Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Excel Still More

Excel Still More artwork

The Marshmallow Experiment - More Environmental Than We Think

May 11, 202621 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! emersonk78@me.com Excel Still More Journal - Amazon New GENESIS Daily Bible Devotional! Daily Bible Devotional Series - Amazon Title Sponsor: Tyler Cain, Senior Loan Officer, Statewide Mortgage Websites: https://statewidemortgage.com/ https://tylercain.floify.com/ Phone: 813-380-8487 Have you ever seen the Marshmallow Experiment? It's old and certainly makes you think. How we train ourselves, even in our youth, directly correlates to discipline, success, and productivity later in life. BUT - that is not the whole story. It's too. - ME FOCUSES -- I learn discipline. I delay gratification. I learn to say no. Life is so much be than you! And that's where new experiments with the marshmallows have the most valuable things to teach us. Tune in today to learn more.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to the ESM podcast. I'm so thankful that you've joined. Today's episode is sponsored by Tyler Kane with Statewide Mortgage. He's a senior loan officer with 20 years of experience in helping people with their home mortgage needs. Whether you're a first-time buyer, looking to refinance, or just want to discuss future home ownership goals, give Tyler a call 813-380-8487, or you can set up an appointment at his website, which is provided in the show notes.

SPEAKER_00It just does not get any better than Christians helping Christians. Speaking of which, thank you again for being here with me. Let's get started. Welcome back to ESM this morning. I hope things are going great for you, or God has great plans for you. And I'm just so thankful that He's blessed us with this 20 minutes or so together. I want to jump right in today and talk to you about an experiment that was run on preschoolers back in 1972 at Stanford University. It's called the Marshmallow Experiment.

SPEAKER_00Maybe you've heard of it. It's interesting that when it was conducted and all of the follow-up research led to some very definite conclusions, as experiments often do, and we will talk about those conclusions, but there have been subsequent tests run afterwards that have in some ways mitigated those outcomes and put greater weight on elements, external elements that weren't even considered before. As I've gone back through the research, both from the 1970s and in more modern times, it all comes together to make a series of points that in some ways contradict one another, but in the end complement.

SPEAKER_00So we're going to look at that. The first thing I will tell you, just in case you learn nothing else today, you can say, I learned something today. There is no E in marshmallow. It's marshmallow, not pronunciation-wise, but in terms of spelling. So you can use that at a party or something and say, boy, ESM is really, really helpful stuff. While we're at it, I'll give you another one that has nothing to do with today's episode. Genealogies. That's not the way we pronounce genealogy, but there's an A in the middle. So similar to me. I don't know why I told you that. But uh shout out to A's in the middle of words that sound like something else.

SPEAKER_00Okay, enough distraction tactics. Let's get down to it. This experiment was in the 60s and 70s and measured onward. And they took young children, mostly as I said, preschoolers, placed them in a room one at a time, all alone, and placed something in front of them. Usually it was a large marshmallow, sometimes a cookie, sometimes a pretzel stick, and they were told very simply, you can eat this right now. But if you wait until I come back, you get two of them. And they would leave, usually for a 15-minute duration.

SPEAKER_00If you have social media, you'll find that this is still around. I just saw a video last week of somebody who did this with their daughter and they filmed all the hilarious ways that she tried to cope. And if you find a few of those or the algorithm finds you searching for them, you'll see that sometimes people eat the thing and sometimes they don't. And so the experiment is testing things like delayed gratification. Even though a preschooler wouldn't know that term, they are living out either the ability to wait, to understand future value, and to be self-disciplined, or to simply not grasp those concepts and go for that immediate payoff.

SPEAKER_00Now the experiment measured several things, like the way that kids tried to cope and wait, the ones who were seeking to put it off until they could get to, things like covering their eyes or looking away or singing songs. We'll talk about that all in a little bit, but really in the end, it came down to two categories. It came down to those who ate it immediately or couldn't wait, and those who did. And so they tracked these kids for the next, I don't know, 10, 20 years, something like that, and they found a correlation between those who delayed gratification and future success.

SPEAKER_00Now I've got air quotes around the word success. Depends what metric you're studying, but they were looking at things like better SAT scores, which would require discipline and putting off things and focusing on the right things first. They measured things like coping skills, healthier body weight, stronger academic outcomes, or just generally less impulsive behavior. And they came away with this idea that for the most part you study the tendencies of these kids or how they're trained to be, and there's a correlation between self-control and future success.

SPEAKER_00Now, as you will hear in the back half of the episode, this test missed some key things. They were so focused on the individual, the kid, the way that they were trained or coded as the central motivating factor that they missed a lot of other factors that they should have measured. I think if I remember, they took mostly children of Stanford staff, and so they felt like they had this uniform sampling where the variables were mitigated and they didn't quite have that down. But before we get to that, there are some things that we can learn from that experiment.

SPEAKER_00There are some truths related to your ability to understand waiting, your ability to suppress the impulses and what happens later. And from a parenting standpoint, I think there is room here to say, I want to teach my children discipline. I want them to understand that what discipline often means is delaying or saying no to something that you want because there is someone or something bigger and better that's worth that decision.

SPEAKER_00If this was a sermon and I presented this experiment and got into scripture and wanted to make three points for the outline, it would be this. Number one, maturity waits for what matters most. There are all kinds of great Bible examples for this. Hebrews 11, Moses refused temporary pleasures in Egypt for greater reward, even in his younger years. And faith just uniformly across the tapestry of belief in God. Faith often means choosing two marshmallows later over one marshmallow now, whatever that might mean.

SPEAKER_00Improved relationships, stronger work in the Lord, or eternally to be in heaven. Examples might be moral purity, or being honest with people, or being generous with your money to help others, or taking time away from your life to pray, or parenting, or marriage, or the way you invest your time in the church. There's always this: what's the immediate gratification? What do I get out of it now? What's the payoff? But if you can make it less about you and more about trusting in something down the road, something bigger than you, where you invest yourself in it, you invest your character in it, then the payoff is greater.

SPEAKER_00For you, yes, but also for everybody in your life. A second point associated with that, number one, might be, you know, maturity weights for what matters most. But secondly, self-control. Self-control is not just about desserts, and it's not just about SAT scores, it's about living a life for God as a spiritual strength. Self-control is a spiritual quality. If I went to Galatians 5 and I read for you the fruit of the Spirit, that which comes from the Spirit and that which manifests in spiritual people, what you would find is self-control.

SPEAKER_00And while self-control can sometimes mean the ability to keep doing the right thing over and over or build on it, self-control is, I think, most often associated with the word no, particularly when you want to say yes. Can you see this kid looking at this marshmallow? They've been told there's a reason to say no, a good reason, a rewarding reason. But all of their senses, from sight to touch to smell, to maybe, and some of these kids would lick it, maybe a little bit of taste, is I want this now. But saying no, waiting, enduring, staying ready for something else, those are qualities that we see missing in adults who did not mature into that.

SPEAKER_00And maybe when they're young, we need to be seeding these ideas, giving them tests, teaching them how to wait. A third point that was interesting, just going through the research, is the waiting children, they wanted to be mature. They wanted to wait, but it was hard. So they used a lot of distractions to help them. And so my third point might be wise people, those who are in it for something more, create distance from temptation.

SPEAKER_00Look, you can imagine this. The more frequent tests, more recently run, kids who just sit there and stare at that thing and touch it and lick it, they're going to eat it. Like they can't wait 15 minutes. Could you? But there are those who looked away. There are those who were singing songs. I think the most recent video that a mom posted of her little girl, the girl would just sing some songs or something, moved from the chair and walked around. They turned their attention away so that they wouldn't be overwhelmed by it. It makes me think of 1 Corinthians, where God will not tempt you beyond what you are able, and you go, man, I don't know if that's true because I keep falling into these same temptations and I don't want to do it, but there I am.

SPEAKER_00But are you keeping it right in front of you? Are you interacting with it readily and then expecting yourself not to grab that thing? When you know the answer's no, but you're putting the yes so close to your consumption, you have to expect poor results. So those are a few things that have been researched, and again, there was some correlation. Let's not act like there wasn't. They studied the SAT scores, the future things, happiness in marriage, all these interesting things. And I think from a parent standpoint, it's worth noting that the time you invest to helping your young one understand these concepts and understand this sense of future reward and trust and all of this is well used.

SPEAKER_00It's helping to build them, that individual in the center of the experience, which was pretty much what that experiment was looking at. Now here's the thing in the back half: there were lots of questions about this. The main question was: are there external pieces to this that were missing? In other words, is this child's behavior as much attached to what's happening around him and who is around them than it is even them? And so they did a couple of different things. There was a trust challenge, a reliability challenge back at the University of Rochester in 2012.

SPEAKER_00And here's how they changed things. They did the whole thing with the marshmallow, 15 minutes, the whole deal. But before they had the child interact with an adult, the one who was conducting the experiment. In one condition, the adult promised something good before the whole marshmallow even came out, promised to do something. I'll go get you some more art supplies while we're waiting for this thing to begin. And then the adult didn't do it. They'd never brought the art supplies. And then they came out later after this adult had proven to be unreliable and they administered the marshmallow test.

SPEAKER_00What do you think happened? This isn't rocket science, is it? The children who were exposed to a reliable adult who had already proven some level of trust, those children not only waited longer, they waited way longer than those who had been exposed to an unreliable adult. Now you could say, well, it's still up to the kids to have self-control, but they're learning and they're adapting to their environment. And where there is no trust in those who've made the promises, it became impossible in many cases for them to wait.

SPEAKER_00This got expanded out in a study more recently in 2018, where they had many, many more kids and a wider spectrum. And once you controlled for things like family income, who was impoverished and who had plenty, home stability, a mom and dad in the home who had supported well the child versus that which didn't, parental education, that's an interesting one, the discipline that the parents had employed in delaying instant gratification and accomplishing meaningful future projects, or the early cognitive environment, the things that those children were taught or saw, or just general family support systems.

SPEAKER_00When you took into account all of those things, the long-term predictive power of waiting became much smaller, not zero, but far less dramatic. What are we saying? We're saying that that list I just gave you was a major factor. In other words, if you took a hundred kids who came from a middle class, upper middle class, very stable home where the parents had showed discipline in their lives, where they were passing that on by example to their kids, and where they were trustworthy and loving, the vast majority of those kids would have no problem waiting for that second marshmallow over and over again.

SPEAKER_00The takeaway is this some child's instinct or character, those things matter. We're not throwing out the whole first half of the episode, but as powerful and in some ways much more powerful are the circumstances and externals that are influencing them. Children from stable, resourced, rich homes are often learning waiting works. That's how we gotten where we are. Children from unstable, volatile settings may learn, I need to take what's here now because I may not have anything tomorrow.

SPEAKER_00Children who trust their parents believe them when they say, look, it's going to be hard now, but I promise you it will be better later. Children who are from homes where the parents are unreliable and untrustworthy, just again, have to take whatever they can get because there's nothing within them, faith in them, that their parents will be there. So on the application side, let's talk parenting and grandparenting a moment, but let's finish not by talking about the kids, but talking about you and me. First, a couple of things about the kids.

SPEAKER_00Young people flourish when they are formed and built by trustworthy promises. This is ultimately true of all Christianity, but if your children can count on you to be consistent, and this is where spirituality in your life sources you in this, because you serve a God who is consistent and you know the peace that comes from that. But if you can provide that for them, it will shape them greatly. The Bible talks about Abraham waiting because God said so, and he believed that God had a better outcome. Waiting for the Lord means I know that he will do what is best and that this won't cost me and I won't regret it.

SPEAKER_00Is that the way things are with you and your kids, grandkids, nieces, nephews, or whoever you influence? When you say things, do you come through on your word? You go, well, this is really up to these kids and how they are. They're being trained. And they're being trained by you and by me, and more by what they're experiencing with us than just the things that we tell them to do or not to do. As a part of that, their environment matters to the best of your ability. You want to surround them with people who also understand discipline. Surround them with parents who are also consistent and trustworthy.

SPEAKER_00Make sure that they're hearing voices, instruction, and teaching from people who are teaching them about self-discipline. We live in a weird world for our kids. The tail is wagging the dog all over the place. Whatever impulses kids have, parents do the most outrageous things to give those kids what they want, which is the antithesis of like everything we're talking about today. Surround them with people, voices, examples, and habits that show them a better way. Again, that's in the adults around them, not just what you're trying to put into them.

SPEAKER_00In the end, things like your church family matters, family matters, friendships matter, and so do daily habits. And from the earliest possible age, help your kids understand the reliability of God. The word of God will tell them to do things that they don't want to do. The word of God will tell them to wait when they don't want to wait. The kingdom is about self-denial, even bearing under the cross of burden because you know there is a joy set before you.

SPEAKER_00There are promises, some of which come to fruition in this life, all of which culminate in heaven. Their relationship with God is everything, a trustworthy God, a promise keeper, one who's present at all times and who loves them and who has done great things for disciplined people who denied themselves for Him throughout the centuries, including in your life. Just like you want them to say, I don't need this marshmallow now. I know that this person's going to bring me more later. You want them to say that about God.

SPEAKER_00I don't need dot, dot, dot, whatever it is. I don't need that right now. It doesn't have to be about me right now. I can suppress that urge by the help of God and the power of the Spirit now, because I know that God will do what he says. And look, just quickly here at the end, I was talking to you about kids, but I was really talking to you. I just wanted you nodding. I wanted you going, yeah, that's exactly what kids need to see and learn. And those things are super crucial. And we're really going to work on that so that I could then turn the thing around and go, I wasn't really talking about them, not yet.

SPEAKER_00I was talking about you. The very same things. If people flourish when they're formed by trustworthy promises, what are the promises of God that help you control yourself? What are the promises of God that cause you to be disciplined now? And who are you surrounding yourself with? What kind of voices and influences and examples and what are the habits that you're engaging in? Do they foster doing the right thing now so that great things can happen later?

SPEAKER_00Or are they really all about great things now and just we'll worry about tomorrow when we get there? Do you understand that church matters and families matter? And your friendships matter, and so do your daily habits? And again, as I just mentioned, how do you view God? Is God your great promise keeper? Does God see you? What kind of promises has he made where, boy, you really just wanted to do what you wanted to do, but somehow you decided that God knew best and he did know best.

SPEAKER_00And now you believe in so many things that are beyond you, and that's kind of the point. They're environmental, they're God surrounding you, they're bigger than you, which helped you take the focus off whatever marshmallow might be sitting at the table. Are you distracting yourself from that? Are you focusing on prayer and Bible reading and spiritual environments, or are you just staring at the temptation all day? It wouldn't work for kids, and it's not going to work for you. Faith in your life says, I don't need this marshmallow now. I'm chasing down greater things, and this is worth the cost.

SPEAKER_00And it also says, I don't need dot, dot, dot, whatever it might be. I don't need that now. My father always keeps his word. So to sum up, back to the experiment. For years we thought that the marshmallow experiment taught that successful people have stronger willpower. And we certainly cannot negate that entirely. It's a factor in some ways, but it's not the entire factor because maybe the deeper truth is successful people learn to trust dependable promises.

SPEAKER_00Successful people have dependable, faithful parents and influences. Maybe the internal person is shaped by the external imprint of the people around them. But here's the good news, and what I came away with if I can combine those ideas, whatever it is today that you're facing, whatever the temptation in the moment, if you can number one, know that internally you do have to make some decisions here, and it does matter, and you need to work on yourself, but you also combine that with a healthier environment and more supportive people and better inputs.

SPEAKER_00When you put all of that together for our kids, absolutely, but they're only going to get what they get from studying you. So in you as well, you combine these efforts in prayer and in faith. No matter what it is or what it looks like or where it is conducted, you will excel in the marshmallow experiment. Thank you again for listening. If it's helpful to you, please consider sharing with a friend.

SPEAKER_00Speaking of friends, I want to mention once again the sponsor for today's episode, Tyler Kane, with Statewide Mortgage. They service Florida, Texas, Georgia, South Carolina, Tennessee, Kentucky, Indiana, Colorado, and Alabama. Twenty years of experience, they can help you with home mortgage needs, whether you're a first-time buyer, refinancing, or just discussing future home ownership goals. Their website is in the show notes, or you can reach Tyler directly at 813 380 8487.

SPEAKER_00He is a trusted friend and brother, and I encourage you to reach out to him. And in whatever you do today, in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, excel still more.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Training Your Brain - Using Neuroplasticity to Your Advantage!

    Nov 16, 202623 minAudio

    Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! You Really Can Change! Have you ever said, “That’s just the way I am”? Maybe you’ve struggled with anxiety, anger, negative thinking, or...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Parenting: Gifts, Arrows, and Olive Plants - How to keep the tail from wagging the dog.

    Nov 9, 202622 minAudio

    Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! Check out the brand-new book: How to Find Jesus in the Psalms. Visit our new website with many study resources: ExcelStillMore.life For any future...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Calling All People-Pleasers - Learning To Choose Love Over Being Liked

    Nov 2, 202623 minAudio

    Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! Check out the brand-new book: How to Find Jesus in the Psalms. Visit our new website with many study resources: ExcelStillMore.life For any future...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Forgiveness is Complicated - How to Find Mercy in Challenging Situations

    Oct 26, 202622 minAudio

    Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! Try our New Website! And check out the new book: How to Find Jesus in the Psalms Cunningham Financial and Jon Cunningham have been an amazing...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Lifting All Boats - Creating an Environment for Everyone's Benefit

    Oct 19, 202623 minAudio

    Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! Check out our New Website: www.excelstillmore.life. You can read the Bible, read articles, listen to podcasts and sermons, check out new books,...

    Credit the people on this episode