Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Cops & Congress by Annie Dance

Cops & Congress by Annie Dance artwork

LISTEN: Polk County recreation loan wins conditional state approval for YMCA

Nov 16, 20261 hr 43 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The $12 million borrowing advanced over the state auditor’s objection as commissioners questioned public support, development approvals and taxpayers’ future obligations. By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary North Carolina’s Local Government Commission conditionally approved $12 million in borrowing for Polk County’s proposed recreation center Nov. 3, following objections from resident Robin Atkins Wierzbicki and questions about whether the county was moving ahead before completing local approvals. The approximately $18.6 million project would combine borrowing, private donations and county cash to build a county-owned facility operated by the YMCA of Greater Spartanburg, according to the Department of State Treasurer. The commission’s approval depends on the Columbus Town Council approving the project. County officials said the town’s review was scheduled for Nov. 19. State Auditor Dave Boliek cast the lone vote against conditional approval. He questioned why the county had not put the borrowing before voters and whether the commission should wait for Columbus to act. “If the zoning and permits are not in place, it would seem to me to be premature to borrow money on a project that doesn’t have a green light,” Boliek said. The proposed loan through Webster Bank carries a 5.185% interest rate over 20 years, commission staff said. Wierzbicki, a lifelong Polk County resident and chair of the county Republican Party, urged the commission to deny the application. She identified herself as a taxpayer, mother of two teenagers, Army wife, former teacher and co-owner of a multigenerational family business. “We love our rural county and want our children and grandchildren to be able to afford to live here,” she said. Wierzbicki argued that the county was committing taxpayers to a membership facility while school maintenance needs remained unresolved. Citing a May school facilities study, she said Polk County High School alone had approximately $4 million in immediate needs. “Schools are a necessity,” she said. She also questioned donation commitments, development approvals and the absence of a completed operating lease. “The county would close on taxpayer debt and only then negotiate the terms,” Wierzbicki said. County officials disputed several of her assertions. County Attorney Jana Berg described the project as an expansion of an existing YMCA partnership that already provides recreation programs and operates the county’s outdoor pool. The proposed center would include a year-round pool, indoor track, exercise areas, meeting and educational spaces, and areas for child care, Berg said. She argued that it would offer opportunities for exercise and social interaction, particularly for older residents and young people. “This is to be a continuation of our partnership that we already have,” Berg said. The discussion exposed different interpretations of public support. Wierzbicki said 62% of respondents to a 2022 survey would not support construction through a donation. Berg said more than 80% of respondents supported a YMCA-operated community recreation center. Those figures addressed different questions: willingness to donate and support for the facility. Boliek asked why the county had not pursued a general obligation bond referendum. Berg said officials believed the survey demonstrated sufficient community support. “So if it had have come to a referendum, it would have been a landslide,” she said. That prediction had not been tested at the ballot box. A financial adviser told commissioners that officials also evaluated publicly sold limited obligation bonds. Direct bank financing offered lower upfront costs and required less staff time, the adviser said, particularly because Polk County had not previously issued bonds in the public market. The project’s development review drew additional questions. Wierzbicki contended that the approximately 6.5-acre property failed an eight-acre requirement in Columbus’ development ordinance. Berg rejected that interpretation, saying the requirement concerned the zoning district rather than an individual parcel. Berg said the county already had a zoning permit and that a community center was a permitted use. However, the site plan still required Town Council approval. The Columbus Planning Board had tabled the application without a recommendation. Berg said subsequent resignations left the board without a quorum and that an ordinance provision allowed the application to advance to the council after a specified period. Boliek questioned approving the financing before that review concluded. County representatives warned that waiting could affect the interest rate and the project’s guaranteed maximum construction price. The financial adviser said the rate was believed to be locked through at least Nov. 24, the proposed closing date. The commission ultimately approved the borrowing subject to Columbus’ approval. Staff clarified that if the town rejected the project, the financing would lack the commission’s authorization. Members also pressed county representatives about donations and future operating costs. Officials said approximately $5.8 million in donations was already in hand and described additional contributions tied to construction milestones. County Manager Marche Pittman said a memorandum of understanding assigned maintenance and ongoing building costs to the YMCA. But the county would retain ownership and could assume operations if the arrangement failed. “Ownership of the building will continue to be Polk County,” Pittman said. “So if 10 years from now the YMCA agreement does not work out or we can’t come to a lease agreement, then Polk County will operate the facility itself.” The Polk County decision came during a meeting that also addressed the financial futures of two struggling municipalities. The commission approved resolutions beginning a formal review of whether Ronda, in Wilkes County, and Rowland, in Robeson County, can be financially rehabilitated or should ultimately be dissolved. The commission assumed financial control of both towns in October. Staff have since secured access to financial records and bank accounts, overseen transactions, processed payroll and urgent payments, and reviewed outstanding obligations, according to the treasurer’s office. “People in Ronda and Rowland deserve local governments that can pay their bills, manage taxpayer dollars responsibly and provide the services residents depend on,” State Treasurer Brad Briner, who chairs the commission, said in the department’s announcement. Ronda’s problems included repeated budget violations, late audits, declining reserves and an approximately $225,000 Water and Sewer Fund net operating loss in fiscal 2025. Rowland had repeated budget violations, late audits and unauthorized use of restricted grant funds. Its available General Fund balance fell to negative 16.48% of expenditures and transfers in fiscal 2025, the department reported. Commission staff will prepare reports examining both towns’ finances and municipal services. Elsewhere in Western North Carolina, the commission approved $9.75 million for the Asheville Housing Authority’s 319 Biltmore B development, a 112-unit affordable housing project. Members questioned approximately $3.4 million in financing expenses before approving the request. Bond counsel said the figure could include legal and loan fees, tax-credit fees and other closing expenses, and agreed to provide a detailed breakdown. Henderson County received approval for up to $65 million for a new medical office building for UNC Health Pardee and $10 million to refinance debt associated with educational facilities. Transylvania County received approval for $40 million to construct and e… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit anniedance.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Good afternoon.

SPEAKER_02Call to order the November 3rd, 2026 local government commission meeting. I welcome everybody. I will turn it over to Denise.

SPEAKER_01We'll start with the housekeeping as usual. Turn it over to Cindy. Hi, thank you.

SPEAKER_00Good afternoon. Welcome everyone to the Local Government Commission. Cindy Aiken, Assistant General Counsel. We'll start with the role of members. Auditor Bolick.

SPEAKER_02Aye. Or here.

SPEAKER_00Sorry. It's all good. Secretary Wooten.

SPEAKER_02Aye. Or here.

SPEAKER_00Also in the room, Mr. Brown. Present. Thank you. Ms. Hoffman. Present. Virtual today, Mr. Hughes. Here. In the room, Commissioner Johnson. Present. Thank you, virtual today. Mr. McBrayer. Present. Mr. Stiff.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Treasurer Briner.

SPEAKER_02Accounted for.

SPEAKER_00Right. All present and accountant. No absences. I love this commission. Roll call of our staff. We have Denise Canada, Secretary of the LGC. Jennifer Wimmer, Director of Debt Management. Kendra Boyle, Director of Fiscal Management. Laura Rowe, Director of Policy and Compliance. Some housekeeping items. Our meeting is being recorded and will be made available to the public pursuant to the department's recording of public meetings policy. We ask that all those speaking today please identify yourself.

SPEAKER_00If you are participating virtually, we ask that you mute yourself when you are not speaking. The agenda has been posted to the website. Www.nctreasure.gov at the Local Government Commission page. If there are changes to the agenda, the Chair will announce this during the meeting. All votes will be taken by roll call. Without objection, members, your motions and seconds will be considered as a yes vote unless you want to change that during the roll call. We ask that everyone Keep in mind that the microphones are very sensitive in this room.

SPEAKER_00And if you need to have a private conversation, we ask you just quietly go into the lobby. It's just fine. I will try every month not to rustle my papers because you'd be surprised what those microphones can pick up. And that just helps keep the recording clearer.

SPEAKER_01That will do it. Thank you. Thanks so much. One more item of housekeeping. Specific for the recording members, we almost had to move into a different room. Due to technology problems, so Michael and Robbie and Kara over Running Tech, thank you so much for getting us online. Please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Pledge of Allegiance to the Republic of

SPEAKER_02the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one and justice for all. Thank you.

SPEAKER_01Members, please make a moment to review the agenda. Commission members are reminded of your duty to avoid conflicts of interest. Does any member have an actual or potential conflict of interest with respect to any matter on the agenda?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'll recuse page 825 of the NCMCC.

SPEAKER_01Okay, sure. The Medical Care Commission on page 845 will pull that out and vote on it separately from the Pacific Consent Agenda. Any other conflicts of interest? All right, thank you. Moving on to the approval of minutes from the October 6, 20-26 meeting. The minutes were included in your packet. I ask for a motion and a second.

SPEAKER_02So moved, Ms. McKenna.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. Any questions or discussion about the minutes?

SPEAKER_00All right, seeing none. Cindy, will you call the roll? Sure. October six minutes, motion Wooten, second by Stiff. Auditor Bullock? Aye. Mr. Brown? Aye. Ms. Hoffman? Aye. Mr. Hughes? Aye. Commissioner Johnson? Aye. Commissioner Greger? Aye. Treasurer Breiner. Aye. Commissioner Breiner? Aye. Motion carries.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. Members, I believe you know that our public participation policy allows members of the public to send written comments and also to request to appear before the Commission to provide oral comments. We had one request to speak in person, and I'd like to call Robin from Polk County to speak to the Polk County item on your agenda. Thank you so much. You can take any of these seats. It's the choice of yours.

SPEAKER_01And Cindy will be our timekeeper. You have five minutes and she will hold up a sign.

SPEAKER_00I'm going to hold up this sign with one minute's left and this one when time is up. Thank you, ma'am. Thanks for being with us.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. Chair and members of the Commission, thank you for this opportunity to speak. My name is Robin Wears-Bickey. I'm a lifelong Polk County resident and taxpayer, a mother of two teenagers, an Army wife, a former teacher and co-owner of a multi-generational family business. I serve as chair of the Polk County Republican Party and on volunteer boards that work to preserve our local history, school traditions and community values. I know this county and its people and I'm here representing them because we love our rural county and want our children and grandchildren to be able to afford to live here.

SPEAKER_01I ask you to deny Polk County's application for $12 million in installment financing for the Community Recreation Center. The project does not meet General Statute 159 -151 or the Commission's March 2023 guidelines. At the March 16, 2026, Polk County Board of Commissioners meeting, a citizen asked why we are using our land and money to build a YMCA with no public say. The county manager replied that this board and prior boards have wanted the project and have been pushing it since 2020. When asked why a small county is pursuing what failed in larger counties,

SPEAKER_01he said it's not about size, it's about the board's priorities. There's no other county comparable to our size that has funded the construction and operation of YMCA on the backs of the taxpayers. This is the context for every finding that you must make. The contract is not necessary or expedient. The private capital campaign has failed three times, in 2008, in 2013, and the current effort that began in 2020. Federal and state funding were denied. The 2022 survey does not prove necessity. 62% of respondents said they would not support building YMCA with a donation.

SPEAKER_01The county inverted that result, claimed majority support, and refused to correct the records. This is a non-essential membership facility operated by a South Carolina YMCA that keeps the fees while Polk taxpayers fund the capital in residual costs. It has been marketed to surrounding counties in South Carolina. Schools are a necessity. The May 2026 Polk County Schools Facility Study documents millions in immediate needs, including roughly $4 million at the high school alone, one of which includes our roof. The roof fell in just a few weeks ago at our high school.

SPEAKER_01The school board will request at least another million dollars next year through a two-cent tax increase. Approving non-voted debt for a fee-based YMCA while quantified school board needs remain unfunded fails the test. The site itself cannot comply. It's 6.58 acres in a traditional neighborhood development district that requires a minimum of eight acres. It can never meet the ordinance. The Columbus Planning Board tabled it on October 6th for an incomplete packet. Related litigation is pending. Approval while the parcel permanently violates the UDO is premature.

SPEAKER_01Installment financing is not preferable to a bond. It was chosen to avoid a referendum. The resolution itself says there can be no assurances that the project will be approved by the voters. That is evidence the project lacks the support required for non-voted debt of this size, not a reason the installment contract is preferable. Support for the YMCA at the August 17 Board of Commissioners hearing was prompted by the YMCA Development Committee Chair. Mr. Bowman sent an email urging supporters to show up just until the contract with the builder is signed. The rate is 5.185%, not bank qualified, with total payments of $19.3 million.

SPEAKER_01No analysis shows that is the least cost method. The sums are excessive and other funding is not committed. The $6 million in donations is not fully binding to the county. St. Luke's $3 million is contingent on an unsigned MOU. The rest is controlled by the YMCA with no enforceable transfer obligation. There is no operating lease. The YMCA will not sign until the building is move-in ready. The county would close on taxpayer debt and only then negotiate the terms. Operating costs, utilities, and most furniture, fixtures, and equipment remain open-ended taxpayer risk beyond the $19.3 million debt service.

SPEAKER_01The January 2026 letter of intent with J.M. Cope expired on August 1st, yet the county continues without a working contract. Tax increases and debt management findings Cannot be made cleanly. The county already imposed two cent increases for this debt before any local government commission approval. On March 16th, it transferred $863,135 from the budgeted debt service fund to pay the architect.

SPEAKER_03One minute.

SPEAKER_01That money was collected in fiscal year 25-26. The county is estimated to collect an additional $900,000 plus for the current fiscal year. The second year of forced donations to build a facility that benefits the YMCA, not Polk County citizens. Laying roughly a million dollars in annual debt service on top of existing increases, the 2025 property tax re-evaluations, Haleen recovery, and the expected additional school tax increase is excessive for a non-essential membership facility. The March 23 guidelines are not satisfied. No major permits have been issued. None.

SPEAKER_01The planning board has not recommended the project. They meet tonight at 6 p.m. to make a recommendation based on limited information. The parcel could never meet the eight-acre minimum. Related litigation is unresolved, which directly affects the YMCA. Of the comments submitted to this commission, the early ones were ones that were in opposition and fact-based. All the ones that were followed were prompted by yet another email by the YMCA Development Committee Chair. They're all emotional. They have no content. Many of the commenters are YMC committee members, their family members, county employees and their family members,

SPEAKER_01board members from the organizations that made donations or pledges and donors. This is a small orchestrated group, not broad citizen demand. I submitted multiple public records requests for the YMC development committee meeting minutes and agendas. Those requests remain unfulfilled. The statutory findings cannot be made. Please deny the application. Thank you very much. Thanks so much for joining us.

SPEAKER_01All right, Congress, moving on with the consent agenda. We have one item that we have pulled off, that's the Medicare Piedmont Affordable Senior Housing. We'll put on that separately. So this is a vote for the rest of the consent agenda. Looking for a motion in a second. Thank you, Mr. Hughes and Mr. Stith. Any questions or discussion about the consent agenda? Anything you would like to highlight? I don't have any comments at this time. Thanks.

SPEAKER_02I'd like to remove the Asheville Housing Authority item to discuss separately. Asheville Housing Authority to...

SPEAKER_01Friendly amendment to the motion.

SPEAKER_02Okay, I thought you'd already... Sorry. Yeah, I'd like them also.

SPEAKER_00A separate vote.

SPEAKER_02Yes, please.

SPEAKER_00Thank you.

SPEAKER_01Cindy, do we need to vote to... Let's pull that item out or?

SPEAKER_02I'll accept as a friendly.

SPEAKER_01Yep. All right. Thank you so much. So now we have a motion for the consent agenda, excluding Asheville and excluding the Medical Care Commission. Any discussion about the remaining items on the consent agenda? All right. Seeing none, we have a motion and a second. So I will ask Cindy to call the roll.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Consent agenda is Archdale through the Miscellaneous Action Item Raleigh Housing, accepting out the Medcare Commission Piedmont and Asheville Housing, those two matters. Mr. Hughes, Mr. Stiff, Auditor Boland. Aye. Secretary Wooten. Aye. Mr. Brown. Aye. Ms. Hoffman. Aye. Thank you. Commissioner Johnson. Aye. Mr. McBrayer.

SPEAKER_02Aye.

SPEAKER_00Judge Breiner.

SPEAKER_02All right.

SPEAKER_00All right, thank you motion here. All right.

SPEAKER_01Thanks so much. Let's take the Medical Med Care Commission Piedmont Affordable Senior Housing Foundation item first. I'll make a motion to move that item for discussion.

SPEAKER_02Thanks, Mr. Brown. Looking for a second.

SPEAKER_01Second, third, fourth and fifth? We're not sure we'll leave it Commissioner McRaeer. Any discussion about this item? Any questions about this item?

SPEAKER_00All right, Cindy, call the roll, please. Medicare commissions matter, Mr. Brown, Mr. McBrayer, Mr. Stiff is recusing. Auditor Bolick? Aye. Secretary Wooten? Aye. Ms. Hoffman? Aye. Mr. Hughes? Aye. Commissioner Johnson? Aye. President Breiner? Aye. Motion carries.

SPEAKER_01All right, thanks so much. Now we will turn to the Asheville affordable housing item. Start with We'll take a motion in a second, then we'll do discussions. Looking for a motion on this item. So moved. Thanks so much. Before discussion, I'll turn this over to Jennifer to explain that. Sure. This is a 9.75 million dollar requests. The terms of the loan include having a federal low-income housing tax credit.

SPEAKER_01So you'll notice that the 9.7 figure does not specifically get listed in these sources. There are several other developer equity and deferment And there is a construction phase and permanent phase of this loan. Thanks so much. Looking forward to discussion or questions on this item.

SPEAKER_02Sure. I have a question really around the net financing expenses. So I don't know if the Bond Council is on, but it caught my eye that $3.4 million of net financing expenses against Depending on how you define it, at most $35 million total private costs, but probably more accurately, something like $20 million of costs that are attached to those financing expenses feels like an extraordinary amount. You're at least 9% and upwards of 3% of the cost of issuance for this money,

SPEAKER_02which doesn't, to my mind, make anything affordable. And so I'd like to understand all of that.

SPEAKER_01Do you want to speak to that or shall we just call on Kristen Kirby? Who is a partner with McGuire-Woods and their Vaughan Council. Yes. Can we unmute Kristin Kirby, please, from McGuire-Woods? Ms. Kirby, can you hear us? Yes. Sorry. It took a minute for me to get elevated to a panelist.

SPEAKER_01That's all right. Thanks so much. Did you hear the question? This is Kristen Kirby and I apologize. I was trying to pull up the more detailed sources and uses so I could speak to perhaps what all is in that line item. It might be that that is capturing a number of different things in the financing costs, including You know, legal fees, loan fees, but also the tax credit reservation fee that's paid in connection with the LITEX

SPEAKER_01and other expenses. So, you know, there's a number of things that go beyond into that, perhaps beyond just the typical cost of issuance, because there are multiple sources, there's loan fees related to each of those, legal fees, if that's including, you know, NCHFA application fees, allocation fees for the tax credits, et cetera, that those can be some sizable numbers.

SPEAKER_02Just the back of the envelope math.

SPEAKER_01But that's the information that was provided by the developer. Thanks so much. For their overall closing and soft costs.

SPEAKER_02The back of the envelope math of $3.4 million divided by total project costs of $35 million, or 9 plus percent, even by affordable housing standards with all the different agencies and appraisals and lawyers involved, feels very high.

SPEAKER_01Sorry, can you all hear me still?

SPEAKER_02We can hear you. You can't hear us?

SPEAKER_01Can you hear us? Hello. Sorry. Can

SPEAKER_02you here us now or

SPEAKER_01no? Are you able to tell if she's still on the line? Okay, sorry, can you guys hear me? I lost your audio. We can hear you. Okay, now I can hear you. All right, great.

SPEAKER_02No worries. So the $3.4 million divided by the 35, so call it nine change percent. Even by affordable housing standards, which I know have a lot of lawyers and appraisals and all the things involved, feels very high. Is there anything that makes this transaction exceptional in that way?

SPEAKER_01I would not expect there to be anything that makes this transaction different in terms of Total cost of issuance, again, it might just be that that line item, and I'm sorry, I was not able to find a more detailed breakout quickly of what is being picked up there. I don't think overall, in terms of one of these financings, having $3 million of total closing costs and expenses is that far from the norm,

SPEAKER_01but the percentage is higher to your point.

SPEAKER_02So it's a small transaction, I think is what you're saying.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's relative to the transaction sides. It is high, but I don't know that it looks like the total cost for doing one of these deals is drastically different than normal.

SPEAKER_02It's just deeply ironic to me that the least affordable of our financings are for affordable housing.

SPEAKER_01It might be interesting for the commission members if we were to get a breakdown of the costs, whether it's the side passes and provide that to commission members after the meeting. Yeah, I'm happy to follow up and ask for more details on that. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_02So I have a question. I don't know if it's bond council or if there's the developer. Is there anybody representing the developer on the line?

SPEAKER_01My understanding is that we only have bond council on the line, but Ms. Kirby, do you know if there's anyone else from your transaction on the line? I don't believe so. I don't believe anybody was asked to attend this one. Thank you.

SPEAKER_02I asked this question and with due respect, you may not have the answer to it. And that is when we when we see these affordable housing projects come in before this board, just like this and utilizing the condo revenue bond. Window in order to finance this. And this project includes direct loans from the city of Asheville as well as clear federal subsidization.

SPEAKER_02The units are marketed to 30, 60, and 80% of AMI. What is the long-term regulatory check that The actual percentage of those units goes to folks that actually fall within that median income range. What's the long-term check on the community? I mean, the purpose of being able to access these financing windows is

SPEAKER_02to provide affordable housing, and this is done in a tiered format. I'm just curious, what if the developer in 10 years decides to really want to market these to people 30% AMI?

SPEAKER_01Sure, I'm happy to address that. So at the closing, there will be various restrictive covenants that are filed in the Register of Deeds Office related to these projects. So both the bonds The federal tax credits and I believe the city of Asheville alone each have certain affordability set aside requirements. On the bond side, you can speak to that those have to stay in place for a minimum of 15 years. Typically with tax credit financing that's extended to 30 years.

SPEAKER_01Those income set asides are documented in those restrictive covenants that are filed against the property and the developer of the project has to file Reports annually confirming that they are in compliance and maintaining those income restrictions.

SPEAKER_02Where are those reports filed?

SPEAKER_01They are submitted, you know, with respect to the bonds, they're typically submitted to the issuer and to the lender. The tax credit compliance forms go to the North Carolina Housing Finance Agency every year. There's also... A filing that has to be made with the Internal Revenue Service every year. And then I would suspect, you know, on what for other sources of financing, they might be reporting to those lenders. But at a minimum, they're sent to NCHFA to the bond issuer

SPEAKER_01and certifying compliance with those set of sets.

SPEAKER_02Right. I appreciate it. That's actually very helpful. Thank you. Of course. I have one more question while we got you. Is the City of Asheville line a forgivable line if they meet certain criteria, or is it truly the line they'll get paid back over a certain term? I Thank you have an answer to that.

SPEAKER_01I don't know the answer to that off the top of my head for this transaction. I mean, since that's directly between the developer and the City, I don't have those documents handy. To answer that, but certainly can report back on that to the commission.

SPEAKER_02We saw that in Wake County, Raleigh, City of Raleigh had that. All right.

SPEAKER_01Any other questions? We have a motion and a second. So I'll ask Cindy to call the roll. All right.

SPEAKER_00Hearing no further discussion. Asheville housing item. Motion moved and second stiff. Father Volick.

SPEAKER_02Aye.

SPEAKER_00Mr. Brown?

SPEAKER_02Aye.

SPEAKER_00Ms. Hoffman? Aye. Mr. Hughes? Aye. Commissioner Johnson? Aye. Thank you. Mr. McBrayer? Aye. Commissioner Breiner? Aye. Thank you. Motion carries.

SPEAKER_01Thanks so much. Ms. Kirby, thank you for answering the question. Yes, thank you. And I will follow up with those two items that you asked about. Thanks. Thank you. Turning to attachment fee, we have one unit with financial performance, material financial performance indicators are concerned. This is the City of Trinity and a state revolving loan for water sewer. Turn it over to the agenda and purchase to start the project and financing and then Kendra to review the financial conditions. Thanks. The City of Trinity is coming to ask

SPEAKER_01for $1,354,000 state revolving fund loan. For a wastewater regionalization project, it's going to connect and redirect the wastewater to the City of High Point's treatment plant, and the rest of the wastewater will be sent to the City of Thomasville's system for treatment. If you noticed on the sources and uses, the entire project is $13.9 million.

SPEAKER_01This $1.3 million loan Is in addition to the several grant funds and direct appropriations that the city has received. So this is the final $1.3 million to complete that project. And it is a term of 20 years through the state of North Carolina DEQ DWI fund. I'll turn it over to Kendra. Thanks.

SPEAKER_00So the city of Trinity has two financial performance indicators of concern based on fiscal year 2025. And those are related to the sewer fund. It's the operating loss as well as a use of transfers from the general fund to cover that operating loss. And the city has a history of operating losses. It has a history of large transfers from the general fund to support operations. But that has been trending down.

SPEAKER_00And also this project will result or is expected to result in increased revenue. It's expected to result in decreased expenditures, thus decreasing the operating losses that it's been experiencing, decreasing the transfers that it would need. So this is why it comes before you today. The city has made strides in reducing the reliance on those transfers. This is something that has been longstanding.

SPEAKER_00There have been issuances in the past that The understanding was that debt service would be paid from sales tax revenue for those issuances. That debt service will be coming off the books in the near future. That will also contribute to operating losses decreasing or hopefully an elimination with all these combined issues. So that was the context that I felt like the commission needed to have in order

SPEAKER_00to make your decision on this debt request. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_01Looking for a motion and a second, then we can discuss.

SPEAKER_02Thank you, Mr. Stitt.

SPEAKER_01Mr. Stitt, questions?

SPEAKER_02And just for a point of clarity, on both of those indicators in my earlier discussions, just querying whether there is an actual plan, you know, significant debt in their sewer fund, is there a literal You know, it seems to be trending positively, but is there a literal plan that will show solvency is one question. And I'll stop and let you answer that.

SPEAKER_01Excellent question. Kendra, but I'll also let you know that the city manager, Michael Burroughs, is on the line, so we can also maybe go ahead and unmute him in case there are questions for him.

SPEAKER_02Can I ask the second one so he can hear them both at the same time? Then the second question is, while they are greater than the 3%, Do they know how much greater than 3%? Because to me, that's indicated, you know, you're over, much over, therefore you kind of have your arms around the financial challenge that you have. So those are the two questions. So the managers on the phone would love to hear the response. Yes, I'm here. Can you all hear me?

SPEAKER_01Yes, thanks for being with us.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, thank you. So we do have to address your questions. We did implement for this budget year, fiscal 2026-2027, whenever I first got here, a 33% increase in the sewer rates, which will tremendously bring up Our revenues and that and we will not be transferring general fund dollars into the sewer fund after this. So that's that's our first step in the plan and future as far as future strides towards it.

SPEAKER_02Then we're going to keep up with the trends. I know that in the past that was not kept up with before my time and the finance director's time. So they didn't keep up with sewer rate and we're keeping on top of that. And each year we're continuing to strive forward. So does your modeling show you have a 33% increase this year, which is, you know, you're taking appropriate steps. Does your modeling show when it will be solvent based on your data now projected?

SPEAKER_02After this year, it'd be self-sufficient. So you, so you recoup that 849 after this year, being no longer negative? Yeah, there's nothing negative right now, after the 33% increase. Okay, so you didn't. All right, thank you. And then on the second point, did you have an idea of how much over 3% you are at this point? I'm sorry, repeat the question.

SPEAKER_02On your second indicator, your sewer fund is showing greater than 3% response did not state the percentage. So I was just wondering, do you know how much farther over 3% you are on your second indicator, your transfers at this point? Yeah, we aren't over the 3% transferring in because we aren't transferring in at all.

SPEAKER_00So in fiscal year 2025, they were at about 27% of their expenditures they were transferring into that fund to cover. I think now what they are anticipating that is when they get their fiscal year 26 audit report that there won't be transfers, so they're taken care of. Okay.

SPEAKER_02Thank you so much. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_01Thanks, members. Other questions about Trinity? All right. Seeing none, we have a motion and a second, so I'll ask Cindy to call the roll. Sorry, you were just about to open that coffee.

SPEAKER_00Yep. We have Hughes and Stiff for the State Revolving Fund Loan. Auditor Bullock. Aye. Thank you. Secretary Wooten. Aye. Mr. Brown. Aye. Ms. Hoffman. Thank you. Ms. Hoffman, Trinity. Okay. Commissioner Johnson? Aye. Thank you. Mr. McBrayer? Aye. Reiner? Aye. Motion carries.

SPEAKER_00Okay, sorry. It's okay. Commissioner Johnson? Aye. Thank you. Mr. McBrayer? Aye President Reiner? Aye Motion carries. Thank You.

SPEAKER_01All right thank you. Turning over to us for a unit on the unit assistance list with the lower debt threshold. We have one unit, which is Columbus County. I will turn it over to Jennifer to describe the financing and then to describe the financial condition of the unit. I will let you know, members, that Columbus County is in the room. Thank you for being here. We have the county manager and deputy county manager, finance director, and a chief and captain with us as well.

SPEAKER_01So if there are questions, then we'll call you to come up. Jennifer. Columbus County, in addition to the lower thresholds, units on the unit assistance list in financing or leasing vehicles must come for approval. This financing is for $770,000 for 11 Chevy Tahoes for the Columbus County Sheriff's Office. So it is withdrawing at a fixed 4.8%. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00So, commission members, you may remember that last month Columbus County came before you with a water and sewer request. And at that time, we reported that their water and sewer fund had no financial performance indicators of concern and did not cause staff any fiscal concern. But we did have concerns about their general fund. In their general fund for fiscal year 2024, they were at 18% on balance available as a percentage of expenditures.

SPEAKER_00Fiscal year 25, they went down to 7.94%. So that's not only a strong decrease, but well below the threshold that we like to see of 20% for a unit that has their level of expenditures. It's also They're down to less than one month's worth of expenditures to have available for unforeseen circumstances. So that is something that causes some concern.

SPEAKER_00And you may remember that Commissioner Steth asked the very good question about, well, have they adopted their revised fund balance policy that they talked about in their response? And I can report that they have now adopted that policy. They've set their goal at 20%. They have set it so that if... They drop below that. They put together a plan to increase it over the course of three years. They also have implemented some measures to address their internal control concerns,

SPEAKER_00things that staff has observed as the coach team has worked with them, and they feel that will address their internal control issues. We also, there was a recommendation in the Office of State Auditors report on the county that suggested that they should be providing budget to actual reports on a regular basis. And we have been provided evidence that that is happening. So there are things happening in order to address the issues that we saw,

SPEAKER_00but we also believe that Because of this request, there is the opportunity, unless there's offsetting action, that this could further deteriorate their fund balance available. Albeit it's $770,000 over three years. Will it deteriorate it much? Probably not. But there needs to be some offsetting to get towards a higher comfort level on this ratio. So we do have The staff here available to address any questions that you may have

SPEAKER_00and just wanted to make sure that you had that context and information to make your decision today.

SPEAKER_01Thanks so much. Members, I'll look for a motion and a second and then discuss the item.

SPEAKER_02Motion to approve. Second.

SPEAKER_01Mr. Siddh, Secretary Wooden. Questions for Jennifer and Tindra or the unit about this financing?

SPEAKER_02So maybe one of the county officials can answer this question. I don't have any doubt that you need 11 police vehicles from the sheriff's office. The question is, do you need these brand new Tahoes at $77,000 or $70,000 a piece? We see a lot of folks come through here with $50,000 vehicles that serve the purpose. So that's a 40% difference. And you guys are in deep financial straits. So help me with that. So one thing with that, Captain Creech, Columbus County Sheriff's Office,

SPEAKER_02we went with the Durangos for a long time, chargers. We were spending $600,000 a year in maintenance cost because they're just not reliable. When we get through with them, they are ready for the junkyard. We get $2,500, $1,500 a piece out of them. We had a Tahoe that we leased. That we sold back to Enterprise last year that was four years old, 130,000 miles.

SPEAKER_02We got $29,000 for it. What we get back out of a Tahoe or a much nicer patrol vehicle is you get back a lot more than you put in it. And you don't have the cost associated that we've had with the Durangos and the... Ford Explorers and the Chargers. So the total cost of ownership is lower. It is a lot lower. Yes, sir.

SPEAKER_02We're 954 square miles, very rural county. We do the security for all the schools in the county. And if we miss one call because of a broke down vehicle, what is the cost of that?

SPEAKER_01Mr. McFrayer.

SPEAKER_02So how many vehicles do you have? We have about 140 vehicles in our fleet. And you're willing to buy 11? 11, yes sir. We had leased 40 vehicles back in 2019, 2020, and it kind of got us out of what we were in at the time. Out of those vehicles right now, I think we have maybe 9 or 10 that are still able to run it.

SPEAKER_02We just have not got any service out of them. 80% of our fleet is over 100,000 miles right now. We have to do something. Over how many miles? Over 100,000. Most of them are over 200, but 80% are over 100.

SPEAKER_01Other questions for the county or for our staff about this financing? See you.

SPEAKER_02Have Another question, just because it bothers me here a little bit. You know, and I don't know your business well enough to know, but as one breaks down, maybe buy one, And a little year later when one's going bad, buy one instead of 11 at one chunk. I mean, it's a little easier on the wallet, in my opinion. Yes, sir. You're exactly right. But we were at the point we had,

SPEAKER_02when we asked for the TN last year and we got the TN, we were at the point we had no spares. Now we have four spares. So if one vehicle goes, one vehicle will not, Until we get back ahead of the game, one vehicle won't fix the problem. Measure use. One question. Does this include the cost of upfitting? Yes, sir. That is including the cost of upfitting all the vehicles. The $70,000 is not for just a vehicle.

SPEAKER_02That is cost of upfitting it also.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. Any other questions for the county or about this financing?

SPEAKER_02Since it was mentioned, I mentioned last meeting about, I just appreciate the thought process that you've taken and the diligence on this. It seems like it's on track and I appreciate you hearing that from last meeting. All right.

SPEAKER_01I'm looking for Cindy to call the roll. All right.

SPEAKER_00Columbus County, that was motion stiff. Second move. Mr. Bullitt? Aye. Mr. Brown? Aye. Ms. Hoffman? Aye. Thank you. Mr. Hughes? Aye. Commissioner Johnson? Aye. Sound like a yes. Thank you, ma'am. Aye. Mr. Treasurer Briner? Aye. Motion carries. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_01Columbus County team, thanks for joining us. County Manager Robinson, you've been on the job seven days? Seven days.

SPEAKER_00Congratulations.

SPEAKER_01This is the item that you heard public comment on at the beginning of the meeting. I will turn this item over to Jennifer to explain the financing and I will let you know that we have multiple members of the Polk County team on the line. In addition, Or send you out by email the county's additional response in response

SPEAKER_01to the public comments that have been received. Jennifer. Toll County, as mentioned, wants to construct a new community center operated by the YMCA of Greater Spartanburg. The loan amount, $12 million, through Webster Bank at an interest rate of 5.185% for 20 years. The amount is not the entire project cost. Those are coming in from other sources. But if there are questions about the financing or project,

SPEAKER_01and we have staff on the line, as well as myself. Thanks so much. Why don't we go ahead and unmute the Polk County team. So I believe we have County Manager Marsh Pittman, Finance Director Sonia Ayers, Advisor Amy Bentner from First Tryon, and County Attorney Janneberg.

SPEAKER_00No, not next to town. No, that's what I thought. I just, I knew you were wandering around.

SPEAKER_01We can hear you. If I wander,

SPEAKER_00I'll look for a paper cutter or whatever.

SPEAKER_01Let's see them in favor and get them back. Great. Thanks so much. Members, question or discussion about the Polk County item?

SPEAKER_02I've got some questions for the Polk County. Folks, are they on?

SPEAKER_01They're on. We muted them since they had a hot mic.

SPEAKER_02There we go. Okay. Okay, great. I did have some questions. So I was able to visit Polk County last week. So I am a little concerned with respect to applicable permits and zoning and whether that has already been completed. And If the zoning and permits are not in place, it would seem to me to be premature to borrow money on a project that doesn't have

SPEAKER_02a green light. So I'd like some clarification on that or information on that.

SPEAKER_03Thank you. This is Jana Berg, the county attorney, and I think I can address your questions or answer them. The neighborhood in which the proposed facility is located is called a traditional neighborhood district. A permitted use within this particular district is a community center. Ms. Rosnicki, who earlier said that we were in violation of the town's unified development ordinance is incorrect.

SPEAKER_03She, I think, was referring to an old version of the unified development ordinance, which required a particular district to be at least eight acres. That is the district, not an individual lot. Our individual lot is almost six acres. It's 6.5 acres, as a matter of fact, and it meets the criteria. So with respect to the zoning, we currently have a zoning permit issued by the town of Columbus that the particular facility that we wish to build is zoned or permitted by right.

SPEAKER_03Because it involves land disturbance of a certain acreage, it qualifies as a major subdivision and it requires the town to approve our site plan. But this is an administrative review in that the town council looks over our plans and determines whether or not we have met all the criteria. So the town staff and the county staff went together in a technical review meeting

SPEAKER_03and have determined that Polk County's application does, in fact, meet the criteria. There are a few things with respect to the lighting plan. However, with respect to Duke Energy, who is proposing the lighting plan, who is doing the lighting plan for us, they have agreed that the lighting plan that they will present will be in accordance with the unified development elements. Initially, there was some concern about Kind of trees that we were going to plant for screening purposes and we have since modified the plan so that the trees that are on the approved UDO list.

SPEAKER_03Dumpster screening at one time was an issue and with the technical review, we also modified those. So we have submitted a complete application showing that our application for the development permit or approval, it's not a permit, it's just approval, is in fact in compliance with the town's UDO. Like I said, we already have our zoning permit. This is a mere ministerial process to determine whether or not our plan actually conforms. And their staff has already agreed that it does conform.

SPEAKER_03As far as it going to the planning board meeting tonight, that is not true. The planning board meeting is not going to happen. And they were merely an advisory function anyway. The town council is the one who actually approves the plan. And that's going to town council on November the 19th. And like I said, we anticipate approval of it because our plan, our development plan meets with all the requirements of the unified development ordinance.

SPEAKER_02Questions? Well, go ahead. I'm sorry, Bill. No, go ahead, Mr. McBurner. Well, I was just thinking in most towns, that type of thing would go in front of a planning board. And it sounds like you admitted going before the planning board this time and took action just by council. Is that a regular... Procedure or is this a runoff?

SPEAKER_03What happens according to the Town of Columbus Unified Development Ordinance, major site plans are reviewed by the staff and they recommend approval or not. Then it goes before the Planning Board for their recommendation to the Town Council. And then the Town Council is the ultimate deciding authority. The planning board did not reach a determination and in fact several of their members I understand have resigned so they are unable to make a quorum

SPEAKER_03to vote on this particular matter so it is going to be for the town council without planning board review. And that is in accordance with their ordinance.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. Auditor Bullock.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I have another question. And clearly there are a lot of opinions on this issue. Why did this not go to a general obligation vote by the people in Polk County? For me, it would have been the probably, given my personal opinion, it would have been probably the way I would have wanted to go.

SPEAKER_03Back in 2022, Polk County conducted a survey of a sampling of its residents to determine whether or not there was support for a community recreation center to be operated by the YMCA. Based on the results of that survey, over 80% of the residents who responded to the survey indicated overwhelming support for this particular facility. So if it had have come to a referendum, It would have been a landslide. It did not go before referendum because we felt we had all the community support

SPEAKER_03that we needed to have in support of this. And in fact, if you look at the public comments that you received pertaining to this particular matter, you received approximately 117 of those. Of those, almost 80% approved of it. Only 20% were in opposition. So there is admittedly some opposition. But they're small relative to the population of Polk County. And they are very vocal. They have appeared at meetings and you can tell by their comments that they have made to you.

SPEAKER_03But as I said before, almost 80% of the residents of Polk County expressed a support of it. In fact, Polk County has gotten a lot of donations for this purpose so that we don't have to borrow that much money. We've got nearly $6 million in donations. We have the land upon which this facility will be located donated. So it does have overwhelming public support with a lot of our citizens and residents actually contributing money out of their own pocket in order

SPEAKER_03to support this.

SPEAKER_00Mr. Treacher.

SPEAKER_02You mentioned the $6 million of donations. Are those donations in hand or are those pledges?

SPEAKER_03$5.87 million of the donations are already in hand, and about $900,000 of it is coming in after the construction begins.

SPEAKER_02And are you continuing to ask for donations so you can further offset the expense of the facility?

SPEAKER_03Yes. To the extent we could get more donations, we will. We do have a significant number of donations already. And also, in support of this application, back in 2021, Holt County conducted a community health assessment to determine, you know, what are areas of concern for our community. And the biggest concern or one of the biggest concern is the health of our population. 32% of our population is elderly.

SPEAKER_03The average age is 54. Our obesity rates are alarmingly high at 66%. And only 26% of the individuals surveyed report meeting daily physical activity. In addition, you know, chronic disease is an important factor with respect to our community health. And so providing an affordable, safe and inclusive indoor facility recreation space with access

SPEAKER_03to child care resources will benefit our communities. Another area that was of concern was mental health. Suicide rates have been rising in Polk County, with social isolation as one of the key factors, as well as substance abuse. We hope to provide this facility to provide a place, a community hub for citizens to meet, to exercise, to learn healthy living habits, to learn nutritional Things that they could do for their diets

SPEAKER_03to improve their health and also provide a safe place for elderly people and young people to meet. Also, it would provide some opportunities for our local school systems in that they could have a swim team that would meet the criteria. Currently, Polk County only has two recreation facilities. One of those is an old high school gym that was constructed in the 1930s. The other one is a pool That is also aging. It was constructed back in the 1980s.

SPEAKER_03The outdoor pool is not regulation size, so we could not have any competitive swimming events there. And it's only used a part of the year. The proposed facility that we have has several things that would meet our residents needs, including, you know, the workout areas, an indoor track. A year-round pool, meeting spaces, educational spaces, spaces for childcare to occur. Right now, we are already in partnership with the YMCA of Greater Spartanburg.

SPEAKER_03In fact, they provide services and programs at the old gym that I told you about. And they also provide swimming lessons and they operate the old pool that we have. This is to be a continuation of our partnership that we already have. Except for it would be in a facility that would be better used by the citizens of our county and they would contribute to their better health, mental health, and I believe also would lower the amount of substance abuse that goes on amongst our youth because we would provide a place and activities for them to do.

SPEAKER_01Thanks so much. Number six. If you would indulge me, so to speak, I meant at the beginning of this item to address one point about the public comment. So a fair amount of the public comment does not speak specifically to your required findings. And so I had asked Cindy, and then forgotten, to review the findings with you about exactly what you were being asked in this vote, which I think is helpful on items that are a little bit more sticky. So Cindy, even though it's mid-item, if you would review the findings, I would appreciate it.

SPEAKER_01We have six.

SPEAKER_00Number 159-151B, like boy. Number one, the proposed contract is necessary or expedient. I always have to look up expedient. So no definition statute. So we just use a common definition, convenient, practical, effective for achieving its goal. Effective statute. Number two, the contract under the circumstances is preferable to a bond issue for the same purpose. Three, the sums to fall due are adequate and not excessive for the purpose.

SPEAKER_00Four, the unit's debt management procedures and policies are good, or if not, reasonable assurances are given that its debt will be managed in strict compliance with law. Five, the increase in taxes, if any, necessary to meet the sums to fall due will not be excessive. And six, the unit is not in default of any of its debt service obligations.

SPEAKER_01Thanks so much. And as you know, we set up the debt sheet to specifically address those questions. Commissioner Rick Breyer, you had your hand up and then Commissioner Hughes.

SPEAKER_02So at any time, did you ever think or discuss a possibility of partnering with the Isothermal Community College? I think they have a campus over in Polk County.

SPEAKER_03The president of the Isothermal Community College is in support of this project. In fact, I believe she's one of the contributors to the public comment about just how much they support this project. Also, the Isothermal Community College is located in Spindell, which is a significant distance away from Polk County. Of the residents that we surveyed pertaining to use of a public recreation facility, the majority of them indicated that they would be willing to travel up to 20 minutes. Spindell would be outside of that 20-minute travel time in order to Use

SPEAKER_03the public recreation facility.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I realize where isothermal is, but don't they have a presence in Polk County? And the question is, did you ever talk to them about partnering with them with a project like this?

SPEAKER_03The Spindale Community College does have a presence in Polk County, you're correct. However, that is located within the public library. The campus is located within the public library. So as far as having a community recreation center where they're currently located, it would not be feasible. But if the community college would like to avail itself of the recreation facility,

SPEAKER_03we would certainly be amenable to entertaining whatever we can do to help with that.

SPEAKER_02With regard to the lease that's mentioned here, would the county have any obligation to underwrite the future costs, operating losses? How will that work? Will it be essentially a triple net type lease where the lessor will absorb the costs of ownership? Have you gotten that far?

SPEAKER_03I am not familiar with the financing, so I'm going to throw this over to the county manager.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'll take this one. No, there's no memorandum understanding that we have clearly states that they're responsible for all maintenance and ongoing costs associated with the building. You know, that's up to the YMCA Graduate Department to continue.

SPEAKER_01Mr. Stetson.

SPEAKER_02Two questions, one little follow up on the Treasurer's question on the donations, because I've seen donations and then I've seen donations that don't materialize. And so it sounded like the answer was 5.8 million are in hand, a little bit of around 900,000 after construction. So if that does not materialize, what would the plan be if that full 6 million is not realized through donations? What would the plan be and the effect on the capital stack of the project?

SPEAKER_02Really, I don't think that's going to be an issue because we're at 5.8 now and there's some outstanding grants that we know that we're going to be able to gain access to. It's staged, so you have Once your contract is signed, then it's $125,000 with Hospice of Carolina Foothills. And then at the end of the project, it's another $125,000. So it's not just local dollars coming out, and I don't think it's going to be an issue to hit $6 million at all.

SPEAKER_02And the second one is more of a statement because in going through the materials earlier, It was a question of what lens. We obviously can ask questions, whatever questions we want, but I think it's important for all parties to understand what we ultimately evaluate on. So I appreciate staff outlining that for us to inform us as we make the decision on that. Thank you. I have a question, staff.

SPEAKER_02What is the nature of this financing contract?

SPEAKER_01It's an installment purchase. Installment purchase.

SPEAKER_02I see it's an installment. So it's not a limited obligation bond.

SPEAKER_01So this is a direct bank placement. So it's not a public bond. It is directly with Webster Bank.

SPEAKER_02And what's the rationale? Because one of the considerations is, is this expedient as opposed to issuing a bond? And so the question I have is twofold. One, why was it not made a general obligation on the ballot? Could have been owned, by the way, today. And number two, why was this not passed by the county commissioners as a limited obligation bond and utilized the municipal bond window as opposed

SPEAKER_02to going through bank financing?

SPEAKER_01Turn that over to the policy decision by the county, so I'll turn that back over to

SPEAKER_02Andrew Cameron and his team. Yeah, I think the finance and methodology was adopted. Amy Wittner with First Trine, she might can speak to that a little bit better as to why we went the direction we went with that. This project has been going on since 2019. And I think the board felt like once all those donations came in, we needed to move forward and we needed to get this project done. But Amy can speak to the methodology and why we chose it.

SPEAKER_01Amy Vintner, are you on the line?

SPEAKER_00She is on.

SPEAKER_01Amy Vintner from First Try On. All right, here we go. Can you hear me now? Yes, we hear you. Thanks. Great. Great. So, sure, I can speak to the why in installment financing versus a publicly sold limited obligation bond. We did look at both methodologies. A limited obligation bond, the upfront costs were more expensive than a bank, direct bank place transaction.

SPEAKER_01The County has also never issued bonds in the public market. So it would have been a new financing for them to get a little bit more to get the credit ratings and to get the credit ratings established and to draft the offering document and all of that. So at the end of the day, when we evaluated both methodologies, it seemed like to do the direct route with the bank. Made more sense for them just from a cost standpoint with the upfront fees involved

SPEAKER_01and a staff time standpoint. And I'd also say that there is not a lot of differential right now between the bank market versus the public market, just with the increase in interest rates that we've seen in the public market over the last couple of months. Thank you. Auditor Bullock.

SPEAKER_02So can you explain to me the ownership of the building and what that looks like? Yeah, that's a great question. Ownership of the building will continue to be Polk County. So if 10 years from now the YMCA agreement does not work out or we can't come to a lease agreement, then Polk County will operate the facility itself. And then another question.

SPEAKER_02So I'm a little concerned about planning board and this not going through the planning board and through that process. I'm looking for some understanding on why there were these, were there mass resignations because this is so contentious or was this just, I mean, it seems to me that, you know, in order for this to go through, we're sort of, In some respects, crossing our fingers and hoping that the City Council in Columbus approved this. And I'm assuming there will be as much public comment or more based

SPEAKER_02on the City Council's rules with respect to this project. So I am I am concerned about the lack of process through the Planning Commission and then Ultimate approval by the council first before it's brought before the LGC. I almost feel like we're a little bit caught before the horse.

SPEAKER_03If I could address that with you, I'd be happy to. The planning board, essentially, the way the town UDO is currently written, the site plan, let me say this for example, first. The use the county wishes to make of its property located in this traditional neighborhood district is permitted by right. It has the zoning permit that it needs.

SPEAKER_03The issue is whether or not there needs to be any adjustments to the site plan we've submitted based on the unified development ordinance standards. We have gone through the technical review process with staff. And they have determined that our plan meets all of the required elements that it's supposed to meet. The planning board recommendation, I don't know why they have one,

SPEAKER_03because it's more ministerial or an administrative review. The staff recommended that they approve it. I understand that I was not there. But I understand that when it did come before the planning board, a large number of the people who made comments to you in opposition showed up and they are very vocal. And I understood that they kindly took over the meeting, which afterwards,

SPEAKER_03I think a lot of the planning board staff resigned because of some of the comments that were made or some of the attitudes that were Revelling at this particular meeting, so now the Planning Board no longer has a quorum. However, the UDO does provide for after the recommendation, if one is not made, that it automatically goes for the ultimate approving authority, which is the Town Council. The Planning Board never had a vote on whether or not to approve or not.

SPEAKER_03Their only vote was whether or not they recommended something to be approved or not. And that is supposed to be based on whether or not our plan meets the major site plan criteria contained in our Unified Development Ordinance. It does. We have all the permits. We have secured all the permits that are necessary as opposed to what you heard earlier from the public comment. We do have all our permits in place. Certain things can't be done. They might want to move the driveway over a bit from one place to another to create

SPEAKER_03a greater line of sight. They might want to put a lighting pole in a different location than what we have. But essentially, our site plan is in compliance. And this is a mere administrative review to assure themselves that our site plan is in compliance. And this is a use that is guaranteed by right. A Community Recreation Center is a listed, permitted use within this particular zoning district, and our lot size meets the criteria, and our site plan meets all their criteria as well.

SPEAKER_02So the plan board did meet, did they actually make a recommendation one way or the other?

SPEAKER_03No, they tabled it. They tabled it. Yep, they tabled it. And then they all, the majority resigned.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so now they can't meet again since it's tabled until they get a quorum.

SPEAKER_03So they're stuck in this.

SPEAKER_02That's why it's going to council.

SPEAKER_03Luckily, the unified development ordinance has a shot clock provision in it, whereby if they do not receive planning board recommendation on a particular project within a certain amount of time, it's automatically deemed approved. And it goes to the Town Council. It is by operation of this particular provision in the Unified Development Ordinance that this matter is going before the Town Council on November the 19th. And I submit to you, in accordance with staff recommendation and everything else, that our plan does meet.

SPEAKER_03There may be some minor modifications, like I've mentioned. They might want a light pole move. They might want our dumpsters relocated to a different place. But these are all minor modifications that we're happy to make to the plans. And as I said, this is permitted by right. So there is no question about whether or not we're allowed to put this facility there because we are. Yeah,

SPEAKER_02I understand. And I'm in those situations, but I've also been on the board that had a vote yes or no. And so If a board can vote yes, it can also vote no. And so I'm moved that we as the LGC table this until we hear from the town of Columbus, because in my opinion, maybe they approve it. I know the county commission, I believe, approved it 5-0 in a vote, but we haven't heard from the city of Columbus that ultimately,

SPEAKER_02and they throw everybody a curveball and we're sitting here without complete information. We're talking about, what, three weeks? And then we have a meeting in December.

SPEAKER_03The downside of that, just to make you aware, is that it's going to cost the county a significant more amount of money because our rates are locked in for a particular amount of time. I appreciate the fact, and I understand totally. I just want to make you aware of that fact as well.

SPEAKER_02When does your rate lock expire?

SPEAKER_03Amy, can you speak to that?

SPEAKER_01Yes, I believe it's locked in until the calendar. Yeah, I think it's either November, because our closing, our proposed closing was, I think, the 24th. So I believe it's locked in at least until the 24th.

SPEAKER_02There's also the impact to the guaranteed maximum price as well, that GMP and that rate. It could impact us there as well. Is it possible to approve subject to approval?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, hold on just a minute. We already have a motion on the floor in a second. So Cindy's going to tell us.

SPEAKER_00There is a motion on the floor. Okay, I apologize. You made a motion. I made a moment to go to the table. Yeah. Is there I would

SPEAKER_02second that? Sure. Also, I do want to say, I mean, to bring something to the LGC with tight windows on financing too is a little bit, I think that's a little unfair to this body. I just got to be honest about that. I mean, if you're going to tighten your windows within a period and you've got The most number of public comments that I've ever gotten as a member of this board on any issue and you tighten these windows to two or three weeks.

SPEAKER_02I got a problem

SPEAKER_01with that. I'll speak to that briefly just to let you know that the. In working with the bond council and the underwriters, the process that Folk County has followed through that specific aspect of that is the way all of our units handle this because of the limited amount of time that a rate can be locked. I just want to make sure you know it's very typical.

SPEAKER_02But they've been doing this since 2018. Sure. Project since 2018. Sure. But there's a cost to it. Commissioner Hughes. I'm sure there's a cost. There's also a potential cost that rates are lower in 30 days. Could be. You reconhece. Sure. I'd raise a question as to whether or not it's possible to approve it subject to approval by the town of Columbus.

SPEAKER_01You have approved conditional, you've made conditional approvals before, so certainly make a motion that would be conditional on the approval of the town.

SPEAKER_02Same.

SPEAKER_01And then we would obviously report back on that in December, if you're sure.

SPEAKER_02Did you mean to make a motion? I just apparently just did some. Here for the next one, and I won't drop myself. In. I'm going to find my brother Thank you,

SPEAKER_00it was second by Mr. Stith so motion fails for lack of a second. Just keep track of all. Excuse motion contingent upon city or town of Columbus approval. And stiff second.

SPEAKER_00So that in practical practicality as director of debt management, you need to hear right after the meeting what happened. Because if they fail to approve it at the town level, this was not approved.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's what I want to get clarification on. So we're saying we would approve subject to there. So nothing would have to come back to us if...

SPEAKER_00Right. Yes.

SPEAKER_02Gotcha.

SPEAKER_00Okay. All right. We're good on the motion. We're good on the second. Thanks, Cindy. And staff just making sure... I said it right. This financing is for Polk County, but it's contingent on the town, the situs. It's in their boundaries where this project is. That's who's approval we're waiting for. Just so it's clear. It's very easy for me to get confused. All right. Hugh Stith with this contingent approval.

SPEAKER_00More discussion. All right. Auditor Bolig.

SPEAKER_02I'm a no on that motion.

SPEAKER_00Secretary Wooten?

SPEAKER_02Oh yes, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Mr. Brown?

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_00Ms. Hoffman? Yes. Okay, thank you. Commissioner Johnson? Aye. Thank you. Mr. McBrayer? And still. Treasurer Bryden? Aye. All right, so that motion carries with one note. All right, so we don't need, yeah, staff will get with Polk County staff to arrange the communication.

SPEAKER_01Polk County, thank you for being on the line to answer questions.

SPEAKER_03Thank you.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. Thanks.

SPEAKER_01Let's turn to the Town of Rowland and the Town of Rhonda. So we have separate updates for you, but some of the updates are very similar and go across both towns. So first of all, start off generally, as you saw from the memos that were included in your packet. Our staff have immediately took financial control of the town's accounts after your vote in October. You appointed Kim Boyle as the finance officer and Kim Denton also at the table with us as the deputy finance officer. The two of them have been involved daily with the town's finances.

SPEAKER_01They're both here to answer any questions that you have. That said, I want to say specifically with the town of Roland. Well, one more statement about both towns. I'm not yet at a place where I feel I can make a recommendation to you as to whether or not the town can be financially rehabilitated. But the resolution that's in your packet allows us to take the next step on that. So going into Roland, Laura Rowe is going to walk through the resolution in the packet with you. But at a high level, what we're doing is following a process

SPEAKER_01that the LGC created previously and passed by resolution several years ago. That resolution that was passed by this body laid out several criteria that must be considered. And those criteria are summarized in the memo. Maybe a question for you is how much detail you would like us to review that memo in. High level, you can ask questions. Laura can go through it in detail. So, looking for any guidance for any of you. And seeing none, I think Laura may be at a high level on each criteria.

SPEAKER_01Thank you. Yeah, so starting with Roland. I'm so sorry. Yeah, starting with Roland. Yeah, rural road director, policy and compliance. So the criteria are eight items that, like Denise said, the LGC put together that they felt would indicate whether or not the town would be a gauge on the town's potential for a future. If the resolution is approved,

SPEAKER_01That would place the town of Roland within the process under Article 32 Chapter 168 for further review to see whether or not it's financially can be financially rehabilitated. So you'll see there that the first criteria is a population trend. That one looks at a five year historical trend. Declining population could indicate that people are leaving the town and there might not be a unit there that would survive in the future.

SPEAKER_01Roland, we didn't see a necessary huge decline of population. Property valuation planned. We have information there on the valuations that Roland had on taxable property in the same years that the County of Robinson Conducted their re-valuations, and so we look at the last three years that the county did that re-val, those valuations are there, along with the municipal rates that the Town of Rowland put in place for the following fiscal year.

SPEAKER_01You can see there that I couldn't speak to this individually, but I understand that the municipal right there is a little bit high for a town of that size. The next criteria is a review of the history of fund balance available. We have a description there of what we're looking at with respect to fund balance available and what that figure represents. You can see there that for fiscal year 25 and 24, we actually had negative Negative numbers indicated there,

SPEAKER_01which again can potentially be a factor that they are trending in actually the wrong direction. I would note that we don't put a weight on any one criteria being more important than the other. I think we would tend to leave that to the members to see as they're assessing both of these resolutions, what is maybe standing out to them as important indicators. The next criteria is the time of the completion and filing of their audit reports.

SPEAKER_01You can see from there is a history of being late with submissions. Criteria 5 lists from the audit reports compliance findings that the auditor had listed there, and this indicator Ask the Commission to look at are there are there repeat findings and how serious are how serious are these findings and so the table that we provided lists the fiscal years in which each finding was was indicated,

SPEAKER_01and you can see there that excess expenditures over appropriation has been a recurring issue with with the town of Roland, along with other. Other findings, including late audit reports, issues of segregation of duties, and use of restricted grant money for operational purposes, which we heard about at the last couple of meetings that they attended. There's also a note there that in the fiscal year 24-25 audit, the auditor did note that Concerns and substantial doubt

SPEAKER_01about the town's financial distress and its continuing ability to function as a growing concern. Criteria 6 lists factors involving governance, and the table there shows for the last four elections what the interest was, the participating interest was in filling the governing board for the town of Rowland, and you'll see there when there were candidates that had filed, whether there were write-ins that were filed for those elections.

SPEAKER_01Roland didn't have a particular history of vacancies like you will see in the RONDA situation, but you'll see that that government's history there. Number seven is the water sewer fund quick ratio. A quick ratio of less than 1.0 is described there and can indicate that current liabilities are greater than unrestricted cash and investments plus accounts receivable. So you'll see there that They had a pattern of quick ratio.

SPEAKER_01They've been above that, it looks like, for a little bit. So that criteria might not indicate a particular concerning problem. The last criteria is also deals with the water and sewer fund operating income, excluding depreciation and including debt and principal payments. You'll see in that table there for the last five fiscal years, they have been in the negative in that regard for their operating income

SPEAKER_01in that water sewer fund. So that's the data that we put together to help you review the information of what these criteria show for Roland in particular. The other piece of this resolution is that if we do find that Roland needs to be put in this process to review, because it is an unsustainable city and we need to further review it for rehabilitation,

SPEAKER_01We also included a finding that our staff should prepare the required services report rather than having the Town of Roland do that. So our staff would prepare both the Financial Affairs Assessment Report and the Services Report. And those are two items that are required as we place a unit within this process of the transition for unsustainable cities. So that's that second part there. Laura, thanks so much. One thing I want to make sure members are clear on is that, as Laura said,

SPEAKER_01a yes vote on this resolution would place the town in a process whereby we as your staff evaluate whether or not the town can be solvent and can be rehabilitated. A vote of yes on this does not dissolve the town. It does not say that you have made a decision about the finances of the town. Moves the town into this process of an additional and further evaluation. So I also just believe we look at the ownership for the town and its limited staff to prepare this report for services.

SPEAKER_01Of course, our staff will be working with staff on the ground in the town. So I ask for your yes vote on this. Commissioner, please.

SPEAKER_02So as the newbie here, I've not gone through these, but out of everything she mentioned, I didn't really see anything positive. I'm like, You started after your comment that you can't make a recommendation. And I'll just take it at that, but as a new one, I'm not seeing much in my way of my lifeline.

SPEAKER_01Across these criteria, things are not looking good at all for the Town of Roland, and I think that that would be an understatement. But I want our staff to have a firm handle on the Town's assets and liabilities. Before we can make that final recommendation, I will tell you that this is a situation, correct me if I'm wrong, of reviewing stacks of bills and trying to understand who the town owes what amount of money. This is not a case where the unit has been functioning well enough that they know what money they owe.

SPEAKER_01I think it's critical that we can tell you here's what they have and here's what they owe. That's a big factor in it. And I want to make sure that I'm thoughtful and thorough before making that recommendation to you. But you're right. On the surface, it doesn't look good.

SPEAKER_02And then you said, or I read somewhere, that there's three members of your staff dealing with it.

SPEAKER_01Oh, there's many more. Kendra, do you want to talk about the team you've worked with?

SPEAKER_02And with this one and the Ronda one, they do the same. It's not a group for this one and a separate group for the Ronda. They do them. You're doing some overlap.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but we are doing it, but there is some overlap for staff. For Kim and I, there's overlap on both of them. Cindy's been involved. Of course, Denise, we're pulling in different members of the team, different vendors to assist. So there is probably Yes, involved with each in addition to the town's staff.

SPEAKER_01To add on to the end of that, I mentioned this in the memos, but a few years ago the legislature changed our budget to include $500,000 of funds that we can use to contract with outside staff as needed when the LGC is in control of a town. This is our first time going through this process since we have had those funds earmarked in the budget. And so we have contracted with a retired city manager to provide town administrator services to us. He is not an employee with the town. He is not the town's administrator.

SPEAKER_01He works for us providing those types of services. We also have contracted with a law firm that specializes in local government law in North Carolina. Both of these units have an attorney that is not in staff, but is paid hourly, and neither of these units have any money. And then we've also contracted enrollment, and we do this as well, with a keeping CPA firm that we have worked with regularly. And also we'll be evaluating the town's payroll practices in specific,

SPEAKER_01where staff have pretty quickly identified a lot of state and federal law violations. So it's our staff. And it's contracted staff.

SPEAKER_02And my concern with the, what were we all doing before they showed up? Hey, you're doing what you were doing and doing this too.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Some of that question. That's my concern.

SPEAKER_02As just an editorial comment, I mean, I think anyone who read all this is struck by the diligence and thoroughness of our team. And so, thank you. I know how hard this is, but it's critically important, so thank you for everything

SPEAKER_01you're doing.

SPEAKER_00Commissioner Johnson. Yes, hearing everything I've heard, I'd actually like to make the motion to move forward with the resolution to get the ball rolling.

SPEAKER_01All right, thank you so much. Motion from Commissioner Johnson, a second from Commissioner Stith. Any other discussion about this resolution for the town of Boland?

SPEAKER_02Mr. Brayer talked about, you know, this is not something, this is just not something that we've read a lot. So at some point, I think it's gonna, unfortunately, I think we're gonna see probably more of these in the coming year or two. I think it will be helpful Just to have a, it's kind of a, what actually happens? You know, when you're contracting with someone wanting to act in the stead of a,

SPEAKER_02and our manager, what exactly is being done? So I think that would help us understand. And when we get to the point of making a final decision, we'll have in our mind, this is where they were, and this is everything that the staff You know, to get us to, because it's still something that's relatively good for us and for us to understand kind of what our staff and everyone's having to do, I think we'll also have

SPEAKER_02a comprehensive kind of understanding when we have to make the next decision, which I think is your life.

SPEAKER_01Thank you.

SPEAKER_02Also, as the process goes forward, what provisions will be made for the residents of these communities to be updated, have input, whatever?

SPEAKER_01Sure. So the report that this resolution asks staff to write instead of the town is a report on the services that the town offers. And that's partly the requirement is partly in place. To communicate to the residents, here's what's being offered right now. It's similar to what you see over the voluntary dissolution pathway, where the town prepares an impact statement for residents describing what happens.

SPEAKER_00Anything you want to add on that? No, I'll just say that For every unit that we will encounter in this market, there will be different challenges. It's going to be different and unique for each unit. So we will give you a primer, but it's going to change every time, depending on what services, depending on the makeup of the community. It'll be different. Thank you. Cindy. Cindy Aiken. So a couple of us are veterans of this, but I believe the entire commission,

SPEAKER_00except for Ms. Hoffman, this is the first time, I think. Ms. Hoffman, you were here, I believe, with Jenny Slorenberg that The staff had prepared monthly maybe Updates at a high level just to keep the LGC informed so we can work out what's important to keep you all informed as to what's happening on the ground.

SPEAKER_00And as we go through the process, there may be budget limits that need to be presented to you. So there will be things that are strictly financial in nature that we will have to ask you to step in as the role as the board. In that way, and take a vote on for us. So we'll let you know that. And say that when I was with the Commission back in 1995, I was on the team to be the first one of these.

SPEAKER_00And it definitely, again, I'll just reiterate, it's going to be different for every one of them, what we encounter. And I'm sure you were just a college intern then. Thank you. You know,

SPEAKER_02I said yesterday in our small group meeting that unfortunately we're probably just going to continue to see more of these.

SPEAKER_01There certainly are a number of local governments that are struggling. One thing that I'm hoping we can do through these discussions is to let other local governments In a financial precarious situation, probably do not have a financial future, know that it is okay to pursue voluntary dissolution. It's not an inferior state of being to be unincorporated. You've heard me say before, 40% of the state lives in unincorporated communities.

SPEAKER_01So I think it's very likely that you will see fees coming to the LGC, but I'm Hoping that also we can give that exit ramp to local governments who can see the writing on the wall for their own. Thanks.

SPEAKER_02And I'll just kind of lift something that Mr. Hughes said, that that is the information that is going to the public, to the citizens who are being affected by these decisions that I think it's important for us. If we're not communicating, if staff's not communicating, That we're asking the persons of the locals, how is this getting, how is this decision getting communicated to the folks that are going to be affected by it as well? I think it's important for us to always keep top of mind as well.

SPEAKER_01Any other discussion or questions on Roland? We have a motion and a second. I need to call Roland this resolution.

SPEAKER_00Hearing no further discussion, that was Johnson, Stiff, motion second for the roll resolution. Auditor Bullitt? Aye. Secretary Wooten? Aye. Mr. Brown? Aye. Ms. Hoffman? Ms. Hoffman? Oh, resolution vote. Aye. Okay, thank you. Mr. Hughes? Aye.

SPEAKER_00Mr. McBride, Treasurer Briner. Motion carries.

SPEAKER_01All right. Thanks so much. Let's turn over to your last attachment, which is attachment F, the town of Rhonda. Again, you have a memo that summarizes high points of the staff's work over the past month and explains the resolution. I'm going to turn this over to Laura to walk you through the findings, things on each of the criteria, the same Criteria, of course, that were reviewed in the last resolution. Could we be able to touch on some criteria that stood out?

SPEAKER_01Do you want me to? No, to not go through everyone, but maybe to Alex.

SPEAKER_02And the highlights.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Highlights. Thank you very much. So one of the first areas that shows concern for the town of Rwanda is the fund balance available. That's criteria three for a unit of this size. Well, for a unit that has a general fund of this size, 71% is the minimum adequate level for fund balance available. And you'll see that they're trending in the wrong direction with fiscal year 25,

SPEAKER_01doing 39% that they have available there. They have had a history of being late with filing their audit reports, so they're in Criteria 4. Criteria 5 again has a summary table. That lists the different non-compliance findings that the audit report had for the last five years. And you'll see that for late audit filing and excess expenditures over appropriations had several years of findings for that town.

SPEAKER_01With respect to governance, again, you'll see the table showing candidates and interest in holding positions on the governing board. Whether there were write-ins or not for these elections, you'll see that participation there. Coupled with participation, you'll see that there has been a bit of a history with individuals in the mayor position resigning. Of course, there's an election today, but Rhonda's been functioning without a mayor for a little bit now.

SPEAKER_01And they've had resignation of a commissioner recently where another commissioner had to be appointed. We also note... The investigative report issued by the State Auditor's Office recently involving the Town of Rhonda and your office's findings are summarized there in that criteria. Part number seven, with the quick ratio for the water and sewer fund, again, the ratio of less than 1.0 can be an indicator.

SPEAKER_01And you'll see here for the last several fiscal years, Rhonda had a quick ratio of less than one, which can be an indicator that they're having, that that fund is having difficulty meeting expenses. And in criteria eight, the water sewer operating income fund, You'll see there also for the last four fiscal years that they've been functioning with a negative balance. Similarly to the town of Bond and Rowland,

SPEAKER_01we're also including a finding that the preparation of the services report would be a hardship on the town, so we would be looking for LGC staff

SPEAKER_00to get that report also. Thank you, Laura.

SPEAKER_01Commissioner, is there any questions about the town of Rona specifically or general about this process that we haven't covered?

SPEAKER_02I didn't have to...

SPEAKER_01Sorry, sorry.

SPEAKER_00Shafi, you were making a motion correct?

SPEAKER_02I going to make the motion that we that we accept your recommendation to have another month for you to to to bring us a final recommendation for this city, for this town.

SPEAKER_01All right, thanks. We shouldn't have a second. I think you should. Seeing no other discussion last Sunday to call.

SPEAKER_00All right. On the resolution presented, Mr. Brown. Aye. Ms. Hoffman. Aye. Okay, sorry. Mr. Hughes. Aye. Commissioner Johnson. Aye.

SPEAKER_00Thank you

SPEAKER_01so much. That completes our scheduled business. Is there any other business to bring before the Commission? Hearing none, I'm looking for a motion to

SPEAKER_00adjourn.

SPEAKER_01And I think we'll do a little bit on this in favor. Thank

SPEAKER_00you.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. WATCH: Columbus Town Council Delays Polk YMCA Vote

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Columbus delays Polk County Recreation Center review as residents debate costs Council members plan to vote on Dec. 17; residents also raised questions about a proposed $12 million county loan. By Annie Dance | Cops &...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. WATCH (EXCLUSIVE): Lake Lure adopts 2040 plan as rebuilding, utility costs mount

    Nov 20, 202624 minAudio

    Long-range guide will shape future land use and public investment; council also approves $195,125 utility project and winter restroom funding By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary Lake Lure’s Town Council...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. WATCH: WNC water recovery faces funding questions, with 160 ‘distressed’ entities

    Nov 17, 20262 hr 7 minAudio

    State committee advances utility planning framework as mountain communities rebuild, and a reserve for distressed systems sits empty. By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary Western North Carolina’s effort...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. WATCH: Council of State approves prison deal at Tryon Palace meeting

    Nov 16, 202641 minAudio

    By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary North Carolina’s Council of State approved $18.85 million in prison energy financing Nov. 10, after questioning savings guarantees during a hybrid meeting repeatedly...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. WATCH: Outgoing Rutherford board leaves long-running growth plan to incoming commissioners

    Nov 14, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    After two years of planning, commissioners schedule a Dec. 7 public hearing on advisory Rutherford 2040, leaving adoption to the next board. By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary Rutherford County’s...

    Credit the people on this episode