions: W: https://caitlinboyle.co E: hi@caitlinboyle.co

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1You are listening to the IFH podcast Network. For more amazing filmmaking and screenwriting podcasts, just go to IFH Podcastnetwork dot com.

Speaker 2Heitlen, How are you today, I'm great, Thanks so much for having me.

Speaker 1Thanks so much for coming on. I really really appreciate it. Since listening to your I think it's I'm right by saying a webinar you've done with a dot NYC and going on your website and finding out a lot about you, I thought there's no one better to discuss strategic distribution and crosswolds audience building. So I'm happy to have you on the podcast.

Speaker 2Thank you so much.

Speaker 1So I've done a lot of research about you and looked into your career and everything, But can you give us a brief overview, a small origin story of your background?

Speaker 2Sure? Absolutely. I began in production right out of graduate school. I got an internship at w NET, which is the flagship pbsd SH in New York City, and sort of by chance, like a lot of first jobs are, I was assigned to a film series called Wide Angle that repackaged feature length documentary films for television, and that was my first kind of job in the documentary space and

Speaker 2then I went on to work for some other independent producers and directors, and then again sort of by accident, I fell into the distribution space. A team that I had worked with doing you know, sort of low level associate production work, associate producer work, was in theatrical distribution and they were beginning to bring their film out into the world and needed somebody to help field the requests that they were getting. So I kind of raised my

Speaker 2hand and jumped into doing that. Little did I know that I was sort of testing out some new ways or some kind of reinventing some old ways of showing films and grassroots settings with that project, and so I kind of began to hone my skills in booking films in sort of unconventional or non traditional venues, and eventually I started a company called film Sprout that that kind of did that full time. So I started out as a freelancer, kind of working project to project, but when

Speaker 2I was twenty six, I started a company called film Sprout, and that really began to formalize, you know, my practice of experimenting with and trying to hone best practices of grassroots distribution. And I did that for ten years and then I sold Film Sprout in twenty nineteen and I continued in the documentary space. I worked at doc and MIC for several years as a director of filmmaker Development and the director of Industry. There. I've worked as an

Speaker 2impact producer and a consulting producer for dozens of documentary is maybe even hundreds at this point, and I currently in addition to doing impact producing with documentaries that are using the tools of grassroots distribution and social impact, I am also the executive director of the Middlebury New Filmmakers Festival, which is in Middlebury, Vermont and is a festival that exclusively showcases the work of first and second time directors

Speaker 2and producers.

Speaker 1Wow, what on origin story? I think that has to be the top one of the year. Easy, so involved and everything can start up Film Sprout, which I know and love. Can you tell us a bit about Film Sprout and what actually inspired you to take that direction of your career?

Speaker 2Yeah, sure, so yeah. I mean I think a lot of films, especially feature documentaries, which is my specialty, they have an ability to capture conventional distribution you know, television, broadcast, theatrical release now you know streaming or you know what used to be called home entertainment, but that often doesn't that kind of distribution. Even though it's sort of the conventional pathway for filmmakers to have their film seen and

Speaker 2to build an audience and hopefully to build or earn back some revenue, it often leaves the film team sort of feeling a bit of I don't want to say emptiness, that's probably too strong, but you know, feeling like something's lacking. You know, theatrical distribution less so, I think than broadcast and streaming because there's real live audiences in brick and mortar settings within the actual release. But you know, broadcast and streaming are just so anonymous. So even when you

Speaker 2have a really good, sort of solid, financially solid distribution deal through a broadcast and or a streaming contract, filmmakers often feel like they are disconnected from the audiences that are actually watching your film. They're disconnected from their viewership. They don't have the chance to kind of experience their film having its public life, and that is I think particularly sobering when filmmakers have made a film because they

Speaker 2want people to be engaged, because they want civic engagement or education or some kind of social change or some kind of you know, pose social activity to follow the film. You don't know if your film is on Netflix or Hulu or you know, broadcast on HBO. You don't really know who you've reached. You don't really know how you've moved people, whether you've moved people. You don't really have a clear sense of how your film is impacting audiences. And so films really grew out of a desire from filmmakers to make direct connections with their audiences and to

Speaker 2do so in settings where real, authentic, robust civic engagement could take place. So we took on. Eventually, we took on about ten films a year, and we complemented those films traditional conventional releases with grassroots what I called grassroots distribution, sort of grassroots distribution tours that would take the film on the road quite literally anywhere from thirty or forty screenings over several months, all the way to some films

Speaker 2having you know, hundreds of screenings over the course of a year or eighteen months. And what interesting about that model is not only did it meet the filmmaker's social goals, their goals to actually engage audiences and have audiences take action or their audiences kind of come together and do something meaningful after the film. It also was a source of revenue, and sometimes the revenue often actually the revenue from these non theatrical screenings, these grassroots screenings would match

Speaker 2or surpass the revenue that was coming in from traditional revenue streams over that same time period. So a theatrical release might bring in, you know, for a small film, you know, low six figures, and we could do the same revenue or better in non theatrical screenings. So not only was it sort of a way to engage audiences and develop audiences beyond the you know, theatrical audience or beyond the broadcast audience, it was also a way for us to generate some you know, modest but substantial revenue

Speaker 2for the film that would enable it to kind of be self sustaining in that space. So that was really you know, the for work and mission of film Sprout, and it worked really really well for ten years. It actually probably would have worked well for longer, but I was ready to grow after ten years, I was sort of ready to try new things and experiment and work in a new space. So it definitely, it definitely is a concept that is still quite viable, and lots of filmmakers will still pursue grassroots distribution on their own for

Speaker 2their own films, which I you know, I am a champion of and often wearing my consulting hat, I will often help filmmakers do that work, you know, aligned with best practices, but doing it themselves, you know, under their own shanngle.

Speaker 1We've specialized in navigating both traditional and alternative distribution pathways. Can you share your thoughts on the evolving landscape or film distribution?

Speaker 2Yeah, you know, I think film distribution in independent film distribution is and probably always has been a volatile sector. It's changing all the time, it is always in a state of rediscovery, let's say, to put it positively, I think, you know, technology has changed and has always changed and is now still changing quite rapidly, which influences how films

Speaker 2are exhibited and how audiences in age with those films. And I think that creates this kind of prey, precarious quality to distribution that can be really hard to navigate. So, you know, I think the place that we are in now, as even you know, lay people can see, is we're in a place where there's an enormous amount of content, and content even as a word, kind of signifies what has been happening, which is this modification, this idea that

Speaker 2films are sort of a product and that we need to have a lot of product in the warehouse in order to create capital, which is it's sad. I actually I think, you know, I actually think it's really antithetical to the reasons that a lot of filmmakers make films in the first place. So we're in this kind of distribution landscape that is devaluing films as a form of artistic expression, as a form of you know, esthetic development of the particular artist or the you know, the director.

Speaker 2I think we're in a place where journalistic values, which have often informed documentary productions at least in part, you know, those are devalued as well. So we're in a tough moment right now. And I think the streaming apparatus, which you know, over the last ten to fifteen years has sort of emerged and shifted multiple times. I think it contributes to this sort of cultural conception as as film as content as product, which is particularly sustainable if you

Speaker 2don't think for the like sort of artistic project or the creative project that that is film, and I'm not even so sure it's sustainable as sort of a you know, a profit bearing enterprise either. We are seeing that streamers have really tightened their perse strings when it comes to purchasing independent content. They're not buying as much from you know, almost almost nothing at all from independent producers, and when they do, the figures that are being paid are pretty low, certainly not numbers. Filmmakers are certainly not receiving revenue from

Speaker 2streamers with any kind of consistency that could actually sustain you know, future production or even help them recoup their their production costs for the film they're selling. So, you know, I think we're in a bit of a pickle when it comes to the conventional distribution landscape. That said, the hopeful side of that equation is that I think wherever there is you know, sort of bleakness or closed doors in the conventional landscape, the more opportunity there is for

Speaker 2creativity and innovation and experimentation outside of the conventional landscape. And I think what we're seeing now is that filmmakers are you know, really thinking hard about when their film is done, how can they bring it to audiences directly, how can they work around or in complement with conventional sort of commercial distribution strategies to to find audiences on their own. And I think that's a trend that we've

Speaker 2seen over and over sort of in fits and starts, as there's been a you know, a condensing or a limiting, you know, as there is scarcity in the conventional space, I think there is more like expansion in the you know, independent distribution and grassroots distribution space. So that's hopeful to me, but it does put a lot of the onus on the filmmaker, the filmmaking teams themselves to kind of imagine

Speaker 2that distribution and to then you know, manifest it, to actually make it a reality. You know that that's where that's where that work is taking place, is taking place within small production companies, within small film teams. It's really not being champed and by by any sort of conventional distributors. So yeah, I think there's reasons for hope, there's reasons for optimism, but there's also you know, the sobering reality of a very very limited commercial landscape for independent film.

Speaker 1Compleatally understandable and as you said earlier, I understand completely about content producers and the word content and what type of effect it's had on things, and how people view films and why they're created in the mass of content that people like to hear or talk about some people anyway, but a different subject in some ways. But you work on a hundred independent films you mentioned, I would say it was close with the five hundred. You know so

Speaker 1much you've done. Maybe what common themes or challenges do you often see when it comes to distribution strategies that filmmakers are definitely implentent.

Speaker 2Yeah, you know, I have worked on both narratives and nonfiction features, but certainly my area of expertise has been in documentary film, and I think there is probably the most expansive opportunities within documentary, So that's one area of focus. I think there are exceptions. There are narrative films that do very very well with grassroots distribution and sort of alternative distribution techniques, and that's particularly when those narrative films

Speaker 2have really clear pro social aims. You know, they're really trying to engage audiences that belong to certain groups or that care about certain issues. But documentary in general, that's sort of the first specialization and then in terms of common themes. I mean, one of the things that I often will counsel filmmakers about when they are trying to imagine and envision an alternative distribution pathway for their film outside of the commercial system. One of the things I counseled them to think about is, you know, what is

Speaker 2the ethos of the films narrative itself, and then how can you tap into that ethos, that story that you're telling to find like minded audiences who will champion your film. So, for example, films that do really well in grassroots distribution often have narrative themes within them that champion grassroots activation. You know, so a film is about I'll give an example of a film I worked on really early on, probably around two thousand and eight, I worked on a

Speaker 2film called Pray the Devil Back to Hell, directed by Jenny Reticker and produced by Abby Disney, and the film was about a group of Liberian women who joined together as peace builders, as peace activists in Liberia against the regime of Charles Taylor. And the film is this incredibly harrowing and also inspiring document of these women coming together against incredible odds and up against incredibly oppressive power structures

Speaker 2to essentially stop a civil war, you know, end a civil war. And that film did incredibly well in grassroots distribution, I think in part because it was telling the story of women who started with nothing, formed grassroots networks and you know, banded together to speak truth to power without a sort of concentrated source of income or structure or organization. And whenever you have a film that tells the story

Speaker 2of local power, grassroots organization, kind of the David and Goliath story where the small rise up, you're going to attract the kinds of organizers and programmers and curators and audiences who like that kind of story. You know, those people who are willing to kind of put their their blood, sweat and tears, you know, invest their blood, sweat and tears into hosting a big community screening. You know, they're the kind of people who are going to think outside the box and say, hey, let's host this film, you know,

Speaker 2on the campus squad and project it against this building. You know, let's let's project this building on the side of a barn. Let's let's use this vacant lot and show this film about you know, urban development. And you know filling in brown fields in the urban environment. Let's use this vacant lot for that. You know you're going to attract those kinds of audiences. So a lot of times filmmakers are kind of thinking, okay, yeah, I want to pursue alternative distribution, So like, how do I do it? What's step one, what's step two, what's step three? And to an extent, there is sort of a method to

Speaker 2the madness, But you also have to really lean into the particular qualities of the film itself and say, who does this film speak to? Who are the audiences who are going to naturally champion this film, what do they belong to? Where are they already? Where are we going to meet people where they already are. You know, that's why grassroots distribution works is it doesn't require someone to come to you. It actually brings the film to people where they are, to the classroom, to the boardroom, to

Speaker 2the conference room, to the vacant lot, to the barn, to the campus squad. It actually says, you know, you, guys, say where you are, you have a good thing going, and now we're going to bring you the film and you're going to integrate that film into this existing social fabric that you're a part of. Conventional distribution is the opposite of that. It says, buy a ticket, come to this place at this time, and if you follow all those rules, then you can watch this film. You know. It kind of demands that the audience show up outside of their home, outside of their workplace, outside of their

Speaker 2vocational space. And that can work. But there's no real surprise then that those kinds of viewing experiences are limited because they're pretty dogmatic, you know, they kind of enforce rules upon an audience, and grassroots stitution turns all of that on a seat.

Speaker 1Excellent. I love that, and yeah, it's so true. Demanding of an audience turn up, so I don't speak today, turn up, show up and you know, and watch the film at this time. That is certainly not the best way sometimes nowadays. Now one things, one thing that can be a really slow process thinking about what you said, is building a strong, dedicated audience. I mean, what advice could you give to filmmakers who are just starting out and how to build a nurture a grassroots audience from the ground up.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's a great question. A lot of the work that I do with filmmakers, either as a consulting producer on their projects or as an impact producer or a distribution consultant, is actually really like rolling up our sleeves and digging into that question, like who who are your audiences? And let's be really candid and honest and frank about who your audiences are. I think there's a tendency for filmmakers to kind of think that their film is for everyone, or that they've made a general audience film, and I actually think there's like that's just a big mythology, Like

Speaker 2I don't know that there's any real general audience. And even when we have said, oh, this film is for general audiences, like who are we really talking about. We're talking about probably like mainstream, dominant culture. We're probably not talking when we say general audience about everybody. We're talking about like white, mainstream sort of maybe middle America, middle class even upper middle class audience, so you know, able bodied, you know, all the sort of like you know, uh, all the sort of most empowered audiences is what we've

Speaker 2historically thought of as general audiences. So I like to say, like, let's really think about how who your core audiences are for this film and start there and let's let's imagine those audiences in great detail. And one of the ways to do that is to look at the protagonists of a film. So you look at the film's narrative. You look at who the protagonists, the participants in the film, if it's a documentary, if it's a if it's a fiction film, the the you know, fictional protagonists, and you say, hey, who are they? Who are their identities, how old are they?

Speaker 2What are their demographics? You know, what's their race, what's their ethnicity, what's their income level, what's there are they? Are they disabled? Are they you know, are they empowered in their communities? Are they leaders? Are they followers? Like really digging deep into like who are these main characters of your film, what are their professions, where do they live, what do they belong to, what do they believe in? Are they liberal? Are they conservative? That's your core audience, you know, core audience is your protagonist. And I think a lot of people kind of bristle at that because

Speaker 2they're like, well, I didn't just make my film for like to preach to the choir, like I want other people to see my film too. But the reality is that without you know, multi million dollar advertising budgets which can really cast a wide net. And you know, put your film out in front of millions of people. You know, you're you're going to have a whisper campaign is going to be your your marketing strategy. Word of mouth. You know, people in what sociologists call in group validation. You know

Speaker 2someone your sister, your mom, your friend, your teacher is going to say, oh my god, I just saw this incredible film. You really have to go see it. That's how you're actually going to build audiences is person by person, group by group, affinity by affinity. So I actually really counsel filmmakers to think about who their protagonists are and then say, okay, which audiences are most like our protagonists. Sometimes I'd even done an exercise with filmmakers where we really charted out. We actually like put it in a

Speaker 2spreadsheet and we say, okay, like, you have person a in your film, and this is what they do, and this is how old they are. You know they're a teacher at a urban high school. Okay, urban high school teachers, Like that's one of your core audients. How are we going to reach them? Where are they? What groups do they belong to, What conferences do they attend, what kind of professional development do they seek out? You know, where do they go, what do they do for fun? Where do they go for fun? And then that's how you build your strategy. Now, all of that is just not to say that you can't show films to people or

Speaker 2build audiences among people who are not represented in your film. You can, but you first need to sort of evangelize and communicate with that core audience. Because that core audience is who is going to tell their mom and their sister and their boyfriend and their cousin. That's how you're actually, you know, their coworker. That's how you're actually going to start to step beyond that choir is to really empower the choir to like sing that song, you know, like you really want that core audience to feel like they have the tools to spread the word about your film.

Speaker 2And so, you know, I often will sort of procedurally walk filmmakers through the process of ide eating and like enumerting who those audiences are. It's a bit of a slog, you know. It's it's real, like tactical work. It's not it's not just like envisioning, like making your vision board of who your audience is. It can be that, and I think you do have to first kind of imagine what your goals are. But it's really tactical work, like

Speaker 2you really have to like build spreadsheets, make lists, figure out how you're going to reach people in their communities and in the groups they already belong to. And that's pretty onerous, kind of administrative, almost you know, clerical work that needs to happen. So a lot of the counseling I do with filmmakers, a lot of the coaching I do with filmmakers is about, like, you know, do you is that what you want to do? Do you want to be doing a bunch of data entry and kind of really really procedural sort of you know, detail oriented

Speaker 2work to reach your audiences because that is what it takes. And if you don't want to do it, then you have to find someone who does, or grassroots distribution isn't going to be for you, you know, that's the sort of that's the reality of that work is. It's it's it's like political campaign. You got to knock on doors, you know, you've got to go house to house and knock on doors and get one dollar and five dollars donations. And that's that's what grassroots distribution is like as well. It's it's person to person and then every so often you hit on this sort of gold mine. You you reach

Speaker 2somebody who says, oh, yeah, I run a thirty thousand person list SERVE and everybody on that list Serve needs to see this film. And then you're like, whoa, Okay, it's this gold mine and we're ready to go. But you know, it takes a lot of sort of one to one outreach before you get to that, you know, get to that point.

Speaker 1That's amazing. And I completely understand what you mean because I know some one or two really good filmmakers, documentary filmmakers in particular, But when it comes to the grassroots side of things, of spreadsheets, knocking on doors, doing the things that they feel someone else to do it, it doesn't really work out the way possible for them because it's better that they're involved, even if they have someone helping them out. Yes, it's better if they're involved. So, you, yourself, have been central to so many great films. Could you

Speaker 1share an example of a successful impact campaign you've been involved with and what exactly made itself successful.

Speaker 2Oh, that's such a great question. There's so many there's so many kinds and permutations. I'll give an example of one from you know, several years ago that was just really broad in scope, because I think sometimes the size and the quantity of a campaign is one measure of its success. I don't think it's the only measure. But I was part of a film impact and distribution campaign, Gosh, I guess it was about eight or nine years ago now,

Speaker 2for a film called The Hunting Ground, which is about campus sexual assaults. And the film really sort of investigated, pulled back the curt in on an epidemic of campus sexual assault in the United States. Of course, it takes place everywhere as well, and the campaign eventually actually extended to the UK and Canada as well as the United States, and I think to some extent across Europe as well. But the film really, especially especially investigated the not so

Speaker 2much the kind of rampant condition of sexual assault happening on US colleges, but the mishandling or the intentional silencing and sort of covering up of that particular epidemic on college campuses by campus administration. So it really was kind of a seeking you know, speaking truth to power kind of investigative film with a journalistic then it was kind

Speaker 2of breaking this story, you know, in many ways. And the film had a conventional release. It was released in theaters by a distributor that doesn't exist anymore, but it was a subsidiary of the of the Weinstein Company and sort of ironically, and it also had a broadcast on CNN, which again this is like, this is actually an example of how volatile are our industry is CNN films documentary films also doesn't exist anymore. And the theatrical distributor, which

Speaker 2was called Radius, doesn't exist anymore. It's parent company doesn't exist anymore. And this is this is within a decade, you know, So there's so much volatility. But you know, so the film, the film had these conventional, you know, structures in place to get it to audiences. But the film is about college campuses. So here again is this example of where do you go if you want to build an audience, go where the protagonists are. And the main protagonists of this film were these two particular student activists who were really kind of ringing the alarm bell

Speaker 2around this epidemic of campus sexual assault, and so we really really leaned into developing and building audiences on college campuses, mostly girls and women students of all kinds, who were really organizing, again in a grassroots fashion on their campuses to you know, to raise the alarm for their administration and to hold their administrations to account. And so we ended up doing hundreds upon hundreds of screenings across the United States on college campuses, and in many cases the

Speaker 2folks that were hosting the screenings were already sort of active on this issue on their campuses, but they didn't have a way to like tell the story in a concise, ninety minute, you know, emotionally impactful way. So they were doing this long slog of grassroots organizing and advocacy and activism, and suddenly here was this tool in the form of a featured documentary that could kind of, you know, really you know, jump start their activism or could continue that you know, kind of you know, propel their activism forward.

Speaker 2And we ended up having you know, I remember in the early days of that campaign, when the film was still in theaters, we were getting like one hundred requests a day to screen the film. Of course, not all of those kind of materialized, but it was extremely high volume, and we ran the campaign for about eighteen months. And ultimately this was under the Obama administration. Ultimately the White House you know, formed a task force on the issue, and there was real change. There was real change from

Speaker 2the Department of Education at the federal level in the United States to change how sexual assaults was viewed and adjudicated and handled and sort of culturally seen on college campuses. So that's an example of a campaign that really, you know, lad an enormous national impact. But like I say, quantity and scope and like the sides of a campaign is not the only you know, it is not the only measure of a campaign success. I've also worked on campaigns that were much more modest in size in terms of

Speaker 2the number of screenings or the number of people who saw the film, but were impactful in their own way. You know, I worked on a film. I've worked on several films about reproductive justice where you know, the film was used to raise money to help women in the US, you know, pay for abortions that they couldn't pay for because we don't have abortion care you know, enshrined in our in our you know, constitution, as a as a

Speaker 2national right, and so you know, sometimes there's a campaign that maybe serves you know, maybe has fifty screenings, you know, it maybe serves five or ten thousand audiences instead of hundreds of thousands of audiences, but it still could make a huge difference in the life of a person or the like or the you know, the life of you know, a dozen people, or it can serve as sort of an emblem for activists and advocates to say, here's what's possible, Like here's the here's an example of what's possible, and you can imagine new future. So I like to be

Speaker 2sort of, I don't know, generous in my interpretation of successful campaigns, because I think any time of film sort of inspires someone to make a move towards social good, whatever that is. I think that's an impact. I have sort of a low bar for impact in that way, because I think we can't only measure it by like legislation changing, you know, or you know, some kind of being bold national news, you know, event taking place.

Speaker 1So, so, how do you approach the challenge of align in a film social impact goals with its distribution strategy can then coexist without one of the shadow in the other.

Speaker 2Yeah, that's the trick really is keeping them in balance. I think that in one sense, a rising tide lifts all boats. So if a film has really broad distribution, its potential for impact is that much bigger. You know, the more people who see it, the more publicity there is around a film, the more critical review, the more screens it's on, the the you know, the more profound its festival life is. That's just an indication of how much more potential there is for that film to make

Speaker 2a social impact. So I think in that sense they can kind of like they're not in conflict, you know, they kind of rise in tandem with each other and they're not mutually exclusive. On the other hand, there can be moments strategically where a film's you know, revenue bearing goals, let's say, the needs for the filmmakers or the distributor to recoup revenue can sometimes be at odds with the desire to bring a film to a pro social audience, you know, or an engaged audience. For example, lots of

Speaker 2grassroots film campaigns are self funded, so the audience pays a small amount for the film, either a small ticket fee, which then is returned to the filmmakers, or a licensing fee that let's say a campus or an organization pays let's say two hundred dollars or three hundred dollars or five hundred dollars, something like that, something relatively modest, and in exchange for that licensing fee, the filmmakers, you know, provide the film. They often provide discussion materials or screening guidelines.

Speaker 2They might the filmmaker might travel with the film and make a small fee, and in that way, by charging a licensing fee or an honorarium, the filmmakers typically will be able to kind of sustain those efforts. So it becomes this sort of you know, virtuous circle where by getting a small amount of revenue from each person who screens the film, the filmmakers can continue to offer the film for community organizations and it can be you know,

Speaker 2economically self sustaining. But you can imagine then how sometimes the revenue goals of a film might be at odds with the access you know, that that might be possible for a film. So let's say an organization says, well, we can't pay the two hundred and fifty dollars for the film, but we have a thousand students, who are you know, the perfect audience for this film. Well, the filmmaker, the film team has to make a decision, you know, strategically, like is it better for us to get this fee or is it better for us to reach this audience?

Speaker 2And so those you know, that's just a sort of microcosmic example that that can happen on a much larger scale as well. But you know, those are the kinds of decisions that I usually am coaching filmmakers through. And you have to make sure that your eyes are sort of on the prize holistically. So what I would say is like each film team has to identify a goal at the outset of their distribution and social impact and

Speaker 2then make decisions that point toward that goal. So, if in order to have a social impact campaign, you need to charge X amount for your film or else it's not sustainable, well charging that amount is probably has to remain your goal and your priority, because otherwise you just can't continue to provide the film. On the other hand, some film teams will start with some charitable funds, some you know, grant funds that don't have to be repaid, and they can put that towards the effort of getting their film out and so they can be more generous in terms of, you know, whether they charge a licensing fee,

Speaker 2and so their goals are a little bit different. So every film team kind of needs to identify, like what is the core mission for our distribution and our social impact and then make you know, a range of decisions that you know, kind of filter under that core goal. And it's really for every project. It's hard to like make blanket statements about, you know, the perfect way to keep this in balance for every film, because every film has slightly different goals around you know, the amount of money they need to recoup, how often their filmmakers can travel,

Speaker 2you know, what their particular audience can afford to pay for a film, whether or not they have philanthropic support that enables them to maybe take some more risks or be more generous. So it really does depend on each particular project.

Speaker 1And you mentioned funding something you've consulted on and grant writing, which I think sometimes filmmakers need a lot of help with. How can filmmakers effectively pitch their films to funders and ensure they are communicating the social impact of their work clearly.

Speaker 2Yeah, I think this is something that has evolved a lot in the last you know, fifteen years or so. Really, what I often counsel filmmakers to do when they're writing grants or when I support grant writing filmmakers, something that I'm often editing in the grand proposal is the scope and size of the social impact campaign and the goals. I think there's a tendency to think really big and to kind of imagine, like what would you do if

Speaker 2you had unlimited resources? But the fact is, the reality is, like I was saying about grassroots distribution, is social change work is like really difficult and time consuming and labor intensive, and it's incremental. You know, it happens over years and decades and generations sometimes. And so what the most common mistake I see filmmakers making in their grand applications or funding pitches is kind of promising too much, Like they're imagining that so much more can be done with so much less money and in so much less time than

Speaker 2is really kind of realistic and feasible. So I think again, it's kind of striking a balance between like your ultimate target for a film, the mission or the social change that you hope it contributes to and keeping that sort of wild imaginative expanse of vision, keeping it in check with Okay, but what can we do in the life cycle of a film, you know, on the other side of the spectrum, like what can we do in eighteen months? What can we do in two years? A lot of

Speaker 2films will uncover stories of in let's say, you know, deep systemic injustice or long term generational human rights abuses, you know, or you know, generational conflicts or systems of oppression that have been kind of built over you know, decades or generations or even centuries. You know. So many films, especially documentary films on social issues, are really you know, sort of telling the story of social problems that have

Speaker 2been created over huge sloths of time and are really deeply and then they'll propose a social impact campaign that will be like, hey, a film will like undo this, you know, in two years, and it's like, no, like that's not gonna happen. But what I think, you know, that's not cynicism that drives me to say that, it's just realism. It's it's actually a sort of hopeful thought, which is, you know, you're not gonna undo you know, decades of oppression or decades of harm. But what you

Speaker 2can do is be part of a conversation and part of a movement and a tool and a resource for the kind of long term crusaders and organizers who have been working on this issue for a long time before you made the film and for a long time after the film will be, you know, obsolete. You are creating a resource for those folks to do their work better, their existing work better. So grant applications funding pitches, they really need to kind of realistically situate a film within this like broader context of the social movement or the

Speaker 2social change or just the pro social activity that is already taking place within that issue area, and then needs to kind of say, like the pitch itself needs to then say, here's how our film can like uniquely empower that group or offer a tool that doesn't exist yet, or a more efficient tool, you know, a more efficient way of communicating or rallying people together, or getting people pumped up about something, you know, or emotionally charging people who are who are tired or fatigued, you know, are ready to give up. Like it's more about figuring out

Speaker 2where do you belong within this big ecosystem of the social issue, as opposed to saying like we are the thing that is going to you know, tip the scales or turn the tides on this issue, which is just so rarely you know the case. So it's really about being realistic and specific and you know, like really kind of brutally honest with yourself as a filmmaker, is like, well, what can my film do? Because the truth is that to make social changes, we need all the things. We need legislation, we need policy, we need leaders, you know,

Speaker 2we need better organization, we need resources, and we need stories like stories or peace of all the things we need. So it's really about like rapespizing your your ask. You know, it's about right sizing your pitch more than more than like the exact you know words you use or you know, the amount of money you ask.

Speaker 1For perfectly put. And I think many many, many of the listeners, the filmmakers, documentary filmmakers will really really appreciate that that was an amazing answer to the question. I'm very thankful for and I'd also be thankful for if I can put in one sneaky last question, if that's okay, what advice? So not what advice. That's a wrong way to start. Having made the transition from a big city like New York to Vermont, how does the current environment

Speaker 1shape your perspective on independent film and community outreach.

Speaker 2Oh, that's such a good question. I don't think anyone's asked me that before. I think actually I've gained some perspective, like moving out of New York City. I live now like five hours outside of the city, so it's not particularly easy to get to New York, although I am in New York somewhat frequently. But I think it's just that perspective of kind of just being at a remove from the you know, sometimes quite insular world of independent film, especially the New York based documentary world, is really small,

Speaker 2and I think just being at a slight removed from it helps you see like what's important, what's not important. And I also think the other piece that's been really personally gratifying is just to see how much film culture can thrive in a small place. You know, Vermont is really rural. There's not very many people here, you know, just in terms of sheer numbers, we're all spread out, and yet there's this like super rich art culture, literary culture to some degree, cinema culture in the state, and

Speaker 2for someone who has really dedicated themselves for a long time to like grassroots ways of consuming film, it's really gratifying just being a place where small communities, small community owned theaters, family owned cinemas, you know, community community run like you know, performing arts organizations are really thriving, you know. And so yeah, I think it's given me sort of like a fresh look at the industry. And you know,

Speaker 2just the perspective that comes from being at an arm's length from.

Speaker 1Something sounds amazing. Family one cinema and the community performing arts. Sounds like you made a wise move real Yeah, except well, thanks so much for coming and I really really appreciate it. You've been an amazing guest on the podcast, really good, great answers. People are going to learn a lot, and I can't wait for people to listen to this. And I'll put all your details in the show notes of your website and everything else, and I hope people learn even more from you. Thanks so much for coming.

Speaker 2On, Thank you so much for having me and for your excellent questions. It was a pleasure.

Speaker 1Thank you

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep 298: Saila Kariat on Jesus Land: Adapting Trauma and Directing Juliette Lewis

    Nov 1, 202658 minAudio

    How do you bring someone’s most painful memories to the screen with honesty and care?Damien Swaby speaks with writer and director Saila Kariat about Jesus Land, her adaptation of Julia Scheeres’s memoir exploring...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep 297: Joshua Lastine: Film Contracts, Copyright and Creative Ownership

    Oct 31, 202656 minAudio

    When someone helps rewrite your script, who owns the finished story? And what happens when the person financing your film wants to change it? Entertainment lawyer Joshua Lastine joins Damien Swaby on Filmmaking...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep 296: Stop Waiting, Start Filming: Mike Gallant and Seled Calderon on BACKPAY

    Oct 14, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    Mike Gallant and Seled Calderon join Damien Swaby to discuss BACKPAY, an independent neo-noir crime thriller about financial desperation, family and the consequences of believing one bad decision can fix...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep 295: Emmy Award-Winning Filmmaker Luchina Fisher: The Stories We Carry

    Sep 18, 202657 minAudio

    Documentary filmmaker Luchina Fisher joins Damien Swaby to discuss the people and experiences that shaped her work.Growing up in a military family took Luchina from Texas to Germany and North Carolina. She reflects on...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep 294: Katie Cokinos: From Slacker to I Dream Too Much

    Sep 7, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Filmmaker Katie Cokinos joins Damien Swaby to reflect on a career shaped by independent cinema, personal vision and the determination required to get unconventional films made. Katie recounts beginning her career at the...

    Credit the people on this episode