After operating her tea house for 15 years in the Gruene, a historic community located within the city limits of New Braunfels, Texas, Carol Irwin decided it was time to think bigger. Irwin explored the larger New Braunfels market. And there she found the right spot for a breakfast, lunch, and brunch cafe concept. In the summer of 2011, she and her daughters opened Buttermilk Cafe, which quickly became a New Braunfels’ favorite. In fact, its popularity presented the only downside of the 3,000-square-foot space, which was not large enough to accommodate the crowds and often resulted in an hour-long wait to be seated. So Irwin went to work on expanding the cafe’s footprint, and in 2015, she took over the space next door. Now, with 4,600 square feet and 150 seats, Buttermilk Cafe even offers additional space for private parties and meetings. Irwin explains how caring for her guests and staff has created a "people-first” culture in her concept that promotes customer loyalty and low employee turnover. Says Irwin, “I learned long ago that treating staff like family helps them bond with you, care for one another, and stay longer. I also believe that although the customer isn't always right, they are always the customer - the most important part of this business.” Irwin shares her approach to seasonal menu development and commitment to quality. “I am concerned about product cost like anyone else,” she says. “However, I prefer to build volume by offering better-than-breakfast-chain quality at reasonable prices, even though that creates tighter margins.” Irwin also provides tips on community marketing and how to integrate technology without sacrificing guest engagement. “At this point in my life, it’s about maintaining a good work-life balance, which is why closing on Sunday has always been important to me and my family.”
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to another episode of The Corner Booth, the official podcast of RestaurantOwner.com. Today, the restaurant industry is changing faster than ever. Learn from successful independent restaurant operators and other industry leaders as they share best practices that will help you engage your team, delight your guests, and grow your business. Hey, hello, everyone. Welcome to another episode of Corner Booth.
I'm Chris Tripoli with RestaurantOwner.com. We're going to have a really good, fun conversation for you today because I was thinking that when we normally bounce around the states and we talk about the successful independent restaurant operators, the wide variety of restaurants we have, a lot of times we're drawn to the bigger cities. You know, if you're in a big state like New York or Florida Texas, California, we're always hearing about or reading about trends being set, the chef-owner restaurants that are maybe in the larger cities.
And to a certain extent, that's true. But I find a lot of times the best gems and sometimes the best stories come from the smaller towns. Today, we are in New Braunfels, Texas, and we're going to talk about a really successful breakfast, lunch, brunch concept that the neighborhood's really connected to. That if you want to go, come early, come early, come often, but don't be surprised if you might have to wait. I'm talking about the Buttermilk Cafe. The chef owner operator is Carol Irwin. Carol Irwin has a really interesting story, a great concept.
So let's welcome Carol. Thank you so much for being with us today. Welcome to Corner Booth, Carol. Thank you so much. I'm pleased to be here. Well, I love your place. I know that if any of our listeners, you know, were close or in the New Braunfels area, they'd probably be there and they'd say the same thing. But for the listeners who aren't, let's get started first by telling them maybe a little bit about you. How you first got interested in the business. Then we can kind of go into how that became your current concept. All right. Actually, I got into the business, dragged into it, to be honest with you, by my first husband,
cut my teeth on the businesses that he learned to do, and somehow I ended up dragging him down here because this was going to be my first business. My first business was called the River House Tea Room in Historic Green. It lasted for 15 years when I sold it to a young man who wanted to be another restaurant owner. My first husband and I divorced because, as you will know, most restaurant people just end up divorcing because of the hours, the dedication it takes, and either your husband and wife working in it,
or sometimes you just grow apart and we just grew apart. During that time, after the divorce, I was approached about opening up another restaurant. And my daughters and I came up with a concept that we thought New Braunfels needed. Not something that we wanted to do, but what did New Braunfels need? And I had remembered the time when there was the Hill Country Cafe that was associated with a hotel in the background. and they had mowed the thing down
and put up a CDS pharmacy thing on it. But all the VIP guys would go there for coffee and breakfast in the morning. And I thought, one day, I want to be a Hill Country Cafe where all the VIPs, all the townspeople go to eat. They don't go to corporate. They go to another restaurant. And it ended up happening. So Gordon Hughes was our landlord,
owned the Chandelier Shopping Center, and, He said, let's do this. He held my hand. He showed me how to get into it. He looked over my papers. He scrutinized it. He sat with me at the bank as we borrowed money and put a lot of handholding in order to, because it's risky getting that much money. And, of course, single at the time, I was just not sure I was big enough. Yeah. But he could see my potential, and it just worked out.
The townspeople came. We started off doing lunch and dinner. The restaurant was starving. It was good food, but a lot of competition at night. So we switched over to breakfast like I had wanted to, and that was the key thing that changed everything. We're known more for our breakfast than lunch, and we don't even try for dinner. We all get to go home. We have a normal life. We work a seven to five, you know, basically normal work day,
and we're closed Sundays. So we can all go to church. My group needs to go to church. Okay. Okay. Well, you don't even want to touch that one, but I hear what I'm saying. You know what? And I tell you what, that's a strong. conviction for a commitment to lifestyle because if you are really strong and you are a strong breakfast place breakfast brunchy lunch you typically sundays would be one of your unbelievable over-the-top days it was our best day so to be committed to closing on sunday
says a lot about you know commitment to you know you do in staff and yes the need for we've been doing fine you You know, you're not going to be able to spend it all anyway. So why, I don't want to work all my life and I don't mind working hard, but you just need to find time for you and your family. You don't want to go down the same road you've already been on, because that doesn't work. You can be successful, but not so successful in your marriage or your relationships.
So you got to pick and choose. You got what you want to change, and it starts with you first. Wow. Yep. Very important. I think the other important point you made, there were two things that I thought I liked, and that was when you were concepting this, when you wanted to do this, you latched on to somebody that obviously was the right piece of the puzzle. And sometimes we need that. We need a little outside advisor. Your landlord helped you play a role on business planning, sat with you on funding. That's a very good point. I hope everyone's making note of that when you are
ready to do this, you can't do it alone. You kind of need a small team around you. That's exactly right. Fill the gaps. And then the second point you made is, you know what? Be true to the original idea. Yes. As a lunch, dinner cafe, you weren't doing well, then you switch to saying, this is what I wanted to be originally, and boom, you're on fire with breakfast and lunch. Yes, they sure were. And it hasn't stopped yet. So when was this? How many years ago was this that Buttermilk Cafe opened?
We opened in 2000, let's see, 2012. Okay. So, yeah, so it's been... 7-7-11 was our opening day. Oh, 2011. 2011. So we've been here, what, 14 years? Is that a good math? Where's my calculator? Yeah, it does. You lose time when you're having fun. But yeah, really, to be around for 15 years is a strong note.
Can you describe a little bit of the Buttermilk Cafe? We know that it's in a shopping center because you told us that. But how about size, seating capacity? Do you have private dining facilities for family parties? How do you operate? Well, it started off just a little smaller when we first occupied the space. It was probably about 3,000 square feet. And a restaurant happened to have been there originally, but his wife had passed
on and he wanted to do something different. And so we occupied that space. About five, four to five years into it, we expanded the dining area because we were already on an hour to an hour and a half wait when we began the breakfast part of it. And my landlord said, your next door neighbor's moving out. I want you to expand to that. Okay. Hand-holding again, nervous mini here. But I knew what kind of note I could handle and we made it work with the bank in,
Took a little while to get started. So now we have about 45, not quite 5,000 square foot restaurants with kitchen. Sometimes we do private parties. There is definitely a call for it, but I don't like to do them on weekends. Okay. Because weekends are the toughest. You're just full from the time you open at seven till you close at two. And private parties occupy a lot of time and a lot of space and a lot of kitchen attention. And I don't want to sacrifice the daily guys that come in.
Well, you know, and that's another good show of care and concern for the regulars. You're not alone in that. We see that as a good trend that private parties are welcome, but they kind of have to be, I guess, around hours. Yes. So we'll do it after we close. I mean, but they're going to have to pay a particular fee because I still have to have a full cruise. Sure. So if they're willing to ante up, then it's a go. And they can occupy the restaurant up to three to four hours,
depending on what the meal is. But I got to pay the crew no matter what. So it's just a normal workday that's just been expanded. Well, that makes sense. And out of that 4,600 square feet, you probably seat, what, 150? Yes, 150. And if you brought a TV tray, that means we could seat more. I love it. I love it. Maybe that's what the hostesses should start saying. Listen, you want to wait maybe a shorter period of time? Come with a TV tray. We can serve you right here.
We've got to think outside the box, Chris. Well, you've been doing very, very well, really, since 2011, 2016, with the expansion, more seats. Okay. How about a little bit about the concept? What seem to be the more popular items that people are ordered? Do you have, like some people are doing now with trendy breakfast brunch menus, and that means offer alcohol as well to do Bloody Mary mornings or not? We do have beer and wine.
We don't, it's not a big part of our customer base. I don't know if it would increase alcohol sales if we had a full bar, but definitely I don't have room unless we expand it again. And I don't know if I want that kind of a drinking customer. I usually, when I talk to others, you don't just get the, you know, those who just want to come in for a cocktail. You get the heavy drinkers. So I don't want to mess with that.
It wouldn't necessarily be a part of your concept. You know, it's a breakfast-lunch menu, really good brunchy. Even in the concepts that I do see that offer alcohol, in this particular concept, they don't do like a setup bar, not a full bar. They don't even have bar stools or bar customers. It's just meant to sell to the tables. And they don't have promotions on things like, breakfast-related drinks, mimosas, Bloody Marys, things of that nature, but it certainly isn't meant to be a bar.
But you probably do a little bit of that, I guess, with beer and wine. Well, we sell what we call bloody beers, which is the beer of their choice and the zesty zing-zang, I think that's what that's called. And then we'll sell lots of mimosas, whether it's traditional or pineapple or cranberry that goes along with the juices that we already carry. So we will sell quite a few of those or just bottles of champagne if somebody's having a special day.
So that works for us. Do we have a bartender? No. The man who makes the salads mixes the drinks. I love it. There's no bartender tip out. I love it. That's a good example of cross-training. What's your position? Well, I'm pantry and bar. That's exactly right. And yes, they have to be TABC certified. So, but that's not what it is. What's the approach to food at Buttermilk Cafe?
I know that you are a certified chef. So maybe you could talk about how you did that in addition to, you know, already being in the business, getting in, operating residence. How did you go about the culinary training required? And then how did that, I guess, impact how you approach your menu? Well, I'm not sure if it's training or not. However... Being in the food business or just being a people watcher before I was ever
in the food business, the first thing you need to concentrate is what does the customer want? I mean, because that will drive anything. So you need to find out first, what are their immediate needs? And then you can expand on that. It's kind of like selling a car. You've got a body with four wheels, but now it comes with a radio. So that's my philosophy in it. You can meet their basic needs,
but how are you going to do your plate presentation? What else might trigger something else? Like, for instance, we do bacon and eggs and biscuits. But we introduced a strata. Not every restaurant has a strata because I only know that I'm the only one. But because of my background, I know what that is. It's an egg dish and it's baked in an oven. So we've got our pantry set up so that we bake those to order. So it's to provide something different that they want to try and it works well.
Quiche isn't always sold at breakfast places, but the ladies love quiche. and they like a variety. So it's just appealing to the customer what, I mean, they could get bacon and eggs at home. So what are you going to make them come out the front? Exactly. So what I'm hearing, and I think you're right on target with what people need to know, is that when it comes to menuing, you've got to deliver what the customer wants. The more you understand the profile that you're attracting, you want to hit
what the customer wants. But then I guess your rule number two is then tell your story. You put a little spin on it. You might put a little uniqueness. That defines your point of difference because to your point, if it's just good bacon and eggs, heck, you can get it anywhere. You can stay home and make that. So now that makes a whole lot of sense. If I look at your menu again, I can see that these are things that you know are popular. The customer likes it. You're working with eggs. You do a really good bakery. You've got all kinds of pancakes.
But they will look a little different. And you whispered with your own spit on things. That's true. Exactly true. What seem to be the house specialties? What do people seem to like most about your place? Well, if you're talking about menu, the thing that sells the most are three eggs, bacon, potatoes, toast. To me, it's too much breakfast, but I don't know that they can eat it all,
but that's what they want. The next thing that is ordered a lot is chicken and waffles. That's also a good item. We've tried different kinds of chicken. We've tried getting chicken breasts. We're cutting it into our own strips, putting our own batter and twist on it. And we've even used a commercial chicken breast that's already come battered and you just fry it up. The customers know when it's not made by scratch. And that's my customer.
So we may have tried the box stuff, but we went back to giving them that extra little special twist of having it. It just tastes different. It just looks different. It feels different, the whole thing. And it looks like a better coverage of plate, too. So, scratch made. Yes. You don't seem to cut corners on quality. I do not. I buy an expensive bacon. I keep trying to find an inexpensive bacon, but it just doesn't work out.
Wouldn't it be nice if we could actually find less expensive items that we still like? That's good. Even eggs. I can't even just use a white egg. I have to use a brown cage-free egg. Not that the customer's demanding that, but that's my issue. I like the way the eggs come from underneath the chicken. And it's a bright orange, you know, it's not a pale yellow. So that's already a color pop. And it tastes just slightly different,
or maybe it's my imagination. I don't know. But I got the crayon. That's how I want to color it. I like that. I like it. So then do you have, let's moving from food to a little bit about the operation, the idea of developing, implementing day by day to maintain your business and maintain your standards. What type of a team did you develop around you? Other managers, shift leaders?
How is it that you're structured in order to get what you want done, done consistently? Well, you're probably not going to like the answer, but starting off, there was no structure. I was being led. And so you either you either learn quickly, which I did, and take over and or you're just going to you're just going to die on the vine. But but I did have starting off, I had another executive chef there in the kitchen so I could operate the general business because you can you could just wear
so many hats and they're all going to fall off. They've got too many hats on. And I did have some good front-of-the-house managers, and somehow we just made that all happen. My first executive chef, when we were working on the menu, he and I would collaborate his input on his tape and how we developed the recipes. I mean, you would have thought that with our background, we would have been a little bit more organized and walked in with our cookbooks and ready to go.
Oh, no, that would require a whole other class we didn't take. No, we just started cooking. I don't even know how to, you know, I wish I could tell you how impressive I am, but we just started cooking and made the changes as we go along. We still cook like that. Uh-huh. But not necessarily, it's a plan that we still cook from the hip. And why is that? Because things have changed in what you get in the back door. Yeah.
The quality has changed. I've even grown to that. I'm only going to buy name brand products that I know and trust. I can't just trust the label from the rep brand. I have to have a, you know, if you're buying Fritos, you better be buying Fritos. So those are some pretty good principles to operate by. I know it does help when you have a concept where the hours are limited. Everyone's getting this about seven.
You know, you close, I think, at like three. So everyone is, what, done by five. Well, we actually close it too. And they're usually, depending on who it is, done by three or three thirty. They're home. So that is a little bit easier on scheduling, management structure. Yes. So, yeah, so some of the listeners don't have, I think, you know, that advantage because they're trying to structure something to have enough supervision and opening and closing and shift change rules and things
to last through the whole day and work the evening. So that's a little bit of a break. But truer words were never more spoken. We get into the business, and the good news is you knew your focus, and you delivered on the focus, which was quality. And you're honest about the fact that you weren't really systemized for policies, procedures, probably having items currently item-costed, labor schedules done to a budget. These were probably things that were not at all on your mind.
I didn't even know what you were talking about if you'd been talking to me about it earlier. Who are you? Okay, we've all been there. That's now. How do you find, however, now that we, you know, move into, say, the current challenges of today's operations, where in order to maintain that quality... Most everyone I talk to is very concerned with increasing costs, dairy costs, protein costs, paper costs, any of our to-go materials,
things that are imported, avocados. It's like it's a constant worry from what country our product's coming in from and can we maintain the quality without having to really, you know, jump up prices. Let's kind of stop there and have you talk a little bit about your philosophy on things like managing cost and setting menu prices. I am probably the worst at setting menu prices. I usually do an increase every other year. I don't do it yearly.
I probably should do it yearly, but when I do an increase, you're going to notice it on the menu. I don't nickel and dime people. You're just gonna you're just gonna have to pull your big girl pants up and just just do it and you you may lose some customers who are on fixed incomes that i mean if if you're gonna let a dollar. Make your decision on where you eat you probably should be eating home anyway but that's okay everybody makes their own decisions
we are due menu pricing so we're already looking at trying to get maybe a smaller menu so that we can fine-tune maybe what comes in the back door. You know, there's some things you'd buy that's only used for one dish. That's not really a good idea. So be fine-tuning things like that. Even for the idea to have cucumbers on a salad, if you're not selling enough cucumbers, I mean, if you're not selling enough salads, That means your cucumbers
are needing to find another place, like you're creating a cold salad to move the cucumbers along. So I don't need to work so hard. So we're trying to refine our menu to do things like that. What was your other question? Labor? Well, those are great steps right there. The idea of cross-utilization, I think that deserves to be underlined. People need to realize that, that sometimes a more limited menu that is funneled down to what the customer really wants, and you know you can do really well, is the best way of managing costs.
More items on the menu only mean more items in inventory. It doesn't really mean more customers in seats. Yeah, so you made a very good point there that I think everyone really can learn from. The second point was cross-utilization. If you've got something in-house that you know you use, it's a key product, well, then using that main raw ingredient in other areas helps you stay creative. So important. I can't be throwing my money in the trash can. That's my... That's right. Good money. Don't be throwing it in the trash.
I know. Listen, that's my crayon, and I'll do the coloring. I learned that. I heard that from somebody. You're a good listener, Chris. I got that one. I'm used to that one. I like that a lot. Okay, those are good menu points. But now let's talk about the flip side of that. You got the planning of the menu, the limiting of the menu, the use of the product. Do you stay current with item cost? And is that something that can come off of your point of sales with your, you know, taking a look at what item sells?
A lot of people I know are sort of married to that item sales report, and they want to know that their big sellers cost a certain percentage, and they try to keep that percentage current. Is that how you try to work on item cost? Yes and no. I do have a POS system that does tell me how many items we sell a month or a week or a day. So I know what the popular items are. And if you need to sell one of this or one of that, that doesn't bother me so much.
If it's, if it's, if that product is being utilized in other areas, like for instance, you might be selling hamburgers. Well, you're going to also find a hamburger steak on the menu. So if we only sell, you know, one hamburger or let's just say one hamburger steak that I'm not going to, I'm not going to do that. It's just way to push my product. Yeah. I already always know the big sellers. I wish everything could be a big seller, but maybe I should be thankful it's not. I'm not really sure. But it just also tells me the things I need to fine tune
of what things I need to eliminate or find another use for. Because you don't want your menu to get boring. No. And I do look at food costs. I know when things start rising up on my nose. I know corporations use it. I don't know what our other small business units use, but I learned to have an Excel spreadsheet with everything that comes in the back door. And I have somebody that inputs what it costs, you know, refigures it so that
we know what how much food I'm buying, if it's changed in the whether it's come up or come down. So I know when things move up and move down. Do I change my price menu immediately? No, but it is that I'm cautious of. For instance, like when eggs went up, because I buy an expensive egg anyway, you used to buy white eggs at $35 for 15 dozen. And my eggs, because I use brown eggs, my eggs were $55. That was fine. They went up to as high as $180 per 15 dozen.
Holy moly. Now, I didn't raise my price, and I didn't do the charge what other businesses were doing, like charging a dollar more for, I think, what, EJ? I just bid it because it couldn't—because that's just too much up and down. I let my customers—they knew there was no price change, and it wasn't going to be forever. If it was going to be forever, we were all going to lose anyway because nobody was going to be buying eggs. And it didn't last that long, maybe six weeks. Somehow we made it through, still had a good profit. I don't know how that happens, but it did.
So some things are just short term, some things are longer term. So it's already a better year even over last year. Wonderful. See, and that's wonderful to hear. A couple of really good points were made there. Yeah, if we understand our menu and what's selling, if we have a decent markup anyway, then yeah, sure, we're not going to like it when costs spike. But like you were saying, we don't have to react every time a cost spikes. We don't have to do one thing like keep changing menu prices or another would
just start adding extra charges. Side egg goes up a dollar. Yeah, that doesn't feel very good at the customer. I learned that a long time ago, I guess self-taught with avocados. They have a season. They always go up in the winter season and they're down in the summer season. So price it at the winter price and just leave it there. Sure. You'll be fine. That's true. That's true. You'll be fine. So let's take a look at another concern that I'm sure listeners
have on their mind, and that is the labor structure. Because you are high quality, a lot of fresh made in-house, do you have a pretty large back-of-the-house kitchen staff? I think so. You do? I do. And so is labor a market in your area, something you're concerned with? Is it hard to find and hard to retain people? It most certainly is. Needless to say, I'm probably the most skilled in my kitchen, which gives me probably respect.
And thank goodness they all respect when I say jump. Otherwise, that would be a whole different problem. But I've been able to have and keep chefs that have come from corporations that get burnout because they're open all night long and they don't want those kinds. So I've been able to get skilled people on eggs. And that is a skill in itself, just like steaks are. So I have a good crew like that. I have a crew that some only speak Spanish and I don't speak Spanish that well.
We do a lot of sign language, which I can't talk about. But we understand each other in love and I have some who have a culinary background they have gone to school so they just know the books and now they're in the kitchen getting to know what that feels like do they some don't even have a sense of urgency they have one speed that can drive me crazy. They don't belong on the hotline, so you need to relocate them to someplace
else where the speed fits their mentality. Some people's 100% is not the same as other people's 100%. I don't know how else to describe that. Not only are you trying to hire not as skilled labor, but then you're trying to fit a person into a position that fits their personality. So I just can't go around just firing people just because it doesn't fit. Although I do that sometimes too, depending on what all happens, but I don't like to do it.
I helped them relocate. That is true. It's a shame, but yes, sometimes even in the best of situations, as long as everyone's had an opportunity to sell, an opportunity to demonstrate and to learn and to get better, that seems to be what I'm hearing is the best we can do is create an operating environment where people feel like I've got a chance to fit in, to connect, to do well. Now, some will do better than others, and some, every once in a while, that is true.
They have to be sort of blessed onto their next place, or maybe things will fit a little bit better. Well, everybody will be happier in the long run, for sure. Well, you know, some people come in with the background of they are dishwashers. And but after talking to him they've also worked in other areas of the kitchen but they prefer the dishes because it's less demanding as a
per if a person's happy there I'm going to be happy for them it's just finding the right personality for the right job and I've had people who have been with me gosh you know my dishwasher has been with me since the beginning so he's one of my highest paid staff, needless to say. I wouldn't want to lose it. Waitstaffs had been with me from the beginning and some of my kitchens, so it's not always about money. It's probably about being comfortable.
Working with Sam's way. What a good point. No, I'm hearing that a lot. People might say it a little bit differently, but I think a lot of hands-on operators are saying that that's one of the key things they've learned over these last few years is that good workers stay. Of course, compensation is important. But I hear that a lot, that it isn't just the money. People are staying if they feel like they belong. They fit. They really like it. They're engaged. They feel appreciated,
maybe tested. They're learning. All these other things are just as important as, yes, I get a check every two weeks. That's true. And if you treat them, you know, if you have somebody who's had a death in the family, they will get a check to help them if they have to travel. And it's not alone. It's just a given. You would do the same thing if it was to a family member. So those are just little tweaks that we do to help people yes they have to prove that they've actually had family
that died but that's usually not you know a real a real issue they're just you know happy to have it so they can fly out to california to be with the rest of the family or or whatever and. We have tried to hire 16-year-olds. I don't know if you've heard anything about hiring young staff that doesn't fit all the time for my cafe. I wish it did, but they don't have a mature enough mind yet,
or the ones that I've hired, have that sense of urgency. They're not looking for things to do. They have a lot of play in them. And it doesn't really seem to matter how much instruction you give them. They are not wanting instruction, the second thing. So too young of a person in my restaurant doesn't work for us. It's like saying not everybody is my customer. Not everybody's going to like us, and it's okay. It's just okay.
Everybody has their favorite, everybody drives a different car for personal reasons, and therefore not every customer is my customer. Some people we've had to run off, but that's a whole other thing, too. Well, hopefully that doesn't happen very often. No, it does not, but I never feel bad about it. No. Okay. Well, that makes great sense. It does. And it sounds like if people get in, they're working well with the volume. You cross, you know, I would imagine people do prep, also work the line.
People that work one line position, are they trained to work others as well? Oh, most certainly. You have to have, you have to know, you have to be, you just have to be ready to drive the truck, you know, or learn how to change a flat. You just have to know how to do that. Sounds good. Cross training seems to work. Yeah. I've heard that not only does it work in that instance where it works for the benefit of the owner-operator because they're flexible. Like you said, everyone knows how to fix a flat. I can move someone if I need
to from station to station. We also seem to find that it works to the benefit of the staff person. They feel the more they know, the more they can do, the more valued they are. We seem to find that the longer they stay, the better they do. So everybody seems to win. One of the things I also do, I know it's not always practice in other corners, but I have to be ready to work a position also. Sure. So I better know that position also. Otherwise, I'm just nothing but talk.
So I need to show them that I'm willing to scrub a toilet or wipe down a table or carry a tray back or get in the dish pit and help mop, whatever. A lot of owners... Don't feel like that's their job. To me, behavior is part of your job. You need to show them that you're willing to do it. And this is what you set the bar. Yeah. You set the bar. You're setting the example by doing that. You're also showing what a sign of support if the owner jumps in to help bust
a table because you're busy or help run food because you don't want it to sit or jump on the line because the fry guy's behind. That's exactly right. Exactly. You need to do your part instead of just stand there and say, you need to work harder. Well, that's it. Somebody told me that once where it's like, it's not going to work. They're going to walk off. That's it. Somebody told me that once that he said, you know what, if you're an owner, that means you're actively walking. You're doing a figure eight all the time.
You're looking at the customer, you're assessing the needs and you're working with your staff. If you're just standing there watching, you're a spectator. You're not an owner. Yeah, that's exactly true. I'm looking at plates. I'm looking to see, you know, what else do they have on the table? Is it moving? Are they eating it? Or even what's brought back into the dish pit? What's being thrown away? Why? Right. So I'm trying to learn what the customer is eating, what they're throwing away.
Why are they sitting unhappy at the table? Did a server not come up to them or did they just walk in the restaurant unhappy? And now you need to figure out what to do next. So there's all kinds of stuff. Well, can we talk a little bit about customer acquiring customers? You've obviously done such a good job over the years. You've got a loyal clientele. Well, and congrats to you for doing that. That's the kind of thing that everybody wants to have is a loyal, regular following.
But do you find that you've developed that by using certain community involvement? Are there marketing tactics you do? How do you keep your staff, I mean, not your staff, how do you keep your customer base informed? And is one thing working better than another? Yeah. Most of my staff, my front of the house staff, knows their customer. The customer eventually will say, I want to sit in so-and-so section. So they know their customer. To the point even, they know what they're going
to order before they have even said it. So I like that. They know their names. They know their history. They know who's going to the doctor, for what reason, who didn't show up that Saturday to come in for breakfast. They're going to find out what went wrong last week. So they're engaged. They have developed a relationship with the customer. My husband worked with me out front also. He liked to pour the coffee and talk with people. He was a salesman.
He passed away in March, and we definitely missed his. He was the mayor of the cafe. He would shake hands and kiss the babies. Perfect. I need another one. another guy just like that but he would pour the coffee and and he would have a table say well can you bring me a glass of water also and RC would say I'm the coffee guy I'm not the water guy so he had the tables laughing you
know who says that to people we do we like to joke with them and tease with them and find out how their day is going. And usually it works out really well for us. There's always some people will say, well, my egg is not right. You never fix my egg like I want it. And I go out there and say, well, why do you keep coming back? There's other places to go to. They can probably do a better job. Obviously we can. So like I said,
not every customer is our customer. Did they come in mad or did you make them mad? Whatever. So. Every, everybody's different. Every day is different. Well, you mentioned your front of the house staff, and that is true because we didn't talk very much about that. But this is a full service cafe. Hostess can reach you, manages the wait list. Yes. Servers and bussers on the floor. And it's really good that you've been fortunate that you've got such a good, steady staff that they bond with.
Yes. And fill up a relationship with the guest. That seems to be the goal in this day and age is for independent restaurant operators to feel like they're creating that work environment where the staff feel more like family, which means they will treat guests like they would treat their family. Without building that relationship, without building that connection, it's going to be really hard to get that loyal following. That's true. Without the loyal following, the guy down the street might get the loyal following. One of the things I want to point out, too, and this might be to my detriment, you know, but I don't see it happening yet.
A lot of restaurants, even smaller restaurants, are getting those handheld computer, you know, cash in, cash out. We don't do that. And I also don't have a computer system that have you signed in or there's an app where you can call in, make a reservation. We don't do reservations. We'll do a call ahead. Wait. We know you're coming. We'll put you down on the list. Before you arrive, you can wait at home and then come in if I'm telling you it's an hour wait. So we don't have any of those electronics because it's been my note,
you're less engaged with the customer if you're using too much electronics. Social media or, or handhelds, you're not looking them in the face. You're not engaged with them. So we are, I make my, my servers go back to the computer with the, with all their cards and stuff and, and run the tickets and talk to them and, and things like that, instead of just here, sign this on the ticket. And here's a, here's an option for a tip.
That's too much in, that's too much in my face. I don't like it when it's done to me. I don't say anything because Thurber can't help it. Somebody else made that decision for him to use that, but we don't do that. We are old, old system. Maybe because I'm old. I don't care. I'm not going to pass for it. Actually, no, there's a really good growing trend in that where people feel like, hey, we're challenged because restaurants are a big, big part of the hospitality industry.
So one thing that we could slide off the ledge and forget about is hospitality. So we can't allow convenience to take the place of good old-fashioned eyeball to eyeball like you're talking about hospitality. So keeping the tech in the background, keeping the staff very engaged, those are wonderful principles. I want to touch on one other principle too and see what you think about this one. And that is with certain costs that seem to be more increasing than others,
there seems to be a trend in some operators to say, let's just show the cost to the customer. If you use a credit card, just charge them the 3% for it. Or let's go ahead and pay our people more, but go ahead and charge the ticket a service fee or what some people call living wage fee. And so everyone is sharing that cost with us. You probably don't share that opinion, I would bet, do you? Oh, I share an opinion. It's probably been about two years, but we swung over to a credit card system
that give the customer the option to either pay cash or they can use their debit or credit card, but it's going to be a 3% charge onto them that we're up front with. And I had to do that. I didn't want to do that. But it became so expensive on the owner's side. For instance, it was nothing to spend, give the credit card people $6,000 to $7,000 a month from fees uncollected.
Sure. Well, that's because, what, doesn't 90% of your customers charge anyway? Well, no. Yeah. But that's even on top of tips. You would have to even process a charge for tips. So it just became, that's a whole person's salary. Yeah. I just, I couldn't afford it anymore. I just couldn't afford it anymore, or I just needed to bow out. And I'm probably becoming of the age where I need to bow out anyway.
Hey, I've got a place for you to buy. Okay there you go you guys have heard it if you want a really good successful, seven to five operation come to new braunville's meet carol take a tour have a cup of coffee and fall in love with the buttermilk cafe just hand me a chick. Okay, that's between you two. Carol, this has been wonderful. I mean, I hate that we have to wrap up. You are charming.
Love your place. Love your philosophy. Thank you so much for sharing all of these tips and trends and your thoughts on the industry. So I say continued success to you. Keep setting the example, raising the bar in your local community and doing what you're doing. I hope to cross paths with you very soon. and have another waffle and a cup of coffee or something. Let me know when you're in. I'll come sit with you. I will do it. I will do it. And listen to everybody else out there, if you aren't fortunate enough to live in or get close to New Braunfels, then you're just going to have
to go look her up on the website, read all about Buttermilk Cafe. And I hope that you'll go have a great shift. Go make it a good day. And let's get back together real soon on another episode of Corner Booth. Thanks. Thank you for joining us on The Corner Booth. We'll be back next Tuesday with more inspiration insights and industry best practices to help you engage your team Delight your guests and grow.
For years, Joe Cervasio and Alex Melillo followed different paths through the hospitality industry. One developed his career in some of New York City's most prestigious hotels and event venues, while the other built...
Matt Brice, founder of Federal American Grill, built his career from the ground up. After starting as a dishwasher at age 12, he developed his leadership skills through national restaurant brands, independent restaurant...
Ashley Morris, CEO of Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop, followed a path few restaurant leaders ever take. After becoming a devoted customer, he invested as a franchisee, helped grow multiple locations, and eventually became...
Kim Brown founded Belong Kitchen after confronting a challenge faced by many families of adults with intellectual and developmental differences: the lack of meaningful employment opportunities after high school. What...
Richard Zoob, CEO of Rosa Mexicano, is leading one of the restaurant industry's most established brands through a period of renewal. Drawing on experience across independent restaurants, national chains, private...