In Episode 210 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, welcome back Libby Cantrill, Head of Public Policy at PIMCO, for her fifth appearance on the show. With the midterm elections about two weeks away, Libby explains why the data is flashing signs of a potential blue wave: President Trump’s net approval is roughly 20 points underwater, the generic ballot sits near Democrats +9, and an enthusiasm gap favors Democrats. The group discusses why flipping the House is a low bar, why the Senate remains a difficult map for Democrats, and why Texas and even Kansas are suddenly in play, with Sonu noting that prediction markets and models now put Democratic Senate odds at roughly 63% to 70%. From there, Ryan, Sonu, and Libby dig into the policy and market implications. Libby makes the case that voter backlash against AI data centers, with about 70% of voters disapproving, will not fade after Election Day and could bring moratoriums, tougher permitting, and higher costs for the AI infrastructure build-out. They discuss why yields are rising amid the AI capex boom, how a Democratic Congress could mean more spending on the Affordable Care Act subsidies, Medicaid, and defense, and why bond markets may sell off on higher deficits. Libby also explains why risk markets tend to prefer a split Congress, with Ryan correcting the historical S&P 500 returns by party control. The episode wraps with a look at the Fed under Chair Warsh and its communication gap, the limits of presidential power over spending and equity stakes in companies, the odds of nationalizing AI firms, the coming Social Security reckoning and the debate over taxing capital versus labor, and early thoughts on who may run in 2028. [Key Takeaways] Wave election indicators are flashing blue. Trump’s net approval is about 20 points underwater, the generic ballot is near Democrats +9, and there is an enthusiasm gap. Flipping the House is a low bar with Republicans holding just a three-seat majority, and Sonu notes Democratic Senate odds of roughly 63% to 70% across Kalshi, Nate Silver, and Split Ticket. The Senate map is still tough for Democrats. They need to defend seats in Michigan, Georgia, and New Hampshire while winning four additional seats in places like Ohio, Iowa, North Carolina, Maine, Alaska, and Texas. Libby says candidate quality is helping, and that this is more about Republican turnout falling than voters switching parties. Data center backlash is bipartisan and may last. Polling shows about 70% of voters disapprove of data centers, versus roughly even sentiment in September 2025. Libby expects more friction from state moratoriums, permitting, rolled-back incentives, and higher costs in 2027 and beyond. Markets may prefer gridlock. Libby expects risk assets to respond better to a split Congress than a Democratic sweep, and Ryan notes the S&P 500 has averaged 13.7% annualized with a Republican president and split Congress, versus only 4.9% with a Democratic Congress, a figure skewed by 2008. Deficits could rise under either outcome. Libby sees a path where Democrats back more defense and Iran-related spending in exchange for ACA subsidies and reversing Medicaid cuts, which could push bond yields higher. A Democratic Senate would likely block controversial Fed nominees, easing worries about Fed independence. Libby also reminds listeners that Chair Warsh is just one vote of 12 on the FOMC. Jump to: 0:00 - Cold Open And Election Timing 3:10 - Libby Cantrill Joins The Show 6:30 - Data Pointing To A Wave 12:20 - The Senate Map And Candidate Fit 21:05 - How Markets React To Gridlock 23:35 - Voter Revolt Against Data Centers 30:20 - AI Capex And Higher Bond Yields 35:35 - Deficits Defense Spending And Health Care 41:50 - The Fed Under Chair Warsh 48:55 - Limits Of Presidential Power 53:30 - Social Security And Capital Tax Politics 55:25 - Who Runs Next And Party Risks 58:35 - Final Thoughts And Farewell 59:20 - Disclosures Connect with Ryan: • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/ryandetrick/ • X: https://x.com/RyanDetrick Connect with Sonu: • LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/sonu-varghese-phd/ • X: https://x.com/sonusvarghese?lang=en Questions about the show? We’d love to hear from you! factsvsfeelings@carsongroup.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Facts versus Feelings Podcast. I'm your host, Ryan Dieter, and I'm joined by my co-host, Sony Varke. Coming through the noise, Ryan Dieter, Chief Market Strategy, Sony Varke, Chief MacroStratic, taking out the board and helping investors focus on what really matters. Well, we just recorded an extremely special edition of Facts versus Failing Stone, didn't we?
SPEAKER_00We had Libby Kentrell over at Pemco join us, and we talked about all the stuff going on with midterms and the Fed and Washington and the Middle East and Oil. And I mean there's more than that. But um we've had Libby on now five times. So this was her fifth time she's joined us. She our most, you know, the the guests we've had the most number of times, probably, right? Either her or Neil Dutta. I mean, they're definitely the two, I guess, that stand out. But um, you know, we recorded this you know a couple days ago, but I know you're enough to be dangerous.
SPEAKER_00Um, what what'd you think of that conversation we had with Libby?
SPEAKER_01No, it's perfect timing, just two weeks left for the you know, two weeks minus one day. And then this is released, right? For the election. Funnily enough, we haven't heard too much about elections. Usually going into this period, it's like there's election jitters, what's happening in the market, but I think that's all been sort of subsumed by the AI trade, right? And right now, everything's the AI trade, right? You look at the stock market, the bond market, commodities, all of it private equity, private credit, it's all this, you know, one big trade.
SPEAKER_01But that also gets to the politics of it. And that's why this conversation in Libya is so interesting, because yes, whatever happens, we we're likely going to have mixed government, right? The White House is still going to be controlled by Republicans and President Trump. And at least one house is going to, one house of Congress probably going to the Democrats, right? You know, safe to say, uh unless the polls are really widely off. So then what happens after? And that's what we get into the conversation, especially what happens after with respect to the AI trade.
SPEAKER_01One thing I thought, which I wasn't expecting, because partly because I don't think stuff will happen, but you know, uh suffice to say, Libby thinks that the political opposition to things like data centers, AI, right, is going to be so strong that we may see some regulation. This, you know, and I was thinking, okay, after the election, everyone's going to go their separate ways, including Republican governors, like, for example, in Texas, are gonna be like, you know, right now they're like, oh, we're putting a moratorium on data centers. But and I was thinking, okay, after the election, nobody's gonna talk about that.
SPEAKER_01But she seems to think otherwise. So that'll be interesting to see.
SPEAKER_00No, it it will be, and I mean we'll have her back and talk more about it probably next time. But yeah, this one was really, really good. Uh, we put we were gonna use it last week, and then a couple of things popped up, mainly the bull market hidden new birthday. So we we did push it back one more week. So again, we pre-recorded this a couple weeks ago with Libby, but I think all of the conversations are still extremely real time. You're gonna absolutely love this with all of that. This is episode 210 of Facts versus Feelings coming to you right now with Libby Cantrell from Pimco. And we have a very special Facts vs.
SPEAKER_00Feelings. Ryan and Sony here as always. And we're joined by, if my math was right, I call them offenders, Libby, a fifth-time offender of joining our podcast, Libby Cantrell over at Pimco. Libby, um, have you ever done any other podcasts five times? It sounds like a lot.
SPEAKER_03It does sound like a lot, guys. I'm so honored. Um, I don't think so. I mean, you all are, you know, you're a fan favorite here at Pimco. So very happy to be so very happy to be here with you.
SPEAKER_00Well, no pressure. You're a fan favorite of our um our listeners as well. I think it's been a little bit of a minute. We took a little break. We took a little break, but listen, there's a lot of politics stuff to discuss, a lot of stuff on everything. Um, but Libby, we like titles around here. You know how we live. We all live in a world of compliance. I mean, I guess I like to start it like this. People probably know you, I hope, but if they don't, what's your title and what do you do all day?
SPEAKER_03So I have a very amorphous title. My title is Head of Public Policy at PimGO. Um we don't have a big public policy department, so I'm sort of like a head of one. Um uh I get wonderful performance reviews at the end of the year by my subordinates. Yeah. Um, I but I I do sort of, you know, several things in that kind of that that amorphous title. Um, one is just helping lead any sort of engagement with policymakers. So as you might suspect, we engage with the US Treasury and with the with the Senate and the House and the White House sometimes.
SPEAKER_03And so I'm sort of the one who's strategizing all that engagement. Um, I also help our portfolio managers think through political risk and policy risk. So, you know, elections, regulatory risk, um, things, you know, legislation that might be kind of percolating on Capitol Hill. And then the last thing I do, which I actually I enjoy even more than those the two other uh kind of uh areas of my job is that I get to talk to clients. Um so I would sort of put the bucket this uh this engagement and and uh under that.
SPEAKER_03Um, but really wonderful to be able to be with you all, but just to talk to our clients, you know, hear from them what they're sort of top of mind and help them kind of you know um decipher the signal from the noise, if you will.
SPEAKER_00Uh love it. You know, uh one from me, this is a fun one, and I don't know if you're allowed to answer it or not. This is how this is our podcast. We like to have fun on this, you know that, Libby. You mentioned treasury, it reminded me there was a rumor that Scott was sent punched Elon Musk in the White House, gave him a black eye. I I didn't even think I was gonna ask you this until you said that. You, if anyone, maybe if you can't answer, just wink or something. Is there any truth to that when Elon had that black eye? Did he get it in the White House? Are you allowed to tell us? What did you think?
SPEAKER_03I'm not gonna confirm or deny. But I think that's I think that that Secretary Bessant would even say that he um he is an enthusiastic, he's an enthusiast. So he uh, you know, he can he can have enthusiastic responses.
SPEAKER_00Where there's one way to expire. Okay. All right, good. I I think uh read between the lines there. Everybody's talking about it. All right, well, Libby, we're we're pumped you're here. Sonu, let's just start having some fun. What where do we want to start?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was just thinking about last time I was looking, when did we have Libby on last? It was to 2024. Yep. And it's not for lack of like policy stuff, right? Because like from Liberation Day last year and the US-Iran war, but anyway, so yeah, we are election year again. So I guess let's just start with that, right? Is a wave election brewing?
SPEAKER_03So, well, first of all, I mean, we're, you know, we still have several weeks until an election, so a lot can change. And it looks like that President Trump and the Republicans' PACs are gonna be spending a ton of money. So um, you know, again, a lot can change. With that said, there are a couple of things that we're looking at, um, and they are flashing red, if you will, in terms of a potential wave election. Uh, one is the president's approval rating, but really his net approval rating. So kind of the approval versus the disapproval. Um, like lots of presidents in the time in their administration, he's underwater, but he's underwater by by about 20 points.
SPEAKER_03Uh, if you also look at the generic ballot, the sort of general view of one party over another, that's about Democrats plus nine right now. That's also in wave territory. And then the other indicator has is a sort of this enthusiasm gap. Um, how excited is one party over another? Uh, again, in different in other wave elections, those sort of three indicators have been big gaps, like they are right now. So I would say just the current data is suggesting that we could see a blue wave, you know, flipping out the Democratic House, which is, or the Republican House, which is honestly a pretty low bar given Republicans only control the majority by three seats.
SPEAKER_03The Senate is a really difficult map for Democrats, though. And so they really do need all of those things to be kind of turbocharging in order to take back the Senate. But again, you know, if this there's the political environment stays the way it is right now, um, you could see, you know, a Democratic Senate. I think we'll, we'll, I'm sure we'll talk about this. I think the implications of that actually are maybe less than people think. Um, but but certainly, you know, it does look like again, those indicators are sort of flashing red, if you will, or flashing blue in terms of a potential wave.
SPEAKER_01I was looking at some historical data, and one is like this is from Nate Silver. So apparently the average, so I think most people are like the opposition always gains ground in midterm elections. But I was looking for by how much, right? Especially how much, what is the vote swing from the presidential election to the midterm election, just going by the house popular vote. And since 1946, that swing from the presidential election to the other party in the you know, the house popular vote from Nate Silver's data has been about seven and a half percentage points.
SPEAKER_01And uh, you know, since 2006, it's actually been about 10 percentage points. And normally, like, and why I brought that bring that up is you know, I I looked at the potential swing, and right now people are saying it could be 10, 11 points, and I was thinking, wow, that's a lot. Are things that bad, right? And then I was like, oh, this is actually it matches history for one thing. And then, you know, you mentioned all those indicators. I would just add two. One is consumer sentiment, which I and I'm sure the folks at Pimco see that, we all see that, and then gas and diesel prices.
SPEAKER_01So it's it seems like, oh, this kind of makes sense if you look at the inflation story and sentiment.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, yeah, absolutely. So, I mean, one is I mean, I sort of joke that you know, we voters in America, we sort of date our politicians, we don't marry them. Um, you know, we're kind of always like, you know, shopping around for maybe a better, a better match. And and I do think that has been true at least since the turn of the century, where um, you know, we basically you kind of fall in love with somebody for two years and then you, you know, vote them out of the office the the next election cycle. Um so yes, and then you know, gas and groceries, I say this a lot to our clients that, you know, the price of a gallon of gas, the price of a gallon of milk, you would also put the price of healthcare, um, but also the price of housing, and then, you know, we talk about AI, but I think it also kind of dovetails into this just general angst around affordability.
SPEAKER_03I think that the only reason I brought up the generic ballot and the enthusiasm gap are those are things that have been kind of constant in other wave elections. And I think those are in some ways an output of that angst, right? The reason why people are there, there's they're they're kind of uh favoring Democrats is because they're sort of so mad about the kind of the existing economic situation and the party in power. Um, but yeah, absolutely. Those are, you know, we're not we're pretty reductive as a people. If you actually look at um an interesting chart, you chart the the price of gas versus the president's approval rating.
SPEAKER_03And this was true under President Biden when Russia invaded Ukraine in June of 2022, as you guys remember, when gas sort of top-ticked at you know five more than five dollars a gallon on average. Um, you know, President Biden's approval rating went down. It kind of recovered a little bit. President Trump has his approval rating has also followed the same course that as gas has gone up, his approval rating has gone down. So we're not necessarily one-dimensional voters, but wow. I mean, does so the price of gas really weigh on the zeitgeist of the American voter?
SPEAKER_03Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Wow. So I'm gonna read um something someone really smart wrote recently. It's you. Um you said in order to win the Senate, however, Democrats would very likely have to win the Midwest, including securing uh current Democratic Senate seats in Michigan and seats in Iowa and Ohio. And then you point out this is what I thought was fascinating. Dems have a shot in Kansas, you said, where the uh they have not a Democratic Senate seat since 1932. Last I checked, that was the Great Depression. I mean, just talk to me about that. I mean, they have a I mean, what's the old you know, Jim Carrey, uh Lloyd Christmas?
SPEAKER_00You tell me there's a chance. You told me there was a chance there could be a Democrat Senate seat in Kansas for the first time in almost a hundred years. Just build on that a little bit Libby. Maybe it's the diesel prices too.
SPEAKER_03I mean, yeah. I mean, it's yeah, and it's really been a perfect storm in some ways for these farm-oriented states. Um, so of course, it's been the price of diesel, it's been um the price of fertilizer because of tariffs. Uh, it's, you know, also in Kansas, it's been um this Bombeyard uh kind of situation with with uh with Canada. So there's a, you know, there's been kind of sort of other kind of nuances, but I mean, I I would argue if we're if we're talking about a Democratic Kansas seat uh in front of the Senate, I mean, you are talking about probably a Democratic majority of, you know, having them win, you know, 40, 40 seats, I mean 35, 40 seats.
SPEAKER_03So it would they would be a gangbuster of a night in order for Kansas to flip. But certainly the polling uh looks, you know, some, you know, somewhat favorable to Democrats. They also have, and I think this is also very important, right? It's the political environment, but then it's also the candidates. And you know, Democrats, for the most part, have actually selected candidates that are pretty good fits for these, you know, specific states. So for places like Ohio, for Iowa, for Kansas, sort of a former Republican who's running as a Democrat, who's a Christian minister, who is very articulate, um, and I think has has been able to sort of again tap into that zeitgeist of kind of voter angst very well in Kansas.
SPEAKER_03Um, so I mean, I do think this is, of course, the political environment matters, but also Canada quality really matters. And so I do think that the Democrats are um benefiting from, you know, from both. But again, for Kansas to flip, yeah, I think you could be talking about Arkansas, you could be talking about Louisiana. I mean, there are some places that it, I mean, I don't I don't think it's our base case, but if you did see this massive wave, you could actually see some Democratic victories in places that you really would not anticipate.
SPEAKER_00Well, maybe one more for me than Sandy jump in. I I love um we talked about this before. I remember you talk about like the idea of challenging maps, easy maps. I mean, according to you, you said this is one of the more challenging Senate maps in modern electoral history. Like, kind of tell us about why. Like so many seats to defend, so many new seats up for grabs. Why is this such a difficult map for the for the uh Democrats coming forward in the Senate?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so I mean the Democrats, I mean, in order for Democrats to take back the Senate, they need to win four seats. Um, it history would suggest that the party out of power on average wins four seats in the Senate. So again, you might assume, okay, that, you know, good odds, you know, would favor Democrats, at least in this sort of this particular environment. Um, but to your point, in order for Democrats to win those seats.
SPEAKER_00Really, Libby, it's it's your point. I'm just reading your note. Okay, well, I mean, that's easy.
SPEAKER_03I don't know your your reiteration of my point. There you go.
SPEAKER_00There you go.
SPEAKER_03They they have to defend current Senate seats in places like New Hampshire, in Georgia, um, in Michigan. You know, Michigan, I think arguably probably shouldn't be as uh much of a toss-up as it is, but they have a candidate who's a little bit more controversial there. So even if they are able to defend those existing Senate races, Senate seats, they then need to win four uh additional Senate seats in places like Ohio, Iowa, North Carolina, Maine, Alaska, and Texas.
SPEAKER_03And then of course Kansas and all these other places that we were just talking about. Um, that would just be kind of gravy, if you will. But it means that they would need to win in places that President Trump won three times, right? 2016, 2020, and 2024. And in some of those cases, he won by double digits and like 13 points, 14 points. So it is, I mean, my view had been that this would be a split kind of government outlook in that because the Senate map was just so difficult for Democrats.
SPEAKER_03But again, because of the political environment, because of some of the candidates they run, I mean, they're running. I mean, obviously, it is um, it is sort of more on the table. But again, they have a lot, it's still challenging. That's why I just think like we're, you know, we're about a month away from the election. A lot can still change. Voters kind of come home as they get closer to the election. There's gonna be a lot of money spent. President Trump is gonna be spending time on the road. So I do, I don't want to overstate this. I, you know, that even though it does look like a blue wave is brewing, um, that is definitely not a fed accomplished, and a lot can change in you know in 30 days, as we've as we've seen in politics.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. I was looking at the odds. Kalchi has odds for his Senate Democrats taking the Senate at 64%. Nate Silver with the quantitative models, I mean, the betting markets look at all this stuff, right? Nate Silver has it at 70%, split ticket, those guys have it at 63%. I mean, if you told me at the I and I follow politics a little bit, if you told me at the start of the year, it's gonna be 60 to 70 percent odds that the Democrats take the Senate out of like, you've gotta be out of your mind. No chance. Sell that. There's just no way.
SPEAKER_01I'm amazed that we haven't talking about Kansas right now. Forget, you know, that's a possibility of victory. I'm amazed you're talking about it. I what I find most surprising is Texas seems more likely to flip than Maine, Alaska, and Ohio.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, definitely um I the fact that Texas is in play, I mean, again, I think represents two things the challenging political environment, but again, also the candidate quality. And um, you know, the Democrats, I I think we would probably be having a different discussion if Senator John Cornyn were the Republican nominee. He obviously had a very contentious primary. Um, he, you know, Paxton ended up beating him. Um, you know, he's a you know, I objectively he's a more controversial candidate.
SPEAKER_03Sure. And so I, you know, I do think that um, and then and then James Talarico is again, and he's also has a you know Christian ministry background um and is a very, you know, he's very articulate. And I and I think he's sort of saying all the right things for the the Texas voter. One thing I do think that's really important to just distinguish here, we are not talking about flipping many Republicans to Democratic territory. Like that's not what we're talking about. What we're talking about is that the Republicans just stay home. The Republicans are just upset.
SPEAKER_03They don't feel like, you know, why would I I have to drop my kid at school? I have a busy day at work, why would I just like make the effort to make it to the polls? And so it's the it's that is the issue. The midterms are all about turnout and getting your base to turn out. And so this is not about again, like converting some Republican into sort of the Democratic column. Uh that could happen, but like that's less likely. What we're really talking about is that Democrats really turn out and that that those independents, and this is interesting because if you look at the polling around the Iran conflict, it is the independents that are actually incredibly negative, right?
SPEAKER_03Democrats, of course, are very negative, but about 70% of independents disapprove of the Iran conflict. And so I do think that that, of course, and then having the derivative impact on, you know, on gas prices and on diesel is one of the reasons that we are talking about Texas being in play. Um, because in in that type of an election, you obviously need the base to turn out, but you really need the independence. And I think the independents right now are at least suggesting that they are very upset.
SPEAKER_03Um, and are there they may take it out on the on the party in power.
SPEAKER_00Interesting. And um one other one here. Like in your career, what was the most surprising thing you've seen in politics? Maybe Trump winning in 2016 or something else. I mean, what stands out to you? What was really a curveball?
SPEAKER_03Yes, Trump in 2016. Okay.
SPEAKER_00That one's so obvious. Well, what else then? Well, what's another one you didn't see coming? I mean, that one, yeah, but what what other, like in one one more in the right?
SPEAKER_03You know, I think um, and this is where I do think there's some limitation to prediction markets. I think it wasn't necessarily a surprise, but in 2022, for instance, you know, a lot of folks were talking about a red wave. And this is where I go back to those indicators that I had mentioned in the beginning, the generic ballot split, um, sort of the that this that that kind of that difference, and then also the enthusiasm gap, those two metrics were not necessarily pointing to a red wave. So when we were talking to our clients, we were suggesting that actually it sure, Republicans would be able to flip the house, but probably by a small majority, and that the Senate was probably a toss-up, if not actually maybe a Democrat lean, you know, one seat.
SPEAKER_03And that's actually ended up what happened. So I think that it was made not necessarily a surprise in terms of an electoral outcome, but it it was a surprise by how many folks had sort of convinced themselves that um, you know, they're a political analyst, maybe. But no, but just that just that they weren't necessarily looking at the necessarily looking at the data. And that's why it's just good to caveat all of these, you know, all these things.
SPEAKER_00And one more from me then. You know, we we look at this, I look at this, I know you guys absolutely do. So I want to hear your take on it. But you break down, okay, you have a Democrat, well, Republican president with a split Congress or all red wave. I think one of the more bullish scenarios for stocks, though, is a Republican president with both chambers of Congress Democrat. Am I am I correct on that, Libby?
SPEAKER_03Oh, interesting. I so I would expect risk markets to respond better to a split Congress. So a Democratic House and a Republican Senate. Um, so you have, yes, a little bit of a check on the presidency, but then you also have a check on each other, right? Each chamber has a check on, and as a result, you sort of have gridlock. I mean, as you know better than I do, that is usually when risk markets have performed the best when you have this sort of composition of a split Congress, if you will. A Democratic Congress, I do think that the markets may be worried about more spending.
SPEAKER_03And I would argue that there's gonna be more spending regardless of whether it's a wave or if it's a just a democratic house. Um and I I can I can you know assess that out a little bit more if you'd like. But um and and then I also think that the markets will be uh maybe more worried about AI regulation. Um I would sort of suggest though that again, there are these constraints that even if you get a democratic wave, you need 60 votes in the to to to pass most legislation, including AI regulation. Um so that doesn't change.
SPEAKER_03And even if Democrats have a massive night, uh, they are very unlikely to get to 60 votes in the Senate. If we're talking about a 60 vote, you know, wave and then, you know, that then the House is gonna be like they all have won 100 seats. And that's that's you know very, very, very unlikely. Um so they won't have a filibuster-proof majority. And then of course, President Trump will still be in the White House. So I think that, you know, the the markets may behave or react one way, but the actual policy reality is that even in a wave election, there are gonna be lots of constraints on um on a Democratic Congress.
SPEAKER_03But I guess I'm not convinced that the Republic that the market may see that that way. I think the market will respond as if there's gonna be much more of a um, yeah, Democrats have more power than they actually do.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, one quick one. I mean, I know it's 13 years in a row where when you've had a split Congress, S P 500 has been higher. You know, now they can pick some random stuff to it. At the same time, what you just said, sometimes gridlock can be good and Washington has to work together to get anything, anything done. A market's kind of like that. What do you think, Sonu?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I want to come to a policy impact real quick, but just before on the election itself, are you surprised by how much uh pushback, bipartisan pushback, there is on AI data centers? To the extent that I think, you know, even in Texas, yeah, the Republican governor of Texas. Yeah, I guess the polls are tight. It kind of tells you what's happening. But the polls, maybe that even internal polls that they're looking at, that the Abbott, this Republican governor of Texas, is saying, hey, let's hold let's wait on data centers here.
SPEAKER_03It has been actually, if you're asking about surprises, that is a that is something that has been just the probably the most surprising in terms of a change in public sentiment in an incredibly short period of time. I mean, if you go back.
SPEAKER_01Me too. I mean, Ryan and I do client events, and we were at a client event, and there was some opposition there. Like, we don't want this stuff.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, if you go back to poly in September of 2025, you basically had just as many people disapprove of data centers as you had approved. It was kind of like a net neutral, you know, in terms of approval, disapproval. Right now, it is a there, it's 50% underwater, meaning 70% of uh of uh voters surveyed have a disapproval view, disapproving view, and only 20% approve of it. I mean, that is to have that massive of a swing in, again, like basically less than 12 months is just I think incredibly you know shocking.
SPEAKER_03Um, but I also think it sort of speaks to this moment that exactly what we were just talking about. People are really mad about cost of living. And I would argue that this goes back to not just 2024, but 2022. I mean, it goes back to really to COVID. And um, they're upset about you know, just the the rise and all prices and everything kind of across the board. Of course, they're mad about gas in particular. And that this just this issue is it's it goes from kind of the prosaic to the existential, right?
SPEAKER_03The prosaic meaning that worries about higher electricity costs. And by the way, as you guys know, I mean, electricity costs have increased significantly over the past year or so. Um plus, you know, environmental impact, okay, the noise, all that quality of life stuff, to the more existential, like that, you know, AI is gonna replace us as you know, even sure a good thing.
SPEAKER_01It's as like, you know, it could replace all of us and we have to pay more for electricity now.
SPEAKER_03And so, and like and if you're not using AI, or if you don't even know that you're using it, right? If you just think your Google search is now all of a sudden a lot better, um, you know, you just you may you you're not gonna sort of put the two and two together. So I I I think in some ways this is just it's like really tapping into this incredibly negative sentiment the voters already had, and again, voters have had since kind of coming out of COVID. Um, and it's like the manifestation in many ways of that ire, of that angst. So I I guess one thing I will say, and I have maybe have a bit of a contrarian view on this, I think there's a lot of commentators who are just talking about how this is just election year rhetoric.
SPEAKER_03That, you know, after 2027, this is going to subside and that kind of cooler heads will prevail. Sure, that may be the case, but I would say that a lot of these folks, particularly at the state level, so 30, there's 36 governors that are up for uh election. A lot of the candidates for those governors in those governor races are running on a mantle of anti-AI and anti-data center. And they're not just Democrats, they're Republicans, as you said, governor Abbott. And I think that a lot of those folks are going to have to deliver on some of that election year rhetoric, right?
SPEAKER_03Policy follows politics. Politics leaves policy. And the politics of this are just so negative that I find it hard to believe that an elected official gets into office and just like actually, that was just campaign rhetoric, right? So I think that I mean, and and I the other fear is that the easiest thing for governors to do is just press pause, right? Just to say, actually, we're gonna have a moratorium on the data center build out because that's the easiest thing we can do. And um, I think even if there isn't that, we're just gonna see much more friction in the kind of AI infrastructure build-out because the politics are just as bad.
SPEAKER_03And again, maybe cooler heads prevail. I just don't foresee that, just given how acute all of this is. I mean, they are it's less popular than uh nuclear sites.
SPEAKER_04You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_03It's it's really just in, yeah, again, that that has been a uh certainly a policy surprise that has developed really in you know in real time.
SPEAKER_01I mean, it's been shocking to me. That's why I asked the question. I was going to literally ask you a question. Do you think this changes after election day? But sounds like likely not. I mean, I could see because this is such a physical thing, this physical instruct infrastructure. It's not just software, right? Like you there has to be permitting. And all you have to do to stop, you know, put a wrench into this whole thing, a data center, is, you know, muck around with the permitting stuff at the state level.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and you're already right, you've already seen some of that. I mean, you've already seen kind of headlines that suggest that, you know, some of these municipalities are going to at least be making it much more difficult for these, you know, permits to be um, you know, to be to be given out. You also, of course, I mean, all the incentives that were there for the build out are also being rolled back. So not only do you have the the kind of the states who are saying, actually, we're not gonna like lay out the red carpet for you, roll out the red carpet for you, we're actually going to like make it even harder.
SPEAKER_03So I think regardless, come 2027, 2028, there will be more friction in terms of this build out. And I think it can range from states, again, imposing oratorium, to just like making it much more difficult for getting those permits. And also the cost of doing business is gonna be much higher, right? You're gonna have to pay for the electricity, but then also probably pay for school teachers' bonuses and all of those other things. So yeah, I think it's gonna be a really different uh kind of environment for the AI infrastructure come 2027.
SPEAKER_01That's fascinating to me because obviously we think of, I'm sure Pimco thinks about inflation and yields too. We've been talking about that a lot. And everything you just said right now, in my head, I'm thinking it's gonna raise prices, it's gonna be more inflationary. I don't think they'll stop building this stuff. They'll find some way or somewhere to build it, but it'll be more expensive to do it.
SPEAKER_03It will be more expensive. Yeah, and maybe they'll build it on the moon, but that doesn't seem like it's going to be really cheap either.
SPEAKER_00So I want to combine a couple things here. This would be a great discussion, uh, by the way. So AI, CapEx boom, right? The hyperscalers spend what between 700, 800 billion this year, 1.2, 1.1 trillion next year is probably going to go higher. Where does Pimco sit on, you know, is all of that kind of acting like um oh, like competition for capital and increasing real weight, real yields? And why are yields so high? Is it a combination of inflation expectations, strong economy, AI, something else, just yields are just going higher globally?
SPEAKER_00Um, where do you guys sit on all that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I think it's a little bit out of the above. I mean, again, I think just those assumptions that you said about the AI CapEx Well, it may be a little bit, I mean, you know, we'll see, right? We'll see if all of that comes to fruition just given the politics of this. But yes, I mean, clearly the facts are that all these hyperscalers are issuing very long-term debt, um, which is certainly competing with, you know, the longer end of the treasury yield, uh treasury curve. I mean, I think that in general, we would say all of the above, honestly, in terms of the reasons why you are seeing higher yields.
SPEAKER_03Um, there's also fiscal concerns, right? And none of this is necessarily new, right? That that the government is running sort of six plus percent deficits. Um, so there's been some concerns around that. But if you actually look at like what's been driving the run-up in yields most recently, it does seem like it's just a repricing of Fed expectations that um the growth is higher and that the Federal Reserve uh is likely going to have to sort of stay higher for longer in order to um bring some of that potential inflation down.
SPEAKER_03And now, if you look at breakevens and inflation expectations, those have been pretty well behaved. Um so it would just sort of suggest this is a more of a kind of real rate story, a real growth story versus really concerns around inflation or deficits or necessarily a competition for capital. But I do think the kind of the run-up over the last 12 months or so are because of all of those things, right? A little bit more term premium, a little bit of a steep, and we think kind of steeper curves just in general, structurally, because of the deficit situation.
SPEAKER_03And then again, it's sort of exacerbated by the fact that like now the Treasury is competing with a bunch of corporations that um are kind of price insensitive in terms of issuing long-term debt. I mean, that's the interesting thing, right? Is the Fed raising rates at the front end really going to assuage or abate some of that appetite for the CapEx build-out? You know, I think the politics are much more likely to do that, honestly, than the Federal Reserve at this point.
SPEAKER_01I do think the pol everyone's sort of underestimating the political opposition to this stuff. Right? As fast, it's interesting, like this data center build-out has come so fast, AI improvements have coming have come so fast, and now political opposition, as you mentioned, is also coming really fast. Right. It's just this age of how fast we are moving through.
SPEAKER_03You know, as part of my, and you guys might do this too, as part of my job, I listen to a lot of focus groups, actually, which I think is probably one of the um, I think more people should do that who are kind of political fads or what have you. Um, because if you listen to the focus groups, Republican and Democrat, like the one big unifying thing, well, two, is that prices are too high. Sure. Um, and that like the part, you know, the the the the political establishment, Democratic and Republican in Washington, are kind of at fault for it.
SPEAKER_03Um, and that two, that data centers are like the boogeyman. That like we don't want them around, they're bad for our community, we don't see value in them. Um, even if they're, you know, even if they actually can bring, you know, bonuses to our teachers, um, it's just not a price we want to pay. I think the the other dynamic here that I didn't mention, but I think it probably is worth stating is that some of this is also tapping into sort of just general distrust of big corporations, corporate consolidation, but also big tech in particular.
SPEAKER_03And I think this is like, again, kind of tapping into another sentiment of like, you know, parents feeling like big tech didn't do enough to protect their kids and what have you. So it's just, it's a there's a lot in there. Um, but it's one of the reasons why I don't think this is gonna be a flash in the pan. Why I do actually think that some of this political opposition is likely to have maybe more, more legs, more longevity than folks, than folks expected.
SPEAKER_01It's ironic. It seems like big tech is Mr. B tier. Every time any of the lab folks on the lab speak, it's oh this is gonna wipe out all their jobs. It's like that's not the way to get people on this side. Whether you believe that or not, different things.
SPEAKER_03When you had 10% chance of extinction within 10 years, you're like, sorry, what? I mean, I hope plus one, which we haven't necessarily seen from Anthropic, but you're like, how do you talk about the risks of? I mean, it just, yeah, it's it's wild, obviously. And you know, again, it's like not necessarily surprising that the sentiment is so bad, like the politics are so bad when you have the CEOs of these companies that have more information than the average voter, basically talking about post-dystopian, you know, kind of outlook.
SPEAKER_01I have a theory, and you can you can say that you're out of your mind, Sono. But so President Trump's from New York, and let's say Congress goes to the Democrats, both the House and the Senate. So Senate is presumably going to be led by a Brooklynite, uh Chuck Schumer, and the House by also a New Yorker. I don't know which borough he's from. Uh Hakeem Jeffries. I also New Yorker. Considering Trump seems to love New York politicians, irrespective of which side of the aisle they're on, like his love affair, dare I say, with Mam Dani right now.
SPEAKER_01I feel like, you know what? He may actually enjoy negotiating and doing a little bit of give and take with them. Every, you know, the biggest thing I think, or one of the biggest things, and you can correct me if I'm wrong, I think what Democrats want is reverse the Medicaid, Medicare cuts that happened with OBBB, how many of these there are, right? Reverse the Medicaid and Medicare cuts. That's about$900 billion. A lot of money. They haven't quite gone into effect. I think it's coming 2027, 2028. Irrespective. Reverse that. But Trump says I want something in return.
SPEAKER_01What did they give him? Give him more defense spending. Ergo, it goes back to something you already said, but you know, maybe I'm explaining this is the path to higher deficits. You can say yes, higher deficits go up. You know, deficit spending increases, which is amazing to think about. It's already six percent of GDP, but this is the path I see to more deficit spending. Now, from a market perspective, where Ryan and I sort of live, it's like that's great, great for profits for now, but I can see bond yields not liking that at the same time.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. So I think a couple of things that you just said that I think are absolutely right. I mean, one is and it's like a little bit more of a black swan in that he wants just to do deals. Like he pivots to legacy mode, right? This is he's not running for re-election. Yeah, he has two more years, just period, of being president. Um, and so what can he do in that time period in order to for legacy building? Uh, I think Iran, honestly, is one of those things. I think tariffs are another. I think Venezuela's so I think he's already kind of in that mode, honestly. I think people underestimate.
SPEAKER_03Like, I think he, of course, he cares about approval ratings, but he really does care about these issues that he's been thinking about for four, you know, four decades. And I do think that you could see, in terms of housing, even immigration, which I know people are probably gonna be like, what? Um, but there are enough things that actually I think that President Trump, being sort of the practical business person, understands that you know economic growth needs, you know, immigrant labor. And um, and so you're doing some reform there. Again, these are sort of more black swans.
SPEAKER_03On the spending, though, I don't think that's a black swan. I think President Trump is gonna need more spending on Iran and the Pentagon. That we just know that. Um, he's been using actually money from the one big beautiful bill for some of this conflict. Um, that has a natural limit, both a congressional legal limit, but also just it's gonna, you know, it's$150 billion. He um, you know, they but they have been spending quite a bit of money on this. So he's gonna need to go to the Congress to get more spending on the Iran conflict and for the Pentagon in general.
SPEAKER_03I can absolutely see Democrats say, sure, you know, we'll we want to support our troops. We're of course we will, you know, we'll approve all this, conditional that you then increase non-defense discretionary spending. Um, and to your point, reinstate. And I think it's some of the, it's the some of the Medicaid cuts, but I think even more importantly, the Democratic caucus right now, it's to, it's for these enhanced subsidies for the ACA.
SPEAKER_04Oh, sure. Right.
SPEAKER_03And not to kind of wonk out too much, but obviously in an insurance, a pool, you need to have healthy folks paying into the pool in order to make the insurance program work. Right now, with those enhanced subsidies that expired, what you're seeing is a lot of people are just not paying into the pool. Like the people who are can afford can afford health-wise not to pay for it, are not. And as a result, this the pool is getting sicker. And that could obviously could sort of, you know, crush under its own weight. So they need, in order for the ACA to continue to work, they are going to need these expanded, enhanced subsidies.
SPEAKER_03And I think that will be kind of priority number one, honestly. Um, but then these Medicaid cuts that you absolutely said those come into effect in 2027. I think that will also be another priority. But as a result, it's like more spending.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_03It's like it's higher deficits. And I do think that's why I didn't the bond market, particularly if it's a democratic sweep, will, you know, maybe sell off a little bit. Um, because uh on the expectation that we will see kind of higher, you know, higher deficits.
SPEAKER_01One way to say is just just Trump may say, you know, stop calling it Obamacare and call it Trump care, and it's a done deal.
SPEAKER_03Oh, and Democrats would be fine. They'd be like, sure, you know, Nancy Pelosi's not gonna be in Congress anymore. This was obviously her baby. You know, they will be President Obama's not in. I mean, I think they would be fine. Call whatever you want.
SPEAKER_00Um so I need to correct something I said earlier because this is important. I I pulled it up. So there's six potential scenarios, right? You have a Democratic president with Democratic Congress or Republican Congress, just play Congress, and the same thing on the Republican side. When you have a Democratic um full half full Congress with a Republican president, annualized return for SP 500 of only 4.9%. That's actually the worst. That's the worst one. That's the worst one versus a split Congress with a Republican of 13.7% annualized, which is really good, is a little bit better on a Democratic side when you have a Republican with a Democrat.
SPEAKER_00So I got it mixed up. So if you have a Democrat with both Republican uh chambers, that's really bullish. But you're right. So, you know, this is where this comes into. I guess the bottom line though is right now we have a quote unquote red wave, but you know, the market rallied after the election. I think it was because you know, people looked at a what a three-seat majority here and a couple seat here. It's like, okay, there's still a lot of gridlock, there's still a lot of checks and balances. I just wanted the point um I got that four percent you mentioned is probably skewed a lot by 2008.
SPEAKER_01It is. Yeah, right? That's right. Was it a Democratic Congress? Yes, it was, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, my huge, huge Democratic Congress. Yes. It had like, I think they had almost they almost had a two-thirds majority. I mean, it was the biggest Senate, like Democratic Senate that they've had, you know, since then.
SPEAKER_00And you had a Republican in the White House. So, one more for me. I want to I want to kind of change gears a little bit. Um, the Fed, the Fed. So Warsh is in charge of the Fed. I know you've written about this. I'd love to let the listeners know. He's not your average bear, right? He doesn't seem to say anything. I mean, some and I have talked about this. He's literally done like three different Fed meetings. Every time the guy opens his mouth, the market sells off like big time. Then it rallies afterward. And I don't think it's because of anything he says. I think it's what he doesn't say. The market wants him to say something. He just says he's like the Alan Greenspan book where you say a whole bunch and literally don't say anything.
SPEAKER_00How do you guys look at um you know new leadership without giving you a lot of guidance, maybe like we used to have?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, it's interesting. I actually worked with Kevin Warp at Morgan Stanley. So my first job at a college, yeah. He was uh he was on a couple of my deals I worked on as a lowly analyst. Yeah, I was a lowly analyst. He was uh executive director. Um he was a very impressive person, by the way. And also very articulate. And like, you know, he's a he he's uh he understands, he knows how to kind of work a room, if you will. But um uh, you know, I think that in some ways, um, it's interesting because he's not saying much, but a lot of the governors are still sick.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. It drives me crazy. They're all talking. Sony loves it. I I get sick of it. Too many opinions.
SPEAKER_03And I do you do you do wonder that once these working groups um sort of conclude their, you know, the several working groups that he's put together on the communication working group, you wonder if one of the outcomes or conclusions of that is like maybe less talking just in general, because it has been a little bit undermining of him, where he's not saying very much. So there we they don't really understand what the framework of the of the chairman is necessarily. Um, but a lot of the regional presidents and governors are speaking. So I do think there's been that sort of strange contradiction a little bit.
SPEAKER_03I think in general, though, we would not necessarily push back on the idea that like maybe less information in the market is like a better thing, in that um it was a bit like information that the Fed was providing. Uh, we understand why they were doing it at the time, but in terms of the dot plots and what have you, forward guidance, um, it just like didn't necessarily mean much because at the end of the day, they were ultimately data dependent. They were ultimately dependent on the dependent Ultimately, like listening to the markets.
SPEAKER_03And so a lot of times that forward guidance just didn't really mean very much because things were changing so quickly. So we think that frameworks are still helpful, but that maybe some of the, not necessarily prescriptive, but all of the transparency that I think the Fed was trying to give and with the best, you know, possible kind of intentions, um, didn't necessarily kind of advance what their objectives were because a lot of times they had to kind of backpedal. Um, you know, they were a lot of these supply shocks are very difficult to anticipate.
SPEAKER_03So it just didn't end up necessarily meaning so much. I mean, we're obviously, you know, active managers, so we like anything that kind of has there's some volatility. Um we also think even though higher rates on the journey up is a little bit hard for a for a bond manager, um, you know, we think it's like a great time to be in the bond market because of it. So I guess as active managers, we wouldn't necessarily push back necessarily. But I do think that you know some of the intentions of Chairman Warsh have maybe not necessarily been totally realized because of this sort of disparity in terms of uh the communication gap with other folks just talking and and him not talking so much.
SPEAKER_01I have a question on that. What uh on that communication thing, can Wars stop the Fed governors from talking too much? And maybe he can, but can he talk the presidents off the ledge? I mean, can he stop the regional Fed presidents like Laurie Logan or Eil Kashkari?
SPEAKER_03Also a former colleague of ours at Pimco.
SPEAKER_01There you go.
SPEAKER_03Um yeah, you know, I think it would have to be, it would sort of have to be kind of a norm that they that the F OMC would decide on. So I I'm not sure there's anything in the bylaws that you know that Chairman Worsh could could change. I mean, the other thing that I think has been like the reality and what something we were telling our clients pretty, you know, vociferously, is that even though the chairman's important, he's not omnipotent. He's one vote of 12.
SPEAKER_04Yep.
SPEAKER_03And so all of these things really do require a majority of votes. Obviously, the rate decision, the balance sheet decision. Um, and assuming that they had do come up with some conclusions, you might think that you could see the Fed wanting to have a majority of folks agree to those conclusions as well. So um I, you know, again, I think there was almost too much focus on, I mean, the chair is very important as a from a persuasion persuasion uh and as kind of a figurehead and and what have you. But like the the reality is that is that the FOMC C stands for committee.
SPEAKER_03And so this is a, this is still, you know, this is still a committee. You know, one thing I will say, another thing, sorry, I will say is that in a republic uh democratic Senate, I would say this is the biggest, I, in my view, the biggest difference between a Democratic sweep and then a split Congress is that in a Democratic Senate, President Trump will not be able to get basically anybody confirmed at all controversial. And so this worry about Fed independence, I think will hopefully be completely in the rearview mirror.
SPEAKER_03Because again, not only do you have this guard route, the Fed itself as an institution, a majority of votes are required, but then you also have this other check that Democrats are just gonna not, I mean, they're gonna have a hard time, they're being hard-pressed to confirm anybody, honestly. I think just given sort of the polarization and what have you, and the antipathy between the two. But um, but I think it particularly if somebody is has any sort of suggestion of being too political or you know being kind of doing doing President Trump's bidding.
SPEAKER_00So you mentioned a vote. I remember when you joined us a couple years ago, there's a very big uh vote in your household. Your son was running for student council. Now, I don't know if he ran the next year, but just give us the update. He did, he was a president.
SPEAKER_03Oh my goodness. So that maybe tell us the update.
SPEAKER_00Give us the update.
SPEAKER_03All right, I have to say that he um, like I'll think a lot of people who run for office who then you know win. Uh he was sort of on a high, and then the realities of governing really like fall, you know, incredibly imparent. And so what he has said, it's like all of the responsibility, but none of the power. Um being an eighth grade student council president, he was co-president. He felt like he didn't have enough agency over the agenda. He kept getting stopped out by the the head of school.
SPEAKER_03So um, you know, he I don't know if he's gonna run again. He's you know, he's now in eighth grade. So we'll he has a couple of years until the the next big vote, but uh we'll see if he he actually you know does it again.
SPEAKER_00All right. That's good. We have less than 10 minutes to go. Uh Libby, this has been amazing. What are what are we missing? But my question is just a lob one to you. Well, where do you want to take this? What are we missing? What's something that we haven't talked about yet that you think the listeners need to know about? And maybe something, you know, you could talk about a black swan, potentially.
SPEAKER_03Well, so I think so. One thing I actually I'd like just to take, if you don't mind, I one uh one question I get a lot from clients that I and I think there's a lot of um you know confusion around, understandably, is that you know what President Trump is can do unilaterally is quite limited. And this is true of any president, President Biden, President Trump, whatever. And it it it you know, the the the executive branch uh executes the laws. And I know that sounds pedantic, but it's just it's worth kind of keeping in mind, right? It's a Congress that creates the laws, the executive branch that executes them, and then the judiciary that adjudicates them.
SPEAKER_03Um, but I think because if President Trump and honestly previous presidents have been sort of pushing the kind of norms of executive power, there is this like confusion about what folks can do as a president kind of unilaterally. And I think that I would uh suspect that a lot of people, if Democrats take back the Congress, they'll say, oh, does it even matter? Because President Trump can do all of these things. One area that I think is quite relevant to what we all do is this idea of the executive branch taking equity positions in companies.
SPEAKER_03Um and he has talked about how, you know, maybe we'll just take an equity position in open AI or one of these areas, you know, AI companies or what have you. Um, I just think this is important just to keep in mind. He can only do that uh if Congress gives him the money to do it. And the only reason that he was able to do this with Intel, for instance, was through the CHIPS Act of 2022. Um, there was enough kind of gray in that, in that way that that legislation was written that these grants that under was under Biden, he ended up converting those into equity, but that was like that was permissible under the law and and Congress had given them a bunch of money to do it.
SPEAKER_03Um, he's taken some equity positions in these sort of critical minerals companies. Again, that was through the one big beautiful bill. Um, that was money that was allocated to so there is a limit to all of this. So I just think it's it's quite confusing, I know, because presidents like when President Biden tried to forgive$300 billion of student loans, you know, I was kind of telling our IC like he cannot do that. Like he that is going to be found illegal because that is the Congress, um the power of a person, what have you. And of course, it was then found illegal.
SPEAKER_03But I think there's a lot of confusion about what he what a president can and cannot do. But just remember if anything happens with money, like the president will have needed to have found that money through what Congress has already uh given, allocated to to the executive branch. And um, that will be just as, you know, uh just sort of just as acute in 2027. But again, in terms of these equity positions, not only is he going to be limited, but then the last thing I'll just say is oversight is going to be one other big function. It's always a function of the party out of power, right?
SPEAKER_03Republicans came in in 2022, a lot of oversight of the Biden administration. We should expect Democrats to do the same thing. But one area that I know that they're gonna be looking at are some of these equity positions that they have made in defense companies. And so I just think like this is gonna be um an area where they're gonna be had some confusing headlines, but just worth keeping in mind as investors that you just cannot do this. No president can do uh can spend money unilaterally without without congressional kind of appropriation and authorization.
SPEAKER_01Given you raised a very interesting point. I hadn't thought about this, but I I guess maybe this is a good question. I'd love to see where you take it. Uh and you also mentioned like policy follows politics, and given all the opposition data centers, things like that, do you see two years or maybe four years from now, the US government nationalizes open AI and Anthropic?
SPEAKER_03No. I mean, can I see maybe in two or four years that you know Congress has created a construct, a regulatory construct that sort of binds some of these um AI companies absolutely. Okay. I think the politics are just gonna have to like, I think they're gonna necessitate that. I don't necessarily know if I'd see that under Trump, but potentially that could be an area where they compromise. Um, but I I think that yeah, but I cannot imagine them nationalizing, you know.
SPEAKER_01Well, let's say if they're a majority shareholder, you know, through some mechanism.
SPEAKER_03It would have to be in a crisis, right? I mean, look, look at what we have with Fanny and Freddie or AJ. I mean, all of these companies where they're PM, I mean, it'd have to be in some real crisis. So I guess it's not impossible, um, but it certainly is a black spawn. The other thing, can I just mention one other thing, just have people, and this is not necessary over the next two years, so it's not necessarily totally investable, but um, you know, my view is that there is gonna be a reckoning around the deficit. And one inflection point is this Social Security Trust Fund supposed to go bankrupt in 2032.
SPEAKER_03That just means that there's gonna be a benefit cut if Congress does not do anything. That is an act of meta Congress, they're gonna have to step up. They, it's just you know, too politically popular for them not to do anything. But then I think if they're opening up Social Security to reform it, um, they're they're gonna have to pay for some of this. And you could see increased payroll taxes, sure. But I think one area that's really gonna be looked at is how we tax capital versus how we tax labor. And this used to be sort of a fringe, you know, left view.
SPEAKER_03Um, but now you're hearing a lot of folks on the right talking about this and even centrist Democrats talking about, well, maybe we do need to like look at this because so much of the kind of the spoils have been gone, have been going to the capital owners, right? Like the the benefits have been going to the capital owners. Um and so I just think like capital gains taxes could be going up, whomever the next president is, because of the sort of populist moment that we find ourselves in, especially if affordability is not necessarily addressed over the next two years.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I see this chart going all the time, which is that labor's share of income, national income, has just keeps collapsing. Right. I'll put a chart up. I'll share this chart up.
SPEAKER_03I again we're our economist, Tiffany Wilding, shows us that as I mean, that has real political implications, right? And you just think that's just growing, right? As so many people who are in the market, great for them, but it's been really going to those folks. It is the richer get rich getting richer, um, and kind of labor being left behind.
SPEAKER_00Well, Libby, we want to be respectful of your time. We have only a couple minutes to go, so I guess I have to ask this one. Is a um lame duck president coming up, meaning we're gonna have an election with new people. Who do you think is gonna run for president um on each side?
SPEAKER_03Well, I do think one risk for Democrats is that if they do take both chambers, they will over, they'll extrapolate too much from that victory. They will think instead of it just being kind of a protest vote, like it is oftentimes, midterm years, that it's more of an endorsement of their party. I think that is a risk that, you know, they kind of overinterpret their mandate and over whatever. Um I think that on the Democratic side, it's none of the folks who are polling right now.
SPEAKER_00Interesting.
SPEAKER_03I don't think it's gonna be Gavin Newsom or Connell here. This is only my this is just my personal view, not the view of Pimco, I should say.
SPEAKER_04Okay.
SPEAKER_03I also think that prediction markets like just don't know anything at this point. So I would I would not pay a lot of attention to those as sort of a signal either. Uh I, you know, my own view is that on the Democratic side, you could see a Democratic governor from a pinkish state, or just a couple of those, um, or even a reddish state. Um, you know, there's only really one of those. Um, or you see a celebrity or a reality TV star. I think I to sort of break through on the Democratic side, you need you might need somebody who's just a complete, you know, somebody who's known to voters, but not necessarily known because they're from Washington, D.C.
SPEAKER_03or what have you. And on the Republican side, of course, you have to assume it's JD Vance. You know, he's the number two in the party. But if, you know, if if President Trump's approval rating declines further, um, and I would say it's a real open question, because a lot of times presidents like their bottom, they bottom out in the second year and then they actually recover in the third year. And that could very well be the case with President Trump. But if it's not, and his approval rating said it declines to like where Bush's was, kind of 33, 30, it will be very difficult for him, I think JD Vance to run uh as the nominee.
SPEAKER_01That's what happened to Kamala Harris, right? Like if you have to run on your predecessor's record and nobody likes that record, it's a tough going.
SPEAKER_03It's it's difficult to sort of distance yourself. Also, just keep in mind he will still be the vice president when he's running. Right.
SPEAKER_02Right?
SPEAKER_03This is where Kamala Harris, I mean, for like lots of we could, you know, we could spend an hour digesting that, but but like for lots of reasons. But one of the reasons is she was never able to separate herself from Biden because she was the vice president at the time. So I think that that is something that's hard. And then I even think Marco Rubio, you know, Secretary of State Rubio, would have maybe a hard time in that environment too. So that's sort of the big open question. I actually think it might not be great for markets because I think it will be very noisy, but I think open primaries, crowded open primaries on both sides, great for democracy, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. You get some like new blood on the on the left and on the right. Um, I think Americans maybe are reassured that we have young people to run for election, that it's not just gonna be a bunch of, you know, with all respect, eight-year-olds. Um, so I actually think it could be quite good for for our democracy or for you know the country, but maybe noisy for markets, because I think then you'll have a lot of different, you know, types of proposals and what have you, and people won't know what to kind of make of them.
SPEAKER_00Well, we ran out of time. I was gonna ask you about Jake Paul running, but we'll just leave that there. Um, Libby, this was amazing. Uh, thank you so much. Again, the fifth time you've joined us on Facts versus Feelings. Uh, Carson Group appreciates you. Obviously, our our relationship with Demco is just top-notch, and we thank everyone for making this happen with all that, everybody. Again, this was the latest episode of Facts versus Feelings. It's in the book. Thank you, Libby, and let's get ready. A couple more weeks, it'll all be over. And then we can talk about the election, right? Then we talk about the election two more years. So then 2028.
SPEAKER_032028 will begin on November 4th, unfortunately.
SPEAKER_00Oh my gosh.
SPEAKER_03Guys, thanks so much for having me. Wonderful. Always a great conversation.
SPEAKER_00Do you get to take a break after this, Libby, real fast?
SPEAKER_03No, of course not.
SPEAKER_00Okay. November.
SPEAKER_03Working for our clients, guys, because you know that.
SPEAKER_00All right. There you go. All right. Thanks, everybody. See you next week. Take care. Bye-bye. Information provided on facts versus feelings with some of our geeks and Ryan Dietrich are for general information only and are not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. The statements and opinions of Joe Gaps may not be reflective of CWM LLC or its affiliate. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All entities are unmanaged and may not be invested indirectly.
SPEAKER_00Investing involves risk, including possible loss of principal. No strategy of sure success or protects against loss. To determine what may be appropriate for you, consult with your attorney, accountant, financial, or tax advisor prior to investing.
In Episode 214 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, ask whether the Bank of NVIDIA is closed. With NVIDIA’s market cap falling from $5.9...
The Social Hour is back, and this live stream landed on a Friday after one of the wildest weeks in recent memory. Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist at Carson Group, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist at...
In Episode 213 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, are joined by Carson Group’s Blake Anderson, Director of Portfolio Management, and...
In Episode 212 of Facts vs Feelings, Carson Group’s Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist, ask the question on every investor’s mind: when will the madness end? With the Nasdaq...
The Social Hour is back, and this live stream landed on one of the wildest days of the month. Ryan Detrick, Chief Market Strategist at Carson Group, and Sonu Varghese, Chief Macro Strategist at Carson Group, are joined...