Most of us have been told the same thing for years: “Always max out your retirement accounts.” But is that really the smartest move for everyone? In this episode of Compound Growth, Wheeler and Colin dig into the myths and realities of saving for retirement - exploring when conventional wisdom makes sense, and when it might not. From 401(k)s and IRAs to Roth accounts and taxable brokerage accounts, the hosts break down how each fits into a financial plan. They explore the hidden costs of required minimum distributions, the power of employer matches, and how taxes can eat away at your nest egg if you don’t diversify where you save. Colin even shares his own decision-making process from last year, when he chose not to contribute to his 401(k) - and why it actually made sense for his family at the time. Beyond the numbers, this episode touches on the importance of flexibility and choice in planning for the future. Wheeler and Colin show that personal finance isn’t about one-size-fits-all rules - it’s about asking questions, knowing your options, and building a strategy that works for your goals today and tomorrow. Follow Us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/compoundgrowthpod YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CompoundGrowthPodcast TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/@compoundgrowthpod Wheeler’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/wheeler-crowley-0a63933b/ Colin’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colin-walker-mba-6099a038/ Credits: Created By: Wheeler Crowley and Colin Walker Production, Editing and Post-Production: Tori Rothwell
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03I was listening to the CEO of Rivian the other day giving a lecture about electric cars.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_03It's actually in a podcast, it wasn't a lecture. But what he was talking about. I heard words. They were spoken. Yeah. Um, what was interesting that he brought up is everybody kept asking him, Are you too early or too early to the electric car game? Because it's got a long way to go. Adoption hasn't picked up like as much as they thought it was going to. We're kind of behind on a lot of different things in emissions, both the US and EU and China.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So anyway, he was talking about when was peak horse? And everyone was like, What are you talking about, peak horse? And he was like, When were people buying and using horses the most? And they were like, I don't know, the 1800s. And he was like, No, 1920. When the assembly line was really gaining speed and Ford Model T's were flying off the line and all this other stuff, when the car was really starting to get traction, was when horses were most popular.
SPEAKER_03And the point was now that a lot of car companies have started to divert to internal combustion again, Dodge has kind of come out and been pulling back on electric. So has Porsche, so has Ford. I mean, Ford just came out with a small truck. But anyway, companies are putting more money into internal combustion engines now. It's interesting that his take was we're basically peak combustion engine and there's going to be a shift.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And it kind of reminds me of the saying, you know, it's darkest before dawn.
SPEAKER_00So does that mean that I should have so here I think here's what really gets in the way of like the electrification of America when it comes to our just our roads, right? It's how quick these cars can recharge. People are just they love convenience. That's the whole point. That's why cars are they just convenience, right? So to go to a charging station and like say, Well, I gotta find a charging station near an errand I need to run or lunch or something, if these cars can get to the point where they can give you at least like up to you know from twenty to eighty percent in five minutes.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Or what I don't there's a barrier. I don't know what the barrier is. I don't know either. But at some point you hit a barrier where like once you get past that threshold, it's acceptable. And then I think honestly, you know, you know I drive an EV. I think EVs are are more fun to drive most of the time.
SPEAKER_03EVs are better cars, they're safer, they're more efficient, they're more practical because you get way more storage out of them, they have better technology than internal combustion cars, but the adoption isn't there, and I think another reason why the adoption isn't there is because they're more expensive currently. Yeah, and we talked about this briefly, but there's many, many cars that are sub-50,000 in terms of price, but there's very limited electric cars that are available. But to get back to your point about the charging, what's like to go back on that?
SPEAKER_03You have an electric car. How many times have you actually used a charging station? Because don't you just plug it in when you get home at night? Well, that's the thing, is that usually I do, right?
SPEAKER_00Right. But what gets in the way of a longer trip is that concern about being able to charge wherever you are. You don't want to have they call it like range anxiety. Right. Um, I used to charge. I for when we first got the car, we had, I think it was a year, maybe two years. I think it was maybe just a year of free charging with Electrify America. So I'm like all about that. I'm like, I'm gonna go charge for free. This is great. But the charging stations were horrible, they never worked. They there would be like a 15 to 25 minute delay while you're like resetting the station and calling somebody to reset the station and then trying to get it to charge, etc.
SPEAKER_00So I never ended up doing it. It was too much of a pain. It was the opposite of convenience.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, I mean, if you go back, I mean, really when was it when electric cars started to become an actual thing? Maybe 2014, 2015, Tesla started to gain more and more attraction, it started to become bigger, but then most car companies didn't come out with a legit electric car until probably like 2018-2019. BMW had the i3, which had like an 80-mile range.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And now they're starting to become bigger, but we're in such early stages. I mean, if we're talking 1920s, we're basically in like 1928.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's the thing, right? Like if you think about the Model T, which by the way, my my brother, the mechanic, has some thoughts about our comments on the history of cars. I'm excited. And he's like, So I didn't know he was listening to my podcast. The only thing he's ever texted me about the podcast was the car thing. Was that we made a mistake on the car thing.
SPEAKER_03Well, probably he'll bring up something here too.
SPEAKER_00But he was talking about how we for we neglected talk about Japan and how quickly Japan completely changed our entire car industry. Well, and that they were early on, they were like 1919, 1917, something like that. He said um, so we just like we just had an omission. And he would also say that electric vehicles are not safer.
SPEAKER_03Interesting. Yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_00Uh he told me this once, and I don't remember all the details, so he will correct me again later. Uh, but essentially, how you get into an electric vehicle in a wreck is more limited because you can get electrocuted more easily, I guess. You know what? Maybe we should ask him. He can be a future guest. Yeah, there you go. We'll talk ours with him. He will tell me about my family's very judgmental today. I walk downstairs and I'm wearing a lot of black today. Michaela's like, oh, you look like you're going to a funeral.
SPEAKER_00And then she looks at me, she's like, black, black, black, black. I'm like, oh man. And so Jeff's like, I'm gonna go. Why don't we get a little pop of color? And Michaela's like, ugh. Did they make you change your outfit? No, I'm like, I'll do a little pocket square. And she's like, You're not Terry Cruz. Like, what's it? Yeah, right. So my family's been very critical of uh my attire and our podcast. And Jess is like, I didn't, you didn't you didn't reference me correctly in the previous episode.
SPEAKER_00I brought up the idea of the pause, and you took ownership of it, and so I am officially recognizing that that was not the original recognition morning that your brother had a good point with electric cars. My brother was right uh about the well the Japanese cars, the Japanese cars.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, I mean, we never said America invented the car. No, we didn't. Mercedes-Benz in 1892, I think it was. We omitted we omitted that Japan had a huge impact, though. And Japan had an even bigger impact in the 70s and 80s when they came in and flooded the market, yeah. Um, which completely changed the entire trajectory of manufacturing in America. But anyway, yes, and Jess, we give credit.
SPEAKER_00Jess deserves full credit for all of the conversation that we had when she was a guest in our in our podcast. I am sorry for not giving appropriate credit. I do this a lot. This is actually this is a pet peeve that she's developed because towards you or in just towards no, towards me, because I will she'll say something and then I will like agree with it or present what she said as if it was my own idea.
SPEAKER_03I do the exact same thing with Kaylee.
SPEAKER_00I am not trying to do it, but it's just I don't like I don't say, you know, you're right, that's a good idea. I just say that's a good idea.
SPEAKER_03We were out with our friends the other day and we were having dinner and um they were talking about something, and I spit off a medical fact.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03And I was I don't remember what it was, but I gave off some medical fact, and Kaylee just puts her fork down. She goes, And where'd you hear that fact from? I was like, you, babe. I'm not saying I came up with this fact.
SPEAKER_00I'm not a scientist. We don't get to have ownership over everything. I feel like as you know, maybe maybe this is like a privileged white man thing where we just like say that everything is right and we act like it's all our thing.
SPEAKER_03I am I'm just a megaphone for everything else that comes through. You're so American. I know.
SPEAKER_00Welcome to the compound growth podcast with Colin and Wheeler, where we talk all things growth, from financial growth to career growth, personal development to societal progress. We explore how each layer builds on the next, compounding over time to shape who we become. Each week, we break down complex ideas and emerging trends into clear, actionable insights. Because growth isn't just about numbers, it's about understanding the world and our place in it. The information in this material is for general information only, and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual.
SPEAKER_00Investment advice offered through Integrated Partners doing business as Ko-Fi Advisors LLC, a registered investment advisor. Integrated Partners does not provide legal, tax, mortgage advice or services. Please consult your legal tax advisor regarding your specific situation. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All investing involves risk, including loss of principle. No strategy assures success or protects against loss. The economic forecasts set forth in this material may not develop as predicted, and there can be no guarantee that the strategies promoted will be successful.
SPEAKER_03Today we are not just spelling, but talking through maybe a retirement myth.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I feel like the here's here's what we're doing. We're questioning things. We're being curious, and we want to start to if there's all of these little financial rule guidelines or black and white play by these rules, paint by numbers, approximately finance, maybe some of these things are not holistically 100% always accurate.
SPEAKER_03And today we are talking about maxing out retirement accounts. Yes. Not just maxing out, but just contributing to in general.
SPEAKER_00Contributing and should you contribute to your retirement accounts. I feel horrible just saying it. No, I know.
SPEAKER_03You feel bad. You feel like like I just like kicked a rabbit or something, you know, like something bad. Exactly. With that being said, though, um, I think what would be great to do today is to talk through why you should and why you shouldn't, and going through these myths and trying to eliminate some blanket statements.
SPEAKER_00Totally agree. Why don't we lay out the foundation of this? Why don't we explain why it makes sense to contribute to a 401k or an IRA, something like that? You I feel like you have like a list of reasons. So you go first. Okay. I'll add, I'll color in.
SPEAKER_03Sounds good. Well, first off, maybe it would be important to talk through what a retirement account is.
SPEAKER_00Yes, let's do it.
SPEAKER_03Okay. So there are different forms of retirement accounts out there, but most of retirement accounts that people are generally familiar with are IRAs and 401ks. Yep. Now there's different flavors of them, like um SEP IRAs or 403Bs or a nonprofit version of a 401k. But the idea is you put money into an IRA or a 401k, you get a tax deduction, and you get tax-free growth. So if you think about it, let's just say easy math, you make$100,000, you put$10,000 into a 401k, you don't pay tax on$100,000 of income.
SPEAKER_03Now you're only paying tax on$90,000 of income. So you reduce your basically your taxable footprint, right? 100%. Yep. And then that money goes into that$401 and it grows if you invest it, which hopefully you're investing your retirement accounts that will grow over time. And then when you take it out in retirement, you A have a nest egg, but B, you will also have to pay tax on the way out.
SPEAKER_00Right. And that's the traditional traditional account. So fun question. How do you feel when somebody calls an IRA an IRA?
SPEAKER_03Um, well, I feel as if that's an IRA isn't a word, it's an abbreviation.
SPEAKER_00But there's no little dots in between the letters.
SPEAKER_03There are no dots in the in between the letters. What an IRA stands for is an individual retirement account. Yes.
SPEAKER_00So we should probably flesh that.
SPEAKER_03We should flush that out right now. It is not an IRA, it is an IRA because it is an abbreviation for individual retirement account. And a 401k is a workplace retirement plan that is offered by your company or provider. Yes. And with 401ks, you often get a match. And what a match is is when you put money in, the company will match you or put another dollar in for your contribution. So if you put 10% in and your match is 3%, they'll match you the first 3%. So if that's$10,000, the company is giving you$3,000 if you're putting in 10%.
SPEAKER_03So that's the way that a match typically works. Now there's different flavors of that as well, but just generally that's how a match works.
SPEAKER_00And I like to think of that as total compensation. Absolutely. This is money that you are owed. It's available to you. All you have to do is save money on your own. Right. Yeah. And that seems to me like the most layup, no-brainer reason to contribute to a 401k. It's essentially if you put money in, you'll be given other money. And if you don't, then you won't.
SPEAKER_03It's basically a bonus.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You know, and if you don't contribute to it, if you're not getting that match, you're leaving compensation on the table. Yes.
SPEAKER_00100%.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_03There's also Roth.
SPEAKER_00Uh-oh. So. Now, Roth is not an abbreviation. No. So now. Roth is a word. Why is Roth a word?
SPEAKER_03Don't know. It's confusing. It is confusing. It's very confusing. It might be an abbreviation, but um, I don't know. We should look this up. Tori, can you look up Roth as an abbreviation for anything? Roth. All right. So go. Anyway, we'll get back to that. Um, so Roth acts similarly to these retirement accounts where you have tax-free growth. But the difference is, is as opposed to getting a tax deduction up front, you pay tax on it. So you make$100,000, you're going to pay tax on$100,000, even if you put$10,000 on a Roth IRA.
SPEAKER_03The difference is when the money goes into a Roth IRA you're taxed up front, it grows tax-free, and your future withdrawals are tax-free. Now there's a myth that I want to debunk right away.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_03Okay. So with IRAs, there is an income threshold where once you make money over a certain amount, you can't contribute to a Roth IRA. With a Roth 401k, there is no income threshold. You could be making$20 million a year and still contribute to your Roth 401k. It doesn't matter. But you're not getting that tax deduction.
SPEAKER_00If you're making$20 million a year, it's like finding pennies in your couch cushion retirement. Yes. Yes. My favorite story about kind of like a blow-your-mind Roth situation is a Peter Thiel story. I love this story. One of the founders of PayPal, right? He got his PayPal shares put into his Roth 401k, right? And he had, or actually, maybe it was a Roth IRA, but he had PayPal shares as a founder inside a Roth IRA.
SPEAKER_00And it grew into millions and millions and millions of dollars, right? That he's never going to pay taxes on. So, like, yes, you could always, and this is where the gambling stuff comes in. You could always place a bet and say, I'm going to buy Tesla IPO in my Roth IRA. And that bet could really play out very well. And you could, you know, turn$10 into a million dollars. And you'll never pay taxes on any of that.
SPEAKER_03That's correct.
SPEAKER_00Not investment advice.
SPEAKER_03Not investment advice. Very true. With that being said, though, um, you are absolutely correct. And Roth IRAs can be one of the most tax advantageous accounts, depending on your personal situation, if it's played correctly, as can some 401ks and IRAs, too. So that's the lay of the land with what a retirement account is, without getting too into the weeds on different types of everything.
SPEAKER_00I feel like these are the most regularly available retirement accounts. There's the simple IRAs, the SEP IRAs, there's the 457 and the 403B, and there's all these other iterations, and they all have like their own subtle rules. But I feel like if you're just a modern working American these days, these are the options that are available to you most regularly.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, 100%. And for someone that's a high earner, you know, it could be argued that a pre-tax account might make sense because you're going to get a tax deduction up front. It's going to lower your income. So if you're um of the opinion that your tax bracket will be lower later on, maybe it makes sense to reduce it now by contributing. On the flip side of that, if you think your tax bracket's going to go higher, maybe you do more in Roth now. And um there are ways to plan around it, but there are some negatives to it as well. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So I actually, here's my first challenge. Should you worry about what your tax bracket's going to be in the future versus it is now? Should that even be a consideration?
SPEAKER_03I don't think so, because we talk about this, and I don't think taxes should wag the tail of your decisions. Because A, it's unpredictable. Um B, historically speaking, taxes have come down a pretty dramatic amount over the last however many years. But if you can't predict something, it's really difficult to base a decision off of that, especially when you're going off of statistical data.
SPEAKER_00You know, I think actually the best way to ensure that your taxes are lower later on is to contribute to a Roth.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, definitely.
SPEAKER_00Because then you don't pay taxes on you don't have income tax on your retirement distributions, right, later down the road. So one of the biggest things that we run into when we're doing financial planning is we have all of these, let's call it boomers or people who are approaching retirement. They've been taught to save into their 401k as much as possible. It's always a good idea. Always max it out. They don't have pensions available to them, right? A lot of them. They uh are concerned about Social Security going away, they're concerned about inflation and Medicare and Medicaid costs, etc.
SPEAKER_00So they max, max, max, max, max. And then they get to a point where they hit their required minimum distributions. Right. And they start to take out more each year than they were planning on, and every dollar that they take out gets taxed. And that pushes their taxable income up, and now they're at a higher level of of income tax than they ever thought they were going to be. Yep. So I I know I'm probably jumping the gun, but I think it's interesting to just ask questions along the way because it's you have to say to yourself, is this what's best?
SPEAKER_00Why is this what's best? And that's kind of what we're doing today.
SPEAKER_03So, not to get personal with you, but you didn't contribute to a 401k last year, right?
SPEAKER_00Yes, that is that is correct. I did not contribute to a 401k last year. Tell tell me about that. Don't don't judge me, Colin. I'm not judging you. This is a judgment. This is Planet Fitness. This is a judgment free zone here. So I had a bevy of reasons. And I'm writing about this, and I'll send this out in the newsletter as well. But long story short, last year we launched a business, right? That was a bit of a risk that we came with a disruption in income.
SPEAKER_00It came with a lot of uncertainties. So at the beginning of the year last year, I was prioritizing liquidity. I wanted to make sure that we had enough money to pay our bills and that my family could live our lives the way we'd been accustomed to, but you know, acknowledging the fact that maybe we'd have to save or spend a little bit less during this transition period. So I was prioritizing that over saving for you know 30 years down the road, Wheeler. It was all about 43-year-old Wheeler at that point. Maybe it was 42. I don't even know how old I was.
SPEAKER_00So it was a prioritization prioritization exercise for me last year. Do I want to focus on the near term, the intermediate term, or the long term? Can I do it all? And I didn't feel comfortable doing it all at the beginning of the year. As the year went on, I started to look at other ways to save money. And I started to spend a little bit more freely on things like travel. I said travel is something that's really important to my family. We've always wanted to go on this trip.
SPEAKER_00It's gonna be a 2025 trip, but I had to start paying for it now. We're planning for it now. So I started to prioritize travel. Then I started to prioritize saving for my daughter's retirement or putting getting dot my, you know, getting my daughter set up for financial success in the long run. So I prioritized getting her Roth IRA funded, which is another fun creative thing for us to explore. And looking back, what I did ultimately is say, is putting money into a 401k or an IR IRA the best thing for my family this year?
SPEAKER_00And I don't think it was. And I had some fun with numbers this morning. And I'm gonna paint a little illustration here that defends my thinking, but um why else would I do it? Right. So 401k saving versus saving into a taxable account, non-qualified brokerage account. Okay. All right, here's the scenario key assumptions annual saving,$20,000 a year for 30 years. Fund with numbers, not what I did last year, just had to have a scenario, right?
SPEAKER_00Annualized return, 8% growth account during accumulation, potentially dialing back to 5% in retirement. Right? So I did a couple of different scenarios there. But let's assume it's either 8% all the way across or 8% and then 5%. Dividend yield on the That portfolio 2% qualified dividends. So it's you know taxed at 15%. If it is in the non-qualified account, obviously you're not paying any taxes on that in a retirement account.
SPEAKER_03And just to preface, what does non-qualified mean?
SPEAKER_00So a non-qualified is a taxable account.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Doesn't qualify for special tax treatment like an ARA or something.
SPEAKER_00It's better when you explain things than when I explain things. All right. So tax rate. I assumed a high income tax. So I said 32% is the pre-retirement tax rate, and I did 24%. And this is all federal. Right. So order ordinary income tax is 24% in retirement. Then of course I assumed 15% for capital capital gains. Right. Contributions taxable funded with post-tax dollars. Right. So I paid taxes on that$20,000 that went into the non-qualified account versus I didn't pay taxes on the$20,000 going into the 401k.
SPEAKER_00Right. Withdrawals, 4% annually during a 30-year retirement period. Okay. Right. The sustainable withdrawal rate if you go on to go to the black and white finance rules. And then a state. I factored in a state.
SPEAKER_03Okay. So you did take into account your IRD tax and all that.
SPEAKER_00I took into account my death. Yeah. I worked for 30 years and then I died 30 years after that. And that's it.
SPEAKER_03Sounds good.
SPEAKER_00So the 401k would be taxed to my heirs at 24%. And then of course the non-qualified account would have a step up. Yep. Okay. So that's the scenario. Over if I if you look through those two paths, let's say you go path A, 401k. So$20,000 a year for 30 years, 8% annualized return. You start at retirement with$2.45 million in that$401K. Right.
SPEAKER_00Assuming that you continue a growth mindset there, you have$7.24 million in that account when you pass. And that's because I'm only doing a 4% distribution. Yep. Right. And 8% on growth. It's going to grow. Right. At the end of retirement, if you did the 5%, if you said, okay, I'm retired now, I'm not going to take as much risk. I'm going to try to target a 5% annualized return, then it's a$3.11 million estate. So it's the difference of$4 million. Yeah. Which is a big deal.
SPEAKER_00It's a big deal. All right. Now, taxable. Start of retirement,$2.31 million. So I have less money in my non-qualified account at the start of my retirement than I do in my$401. Okay. That is because of a tax drag on that dividend income. So talk me through what a tax drag is. So essentially what's happening there is let's say that I threw all of that money that I put into the non-qualified account and I threw it into the S P 500 index fund. Yep.
SPEAKER_00Right. I'd never sold all along the way, but I did receive dividends from the companies that I was investing in through that income or that index fund.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So every year you get a tax form that says you made a certain amount of income on this.
SPEAKER_00Just like if you have a interest on your savings account. Right. Right. Interest, dividends, you pay tax along the way. Sure. Right. So that's why I had a little bit less in that account at the end. Makes sense. Okay. At the end of retirement, I have$6.28 million in that account, the non-qualified taxable account. So it didn't grow by as much.
SPEAKER_03So just to reiterate again, so the first scenario where you put it all in your 401k, you had around 7.2 million. Right. And then if you were to split it between non-retirement and retirement, you have about a million less.
SPEAKER_00Yes. I would say, yeah, you you're hitting, you're hitting the end of my road here, end of retirement. Call it 95. Yep. Let's call it 95. Sure. And then I die with a million dollars left.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00Okay. So in that scenario, 7.24 million dollars in my 401k goes to my family in the amount of$5.5 million. So you have significant tax. Significant tax because they're taxed at their income tax rate. Right. So they would receive this account, they wouldn't pay the taxes on it right away. But as they took the money out over 10 years, as is the rule right now, then they're really netting about$2 million, maybe$1.75 million less.
SPEAKER_00Right. If I end with less in my non-qualified account,$6.28 million in my non-qualified account, my heirs, my beneficiaries, receive$6.28 million. The legit full amount. The step up gets them to a so they don't pay taxes on that. Right.
SPEAKER_03Because if you inherit something that's not in a traditional IRA$401K, you don't have to pay tax versus you do with a regular retirement account.
SPEAKER_00So that's kind of like the whole picture there. And again, that's that's saying essentially, you know, I'm thinking about me and my journey, and then I'm also thinking about what happens after at the end of my journey. The other thing to factor in is the average annual after-tax retirement income, right? Because I'm starting with more in my 401k in this scenario, but I'm paying taxes on it as it comes out. Right. Right.
SPEAKER_03Because you have to take money out at some point in your life. Now we could say it's 74, but it'll probably be different by the time you get to that phase. But either way, I'm living off of it. Correct.
SPEAKER_00So I need to take out, so this portfolio is providing about$97,000 in income after tax. So that's my net to my to my wallet, right? At the end of the day. The taxable portfolio is giving me$104,000. So I'm getting$7,000 more a year. I'm paying 15% capital gains rate taxes on that. I'm paying 24, I think I said 24% income tax on the retirement.
SPEAKER_03What's interesting about this, and I I really like this concept because we have this happen all the time with clients, where we'll have retirees come in and they'll have these fantastic, you know, portfolios that's all pre-tax. Yeah. And there's a very, very small sleeve of non-retirement stuff. Yeah. The other thing that I see being a big problem, what happens if you need to buy a car? What happens if your roof goes on your house? What happens if you want to do a renovation? What happens if a major expense pops up and you need to pay for it?
SPEAKER_03What happens if um you want to gift, you know, your kids money? Every single time a dollar comes out of that, you're gonna lose money right off the top to the IRS. Yep. And there's no way around that because you can't get deductions to lower your, you know, I'll say income from that because that's ordinary income.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I had a client once, uh, she had uh she had accounts with me and she had accounts with another advisor, and they were all uh retirement accounts. Okay. So they were all in an IRA's. Uh she wanted to buy a house and she wanted to take$400,000 out to buy a house. Her advisor said, okay, we can do that. And I said, Wait, what? Because you need$400,000, you're gonna take that all in one lump sum from your IRA. You're going to need like$700,000 from your IRA to pay for this$400,000 house that you want.
SPEAKER_03Welcome to the top tax bracket.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So, and that's you know, the very top, but it's my and this was a few years back. But the the point is thinking things through, she realized that purchasing the house wasn't worth paying$300,000 in taxes and income tax that year. And if you if you put everything into a restrictive account, then you have to deal with those restrictions down the line.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we always say, uh, you know, when you die, your money can go to one of three places. It can go to your beneficiaries, it can go to charities, and it can go to the IRS.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And our goal is to maximize the first two destinations and minimize the third.
SPEAKER_00Right. So what I'm finding in this scenario that I'm painting here is the best way to get money to my family once I kick the bucket is or out of these two options is the non-qualified portfolio. Right. The portfolio that's providing me the most income during retirement is the non-qualified portfolio. It didn't grow as much over the years. I didn't even get into the fact that I could do tax loss harvesting strategy and offset a lot of these taxes downshore.
SPEAKER_00But outside of that, it's given me the most flexibility, it's given me the most control, it's giving my heirs the most at the end of the day, and it's giving me the most income in the future. So why wouldn't I do it? I guess only if I was worried about either getting a match, which you're not giving me, Colin, uh talk about that at the end of the year. Yeah. Or uh or or I'm worried about paying taxes now. So it's really worth noting that if you were to take that$20,000 a year and put it into a non-qualified taxable account instead of your your 401k retirement account, you are paying taxes, more income taxes every year.
SPEAKER_00And it was at the 32% bracket. So cumulatively, I did pay$282,000 in that non-qualified journey while I was working that I wouldn't have paid in retirement.
SPEAKER_03But it yielded your beneficiaries an extra million dollars, roughly.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh yes, at least a million dollars. Well, yeah. And then I did also, in that scenario, pay fifty-two thousand dollars in dividend income taxes along that 30-year period. Right. But the total tax hit at the end of the day, the the 401k route, there would have been$3 million that went to the IRS, and the non-qualified account would have been one. So that's an interesting story to explore. It doesn't mean that it's what everybody should do.
SPEAKER_00It doesn't mean that's what I should do every year. Right. But it means to me that there's just no black and white, check a box, pick your path, always do the same thing without thinking it through.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I uh ran actually a very similar scenario to do to you. Actually, we tend to think a lot of that. As it as it turns out, um, I don't think that's particularly a surprise. But with that being said, um, the concept of a tax bomb is something that I find a topic that isn't very discussed very often. And what a tax bomb means, and we touched on this briefly, is there's something called an RMD, which is a required minimum distribution. When you get into your 70s, the government says, I let you take a tax deduction all along the way when you were working.
SPEAKER_03But now that you're call it 74, 75, 76, when we get older, who knows what the actual age is going to be 20 years, 30 years from now. You are going to have to pull money out of your IRA and 401ks, and you are going to have to pay tax on it. I have a very specific picture in my head when I think of this.
SPEAKER_00Okay. You know, the show family guy.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know, Stewie. Yeah. At one point, there was an episode where he lent money and then he wanted to get his money. And he was like, Where's my money, man? Where's my money, man? That's what I think the government is doing.
SPEAKER_03Basically, exactly what it is. Yeah, that's the government. Yeah. I think people have a hard time grasping the length of time the average person's retired for. Yeah. You know, like if you retire, let's just say you did a great job saving and you retire in your early 60s. If you know, you have decent health care, you have good genes, um, no major medical problems, the odds of you living to your 90s is quite high.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's and it's getting higher.
SPEAKER_03And it's getting higher. So by the time 20, 30 years from now, you know, you're talking you will be retired and living off of this money for over 30 years, potentially. In some cases, maybe it's even 40 years, depending on the timing. So that means that I'm living off of these portfolios longer than I've currently been alive.
SPEAKER_00Which can be really scary. It is. You know, it's it when we are conservative with planning, we have to assume that you're going to need your money for longer, right? So we have to assume that you're going to need more money. And really, the way to insulate people with conservative, when you're when you're building a portfolio, you're taking, you're trying to take less risk. It's the same thing with planning because there's longevity risk, right? I think what's interesting, and you bring you bring up a really good point. We've talked about retirement and maybe rethinking retirement, right?
SPEAKER_00And whether we should just fully retire. When you say live off a portfolio for 34 years, my chest tightens. I'm like, really? Like, I'm just relying on this other thing to take care of me. And that's kind of scary. It is. So I feel like what your illustration does though is give you a lot of flexibility. And I'm a big fan of flexibility. So if you've got traditional and Roth and then some non-qualified, like if you've got all these pieces, my illustration there was just comparing non-qualified and 401ks. If it was a Roth 401k, it's a complete game changer.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Personally, for me, um, I'll say in my situation, I'm a big fan of paying more taxes up front and having to defer it later. Because odds are, if you're a believer in compound growth, name of the podcast plug, uh, your money will be larger if you invest it properly later down the line. So if that's the case, then I would rather pay tax on a smaller amount of money now than have to pay tax on a greater amount of money later on in my life. I would rather personally eat it.
SPEAKER_03It's a personal preference, um, but there are a lot of reasons to argue that Roth makes a lot of sense as well. Now, you can't get an absorbent amount of money in there. There are certainly ways to do it with backdoor conversions and stuff like that, which is too big of an illustration, I think, to talk through verbally. Uh, with that being said, though, I love the idea of having liquid money in brokerage accounts, having money in the Roth, and having money in the pre-tax. Um, I heard a quote a long time ago that was talking about financial planners, and it was basically saying, you know, the average person is really good at juggling maybe one, maybe two financial things.
SPEAKER_03I think where we probably do a pretty good job and help out clients the most is painting a picture and juggling multiple different tax avenues for clients to max out because you don't just want to have one strategy, you have to be holistic, as you were saying.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I totally agree with that. And it I think it's also it comes down to uh just having options. You know, there's the bottom line here, and this is something that you know you I guess you as you grow, right? As you as you learn to think about things uh counterintuitively and just differently and and question what you've been told, you realize that there's uh the more flexibility you have, the better off you're going to be. And it's really hard to be flexible when you're existing inside inflexible rules.
SPEAKER_00I think uh you know, when you uh a lot of people will get their financial advice from a podcast, right? And they might go listen to Dave Ramsay or something, and Dave Ramsey will speak in very specific figures that never change and they're always the same. Yep. And I'm sure that helps a lot of people because what we're talking about really is what do you do when you're privileged to have options, right? And not everybody is privileged to have options, so you always have to address that. I'm also going to take the other side of this and say, here's why you should consider reading, you know, saving it to a 401k.
SPEAKER_00Obviously, getting that total compensation match is huge. 401ks also provide some protection from uh creditors, which is very important. Uh, they have less of an emphasis on your the uh the financial aid or need that you might get for school, right? Um and you saving money now can be very valuable on your taxes. You know, like I I could clip that little section that you just had and says, I'm a big fan of paying now more in taxes now. No one likes paying taxes. Of course not. And you have to assume that there's that kind of like the psychological benefit that you get from certain things.
SPEAKER_00So even just like if you put money into a 401k, it's held hostage essentially.
SPEAKER_03So 59 and a half.
SPEAKER_00There's ways to get it, but it's not, it's very detrimental. It is. You know, it's kind of like you they slap your hands with a ruler and say, no, no, you can't do that. Whereas if it's in your non-qualified account, they somebody could call you up and say, Hey, Colin, I want to buy a Ferrari. I've saved. I did what you told me I could do. I save, save, save, save, save, and now I want to spend and I see this money, I'm gonna get it. I had a client the other day email me and say, Hey, it says I've got like$2,000 of cash in my IRA. Can I get that? And I'm like, no, you're 32. You can't, you can't do that.
SPEAKER_00I mean, you could, yeah, right. And he knew that there would be penalties involved if he did. Um, but yeah, the force, the force saving, the psychological uh aspects of it, there's a lot of reasons why you do want to save into a 401k.
SPEAKER_03There is, yeah. And what we're talking about today is really optimization. What I like about uh the Dave Ramsey kind of approach in general and just some of these blanket statements is it does get the mindset across that you need to save. Yeah, you know, and that's like the main important point. You know, these things that we're talking about today are really tweaks that can help maximize wealth and maximize or minimize the amount that you pay the IRS. The fact of the matter is, though, is getting the match, getting that, I'll say free money is extremely important because I actually did this.
SPEAKER_03Um, the difference between a company having a match and not having a match is an absolute game changer.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_03Okay. So what I said was let's just say you make 100k a year. You put 10% into the pre-tax 401k, and you do that for 30 years, and you're getting historical rates of return. I said 10% annually, you know, across the SP 500, which, you know, is a relatively fine number. And I said, what happens if you didn't have a match? Where would you be at the end of this? And you'd have$1.64 million. A 3% match brings you up to$2.14 million.
SPEAKER_03So that 3% match netted you over$500,000. Over what period of time again? Over a 30-year period. So over a 30-year period, now keep in mind it could be much longer than that. You know, if you started working at 20, 22, 25, you know, you work till 65, that's really a 40 plus year rate of return, which just compounds it even more. I'm saying 30 here, it's an extra half a million dollars you left on the table.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's the other thing, is that you know, the duration of the time that you're contributing is a really big factor as well. That's this is why I was trying to find creative ways to get my daughter at age 10 started with a Roth IRA. I'm like, hey, let's let's get going on this, you know. Um, because if we if we max out your Roth IRA now, that's just gonna and we do it every year from here on, you don't need to worry about saving as much when you're 50. Yeah, right. Um, that's a really interesting way to look at it, Colin.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I I just to me, you know, when we talk through these types of things um and just go back to the optimization, by no means are we saying pre-tax is wrong. I think a blend is fantastic.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You know, I think it's fantastic to reduce your income, but don't reduce your income so much and focus on that bucket so much where you're forgetting about the fact that major expenses might pop up, where you're forgetting about the fact that your RMDs are going to be huge down the line, where you're forgetting about the fact that your kids will probably get this money one day and you don't want them to get the tax bomb. So it's keeping in mind that there's, I'll say, more buckets to save into. And then there's a bunch of myths that people might not know about. You know, we were talking with a business owner the other day, and um, we were talking through the benefits of the different accounts, and he literally goes, Man, I just I wish I could contribute to a Roth, but you know, obviously I'm I'm phased out of that, and it's just not an option for me.
SPEAKER_03And I'm like, You're not phased out, you could do a Roth 401k.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And he was like, No, I can't do that. I'm phased out. And um like, no, you're not, there's no income limit. And this was like an absolute game changer.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So know your options, know your options, have people to talk to. And should when you get questions about, you know, I I constantly get these questions, how much should I put into my 401k? It depends. Should I max it out? Maybe. Depends. Yeah, it depends. Let's let's figure out what else you're trying to solve for. Is your emergency reserve all set? Are you saved for a college education? Do you have any big expenses coming up? Are you prioritizing the future more than the now? And to what extent are you doing that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, a perfect example of this too is if a client wants to retire early. Say you want to retire in your mid-50s. Well, you can't have all your money in retirement accounts because you can't touch them really until 59 and a half. Now you can touch them, but there's a 10% penalty and you shouldn't pay that penalty.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So it's a blending act, and that's what's really important is to keep in mind that you know there's different advantages to different accounts. It's not that one is better than the other. It's you should have a holistic approach to this and think things through.
SPEAKER_00Well said. You sound very intelligent. Tori, what does Roth mean? Oh, it's named after a politician. This is like a Trump account.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's just a name. Interesting. I did not know that.
SPEAKER_00Is was his name did he walk around with all four letters? Mr. Roth capitalized. Oh, that'd be pretty cool. We're getting out of the manager's account. I wonder how many of our listeners already knew that and they're like, these idiots.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I don't know. Well, when you uh become a financial advisor, they don't necessarily talk to you about the history of the account naming. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, quick PSA before we go. Uh I've been thinking a lot about stress lately because I've been feeling a lot of stress. Okay. And you know, I was talking to my daughter last night. She's she's using Duolingo to learn Spanish because she's going to a new school. In this new school, she's going to sixth grade. That's normally a time where people start Spanish, but in this school, they've started in fifth grade. So she's trying to catch up. Right. And she reached a point last night where she was beyond her like her screen time limits, and you know, she was late in the night and she's like, I forgot to do my Duolingo.
SPEAKER_00I'm gonna lose my streak. Oh, my friends are going to see that I lost my streak. And I said to her, I'm like, you can't worry about these types of stresses. There, you know, there's there are so many stressful things in life worrying about what other people think about this Duolingo streak that you didn't even know existed two months ago because we never heard of well, you'd heard of Duolingo, but you weren't doing it. You know, it's I feel like we find these unnecessary stressors to put on ourselves. And I I'm in a place right now where I have a lot of stressors that I think are very necessary.
SPEAKER_00They're unfortunate. I can't I can't take them out of my life, and I'm looking for ways to reduce some of the stress in my life. And I just would encourage people to pause every once in a while and take stock of what's stressing them out, uh, where it's stressing them out, because I'm in you know in physical pain from these emotional and in and psychological stressors. And so I think it's really you know, stress is such a a detriment to your life. It's a killer, right? It's yeah, it it can do so much that we're you're so unaware of, and it can come out of nowhere and hit you in a way that you had no idea you couldn't see coming.
SPEAKER_00So just take care of yourselves, I guess.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I um I think that's great uh to put that message in. And with that being said, I had a ton of stress last year between the marriage and the wedding and the business and the dog and the dog and all kinds of stuff too. And I had never this sounds bad, but I I I had never really had like a visceral reaction before in my life to stress. This was like the first time like where I couldn't sleep at night and stuff like that happened. Um, what helped me get out of it was, and this may not apply to everybody, but um meditation and meditation on what's going really well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And I found that when I focused on the things in my life that were going really well, it brought more good stuff into my life. And when I sat around and was freaking out about the wedding and the bills and the dog and the business and the this and the that, it just put me in a bad spot.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And um, it may not work for everybody, but that's what helped me get through it.
SPEAKER_00I think it's reframing. It's a reframing exercise. I think that's really important. And I'm going to credit Jessica again and go back to the power of the pause, which I know she got from another person who really she respects and is influenced by. But uh it's we'll give her credit though. We'll give Jessica Jessica. Um but taking stock and pausing and acknowledging both the load that you carry and or maybe in some cases the many loads that we carry, um, and also the accomplishments that you have.
SPEAKER_00You need to do both, and both are good for your well-being. Because if you acknowledge the load, then you can say, Man, I'm really doing a lot, I'm taking on a lot right now. Maybe I should take a break from this or that, maybe I should stop pushing so hard. Is this what's best for me, etc.? And if you acknowledge your accomplishments, like, man, Colin and I just launched a business and it's it's up and running, and it went better than we thought it was going to. And and you know, there's all these things we want to do, but we're like a year and a half in. Let's just calm down. We're doing okay.
SPEAKER_03Well, it's like for Michaela too, right? Like, um, yes, she didn't hit her streak last night, but she didn't even know Spanish a few months ago. Now she's speaking another language, like take stock in the fact that holy crap, yeah, I can communicate with someone in a different country and doesn't speak English now. Yes, and she's way better at it than I am.
SPEAKER_00Not that I'm like the measuring post for her, like it's it's those other 11-year-olds that matter, not the guy who looks like he's going to a funeral. Yeah. So thanks for tuning in to episode 17 of the Compound Growth Podcast. Today we walked through some real life examples of contributing to retirement accounts, and I shared a bit about my own decision-making process around not contributing to my 401k last year. We'd love to hear what you thought of this episode and whether these real-life scenarios help make the retirement planning conversations clearer for you.
SPEAKER_00If you enjoyed it, please share the podcast with a friend, leave us a review, or reach out to let us know what topics you'd like us to cover next. Until next time, thanks for listening, and here's to making smart, intentional decisions for your financial future.
SPEAKER_02Compound Growth was Willard and Colin, sponsored by Coby Advisors. Reach out today, yay!
Nvidia is down roughly 30% from its highs after the Jensen Huang headlines, the market has swung hard since the midterms, and year end is bringing a tax bill some investors won't see coming. It's hard to tell which of...
The headlines say the economy is strong and the market is near its highs, but for a lot of people it doesn’t feel that way. Wheeler and Colin are joined by Dan to look at who this economy is actually working for....
Property tax bills keep climbing, a bill in Congress promises lower card fees while card companies warn that rewards could shrink, and everyone seems to be waiting for the AI bubble to burst. It’s hard to tell where the...
Homes cost about five times the typical household income, the average car payment has climbed by about a third in five years, and letters from the Treasury keep arriving with help that rarely adds up to much. It can...
In the race of technology, is AI truly the fastest adopted innovation in history, or is it just a case of mass distribution? If you’ve been questioning the impact of AI on the economy, your portfolio, or even just your...