Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Field Frequency

Field Frequency artwork

Stop Investing in Chargers. Start Investing in Systems

Sep 29, 202650 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts

Send us Fan Mail Most EV charging failures don't start when the charger goes down. They start in planning and procurement, long before ground is broken. In this roundtable episode, host Jason Cortes sits down with Grayson Eady (Founder & CEO, eVision Solutions) and Laolu Adeola (Managing Director, Leke Services). Grayson is a former Rivian charging interoperability engineer. Laolu is a fleet electrification veteran who has helped raise more than $2B for EV startups. Together, they break down why cheap infrastructure turns into expensive infrastructure, and what buyers should require before they ever issue an RFP. They cover: Why charging is a "system of systems": hardware, OCPP, charging management software, firmware, cybersecurity, data, and O&M Treating charging like a vehicle purchase, with total cost of ownership instead of the lowest install cost A real case where a charger was down 60+ days while every dashboard said "available," and why hardware data logs sat behind a paywall The "crossed-arm salute": what happens when nobody owns the problem Why uptime is only the baseline, and why first-time plug-in success and mean time to repair are what separate strong operators from the rest Buy Better, their workshop that helps fleets, municipalities, and CPOs build RFPs that screen out bad vendors from day one Why the industry needs airline-style data sharing, and why charging should compete on price and amenities, not on whether it works Guests: Grayson Eady, Founder & CEO, eVision Solutions | Laolu Adeola, Managing Director, Leke Services Host: Jason Cortes Learn more about Buy Better at buybettercharging.com. Field Frequency is powered by Field Advantage, a company that specializes in maintaining EV charger infrastructure. Produced and edited by Autozy (autozy.co). Follow Field Frequency so you don't miss an episode.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Problems at an EV charging site don't start when the charger fails, they start when someone buys into the wrong system or program. EV charging is a system of many components hardware, software, parts, service, and accountability. These things determine and dictate uptime. In this week's episode of Field Frequency, I'm joined by two industry vets. We get into what good operators measure, why cheap infrastructure usually turns into expensive infrastructure, and why some failures are starting before installation ever even begins. Let's get into it.

SPEAKER_01We're here to do it. All right, here's the reality: a lot of charging problems aren't created in the field. They're created upstream in the planning and procurement phase, long before ground's ever broken, long before there's any electrical rough-in. And so today, joining me are two industry experts and founders, Laulu Adeola, managing director of Lecce Services, and Grayson E. D., founder and CEO of eVision Solutions. So kind of a bit of a uh roundtable conversation today. And uh so, gentlemen, welcome.

SPEAKER_01Let's start with introductions over to you guys. Walk us through your backgrounds and what pulls you into EV charging.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Thank you so much for having us. Happy to be here and talk about our view on how best to tackle EV charging problems from the start. But I'll start with with a little bit about my background. You know, I've been interested in the EV space for actually a long time, probably since I was in high school when we were seeing the Model S and Model 3 come out with Tesla back in the day. And from there, as I started studying electrical engineering, I realized there's a real opportunity to get into electric vehicles.

SPEAKER_00And I happened to intern at this company that hardly anyone had heard of at the time and ended up as everybody anxiously checks the stock each day, being Rivian, you know, shortly after the big public launch in in 2018, 2019, 2020, that era. So I kind of fell into the charging team. I went back and worked there for a few years as a full-time charging interoperability engineer and got to work both on the vehicle side, helping make sure that Rivian vehicles could charge on any public charger and eventually moving more to the charger side as Rubian prepared to open up their charging network to third-party vehicles and ensure that the chargers could charge any vehicle on the market and really focused on designing a user experience that that was for the masses with that project.

SPEAKER_00So took all that charging experience and realized that there was an opportunity to bring the technical knowledge for product development to deployment in nascent markets like the Southeast. So I moved home to Atlanta and founded my consulting firm to try and bring some of that expertise to the projects I wanted to see where I'm from in the Southeast. Thank you.

SPEAKER_02Thank you, Grayson. Over to you, Lalu. That's awesome. I'm always inspired by Grayson's story. I'm I'm Laulu Adola, the managing director and founder at Lake A Services. We are a management consultancy that's focused on supporting leaders as they navigate the mobility energy transition. My my my background and attraction to this industry spans over 15 years when I first started as a as an engineer with uh international uh an OEM that builds medium and heavy duty vehicles out of uh the Chicagoland area. And and there I was first tasked with uh as a as an aerodynamics engineer again trying to improve fuel efficiency.

SPEAKER_02So taking these heavy duty vehicles from six miles per gallon to nine miles per gallon. And I mean right there that's a fifty percent increase, uh improvement. And it was wild to use the the the the uh the inefficiency of these large diesel engines that are so critical to moving our economy around. Uh and that was my first exposure to the EPA and environmental regulations and and all this engineering effort that goes into making sure that we can get reliable vehicles delivering and moving our people around. Uh fast forward I went through EV startups, raised it was involved in over raising over two billion dollars of capital.

SPEAKER_02I worked at McKinsey and Company, one of the largest consultants, and and and fleets having to navigate this transition which had such rosy promises of of being so green, uh, first of all. Uh, but now the focus has been on how how is it gonna reduce costs, how is it gonna uh improve my my margin. And and doing that, capturing that opportunity takes a lot, a lot of effort. And and it's in that journey that Grayson and I ran into each other on the circuit and realized that uh we could work together to to help solve some of the problems that we've been seeing, which uh we're gonna talk about come when we start thinking about charging the new sort of energy distribution infrastructure that that is so critical for different transit.

SPEAKER_02Like has been such a big ball neck. So we're excited to be on here uh on on this podcast on Feel Advantage. I mean a big fan, so excited to be part of uh thanks for having us, Jason.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well thanks for coming on. And uh for the audience, uh we're gonna probably have a couple of different conversational tracks. Uh Grayson may be taking retail and and public charging, and Lalu may be taking fleet, but they're gonna probably riff off each other a little bit. And so, you know, just sharing that with the audience. But uh Lalu Grayson, you you're focusing on different sides of the market, as I mentioned, fleet and public charging. Maybe share some perspectives about those experiences that led up to what you're doing right now and and how that's helping you help your your clients today.

SPEAKER_02I I can get started on that one. So, yeah. I as as this industry has evolved. I mean, 10 years ago, that's when I first got into electric vehicles, Tesla had just was that the beginning of that meteoric rise, and everyone was inspired by the potential. Though there was this understanding that we needed charging infrastructure everywhere. And and so there was this, there's been this mad dash, and you gotta give credit where credit is due. We're not quite Europe or China, but the the impressive scale of deployment of infrastructure, starting with the Tesla superchargers.

SPEAKER_02I mean, then you see EVGO, Electrify America, Walmart, Prologis, like all these companies that have just really leaned into making sure that this new infrastructure has built out. It was amazing to see. And then probably about maybe about five years ago, we started realizing, okay, we we don't we can't just build these things. We have to make sure they work. Not not most of the time, not better than most of the time. So we started hearing things like 97% uptime, and and that really moved the industry. And I'm sure Jason, you're a part of it, and especially what what what you all do. But then over the last two, three years, where I think for me, it's like a a marker of where the industry, how how much is that evolved?

SPEAKER_02We're starting to say, okay, maybe that uptime, that 97% or even 99% is not good enough. What happens in those three percent when it's down? If it's up, is it actually charging? Like how do we define and get into this nuance? And so the dashboards that we've what that we've evolved to get us to this point are no longer sufficient as we look for that excellence, as we start converting critical infrastructure, you're talking about emergency response, you're talking about food distribution, you're talking about once these industries need to rely on technology to get to that nth order uh performance.

SPEAKER_02So you hear us you hear us talk about mean time to repair and and and first-time charging success, right? These are next order. And so we want to talk to the people who are making the decisions and help them get better performance out of their infrastructure. That's that's that's where we're going. I don't know if you want to add anything there, Grace.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, really, I I think Laulu and I came to consciousness about some of these industry trends at the same time from different angles. Laulu was hearing from fleets that the charging solutions that were supposed to be just an add-on to the the vehicle procurement process, you know, weren't working out to be that simple. And I was seeing, you know, charging reliability in the field was starting to become a real pressure point as EV adoption increased when I was at Rivian. And then even more so once I started my firm, a lot of the the work I was getting was, hey, I bought these chargers because they were cheap and I could procure them quickly for a quick turnaround project I had.

SPEAKER_00And now they don't work and I don't know what to do, and I've spent so much money trying to get them to work. And so it was really helping people realize how complex charging is as a system and how to bridge that gap by by starting early in the planning process. And and that's that's kind of similar to what Lala said in where where fleets have started to look too, folks have been burned. And now it's time to help them fix it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, there go ahead, Lola. Yeah, yeah. If I add a little bit to that, I think Grayson, you hit the nail on the head there where you say it was it was the cheapest, and you have a great line, like cheap, the cheapest, not always the best. Uh I'm I'm paraphrasing, but uh I'll I'll let you on that. However, I think in that in that mad dash to just get this stuff done and get it out there, we weren't patient enough, weren't ready for for this complexity. The fact that the fleet manager is not the only person responsible for this decision. Or nor is it the facilities director.

SPEAKER_02It's it's the IT, it's it's the uh procurement, it's the operations manager, it's the data like uh analysis folks. So now we're looking at this, okay, it has to be a a concerted effort, a coordinated effort, right to to make to pull this thing off. And that's what we want to help people get get to.

SPEAKER_01Our our industry has had several gotcha moments, hidden problems that were exposed during deployment, uh, demand charges is a prime example of one. But then when you even get beyond that's operational, that's downstream from operational. When you just get into the the complexities of deployment, a lot of the uh industry, of course, attention goes to deployments and then consequently the the utilization and then because you want to be making money and you want sites to be operating, but then the uptime component.

SPEAKER_01So both of you have seen and spent a lot of time thinking about things from an upstream standpoint beyond uh beyond the deployment early on, upstream. What uh what do you think the industry is underestimating about the planning and procurement phase in a in a charging site project? You go ahead, Laura.

SPEAKER_02Okay, I can take I can I can start on this one. I think great great question. I folks are familiar with with buying infrastructure. I mean, we've bought this for hundreds of years. I think we're we're getting to a system to to an era where in a we're friendly in an era where you're buying system. And so you you're not you're not just buying a box and an installing JC and talk about okay, when you get to deployment, you realize the box is all over the other end, the the the grid connections all the other uh all the way on the over end on the other end of the parking lot. Now you have to trench and that adds more complexity and you didn't realize all the support planning.

SPEAKER_02That that that being said, there are all their there there are five other layers. There's a reliability. What happens when you need to push firmware updates? I don't think fleet managers were thinking about firmware updates five five years ago. Now now they have to. I need to otherwise they're not flat footed. How they're thinking about OCP, uh, what is OCBP? And is it a is it a God send is it a does it fix everything? OCPP is a cre is a is a crucial, uh, what's it called certification for the industry that that mandates that that that standardizes how you send sort of fixed data data pieces to help you understand the the the the the status of your charger.

SPEAKER_02It was it it was brought to it was brought to life because of a need. People realize, okay, all these chargers need some standard ways to talk to each other and to talk to this software, which I'll get to, which is the next layer. Uh and so that's been implemented widely, but it's not it's not a requirement for people use it or they don't. And that connects to your to your charging management software, which is a whole new software as a service opportunity that didn't exist 10 years ago. And so now this software buys that have connect to and and and help you operate your chargers, they have their own protocols, they have their own APIs, they have their own opportunities they open up, like helping you kind of play with demand charging, like you brought up, Jason.

SPEAKER_02And then you have cybersecurity issues, and then you have data and diagnostics, then you have repairs, your O and M folks that you send to the site. Now this is a layered stack of decisions you have to make and not, hey, I just bought a box and an installation. And so walking through each of those and bringing the right stakeholders, I mean, it makes it a bit of a longer process. But if you're if you're buying 50 chargers, 100 chargers, if you're managing a couple hundred vehicles or have that kind of throughput in your facility, it is crucial for you to address that head on and to start to play a game of whack-a-mole, which is which will cost you a whole lot more down the road.

SPEAKER_02Grace, any comments on that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think Lally really well covered that so many EV charging buyers are just underestimating complexity and and the vast problem space they they have to solve for to have a successful charging deployment in a kind of a helpful concept, you know, to bring it into terms that a lot of the buyers are more familiar with is thinking about when you buy a vehicle, you consider total cost of ownership. You're projecting maintenance costs, insurance costs, fuel costs, and you build all of that into the cost profile for the vehicle that you're buying, uh, whether you're a city fleet or a private fleet, because you understand that that's how that's how you're going to experience the use of that asset.

SPEAKER_00Charging traditionally was not viewed that way. And so the operational costs, due to the complexity that the Laulu just covered, were totally left out of the equation. And that's why we talk about, you know, don't just buy what's cheap to install, because that's the first half. And so looking upstream really means doing the full analysis for what you can expect and what your budget for total cost of ownership is. And then also looking at, you know, what are the kind of requirements you want to expect of your bids coming in to a procurement process to screen out potential liabilities in that space.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01Um you mentioned the example of the fleet manager, Lalu man the fleet manager not having to worry about firmware, uh, but now he does because it's a it's a new problem that's been introduced through a new uh software stack or through a stack of solutions, and now that's a complexity that they didn't have to worry about. And you think about uh what their perspective has been prior to that, in a traditional liquid fueling context, they had a fuel pump. It was either DSOR gas sitting out there on the fuel island, and the fleet fueled there, and you know, pretty much there was no software to worry about for those.

SPEAKER_01There was probably a filter that needed to be changed and damaged toes or nozzles that needed to be replaced, and that's it. But you know, as as as fleets are migrating to alternative energy programs, uh there's always been the introduction of other complexities and other just that stack you were talking about. And so looking at how projects go sideways, you know, I've t I've mentioned it and we we were talking about it, but uh where where's the line when it's a it's a charger problem or maybe it's not a charging problem, maybe it's a planning problem over over over-engineering a site because maybe a fleet profile could be accommodated by uh a lower watt DC or possibly even AC charging solutions.

SPEAKER_01But you know, maybe what was presented on the f early end was no, charge them fast, get them out of here, and you know, build out this infrastructure. And it's uh it's kind of over-engineered solution. So kind of comments around how projects go sideways or maybe experiences, citable experiences and that you've had with with that for either one of you.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, happy to speak to that. Uh I I I think there are two dynamics that we see play out, right? There's the when they when people realize a project has gone sideways, and the when we're telling people the the original sins were the real moment that the project went sideways, right? I think the the way that we see projects go sideways is let's even assume that that the deployment process was perfect. And I'm sure you you being working with Field Advantage can attest to the fact that rarely do deployments go perfectly, but let's assume that it does. You know, utility coordination is good, construction is good, timelines aligned, we get the chargers installed and six to eight weeks, just like we plan.

SPEAKER_00Couple months, no issues. But then there's a firmware update, or there's a broken power module, and there's no one on the other end of the line to help you. There's no visibility as to what firmware or when the changeover was that caused the issue or what the root cause of the issue is, because maybe the hardware manufacturer is not a good technical partner, and that was not a part of the process. Maybe there's no parts warranty included, and you you can't get a power module for a month, and that's a month of not being able to use an asset that possibly costs you hundreds of thousands of dollars to install.

SPEAKER_00So that that's kind of the the moment people realize we have an issue. Where we kind of our thesis in this is that the project went actually went wrong in the requirements and scoping phase long before ever anything ever broke. Because if if you have figured out, you know, we need to assess what is the firmware rollback plan if there's an issue. Do we have the minimum required parts on hand for expected wear items like power modules, cables, air filters, et cetera?

SPEAKER_00Those are the items that you can really build into a robust planning process, whether it's it's going through and scoping requirements for cooperative purchasing or writing an RFP, then you can avoid the operational challenges later because you'll you'll have all of the systems in place to hopefully screen out the worst technical partners. And I mean, you know, both your hardware provider, your software provider, your the company that maybe is doing maintenance and repair on an SLA. You'll screen them out by requiring strict standards that that meet your performance and operational needs.

SPEAKER_00And then you'll also have defined processes for how to fix it when something goes wrong. And so we look, we'd like to get out ahead of this oh no, what have I done? I spent a million dollars on infrastructure for my my fleet and and it's not working out and go back even further. But really we we're trying to reframe that conversation because rarely have I entered a project in that phase. Maybe, maybe I'm I'm able to help out with the the next round of procurement because the the lessons were learned on the last one, but rarely, rarely do I get to to come in from day one and say, let's do this right the first time, because you're not gonna want to do it a second time if you don't.

SPEAKER_00And so we're we're trying to flip that script and really get in early and help you folks realize that this can be done well and done right and and find good vendors from day one.

SPEAKER_02And the real hope here is that is considering that most chargers that are gonna be installed have not been installed yet. So it's on the precipice of, I think we're on the precipice of this even greater deployment of charging infrastructure everywhere. And we're also at this point where folks have been have had these like infrastructure they put in five years ago, maybe eight years ago, when when deployment was starting to really scale and and they're at the point of refresh and saying, what lessons have I learned? How do we help you put this uh put these learnings into place?

SPEAKER_02We we have the privilege of having talked with a lot of different folks in different phases of the deployment. I'll give you uh talking about case studies. There's one was one I wrote about in in uh in Charge Fleet magazine, I think uh it came out in June a month ago, where this is operator, they were they were testing vehicles, EV charging infrastructure, and doing some competitive benchmarking. And they had uh a charger that had been down for over, I think almost 60 days, over 60 days. But all the charger management software and the and the OCPP indicator said it was good. Then they get their uh OM folks out there to come inspect the chargers.

SPEAKER_02They they look at it, they thought maybe it's like a bent pin, which by the way wouldn't show up on your OCPP or or it was to show available because it's a physical change that doesn't register anywhere yet. No, it wasn't, it wasn't anything obvious and physical. And then after some some deep diving, they they they went in, they went to the device into the box, tried to get some hardware data logs. They realized that's behind a paywall. You gotta go back to the to the to the OEM and ask them for data of the asset you own. And then they say that's that's a couple hundred bucks, the new new expense, and and it takes them three, four days to get back to you.

SPEAKER_02This is infrastructure you want to be using. After about 1, I think 20 days, they're finally able to root pause, scrum of those data logs, and identify some firmware update that went wrong, which was something that they they could have specified. So going back to what Grayson said, they could have specified in the RFP if they had the foresight for the types of problems that that could happen. Again, this this is this is a critical process, especially for folks deploying infrastructure at scale. If you're thinking about it for revenue, if you're thinking about it for more critical operations like emergency services, if you if you can't afford this stuff, this types of lapses, it's not gonna happen for everybody.

SPEAKER_02Be able to plan for this the right way, take you a little bit more time and a lot more coordination. And it might look slightly more expensive on the face of it, but our guarantee is like over over the lifetime of your ownership, it's better. You get a better peace of mind. You know that when something is down, you're gonna get it fixed within a fixed SLA because you have all the keys to every lock that you're about to encounter down the way. And then you're holding each stakeholder accountable for their piece of the puzzle because you understand where those interfaces are. I mean, it's it's not something that you just walk in on the first day of school and be like, I know exactly how to have to deploy this.

SPEAKER_02And so that's why again, great Grayson and I put together this buy-better program around helping these buyers understand, okay, what a decision I have to make, what framework should I use, how should I think about this problem, what can I afford to do now versus what should I wait for post-deployment to figure out. Uh, but I'll give you, I'll give you the the the the spoiler here is like you get this group of people together, think through this stack, and then you make some intelligent choices.

SPEAKER_01Well, Lou, while you were talking, you mentioned uh a buy better program that you and Grayson are working on. Can can one of you comment more to that, please?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, happy to explain. So we've been talking about hinting at the work that Lalu and I do together. And in trying to co market our services and partner on projects, we we discovered that there was potential for really strong offering using our experience to just help folks actually make those procurement decisions in a standardized format. And so we we came up with this idea for a workshop called Buy Better, and it's really targeted at fleet. Up and coming charging operators, municipalities, really anybody who's making these huge purchasing decisions around charging, perhaps for the first time or with lessons learned from the first time, and trying to help them get all of the right components of a solid procurement built into their process in the form of a workshop.

SPEAKER_00So we we have a multi-day curriculum where we'll really work with the organization to review all the material, help them understand charging as a system of systems and where the complexity is and where they maybe need outside help and where they need to be thinking about certain key decision points, bring them up to speed on charging within those areas. And then the output is a framework, mostly complete RFP, a request for proposals that they can put out in the world to solicit charging services, really tailored to their use case.

SPEAKER_00We're also working on some opportunities for smaller, you know, one to three hour engagements where we can get a good chunk of the highlights without the total multi-day commitment. But the goal is the same. Charging is hard. We want to not make it easy because it's not easy, but help people realize how they can plan for that difficulty and really properly address the complexity. So the workshop is called Buy Better, and we're really looking for who can benefit from learning more, applying their operational areas and needs, and then coming out with a request for proposals that matches for the reliable charging for their fleet or for the public in a in a way that really makes everybody happy, most especially their operators, because that's what it comes down to, right?

SPEAKER_00Is making sure that the operators of the charging and users of the charging have a good experience.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well sorry, Grayson. And Jason, you can probably speak to this. I mean, you you get called out on a service request, but even before that, you can you can look, you can ask a couple of questions and and realize, okay, this this customer, this operator didn't really get all the right things in place. You ask them questions like, okay, what what are you doing about firmware updates? What what kind of warranties do you have on your parts? Uh do you have access to the data logs, like like we've said a couple of times. And and and there's only so much you can do when you're on a site, and then you do a hard reset, uh, you check the you check the physical hardware, you you clean the site, whatever it is, you reset, I mean, do some diagnostics to get OCPP logs, and and then you get you get to a wall where it's really on the the hardware manufacturer, it's really on okay, how is your charging management software or charging station management software sending sending commands?

SPEAKER_02What are the handshakes like with your vehicles? And if we go back to this transition and and the drive the the current driver, I think is is is largely economic. I think it first started as an environmental mandate, but very, very quickly it started proving out its potential to save a lot of money. For most fleets, about 20%, uh roughly 20% of their costs are on on fuel and and maintenance. That is what the transition is really a tax to to to get that down. It says you're gonna have to maintain this vehicle less, you're gonna have to you you have the opportunity to spend a lot less money on on your energy to power to do it.

SPEAKER_02To do that, you need this infrastructure work. To do that, you need this infrastructure available when your vehicles do come around. Uh and and that and and when it's not working, then you have to to to either call emergency services or use backup systems or pay a lot more per kilowatt hour or per kilowatt than than you had planned. All these things are are what make this transition difficult. When this infrastructure is not working, then you gotta start calling around. And so it really disrupts your operations. And I think a lot of this gets in the way for a smooth transaction transition.

SPEAKER_02This came to us, I mean, this idea, like Grayson mentioned, it grew from pools. So a friend of ours got asked by by a big municipality on the on the East Coast after after after they ran into these issues over and over again and said, please help us. We need we need a coordinated effort. We need our IT, we need our procurement, we need our facilities, we need our fleets, we need our analysts to be able to talk and be able to coordinate this because this is killing us. And as we started putting together content to help them and train them, we realized, okay, they're not the only ones with this problem because we've heard different flavors of it before.

SPEAKER_02Again, large real estate companies who are deploying charges at scale because now this is a public benefit. Now, if you go to a Class A real estate facility, they want to see that there's charging infrastructure in there. Uh, but it quickly loses muster. I'm I'm I I'm sure you all have gone to a place and there's there's it's marketed to have charging, and then you're just so disappointed and it takes away from the experience. And there's different schools of thoughts, people giving out free charging is probably not the right way to incentivize the adoption, and and that's a different discussion. But where there are chargers, they they should be working.

SPEAKER_02Uh and they're and they're a lot and they should be working all the time, not most of the time. I mean, we go to gas stations and every once in a while we see that plastic bag on on the pump and and it's like it's a bad look, but there's another pump right over that you can use. It's a different experience for for EVs, right? I mean, you plug it in and you're you're out at lunch, and then you get an unletter in your phone, it's like it's not charging. That's that that that really breaks the experience. And so, like we're saying, before the RFP, you have to get this course so that your demands are clear and so that you actually enable your vendors to be able to deliver the best performance to you.

SPEAKER_02And and we think that's a that's a crucial next phase that this industry needs to transition into.

SPEAKER_01Agreed and well said, the the Buy Better program would be optimal for RFIs. Before the even RFP stage, that would be optimal for any operator that's looking to integrate new hardware, add to existing sites, build out new sites, well before there you start requesting pricing. You should be requesting information. And so the better uh the the Buy Better program sounds like optimized for requesting the right information, ingesting at a site level what you really need and what you really want.

SPEAKER_01So that way, to your point, Lalu, that that the vendors that are going to respond to that know how to action the right way uh based on what the real need is. I you know, we've all seen different RFIs and RFPs, whether they came from the public sector or the private, you know, the private sector that were reactive more so than proactive. And vendors are then just kind of caught their captive audience to these these events. And so that's uh that's fantastic. And so I also like that you mentioned that you know there's there's some iterations of of the program.

SPEAKER_01You've got a three-day clinic where you can, you know, walk walk the journey with someone, or maybe a hyphenated version of that to help buyers that don't have timelines for maybe even RFI, so they got to get the RFP right. So that's good. That's good that you've brought a product that uh you you've developed a product that can target all of that.

SPEAKER_00And that that really speaks to our experience in that every organization is is different. You know, we we want to come up with kind of some standard ways of talking about these things, and and you know, we we obviously have material we're we're we're using for e each client we work with, but every organization is gonna have different charging needs, and they're also going to have different procurement processes and needs. And so we we really like to try and meet them where they're at in terms of process and figure out what makes the most sense. Like I have two different municipal clients right now, and and one is a larger city with a lot more bureaucracy to work around.

SPEAKER_00And so that that can't really fully be fit into a workshop, right? Uh whereas another client, you know, had we maybe developed this a little sooner, we probably could have done a three-day sprint and gotten this RFP developed with everybody in the room. And so we're we're we're trying to meet folks where they're at and give knowledge where it's best injected for the process.

SPEAKER_02So, so in addition to that is is thinking about athletes who might not even be deploying, just to build on that, Grayson, their own, building their own, doing their own build-outs. So, I mean, we anchor around municipalities and this real real estate kind of majors who have large assets. And you think about a Walmart, think about a Prologis, think about uh ABB, CBR, like they have huge hundreds and hundreds of facilities all with charges. And so it helps them to be able to say, this is how we think about these charging uh relationships or this charging ecosystem and the stack that we have to deploy.

SPEAKER_02Then then you think about the small and medium-sized fleet fleet, which is where where where I cut my teeth really. And they're they're often just customers and they're they're they're they're getting relationships with charge point operators or they're using programs where where they have access to facilities and the and the go and charge. And the question, the the the the the benefit for them from something like this is to think about what do I have to require from these partners that I'm working with to make sure that when I come, my vehicle gets charged so that I can go and do my business, so I can go run my operations and not have to think twice about it.

SPEAKER_02So again, back to that cheaper is not always better is thinking about what kind of contracts do I sign if I'm going to work with a charge point of CPO to make sure that I'm covering the spaces. So what what this looks like in that situation is that you you ask these CPOs how many of these things have you addressed across the stack? And so the ones who actually can say, yes, I do get my firmware uh updates and have systems around reversing those updates in case that they brick something or stall something. Uh I do have that data uh data log access so that my my my uptime is guaranteed.

SPEAKER_02So when my OM folks come to that site and are asking a hundred questions, they already have the data they need, so they come prepared and they can actually repair it within a given window. So you know who you're you're getting into relationships with. And so this is I think a mutual benefit for the whole ecosystem. Even when you're not responsible for this whole stack, you can ask for it from your service providers, from your from your different vendors to to get and keep your fleet running right. Exactly. Knowledge is power. Exactly.

SPEAKER_01That's right. I love it. And and using it, using it to your advantage too, because there's I I can just imagine when you're reviewing projects with existing clients or prospective clients, and you're talking to the operators, you've already encountered some of the common mistakes, and you could probably see your client or prospective client trending in a certain direction. I I'm I'm curious, and you know, maybe Gracie, you take this from the retail side and and although you take it from the fleet side. Uh what when you're reviewing, what is what is the common part what is the common mistake?

SPEAKER_01Is it with how they're selecting hardware? Is it how they're planning for maintenance and operations downstream? What what you know, retail side, this is the one there. This is where there's too much noise, not enough signal, and same for the fleet.

SPEAKER_00It's it's hard to pin it down to one, I'm sure. Lou is thinking of a few himself. I I would say on the private public charging side, it's it's going to be not having the operational components in mind and lined up until the problems arise. So, you know, oh, there's this cool new charging hardware provider that that's giving me a good deal. They seem like they got their stuff together. And then not not planning, you know, what are what are the operational mechanics then? That I I often encounter folks on the private deployment side that have a solution in mind that I see the holes in as I'm approaching, and I have to walk them back from that that assumption everything's gonna be okay.

SPEAKER_00On the public side, because you know, I also see a lot of cities that are getting grant funds or just investing in and charging for economic development purposes. I see them going for the first provider that they have a good conversation with. And the relational component is so, so, so important for local government folks that it it can be a blinding factor for really complex procurement. I don't blame them. And you want to have a good relationship with the technical partners on the other side. And it takes those relationships souring on the back of issues to realize that. So I I try and say, that's great.

SPEAKER_00I know those folks, they're really nice, but let's let's look back and see how it really meets your needs. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Lalo, you got some comments. I think there's some similarities. I think uh from from the fleet side I have seen, and it's it's it's one of two flavors. One is there's no clear responsibility. So when I was when I was back in Incorporated, it was what we call the cross-arm salute. It's like it's your problem, it's your problem. The CS the CMS guy says it's the hardware, the hardware says it's OCPP or it's ONS, or it's like, oh, this is not in scope. So it's like no no one is clear, and then it just stalls in that chaos, and the driver or or the fleet manager is is is just like, man, I this is not working.

SPEAKER_02We don't we don't like electrification. So it kind of kills it. The other side of it is someone who tried to just do it by themselves all the way and didn't ask for help. So they thought the Google searches and I I love an enterprising fleet manager, and I think they run the world, and I believe they still do. Now it's like here's here's a helping hand, where they said, I got it. It's just energy. I've I've done I've done this before. I changed the breaker in my house, or we've always done our work ourselves, and then they buy these chargers and they put them in there, and it's like I bought it on Amazon, and that's fine, we have enough capacity, and then this comp this problems compound, and then they blame the technology.

SPEAKER_02And so it's two flavors of the same thing where there's no clock clear accountability and and and no or or or know-how, and it's typically because there's not a clear understanding of the need, the operational environment. And on the other side, there are people that have deployed just splendidly that that that think ahead through through a lot of these issues. Uh a lot of I mean, Tesla is a flagship for this, right? And and I mean it helps that they own the whole vertical stack and then they did their deployment. That's why there's agents that reputation for the thing that is starting to crack now that they're federating it to independent owners who again might be a lot more enterprising and say, I can just figure this out.

SPEAKER_02But we're realizing that there are there there's a right way to do this, and the right ways are few, but there are many wrong ways to do this. And so how how do we how do we use that?

SPEAKER_01You know, I got a I got a question. It's it's somewhat uh, you know, probably selfish to ask as a service provider, but I still got to talk about it. And it's in in the vein of reliability, reliability and uptime gets thrown around. It's those are terms that are used and abused in our space. Very important meaning behind these terms, though. And and so I'd I'd be curious from your experience with your clients, what what are you seeing as is those like you said, you got some that have it together and others are kind of just piecing things together? What what are some qualities of of a high performing charging program versus a struggling one?

SPEAKER_01And and the reason I'm asking for that is is in the vein of reliability, as they're as you know, will this operator they they they addressed an SLA, they had parts logistics defined in that SLA, or or you know, kind of what are some of the qualities of those that are prepared versus those that are just kind of you know piecing things together? And you can answer that from either either perspective, retail, public charging fleet, however.

SPEAKER_00I I think I think there are there are common things, and I'm I'm I'm sure Laulu will catch what I miss here, but something that Laulu and I both value and and why we work well together is is good metrics and precision of language. And it's a silly place to start, seemingly, right, for for you know who's doing the the real hard like mechanical and operational aspects of charging well, but it's understanding that you have the right facts and the right shared knowledge with all partners. And what that looks like is choosing the right metrics to base your success off of, tracking them diligently, and having an owner tied to each one.

SPEAKER_00So I'll I'll give an example. I'm I'm sure Laulib has some complimentary ones as well. But the one that I really focused on in my time as an interoperability engineer is moving away from uptime and focusing on plug-in success or first-time plug-in success. And so from the operator perspective, uptime means that you're seeing in a portal that your charger says available and it's the percentage of time it says available. The technical layer is very often being calculated just by is a I'm here, I'm alive signal being sent via OCPP from the charger to the CSMS.

SPEAKER_00No information about uh you know how it well it's performing or what the user experience is like. That's useful. You know, we want to know that the charges are up. We want that 97 plus percent uptime, but it is so incomplete and it's it's used as a catch-all. And so we say uptime is the assumed. If you if you can't meet an uptime requirement, then then you're phased out in that first thought exercise. The next layer down is this plug-in success. Of what percentage of plug-ins from a charger to a vehicle do you reach a successful charging session that delivers a meaningful amount of energy that ends gracefully and all parties are happy with?

SPEAKER_00That captures end-to-end reliability. And if you found the partners that can really measure that well for you and with you, both from a hardware perspective and a software perspective, and you are monitoring that closely and have the ability to see where in the chain it broke, you're doing well. And I I would be willing to bet that even the operators that I don't have visibility into, you know, you're you're big players that are are coming out of the gate, performing really well with some of the the new impressive hardware manufacturers where we've just now started getting to the states.

SPEAKER_00This is the metric they're centered on.

SPEAKER_02I I like that, Grace. And and once you have that clear signal, that's where folks like you, Jason, come in and then you say, okay, this charger is down. We need we need we need boots in the ground, and and and you guys get metrics around how fast you can get your folks out there to address the issue. I think a stronger, stronger metric is is mean time to repair. How the time between you flagging the issue and getting it back online. I think that that responsibility owns sits either with the fleet manager or the facilities director, however that operation is set up. However, how how that comes to light is is through a very uh a few different things.

SPEAKER_02Are you able to diagnose the issue quickly? I mean, like like Grayson was speaking to. And after OCP beats, it's then access to your hardware data logs to make sure they're looking at the right thing. Then all of this stuff, is it filtering through to your charging management software provider or or charging station management software provider? And then are those guys, I mean, I have a client in in that space and and they end up holding the bag just because they're the most responsible ones in the in the buck. When they see some trends that they don't they don't understand, they go and call the hardware at the OEM, they go, they go and talk to the fleet.

SPEAKER_02And so the fleet just starts relying on them more and more just because they they care more than the other folks, not because it was mandated in their like contract or anything like that. So with those three things triage, it should result in a clear fault, uh a clear pack to fix, maybe whatever spare parts are are needed, which should be contracted with your OEM or whatever other situation you get there, so that by the time field advantage that Jason is called up, you know what it is. Your folks are getting on site with the bag with the parts, going to the charger, and they they have the step-by-step.

SPEAKER_02And then that helps you get get that that that device up and running in in no time. All of that rolls into the meantime to repair, which I think is going to be very quickly the most critical, one of the more critical uh uh things that uh operators are are held to. But uh it's all predicated on first-time success after the uptime. It's so there are these layer things and and it's nuanced, and that's how that exceptional performance and to start kind of expanding that margin performance and and uh customer retention and and all those other metrics that that really drive profitability or success versus the the the bulk, right?

SPEAKER_02The long tail of just most folks just doing the bare minimum to get to get things uh up and running.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely, yeah. Yeah, it's the complimentary pieces. It's it's uh the the best in class operators know when and why every session fails, and then they fix it. And they've they've figured out how they're going to fix it and how they're going to measure it long before there's ever an issue.

SPEAKER_01Greedin. Green. I've appreciated that this conversation, uh, especially that it's with two different engineers, uh, has been has been easy to track and easy to follow through, and and you've offered some real insights and some you know legitimate feedback on on planning and preparation. And so, you know, our industry kind of gets a bad rap that it's it's it's by engineers for engineers. And so when you look at it when you look at it from the design of hardware to the design of vehicles or anywhere up and down the value chain, it's been it's been it's been architected by engineers with in other engineers in mind, and so there's been these complexities to it.

SPEAKER_01I mean, you you've seen the the mature maturation of the way product is developed, whereas open up an early DC fast charger and it looks one way, whereas you open up uh a different one today and it's it's been designed with serviceability in mind or other other things. And so, you know, we've had all learning to do uh and and growing to do. But uh, you know, I've appreciated that both of you have shared some some practical and and real-time insights and and really, you know, the the the the Buy Better program I think is is key for especially for any operator listing right now, whether you're in a fleet world or public charging world, you know, give these guys a call and and see how they can help you, whether it's you know just deploying a new site or remodeling an existing site, because they probably got some good questions to ask you uh that will help you know forecast what you need to do and and lay out a good uh a good plan.

SPEAKER_01So Lalo Grayson, uh as we get ready to round the corner on this conversation, I I'd just like to zoom out and get get some some kind of macro industry commentary from you as our industry is maturing. What what are what do you think needs to happen for charging infrastructure uh to be planned right, bought right, operated right? What what what are some curves we need to take, some some changes we need to make as an industry? That that that that's a good one.

SPEAKER_02Uh first, thank you to be too kind telling an engineer that we're we're speaking out in a world that actually sounds logical. I tell that to my wife, and I think she needs to hear that more. I think I I get I get in my own head too much sometimes. So I really appreciate that. I think at the crux of of your question, Jason, uh is uh is it's something that has proven very hard to do, but is to start to treat this data sharing. I heard an analogy, I mean, is where I'm going to this, going to with this. Is it this is not quite as critical as the airline industry. But if you think about the safety record and maybe the last couple of years could be a little questionable, but I think the airline industries won and the FAA and what they've done to kind of almost eliminate like tragic incidents in in the last in the recent past.

SPEAKER_02And it's through them voluntarily saying we need to share data with each other so that mistakes, when they do happen, we're not embarrassed by them. And so we raise them and address them to together so they have protocols to avoid them down the road. Charging infrastructure is not nearly as critical as air travel. However, uh it's it's rapidly growing. I I I still strongly believe in the in the climate crisis being real and us being able to do something about that. We might not be able to solve it. But if we do care, let's reduce emissions on the road. And one way we can do that is drive more EVs. So again, a big part of why I'm in this industry is the passion around that big North Star that I think us as humankind can really do something about.

SPEAKER_02And to do that, we have to get more EVs on the road, which by the way are a lot cheaper to operate when done right. A lot of conditional terms, but when we start sharing data and like sharing learnings about what we know works, and I think that's why Grayson and I are in such a unique position, because as consultants, we get to kiss a lot of frogs and help them become princes or whatever that analogy, how that might work. And so by that, we gather this, we we get to pull this knowledge. I mean, confidentially, we don't betray confidences, especially and we were under a lot of NDAs, but there are pieces, there's pattern recognition we start to bring together.

SPEAKER_02And how do we do that on a more official scale where we're saying, here's hundreds of thousands of data flu line, and then feed it back to either the fleet operators or or or the OEMs in a way that it's not quite collusion, but then it's also enough to to to help us move, progress together. Again, fine line to draw, and and and there's more work to be done there, but I think that's one thing that that will go a long way.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Yeah, yeah. I I I think everybody in the industry, whether they'll say it publicly, will recognize behind closed doors that that data sharing is long since needed. And it's it, I think we maybe saw during the previous administration where there was an effort to have some government coordination and and uh agenda setting on that front, that it's not enough for it to just be mandatory. It's also we we we have to see our common goals in the industry. We have to understand that the rising tides lift all ships. And it and I think that's a that's really speaks to a larger trend that I want the industry to go towards, and I think we're just now starting to see it, which is this normalization of charging as a normal part of life and the economy that operates without extreme distortions that create strangeness, right?

SPEAKER_00So I mean both on the customer experience side of making charging something that you don't either have to be an engineer or a tech pro to understand and having an experience that's very familiar and comfortable for new EB drivers. I mean on the procurement side of building that educational muscle for the society to understand that charging is complex and to pull in experts and to you know buy the system as you would any complex technology, say a whole city's IT system. It's not it's not that different in terms of the needs for very specific hardware and software requirements.

SPEAKER_00And I also mean it in terms of you know moving towards competing in logical ways on price and not reliability. We should be assuming that our systems are reliable. We should, that should be the baseline that we're all operating on, that you can't make it in this market if you're not a hardware or software provider that delivers a good experience so that we can then compete on amenities and price and all these things that make people want to stop at your charging station, not is this going to work this time? I really need it to.

SPEAKER_00And so I think Lalu spoke really well to what we need to see industry players do. I think we're we're gonna see more pressure in that direction. We see mass market adoption. There's been a lot of good press about the used market popping off over the next couple of years as those subsidized IRA era leases are coming off of term and when we see a lot more cheaper EVs hit the market. So I I think it's it all snowballs into charging's gotta be commonplace and everyday and accessible.

SPEAKER_00And that's that's why we wanted to start both of our businesses, but also specifically this offering of buy better charging to help folks with that education piece in and solving those the charging issues that honestly gate adoption.

SPEAKER_01Well, I appreciate both of you guys coming on and and sharing your insights and and being a guest. There you there you have it, folks. Uh Grayson Edy with eVision solutions. And Lalu Aduolo with uh Lecke Services. Both firms uh will have links to their websites in our show notes. And of course, both Lalu and Grayson are active on LinkedIn. Feel free to connect with them directly. If you're listening, you got interest in in the program that they've co-created, the Buy Better program, please please reach out to both of them to schedule some time to let them guide you through your electrification program.

SPEAKER_01Show notes will include contact and LinkedIn links, etc. But uh thank you to both of you for coming on Phil Frequency and sharing some time with us.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, thank you so much for having us. And and for those listening, you can learn more about the program at buybettercharging.com. Great, great. So there's actually a domain for for the for the program. All right.

SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep, and it'll have have our contact information on there as well. Awesome, awesome. Well, we'll include that in the show notes as well. Thank you both for coming on Phil Frequency. It was a pleasure.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. It was great.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much, Jason. Enjoyed being on. This episode was produced and edited by the team at Atozi. To find out more, visit autosy.co a u t o z y dot co.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Charged EV Hubs: Emerging Operator, Proven Network

    Nov 18, 202638 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What does it take to build a charging business around an established network? In Season 2, Episode 7 of Field Frequency, Jason Cortes sits down with Jeremy Watrous, founder of Charged EV Hubs, for an...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Mike Calise on the Convergence of Energy, Transportation and AI

    Nov 11, 202650 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail EV charging is no longer just about putting energy into a vehicle. As AI, transportation and the grid start drawing on the same power, EVs are becoming energy assets that can store, dispatch and earn...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. EV Wire | Electric Trucks, Robotaxis, and the Business Between

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail The companies that built charging for electric trucks are now building depots for robotaxis. They already know how to bring power to a site and design around a fleet. So what does today's infrastructure...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. EVSTAR Part 2: What It Actually Takes to Restore Uptime

    Oct 28, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Transferring the financial risk doesn’t fix the charger. Someone still has to diagnose the failure, find the right parts, coordinate with the site, and get a qualified technician there to complete the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. EVSTAR Part 1: Who Carries the Risk When Chargers Fail?

    Oct 21, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail EV chargers fail. That part isn't up for debate. The real question is who pays when they do, and most of the industry still isn't answering it when the deal is being made. In Part 1 of a two-part...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode