Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Facts vs Feelings with Ryan Detrick & Sonu Varghese

Facts vs Feelings with Ryan Detrick & Sonu Varghese artwork

Social Hour With Alvin Graylin (Ep. 6)

Nov 3, 20261 hr 2 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Social Hour is back, and this live stream landed on one of the wildest days of the month. Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist at Carson Group, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist at Carson Group, are joined by Alvin Graylin, Digital Fellow at the Stanford Institute for Human-Centered AI, Senior Fellow at the Asia Society Policy Institute, author, and a 35-year veteran of AI and semiconductors who has worked on both sides of the Pacific. Fair warning: Ryan threatened to chug his whiskey on air if the market kept sliding, Alvin showed up with a coffee and a one o’clock flight to catch, and the group went deep on poker stories about Binance founder CZ. But in between? Plenty of substance. They dig into Intel’s historic one-day drop and Alphabet’s worst day since its IPO, with Alvin warning that negative free cash flow at the hyperscalers and distressed debt at the neo clouds could be just the beginning. Alvin explains his “beer bubble” analogy for why AI is real but overfunded, and why the first to scale, not the first to invent, tends to win. They also cover the stag hunt versus the prisoner’s dilemma in US-China relations, whether chip controls are working, how AI search is cannibalizing Google’s ad business, and what healthcare and low volatility are signaling as momentum gets hammered. Plus: the stolen Bitcoin, cyber vulnerabilities, who’s liable when AI agents cause harm, and why Alvin thinks AI should be treated as a global public good. Key Takeaways: A historic drop: Intel fell roughly 31% in a single day, yet is still up about 65% year to date. Alvin sees it as more of a PC slump and years of poor management than a macro signal Cash flow warning: Every major hyperscaler now has negative free cash flow, and Alvin says debt-fueled neo clouds are the most exposed, with circular funding adding risk The beer bubble: Alvin explains that AI is a “beer bubble,” not a “soap bubble,” because real value sits underneath, but pouring too fast leaves mostly foam Scaling beats inventing: China is focused on diffusing AI across industry with cheaper open source models, while the US is spending over a trillion dollars chasing the frontier Search is under pressure: Alphabet’s AI search is cannibalizing its own ad revenue, and AI agents don’t click ads Diversification is working: A large low volatility ETF is up about 6% for the month while a major momentum ETF is down 11%, and healthcare is up roughly 10%, with tech and tech-related sectors at around 51% of the S&P 500 Accountability gap: Alvin argues that it’s unclear who is liable when AI agents cause harm in the US, while China holds companies and executives directly responsible Jump to: 0:00 - Welcome And Market Whiplash 2:05 - Alvin’s AI And Policy Background 4:57 - Intel’s Drop And What It Signals 7:54 - Hyperscaler Capex And Debt Risk 14:25 - The AI Bubble Beer Analogy 18:05 - Why Scaling Beats Inventing 22:31 - Stag Hunt And US China Tensions 27:11 - Google Search Disrupted By AI 34:04 - Chip Controls And New Competitors 40:31 - Diversifying Beyond Mega Cap Tech 47:53 - Cyber Vulnerabilities And Crypto Theft 52:43 - Accountability For AI Agents 57:00 - AI As A Global Public Good Connect with Ryan: • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryandetrick/ • X: https://x.com/RyanDetrick Connect with Sonu: • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sonu-varghese-phd/ • X: https://x.com/sonusvarghese?lang=en Connect with Jay Woods: • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/jay-woods-cmt-5972679/ • X: https://x.com/JayWoods3 Connect with Scott Brown: • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/scott-brown-cmt-22b62891/ • X: https://x.com/scottcharts Questions about the show? We’d love to hear from you! factsvsfeelings@carsongroup.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02That's the advisor services are officers. CWMLLC STC registered F advisor is reporting its information process only as intended for an audience but its professional of CWMLLC. Gas presenters over show are not affiliated with CWMLLC and expressed but he preserves not representative of CWMLLC.

SPEAKER_02I don't know who's cheering. There's not much to cheer about today.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's although Alvin, I was a little unexpected. I think that's that's the thing.

SPEAKER_02All right. Well, glad you could make it, Alvin. Sonu, Ryan here as always. Thanks to everyone who's out there listening to this live stream of the social hour. Uh we are so excited. And it's like, Alvin, we sent you a bunch of questions. And I was joking with Sony the last 24 hours, I think everything just changed. We've got we've got more we want to dive into. We have a lot to talk about. So uh yeah, we've got to be so bullish. I'm wearing my horns, but I will say, so here's my Dietrich whiskey. The way this is going, I might just chug this live on um on air the way this the way this does. I just have a diagonal.

SPEAKER_03Okay, I've got my coffee. I'm I'm ready.

SPEAKER_02Now, Alvin, I want to we want to get into it. You're I'm heading to the airport like almost as soon as this is done in about 59 minutes. You're going to the airport too. Is that correct?

SPEAKER_03I'm leaving at one o'clock to the airport, which is in an hour. So we all have a hard hour.

SPEAKER_02Sono can just talk by himself if he wants, but but Ryan and Alvin have to have to get rolling. Um, well, Alvin, we are so excited you could join us. And honestly, the timing of this is really nice because everything going on, all this uncertainty that's happening. Um, you know, we're gonna we're gonna dive into all of it. And I'm gonna ask Sonu some questions, I'll chime in. But I guess first things first, Alvin, I always like to start it with a kind of a layup. What do you do all day? Let the listeners know who don't quite know um what you're doing. We do like titles, we live in a world of compliance, whatever your official title is, just to keep the compliance officers happening.

SPEAKER_03Sure. I I've got a lot of hats actually at the same time. So I am uh professor of AI policy at Union Washington. Uh, I'm a digital fellow at the Stanford uh Human Center AI Institute and a senior fellow at the Asia Society Policy Institute. So uh and an author and speaker.

SPEAKER_00So how'd you get involved in AI? And you know, I know we've chatted before. I'd love for the listeners to hear your background because you have a long background in technology and then policy advice and not to mention writing, right?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I've been you know developing AI since the early 90s. So um about 35 years. I've I've you know we're working on uh natural language uh processing and neural networks back in the 90s, and then uh you know I was also in semiconductors. I actually designed the initial instruction set for Intel uh that was about 10 years ahead of uh NVIDIA and doing uh multimedia processing. It was called multimedia extension. And um, you know, uh Intel unfortunately didn't do much with it, and today it's actually interesting.

SPEAKER_00I was just going to say, yeah, this is not a recommendation for anyone, by the way. You know, we may mention some names and Alvin obviously works.

SPEAKER_03So I I've actually worked in all five layers of the of the uh NVIDIA or the Jensen Huang AI cake. So everything from data centers to chips to AI models to applications to devices. So I I can and I've done it in uh you know the two sides of the Pacific. So half my career has been in China, half of it has been in the US. So just to give a little background.

SPEAKER_00That's fascinating, especially that connection between China and the US. And we'll dig into you know how you think about that. I think you have a very unique perspective there. But just since you mentioned it, what was the big difference working on tech in China versus here?

SPEAKER_03Um they they work at different speeds. I think both both, you know, if you're in Silicon Valley, things move very fast. The rest of America, actually, not that as much. Uh in China, everything is fast. And it's not just the software side, it's you know, it's uh infrastructure, it's hardware, it's energy, it's robotics, it's you know, deployment. Um so uh it feels like when you're in Asia, everything's on fast forward, right? I think that that's the uh you know, I think there's a saying that uh Europe crawls, uh US walks, and China or Asia runs, right?

SPEAKER_03So in in some ways, I I feel like there is some truth in that.

SPEAKER_00Parts of Asia, I should say. I originally from India, it's like there are parts of India that crawl, like no offense to anyone here, but yeah, maybe it's uh more East Asia or in Southeast Asia a little bit. Sometimes I wish I could, you know, things in India would run faster, but you know, East Asia for sure.

SPEAKER_02Let me let me just start with this. I'm just making sure I have the correct number. Intel, not a recommendation. That stock is down 30.88 percent. That is worse 87 crash, worse than anything financial crisis.

SPEAKER_03This is like the worst day in history in 50 years, I think.

SPEAKER_02For now, you said you you you've got it some in you've got some insider, uh not inside, it's probably the wrong word to use, but you know about Intel because you've done a lot with them. Why in the world? I mean, yeah, they missed why at 31%. Do you have any thoughts on that, Alvin?

SPEAKER_03Uh, I mean, I I think the idea is that uh well they they've also gone up a couple hundred percent this year, right?

SPEAKER_05So true, sure, true.

SPEAKER_03Um, so they're they're still significantly higher than they were the beginning year before the the various uh uh governments getting involved. So in in some ways, um you know you know, and and they've actually come down almost 50% from the peak of just um maybe a couple months, a month ago, right? So uh today was it was a a uh a big drop, but I don't know if it's a um a sign of something as macro. Um clearly the the PC industry is is going through some some slumps and they are you know heavily PC centric in their revenue base.

SPEAKER_03And you know, they they've also had a number of years of of uh I think poor management and poor decision making. I you know I was there during the boom boom years when when Andy Grove was was uh the CEO. We could do nothing wrong, right? We were the number the most valuable company in the world when I was there. So it was uh it was a glorious time for that company. Um the funny thing is I think it's it's actually worth less now than it was uh in the in around 2000.

SPEAKER_00So wow, isn't that amazing? Wow, like I didn't realize that.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, so or maybe maybe around because after the after this drop, it's probably uh around the same, but it you know, for a very, very long time it was actually worth less than it was 20 years ago, which is kind of so I do wanna I'm gonna ask Sony a question here.

SPEAKER_02This is let's see how good he is. So again, the stock's down 31 today. I just looked, so I know the answer. You know how much it's up year to date, Sony? You want to take a guess? I mean, I just said up, so now you know it's up, but how much do you think it's up year to date? Down 31 today. You want to take a guess, Sony? Let's say 70. Yeah, 61. The stock's up 65 year old. I swear I didn't look this up. Down 30 today. So Alvin, that's a great point about the stretch.

SPEAKER_00Part of it was Alvin just said, you know, maybe up 100% or something. I'm like, okay, something that goes 100 and gets cut by 30, you get to 70. There you go. That's why I just get 70. No, it could have been off there. But no, going back to Alvin's point, it's like obviously these reported earnings and weak guidance, PC weakness. What was interesting is the contrast to Amazon. Amazon is actually down a lot more pre-market last night. I think it was down six percent. This today doesn't look as bad, probably everything's relative, right?

SPEAKER_03Oh, everything doesn't look as bad. We have somebody's down 30. So Amazon's down only two percent. Some bad numbers a couple of days ago as well. So right.

SPEAKER_00What was interesting is you know, over there the concerns are more like AI spending concerns. Now they're trailing 12-month cash flow has turned negative, yeah. Right.

SPEAKER_03And which gets it like this is the problem. Every single major hyperscaler right now has a a negative free cash flow, and that that was not the case for the last you know many years. And this this is the problem. And you know, we we spoke about this last week when we were having our more private chat, but you know, I I've been kind of ringing the alarm on this type of a thing happening, and I think this is really just the beginning.

SPEAKER_00So I want to ask about that. Do you think they made I mean it's easy to second guess you know the CFOs and CEOs of those companies, right? I'm not I'm not Sundar Pichai or Andy Jazzy, anyone like that. But still, do you think they made a mistake by putting all this enormous capex spending on their balance sheets rather than doing things like joint ventures, going to the banks, and maybe it's a good thing for the rest of the economy that they didn't involve the banks in this thing, otherwise, today financials may be down a lot more.

SPEAKER_03So now they're sort of, I don't want to say insulated from this from you know, they were fortunate that they actually had cash flow, free cash flow. Most of the the uh neo clouds do not, and they completely relied on debt. And this is why if you look at what happened to um Corweav last week, you know, and you look at their they're essentially distressed debt now. They're rated at distress, which you know, and when you have 50 or 60 billion dollars of debt that, you know, you have a you don't have ability to repay right now, and your interest rates are going up, you know, up a wall, uh, the company's at risk, right?

SPEAKER_03They're there, you know, I think you you probably saw the um the tweet from Elon about a week ago where he said uh all debt has dried up for these neo clouds, and you know, there's going to be uh guppy level death, I think was what his his uh his quoted term was too hard to describe what's coming. And that's that's a little scary when when there's that many companies, and these companies are all multi-billion dollar companies just a few weeks ago, you know, with enormous moats as well.

SPEAKER_03A lot of them. Well, and the problem is a lot of them were also backstoped by NVIDIA. So this is why I think we're we're just at the beginning, because the the insulary funding, circular funding issues are are going to become exposed a lot more when we you know start to have uh you know companies not be able to pay back their debt, uh, then that that backstop has to be executed. And uh all of the uh you know 70 seven 70-80% of NVIDIA's profits and revenues are coming from you know data centers, right?

SPEAKER_03So if that purchase slows down, stops delivery, doesn't get happen, doesn't get taken. Um, there's gonna be a chain of events that's gonna happen.

SPEAKER_00And Broadcom just did a big deal with anthropic similar structures, like, oh, we'll backstop a little bit, but then you buy our chips and then TPUs and things like that as well.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I think the the the time for that type of arrangement is um is coming to a close. You know, the the the the the frenzy that came, a lot of it was because in the first half of this year you had um you had anthropic showing you know like 10x growth over two quarters or something with some crazy numbers. Uh but if you notice in their S1, there is no data about Q3. We're in October, but there's no data on Q3.

SPEAKER_03Uh why? Because Q3 was essentially flat. And and that's a very bad sign when when everybody is expecting uh that 10x to continue, and if this slows down, you know, even if it doesn't stop, even if it doesn't go flat, even if it slows down, it's going you know 2x instead of 10x.

SPEAKER_00And that's that second derivative where it's coming falling, right? First quarter of 140% plus.

SPEAKER_03I remember there was a podcast in like you know, maybe June or July, people say, well, it's gonna come out 10x this year, next year they're gonna be a trillion dollars in revenue. The year after they're gonna be 10 trillion dollars, and then they're gonna own the world, right? I mean, this and people just expect that these kind of rates are going to continue forever. And we live in a real world, a physical world that has physical constraints. Um, and you know, what happened in Q2 with the the token maxing was a temporary blip. Um, I'm not saying that you know there's no demand for AI.

SPEAKER_03I think there's an amazing demand for AI. I think AI is going to do great things for businesses, for consumers, but for any technology, it takes time for it to diffuse into industry, for companies to change their workflows, for you know, uh for uh employees to be trained up on how to take advantage of what's coming and not be afraid of losing their jobs and and sometimes you know sabotaging these these projects because they're they don't want it to be successful. Right. So there's a lot of concerns out there uh in the real world that is different than a startup you know that is going starting from scratch with with you know a small number of employees and and no existing infrastructure and processes.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_00Actually, on the topic of anthropic and debt, I just saw you know the news that Blackstone had told investors that Anthropic will probably get an investment grade credit rating after IPO. Now they're saying they're going to be like double B, which is close to junk.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, right.

SPEAKER_00I mean, goes to what you were just saying, but this just came out over the last hour or so.

SPEAKER_03Anthropic has something like five or six hundred billion dollars, billion dollars of committed uh capital. I think 80% of that is non-cancelable, right? Um, you know, and their revenues for the first half was 16 billion. Um, so we'll we'll see. And and also their 16 billion is based on transfer of actual revenues of their partners who are selling it at a at a premium, uh, not the price, not the money they're getting, but the money that their customers are getting. So you gotta discount that by, I don't know, whatever their arrangements are with their distributors.

SPEAKER_03So we need to be a little bit careful in terms of how the books are actually being um reported or cooked.

SPEAKER_00So I get to go ahead, Ryan.

SPEAKER_02Uh you know, I was gonna say, I just want to circle back on something. I know twice I think you've said, you know, it's just the beginning. I want to make sure I understand for the listeners, Alvin, when you say just the beginning, are you saying like these drops is volatility? What exactly does that mean? Just to make sure everyone understands.

SPEAKER_03Um so I I I wrote a paper about two months ago called The The Reckoning, the Great Reckoning and the Reconnecting. And it essentially talks about um the current bubble that we have in the AI space. Uh and when the market realizes the you know the valuations are not consistent with the actual revenue potential near term. Again, I I'm a big believer in AI, but you know, it just like the internet was an amazing thing, but it took 10 years for it to you know come into its own weight.

SPEAKER_03And you know, the same with the railroads were great, but it was one of the biggest busts in history, you know. So um, and I also want to make sure we understand there are two types of bubbles. There's the soap bubble, uh like uh, you know, tulip uh minia or or NFTs. And when they pop, there's nothing there. But then there are the the beer bubbles, the the you know, the the railways, the the uh internet, and now AI, where uh when it pops, there is beer, there's real substance there.

SPEAKER_03Um but the problem with with beer is that I'm sure you guys have all poured beer. When you pour it quickly, it's mostly foam and a little bit of liquid. And when you pour it slowly and you tilt the cup and you let it you know go at it at the right pace, you could get you know 95% liquid. And and uh if you go too quickly, it actually flows over the cup. And that's what we're doing right now. We we are overallocating to AI uh resources uh before it's able to bring value into the economy.

SPEAKER_03And and that's that's the real problem. In fact, if you look at the the the biggest uh in terms of percentage of GDP, the biggest um bubble in history was actually uh was actually the railway bubble. It was around 65 percent uh of the of the GDP of America was this one segment. Right now, um the AI sector is around 45 percent of the total uh total stock market. Okay. Actually, I take that. 65% of the stock market was railroads back back in the the 1800s.

SPEAKER_03Okay, um, now around 45%, and that 45% is worth more than the entire GDP of America. Okay, and if you take it on a per year basis of spending, we are actually now spending more per year in terms of uh percentage of GDP than the height of the the railway bubbles. So even though the the the railway bubble is bigger, I mean percentage of of market, uh right now, in terms of how much we're we're allocating, it's uh higher than than any industry ever.

SPEAKER_00Now that's yeah, I mean we've been talking about the amazing amount of spending, right? And I mean, we this was in our outlooks. And speaking of, I've never heard anyone use that beer analogy. I have some thoughts about you know our outlook now and what you know, some images in mind, right?

SPEAKER_03It's that you have to pour it at the right speed because we have you know when you have useful things, if you pour at the right speed and it's absorbed as you're making it, you have an amazing technology that is going to uplift society. But right now, we're just making the market more fragile, we're gonna make the job market more fragile, and we're also making geopolitics much higher tension, right? All of these things are are bad for overall you know global flourishing or human flourishing.

SPEAKER_00So let's uh I'll pull on that and something you said, basically, and this refers to something you wrote. You wrote that the first to scale wins, not the first to invent. Yes. I want you to explain that within the concept. You kind of were talking about that. Are American companies spending too much on pushing the frontier, getting the latest and greatest model rather than deploying existing technology? And I want you to contrast that with what China is doing as well.

SPEAKER_03Sure. Um, I mean, if you look at every technology in history, um, the countries that get the most value from that technology is the ones that are able to deploy it in their society, right? And in fact, you know, you you look at like the steam engine, we didn't, the Americans didn't invented electricity, right? I mean, we didn't invent it, but we we deployed it. We we just put it out to market and it just made it great. And you know, look at China, you know, EVs, they didn't invent it, but they freaking deployed the heck out of it, you know, solar panels, they didn't invent it.

SPEAKER_03It was invented here, right? Right. And they now own 90% of the market for it. So whoever is able to deploy it, scale it, and then you know, create it uh at a at a pace where their economy is able to utilize it, that's where the value comes. And and if you look at the strategy for China, their their strategy is uh is diffusion. Diffusion means diffusing it to industry. And uh they in fact have this thing called the AI Plus Plan. And it says by 2027, they want 70% of their companies to be using AI actively, and by 2030, they want 90% of their companies to be uh utilizing, and that is a national target, right?

SPEAKER_03So essentially, at national level, province level, state level, all their governments trying to get people to use it. What's what's the the the the national AI action plan in America? Be the frontier, that's it. And spending here we are spending whatever it takes to get to the frontier, you know, China's spending one-tenth as much on data centers as we are. They are two percent two percent below us in terms of of all the benchmarks. So to there's they're spending less than a hundred billion dollars this year, like we're spending over a trillion dollars this year.

SPEAKER_00I'm I'm all on that, I'm curious what you're saying, because they people talk about AI and the different degrees of like let's call intelligence, right? And then sentience and things like that. It seems like the American companies are like racing to figure out we need to get to you know, human type intelligence, and that's the race, rather than to your point, you know, let's use what we have and deploy it. Right. And it's it seems from what you're saying, China's not playing that game.

SPEAKER_03Well, I mean, I I I think there's a couple of labs that want to their target is to go for AGI, but the government's saying, hey, while you're going for AGI, it's fine, but don't waste too much money and make sure whatever you make is available for everyone to use. And so this is kind of why they're also going after the open source model. Because if it's if it's cheap, it's free, everybody's gonna use it. If I'm gonna charge you$50 per million tokens, then we have what we have in America, which is you know, probably 10 to 15 percent of companies are actively deploying it, and maybe you know, a few single, low single digital actually successfully deploying it to create ROI, right?

SPEAKER_03Very few companies right now are coming out and saying, you know, I've made a bunch of money from it. Some startups have absolutely, but large companies, uh, it takes time, it takes time for for that to flow through. And they have to completely, you know, essentially redesign, re-engineer their workflow to to make it AI ready before they can get value from it and retrain their workforce.

SPEAKER_00That's that's so interesting. And uh you've made actually what I think is a pretty contrarian argument. And you know, one thing we like contrarian takes. I mean, just being in markets, we're always looking for something that's not priced. By nature, I'm not saying we should be this contrarian for the sake of being contrarian, but I thought your contrarian argument is interesting because you're saying this AI race will actually bring the US and China closer together. Where everything literally for the last decade, I feel like you've been going apart, right?

SPEAKER_00Ever since the trans-Pacific partnership sort of fell apart. I mean, it seems like America's just separating from Asia and not just China, for all of Asia, probably. So I want you also to talk about that. And you explained something called the stag hunt, you know, that framework, well, you know, which it comes out of game theory, too.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. So stag hunt is actually it's a very old game by Jean-Jacques Rousseau, who uh, you know, every when people think of game theory, everybody thinks about uh prisoner's dilemma, and we hear it a lot. Oh, you know, we can't trust them, it's prisoner, and the right thing to do in prisoners mill is to defect and just to screw your your your partner, your opponent, right?

SPEAKER_00Um and that's like a zero sum game.

SPEAKER_03That is a zero-sum game, and that conclusion of screw your partner only works if it's a single turn game. Okay, so we don't live in a single-turn game, we don't live in a zero-sum game, and and we also don't live in a single winner game, right? Um, and we don't have a clear finish line that it's done. This is this is the issue when people start to apply a theory to something that doesn't represent the playing field that you're you're working in, you know. And and the other thing about prisoners' dilemma, everybody, you know, the key the key thesis is you can't talk to each other.

SPEAKER_03You know what? We we have people that talk to each other every freaking day. Not only you know, between the last, but also between countries, between the governments in the you know, side in your track two dialogues. Every day they're talking. And not only are you talking, you can see the actions of each country every day and each company. You know, how fast are they releasing product, you know, which which which new export controls that they put in, you know, what what what uh you know escapes have they had? You can see all of that, right? The the world is actually fairly transparent, which does not represent the the prisoner's dilemma.

SPEAKER_03When much more accurate picture is actually uh this concept of stack hunter. Stack and the the story is uh two hunters go into a forest. They decide do I hunt for the big stag, the thing that's gonna feed my family for a month, or do I hunt for the rabbits and you know and feed my family for a day or two? Okay. And if I go for the stag, I need to go together with my partner who I'm going here with. If I'm hunting for the rabbits, I just everybody do their own thing, right? So you you you just essentially you compete for whatever you want. The worst thing to do is for um one of the the uh hunters to go for the stag by himself.

SPEAKER_03First of all, he won't be able to get it, and even if he gets it, he can't take it home. Okay. Two, is that uh, you know, then he's wasted his whole time and his family stars, okay. And the other guy just gets for more rabbits. Okay, so this is what we're doing today is that we are going for this giant AGI stag, which we don't know how to control, which we have to spend 10 times as much to get, and we're not getting any value out of it yet, you know, and we're rushing to this thing that could potentially create a major, you know, um financial crisis, job crisis in America.

SPEAKER_03At the same time, the Chinese are like, shit, I'm just gonna make open source, it's you know, 98% as good. I spent one-tenth as much money. Um, and you know, everybody's using my things, you know, uh, it's not now I'm the most downloaded uh model in the world. Every country in the world is using mine to create their sovereign AI models. So freaking, you know, did America win? Are we winning? We're we're winning the benchmark, and then tomorrow some other uh lab will win that benchmark by one percent. And then the the day after that, and you know, but they didn't get any money from it, right?

SPEAKER_03They didn't create any value from it. They got they got you know uh a star on the board for that day. That's it.

SPEAKER_00The equivalent of the fields medal in mathematics for solving problems that haven't been solved before. I'm not saying that's not a good thing.

SPEAKER_03I mean, I fields medal is it's it's you know, you you don't not very many people get it. This no, absolutely, yeah. Yeah, yeah. But this thing, everybody every day gets a different one. So it's just like you know, it's like getting getting the star at the at the kindergarten, right? This is that's why it's a star. When you're at a kindergarten, you know, you you okay, I I put my shirt on, right? Oh, here's a star. Oh, you came on time. Here's a star. Okay, this this is what we're we're we're right now fighting for that little star. And you know, the the the Chinese are like, shit, I you know, I don't care about stars, I just want my economy to be growing five or ten or twenty percent.

SPEAKER_03And you know, we're we're we're creating a a market in our GDP right now where pretty much all the growth in the last year or two data center uh uh investments. And we're we're stopping the we're not building offices, we're not building homes, we're not building electric plants, you know, we're and we're not building trains, you know, we're we're building one thing. You you essentially we're all in on one sector that has to pay off right away. And if it doesn't, we're we're gonna be in trouble.

SPEAKER_02So, Alvin, you mentioned stars. You know, one of the stars of this market has been Alphabet. Um you might have some takes too. I'm gonna read some things here, and I just want everyone's take on this. So we mentioned big down days, literally down 12% yesterday. The worst day in the history of that stock since 2004 is IPO, two quarters in a row of negative cash flow, down approximately$500 billion market cap on only one day. Google, here's the here's the big question Google Services, which is really YouTube and Google search, missed on revenue 39.2 billion versus over about 41 billion profit.

SPEAKER_02And they said, Yeah, it turns out that some of the AI stuff, AI search is kind of almost can't our AI search is cannibalizing our revenue on the other side. Yeah, whoops. Um, that is I don't even know where to take this, but clearly the stock was hammered yesterday on that and some other concerns. But that one got me. Do you see that continuing, Alvin? That literally they created something that's hurting their revenue.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, uh absolutely. I think it's only the beginning. I mean, I don't know how many man, I don't know how many uh you know how much uh Google searches you're doing this year versus last year. I can say I'm down.

SPEAKER_00I I'm I'm almost completely out. First of all, that Google search is horrible because it was a whole bunch of ads. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Well, I mean that that this is the business model of Google and of all search companies, is that they're selling you ads, right? And then in fact, here's here's something that I that you didn't talk about, which is uh kind of big on Twitter in the last few days is uh all the companies that were buying ads said, you know what? I used to have um very specific ads, uh words I was buying and I was willing to pay for. Now, automatically in the background, because they're in such dire straits to to generate revenue, they've expanded my words to related to your words that are not really what I asked for, but I'm now paying this high price for a very specific word when they expand it to 10 or 50 times uh the the the audience of the things that I weren't paying for.

SPEAKER_03And so their costs are going up, but they're they're actually um you know, results that they're getting in ROI is actually coming down. And so if that's the case, then people are going to continue to find alternative ways to to reach customers. You know, this is a to me, this is a sign of desperation. Um they also changed the algorithm. They used to have a essentially the second best price was a price that they would charge their customer. Uh so if two people were pacing a bait uh were bidding on the same word, now what they're finding is that they're using the top price, is what they charge for the winner.

SPEAKER_03So they they they've actually secretly in the back changed how they price uh ads to their customers because they need to make up revenues, right? That I mean that this this is why they didn't release uh a chat GPT equivalent when they had it a year before OpenIA had it because they they could see this happening, right? They knew it. Yeah, I mean it's it's you can tell when somebody can give you the answer, or somebody is gonna give you a hundred links and you gotta find the answer.

SPEAKER_03Which one do you choose? It it's it's kind of automatic. I'm surprised it took this long for it to show, but I think that that that trend is not going back the other way. People are not going back to to search. I mean, once in a while, I think you know, I probably I use it once a day now instead of I use it 10 times a day in the it's probably just muscle memory as well, right?

SPEAKER_00Like you had been doing it, it's hard to change something, but slowly, but surely, yeah. Yeah, and like my search takes place in AI bots now.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, now the AI agents might be using the search, but they're not looking at the ads and they're not clicking on the ads, and they're not buying anything afterwards. So they're essentially giving money to do the traffic serving to these agents who are not generating revenue, so it's actually a negative revenue generation for them.

SPEAKER_00Which begs a question do you think ads are coming to the chatbots? Because at the end of the day, a big source of revenue for all tech is ads, right? Yeah, you said it. Yeah, uh on the enterprise level, different. Okay, set that aside. And in Google, we could talk about YouTube. Maybe it should be it'll just be a YouTube company and uh turn a little bit. But do you think ads are coming into the chatbots?

SPEAKER_03I mean, I kind of fear that at some point, but I mean we we we we already talked about well, open AI already talked about this maybe four or five months ago. They said they were experimenting on ads on their low tier, low tier, I think like eight dollar, you know, or or free free versions, which I guess you know, if it's free, then sure I get it. But if you're paying even if it's eight dollars, if you're paying for it, I don't think you should put ads because that completely um conflicts with the the trust you would have in that service.

SPEAKER_03If I can't trust whether this answer is trying to sell me something or this chance, this this answer is trying to give me the truth, uh, I'm gonna I'm gonna use the one that doesn't give me ads.

SPEAKER_00Like if I'm looking for the cheapest flight, I trust that it will give me the cheapest flight rather than you know, American paid them to show me their cheapest flight, and that's it.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, so so this is this is the issue with chatbots going forward or agents in general, is that it will be the best way for any corporation to manipulate you right to buy whatever you want because they did they just bring it to you, it's there, all you gotta do is say okay, and you've bought it. In fact, you might have given it your credit card and just say buy me the cheapest one.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and there is no okay then, right now, yeah, right.

SPEAKER_03So, so if if you trust it to that level and it's not working for you, you are screwed, right? And as a consumer.

SPEAKER_02Um, let me jump in. We're almost we're over halfway. It's amazing how fast this goes. The latest facts versus feeling social hour. Um, we're having a lot of fun here um with Alvin Grayland here. Um, where do we want to take this? How let's go this origin stories, origin stories. How did you meet Mr. Omani Carson? Because Omani connected you with us, and I got a guy, I got a guy who's amazing, and obviously that connected this, and that's kind of why we're doing this. And by the way, you met with our investment committee last week.

SPEAKER_02I I couldn't make it. I was traveling, but I heard it was an amazing discussion. So thank you for taking time to meet with uh our team twice here in about a week or so. But how'd you meet Mr. Carson?

SPEAKER_03Um, so my brother is part of a group that he's organized, and uh, so I I went to one of their events, and I think uh when I went there, uh uh he heard I was a writer and he said, Oh, well, what what do you write? And I sent him something, and and then he's like, Whoa, this stuff is really resonates with me. And then I think the next week he saw I was on uh Peter Diamandis's show, and uh and I guess he's a big fan of of um of the moon moonshots. Moonshots, moonshots, yeah. So I think I think that that kind of prompted him to say, Hey, I I want I want uh you to come to our show as well.

SPEAKER_03So I think that's how it all kind of came.

SPEAKER_02I know we're we're we're thrilled, and I know um you know we all have to stop a hard stop top of the hour. So uh Sony, where else we want to take this?

SPEAKER_00Uh I I was gonna ask about the same US China since we brought it up before, but continuing along that, do you think chip controls from the US side are working, however, we define working?

SPEAKER_03Um, so so from from depends on how you measure working. Um, if you if you say is it is it making life difficult for the Chinese labs? Absolutely. I I talked to all those labs, and and one of the biggest things they complain about is we don't have enough chips. Okay. Is it slowing down from catching up? Not really. Is it is it uh you know creating more revenues for American companies? Absolutely not. Is it is it creating a uh potential future competitor uh that will be getting stronger and stronger over time that then competes with us on the chip market and on the AI market and the AI stack market?

SPEAKER_03Absolutely. So um, you know, again, this is this is like the whole back to the whole uh winning the little star thing. So we're we're winning the the oh, I've got a a rock in my shoe, a pebble in my shoe pain uh race, we're in the long run going to you know essentially lose the uh everybody in the world is using American Stack Race, right? That that's that's what's happening right now. Uh and you know the companies who are making chips in China, their chips are kind of crap. Okay, but because they the the Chinese labs can't buy any other chips, because the Chinese data centers cannot buy any chips, they have to buy crappy Chinese you know GPUs.

SPEAKER_03And so these companies that would have gone out of business if we let them buy NVIDIA chips and there would be no competitors there. No, we've essentially created competitors that are now very well funded, you know, uh partially because they got customers, partially because the government said, shit, we cannot be relying on American chips because they can take it away anytime. Um, so they're putting you know hundreds of millions and in some cases billions of dollars to try to prop up these companies who are now actually making semi-competitive products uh from a hardware perspective.

SPEAKER_03And now they're even making you know uh high bandwidth memory. The the CM CXMT, I think uh uh uh they went public this this year, I think a few months ago, and on first day, they became the most valuable company in China on day one. So uh, and I don't know if you know, but for for the Koreans, the biggest uh benefactor of uh of the Korean stock market was around the the memory companies, right? So uh SK Heinex and and uh Samsung and those guys.

SPEAKER_03And you know, that's where you know, in fact, here's the funny thing. I don't know if you know, but uh US has 45 or 47 of a total global AI-related profits, and all that is hardware, none of it is models, right? Models all lose money around the world. All hardware was in America, 35% was in Korea. Wow, 7% was in Taiwan, and then like 5% was in China, right? So these essentially it's only hardware that's making money right now, and Korea, a country with like you know, not very many people, like 40-50 million people, is making almost as much total profits as America.

SPEAKER_00So I I mean we see that in the trade surplus, right? The annualized trade surplus, just for everyone listening, exports minus imports, Korea always had a surplus. It's like six times what it was just a year ago.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. So and it's it's all memory, and memory have gone up, I think 300%, maybe more this year, in terms of how it how much it costs to buy high bandwidth memory. So um, you know, so but but you you I think what what we'll also find is that very soon these corrections will all uh come back to normal. Uh as we all know, I mean, semiconductors, I you know, I like I said, I spent a lot of years in semiconductor, it's a very cyclical business. Uh and we are it seems like we've forgotten that.

SPEAKER_00And I'll, you know, and who knows when it becomes cyclical, but the way people talk about AGI and all that, it's it seems like have we forgotten that semis are the classic cyclical business? I mean, Ryan's, you know, the technical guys have probably known this longer than anyone else.

SPEAKER_03Well, the problem, you know, the problem is that the people who are pumping this up are you know 30-something CEOs that have lived a very sheltered life in some valley, have only gone through one cycle, um, and haven't made anything that was physical. Uh, and if you're making software and you look at if you use software as an evidence of where the world's going, I can understand where they come from. Because you know, uh a year ago, you know, five or 10% of the code was written by AI. Now it's 95% of the code is written by AI.

SPEAKER_03And so if you think about it that way, hey, next year it's gonna be 100%. And you know, we our revenue has gone up 10x in the last year, uh, it's gonna go up forever. And uh, you know, our our user traffic has gone up, you know, 10 or 20x this year. So that's gonna continue forever. And so we're gonna need uh 10 or 20x more chips, we're gonna need 10 to 20x more memory, we're gonna need, you know, whatever, right? And our our revenue is gonna be bigger than the GDP of America.

SPEAKER_00And our TAM is like 40 trillion dollars.

SPEAKER_03Well, yeah. I mean, this is the this is the issue with all of these companies, is that um they they live in a little sheltered uh echo chamber bubble of Silicon Valley. Um, and everybody there talks the same way, and when they talk the same way, uh, particularly in the software and AI circles, um you you don't realize that there are alternative uh perspectives.

SPEAKER_02So let me jump in there because just two days ago, feels like a lifetime ago, big company called Oracle had their investor day. They said 35% compound annual rate on revenue growth through 2030. And then we mentioned you just said SK Heinex, which remember it reminded me that stock was up 13%. I think it was the ADR was up 13%, but it was up a lot. They said demand is gonna outstrip supply until 2030 again. Record revenue, record profits. Uh, Microsoft had some pretty good news. Um, all in all, their stock was positive, but a lot of these other clear, like we started this conversation, if your cash flow is negative and you miss by a little bit, you're getting absolutely annihilated.

SPEAKER_02Maybe Sony, more for you. How do we think about this? So, Carson Group, we managed close to nine billion dollars for our financial advisors and their clients. We haven't overweight tech. Tech is still up on the year, still outperforming on the year, but my oh my, October has been an absolute just bludgeoning for tech and communication services. How are you thinking that? Because we could give a bullish argument, we give a bearish argument just in the last three days. All the crazy stuff that's happened. What do you think, Sonu? I think I wrote a piece a couple of weeks ago.

SPEAKER_03I want to give you one quick data point to think about. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Um, this in the last few months in China, the air star market, which is like their NASDAQ, has gone down 40%.

unknownWow.

SPEAKER_0340%. Okay, so so their their AI bubble has deflated. We have not, you know, we we from the peak, we're down like 10%, right?

SPEAKER_00Which is which is like part of the course, like Ryan's shown numbers, like you should expect that all pretty much every year, or sometimes even twice a year, right?

SPEAKER_03That's uh so so what that this is why I said in the beginning, we're just starting, right?

SPEAKER_00And that gets to like Ryan, your question, you know, we've written about this in a full-year outlook, mid-year outlook. There's something big happening. And usually when you're recycling capex into earnings, I mean that's driving the market, right? Multiples have gone down. If you just look at that, you think, oh, the stock market's struggling, but then what's held it up? It's earnings growth, right? Now, where are earnings, where's earnings growth coming from? It's re CapEx being recycled, right? One company's spending is another company's revenue and social profits.

SPEAKER_00As long as that flywheel continues, that's okay. But that's also why B wrote you want to avoid a wipeout, you want to be diversified, you want to combine things like momentum with, dare I say, one of the most unloved parts of the market, which is low volatility stocks.

SPEAKER_04Yep.

SPEAKER_00No, everyone hates that. You look at, you know, our friend Todd Sohn has some great charts on this showing, you know, cumulative flows into low volatility stocks. If that line just goes down, nobody wants it. And what's interesting, historically, low volatility stocks have a beta, which is you know, your exposure to the overall market, about 60, 70 percent thereabouts. Right now, it's almost zero. It's it's the correlation is negative. What's amazing, the correlation of a big part of the market, you know, certain sectors, sub-industries, to the overall market is negative.

SPEAKER_00And that gets to you know the concentration issue, right? About 38, 40 percent of the SP 500 is tech stocks. You add Meta or Alphabet, which are in comp services, Amazon, Tesla, which are in consumer discretionary, that's 51% of the index. You have a concentration problem. But going to Ryan's point, what have what have we done about it? Well, we want to diversify. And not just low wall, I would argue, even Europe, for example. Europe's doing just fine.

SPEAKER_00You know, nobody's talking about Europe being an AI leader or anything like that, but we think that's a diversifier, right? So just to give you know everyone listening some context on how we're thinking about all of this and managing money at the same time.

SPEAKER_02And I want to jump in, then I'll gonna go to you. So just again, context around this. And I'm not gonna mention the specific ETFs, but there are a bunch of them you can find. I'm looking at a very large momentum ETF, down 11% for the month. Now you ready for this? The low, the biggest, biggest low vol ETF, up six percent for the month. I mean, it's About just incredible what we've seen this month. I mean, it is uh an October massacre, and yet if you're a value investor, you're a low-vol investor, you're a healthcare investor. That's where I wanted to go with this, Alvin. Literally, the time we're doing it's XLV, not a recommendation.

SPEAKER_02The large healthcare ETFs hitting the highest level ever. Healthcare is just ripping. Uh, you know, a lot of smart people as well. Your take on this, think healthcare. I think it's more the anti-AI trade. At the same time, maybe healthcare is going to benefit from AI. How do you think about investing with healthcare as a diversifier away from AI? Because it sure seems to be working as these AI stocks are going lower. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00By the way, healthcare is up 10% for the month, thereabouts.

SPEAKER_03And I actually think that healthcare will continue to go up. You know why? Because the cost of drug discovery is going to come down. And they have something that the AI companies don't have, which is uh a, you know, the data sets of all their users and customers and patients and different drug combinations and molecule combinations, uh, and the pathway to clinical trials and all these things that they've had, in fact, all of their prior data of prior clinical trials, they can now have AI look through it and see if there's things that they missed.

SPEAKER_03Right. And so this, and and they can they don't have to have the biggest frontier models to do it. This this is the lie that the frontier AI companies tell everyone is we can't slow down because if we slow down, then we're not gonna come up with the cancer cures and people are gonna die because we went too slow. And it is a complete lie because not none of the the big drug companies are using frontier models to make their next drugs, they are all using specialized small models trained on specialized data, and and no smart AI uh uh drug company would give their entire data portfolio to these AI companies because we can see what happened.

SPEAKER_03They're gonna go make their own thing and then they're gonna screw you, right? So there nobody's gonna give that away. So um, you know, when it normally it takes billions of dollars right now to make a big drug, and I think that that number is gonna come down dramatically, but they can still sell it for high numbers because there actually is a patent you know protection system in in medicine that is not the case in open source models. Um when when night when somebody creates a a closed source model that costs them five billion dollars to do a training run, and then the next day somebody releases an open source model that is one-fifth the price, they've completely destroyed the value that you've had in that five billion dollars of investment.

SPEAKER_03Right. You could put five billion dollars into drug discovery, and you might get you know ten or fifteen billion dollars back over the next five years. Yeah, that's incredible.

SPEAKER_02I'll just say this. Uh, so jump in a second. We have close to 3,000 people watching us at this very second. We've had many thousands over the past 45 minutes. So thanks to everyone who joined us on this latest social hour. Obviously, thanks, Alvin, for joining us. We have less than 15 minutes, Sonu. So, um, what else do we want to talk about?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, uh Alvin, maybe you can mention how people can find all your stuff and where they can, you know, feel free to name your books and where they can go to read everything you write. And I've read a big job of it. It's fantastic.

SPEAKER_03Um, I I would I guess that probably the place to go is on X, uh just a Grayland on X, uh, or the Abundanist uh on uh Substack is probably a good place to find me. And I I usually publish uh papers and articles and essays on there. Um yeah, so hopefully that'll give you uh uh a few places.

SPEAKER_00How many podcasts have you done? By the way, that Moonshots podcast was like three hours long or something. It was like two and a half hours, I think. Two and a half exploded, sorry.

SPEAKER_03Um, I think this this week I did three podcasts. You're my third one this week. Wow, so I mean it's it's a hot topic. I think everybody is a little concerned about what's happening with all the issues, and yeah, one thing we didn't talk about is all of the uh cyber issues.

SPEAKER_02You know, we just had I wanted to talk about the Bitcoin, the the the six billion dollars of bitcoin. I wanted to take there as well. Go ahead and build on this.

SPEAKER_03In fact, uh a CZ was an old friend of mine. We used to play poker together when we were really both in Shanghai when before he became rich and famous. We when he was just an engineer, we used to play.

SPEAKER_02You got some skeletons in the closet on him, I'm assure you drinking, hanging out, playing sure you can write a book on that, but but go ahead, yeah. Yeah, yeah. What so what's your question, Ryan? Well, I guess what's your take on the Bitcoin that was stolen? I mean, you know, that's shouldn't we have expected that?

SPEAKER_00Like, you know, when you take decentralized finance, and it's almost like, and I want to get to regulation and all of that. Part of it is like it's a free-for-right.

SPEAKER_03I mean, very simply put, and a free-for-all means you know, anything can happen, and now it looks like and it's actually in some ways, uh, you're the the people who got affected were lucky that they were on Binance because I think Binance had agreed to make them whole, right? Which which is a very generous thing because that's you know, six billion dollars or something. Um but if you were if you just had something in the in your on your computer that was a you know key to something, and right now every computer is vulnerable to being hacked.

SPEAKER_03Uh, I mean the fact that 70% of the websites last week were essentially made available and open to you know the hackers to go and and essentially fully own with an external connection, that you know, that was what the PHP um bug essentially exposed. Uh Lyman. Luckily, they also put out some patches, and you know, it depends on how quickly people patch things up. But the reality is that you know, I used to work for a cybersecurity company, and the average patch time for it to be fully deployed is around two to three months. So you put out a patch and it takes months for to get all these companies getting in all their systems and all the the end user consumers saying yes, right.

SPEAKER_03And when that happens, every every moment that that's not patched up is an open door for bad guys to do something. And you know, we all, you know, no matter how secure you are, you would you think your computer is pretty secure, you probably have a file that says, you know, a Bitcoin key or whatever you want to call it. You might have a secret name for it. But you know, somebody can just go and scan your your drive. Uh, if they if they have you know, the cost of these small agents right now is essentially free. You can run them on, you know, uh uh a uh an edge device and just say scan everything on the on the internet, look for holes, go in there, steal whatever data you have, and let's figure it out later.

SPEAKER_03So I'm actually surprised that there wasn't this kind of um essentially crypto losses before. Or maybe some people have had it, they just haven't announced it. Yeah, we don't know yet, right? Yeah, so but but I I think what we will find is that there this issue uh will continue to expand. If you look at the the CVEs that the common uh vulnerabilities and exposures list, uh it has gone up, I think 700 uh no 300 for uh severe and 700 this year for critical bugs.

SPEAKER_03So there are thousands and thousands of open vulnerabilities right now that if a bad guy wanted to and they were smart and they go and go just I mean, it's all public. Those those vulnerability lists are public. If you want to use that, I mean it's it's meant for the the good guys to go patch. But if the bad guys went there and said, Where what are all the vulnerabilities? Let me go make some some hacking systems to go through all of these. Um, there are hundreds of millions of devices right now that are open for attack.

SPEAKER_02Well, we probably only have time for two more. Here's mine, and then Sono, feel free. Um, it's more of a playful one. But I I grew up in Springfield, Ohio near Dayton, Ohio. The Wright brothers, right? Kitty Hawk, the first plane to fly way back a long time ago. I've heard one of the craziest stats I've ever heard is if you look at all the profits made from all the airplane companies since that fateful, well, not fateful, that first flight. They've literally made no money. Like literally, airplanes have never made any money, even in boom times, airplanes don't make money. Yeah, my question to you that didn't make any money, and be honest, you're on a podcast, you're not allowed to, you're not allowed to fib.

SPEAKER_02You versus C um C Z in poker. Did you take money from him or did he take money from you? I I have to ask. I'm sorry, I just have to go down this path. I'm I'm very interested to know who's the better poker player.

SPEAKER_03He's a very good poker player. I'm sure uh yeah, he he's very analytical and he doesn't he doesn't bluff as much, right? So he's he's very uh methodical in his play. I remember he probably won more than he lost. I'll just say that.

SPEAKER_02I can I I can see that. He yeah, okay, all right. You're we're pretty good too there, right? You're good, I'm sure you're good poker players. I I held my own, but there you go.

SPEAKER_00That's great. Go ahead, sorry. Alan, you mentioned when you were talking about cybersecurity arrests and like mentioned the bad guys being able to do something now. That's in that event, well, if he catches them, put them in a jail. Throw the book at them, put them in jail. What if an agent is doing this? Who should be held liable if any of these agents have caused harm? Should it be the companies or shareholders, executives, or the people deploying them?

SPEAKER_00And I want you to contrast that we don't have a lot of time, but you know, maybe in five minutes or something, three or four three to five minutes. How does this differ from China's approach to accountability? And compare that to you know what we have, the Western world has really.

SPEAKER_03Um, I I think this is actually one of the biggest problems we have as an industry, particularly in the AI space right now, is that that's not clear. Nobody can answer that question for you today. And if it's not clear, then that means that people are just going to do whatever um they think will give them the highest return on their investments or the highest value for their IPO. So it pushes people to take bigger risk. So if if we were playing poker and somebody says, uh, all your winnings you get to keep, and all your losses, uh, we'll just uh you know make it sharing.

SPEAKER_03Ryan D. Track to Yeah, we'll socialize it.

SPEAKER_02You want to play poker with me, I'm terrible.

SPEAKER_03I'll big I'm funny, I'll just drink a bunch, I'm fun, give me your money. Essentially, every play, every hand is an all-in hand. That's what happens, right? This this is the problem, is that you only get the good side, there's no downside. And um, this is actually very different than what's happening in China. If you look at China, they they have uh direct liability to the companies and to the executives of those companies if the models create harm in society.

SPEAKER_00Can they just make an executive disappear?

SPEAKER_03I mean, I'm being very facetious there, but I mean, I I think they they will definitely be called in for uh for some tea. Um but but I mean, and and the the risk of that, I think is is what it is. The key is when you have that risk, you self-police because sure, because you have something to lose. Yeah, and right now these companies only have something to win, and they're all in a race to get to IPO because once they get the IPO, then they can pay off all their investors that's put their money in them for five to ten years who are closing out their funds and saying, get my money out before people wake up to this bubble.

SPEAKER_03Um and let's let's socialize it to all the the retirement funds and and the pension funds out there, right? And so um I I I think this this needs to be clarified in America. And if it does, it'll actually make the world safer because then these companies will decide to move at a pace that is reasonable uh when they consider that there's there is upside and downside. In fact, I was in the in a uh uh in a AI kind of conference uh yesterday, yesterday, um, with uh one of the kind of big safety advocates, and they're saying, Oh, you know, what we need to do is get the insurance companies to to put higher fees on these companies.

SPEAKER_03I'm like, how do you ensure the the destruction of all humanity? How do you price that? I don't know how you price that. I don't know. Well, in that case, we don't have to worry about it. Well, no, but but this is the problem. And if you look at the anthropic s1, it's uh 90 pages of risk disclosures, and right and it specifically says uh one of the risks is that we might kill all humanity.

SPEAKER_01Um SpaceX was what 68 pages of risk? They send space, they send rockets outer space, it was less pages, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, but although I think a lot of the SpaceX was also AI related uh risk as well.

SPEAKER_05True, true.

SPEAKER_03Um, and in fact, uh, SpaceX, um, I think 93% of their revenues were not space-related businesses, it was all AI businesses, and their$40 trillion you know, uh total available market was all about uh software and AI and and what they call application services, which essentially uh is uh replacing white-collar worker payroll. That was what the$35 trillion was. Was uh local white-collar payroll uh uh amount.

SPEAKER_02So well, Alvin, this was incredible. Uh this was the latest facts versus feeling social hour. Uh, we really appreciate this. And we've done six of them. I mean, this one I've I've learned more during this one than the rest of them because I didn't know too much coming in. Uh, we want to give you the floor for like the final two minutes or so. Maybe what makes you excited about this, about the industry? What what what excites you about the future with AI and technology and all that stuff? And we'll kind of wrap it up with that. But again, thank you so much for joining us today.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I I I'm I'm both excited and and scared out of my mind at the same time right now. Because we what we do as as a society, as a species, the next three to five years is going to decide how you know our species turns out for essentially the the remainder of time. And um right now the decisions that are being made by both our business leaders and our government leaders are pushing us towards a path where it does not end well.

SPEAKER_03Um, and unless we change our ways, unless we change our our perception of how we deal with this technology, right now it's seen as a weapon for wealth or a weapon for power and domination. When you see it that way, then whatever it costs to invest to get it is worth it because at the end of that of that race, you own the world. And then you've heard that in some of the leaders around saying things exactly like that. Um and whatever risk that you put yourself in for that is worth it because you're now leader of the world or something.

SPEAKER_03So the the we we we need to change to a new way of looking at this. We need to change it to uh AI as a global public good. If we if we looked at it as you know, fresh air, fresh water, you know, just the the parks, right? Nobody's fighting to say who can make uh the freshest air. There aren't you know, people just like I we all want fresh air, let's let's just like not make bad air, right? That's kind of the the the type of thing, but nobody's racing to spend the most amount of money to to to clean up the climate right now. At least I wish there were more people doing it, but nobody's doing it.

SPEAKER_03Right. So if we looked at it as a public good, we want to make it available to everyone, we want to make it accessible and affordable. And right now we're we're doing the opposite. So uh, and if we if it was going to be something that everybody shares, then everybody should pay for it. So we should work on it together. We shared the cost. We don't have to build another, you know, five or fifty trillion dollars of data centers. We could take the the amount of data centers we have today and just make one giant foundational model, which then everybody can fine-tune and and and you know do whatever they want with it afterwards and and distill the smaller models or whatever.

SPEAKER_03And you know, right now 70% of the global compute for AI is used for training, not used for inference. Okay. So if we just and then it's split between you know probably 20 or so labs, if if they all just made one, we immediately essentially, you know, 20x our compute capabilities, so we without spending any money. Right. And then if we aren't racing, then we're gonna have more time to keep it safe. We're gonna put the right guardrails around it, you know, we're gonna have it come out in a time where uh the companies can actually utilize it and uh improve their productivity, improve their their innovation, right?

SPEAKER_03Right now we're we're releasing models every week, you know, sometimes every day. Yep. How many people can actually keep up with that? How many companies, no, no companies can keep up with that? So why are we doing it? It is for this ego trip of saying I have the star for the week of I had the highest you know uh benchmark score. That that is worthless in the long run.

SPEAKER_02Well, you get a star for joining us. I'll just say that. Uh Alvin, this this was amazing. Thank you to Sonu. Thank you to our producer, Pod Pony. Um, and thanks, Alvin, and thanks to everyone. I mean, I was looking, we had well over three 3,400 people or so listening just a few minutes ago. So throughout the I know both of you have flights to catch.

SPEAKER_00So we're both a flight to catch.

SPEAKER_02I see people down here doing something in the basement. I need to start hacking and getting out of here. But Alvin, thank you so much. Sonu, I'm sure we'll chat soon, and thank you to everybody who paid attention. RPG has some fun.

SPEAKER_03Uh look forward to coming in the future. Take care, guys.

SPEAKER_02See you guys, and thank you. Bye-bye. Investment advisor services are offered through CWM LLC. That's the C registered investment advisor. This reporting is for informational purposes only, as intended for an audience of financial professionals who should not be opted. Guest presenters of our show are not affiliated with CWM LLC. Offin's expressed by these presenters may not be representative of CWM L L C.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Is the Bank of Nvidia Closed? (FvF Ep. 214)

    Nov 18, 202645 minAudio

    In Episode 214 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, ask whether the Bank of NVIDIA is closed. With NVIDIA’s market cap falling from $5.9...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Social Hour With Mike Larson and Sonali Basak (Ep. 7)

    Nov 17, 20261 hrAudio

    The Social Hour is back, and this live stream landed on a Friday after one of the wildest weeks in recent memory. Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist at Carson Group, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Are You Not Entertained? (FvF Ep. 213)

    Nov 11, 202658 minAudio

    In Episode 213 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, are joined by Carson Group’s Blake Anderson, Director of Portfolio Management, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. When Will the Madness End? (FvF Ep. 212)

    Nov 4, 20261 hr 5 minAudio

    In Episode 212 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, ask the question on every investor’s mind: when will the madness end? With the Nasdaq...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Live From Excell 2026 (FvF Special Release)

    Oct 30, 202638 minAudio

    In this special release of Facts vs Feelings, recorded live at the Excell Conference 2026, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, are joined by Ed Fitzpatrick,...

    Credit the people on this episode