Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Entropy Rising

Entropy Rising artwork

Wormholes: What Physics Says and Sci-Fi Imagine

Sep 28, 202637 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Wormholes are one of the most fascinating ideas in theoretical physics, but how much of what we see in science fiction is actually possible? Support us on Pateron :https://www.patreon.com/c/EntropyRising In this episode of Entropy Rising, we take a deep dive into wormholes, from Einstein-Rosen bridges and general relativity to the biggest problems with keeping a wormhole open. We explore what physicists actually say about traversable wormholes, exotic matter, stability, and whether these shortcuts through spacetime could ever exist in the real universe. Then we push beyond the known physics and ask the fun question: if stable wormholes did exist, what could we actually do with them? Interstellar travel, instant transportation, communication across enormous distances, and some of the stranger consequences that science fiction loves to explore. From real physics to hard science fiction, this is a full discussion of what wormholes are, why they are so difficult, and what they could mean for the future of space travel. Support the show Website: https://www.entropy-rising.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

however, there is a really important distinction with the Einstein-Rosen bridge idea. What they essentially found was that, yes, the physics allows for the connection of two points through a bindure of spacetime, which is a wormhole. But they also found that it is immensely unstable To the point that the actual throat, the bit that connects the two points in spacetime- Right basically collapses instantaneous. They actually did the math and found it collapses so fast that once formed, it's impossible for even a single photon of light to connect through it.

Hello, and welcome to Entropy Rising, a podcast dedicated to discussing science and the future of humanity. I'm your host, Jacob. And I'm Lucas, and today we're going to be talking about wormholes. Yeah, this is a topic that I'm glad we finally got around to covering. It's one that we definitely have needed to touch on. It's a quintessential part of science fiction. I can't even count how many different stories wormholes show up in. But it's also got some basis in physics. I mean, the, the initial idea of wormholes comes from physics and general relativity. Right. And so I'm really looking forward to diving into this.

Uh, I do wanna start really though by talking about the physics of the wormholes and how they function under known relativity, and where some people are starting to take some liberties with physics to get models that, uh, work a little bit better in, like, science fiction, for example. Okay. Yeah. I mean, I definitely agree with you. I feel like wormholes are- Something that we, we have touched on a little bit here and there But actually diving into them and diving into the physics is probably going to be a really interesting journey. Yeah. So I'm curious, what … Obviously, you did some research before we recorded this episode.

Did you look into the physics at all? And, like, what did you find out about them, and what do you think and know about them? Yeah. I mean, just mostly jumping into, like, like you said, with relativity, just bending space time- Mm-hmm to a point to where you can bring two points together to travel through them, whether you do it with gravity or with other theoretical means, um, is like the base concept of, of wormholes that I've touched on. Yeah, so that's the general idea. Uh, essentially what happened was you had Einstein's theory of relativity come out- Mm-hmm and special relativity came out, and then you had this physicist called, uh, Schwarzschild come around and play with some of the Einstein equations, and that's where we got the idea of black holes.

And you've probably heard the event horizon called the Schwarzschild radius before. Yes. So then based on the math that Schwarzschild did, Einstein and another physicist by the last name of Rosen came in and started playing again with these Schwarzschild, uh, ideas behind general relativity. And they found that it is possible to get a situation, kind of the same situation going on with black holes, . but instead of just being this infinite density point in space like a black hole- Mm-hmm it can actually warp spacetime in such a way that you connect two points, and this is called an Einstein-Rosen bridge, which is kind of the initial idea behind a wormhole.

And if you've seen some science fiction that's trying to be a little more realistic or trying to at least invoke ideas of realism, they might have called it an Einstein-Rosen bridge instead of a wormhole. I know Eureka does that. I'm just … I don't know if you've ever ran into that term, but that's where the initial idea of wormholes come from. I have, and I, I do know that that initial idea is actually one that's, um … I don't want to say, like, like broadly thought of, but I've run into, you know, a few people that I've just talked back and forth with that have been like,"Well, what is keeping a black hole from just being a wormhole?" Just because it is the only thing in our universe that theoretically could create that gravitational density to even have the concept of a wormhole be possible.

Yeah, that makes sense because from the outside perspective, a black hole and a wormhole could appear to be the same. Mm. I mean, in theory, if you had a stable wormhole and nothing was passing through it, it would very much look like a black hole. Things would fall into it and disappear. Right. Uh, however, there is a really important distinction with the Einstein-Rosen bridge idea. What they essentially found was that, yes, the physics allows for the connection of two points through a bindure of spacetime, which is a wormhole. But they also found that it is immensely unstable To the point that the actual throat, the bit that connects the two points in spacetime- Right basically collapses instantaneous.

They actually did the math and found it collapses so fast that once formed, it's impossible for even a single photon of light to connect through it. So even though Einstein and Rosen did the math and showed that it is possible under known physics to get geometries of spacetime that connect two points, they also found that it's impossible to get anything through that, which kind of is good because it preserves the idea of causality. Right. And it preserves the, an, a general notion we have that nothing can move faster than light. but it is unfortunate 'cause it, by their model, shows that nothing can pass through it.

Well, I mean, I do love also hearing about things like that where it could be so instantaneous that we can't even observe it, but it makes it even more theoretically possible to me. Like, like if we could find a way to stabilize that portal between the two points in a wormhole, then, you know, we could actually cause them to function. Now, we don't really know a lot about them in any way to be able to do that, but it just leaves more of that room for possibility. Well, that is kind of where the more modern notion of wormholes come in, because Einstein and Rosen developed this idea of connecting spacetime.

Then down the road, some other physicists came in and said, "Okay, we know that this can exist." Mm-hmm. "And we would like to have faster than light travel 'cause who doesn't want faster than light travel? So how could we actually stabilize the wormhole?" And this is where you start coming into the idea of things like, areas with negative energy density to basically prop open the throat of that wormhole and hold it up against the immense pressure that's trying to close it, uh, from the universe. And this is where we get ideas of stable wormholes, or I've even seen them called stable ways or gateways or star gates. Mm. Call it whatever you want.

But yeah, no, some physicists have came in and done that math. Well, I mean, then that kinda makes all of these different ideas that we see in science fiction become even more, rooted in science, which I think is pretty cool. It is rooted in science in a way, yes. Yeah. Um, and what I mean by that is that while you can, on paper, make this all balance out and have a stable wormhole that's open, in doing so, though, you invoke a material to make this happen that as far as we know, doesn't exist in the real universe, and if it did, would fundamentally change how we have to think about physics because it violates, uh, many laws of physics that we have now.

And so the main thing is, I mentioned that term negative energy density before. That's what you effectively need to hold these open, right? Like, they're, they wanna collapse, and you need something to prop it open and force that, that mouth open. And so what you need is, uh, an area of space that has negative pressure to push this open. And to be clear, this is the same issue with things like Alcubierre drives, warp drives. Right. Right? You need something with s- I've seen it shorthand called negative mass, and in some instances it literally is negative mass, but not always but you do need something that basically does the opposite of normal gravity and what the, the universe normally wants.

And the issue is, um, as far as we can tell, that doesn't exist. Right. so far, it's just like with, like dark matter and, and that, and that vibe that, you know, we, we theorize that it could, but, you know, but it doesn't. I would say this is different than that, 'cause dark matter kind of the opposite. Dark matter and dark energy are observations. Right And then we slap that title on it because we don't know what they are. So like dark energy is to explain the increasing expansion of the universe. We don't know what it is, but we can observe its effect. I see. This is almost the exact opposite. This is something that we've never observed in the real universe, but we did the math and we said, you know,"If this existed, you could make a stable wormhole." Okay.

So it was just something that was used to essentially complement the math done already to show that it could be possible if we had a, an substance like this. Yeah. Oh. And so I think the best way that I… the best analogy that I can pull on the top of my head, because when you're doing mathematical modeling, right? Mm-hmm. A lot of times you will get situations in mathematical modeling that aren't actually realistic in the real universe. Like numbers can be positive or negative on paper, but parameters in the real world can't always do that. And my example that I kinda came up with this is like, you probably remember back in high school or college doing a very basic kind of quadratic math problem, trying to calculate for how long a baseball is in the air off of a parabola, right?

Right. If you do this, you're gonna get two answers. You're gonna get a positive and a negative answer typically. Well, we know that that baseball can't go in the air for a negative amount of time. That, that's not physically possible. So you just throw that answer away. The math says it's there, because that's just a byproduct of a quadratic equation. But you know that's not a physically accurate prediction of the model. Right. And that's kinda what's going on here. You can put in a negative sign for mass and energy density and make this calculation work, but that doesn't mean that this negative mass and energy actually exist in the real world.

Yeah, because once you get into the negatives, you're kind of starting to defy our laws of physics- Yeah in our physical world. Yeah. And it would give some really weird effects. I mean, for example, if you used something that had negative mass, which some of these wormhole models do actually generally require something that would have a negative mass, trying to think about what that would look like in the real world is weird. For one, it would have a negative sign for gravity, right? Like if you had a planet made of negative mass, you would fall upwards and not downwards, which is weird to think about. Yes. But it also opens up the door for something called a bias drive, which is that you can take, like let's say you had a kilogram sphere of matter and a kilogram sphere of negative matter.

Mm-hmm. And this isn't antimatter, to be clear. This is not antimatter. This is something very different. But let's say you had a kilogram sphere of matter, a kilogram sphere of negative matter, and you chain them together with a pole. Well, that normal matter is gonna act like just normal matter in the world. It's going to attract the negative matter to it through gravity. Mm-hmm. That negative matter, though, has a reverse gravity science, so it's actually gonna repulse the normal matter, and these will chase each other off into infinity. These two balls would eventually get 99 point whatever 9s the speed of light, and you could theoretically chain them to a generator and get infinite energy. That's kind- that's the kind of causality and violations we'd get- I see out of allowing for negative matter to exist.

Well then, I mean, with that thought, then it goes against our laws of physics. It would be easier to assume that it, it probably doesn't. Yeah, exactly. And that's the issue. Yes, on paper you can get a wormhole, and yes, on paper you can even make it stable, but in the real world, it doesn't seem like it's possible. Now, I will say, and some viewers watching this video might point out and say,"Well, what about the Casimir effect?" Are you familiar with the Casimir effect, Lucas? Uh, no. So it's a- Please enlighten me. Yeah, so it's an interesting phenomena where if you put two plates really close to each other in a vacuum, they will actually feel a force pulling them together, and the explanation for that is that there's actually negative vacuum energy basically between them, and it causes the outside, um, to have a positive force, and they fall in together.

So you basically get a region of space of negative energy density. And so some people try to take the Casimir effect and extrapolate that and say,"Well, that's proof that negative energy density regions can exist," and therefore you can extrapolate and say,"Well, we can then do this on a much higher scale to stabilize wormholes." The issue is, as far as we can tell, yes, you can have very short-lived, very small areas of negative energy density, but that seems to be the extent. Quantum mechanics seems to put a limit on how big that area can be and how long it can last.

Well, do we know the math behind why that is, though? Uh, yes, so it, it mostly just comes out to… I think it comes down to, like quantum probability, like the quantum field. There's ultimately, um, just the odds of… 'Cause then you're getting into, like the idea of vacuum energy. Right. Are you familiar with the idea of vacuum energy? Yeah. So there's, like a background amount of energy in our universe, and there's an idea we live on, like a false vacuum- Mm-hmm. and that there's actually a lower energy state available, and that's also kind of a scary thing 'cause if there is, then you get vacuum decay, which could be, uh, something that ends the, the universe.

So effectively, it's a fluctuation in that field that gives you an area of, um, effectively negative energy density relative to the normal vacuum energy. Right. We don't know if there's a lower floor of vacuum energy. There is, potentially. Um, there's theories that say that it is. Uh, but the issue is you don't wanna poke through to that because then you effectively end the universe . So maybe if that's what you have to do to get a wormhole- Faster than light travel might not be worth it in that case Well, you know, there's… Ge- just give it a try Yeah. Try it once. If the universe doesn't end, then we have wormholes.

Well, yeah- … you better hope that it works and you get faster than light travel from it, 'cause if you were to break through to the, the lower vacuum state of the universe, then that would propagate out at the speed of light. So if you can't escape that event horizon, uh, then you are gonna cease to exist. So you better get faster than light travel out of it if you're gonna do that. Yeah, that would, that, that is, that is a crazy concept, not even thinking of how we would even begin to start doing that. But it, again, is just another one of those things that is, well, maybe. Yeah, yeah. Well, maybe. So we do know that there is a possibility for small areas of negative energy density.

It doesn't seem like you can scale that up. And, uh, one last thing on the physics I do wanna touch on before we dive into the fun ideas of what you can do with them, because I know someone else is probably gonna think this too, what about dark energy? 'Cause that's something you brought up, too. Mm-hmm. And so dark energy's interesting because it, it does appear to be a region of space that is expanding the universe, right? It's this increasing expansion of the universe, and so I think it's a natural question to ask, can we use that expansionist force to hold open a wormhole?

And it seems like probably not. Uh, for one, we don't actually know what dark energy is. Uh, right now I think a lot of models look at it as a cosmological constant. It's just a background rule of the universe, not something that can be harvested and used. But it is worth pointing out that's a model. We don't know. Dark energy is a big question mark. You know, we slap a label on it 'cause we observe its effects, but we don't actually know what it is. It seems to be the case, and if it is a cosmological constant, you probably can't harvest it, and you probably can't concentrate it. And even if you could, you would end up getting a, corresponding external force building up with it that would negate any ability to make a wormhole and stabilize a wormhole.

Right. But I am bringing it up 'cause it's a big question mark in our understanding of physics, And we can't say for certainty that it's not gonna be some unicorn, uh, material that allows us to do something or open the door to brand-new physics that would allow us to do something that right now we believe is impossible. We clearly are missing a very big key part of how physics in our universe works. Right, and that I feel like is the exciting part. It is. Because there's so much about our universe, I should say, that, we don't understand. But just like many of times before us, we feel like we understand most of it, but it could be infinitely more stuff that, that we can learn about.

And, it just doesn't seem like it right now, but there could be a future where we can stabilize a wormhole, you know, using some kind of crazy method or material or, or something. Like, who knows, we could maybe get to the edge of our universe faster than it's expanding and then create a wormhole from the edge of our universe to farther out. The thing is, you know, it's, it's a big question mark. It shows we don't understand all of physics. We always on this show work off the assumption that we're not gonna have some breakthrough change that fundamentally changes things like special relativity and general relativity, but- Yeah … we obviously don't know, and we don't know what's possible.

No, yeah, that is true. It is always best to assume that what we know right now as humanity is what we should work off of for the future. But then there's also, you know, the fun parts of our show I feel like really come from us speculating on, well, what if? Yeah, absolutely. And speaking of that, so what if? What if you actually do have a wormhole? What does a society look like that has wormhole travel, and how can you utilize that versus something like faster-than-light travel, I guess, or, like, a traditional, like, warp drive?

let's assume that, like in most science fiction, they work under the assumption that these wormholes are these massive things, or you create them in, like, a, an area that's pretty large- Mm-hmm um, that I feel like people go in and out of. Usually, you see them suspended in space between, like, bridges or types of, uh, projection systems that work around them, which would be the theoretical stabilization of the tunnel itself. but I feel like if humanity was able to actually create wormholes and that civilization was able to travel back and forth with them, what's keeping you from just using it for all of your daily travel?

To, to anywhere. Yeah. If you could create wormholes on demand, expand and collapse them, because they naturally wanna collapse, and as far as we see, if they are theoretically,, Existing, they don't create when they do create and collapse. So you could use them for anything. Well, it depends on the model. And I guess for that model, what that comes down to is how expensive are these wormholes to actually keep and maintain? ' cause some current models of wormholes where we're using the negative energy density quantity, require a pretty extraordinary amount of it.

For a wormhole that's a one meter wide throat, which is roughly big enough for a, a human to walk through, right? Mm-hmm. Some of these models predict you will need, like, a Jupiter's worth of negative energy to actually hold that open, or a Jupiter's worth of negative mass. And some of them go even further than that and say you're gonna need, like, a whole star's worth. So if that's the case, then I don't think you're gonna be using these for everyday travel, right? These will probably be extremely valuable, extremely rare, probably only connecting your planet with another planet. You might only have a few of them open. Yeah. Or I have also seen some predictions that say it's, like you said, very cheap and very easy.

And if that's the case, then yeah, you can use it for anything. You can link two cities on your planet together. You can link, uh, two planets together and g- have a daily commute between them. Every town might have a wormhole. It really just depends on the actual cost to keep these open. Yeah. just thinking here, if we were able to have wormholes in general, I feel like energy at that point becomes almost irrelevant. Oh, absolutely. Yeah. Um, because you have access to literally infinite matter that you can turn into infinite energy. Yeah, I mean, you could throw one in the core of a sun presumably, and then just harvest that energy on the other end- Yeah, you could-… to power your whole civilization… put it right into, like, a, like, some kind of turbine that turns it into electricity and f- s- vacuum out the sun.

Yeah. Probably want a very small wormhole. You don't wanna let all that energy Oh, yeah. out at once, But Absolutely… maybe a microscopic one to just siphon some energy out of it. Yeah, you could absolutely do that. But the other thing is you could have 500 billion of those- Yeah, exactly. I mean- … functioning at one time for the, universal wormhole generation system. Yeah, unless there is some method by which transmitting energy through them takes more energy than you get out of it, you have unlimited access to energy. And it gets even worse than that,'cause what's stopping you from taking two wormholes, stacking them on top of each other, throwing some mass in there in a gravitational field, and letting it accelerate infinitely, and then slapping some, copper coils around that and making a, a, a motor that harvests effectively infinite energy?

I mean, that would be cool. Now, it's just when you say stuff like that, right, it brings my mind immediately to, perpetual motion machines. It would be a perpetual motion machine. Exactly. Yeah. And then, you know, uh, it's like they say, hardest part about it is where do you hide the battery? Yeah. Well, in this case, you're basically tapping infinite gravitational energy 'cause you have, you know, two portals. Right. Well, it just makes it… For some reason, that there is what made me feel like it would be less realistic. Yeah. Well, yeah, and that's some of the issues you get with them. Now, could you presumably imagine a mechanism in place where, you know, as something gains velocity, it also gains kinetic energy, and maybe- Every time you transmit something with kinetic energy through the wormhole, that requires even more energy to stabilize it.

And so maybe you could put a system in place where you can't do that. It would actually take more energy to stabilize the wormhole as this falling mass gained energy, and there you could have some conservation. So I'm not saying that in that sense you always get a perpetual motion machine. Right. But if those conditions don't exist, then you do get a perpetual motion machine. That's true. And my question when I read some science fiction is I always laugh when they have this wormhole-powered society, and they talk about how energy intensive they are to maintain because if you can do things like this, you get unlimited energy.

Yeah. If you go one step further and don't just see it as transportation, but as the thing that generates your actual energy, then it becomes a lot more vast what you can do. Yeah, absolutely. But I wanna kinda go off of the assumption that what if we, what if they are super energy intensive and you can't really use them to harvest energy because they don't stay stable for, for super long? Okay. So a civilization where you're using wormholes just to travel back and forth between solar systems or even galaxies- Okay at that point. I feel like that, that civilization should be our first starting point in this feeling because it kind of goes with a lot of stuff that we talked about in other videos, except speeds it up vastly.

It does. I mean, you can at that point really have a, a true K3 civilization. You can inhabit every planet in your solar system and have it be, you know, an instantaneous communication range from your, your home world. Yeah, because, uh, that's another thing. You don't just have to send matter, but could you send information, right? Or- There's no reason not to. Exactly. If you can send matter, you can send information. Absolutely. So now you essentially have these wormholes that are used as communication between everything, and that allows you to broaden your horizons with, on materials, transportation, and actually being able to manage a larger sprawl of an empire.

Yeah, and actually, speaking of the information transfer, that in and of itself is fairly useful because even if you can't stabilize a one-meter wide wormhole that a human can pass through, as long as you can stabilize a wormhole that's large enough to pass the photon of light that you would like to use for communication through, you can use these for faster than light communication. So maybe it is too expensive to keep a wormhole open large enough for a person to walk through, but if you can make a, a microscopic one big enough for photons of laser light to get through, then you could use that as FTL communication.

Oh, that too. That's the next step after fiber optic internet. Yeah, no kidding. Yeah. It's wormhole internet. Yeah, it doesn't get much better than that. And so even if you could never use them to physically transverse the universe, just having access to FTL communication opens up a lot of doors- Mm for empire building. Yeah. It opens up exactly what we would need for that to really be a possibility. it's, uh, really interesting to think about everything that you could do, but the reality of it is it's just everything that you think you could do, but faster.

Yeah, effectively. I mean, if you do have that type of wormhole where you open it up on your planet like a stargate and it opens up light years away to a different planet and you can walk through it, then exploring the universe becomes very easy. Granted though, maybe that's not the case 'cause I have also seen some… And this is really, you know, more of a science fiction discussion, but I have seen some, some works purposefully design their wormholes in such a way that when you open them, they physically open next to each other in space, and the only way you can get a wormhole somewhere is to take it the slow boat way- slower than light.

And then once it's there, you have FTL travel. Yes. But you have to first make them next to each other and take it out there. If you've ever read the Bobiverse, that's how their wormholes work in the later books. I mean, and that makes sense too, right? Like, you can't just have a highway, you have to build it first. Yeah. You know? So it, uh, it, it makes sense to my brain for us to have to bring the material out there to have a start and an end to a wormhole. Or else how are you, you know, planning the trajectory of the wormhole once you open it? Yeah. Like, like where's it gonna end up? Or unless they just open up at random places.

Maybe you can't control where the end happens, you just have to open it and hope it finds somewhere useful. Well, I mean, it… That could be useful if it was consistent, right? If you opened it and it opened up in the same spot every time. Um, but for some reason I feel like it would be like a fire hose. Yeah, you just open it and wherever it opens, yeah. Just opening wherever it ends. Um. And maybe you just open and close them repeatedly until one lands close enough to a habitable solar system to go explore. But if you were to open them randomly The, the odds of it opening even in a galaxy are pretty low, much less opening in a solar system, and definitely not opening in a planet.

So you might have to sit here and open and close this thing billions upon billions of time to actually have it land somewhere that's useful to you. And you see, the more we talk about it, the more these stipulations that seem more and more possible come up to conflict with wormholes. Yeah. But I still believe in them. I know, I still… I, I definitely don't believe that they're, they're physically possible, but they're fun to think about. Um, I do wanna go back to the idea of actually if you open two next to each other and you need to physically transport them. Okay. Because in that case, you still get some fun things you can do with them. For example, let's say that that's the case.

Every wormhole has to make it to its destination through slower than light travel. Mm. Well, we've done episodes on travel, and how you would try to achieve that, and it's immensely complicated and borderline impossible just due to the sheer energy demand that the rocket equation requires. Right. you have wormholes, you don't need to follow the rocket equation. Why keep your fuel on the ship? Take your wormholes. If you can magnetically link them to your ship, then throw the other end in a star, and then just let the energy streaming out of it be your, your thruster.

And that's how you can move your ship. Or if you even didn't wanna do something that crazy, you could just have a normal, even chemical rocket if you wanted to, although hopefully not, but you could just have your fuel tank back on Earth and just transmit the fuel through the wormhole, that way you're not following that rocket equation of adding more fuel adds more mass, which needs more fuel. Yeah, I mean, I, uh, I know that we discussed it before, but it's like why even have, have crew on there? It's like we were saying, they could, they could hop off the ship, go back home, get back on the ship on, you know, for their next day of work. The ship is still flying at, Almost the speed of light.

Yeah, you could 100% do that if they were cheap enough to run and maintain. Y- Working on the interstellar spaceship might be a nine to five. You've got a wormhole in your ship that you're ca- hauling off to some new star system, and you've got one back on Earth, and it's just you clock into

your job at 900, you walk through the wormhole, and you're eight light years away on this super relativistic ship. Uh, you spend your day working at your console, and then when it's time to clock off, uh, you walk back through the wormhole. You're back home in time for dinner with your family, and the next guy walks in to take your spot. Yeah, I mean, it's, uh, it sounds like a pretty good gig. Yeah, exactly. Honey, I'm taking the wormhole to work and then I'm taking the wormhole, you know, uh, from h- the house to work and then from work to the ship." Yeah, you just pray that that wormhole never collapses 'cause then you're stuck on a ship however many li- With no propulsion system.

your job at 9Yeah, hopefully. I think realistically if you did this and if wormholes are this cheap and you're hauling them through the galaxy, presumably you're gonna have a ship generate like hundreds of these, right? And then carry hundreds of them with it, not just for redundancy, but also just to dot them through the galaxy as it goes. You could just plot a route around the galaxy and just be dropping off wormholes as you go and have them all linked back to Earth. Man, what a crazy life that would be. It's just like having a, a highway built of wormholes of, of instantaneous travel would be, uh, be pretty incredible.

your job at 9Yeah, absolutely, and then just every time it sees a, a potential habitable system, it just drops a wormhole that way, and then there you go. That does, though, then beg another issue, which is that if you have two linked wormholes like this and you carry one away at super relativistic speed to a new destination, they are now not synchronous in time. The wormhole that's moving is going to experience slower time because of general relativity, which theoretically means if you were to cart this thing around the galaxy and come back to Earth, you would effectively have time travel. You could… The wormhole that stayed on Earth would be in the future, and the wormhole that came back around would be in the past, and you could just walk through and go back in time.

your job at 9Yeah. Uh, th- I, I think I might have flipped that. No, no, no, yeah. Uh, but it… But your, your concept makes sense. Yeah. One of them is gonna be further back in time than the other, and you could theoretically use that for time travel, especially if you were able to bring it back to the source, and that does create some issues. It does. Uh, that, that breaks, um, a lot of, a lot of fundamental laws as well. Mostly causality. Yeah, so that, that one does, does make it, uh, make it a little bit difficult. It is really hard to try and grasp the idea of a wormhole that could be moving so fast that it would actually break time, and you would be able to enter a loop.

your job at 9'Cause what happens if you go all the way around the wormhole, then get back on it and ride it again? Are you then going back in time even further? No, so the way the system works, though, is that the, they're both linked to each other, they're just at different points in time, so you can't y- go back further than when the first wormhole was made. You have a time machine that can always take you back to when the time machine was made. I, yes. Yes, okay, that, that makes sense. Well, it does kind of follow the, the idea of the time machine, then. Maybe it, maybe it could work. Probably not, 'cause then you can get paradoxes, and I, we don't know how the universe would resolve that.

your job at 9Does the universe just fail to exist- Mm … if a, if a paradox happens? It tears itself and pulls us all into the infinite vacuum. Yeah, so and maybe that's where the vacuum decay finally comes from. It's all starting to make sense. Maybe we cracked… Jake, we should be writing this down. I think it's good, yeah, it's good food for thought. If anyone's writing a, a short story or something, this, this could be worth exploring for fun concepts. There is idea, though, of a chronology protection, which effectively says that even if you were able to violate causality, the universe would always protect itself in some way.

your job at 9So presumably, right, let's say you did try to do this situation, move a wormhole at super relativistic speed, come back and use it for time travel, uh, this chronology protection conjecture, uh, that Hawking came up with says that something would happen to stop it. Like, it would be unstable, maybe there would be a feedback loop of energy. Something would happen to stop it, because the argument is essentially

thisIf a paradox was allowed to happen, the universe would stop existing, not just from that point on, but that point backwards. 'Cause if you have time travel, time works both directions. Mm-hmm. You have to accept that you, things don't just propagate forward in time, they propagate backward in time. However, we exist, so that inherently proves that didn't happen, and that either didn't happen because it's physically impossible from the laws of our universe, or if it is possible to have time travel, then something always stops it from causing a paradox that would end the universe forward and backward in time.

thisYeah, I mean, it, it makes sense that, that these laws would have things in place for them to not be broken. obviously, it- its most prevalent thing would probably be that just that it doesn't allow for things like this to exist in the first place. Which I think is the simplest solution. And again, this is what leads me to have the claim I have, that FTL travel's probably impossible. Mm-hmm. Wormholes are probably impossible. Uh, any form of FTL travel, to be clear, is a time machine. Yeah. There's no way around it. . Doesn't matter if you go through another dimension. Doesn't matter if you use wormholes. It doesn't matter if you have an Alcubierre drive.

thisNo matter what you do, it's going to allow for time travel. And so that's why I just tend to believe probably not possible. Yeah. It's just, wormholes worked as a little bit of a different concept, in my brain, as the way that they work through time,'cause they weren't actually traveling an amount of distance, but they were more just traveling the same distance but between the same points- Yeah but within space time. But even then, uh, you still get wormho- you still have the possibility of going through the wormhole and sending a message and getting it back before you s- Oh, yes, absolutely.

thisAbsolutely. It was just I, I guess the way that my brain was working, I didn't even really think of the way that it could be time travel in the same way that I think of it in other forms of faster than light travel. Although I do wonder if even if you're trying to go through this, Chronology protection principle, would you then be allowed to have two wormholes that exist so far away from each other that there's no possibility of them being connected through any other means? So a great example is, you know, beyond our observable universe, things are moving so far away that unless you have FTL travel, there's no way you could ever reach them.

thisSo presumably, if you had a wormhole here and a wormhole there, it doesn't matter if they become desynchronous in time because you could never send a message from one wormhole to the other slower than light. There would be no connection other than through that wormhole, therefore you never get any paradoxes. I see. That would make sense. Like, like if you were tr- reaching out so far that it was literally impossible for you to ever get there without faster than light travel, you then could use something that was faster than light travel, but then it would be like once you go there, can you come back?

thisYeah, it's fine as long as you maintain the connection through the wormhole. The issue would be trying to send a message outside of that wormhole 'cause that's when you're gonna start running into issues. But since you can never observe that faraway destination except through the wormhole, it gets around the time travel issue. Yeah. It, it does. I, I guess to at least the people in that… Or not just the people, but the matter in that area. Yeah. Or what I should say is even if they're in a different point of time, it doesn't matter because they're gonna stay connected to each other relatively. There's no way to verify that from an external source.

thisYou don't have any issues with causality, no violation of causality. So maybe that's your solution. Your wormholes can only ever exist so far away from them that everything is expanding away faster than light, and so you have some galactic empire with hundreds, thousands, millions of planets that are actually spread off of an enormous volume. Each connected planet, which might be a two-minute walk away, uh, through your wormhole, is actually hundreds of thousands to millions of light years away because that's the only way the system can work and protect causality. Uh, it, it is an interesting idea.

thisIt's almost like seeing causality as the same way that a game renders in graphics. It doesn't feel like it has to adhere to it until it is being observed. it's a good way to put it. Yeah. So it's, uh, that, that is, that is actually a really interesting, uh, theory. Yeah. And wormholes also change things too with like defense and warship. Obviously, if you have a wormhole connecting your solar system, then that becomes a hugely important point, and it's susceptible to things like blockades, naval blockades, or sabotage. So I mean, that could also be a huge fear, right? Imagine you have a solar empire that takes up your entire galaxy and someone sabotages your wormhole.

thisAnd the next nearest connected planet is 100 light years away. That could be death. That would be tough. Yeah. That would be tough. But it would be great for space pirates. Hopefully that episode does well then. Yeah. Yeah, nice, nice little spot for them to hang out and steal stuff. Yeah, that is true. State space pirates, naval blockades, you name it. Mm-hmm. That would be a good situation for it to work. It always blows me away whenever we talk about, like, these, uh, these newer concepts, just like, um, the crazy stuff that can happen. Like, I had… Like I said, I didn't really think a lot about, like, the time travel aspect, but it's really cool to think about.

thisYeah, and it's an important one for any type of FTL travel. It's obviously overlooked in most science fiction. Most science fiction doesn't wanna deal with that, and most science fiction… Like, I just read The Commonwealth Saga. Really good. They didn't touch on the time travel aspect of FTL travel because why would they? It would get in the way of the story. It gets weird, and just because that's a consequence of real FTL travel doesn't mean you need to have it in your story. Yeah. So I agree with that. If you're writing a story, leave the time travel out unless it's relevant to your story. Yeah. Or if you're making the… Yeah. Like you said, if you're making an entire story about time travel, it, it feels in place there, but in other ones it just gets too jumbled.

thisIt also does make for an immense weapon. I mean, if you have a wormhole and you can throw the other end in a star, I mean, that's, uh, it's literally the power of a star. And if you were to have that on someone's planet you didn't like, then they're in for a bad day. Well, that would be like the new nuclear deterrent. Yeah, no kidding. Like," Well, we have 500 wormholes." And that's even more terrifying if it's not in the model where you have to connect them and physically move them, but if you could connect them anywhere. Imagine some mad scientist on your planet opening up a wormhole into the core of your star. Yeah. No, you're right. Any, any person who loses their mind, if they were so readily accessible, could just destroy, uh, countless amounts of life- Yeah at, at any point in time.

thisYour entire planet. Yeah. Uh, presumably your entire solar system if they were crazy enough. You could definitely use that to take out a star, depending on how big of a wormhole you could make and how much matter you could transport. I think that, that, uh, that the assumption of them being well-maintained, just I guess by their, by larger powers, it would probably be the, uh, the most ideal one. Yeah. And I mean, presumably these would be very expensive to make and run, so probably not making it in your backyard. Yeah. Well, you know, I've seen people make impressive stuff in their backyard. That is true. People have made nuclear reactors in their backyard, so.

thisMm-hmm. But a nuclear reactor's pretty easy to make, so. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, this is… I mean- Yeah. We've all made a nuclear reactor. We've all made… It's relatively easy to make, harder to control and do safely. All right. So that's our episode on wormholes. I hope you enjoyed the episode. I know Lucas and I both very much enjoyed talking about it. Mm-hmm. That was a fun one. That was a fun one. Uh, please join us next week, where we are going to be discussing how humanity and other species are probably gonna live in space without planets altogether and how that would function and what a society that abandons planets would look like.

thisIf you like the show, please consider subscribing on your podcast platform of choice. If you're on YouTube, give us a like, hit the bell icon, uh, subscribe, and if you really love what we do, you can always support us on Patreon. It helps a ton to buy all the equipment and maintain the show. Yeah. Thank you all so much. Take care. Bye-bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Why Boarding a Spaceship Is Harder Than You Think

    Nov 15, 202640 minAudio

    How do you capture an enemy spaceship without destroying it? Boarding actions are a staple of science fiction, but how realistic are they? In the vacuum of space, getting aboard an enemy vessel might be the easy part....

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Would Immortality Lead to a Stagnant Civilization

    Nov 9, 202630 minAudio

    What happens to civilization when people can live for hundreds or even thousands of years? Life extension could transform humanity, but it also raises some difficult questions. If people no longer die of old age, what...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Lofstrom Loops and the Physics of Actively Supported Structures

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    What if we could build structures that reach into space without relying on the strength of steel or concrete? From Lofstrom loops capable of launching spacecraft into orbit to towers stretching 100 kilometers into the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What Will Technology Make Possible in 100 Years?

    Oct 26, 202638 minAudio

    What will technology look like in 100 years? By 2126, advances in artificial intelligence, biotechnology, energy storage, and space exploration could fundamentally transform how we live. In this episode of Entropy...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How Stars Work: The Physics of Fusion, Gravity, and Death

    Oct 19, 202635 minAudio

    How do stars work, what powers nuclear fusion, and why do some stars survive for trillions of years while others burn out in just a few million? In this episode of Entropy Rising, we take a deep dive into the physics of...

    Credit the people on this episode