Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Compound Growth

Compound Growth artwork

Property Taxes on the Ballot, Visa and Mastercard Under Pressure, and a Bubble on Watch

Nov 2, 202646 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Property tax bills keep climbing, a bill in Congress promises lower card fees while card companies warn that rewards could shrink, and everyone seems to be waiting for the AI bubble to burst. It’s hard to tell where the real costs and risks are coming from. After kicking off Movember, Wheeler and Colin take on property taxes. Colin shares that his own bill is up 120% in seven years after his town’s new high school ran over budget. Wheeler makes the case that property taxes work like membership dues for your town and points to one big reason those dues keep rising. Portsmouth’s proposed FY2027 budget lists a $3.3 million increase in health insurance costs as its single largest growth driver. Colin then explains what happens when you swipe a credit card and what the Credit Card Competition Act would change, with US merchants paying about $200 billion in card processing fees in 2025. He looks back at the 2010 Durbin Amendment, when merchants’ early savings faded over time, and the two debate who really pays for rewards points. To finish, Wheeler uses three charts to ask whether something can be a bubble if everyone is waiting for it to pop, and the hosts separate AI itself from the companies spending on it. The episode closes with a client win about paying off credit card debt. By the end, you’ll understand what drives your property tax bill, how card fees flow through to the prices everyone pays, and why Wheeler and Colin think bubble talk deserves a closer look. Compound Growth is produced by CoFi Advisors. If this episode raised a question about your own plan, we’re happy to talk it through. Sources: City of Portsmouth, Proposed FY2027 Budget Credit Card Competition Act (Sens. Marshall, Durbin and Welch) Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, research on the Durbin Amendment and debit card fees Duality Research (forward earnings, tech vs. staples and risk-on/risk-off charts) Movember Foundation Follow Us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/compoundgrowthpod YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CompoundGrowthPodcast TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/@compoundgrowthpod Wheeler’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/wheeler-crowley-0a63933b/ Colin’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colin-walker-mba-6099a038/ Credits: Created By: Wheeler Crowley and Colin Walker Production, Editing and Post-Production: Tori Rothwell

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00My thesis here is: can AI become a bubble if everyone is waiting for it to burst? Bubbles feed on irrational enthusiasm, the belief that upside is limitless and the risks don't matter. And inside the biggest technology companies, that enthusiasm looks very real. They're spending staggering amounts of money to build an AI future, they're convinced it's coming, right? But investors seem less convinced. Forward priced earnings are dropping. And if we all feel like there's a bubble coming, can it actually come to exist?

SPEAKER_00And is a bubble even the right term?

SPEAKER_01In theory, a bubble defined is defined by the fact that you can't necessarily see it coming.

SPEAKER_00So let's define a bubble. What is a bubble?

SPEAKER_01Well, a bubble to me was basically an overspend that basically overvalues. That means that there's a regression to the mean eventually in regards to total value.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Compound Growth with Colin and Wheeler, where we curate the most important stories and ideas in personal finance and the economy to help you compound your wealth, health, and personal growth.

SPEAKER_01Here we connect the dots between money, markets, and the decisions that shape our lives. If you find that useful, like, subscribe, and share the show with someone who might too. Because there's always more to this story.

SPEAKER_00So let's get into it. So I said to my wife and daughter this morning, I said, look at this face. Feel how smooth it is. But this is the last time you're gonna see this face in 2026. Because the rest of the time, I'm either going to have my Christmas beard in December that I grow out every year, or as we're doing as a team this year, a mustache for Movember.

SPEAKER_00And I'm curious how your conversation went with your wife around about this because Jess is like, I guess fine, whatever. Like she's she's putting up with it. She's she's supportive. My daughter wants nothing to do with this. She is like absolutely 100% opposed to the point where I was like, you know, to our conversation yesterday, we were talking about wearing flannel shirts, which is sort of what you did. Full fall. I came downstairs. I have multiple flannel shirts. I like to have flannel shirts. Love flannels. I have Vermont flannels, my favorite flannel brand.

SPEAKER_00Shout out Vermont flannel. So I came down with multiple flannel shirts and I was like, hey, which one should I wear for the photo today? And Michaela's like, oh. And that's the whole response. That one, I guess. Which is the one I'm wearing. I wore what she told me to wear. That's usually the safest way to do it.

SPEAKER_01Looks great. Solid flannel choice.

SPEAKER_00Where'd it go with your with your family?

SPEAKER_01Here's uh here's what happened is uh I sat Finnegan down at first and I said, I'm gonna have hair like you soon. Then uh he didn't respond. Uh then I asked Kaylee, and I I asked her first, how was your day? And she said, Great. Then I thought, should I bring up the beard thing now? And then I thought to myself, no. And then I just went on my day. So it hasn't necessarily been a conversation yet. What I will say is I probed about two or three weeks ago with, oh, what do you think about Mo Vember?

SPEAKER_01She says, I think it's the dumbest thing ever. Why don't you just make a donation? And then she was like, Why do you have to grow a beard? And and then I was just like, Yeah, you know, I don't get it either when I'm telling her I'm about to participate. Necessarily hear this. So what's gonna happen is that I think two weeks in, she'll comment and be like, You ever gonna shave? And then I'll be like, Yeah, I'm gonna get around to it. And then before you know it, a month has gone by because it's gonna be all patchy anyway.

SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, what if you have like a really killer mustache and you're like, I think I'm gonna keep this?

SPEAKER_01Is there such a thing as a killer mustache?

SPEAKER_00So mustaches are variant right now.

SPEAKER_01I know. You know? I I was actually talking about this with someone the other day about how like 10 years ago mustaches were perceived as being kind of like dirty. But now you look at like a lot of people who are like influencers and they have mustaches and it's widely accepted. Tori, are you widely accepting the mustache? Yes, I'm widely accepting. Wow. See? And honestly, facial hair in general.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Bold. Anyways, the point here, Movember. Here's what Movember is. Movember is an annual global awareness campaign held every November where participants grow a mustache to spark conversations and raise funds, to Kaylee's point, for men's health issues. It used to be people would think like testicular cancer, prostate cancer. It's also mental health. Mental health. Right. And as we frequently discuss and will discuss again today, there is a loneliness epidemic right now. And it is specifically hurting uh men more than women.

SPEAKER_00And I think that raising awareness is like, it's great, make a donation. That's that's fine. I think that you're demonstrating something with a mustache. I I I could see two sides here. One, like, hey, look, I'm in this, right? Here's a physical reminder every day that this is what I'm doing this month. Or two, I happen to be doing this at the time where like we're probably peak mustache trend. So no points.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, okay. Well, that's that's fair. And I support the causes, obviously, because I am a man as well. I do think it's a great cause. I'm excited to be a part of it. Am I excited about growing facial hair? It will, I'll say, give me a few extra minutes in the morning, which I am excited about not having to shave.

SPEAKER_00Just this this part. Just this part.

SPEAKER_01Just this 30 seconds is what it will say. But you compound that over 30 days. Yeah. That's several minutes.

SPEAKER_00Well, okay, we're gonna take a before and after photo. So before today and then after after Thanksgiving. And I'm excited to see what happens. I'm excited as well. So, roadmap for today. We're going to talk about property taxes. Ooh, exciting. Yeah, but a lot of people are thinking more and more about property taxes. There is an election coming up, you may have heard. Yep. And uh that election is there's a lot on the docket. Property taxes are there frequently. So we're gonna talk about property taxes.

SPEAKER_00We're gonna talk about credit card points, the latest threat to the city.

SPEAKER_01credit card points and how credit cards are changing in general.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And then we're gonna talk about AI, of course. Plot twist, alert the media. And uh why this may or may not be a bubble.

SPEAKER_01Hmm.

SPEAKER_00I'm not gonna spoil that. So let's start, let's start with property taxes. Okay. Lay it on me. So there have been a number of articles in the Wall Street Journal, New York Times, Washington Posts, local newspapers leading up to November's elections that have highlighted frustration with property taxes. Proposals to cap, reduce, or limit local taxes are on the docket. But is this anger misdirected, Colin? And is this just a continuation of that loneliness epidemic of the individualism and isolationism that continues to deepen the divide in our country?

SPEAKER_00Are we further sacrificing community because we don't recognize our place within it? That's what I'm asking you today. Yes. Yes, yes, we are. I do feel that way. All right. So let's talk about the purpose of property taxes. Because the I think the thing, the the first article I saw about this was an older, older gentleman, I think in Ohio, and he was in his 70s, and he said, I'm old, I have no kids in the system, I've paid my dues, I've worked really hard, I paid property taxes for years. Why do I still have to pay property taxes?

SPEAKER_00Why am I funding all the school systems? Why am I no, just property taxes at all? Right. Right. Now, a lot of a lot of elder citizens who are at certain income limits or below will receive some sort of like benefit towards their property taxes. It could be a rebate, it could be reduction to whatever. Like in many states, you can get quote unquote a discount on property taxes if you happen to be at a point where you are retired, you don't have a lot of income, and your property taxes keep going up. So that is a benefit, but it might not be good enough for some people.

SPEAKER_00And I actually don't think that this is just ageism, right? It's not just this old man shouting at a cloud in Ohio. It's other people who are younger who buy a home and have like these crazy mortgage payments and they also have massive property taxes. And we have seen property values basically double over the last six years in a lot of the areas of this country, which would lead to reassessments, which in some cases have led to higher property tax bills. So we're kind of like all of this is coming to a head right now.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I uh have talked about this several times, not on the podcast, but the fact that Kaylee and I are a younger couple, don't have any children yet. And in our town, they redid the high school, which went$10 million over budget, which caused all the property taxes for said town to go up dramatically. And if I look at our property taxes, they have increased by 120% since we bought our house seven years ago.

SPEAKER_00So I'm confused about that statement though, because like you don't it's like the house that you're building and you things go over budget and you're like, well, I gotta go over budget, right? But in most situations, there's a vote on the budget for the school, right? And the school has to come in at that budget or ask for more money. So is that what happened in your life? Yeah, they kept asking for more money. They kept asking for more and more and more. Right. I've been to that high school, it's beautiful. It's gorgeous. It was like better be after that. It's like when you when you when you go into like the cafeteria area, you feel like there's gonna be just like all of a sudden singing teenagers dancing from the the hallway into the space and putting on a show because it feels like it's a a movie, made for TV, maybe Disney movie, but a movie for high schoolers.

SPEAKER_00It's a really beautiful spot.

SPEAKER_01Oh, it's gorgeous. Like I'm not complaining about the the quality of the school. But as someone that doesn't have kids attending said school, yeah, um, nor will they have kids attending said school. Is that just a tax I have to pay?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So let's talk about that because you're leaving that town. I am. Right? So you paid taxes into that school system for 10 years or so, right? And then you're moving to a different town that'll have different school system, different taxes. Yes. That are lower taxes. Yes, much lower. Yeah. So how do you feel about that?

SPEAKER_01I feel like I am all for contributing to the town that I live in, because the way that I look at it is while I do complain about the property taxes going up, I will say that having a nicer school makes the property value of the home that I'm in better. So if if you live in a community that doesn't have a fantastic school district, it does affect your property prices and it does affect the pool of buyers that is going to be looking at your house if you were to ever sell it.

SPEAKER_01Because the town that I live in has put a ton of money into the school system and it is now very nice, I do think that has made the town more attractive. So while I have benefited from increased property values from the town that I live in, investing in the school, yes, I've paid more in taxes. Has it netted out? I'm not a hundred percent sure, but my guess is it's got to be pretty close.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, I think having a good property values are reflection of the place that they are in, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's many things, and your location is one of the biggest contributors.

SPEAKER_00But it and it's not like so. When you when you're shopping for a home, you're like, this is the place I want to live. There are things that you're looking for. If you're a family, you're gonna be looking for good schools. Yeah. Uh, you might be looking for clean streets, nice roads, sidewalks, right? Safety. Safety, right? Like proximity to a well-funded fire station and police station, et cetera. Grocery stores. Grocery stores are not so much part of property taxes. But I I think that there are things that make a town or city appealing to people who want to live there.

SPEAKER_00And schools are one of those things. But beyond that, it's also just all of these line items are an investment in your community, right? Like you ideally, you're not, I mean, you specifically, Colin and me and Tori, most people I know in this area, are not living up on a hill with a gate at the bottom of our two-mile dirt road, isolating from everybody. Correct. Right. But you can feel really lonely in the town and city that surrounds you at the same time.

SPEAKER_00And I think if you don't feel like you're a part of a community, or if that community has changed and moved away from what your values are, then you could feel very angry about having to pay taxes into that community, just like people on a national level are angry about paying taxes that fund wars, right? Right.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, I do feel as if the property taxes that I've paid, and I actually looked it up, it went 20 million over budget, believe it or not, the high school. But regardless, the I do think that the taxes I've paid have led to a better town that I currently am in right now. And truth be told, if we weren't building a house, I'd be more than happy to stay where we are. But it was a family decision. And I think that if the funds are allocated appropriately, and if the property taxes are put into areas where in theory it should make the town better.

SPEAKER_01And if that is true, then your property values should increase through that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. But again, I think that's focusing mostly on property values. And that's it's fine. Like I think for a lot of people, that's what their uh their attention is on.

SPEAKER_01Well, to that, to the point you brought up in the first place with that guy being like, I paid so much into the system. He's throwing his arms up about it. It's like you've paid so much into the system, but you've gotten some of it back.

SPEAKER_00You get a lot of it back. In fact, I think you get more than what you pay in because there's a value to it's not just like how how much how many dollars that go into the fire department, pay for those people to live there, work there, et cetera. Like it's the the value of what you put into the system is what you feel from that system, right? You it's like how how how how much should it cost to feel like the fire department's gonna come up and pull me out of this window? So you're saying there's an emotional value. There's a psychological value, there's a community value, there's like a sense of paying into something.

SPEAKER_00It's like a club. It's like entry fees. Like if you if you have a golf club membership and you want to go and you want to use those those greens, then that's great. You could also maybe get a like nice restaurant experience. You'll also have the social aspect of that. There are other people in that club with you. And every town that we live in is essentially the same thing.

SPEAKER_01I see what you're saying. So the uh property taxes you're saying are kind of like a club benefit, if you will. Like an entry. They're the cost, yeah. Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_00Your membership dues. Exactly right. If you will. I think that's what we should look at it as. And you do not need to pay those dues. You can leave. Right? Right. I think one thing that people get stuck on again, because of what we've pegged to and anchored to in terms of the American dream, is that this is my home. I can't leave my home. And we become a less transient culture. People used to move for jobs like way more than they do now. Yeah, we moved a bunch when I was a well, not a bunch. We moved when I was a kid for jobs. Yeah. And I'm not saying people should be forced out of their home by any means.

SPEAKER_00It sucks for you to be in a situation where you have a fixed income and property taxes to pay that keep going up while you have the same fixed income with slight you know cost of living adjustments if you have that. Right. That's a shitty situation to be in. Yeah. But I think if we're angry about that, we should not be angry at the fact that we are in this club and the membership fees keep going up, but we should be angry about what drives up those membership fees. And I think so we're we're living in a high inflationary environment right now, right?

SPEAKER_00And it's not just like when you go to the grocery store or when you go to the pump. It's everything else that's gone up in in cost. So a concrete example of larger national issues impacting our local municipal expenses. So Portsmouth's proposed fiscal year 2027 budget identified$3.3 million increase in citywide health insurance costs, 21.4% as its single largest budget growth driver.

SPEAKER_01So what we're saying is all the employees of the town of Portsmouth, because their health care costs have come up, it's obviously passed on to the town of Portsmouth because they're employees of Portsmouth, and that's a$3.3 million additional cost to the taxpayers.

SPEAKER_00Exactly right. School insurance costs increase 26.2%. Wow. So are we misdirecting our anger at teachers and schools? Are people more like bloat or whatever? Yeah. Instead of recognizing the fact that health insurance costs in this country are exorbitant and a total failure.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think that this is one of the things that we were talking about with like the oil and gas thing. It's like the oil and gas thing at the pump isn't necessarily the big issue. The big issue is like all the transportation costs for everything else in the country and what you're paying for has gone up.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And it's the same thing with this in regards to insurance and employee benefits and all the other things that have happened over the last five to ten years that have led to this particular instance.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. How much it costs at schools, at fire departments, at local government offices, like it just there are costs that, just like any other company, the costs for the company go up, the costs for the town go up. And it's not the town's fault that those costs go up. And I think everybody just points fingers and blames and says, use your money better. And there are some things they can't control. And if we put a cap on that, which is the proposal in many places, then we're asking them to make choices. And those choices might not be in favor of something that we agree with.

SPEAKER_00It might hurt the club. It might hurt the club. So there's a I just want to point out one thing. I know we're running law and Tory, but there's a vote on on Tuesday in New Hampshire. And I'm going to just read this specifically the question that you're going to be reading, the ballot question number two. All right. This this is a typical question that you get on these when you go into vote. They're so stupid. And it basically says shall the town limit property tax growth for this school district under RSA 32, blah, blah, blah.

SPEAKER_00If adopted for a two-year period, the local property tax levy may not grow beyond the prior year's amount adjusted for inflation in new construction. I guess that new construction would still happen. Central office's spending may not exceed 6% of total school district appropriations. Bonded capital costs are excluded from both limits. These caps apply only to administrative operations of the central office and do not affect classroom instruction, they say, school-based services or other municipal expenditures. These limits may be overridden. Adoption requires a three-fifth majority vote.

SPEAKER_00You're basically saying yes or no. Should you put a cap? Yes or no. If you were to simplify that, should you put a cap? But what's misleading with something like this is they'll say that it does not affect classroom instruction, which is not true. Yeah, how could it not be true? Right. It's because they're saying it's administrative. They're basically saying, well, we still have the budget for the school supplies. We can still buy computers, we can do all these things, but we're going to impact the people who work at these schools. And if we don't have the budget to pay for the increased health insurance, then we're going to have to cut the band.

SPEAKER_00100%.

SPEAKER_01Well, it's this is actually a perfect segue to the next topic. Perfect. Because the costs get passed down in one way or another. Like there's no way to avoid that. If health insurance is bene and benefits in general are becoming more expensive for the schools, you're telling me that you can just cap those costs. Just decide that health insurance doesn't go up anymore. That's not a realistic argument. The only way that you could combat those costs is to eliminate staff or hire less.

SPEAKER_00Yep. In France, for example, one of the reasons that teachers are on strike is because there's nationalized teacher pay, right? But there's level to quality of teaching. Like so basically, if you, you know, once you get your first five years in, for example, or 10 years or 15 years, you go up in pay increase, but you also uh get to choose where you want to work. And so what happens is if there's a shitty school system or a dangerous environment community, they get the younger teachers, new teachers that don't have seniority.

SPEAKER_00Those teachers are forced to be there. And then as soon as they can, they leave there. So there's all these like impoverished communities that have tons of turnover in the school system because nobody wants to be there. Right. And we do the same thing here in this state and in this country, where teachers will leave one bad school system that's underfunded and go to a better school system that is better funded so they can actually have health insurance and good benefits. Yeah. It's a slippery slope. It is. Anyways, I thought that was an interesting time.

SPEAKER_00That is, that is an interesting time. Be aware of what you're voting for when you go to vote on Tuesday if you actually listen to this or see this before this election. But in general, don't hate on the taxes. Hate on the stupid game that we're playing.

SPEAKER_01Speaking of passing down costs, I want to talk about the Credit Card Competition Act that President Trump endorsed on October 22nd. This has been around for a little while, and um, I don't know if you actually read the article. But if you said this, what are you suggesting here? Well, because I don't want to like do a whole breakdown if you already know all of this. But obviously, I'm gonna summarize the viewers. But if you look at the history of this, which is what I was kind of saying, so this was originally proposed by Republican Roger Mark.

SPEAKER_01With Democrats Dick Durbin and Peter Welsh. So it's um coming from both sides, which I appreciate. Bipartisan, bipartisan, if you will. But I think before we talk about credit cards and what this bill is specifically, I want to talk about how credit card fees work in general, because I think a lot of people don't necessarily understand the plumbing of how credit cards work. And not only that, but the points and cashback and all that other stuff too, because it is important to this. So the way that it works is if you think about a credit card, you have like the Chase Sapphire card is a great example of this.

SPEAKER_01So you have an issuing bank, which in that case would be JP Morgan. So you swipe a credit card, and then you have the issuing bank approves the purchase, which is JP Morgan. Then you have a payment network, which then routes the requests in the transaction. That is usually Visa or MasterCard, are the two biggest ones. You also have Amex and Discover, which is now Cap One. And then a processor carries the transaction data, and the merchant's bank deposits the money with the store. So, long story short, there are multiple facets when you swipe a credit card to what actually happens with the money in the transaction.

SPEAKER_01And along the way, there are different fees. And what this bill is trying to do is basically the goal is to lower the fees by increasing the amount of networks that are basically being used. Because if you think about it right now, 80 of all credit card transactions are routed through the two biggest networks, which is Visa and MasterCard, are the two biggest ones. So, some numbers to frame this out, which is$200 billion in total credit and debit card processing fees were paid by US merchants in 2025.

SPEAKER_01So it's an 80% increase from 2019. So the credit card fees have gone up dramatically. And with that, I think there has been a reliance from people like me on things like credit card points, airline points, cashback, that is being marketed now more than ever. And if you look at the average merchant fee, it's usually anywhere from one and a half to three and a half percent, is what we're looking at right now for swipe fees for what merchants are paying. So when you think about what this bill is trying to do and why it matters, basically, if you think about your airline miles, it may be funded in part by a fee a merchant pays when you use a credit card, but that merchant may build its costs into prices everybody pays.

SPEAKER_01So it's not exactly as if they're eating those fees. What might be happening, and I propose that it absolutely is happening, is that as opposed to saying our credit card fee is 3.5%, I'm just going to eat that cost, they're probably going to increase the price of the goods. And I go back to like sushi restaurants as an example, or coffee shops, or even there's one of our favorite restaurants, and Tori loves this place too, over in Rye, has a sign that says, help our business by paying with cash. And if you pay with cash, what the reason for that is because you're avoiding those merchant processing fees that credit cards basically charge the business.

SPEAKER_01So what Congress is doing is they're considering a bill to give merchants more choice on how card transactions are processed. So the promise is lower fees. I don't actually think there's going to be lower fees, but when you look at Visa and MasterCard having 80%, you could call that a monopoly. What they're trying to do is they're trying to figure out whether or not it would make sense. The bill argues that it would, that they open it up to many different networks. So, as a perfect example, let's say you go into a store, you swipe your credit card.

SPEAKER_01And as opposed to it being automatically routed on Visa, it will give the merchant a choice to potentially say, do you want this on the Visa network? Do you want this on the Amex network? Do you want this to be on any of these other networks? I actually didn't know how many networks there were, but there's Pulse Star, Excel, NYCE, and then there's also Kaliance, which I had never heard. But funny enough, a lot of these are actually owned by some of these other bigger networks like Visa and MasterCard. So the purpose of this is to basically introduce competition to the routing networks when a card is swiped.

SPEAKER_01And the goal with this is to reduce the cost of the payments to the merchants, which will hopefully pass it on to the consumer.

SPEAKER_00Right.

SPEAKER_01Will it actually happen? I don't actually think so. I actually did a little bit of research to see whether or not something like this had happened before, and it had. There was something called the Durban Amendment, which was a 2010 law that put basically a cap on debit card fees. So back before 2010, uh, debit card fees were basically 45 cents per transaction. Then what ended up happening is there was a cap that was put on the transaction cost for debit cards that capped it at 21 cents.

SPEAKER_01People were super pumped because it was going to reduce credit card or debit card fees dramatically and whatnot, but it actually didn't, because a lot of the transaction costs were under 21 cents to begin with. They could go up to 45 cents, but that didn't mean every single transaction was 45 cents. So then what the merchants did is they just made all of the debit card transaction purchases 21 cents. So it actually increased the fee for some merchants using debit cards, and some it reduced, but it was kind of a net wash.

SPEAKER_00So that was a sense per transaction?

SPEAKER_01That was a sense, but there was a small percentage fee baked in there too.

SPEAKER_00So when did that go away? It's still in place. So say that, say that I think could you dumb it down, speak to me like I'm eight. Yeah. How how where and when and why is this fee, this uh quarter being charged?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So when you swipe a debit card. Yep. So there is debit cards act different to credit cards in the network. So before 2010, the average debit card transaction fee was basically 45 cents. Is charged by whom?

SPEAKER_00Charged by Is it by the network? Is it by like who's charging that fee?

SPEAKER_01So the Durban amendment was specifically regarding the network. So it was 45 cents per debit card transaction on average. The average fee was then capped after the amendment was put in place to 21 cents plus a tiny percentage of the purchase, which is what it was before as well. So the Richmond Fed research found that the total merchants did save money in the first year, but over time that savings went away. Yeah. Because what they essentially did is made all transaction fees the maximum amount at that point, versus there being variability up to the 45 cents.

SPEAKER_01So it didn't actually end up saving that much money.

SPEAKER_00So, okay. So debit cards are charged differently than credit cards on the same network. When you go to the copy shop, you use a debit card or a credit card, both are charged a fee, but debit cards are charged a different fee than credit cards.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So the transaction costs on debit cards are less than credit cards.

SPEAKER_00Right. And then you have the costs of what you're suggesting. And I think what the bill is suggesting is that if we are able to rein in the fees charged for swipes for the network specifically. For a credit card or debit card. If we're able to rein in that cost for the merchants, then the merchants will be able to reduce the cost.

SPEAKER_01Yes, but there's a caveat. So this bill only goes after the networks with$100 billion or more of assets, which is basically Visa and MasterCard.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01What's funny about this is that because Amex and now Capital One are both the bank and the network, they are exempt. Say that again. Sorry. So if you think about like Visa and MasterCard, they're not the issuing bank. Right. Of course. Yeah. Yeah. But Amex is. So so is Cap One. But now Capital One owns Discover. They bought Discover in 2025. Yep. So what's different about Capital One and also Amex is that they are both the bank and also the routing network.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. This bill specifically only goes after routing networks specifically and excludes companies that are both the bank and network.

SPEAKER_00Sure. Okay. So, but though, getting to, I guess your thesis here is, if I were to restate it, that the changes that are being proposed by this bill that Trump, for obviously political reasons, is now supporting. Yes. Right. Because he's aware that everybody's feeling the pinch and this is going to make him look good. So now he's on board. So remember Drain the Swamp? Like, when do politics ever change? They never change. Yeah, they never like humans always act the exact same way.

SPEAKER_00Humans are incredibly predictable. Yeah. Okay. So, but your your thesis is it doesn't matter what this bill does, the cost benefit is less, is not likely to be passed on.

SPEAKER_01The two things that I think that this points out to me is that one, when people think about cashback and all of that stuff, and also if you think about the average consumer in general, if you think about people that are, I'll say more well off, that are trying to get airline miles and benefit from cashback and stuff like that, they're not as negatively affected by something like a credit card transaction because they're going to be able to qualify for cards that give them great benefits.

SPEAKER_01And then maybe even use those rewards positively to earn a decent ROI on the transaction, maybe even making out, even when you factor in all the merchant transactions they paid throughout the year. But someone that might not qualify for a card that provides those benefits that is at a lower credit score, they will probably be paying more in merchant fees along the way because A, those same merchant fees are passed on to them, but B, they're not getting those same credit card benefits. Okay, right.

SPEAKER_00So if this won't negatively impact the debit card users and it could possibly benefit them if the merchants pass along the savings, then why not do this? Does this hurt anybody if this bill goes through? Well, what a who it could hurt are the shareholders of Visa and MasterCard. Right. Because their premiums on these credit card points are up drastically over the last five or six years.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's true. But then they also wouldn't necessarily be the network that people would choose.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But it could cause competition between them. But will it actually affect the consumer? I don't think so. I don't think it'll negatively hurt the consumer, but what it might do is it might help the merchant. Okay. Or it could also help the consumer. Could help the consumer too. But how does this hurt credit card points at all? Where this helps, where this hurts credit card points is because if this drops the margins down for Visa and MasterCard, then they're going to cut the benefits to basically up their ROI. So that's what literally Visa and MasterCard came out and said is that if you do this, we're going to cut the benefits.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00That's another question. Will they actually? Or are these now table stakes like you go to your coffee shop and there's a punch card there. It's like a thank you for being a member. Points are now a reason that people use these credit cards. And if the if unless there's like a solidarity attempt here where everybody cuts benefits, there's going to be some people who recognize the opportunity that they'll be able to get more users if they keep benefits.

SPEAKER_01Fair. But if they cut the benefits, would you continue to use the credit card? Yes. You would. You would never switch to debit card, even if there was no benefit to using a credit card.

SPEAKER_00There would have to be zero benefit.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00But I don't think that's ever going to be the the case. I feel like that's really unlikely.

SPEAKER_01I think it's unlikely too, but I could see a point where if it was getting cut so much and if people were carrying a balance, then you could make an argument to switch to a debit card.

SPEAKER_00Oh, I totally think if anybody carries a balance, they shouldn't use a credit card.

SPEAKER_01I totally agree.

SPEAKER_00So a lot of people do. If I would, I would I don't carry a balance and I would continue to use a credit card. All right. My next question for you, Colin, is is this AI bubble a real thing? Probably. Okay. My thesis here is: can AI become a bubble if everyone is waiting for it to burst? Bubbles feed on irrational enthusiasm, the belief that upside is limitless and the risks don't matter. And inside the biggest technology companies, that enthusiasm looks very real. They're spending staggering amounts of money to build an AI future they're convinced is coming, right?

SPEAKER_00But investors seem less convinced. Forward priced or earnings are dropping. And if we all feel like there's a bubble coming, can it actually come to exist? And is a bubble even the right term?

SPEAKER_01In theory, a bubble defined is defined by the fact that you can't necessarily see it coming. So let's define a bubble. What is a bubble? Well, a bubble to me was basically an overspend that basically overvalues. That means that there's a regression to the mean eventually in regards to total value.

SPEAKER_00I think of like blowing bubbles, like a kid blowing bubbles. Sure. And the bubble pops and the bubble is no more. Yeah. I think that is something that has happened in the past with tulips and beanie babies and pets.com. Like there are things that had a value and then that value completely went away. And I think that's what a bubble is to me. I don't know if that's something I see forming in the stock market right now. I don't know if I would say NVIDIA is going to completely go away tomorrow.

SPEAKER_00Well, it can't. I think there's too many companies that rely on it to just go away. Right. So is it a bubble then? Like in that, by my definition of things that had a value that no longer have like really any value.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think that the value of the company might be expensive, which I would argue it's not. But the fact of the matter is there's just a lot of debt behind it. So you look at the amount of debt that's going into AI right now. I think that's the main concern with the bubble. So as per Dan.

SPEAKER_00So I brought a couple charts. I thought it would be worth taking a look at what's happening in the markets right now. The first chart I want to draw your attention to, Colin, is the earnings rollover that keeps getting pushed back. This is a nice pretty green and purple. I don't know actually if you can see these colors. Nope. Uh it's forward earnings per share growth versus historical projection. Okay. All right. So what we're looking at here is dating back to 2023. You've got a green line on the screen. This is just for semiconductors.

SPEAKER_00Okay. They are like the culprits of the AI bubble build out. And you can see their actual earnings per share growth in green versus historical projections. So around 2025, we started to project that these earnings per share estimates would go down, right? They would be worth less and less and less and less. And then the AI build out started to happen, and the green line would work its way up. And then analysts and experts would come out and say, okay, well, it's going to go down from here.

SPEAKER_00And that kept happening and kept happening and kept happening. And now on the very far right, you can see with the little dots on it, that's the current growth expectation. That's essentially the new purple line. The question is, are we continuing to underestimate this earnings per share growth in semiconductors? Because what we've looked at over the last couple of years is just continuous underestimating of the success. So whether this is just the start. Right. Exactly right. Now Jensen Wong says this is just the beginning. Well, of course, he's incentivized to say that.

SPEAKER_00And I think that's where I see the irrational exuberance. It's at the companies. The companies are spending like there's no tomorrow because they feel like if they don't, there is no tomorrow. Right. But the investors, we talked about how when I went to JP Morgan, I heard the large cap growth manager speak, and he was like, Jensen's crazy. I spent an hour and a half with him yesterday. He sounds like the guys that led Cisco in 1999. They thought it was just the beginning and it was basically the end. Right. And because of that, he's making choices in his fund that are not aggressively invested in the AI build-out, meaning that I think the investor class is seeing the C-suite and saying, these guys are crazy.

SPEAKER_00I better hedge my bets. And by hedging that bet, they might be preventing things from getting out of control in some way. That's probably fair. That's the thesis. The next chart up from that, this is looking at tech versus staples. So just like within the S P 500, obviously, there's these different sectors. Technology tends to be like the accelerated growth sector that we all look at and try to, you know, that's the one where you can make all the money. And staples are the conservative PNG, Coca-Cola, things that are just meant to be steady as they go.

SPEAKER_00They don't make a lot of money. Right. So in this kind of spread, you're looking at tech as risk on, staples as risk off. Okay. What you're seeing right now, and you can, it's really kind of cool. You can see the the the forward PE spread. So the difference between the two of them dipping in, you know, 20, this is just 2025. So that's the tariff tantrum. Yep. Right. Followed by just like this major decline in 2026. We're paying less and less. The forward PE, the amount that we're willing to pay for the forward future value of a company is decreasing.

SPEAKER_00We're willing to pay more for staples and less for tech, which shows that there's not a ton of enthusiasm in future value for tech. Even though there's so much concentration right now in it. Right. Yeah. I think I saw something that 70% of earnings growth is coming from two companies. Is that right? Or was it 40%? I shouldn't quote stats without knowing. I can sound really smart if I don't second guess myself.

SPEAKER_01But yeah, I mean, I think that what this is basically showing me is that obviously we know that there's a ton of concentration in tech, but I think people are probably fairly weary of that right now if there is, I'll say, a lot of money going to staples.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I should point out this is all coming from duality research. But yeah, that's that's that's kind of my thought there, Colin. Like it's there's not a lot of enthusiasm going into technology right now, even though it feels like it in a lot of ways. The last chart I sent is a risk-on, risk-off indicator. This one dates back a little bit further, so you can kind of see COVID in it. And you can see that the in the past you have like these little orange declines, right? COVID, the 2022 bear market, tariff tantrum, start of the Iranian war.

SPEAKER_00This is basically risk on when you're above the line, risk off when you're below the line. And we're basically moving back down to a risk-off area. Interesting. So the market is not that far from all-time highs, right lows. Right? Everything more or less looks pretty good in the stock market, but everybody hates it. No one wants to pay for it. And if that's the case, can it ever get to a crisis? Or at some point, do we have to just like wave the white flag and go all in for us to get to a crisis?

SPEAKER_01I don't know. I feel like if everybody's pointing towards a crisis, the odds of there being a crisis is probably low. That's what you feel like, isn't it? Black swans are supposed to be the things that pull you down. Well, yeah, black swans, the definition is basically the fact that it is an anomaly that no one expected. Exactly.

SPEAKER_00This is not an anomaly and everybody expects it to be a bubble. I think what we might want to look at this as is more of a balloon that inflates and deflates and inflates and deflates. And at some point, it might deflate to a place that we're uncomfortable with. But I think there's actually value here in most places where there might not be value isn't anthropic. Because if you look at this company, they are, they are just their S1 came out, right? They are printing buckets of money. Yeah. Right.

SPEAKER_00But they are a closed model that charge high charges high fees for utilization to our corporate America, who is starting to look at that and say, do we need to spend this much? And do we need these two companies, because they are really driving a lot of like the semiconductor growth, the NVIDIA growth, et cetera, 10, 20 years from now, do we need these two companies to exist in order for AI to succeed? Probably not. Right? Yeah. That's kind of where I would be more cautious. I think right now things look really good for these money, these companies, but they are spending a lot of money as well.

SPEAKER_00And I don't think that AI itself is the bubble. I think that there are some companies that don't have staying power. Those are the pets.com companies of the world that are just like they can have a lack of staying power. Well, the internet itself had plenty of staying power.

SPEAKER_01I think it's a good thing they didn't go public. But ChatGPT and Claude. Well, Enthropic is going public. Yes, but they haven't yet. But I mean, OpenAI is not.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. I think OpenAI saw the writing on the wall and they're like, no, we're not ready. Right. Anthropic is going to go public in November. And it's looking like it could be a equal size to SpaceX.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's massive.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I think we've already talked a lot about whether you should or should not buy SpaceX based on other IPOs, et cetera. All of that applies to Anthropic as far as I'm concerned. Not investment advice. It's just historical recognition that IPOs frequently lose 50% of their value.

SPEAKER_01But yeah. I like it. All right. Well, interesting. You want to end with a client win? Yes. Oh, right.

SPEAKER_00It's my client win. It's your client win this week. Uh well, you brought up credit card debt earlier and carrying a credit card balance. And we had some clients that for a long time really struggled with a very expensive hobby that led to high credit card balances. And they recently worked their way out of that and are positioned to never find themselves back in that place again. And it wasn't necessarily about financial literacy, like they knew how bad it was. It was about just recognizing that this hobby was the problem, not the credit card.

SPEAKER_00Right. And by realizing that, recognizing that and making the change, hopefully it's going to lead to just better financial success down the road. So I'm really happy that these people who, these clients that had great credit and they use their points, they fly everywhere on their points. They were really still struggling with this one piece of their lives. And I'm happy to see them get out of that area. Did they have a reckoning moment? They did. What was the reckoning? I won't say. Okay. Things came to a head, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah you know, I think when you have candid conversations with your partner, it can be really uncomfortable, but it can lead to a better outcome. Me too.

SPEAKER_01All right, nice.

SPEAKER_00All right. Uh that'll do it for today.

SPEAKER_01Thanks everybody for listening. Thanks. Go vote. Yes, go vote.

SPEAKER_00The information in this material is for general information only and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. Investment advice offered through integrated partners by doing business as Co-Fi Advisors LLC, a registered investment advisor. Integrated Partners does not provide legal tax mortgage advice or services. Please consult your legal tax advisor regarding your specific situation. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All investing involves risk, including loss of principle.

SPEAKER_00No strategy assures success or protects against loss. The economic forecast set forth in this material may not develop as predicted, and there can be no guarantee that the strategies promoted will be successful.

SPEAKER_01Compound Growth with Wheeler and Colin, sponsored by Koby Advisors, reach out today. Yay!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. With Nvidia Down 30%, What Should Investors Actually Worry About Before Year End?

    Nov 16, 202650 minAudio

    Nvidia is down roughly 30% from its highs after the Jensen Huang headlines, the market has swung hard since the midterms, and year end is bringing a tax bill some investors won't see coming. It's hard to tell which of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The K-Shaped Economy, Bitcoin's Rough 18th Birthday, and the Slow-Go Years That Never Come

    Nov 9, 202645 minAudio

    The headlines say the economy is strong and the market is near its highs, but for a lot of people it doesn’t feel that way. Wheeler and Colin are joined by Dan to look at who this economy is actually working for....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. A Call From Inside the House, the Fall of FICO, and a Retirement Plan AI Couldn't Finish

    Oct 26, 202647 minAudio

    Homes cost about five times the typical household income, the average car payment has climbed by about a third in five years, and letters from the Treasury keep arriving with help that rarely adds up to much. It can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Mailbag: Is AI Truly Being Adopted or Just Distributed?

    Oct 23, 202619 minAudio

    In the race of technology, is AI truly the fastest adopted innovation in history, or is it just a case of mass distribution? If you’ve been questioning the impact of AI on the economy, your portfolio, or even just your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Best 7 Months of the Election Cycle, Apple's Push Into Your Home, and the Fall of AT&T

    Oct 19, 202646 minAudio

    Election ads everywhere, a new Apple product every few months, and maybe a stock in your portfolio that has done so well you're afraid to touch it. It's hard to tell which headlines matter for your money and which ones...

    Credit the people on this episode