Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Field Frequency

Field Frequency artwork

EVSTAR Part 1: Who Carries the Risk When Chargers Fail?

Oct 21, 202634 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail EV chargers fail. That part isn't up for debate. The real question is who pays when they do, and most of the industry still isn't answering it when the deal is being made. In Part 1 of a two-part series, Jason Cortes sits down with Hubert Kim, Vice President of Business Development at EVSTAR, a provider of insurance-backed extended warranty programs for EV charging infrastructure. Hubert spent nearly a decade at Asurion underwriting warranties on consumer electronics, then led sales at SK Signet. There he watched one charger on the New York State Thruway go up and down for six months: remote diagnostics, four or five truck rolls, a firmware engineer flown in from Korea, and more than $20,000 spent before it was fixed. That charger shaped EVSTAR's thesis. Plenty of companies can put a technician in front of a broken charger. What the market is missing is someone to underwrite the cost of the fix. As utilization climbs, power modules cycle harder, failures rise, and the cost of keeping a site online gets harder to forecast. OEM warranties typically cover parts for two years but not the labor, the travel, or the triage that happens before anyone rolls a truck. And when a manufacturer exits the market, its warranty can go with it. Hubert's argument: warranty belongs in the procurement and financing conversation, not after the hardware is already in the ground. In this conversation: • The $20,000 charger, and what one bad unit taught Hubert about life cycle cost • Applying the consumer extended-warranty model to $20K-$100K+ charging assets • Deployment-first to utilization-first, and why higher utilization means more failures • NEVI's 97% uptime requirement and what it asks of operators • Why warranty is a finance and risk management question, not just a CapEx line item • A $3,000 cross-country trip for a two-hour fix: the labor gap in OEM warranties • OEM self-insurance, and why it gets harder to sustain at scale • What happens to your warranty when a manufacturer leaves the market • Who fixes vs. who pays: how field service partners fit into an underwritten warranty • Financing, funding, and proof: the three forces pushing warranty into procurement • Revenue reimbursement when service SLAs aren't met • Two questions to answer before the RFP: what's covered, and who's backing it • Accidental damage vs. vandalism: where coverage starts and stops • Why self-insuring is rarely as cheap as buyers expect Buying the charger is one decision. Deciding who carries its life cycle risk is another. Part 2 moves from strategy to execution: what it takes for coverage to actually convert to uptime.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02EV chargers eventually fail, the question is who carries the financial risk when they do. As utilization increases and charging assets age, operators and OEMs aren't just managing hardware, they're managing an unpredictable path through parts, labor, travel, and downtime costs at scale. In part one of this two part series with EV Star, we examine self insurance, risk transfer, and why warranty may belong much earlier in the infrastructure and procurement strategy. Buying the charger is one decision. Deciding who carries its life cycle risk is another. Let's get into it.

SPEAKER_02Welcome to Field Frequency. This podcast is sponsored by Field Advantage. Field Advantage is a national field services organization supporting EV charging infrastructure across the United States. Today's episode is the first of a two-part conversation that we're going to be having with EVSTAR. EVSTAR is a provider of insurance-backed in extended warranty programs for EV charging infrastructure. And this part, we're going to get into the strategic side of warranty. We're going to talk about risk transfer, where the warranty plans fit into procurement processes, et cetera. And our next episode will be a shift on focus around execution and how coverage converts to uptime.

SPEAKER_02So glad to have Hubert Kim, Vice President of Business Development for EVSTAR with us today. Hubert, thanks for coming on, Field Frequency. How are you doing this morning?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm doing great, Jason. Thanks for having me on and uh excited for this conversation.

SPEAKER_02Likewise, before we get into EVSTAR and the warranty side of this conversation and what EVSTAR is doing in the EV charging ecosystem, could you give us a little bit of your background and how you ended up at EV Star? And what what did you see that made you think there was a problem in this industry that that needed to be addressing and addressed through the through the methods and means at EVSTAR?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. During my time as head of sales at SK Signet, we had a customer who had a charger up in upstate New York on the New York State throughway. It was one charger that was on and off, up and down for about six months. We had done remote diagnostics. We'd done four or five truck rolls, had a service engineer drive out there each time, spent thousands of dollars just on troubleshooting and diagnosis. Finally, we had to fly a firmware engineer from Korea. I drove to the site within myself to figure out what was happening with the charger. Not that I could help, but I wanted to be a part of the solution.

SPEAKER_00We've finally figured out a couple things. There were some wiring issues, hardware issues, and some firmware issues. But at the end of the day, we realized we spent more than$20,000 to fix this issue. And chargers are going to continue to fail. But what I started to realize was that the cost of repair and keeping these chargers up and running are very expensive and it's difficult to forecast and difficult to look forward on. This wasn't a problem that was new to me because prior to my time in the EV charging industry, I worked at Ashurian, which they sell extended warranties for consumer electronics.

SPEAKER_00I worked with Amazon.com and Walmart.com to sell extended warranties on laptop computers, cell phones, calculators, toaster ovens, anything in your home that's electronic. And I realized that by using an extended warranty program, consumers could underwrite the risk of keeping their products up and running. We're taking that same risk model, that same warranty model, and applying it to EV chargers just at a larger scale. So that now an operator who has a$20,000,$40,000,$100,000 piece of infrastructure sitting on their property, they don't have to worry what it's going to cost to fix that charger.

SPEAKER_00And when that charger goes down, we're able to provide a solution that's underwritten by AIG insurance so that that charger stays up and running.

SPEAKER_02So, you know, of course, in our space, industry is, of course, from the from the very beginning, focus has been on getting chargers deployed, getting chargers active in the ground. Now the the shift over the last few years has really been focused on not only profitability around a charge site, but you know, what's driving profitability is utilization. Utilization is driven by by uptime and reliability. And so as the industry has navigated its way through the challenges with uptime, the challenges with the life cycle cost, what what is what are the actual costs to own and operate this equipment and and what has changed and how does warranty become a strategic either piece in that or maybe part of part issue in this?

SPEAKER_02How does that all come together?

SPEAKER_00That's a great question, Jason. Uh I'd say in the early days of EV charging deployments, many operators and smaller operators were deploying chargers focused on getting funding for their chargers from incentives, from utilities, from the federal government, uh with without such a keen eye on utilization or profitability. Now, government would fund those chargers and operators will get that, those funds reimbursed. But then once that funding was available to them, they weren't so much focused on uptime or reliability.

SPEAKER_00For years, a lot of people focused on deploying chargers. A lot of that was based on getting public money, infrastructure money, tax incentive. There were, it was a deployment first strategy, get the chargers deployed so they could qualify for rebate funds or incentive funding. Now operators are looking more at what are profitable sites to develop for utilization. So people are getting, uh operators are getting much more smarter at looking at at specific sites, trying to calculate what is the EV penetration at that site, how many cars are there, what is the traffic density that goes by a site per day, what are the average household income in that area, and what is the growth rate of EV penetration in those neighborhoods.

SPEAKER_00This way they can forecast what the utilization will be. Now, as we see utilization driving higher for EV charging, the life cycle now gets shorter because as you use the chargers, as the power modules are cycled on and off more and more, more heat is dissipated through these chargers. We're gonna see more reliability and uptime issues affecting them. And in that regard, having a charger up and running is critical. It's critical from a profitability standpoint. It's critical from even from a funding standpoint with NEVI funds, there is that 97% uptime uh guarantee that operators have to agree to.

SPEAKER_00And by having that charger up and running is gonna keep them in the good graces of the of the regulators and the departments of transportation that are issuing the funds for those future sites that operators are are bidding on. So in that regard, what we're doing is we're providing some guarantee of confidence for operators that they know what the cost of keeping these chargers up and running will be so they could pay it up front. They buy extended warranty up front and it will cover those charges for the life of that that agreement or that contract. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Warranty seems to the value of warranty, of course, there's there's manufacture warranties that maybe are for parts or on-site labor or some kind of combination thereof, but uh warranty programs or products for the most part have seemed to be just kind of a part of the capex and not really viewed through the lens of operations and uptime and kind of the long time reliability of supporting the site. Obviously, people deport deploy chargers, and then when there's a problem, they they're they're scrambling to resolve it.

SPEAKER_02To the example that you gave when you were at SK Signet with your customer, former customer up there in the Northeast and and so forth, and all that went into responding to that field service need. And so one of the one of the things that I've heard EV Star talk about is that warranty is isn't just you know a CapEx problem. It's not even maybe just an operational problem. It's it's really about finance and risk management, really issues around the life cycle of the chargers. And so do you do you think that the industry looks at that the right way today, or are we still kind of treating warranty as just something that we buy when we buy the charger and then that's it, and either works, it's either successful when there's a problem or it's not.

SPEAKER_02What what what where is the misconceptions around that?

SPEAKER_00And yeah, I think that a lot of operators look at warranty as helping keeping their chargers up and running and operational. We look at our the way we approach it is more from a financial perspective. We put a financial lens on OM so that operators can have the confidence that when a charger fails, they have the funding and the and the support to underwrite or pay for the tr the failed chargers, the the service incident. The industry will look at warranty and operations. At the end of the day, it's uptime, right?

SPEAKER_00We're trying to make sure that these chargers remain up and running, that they are operational. There are many companies in the market today that can physically touch the charger to fix it. And whether that's companies like Field Advantage, other service companies, a lot of OEMs or operators will have their in-house service teams that can go and fix the chargers. What's missing in the market today is underwriting the cost of fixing those chargers. And that's where I saw the opportunity. We as EV Star see the opportunity just to step in and provide a gap for something that's we see missing in the market.

SPEAKER_00And that is the ability to underwrite and pay for the service event when that service event happens. So if there is a hardware failure, if even a cable is damaged by driver misuse, if a driver drops the cable, that CCS1 connection cracks and breaks, we would cover that from both a parts and labor perspective. We would dispatch a service tech to the site to fix it and replace it. And that and that's unique because at the end of the day, the part is often covered by the warranty for those first two years. The labor is not, and then calculating how much that labor is going to cost.

SPEAKER_00If there's a tech nearby, it could be a few hundred dollars to dispatch a technician. I was talking to an OEM recently who said they had to dispatch an engineer from the West Coast to the East Coast. The engineer was there for only two hours to fix the issue, but the cost to get him there was over$3,000 to fix something that was very straightforward once you had a knowledgeable tech in front of that charger. So in this regard, I think the concept of warranty is going to continue to shift and grow in this market. Chargers are going to continue to fail.

SPEAKER_00That's a given. At the end of the day, how are people budgeting for that? How are you going to account for the cost? Do operators or OEMs guess at what that's going to cost? Or they can use an underwritten solution where we're using actuarial analysis to calculate what the actual risk is going to be. And then we're guaranteed backstopping that by an underwritten warranty from AIG insurance that makes sure that once a contract is written, that coverage will be covered regardless of what happens to the OEM, to the operator, or even to EV Star.

SPEAKER_00That contract will still be underwritten by AIG insurance.

SPEAKER_02You know, in that example of the manufacturer having to send one of their engineers out into the field, playing tickets, lodging rentals, all the stuff. But we're talking about risk transfer at the OEM, at the manufacturing level. So they have a product when they sell their chargers, they're bundling warranty with it, et cetera, but it's not enough.

SPEAKER_02It's usually parts, and that's not covering all the downtime associated with just the triage before that engineer ever even got on the plane to go to the site. And so we've we've seen that. We've seen that, of course. Um, you know, I've worked for manufacturers myself and and and work alongside and with manufacturers today. And when they're, you know, their focus on their their core competency, which is building the charger and and and producing a product that goes into the market. But when you talk about supporting it as the OEM, all the costs that was associated, and then of course just the triage to get that that engineer on a plane and out there to the site.

SPEAKER_02There's a lot of moving pieces, a lot of downtime, a lot of stuff that's happening. And so when when you guys are talking about risk transfer, it's it's it's going beyond the operator, but it's it's because there are there are risks that the manufacturer and the CPO are actually carrying today. And I I don't think that the industry fully, fully, I I know it understands it experientially, obviously, but I don't know that it's it's thought about it on the front end of the deals to begin with, because it was just kind of like, ah, I bought this charger, it's got two years of warranty. Well, there's a whole lot that goes into supporting that warranty that that's that's that's got gaps, obvious gaps.

SPEAKER_02And war and EV Star is is like you said, is filling in those gaps, bringing those pieces that are missing and bringing that together. So let's talk about the the the financial realities and and really you know, maybe costs around self-insuring, warranty, you know, things like that. Historically, most manufacturers are are self-insured against their warranty exposure. But as the industry is matured, there is there's an obvious need. And and as the installation grows uh across our US across the US, what what does that how does that become a model that is difficult to sustain?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think industry maturing is a great catchphrase. What we're seeing in EV charging and building out the infrastructure here in the, especially in the United States today and and globally as well, EV charging is growing. Uh and when an industry first started in the early days with SK Signet, when Electrify America and EVGO, they're building their networks, the operators, the OEMs, the service companies, they're all trying to understand how can we make this industry work? How do we get this up and running as fast as possible? A lot of people will do many tasks on their own that because they have to out of necessity.

SPEAKER_00Now, as you say, this industry is maturing. As the industry matures, then other specialized tasks can come in. I make it akin to a small business. When you start up, if you're a one-man band, you're doing your own accounting, you're doing your own legal, you're doing your own HR. As the business grows and as you get larger, you'll outsource some of those non-core aspects of your business to specialists who are specialized in those aspects. I see extended warranty as one of these areas where as the industry is now maturing, this idea of underwriting OM operations and maintenance of your chargers, of your charging network, you can outsource it to a specialist like EVSTAR that's underwriting it with an insurance company so that it's underwritten and not just my word that we're gonna provide support for these chargers.

SPEAKER_00As you know, this industry is still going through a lot of ups and downs, and there are OEMs that have entered the market, there are OEMs that have exited the market. So if customers had purchased a charger from Freewire or Evo Charge or even LG Electronics and purchased an extended warranty from those companies, some of them will continue to honor those warranties, but there's a little bit of uncertainty what the future will be with those in those instances. That's where when a company like EV Star comes into the picture, we can underwrite those warranties. AIG will always provide that backing.

SPEAKER_00So even if EV Star were to something were to happen to EV Star, AIG will continue to honor that warranty. And it's underwritten insured product that is is guaranteed by AIG. They're writing over$20 billion in premium annually, and this EV EV charging market is not gonna cause a dent in their operations, as far as I know. I don't uh until it reaches that billion, two, three, four, five billion dollar scale, that's where we're going. But until we get there, I I don't think we have anything to worry about.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Hubert, you just keyed in on something, I think, for those, especially operators that are listening to this episode that I think really highlights some of the value. Because you you used an example of companies that have become insolvent. They're not operating in the U.S. any longer, but there's product, and and and there is likelihood that there are operators out there with hardware still in crates that haven't been deployed, that haven't even been commissioned. And now, now the manufacturer, that that product doesn't exist.

SPEAKER_02It's it's either sunset, the company's gone, et cetera. All hope is not lost. While you know, original warranties may have dissolved with the with the dissolving of the company, the there's still hope, and that's that's in that product that EV Star is brought to market, that coverage that that looks at the value of the hardware and looks at that cost and says, okay, this is what it was, this was the cost on the front end, and and here's what we have that we can offer to support that, both with with with per parts and with with on-site labor and with mobilization and all the field service aspect.

SPEAKER_02And so to that comment, I would like to tee up uh you know some commentary from from you around partnerships because execution still matters, and that's where you know partnerships between EVSTAR and Field Advantage are the values they're seen. So while you've transferred, as you know, EVSTAR is transferred that financial risk there is away from that operator and is burying some of that. Somebody still has to go out and fix the charger when there is an issue. What happens? And so that's where partnerships come into play. And so I would like to get your commentary.

SPEAKER_02And again, this is Field Advantage is obviously a partner of EVSTAR, but EVSTAR has other field service partners. And so I'd like at a macro level you you to just comment on how how important is the field service piece to making an underwritten warranty product actually work?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think partnerships are very important in this space. When a charger breaks, two things have to happen. Somebody has to go to the charger, take a part with it, fix it, touch that charger, troubleshoot, diagnose what's happening. That's outside of the scope of EV Star's expertise. That's where we rely on great partners. Uh, Field Advantage is a great partner for us because you have very professional techs that are available. We have very strong SLA with the Field Advantage team, and they are everywhere where we need to be right now. As we bring on more customers to our network that have more dispersed geographic locations, we'll partner with Field Advantage to make sure that we have the right staff and right team in place to touch the charger.

SPEAKER_00But that's only one part of resolving a failed charger issue. The other part is who's going to pay for that failure? Who's going to pay for the part? Who's going to pay for the labor to get that charger up and running again? And that's where we come in. So that there's a we have that two-part partnership where EV Star will make sure that the cost of the part and labor to bring that charger back online is covered. And then we'll rely on folks like Field Advantage or other service companies to dispatch to be the hands and feet of EVSTAR executing that. We'll still maintain the claim ownership so that if anything happens, it comes back to EV Star.

SPEAKER_00We will make the determination if we need to dispatch additional parts. At what point do we call it a complete buyout or a rip and replace? And in the cases of rip and replace, we will go in and pay for both the hardware and the labor to completely rip and replace that unit so that the charger's up and operational again. But I think having good partners in this space, it's a small industry. We all work together. We need to rely on each other to get these things done. We're not going to invent the wheel all over again. When there are great service partners out there like Field Advantage, that can help us service the needs of the market and we'll focus on what we're specialized on, and that's the financial underwriting of the OM of these charging infrastructure assets.

SPEAKER_02So when an operator has leveraged the products and solutions that EBSTAR has, they are they are released from some of that burden because typically an operator is is traditionally carrying the responsibility around maintenance. They're carrying, they're bearing that financial exposure because, again, the incomplete warranty products that are offered at the OEM level don't always cover all the call all in costs to resolve a need. And so what I'm hearing you say is is in and for the operators that are listing, an under warranty warrant, uh an underwritten warranty brings some some equilibrium to that to that risk that the operator has.

SPEAKER_02And when there's a need, that's where EB Star steps in and is paying those costs, paying for that truck roll, paying for those parts. That's that's invaluable.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. I think one thing that we are looking to roll out soon is a third leg of this uh three-legged stool, which will be more diagnosis troubleshooting remote services. So coming soon, we'll be able to offload even some of that network monitoring responsibility from the operators so that operators could focus on deploying chargers, having chargers up and running, and outsource monitoring that to someone like EV Star so that we would have knowledge of when something fails, when that fails, we would proactively set an alert, remotely diagnose what's happening.

SPEAKER_00If on-site service is required, we would dispatch through our partners and cover all that for the for the operator, making it a simple, we want to be a simple one-stop shock for operations maintenance.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's a that's amazing because going beyond the reactive and entering into that proactive, that monitoring, that that triage and resolution before a problem even starts. Um obviously field service companies are ready to roll those trucks, but the operator is trying to contain those costs. And so with an warranty administrator upstream from even potential disaster and kind of mitigating that on the front end, that's that's huge. That's really good. And, you know, looking looking at our industry, these are the types of things that it takes to help us evolve and and reach that maturation point that we're all pursuing as an industry.

SPEAKER_02I'd I'd like to talk about kind of the procurement landscape and and and how EV Star kind of drops into that on the procurement side. Because how do we get procurement stakeholders to start thinking about underwritten warranty as part of the charger procurement decision itself, rather than something you come back later and you figure out, or you come back later and you're trying to think about how you're gonna support this hardware? And so kind of moving EV star up, you know, upstream into the into the procurement phase, how do operators begin to start thinking about that warranty in in the charger procurement stage?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, great question. I think there are three things that will move procurement forward as they think about the warranty space. Um, and that is financing, funding, uh, and proof. So, one, financing as operators now start to reach out for private credit or getting lending to underwrite their charging portfolio, just like mortgage lenders require homeowners. To have home insurance. Construction lenders require bonds. DCFCs that are financed with debt, lenders will ask what happens if the hardware fails during the term of the loan.

SPEAKER_00The warranty could become a covenant as part of that funding requirement. That will become very important for the procurement team. Secondly, funding requirements. So funding programs that mandate uptime. For example, NEVI or state programs or a lot of the utility programs, they require uptime as a guarantee, as a condition of funding, getting that incentive funding out. They don't always specify how you guarantee that that uptime guarantee is met, but closing that gap coverage could become a funding requirement as well.

SPEAKER_00And that's something that we're working with some of the regulators and incentive, like utility companies, to more tightly define what is a funding requirement for keeping these chargers up and running. So that's another way that procurement company procurement teams will think about adding a warranty to the mix up front when they're purchasing a charger. And then finally, proof, market proof. That's going to be the best demonstration of why procurement companies are going to look at this. An example that I'll talk about is our partnership with LinkWell. Middle of last year, we launched a partnership where LinkWell provides an end-to-end warranty in one product.

SPEAKER_00They have a software that does some proactive monitoring of the chargers in their network. If anything fails, then we have that extended warranty where we'll dispatch our service team, service partners to fix those chargers. One unique thing, and based on the unique partnership, there's also a revenue reimbursement. So if the claim isn't resolved within a set SLA, we'll compensate for the downtime and not just the fix. Skylar Pukish, the Linkwell CEO, now part of NIAX, they he said that this is more than a warranty program.

SPEAKER_00It's an infrastructure strategy. And that really resonates with me because it's not just, we're not just warranting program. It's a strategy to keep the infrastructure up and running. We're going to fix it, but also it it provides compensation and teeth in the program so that we're held accountable to the SLAs that we're talking about. Again, this is for a larger opportunity for larger operators or larger deployments. But I just wanted to share as the industry continues to evolve as people go out and procurement teams think about not just spending the spending the money on purchasing the assets, but how do they get a return on their investment and protect that investment so that they're continuing to generate that cash flow from charging revenue?

SPEAKER_00Oh, this is going to be very important as this industry continues to m move forward.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that that's huge. And you know, I think it's important, you know, double-click on on the the enterprise aspect of it. You you're talking about loss reimbursement for units that are down. And you know, it's I I I like that, I like that statement Skyler made as well. Infrastructure strategy, that's that's huge. And and and looking, you know, when you think about some of the enterprise level operators, everything for the most part in terms of procurement, you know, product analysis, all of that is is really uh takes the shape of usually an RFI and then an RFP.

SPEAKER_02And so if I'm a if I'm a CPO, if I'm an operator and and I'm I'm looking at that infrastructure strategy, maybe you know, before the RFP is even before the RFI even hits the street, what are what are some questions that operators need to be thinking about or asking as they either develop the RFP or how should they be front loading that RFP strategically to address the the long-term warranty strategy?

SPEAKER_00I'd say two things that are really important in thinking about a warranty strategy is one, what what does the warranty cover? And what's what are the coverage limits? And two, how's the warranty backed? Who's backing the warranty? Because at the end of the day, if it's a warranty with no financial backing behind it, it's only as good as the paper that it's written on. So going back to the coverages, what we focus on is parts and labor, typically for five-year period during the OEM's two-year parts warranty period, we'll pay for the labor to fix anything that breaks.

SPEAKER_00So if in month six, after commissioning a power module goes out or an the screen HMI has an issue, that part will be covered by the OEM. But the labor they'll often charge for, or they would have to dispatch it to someone else. The operator would be responsible for that. That would be covered under our warranty. And then after the two-year parts warranty expires, we will cover both parts and labor for the remainder of the term. Um we'll cover accidental damages as well, which is unique. Not all warranty companies will cover that. This is the most common one is a damaged cable or hose.

SPEAKER_00Again, if a CCS1 connector, if the driver doesn't return that to the holster, they leave it on the ground and a car subsequently drives over it. That would be a covered failure for EV star. We would cover the parts and labor for that. We don't cover vandalism because that would typically fall under the property or casualty insurance policy that that the operator would have or the owner of the site would have. But most of everything else will be covered. Basically anything that hardware that fails. And then secondly, questions that buyers are going to ask about warranties is who's backing the warranty?

SPEAKER_00So in the case of an OEM warranty, the OEM will cover it. So in my mind, the typical model is if Chem Power, if Alpatronic, if Zeroba, if SK Signet sells a five-year extended warranty, they'll take that money and they'll set it aside and hope that nothing breaks. But if something does break during the term of that warranty, they'll take money out of that pool pool of money and apply it towards the fixes. And they're hoping that they don't spend more money than they had set aside, or that they had charged the customer up front. They're taking that, they're they're using some analysis to calculate what are average costs to fix it, what are the average frequency, how often do these chargers break.

SPEAKER_00It's very difficult to estimate how frequently something will break in the future. That's where we're using actuarial analyses from both within EVSTAR as well as within AIG insurance. As I'd mentioned, I worked at Asurian for almost 10 years. Our team, a lot of our team are also legacy insurance folks, Assurian folks, and also from AIG from the insurance side. So they have calculated the risk on millions of consumer electronic devices, millions of washer, dryer components, other devices. So using that same actuarial analysis to calculate what is the cost going to be, how frequently are these chargers going to break.

SPEAKER_00We're using that same model to build a warranty plan for extended warranties, and then getting that underwritten by AIG insurance. So again, the backing is going to be from AIG, so that if anything, if anything happens, if we have made a miscalculation, it's not on us. It's AIG's guarantee to pay that out. It's going to continue to pay out.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Peace of mind for the operator. In those examples, you you listed off, you know, three or four durable EV hardware manufacturers, durable brands, recognizable brands. But uh in kind of that, you know, what questions should be asked response, you you did talk about, okay, what's one of the things they needed to know up front is what what does the out the box warranty offer, but but how is that backed? Because you you gave an example earlier of how, you know, it it's it's looking at how they're backed because it could be a company.

SPEAKER_02You mentioned durable brands, but then there are also new market entrants, new U.S. players coming to market, and they're looking for operators to give them a chance and and and see what market share they can get and try my product and all of that. And the buyer, you know, in some cases, buyer beware, but by also buyer consider. And so it's uh because there's some emerging players, emerging OEMs that are coming to the U.S. that that do have a good product, but you know, maybe there's there's buyer reticence because of of legacy brands that went under or or emerging brands that didn't last long. And so that that peace of mind is resolved by by integrating an EB Star warranty package that that helps support that and fill those gaps.

SPEAKER_02And again, considering the backing in this case, it'd be AIG and bearing some of that responsibility. So that's that's uh that's assurance that's available to the operator and to the purchaser. So, you know, as as as we get ready to kind of round out this conversation and close out here, what's uh I'd like your your closing thoughts around what what's something that you believe or some things that you believe about warranty strategy today that a lot of buyers maybe they don't they don't see it, they don't understand it, but you think over time they actually will.

SPEAKER_02Kind of what's that, you know, oh I get it, I I get the protection, but you know, I'm I'm you know, CapEx is very limited, I've got to deploy, I I I can't really think about it. And so it's kind of like you've been there, you've seen that from both sides of the desk. You know, what what is something that you know or believe today about warranty strategies that maybe buyers aren't really seeing? And like you you had an open mic to an audience of of of of uncertain in in buyers, what would you tell them?

SPEAKER_00You know, what the one thing I'd say is most buyers think that self-insuring is going to be cheaper in the long run. Think that over the long run people will start to realize that that becomes more and more expensive. There's a lot of uncertainty and pricing failure risk requires accurate data at scale with thousands of units, many years across multiple climates and duty cycles. Not a lot of people are taking all this data into account to price how to warranty, either self-insure it or to use an OEM's warranty. And are they also doing that work to ensure that, insure that risk?

SPEAKER_00So I think as this industry continues to mature, we'll see more and more, we're continuing to get more and more data at scale across many units, across climates, duty cycles. As we see utilization go higher, we're gonna see more failure rates. So I think that the assumption that self-insuring it is gonna be cheaper, that will play out in the long run that it's gonna be more expensive. It could be more expensive for a lot of operators. And some operators have the luxury to take that risk. They have, if they have that incremental cash flow, they have funding, they have backing, they have access to capital, they could afford that risk.

SPEAKER_00I'm hopeful that we're able to keep this industry up and running. In the long run, I want to see profitable EV charging stations across this country. I want to see the proliferation of EV vehicles so that people who choose to drive EV have that option for them. They're able to make a choice of whether they drive an ICE vehicle or an EV vehicle, and that having that infrastructure operational up and running throughout this country is going to be critical to that. We face a lot of challenges and hurdles with administration changes and different stances towards EV charging and funding.

SPEAKER_00At the end of the day, just as gas stations proliferated, we're capital through capital markets. I think EV charging will continue to proliferate despite the administration changes. Maybe there are times of accelerated growth, times of slower growth, and we'll be here to help underwrite all that OF for the EV charging industry. Good.

SPEAKER_02Good. Well said. Well, as I mentioned at the beginning of this episode, this is part one of a two-part series uh featuring EV Star. It made sense to uh to kick off the conversation and and for the first episode to feature who EB Star is and and what they're doing in the space and kind of open up that that that dialogue around what EB Star can do uh for the operators out there that are looking for that infrastructure strategy that goes beyond the hardware. And so uh our our next episode will we'll kind of get into the strategic execution of the warranty and and and what does it really mean to transfer that risk and and you know all of that.

SPEAKER_02And so we'll we'll get we'll get into the execution and how that coverage actually converts to uptime. But uh, thanks again, Hubert, for for joining me on Field Frequency for for show notes and and links to Hubert's LinkedIn, links to EV Star's website, and everything that's been referenced in today's conversation. Head over to our our website, fieldfrequency.com. Thanks for listening, and I'll see you on the next one. Thanks a lot, Jason. This episode was produced and edited by the team at Atozi. To find out more, visit autosy.co, a u t o z y dotco.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Charged EV Hubs: Emerging Operator, Proven Network

    Nov 18, 202638 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What does it take to build a charging business around an established network? In Season 2, Episode 7 of Field Frequency, Jason Cortes sits down with Jeremy Watrous, founder of Charged EV Hubs, for an...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Mike Calise on the Convergence of Energy, Transportation and AI

    Nov 11, 202650 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail EV charging is no longer just about putting energy into a vehicle. As AI, transportation and the grid start drawing on the same power, EVs are becoming energy assets that can store, dispatch and earn...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. EV Wire | Electric Trucks, Robotaxis, and the Business Between

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail The companies that built charging for electric trucks are now building depots for robotaxis. They already know how to bring power to a site and design around a fleet. So what does today's infrastructure...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. EVSTAR Part 2: What It Actually Takes to Restore Uptime

    Oct 28, 202629 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Transferring the financial risk doesn’t fix the charger. Someone still has to diagnose the failure, find the right parts, coordinate with the site, and get a qualified technician there to complete the...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Andrew Lambrecht | What the EV Market Is Actually Telling Us

    Oct 14, 202631 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail The headlines say the EV market is in trouble: the tax credit is gone, quarterly sales dipped, and range anxiety still won’t die. The market itself is saying something different. Used EV values are...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode