Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! Check out the brand-new book: How to Find Jesus in the Psalms. Visit our new website with many study resources: ExcelStillMore.life For any future financial needs, call our title sponsor, Jon Cunningham, at Cunningham Financial Group. He's been a great help to my family, and I know he can be for yours. 205-913-1720 People Pleasing: Two Personalities, One Common Struggle Are you a people pleaser? You might be surprised by how many different forms that can take. Some people are outgoing, talkative, and eager to connect. They want to be liked, appreciated, and accepted. Others are quiet, reserved, and accommodating. They avoid conflict, struggle to say no, and hate disappointing anyone. Two very different personalities, but often the same underlying struggle: We care too much about what other people think of us. In this episode of Excel Still More, we explore the strengths and struggles of people pleasing. Being thoughtful, encouraging, helpful, and considerate are wonderful qualities. But what happens when our desire to make others happy begins controlling our decisions, emotions, and relationships? THE FIVE HIDDEN COSTS OF PEOPLE PLEASING Emotional Dependence: Our happiness rises and falls based on how others respond to us. Losing Authenticity: We change our words, opinions, or behavior to maintain approval. Avoiding Discomfort: We struggle to say no, express disagreement, or have difficult conversations. Exhaustion and Resentment: We give too much, commit too often, and quietly grow frustrated. Misplaced Priorities: We allow people's expectations to influence us more than our convictions and responsibilities. WHAT'S DRIVING ALL OF THIS UNDERNEATH? The Need to Belong: We naturally desire connection and acceptance, but sometimes that desire becomes a dependency. The Search for Worth: We begin measuring our value by how much people like, appreciate, or need us. The Avoidance of Discomfort: Whether through talking, entertaining, serving, or remaining silent, we try to protect ourselves from rejection and disapproval. FIVE WAYS TO FIND A HEALTHIER BALANCE Stop Trying to Be Liked by Everyone. Start Trying to Love Everyone. Genuine love doesn't always produce approval. Learn the Difference Between Kindness and Compliance. Doing what someone wants isn't always the same as doing what's best for them. Become Comfortable with Disappointment. Someone being unhappy with your decision doesn't automatically mean you made the wrong one. Stop Measuring Your Worth by People's Responses. Ask whether you were faithful, loving, honest, and wise rather than whether everyone approved. Keep Your Strengths, but Lose the Fear. Remain outgoing, encouraging, gentle, and generous without allowing fear of rejection to control those qualities. Jesus provides the perfect example. He noticed people, served them, encouraged them, and loved them deeply. But He also challenged people, corrected them, withdrew from crowds, and refused to allow their expectations to determine His mission. He was perfectly loving without being a people pleaser. THREE TAKEAWAYS TO REMEMBER Caring about people is a strength. Being controlled by their opinions is a weakness. Sometimes we want people to be happy more than we want to do what is right. The goal is not to care less about people. It is to fear their disapproval less. Whether you're the outgoing person who wants everyone to like you or the quiet person who never wants to disappoint anyone, this episode is about learning to love people with greater freedom, confidence, and sincerity. We don't need to become less thoughtful or compassionate. We need to become more courageous in doing what is right. Because the goal isn't to please everyone. It's to love others while faithfully pleasing God.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Excel Still More podcast. I'm so grateful that you're listening as we march through the second half of season eight. I just want to take a moment and thank the two title sponsors for the episode, John Cunningham with Cunningham Financial Group. He's been a friend for years. He's helped me in tremendous ways. And whatever your financial needs are, I encourage you to reach out to John. Also, Tyler Kane, who is a friend and a brother, he can handle your home, mortgage, and planning needs. He's helped people I care about, and I know he can help you. I will put both of their phone numbers and emails in the show notes, and I know they would love to hear from you.
SPEAKER_00Thanks once again for joining. Let's get started. Good morning and welcome. I really hope you enjoyed today's topic. The principal question of the day is: are you a people pleaser? And if you are, what is good about that? And there are some good things. And if you are, what are some drawbacks? And then how do we balance all that out? I hope that you'll find today that people pleasing is found in many of us, I think. In fact, I'd almost say that like everybody has a little bit of it in them unless they're a psychopath.
SPEAKER_00So if you get 20 minutes into this and you're like, I don't identify with a single thing that was said today, then you know, just seek out some help, some professional help. It'll be good for you. I say that in jest, of course, because I think everybody will find some part of this. It's just the way God designed us. God designed us to be social creatures and to in some way initiate behavior and react based on the people around us, and that can be a good thing. However, people pleasing when unregulated, when harmful to the person themselves, when it mitigates you becoming everything God wants you to be, that's when we need to evaluate, and we'll do a bit of that today.
SPEAKER_00What I want to establish early is that these qualities can look very different in people. Summer and I have been having conversations about this in the morning, on and off over the last couple of weeks. She would be what even she would acknowledge is a more traditional passive, accommodating type of people pleaser. Things like quiet service and avoiding conflict are very important to her. She's someone who seeks approval through harmony, through serving or giving in or keeping the peace, or making sure that practically everybody avoids any form of inconvenience.
SPEAKER_00She sometimes avoids expressing a preference that she wants. She accepts obligations even when she really doesn't want to, because she hesitates to ask for help or to put someone else out. And people like that sometimes wear the disappointment of others upon themselves. Did I let them down? Was I selfish? And are oftentimes too hard on themselves because they generally do really wonderful things for people. But what is interesting is we were working through this is that I would consider myself to be a people pleaser also, even though I'm very different than that.
SPEAKER_00I'm constantly talking and engaging and kind of putting myself into the noise of the room and really thrive on some of those extrovert-like things, at least when around people. And while those personality traits are extremely different, there are a lot of things that end up in a very similar way. Because while the accommodating pleaser, the one we described earlier, certainly fits a category, the expressive or outgoing pleaser ends up in some ways in the same boat, seeking approval, but through engagement, through conversation or humor or encouragement or being memorable.
SPEAKER_00This person may fill the silence of the empty room and overexplain something that they're doing or talk longer than they should and replay whether others enjoy the interaction. Like the whole idea is not to be boring. I think I say that at home a lot. Preaching, teaching, podcasting never bore anyone. So I'm curbing a lot of my behavior to make sure that the first priority is met, and that is that other people are getting something out of it or being entertained. And here's where those two different personalities and people intersect, and in a somewhat dangerous way, is when we let the approval of other people control our sense of value and worth, our sense of peace and honesty, and really start to direct our choices.
SPEAKER_00Now, certainly it's okay if consideration of other people direct your choices, but not in a sense when you cannot be authentic to yourself, or more importantly for the Christian, when you cannot subject your will entirely to God, because doing so would make, well, other people uncomfortable or have to take responsibility, or it may not be pleasant to them. I think Jesus wanted to please people with his ministry, but he was not a people pleaser. His identity was not tied to the reaction of the people in the room, though he loved everyone in the room because his allegiance was to God.
SPEAKER_00So again, the common ground is we strive to gain approval through different means. We want to be liked and appreciated, though we may go through different avenues to get it. And before we jump on the fix it train, let me just note some things that are pretty good about this. Like the accommodating person. They're a very serviceful person. They take care of a lot of people in wonderful ways. Maybe in a way that's a little bit enabling, but they're doing it from the right heart. They're generally gentle. They show restraint and they don't overpower others.
SPEAKER_00They're good listeners. Listening is a way that pleases the other person, and so they're willing to do it, even when it's way beyond what people like me would consider reasonable. And they're thoughtful, and those are things that are true of my wife. She's serviceful, gentle, a great listener, and very thoughtful. And so those are things that happen that are good in somebody who cares about what other people think. On my side, the more expressive person, I like connecting with people. I like hearing their stories and interacting with them, and I think that means a lot to them.
SPEAKER_00I love encouraging people, just kind of affirming them and complimenting them and picking them up. I like to initiate, to get things moving, to get people involved. And I think the expressive people pleaser also has some social sensibility, reading a room and adjusting to what makes people feel more connected to what's happening. So these aren't things that we just abhor and try to reverse. We can use those positive things and keep them. But the problem begins when consideration becomes dependency.
SPEAKER_00I care how you feel becomes I cannot be okay unless you are happy with me. And this is where it begins to break apart. It's not God's plan for everybody around you to always be happy. It's God's plan that they get the help that they need, that they get the guidance that they need. And if I just please you by bending over backwards to make you like me, it's not good for me. It's not authentic to who I really am at my core, and it's not really helping you. If I'm a passive person pleaser and I just do everything for you so that you have no stress or difficulty, then well, our kids may be living with us when they're 40.
SPEAKER_00We have to find ways of not letting this become costly to us and to others. To try and develop how serious that is, let me give you a little handful and I'll get these in the show notes. And by the way, when you go to excelstillmore.life every Monday after an episode is released, it gets immediately uploaded to that page and an article is built and it's right there with it, and it kind of details the data so you can read through some of the high points there. Just something that you might find useful. But in it, again, let me give you five hidden costs of people pleasing.
SPEAKER_00These are areas that we do not want to see get out of control, and they can. Number one, our emotional peace becomes dependent on reactions, not on action and whether it was the right thing, but on how people respond to it. The outgoing person says, Did people laugh? Did I talk too much? Do they think I'm interesting? The reserved person is like, Did I help enough? Did I offend them? Should I have offered to do more? We may replay an ordinary conversation for hours because a small facial expression felt like a verdict.
SPEAKER_00So instead we need to be asking questions like, why should another person's passing mood, where they have their own set of problems and they may not have even been listening to me, why should that have authority over the way I see myself and my attitude for the rest of the day? So number one is our emotional peace becomes dependent on reactions. Number two, and I've been thinking a lot about this, we can lose authenticity. The outgoing person, like me, might exaggerate stories or perform or rush to agree or hide certain true beliefs just to keep a favorable impression, not lying, not deceiving, just curating everything for maximum appeal.
SPEAKER_00I know that pressure in preaching and in teaching. But this same thing can happen with the reserved personality, like suppressing your opinions, never expressing actual things that you need or saying it is fine when it most definitely is not. People might like the agreeable version that we present without ever truly knowing our thoughts and convictions, and that betrays the way God may really want to use us. We're going to get into this on the back half of the episode, but if you are someone who's just overly concerned with how other people react, we need to learn to get comfortable being uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_00And that is so hard to do. But it's far more in line with the life of faith that we've been challenged to walk. And again, Jesus is such a good example. I think he wanted people to be happy and blessed and favored, but he couldn't speak in a way that made that happen for them. He had to speak in a way that was kind but also accurate and true to himself, and then let them do what they needed to do. So number two is we can lose our authenticity. Number three, we avoid needed discomfort.
SPEAKER_00So let's dig in on that point we just made. The talker may soothe over tension with words, and I do that a lot. If I see it going a little sideways, I just keep talking until it irons it out or we just all run out of energy. The quiet person may wait silently for the issue to disappear, you know, just so it's not difficult or awkward. But parenting and marriage and friendship and leadership require saying hard things with grace. A loving no, an earnest concern, a necessary correction.
SPEAKER_00It may disappoint someone briefly, but it will be good for them. I was reading just the other day in 2 Corinthians where Paul was like, it was hard to write to you in a way that was so challenging in the first Corinthian letter, but I'm so glad that I did that because it's a tremendous blessing to see what that discomfort brought about in you, this zealous repentance. So that one's tough, allowing discomfort to happen. I hate it. And that sounds maybe strange from somebody who's a preacher and teacher and does get up there and say difficult things, but I will tell you that it's a different thing to stand in front of people and just kind of preach out towards them very challenging ideas, and then to just stand right in front of someone and have to be disagreeable in times when it's demanded.
SPEAKER_00That's just really hard for me. But number one, people who've been willing to do that for me and with me, with a heart of gentleness and love, have been major difference makers in my life. Okay, number four, and I'll recap these in a minute, overcommitment can lead to fatigue and resentment. People pleasers say yes. They don't really know how to say no because the other person being pleased with what they're doing is what's driving their decisions. The outgoing person volunteering, signing up for things, promising too much in the energy of the moment, and then realizing that they can't do it, and which they end up letting them down or underperforming or whatever.
SPEAKER_00The reserved person quietly accepting responsibility because saying no just feels unkind. And how could I ever be unkind? Now here's the thing about this committing to people and making it about Jesus than others than yourself is a positive thing. But both the outgoing people pleaser and the one who is more reserved may end up frustrated that others use them without genuine appreciation, and it's okay to be frustrated by that. And that others don't see that they need to be the ones to step up sometimes as well.
SPEAKER_00And then I think when it gets really kind of sideways, and I've been thinking about this today, sometimes we give more than anyone requested because we hope appreciation will follow. We really know that this thing is falling off the table when we need those affirmations from people. So to round this out, number one, our emotional peace becomes dependent on reactions. Number two, we lose our authenticity. Number three, we avoid needed discomfort in us and others. Number four, we overcommit and it leads to some levels of resentment sometimes.
SPEAKER_00And then number five, the fear of people can crowd our faithfulness. And this one's just based purely in scripture. It talks in Proverbs, in Galatians, all over that the fear of man brings a snare. If there's one instruction more common than every other instruction in all of Scripture, it is do not fear. Do not fear what men will think, do not fear what men will do, fear only God and follow only God. And we can accept that in some abstract way, like I can't fear what's going on in China, or I can't fear some political movement.
SPEAKER_00But when it's somebody right in front of you and you're fearing their reaction, what they'll say to you or think about you or tell other people about you. I've known this fear, fear of being rejected by the majority in the preaching world, fear of sharing something that I'm seeing right on the page, but that others will react poorly to. Now, I think this is an important point, especially for the more outgoing assertive person and personality, is you don't want to burn everything down either.
SPEAKER_00This isn't a situation where as soon as this podcast is over, you're like, I don't care what anybody thinks anywhere. So here we go. Don't do that. Just be more like the Lord. The Lord was trying to pull people together, to reason with people, to ask good questions. He wanted a sum total good outcome, but when it came down to it, he was going to be authentic to his faithfulness to God as priority one. And he did not fear what other people would say or do. So we need to get to some solution orientation here, but just a quick wrap-up of how this is all working.
SPEAKER_00I think underneath all of this, different personalities, different pieces are three desires: a desire to belong, a desire to feel valuable, and the desire to escape discomfort. In general, if you fit into whatever the people around you need you to be, you get those three payoffs. They accept you, they can use you, and you belong. You have some value to them, maybe not as a person in the way that you should, but it makes you feel valuable to be needed, and you don't have to get into situations where you have to stand up for yourself against them, or lose a friend, or have to face consequences, not because of sin on your part, but because of what you believe.
SPEAKER_00So here's the question in the last five minutes how can we find some balance? And I think we've got a few things here that can help. Keep in mind all five of these are wrapped around dependency on God, fearing Him alone, praying for His help and support, and to know when it's the right time to assert yourself, when it's the right time to challenge people. There's nothing in this list that should take us away from God. It should all tether to him. Let's go through it quickly. Number one, stop trying to be liked by everyone and start trying to love everyone.
SPEAKER_00This is a huge statement for me personally to consider. And I think for Summer and others as well. You can love someone who dislikes you. You can love them by creating a circumstance that they don't like. You want to be compassionate and accessible and helpful, but act out of love for them and for their soul and for the people around them and make love for them more important than being liked by them. The truth on that is the not being liked thing comes and goes pretty quickly if we are really installing actions of love into one another's lives.
SPEAKER_00Number two, distinguish kindness from compliance. I didn't think of this one. I saw it in some show notes from an episode that I was watching, but I really find it interesting. Kindness seeks a person's good, compliance does whatever the person wants. And sometimes those are very different. A parent may say no, a spouse may disagree, a friend may tell the truth, a servant may set a limit. In that moment, you are not being compliant. Certainly not from the view of the other person who wants something, but you can still be kind, and your no may be the kindest thing that you've ever done.
SPEAKER_00This one takes practice, so replace an automatic sure, of course, with a let me think about whether I can do that well, and I'll get back to you. Okay, number one, stop trying to be liked and just love everyone. Distinguish kindness from compliance. And this third one is enormous. Practically every part of research I was in talked about this. We just have to build tolerance for disappointment. If you're that outgoing spokesman like I am, then practice letting silence sit.
SPEAKER_00Resist explaining yourself twice and accept that not everyone will be impressed. Not everyone will get it. Not everyone will like it. I know those statements to be true, but it's going to take discipline on my part to become in any way comfortable with watching them take place. The reserved person needs to practice stating a preference, making a request of people, or just saying a respectful no without excessive apologies. Someone's disappointment is information about how they feel.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't automatically prove anything about you. Practice on this is pick one small, like low stakes moment this week to tolerate some discomfort or to just say no. Number four, evaluate faithfulness instead of popularity. This one we've talked a lot about, it's purely based in scripture. In 1 Corinthians chapter 4, Paul said, It's not about how you examine me. It's not even about how I examine me, it's about how God sees me. Be true to God first and then accommodative to those around you when possible.
SPEAKER_00But always doing right by God inevitably means that it will not always be possible to please others. The practice on that is just prayer, just praying for the presence of God to be known to you, for you to recognize his nearness and his help and to make sure that he's okay with whatever you choose to do. Number five, keep the strengths, lose the fear. This is big. Remember how we started. There's some good things here. The outgoing person, keep up that enthusiasm and warmth, and engagement and encouragement, but also practice listening and have some restraint and accept a little bit of rejection and be like, that was good.
SPEAKER_00I I didn't like that, but I needed it. So keep some of the good, but also expect some changes that are important. For the reserved person, keep your gentleness, your service, and your thoughtfulness, but also practice some honesty. Not that you're dishonest, but you don't express it enough, asking for things and setting some what we would commonly call healthy boundaries. So I know we've tossed a lot out there today, and I hope that you find some things you can work on. Again, this is all going to be on the website and show notes and all that.
SPEAKER_00I just want to finish with Jesus, close with Jesus, hit you with a few quick takeaways, and hopefully your day will be one of great joy. Jesus noticed and served people, yet he also knew when to withdraw, when to correct, when to challenge, when to say yes, and when to say no. Sometimes he did so in cases that defied society or the religious elite, but he was living for God and to help people. Some takeaways on that. Number one, caring about people is a strength, but being controlled by their opinions is a weakness.
SPEAKER_00Takeaway number two, sometimes we want people to be happy more than we want them to do what is right. It ought not be that way. We know it ought not be that way. And number three, the goal is not to care less about people, it is to fear their disapproval less. So I've got some things to work on here. My personality lends itself to people pleasing, my wife, the sweetest person in the world. We're so different in so many ways, but we have this in common. God has a plan for us to use our qualities for good, and he wants us to keep them and refine them, but also challenge ourselves to do some harder things that may be harder on some people, but that accomplish the good will of the Lord.
SPEAKER_00So walk through these ideas prayerfully, but don't do it all alone. Share this episode with a friend of yours who also fits the description because today we're calling all people pleasers. Thank you once again for listening today. I hope you enjoyed the episode. If you think it can be helpful for someone else, please spread the word. If I can be of any help to you, please reach out to me directly, and I'll do the best I can. Let me just once again remind you of two great men who are available to help you.
SPEAKER_00If you have financial planning needs, call John Cunningham. And if you are looking to get a home loan or refinance or anything of that category, reach out to Tyler Kane. Their phone numbers and emails are in the show notes. Please enjoy your day. Thrive in your freedom in Christ, and in whatever you do, excel still more.
Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! You Really Can Change! Have you ever said, “That’s just the way I am”? Maybe you’ve struggled with anxiety, anger, negative thinking, or...
Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! Check out the brand-new book: How to Find Jesus in the Psalms. Visit our new website with many study resources: ExcelStillMore.life For any future...
Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! Try our New Website! And check out the new book: How to Find Jesus in the Psalms Cunningham Financial and Jon Cunningham have been an amazing...
Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! Check out our New Website: www.excelstillmore.life. You can read the Bible, read articles, listen to podcasts and sermons, check out new books,...
Reach Out: Please include your email and I will get back to you. Thanks! GENESIS, EXODUS, LEVITICUS, NUMBERS, DEUTERONOMY: JESUS BOOKS (Book on Amazon) emersonk78@me.com Excel Still More Journal - Amazon New GENESIS...