Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Facts vs Feelings with Ryan Detrick & Sonu Varghese

Facts vs Feelings with Ryan Detrick & Sonu Varghese artwork

Market Breadth is Overrated (FvF Ep. 208)

Oct 7, 202658 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In Episode 208 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, make the case that market breadth is overrated. With the S&P 500 less than half a percent from an all-time high and the Nasdaq printing a new record, the hosts explain why tech and tech-adjacent stocks, roughly half of the index, are carrying the market even as 10 of 11 sectors finished September in the red. They point to Micron's strong earnings, South Korea's surging chip exports, and rising AI capex estimates as evidence that profit growth is overpowering the rise in yields. From there, Ryan and Sonu break down the revised PCE data, arguing that inflation remains stubbornly hot, and cover the dovish turn from Fed officials that dropped October hike odds from about 70% to roughly 20%. They also discuss why the weak headline payrolls mask a healthy labor market. The episode wraps with a look at fourth-quarter seasonality, cautious investor sentiment near all-time highs, and their view that a global bull market supports staying diversified with a tilt toward tech and AI. [Key Takeaways] September's S&P 500 was nearly flat (down 0.3%) with 10 of 11 sectors in the red, but tech rose about 5%. The hosts expect a breakout in the tech sector ETF to lift the broader market as earnings season begins. Q4 is historically strong, averaging a 4.2% gain and rising more than 80% of the time. A negative Q1 followed by a 10%+ Q2 has never produced a down Q4, with an average return of about 6%. Inflation remains hot despite PCE revisions: Core PCE is running about 3% year over year, market-based core inflation is two to three times its historical pace, and ISM prices indexes are at multi-year highs, pointing to an inflationary growth environment. Fed hike odds for October fell from about 70% to roughly 20% after softer PCE data, light payrolls, and dovish Fed comments, though one more hike in December remains possible. The labor market is healthier than the headline 29,000 payrolls suggest, with the prime-age employment-population ratio at 80.7%, low layoffs, and Challenger job cuts at their lowest September level since 2022. Sentiment remains cautious near highs, with the CNN Fear & Greed Index in fear territory. The hosts view that lack of excitement as a net positive, and note that AI capex and profit growth are outweighing the drag from higher yields. Jump to: 0:00 - Welcome and What Matters Now 0:31 - Steve Jobs Legacy and Apple’s Run 6:24 - Why Breadth Headlines Miss the Point 10:56 - Tech Concentration and Sector Damage 15:26 - Q4 Seasonality and Earnings Setup 20:11 - Yields Rising Credit Stress Global Moves 22:11 - Europe Debt Fears and Politics Inflation 27:29 - Sentiment Still Cautious Near Highs 32:39 - PCE Revisions Still Hot Inflation 42:09 - PMIs Say Demand Strong Prices Hot 45:00 - Fed Hike Odds Payrolls Yield Curve 54:58 - Final Takeaways and Listener Requests Connect with Ryan: • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryandetrick/ • X: https://x.com/RyanDetrick Connect with Sonu: • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sonu-varghese-phd/ • X: https://x.com/sonusvarghese?lang=en Questions about the show? We’d love to hear from you! factsvsfeelings@carsongroup.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Welcome to the Facts versus Feelings Podcast. I'm your host, Ryan Dieter, and I'm joined by my co-host, Sonyvarky. Cutting through the noise, we've got Ryan Dieter, Chief Market Strategic, and Sonovarki are our Chief MacroStrategist. Taking out the board and helping investors focus on what really matters. And we are back.

SPEAKER_03Episode 208 of Carson's Facts versus Feelings. Ryan and Sonu. Market breath is overrated. Sonu, I don't know if you saw the cover. Maybe we can send this too. We may put this on the YouTube channel right now, but the cover of Barons has now noted that market breath is weak. Everybody is talking about it. Yet the time we're doing this, the SP is like less than half a percent away from an all-time high. Now that's Monday um morning. But um one thing I do want to point out, I didn't know this. Um shout out to Phil Rosen, our friend.

SPEAKER_03Um, he noted in his blog today that Steve Jobs passed away October 5th, 2011. So that's 15 years ago, the time we are doing this. Um, I don't know, just kind of, you know, well, obviously, one of the greatest um entrepreneurs, greatest leaders, obviously creators of wealth as well. Uh, but that stock, I don't have any numbers, it just came out, but that stock has done awfully well the last 15 years as well. Yeah, the usual, I remember when he passed away, I guess like, okay, who's gonna replace the king?

SPEAKER_03You know, that's a very, very high bar. But I, you know, you know, not a recommendation. Uh, but just look at the numbers. I mean, Apple's done pretty well. I mean, what's um, I don't know, you you know by Steve Jobs be dangerous. You have any takeaways from Steve Jobs as we kind of honor him 15 years ago after his uh passing.

SPEAKER_01I think it was all those cool products, right? It started with, I mean, uh I came to the States in 2000, so I've been here 26 years or now. And you know, I I I know like a lot of you who were growing up, I mean, right, including yourself, right? You the iMacs are there and the colorful Macs and things like that. I never got across, you know, I never got to experience that, but I came and that's when they released those cool laptops, the PowerBooks. I remember one of my my first laptop that I bought with my money was a 17-inch PowerBook, and it was a sleek, amazing looking laptop.

SPEAKER_01That was like the start of that Steve Jobs era, then he got the iPod, right? Yes, and he got the iPhone and then the iPad. And what's ironic over the last 15 years, the stocks did amazingly well. We could look at the stats, or you you all can pull that up, right? Is that when Tim Cook took over, they're like, you know, what new products has is he going to launch? And true, you know, the stocks are going to suffer if they don't release any new products. Guess what? I mean, have they released any new products except for that Apple Vision Pro, which nobody buys, nobody knows that thing.

SPEAKER_01There's nothing. Nothing, right? Like the iPhone was from the Steve Jobs era. I mean, they've got iPhone 15 and 17 and 1 million and all of that, right? All but hey, everyone's still buying this stuff.

SPEAKER_03And not everyone, not everyone, Sonu. Not everyone, huh?

SPEAKER_01Not everyone, yes, yes, my bad.

SPEAKER_03Mike, I well, I'm teasing. I'm an anti-Apple guy. Sorry to say it. I I just I don't know. Maybe I'm contrarian by nature.

SPEAKER_01Well, I guess they did come up with these little airpod things, so you know, those are nice. But but speaking of, you're not an airpod person, you use one of those big headphone things.

SPEAKER_03Well, I do have the big headphone when I travel on an airplane, because by I mean, you talk and you're just exhausted, you put those big things on. It's kind of like a do not disturb uh sign. But I do have some bows, um, the little clip on open open open ear, open air, I forget what they're even called, but I do have some of those. But yeah, my kids repeatedly lose their um anything to do with their ears repeatedly. So maybe that's how they keep making money. People keep pulling.

SPEAKER_00It looks the ears metaphorically as well, which is kind of where they don't listen to us or you parents. That's true. That is true.

SPEAKER_03Um, but you know, on the YouTube channel, Sonu, like show your shirt real fast, pull that shirt up. Yeah, there it is. There you go, that's awesome.

SPEAKER_01So mountains with facts and feelings. This is the first black, all black t-shirt that we've done. This is black and blue. I like the color.

SPEAKER_03It's you know, we should so we we were in uh Denver last week uh with all of our amazing Carson um partners and advisors at Excel. It's our big annual event. I mean, they were close. I'm I mean, I'm rounding up, I'm aware. I'll say close to a thousand, but what, like seven or eight hundred people, I think. And we got a huge room. You and I got to do a live Facts versus Feelings uh from there as well. And it was it was a lot of fun. Um Yeah, maybe we'll put a pen in that. We'll talk maybe more about that. But again, if you're um looking for a new home, looking for a new community, we we've got a pretty good one here at Carson. We had a lot of fun in Denver.

SPEAKER_03We might even share the we were live on stage, we're kicking around, maybe we'll share that as well. Um, as a special facts versus feelings. But let's just dive into this thing.

SPEAKER_01I got the numbers by the way. Apple versus the SP 500, the last 15 years. Okay, let's hear it. October 5th, 2011 to October 5th, 2026. The SP 500 is up. Do you want to guess, actually? How much okay?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I'm gonna say uh 362 percent.

SPEAKER_01Okay, and Apple?

SPEAKER_03Oh boy, 600 612.

SPEAKER_01I'm making that numbers. Okay, twice that. So twice that. The SP 500, which is interesting, like even I would have given you an answer like 300, 400, maybe 500. The SP 500 is up 775. Oh my goodness. This is including different ends and all that. 775 over the last 15 years. That's incredible, isn't it? And we've had how many bear markets? At least two and when one almost bear market in 2018, right? And maybe even in 2025. Apple, now get this.

SPEAKER_01Apple is up not 2x that, not 3x that, it's up 2,848 percent.

SPEAKER_03After he passed away.

SPEAKER_01Wow, after he bent 2848 percent.

SPEAKER_03Hmm.

SPEAKER_01That's incredible. Not a recommendation to buy Apple, by the way.

SPEAKER_03Well, that is amazing. I guess it makes sense because 2011 we had the US debt downgrade in August, the Martin crash, we bounced a little bit, and we had the major lows in October 2011. So, yeah, with the SP of over 7,000 now, it was uh it was a long time ago. It was a long time ago. Um, so good stuff there, good stuff. Um, so Sonu, you know, where do we want to start? We want to talk about breath first, or you want to start this? Uh let's start with breath. I want to talk about sentiment as well. Yeah, so I mean, we've heard, we've talked on this very podcast, market breadth has been deteriorating, but everybody's talking about it, everybody knows it.

SPEAKER_03And I think my take is this, and we talked about this two weeks ago, I believe, when we said tech or bust, you know, technology like the XLK that hit an all-time high, finally back above the June peak. Um, equal weight technology also, Sonu, is at an all-time high. We've talked before about how software will go up and semiconductors down, and kind of vice versa. Well, both were up pretty good um the month of September. So we're seeing broadening out with tech. And I think it, you know, to quote what we said before, tech or bust.

SPEAKER_03And we're not minimizing the weak market breadth, but when you have technology, which makes up what is it, Sony, 40% of the SP 400? 40. That's just technology by itself. Communication is is another 10% there about so half the darn thing is technology and tech adjacent stuff, and that's all doing pretty well. So, yeah, I mean, you know, maybe one more from me, I'll turn it over to you. Um, if you look at the number of stocks above the 50-day moving average on the SP 500, just last week it was down to 20%.

SPEAKER_03That's really low. Now, you argue that's actually oversold in a lot of ways. We were ballparked 20% late March, where the market bottomed. And if you look at the number of stocks above their 20-day moving average, that's actually been going up for the last three weeks. Yeah, it's really low, but there are some signs that there are some potential positives under the surface there. Um, so our take, we're still bullish. You know that if you listen to this podcast, I mean we're aware of the weakening breath, but if tech goes up, you know what? I guess it's be overweight tech like we are, and we can live with it. What do you want to add here?

SPEAKER_01Look, tech over the last tech had a big run March through end of March through April and May into early June. Since then, it's been about flat. And you kind of look at the SP 500, same story. And it's I think in it it's a macroeconomic story too. It's tech or bust. I mean, as goes tech, so goes the economy, so goes the broad market. Because in the case of the market, even more so because it's so concentrated, as you mentioned, but close to 50% tech adjacent.

SPEAKER_01Here are some numbers, right? So for September, the SP 500 is almost flat. It was down 30 basis points. So that's literally noise, right? So it was about flat. 10 out of 11 sectors were in the red. 10 out of 11 sectors in the red. 10 out of 11 sectors are in the red. Uh what's it? Nine out of no eight out of eleven sectors were worse than three percent in September. Five out of eleven, almost half, were worse than five percent.

SPEAKER_01And these weren't small sectors. You think okay, utilities and real estate, yeah, rates are going up, they will get it. But consumer discretionary down six and a half percent, financials down seven percent, yeah, materials down seven percent. So, yeah, these aren't just the small sectors, industrials are down almost four and a half percent. You can talk about industrials, it's it's weird. Um, I'm kind of surprised why industrials is dragging so much. I think it's more probably more of an idiosyncratic stock by stock story rather than anything broad with respect to industrials.

SPEAKER_01But guess what? Tech was positive five percent, slightly better than that, and that dragged the index up. And if everything else, you know, so all this to say if you just look under the hood, it looks horrible. Yeah, but the index was flat because tech held it out, and now tech breaks out. You had a nice chart, and we can share this showing, like you know, that XLK chart, the technology sector ETF chart, sort of going flat for the last several months from June through September.

SPEAKER_01September it started to break out. If that takes off now, which I think it could, I mean, our prediction, but we are in the speculation game here. Uh, we kind of have to be when you're managing portfolios, and we think Q4 will be positive. Uh, you can share the numbers from the you know election perspective as well, but Q4 is generally positive from a seasonality perspective. Q4 of a presidential election, you know, a midterm election in a year is also positive.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, I think once earnings start, once the companies tell us, oh, we're gonna spend even more money, I think this takes off.

SPEAKER_03No, we're in that camp. You know, the XLK, um just on a calendar basis, because the market bottomed on what March 30th, so technically we're playing, but just on a calendar basis, the months of April and May, the XLK, the large technology ETF, was up 44% in two months, Sonu, up 44%. And we talked about this then. That was a stretched rubber band, but history tells us those stretched rubber bands, once they catch their breath, tend to continue to resolve higher. And since then, we've virtually gone sideways on the XLK.

SPEAKER_03And I know we had the big um momentum massacre, I guess we'll call it in July, and the large hedge fund went under, and a lot of worries and a lot of the high flyers were just decimated. Yet again, then you look and the market's just kind of just chopped around since I think it's really constructive because it's caught its breath. Uh oh, that's funny. Caught its breath, bread with a D and breath without a D. Anyway, um, but but the reality is now that that's taking back that baton, and that just is a positive. And like you said, we'll get more into this stuff because earnings season's right around the corner. Well, Micron, Micron on earnings last week, and I don't have all the exact details, but pretty strong, right?

SPEAKER_03Stock reacted positively. They said demand is just insatiable, and we've got a lot more big tech names coming. Uh SB500 earnings expect to be up close to 30% quarter over or year over year. I'm sorry, um, coming up in a third quarter, we'll see. But I think we're expecting again probably strength and to beat, and a big chunk of that will come from uh technology.

SPEAKER_01Uh, so what else do we what else do I mean to that same point, like micron? I mean, now earnings are coming, but from a macro perspective, I think the story matches South Korean exports. You look at like they export more than they import, that's been going gangbusters, they've historically exported more than they imported. So they've always had a trade surplus, and that trade surplus a year ago was about$100 billion. This year, over the last quarter, if you annualize the pace of exports over the last quarter, boy, it's five times that it's five times that we know what the story is, we know it's chips, right?

SPEAKER_01So, you know, so all of this is happening at the micro level of the companies, we'll see that the earnings and things like that. But even at a macro level, you see that with the exports for countries like Taiwan and South Korea. So I'm looking forward to those two data points as well as the month progresses. And you know, if I think the story will continue because what ends this, think about this. Like, are these companies going to stop spending? No, I don't think so. I will be shocked if they come out after during earnings season and say, Oh, you know what, we're taking a step back.

SPEAKER_03That's yeah, that's probably not that's not in the cars, I don't think, either. I mean, one of the crazier stats that I've heard all year, and we share a lot of them, you know, um, Samsung, which has been a company that's been around decades and decades and decades, the most recent earnings they had last quarter, which were just gangbusters, they said they made more in the previous year than they made like in their previous 49 years of existence or something like that, which was not a shock, but again, it is kind of surprising when you hear it, just puts in perspective, I guess, when with the number you just said, um, with all of the exports coming out of South Korea.

SPEAKER_01Um I just think everything, everyone's been like the uh title of the episode says, you know, like breath is overrated. I think everyone's been breath-pilled and a corollary, or maybe it's coming from the fact that everything everyone's been yield-pilled. Oh, the yields are going up, ten year yields is going up, it's at 525, 530. That's terrible. Last time it happened, everything crashed. So maybe things should crash now too. But I think that's more of a, you know, we've talked about this before. It's a stagflationary perspective, right?

SPEAKER_01Oh, the inflation's hot, and it also. We'll talk about that. But the unemployment rate is also going up, and that should, you know, people are spending less. That puts pressure on profits and revenues and things like that. That's not to be clear where we are now. It's inflationary growth, yeah, right, which could be bad for bonds and good for stocks all at the same time.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, those concepts we mentioned all year. I mean, all year we've been talking about inflationary growth environments. It wasn't always popular, um, saying yields might be a little higher. And you and I mentioned this before, and you were on it. You know, start of this year, it wasn't like when's the Fed gonna cut, it's how many times will the Fed cut. Even in April, there wasn't there was, you know, the market was expecting a zero percent chance of a hike. Well, we just got a hike, you know. So anyway, so we we talked a lot about that. Um, I will say, so let's do some quarterly stuff because this is interesting. I know last week uh we talked about October historically pretty strong, which is true, but just from a quarter basis, or from the quarter view, Sony, the fourth quarter is up more than 80% of the time, 4.2% on average, which is like again, 4.2% on average doesn't sound like a lot, then you realize that's like double any other quarter.

SPEAKER_03So that's pretty good. Um, you know, you look at like a longer point of view from a four-year presidential cycle, the fourth quarter of a midterm year, and the next two quarters are like the three best quarters out of 16.

SPEAKER_01But the one 4.2 is over the entire quarter. Over the annualize that, that will be something like a 17% return or something like that. Which is well above average. That would be pretty darn good.

SPEAKER_03Um, and then I'm gonna put one more on the YouTube channel right now. Um, and I say YouTube channel, but we are on Spotify now as well. So I maybe just say the video channel. So thank you. We've got a lot of compliments on Spotify, it is really slick to watch on Spotify as well. So uh definitely check that out. But when you have a down first quarter, like we did, and I didn't realize this until just last night when I put these data together, the first quarter of this year SP down 4.6%. The first quarter of last year down 4.6 percent. When I see something like that, we're I was well, I better double check that.

SPEAKER_03It's true, it's true. Um, so anyway, so a negative first quarter, then a huge second quarter gained almost 15% on the SP. Again, you can see on the channel right now. Um, so anytime you're negative first quarter, then up more than 10% second quarter sounding, the third quarter has never been lower. It's like nine for nine. It's not a huge sample size, but I wouldn't ignore it. And we just had a positive third quarter up two percent. But the fourth quarter does even better. Once again, never negative in the fourth quarter when you have a 10% second quarter and a negative first quarter with like a six percent average return in the fourth quarter.

SPEAKER_03So better than your average fourth quarter is where we are. So there's a lot there, I just said, but I think you know, the fourth quarter, we're still optimistic the tech might take back the baton, pulling along the whole market with this. What do you want to add there, Sonia?

SPEAKER_01No, that's a you have the seasonality tailwind. You could argue there's like a slingshot momentum sort of tailwind as well. Tech seems to be breaking out, and arguably when we get the data from you know, post earnings as to where CapEx spending is, instead of 1.1 trillion in 2000 2027, it's probably going to be 1.2 or 1.3 trillion. And in so that those numbers keep going up. So all of these are tailwinds, and remember, one person spending is another company's source of profit, right?

SPEAKER_01And that's why we talk so much about capex. Right? It's not just uh oh, they're spending capex, but so what? No, this matters to the market. And do I think yields will go up as much as they did over the last quarter? No, I don't think I I don't think they're going to, you know, they could they continue rising? Yeah, maybe they could get to five and a half percent. The ten year yield it's today, it's around 5.3 percent. Could get to five and a half percent. I would argue, yeah, I could see us envision a scenario where it's six percent too, especially if nominal GDP growth continues to clock in around seven, eight percent.

SPEAKER_01But you know, I don't think the speed at which we saw rates increase is going to be replicated. And you know, and that gets to the part about like people say, wait, you're saying the SP 500 is okay, breath doesn't matter, but what about yields? I'm like, yeah, yields have had an an impact, a negative impact to valuations, which is where you would expect the hit to come from. S P 500 valuation, what 21x, 22x is starting to year? It's like 19x today.

SPEAKER_01That's of course, because forward this is forward PE. And it's because forward earnings have been rising, but still the PE ratio, forward-looking P ratio has come down, which is what you would expect if yields are rising. But the thing is, profit growth has completely overcome that and then some, which is why the SP 500 is up 14% year to date. But at the same time, rate-sensitive areas are paying the price for this. You look at small caps, down five percent over five percent in September. Real estate struggling, utility struggling, curve flattening is hitting financials as well.

SPEAKER_01So, all of this, it's not like there's no impact. There certainly is an impact. It's just that the other side, this profit growth story, because of this massive AI capex boom is completely overcoming that.

SPEAKER_03Wow. Well, a lot there. I mean, a lot, a lot there. I mean, you know, these are again concepts we talked about for a while, and then there are negatives. I mean, you know, one thing that that has my attention, uh, we are finally really last week. We're out in Denver all week with our amazing partners and um advisors here at Carson Group, and high yield spreads have started to uh kind of widen out a little bit. So that kind of has my attention. We talked about triple C, which is kind of the junkiest of the junk, if you will. That's been stressed. So is that the first domino? Maybe, you know, I don't I don't know. We're starting to see a little more stress there. The US dollar is breaking out.

SPEAKER_03The Dixie was below 100, now it's breaking out. The euro's in trouble. Europe's kind of they've got some issues over in Europe with all the debt they have. They've got soaring yield in Spain and Italy, different things taking place. You know, I did see also some of just this morning, the election, I guess our morning, but their evening, whatever, either way. Um, with Brazil, right? The Brazilian stock market's absolutely soaring on news of kind of the existing president losing to the young up-and-comer, who apparently the the guy who won, his father is in a 27-year house arrest. He was the previous president. So listen.

SPEAKER_03Listen, there's a lot running. There's a lot there. I just I'm a markets guy. The market loved these this reaction because the um the Brazilian ETF won't even say what it is, no recommendation, but it's up like 13 or 14 percent the time we're doing a half percent. And Latin America in general is is soaring. So there's some emerging markets there. I've an old saying, news Trump's charts. Well, apparently the market was surprised by this because the market's reacting uh accordingly with a with a you know a move higher. And oh, my old friend Jeff saw it, he used to say surprises in bull markets happen to the upside.

SPEAKER_03We can bang our head, why is this happening? Well, you know what? Surprises happen to the upside. It's a global bull market. Now Brazil's taken uh taken some of it along with Latin America. Um, I don't know. I jumped around. You know, let me ask you that, Sonu. We're going all over the place, but that's okay. I mean, there's a lot of worry about the higher yields we're seeing in France. There's a lot of issues. Their debt to GDPs, well over 100%, spin, spin, spin. People are worried that maybe there's another 2010 to 2012 debt crisis like we had starting in Greece with the All the big concerns about Europe. How concerned are you? Because honestly, we are overweight um a little bit on development.

SPEAKER_03We like Europe. And now I don't know. The news isn't great. What are you thinking out of Europe here?

SPEAKER_01I think I'm not worried about short answers. I'm not worried too much. Now, what's happening in France is interesting because yields are going up more than you know other parts of Europe. Like anywhere else in the world. It's going up a lot. You know, all of them have an inflation problem, all of them have a diesel problem and things like that. So why just France, right? So here's where I'm going to say something, I think, controversial. It seems very, you know, hubristic to say this. Uh, you've probably heard about the Milton Friedman code, like inflation is always uh almost always a monetary phenomenon, something to that effect.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I actually think inflation's almost always a political phenomenon. And I think what's happening, and and of course, bond yields reflect inflation volatility, or rising bond yields reflect higher, you know, inflation volatility, things like that, right? And I think you know, the politics in France is a little screwed right now. And you had an election recently where, you know, the far left, the far right are sort of trading each other for whose, you know, they're they could very well win the election next year.

SPEAKER_01And even in the US, right? You think about all the policies. And yes, it's been a function of policies that we have, you know, elevated inflation this year. And now I would argue inflation is already elevated, and the AI capex boom is not really a policy-driven thing, but tariffs, for example, pushed inflation higher. And you can argue that will go away, fine, but so far it hasn't. And tariffs have pushed the price of steel and aluminum and things like that higher, right? You look at the PMI reports and all of these respondents to the PMI surveys, manufacturing PMI surveys are like, yeah, steel and aluminum prices are higher because of tariffs.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so that's a policy thing. And then the war, now you know whether you're for the war or against the war, set that aside. But the war has increased prices, to be clear, right? You have gasoline prices, diesel prices, things like that, right? And diesel prices, yes, it's some of it is not a US policy story. It's also Russia, Russian refineries getting hit by Ukraine. Right. So it's not just US policy, but inflation is overall, respectful of whose policy, I think it is also a political phenomenon.

SPEAKER_01It's a lot of it is policy driven. I would argue even 2021 inflation. We had a lot of inflation. That was after the American Recovery Act, right? Like with uh President Biden you know issuing a ton of more stimulus checks, right? Was that necessary? I think at the time, and maybe even did the benefit of hindsight, no. I mean, none. I nobody complained, but you got more inflation again. It was a policy thing, right? And the Fed choosing not to do much about it, at least in real time, or waiting to do something about it, you could argue that's also a policy choice.

SPEAKER_01So that's why I think of inflation as always being a policy, a political phenomenon rather than oh, it's just the money supply.

SPEAKER_03Well, that's a great point. I mean, we learned the hard way that there's no such thing as a free lunch, right? And again, there are a lot of policy giving people a lot of money. Um, you know, and and then here you go. This is the other side of it. And we just had consumer confidence. The conference board's consumer confidence came at the lowest level since 2014. We've talked before about the Michigan consumer confidence, which is probably a little more skewed by politics and some potential issues, but that's the conference board saying people aren't feeling very good out there. But then again, in the next breath, I mean, you and I were just at um, oh, the Gaylord, uh, the Gaylord um huge hotel convention center out in Denver with our uh Carson was out there.

SPEAKER_03Like I got out there on Tuesday. I wanted to try to get a room on Tuesday because the event started on Wednesday. I had something else. Long story short, this place is huge. These rooms were not cheap. You couldn't get a room, like you couldn't get a room, it was totally sold out. Like you couldn't get a room. And I'm like looking around, like, look at this place. This is crazy how much money people spend here. And you couldn't get a room on a Tuesday, okay? Like that's every hotel, every airplane. I mean, I flew home. They're begging people. I'm tempted, ooh, do I want to come home like they're begging people. If we need like six people to get off this plane, I'm gonna give you a ton of money.

SPEAKER_03Every plane is booked, every restaurant is full, yet consumer confidence is 2014. I know it sounds like a broken record because you and I have been talking about this, everybody's been talking about it. It's like the soft data says one thing, the hard data says another. Um, you know, how many people are gonna take trips to Europe this summer? I'm hearing all types of people doing this. It's like then you complain about paying, you know, 120 bucks for gas, but you're gonna go to Europe for a month in the summer. I I don't get it. You know, I mean, it's it's what it is, it's where we are. But our job as a steward of assets is look at the aggregate. The aggregate says this economy is still pretty solid out there and this bull market's still alive.

SPEAKER_03Well, one more for me, I'm going all over the place. But the fourth quarter, Sonu, it is what it is. Again, we'll put this on YouTube and uh the video series right now. Um, the fourth quarter has been higher, 12 of the last 13 years. Now, now listen, last year went up a ton the year before, but 12 of the last 13 years, the fourth quarter has been higher. You know, so you start stacking all this on top of it. We're not that far from an all-time high. Who knows? My team people listen to this, might be all-time high on the SP. Um, I think they're still gonna have a positive fourth quarter. If your average fourth quarter is 4.2%, gun to my head right now, I think we're having an above-average fourth quarter being led by technology.

SPEAKER_03It's kind of how I see uh things there. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think so. I wanted to ask you about before we jump into you know the inflation data and some payrolls data. Uh, you shared a few charts uh showing uh this morning on our you know advisor call, yep, showing that there aren't a lot of bulls. And the fear and greed index, it's you know, it's at the fear level. But why I wanted to ask you is I was listening to our friends at Renmac talk about uh a whole bunch of stuff, and then Jeff after Graph brought up the fact now this is interesting, I thought I'd never heard it described this way or never seen somebody do it this way, which is look at sentiment, but look at where sentiment should be or where it is relative to where it ought to be given what the market has just done.

SPEAKER_01And he said, like, from the I think this the investor sentiment, which he said is has existed since the 1960s.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's the newsletter, the newsletter um writers.

SPEAKER_01Okay, so you're saying that's since the 1960s or something, and what he said is you may have heard this too, is like the bears are the spread between bulls and bears is about 40 points. So let's say the bulls are at 60, the bears at 20, why it's all okay, whatever that is, it is right. But he said, given the fact that the market over the last you know three months or so has done just about two percent, something like that, right? That spread should be a lot lower. Whereas it's about 40% with 40 percentage points that spread, the bull bear spread, he says our return should be much higher.

SPEAKER_01So you could argue that you know the market hasn't met the sentiment moment, or you could argue that you know, as Jeff was doing, that sentiment is reflect sentiment is too optimistic given what the market just did. Curious what you make of that.

SPEAKER_03Well, again, there's different ways of slice and dice sentiment. I mean, shout out to our friend Tom Cork. I know listen, he listens to all these. He sent we we had a note going back and forth, and you know, he he shared um an email from a client. And I was, you know, just point out the fact the client heard that the Wall Street Journal and article that stocks are the most overvalued they've ever been. And this is wrong, this is wrong, this is wrong. Like then that's what I hear, you know, and when I'm the more anecdotal guy, right? Like when we go around the country and present to advisors and clients, I'm not hearing much excitement out there. I'm hearing worry after worry, concern after concern.

SPEAKER_03And Tom said, This is this is a pretty smart client. Hey this client wants to like get out of the market, like right now, like wants to get out with the SP half a percent from all-time high. Like that's stuff that I'm hearing about all the time. Um, and it is what it is, you know. Uh the the the um CNN fear and greed index, maybe there's issues with it. I in fact I would agree there are, but you know, it's like he says in fear, it's like a tick away from extreme fear, you know, that you shed this.

SPEAKER_01This is it was at 31. Yeah, and I think if it goes below 25 or something, it's at extreme fear.

SPEAKER_03And that's yeah, well, there's always other ways to look at this, but you know, I I there just doesn't seem like much excitement. And then even if you look at like JP Morgan, they had some data, and I don't know if we're allowed to publicly share this or not. I probably can say it though, but like you know, they they got some data from what their clients are doing, JP Morgan clients, and and they they're not buying, they're not, they're selling, they're selling like net sellers, I mean, like of ETFs and and um actual uh equity. So there's there's there's pockets of optimism, yes, but I just still think there's more negativity out there, which should probably be a net positive when this um when this resolves higher.

SPEAKER_03I mean, it's just hard to think that you're gonna have a major peak in a stock market without much excitement. There just isn't much excitement. I mean, I I don't know. Maybe there is. Let me know in the YouTube comments. We like our YouTube comments, right? Positive, negative, whatever. We like YouTube comments, but it doesn't feel to me like there's a lot of excitement out there, maybe almost apathy at this point. Because honestly, the SP hadn't gone anywhere. SP 100 hadn't gone anywhere. I mean, since June, it really hadn't. It's consolidated, but I kind of like that. I like that consolidation. I think that that tightening, you know, I mean, we we barely even have like so no, we haven't had a 1% drop for like over two months.

SPEAKER_03I mean, on SP, like like August and September, because we come in the August after the massacre, the momentum massacre. Everybody told us how bad it's gonna be, and then everyone told us how bad September is gonna be. And we you just laid out, well, yes, tech saved the day, but you know what? Something always saves the day in a bull market, you know. So, I mean, if we haven't had a one percent drop during these volatile months, we'll have a one percent drop one of these days. This is how this stuff works. But those are just still things that I think are amazing. And we'll just imagine if we have a one and a half percent drop for whatever reason, how worried everybody's gonna get. I mean, it might be the next Fed day. Who knows? Every time you know Warsh talks, the market sells off, so then it comes back the next day.

SPEAKER_03So anyway, you want to let's let's um want to dive into it. I agree.

SPEAKER_01I I think everything everyone's like I think I said this before, everyone's been breath-filled and yield-filled. Yeah, everyone's looking at that. That's all I see. I mean, you know, granted, uh, this is also anecdotal. All I see is oh my god, there's no breath. Oh my god, look at the 10-year yield. Yeah, stocks should be much lower than they are.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and then oh my goodness, look at the SP 500, pretty much at an all-time high. NASDAQ is on an all-time high. It's like no one's talking about that, but that's fine. Let them ignore it. You know, uh, again, um, that's fine with us. You know, you listen to this podcast and you use the Carson Investment Research team with uh you have a great Carson advisor helping you, then you've been positioned, you're benefiting from this, and hopefully going to benefit from a pretty good fourth quarter as well. Uh, so we had some inflation data on the week, Sonu, the PCE, the Fed's favorite measure of inflation, so they tell us. I guess it came in a little bit light.

SPEAKER_03Markets seem to like it. Odds of a hike uh decrease pretty big on the week. We'll get into that. But you still peel back that onion, you still have some inflation concerns, though, right? Oh, yeah, plenty, you know.

SPEAKER_01And I we'll get to the PMIs too, which is more, I would take, you know, maybe real time speaking of anecdotes and things like that. But yeah, PC inflation, big picture remains hot. And this is an important release. So this is PC inflation, I should say, for August. And we already had kind of a sense of where it would come because CPI and PPI came out, and that goes into PCE. But still, this was an important release because they made a whole bunch of the BEA, the Bureau of Economic Analysis, uh, they made a whole bunch of revisions with their methodology.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Remember, we've talked about portfolio management services. That's being reliant, you know, if the stock market goes up, portfolio inflation for portfolio management services looks hot. But that's because the stock market's up. And so they changed that. They've changed that to a more employment-based approach. They've also revised, or they did revise, how legal services are calculated, the price indices for legal services, and for computer software and accessories, which normally would nobody care about, except now, you know, that captures AI-related bottlenecks and inflation related to all of that.

SPEAKER_01Anyway, they made all these changes retroactive to 2021, and that ended up revising inflation pretty meaningfully lower. So you look back to July. July headline was 3.7% PCE inflation. That was revised down to 3.4%. July core PCE was revised down from 3.3% to 3%. Now I should say there's no real conspiracy, anything. They were planning to do this. It's just the timing doesn't look great when inflation's elevated.

SPEAKER_03Oh, now let's change the matter in front of an election. I mean, come on, it doesn't look great. So it's beyond doesn't look great. I mean, let's change it all. Hey, look at that. I don't know. I was giving the benefit of the doubt. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01But look, inflation's hot no matter how you slice and dice the data. And that's what I did. I literally look at all sorts of different cuts. And by the way, this is August, so it definitely doesn't reflect that big surge in gasoline and diesel prices that we saw in September. That's next month. But for now, headline PCE, 0.3% month over month. You know, what does that mean on an annualized pace? 3.8%. Like I said, that's before the diesel and gasoline price surge in September. 3.4% year over year.

SPEAKER_01Core PCE month over month in August is up 0.25%. Translate that. That is 3% annualized. The Fed's target is 2%. So we're clearly over that. It's core PC is running 3% year over year. Six months annualized pace also 2.7%. And this is where you know everyone's like, look, you'll see a lot of commentators on the internets saying or X, hey, look, you know, inflation's falling. Inflation's off. A lot of them are focusing on CPI.

SPEAKER_01But let's be clear: the Fed doesn't follow CPI. They use C PCE. They've used PCE since 2000 because it's broader, it accounts for substitution effects. Like if chicken's expensive, I move to beef. If beef is expensive, I move to pork. It accounts for all of that. CPI doesn't.

SPEAKER_03Listen, I don't know how expensive I don't know how expensive it has to be, though, for you and I to become vegetarians. You know, that's that's the big question. If you and I become vegetarians, and by the way, totally sidetracked you, Sonny. Just remember what you no, no, it's fine. We we we had a great week in Denver, just amazing time with our Carson advisors, and the whole community was a blast. Um, if you're interested in finding a new home, a place that you can grow and have a lot of fun. I say there's two things we do with Carson, help you grow faster than industry average. We got all the stats on that and get that to you, and you get to have fun. Those two things. That's what we do. That's my elevator pitch anymore after being our four and a half years. But the other was we Tona and I were tired, we were exhausted, a lot of talking, a lot of fun.

SPEAKER_03We go to the Denver Airport for a nice lunch. We went to that Elways right there, Terminal B, right at the bottom of Terminal B. Oh my goodness. I mean, it was it was a wonderful lunch. Wasn't it Sona? It just was oh, I so tired.

SPEAKER_01I mean, there was some corn, there was some potatoes.

SPEAKER_03We had corn, we had sweet corn with like all types of stuff as the least healthy corn in the history of mankind. But no, we had a nice, nice, nice lunch.

SPEAKER_01But that counts as my daughter would say fries count as vegetables.

SPEAKER_03So there you go. There you go. But no, anyway, I don't I don't know what it would take for me to become a uh vegetarian on the prices of this stuff, especially if you know I don't I don't think the price of vegetables are going down a lot either.

SPEAKER_01Those are rising too. That's true. It's not cheap to make a salad anymore. Mm-hmm. And you're not a fan of salad, we know that. So yeah. The big picture is it remained stubbornly high, despite all the revisions and methodology changes, and they were significant. Right. And so here's another cut of data that I took. I did I look at something called market-based core inflation, excluding housing, set aside housing. And basically, what market-based means it strips out all the components whose prices aren't directly observed.

SPEAKER_01So then you think about inflation price indices, consumer price index, PCE, it's like, okay, how much are consumers paying businesses when they go shopping? How much are they paying? Now, PCE is a broader index than CPI, but there are several components where the prices sort of imputed, like portfolio management services used to be. Or there are other prices where the prices are imputed from like wage growth and things like that. Take all that out. Just focus on prices directly observable, what we call market-based prices, right?

SPEAKER_01How much a consumer is actually paying businesses from our observations, even that's running hard, right? This cleaner read of inflation is running up at 3% year over year inflation. It's at 2.6% six month annual wise. That doesn't sound like a lot, but here's some historical perspective. 1995 to 1999, it was running at 1%. 2003 to 2007, it was 1.7%. 2017 to 2019, it was one percent. 2010 to 2019, it was one percent.

SPEAKER_01We are running over twice, two to two and a half to three times the pace we saw historically for this stuff. We are nowhere close to normal, right? You look at then core services inflation, right? Core services excluding housing. So this excludes energy, it excludes food, it excludes housing, it excludes goods, tariffed goods, AI bottlenecks, take all that out. In August, Ryan, it rose 4.4% annualized. Over the last 12 months, it's running at 3.5%.

SPEAKER_01Again, historically, 1995 to 99 is 2.5%. 2017, 2019 was 2.2%. 2003, 2007, it was running at 3.5%, 3.4% average you know, pace of inflation for core service housing. But the thing is, in the 2000s, we had goods prices go down. Right now, goods prices are rising again because of AI-related bottleneck tariffs and all of that. So we don't have that offset despite hot services inflation.

SPEAKER_01It'd be one thing if you had hot services inflation, but goods prices are going down. We don't have that, so we have an inflation problem right now.

SPEAKER_03Well, you know, time we're doing this. I just looked, uh, NASDAQ's literally trading at the highest level it's ever traded out in history. Boom. Second windows. I mean, the set and then and the SP is not that far away. I'll tell you, heads are going to explode, Sonic, when we hit new high SP is like not that far. Like when that happens, I mean, people are going to lose their minds. Like, how in the world can this happen? Because they told me on TV how bad it is, because they told me how bad breath is gonna be. Um, yeah, our friend Scott Brown, I mean, he mentioned this on uh well, maybe two or three weeks ago. We did the um what's it called?

SPEAKER_03So just one blank. It's why it's a two-man show. The the social hour, social hour, social hour. I'd say it's Monday, but it doesn't feel like Monday. I mean, it was a long week of travel and a lot of getting caught up. But Scott pointed out, and I think rightfully so, I loved how he pointed this out. You look at major history where the market peaks, market breadth peaks well before the ultimate peak in the market. So you see stocks keep going up, but there are less stocks participating. But it can last a while, it can last a year or two. I mean, that's just the way history works. And Scott noted, I think rightfully so, back in like August when we hit like the last high, um, the market and breath peaked at the same time.

SPEAKER_03And he's you know, that's that's not usually how the market, the ultimate bull market peaks at the same time as breath. Um, so just anyway, so something to think about. Now again, we're flirting with all-time highs and breaking out on tech and some of the right leadership. You know, one more thing, and I'm going all over the place, but I like to look at like um high momentum or high beta, sorry, high beta relative to low volatility on a ratio basis. Sono on a weekly basis, last Friday closed at the highest level ever. Staples, utilities relative to the SP 500, closed at some of the lowest levels ever.

SPEAKER_03I mean, there are issues out there, yes, but that's the message of the market. To me, when you layer, if you would have told me breath would be weakened like it is, but low vol would be outperforming high beta, staples would be outperforming the SP 500, utilities outperforming. That would be like, okay. Then I'd be a little more be more concerned, but I still think the message of the market is you want to be risk on in this fourth quarter, you know, ride the wave, use all of our lingos we use, tech or bust, i mean, stuff we've been saying non-stop. That's kind of where we are. All right. So I jumped in. I don't know. What do you want to keep saying?

SPEAKER_01The the reality is activity is strong. You look at the PMIs this morning. We got so this is Monday, uh, October 5th. We got the services PMI index, it's at 54.9. Now the headline is oh, services PMI pulled back. And I was like, oh my god, like let me look at the number 54.9. That's pretty solid. Anything about 50 is great, right? And the ISM manufacturing PMI was at 54.5. That was last week, but that was last week. But then you look under the hood, you don't have to look too far under the hood.

SPEAKER_01Look at the prices index for services, it's at 72.6. That's higher than you know, several since the highest since 2022. You look at the ISM manufacturing prices index, that's at 77.9. Everything's smoking hot. Activity is hot, prices are smoking hot. Not a single commodity that these surveys track, especially the manufacturing survey, things like aluminum, copper, copper products, diesel, obviously, we know what's going on. But even electrical competence, electronic competence, BRAP, memory competence, steel, aluminum, every single thing up in price.

SPEAKER_01Not a single one down in price, every single thing, short supply, not a single one is, you know, like is available immediately. Copper is a big story there, right? For the data center, you know, construction thing, EVs, all of that. You need more copper. Copper's prices are near an all-time record. So I don't know where this whole thing about, oh, inflation's going to go down. Well, if it goes down, I would worry that that's basically a bearish take on the economy.

SPEAKER_03Right. Well, like I said, the Fed starts cutting a bunch, and you should be worried. So I just got an alert a little bit ago. We mentioned a couple weeks ago, uh, bought my daughter the new iPhone, I guess 18 Max or Pro Max. I don't even, whatever it was, whatever it was. I just got the alert it's gonna be delivered today. So this was like two weeks. It took like two weeks for that. I get it.

SPEAKER_00Flip foldable.

SPEAKER_03She didn't do she didn't want the foldable. She she made it sound like only old people get that, which is why I have one. Apparently, I've got I have a foldable phone. To her point, I am thinking of it. So I don't know. I am I love mine. I mean, so yesterday, you know, my son had basketball games all day, which I love. I love watching my son, but also I'm a Bengals fan, which is just so aggravating. So aggravating. Anyway, but like I'm sitting there and I did my fold out and I have you know direct TV streams. I'm watching the Bengals game, watching my son, watching Joe Burrow throw another fourth quarter interception. Just oh, so aggravating. I think I saw a clip of that.

SPEAKER_03But he always does something so dumb in the fourth quarter. It's like, what are you doing? But he's down as top four receivers and yada yada. Just be quiet, but it's so aggravating. But anyway, I'm sitting there, I have to fold out my phone and watch the Bengals game, watching my son. You know, they this team was up like 30 points. They killed him primetime. Uh congrats. They won their tournament, but it wasn't very competitive. But that's fine. But I'm sitting there watching the Bengals just get mad on my flip phone. So there you go. All right. So new, so we had inflation data. Let me let me go this route. I know it's all part of it. Um, the odds of a Fed hike this time last week was like 75% in October.

SPEAKER_03Now it's like ballpark 20%. We had the week-ish, I'm saying not lightly, but the lighter than expected uh monthly payrolls. We got a little better inflation data and some Fed members, I believe it was Williams and who. Williams and who's Jefferson. Well, yeah, I just knew it's like a regal name. Williams and Jefferson. They sound like, you know, they're kings or something. I don't know. They both are a little more dovish. Um, what's your take on that? I mean, you said before that we thought the Fed might hike one more time, maybe. I didn't ever think they're gonna hike ahead of the election. I think they might hike in December that are done. That's my take. I think you're hiking before the election, and now it's looking like maybe they won't, right?

SPEAKER_03What are you thinking?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we'll put the chart up Fed rate hike probability. This is for October. So in three weeks. And up until last week, early last week, Tuesday, the probability of a rate hike in October is about 70%. Now, I don't think I was in the same camp. I didn't think they were going to hike in October. Not because I didn't think I've not because I thought inflation is not a problem anymore. I just thought these guys are all dovish and they're willing to let things run hot. Listen to what they say. This is before the speeches, by the way.

SPEAKER_03What's all uh Marco uh Marco uh Grouch? Grouch? Marco Groucho Groucho Marks Groucho Marks. This is why this is a two-man operation. And listen, everybody, Sona and I have been talking for hours. We have to record another one of these in a little bit. So I I am tired. I've my brain is like starting to not work on a Monday already. But anyway, who are you gonna believe? Me or your own eyes? I love that quote. And it's like your own eyes are saying these guys are dovish.

SPEAKER_01Go ahead, Sony. So the probability it's 70%, and then it dropped to below 50% after that inflation data we talked about. Okay. Then on Friday morning it dropped even more because we got payrolls. Okay. And we didn't talk much about payrolls, but you know, every other. I didn't know if you yeah, you didn't bring it up yet. My bad. I jumped ahead, but yeah. You looked at headline payrolls, and oh my god, only 29,000 jobs created, and then 60,000 jobs, you know, downward revision for July and August combined, three-month average at 51,000. I would say, you know what? The economy maybe needs only 20,000, 25,000 jobs to keep up with population growth right now.

SPEAKER_01We're double that. It's not bad. If the economy needed 120,000 jobs to keep up with population growth, yeah, 51,000 three-month average would be terrible. And even 150,000 jobs would be like, oh, that's not bad, right? That's above what's needed, the break-even employment that's needed to keep up with population growth. We're, you know, okay. And this is not abnormal, right? Like payrolls are volatile because you know, the break-even's low and the confidence in 95% confidence interval is plus minus 120,000 for the payroll survey.

SPEAKER_01So we could very easily get a negative payroll month. You could get a big payroll month, like 100, 150,000 jobs. But this is where you look at the big picture, look at the unemployment rate. It fell, it rose, yes, but it went from 4.14% to 4.18%. But you look at the prime age employment population ratio, 25 to 54 year olds, that jumped from 80.4% to 80.7 percent. 80.7 percent is higher than at any point in the 2000s or 2010s expansion, right?

SPEAKER_01It's only a bit below the 80.9% peak we saw, you know, earlier in this cycle. So layoffs are low. So I think big picture of the labor market is fine, right?

SPEAKER_03Let me so before I forget this, shout out to Janet Alvarez. I join her every single Monday at 10 o'clock Eastern time on channel 132, Sirius XM. I talked about this with Janet this morning. She always gives us a really kind cut shout-out. Uh, it's for this very podcast. So I know she's a listener. So thanks, Janet. Yeah, we talked about that. The labor market's a little bit better under the surface um than most people think. Go ahead, Sonia.

SPEAKER_01The same thing happened on Friday morning. So the probability of a rate hike went all the way down to 20%.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But the 10-year yield, what was interesting, it went from 425 down to 516, 5.16%. But then it was a that was on the headline news. Then it was like everywhere opened up the hooders, like, oh, things are fine. So the 10-year yield ended the week at 527. This morning it's at 533, right? Yep. And then the you you get this, so it wasn't just the inflation data and the payrolls that dropped the probability of a rate hike down to 20%. It also came from the Fed speakers, as you mentioned, New York Fed President John Williams on last Tuesday.

SPEAKER_01He was like, Oh, there's no need for urgency after the September hike. We have time to gather more information. One further hike may be appropriate late this year, late this year, not October. So, to your point about we could see a rate hike in December, and then that's it. Right? Why does it matter? Well, Williams is the vice chair of the FOMC. Yeah, and like he's a big deal. He probably, you know, reflects sentiment, broad sentiment within the committee. Vice chair of you know, the Fed board of governors, Phil Jefferson, came out on Thursday then.

SPEAKER_01This is October 1st, and he pretty much echoed what Williams said. He said, Look, future moves should be based on carefully examining trends in the data and coming to a judgment may take more time. I don't know what needs to happen more. Yeah. So all this to say, you know, they're willing to wait and they're willing to let things run hard for now, and that's the story.

SPEAKER_03Well, that is a story. Um, a couple things I wanted to say. Now I kind of forgot them all. Um, what else do we want to talk about, Sandra? We're kind of top of the hour. I know you've got a meeting coming up. Um, we've hit on everything I wanted. Anything else you want to talk about here?

SPEAKER_01No, I think what's interesting, last thing, you know, on this. So we had the front end of the yield curve come down because the front end prices rate hikes, right? Right. And these guys are all willing to wait. Now, come next year, that may be a problem because I don't think the inflation problem's going away. If the inflation problem goes away, that means that we've gotten our call for a hard economy raw. Okay. We've gotten our call for the capex boom raw. I think that continues. But if that goes the other way, yes, then inflation will fall, yields will fall, all that. But what's happening right now is front-end yields, which basically price red Fed rate hikes, that's falling off.

SPEAKER_01But the long end is rising because things are so hot. Right. You're gonna get nominal GDP growth for Q3 in 20 days, 20, 25 days. How excited are you, by the way? Very is that like your Super Bowl? Between that and PC inflation and all that. Yeah. But that's gonna, you know, they just revised Q2 GDP growth from 8% to 8.5%. GDI was also eight and a half percent. Everything's pointing to the same story. You're gonna get similar numbers in Q3.

SPEAKER_01Yep. So yeah, I I I think I don't know how you can be. I'll wrap, I'll I'll bring this back to the market. I don't know how you can be sort of bearish right now. Right? And and focus, oh my god, yields are going up. The market has to go down. Well, I can answer that. Did you look at market breadth?

SPEAKER_03Uh we're laughing. Hopefully, hopefully we don't make fools of ourselves right now. Um, but but um, you know, what I know this because I just love Sony's reaction. Challenger Gray, I know Sony's a big fan of this one. Okay, um, I know, I know. Um, but it was the Challenger Gray looks how many layoffs are out there, and down 19.9% year over year, down 18 month over month, and year to date, um 573,000 announced layoffs. That's actually down 39 from last year, Sonu. And it was the lowest September and since 2022. So listen, this was one we heard all the time.

SPEAKER_03You mentioned um GDI, so we're not gonna get into all these weeds of this, but I mean, GDI was a huge bearish because GDI was like way down here. Yeah, right. That's what GDI stands for, Sonu. What is so it's domestic income? Income, it's the income line. Sorry. So income was way down here and GDP products way up here. Everybody said that GDP had to go down to GDI. I mean, believe me, we heard this repeatedly in 24 or in parts of 25. You said the whole time, no, no, there's some wonkiness with the way they compute it. Bottom line, GDI is going to catch up, it's going to catch up to GDP, which is exactly uh what's happened.

SPEAKER_03So that was a bearish narrative that didn't work, that no one talks about anymore. And trust me, I saved the receipts. I remember who was calling us out on social media for that one. And then Challenger Gray, I don't hear anybody mentioning, you know what? We thought Challenger Gray was the end of the world this time a year ago. Now that it's actually, I mean, I guess improving, it's all relative, right? I mean, it's like when Einstein married his cousin and asked him why. He said, Well, it's all relative. You know, I think I used that like a month or two ago. I love that joke. I'm gonna start using that more. It's all relative, right? Challenger Gray is a little bit better than it was a year ago. And again, we don't hear about it. So now the big worries are higher and higher um um weakening breath and higher yields.

SPEAKER_03But again, the second we're doing this, the Nasdaq, NASDAQ 100 hitting the highest levels it ever hit in history. Um, anyway. All right, so no last word, let's wrap this thing up. What do you want to say?

SPEAKER_01You know, I think breath is overrated. Like I said, the Nasdaq just hit a new high. Literally, I'm looking at it, it's up 70 basis points, 0.7 percent. The Russell, not so much, it's just a little better than flat. Right now is slightly in the red. And so even after today, every I can see I I know what everyone's gonna say, oh, breath is terrible. But the SP 500 is less than half a percent from an alternate high.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, it makes a lot of sense just to stay diversified, you know, don't go all cute and any one thing, and maybe be overweight, a little bit overweight tech and AI and some of this stuff, like that's what we're doing. But again, we own a lot of this stuff, and um, you know, there's gonna be like today. I mean, Brazil's up up huge today. I mean, Latin America's up huge. Now, we're not like huge Latin America bulls by any means, but again, it's a global bull market, and surprises happen to the upside. And I think that's just um some some some things to consider as we wrap up episode 208.

SPEAKER_03Um I believe so. Yeah, to episode 208 of facts versus feelings. Um what do we call it? Market breadth. I can't remember now.

SPEAKER_00You say market breadth is overrated.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, market breath is what we're that was good.

SPEAKER_00We finished for that too.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's good. That's that's where we are. Um, so give us a like, give us a follow, positive review, negative review, whatever you want. We can't lead the witness, although we do have one we prefer. But you know what? Do what you want. It's free country. Um, but we do appreciate everybody. We've hit some really big downloads. Oh, we can announce it. Why not? It's our podcast, it's our friends. I saw the I don't know if I saw the email string. We are recording with Libby, uh Libby Central over at Pimco here in a little bit. That'll be next week's uh with you know always lawyer stuff involved. But we we cleared the we cleared that. Um so we're gonna record Libby here in a little bit. But next week's Facts versus Feelings with Libby, we've had her on.

SPEAKER_03Probably need to look this up three or four times. I mean, Libby's incredible.

SPEAKER_01She's probably our most frequent yeah outside of Neil.

SPEAKER_03We've had Neil on a bunch, Neil Dutta a bunch, but but nonetheless, she's she's up there um for sure in terms of some of our favorite guests, most most common guests that we have on. It's not a coincidence as we get closer to the election, all the stuff going on. We're having Libby control over Femco going to join us uh next week. Um, assuming everything works this afternoon when we record it, but I'm pretty sure we'll have her on. Should be an amazing uh conversation. Uh, with all that, everybody, I think we're done. I think we're done. We how long did we go, Sonny? Yeah, we went almost a gun for a meeting. Yeah, I know. Yeah, I need to breathe.

SPEAKER_03This has been a crazy morning. Um, so anyway, Sony, when do you and I record? We've got an hour and 45 minute break until we record the next one. So enjoy what a day. What a day. All right, everybody. We appreciate it. Um, keep coming back, we'll keep doing these things. We'll see everybody soon. Take care. Bye-bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Is the Bank of Nvidia Closed? (FvF Ep. 214)

    Nov 18, 202645 minAudio

    In Episode 214 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, ask whether the Bank of NVIDIA is closed. With NVIDIA’s market cap falling from $5.9...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Social Hour With Mike Larson and Sonali Basak (Ep. 7)

    Nov 17, 20261 hrAudio

    The Social Hour is back, and this live stream landed on a Friday after one of the wildest weeks in recent memory. Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist at Carson Group, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are You Not Entertained? (FvF Ep. 213)

    Nov 11, 202658 minAudio

    In Episode 213 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, are joined by Carson Group’s Blake Anderson, Director of Portfolio Management, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When Will the Madness End? (FvF Ep. 212)

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    In Episode 212 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, ask the question on every investor’s mind: when will the madness end? With the Nasdaq...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Social Hour With Alvin Graylin (Ep. 6)

    Nov 3, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    The Social Hour is back, and this live stream landed on one of the wildest days of the month. Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist at Carson Group, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist at Carson Group, are joined...

    Credit the people on this episode