Ep 254: The Science Behind the Screen: A NASA Consultant's Hollywood Adventures
48 minAudio
Hello and welcome back to the show. Today, I'm joined by Les Johnson, a NASA technologist, science fiction author, and consultant on films like Europa Report and Lost in Space. We'll be diving into what it takes to bring science to the screen, how to balance scientific truth with a good story, and the real-world passion behind space travel. Stick around, you won't want to miss this!Show Notes What is a Science Consultant? Les explains his role as a science consultant on films and TV shows like Europa Report, Lost in Space, and Beacon 23. He describes the different levels of input he has had, from a deep collaboration on Europa Report to being dismissed from a project for stating a plot point was "totally implausible". Balancing Science and Storytelling: A major challenge is balancing scientific accuracy with a compelling narrative. Les shares that he and his editors work to avoid "data dumps" and instead provide just enough detail for a lay reader to find the story plausible without getting bogged down in technicalities. He also discusses the common trope of faster-than-light travel and how it's often used to make a story more interesting, even if it's not currently possible according to the laws of physics. Inspirational Sci-Fi: Les names two TV series he considers the "gold standard" for accuracy and creativity: For All Mankind, which presents an alternate history of the space race, and The Expanse, which he praises for its special effects and technical consulting. The Passion for Space: Les traces his love for science and storytelling back to his childhood, recalling the pivotal moment of watching the Apollo landing at age seven and later watching reruns of the original Star Trek with his sisters. This led him to pursue a career as a physicist at NASA. A Personal Imperative: He believes that spreading life from Earth into the universe is an "imperative". He discusses his philosophical belief that life on Earth is special and worth preserving by expanding it to other worlds like Mars and the moons of Jupiter. He also notes that getting to Mars will be a "very, very difficult" process, likely starting with domed cities and self-sufficient colonies W: https://www.lesjohnsonauthor.com Use Promo Code "FILMMAKINGSWABY" for all my deals or just click the link: 25% Off More Labs https://www.morelabs.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off Strong Coffee Company https://strongcoffeecompany.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 15% Off Tussle https://www.tusslegear.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off Eric Javits https://ericjavits.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 25% Off Quantum Energy Square https://quantumsquares.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off Long Table https://longtablepancakes.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off HyperNatural https://hypernaturalstyle.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 20% Off wearplayground https://wearplayground.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 15% Off STAND+ https://www.standshoes.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 10% Off Molly Bz https://mollybz.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY 41% Off Cozy Earth https://cozyearth.com/discount/FILMMAKINGSWABY
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1You are listening to the IFH podcast Network. For more amazing filmmaking and screenwriting podcasts, just go to ifhpodcastnetwork dot com.
Speaker 2Hello, and welcome back to Filmmaking Conversations with Me your host Damien Swaby. Today I'm joined by Les Johnson, and that's a technologist, science fiction author and consultant on films like Europa Report and Lost in Space. We'll be diving into what it takes to bring science to the screen and how to balance scientific truth with a good story and the real world passion behind science. Travel Stick around. You won't want to miss this excellent conversation. Les. So
Speaker 2you've worked on You've worked as sorry a technical consultant on Europa Report, Lost in Space and Beacon twenty three. What does a science consultant actually do on a film or TV project?
Speaker 1It largely depends on the director and the staff that he assigns to it. The most extensive input I had technically was on Europa Report, and I was really pleased because they were very focused on telling a good story and making it believable and we're willing to work with me and me work with them to help make that story believable. And then I've had other experiences where I
Speaker 1was interviewed for a film that shall not be named that they were considering to use me as a consultant. They ran it by me and I said, well, hey, that's totally implausible. No one would ever do it that way. And their response was, well, we won't use you. That was a different film. So it just depends. And then on some of the others, it's a mix. I get feedback from the directors or their staff, well, we appreciate your input, but that's a major plot element. We're going to have to keep that, but we can change this other thing you suggested to make it more realistic. And
Speaker 1it just just depends on who I'm working.
Speaker 2With and when they say make it more realistic in what ways?
Speaker 1Well, I go to see a lot of science fiction films, as you might imagine, I'm such a genre fan, both of the written word as well as in theaters, and make it more realistic would be you know, what would these what would the bridge of the ship look like? What would be some of the control systems that they would have, which makes nice, you know, background to make the setting look realistic. Other elements might be well, how would you what propulsion systems might we have in twenty five years or thirty years or one hundred years that
Speaker 1would enable us to get to say, Europa in a matter of months versus years, right, And I have to look at what possible technologies could be developed and flown and what are their real limits in terms of performance, so that when they're saying, you know, start the few usion engine or whatever it may be, it makes sense and it's not something that's totally ridiculous like you see in a lot a lot of films where they don't hire a consultant or someone just does a Google search.
Speaker 2Are there any recent sci fi films or series that really impressed you with their accuracy or creativity?
Speaker 1Well, there are two TV series that I think have done a really excellent job in the last five to ten years. One aired on Apple TV. I had nothing to do with it. I wish I could claim credit. It's called for All Mankind and it was an alternate history of the space Race of the sixties that imagined the Apollo landing did not happen before the Soviets could get there, and the Soviets were actually the first to land on the Moon and the USA was second. And how that would alter history moving forward toward the present day.
Speaker 1Really really well done. They went out of their way to be accurate, gave a very fair portrayal, in my opinion, to real historical characters, some of whom I had met in my early career days. Thought they did an excellent job with that. The other was The Expanse, which is based on a really best selling science fiction book series.
Speaker 2And.
Speaker 1It's a solar system wide first contact kind of adventure, and they really did a nice job with special effects and had really good technical consultants. Again, I'm jealous that I wasn't involved.
Speaker 2I can understand it sounds like you really know these shows and like them really well. But if you could fix one scientifically implausible situation in a film, what would it be.
Speaker 1Well, that's a tough one because there is a very common theme and a lot of science fiction that we just don't think is possible, and I wish it were, but the known laws of physics say it isn't. And that's going faster than Light and Star Wars, Star Trek. Most science fiction movies have us zipping around the galaxy like we would get on an airplane and travel from here to Singapore right wherever here is, you know, going to another part of the globe, And unfortunately, the laws
Speaker 1of physics aren't going to let us do that as we understand it. I'm holding out hope that we find out we're all wrong, we missed a loophole, and one day we'll be able to do that. But unfortunately, I think there's a misperception in the public's mind because of that, that it's inevitable we'll have a faster than light drive, and it sure doesn't look that way. So I think what I would fix is trying to level set people's expectations, and I would have more science fiction space adventures set in a realistic space travel kind of scenario.
Speaker 2When you say the speed of light, why do you think that mistake is always happening, Because even in the UK, where I'm from, we have that in some of our shows and some of our films.
Speaker 1I think it's because it makes the show more interesting and fun. I mean, what's more fun than being the Captain of the Enterprise on Star Trek and exploring strange new worlds? Right, and you've only got nine worlds or eight worlds to explore in your own Solar system. Where you have to go to sleep for a thousand years to get to the nearest one. It kind of makes could make a boring story arc. So I think they they and I tend to ignore this problem because I like a good story like the next person, and so
Speaker 1I'm willing to suspend by disbelief on faster than like travel because I think it's a it's a clue in order to tell an interesting story. And if they try to get everything else right or close to right, but assume that, Okay, well we found some new theory of physics and we're able to do this, but everything else still holds, I'm okay with that. I like to enjoy it. I love Star Wars. Who doesn't very few I haven't found very many people who don't.
Speaker 2And it's clear that you are a love of storytelling with scientific integrity. As both a NASA technologist and a science fixed sorry and a fiction author. How do you balance the scientific truth with the narrative drama or do the two ever conflict?
Speaker 1The two definitely conflict, and that's why you have a good editor. The editors I've had at both ban Books and tor who are my two science fiction publishing houses, are very very good at telling me when I've got too much of what they call a data dump, where I try to explain somehow in the story the science that's enabling something to happen, and they have to remind me less you're telling a story, You're not writing a popular science and nonfiction book, which I also do, And
Speaker 1so sometimes I mess up and I put in too much detail. I think the balance is to put in just enough detail so that the lay reader or the educated in the field reader knows that it's plausible without necessarily me getting bogged down in the intricacies of how the propulsion system works. Right, So it's story first, absolutely, And when I do mess that up again, I love a good editor. It's actually comforting to know that they
Speaker 1take the time and come back and help me correct that out of the story sometimes.
Speaker 2So how do you approach creating and crafting characters and plots that feel grounded in science yet emotionally resonant for readers and potential viewers.
Speaker 1Well, I try to put the story first. I can give an example the setting for one of one of my novels, Mission to Methany. It was about a first contact and it came about as actually a result of a conversation at work one day in a meeting, and I came home that night and plotted out the story. But I wanted to have a compelling character have this encounter. So the character I created was a man who is
Speaker 1on the autism spectrum, and I told the story from his perspective without ever really mentioning that he was on the spectrum, just trying to convey how someone who looks at the world differently might interpret the events around them. And to get that right, I consulted some folks that have in conversation I know that they're on the spectrum and ask them to read it, and they helped me correct and make sure I was telling the story, you know, in a way that would be plausible for a person
Speaker 1with a different way of looking at the world right, would interpret the events that were happening. That was a story I wanted to tell of a neurodivergent person who was encountering these things in our future, and it worked. The book got good reviews, and I got some really good feedback from pretty broad range of readers on that.
Speaker 2Gosh, that's one of the most original stories I think I've ever heard. Wow, and how much time do you take to do the research for a story like.
Speaker 1That, Well, it takes a first draft of a novel takes at least a year for me, and then my own self editing and polishing and sending it out to beta readers another half year almost. Then it goes to the publisher, and by the time they do editing and everything else, it adds another six to eight months. So the total production time is about two years, a little over two years from first word on screen to actually getting the book published. So it takes some time, and
Speaker 1some go quicker than that, and others take longer.
Speaker 2Your passion for story and your passion for science are amazing. I've only been speaking to you for a short amount of time now, and I can already feel it in my bones. Where do you think this passion comes from? Is it something in your childhood, is it something in teenager life, or is it something you've learned the way through being educated?
Speaker 1That question? I get asked that question a lot, and it's not necessarily in the context of my past for writing, but more of my passion for science and telling people about the wonders of space and space travel. I can definitely relate it to two pivotal events in my childhood. The first was this will give away my age. I was seven years old when Neil Armstrong walked on the moon, and I remember my parents bringing me in to watch on this grainy black and white television the Apollo landing,
Speaker 1and they were conveying to me about always on the moon, how far it is. Let's go out and look at the moon and you can see this, And I was super excited as a seven year old, and I got interested in space at that point. And then a few years later, my sisters, who I dearly love, allowed me to stay up late with them on Friday nights to watch reruns of the original Star Trek, and from there it was all downhill. I started reading every science fiction novel I could get my hands on, reading about science, and decided I wanted to be a physicist and worked
Speaker 1for NASA dog on it. And so I pursued that, achieved that, and almost I don't know, fifteen to twenty years ago, I had the opportunity to start writing and the books sold well enough that the publisher kept coming back, so I had the opportunity to actually kind of pay it forward. I'm trying to reach that next mini me that's out there and ignite the same kind of passion.
Speaker 2And your books are filled with so many cinematic ideas. Has there been any interest in adapting your work for the screen?
Speaker 1Only once? And that was my understanding from the publisher, that it was looked at by a production company and then they decided to pass on it. So none of my work's ever been optioned. I'm hoping in the future that some will be. I think a lot of the books are definitely of a type that could be considered for that, But I don't know. I don't know how you get the right attention to them. I guess as part of it. But I have some great publishers and see what happens.
Speaker 2What would be the ideal relationship for you to have a production company if they were to try and option one of your books.
Speaker 1Well, the answer to that question is, first and foremost, I would be absolutely thrilled at the opportunity to see it come to the screen. I would try not to be one of those prima donna demanding types that you see about in movies. Right or an author has their book option, but I would try to work with them and encourage them to keep at least the core of the story and the elements of the journey I either journey of the hero or heroin that's undertaking the experience
Speaker 1would experience, even if some of the details had to be changed. I don't know how I would react if they tried to do something that was not physically possible just for enhancing the story. I guess I'd have to deal with that in real time. It would definitely be a different feeling than when I encountered that consulting for some of these movies, because they weren't changing my original work. I was trying to get them to change to be realistic. I would try not to take it too personally, I guess, and that might be difficult.
Speaker 2And if a Traveler's Guide to the Stars were made into a documentary, what would you want it to look and feel like?
Speaker 1Oh? I would wow. I would like for it to have the same feel that a lot of my readers have told me they got when they read the book, and the feel that I strove for, and I was so gratified in some of the feedback I've gotten is that when people read the book, they feel like they're sitting in a coffee shop with me having a pastry and coffee talking about how we might go to the stars. And so, if it were ever turned into a documentary,
Speaker 1I'd like to have it be, of course, visuals to be exciting and compelling, and the information conveyed, but I would like for it to have a sense of conversation and not be attempting to go over someone's head. I'd like to have it be the same conversation I might have with someone at my high school reunion that has no technical background at all, that says, hey, less I heard you wrote a book. What's it about. That would be the feel I would like for it.
Speaker 2To have, and why would you like it to have that type of feel?
Speaker 1Because I firmly believe that space exploration and space travel is not something that should be the province of either the very wealthy alone or the technical elite alone of scientists and engineers. The expansion of our species of life on Earth into the Solar System and maybe beyond is something that we'll have to involve everyone, and I think that people need to understand why it's important, understand how
Speaker 1difficult it's going to be, and have them be interested in being a part of making the journey happen. So I think it's more important for this information to be conveyed to people and went to high school and college with, or someone I might just meet at a casual event somewhere to understand it than it is for the scientists and engineers to have it, because those are the people that might actually help make it happen.
Speaker 2And when you say about the expansion of the human race, are you potentially talking about human beings living on Mars?
Speaker 1I'm well, okay, this is where I get personally philosophically at a little I don't know personal here. I look at life on Earth in what appears to be a cold, harsh, dead universe, as being a very special thing and worth preserving. All life on Earth, from you know, plankton in the oceans, to my dog, to you to me. And I believe that music is a gift, and the love that we
Speaker 1feel for our loved ones or that our pets is something transcendent and is morally good. And I believe we as a human species, the technological thinking species on the planet, should not only be protecting the Earth for all the life that's here, but we should be looking to spread that moral goodness into the universe, and so yes, I think someday we should be living on Mars. I think someday we should be living on some of the moons
Speaker 1of Jupiter, and ultimately in several hundred or thousand years send worldships filled with Earth life and people to go live on otherwise dead worlds surrounding other stars. I think it's an imperative that we should spread life far and wide.
Speaker 2So when I was a kid, there was a film called Calto Rico ourn Schwarzenegger, and they went, some of them at least, went to live on Mars. How realistic was the portrayal of that in that film? And how soon could it be possible for us here?
Speaker 1Well, let's hope we don't have the same adventure that Arnold Schwarzenegger had. No, I love that movie, by the way I saw it back when it came out. How realistic is it? It's first off, it's not impossible, but it's going to be very very difficult. I mean, reproducing a self sustaining ecosystem on another world is not going to be easy for the same reasons that life on Earth appears to be rare. It will be difficult to
Speaker 1recreate a lot of those conditions on another world. So I think in the short term domed cities and very large, controlled recycling environments will be the first step. But if we think in terms of geologic history or the history of our species, in a thousand years or more, we might be able to modify Mars so that you do have a short sleeve environment and you can go out. But I don't see that happening anytime in the near future.
Speaker 1I think it'll be more akin to glorified camping and eventually some kind of domed cities with self replicating parts, three D printing parts without the supply chain, and eventually becoming self sufficient.
Speaker 2Interesting, and of course, in so many films we see aliens that come down to Earth, and we go and visit planets that have aliens on in films. What is the likelihood from the work you've done, that there are aliens that have visited this planet And if you were to write a story about that, what would it be?
Speaker 1Wow. I wrote an essay on this that's available online from my public sure at Banned Books. I called it the Aliens Are Not among Us? And in it I discuss the probability of well, let me rewind just a little bit. Do I believe it's possible for there to be life on other worlds in the universe? Absolutely?
Speaker 2Yes.
Speaker 1It appears, however that this life, whatever it may be, is probably extremely rare. And one thing that people who think about this topic are really good about thinking about is deep space and traveling through space to get there. But they don't think about deep time and our existence individually. You know, seventy to eighty years, if we do well, is just a blip in the history of the Earth, and your life is important, and I don't mean to demean anyone's seventy to eighty years, because I think that
Speaker 1we all make a difference and every life is valuable. But in the scope of history, that is a very very small amount of time. And if the Earth we're ever having been visited by a being from another star, it is far more likely that they came during the reign of the dinosaurs, which lasted tens of millions of years, than the time period in which we humans have been around, which might be fifty two one hundred thousand years, right, because it's as much smaller amount of time, and the
Speaker 1likelihood of them coming now in the century where we're actually traveling to the stars, or not to the stars, but into outer space, which is less than one hundred years out of the four and a half billion year history of the Earth. It's a very low probability. That doesn't mean it's not fun to play around within stories. That's why I have first contact stories, and that's why they're believable, is because that happens. But do I believe it's likely to happen. The answer is no. I think we might find evidence that there was once life on Mars. Is their life there now? It's doubtful. I can't say no.
Speaker 1I don't know, but I think it's likely when we started exploring these other worlds and eventually take the steps to the nearest stars, which will be hard enough, we will likely find just very cold, dead worlds there. Now, my comment about spreading life, I have to give one big caveat, and that is if the world we visit already has its own life, we should leave it alone. So if we go to Mars and find out that there is life there already, I don't believe we should
Speaker 1establish a permanent presence or try to change the environment to suit us. But if we go there and find that there is no life and there never has been, then I think it's fine for us to try to spread life to there, and we should.
Speaker 2And when you say life, for example, if we were to find bugs, would that be something you would consider a life not worth time print with?
Speaker 1Yes, I think from a scientific point of view, to understand it and how it came to be where it is and what it does and the potentiality for its future in that deep time sense is more important than us having the real estate.
Speaker 2And why do you think the aliens would have come to Earth or potentially would have come to Earth? Sorry, when the dinosaurs were amongst the planet.
Speaker 1Oh, I'm not saying I don't know why they would have come here. I just know that if they ever did, as let's say, explorers like humans explore, right, we do that the Polynesians in the settlement of the islands in the South Pacific, that was done island by island, you know, boat by boat, exploring group by exploring group, and they had whatever reasons they had for doing it, whether it's population pressure or that young person who said, I wonder what's over there? You know, they did that exploration and
Speaker 1I think it could very well be the same motive for any intelligent species. I mean I a transcendent experience for me is to go out on a clear, starry night and lie down on the ground and look at the stars and wonder about what's out there? Is there anyone there looking back? And I think if I know that, that motivates a lot of people in the airspace community, in the space exploration community to do what they do, because they are driven to go see what's out there.
Speaker 1That's why we build the big telescopes. That's why we send probes to Mars, to Pluto. It's because it's there and we want to understand it. And I think any intelligent species anywhere, if they're an intelligent tool using species, probably has a similar curiosity, and they might have seen the Earth through their telescopes and said, hey, you know, this might be a good candidate for a life. Let's go see what's there. Do I think they're here for resources or anything like that. No, the energy expenditure is
Speaker 1too huge and the difficulty too high. If they're here at all, it's probably a matter of exploration. I don't know. I can't you know that for certain. Yeah, that's my intuition.
Speaker 2So do you think the film industry has a responsibility to represent space and science responsibility or can it be just pure entertainment. Hmm.
Speaker 1When you say responsibility it means to whom right, I mean, if the responsibility is only to their shareholders and bringing in as much money as possible, then the answer is they have no obligation to treat science right. But if they want to do that while they entertain and contribute something meaningful to the culture, which I would like to see more of in our entertainment, then I think yes, they would want to and have an obligation to try
Speaker 1to treat it fairly. So I guess maybe I have too noble a goal that some filmmakers, and I think this is true. Some filmmakers make films because they really want to tell something important and they want to be meaningful and affect the culture. And those are the folks whose films I want to work on.
Speaker 2Ah. I like that. I was going to say, be really biased and to say exactly, that's exactly what I think in terms of well people should want to work on in some of that they're passion about. Everybody's different, everybody's got different points of view. So everything's good and nice in that way.
Speaker 1But I also believe that those important stories can also be entertaining me too. You talk to a lot of people on your interviews, and I speak to a lot of people at events that I go to, and everyone has a story. Everyone has a story, And I find I don't know of anyone that I've had a lengthy conversation with and I asked them about their history and how they got to be where they are. They don't have a fascinating interesting story to tell, even if they don't think they do.
Speaker 2You're right. Everybody has a story, and everyone is the lead character in their story a lot of the time.
Speaker 1Uh yeah, and they don't they sometimes they think they're the good guy when they're not.
Speaker 2Yeah, that is one hundred and ten percent right. But if you if you could write or console on a big budget sci fi movie tomorrow or television show on Netflix, Amazon or even NBC, ABC or whatever it might be, what would it be about, and any dream directors or collaborators you have in mind.
Speaker 1I think I'm fascinated with the topic that I've spent a lot of time talking to you here about, which is this notion of what would it be like if we did find other life out there? What would it be like? How would they think? Would they how would they interact with us? How would they view us? How would we react to them? I'd like I like first contact stories. Yeah, I am very much not a fan of dystopian science fiction. I don't like to read it,
Speaker 1I don't like to watch it. And so in terms of my dream to be involved in such a project, it would be a project that had an interesting story to tell that led to an outcome that improves somebody's life or the society's life, or leaves you feeling hope and optimism. I do not like what was the trend like ten to twenty years ago, very popular with teens, which I found to be very disturbing because my adult
Speaker 1children now are teens at those times. This dystopian that the world is just going to get worse and worse and it's going to become a big fight one day over resources or whatever. I don't want to be a part of anything like that unless it's a story of someone who is overcoming those odds that shows that there's a way out and that we can have that better future. And I think that gets back to my inherent optimism
Speaker 1that I have that I inherited from my parents, who were in the greatest generation. I think about my mother and father grew up during the Depression, fought World War II, were the ones who built the economy and helped establish and ultimately win the Cold War. And I look at that and I think, Wow, those people went through terrible,
Speaker 1terrible traumatic times in an ends, existential crises, the Depression, World War II, fighting Nazism, and they did it and they came out of it and they made a better world. And I think that's that's what we humans can do when we put our minds to it and were properly motivated. Those are the stories I'd like to be involved telling.
Speaker 2See, I love your way of thinking and the type of story want to be involved in. Why do you think we've moved away as a society from wanting to tell those type of stories and looking back in the past from our parents or grandparents that can influence in a great way.
Speaker 1Why have we moved away from it? I think we have been as a people. I'm a boomer, I admit it. I don't like to admit it, but I am. I'm a late boomer, But I'm a boomer. We then betrayed by our institutions, and we've seen institutions that we were told and we grew up with that we should trust betray us. I remember my first really evidence to portrayal for me was Watergate. For my older sisters, it was
Speaker 1the Vietnam War. And then since then, it just seems like all the way from established religion to politicians to just to scientists. Even you just finished series of podcasts hearing about academic fraud and peer reviewed publications and this notion that people make up data that can't be reproduced. It shatters our faith in these institutions that we're supposed to have faith in. And I think it made people cynical.
Speaker 1And I think a lot of creative people took that cynicism and amplified it to create these dystopian stories because they could sense that people were being cynical. But I also have seen the reaction to that among younger generations who still believe a lot of them do you know the world can be a better place. And I'll just tell you right now. When I'm at I'm a person of faith. I am a Christian. When I'm at church. I'd rather talk to the twenty and thirty somethings of
Speaker 1my church than my peers, because they have children, They're optimistic about the future, they have goals and dreams, and I think that for a while we lost that. I think I were seeing a resurgence of that though in film, in Hollywood and in the culture. Although there's a lot to be depressed about. I'm not trying to put on rose colored glasses and say, you know, all the politics and all the institutions are well, they're not. But I also am seeing signs of hope, and so I think
Speaker 1that's not as prevalent as it was, this dystopian trend, but it's still there and it's going to take a while to get over it. Does that make sense?
Speaker 2Perfect sense? And I think I'm right by saying you're based in Alabama.
Speaker 1That's correct.
Speaker 2Great, great, and the film see there in regard to science and aliens and think of that nature? Is it quite big? How is it for you? Do you do a lot of consulting work in the potentially in the future. Can you see that happening?
Speaker 1I would love to do that. There's not a lot of film being made here in Alabama. That's science and space related. I can tell you though, there is extreme interest in the community here. I'll give you an example. I am soon to be retired from my job at NASA, so I'm just speaking as a private citizen here, not speaking for my employer. But when the movie Interstellar came out, yeah, I don't know, ten years ago, and that was a
Speaker 1big deal. The big one of the big new theaters here in town that has the stadium seats really comfortable and all that had a midnight preview the night before the official release, and they asked me to get up after the film was over and talk about the real possibilities of deep space exploration and space travel. And I was not a consultant on the film, but people stayed in that audience until almost one in the morning, asking questions. Wow, it was amazing, and so for me. I also consult
Speaker 1with other science fiction writers. I go to these things called science fiction conventions. I don't know if you've ever ever heard of these. No. They're typically gatherings of anywhere from two hundred to one thousand people in cities all across the country. They tend to be fairly science fiction literature focused. They're not like comic Con or something like that. Nothing wrong with comic Con. Those are a lot of fun too. But a lot of writers go to these and some don't have the technical background that I do, And so I get emails from established writers asking me
Speaker 1questions to help them get the science in their written stories correct. And so I've done some film consulting the movies you mentioned, but I also do literally consulting and have helped some of these writers craft their stories so they're more believable. And I enjoy it because I like talking to people. You can tell I'm the quiet, shy, reserved type, and I also enjoy, like I say, hearing their stories and helping them make them better.
Speaker 2I hope, what type of stories are these? Why to bring in to you? Oh?
Speaker 1It ranges across the board, and that's where it gets really challenging. I had a great writer, a fellow named Jack McDevitt come to me, and he had written a story and written himself a little bit into a corner of how to get the people on the planet off the planet. And he had built this infrastructure in space of an old space elevator. If your listeners don't know what that is, It's an idea put forward by Arthur Clark that would have a big cable that runs twenty
Speaker 1three thousand miles from the equator all the way out to deep space, that instead of launching things on rocket, you would ride the elevator and then throw them off the top of the elevator. You know, it's stuff that we might do, some data we can't do right now. And I had to help him come up with a plausible way where the remains of that space elevator had been broken could be used to get them off the planet. That was fun. I don't know. It was kind of a mystery I had to help him solve. And that would be one example. It's great book. It's called Deep Six. It's been out for I don't know, twenty years, twenty
Speaker 1five years. Great great story, though Jack mcdibbitt is the author, all the way to stuff that I don't know how to help them, because they'll come to me sometimes with not just a totally implausible scenario, but a totally implausible whole background for the book, and I just have to tell them I can't help you with this. This is more space fantasy than science fiction. There's so much here right, there's no way I can help you. So it spans the space.
Speaker 2So what advice would you give to filmmakers or screenwrits is listening to this podcast right now who want to ground their science fiction in real science without losing creative spock.
Speaker 1I would say, you really need to work with your technical consultants and let them help you. And if they come up with something that would cause you to alter your vision of the story, don't reject it out right. Sit down and have a conversation with them with lots of what ifs, because in that brainstorming process you might come up with an innovative solution. That happened in Europa report. And my first experience consulting was the original Lost in
Speaker 1Space movie that was made in the nineties, and that actually happened in that film, although they did a lot of things I told them not to do, and the director said, well, I'm doing it anyway, and that's okay, that's all right. He is the director, right, But they did change a few things and it came about because hours long conversations and what if discussions, and if they're willing to put that kind of time in, then a good technical consultant can help them be more accurate without compromising story.
Speaker 2I see, are their particular scientific concept you think of right for expiration in future films that haven't yet been done well.
Speaker 1That will require some thought, and I'm not sure I can extemporaneously come up with any right now.
Speaker 2I have.
Speaker 1The whole time travel thing has been done so many times and so poorly and so well that it's hard to see how to improve that. I think, yeah, I think so. I think realistic deep space travel was portrayed pretty accurately in the original Alien film. Oh I love that. I also think that the deep space love story Passengers of All Things did a really nice job of conveying
Speaker 1what it would be on an ultra long voyage and what happens if somebody wakes up early, right, and the human tragedy and triumph that that became in that story. If you haven't seen that, you need to see Passengers.
Speaker 2Okay.
Speaker 1I think this notion of what realistic deep space travel might be like has not been plumbed because people think it would be boring to talk about a spaceship that has to take a thousand years to get to its destination. And I would beg to differ because if the people are alive and living on that ship, you've got generations of people with generations of stories to tell in an environment that's very different than our environment here on Earth. Right It's a constrained, closed place, and those stories would
Speaker 1be fascinating to tell. And then what would await them on the other end when they get to a destination that is not Earth two point zero, and the struggles they would have to survive there and create ultimately in the end another Earth. Perhaps I don't think that's been well portrayed realistic deep space long duration travel. I think producers are scared of it because they think it might be boring. But I don't think it'd be boring. I
Speaker 1think that you've got to tell the human story in that backdrop of the immensity of time that it would take and the distance involved.
Speaker 2Yes, that sounds an amazing story. I for one, would love to watch it if it if it came out, I would love to. But you mentioned Back to the Future, and I I am a lover of two of the Back to the Future films, and particular in a way debate which but which one is better? Part one or Pot two? But can you tell me some of the inaccuracies in the time travel in those films that just quiet may be ridiculous.
Speaker 1Well, you're not gonna like my answer. I think nature is not going to allow time travel. And the reason I think that, and by the way, well i'll say this in a few minutes. I think nature is not going to allow time travel for one very simple reason because in every situation in nature that we see, there are two conservation laws that are never violated. One is the conservation of energy. That the energy of a system
Speaker 1total energy can't change. It can change four sunlight can become heat. Ultimately, everything becomes heat. But if you look at the total energy content in the system, it doesn't change. And conservational momentum, which means that basically mass that's moving mass time's velocity doesn't change before or after an interaction. And you're saying, well, how does this relate to time travel? Well, if I travel me Les Johnson or you and your body goes back one hundred years, you have removed energy
Speaker 1and matter from the universe and inserted it somewhere else. Okay, and the atoms that are in your body already exist somewhere in that previous time period in a tree, in the air, in another person's body, or in a skunk that's running across the field. Some of those atoms that they leave in the crop that your parents ate a few days before they conceived you, right became you. And so you are changing the energy density or the matter
Speaker 1density of the universe by time traveling. And I don't think nature is going to allow us to do that.
Speaker 2So the whole concept of Duck creating this time machine is just completely scientifically flawed in every measurable way.
Speaker 1Given what we know about how the universe works, which is an example a caveat I'm always going to give. I don't pretend that we know how everything works based on our current understanding. It's totally impossible. But it's a great story. Yes, it's a great thought exercise, and getting people to think is a great thing to get people to ponder things they haven't pondered. What if I have to say that, I don't think we do that as
Speaker 1much today as we used to because we're too busy on our phones or watching streaming, which I like to do. But what I'd like to do is watch something interesting streaming and then have a discussion with whoever I watched it with about what we just saw, what we liked, what we didn't like, and was it plausible. And I'll give you an example of the best time I had doing that was way back in the nineties was the series Twin Peaks. Oh Yes, and Twin Peaks came out every week and it was such an eclectic, esoteric story that was difficult to really understand what David Lynch was
Speaker 1trying to do, and I'm not sure he really understood. We would have watch parties, we would get together the next day over lunch and try to understand and talk about what that was. To me, that is great storytelling when you can engage people to want to talk about it right and figure it out. And there have been other series that do that. I'm not saying that's alone, but that was the first time that I experienced that kind of communal experiencing of it. And I know people
Speaker 1do that today in discussion groups on their phones, TikTok, other you know, meet me groups or whatever. They haven't watch parties, right, that's great, and they're doing it online. I'd like to see more of people getting together and experiencing these shows and then talking about it. Oh yeah. And if I were the writer or the director or the producer of a show that got people to talk about my work like that, I'd be really gratified.
Speaker 2Oh completely, And you can't be doing that in person, I feel. I believe they're similar to when you go to the cinema and watch a certain film in a group in an audience. You don't necessarily get to talk about it afterwards with everybody there, but you would certainly discuss the film with whoever you went with, or if you went with more than one person, you could all discuss it. So I do wish for those type of things to come back. I would have been a bit too young to have enjoyed a watch along for twin Peaks.
Speaker 2Another project, another series someone I spoke about on this podcast was thirty something when they used to do that for that show. It seems like maybe in the nineties without the Internet and the eighties without the internet, and without these unique well they're not unique now, but these smartphones, things changed and things could have been a bit different.
Speaker 1And I don't want to sound like a you know, an old fuddy complaining about the new time.
Speaker 2I'm not doing no, no, I don't I don't think you are at all.
Speaker 1Yeah, I just I just. I just love people, and I love being around people and hearing their thoughts and having that dialogue. It's just part of who I am.
Speaker 2I'll compete me too, in a slightly different topic, in a slightly different way. That's why I love going to the pub to speak to people and enjoy dialogue and things of that nature.
Speaker 1I wanted a memorable pub experience I had in the UK was I had written a book about interstellar travel. This is been fifteen years ago, and I had a business trip that took me to the UK and someone from the premier space exploration society that's existed since the thirties, the British Interplanetary Society, Arthur C. Clark was a member. It was, you know, they were the forefront of thinking about all these issues of deep space travel. The editor of their journal said, Hey, you're going to be over here,
Speaker 1let's meet at a pub and talk deep space travel. And to meet in a pub with someone from this premier space organization and talk about exploring the universe was one of those moments I'll never forget. It was wonderful. It was just wonderful. So the pub experience is something you get. I'm presuming you in the UK or other places they get that we Americans don't really experience.
Speaker 2So well, yes, it's slightly different from my time in America, and obviously coming from Hey, I see the differences. But what pub did you go to? Do you remember?
Speaker 1I do not know. It was near Surrey. Oh okay, I don't remember which pub it was. I would love for it to have been the pub that J. R. R. Tolkien and Cus Lewis frequented, but it was not, I'm sure, but if I could ever have that experience there, I would do that. I'm also a big buff of going to famous places where writers and scientists lived and did their work, so it's something I get a charge out of when I travel.
Speaker 2Excellent. It's been an absolute pleasure speaking to you. I've learnt so much and thought about so much while speaking to you. You've been one of the most unique guests as well as one of the best guests to come on the podcast, so I truly appreciate you coming on and I hope to have from you soon.
Speaker 1Well. Thank you, and I'd like to extend the invitation to you and any of your listeners, come join us here in Huntsville, Alabama. We have a lot of really wonderful people talking about space and space exploration. We've got a fantastic space museum here, and you never know when you'll run into a rocket scientist walking down the street. So consider that invitation a sincere open invitation to you.
How do you bring someone’s most painful memories to the screen with honesty and care?Damien Swaby speaks with writer and director Saila Kariat about Jesus Land, her adaptation of Julia Scheeres’s memoir exploring...
When someone helps rewrite your script, who owns the finished story? And what happens when the person financing your film wants to change it? Entertainment lawyer Joshua Lastine joins Damien Swaby on Filmmaking...
Mike Gallant and Seled Calderon join Damien Swaby to discuss BACKPAY, an independent neo-noir crime thriller about financial desperation, family and the consequences of believing one bad decision can fix...
Documentary filmmaker Luchina Fisher joins Damien Swaby to discuss the people and experiences that shaped her work.Growing up in a military family took Luchina from Texas to Germany and North Carolina. She reflects on...
Filmmaker Katie Cokinos joins Damien Swaby to reflect on a career shaped by independent cinema, personal vision and the determination required to get unconventional films made. Katie recounts beginning her career at the...