Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Entropy Rising

Entropy Rising artwork

Lofstrom Loops and the Physics of Actively Supported Structures

Nov 2, 202634 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

What if we could build structures that reach into space without relying on the strength of steel or concrete? From Lofstrom loops capable of launching spacecraft into orbit to towers stretching 100 kilometers into the sky, actively supported structures could fundamentally change what's possible in engineering. Support us on Pateron :https://www.patreon.com/c/EntropyRising In this episode of Entropy Rising, Jacob and Lucas explore the physics of active support, an engineering concept that uses continuously moving mass and momentum to support structures that would otherwise collapse under their own weight. We start with the Lofstrom loop, a proposed 2,000-kilometer-long launch system suspended approximately 80 kilometers above Earth. By accelerating a continuous loop of material to incredible speeds, this structure could potentially launch people and cargo toward orbit while dramatically reducing the need for rocket propulsion. We also explore Atlas pillars, skyscrapers that could theoretically extend into space, and actively supported bridges capable of spanning enormous distances without conventional supports. How would these structures actually work? Could we build them using today's technology? And what happens if the systems keeping them standing suddenly lose power? Join us as we explore the fascinating physics, engineering challenges, and potential applications of actively supported megastructures. Support the show Website: https://www.entropy-rising.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

if you can imagine it, it's basically a pipe that is 2,000 kilometers long suspended 80 kilometers in the sky with a chain that's moving inside of it v- very, very fast. Have to be a big chain. It, it would, yeah. It'd have to be a big chain, and it also moves… Like, I cannot undersell how fast this thing has to move. That is probably the biggest downside with this. Like, that chain moves, I think it's, like, 10 kilometers a second. Much faster than orbital velocity. Hello, and welcome to Entropy Rising, a show that talks about science, the future, and technology. I'm your host, Jacob. And I'm Lucas, and today we're going to be talking about actively supported structures.

Yeah. I'm excited for this. you know that I'm absolutely obsessed with actively supported structures. Yes, yeah. You… Pretty much anything that's, that's crazy and, you know, requires a lot of physics and, you know, engineering. Yeah, that does kinda draw my brain into it. And we did an episode on orbital rings, which is my favorite type of actively supported structure- Yeah … and I think one of the most crazy use cases. But there are other ways that you can use these and other advantages to having these, and, um, doing active support compared to just normal passive support opens up a lot of doors for things that would otherwise seem, like, impossible.

Yeah. No, I know that we got a lot of comments on that, t- of people talking about all the different kinds of structures and stuff that you could use instead. So I'm really excited to hear about some of, you know, the other Yeah, we're definitely gonna dive into those. We're gonna talk about Lofstrom loops, Atlas pillars, and some other more kinda mundane structures you can do with it. But I guess really quickly, I kinda wanna talk about what active support is and, and define some terms a little bit before we move on. I think that that's fair because I'm not even super clear on it myself, so it could definitely be helpful. Yeah, I mean, really it's, it's a pretty simple term, right?

So non-active support, I guess passive support, would be what we use today to support structures, either the tensile strength or the compressive strength of the material, right? Mm-hmm. Like, when you build a skyscraper, you're just using the compressive sh- strength of steel, iron, concrete. Right. And when you build a bridge, like the Golden Gate Bridge, right, that's a tension bridge, you're just using the tensile strength of iron. Right. So an actively supported structure is a system where you're not just relying on compressive or tensile strength, you're actually in some way, shape, or form putting energy into that system to support the structure.

I see. So you're using a constant force to, you know, act on it. Yeah, exactly. And that's typically momentum, right? Mm-hmm. So I saw a really cool analogy for it is if you fire, like, a cannonball, that's going to take like a parabola, right? Right. If you force that cannonball to not take that parabola, if you, like, put a ramp over it, for example, and make it go to a shallower path, that cannonball would put force on that ramp. And if you were to fire a cannonball every few seconds or multiple cannonballs a second, that ramp could then be supported on that chain of cannonballs underneath it.

Right. The momentum of the cannonballs is effectively supporting the s- the ramp, and that's, that's all that goes on with the inactively supported structures. Yeah, I mean it's, it's a really cool, you know, concept for being able to keep something either, like, orbiting or, or floating. You know, w- would, like, rocket propulsion technically be actively supported as well? Yeah, I mean, you could definitely do that. We've talked about it in terms of, like, um, I think when we were talking about orbital rings. Not orbital rings. I think when we were talking about, uh, giant rings, you could theoretically put rockets on the outside and fire them inwards to keep it from flying apart.

Yeah. That is a form of active support. I think that's an incredibly, um, challenging way to do it, right? 'Cause that's … You gotta put fuel into the system. Right. But yeah, that, that's an active support ex- example as well. Okay, yeah. So then, I mean that, that definitely makes sense. And what was the structure that we talked about that essentially used, uh, not … And you know, of course not cannonballs, but, um, high velocity projectiles essentially riding across its surface. I mean, that's an orbital ring, effectively. Oh. 'Cause that's, that's one of the main structures that we talk about with active support, right?

An orbital ring is just instead of firing the cannonball in a parabola- Mm-hmm… you have the cannonball in an so it wants to move into a higher orbit, but it's restrained by this basically hoop, this track. And that supplies force to keep the ring from collapsing inwards. Well, there you go. Yeah. so if that's like the main one that we're talking about, what are some of these other structures, and how do they actively support themselves? Yeah. Actually, one that we didn't really discuss in the orbital ring episode that is, I think, maybe a predecessor to orbital rings, and to me is amazing, is called a Lofstrom loop.

Okay. Um, which is just the name of the guy who came up with it, but a better way to think about it, it's just a, a, a launch loop. It's a way that you can build a structure to accelerate, uh, a payload off of the ground in, in, uh, to an orbital velocity on Earth. So the, the core idea of the Lofstrom loop is it's a, a very long track, right? Uh, I believe like 2,000 kilometers, and it goes 80 kilometers in the air. Now, if you try to build a track this big, you really can't. There's no material that could hold a structure 80 kilometers up for 2,000 miles, right?

Right. And that's where the active support comes in. Because what you effectively do, you can imagine this as a basically a pipe where you evacuate all the air, and then inside of that pipe, you have an iron chain. Uh, more like an iron rope, right? And then the, the outer tube, the sheath, has magnets that repulse against that iron loop. Right. And then you bring that iron loop up to speed, and again, just like our cannonball example, or actually kinda like a, uh, a rope thrower, like the little toys. I saw one at a science museum. Uh, yeah, it's like if you take a, a string, right?

Mm-hmm. If you accelerate it, you can actually point it up and, and the whole rope will go up in the sky. Oh, yes, yes. I've seen those. Yeah, they're kinda cool, and that's basically all this is. So instead of string, it's an iron rope, and you accelerate it extremely fast inside this vacuum tube, and then the tube uses magnets to suspend itself off of that chain. that would be crazy. Yeah, so the net end of this is, if you can imagine it, it's basically a pipe that is 2,000 kilometers long suspended 80 kilometers in the sky with a chain that's moving inside of it v- very, very fast.

Have to be a big chain. It, it would, yeah. It'd have to be a big chain, and it also moves… Like, I cannot undersell how fast this thing has to move. That is probably the biggest downside with this. Like, that chain moves, I think it's, like, 10 kilometers a second. Much faster than orbital velocity. So the first thing that comes to my mind with that is m- maintenance. Right. You definitely need to be on top of your maintenance. But the, the magnets and stuff, these are all, like, solid state, so other than the, the wear of the chain, uh, there isn't a ton surprisingly. And the chain, the, the turnaround points are huge.

And so the, the reason you make them very large in diameter so you're not pinching the chain, and so that it can slow down. You don't have as much, like, momentum trying to do a sharp turn. Right. Um, so if you stay within reasonable fatigue limits of that chain, um, everything else is mostly solid state. Yeah. I mean, it's… The, the mechanisms I'm sure, as individuals are very, you know, solid in their, in their construction and the way that they interact with each other. But it's just, like, once that chain starts, it can't stop. That is true. So if you stop the chain, the whole structure's gonna collapse. Right. That being said, if you did wanna do maintenance on it, you've got two options.

Basically, you could have redundancy. You could have multiple chains and spin one up while the other one's spinning down to maintain that force. That way you could take it out and repair it. Alternatively, you could design the structure to be taken down when it needs repair. I mean, it's very possible that you just design it so that when you're ready to repair the chain, you just slowly start bleeding off momentum, and it'll just lower back to the ground. Oh, yeah. No, you're absolutely right. Uh, it's… I mean, I guess, yeah, that's how it would work is as you reduce momentum, it would lose that force that keeps it moving, and you just… Mm.

Yeah, exactly, and that's actually how we talk about building it too. You build this thing on the ground, and then you actually start speeding up the chain, and that provides the lifting force to get it up into the air. that fixes probably most of my problems Because we would just be using this to what? Lift, I guess, people and, you know, not products, um, material off of Earth. Actually, yeah, people and, and materials. That's actually why the, the design characteristics are what they are. So this is 2,000 kilometers long, right? And the reason for that is that you would effectively build this thing and use it as a launch loop.

So you would take your cargo package, and you would accelerate it along this loop up to 80 kilometers high, and then you would use it to get lateral velocity across the surface of the earth- Mm and launch into an orbit. And the reason it's so long is because one of the biggest issues with trying to design a launch system that doesn't use rockets is acceleration. A lot of people talk about, uh, launch loops as an alternative, right, to, to rockets. Right. But the issue is the human body can only withstand so much G-force. And so even this example, this 2,000-kilometer-long track, it was designed to be that long because you can do a steady 3G of acceleration and reach orbital velocity.

If you tried to make it any shorter, you would need to increase the G-force, and that would start to become either unbearable or, at a certain point, just unlivable for human cargo. Yeah, But we could make smaller ones to launch non-human cargo. Yeah, absolutely. And there's already a company, Spin Launch Systems, that basically, like, just centrifuges stuff. Have you seen what they do? No. It, it's literally, like, an arm, and they, they mount their r- rocket to it and just spin it at an insanely high velocity and let go of it. And it just, like, throws the rocket up into the sky.

Oh my God. And, and they use that to, like, do a lot of their launch. And then I'm sure they have rockets to circularize it. But if I'm not mistaken, the, the cargo experiences an insanely high G-force when they do that, obviously. Oh, yeah. I mean, it would have to. But the takeoff is, like, the most fuel extensive part of the, you know, the entire lifting. So if you can remove that, you know… And we, we've talked about this in, in other ways, uh, in other episodes, but just being able to remove- Trying to get off of the planet to start with is, saves you so much fuel. Yeah, uh, you're right, and there's two big issues, is that an orbit is just lateral velocity.

Uh, getting up to the height is a very small amount of that energy, but the issue is you're starting on the ground in this very thick atmosphere. So the Lofstrom Loop kind of removes that issue because you start 80 kilometers up in the sky. Uh, the air is much thinner. It removes that problem. And then the- the length of the loop is designed to provide you the lateral velocity you need at a steady 3 G of acceleration. So it kind of solves both of those issues. Yeah. No, I mean, it's- it's, uh, a really cool concept. God, that- that would be a crazy structure. It would be, like, absolutely crazy to see.

But I would say, compared to like an orbital ring, this is kind of a first step for building out that orbital economy, right? Like, it works on the same mechanism as an orbital ring, and it would potentially substantially reduce the cost of getting into orbit. Um, but you don't need that same commitment, and the failure modes are nowhere near as bad either. Yeah. No, I mean, that- that is true. Like- like, you're not actually building a structure in space. It's like you said, we're building a structure that we can just build on the ground and then spin it up. You know, you're not having to have all of this infrastructure put into space first before starting it.

Yeah, and that's the big thing. 'Cause like an orbital ring, like you said, has to be built in space. Yeah. So you already need, uh, an orbital economy set up just to build the thing. But this Lofstrom Loop is built on the ground. I mean, we- we could theoretically build it today. There's nothing stopping you. It's not any new physics. It's not any crazy materials. Like, everything incorporated into the design exists now and today. Yeah, I mean, I'm just trying to think of, like, the mechanisms that would be required. Because I'm- well, I'm envisioning this cable, and I'm- I know that you can't really see it from the camera, but I'm imagining it's at least as wide as this room, if- if not, you know, larger.

I think the- the original design, the cable was, like, two inches in diameter. What? Yeah, it was not very large at all. Two inches? Yeah, the, the whole system was not very large. Oh my God. Yeah, so not as big as you would think. Now, there, there is a trade-off. So when we're talking about actively supported structures in general, the more mass you wanna support, you've got two levers you can pull to change that. Either you're moving momentum, needs to be m- more momentum, more mass, so you could have a, a thicker, heavier cable- Right… or it needs to move faster.

So those are the two parameters you can change. If you wanna do a lighter cable, it needs to move faster. If you wanna move slower, you need to have more mass in the system. Okay. But you can play with those two parameters as much as you want. So, you know, this is typically talked about operating, I think, like I said, 10 kilometers a second, which is extremely fast. Uh, but if you wanted to lower that, reduce that speed, you theoretically could by using a more massive cable, but that, of course, in a moving system, presents other issues. Yeah. That's crazy. A supported structure on a two-inch cable just sounds insane to me.

Yeah, I mean, there's a lot of momentum in the system. It, it moves extremely fast, and, um, the w- the way it launches is actually kinda crazy, too, because the, the proposed mechanism for launching these rockets was that your capsule or your rocket would actually induce eddy currents in the moving cable, and that would create an, uh, attractive force and pull it along with the cable, and that's what you would actually… You basically take momentum out of the system to accelerate your, your rocket up to speed. Yeah, I mean, you, you might as well, especially if you have enough momentum left over to still support the structure, then just take the energy that's already been applied into that and use it.

Yeah. Uh, yeah, exactly. So, uh, basically the, the way I kinda think about it is it's like magnetic drag, right? Like, it's kinda that effect… Have you ever seen where people will take a magnet and drop it down a copper tube and the magnet falls super slow? Yeah. Yeah, those… That's because it induces eddy currents as it falls, so you're using that same effect to drag your capsule along this loop when you're ready to go. I see. Yeah, so it's, it's like, um, I know roller coasters use that for braking as well. I think they just use, like… Yeah, I think so. Yeah. Yeah. I think they just induce eddy currents- Mm-hmm … on a magnet, and that's how they brake.

Yeah. Because it makes it fr- much softer, so it's just… Yeah, I mean, that's… We, we might as well just take technology that we're already using and flip it and- Yeah launch rockets. That's actually… It's also used in your, uh, power meter, uh, on the back of your house that measures eddy currents. The faster that moves, the stronger the eddy currents. That makes sense. Yeah. I can't remember exactly how those work, but there's, like, spinning discs, or they all work through eddy currents. It's really interesting. Yeah. That's why you've seen people, uh, maybe try to put a magnet on the- … the power meter to, to trick the power. Don't do that, by the way. That's very illegal, and if your power company finds you… But that's, that's the idea.

You can put a magnet on that, and that messes with eddy currents, and makes it harder to meter. Yeah, guys, don't do that. I'm definitely not gonna go home and try. You will get a hefty fine from your utility. And also, you need an insanely powerful magnet, and I don't think it works on modern boxes. Mm. But the old boxes, that, that used to be the trick. Huh. I know somebody who went and put a fridge magnet on theirs once. Oh, God. No, you need, like, an actual insanely powerful magnet. This is so cool to know. Robbery tips with Jake and Lucas this is not legal advice.

but yeah, that's, that's kind of the, the breakdown of the Lofstrom Loop. It's… The whole point is to be an orbital launch system where your rocket just doesn't really need to be much of a rocket. You will need to carry some fuel. Like, it still does kinda need to be a rocket, because this is only launching you into, uh, well, for one, an 80-kilometer orbit, and two, you're gonna need to, once you get up, you're gonna need to circularize that orbit and things like that. But for a system to get mass, material, and people off the ground and into low Earth orbit, this is, I think, a very realistic first step and something we should look at doing.

Yeah, no. I mean, it's, it's great. It's, it just… All that you have to prioritize is maneuverability. Like, for as far as fuel goes, you can cut the size of rockets in half, cut the size of the payloads in half, or just replace that with people or material. I think I read that, um, one of the, the parameters for this, they were looking at rockets that only needed to carry 500 meters per second of delta V, compared to a typical rocket, which needs, like, 7,000 meters per second. Yeah. So it dramatically cuts down on the fuel requirements. You, once you're actually in orbit and above the atmosphere, you don't really need a lot of delta V to maneuver and to circularize things.

So it, it cuts down on that a lot. Yeah, it's, it's absolutely amazing. Now, there are, of course, non-active support launch loops as well. Those generally involve building a huge ramp and then building it up a mount- a mountain, so that you can get above the atmosphere. Uh, but I, I personally favor the Lofstrom Loop because I just think it's so elegant. The energy's already in the system. Uh, you build it outside… not outside of the atmosphere, but in the higher parts of the atmosphere, where there's not a lot of air resistance. And to me, it's just, it's such a beautiful and elegant solution. Yeah, it just feels better as, like, taking our first step into space.

Because, I mean, launching stuff off a mountain, it's, it's cool. It just feels like- Like the barbaric way to do it. Like,"Okay, guys. We're gonna build a ramp up Mount Everest, and we're gonna launch stuff off of there." I guess it's like, uh, an earthen dam compared to the Hoover Dam, right? Yeah. Yeah. Kind of, yeah. You're just building up a bunch of material. But the, the advantage of the Lofstrom Loop, of course, you can place it anywhere. You're not relying on local geography and topology. , and most of the, the designs for this think about building it over the ocean, and ideally you would find two islands that are about the right distance apart to build either terminus, and then the structure itself would just be over the ocean.

So if it did fail, there's no one underneath it to suffer, and the failure modes aren't that bad either because all of the material is either moving at sub-orbital velocity, in which case it falls down, or much, much higher than orbital velocity, in which case it escapes. It's going faster than the escape velocity for the planet. It's… So- I mean, it would be sad to see it go. Yeah, literally. Just flies away. But I'd much prefer that than seeing it coming for you. Yeah. You know? So, um- So if it did fail, it would just fall to the ground in a relatively uninhabited part of the ocean, and some of it would probably shoot up into orbit.

But I imagine that that cable moving so fast, if it did fail and make contact with the, the outer sheath, would probably mostly just annihilate itself. There's a lot of energy in the system. Yeah. So it'd probably just be, you know, a fine spray of molten material at that point going into orbit. Might be tough for anything passing over at the time, but- Yeah. That, that, that orbital economy we built, we're building up with it- Basically taking a shotgun to it… might have… It's like, ooh. But- But, you know. But there is another advantage too, is that because this isn't itself in a stable orbit, it's not at risk of orbital impacts like an orbital ring is.

Because, like I said, you know, it's in the atmosphere. Um, it… There's enough air there to stop anything from, just from orbiting, so micrometeorites and all these impacts aren't really a concern. They basically have one shot at it, because if they fall to that altitude and don't hit it, they're gonna de-orbit before they get a chance to come back around and hit it again. Yeah. No, I mean, it's a, it's, it's a great system, something that I, you know… Uh, when, when do you think we'll be ready to make one of those? Uh, let's start now. We just did an episode on, uh, technologies we could see in 100 years.

I'm not gonna say that we could build this in the next 100 years or we will start building one, but maybe. I mean, if we… We're already seeing a lot of reusable rockets, and we're seeing the beginnings, the, the baby steps of building an orbital economy. And this, to me, seems like the next logical step. Will it be a Lofstrom Loop compared to a standard launch loop where you just build it on the ground and up a mountain? I don't know, but I could definitely see this being something that we look at in the next 100 years to grow that economy and to get those first factories in space. Absolutely. I mean, if you start seeing, like, that space makes money, then the… I feel like we can see a very quick shift into building structures like this.

No, I absolutely agree. I mean, that, that's super cool to, to think about, and I, I do wanna hear about these other supported stru- or yeah, supported structures that you were talking about. Yeah. So one of the other alternatives, right, is we, we talked about the Lofstrom Loop. Mm-hmm. And something else you can do though is you can actually just build insanely high towers. You can use this in, uh, just a building. And so there's this concept called an Atlas pillar, which is effectively just a tower into space. Like, you could literally just build a tower up into low Earth orbit, maybe 80, 100, 200 kilometers off the ground, right?

Right. And no material would be able to, to stand that tall. Like I said, there's just not enough compressive strength. Anything you try to build would collapse in on itself. Even mountains can't be that, that tall 'cause the, the Earth's mantle would struggle to support that. Right. But th- through active support, right, you build this tower, and you build it around accelerating material up to support the top of this, then you can theoretically build towers into low Earth orbit, maybe 100 kilometers off the ground. Yeah. I mean, so how would, how would you add into a tower- … active support?

So the modern skyscrapers are basically built around, uh, a concrete center, right? Right. You have this huge basically concrete pillar, and you hang your building off of it. I think I imagine for, like, an Atlas cow- tower, instead of that being a concrete pillar, that would be hollow, and that would actually house this active support. And so what you're effectively doing is the end cap of this building, right? You can almost imagine… Let's go back to our cannonball analogy, right? Right. You're putting a cannon in the basement of your building, and you're firing the cannonball against the ceiling. If that ceiling, if that cannonball has enough momentum when it hits the ceiling to be stopped, then that sup- that provides support.

Now, if you were firing these cannonballs, like I said, constantly, continuously, then you can see how you're applying force to the top of that building and supporting it through not compressive forces. So but it would have to act as, like, almost like, um- like an oval in the center, right? So, like, stuff would run up the side and still loop around, dump all of its energy at the top, and then ride back down. Yeah, pretty much, yeah. So you could do this through a physical, like, iron rope as an example. Uh, it doesn't need to be like a physical rope like that. You could also just do magnetically charged particles, right?

Like, you could just have theoretically, uh, iron filings or just anything that has a charge, and launch them up with basically a rail gun. They hit the top and stop, and then you just let them fall back down. Gravity will help you out at the end of this, right? Yeah. I, I was just thinking of, like, you wouldn't want to launch it into the falling particles. Mm-hmm. Um, so I, I would think of, like, a loop, but I guess if they're small enough it doesn't really matter. I still think you would wanna separate them, 'cause you don't wanna put momentum into the falling particles- Right … because then that's not reaching the top of your building. Yeah, it's just wasteful. Yeah. So, uh, you can do it however you want.

I've seen some that talked about using charged particles. I've seen some that discuss using kinda like the Lofstrom Loop, a physical loop. However you wanna do it is fine. But the end result is that you can build buildings much, much taller than is physically possible through just traditional compressive or tensile strength. So with these, I feel like to conserve energy we would still build them on the ground, but as they go up, we would just have these mechanisms inside of it so that they could just build infinitely tall, as long as we're delivering energy to them. Yeah. So as long as you're delivering energy, you can go, and the ideas I've seen for these are kind of interesting.

Um, I've seen people talk about using these to connect with, like, space elevators. I've seen people talk about using them to connect with orbital rings, right? Like, if you've got an orbital ring, you could theoretically build a building that just goes all the way up to it. And y- you live in it. This could be a whole arcology. This could be a whole s- like, basically city, uh, that supports your orbital ring. Um, another option is that if you go to the top of this- uh, you're, you're\effectively in a vacuum, right? You're in space. So this could potentially serve as a launching point if you were still using rockets or if you wanted to put kind of like a, a loft room loop on steroids, if you wanted to use a launch loop there.

That's something else you could do as well. Yeah. I mean, it, like, like the sky's the limit. Literally. Yeah, literally. Actually, no. You can go further. Yeah. The, the, the sky's not the limit. Yeah. I mean, it's, um, it's… it, it is a crazy concept. For some reason, a lot more horrifying than the loop structures. I don't know why. Like, uh, because I, I know that if it had, like, m- multiples of these systems applying force upwards, if just one fails or needs maintenance, they could turn it off and it wouldn't collapse. They could build it that way. It's just like in my mind, I'm thinking, you know, the building will just one day… You're not wrong.

That is a concern. If this were to lose power or something were to happen, the, the building would collapse. Yeah. And then also building it so tall, you're at risk of like impacts, debris. You have to deal with lateral forces from wind through your entire atmosphere. Mm-hmm. I think the Atlas Pillar for me is a cool concept, and I like it because it plays with active support. It allows you to do interesting things like have, you know, 100-kilometer-tall skyscrapers that go up to your orbital ring. Though I will be honest with you, I don't see as much practical benefit for it. Yeah. Like, I don't, I don't know why you would wanna live, uh, 80 kilometers off the ground.

So building a, a skyscraper that, that tall doesn't make a lot of sense for me, and the risks are there too. If you have people living in this and it collapses- Then that's, that's bad. I mean, imagine like, like, oh God, I'm just imagining like super cities like in the future and one of these collapse. It could have, could have a million people- Yeah… just in one building. Oh my… Yeah. And then it's just so much material to make it even like desirable to want to…'Cause yeah, you could have a structure that could fit a ship, you know, and you could bring it up to the top and just whatever.

But to actually make it worthwhile thing that people would wanna live in, it would need to be, you know, at least the width of a skyscraper. Yeah. And it- There's a lot of material it is a lot of material. And I guess for me too, I don't really see the benefit. Like when we're talking about Lofstrom Loops and we're talking about orbital rings, there's a, there's an obvious benefit. Like, yes, this is a, a structure you have to build and maintain, and there are failure modes, but there's a benefit, right? Like orbital rings, there's a huge benefit because they're basically the launch loops on steroids. You could theoretically throw something from Earth to Mars- Yeah… and this could support Like, yes, there are risks to building this structure, but there's obvious benefits.

Same thing with the Lofstrom Loop, although I would say the risks there are even less so because you're building it over the ocean. With Atlas Pillars, they're really cool, but I'm not really seeing the benefits compared to the risks. Right. I mean, e- especially with these other structures being just as, if not more possible, right? Then why wouldn't you just do that? Yeah. 'Cause if you can build an Atlas Pillar, you can build a Lofstrom Loop. Yeah. So why not build an, a Lofstrom Loop? Build… You can build several Lofstrom Loops- Yeah, exactly … for, for the same amount of material. So yeah, I mean, it's, it's like you said, g- cool to speculate. I'm maybe, you know, maybe in the future when that, that's perfected and people wanna live- With a view of space.

Yeah. And- And I was … you know, and you don't have to go to space, to be clear. You, you can also just build very tall structures that aren't that crazy. Like, you can build, you know, the Burj Khalifa is kind of maxing out what we can do with compressive strength, and it's a, it's a kilometer, uh, tall. So imagine you can build something two kilometers tall, five kilometers tall. Uh, you don't have to go to space. So it does allow for mega structures that aren't on that level. That is true. Yeah. I mean, I could definitely see it being used practically, like you said, to kind of just, like, extend that amount as cities become more populated.

Like, let's say instead of… What, what, what are we at, like eight billion people on Earth? Uh, we gotta be pressing nine now. Nine, yeah. So, like, let's say- I think we're still in the eights, but we're getting to nine… let's say that we have, like, 30 that we might need structures and cities that are about that tall. Yeah, very possible. I mean, there's more than enough surface area to support that many people, but if people wanna keep moving to cities and you don't want your city centers to spread out, certainly. Uh, there still comes… To me, though, you still run into the risk issue of, like, what happens if that system fails? Now you're also in a huge city.

Yeah. But, you know, you know, people, people live in some sketchy spots- … in cities, right? So I'm, I wouldn't put it past them. I'm just imagining, you know, "Hey, guys, utility bill's due and we really need to pay it this month." Or they- they're gonna turn off the, the lobster loop that's supporting this thing. Oh, God. Yeah. That's, that's, uh, that… I would prioritize that over rent. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, 'cause at least if, uh, you don't pay rent they'll kick you out. Yeah. You don't pay this, the building might fall on you no matter where you move. Mm-hmm, the building takes you down. No, it's, um… It, it definitely is, is cool to mess with.

I don't, I definitely don't think that these are something that we'll see any time soon, but it is definitely cool to play with. I have a hard time imagining any civilization being okay with building these in a populated area. Yeah. An actively supported building in a city to me just seems like a recipe for disaster. orbital ring I can get around. There's, there's fail-safes and there's, like, obvious benefits to it, but I, but w- I just don't see this in a city. Yeah. I, it doesn't, it doesn't make a lot of sense. I'm trying to think of, like, practical uses for it. Maybe, like, like, for, like, uh, point defense systems for a planet.

Yeah. Just being able to be up higher so that you're not fighting gravity to, like, fire either rockets or, uh, projectiles. Um, like, maybe, you know? I don't know. Or, I mean, you could theoretically, I guess, build literally a stairway into space with these actively supported pillars, and maybe make a giant ramp and use that as a, a launch loop. Kind of a- … a combination of atlas pillars and a Lofstrom loop. That's a big ass ramp. That would be a b- that would be crazy. Undoubtedly, as soon as you build this some… Red Bull is gonna sponsor somebody to jump off of it.

Oh, oh, yeah. Oh my God, yeah. Just like, "Okay, we're gonna do an 18-wheeler." "It's gonna do three back flips off the, off the ramp." That is, you know, d- definitely cool to think about. That, that, that is a crazy one. Yeah, I could kinda see that. Maybe, maybe, like, a ramp or something to, again, help you get into orbit. Um, you also don't have to do buildings, right? We talked about the Lofstrom loop as this actively supported, gigantic, basically, uh, 2,000 long spanning structure to get you into orbit. But you could also do a smaller scale version of that, and, and that would enable you to make bridges that are otherwise impractical or impossible, right?

Like, you could do a bridge without having to do towers in between, which could be really important for really deep bodies of water. And you could make these things, I mean, really infinitely long. I mean, there's not a limit i- in terms of that. Just depends how much energy you're willing to put into the system. Yeah. So I could imagine that being really helpful for bridging huge bodies of water. You could have a five, six kilometer long bridge that has no supports in the middle. No, I, I mean… I'm trying, I'm trying to think. I mean, if the sky's the limit… How, how long do you think it would take to drive from across the Atlantic Ocean?

Build a bridge to Europe? Yeah. Let's say that we're all in self-driving cars and they're going, you know, 300 miles per hour. They have charging stations on the side of the road. I think you could get there in, like, what? Like, maybe five days? Yeah, that would be quite a drive, but yeah. It would, it would be a drive. It would be a drive. No, it would be less than that, right? Because, because you can go the entire distance of the United States in, like, like, two days. Yeah, yeah, so probably something like that. Yeah. Could you build one across the Atlantic? I s- I guess I see no reason why that's physically not possible. Would you? Probably not, but- No.

I guess no … I think it would be, I think it would be very… I don't know off the top of my head, um, where this would make sense, but I'm sure there are bodies of water that exist where a bridge would be very economically beneficial to the country or to the, to whoever would build it. However, building one right now is just not feasible, especially this happens if you have really deep bodies of water,' cause trying to obviously put bridge supports when- in really deep water is challenging, or if the bedrock's really far under the ground or not stable. Yeah. So this could potentially be a way to bypass that. No, I mean, that would be amaz- Like, okay, bridge engineering, just as a side note, is a really crazy marvel of engineering in my mind.

I've always been fascinated with how bridges are built. But yeah, being able to make the, a bridge at wherever you need it kind of is a, a huge come up for humanity. Yeah, that would be huge. I mean, it's kinda I guess- boring when you're talking about orbital rings and launch loops. Like, oh yeah, you can make bridges. But from a practical standpoint, that's actually a huge benefit- It is … in technology. It really, really is. Because bridges are limited, like you were saying, by, you know, they need to have a good area where they can be supported. They need a lot of maintenance just on their supports to make sure that… And our bridges, uh, here in the United States are pretty bad.

Yeah. We're, we're not doing great. Yeah. But I mean, you know, they work. They work, so it's- Until they don't … until they don't. But if we could have these, I feel like you can maintain them better, you can build them wherever you need them, really streamline stuff. And like, most of the cities, like New York comes to mind, like the congestion and all the traffic is r- a lot of it is at these bridges- Yeah… 'cause there aren't enough of them. And the failure modes, again, to me, are less critical here because you can do multiple loops and have redundancies and backups and have it be safe. Uh, but if it were to fail, which would be catastrophic for anyone on the bridge, but unlike the- the Atlas Tower, you're not gonna take out the whole city, right?

Presumably this is built over a waterway. Yeah. So not that that would be an insignificant failure mode. There is obviously, uh, a risk to, to people, but it's not as crazy as having a 10-kilometer-long skyscraper that supports 100,000 people falling over in your city. Yeah, no, I mean, you're absolutely right. You're absolutely right. It's just like… But it's the same thing. you're you're putting your life on a line to a metal cable. It's just that that metal cable's now underneath the bridge. Yeah. So. So definitely, um, I see the benefit there, and I see where it could be worth it. Yeah. one thing we didn't really touch on is orbital rings a lot.

We talked about them. Those are also fall into this category of actively supported structures. I didn't really talk on them 'cause we have a whole episode about it. Yeah. So if people are interested, I would recommend they, they watch that. Absolutely. Uh, I think that we answered a lot of the questions in this episode that I saw a- asked on that episode. It, it would be hard to get… There were so many. Yeah. You know? But- Yeah. That episode got a lot of views. But, um, a lot of people saying that it's impossible, they don't believe it, or just fundamentally misunderstanding how active support works. I hope this was a better explanation or, or kinda helped shed some light on that to anyone who was confused. Yeah… who was confused in good faith.

Some people were just commenting to comment. Yeah. But you know, uh, being, being curious and questioning things is always encouraged. Yes. Oh, oh, always. Always. Um, but with that, I, I don't have a ton more to say about active structures. No, this has been, uh, uh, super, super cool to learn about for me, so I hope it was for you guys as well. well, I hope you enjoyed the episode. If you did, please consider supporting us on Patreon and subscribing on your podcast platform of choice, or on YouTube if you're there. Consider giving this video a like or leaving a comment, and join us next week where we're gonna be talking about gerontocracies, or how we can actually run a government in a civilization if people are living forever, and if that will involve into the elders running the entire government.

Yeah, that one's gonna be awesome. Yeah. See you next week. Bye-bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Boarding a Spaceship Is Harder Than You Think

    Nov 15, 202640 minAudio

    How do you capture an enemy spaceship without destroying it? Boarding actions are a staple of science fiction, but how realistic are they? In the vacuum of space, getting aboard an enemy vessel might be the easy part....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Would Immortality Lead to a Stagnant Civilization

    Nov 9, 202630 minAudio

    What happens to civilization when people can live for hundreds or even thousands of years? Life extension could transform humanity, but it also raises some difficult questions. If people no longer die of old age, what...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What Will Technology Make Possible in 100 Years?

    Oct 26, 202638 minAudio

    What will technology look like in 100 years? By 2126, advances in artificial intelligence, biotechnology, energy storage, and space exploration could fundamentally transform how we live. In this episode of Entropy...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. How Stars Work: The Physics of Fusion, Gravity, and Death

    Oct 19, 202635 minAudio

    How do stars work, what powers nuclear fusion, and why do some stars survive for trillions of years while others burn out in just a few million? In this episode of Entropy Rising, we take a deep dive into the physics of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Dyson Spheres Are an Outcome, Not a Megaproject

    Oct 12, 202634 minAudio

    Dyson spheres are among the most iconic megastructures in science fiction, but they're also among the most misunderstood. What if building a Dyson sphere wasn't a massive engineering project spanning thousands of years,...

    Credit the people on this episode