Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Cops & Congress by Annie Dance

Cops & Congress by Annie Dance artwork

WATCH: WNC water recovery faces funding questions, with 160 ‘distressed’ entities

Nov 17, 20262 hr 7 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

State committee advances utility planning framework as mountain communities rebuild, and a reserve for distressed systems sits empty. By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary Western North Carolina’s effort to rebuild water and sewer infrastructure after Hurricane Helene is intersecting with a broader state push to make struggling utilities financially sustainable - even as a grant reserve intended to help distressed systems has no money available. The State Water Infrastructure Authority’s Viable Utility Committee voted on Nov. 13 to advance a framework for long-term viability plans. The proposal would help designated local governments connect infrastructure repairs, customer rates, staffing, and financial management. The meeting agenda identified Item C as approval of the framework for long-term viability plans required of local government units designated as distressed, an action item presented by Tim Baldwin of the Viable Utilities Unit. Item D separately scheduled a discussion of the process for removing distressed designations, presented by Victor D’Amato. The committee approved forwarding the framework to the full authority for review Dec. 9. It did not award construction funding or adopt a final process for removing distressed status. According to public records, Rutherford County has four local government units on the state’s distressed water and wastewater utilities list: Chimney Rock, Cliffside Sanitary District, Lake Lure and Rutherfordton. Statewide, the list includes 160 entities across 64 counties - 136 municipalities, 19 county governments and five sanitary or sewage districts. For mountain communities, restoring service after a disaster and sustaining a utility over decades involve different financial and management needs. D’Amato told committee members the Viable Utility Reserve currently has no funding available, leaving uncertainty about assistance for construction projects emerging from the planning process. “We have no forecast on when or if we’d be able to fund those,” D’Amato said. Other water infrastructure programs remain available, he said, including asset inventory and assessment grants, but demand is high. The reserve’s funding shortage comes alongside substantial, separately funded recovery work. In July, North Carolina Gov. Josh Stein and Department of Environmental Quality Secretary Reid Wilson announced more than $1 billion awarded for water infrastructure and resilience projects in western North Carolina. The governor’s office said more than $758 million in unmet needs remained at that time. “It’s an important milestone that DEQ has awarded over $1 billion for Helene recovery, but in some ways it’s just the beginning,” Wilson said. Burnsville had received more than $17 million in authority funding, including assistance for replacing its raw water intake and improving water and sewer infrastructure, according to the announcement. I previously reported for Carolina Journal about the regional funding milestone and the lengthy reconstruction ahead. I also reported for Cops & Congress on the $12 million in announced Helene grants for Lake Lure, including emergency waterlines, a wastewater treatment plant outside the floodplain, and chemical storage. Those recovery awards are distinct from the reserve discussed on Nov. 13. Canton illustrates another challenge facing mountain utilities. In May, state officials highlighted a $3.5 million award for its new wastewater treatment plant and interconnection project. DEQ said Canton had received $24.5 million for Helene water infrastructure upgrades. Canton’s financial pressures reflected problems confronting small utilities more broadly: aging infrastructure, rising costs, and relatively few customers to share expenses. The Nov. 13 agenda materials explicitly connect the proposed framework to experience working with distressed utilities and systems affected by Helene. The accompanying staff report said the program’s final planning component would address infrastructure, finances, and organizational management under NC General Statute 159G-45(b). Existing guidance requires infrastructure assessments resulting in at least a 10-year capital improvement plan. Rate studies must include a scenario showing how utilities could achieve full-cost pricing within five years. The proposed guidance would also ask utilities to calculate residential monthly bills for 5,000 gallons under current rates and projected full-cost rates. Local governments would consider affordability and governing boards’ willingness to support adjustments. For projects planned within five years, one proposed question states: “Explain how these projects could still be funded if no grant money was available.” The proposed questions would also examine financial audit concerns, staffing vacancies, compensation, employee retention, and whether finance and operations employees regularly review information together. They would ask utilities to explain how new board members learn their responsibilities. The framework would include a guidance workbook, a standardized response form with an action summary, and a companion reference document. Baldwin said staff wants local governments to develop plans they understand and can implement themselves. “We want to maximize the ownership of this document by the units,” Baldwin said. The staff report also recognizes that some systems may need partnerships or other alternatives to become viable. Plans would preserve institutional knowledge through staff turnover and elections. Committee members discussed local governing board approval, identifying plan participants, and publishing completed plans online. “All of this is about accountability, it sounds like,” said committee Chair Shadi Eskaf. Those measures remain under development. Members also considered tying future funding decisions to progress and projects identified in viability plans. The separate discussion about leaving distressed status examined how systems could complete statutory requirements while continuing longer-term improvements. A draft proposal would retain eligibility for Viable Utility Reserve grants for five years after leaving distressed status, subject to conditions. D’Amato said the current lifetime eligibility limit is $15 million per local government; eligibility would not guarantee funding. The broader discussion about removing distressed designations will likely reach the full authority next year, Eskaf said. Staff anticipates developing the planning materials before testing them with selected local governments next summer and beginning full implementation in fall 2027. - This newsletter is supported by readers like you. Paid subscribers have access to the full archive. - 🏛️ All those mentioned are presumed innocent until proven guilty. Learn more about this newsletter, ethics policy, how you can help shape this work, and support it. Follow on X and Facebook. Send constructive criticism, fan mail, and tips with public documents for future stories: CopsandCongress@gmail.com - Annie Dance is the publisher of Cops & Congress, a newsletter that analyzes what happens when crime, courts, disaster, democracy, and small-town policies collide. Views expressed here are covered by the First Amendment. Dance has a Bachelor … This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit anniedance.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02All right. Good afternoon, everyone. I'd like to call this meeting of the Statewide Infrastructure Authorities Viable Utility Committee to order. We are meeting here virtually today. We have new committee members, actually, for this meeting. The last time we had a committee meeting was in March of 2025. But I'd like to go ahead and introduce both Jeff Hughes and Jeff Polley as new members of the committee. Thanks for joining Joining us as well.

SPEAKER_02Corey, you were on the call last time that we had a meeting. So I guess we're just going to rely on the two of us to try to remember some of the history going back to previous conversations. All right. So we're online. We'll try to monitor. Sometimes I won't see actual faces if I'm looking online. Other things on my screen. So if there's something that any committee member wants to mention, just feel free to interrupt, raise your hand if you want,

SPEAKER_02but feel free to interrupt and just ask questions. We have a couple of presentations and one action item for today's meeting. While the meeting is being recorded and broadcast online on WebEx, members of the public are on mute. The meetings have a specific time reserved on the agenda for informal comments, if there are any such comments. On the public, we can take them at the end of the meeting. General Statue 138A mandates that the chair inquire

SPEAKER_02as to whether there are any known or potential conflicts of interest with respect to any matter before the committee members today. If there are any known or potential conflicts of interest, please identify them when that becomes apparent. But at this time, are there any known or potential conflicts of interest? That any members would like to identify. Okay. Hearing none, we'll take roll call. This is a good time for us to also check your mics. I'll just go in order, Corey Gooden.

SPEAKER_02Corey, can you say it one more time? Sorry. Present. Gotcha. Now, thank you. Jeff Poli. Present. Thank you. And Jeff Hughes. Present here. Thank you. And we have a quorum. Let's see my notes. Okay. That's all we've got right now. If we can move to the next slide, please.

SPEAKER_02First action item for the committee is the approval of the meeting minutes from our last meeting, which I mentioned again was March of 2025. Corey, you are the only committee member that was present at that time. I will note that we've made an edit to the meeting minutes since we sent it to you all. The edits were removing Jeff Poli as an attendee of that meeting because we just confirmed also that Jeff did not attend.

SPEAKER_02And we reorganized the attendees list. So right now it mentions, it lists several people who attended, but it had some of the Department of State Treasurer's staff listed as Division of Water Infrastructure staff. So we just moved them to a separate section. But these were the only edits that were made to the meeting minutes that were shared to the committee. Corey, did you have anything else to add or edit to the meeting minutes? Or do you want to vote to approve the meeting minutes? No, I'll make the motion. Okay.

SPEAKER_02Well, you're the only one voting, so you can make motion and votes to approve it if you want. Okay. So motion and R. Thank you. I appreciate it, Corey. So that motion carries. I think we are, Jeff Hughes and Jeff Pauly, we're taking you as absent, because you weren't attending those meetings as well. There was some background noise, Cory, when you came online, or you just wanted to confirm that was from your microphone.

SPEAKER_00Can you hear now?

SPEAKER_02I had to switch microphones. Yep, I can hear you fine. And there's less background, so I appreciate that. Okay. Thank you. All right, next slide. All right, so we have two agenda items today. The first one is an action item. The second one is an information item. Potentially with some discussion that we need to have. The first item is... Sorry, there's some echoing here.

SPEAKER_02Okay, there we go. Thank you. The first item is approval of a framework for the long-term viability plans that are required for local governments that are designated as distressed. Tim Baldwin will be presenting that action item. Put us up front that what we're seeking here is not just input from the committee, but if the committee members feel like this is a good framework as is, then the committee can vote to approve it and it would go next to the full authority, potentially in the December meeting.

SPEAKER_02And if SWEA votes to approve it, then it will be taken to the local government commission as well for their review. So that's the of the schedule and the timeline for the long-term viability plan framework. And with that, I'll turn it over to Tim Baldwin, who's here in the room presenting as well.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_02We'll keep you muted because we're using the conference room mics, so you're good. Everybody can hear you. Thanks, Charlie. Appreciate that. Appreciate your help.

SPEAKER_03Microphone, too. If you can advance the slide. Okay, so we have about an hour and 25 minutes set aside for discussion. And what I'd like to do with that time is provide a brief overview of the conceptual framework. I know we introduced it a couple of months ago at SWEA with a couple of slides, but I want to go in so that you have content to talk about.

SPEAKER_03We as a group would like your thoughts and ideas on, but it's also free discussion for the committee. And then finally the action item at the end. Okay, so this was one of the slides that I presented a couple months ago, but the general statutes, 159G, This is item three under the requirements of three.

SPEAKER_03The first and second items include doing asset assessment, rate study and doing training, which are already pretty well developed within our program. And so this third item is the last of the requirements we're trying to define and it's to develop an action plan. The action plan needs to include short-term and long-term infrastructure planning, continuing ed for the governing board and operating staff, and then long-term financial management for the system.

Of course, any other matters identified by the authority in LGC.

SPEAKER_03So this entire item three we're bringing together as a long-term viability plan. And yeah, go ahead, Rosemary, thanks. The organizational management aspect, in my opinion,

SPEAKER_03might be one of the most important of the three, seeing as in order to properly execute the first two focus areas,

SPEAKER_03It focuses on organizational specific. Okay. The development, developmental process. It included even the BUC meeting that we just approved the minutes from back in March of 25. There was a presentation on the long-term viability plan.

SPEAKER_03We've met numerous times either individually or as our RAPRU group, which is a resource agency partners for water and Cops, LGC staff, CERCAP, League of Municipalities, et cetera. Recently, we gave a detailed presentation to LGC staff and received some very constructive comments from them. And then a brief intro with SWEA.

SPEAKER_03So we've been working this through internally, our staff. We've had several meetings, worked as a complete group in order to utilize our various backgrounds, which span Permitting of systems, design, construction, operation, finances, management, and regulatory oversight. So, and, you know, over the years of our program, we've of course been working closely with many distressed units, learning from them, learning about our program and how best to meet their needs,

SPEAKER_03as well as more recently, very intense one-on-one work. And that includes of course three focus areas approved to do financial, another one for infrastructure and organizational. We've also had a team focused on KPI metrics type work as well as ordinances and policies.

SPEAKER_03And then one specifically looking at the implementation and maintenance of the long-term viability plan by the actual units. So how do we get them to be able to do this? How do we focus on making it useful for them and something they will continue using? And finally, we did have a group also just working on making sure that we're coordinating with our overall program and the designation that's coming up from Vic later too. Right.

SPEAKER_03So any questions on sort of where we've been? I know we have some new members, but that's okay. I'll just keep going otherwise.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, feel free to interrupt or just unmute yourselves. I'll see if you want to say something, but I'm not seeing anything right now. Okay.

SPEAKER_03So we wanted to start from the top and develop some guiding principles for our process that we're developing. We wanted to keep it simple. We want this to be a process that the unit can work on by themselves and not require a consultant. So we want to maximize the ownership of this document by the units. And probably the best way to do that is for to be something they develop themselves to give it the best chance of something

SPEAKER_03that they actually kind of believe in and want to implement and follow. We need to keep this process flexible enough to accommodate the very unique needs of the systems that are going through our program. The problems that they're confronting are unique to them as to why they are in our program, and then the solutions are just as unique. We want to work on the unit's capacity to utilize their existing tools.

SPEAKER_03These are all tools and we want to make sure they know how to get the most out of them. We'd also, another goal is to create a continuity plan. One system is staff turnover and loss of institutional knowledge, but almost more critical The typical board member is not utility-focused or from a utility background. And so if we could create a document that helps preserve the long-term goals

SPEAKER_03for the unit and help bring everyone up to speed, that'd be another good part of this. And then finally, we don't need to reinvent the wheel. There's obviously a lot of good information out there on best management practices, effective utility management, et cetera. So we want to lean on what's already out there. And spend our efforts on tailoring it to our specific programs needs, the units needs, and that we see across North Carolina.

SPEAKER_03So we developed some purposes and goals from those guiding principles. What do we want to get out of this then? A couple pages of those. We want the units to be able to explain their utility

SPEAKER_03Again, going back to those tools that they have, get them to utilize the data plans and evaluations that they already have. A process to create new material as much as it is just to get them to go through thought processes and utilize their existing material as best as possible.

SPEAKER_03And continuing on those purposes and goals for the long-term viability plan process, we want them to look to see what levels of service goals they may need, metrics and targets to follow those, you know, basically key performance indicators that they might track. We want them to look through their ordinances and policies to consider what might be needed to meet their, you know, not only permit regulatory or statutory requirements, but also their actual specific operational needs of their system.

SPEAKER_03We want them to be able to self-identify those areas of their program that need improvement in all three areas. Any concepts that would include partnering with other utilities for assistance or regionalization. And this isn't going to be an actual master planning long-range document we're creating. We just want to start that thought process and capture some of that long-range needs

SPEAKER_03of the utility so that can be carried down through this document, again, as a continuity document for changeover. And then finally, going back to the Go back one second. Going back to the actual general statute requirement that we're trying to meet is creating an action list of action items. We're going to cover that by after they've gone through and created all these thought processes, the things they need, we'll collect it all into a concise list of action items.

SPEAKER_03Any questions on goals, objectives, what we're trying to achieve here? So the way we set up the framework and some of the initial concepts in format of the documents, we're thinking a good way to present it would be three separate documents. Long-term Viability Plan Guidance document.

SPEAKER_03It's essentially the workbook for filling out the deliverable. It will contain the questions and the explanations of how to fill out that deliverable document. And that deliverable document, the LTVP deliverable, It's sort of a standard answer form, standardized answer form. It'll be long and it will be where they put the answers to. There will be short form questions just to gather information, but also the key of the whole project is these longer, structured,

SPEAKER_03open-ended questions that cause them to have to think through some of their processes, think through their tools, if you will. Answer questions for us. So we give them space for that. And again, that process between the guidance document and deliverable, there will be an action plan summary content at the end so that they know what they need to do over the next few years to go down that path towards better viability.

SPEAKER_03And so we're going to take a look at that. And also references to that pool of knowledge I said that is out there and put that all in a reference document that has, will have linkages so people can move back and forth, but not to overwhelm them with a 50 page, 100 page document.

SPEAKER_03So, and one of the goals, we want to be able to explain why we're asking these questions. So not just, you know, answer this, but the reason we're asking you is to better approach this, you know, work through your decision process, access this information in your tools.

SPEAKER_03We're asking these open-ended questions that get them to dive into their utility, how they operate. So I want to give a couple examples. There's a big list of just, you know, again, these are just our first blush of conceptual questions, but there's a big list at the end of the staff report. First one, as an example, is essentially, you know,

What it is that they're doing to try to fix that. Second bullet, example question is essentially from the LGC, you know,

SPEAKER_03are you on the unit assist list or are you experiencing any financial or fiscal constraints that are causing you difficulties in the operation of your utility? And then again, going into the depth of please explain those to us and those decisions you're making to correct those. Another example question is how likely are you going to be able to meet the full cost pricing understanding customer affordability

and governing board resolve issues that you may be facing.

SPEAKER_03If you are presenting a more achievable rate adjustment plan and it will not be full cost pricing as calculated in the You can either start developing or maybe it's already there and you just need to be tracking it and analyzing it in order to make better decisions

SPEAKER_03for your utility. The last slide of examples, your 10-year capital improvement plan, please explain how it is focused around long-term viability of your system and are there items that would help your viability that are not Like a meter replacement program, equipment replacement, et cetera,

SPEAKER_03that need to also be on that capital improvement plan to register them for your revenue needs. And then partnerships and agreements. A little bit on getting them the types of questions to get them moving towards long-range planning, you know, any issues with capacity on, say,

SPEAKER_03water supply or wastewater treatment or quality issues. So getting them to do that long-range thinking so that this can be recorded and carried down as people change over. So it's kind of, in essence, what we've worked on developing. There's, like I said, a bigger list of example questions in the staff report towards the end, and then also that guidance companion document.

SPEAKER_03There's sort of like a rough table of what we'd like to include in there as well in the staff report. The remaining stuff from our point of view. So we'll be working on building up implementation strategy in order to make this roll out as smooth as possible. We realize we need to consider the existing and any new units that come in our program.

SPEAKER_03And when we implement it, they'll be in all different stages of the distress program. So how do we handle those? We want to figure out what types of meetings and workshops we might like to have between our staff and the local government units during the production and review of their deliverable. We want to have our review and approval procedures figured out before we get this whole program moving. And also looking forward, you know, with the information we'll be getting in in these long term viability plans,

SPEAKER_03is there information that we want to start collecting Inside our efforts, our assistance or either our technical assistance or financial assistance. And then finally, making sure we are coordinated with both the rest of the viable utility program process and the de-designation process, which Vic will be talking about a little later.

SPEAKER_03Next steps. One of the items is when we get into the actual intense production of content, we would like to form a focus group. So I want to kind of put forward some of the groups that we are looking at and have a later question during our discussion period about anyone else we might need. But obviously some sister state agencies that work with the utilities quite a bit. The School of Government has a unique point of view that we would like to have on our team.

SPEAKER_03Obviously, the COGS and other TA providers work closely with all the utilities, both in the infrastructure, financial and organizational areas, and we see them as possibly We want those units that maybe have lower capacity and might need some assistance between our help and our TA providers. We want them on board helping us understand the best way to implement this and structure it.

Finally, we'll obviously have some representatives from utilities, local government units, trying to cover all three areas

SPEAKER_03We have some review on our focus team so we can make sure that that point of view is being addressed. And then finally, a proposed timeline. As Shadi mentioned, if it seems like our concept and framework are on target, we can get this approved to go to the SWEA meeting December 9th. If all that's good, writing content and that focus group work can begin right away.

SPEAKER_03We'll work on it through the winter, probably into the summer of next year. As we are getting the concept polished up, we would like to try to bring in just a very few number of local government units in order to do a trial run. To further polish what we have, make sure it made sense to them, and it worked them through the program like we intended. And if all goes well, we would hope maybe for full implementation this fall.

SPEAKER_00Thanks, Ted. I have a question. How long do you anticipate this plan, starting a plan through getting through the plan? I guess I know implementation is going to be talked about later. I guess I mean, how long are we going to give people to do their AIA and so on to get the plan in front of them?

SPEAKER_03So our current thinking is that this might actually be implemented as soon as the unit, you know, for a fresh unit that comes into our program, newly designated, we might get them thinking about it immediately. Because like you said, there will be processes along the way, you know, first they'll get working on AIA, which will address some of the issues in here. And so as they're doing the other reports and requirements, they can fill in documents and Us as a team,

SPEAKER_03our project managers or case managers will be able to help move them through so that it's not one big lift at the end as much as just a thought process and moving them through our programs. But some, of course, you know, implementing it right now, some will be at the very end. So it will be a report that's written up in whatever the months it takes for us to work with that unit and And I

SPEAKER_02think another way to look at the question that Jeff asks, which might be a different question than I'm asking now, is whether or not the action plan is going to put the systems on a specific timeline or the action plan itself will have a timeline of like, it's a 10-year plan or a 20-year plan or a two-year plan. From my understanding, and correct me, Tim, but the action plan doesn't necessarily give a specific timeline for the systems. They just need to figure out what the What they want to put on the plan and put an appropriate timeline on it themselves,

SPEAKER_02but that we we would not specifically say we need a five year plan for me.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, we haven't set that yet. So if that's something that maybe the action plan needs to cover a certain number of years, but it's more what do you need to do and what would your projections be as to when you see yourself implementing this?

SPEAKER_02And I don't know, Jack, if that was what you were asking or It's a great question. It's a great question. I guess I was trying to ask,

SPEAKER_00are we going to give them three months, six months, a year, figure it out later? I just don't want, you know, the way some of these change over, so on. I just, you know, I hate to use all deliberate speed, but, you know, I think once they get in the program, we should try to get them going because people lose attention. So I don't know if I have an answer to my own question or So on, and I think Tim said we don't quite know yet, but we kind of start as soon as someone comes into the program.

SPEAKER_00But I just want to emphasize that this creating the plan shouldn't take a year, at least unless the AIA takes a long time. So that's my two cents.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's a good point, Jeff. And I think right now, because we're developing this, we have a lot of systems that have been designated for a few years already. They are going to have this kind of a, now we have this plan, we have this framework, so they're starting now, but for new systems I'm hearing, which is, I agree, systems, as soon as they're designated as a stress, we get them started on the plans, on everything all at once. They have the rate study guidance, they'll have the asset inventory guidance, and they have the long-term action viability plan.

SPEAKER_02So all three can get started right away. I personally would like to see progress, at least in A starting process for some of those things within the first six months of being designated and within 12 months, it should really be like actually doing something, maybe not complete on the plans, but they can actually show that they're making some significant progress with it. I think a lot of that might depend on the timing of their trainings as well. Some of them may want to go through the training first, the best utility management practices, and that might affect the timing of some of these actions.

SPEAKER_02That's just my two cents on it.

SPEAKER_00I agree, Shadi. I think when someone is new to that list and we get going as part of the AIAs and the other very kind of preliminary short-term plans, that somewhere in there, there should be either quarterly or biannual updates regarding this. Because your long-term plans, in essence, start from some very short-term kind of immediate things you have to address. And, you know, I would like to see it at least twice a year and update

SPEAKER_00on where they are, you know, because it's going to change, you know, as things short term are fixed. But for the older units like myself, You know, for us, once we got to the point of establishing CIPs, which is really kind of a 10-year forecast, that's where we can look at years 11 through 30.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I don't know, Chuck, if you had some reactions to that.

SPEAKER_01No, I don't have any reaction. I mean, I don't know what the right time is. I just don't want to. Them to lose attention to this and it's three years on. They're still on the list.

SPEAKER_00You know, we should suspend funding requests, you know, until this is done or things like that to get them going.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's, I'm not sure if that was going to be part of your slides a little bit later, Tim, in terms of funding and how this ties to funding.

SPEAKER_03And that's probably more carried over into Vic's presentation on de-designation and how that affects the VUR funding. Okay.

SPEAKER_02So I'll just say for the long-term viability plan, I mean, we've had conversations at SWEA before where the VUR grant funds moving forward really need to be targeted towards projects that will specifically address viability and get the systems to do what they need to do to implement Viability plans. Well, now that we have a framework or potentially have a framework for long-term viability plans, one thought that we can have in front of you now and in front of SWEA is going forward, BUR grants will only be used for projects that come out

SPEAKER_02of long-term viability plans. So you do your long-term viability plans and then when you're in a good position to apply for funding, then they can apply for specific projects coming out of this planning process. So that might relate a little bit, but I do see also Vic's hands is raised. So Vic, do you want to weigh in on this?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, hopefully moving forward in the call, let me know, Shani and Rosemary, if raising my hand is okay, if you guys can see that, or if I should just interject. But yeah, I think there's There's a lot of good questions about timeline there, but they are, I think, different questions. And then there's another point I wanted to make, and it relates to timeline, but it's, and I don't want to complicate matters,

SPEAKER_01but it's certainly something that needs to be out there, which is the fact that, you know, there's no funding in the BUR right now, which means A, anything tied to long-term viability plan, construction projects, CIPs, we have no forecast on when or if we'd be able to fund those. And B, and maybe even more to Jeff's point about the overall timeline. And Corey, what I heard you say with twice

SPEAKER_01a year check-ins or status reports, I think what you're saying, or at least the way I interpret it, is as where they are in the process, because it is a process. You can't do the viability plan before you do an AIA. As Tim said, you can start it. You can start certain sections of it, understanding what your current situation is and why you've been designated, but you're not going to have a CIP, for example, and that's a huge part of the long-term viability plan.

SPEAKER_01So there's different moving parts there. Overall of it is the fact that we don't have funding, and if we don't, we can't even guarantee necessarily, I don't think, funding for all distressed units that even need an AIA, let alone a construction grant. Of course, we do have our regular AIA grant program out of the State Reserve. It does prefer, or there's some prioritization given to distressed units, but nevertheless, there's high demand there.

SPEAKER_01So that's just something for y'all to kind of keep in mind. But Jeff, I wanted more specifically, yeah, we don't have a time limit for when a unit comes into the program. We always try to get them engaged as soon as we can. Bump training is a great way to do that. Then they really understand what an AIA is about and how it's going to help them. If it times up, you know, with the fall funding ground when we know we'll have AIA funding, definitely try to get them, you know,

SPEAKER_01focused on that. But as you guys know, and again, another just kind of thing to keep in mind is that we don't really have, we don't have a good way or really maybe any way to compel units to do anything we ask and certainly not to hold them to a time. The only times we sort of have that Or when we grant a project like an AIA and we give them a list of milestones and when they are to be completed by, and that's by, you know, binding for that funding.

SPEAKER_01That's the linchpin there. But for the program as a whole, there's really no, you know, there's only this sort of carrot of VUR funding, which we don't have currently, and no sticks really to, you know, make sure that folks do things Intentionally and in whatever we would consider, you know, a reasonable timeframe. So. Right. I guess maybe since we are SWIA,

SPEAKER_01can we create a stick in that unless it's a true emergency, you're not going to get,

SPEAKER_00don't bother sending us an SRF application for, except if it's an AIA until you've done this. And until you've implemented your plan, you know, whether it's a point system or whatnot, we need to create rewards and stakes, I guess, with with points on the applications, perhaps. Because. That might be what's, you know, that may be all we have right now,

SPEAKER_00but that's something that we could use, perhaps. I think one of the milestones for new State revolving loan application for one of these AIAs distressed or not, I think one of those milestones has to be how a short term plan is changing into a long term as a part of that. I mean, we went through for both CIPs for us, for water and sewer.

SPEAKER_00Really what we knew was immediate need. And when I say immediate, I mean, that got us in a 10 year window when we think about lending and we think about construction and we think about permitting approvals, et cetera. You know, that first 10 years really is what you can get to quickly. And then I think, you know, Years 11 through 20 or 11 through 30 or whatever we want to do for what we call the time range of long term.

SPEAKER_00I think that should lead like, in my mind, it's like if you had your magic wand and you had all of your short list items taken care of at that point, now what do you do going forward since what you think are problems are addressed? So, you know, And that's just the way we really viewed that. And these ORCs can really funnel that data and that information to these managers and utilities directors and engineering firms and really make that clear.

SPEAKER_00I think about just, I mean, Vic, right now on the second phase of the INI project we're on, I remember that from 2020. That's on our short-term list. And, you know, we're on year six, and it's getting really close to completion. But, you know, now that all that's behind us, it's like, now what are we doing? And I think you should think about that. And I think those operators know what happens on year 11.

SPEAKER_01I just kind of put this thought out there that, you know, I think The way we've looked at it from our purview as the viable utility program is that, and Tim, please jump in and correct me or nuance what I say, but I think for us, like the long-term plan, the term of that is essentially how long does it take them to get to quote viability or whatever we call that viability endpoint. And then, and you're right, Corey, there's still a lot to do after that,

SPEAKER_01but from the programmatic perspective, If they're viable, we're, you know, they've successfully navigated the program from our perspective.

SPEAKER_02I think also in the session, in the general statutes, again, the requirement for local governments that are designated as a stress is to develop an action plan, take into account specific things. It does not say that they have to complete or implement all the action plans. The idea is to get them to create the plan so they have an idea of which way to go and what to do. That's the statutory requirement. In terms of providing additional incentives, whether it's, you know,

SPEAKER_02through prioritization or how SWEA might prioritize funding other funding as non-VUR. For local governments are designated as distressed. I think there are multiple implications to that. I mean, what happens when a system that had funding for a while for SRF and then becomes designated as distressed, but they need more funding for that same project? Are we going to send a note to them? There's lots of things to consider in terms of limiting access to other funding unless they're doing a viability. But I think Jeff Polian hearing you say like, well, you create an action plan like this.

SPEAKER_02We want to provide as many incentives as possible. Or carrots or carrots or sticks as possible to implement this as well.

SPEAKER_00Because, and yes, I, I, and I realize it may, you might have to go, uh, figure out all the permutations that can happen. For example, if they had a project and they just needed more money for a project, that's one thing, but it's another thing. Um, if there's, they're, they're refusing to raise their rates and they're always asking for, um, For funds, basically, we're rewarding them for not raising their rates. So we have to kind of figure out with the point system, the carrots and sticks.

SPEAKER_00They get points for being on the BUR. If they're not doing any BUR stuff, they should get deducted points. I'm not saying it's an easy way to do it. I mean, easy way to just do it, but we have to think. The VUR units are the ones who have been doing it wrong for the last 20, 30 years. And they're the ones getting rewarded by extra funds. So that's kind of unfair to the rest of the folks.

SPEAKER_00But I understand the dilemma.

SPEAKER_01You're trying to encourage one thing and discourage others. How do you do it? This is a health and safety issue as well.

SPEAKER_02But I think we need to put in that time. Yeah, and I think in the rating systems, I mean, a rating system is a little more nuanced than that, where you get points for good system management. Well, this, you know, local government that's designated as a stress is probably not getting those points. So there's differences there. But I think for me, the point that you brought up or this discussion has kind of raised a thought, which is if a system that's designated as a stress comes up with an action plan, the action plan is to regionalize,

SPEAKER_02and then they apply for funding, So just build their own water treatment plants or their own wastewater treatment plant. And it's not the regional project. Then we know at that point, there's something like this application for funding doesn't match your viability plan. So we need to have conversation. We need to, you know, SWE at that point may decide not to fund this project because it's not consistent with the viability plan. So I think something like that, once we have these viability plans implemented, I think that could feed into funding decisions.

SPEAKER_02Depending on what the application, what the project is being applied for, whether or not that's coming out of the plan or not. But I think those things can be discussed in the SWEA meetings at that time. I think it will require staff to be able to review the applications and to identify those ahead of time too. So we're not there yet because we don't have a viability plan concepts or framework. So it's a little harder to do that at this time.

SPEAKER_00Well, the minute they approve a plan, they're no longer a viable utility for the statute. We can't designate it for another two years.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we need to talk about that de-designation in the next agenda item today.

SPEAKER_00Oh, I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_02But you're right. And there is actually, we have some discussion about that and access to funding, et cetera, moving forward. So that's going to show up in the next agenda item.

SPEAKER_00I'll just wait then. Okay.

SPEAKER_02I'd like to ask that first question that you see on the slide here, based on what Tim has presented in terms of what the concept is. Again, you know, we're basically providing... Oh, I'm sorry. Jeff, I didn't see your hand. It's hard for me to notice hands. Go ahead, Jeff.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and this is my first meeting, and I'm still getting really familiar with all the different inner... Interconnected ideas that were going on. So I had just a couple of questions and maybe if you're going to answer them later or just let me know. But one of them is we've referred or you referred to the utility throughout the presentation. Is there any thought to identifying who is going to fill these out?

SPEAKER_00You know, is it anyone that just happens to get the request? Is it a operator? If it's a municipality, is it the public works director, the water supervisor? Are any elected officials going to be asked to participate in this? I just, over the years, seen a lot of plans that come back and they're an administrative assistant, fill them out. And so I just, that was, that was my first question.

SPEAKER_00I'll just go sequentially. So if somebody can address that question, I'll have a few more.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And so a very good question. And we have been thinking about that. We would like, you know, someone from the finance team of utilities, someone from the operations team, and of course, town management, the hardest thing is board involvement. And how do we, how do we require that? You know, we've, Tried to think about ideas, if you all have any. I mean, we've even thought, well, yeah, you could require a board member to sign off on the report or something,

SPEAKER_03but even that doesn't necessarily ensure that they're involved in the process of making it. But we're open to suggestions, but we have the same feelings. We need full engagement of all the aspects of that utility, including

SPEAKER_00the board. Well, couldn't you? But just jumping around, but couldn't you just require or maybe it is the idea is to require that these are approved by the board, that the governing board has to. Maybe that's just obvious and that you're already going to do that, but and then if there was a list of people that participated on the bottom of it and that was part of the board approval, then. You know, it gives a list, you know, so if there was a which team filled this out and it said Assistant, you know,

SPEAKER_00a council member, and that was in the report, and then all of that was approved by the board. Yeah, I would think a resolution from the board is going to need to be, you know, action taken, and I think some of the framework for that Looking back at what some of the towns and counties and vice versa have had to do for some of the requirements

SPEAKER_00for the merger and feasibility studies, that kind of gave some criteria where both boards had to basically affirm They're supporting that, you know, I think at a minimum, it should at least be the local board. And I like this line of thinking and I'll even throw out there.

SPEAKER_03We were thinking, yes, maybe there would be not only a board approval. Not only maybe signatures, but, you know, would it be worth asking that these be put on a website or something so that, again, trying to work on the sort of like follow through. Are these people going to be doing this? Are they going to be held accountable to follow the plan? That's one option we've considered.

SPEAKER_00Well, I think on that there's some language around advertising and public hearings for those types of actions. Similar to resolutions for Department of Commerce or for CDBG or anything like that. I mean, there's some advertising and public hearing requirements because residents may come and completely disagree with that and then that board vote that down and vice versa.

SPEAKER_00The public may want these things implemented and want them corrected and the board doesn't for the fear of What it does from a political standpoint. No, that's all helpful for that question, so I can keep going. And I apologize, I'm at the airport, so every once in a while there's an announcement that comes on. But no, that's all along. I mean, I like all those ideas and the idea of them having to Put it on their website.

SPEAKER_00I mean, in theory, once it was a resolution, it's a public document that should be accessible. But the other thing was, is it too early to just plan that SWEA will make all of these, a link to all of these public so that there's just a lot more transparency? I mean, I don't know of any state statute that would make Any of this stuff, private information, or, you know, or not public information.

SPEAKER_00So that's just a side thought. You don't have to answer it. But I have some other questions.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we can definitely check in with counsel on that. I don't personally, I don't think there is anything that will prevent us from posting all the approved action plans that have been submitted to us. But All right, interesting concept. And all of this is about accountability, it sounds like.

SPEAKER_00It's to get

SPEAKER_02the governing boards to see it, to approve it,

SPEAKER_00to post it

SPEAKER_02online, to have public hearings if they need to have public hearings, and for us to post it so that it's public and it's available for anybody to see. And it holds not just this current governing boards, but future governing boards to the action plan. You need to continue to implement what's been Yeah. Go ahead. Sorry.

SPEAKER_03I was going to say, adding on to that concept, we would really like this to be a document that then gets shared across programs. So like LGC has access to this information, just like we would appreciate our interactions with LGC's data. And then even our TA providers, if they have these documents available,

SPEAKER_00I would just suggest maybe because we all seem to be coming from the same concern about this being a plan that doesn't end up with anything is to make part of our goal in it that these are very transparent. There's mechanisms for accountability. That units will be expected to be accountable.

SPEAKER_00You know, and I know we don't statutorily have, you know, you can't punish someone, but there's nothing that's saying that we can't, you know, have a staff member call, you know, or email everybody or robo-email everybody every six months and just have them respond that, you know, what have they done or just simple ways like that. So it just seems that we put that up top. It might, it might help us all kind of keep going with that. And I, and I admit I, at this point in my career, you know,

SPEAKER_00the number of plans I've worked on, reviewed, and I just, it's an, it's an art. We have to be really creative to figure out a way of taking just a statutory required plan and actually having it do stuff. I mean, I think the momentum is the opposite. Just sadly, you know, people prepare plans and, uh, So, you know, with that plan, you know, my, again, a little bit of cynicism or skepticism, I should say, about plans.

SPEAKER_00How do these plans, or are they perceived to relate to other required plans by rules? So, you know, I think, and it's been a while since I've been involved with these, so maybe these aren't even a thing anymore, but the water system management plan was a thing. Where if people were constructing or altering community water systems, they had to actually prepare something called a water system management plan.

SPEAKER_00Then there's the sanitary surveys where DEQ is going out and actually, I don't know if they have a report on those. And then there's the collection system permit have a requirement for It might be a CIP or a finance. It's some plan. And I know some of these are a subset of these units, like the collection permit plan or part of the collection permit.

SPEAKER_00That plan, I think, is only required for people above a certain size or have a collection system permit. So anyway, are any of those plans still around? And what's the idea of maybe connecting some of those?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, those plans are still around. And that's I think what Tim was alluding to in terms of there are lots of tools, quote unquote, tools out there. Those are some of those tools that we would be referring the systems to use as part of the viability plan. But Tim, if you want to add to that, that'd be helpful.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, 100%. We'd like to make them at least aware of, say, their local water supply plan and the information in there and all these different reports you're talking about. So We intend to at least have either references or have them indicate that they have a current one, et cetera.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, very good point. Yeah, and just where we are with technology, I know for a long time, especially state government was not always high in line of doing really good databases, but I always thought DEQ was beyond a lot of the other state departments, but it just seems like, yeah, there's an... You should be able to just do everything through links. I mean, if they have a document that has been submitted, you know, somebody could just pull up the local government name

SPEAKER_00and then the different plans would pop up. And I know Shadi's very used to me saying something is easy and it's not because that was my whole relationship with Shadi. But anyway, I just think, you know, the more we can use technology to kind of Connect all those so somebody could see that they've done those. The last question I have is kind of a selfish question from where I was

SPEAKER_00for six years, is I know all the statutes call local government unit, local government unit, but just as a public health, as a DEQ commitment to water customers, I can tell you for sure the utility commission and public staff, they're interested in some of this, but they don't have any statutes that get anywhere close to any of this. You know, now that Chuck Junis has left, Shadi,

SPEAKER_00I don't know who's leading the charge of some of this thing. So, you know, I know Jeff Foley, you're not even really involved in that, but the DEQ folks, is there any thought to like, Rolling this out as voluntary or kind of connecting to, you know, I just looked at the website. I think there are still about 90 small water systems that are commission regulated. And my guess would be that 50 of them are non-viable just from a common sense standpoint.

SPEAKER_00So anyway, I'll get off my soapbox there. Having dealt with those systems in my previous life, I'd love to see something that could be connected to that.

SPEAKER_02Jeff, I think that's an excellent question, but I would say that's for later. Right now, the statute's definitely specifically on addressing local government units, designate them as a trust, and figure out the program for them first. So the purview of us and SWEA right now is only local governments, but the idea to make this a Optional thing for other systems as well. There'll be a lot of great material out here. If anybody wants to voluntarily use it, they're welcome to. I don't think that we would be following up with them to the level that we would do

SPEAKER_02with the local governments. If they're designated distressed, we're going to be checking up on them, making sure that they're submitting these documents, they're meeting all the requirements. We wouldn't necessarily do that. DWI, DEQ wouldn't necessarily be doing that for other systems that don't have to do it under statute, but they're choosing to do it. They can do it, they can, they can use the materials. But to pull them into the program as well, I think goes beyond what we are authorized to do. And I think it would require a little bit more discussion. But right now, let's get, let's focus on the local government units, I think,

SPEAKER_02and get that program running for that first.

SPEAKER_00No, I didn't mean that we, because the metrics would all be different. Yeah, so I didn't mean that. But is there still that, is there still that committee, Shadi, that Just the Ad Hoc Task Force between the Utility Commission and DEQ. Have they met at all or do they still meet?

SPEAKER_02We'll be on and off. It's been a while. We'll probably be following up with the Utilities Commission staff for other reasons and we can talk about this as well because I know that would be of interest to them as well.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that's all I would. I clearly understand that it's local government units and that's our marching order. Go ahead.

SPEAKER_00I mean, given my diatribe, I would certainly say yes, but they can apply for the SWEA funds now. So anyway, I just thought of that after we said it there. I don't, you know, anyway, if it's just, but that might be a really easy thing.

SPEAKER_00I don't know what Shadi thinks about that is to just, just put somebody on the utility commission on that focus group just as a non-voting, you know, ad hoc person or something. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I think it would probably be good to include somebody from public staff. Okay. I don't see any Jeff, you still have your hand up. Did you have another? I think you said you had a couple of thoughts or no, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I think I had three and I got them out.

SPEAKER_01Thanks.

SPEAKER_02So going back to this, again, first bullet point, which I think is most important for today's discussion is the concepts, the presentation Tim provided in the conceptual framework for the law-term viability plan, which involves Quoting them to resources that they already have, giving them a companion document that provides a lot of references and resources and materials, and a guidance document, which is more like a workbook to ask them questions. Some of them are open-ended questions without the specific timeline or specific,

SPEAKER_02we need an X exactly. Some are open-ended, some are kind of specific questions, but they're a list of questions. And then local government takes those questions and using the guidance document as a workbook, Fill it out and create an action or an action plan, a viability plan, complete a deliverable form for us. But now we're also talking about taking it to the governing boards to get approval of that plan as well, to submit it, to post it, et cetera. Overall, does that cover what we as a committee think in terms

SPEAKER_02of the statutory requirements that local governments designated as distressed must develop an action plan that must take into consideration A short and long-term plan for infrastructure repair and maintenance managements, continuing education, long-term financial managements to ensure that the systems can generate sufficient revenue and any other matters identified by the authority and local government commission.

SPEAKER_00Does this concept work? Sounds good to me. I feel like that.

SPEAKER_02Okay. Great. I'm hearing positive notes on that. Tim, what other main questions do you want to ask the committee?

SPEAKER_03So we'll still, I mean, still got 20 plus minutes and we can leave it as an open discussion forum, but I'll just kind of go down some of this list because we do have some things we want to, you know, get your opinion on. But it's essentially an expansion of the previous question, but, you know, does this seem like it is aligned with the brand new draft of the master plan and the rest of the viability utility program?

SPEAKER_02I mean, I know my answer is yes, but

SPEAKER_03the rest of the committee

SPEAKER_02members.

SPEAKER_03And speak up if some of this doesn't work rather than having to say like yes or anything. The next one, Shadi kind of already alluded to, but again, rephrasing it, you know, is our concept meeting the intent of helping these units find their path towards viability? And that path towards viability, the definition includes

Any other concepts for the focus group?

SPEAKER_03I think we will talk to someone at public staff over at the commission, but any other ideas for perspective that we need on this? Okay, Rosemary, if you could go ahead. The purpose and goals that we kind of set up, not that they're so exacting, but are there any that we didn't identify? Are there glaring absences that anyone can think of?

SPEAKER_03And our intent is that these units can produce them themselves. Some units will need a good bit of assistance possibly from our bio-utility staff, Steve McLaughlin, These managers and also the team riders. I mean, we see rural water. Steve McLaughlin, League of municipalities is also being able to help them cruise these documents. Does this seem feasible that with help pretty much all of our units can produce things.

SPEAKER_00If you keep to the goal of making it simple and having forms and all that, that seems like it's going to be possible. I think you could easily branch off into questions that would require looking at data that they don't have or things like that. But I think that it should be They should feed into each other. So once you have it down, then when you do your pilot testing, you know,

SPEAKER_00when the pilot testing is to, you know, see how easy it was for them to fill out, you know, especially if you do a pilot, I call it pilot test, but I think you called it trial run. Pick some really low capacity systems that you think. That's one of the things I would suggest that we test. Yeah. Perfect. I think this works for getting a plan, getting them viable again.

SPEAKER_00I think we have that whole issue of statute only says, you know, do a plan. But I don't know if there's anything we can do about that other than some of the things you've already mentioned.

SPEAKER_03Go ahead.

SPEAKER_03Additional detail if they need it. Asked okay in the rosemary?

SPEAKER_02Actually, I want to ask a question on that too. So the guidance document questions list a lot of questions. Have we thought about how, what would we do if the viability plan that we receive from the local government has basically one word or one sentence answers to some of these questions? At what level Do we or does the authority need to review these plans and approve them and say this is sufficient? Yeah.

SPEAKER_02How do we, how does that get looked at?

SPEAKER_03Rosemary, can you advance this slide one? No, it's a perfectly legitimate question. That's, we would love input on this because, you know, our thought is. Oh, sorry. That's right.

SPEAKER_03We are thinking that they didn't do either of those is something that we need to work on while we're developing the actual questions and our review procedures. But I think it is a very different review than typical.

SPEAKER_02So this is like the case manager would basically be doing along the way reviewing as not just don't wait for the final deliverable, along the way kind of seeing what they're working towards, providing some input and feedback so that way the local government can continue to refine and Add more into what they need to do to make it up what we're expecting to see. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And one of our thoughts is that we could have, say, you know, like parts of our They provide consistency among all the units, and then the different people who bring in their units that they're working with,

SPEAKER_03something along those lines. Okay.

SPEAKER_02Well, and I'm wondering now for the committee members, if you all think that, is it SWIA's role? I mean, in statute, it's not SWIA's role to approve the action plans, just to make sure that they actually create one. I don't know that you would want to see and review and approve every one of those, but I just wanted to run that by the committee members.

SPEAKER_00You're right, the statute, going back to your first question, what if they said, no changes, that's our action plan.

SPEAKER_01Okay, at that moment, they're off. They're no longer a viable utility, and I think we need to go back. That's what you want to do? You're not, I mean, I know Shadi didn't like the example.

SPEAKER_00All right, well, don't be looking for SRF or something like that. But you're right that the statute doesn't say what to do with the plans.

SPEAKER_02Well, but I think Tim's what Tim was describing to me would work where SWEA is coming up with a concept and SWEA you are the committee right now SWEA later on would say we want to make sure that the action that the viability plans that come out of this process is a good feasible plan that's an achievable plan and that will address Whatever the issues are that makes the system not viable or potentially not viable. So then it comes to our staff that has to review that and to say,

SPEAKER_02this is sufficient, this would work. And if it's not, then it doesn't meet SWEA's criteria. So it doesn't actually meet the statutory requirements of the international plan. But Vic, go ahead.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, what I'd like to propose is that we treat it similar to the AIA rate study process, where staff review these as, did you meet the requirements that have been handed down from SWEA for these documents? And then now they have a collection of documents that they've created.

SPEAKER_03I think that's separate, and I think we could keep the approval of the long-term viability plan, just like we sort of approve of the rate study or approve of the AIA document.

SPEAKER_00Does that sound good for committee members? It sounds good to me. I'm still unclear, you know, that the fine line between we can't approve it, we're reviewing it as far as helping them do it, or do we ever have to have anything that says that their plan followed our criteria? Because that seems like approving it,

SPEAKER_00borrow something that we did with the Utility Commission and we acknowledge things. You know, we wait until they do it and then we acknowledge that this is good for planning purposes. I'm just a little confused because, you know, there's this criteria that we say whether they do it or not, but that's not approving it. And I do like the idea of having staff review it from a standpoint of let us help you.

SPEAKER_00You know, we're here to help you and what you've said here. You know, it's going to require a lot more money, you know, or something like that. I don't know.

SPEAKER_02So, I mean, what Tim was saying is that we would treat this just like we're doing the asset inventories, sorry, asset assessments and the rate studies. Yeah, I don't know how those are done, so that was... Yeah, so, yeah, so Jeff uses to do this. SWE has come up with the concepts, the framework. These are the things that we want to see that every asset assessment or every rate study needs to include. There's a particular framework. And then SWE has already approved that concept, the framework.

SPEAKER_02And here are the things that need to be included in the asset assessments and the rate studies. LTC has done the same thing. And that's it. And then the division staff now review the documents that come into us, the asset inventories, assessments, and the rate studies. And if there's a piece that's missing from what SWIA has said it needs to be included, we go back to them and say, you need to address this. So we're constantly reviewing to make sure it addresses all the things that are in the framework that were approved by SWIA. And when it looks sufficient and complete, Then staff can say, all right,

SPEAKER_02you've met all of SWEA's requirements. So that's done, that's complete. The idea would be to do something very similar with the viability plans. I'm looking to Tim for any visual cues. Everything I just said sounds about it. So that's basically how it's done, Jeff. And I think it's just, it would be on staffs, whether it's individual or a committee of three people, kind of their opinion, whether or not what they see in front of them is complete, it's sufficient, it meets Okay, so

SPEAKER_00yeah, I get it now. So we're not, we could think that something they wrote was ridiculous. And I mean, I'm saying this seriously, that we could see something that they said that they were going to do that we knew was unlikely. And we might be prone to saying, you know, no, we're not going to accept that. But if it's, If it's part of their goal, then it would still fit in. So that's like the difference between us actually accepting it

SPEAKER_00and then staff just acknowledging it that it's process. Is that like a fair difference? And we don't have the ability to actually go in and say, you know, this part's unreasonable, you know, like the LGC would, you know, accepting or rejecting an application based on I

SPEAKER_02mean, to me, if a local government submits something that it does not look feasible in any way, it's not going to help them towards viability, and we can easily see that, it does not meet criteria 159G45B3D, which is the development action plan that addresses any matters identified by the authority of local government commission. The authority clearly is saying, we want to see an action plan that addresses the viability issues and concerns. And if we receive something that does not do that, it doesn't meet that statutory requirement.

SPEAKER_02So we would reject it and would say, you need to come back to us and do it again. So I think we have some authority, Jeff, to be able to keep working with the local government until they come to a good plan. But they may come up with a plan that surprises us. And then we have some conversations with them and understand it. And if that plan actually works, great. And if it doesn't, then we'll have to have conversations and see if we can find common grounds.

SPEAKER_03One thing we have all identified on our team is that we don't want to be endorsing that this is your path towards viability and you'll be successful if you execute it either. That's not necessarily our purview. So if that helps, I think we'll work to structure the acceptance or whatever appropriate thing.

SPEAKER_02Acknowledge that they've completed the action plan according to SWIA's and LGC's guidance.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was my exact, that was my exact, and it wasn't a concern just as, just to understand that is how it's going to work, you know, which is, which seems to follow the statutes, you know, whereas if we said, you know, proved us, you know, real regionalization is going to work because you've tried real regionalization, you know, five times in the past or something, you know, something like that, then that's beyond, that's clearly beyond the purview of this particular. Exercise. Yep.

SPEAKER_00Okay. When these action plans start coming in, are we going to be giving staff recommendations like we do for awarding these projects? Because if we look at, it seems like, Item D, any matters identified by the authority, if we had staff recommendations that these were sufficient, the authority has the ability to approve those long-term plans.

SPEAKER_00And then if anything comes back and staff makes recommendations on things like, hey, this group is not complete and here's what we found based on what they submitted. At that point, I read that as the authority has that ability to Identify those matters. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I think it's part of what we want to discuss today. I would say, again, if we're treating this similar to how we're addressing the asset assessments and the rate studies, those are not coming to your authority every single time for your, for authorities approval. We, the staff already have the guiding principles that SWEA has approved. Similar to the viability plan, we would know exactly what, staff know exactly what is expected of these viability plans. So staff would be able to review and say, yep, everything looks complete.

SPEAKER_02We acknowledge that you've completed your action plan in accordance with SWIA's guidance. I would say that potentially what might come to SWIA is if there are some uncertainty about some plans and the staff wants to bring, all right, here's what we received from this particular town. These are the things that look straightforward and easy, but these are the things that we are, we're not sure how to address this. Swia, do you have any additional things that you want to see in this action plan? So maybe the one-off ones that needs a little bit more guidance from the authority

SPEAKER_02to identify what those other matters identified by the authority. So those may come to the authority, but not necessarily every single one of the Viablee plans. Reactions to that, Corey?

SPEAKER_00Does that sound Yeah, that's what I was thinking. The problematic ones, we should be made aware of those, discuss, figure out, help with guidance to the staff and to the entity on what we feel like is sufficient for them. Okay. Thank you.

SPEAKER_03And then... Last few questions are simply, we've brought them up already, but should there be any effort to address follow through implementation of these with the units? Currently, our thought is that at least four So, I'm going to ask you a question.

SPEAKER_03I'm going to ask you a question. You know, if there are any thoughts on information we'll be getting in, what of it,

SPEAKER_03we might make it all public and so everyone can digest this information, but what of it would be useful in helping to guide our program, DWI funding, and it's almost like a carry on from the last question, you know, what do we want to do with all this information we get in? Are there any suggestions?

SPEAKER_00That's the end of my I'm intrigued by the open-ended question about why you aren't viable. If somebody says, we're not viable because our population is growing down 15% a year, and we have no economic abilities, and we lost our largest industry, and I'm I don't know what happens if they say something like that.

SPEAKER_00And it could be staff say that, but then that might be a little touchy for the board to prove. That first question where they're sort of doing it, if I got it right, they're kind of doing a self-diagnosis. They might be saying in that thing that the reason that they're not viable are all these reasons that they can't control. And then the rest of the plan they're talking about What they can do to become viable. It just seems like, seems like actually the truth of what we're faced in North Carolina.

SPEAKER_00But I, you know, I don't know if we care about that, but that's something I'm interested in.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that self-assessment's important, even if it is things that are outside of their control. But there might be some solution to some things. It might not be loss of population. Well, maybe regionalization is an option. There are ways they can maybe address some of those things that are not really directly under control, but they can indirectly try to help their system stay viable or become viable. So I think that self-reflection and self-assessment might be illuminating for some

SPEAKER_02of the local governments.

SPEAKER_00I think it'd be super interesting. That question to me really is really interesting.

SPEAKER_02And Matthew Rushing is in the room here. He's got something to add as well.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, Jeff, to your question, I think from our experience, most of the 160 currently distressed systems, it was not one thing nor one acute thing that occurred that put him in that situation. So I think that's where I like your thought of the acknowledgement that the plan is complete because we're not saying, oh, you now have sole control over all of these little aspects that will get you viable.

SPEAKER_00But it's like you said, that self-reflection of here's what was outside of our control, but it wasn't just one thing outside of our control that put us in this spot. It's all these other things that Kind of either cascaded from maybe it was a one-off event, but really it's an accumulation of not reinvesting is ultimately what it comes down to. So I think it'll be a little more clear when something is feasible, because again,

SPEAKER_00it'll be more of that collective, all the things they've had to deal with, but have not, and hopefully trying to turn that corner to some extent. And I think the reality that I'm picking up here is that that corner may be very slow to turn and round, but if we're making a little progress, however little, but progress is progress,

SPEAKER_00how high is the bar for what would be acceptable? I think that's really where we're trying to start getting into with the long-term plan, as Tim has been talking about.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, Chris has got a question as well, and then I need to take on the action item.

SPEAKER_00So on that note, I was just wondering right now how we have drafted the question. It seems to point towards what led you to be designated as distressed originally. And one of my questions is, do you think, do we think that units might interpret, some of our units may interpret that narrowly in terms of what led us to originally

SPEAKER_02Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp,

SPEAKER_00Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp,

SPEAKER_02Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp, Stapp

SPEAKER_00Dealing with more broadly at this time that they're trying to resolve the new long-term viability plan. So somebody's not just thinking about it narrowly.

SPEAKER_02Just not, not just the numbers and the metrics, but also like broader picture. So maybe that could be part of the guidance, the document, the guidance document question that, that question can be reworded to add, like just think big picture, not necessarily just what's on your metrics, your assessment score. I think that's a good one. All right. Um, In the interest of time for the agenda for today, we do need to start moving on to the next agenda. But before we do that, we do have a SAF recommendation, if you'd mind going to the next slide, please.

SPEAKER_02Is it on the next slide? Yep. So if the committee members, if you all have any additional thoughts right now for the viability plan, what you would like to see changed or added or amended, now is the time to mention it. Otherwise, Tim, you can go ahead and read what the recommendation is. Okay. Okay.

SPEAKER_03Uh, staff recommends approval of the conceptual framework of the LTVP process as presented to serve as a basis for the action plan required under NCGS 159G 45 , and present the conceptual framework of the LTVP process to the full authority for review.

SPEAKER_02So moved. All right. Jeff Pulley moves. We have a second. Jeff Hughes, seconds. Thank you. Any discussion or anything else that you want to see change or difference in the concept, the framework? Sorry. Okay. I'm not seeing any discussion. So we'll go ahead and take votes. Corey, your vote. Aye. Thank you. And then Jeff, your vote as well. Aye. Thank you. All right. Thank you.

SPEAKER_02We appreciate that. Thank you, Tim, for the presentation and for everybody's thoughts that went into this. I know it's been a long time, long process to get to here. This will now be presented at the SWEA meeting on December 9th. And if the authority then approves it, then we'll talk to Jeff Boley and the LGC about getting it in front of the LGC as well. Because I think this is one that LGC also has to approve. Is that right?

SPEAKER_00Actually, I'm not. I don't know if we technically have to approve it. You're right. We're just way in,

SPEAKER_02but we can figure that out. Yeah, you're right, Jeff. I think we'll, unlike the other ones that mentioned specifically LDC doesn't, but we'll follow up Jeff on that. All right. Thank you. So next agenda item is information item, but probably going to generate some discussion is the process of de-designating systems. So they're being designated as a The stress utilities and how do we get them

SPEAKER_02to be de-designated and the statutes don't make it clear except that they just need to complete all of the requirements under the viable utility statutes. Vic DiMato is going to present a concept, an idea, and we'd like to get some thoughts on what you all think is appropriate. Vic, go ahead.

SPEAKER_01Awesome. Yeah. Hey, thanks everyone. And good afternoon, guys. Appreciate all the good discussion. Shadi kind of jumped the gun there with the punchline over the ambiguity in the statute, but that's okay. We're kind of used to that. This does overlap a lot with, of course, Tim's discussion on the long term viability plan because that's kind of the last piece of the program that we need to You know,

SPEAKER_01formalize before we have the ability to have an off-ramp, before we have the ability for LGUs to actually meet the statutory requirements. So, Rosemary, next slide, please. Yeah, so again, just my presentation is brief. We'll have this background slide as well as a few slides to outline the ideas we thought for what the process might look like.

SPEAKER_01We want your input on that. Much like Tim's presentation, we had some specific questions for the committee about several of the elements that are in the draft process. And then we will want to get some guidance from you all So we're not asking for any approval today, just your ideas so that we can kind of go back and come back, I guess, with a more formal idea for broader consideration.

SPEAKER_01So again, we're 159G45 is where a lot of our viable utilities program stuff resides. Among other things that you've already heard, 159G45 authorizes SWEA and the LGC to determine criteria or develop criteria to determine how LGUs should be assessed and to identify distressed units.

SPEAKER_01So clearly, you know, that identification process, what we call designation, is a joint SWEA-LGC formal process. As we've heard already, C of that statute states that once an identified distressed unit has completed all of the requirements, that unit shall no longer be identified as a distressed unit for the remainder of that assessment and review cycle. So there's a few things in there that are noteworthy, I guess.

SPEAKER_01One is that it's very big and it's not There doesn't appear to have been envisioned a formal process, however, and there's really no, unlike with A and B, where, you know, SWE and LGC were given that responsibility to create a process that is not intentionally or, you know, Clearly stated as it relates to de-designation,

SPEAKER_01just kind of statute kind of trails off, if you will. So, you know, there are some big questions there. You guys have started talking about what does SWIA and LGC really have to approve? And I kind of want to defer to, you know, the chair and the board or this group, at least, you know, to help us figure out what the best approach would be there, what that might look like. So yeah, that's really what we're talking about today and is really what is that process right now.

SPEAKER_01We have no off-ramp. We have 160 distressed local government units. That number has gone up and down a little bit, but it only goes down if a unit dissolves or is no longer a unit. So we want to have a way to really get units off and hopefully get them on the right track to You know, not coming right back and doing what so many of us do when we get off at the wrong exit. You know, we do the cloverleaf and get right back on. We don't want that to happen.

SPEAKER_01And hopefully the long-term viability plan is a guiding document in that direction. But let's go on to the next slide, please. So here is, and this process is not each number, each number is not necessarily a step. Or at least a step that DWI takes, for example. First step is really the LGU completing those statutory requirements. And I just put in here for your reference that we do have, you know, standards,

SPEAKER_01minimum standards. We touched on that a little bit for The other statutory requirements, asset assessment, rate study, training, and education that have been approved by LGC and SWEA. And now we're up to the action plan piece, which of course, Tim just gave a great overview of our work on that. So once that is done, or not necessarily, you know, not necessarily sequentially either, as we talked about earlier, People or LGUs could start working on a long-term viability plan from day one,

SPEAKER_01really. There's a lot of that background kind of understanding of the system. So please don't get hung up on ordering here too much. But basic idea here is that, and we did talk about this a little bit in the last piece, is that the case managers, and that's in our unit, We have a number of people, and we all wear multiple hats, as you guys could probably imagine. But what we call, when we say case manager, what we mean is an individual or sometimes, you know,

SPEAKER_01there's sort of like a tag team, if you will, that works directly with the LGU that is distressed on, you know, kind of on their journey through the viable utilities program. And that can, you know, that is, it's very, we try to be very responsive. It's not an equal service. Amount of, you know, of support that we provide to each unit. It kind of depends on who needs the support and, you know, who doesn't and who's engaged and who isn't.

SPEAKER_01So, yeah, so that's what a case manager is. So case managers should be working with the LGU all along and getting them, you know, getting them to do their AIA and to understand their AIA. To think about the right study and, of course, to work on their plans, their viability plans and their roadmap to viability. The way we kind of envisioned this is, you know, again, that kind of determination as to, yeah, these guys have done everything in accordance, you know, all the boxes are checked.

SPEAKER_01We want that to stay with the case manager. They're going to be working most closely with the LGU. And then what we've kind of conceived, and I don't want to get too into the weeds here, but when we do application reviews, we have what's called a consensus meetings where maybe one or two people will review an application and then take it to a broader group. They kind of lay the case out for why they scored the application a certain way. We kind of see that as a really good model for approving or vetting

SPEAKER_01a de-designation, potential de-designation. So what we would see is the case manager or managers coming to a standing group internal. This would be DWI and or viable utilities program. To, you know, review the case, kind of go through that checklist, see if there are concerns, comments that could go back to there. Perhaps this could be somewhat of an iterative process, but you know,

SPEAKER_01the hope is that it's We don't have to assemble this group multiple times for the same case. Hopefully we get to a place where we understand and we have the guidance where we understand what is expected. And by the time it comes before that group, it's hopefully pretty close to being ready for full consideration. So next slide, please. So that full consideration is really looping in LGC. And Jeff, this is where certainly we value your input and that of your staff.

SPEAKER_01But on the other hand, we don't want to burden you. We don't want to come to you guys too soon, especially when some of the issues that we're grappling with may be outside of your wheelhouse. So our thought is that we kind of, as a DWI, feel good about it, and then we Reach out and or, you know, in some forum which we can discuss, you know, whether it's regular meetings or ad hoc meetings. Of course, we have our, you know, monthly coordination meetings could be part of that.

SPEAKER_01Whatever the case is, we would loop in LGC and get the same kind of feedback, same kind of hopefully buy in that, yes, these guys have done what they need to do. They've got a path. Let's, you know, let's consider new designation or bring it to the boards.

SPEAKER_02And Vic, just to point out, just to make it clear, number three doesn't mean that we're asking LGC staff to review all the things that we said that the DWI is reviewing. It's more of a, DWI has checked everything, looks like they're ready for the designation, but let's just check with the LGC staff in case there's something we don't know that's happening with that local government that the LGC staff might want to like say, hey, we need to consider this, we need to consider this, but they're not ready because of this. But not necessarily to review all the things that we're saying we're reviewing. Is that what we're talking about?

SPEAKER_01I think we'd be flexible about that, depending on how deep LGC wanted to plug in. I think one thing you said, Shadi, that I think is important to note is that we may approve, quote unquote, approve a de-designation for referral to the boards, but still have some concerns and say, these guys are great, but we have a concern about this. We want to make sure we document those concerns and some of You know,

SPEAKER_01LGC staff may have certain financial concerns, as well as the boards, and those are things that we can kind of carry forward as part of their status, if you will, moving forward, which may pop up as a term and condition in future funding, for example, especially if we're looking at VUR funding. But yeah, so great point, Shadi, thank you. And then So once that is actually okay, yeah. So then once agreement is reached, it's all kind of captured there in number three.

SPEAKER_01Number three covers a lot. Our initial thought is that we would refer cases for de-designation annually at the December SWEA meeting because that is the meeting where we're going to be doing our new, if we have any new designations, basically the results of our annual assessments. And then, you know, assuming that, you know, the ones that are brought before SWEA are approved, then they would be considered by the LGC at their subsequent meeting,

SPEAKER_01most likely January. So that would then, you know, that's the formal process. And that's kind of, okay, now they're de-designated. So then there's still a couple pieces here that I think are really important, maybe even more, you know, Tricky and sticky than the actual de-designation consideration itself. One is, you know, we've talked about this a little in the last discussion, but like implementation of the long-term viability plan,

SPEAKER_01since that is really brings all of these pieces together and is kind of like their roadmap, you know, what do we do about that? And what do we do about funding? So I know you guys... Maybe everyone on the group here has not been around for the entirety of the program, but the eligibility for BUR grants right now is somewhat limited, but that sort of criteria for what can be funded out of the BUR,

SPEAKER_01some of it's statutory, and that's really related to You know, making sure it goes to a local government unit or a COG, which is possible for managing those funds for the VUR. But then also, what was I going to say there? I forget, I'm losing it there.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. So the statute talks about the kinds of projects that could be funded and eligible recipients, but we in the LGC have really determined who specifically, meaning distressed units or at least maybe merger projects that help a distressed unit. So this kind of falls under that award And one of the responsibility that SWEA and the LGC have

SPEAKER_01for VUR grants is what do we do once a unit is de-designated knowing that most likely their long-term viability plan is going to be reliant on funding from the VUR ideally. Again, the kind of point that I made earlier is the lack of funds in the VUR and the lack of sort of confidence And, you know, knowing what's going to be available is a big kind of side issue.

SPEAKER_01But even assuming that that wasn't an issue, what would we want to say? I mean, I think we agree internally that we would want to allow units that have been de-designated to still access their eligible VUR funds. And just as a reminder, that's up to 15 million per unit lifetime. But again, like we would want Projects that are funded to possibly be, you know, or to be a priority on their capital improvement plans and coming out

SPEAKER_01of their long-term viability plans. So thinking about, you know, what does the funding availability look like and how do we kind of create a process around that I think is a decision that, you know, the SWEA and LGC needs to weigh in on. So think about that. And then we thought about, you know, how do we, Again, we don't want people doing the cloverleaf and just getting right back into the program. So how do we compel units to stay on track?

SPEAKER_01We did want to offer at least annual check-in on the long-term viability plan for units that request that assistance. We certainly would have, I think, a short list of units where we're like, these guys will definitely need us by their side. Um, that we will, you know, we'll, we'll want to put more resources into, um, and it's possible that, you know, that could be a requirement, you know, for certain units. But, um, again, we don't necessarily have a good compliance mechanism there,

SPEAKER_01a way to require it. However, we do have the BUR. So to be able to retain access to those funds, you know, it might require for certain units some kind of, um, You know, more formal check-in or, you know, assessment of their progress versus the long-term viability plan. So, next slide. I know we're running low here and won't have a lot of time for discussion. We also thought about, you know, what do we do about annual assessments for de-designated units,

SPEAKER_01knowing that in a lot of cases, their numbers and their assessment score are not going to rebound quickly. And in some cases, they may not rebound To non-distressed status for quite a while. And the number is what it is. It's a tool, but it's not the be all end all. It doesn't mean anything besides what we've made it mean. So we've certainly thought about having some kind of grace period or other metrics,

SPEAKER_01other ways to measure The progress, let's say, or the improvement of that distressed unit or formerly distressed unit, and that could be tied to the long-term viability plan and metrics established there, which I like. It can also be sort of a combination of that with their assessment criteria scores. So thinking about what that grace period looks like, how long it is, et cetera, is something we would like you all to weigh in on. And then we've also thought about, you know, as we look at the units in the program,

SPEAKER_01we know we have some that are clearly distressed, need the help, all the help they can get. And then we've got some that are like, they don't really seem like they should be in here. A lot of times before Jeff came on to the LGC, the first few years of the program, the LGC automatically designated any unit that was two or more, I guess I'm going to synopsize it by saying two or more years late in their annual audits, which pulled in a lot of folks,

SPEAKER_01especially kind of COVID times when this was starting up. So one idea we had to sort of have, you know, To lessen the burden, quite frankly, for us and for them is to, for those units that have been designated based on noncompliance with their audit report requirements, is to, when they catch up, go back and essentially redo those analyses and see where they are. If they score, continue to score above the threshold,

SPEAKER_01meaning they score as distressed, then we would You know, keep them in the program and they would still have to do their statutory requirements. But if they are not scoring or if they're scoring below the threshold, then we would just de-designate them as is, essentially. The one trick there would be if we de-designate them, then they're, you know, without a long-term viability plan, capital improvement plan, you know, compliant with that, then they wouldn't be eligible for future funding from the BUR.

SPEAKER_02So Vic, before we move on to the next slides, I just want to point out a correction on the slide that we need to make. Number six is to say potential fast recognition for the two units that have two years of audits missing, not other LGC control. So we just need to correct that on the slide.

SPEAKER_01Yep. So we can move on. Those were our ideas for a process. Granted, a lot of details to be filled out there, but wanted to get your initial thoughts on that. And then we've got basically four main questions, most of which I've already touched on to some extent. Maybe I'll just pause here, especially since we've only got a couple of minutes. And see if you guys have any questions or immediate thoughts and Shadi as chair,

SPEAKER_01please, you know, change direction if you want to. But yeah, if you guys have any immediate thoughts, if not, we can just kind of zip through briefly in the last few minutes and ponder them for the next time we meet.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I do want to get just initial reactions to the overall plan that Correct. I agree with you.

SPEAKER_02Any questions or reactions from Jeff Hughes or Corey or we can talk

SPEAKER_00about specific questions. Nothing as dramatic as Jeff.

SPEAKER_02All right. Then let's start with that first question. And I would, I mean, I have a thought on that already, which even though the statute doesn't specifically say the LDC and LDC, SWE and LDC get to de-designate systems, it just says, SWE and LDC designate systems, and then they need to complete, the local government needs to complete all the requirements that they're automatically de-designated. I would say that SWE and LDC have the requirements and the authority to identify

SPEAKER_02the systems that are designated, which to me is a continuous requirement. So I do think that bringing the list of systems that have completed the requirements and they're ready for de-designation to the authority during the time of assessment, so that, you know, December, once a year, saying, all right, we've re-reviewed everybody, here are the ones that score a specific way, they may need to be designated, but here are also ones that have completed all the requirements. We don't think that you need to continue to identify them as distressed utilities.

SPEAKER_02So to me, my suggestion is that these would come to the authority at the time of the annual assessments. Just let everybody know these are the ones that have been completed requirements. We think they'll be de-designated. And at that time, SWEA and NOJC can voice if they want to continue to identify a system as designated as distressed for other reasons. They have that authority to do so. So that's just my suggestion. I wanted to see if there are reactions to that.

SPEAKER_00Sounds good to me.

SPEAKER_02Okay. Vic, was there anything else in number one that you want to specifically address or was there another question?

SPEAKER_01I think, yeah, I mean, the only, yeah, I mean, those three bullets are things to think about. It sounds like You know, what you proposed, Shadi, which I generally, I think I concur with that. Maybe think a little more, we don't have to decide this now, but think a little more about that second bullet. What would you all want to see? What would you want to hear from us? Would you just want to list and then ask questions? Or would you want us to actually kind of present, you know,

SPEAKER_01a little blurb or a few bullet points about each unit that we think is ready for de-designation? Um, what their plans are, you know, there's a, there's a broad, uh, spectrum of, of ways we can go with that, but don't really need, although Jeff, I see you took your mute off. Do you have something? Yeah, uh, I think again, this can work itself out. I'm just thinking the LGC will never de-designate until they're at full cost pricing.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Yeah, so the full cost pricing. Yeah, this came up yesterday in a chat we were having. Thanks, Jeff. Okay, well, let's keep going since we're pretty much at time here. The next piece, sorry, the next piece was about access to, thank you, just one more minute, to the eligibility limit for local governments. How do we want to manage that?

SPEAKER_01You know, that access to the BUR for units that have been designated again, considering that right now we don't even have any money. So it's really a tricky situation. I mean, most units that are in the program probably want to max out their $15 million eligibility limit. So, you know, how do we balance that stuff? And that's that's a really big question. So think about it and do Also note, again, that the statute does not restrict the award of BUR funds to distressed units.

SPEAKER_01The project types are statutorily referenced, but who among our group of LGUs, our master list of LGUs, actually receives the funding is not. That is really up to you guys.

SPEAKER_00Jeff? Yeah, I think the old adage that You know, it drives a lot of people crazy is that you get rewarded for being in bad shape. So I think this shows an important opposite of that. You know, we're not going to, as soon as you get into good shape, we're not going to penalize you. So I would be supportive of this. Cool.

SPEAKER_01Okay. You guys could go to the last slide here or next to last. Next slide. Okay. Yeah, and then the same question related to annual assessments and designation. And that I don't think is, Jeff, you still have your hand up. I don't know if that's intentional. But yeah, I don't think we need to spend time on that. That's not as big of a deal. It's a little more in the weeds. And then, I mean, I think number four is an important one.

SPEAKER_01But like, you know, considering some of the unique situations we have, every case is different. Are there other circumstances where we would want to think about, you know, something that deviates from the process and that may inform the process as it, you know, finally or eventually rolls out? Or it may just be, you know, cutouts for certain types of units like the D2 audit, late audit, not under LGC control units.

SPEAKER_01So any thoughts there?

SPEAKER_00Someone named Hope Taylor.

SPEAKER_02Well, let's continue the conversation with the committee members first before we take informal comments.

SPEAKER_01And Rosemary, you can just go to the next the last slide. And I'm sorry, guys, I know we're a minute over already, but I think we're we're there. Yeah. So, you know, our goals are to try to develop this. As you heard from Tim, we've got a lot of work to do on both of these things, but long term viability plan developments, you know, really fleshing that out is going to take And we think we could probably line things up so that we have both things for SWEA and LGC to consider at roughly the same time.

SPEAKER_01And what we really want from you guys is what do you think the next steps are? Should we go back and maybe circle back to some of these questions in a future BUC meeting? Should we bring it to full SWEA for their input or any other ideas you guys might have? And that's really all I

SPEAKER_02And I think that's, I want to end on that one too, because that is an important thing. Like what does the committee, we as committee wants to bring this back to a future agenda item and talk about it some more? Or do you feel like this can just go straight to SWEA, you know, come up with a proposal and just take it to SWEA? It was a lot of information to try to kind of do it in a half hour, half an hour today. As committee members, do you want more time to think through this, come back to talk about it as a committee?

SPEAKER_02Or do you think that we, as a committee, don't need to really discuss further?

SPEAKER_00I don't think we need to discuss it further. I think, again, once we get into these designations, we might figure out that Yeah, this isn't the best course, or it would work great, you know, but if we can address it at that time, I would think. But, you know, what was set out all makes sense. Okay.

SPEAKER_02So overall, proceed with this current plan, see how it works, we'll bring it The first time we will see this come up will probably be at the SWEA meeting when we are potentially de-designating some systems and we can have a conversation the first time around. I think we can have a good conversation about it then. Um, but no, no need for the committee to discuss further. Vic, does that, what do you think about that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we may want to think about, you know, giving SWEA a chance to, um, You know, provide, provide their thoughts at the broader SWEA before next December. But, but yeah, otherwise I think it sounds fine.

SPEAKER_02Okay. So you do a presentation on that information item again, um, in a future SWEA meeting, but

SPEAKER_01yeah, once, once we get, you know, some of the other ducks in a row, I think, you know, just give them a heads up on what's coming.

SPEAKER_02Corey and Jeff Hughes. Does that sound like a plan forwards? Yeah, I'm good for that.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Jeff Hughes? Yeah, there's an announcement going on, so I try to give a... Yeah, it's all good.

SPEAKER_02Okay. Thank you. And if you do have some thoughts, think about it and bring it up at the SWEA meeting. I'm not sure it will be scheduled. It's not going to be scheduled in December. We have too much on the SWEA meeting agenda already for December. It'll be likely sometime in 2027 to bring this to the authority. Any... Closing thoughts on this before we'll take, I will see if, and we're a little bit over. We did have one person raise their hand and lower their hand again. So I don't know if that's a comment that still needs to be made.

SPEAKER_02If you're still interested, hope in making a comment, raise your hand again so we know. But committee members, are there anything else that you want to add or say? Seeing nothing. And also, I don't even see Hope online anymore. So I think we are good. I don't think anybody had signed up for comments ahead of time. So with that, we're going to go ahead and conclude the meeting. Thank you to the Viable Utilities Program staff for putting together some thoughts

SPEAKER_02and ideas on this and moving the ball forwards. Thank you to the LTC staff as well. Jeff, your team is really great. We love the coordination that we do with you all as well. And committee members, thank you for your time and attention and your thoughts on this. And with that, we are adjourned.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. WATCH: Columbus Town Council Delays Polk YMCA Vote

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 13 minAudio

    Columbus delays Polk County Recreation Center review as residents debate costs Council members plan to vote on Dec. 17; residents also raised questions about a proposed $12 million county loan. By Annie Dance | Cops &...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. WATCH (EXCLUSIVE): Lake Lure adopts 2040 plan as rebuilding, utility costs mount

    Nov 20, 202624 minAudio

    Long-range guide will shape future land use and public investment; council also approves $195,125 utility project and winter restroom funding By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary Lake Lure’s Town Council...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. WATCH: Council of State approves prison deal at Tryon Palace meeting

    Nov 16, 202641 minAudio

    By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary North Carolina’s Council of State approved $18.85 million in prison energy financing Nov. 10, after questioning savings guarantees during a hybrid meeting repeatedly...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. LISTEN: Polk County recreation loan wins conditional state approval for YMCA

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 43 minAudio

    The $12 million borrowing advanced over the state auditor’s objection as commissioners questioned public support, development approvals and taxpayers’ future obligations. By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News &...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. WATCH: Outgoing Rutherford board leaves long-running growth plan to incoming commissioners

    Nov 14, 20261 hr 18 minAudio

    After two years of planning, commissioners schedule a Dec. 7 public hearing on advisory Rutherford 2040, leaving adoption to the next board. By Annie Dance | Cops & Congress | News & Commentary Rutherford County’s...

    Credit the people on this episode