Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Entropy Rising

Entropy Rising artwork

Have You Ever Considered That We May Not Need Planets at All?

Oct 5, 202627 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What if planets are actually one of the least efficient places for an advanced civilization to live? In this episode of Entropy Rising, we explore why humanity may eventually move away from planets and build massive space habitats instead. We compare terraforming Mars or Venus with constructing O’Neill cylinders and other artificial habitats, and look at how a mature space economy could use asteroids, Mercury, and other planetary resources to create vastly more living space than planets provide. We also dig into what life inside these habitats could actually look like: customized environments, farms, cities, nature preserves, and entire communities designed from the ground up. Rather than cramped space stations, future habitats could hold anywhere from thousands to millions of people and eventually scale into much larger structures like McKendree cylinders, Bishop rings, and Topopolises. The biggest advantage may be scale. A planet uses most of its mass simply to produce gravity, while that same material could potentially be converted into an enormous number of rotating habitats and far more usable living area. That raises a strange possibility: instead of terraforming planets, future civilizations may harvest them for raw materials and build millions of artificial worlds in space. And once civilization already lives in self-sufficient habitats, interstellar expansion starts to look very different. A habitat can remain a home whether it is orbiting the Sun or spending centuries traveling to another star, making generation ships and distributed interstellar civilizations far more practical. Would you rather live on a planet or inside a massive space habitat? Support the show Website: https://www.entropy-rising.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

But building space habitats is much, much better. We can realistically start doing that today. Would it be ruinously expensive and take more than the GDP of maybe even the entire world to build an O'Neill cylinder right now? Probably. But you could, you could lay the groundwork for that today, is how close we are in technology. Well- Give it another 30, 40, 100 years and that becomes a lot more- achievable. Hello, and welcome to Entropy Rising, a podcast dedicated to discussing future possibilities of humanity and the way we can achieve that through known science.

I'm your host Jacob. . And I'm Lucas, and today we're gonna be talking about why planets might not be the best place for humanity to settle. Yeah, so this is a topic that I think long time channel regulars will be familiar with. Mm-hmm. I mean, I don't know how many times we've said space habitats are the future, uh, but I think it's gonna be nice to actually dive into this a little bit and maybe back up some of our assumptions and talk about why we think the way we do. Yeah. I definitely think that it's a, it's a topic that has a lot of good points as to, um, why humanity would probably prosper better just building out its own space habitats.

Um, the first big one that comes to mind for me is, , terraforming is crazy hard. Yeah, terraforming is extremely expensive, and whenever I talk about on, like, threads or other platforms the future of space, it's kinda one of the biggest counter arguments to living in space is that realistically terraforming takes an insane amount of time. Yeah. I think a lot of people wildly underestimate the actual amount of time it will take to terraform a planet like Mars or Venus. Yeah. People seem to think this happens on, like, human timescales, or maybe, uh, a thousand years at most.

But no, this is gonna be tens if not hundreds of thousands of years. Yeah, I think that people naturally will think about, you know, a project that gets set in motion as something that'll be finished in their lifetime, if not in their lifetime, in the lifetime of someone that they care about, like their children. But the reality of it is if we wanted to settle, like you said, Mars, Even if we had more futuristic technology, it would still take, like you said, at least 10,000 years. Yeah, it's not going to be a fast process. Mm-hmm. And that's really unfortunate for us because the only even close to habitable planet in our solar system is Earth.

Yeah. We don't have anything like it, so if we want to live on an alternative planet, we have exactly two options. Like, well, okay, I guess exactly three options. We have option A, which is terraform one of our local planets- Right either Mars or Venus. Option B, travel to a new star- Mm where there already is a habitable planet that needs much less terraforming, which I actually think would be cheaper and easier than terraforming one of our own planets- Right depending on the density of those types of planets in the galaxy. E- energy-wise, absolutely. Yeah. Even time-wise. I mean, you could potentially get to another solar system within a few hundred years, maybe even a thousand, much faster than terraforming.

Yeah. And then option three, though, is you just build your own planet, which you're not much better off from, uh, building habitats at that point. But you can build a planet. We have a whole episode on it. Well, you know, yeah, we, we have. It's like, but at, at one point, you know, it's like you said, that kinda feels just like a giant habitat. Yeah. It would be, it would be structured towards us. I'm sure that we'd make better use of the inside. Like, it Would it even really be a planet at that point? Yeah, I mean, I, I guess so. I mean, it kinda- It depends on the definition… kinda goes with, like, what we're talking about here, is that human manufactured would be better- Yeah… even in that standard.

That's true, and I mean, realistically, building a planet isn't much different from terraforming a planet on timescales and resource allocation, so. Yeah. And if you're getting your gravity from the sheer mass of the thing- Mm you still need the same amount of material. An Earth-sized artificial planet needs an Earth's worth of mass to work. Yeah. So you're not saving anything there. No. I mean, it, it just, it just proves the point even further. Yeah. That, that, that just human-made would be better. Yeah, so building a planet, probably not. It's doable, but I don't think it's a, a reasonable alternative to settling a planet. Of course.

Uh, when it comes down to either terraforming or traveling, uh, it sounded like there was some debate there, but I think- Depending on how far away it is, traveling to a new star and settling a planet that's much closer to what we need is probably gonna be faster and, if not easier, than terraforming. It, I definitely agree. It probably would be faster. The reason why I believe that, you know, if we were going to go to one, that terraforming would be better is just because they're right next door. That's true. You know? But it's, it's a lot of energy. It is. And if we found a habitable planet for us within five to 10 light years, I think that'd be a lot easier.

I do agree that, that going out and going to a, an outside planet would definitely be better for energy-wise and for labor-wise and time-wise. It all makes more sense there. It's just the only benefit that you get from actually terraforming one of our closer planets is being closer to us. That is true. Being close is really nice. If we want to live on an alternative planet in our solar system, terraforming really is the only way to go. Yeah. And even if you don't wanna terraform, realistically, even if you go to a star, even if you find a reasonably Earth-like planet within a couple of light years of Earth, which is not a guarantee, We don't know how many Earth-like planets there are out there.

Might be a handful in the galaxy, so they could be hundreds of light years away, or they might be relatively common. Probably not relatively common, but, the notion that there might be one close enough to be easy is not guaranteed. It's very possible the next Earth-like planet is hundreds if not thousands of light years away. Yeah. But assuming there was one within 10 light years, that's an option as well. But realistically, Lucas, even if we were to find an Earth-like planet that's within a few light years of our solar system, what are the odds that it's actually, truly 100% Earth-like? Like, it doesn't take much to make it uninhabitable for us, right?

So you're probably still going to have to put in quite a bit of work to make that planet actually habitable for humans, even if it's got roughly the right gravity, temperature, and even atmospheric mix. I mean, if it has 10% CO2 versus our, like,.01%, .02%, that is not habitable for us, and you need to do a lot of work to fix that. Yeah. And that's just one example. No, At the end of the day, it, it just doesn't make sense almost ever. E- even if it is close to Earth-like, like, um, a great example of this exact theory was, uh, Interstellar.

Mm-hmm. You know, when they went, they found a lot of Earth-like planets, but then they go to them and they're ocean worlds with n- you know, skyscraper-sized tsunamis, still frozen planets with, you know, toxic gas around them. Just because they look like they could be Earth-like, mostly made of water, live in a habitable zone of the, the solar system, doesn't mean that, like you said, it's not gonna take… It's still thousands of years of work to make it a groundwork. And then you just have all of these unnecessary risks that you're gonna put your through. Yeah. So I mean, certainly, maybe a long-term project, but in the near term, not something we would do.

Well, it's just like, why? Yeah, why would you? And it's making a lot of assumptions, and it's also, no matter what, a far-off project, 'cause you either need to have the capability of interstellar travel, assuming you find a planet close enough, or you need to terraform a planet. Those are your only two options. Yes. But building space habitats is much, much better. We can realistically start doing that today. Would it be ruinously expensive and take more than the GDP of maybe even the entire world to build an O'Neill cylinder right now? Probably. But you could, you could lay the groundwork for that today, is how close we are in technology.

Well- Give it another 30, 40, 100 years and that becomes a lot more- achievable. Yeah. I mean, that's… You said the big word right there. It's just the groundwork. Yeah, exactly. Right? Building up the, Infrastructure and the ability to be able to mass produce these O'Neill cylinders, because once we have our economy built to get into and out of space easily, whether it's through, you know, um, a ring around the planet or a space elevator or whatever you need to do to make that more readily accessible, once we have that groundwork laid out, we can s- start pumping these things out. Like, O'Neill cylinders, you know, you, you can master them and then just start producing them in space factories, and that would really make just everything seem a lot more approachable for us as, as a civilization.

And I feel like that's where this topic really comes from, is thinking about, well, if we're able to make these and completely fill our solar system with the perfect way to live that we've designed ourselves where we can build food on them and have entire civilizations integrated within each other, bouncing back and forth from these O'Neill cylinders, why do the risk and take the long journey and the arduous, you know, trek to try and colonize or terraform a planet to begin with? Yeah, I think you hit a lot of major points there, and I do wanna touch on one of them, which you talked about having basically cheap access to orbit- Mm-hmm through something like an orbital ring, space elevator, what have you.

I do think that's a huge bonus. If you have that, things are easier. Right. However, I don't strictly think it's required. Okay. Because once you are able to get the first factories into space, you can then source resources from, like, asteroids or other places, and then bootstrap that economy and get going. You don't need to launch all that material off of Earth. Yes, you need to launch, like, the initial bit, but you need to launch that anyways to build an orbital ring or a space elevator. So, uh, I think you can actually get to the point of building O'Neill cylinders even without that cheap and ready access to orbit, with just reusable rockets would presumably be enough.

Yeah. I definitely think that it's possible. It's just sourcing the material is one thing, but then sourcing the people to go up there would be another one. Yeah, but the thing is with people, they're kind of self-reproducing, so once you hit a certain critical mass, then you don't need to bring more up unless they wanna go. That is true. Yeah. I mean, it would still take a couple hundred years. Yes. This is not gonna be fast, no matter what. Yeah. And you're gonna have to have a lot of orbital economy already ongoing to build something like an O'Neill cylinder anyways. Right. These can house between, like, 10,000 and a million people, depending on the density. Uh, but that's all just to say that actually building these and getting the first ones up, not going to be something we have to wait forever on.

We can really get that ball rolling relatively soon. Yeah. And to move on from that there, and talk about why you would wanna do it and how it's going to be, is once you actually start building these, you can make them whatever you want. I know we've touched on this in our O'Neill episode, and some other… Like, I think we did one on ring worlds as well. Mm. The benefit of cylinders, and space habitats in general, it's infinite customizability. You can make this a, a park, like a national reserve. You can put endangered species on it, and it's a very controlled environment.

You can make this, like, a, a farm town with, like, 10,000 people on a several-kilometer-long ring that's, you know, about four kilometers in diameter. That's a lot of living area. Everyone can have their own acre of land. Or you can make this as dense as New York City, and have a million people on this thing. You know, the, the options you have are unlimited, and you can just keep cranking them out and keep making them. This doesn't need to be some, like, cramped, harsh living environment, like some people seem to think that it does. Yeah, no. I, I think that people naturally get that idea in their mind because it's like you think of tight spaces, tight corridors, when you're trying to design something to be able to fit, you know, in some sense, like you said, as many people as possible, if that's its objective.

But that doesn't mean that, like you said, again, doesn't mean that it needs to be cramped. It can be modular. It can have things added to it as it's growing. That way, you know, yes, maybe your, your family gets bigger, and then you wanna move to something bigger. It doesn't mean that they need to put another building next to you. It just means that they have to add another segment to the cylinder. . Yeah, you can absolutely expand these, or what I think is more realistic is you'll just make new ones as you go. You know, you build one, and you start it off half full, and then once it starts reaching a point where the population density is becoming too much, you just commission and start building another one.

And these don't need to just be O'Neill cylinders. There's all kinds of different space habitats you can build. Rather, it's the O'Neill cylinder's bigger brother, a McKendree cylinder, which is roughly 1,000 kilometers in diameter- Mm-hmm or using the same thing to make a ringworld and getting, like, a Bishop ring. Or you could potentially even do a topolosis. Topolosis, Jesus. Um The populace? The populace Akumenopoulos? No. Aquapolis.

It's like a topolysis or something. No, not another one. It's okay. Topolysis, it's basically an annual cylinder that wraps around the sun Topopoulos Topopoulos. See, I was close You were Yeah, so what'd I say? There's like- So you could see… You said it could be like, um- Yeah like a McKendree cylinder or… Yeah, there are a bunch of different options.

You can do, like, the O'Neill cylinder's bigger brother, which is a McKendree cylinder, which is roughly 1,000 kilometers in diameter. Uh, you can do a Bishop ring, which is effectively a ring version of the McKendree cylinder, or even a Topopolis, which is effectively, like, a O'Neill cylinder that wraps, like, around a star, or you can even do, like, around a gas giant as well. Mm. Um, there's a lot of options for space structures and for living in space, and they don't need to be these cramped stations that people seem to think they will be. That's a great starting point, a small little ring just to, to house a couple hundred people for the first type of station.

Yeah. But eventually, once you start building these things out, just the infinite customizability is really hard to get around. Yeah, You need that efficiency in the beginning because it's very expensive to get started off. But, uh, as you build out and go vaster and vaster and the technology gets better and you work out all the kinks and then you have the infrastructure built out, why not build them up to a… I mean, there's o- only a certain point that you can build O'Neill cylinders out to, to where they aren't effective anymore, but- At least in diameter, but in- Yeah … in length. In, in length, yeah, they could go forever. Yeah. Yeah, but, you know, it's still a wide open space that, that will remind you similar to, like, the sky when, when you're in, uh, one of them, and they can even do things to replicate it.

Yeah, like, there's this whole idea of putting an inner tube that would replicate the sky. Um, it's not crazy to do, and it actually looks pretty nice, and I think you would get used to it relatively quickly. Yeah. Having your horizon go up over the sides would probably be an adjustment, but… It, it would only be a problem for one generation or maybe two, and then after nobody remembers what a planet's like, it doesn't matter anymore. Yeah, it's kinda what I liked about The Expanse. Most people have never even been on a planet. But I would say how they depicted space living was a little more bleak than how we imagine things like O'Neill cylinders with a bright open sky, and, and they actually look quite nice.

Well, I feel like that's also kind of the root of it 'cause whenever you see, uh, you know, science fiction, it's always a cramped quarter on a ship. O'Neill cylinders were very rarely depicted except for, I feel like, in Interstellar they depicted one pretty well. They did, and they had it, like this idealistic farm scene as well. Mm-hmm. So I thought that was actually a nice depiction of it as well. Yeah. So if you guys are looking for a reference of, you know, what we're talking about, that's a great one to go to. Yeah, that's one I've seen a lot. Although it only shows up for a couple, Yeah, a couple seconds, and it's a little bit smaller than I imagine an actual one would be, but it's still… You can build them that small though.

Yeah. No, you can, yeah, effectively build them relatively small. I think, like, the limit's, um, like 50 or 100 meters or something like that. Mm-hmm. Uh, you can get pretty small before the, the spinning starts to cause issues for you. Yes, yeah. it's a lot of different things that we can do as humanity to make it not just comfortable, but, like, excellent living. Yeah, absolutely. And then I guess the, the main benefit, too, of expanding off of your world and onto these cylinders is just the sheer amount of living space you can get for the mass you have available in your solar system. Like for example, Earth, right?

Mm-hmm. I'm gonna use this as a reference. Uh, right now Earth has exactly one Earth worth of living space on it. Right. Not much you can do to get around that. But if you were to deconstruct the planet- Mm-hmm and use those raw materials to make O'Neill cylinders, I think you get something like a million or 10 million times the surface area, because you can use every single piece of that matter to build the spinning structure. Like, most of the matter on Earth is just going to giving us gravity. It's underneath our feet, right? Right. Uh, but if you actually use that to make O'Neill cylinders, you get so much more living area.

Wow. Now, to be clear, I'm not saying we should actually dismantle Earth. Of course. I think we should, we should keep it. But when you're talking about planets like Mars, Venus, Mercury, where you have to look at do we want to terraform these, or do we wanna harvest those materials and turn it into effectively exponentially more living space, and easier living space, especially in the case of Mercury, where there's no atmosphere, and it's super easy to get material off planet 'cause it has low gravity. I mean, that's, y- you know, so much resources. If you mine out Mercury, turn that into O'Neill cylinders, you're gonna get more living space than Earth from a planet that's tiny.

Yeah. if you ask me, yeah, we should keep Earth to, you know, have it as, like the place where we started, but take apart everything else. Yeah, you don't need it. And- Take it all. And surprisingly, 'cause I know this question's gonna come up, I've talked about it on threads, removing planets like Mercury, Venus, even Jupiter, doesn't really have an effect on Earth's orbit. No. Uh, people seem to think it does, but it really doesn't. I mean, there's a small effect. They do perturb Earth a bit, but it's not going to have… It's not gonna, like… Earth's gonna go flying out of its orbit if you were to remove those planets, right? No. No, I mean, we, we keep our moon.

Yes. No, keep the moon. Don't- Um, and, and we, we keep the stars, right? Uh- Well, if you're going and getting stars, we're in a… we're playing a whole different ballgame at that point. Well, of course. Well, you know, my, my main vision, right, is, like a grid in a three-dimensional space that is just entirely made up of O'Neill cylinders. Just, just like, like, like as far as the eye can see in all directions, uh, it is O'Neill cylinders. And that, you know, that, that of course is a crazy idea, but if you wanted to be space efficient, that would be the right thing to do. But yes, we, we leave our planet, We, we leave our moon. It's going to make the astrology people upset that we stole their other planets- … 'cause now they can't read their signs.

But, it is effective for us to just take all of that material and turn it into the most living space possible. Yeah, you can absolutely do that, and it also just lets you live near where other resources are. If you wanna be by Jupiter, you can put O'Neill cylinders there. If you wanna go to another star system, you can put O'Neill cylinders there. I mean, these really are a one-size-fit-all solution. It Doesn't have to be O'Neill cylinders, but they're the one that we talk about a lot. Yeah. And I mean, for good reason. They, they are the most effective. Yeah. And I think, you know, I'm actually gonna make a bold claim here. I do think at some point, uh, in the far future, of course, we are eventually going to cross a threshold where more people live in space on habitats than live on planets.

Well, we'll, we'll have to eventually. Or it's either that or just stop reproducing as much. Um, but- Yeah, which we are kinda hitting a plateau in our population, so that's possible. Well, you know, when you put a koi fish in a small pond, it doesn't grow bigger. Yeah, so and that's kinda what I think too. Once you make these cheap and readily accessible, people will move into them, and they'll naturally expand and split and divide. Yeah. And the nice thing is, I mean, it's redundancy too. Once you have your civilization off of a single planet and diversified into thousands to millions of O'Neill cylinders, the odds of you being extinct to that point are, are nil, right?

It's almost zero, especially if you can move those to another star system. Oh, yeah. No, I mean, a, a catastrophe will still strike every once in a while, but you have 100 more of the same that harbor the same amount of people. I mean, that's, that's it. Humanity has taken that next step into its foothold, and we've surpassed that great filter. Yeah, absolutely. So that, that really does move on to that next step. And the nice thing too is once you accept that you're gonna live off of a planet, and especially if you build up these vibrant living communities of space habitats, then taking it a step further and decoupling yourself from our star and going interstellar also just becomes so much easier.

Yeah, no, I mean, that's, that, that, that is crazy because at that point we've become a, an interstellar, you know, civilization, which, um, es- essentially immortalizes you until the end of the universe- Yeah, effectively … if you can do it effectively. Yeah, effectively. Once you reach a few stars, the odds of you collapsing… Well, I should say once you reach a few stars and you're self-sufficient at those stars, you've made it. I mean, the odds of there being a big enough event to knock your species out are next to zero, I would say. Like you said, you're gonna make it to almost the end of time. Yeah. And that's what I kinda like about this because if you're already living in these habitats, then the notion of a several hundred year voyage to another star, well, you're gonna spend several hundred years in these cylinders anyways, right?

Like, your civilization is already existing in these habitats, So what difference does it make to you if that habitat is orbiting our sun or if it's drifting to a new star? Yeah. I mean, it would, it would make relatively none. You could tell the people no difference, uh, that, whether you're traveling or not. I personally would like to know- Yeah if we're, if we're moving 'cause then I get to celebrate or my, my fourth generation does, uh, that we've made it to a new system, you know, hooray. But life would be the same. It would be like when humanity started, um, you know, several hundred thousand years ago, and you know, and finally we reached a new star system today.

Everybody would be like, "Oh, yeah, that's right." "We were doing that." And many people are probably gonna choose to stay in their cylinders and just… You know, some might go and live on the planet- Mm …but I think it would actually be a pretty slow start. People are gonna stay to what they know. And you don't need to just send one. In fact, I really don't think you would send just one. I think you would effectively send a group of these to any given destination. Yeah. Maybe a few hundred of them. So- Send a community. Yeah, basically send a community. That way you really do have a diverse representation of society, and you have, more importantly, uh, options to move.

You might be on more of, like an agricultural setup that, kinda like what we saw in Interstellar, like farmland rural, and you might get sick of that and decide to move to the city. And there might be several of these in your fleet that have densities of major cities, and so you can move to those, just like how you or I could move to New York, London, or anything else. Yeah. And then they have, like, the, the one that's like a geriatric- … uh, community. you know? Where it's like, like they- It's Florida. Yeah, it's Florida. They, they have the Florida cylinder with the gator attacks. representing the hurricanes will be tricky- Yeah … but I think we can make it happen, yeah.

With the Everglades. Yeah. After a storm on the cylinder. But when you start, to me, thinking about sending hundreds of these things to a new star, and you have the options to move between them, then i- it makes interstellar travel just sound like a non-issue. Like, you're really sending a whole self-sustained civilization at that point. And when you get there, people deciding to move to the planet will be no different than people deciding to move between cylinders, or people deciding to branch off and make their own cylinder. Yeah. I mean, it's because it makes time a non-issue.

It's like, Why would you care? Uh, because you're going to be living your life anyways. So, yeah, I, I think just another, you know, cherry on top to why living interstellarly just opens up so many more possibilities for us. You know, it immortalizes us, and we can just travel to wherever we want without people caring that they're spending their lives doing so. Yeah, yeah. I think you kinda hit it too. It's like you're going to be on one of these regardless, so why would you care? And presumably, these could be even better than the Earth you left. I mean, depending on how things go with our climate, uh, you might decide you actually really do wanna live in a cylinder versus living on a planet.

Yeah. I mean, mean, you know, it is nice to at least give people the option. Maybe we have cryostasis done by then, and it's like, "Okay, planet goers in whatever generation, generation 70 of this trip, uh, if you wanna live on the planet, you go in there." Yeah, I guess you- Cryo-chamber… you could also presumably see that who decide they wanna branch off from humanity and explore the stars. Maybe a way they fund that voyage is they say, "Look, we wanna do this anyways, but anyone who wants to be the first human to live on a new planet, uh, we'll freeze you. We'll have cryostasis, and we'll carry you as sleeping cargo, while we'll continue to run, maintain our civilization, maintain the cylinder, and we'll drop you off when you get to your new destination." Yeah.

And that could be the way that they fund the launch of this because to them, who cares? Like, like I said, you're gonna live in the cylinder anyways. If, if I have decided to make my life on the cylinder and, uh, I'm gonna live here forever, why do I care, like I said, where it orbits? Yeah, I mean, exactly. It's like, might as well if you have, you know, so much plenty and your civilization is so well established. Um, and you have this ability to give people the option to freeze and do what they would wanna do. Because, you know, naturally not everybody's gonna wanna live on a cylinder. Yeah. You know? Pe- people will feel connected to planets or have different preferences.

so why not just give them that option and, you know, use it like you said, as something to help fund the venture. Yeah, I guess I think it really depends though because you're saying that now as someone who's always lived on a planet, but if you grew up on one, you might not think that way. You might think, "Who would ever wanna leave?" Granted, some people will always be different, but… Well, think, think about us, for example. Would you like to live on an O'Neill cylinder? I'd like to give it a try. You didn't spend your whole life on one. Yeah. Yet I would wanna live on one. But what I'm saying is,. Everyone already lives on a planet. Right. And there's already people open to it. So imagine what happens when you're several generations into these cylinders.

And people love them and stay on them, right? No, no, I know. I mean, it does make sense, but I'm just saying, like, even if it goes ag- Like, it has a shift, and it goes against the grain to live on a planet, um, there will still be people that will wanna do it. Yeah, no, for sure, for sure. Guess it depends on the planet, but- Yeah yeah. No, it does. But just having the ability to go back and forth like, "Oh, maybe we're taking a vacation down to, you know, Parsec Five." Oh, man. Uh, I do think that you, you are right. I think there are a certain amount of people who might feel an attachment to the system. And even though it theoretically wouldn't matter if you're orbiting our star or drifting toward a new one, some people might not feel comfortable with that.

And it might be a psychological toll if you're moving away from the, our home solar system. So there are exceptions, of course. Yeah. But I think especially as you start expanding into, like, a K2 civilization, you have so much population that even a tiny subset of a population is hundreds of millions of people potentially. Yeah, enough to populate a planet. And the best thing about having these space habitats is options. Mm-hmm. You don't wanna leave the solar system, then don't. You know, you can stay here for another 150 million years as it fills with more and more space habitats.

But if you wanna go somewhere else, then you start your journey. If you wanna be the one who arrives there, you go into cryosleep. The, the, the world is yours. And once we, like you said, enter that K2 civilization, it just gives you so much opportunity to do whatever it is that you want. absolutely. So I've always been a fan of it. I've said it multiple times in the show. I think that space habitats and living off-planet just makes more sense in the long run. And presumably, planets will always play a role in humanity, but they're probably gonna be rare and far and few in between- Mm-hmm at least ones we can actually utilize.

And so when we're actually looking at the stars, I think a more practical way to look at it is, and either O'Neill cylinders, rings, what have you. Yeah. yeah. I mean, it, it makes sense to me. I have no, no disagreeance with that. I would be, uh, you know, open to hearing what people have to say, but- Yeah, please comment. Let us know what you think. Would you live on an O'Neill cylinder, or do you think planets are always going to be an integral part of humanity's expansion into space like so much science fiction shows? Yeah. Except for the Culture series. The Culture series I think actually kinda hit it right.

Most people do not live on planets in the Culture series. Most of them live in space habitats. Well, there you go. Maybe they're onto something. Yeah. Granted, these space habitats have more living area than your normal planet. Uh, they're very large. Banks' orbitals are not small. Yeah. But they're ring worlds bigger than a star But most people don't live on planets. Yeah. I mean- Which is a future we might see, too. Why would you when you could live on a cool star ring world? Sounds awesome. Uh, do you have anything else you wanna add? No, no. It was a, it was a fun episode, and I enjoyed this one.

Yeah, me too. So please let us know what you think in the comments, and please join us next week, where we're gonna be discussing how you would actually go about building a Dyson swarm and whether that would happen by accident. Yeah, yeah. Kinda ties in with this episode a little bit, so it should be fun. Yeah, should be a fun topic. If you enjoy the show, please consider liking, subscribing on your podcast platform of choice. If you love the show, you can always support us on Patreon, and we appreciate all the people who already do that. Have a great rest of your day, and thanks for listening. Take care.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Boarding a Spaceship Is Harder Than You Think

    Nov 15, 202640 minAudio

    How do you capture an enemy spaceship without destroying it? Boarding actions are a staple of science fiction, but how realistic are they? In the vacuum of space, getting aboard an enemy vessel might be the easy part....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Would Immortality Lead to a Stagnant Civilization

    Nov 9, 202630 minAudio

    What happens to civilization when people can live for hundreds or even thousands of years? Life extension could transform humanity, but it also raises some difficult questions. If people no longer die of old age, what...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Lofstrom Loops and the Physics of Actively Supported Structures

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    What if we could build structures that reach into space without relying on the strength of steel or concrete? From Lofstrom loops capable of launching spacecraft into orbit to towers stretching 100 kilometers into the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What Will Technology Make Possible in 100 Years?

    Oct 26, 202638 minAudio

    What will technology look like in 100 years? By 2126, advances in artificial intelligence, biotechnology, energy storage, and space exploration could fundamentally transform how we live. In this episode of Entropy...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How Stars Work: The Physics of Fusion, Gravity, and Death

    Oct 19, 202635 minAudio

    How do stars work, what powers nuclear fusion, and why do some stars survive for trillions of years while others burn out in just a few million? In this episode of Entropy Rising, we take a deep dive into the physics of...

    Credit the people on this episode