Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Corner Booth Podcast

Corner Booth Podcast artwork

Episode 151: Ashley Morris with Capriotti's Sandwich Shop

Nov 3, 202650 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Ashley Morris, CEO of Capriotti’s Sandwich Shop, followed a path few restaurant leaders ever take. After becoming a devoted customer, he invested as a franchisee, helped grow multiple locations, and eventually became part of the team that acquired the brand. That experience provided a front-row seat to the challenges of transforming a small regional concept into a growing national chain while protecting the elements that made it successful in the first place. For operators considering restaurant franchising, growth can create a difficult tradeoff. The systems, support structure, and resources required to help franchisees succeed often look very different from what was needed to operate a handful of company locations. Questions around unit economics, distribution strategy, market selection, and long-term scalability can determine whether expansion creates value or creates problems. Those same decisions become even more important in an environment shaped by rising development costs, increasing operating expenses, and rapidly evolving technology. Operators evaluating restaurant expansion, investing in restaurant data analytics, or exploring the role of AI in restaurants are facing pressures that did not exist a decade ago. Morris brings the perspective of someone who has evaluated growth, profitability, infrastructure, and brand development from both the franchisee and franchisor sides of the business. Book a free restaurant financial consultation with the Cerboni team: Cerboni Services. RestaurantOwner.com members receive a special discount when signing up with promo code: ROCERBONI.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker1Welcome to another episode of The Corner Booth, the official podcast of restaurantowner.com. Today, the restaurant industry is changing faster than ever. Learn from successful independent restaurant operators and other industry leaders as they share best practices that will help you engage your team, delight your guests, and grow your business. And welcome everyone to another episode of Corner Booth. I'm Chris Tripoli with RestaurantOwner.com.

Speaker1For those of you who are active members on the site, you appreciate all that it might be doing for you. For others, I really recommend that you go to RestaurantOwner.com. It is the single greatest source of information and educational material directed at the independent restaurant operator that's on the web today. Cash flow issues in restaurants don't usually happen overnight. They build over time from not having the right visibility. And if you're not closely tracking things like prime cost and food and labor, profitability can slip pretty quickly.

Speaker1Cerboni helps restaurant operators stay ahead of that. Cerboni brings together clean financials, operational reporting, and forecasting so you actually know what's happening in your business. If you want to get ahead of the numbers instead of chasing them, go to serboniservices.com slash contact us or call 281-888-2413 and use code ROCERBONI to book your free consultation.

Speaker1We are all the way in northern Idaho today, and we're going to bring to you the story of a well-established brand that's in over 30 states. I've lost count, 100 and some operations. We're going to hear about Capriati Sandwich Shop. To tell us that story and to share a little bit about himself is Capriatus, Sandwich Shop CEO, Ashley Morris. Ashley, thanks so much for giving me some time and joining us today on Corner Booth. Welcome.

Speaker0Hey, thank you so much for having me. Really appreciate it.

Speaker1Well, you know, before we jump into the concept and how well it's doing and all of its interesting things, maybe you could tell our listeners just a little bit about you. What got you interested in this business to begin with, maybe, and who were your early influences?

Speaker0Yeah sure so i had no plans of becoming a career restaurateur by any means when i was a kid, like a lot of people you know first job second job third job were in restaurants for sure bus boys and dishwashers and things like that but other than that i was primarily focused on finance and working on wall street one day or something like that so, i had not known i was going to be a restaurateur would have lost a bet if you

Speaker0would have bet me back in the early days. But I had fallen in love with Capriati's in college while I was studying finance and really just fell in love with the product. My best friend who I lived with at the time introduced me to it. And I'm a big, you know, I'm a big sandwich guy already, just generally love sandwiches. And cheesesteaks are like one of my favorite sandwiches of all time. And I stumbled onto this place thanks to my best buddy. And, you know, he introduced me to it and I had the cheesesteak at Capriati's and I thought, man, of all the cheesesteaks I've eaten in my entire life,

Speaker0this one was by far hands down the best. And so I started to eat it a lot. My best buddy was also enamored with the product and ate it a lot. And so we actually moved out of the apartment that we were living in, which was pretty close to school and moved into an apartment farther away from school that actually shared a wall with a commercial center that had a Capriati's in it. So sometimes we were eating it for lunch and dinner. I'm serious. We were eating it three to five times a week. It just became a

Speaker0habit. And I just became a very, very heavy user of the product because I just loved it. From the turkey to the roast beef sandwiches to the cheese steaks, the Italian subs. I mean, I went through the entire menu. I couldn't find a sandwich that didn't wow me. And so that's what it was.

Speaker1It was really incredible

Speaker0Yeah it was.

Speaker1Just when you think of it we've had again we've had a lot of different guests different stories it isn't unlike a story to, say, study something else, business background, finance, but then come into the restaurant business. But I don't think we've ever heard one that actually had them and a roommate move to a location that could share a wall so you could be eating there twice a day. That's a record.

Speaker0Well, thanks. I officially hold the record. I'll take it. But, you know, So we, you know, in getting into this business, we, again, even at that point when we were eating it so many times, I graduated college and I went on to my career and so did Jason, my best buddy. So he went on to doing what he was doing, which was in computer science and mathematics and running large scale infrastructure. And I went into finance and worked at Wells Fargo and became a portfolio manager. And so as we, you know, continued to do our careers, we still were eating at

Speaker0the sandwich shop. And eventually we got to a point in our careers where we were making enough money. And we had always wanted to be in business together. And we said, hey, look, this is the time. We have disposable income. We don't have kids. You know, neither one of us were married. Let's have a side hustle. And we had this meeting in the public library because obviously we didn't have an office. We had a public library meeting and we said, bring all your ideas to the meeting. and we'll go through them and we'll vet them together. We'll figure it out. And I remember walking into the library thinking, man, I'm such a failure of

Speaker0a friend because I had only brought one idea. And it turns out he had only brought one idea as well, feeling the same thing. And we both brought the idea, let's become a Capriati franchisee. And so we were aligned literally from the inception of the thought process to become business partners. And so it was that simple. And we went out and spent a year of our life trying to figure out how to become a franchisee of this little teeny tiny regional brand that was primarily in Delaware and had a few locations in Las Vegas.

Speaker0And so we did. And after doing so. We bought and built our first store. We acquired a second store. So one became two, and then we built a third and two became three. And at three, Jason quit his job. We were making so much money in these sandwich shops that he became a full-time area manager and operator of the stores. And my passion pendulum had just further swung to this brand. And I just knew that I no longer wanted to make my life in stocks and bonds

Speaker0and mutual funds. I wanted to make my life in this sandwich shop. And so that's where we started our drive to acquire the business.

Speaker1No kidding. So when was this that you became the franchisee? Had they had a very established franchise program at the time? Well, you kind of have to go in and help develop it.

Speaker0No. So they had an established franchise program. I'm not sure looking at it today or any sophisticated franchisee looking at it today would say it was established, but it was a franchise process nonetheless. So the founder, you know, was incredible at recipes, incredible at, you know, making sure the food tasted right. But really, I don't, you know, she didn't set out to become a large franchisor. She set out to own a business. And that business, you know, created franchising sort of on accident, like a lot of businesses do when they become successful.

Speaker0And so she was running it very, very, you know, light, I would say. You know, I signed my franchise agreement on her living room table. There was no corporate office. There was no formal training program. It was, hey, here's a hat and an apron, come work in our store on Sahara until you figure it out. When we were building our restaurant, it was two pieces of graph paper taped together. It says, put your prep table here and your oven here. So it was very mom and pop for sure. No technology to speak of, but none of that really seemed to matter to us because

Speaker0of our love of the food and our passion for the business. And so as we evaluated it, we looked at it and said, I'll see you next time. It's come this far with all these limited services where we're really have a group of great passionate franchisees that are particularly more mom and pop than, you know, multi-unit. And the locations weren't really much to speak of. They didn't have a great design. They were in B and C locations. Business was successful. And so we thought, hey, if all of these attributes

Speaker0are there and the business is successful, what if we could take it and really level it up? How far could we send this thing into the stratosphere? And that was the investment thesis that led us to look and raise capital to buy the company. So to answer your question, in 2025, excuse me, 2005 was when we became franchisees. And 2027 is when we made the deal with the owner to acquire the brand. And we closed on the transaction Jan 1, 2028.

Speaker0So the perfect time to own a brand new business with no sophistication and limited capital. You know, and about three months after we bought the company, you know, the financial markets collapsed and, you know, we had a completely different business plan than we had originally thought.

Speaker1But here we are. Holy moly. So, yes, it didn't take very many years from the time you became a franchisee to when you guys circled the wagons and decided, let's take the bigger step now, raise capital and purchase the brand.

Speaker0Yeah, I mean, it did. It seemed at the time to be longer than it was as looking back, though. But it was a quick stint for sure. We were pretty aggressive in our growth plans, no doubt.

Speaker1And what a good step to feel like you have something that's successful already. But as you were describing it, it was successful at sort of BNC locations. It was successful as you described it, but without maybe having a sort of a tier one brand identity. And so you thought, what if we controlled that future, updated, upgraded, put it on a new growth plan for better locations, would it work? And maybe you could describe a little bit about how were the differences.

Speaker1I mean, because obviously that means you had to have higher expectations from an initial investment for franchisees to find those kind of locations or have that kind of look. But they probably had an expectation of higher revenue And did that work as you anticipated?

Speaker0Yeah, I think, you know, all great questions. I feel like what we have changed is everything other than the food. So I'll give you a quick story to give you an idea of like, how we thought about this. When we were acquiring the company, I was sitting with the founder in a law office signing the documents with her. And she took off a ring that her grandfather, so the brand is named Capriati's because the founder's grandfather's last name was Capriati.

Speaker0And so she took off her grandfather's ring that she was wearing and she gave it to me and she said, put this ring on and make me a promise. And I said, okay, I'll make you a promise. She goes, you're probably going to change everything and it's going to make me go crazy. But, If you just don't change the quality of the food, maintain the quality that's built this brand for 32 years. And if you do that, you know, everything else will fall into place. And so I made her that promise. And we've, you know, 16 years later, have not only withheld that promise,

Speaker0but we've actually improved upon the quality where we can improve upon the quality. So, you know, everything else is vastly different. And even the menu is slightly different, right? But for the most part, the superstars on the menu that built the brand in 1976, the cheesesteak, you know, the capistrami. The Bobby, those sandwiches have stood the test of time and continue to be there. And we just continue to follow that mindset, which is, you know,

Speaker0for our brand, the food is the franchise. You know, quality is what this brand does. And it's not a lot of brands say that, but we actually live it and I can prove it, you know. So I always say this to people when they say, yeah, everyone says it, right? I mean, every player says we have the highest quality, but here's how I can prove it to you. So if you went to pick your celebrity chef, pick your favorite chef on the planet, and let's say that's Thomas Keller who runs French Laundry, right? Everyone's heard of this guy. He's incredible.

Speaker0If you said make a higher quality turkey sandwich than Capriati's is making, We have a fresh baked roll. We have butterball grade A turkey that has one ingredient that we slow cook in the restaurant every single night. We pull it apart every single morning. We chop our vegetables fresh every single morning. Nothing's in a bag. And make a higher quality, Thomas Keller. The answer is he could not. Could he make it taste different? Absolutely. Could he use, you know, fagouche? Sure, why not? But he could not make a higher quality turkey sandwich.

Speaker0Our steak product, our beef product inside of our restaurants is Snake River Farms American Wagyu. If you went back to Thomas and said, hey, make a higher quality cheesesteak than a Snake River Farms Wagyu cheesesteak or steak sandwich, he could not. Could he make it taste different? Sure. But he couldn't make it higher quality in America. And so that is, you know, effectively how we run this business, right? We look at it and go, how do we bring in the ingredients and how do we bring

Speaker0in the quality that really cannot be matched by our competitive set? And then let's figure out how to bring that into quick service, which is a very difficult task. Sure. So far, we're doing it.

Speaker1I'll tell you what's not very difficult, though, and that's just getting hungry. If you listen to the description that we just had. I think all the listeners need to take a break now and go try to make a really, really, really good sandwich. But, you know, it might be good before we go further for those who haven't had the opportunity to be in a unit and experience those sandwiches. If maybe we just took a couple minutes to describe the concept. I mean, we know, however, it's been longstanding. But if you kind of give us a little bit about what is the traditional size, hours, menu,

Speaker1price range, locations, where can we find you? So that people who, again, aren't that familiar will get more familiar?

Speaker0Yeah, I think the first step is capriottis.com, right? That'll tell you there's a brand story there, there's the locations, the menu, everything like that. Our brand is primarily 1,400, 1,200 to 1,500 square feet, you know, optimally about 1,400 square feet. You know, we are a kitchen disguised as a fast food sandwich shop. And so, you know, we have ovens in our restaurants and griddles in our restaurants and cooking equipment, we are not an assembly line. When you come into Capriati's, you're not walking down the line saying, can I have this, this, this, this, this?

Speaker0You're ordering off a chef-driven menu. And, you know, can you customize it? Absolutely. Can you have it your way? Of course. But generally, you're starting with a menu that has crafted recipes on there that are tried, true, and delicious. So that is really the, you know, the main difference of Capriati's. And, you know, we are, I mean, to your point, I think we're in about 25 states right now. We're about 165 restaurants across the country, including Hawaii, which is really cool.

Speaker0And we probably have somewhere in the neighborhood of about 120 restaurants in our development pipeline in various states in America currently. No plans at the moment to be international, but, you know, we're focused domestically on on building the brand to, you know, what I would call a national brand, which, you know, is probably somewhere between three and 500 units.

Speaker1And then how many do you operate as the company and how many are, you know, franchise locations?

Speaker0We currently operate 18 locations. We do have some growth plans, not heavy growth plans. I think, you know, we build, you know, two restaurants-ish a year. So the brand is primarily franchised, but we love operating the business. And I, you know, couldn't stress this more to anybody listening who's thinking about franchising. The idea of franchising without having company stores, to me. It feels very short-sighted.

Speaker0And, you know, number one, if you're not willing to put your money up to open restaurants, then how can you ask somebody else to? Number two, you will not be aligned with your franchise partners. You know, we are the largest operator of our brand in terms of number of units. So if we make a decision to do a marketing campaign, if we make a decision to discount, if we make a decision to change a product or whatever it is, we have to first look at it as this will impact us the most. And so it keeps us, you know, very aligned with our franchise community and

Speaker0doesn't allow us to make short-sighted decisions that could short-term help the franchisor and long-term hurt the franchisee. And I think that comes back to the experience that we've had as we were franchisees first, right? So we understand or understood at the time what it took to be successful. And, you know, when we were making this investment, it was, I don't want to say life savings, but it really was. I mean, it was every day we had at the time going into these restaurants. And so if they failed, it was a lot of money lost. It would have been a very, very, very hard pill to swallow.

Speaker0So we try our very best to make a system that if you follow and execute our proven process, the odds of you being successful are greatly increased, right? And so we've seen it, again, 160 times where when you follow the process, you achieve a successful result.

Speaker1Boy, right on target. Excellent words. And if it's okay with you, I'd like to stay on this subject, maybe just a couple more questions because there does seem to be a growing interest, I've found, in the independent restaurant community to grow their brand by choosing franchising. And so having the uniqueness, you know, here, and not delve into it a little bit further, I think would almost be criminal. I mean, you were a franchisee first, then you purchased the brand.

Speaker1You see this brand and how to protect the brand and increase its value through both eyes, franchise or franchisee. So could we talk maybe just about a few tips? If somebody does have a strong operation, yeah, they've got a few units, I don't know, four, five, six, and they think that they want to grow through franchising, what are the key things that you would maybe coach them on right from the start? Things that they need to look for, say, within their operation, and then maybe planning areas to go to.

Speaker1How do you decide that? I'd love to have you talk about the selection of a franchisee because I've heard about how, you know, that's just premium. It's almost like selecting a family member. So if you might be able to talk a little bit about those three things and how it works for you guys. Sure.

Speaker0So, you know, the question you asked me is a little bit weighted and I don't want to just give blanket advice. So let me caveat the advice I'm going to give you with a couple of assumptions. So, you know, to answer the question about a guy who's got four or five, six restaurants thinking about franchising, the first question I would need answered before I could really give that advice is what is your vision? Do you want to build a 500-unit chain or do you want to build a 15-unit chain and sell the company and monetize your investment?

Speaker0Because it is a completely different road to do those two things. So my assumption is the question you're asking me is for somebody who wants to see their brand one day become a tier one national restaurant company. And I'll answer it that way. If not, don't franchise, because if you're looking for, hey, I want to do this for five more years, I want to set this thing up and I want to sell, you're much better off not franchising, because as soon as you turn the franchising machine on and you have one franchised unit,

Speaker0you will no longer trade the way you would have normally sold your business, which is a multiple of EBITDA and a, multiple moves based on how big can we take this brand. You now are required to build a support center. You're now required to have the infrastructure to support a franchise model. And so you've just taken your ability to sell and almost eradicated it for some period of time until you build a machine that has value, a franchise support center machine that has value.

Speaker0So, anecdotally, don't do franchising if you are looking for an exit in a smaller time period or you're looking to maximize your exit in a smaller time period. Just keep building company stores and trade on EBITDA. So, now going back to your question.

Speaker1We want to build

Speaker0A tier one 500 store brand and we want to get into franchising. Here are the things that I have felt are the most or I have found are the most important in terms of obtaining a franchise partner that has a high likelihood of success and that can help you scale your business. First and foremost, before you franchise anything, you need to have a four-wall economic model after franchise fees that produce, you know, plus or minus 30%,

Speaker0cash on cash return. So if you don't have that inside of your four-wall box, and you have to be honest with yourself, right? You can't say, oh, I have that now, but, you know, I share management between store A and store B, right? Right. Oh, I have that now, but I'm not counting the up to 10 percent royalties that we would put on the brand. Right. Six percent for the franchise or two percent for marketing, two percent for local. You've got to be honest with yourself. Are you doing the accounting yourself or do you pay someone to do an accounting? You've got to add that. You've got to be honest with your P&L and go all the

Speaker0way through and say, what is a third party who has absolutely none of my, you know, none of my infrastructure? infrastructure, what would they produce on a P&L? And if you can get to 30% cash on cash return, so if your restaurant costs $500,000 to build, and that's an actual factual number, and you vet that across a few state lines, because. There are definitely states that things cost more and things cost less, so you have to average it, and you can achieve 30%, you can check box one.

Speaker0Box two is, can I get distribution? And distribution becomes the biggest barrier to entry for you to scale and grow outside of your sphere of influence. So if you have the ability to, if you're buying retail right now, like, yeah, I'm using US Foods, I'm using Cisco, I'm using whatever, but you're not in some negotiated purchasing agreements with your vendors and you don't have assurance that your vendors and your products can can deliver to other opcos, you need to get that short up and and otherwise your ability to grow outside

Speaker0of your distribution center is highly limited, and so you will not be able to do it so if you are residing in las vegas and a franchisee calls and says yeah i want to open up mississippi, you're not going to be able to do that with the distribution center in las vegas, so you need to get that short up that's checkbox number two. Checkbox number three, before I would franchise, I would want to prove to myself that my brand works outside its sphere of influence. So again, if you're concentrated four to five units, take a state,

Speaker0I'd go a few states away to a different demographic of a human, right? The Midwest thinks different than California. New York and Florida think differently than Wyoming. The Northeast is vastly different than the Southwest in terms of what they like. You've got to go to a different trade area that has a different customer and make sure you can build that brand in that area the same way you built it in your primary trade area. If you can do that, you can check box number three. Now, at box number three, here comes the really hard part because the first three were super hard.

Speaker0But now here comes the really hard part, box four, which is I am going to have to build a real infrastructure. Meaning if I'm going to open stores for people, I'm going to need someone in construction. I'm going to need someone in real estate selection. I'm going to need someone in franchise development. And when you need to put together an infrastructure that probably will take about, I think on the lowest end, about $2 million a year to pay for. So you need to find a way to either raise capital at that point and get yourself,

Speaker0you know, a good amount of capital so you can go out and get a team to start to build this. Or if you're going to grow very slow and very organically, just know you're going to need to be, reinvesting, you know, several millions of dollars a year for the next foreseeable future until you have that infrastructure built, because otherwise you will not attract a franchise partner. That is at a level that you will long-term see success with. So you have to also be willing to take a step back and say, okay,

Speaker0my five, six restaurants are producing, let's just make it up $3 million a year. Are you willing to change your lifestyle now or take that $3 million a year and reinvest it back into your business? Because that is a very hard pill to swallow for a lot of people. If you're willing to do it and you're willing to check that box, congratulations. Welcome to franchising. I think now you get to fight the good fight for the next 10 years and see what you can do.

Speaker1Hey, everybody. I hope you were taking notes. I mean, that right there was summarized in just a couple minutes, a semester course, if you could find one, at the university level of the basic premise of successful franchising. Thank you. A really well point, I mean, points really, really well made about how the work on your existing concept first, the operations success that must be needed, the financial return on investment that really must be there. I love the idea of the testing, four, five, six success stories in one market

Speaker1area isn't necessarily a test. I love the idea of the testing, and I love the idea of the commitment to the long-term future, because I agree with you wholeheartedly that if what we're really looking for, and quite frankly, many people are, which is to develop brand value, put a multiple on that and sell it, and then that really is better if that is the end game to do without necessarily setting up all the franchise infrastructure. So thank you for that.

Speaker0Yeah. I mean, look, there's a reason why franchisors that achieve a level of success trade, you know, upwards of 20 times EBITDA. Restaurants typically trade between three and six times EBITDA, depending, you know, your ability to produce return on investment. So the reason why that jumps so significantly is because of the hurdles I've described, is that you really have taken a next step and built something that is, it's fairly difficult to do.

Speaker1You know, and speaking of fairly difficult to do, we have had, from an operator's point of view, some fairly difficult times this last year or two. We've had challenges for people who are expanding with finding, say, what we might consider relatively reasonable rents, occupancy costs in really good expansion areas, relatively reasonable opening costs, the cost of construction, design, equipment. I mean, I love that where we thought we had the temporary jump up and it was

Speaker1all blamed on the distribution issues, COVID-related, but hopefully they'll come down afterwards. And we haven't seen that. And so we've got costs now for mechanical, electrical, plumbing, restaurant equipment that are higher than ever before. And so the costs of opening in order to find good locations, negotiate rent, and then be able to afford them are much higher than before. How has that impacted all of the units that you've got under development is that is that a cause of concern are you still able to you know grow you know

Speaker1with the pace that you described earlier

Speaker0It's greatly impacted that it is it is a new world that we're in and sometimes people ask me this question i tell them a story i said you know, When interest rates are very low and capital is very, very easy to acquire, you're sort of playing, on an easy level because everything just sort of pencils because the cost of capital is so low, you have access. When the cost of capital is where it is today, which is very average for historical,

Speaker0you know, if you look back at history, you know, the cost of capital at 6% to 8% is probably very fair and very reasonable. You really do have to have the right economics, again, for your business. And so, you know, we're in a new world now where I just don't see any of those things that you've described ever reverting back for at least the next 10 years. There is some theory about, you know, will AI and will automation push economic

Speaker0output tenfold over the next 10 years? And if so, it'll demonetize everything. That might be a different conversation for another day. But right now, looking into, you know, whatever crystal ball we're trying to talk about, over the next five years, the reality is restaurants will not be cheaper to open. Equipment will not be cheaper. Labor will not go down. And, you know, it will just be the new norm. So... That is a huge disruption to restaurants. And restaurants, unfortunately,

Speaker0were already sort of low margin to begin with compared to other industries. That it has definitely impacted it. So personally, how did it impact us? I mean, post-COVID, the stores that were hanging on by cheap capital were damaged to the point of no return. So we had a period of time post-COVID where, you know, we sort of had the haves and the have-nots and the have-nots, unfortunately, had to close and or move locations and enter new trade areas.

Speaker0And so we had some consolidation of our brand for sure. And it definitely slowed down franchise development, but not to the point where, you know, we were impacted and not building restaurants. But I believe if you would ask me in 2019, 2020, pre-COVID, how many stores will you build over the next five years, my number would have been much larger, than what actually happened. So, yeah, it definitely taxed us. And I know we're not alone in that. But, you know, it definitely,

Speaker0you know, it's challenges you have to be prepared to hit head on and figure out how to navigate through them, you know. Yeah.

Speaker1And let's talk a little bit about how you've been able to navigate not so much on the opening side, but ongoing operations. Because, you know, we hear constantly now in order for people to maintain purveyor relationships, stick with the quality, like you talked about earlier before, products are either getting scarce or products are so much more expensive. And so cost of goods are harder. It isn't just the labor that I know we can talk about how labor expense is higher, but it's also cost of goods, just the regular cost to operate. So how do you analyze that and stay current with maybe the guest expectation on pricing?

Speaker1How much can we, you know, absorb? How much do we have to increase costs? How do you really balance that? Because that's a really hard thing, I think, for most independents right now to juggle.

Speaker0Yeah, it is. It is a very difficult thing to juggle. What I have found is if you don't have someone in your organization, who is really good at data insights or FP&A, if you don't have, if you're not that financial minded person that can constantly be wrenching on spreadsheets, and figuring out exactly where we are, where we think inflation can be, how we can price our goods and to find that get maximum, you know, price without, you know, achieving, you know, a loss of customer accounts.

Speaker0You probably need to get somebody in your organization like that, or you need to partner with third parties that do that for you. And because it is, it is very critical. Now, we substantially leveled that piece up for our brand over the last five years. And it really has helped us, you know, there are some AI companies out there that, that, that look at credit card data, and that can tell you exactly what's going on with your customer, where your customer's coming from, how often they're eating, what are they eating when they eat there,

Speaker0how often do they come back if they eat a particular sandwich. So we start to generate a lot of data. And that data helps us understand where we have price elasticity on our menu. It also helps us understand what products may be worth looking at. So for example, we have some sacred cows in our brand, right? We're never going to change the quality of our turkey. We're never going to change the quality of our steak. We're not going to change the processes like homemaking our coleslaws and our stuffings and things like that, but. Where we buy gloves or where we may buy a certain, you know,

Speaker0seasoning or where we may buy things that that are, you know, sort of lower, lower margin and lower volume. Maybe we have an opportunity to rotate those out or find a way to substitute those without sacrificing what we promise the consumer. Right. So so, again, you can't do that by sticking your finger up in the air and hoping you get the right answer. You really have to do that with data and so you have to become great at getting customer data and you have to be great at being able to,

Speaker0articulate it with numbers on a spreadsheet so that it helps form a viewpoint on how i do it and if you can do those things you know look there's there's enough competition out there if you're working with cisco, and you don't like your con you don't like the you know the pricing is going too high and you can't sit down with them and change their mine, then go find someone else, right? And then go find a competitor that will inevitably, you know, beat that price up and, you know, start looking at that stuff.

Speaker0I'll give you one free one that we did that I just thought was really interesting. You know, linen in the restaurant business for everyone who owns a restaurant, right? Linen is just such a weird line item expense. You got to, unless you, you know, got a washer and dryer in your house, you're bringing home your towels and you're just washing them. If you're doing that, you're at sort of the bottom cost. But if you are... If you are with a linen company who's bringing you linen and bringing you, you know, mop heads and things like that, you know, it never ceases to amaze me that whatever price they give you within

Speaker0about four months from now, you're paying double because, you know, they all will bring you 40 towels. And then next week they ask an employee and the employee's like, yeah, I'd love some more towels. And then all of a sudden you have 80 towels. And then you're like, holy crap, how'd this line item go up? So one of the things we did was we used AI, we used Claude. I said, here's 12 months of invoices. I want you to deeply research how I can make this go away. And what it found was that every single product we were basically renting from this linen company, paying $400 or $500 a month for, we could simply buy at

Speaker0Webstron store or Amazon, have it auto shipped to us. And we were able to save like $2,500 to $3,000 per restaurant per year by just making that simple shift. So you could go into, you know, you can go into Claude Chat, whatever you use, and have them be someone, something that can analyze, you know, a line item on your P&L and say, hey, how can we make this better? And we did that with Linen, and it saved us a ton of money, and now we own all our stuff.

Speaker1Incredible. And it's an incredible use of that example because I have to share a story, too, from a small world department. I was told that a multi-unit independent operator in the Dallas-Fort Worth area was telling me that, in fact, he was kind of giggling because he said for the last couple of years, we've been spending so much time on credit card fees, merchant fees, yelling and screaming, beating them up. You know, I know a lot of people are just simply adding the 2.5 to 3.0 if you charge, but, you know, 97% of the customers are charging.

Speaker1So, you know, we're trying to find a way of putting it into the, anyways, what was so funny was that after all that time that we spent on that, and then we just quickly found that by spending a little bit of time researching linen and paper costs, We found better ways of purchasing both and we're saving twice, Between the two of them, we're saving twice annually than the 2.5 that we were sweating bullets over for the last couple of years. So yeah, utilizing sources, there's a lot of popularity right now for smaller

Speaker1companies that don't have, say the in-house person that you were describing. We have seen a trend in, say, these purchasing analysts, purchasing consultants, for lack of better term, people that have maybe had tenures with large companies that did nothing but research, negotiate, and do purchase contracts that are now traveling around working with the smaller restaurant operator doing the same thing. So I would encourage anybody, you know, who's looking interested needs a little annual budget assistance if they can't do it on their own find a source like that

Speaker0Yeah absolutely and they're purchasing co-ops as well if you google purchasing co-ops or again clotted or whatever you use and and find one you may find one in your area and if you join that co-op and you're buying you know probably 75 of what you're buying is probably being purchased by this co-op. And if so, then you get to participate in the savings by having a much larger purchase.

Speaker1So there are good things to do, good things to do. I want to switch gears pretty quickly to marketing. The idea of holding brand value, building customer base, and forming of specials. When you get to a point of managing not just your stores, but also directing and supporting franchisees, how does that work? Is it always the same? Or do you make recommendations that are different due to different areas, different products. How do you manage marketing now?

Speaker0Well, fortunately, I don't manage marketing in my company because that is my biggest, for sure, my biggest deficiency. My brain thinks in math. I'm good at strategy. I am terrible at marketing. So everything I'm going to tell you is also me learning this from incredibly talented marketing people that work for me. But absolutely, there is no marketing plan that is just rinse, wash, and repeat. I think that there are marketing strategies that seem to deliver return on ad spend in multiple markets that tend to go across state lines and are useful.

Speaker0But every market is different. And I would say, you know, for the smaller operator, you know, you're not going to have enough capital. You're not going to have enough marketing money to actually, you know, truly, you know, generate true, you know, reach and frequency, most likely outside of a three mile radius or five mile radius to your store. So thinking about, you know, those more mass marketing type things connected television, radio, you know, regular TV, those kinds of things.

Speaker0I just say, don't even spend your time on it because frankly, you're not going to have enough money to move the needle where you want to be really good is, is utilizing, you know, social, you know, Facebook, Instagram, things like that. Different TikTok marketplace things that can have the ability to really outsize, deliver return on ad spend. And you can become quite proficient at that if you do it yourself, again, by using a Claude or a ChatGPT and saying, hey, let me,

Speaker0you know, ask me all the questions you need to ask me, but I need you to become my digital marketing ad buyer. And within an hour of conversating with this thing, you'll have a hundred great ideas of how to do it and you can execute it. If not, there's a ton of companies that do this for restaurants. And, you know, the trick is to find the one that's successful. So, again, you want to make sure that they're, presenting you real results so that you can see what the return on ad spend is, and you just push them very hard to keep raising that bar.

Speaker1Sounds good. There is no magic, I guess, number for small independents to be budgeting. I do find that most people are trying to budget two and a half to maybe 3% of their sales in some type of digital marketing, community programming, backup media, that kind of thing. Does that number grow when you're franchising? Or because maybe you've got more units and more masks, can you actually be spending less per unit than that?

Speaker0I mean, look, that's a hard question to answer because it really depends on the rest of your P&L. For us, we are 4%. I mean, look, Subway is closer to 8.5% in marketing, but their food costs are so substantially lower that they can afford to spend that money on advertising, right? So it depends on your unit economics of your business, what you can afford. I would say you definitely don't want to be less than three. You're less than three. You're getting outspent by almost everybody.

Speaker0And so, you know, just be prepared that if I'm not spending three points on marketing in my trade area, that, every other restaurant company that has any scale at all is going to be taking your customers' eyes and taking some time. And so if you want your fair share of that, you need to be spending about 3%. So if you're doing a million dollars in volume, you want $30,000 a year. You want $2,500 a month to be going into these programs.

Speaker0And if you do, you have probably a real good shot at hitting your reach and frequency within a three-square-mile trade area of your business, depending on geography. Or if you're in a more rural area, maybe it's five to ten miles, right? So, and typically you might not even, you might, in a more rural area, you might be able to be much louder for that fee than it would be if you were in Los Angeles, right?

Speaker1Yeah, yeah, that's true. It does really do very, depending on the market area, that you have to compete in. Another topic that I had on my list I wanted to throw at you is aside of using AI, how do you determine maybe the advantages of technology now? Are there improvements in, say, you know, reporting or improvements in equipment that you have noticed can either substantially decrease labor, maybe improve consistency? How do you see the technology impacting those areas? Yeah.

Speaker0In our business, it's really early. Have I seen it? Absolutely. Again, it's hard to look past sort of this AI singularity, or whatever you want to call it, right? There's a new world on our horizon that's probably going to show its face around 2030, 2031. And I don't really think anyone understands what it's going to look like just yet. But if you if you surmise that at some point, right, at some point in the future, every piece of your business will be disrupted at least one more time,

Speaker0but most likely one more time. So, for example, you know, if robots become proficient in running your restaurant and you have a restaurant that the customer will accept a robot, you know, to run it. So, you know, you're not providing an experience like, you know, some experiential restaurant that relies on human capital. If you are more of a quick service, fast casual, you're more providing fuel, you're going to leverage automation very heavily. And when you do, you're going to find that your labor is substantially reduced, right?

Speaker0So that works in every piece of your business and it will happen. But in the short run, what we're seeing, you know, really is sort of, it's not huge, huge cost reducers. It really is more efficiency boosting. So, again, analytics, software as a service. And really, you know, we're starting just now to see some new technologies present themselves that are, hey, you want to have, you know, eyes on four restaurants

Speaker0at once. We have this vision technology. Do you want to have a better ordering system? We have a better ordering technology. So again, it is predominantly software where we're seeing the automation and AI really hit. But again, it's super early. And the worst part about being in the restaurant space is if your name is not McDonald's or Chipotle, who will ultimately be, the bleeding edge leaders on this, right? There's already a McDonald's that is 100% autonomous, and most people don't even realize it. You know, besides those two, unfortunately, the AI money is moving into manufacturing.

Speaker0It's moving into, you know, tech space. It's moving into industries that generate a higher ticket than $15. So we have to wait our turn, so to speak, for these technologies to demonetize, right? And I looked at, for fun, I looked at this virtual, this commercial Roomba, for example. And they have this thing and they claim, you know, you put it in your restaurant, move your tables and chairs up. And, you know, you wake up the next morning, your floor is spotless. And it's like, okay, well, when I do the math on that robot that actually gets your commercial floor spotless, because that's obviously a different exercise

Speaker0than your home, you wind up like $300 a month, $350 a month to run this thing before it breaks. And then you start doing the math on, well, that's, you know, 15 hours, 20 hours, it's about a half hour. Like, it didn't save me any money. And all it really did was maybe look cool in the middle of the night when no one's watching. So we're just not there yet. But where I would bet we will be, the ordering experience will get really cool over the next three years. I really do believe that will get really cool. And again, just being able to use data and insights.

Speaker0To get better return on your investment in generating customers is where all the money is right now to be saved. And again, if you're not thinking about this, companies like Capriati's are. Companies like any size, anything over 50 units is thinking about this, and they probably have a human being that is becoming their AI master or becoming the AI expert. And so if you're not doing it for your own business, be prepared to have your

Speaker0return on ad spend start to dwindle when other people are starting to go like this because they are, you know, really increase or they're starting to increase. And, you know, you're going to wonder why and scratch your head. And it's because they're using this AI technology that you're not using. Yep.

Speaker1Well, I've really, really enjoyed this conversation. I tell you what, every one of your points, so on target. Everybody can really, really improve, I think, their thought process or their productivity or their growth planning, certainly by the points that you've given us today. So, Ashley, I really, really appreciate that. Appreciate your time. Wish we had more. You've got a wealth of information. And I thank you for taking some time today and sharing that. This is Ashley Moore, CEO, Capriati Sandwich Shop. Check them out, okay? Hopefully there's one close by you.

Speaker1I live out in the hill country of Texas. I'm not sure there is one close. If I drove into Austin, would I find one? Or maybe San Antonio?

Speaker0Not yet. We are more in the Abilene area and sort of those areas. We are not in, we do have one in Frisco. So we do have one in Dallas, two in Dallas, excuse me. One in McKinney, one in Frisco. So Dallas is our first entree into the bigger markets there. And then we have some other more suburban markets that we're focused on.

Speaker1Well, I will look for that. Those are a little further, but not out of the question. Hey, everybody, I hope this was a good use of your time. Go make it a great shift. And please check out restaurantowner.com for assistance with your opening, your improvement of operations, training, or if you're already planning your expansion. Hopefully, we will see you soon on another Corner Booth. Special thanks to Cerboni. If you want more confidence in your numbers, check them out at cerboniservices.com.

Speaker1Thank you for joining us on the Corner Booth. We'll be back next Tuesday with more inspiration, insights, and industry best practices to help you engage your team, delight your guests, and grow your business.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Episode 153: Joe Cervasio and Alex Melillo with Mama Hospitality

    Nov 17, 202651 minAudio

    For years, Joe Cervasio and Alex Melillo followed different paths through the hospitality industry. One developed his career in some of New York City's most prestigious hotels and event venues, while the other built...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Episode 152: Matt Brice with Federal American Grill

    Nov 10, 202649 minAudio

    Matt Brice, founder of Federal American Grill, built his career from the ground up. After starting as a dishwasher at age 12, he developed his leadership skills through national restaurant brands, independent restaurant...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Episode 150: Kim Brown with Belong Kitchen

    Oct 27, 202641 minAudio

    Kim Brown founded Belong Kitchen after confronting a challenge faced by many families of adults with intellectual and developmental differences: the lack of meaningful employment opportunities after high school. What...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Episode 149: Richard Zoob with Rosa Mexicano

    Oct 20, 202649 minAudio

    Richard Zoob, CEO of Rosa Mexicano, is leading one of the restaurant industry's most established brands through a period of renewal. Drawing on experience across independent restaurants, national chains, private...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Episode 148: Julie Nguyen with Crawfish Cafe

    Oct 13, 202648 minAudio

    In this episode of Corner Booth, host Chris Tripoli sits down with Julie Nguyen, co-owner of Crawfish Cafe, a five-location restaurant group built around one of the restaurant industry's toughest challenges: a highly...

    Credit the people on this episode