Episode 30- November Recap: Retail Reality, EV "Peaks" & The Sentiment Gap
45 minAudio
In this month’s "What Just Happened" recap, Colin and Wheeler take a look back at November to make sense of the mixed signals in the economy. We start by breaking down the shift in retail season - why Black Friday deals feel different this year and how "sales season" has morphed into a month-long event. We also discuss the cooling auto market and ask a controversial question: Did "Peak EV" excitement actually happen back in 2015? The conversation then pivots to the biggest question on investors' minds: Is Artificial Intelligence a bubble waiting to burst? We analyze the data comparing today's market to the Dot-Com crash, looking specifically at how current S&P 500 earnings are actually moving in lockstep with valuations - suggesting we aren't seeing the "irrational exuberance" of the past. We also look at global market concentration to show that, despite the headlines, the U.S. market is surprisingly well-diversified compared to other major economies. Finally, we address the human side of the numbers. Despite strong corporate earnings, consumer sentiment remains low, driven by a rising fear of job insecurity that is hitting younger generations the hardest since 2008. We explore the disconnect between a booming stock market and the real-world anxiety many are feeling, aiming to help you process the noise and navigate your own growth with a clearer perspective. Follow Us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/compoundgrowthpod YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CompoundGrowthPodcast TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/@compoundgrowthpod Wheeler’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/wheeler-crowley-0a63933b/ Colin’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colin-walker-mba-6099a038/ Credits: Created By: Wheeler Crowley and Colin Walker Production, Editing and Post-Production: Tori Rothwell
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Compound Growth Podcast with Colin and Wheeler, where we talk all things growth. From financial growth to career growth, personal development to societal progress, we explore how each layer builds on the next, compounding over time to shape who we become. Each week we break down complex ideas and emerging trends into clear, actionable insights. Because growth isn't just about numbers, it's about understanding the world and our place in it. The information in this material is for general information only, and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual.
SPEAKER_01Investment advice offered through Integrated Partners doing business as Co-Fi Advisors LLC, a registered investment advisor. Integrated Partners does not provide legal, tax, mortgage advice or services. Please consult your legal tax advisor regarding your specific situation. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All investing involves risk, including loss of principle. No strategy assures success or protects against loss. The economic forecasts set forth in this material may not develop as predicted, and there can be no guarantee that the strategies promoted will be successful.
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to our latest episode, looking back at a monthly recap. This is our What Just Happened series. We're going to be looking back at November. To be fair, it is November 25th today, so there's still stuff that can happen in November before people listen to this. But it's also Thanksgiving week. We're going to take some much deserved time off. We hope everybody else listening is doing the same or did the same. I guess they'll get this after Thanksgiving.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, actually, the first thing I want to talk about today, which is retail sales, which is kind of funny because we're filming this prior to Black Friday. But with that being said, there are a lot of estimates out there for what spending is going to be. This is the first year that from November to January, US holiday sales is projected to be over a trillion dollars.
SPEAKER_01Well, it's the large the law of large uh numbers, right? Like it's it's so funny because Black Friday just isn't a thing anymore. It's just like the month of November is sales season.
SPEAKER_00I have a fun story for you. In fact, I think I I think I told you this, but I used to work at Ralph Lauren. That was like my first job ever. Yes. And um Black Friday, we would be open for 24 hours, as all the outlets were at the time. During that time period, any time during the year, you could walk in, and this was back, gosh, this was like 2005, maybe 2006. So it was a it was, you know, 20 years ago. And at any basic day of the week, you could come in and get a polo shirt for$39.99.
SPEAKER_00That was the the list price of a polo shirt at the time. Black Friday, though, we would have a sale where you'd get 25% off your polo shirt, but the polo shirt was$59.99. So we would mark the polo shirts up by 50% and then give you a 25% discount on the Black Friday sale. So, long story short, um, Black Friday doesn't exactly have great deals, but for some reason, there's this stigma around buying stuff in Black Friday, and now there's Cyber Monday and all this other good stuff.
SPEAKER_00And there, I find there to be better deals with Cyber Monday.
SPEAKER_01Just personally, honestly, it's all the same. Like it's every deal I've been buying, it's like by now, between now and like December 1st, right? Like if there was stuff left as long as it's this month. Yeah, totally. I I've been doing my Black Friday shopping for like a week and a half. And I I I don't know that I agree. First of all, this is why people hate big business because they do this shit that you were just describing. But I don't know that I agree that there aren't good deals to be had because there are.
SPEAKER_01It's just that those deals are not unique anymore because they'll be there later. Like I was just buying something for a family member, it was like 30% off. That's great. Also at the end of the season, it will be 30 30% off again. Right. Right. So it's not the only time you have.
SPEAKER_00I should clarify, I do think that there's good deals, but there are definitely some shady things out there in regards to discounts. Uh so I don't know. I mean, historically speaking, retail sales have grown anywhere from 3.7 to 4.2%. Um, and this year they're anticipating it to be the exact same. So I don't know. We'll see where the numbers come in, but you know, retail's been just a tough place in general to be this year. And, you know, even with consumer spending going up, I think people are starting to be a little bit more cautious about their spending coming into the holidays versus what it was historically, just based off of the numbers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, there that we've heard a lot of, we've got a lot of the retail earnings so far. Um, and also a lot of, you know, some of that's restaurants, right? And I've been hearing some chatter from, you know, the the kabas or the chipotles of the world. And they're basically like, hey, things aren't looking too good. The young consumer, especially, is not coming out to eat at our restaurant right now. Maybe fast casual is not in. And they're blaming like the young consumer, but like, have you been to Chipotle lately?
SPEAKER_01Because it's not very good. It's not just that.
SPEAKER_00We went two weeks ago and literally Kaylee and I were eating our burrito in silence. And not the same burrito, different burritos. We each had a burrito. Yeah. We're like, what is that with the the pasta? You know, the lady and the tramp. Lady and the tramp. Yeah, we weren't lady and tramping a burrito. Yeah. But with that being said, we both stopped and looked at each other and we were like, this isn't very good. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's now look, I'll eat it, right? I it's better than some alternatives, I think, but it's not as I remember it. And I feel like this happens. Like, honestly, when I was a kid, McDonald's was a very different restaurant than it is now. And I feel like these companies, as they continue to grow and they have to squeeze their margins, they can raise prices. But at some point, people don't want to pay$16 for a bridle bowl. My daughter just went to not Chipotle, but a local Chipotle type food uh chain in the Seacoast area with her friends.
SPEAKER_01And I gave them like$60. And I said, go, you know, go to lunch. And then they were going to go to a little market next door. And I got a text from her friend, like, it was$42 for our meal. And I'm like, yeah, that's how much things cost. Did you get guacamole?
SPEAKER_00You got the guac. It's it's the guac, man. It's always the guac that marks it up.
SPEAKER_01But I think it's funny when 11-year-olds are like, wow, that's expensive. I know, man.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I guess it depends on which restaurant you go to, too. But yeah, I mean, it's everything's really expensive. I just went and got a a tea this morning and it was like$650.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00For hot water.
SPEAKER_02What are you gonna do?
SPEAKER_01You know, it's I was I was reading a book called The Service Berry. And it's this book that Jess has been encouraging me to read. And it's basically like an alternative to the economy. It's like it's a give and take barter type of system or like symbiotic, you know, nature, harmonious natural existence, et cetera. And she pointed out that like one of the biggest scams that's ever been put on us is the thought that we should be paying for water. Like water is free in the world.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we will pay like$3 for a Dasani bottle of water, or like$8 at the movie theater.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's it's actually funny you mentioned that because I think I read something similar, an excerpt from that book one time. And I thought of it and I was like, that's what incentivized me to carry a water bottle around everywhere. So I was like, that's a great point. Why am I? One of my favorite things. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's true. On the retail front, too, while sales are going up, normally there's also Black Friday deals on autos and cars in general. But actually, car sales have continued to cool and it's been a rough year in general for auto sales.
SPEAKER_00I think a lot of that has to do, we talked about this last time where the EV sensive was going away. We weren't sure how that was going to impact cars, but we had a pretty good idea that it was going to, I'll say, give tough times to a lot of EV automakers. But it's also affecting not just EV automakers, it's affecting pretty much every automaker out there because most automakers now have an EV or a hybrid component to them. So with that being said, EVs are also down for the month of October in terms of sales from basically 4.8% from where it was last year.
SPEAKER_00And I think most data suggests that that will probably continue to cool for the rest of the year.
SPEAKER_01I have a conspiracy theory. And it's going to start with a question. Okay. When do you think and now look I recall your Ribbian story about peak EV, but let's assume that peak EV has already happened. Right? Like we've already hit the peak. I think that's not that's a false narrative. But this is just as just as like for this game. Assume peak EV happened. When did it happen?
SPEAKER_00Do I go back to the first car? No. No, no. I think modern like Tesla. Like legitimate Tesla. Yeah. I think I think peak EV was probably like 2015-2016. I feel like that's when adoption rates for Tesla was like super high, stock was growing, people were excited about it, the network was getting built out, everyone flooding into the space. You know, to me, that's when it was the most exciting, which I know we're going to talk about this in a little bit, but it kind of reminds me of where AI is right now, where like everybody's running into the space and everyone's super excited about it.
SPEAKER_00Like everyone's getting into the idea of having an EV and saving the world and kind of all that other good stuff. With that being said, I think EVs are still great in a lot of ways. They're better cars than honestly internal combustion in a lot of ways. But that's what I think peak EV was. But what's the conspiracy? Is this the correct answer or no? I don't know if it's the right card.
SPEAKER_01Um I'm asking, well, in what year did let's say the largest adoption of EVs occur? Or like what in what year did we hit the largest adoption of EBs? Is that how you measure this?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think so. That would be what I would take a stab in the dark. Because I mean, when was the Tesla Model S release? That was like back in 2008 or something, 2006.
SPEAKER_01So worldwide sales of electric cars exceeded 17 million units in 2024. So that was the highest point of sales, I think. So let's say that like we never see those sales again. We could say that we hit kind of like peak EV adoption at that time. And then everybody's like, wait a second, it's a pain in the butt to charge on the road, and maybe I'm not saving as much money, and then yada yada yada yada.
SPEAKER_01I was thinking about this last night and how cheap gas prices are. Just like ridiculous. They feel like they've been suppressed for a long time. Um, and they have been, right? So if you look back into the early 2000s or like mid-2000s, let's say 2005 to 2015, that 10-year period there, gas national gas prices were above$4 consistently.
SPEAKER_01Right. Like we would hit that mark or like three to three to four dollars, somewhere in that range, like consistently, right? Yeah. Now the national average is three dollars, but it's been like kind of hammered down. It's been, it peaked during like it peaked like post-COVID, interestingly. 2022 was like the peak uh recently for gas prices. But I know that the US like achieved independence, right, in terms of just like oil production and et cetera. And maybe that's a part of this, but I know that a lot of the what we you know burn is refined oil, right?
SPEAKER_01That the refining doesn't all happen in the US. So we like we produce and export and then we import refined gasoline, isn't that right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, it's true. Well, um, and when I was saying, you know, peak EV, like I was trying to think of like when it was the most exciting, but not necessarily sales. Like I agree. Sales have definitely continued to go up for EVs, which is, you know, gonna happen because just in general, even though car sales are down from last year in general, I'll say EVs do continue to slowly gain more market share over time, especially in the form of hybrids and plugins and things like that.
SPEAKER_01Well, this lines up with this conspiracy, though, because if you're thinking 2015 was peak EV or peak excitement about like what EV could be, that's also when gasoline prices got squashed. Right. So they've they actually went, you know, the the lows are like two, not actually one eight$1.84 was the national average in 2016, February 22nd, 2016. Yeah. So I just I wonder if we're seeing the price of gasoline used as a weapon against the EV adoption by the people who need continued gasoline consumption.
SPEAKER_01And I understand that oil is also like something that we used for our energy and that energy powers EVs, et cetera. Like I understand it's all tied together, but I'm just curious about this relationship.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, it's a great point. I mean, it's no, it's no surprise that obviously when the EV tax incentive went away, the sales of EVs plummeted. You know, I think what was it, the month after was September, October, when it officially went away. And um, that was like the lowest recorded month of EV sales for years. Which makes total sense because but that's it doesn't, it's not a really relevant number because everybody who was thinking about getting an EV got it the month before. So it doesn't necessarily mean that October was a bad month.
SPEAKER_00It just meant that September or August was an unbelievable month. And when you take the average, I'm sure it probably averages out to pretty close to where expectations were. But the Tesla Model S, by the way, was unveiled in 2009. Oh, wow. Yeah. Which is kind of crazy. It's been 16 years.
SPEAKER_01I had no idea it was well, that's back when Tesla was like fly by night, like almost, you know, in danger of not making it, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there wasn't that many people in the company in general. But yeah, I don't know. I I'm gonna use this to bridge into an AI conversation that I know we wanted to talk about, which is I feel as if the excitement that EVs had in 2014 and 2015 is kind of how everybody feels about AI right now in that sort of trade in general and just the amount of excitement that's going into it. And is it a bubble? Right.
SPEAKER_01So what's funny is that I get a message from a client like I think it was right before NVIDIA earnings or somewhere around NVIDIA earnings last week, and NVIDIA had an amazing earnings again this quarter. So they were reported this November, and the stock went up and then it went down with the rest of the market, and then it's you know kind of recovered from there. But I get this this message, and he's like, hey, is AI over? Is open AI over? And I'm like, if this was a bubble, this was the worst bubble in history. Like nothing happened.
SPEAKER_01We didn't have any exuberance. Like, no, this is probably not the top because this is not what the top looks like. But, you know, the fact that you have you have people who there's a there's so much pushback against AI. There's a lot of anti-AI sentiment. AI is the bad guy. You know, don't share your information with AI. AI is gonna take your job. AI is going to take over the world. I even hear this stuff. Do you ever do you ever come across this where people are like, are we living in uh a simulation?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the Matrix all the time. Yeah, but no, but no, now I'm hearing this like, yeah, I know it was a movie like 16 years ago, 26 years ago, 26 years ago. And now, like, I I was listening to this podcast the other day. It's called Moonshots, and they were like, you know, people are sick of us talking about is this a simulation? I'm like, what? This is the first time I've heard you talking about this is a simulation. I've literally never heard you mention this. But if yeah, I'm sick of it already too. I heard it once and I said, no, that's dumb.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I uh I I have talked about that. Kaylee and I always talk about punching out of the matrix at some point in our lives and like, you know, escaping from the world. Um I think it's more romantic. Yeah, I don't know. I think that means to her opening a bed and breakfast in France or something. Um I don't think that's gonna happen anytime soon. But with that being said, yeah, the simulation thing I have heard before, and it's it's an interesting theory.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's dumb. Uh whatever. If this is a simulation, I'm happy to be in it because I remember what it looked like outside of the Matrix, and it was a really unpleasant environment. They were like all eating mush and like I'm happy here in my main in my matrix. So, anyways, yeah, it's it's funny that we can have this like feeling that AI is over, and then at the other same time, it's like people are worried that we're you know partying like it's 1999. So I wanted to share a chart um that I thought was was pretty interesting, and this is coming from um the head of research, global research at Fidelity.
SPEAKER_01Um, so let me share this with you. All right. So this I think is what kind of scares people. And I think you can look at a chart like this. What we're looking at is the journey of the stock market from 1996 up until the the top in uh in 2000, right? And that's what we we reflect as the the uh the tech bubble, right? Yep. Uh and we're comparing that to our journey right now. So we start in 2022 in this, in this case, um, and that's probably my guess is that's like October 2022 when we start to recover from the lows, or maybe that's June, and we worked our way up and then down and then back up again.
SPEAKER_01Either way, at some point in 2022, which is when people feel like this current bull market, depending on who you talk to, this is when the bull market started because the bear market ended or the bottom was hit. So if you look at a chart like this, you're seeing a couple of different things. You're seeing that, you know, the direction and the kind of like the movement is very, very similar. You're also seeing that if this is like 1999, then we have not hit that exuberant stage, right?
SPEAKER_01So if this is a bubble, the bubble is still forming. I think that's what you would take away from this chart.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, and this is specifically in regards to is this this is just tracking the market in general. So I'll say I wonder if this is magnified even more when you drill into specific companies like NVIDIA.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I think NVIDIA, NVIDIA is a really good example of what doesn't look like a bubble right now because you're not seeing that like that crazy growth track. But you're also in here, you're seeing the percent of companies above the 200-day moving average, which is basically to say, are they staying above their price over the last from like the last 200-day period? And when you have these extreme concentration, people are always worried about extreme concentration. Actually, I've got another chart for that one. Um, but people are worried, like, well, that the market's too heavy.
SPEAKER_01We've talked about this before on the podcast. Um, and I think it's we've probably even looked at a chart like this before. But when we're talking about what what the market is too heavy possibly means here, on the screen right now, we're looking at the weight of the top 10 holdings in each country's ETF, like the 25 largest countries of the world. So obviously the USA is in there, China's in there. Um, funny enough, we we might not talk about the Mexican stock market, but that's represented here.
SPEAKER_00Um didn't even know they had one.
SPEAKER_01Japan, India, UK, France, Germany, all of the stock markets that you could possibly think of, I think. And the average weighting of the top 10 holdings in each of these countries, like their largest ETF, is 67%. So if you go to let's say, um, let's say Taiwan, for example, and you look up like the 10 largest companies in Taiwan equals 76% of that ETF, right?
SPEAKER_01We're all the way down here on the left, 39% in the US, which is heavy, right?
SPEAKER_00Like that's it's heavy, but that means in theory, we're one of the top four most diversified countries in terms of our top 10 holdings.
SPEAKER_01Totally. Yeah, that diversification is huge. And I think that's you know, one of the reasons that you're seeing you're seeing NVIDIA not look very bubbly right now. It's having pretty you know basic performance. I think what is it up year to date right now? Because if you compare NVIDIA to some of like the high flyers, it's not all that exciting. Um the NVIDIA up this year, year to date, it's 36%. Right. If you look at, I don't know, Robinhood, for example, uh Robinhood is up 209%.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Right. Yeah. I mean, it's pretty crazy when you look at this. Obviously, you we've gone over the heat charts before that show obviously the Magnificent 7 and all of the major companies. Companies in the US stock market and how they all play such a big role and how they're driving. But it is refreshing to see that when you zoom out, the concentration isn't nearly as much as what people expect it to be when they hear the news. Certainly not based off of historical numbers.
SPEAKER_00And then on top of that, it's good to also see that we're actually quite well diversified, benchmarked against everybody else. Because that hasn't always been the case. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I think the other thing is that that that exuberance and that like that excitement around the market isn't there. Right. And it's, you know, you were saying, well, you know, we're starting to adopt AI. It's getting a lot of use. Like everybody is using AI, but not everybody's using my AI. You know, my mom isn't using AI. I'll tell you that.
SPEAKER_00And she she's probably not my best. My dad just started using ChatGPT.
SPEAKER_01Here's one thing that I think about when I when people ask me, like, is this a bubble? Um, this is the investor sentiment charted, essentially. We're looking at a weekly uh kind of note of where we are with bullish versus bearish versus neutral sentiment in the investor clientele, right? So this isn't retail investors, these are professional investors. And the question is where will the stock market be in the next six months? Will it be higher, lower, or I don't know.
SPEAKER_01And right now you're seeing the majority of investors feeling like it's going to be lower, right? It's or lower or neutral. It's not bullish. Like there's no, there's nobody thinking like we're going to the moon, right? Like, you know, there's there are certainly like some areas of the market and some stocks in the market, like the irends of the world where people are like, yes, this is this is it. This is the next big thing. We got to get in now. But that's not what you're seeing in our everyday conversations with clients.
SPEAKER_01And that's not what you're seeing in the professional investor sentiment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I um I have a theory on kind of like the best way to define a bubble. And I'm curious to get your expectations or your thoughts on this. Because I was going back and forth with our thought partner, ChatGPT, on this. And I was like, how would you define a bubble? And it was basically like when expectations of a company don't meet results and there's a reckoning, so to speak. And I think that that's a really great way to break it down.
SPEAKER_00Because if you go back to the dot-com bubble and just think about that in general, you had all of these companies that were going to change the world. And people were just throwing money at them and throwing money at them and throwing money at them. But if you are basically, let's just say, spending$10 billion a year, but then you get a massive influx of, say, hundreds of billions of dollars from the stock market and funding and lenders and all of this kind of other stuff, you can't just take that extra hundred billion dollars and just do something with it that's going to generate the same level of profit.
SPEAKER_00Does that make sense?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it does. I think in in terms of figuring out like how to continue to get that growth engine growing, right? Is that what you mean? Like just like how do we continue higher and higher?
SPEAKER_00OpenAI's annual run rate is$20 billion, but they received a trillion dollars in terms of flows and funding, like everything that they've kind of received over the last year, from what I understand. So the point is, is like if you're used to$20 billion and you're just handed a trillion dollars, that doesn't necessarily mean that you're going to be, we'll just say 50 times more productive. That just means you have more money that you need to figure out what to do with. But if that's driving up the, I'll say, expectations of your business and also the valuations of your business, I think it's expectations that can cause something to blow up in general.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, I I think that's that's fair. I think what causes the bubble is feels like what you're what you're working on there is like what causes the bubble, right? And we can get into what a bubble actually looks like. And actually, I'm writing a substack about this. So I've been doing a lot of thinking about this. So it's it's funny that you bring it up. But I do think that we have to keep in mind that open AI is not a publicly traded company. No, it's not, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And everybody looks at open AI and uses this as the benchmark, right? But it's not even in the stock market. Yeah. You know, now, granted, a lot of companies that are in the market do rely on its technology. Right. But it's not traded.
SPEAKER_01But it's it's also not the only game in town, right? Like you have Claude, you have perplexity. Um, you have, you know, someday Siri is going to be real AI. It's going to be a real boy, a real girl, I guess. Let's just case. A real a real AI. But I I I think that the open AI risk is real, substantial, because it is intertwined with everything, but it's really hard. It's private equity. It's like it's a privately held company, and we don't know how to what the what the market really thinks it's worth.
SPEAKER_01It's not an open market valuation. So we can't really get into what that company is actually worth. But I think what pops a bubble can be a lot of different things. But what it looks like on the other side of that bubble pop, I think, is something that people get kind of confused by because there are a lot of people throwing around this term bubble right now, including us. Like we've said it multiple times in this podcast. But what does that mean? Because it's not like a 2022 bear market or COVID or the 2008 financial crisis necessarily.
SPEAKER_01Like that was a housing bubble, but the stock market didn't act like a bubble. So if you look at the biggest bubbles in history, it's something like an 80% decline and a prolonged recovery. 15, 25, 35 years. So that's really important to keep in mind what the the tech bubble was at. The, you know, we we the Nasdaq didn't get back to new all times till post-financial crisis.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was gonna say it it it came close in 2007, but it never outpaced where it was back in 2000. Like I don't think we, I don't think we passed where it was in 2000 until what was it, 2015 or something like that, or 2014, if I recall. Yeah, it might have even been a little bit later than that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it like it, it was a long the duration is the most painful part. It's not just that it goes down 80%, because there's still some stocks that you could say that there's like a bubble, maybe that's like it's it's comprehensive and all inclusive and it takes over the whole market. And then there's maybe bubbles within the stock, like the individual stock. And you can see like stocks like Zoom and Peloton that never recovered from, you know, never. They they have time ahead of them, but they haven't recovered from their pricing during the you know post-COVID bubble.
SPEAKER_01The Nikkei, the Japanese stock market. Boy, I'm messing that one up. The Japanese stock market just barely got back to new high all-time highs that it hit in the late's. That's a bubble.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man. It's nuts. Well, we always talk about this with consumer expectations and sentiment. And think about like we always talk about, you know, grandparents and things like that that lived through the depression and depression babies act very differently with money than people who grew up in the 50s and 60s. And additionally, like think about that. If say you sold a business or you had some sort of windfall and you put all of your money to work in 1998 or 1999, and you put it in the stock market, you invested, then next thing you know, the stock market blows up, it goes down, then you ride it back up.
SPEAKER_00You're almost back to where you were in 1998, 1999. Once 2007 rolls around, another crisis comes down. You basically had 15 to 16 years of no progress in your portfolio. Now, granted, you're earning interest and dividends and things like that. But when you look at total return in general, just across the S P 500, depending on when you put money in, it makes a huge difference in your impact in terms of your psyche and investing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And you get that timeline right, by the way. It was 15 years for the the NASDAQ to recover from that bubble. But you're right. And I think that that's what people are not necessarily thinking about when they say bubble. They're they're thinking like a, I don't want to say garden variety, a 50% decline, but a 50% decline is not a bubble. Not in the stock market, anyways. No, you know, those beanie babies that you were talking about not so long ago, like they're never gonna recover. No. It's like a prolonged bubble right there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's just, it's honestly just at that point, looking at the beanie babies or even the tulip bulbs, you know, tulipania was was a very famous one as well. Yep. That bubble popped, but it never re-inflated. It's just, it's just gone. The value of it ceases to exist. It's no longer a valuable product. You know, you can list a beanie baby on eBay for a million dollars, but no one's buying it. And it's the same thing with tulip bulbs. The moment they lost value, the value never came back. Now, with that being said, you know, when you look at a lot of these products and companies that people think are overinflated right now, I think there's some validity to that.
SPEAKER_00And maybe there is a lot of funding going in there right now. We don't know if it's going to pan out and increase the level of productivity and be this amazing situation that everybody's anticipating it's going to be for sure. But there is still use to the technology. So there is value there versus tulip bulbs or something like a beanie baby. Once the value goes away with that, it ceases to provide value to society.
SPEAKER_01What was interesting is NVIDIA, the a lot of people have been talking about the AI build-out as essentially like akin to the railroad build-out. And one difference that was being highlighted was that those tracks that the or or even the the internet build-out, like the fiber that was laid is still used. The tracks from the the train build-out still root used right now. And people were saying, well, these chips, they're gonna get outdated, they're gonna be replaced, they're gonna be obsolete, so you need to keep buying more and more and more.
SPEAKER_01And that's actually what's gonna drive the value of NVIDIA. Here's the thing NVIDIA is using their software as a service to keep these chips running at full capacity. So they don't need to replace these chips. NVIDIA is becoming a SaaS company, which is Oracle's big thing.
SPEAKER_00Right. Right. Yeah. You know, that's why they're taking off because their SaaS, their SaaS platform is exploding.
SPEAKER_01Right. And SAS, SaaS SaaS services for hardware, essentially, allows you to play both sides of that. I think it's really interesting. Okay. So let's talk about valuations versus earnings, because this is kind of what you were talking about. A company is it able to continue to increase its earnings growth to justify the valuations. And what we're seeing on the screen right now is the S P 500 in blue and the earnings for the S P 500 in orange, gold, whatever color that is.
SPEAKER_01And what you're seeing is that they're moving more or less in lockstep, and the SP 500 is not vastly out ahead of where the earnings are. So when we're seeing this, when the market increases in value, it's doing one of two things. It's either in you know, increasing market cap based on valuations or based on earnings, right? It's based on like what we think it's worth versus what is actually, you know, what the earnings that are driving it. And these earnings are driving the returns that we're getting in the market.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, sure, like like there will be some sort of earnings decline. There always is. But is this earnings growth the result of an AI bubble? Or are we in the early stages of adoption of AI in these big, big S P 500 companies?
SPEAKER_00I mean, it's a decent, it's a decent point. Is this just specifically to this is every S P 500 company right now, right?
SPEAKER_01This is the index. Yeah. This is the average. And this is this is one of the reasons why, to your point earlier, like we're one of the most diversified markets in the world, and that's a strength. Even though we're somewhat top-heavy, we're nowhere near as top heavy as we were during the tech bubble when we did have valuations far outpace earnings.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I mean that's a thing. And pointing that out earlier with OpenAI, I think given what's going on there, it's great that they're private because I would say those expectations might be skewed even more if they were publicly traded. But with that being said, you know, I think a lot of people get freaked out when it comes to politics and things like that affecting the market. But um, I'll say that oftentimes politics in the markets are disjointed and they don't move in lock and step.
SPEAKER_00You know, when you hear something crazy going on in the news, that doesn't necessarily mean the stock market's gonna go down. However, what the market does tend to trade off of is earnings. And whenever you see an earnings miss or an earnings outpace, you know, then the market does tend to react correspondingly to that. And when you have earnings in lockstep with the SP 500, I would say that's probably a fairly bullish indicator that we're not overvalued at the moment and that things do look pretty solid in terms of a foundation in the market.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think what you're what you're actually uh helping us transition to here is consumer sentiment, pessimism, kind of like what's going on with the world. And I do have another chart to share on that because as it relates to AI threatening jobs, you can measure that through survey sentiment. And this survey data that we're looking at right now suggests that the younger generations, younger workers are really concerned about the risk of losing their job, and that that risk is rising to highs that we haven't seen since the financial crisis, or maybe just like just post-financial crisis, when it was really hard.
SPEAKER_01Like if you, if you to your point about like the timing that you retire, you know, and where you are in the market and having a big impact on your financial success, when you graduate college and go into the job market, that can also have a big impact on your financial success. And of course, what we're looking at right now is this, you know, this group of 18 to 34, which you still fall into.
SPEAKER_00Um 35, but yeah. No, you're 35. Yeah. Sorry. Sorry. I'm 40 by one year.
SPEAKER_01You're almost there. Yeah. So you are just outside of that. So you're in you're in my range now, um, which is also rising to high. I this is actually, yeah, that we are at the highs. If you're age 35 to 54, the perception of potential job loss risk is the highest it's been since the 2008 financial crisis. Same thing for the age 55 and up group, right? They're not as concerned about losing their job, probably because they see retirement on the on the horizon.
SPEAKER_01And as you brought up before in recent conversations, some of these uh clients are excited to kind of punch out early from the job or the workforce.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I mean, that's honestly reflective of what we're also seeing in the job market in general. November hiring slowed. Um, and we've seen that this year just in general. And not only that, it's also led to a decline in, I'll say not a decline in wages, but a decline in wage growth. That's decelerated as well. And I do think that a lot of the issues with consumer sentiment have to do with job security. And if you feel as if that you don't have job security, and if you fear that your income will cease to exist at some point in the future or you will be replaced, that's going to lead to negative consumer sentiment.
SPEAKER_00And we've seen a lot of negative consumer sentiment over the last few months. You know, we had, you know, on record the longest government shutdown. Was it 43 days? Yeah, 43 days, um, which ended this month. But uh I'll say that while AI and earnings and those things right now look good, it doesn't necessarily make you feel good if you're worried about losing your job. And that certainly doesn't give you a whole lot of confidence to put a ton of money at work in the market in general right now. So, you know, I can appreciate people being fearful of things when you look across, I'll say the landscape in general, and you're seeing wage, I'll say wages, wage growth decline.
SPEAKER_00And then on top of that, hiring also slow down as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And that's why you're seeing also the approval rating for the president at all time lows. Yeah. Even below his previous term, which was also not great. But yeah, I think people aren't happy. So, like to recap and to kind of like put a bow on this, is this a bubble? We don't have the irrational enthusiasm that you usually get or exuberance that you usually get with a bubble. There's a lot of fear and concern. There's that wall of worry that we're climbing right now. So I'm gonna go on the record and say, I don't think that this bubble is popping tomorrow if it is a bubble.
SPEAKER_01And if it is a bubble, I don't think it's gonna be what we what we perceive it to be, right? Like the the housing bubble was something that came out of kind of left field. Like there were some people who saw that coming, but most of us were pretty ignorant to it. You know, I think that the tech bubble was maybe a little bit easier to predict, but there's still a lot of, I would say, justified earnings out there and justified reason to believe that we can continue at this pace without the world coming to an end.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So just in summary, basically what we're saying is that it doesn't feel like a bubble because there's not that I'll say optimism that's out there in the market right now in general. Normally, when you have a bubble, you see a ton of overspending, you see people really excited, throwing a ton of money into the market. We're not necessarily seeing that. We're also not seeing a disconnect between earnings and the market in general right now. And we're not seeing too much concentration. We're actually fairly well diversified in the market in general right now as well. So I'll say in terms of markets, it seems like it's okay.
SPEAKER_00And we often see that as well. When consumer sentiment is down, that doesn't necessarily mean that the stock market plummets either. Oftentimes when consumer sentiment is down, the market goes up, which is kind of what we're seeing right now. You know, it's been a pretty good year in terms of market performance. It's actually been a great year. And um we'll see where we end up. But yeah, it's interesting when you look at all the numbers because we've talked about this before in podcasts. How you feel isn't necessarily reflective oftentimes of the results.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think that's the hardest thing for people to digest is that what's happening in the stock market, what's happening in corporate earnings is all in the face of a lot of concern, right? There's there's political concern, there's climate concern, there's just a lot of unhappy people. We might not be at peak optimism, but it feels like in a lot of areas we're at peak pessimism.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think what this shows too, and I think like the takeaway that I'm talking to with a lot of clients about is it's disconcerning when companies make a lot of money by not necessarily benefiting the employees and the people that are out there. Right now, companies are generating higher profits by not hiring as many people, not giving raises to them, and honestly laying off as well by replacing them with technology. So, of course, people are gonna be unhappy in that type of environment. And that directly contradicts with what's happening in the market because when you do that, obviously the profits of the company are gonna go up.
SPEAKER_00So the profits of the companies are going up. Certainly at some could argue at the expenditures of the employees and the people in general.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I think that's it doesn't even need that's just the truth. Like you don't have to argue it. Like it just is what it is. It's how they're designed, right? Right. And I think that's the thing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, the cost of labor is the biggest line item for most of these companies.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And I, you know, I've I've been thinking a lot about we talked about like different, you know, jobs that used to exist that don't exist anymore. And um, you know, our I guess our our resiliency or our ability to adapt and find new purpose and new ways to make money in an ever-changing world. And I do think that we have to take a moment every once in a while to reflect the fact that things are changing at an exponential rate, like all the time.
SPEAKER_01And it's really hard to keep up with it all. It's really easy to feel left behind, and it's really easy to latch on the fear of to the fear of change that like we so naturally gravitate to.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, people don't like change. And um, change inherently means a certain level of unknown. And we don't really know where we're going. Certainly, people can predict it, but we won't really know until we get there. And once we get there, there will be a fear of something else, too. So it's gonna be really curious to see where this all goes and how regulation plays into the whole AI situation as well. What actually gets replaced, what's here to stay. People can make guesses, but no one really knows for sure. And um, it's gonna be fascinating to just sit here and watch.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, for sure. Um, all right, cool. I think that's a great place to leave it, Colin. I agree. Yeah, this is great. Um, thanks for tuning in. Like, share, subscribe, and uh tune in for the next one. Thanks, Colin. Thanks.
SPEAKER_02Compound Girls with Wheeler and Colin, sponsored by Coby Advisors, reach out today.
Nvidia is down roughly 30% from its highs after the Jensen Huang headlines, the market has swung hard since the midterms, and year end is bringing a tax bill some investors won't see coming. It's hard to tell which of...
The headlines say the economy is strong and the market is near its highs, but for a lot of people it doesn’t feel that way. Wheeler and Colin are joined by Dan to look at who this economy is actually working for....
Property tax bills keep climbing, a bill in Congress promises lower card fees while card companies warn that rewards could shrink, and everyone seems to be waiting for the AI bubble to burst. It’s hard to tell where the...
Homes cost about five times the typical household income, the average car payment has climbed by about a third in five years, and letters from the Treasury keep arriving with help that rarely adds up to much. It can...
In the race of technology, is AI truly the fastest adopted innovation in history, or is it just a case of mass distribution? If you’ve been questioning the impact of AI on the economy, your portfolio, or even just your...