Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Compound Growth

Compound Growth artwork

America's Wealth Divide: A Conversation with Bryce Gill

Mar 23, 202657 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The economy looks fine on paper. But if you're young and trying to build a life in America right now, it doesn't feel that way. Bryce Gill, economist at First Trust, joins Wheeler and Colin to explain why both things are true at the same time. Bryce breaks down the structural forces quietly reshaping who gets ahead in this economy and who gets left behind. The conversation covers the widening gap between asset owners and everyone else, why the wealth divide is less about capital versus labor and more about age, how AI is actually changing the labor market versus how it's being talked about, and why the economy has become more dependent on the psychology of financial markets than most people realize. They also get into what's really happening in private credit, why the median age of a first-time homebuyer is now 40, and what the federal budget actually tells us about where resources are flowing in this country. Bryce closes with something most economists won't say out loud: the biggest threat to the United States isn't geopolitical. It's internal division. Follow Us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/compoundgrowthpod YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CompoundGrowthPodcast TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/@compoundgrowthpod Wheeler’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/wheeler-crowley-0a63933b/ Colin’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colin-walker-mba-6099a038/ Credits: Created By: Wheeler Crowley and Colin Walker Production, Editing and Post-Production: Tori Rothwell

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01So with us today is Bryce Gill, economist at First Trust. And Bryce, you're going to have to give us a heads up if there's any territory that we can't dive into today. Feel free to claim the fifth. But I think that we're really excited to get into what's going on with the current economy with you today. We want to kind of suss out signal from the noise. One of the things that we like to do with our clients is curate, right?

SPEAKER_01Help them focus on what's the most important thing for them to see and think about, and what's just a bunch of nonsense that's just a distraction. And I feel like more and more we live in a time where there's just more noise, more nonsense, more distraction. And we have to kind of keep our eyes on the prize and, you know, try to tune as much out as we possibly can.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think I think that's right. We all have smartphones in our pockets, we all have access to abundant technology, right? And the promise of that, I guess theoretically, was we have access to all the information in the world and we'll all be smarter and better informed. And really, I mean, like what it seems like to me is this is just a way to pump like propaganda and dissatisfaction into the population. So we all kind of like fight each other. So um listen, I think a lot of it's noise. Uh, I'll try to do my best to clear some of it up and maybe give people uh a clear picture.

SPEAKER_00Certainly, it's it's never been harder to like control your information diet and and focus on the ball than it is today, I think.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think you guys do a great job of that. Brian Westbury is somebody that we've been following for a long time as well. And and uh, you know, I think that sometimes we can all get distracted. And I've seen that a little bit from time to time from my favorite economists. But yeah, let's uh let's get into it. Welcome to the compound growth podcast with Colin and Wheeler, where we talk all things growth from financial growth to career growth, personal development to societal progress. We explore how each layer builds on the next, compounding over time to shape who we become.

SPEAKER_01Each week we break down complex ideas and emerging trends into clear, actionable insights. Because growth isn't just about numbers, it's about understanding the world and our place in it.

SPEAKER_02So I guess, Bryce, probably, you know, not a ton of our uh viewers and readers know a lot about economists. So maybe we can just start off with how you became an economist and what your kind of day-to-day looks like and a little bit about what you're interested in.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I have a weird story, man. I I don't sometimes I'm like, I don't even know how I got here, to be honest. Um, I'm not I'm not like a lot of economists. I guess you could start by saying that, right? Um, but listen, uh, I guess I starting out as like a kid, right? If you were just like going way back, I was always I'd get like very obsessive. I I always wanted to like know everything there is to know about whatever subject I got focused on, right? So I think there's this always like this this internal need for understanding and to try and uh you know figure out what makes things tick.

SPEAKER_00Uh and over time, as you kind of grow up and you go through elementary school and high school, there's all these individual subjects, right? You got like science or you got math or you've got history that kind of focus on one little section uh of the world. And so what I loved about economics, and I think the first time I ever did an economics class was maybe like senior year in high school, we had like an economics 101 class. And it was the first class that really took like all these disparate subjects, right, and combined them into one sort of discipline that tried to explain why the world worked the way that it worked, right?

SPEAKER_00And there's there's plenty of, and maybe we'll get into it, there's plenty of you know, I guess, holes in the way that economics looks in the world. It's not like a perfect thing, but I think of all the disciplines, what really fascinates me about it is you know, it takes like math and history and psychology and statistics and everything and trying to try to kind of combine it together to make the world understandable. Okay. And we have a more and more uh, I guess, complex world that's hard to understand.

SPEAKER_00So it just kept sucking me in. I went to college, I got an economics degree, I graduated with that, and I was like, well, that was fun because nobody's actually an economist. I didn't even try to become one, really. Uh I, you know, I guess interned with Brian and the rest of the economics team at First Trust a couple of times, but in my head, I wasn't like, hey, I'm gonna be an economist professionally. I actually moved to Atlanta after college and took a job with ATT and was doing like enterprise business sales with ATT for a while.

SPEAKER_00And then they were sending me back to Chicago. Uh, I was like, hey, maybe I'll reach out to Brian Westbury and the rest of those guys and see if they need somebody. And at the beginning, I was just doing like data entry and dealing with compliance and proofreading documents, and you know, I was like completely useless. Uh today, I guess you just use like Chat GPT to probably do all of that, right? I think now about like AI, I'm like, you know, wow, there's not gonna be anybody in the pipeline in a lot of these positions that we're automating.

SPEAKER_00So that maybe that's a big problem for tomorrow. But uh over time, these guys let me kind of learn on the job and they taught me a lot, and I had amazing mentors, and all the people that work at First Trust are awesome, man. I feel really blessed to have had the opportunity. And, you know, over time they let me start writing and then ultimately start doing public speaking. I moved on to Texas, and uh I've kind of been doing it ever since. So uh a lot of it's just been learning on the job. I do have a formal economics degree. I went to grad school as well, but um honestly I didn't learn a ton in school.

SPEAKER_00It was more learning from Brian and the rest of the team and traveling around the country and learning from people on the ground and sort of putting it together.

SPEAKER_02So it sounds like basically, and correct me if I'm wrong here, but you're kind of like me, a rabbit hole guy, where like you get obsessed with one particular thing and then you just dive in, and that's just kind of like kind of your thing for a while.

SPEAKER_00That is very accurate, yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So I guess when it comes to that sort of thing and the economy in general, I think most people and certainly a lot of our clients ask us this all the time. And it's such like a generalized question like, is the economy good or bad? And just like, how do you approach that conversation? What is it that you're exactly looking at to determine whether or not things are good or bad at the moment? And what conditions are you kind of focused on?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I guess I mean, like the first thing I'd say in like absolute terms, right? America's a very wealthy place. Um, we have problems, obviously, like everywhere else does, but big picture, like things are good in the scheme of history, right? Um, so you know, and I'm sort of a history guy. So with that type of perspective, it's it's kind of hard to be really that upset, I guess I would say. But, you know, in relative terms, okay, I think things are really good if you're old and rich right now, and they're not so good if you're young and trying to like build a life for yourself in the United States.

SPEAKER_00I think that's the bottom line. You know, we've and maybe this is really since the collapse of the Soviet Union and sort of like the unipolar moment, but US policy just became about, you know, hey, we're gonna prioritize things that benefit asset holders to the detriment of everything else. And if you've been an asset holder, it's been amazing, right? I mean, like, bottom line, the asset markets in the United States have done very well over the past 30 years. Um, that said, like, hey, if you're just graduating from college today, right, all of a sudden AI is automating all the white-collar positions, or you know, allegedly it is, right?

SPEAKER_00And we can get into maybe some of that. But uh I I think the big picture is young people are upset because hey, old people kind of run the entire economy and you know, they're very wealthy and they have a huge and growing share of consumer spending. A lot of people talk about like the K-shaped economy. I I love this term, right? It's all over like CNBC and the mainstream financial press. Um, and it's like, hey, we have all this inequality in America, and you know, Zoran Mom Donnie wants to fix it, right?

SPEAKER_00We're gonna use socialism to fix the problem. I really don't think we have like this capital versus labor like inequality issue in the United States. I think it's really more like young versus old, to be honest. And that's where a lot of the dissatisfaction comes.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a really good point, man. Um, because that's kind of something that you've touched on already in your own journey, right? We've talked a lot about this on our podcast and wrote about it and talked to our clients about it. You know, there used to be kind of like an incubation factor to the workforce where, you know, in my background, which is even more askew in my journey to get to where I am than yours is, but my background was in screenwriting. And in that world, there was often a writer's room where you'd have kind of like a almost like an on-the-job training program for writers to come up and and become, you know, the next, the next guy to have their own TV show.

SPEAKER_01And that's kind of going away right now. And it's not just because of AI. It's just kind of as we, I think, as an economy, have learned to find more and more productivity at occasionally at the cost of labor. It feels like we've just kind of supercharged that trend. And when we talk to you know, clients who have kids in college who are either getting ready to graduate or have recently graduated, it feels like they are entering a workforce which feels challenging to them.

SPEAKER_01And I think it's it's hard for us to separate the facts from the feelings from time to time, but anecdotal evidence is still evidence, and that's what we kind of hear a lot of. So, where do you see that in the hard numbers and the hard data? Is that something that's manifesting? Is it early innings in that in that space, or is this kind of something that feels like it's gonna be worse than it is?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, man, like uh I guess I'll give you like a really big picture kind of answer. Okay. So what we're sort of talking about is like the human capital that makes us valuable in the labor force, right? So if you go back, like, I don't know, let's say 50, 60 years ago, for most people, what human capital really was is like you show up and the capital that's gonna make you valuable is not, hey, I've gone to college, right? And I have like these degrees. It's the capital's like the physical plant and equipment at a factory.

SPEAKER_00And so you show up and you have to work this plant equipment. That investment's been made by your employer, right? So you come in and you have like some basic levels of skills and you need to like show up on time and all that, but the capital exists and you're sort of like plugged into it, okay? Once globalization really ramps up and we kind of outsource a lot of the manufacturing industry, we we push everybody into the service industry, right? And now services include everything from like you're a waiter at a restaurant to you're the CEO of Goldman Sachs, right? So how do you kind of compete in this service industry?

SPEAKER_00Well, you need to get human capital that like differentiates you from your peers. Really simply put, you need to get a bunch of like education, right? Now, the difference here is when the human when the capital was like a physical plant and equipment, your employer paid for it, right? Today, the capital has been outsourced, you need to pay for it.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_00And so go to college, take out student debt, all these things, prepare people for like the knowledge work or like the high-end service industry work. And kind of what's changing now is we're automating that last thing, right? Uh, supposedly. Again, it's like the knowledge part is being automated away with AI. And so people, I guess, are kind of looking around and saying, like, hey, now what do we compete on? Uh, really, what's left at that point is like, I guess, social status and like politics and being like the most likable person or something.

SPEAKER_00So I feel like that's kind of part of what this anxiety that everybody's feeling is. It's like the need to compete. It's not even just on like grades anymore. It's like uh the social hierarchy is going to get even more important here. If I I guess like, hey, the credentials and the ability to, you know, show up with like a really impressive college degree don't matter anymore. So I and that's like kind of a very abstract way to answer your question. But no, I do think like the anxiety people feel is real here for sure.

SPEAKER_02So basically what we're kind of saying is, and and I agree with this, is that the idea of education becoming more homogenized, like at this stage of the game. And basically it's becoming more, it's becoming tougher to differentiate yourself, even with all these college degrees and everything. And then at this point, how does someone actually get ahead?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. How do you differentiate yourself in in this economy? Um, much harder to do, right? It's like personal connections, it's, you know, I guess, again, social status, it's the ability to have like your own personal brand, right? Who's got like a social media account with 500,000 followers? There's like some kind of you know, implicit value to that, right? If I was a company and I'm hiring somebody, that might be more important to me now than like, I don't know, a degree from Harvard University or something.

SPEAKER_00So things are sort of changing, right? Uh, and people feel like they can't ever keep up. And more and more of that capital that they need to invest in is being offloaded onto the individual and is no longer taken on by like society or the corporation or whatever institution is supposed to do it.

SPEAKER_02Right. So I guess if we're at a point right now where, and and I agree with you on a lot of this, that there's a seemingly like this seismic shift in the way that people and you know companies are operating at the moment. Like, if an entire generation can't access like primary wealth-building tools like assets, you know, it's a very asset-heavy economy. And if you don't own, then that's really tough to get into. Like, what are the economic consequences for when this happens in such like a concentration of wealth at the top and seemingly a generation that can't buy in?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I mean, the first thing I'd say is like, I understand people's frustration. I'll answer the second half of this question in a second, but it's never been easier to buy in, right? Now we can all say, like, hey, the assets are they seem overvalued, or like it's very difficult to buy a house, for example. But it's never been easier to buy assets. Assets have done very well. So I think you know, sort of democratized access to finance. That's like maybe the positive year. It's just you have to have like the personal initiative and the discipline to sort of index into this stuff consistently.

SPEAKER_00It's not very sexy and it's gonna take a decade or two for you to really see it pay off, right? What are the implications of for like the broader economy in this way? Well, like when all the wealth gets trapped at the top, okay, and this is not like the first time this has ever happened. And I think what's different is again is it's like generational this time. It's not just like, hey, a couple big families that are sort of aristocratic control everything. It's just, it's like the older you are, the more time you've had to accumulate financial assets or houses or whatever, and they've all gone way up in value, and you're living very comfortably in retirement, more so than any retired person in history has ever really lived, right?

SPEAKER_00On mass. Um, when that happens, you know, younger people, one don't seem to have a lot of motivation because they're like, hey, it's gonna take me till I'm 40 years old to buy a house, right? So I think it pulls some of the natural energy out of the economy. I think you start seeing people fill the gaps with like debt, consumer debt, these like buy now, pay, pay later type of companies have obviously uh had a huge, you know, uh explosion in the past couple of years.

SPEAKER_00And overall, like the economy starts growing more slowly, right? Because money gets trapped up top, like there's only a certain amount of things people want to spend all that money on. Mostly they want to spend it on more financial assets, right? So if the CEO of a company gets a thousand dollar raise versus the employee gets a thousand dollar raise, one of those people is gonna spend it on goods and services more than the other. That's kind of like the basic idea. So, like velocity of money falls, real and nominal GDP growth slow down.

SPEAKER_00Now, obviously, we've seen GDP actually accelerate recently. We can talk about why that is, but it's not consumer spending that's really done that. It's it's kind of like the massive investment boom happening in the country. So listen, you just get like a slowdown in in everyday kind of business to business, person to business commerce, and you basically see the economy age and a lot of the natural energy gets pulled out of it when the natural cycle of like, hey, old people sort of pass their reins to younger people gets disrupted, and a greater and greater share of the economy is just kind of driven by retired people.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_01You know, it's funny because we, you know, we talk about like democratizing capital. I mean, that's kind of like democratizing markets is like the Robin Hood MO, right? But, you know, people just we've had savings accounts, for example, in this country for a long time. And anybody could have one, but that didn't mean that they could put the same amount of money into the savings account. And just because anybody can buy an index fund doesn't mean that everybody's putting the same amount of money into an index fund. So access isn't necessarily the point.

SPEAKER_01It's your experience with the access. You know, we can get into the housing market, but to your point, we have to leverage excessively to do it. Maybe the housing, and some of this does come down to just like, you know, we talk about the economy is one thing, but obviously it's a pocket economy. You know, we all have different experiences. You're in Austin right now. The housing situation in Austin is significantly worse than the housing situation in the Seacoast, New Hampshire.

SPEAKER_00Yep.

SPEAKER_01And I think that that's, you know, there's there's the experiential element that's really important. But one thing that you were just talking about that I think is really interesting was if you've kind of painted the picture of it's an age barrier, right? It's basically the haves and the have-nots, there's an age band to that to a degree. And I think that's that's true. I remember, I feel like it was a decade ago, we started blaming the boomers for everything. And, you know, I don't hear as much of that. Now we've got bigger boogeyman to point the fingers at.

SPEAKER_01But if we think about kind of like the journey of human capital, and you painted it as essentially it was a tangible, you know, capital that people they physically existed, and that was what brought value to the company. And then it became a little bit intangible, right? It became about whatever your degree was, like whatever you learned along the way, et cetera. And now it's almost like ethereal. It's kind of like how good at relationships are you? Right. Because, you know, we talk about that, Colin and I, all the time.

SPEAKER_01Like, what is the future of this business? It's a relationship business, it's a communication business. It's certainly not tangible, right? If you see the experience that these different generations have had, is there anything like this that we can like younger generations can lean on and they can say, you know, the boomers had to go through this, right? The silent generation had to go through this. How is it similar? Or is this kind of like uncharted territory?

SPEAKER_00Um, I think it's more uncharted territory, right? And you guys will notice, like, I didn't even use the term baby boomers, right? Because I think it's actually a bigger picture issue than baby boomers. I like, for example, you look at it today, just like people 65 plus and their percent of consumer spending, yeah, that's the baby boomers, okay? But by 2099, okay, the share of the population 65 plus is just gonna go up and up and up, right? I think there's this idea that like, and I had this idea for a while, right, until I looked up the data.

SPEAKER_00It's like, uh, like the baby boomers all eventually die, and then the problem's fixed, right? But that's not true. The population is gonna keep aging and aging and aging. Yeah. And the share of consumer spending done by people 65 plus is gonna continue to grow and grow and grow. Today it's 25%. By like the end of the century, it's like 40% of consumer spending's done by retired people, right? If their ratio doesn't change at all and it's been growing. So I think it's a bigger picture than just baby boomers, but we've structured the economy in a way where the longer you have time to save and invest, the more and more capital you accumulate, and then you can kind of live off that capital, right?

SPEAKER_00And so, in a lot of cases, you have people that are retired, they're making more money in retirement than they were when they were working. We all know people like this, right? I think when that happens, it short cycles the sort of natural sense of like, I don't want to, guys, I'm very like free market, right? But like, so I have to like kind of grapple with some of these new things that have been happening. But like it almost like short circuits people's natural sense of like economic justice, right? That seems like a very left-wing term. Yeah, I don't mean it in terms of like AOC.

SPEAKER_00I just mean it in terms of like my intuition is when I'm in the prime working years of my life, I should probably make more money than when I'm retired. And when that's not happening, people get upset about it, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and then you get pushback to the OBB and they're like, Hey, I shouldn't be getting this tax discount. Like, why am I getting this credit? Like, I don't need this. It's you're right, it's an interesting situation. And If so much of the spending, I mean, we're a consumer society, so we spend, right? That's how we generate a lot of revenue in this company or a country. Sorry. Same thing, I guess, these days. Um. But if so much of that is coming from that upper age band, then isn't the economy kind of living off that as well?

SPEAKER_01Like, is it an issue when you know people in the 20s and 30s are struggling and aren't able to spend as much when the people in their 60s, 70s, and 80s are able to spend kind of as much as they want?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So like the benefit of this, okay, is that it's made the economy very non-cyclical. And like we've all heard like calls for recession in the past few years. Like, by the way, like first trust, we thought there was going to be one a couple of years ago and there wasn't, right? And so everybody's kind of starts looking into this, and we realize, oh my goodness, post-c pandemic, retired people became the biggest consumer demographic. They continue to grow and grow and grow. That's why last year the big mystery to me is not like the economy grew with tariffs. Okay. I never thought tariffs were going to cause a recession, personally.

SPEAKER_00It's really the economy grew even though the labor market decelerated massively, right? It's because retired people don't care about the labor market when they're making consumption decisions. And so we've got like this non-cyclical like asset holder consumer base that just spends money as long as assets do well. So the economy becomes kind of non-cyclical based on traditional indicators like the labor market. The problem here, and what kind of scares me about all of it, is like now we're just all at the behest of like the psychology of the financial markets, right?

SPEAKER_00And my personal opinion, guys, okay, is that the market looks overvalued. I don't think fundamentals are really driving this market. I think a really powerful story around AI is driving the market. So if that's true and the story falls apart based on whatever reason, all of a sudden the retired people pull back on consumer spending and we're in a recession just because the market fell, right? So it is like less cyclical when we talk about like real economy and indicators, but we almost have like this tail risk now of just like the financial markets are gonna drive everything.

SPEAKER_00And I think it could get us in like a tough situation for sure. And you naturally want like young people to be encouraged to go out and work hard and build something for themselves. At 20, it's a lot easier to envision that when hey, I'm gonna have a house by 25. If you're 20 and you you're like, hey, uh it's gonna take me till 40, but that's the median age of a first-time home buyer in the US today, is 40. Right. It's really hard to sort of envision that future and work hard for it, right? It's like very very far in the distance.

SPEAKER_02Well, yeah. I mean, if you're having to delay till 40 and you're gonna pick up a 30-year mortgage that's not gonna be paid off till you're well past retirement, hopefully, then you're gonna start asking yourself, what's the point? But on that front, like, so I was just thinking through this as you were chatting. So I've had a bunch of meetings so far, year to date, with retired folks, and we're getting their spending together uh for the year. Their spending has gone up when they retired, and they're doing more travel, they're spending more time with kids, they're gifting more, whatever it might be, buying the dream car they always wanted, um, whatever.

SPEAKER_02But I guess my question to you is is that really much of a change? Because having been in retirement planning for a long time, it's very common that people increase their spending when they do actually reach retirement. Like, is that actually that much different?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I'd say it's not different on like in an individual basis, right? It's in it's different now on like the mass scale that it's happened. Okay. It's like we can just look at the consumption share of people 65 plus, you know, in 2012, they were the smallest consumer demographic. Today they'll they're the largest. It's not just because like more people are 65 plus, like their actual per capita spending has gone up. And so now what you've got is like basically retired people, you know, doing better than they've ever done on average in retirement in human history.

SPEAKER_00I I don't know another time where this would be the case. Maybe we could point to like some tribe where the elders kind of controlled everything. I don't know, right? I'm not, I'm not that, I'm not that big into anthropology, but you know, it does seem like sort of unique to me. Um, and I think it's short circuiting some of like the natural progression that's supposed to exist between generations in the economy, right? And I think this is reflected in the fertility rate, it's reflected in young people's anxiety about the future, it's it's reflected in a lot of different places.

SPEAKER_00So it's really the mass scale that it's happened on. And by the way, like maybe this shouldn't matter that much, uh, except for hey, the entire government as it's currently structured in the United States, like federal government, exists to basically send resources from young people to old people, right?

SPEAKER_02So we got what do you what do you what do you mean by that? Can you can you unpack that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so like Social Security, Medicare together are probably 50% almost of the federal government's budget, right? The two biggest single components. Then you add interest on the debt. Okay, interest on the debt's like a trillion dollars a year, something like probably 15% of federal spending, I would guess. So you add those three things together, you're like 65-70% of all the money that the federal government spends on an in an average year is basically payments to retired people, right?

SPEAKER_00They get social security, they get Medicare, and then interest. Maybe I'm a little bit more playing for fast and loose with that, but most of the people that own treasuries are older individuals. So again, like the idea behind Social Security was like, hey, people retire, they don't have an income, they're relying on family, or they're relying on whoever to take care of them. Let's institute something in society to support retired people. Well, we're still it's eaten in the entire budget, and now it's just going to the wealthiest demographic in the country from the less wealthy demographics.

SPEAKER_00So it's become like, you know, this is what drives the debt and all the other problems at at the federal level.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I I think you're you're right, but it's it's kind of supporting two demographics. It's not just the older Americans, but it's also the wealthiest Americans, right? Because they're also more likely to own the treasury. So they're they're the ones that are receiving the bulk of that interest. The people who have money are the ones who are receiving the bulk of the interest. And then, you know, what's tough is because again, going back to I don't know what the right thing to call this economy is when it comes to like, you know, senior citizens who are relying on social security, because some of them are, some of them aren't.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01But like there has to be, in my mind, some solution that differentiates between the two. Um, because social systems exist for a reason, but that reason doesn't exist for everybody. So that can be, I think, tough for us to navigate.

SPEAKER_00No, I think the easy way to do that, right, is you means test benefits at the top. I think it's a pretty, you know, we'll have to fight about it, obviously, but like it's not easy, but it's simple, right? Like the solution to it. Um I think there's a lot of resistance against that, obviously, because people want to receive their social security benefits. I get that. But when you look at like when legislators will talk about this, or there'll be debates in like the policy space about means testing social security, what they always talk about is hey, we don't want to touch this because right now it's a universal program and there's a universal buy-in, right?

SPEAKER_00I think there's a fear that you means test this, all of a sudden you lose support for the program at like the highest levels of society, and you start seeing like them go after and like kind of trying to disassemble the safety net that exists for everybody, right? So listen, we need to find a way to avoid that happening, right? But I don't see any other way around it uh at this point. You know, something needs to be done. We can't just send all the federal budget to like the richest, most well-off people in the country, right?

SPEAKER_00It doesn't make sense.

SPEAKER_01And you can't just expect altruism to save the day either, right? It's you know, there are certainly people that feel like they paid into it, so they should get it back. They think of Social Security as a savings account or like a you know a payback system. And it it is to a degree, but it is supposed to be spread out, right? It's it's not supposed to be concentrated. Just to push back, though, on the idea that you were kind of referencing the economy as almost like a vibe economy. Like if we're essentially driven by market mentality and animal spirits, which I I I see that so much these days.

SPEAKER_01We've we've talked a lot about the rise of the retail investor and and how much they can actually directionally impact the market these days. And algos will respond to like uh, you know, a trending article about aid AI doomerism and markets. Yeah, right. So it's there are all these factors that are not like just, hey, let's look at the data, which makes it tough. But at the same time, there's an army of financial advisors out there that are coaching their clients not to panic when the markets don't support their ideas.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, if you have people like Colin and myself working with the, you know, the older clients that have either a bucket approach to, you know, spending retirement or just like somebody they can call without hitting a the panic button, is there a reactionary element to that where they'll see the markets go down and they'll be like, oh my gosh, I gotta sell, or will that not happen? Who is actually gonna be selling if we see a prolonged, you know, 30% decline that's not just like eight, eight months?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I mean it's a great point. I think, listen, financial advice has never probably been more ubiquitous than it is today, right? And uh they do have access to someone talking them off the cliff. That's never existed in such a widespread sense before. Ks have never been as big as they've been before, right? Every two weeks, okay, the market's down 40%. I'm still putting money into my 401k, right? So there's all these stabilizing factors that exist around the market. I think for me, though, I look at it and say, hey, market goes down because of AI.

SPEAKER_00Okay, my brokerage accounts down 30% or something. I don't know. We're just spitballing numbers, right? I probably look at that and say, hey, maybe I should take one less vacation this year, or maybe I'll delay remodeling my kitchen. And at the same time, you know, the large AI companies probably pull back on CapEx at the same time. That's that's enough to probably give us a recession in the United States by itself. I don't want to overstate it, right? It's not gonna be 0809. Though when you look at like some of these private credit funds, right, it kind of already does look like 0809.

SPEAKER_02Oh god, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Like blue owls out like 65% or something.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And we can maybe talk about that in a second, but big picture, that's like where I see the big the risks here. Like the United States economy very stable. Consumer spending is very top heavy, right? Uh top 10% of incomers do like 50% of consumer spending. Retired people do 25% of consumer spending. These are all stabilizing factors. So it's positive in that sense, but it does make like the wealth effect more of something to contend with. And we've only really heard about the wealth effect in a positive sense.

SPEAKER_00The Fed would always be like, we're cutting rates because the wealth effect boosts consumer spending by some percentage point amount, right? Today I think the negative wealth effect is something we actually have to contend with uh in, you know, probably a way we never have before.

SPEAKER_02So on that, on that front, Bryce, and uh you brought up two things that I feel like we could have a whole episode about, which is private credit and then also AI. But um, I've been keen to dive into the AI because we've been kind of dancing around it a little bit. We've seen a ton of articles lately about, you know, potential smoke with open AI overspending, you know, obviously the build-out of huge infrastructure and the spending that's going on there. What's your take on AI at the moment?

SPEAKER_02And is this, I don't want to say a bubble because that's a word that's thrown around a lot, but is the hype justified in the current market? I just threw it out anyway, but is the hype kind of justified in the market? And do you think there's fire behind the smoke?

SPEAKER_00I mean, my personal opinion is I don't think this justifies like, you know, if you look at the fundamentals, I think this looks very frothy and I think it looks like a really powerful story with not a lot behind it. Um, the capital spending is is like great in the sense that it boosts the economy and it creates jobs and like you know, whatever something bad happens with AI, all the data centers still exist. We can use them for something else, right? But it seems to me like I don't know how they're gonna monetize all this stuff.

SPEAKER_00Um, when I look really at like the market that's being created for AI here, what have we seen really in the past like couple of weeks? The stocks that are getting hit the hardest by this are like existing software companies, basically. I I think basically what we're gonna see happen here is AI is gonna cannibalize other parts of the software market. Uh similar thing happened with like the coders, right? All of a sudden, hey, I can do four times as much coding with half the people. The Silicon Valley guys see this, they're like, this is incredible.

SPEAKER_00This is the best piece of technology that's ever existed, and it's gonna do this in the rest of the economy. I think they're just extrapolating there. I think it's much harder to automate other areas of the service sector than it is to automate like coding, right? It's obviously AI would be good at writing computer language. It's a computer, of course, it's gonna be good at that, right? Obviously, it's gonna be really good at creating better software faster. But can it really automate away like a third of jobs and like you know, automate a huge chunk of the service sector in the United States?

SPEAKER_00I'm much more skeptical about that. I think it's gonna be really difficult to achieve that. And you look at the amount of money they're all spending, I think their idea here is like, hey, I have to spend because the other guy is spending, and I'm, you know, if I don't spend, like, I'm gonna get left behind, right? And part of this too is downstream of like there's a national AI race in competition with China, who's also going for AI, right? So, but these individual companies, I think their idea is like there's gonna be a winner-take all sort of AI platform here, and whoever wins is is the top dog.

SPEAKER_00The problem is, is like the reason we love tech, at least I thought, okay, is that it's asset light, it has massive revenue per employee, and there's no marginal cost to produce, right? It's like a dream business because of that. AI is changing all of that, right? It's not asset light anymore. I mean, it's still high marginal revenue for or revenue per employee, obviously, but there's huge marginal cost to produce. I gotta spend$200 billion on a data center so I can offer the exact same thing with basically like the Google AI thing at the top of the search results, which I don't even use, right?

SPEAKER_00So I I see them taking out a lot of balance sheet risk. I don't really see the service that they're offering getting much better. And like if really like AI for most people is a is a chat bot, we have a massive capital investment to offer like a commoditized chatbot to everybody. That's like the airlines as a business. That's not like this revolutionary new like business model that's automating everything away. So I'm I'm kind of more skeptical here. I think it's great for the economy short term, but um, and we'll use the data centers for something, right?

SPEAKER_00But uh, I I worry about them being able to monetize all this. Open AI is the obvious, sure, but worst case one. Because it's not like Microsoft doesn't have a core business to fund all of this with.

SPEAKER_01Uh right, but it's looking like the MySpace of AI, right? It is very much so. It feels like it's the old, it's the old name, and the first first move advantage seems like it's gone right now.

SPEAKER_00I think that's totally right. You know, that's the problem with software, right? Is like, hey, I can very quickly create a better software than you have. And that's what's happened to all these other companies. They're all getting disrupted by like AI potentially could write software better than this.

SPEAKER_01Potentially, though, right? I think the thing is that people are are really focused on what could happen in a like excitement or enthusiasm, to your point, for AI, without recognizing that these are enterprise services that are not easily replaced. You know, you're not replacing open heart surgery on your CRM because you can create your own quad CRM. Like that's not what is going to happen. And it at least it can't happen quickly. And in the time that it takes to happen, I feel like these software services will just get better at providing service.

SPEAKER_01Well, yeah.

SPEAKER_02And then it's like on top of that, we always talk about this too. Wheeler and I go back and forth on this. It's like you have so much hype around this, and it feels like so many people just forgot about fundamentals. And eventually you need to make money off of this. Like you can't just unlimitedly spend to build out this system if there's no capital generation behind it. And then from a business perspective, yes, we use AI in our business and it has streamlined a lot of our processes. But with that being said, it hasn't necessarily saved us a ton of time because we're having to interact with the AI all the time to generate a product.

SPEAKER_02I think the output is probably better because of it. But that doesn't mean that we'll going from working an eight-hour day is now going to working a two-hour day because all the rest of the stuff is taken care of.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we're actually just hiring people to do more and better work with AI. Yeah. So it's uh it's doing the opposite of what we were concerned with. And you brought up froth. You know, I think when people were talking about the bubble that Colin wasn't going to mention last year, they were really focusing on the hyperscalers, right? Or, you know, just the AI-specific companies, or even some of the software companies that were just like talking about AI all the time. And now the froth has come out of a lot of that area. I mean, you look at Microsoft as like negative over the last year and a half or two years or three years, you know, depending on when this episode airs.

SPEAKER_01And uh now you see the froth move into you know, the quote unquote halo assets or the intangible or more the more tangible assets, right? And you see like the PEs for John Deere and Caterpillar scale up, or you see, you know, Costco and Walmart inflate, and you see kind of like these vacuums, you know, in gold and silver kind of vacuuming out the the risk appetite. And it's it feels like if this is that bubble that shall not be named, it feels like maybe it's just different than what people expected it to be.

SPEAKER_01And it could be like what we see in 2022, where it was kind of like a rolling recession that didn't quite exist. It wasn't actually a recession, but you saw you know the layoffs hit different sectors, you saw the decline in asset value in different sectors, and maybe the software has just been hit first. But I don't know if I think it I don't see froth in the software. I don't you don't see froth in in the Nasdaq really right now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think you know, maybe like the optimistic view here is we we're having this big rotation, like the kind of market fundamentals are improving here. There's no question about that. And maybe like the AI bubble was again in like the private credit space or something. They're all investing so heavily in these data centers. And like the beautiful thing about private credit is like 08-09, right? Like, we had banks obviously lend for these mortgages that were subprime and people couldn't pay them off, and there's all this fraud and all this stuff, and then the whole banking system kind of collapses.

SPEAKER_00We've basically taken all the risk out of the banking system. They're not really making like risky business loans, right? They're making mortgages, you know, they buy treasuries and then do a little consumer lending on the side. You know, we basically just outsource all the risk to private investors.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So, like, hey, people are down 60% because they invested in private credit, but like the rest of the economy is pretty much fine. You know, maybe that's where all the AI froth happened for the most part, and we've already seen it all wash out, right? Like, that's the most optimistic I could kind of be about it. I do think that's the benefit of private credit, right? It's like let private investors that can afford it take the risk.

SPEAKER_02I can't tell you the amount of people that have come into our office over the last two to three months to pitch a private credit fund. Two to three years, even like it's it's nuts. I mean, it just seems like everybody right now is so hot on private credit, it's it's alarming. And like this isn't strictly related, but it just seems like it's just a business that's so propped up on some of these things that it just scares me a little bit. But to your point, like it seems like offloading all the risk into one particular sector.

SPEAKER_02And if that one blows up, it does affect a very limited amount of people, which is, to your point, a good thing.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I, you know, I think that's been the big trend in finance over the past few years, is like the 6040 wasn't really working because of treasury volatility or whatever. And so, like, hey, let's get you access. To this new bucket of assets, alts, and you know, that includes private credit and includes private equity and all that. We're gonna like democratize the private markets, right? Democratize alts.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. So we're democratizing again, right? Um, and I I like kind of like the idea in theory, first of all, I'll say that. But the problem here is scaling it, right? Like, and I don't know how it is with you guys in your area of the country, but like the amount of money private equity is paying for like small businesses, and you know, like, why is my barber shop being bought by private equity? That doesn't really make a lot of sense to me, right? So hoover up anything they can and repackage it and like push it out the door.

SPEAKER_00And I I think like they're gonna have a ton of problems scaling this. Like maybe they'll eventually be able to figure it out, but I think we're just trying to grow maybe this this asset class too fast in the industry. That that's like sort of my working theory on it. And like the data centers were all tied up in this, and you know, there's there's a lot that a lot of things going on, but I think that there's problems with scale here for sure.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So how do we move forward, right? Like I think it's what's what's fun about economics is you get to explain what happened after, and that's the the easy part or the the kind of like understanding element to it. Um, I feel like there's like a daily, you know, be here now prescription that people could follow where they just try to figure out what matters and what doesn't. I think it's like it's if we all know that it's impossible to predict the future, and we have the best ideas of how we think things are gonna go, and and we're frequently wrong, and that's why we just try to stay flexible, right, and keep our options open.

SPEAKER_01But how do we think about like focusing on what matters and what's noise? What's what are the indicate indicators you watch? What do you rely on for your information diet to shape your thinking?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I people ask me this all the time. I wish I had like a better answer. I just I sit on planes all the time, right? I'm traveling constantly for this job and I just try to read as many books as I can. I think books are by far the best way to kind of get information. If you're interested in a subject, like you should just buy a book on it. And preferably it should be a book that was written five years ago or more, because if it's a book about a current topic that just came out, there's gonna be all this political narrative that's injected in there.

SPEAKER_00Read like a long-form kind of exposition of what you're interested in. I think that's number one. Number two is I'm lucky, guys, because I'm an economist. I've been trained to look at like actual government data, right? And understand these indicators a little bit better. So those are the two things I think that make up most of my information diet. Honestly, I try to avoid the news as much as I can. I I think there's important things in the news, obviously, but 90% of it is just like rage bait almost.

SPEAKER_00So I don't think it helps you. I there's this book I read years ago called Stop Reading the News. It's by like a Danish psychologist. It's like 70 pages long. I think everybody should read it. Um, and it talks about just like, hey, modern news diet is just making you anxious and stupider. And here's all like the scientific reasons why. And this was like basically written before social media really existed, right? So you can understand how much worse it would have gotten since then. Um yeah, it's just it's about honestly controlling the amount of information you take in, and I'm still not even good at that, right?

SPEAKER_00We're just constantly on phones and everything else. So long form, maybe if you can read some actual government data that comes out. I know most people aren't probably gonna do that, uh, but just read books. Books are the best thing to do.

SPEAKER_02I uh I'm in the process of, I don't know if you're a Tim Ferris fan, but um, I was rereading the four-hour work week and I came to uh a little excerpt last night that was talking about him with the news, and he was literally saying the exact same thing, which is the moment I stopped watching the news, I started making better decisions. And he was just kind of talking about thinking things through versus reacting to things, informing your own opinions and having the time to sit down and think was one of the biggest benefits that he had to streamline his life.

SPEAKER_02And to your point, I think you're being pushed a lot of stuff for a reason, and it's probably trying to influence you one way or another. And I think probably the best thing about being an economist is having the ability to kind of make your own decisions and directions and trying not to be influenced by other people.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, it's funny because I feel like even just, you know, stop stop reading the news, stop paying attention to the news is kind of that's a difficult ask, right? I think it's maybe limiting how much of it you consume to a degree or or just trying to stay focused on the facts. I was thinking about this because of the the USA men's hockey team winning the gold this year. And the last time that happened was Lake Placid, 1980. The country was working its way out of stagflation.

SPEAKER_01Like economically, we were not in a good place. And uh people latched on to that story, especially, you know, beating the USSR. It wasn't even the gold medal game. We always we always like focus on that. But when they beat Russia, it was semifinal final game. But that was like celebrated like enormously, and it was it was a great game, and it was a great moment for the country. Uh we have like a similar struggle right now. It's not stagflation by any means, but it's it's a you know, there's economic uncertainty.

SPEAKER_01Uh we had a amazing gold medal game that people were really behind until like social media started like making it political. And I'm just trying to point out the difference between those two experiences because there was no opportunity for that pushback, for that fallout following the 1980 game. And I wonder how things would have been interpreted differently if there was. And is it just like this this impossible accent?

SPEAKER_01Like, there's so much content at our fingertips all the time. If I just had a phone without all the internet, I would probably have a more peaceful life right now.

SPEAKER_00Totally, I totally agree. And I think like uh, you know, maybe that that's that story you just kind of told about winning gold in hockey, I think it's reflective of, you know, like a loss of national identity or like an ability to sort of all kind of appreciate something together. Like we're running out of these like unifying almost rituals or like you know, events, even like you have the Super Bowl, right? And like the it's really just a controversy because it's a it's in Spanish, right? So I I think there needs to be like a concerted effort in the United States to have like consistent kind of events that we all appreciate together.

SPEAKER_00And I don't know if it's like hey, the powers that be are let's push a political narrative into this and make them all fight each other, or if it's just like we've you know basically turned information into the Wild West, it's not just Walter Cronkite anymore, given like the one line that everybody agrees with. It's like you've got people from all different like walks of life saying their piece on it. Uh, but I I hope Americans become more and more kind of cognizant that we need these like unifying events and and like topics and things to kind of hold us all together culturally because we're obviously not bound together by like religion or race or whatever anymore, right?

SPEAKER_00So we need something else to kind of unify everything together. I think we need to be more intentional about this stuff, and there needs to be like a certain amount of this needs to be kind of sacred in like a secular sense, uh, because we got like almost 400 million people in this country, right? And we're not all gonna agree on values, so we gotta at least agree on men winning gold at the Olympics, is good.

SPEAKER_02I feel like that should be pretty Yeah, just as women winning gold is good, right? Like winning gold is good. Gold is good. So, Bryce, on that front, you know, we're coming up to an hour here, and um, we appreciate your time. It was awesome having you on. We usually ask a closing question to most of our guests. Our question for you, given everything that we talked about today, is what's the one thing that you wish more people understood about the way the economy works?

SPEAKER_00Hmm, that's a good question. I guess uh I would say, listen, there's a lot of intangible things about the economy that like we can't really measure, right? That that's the problem here is like I mentioned at the beginning, economics has limits, right? Uh, and we're all focused on like, hey, what can we measure with like empirical data? I think the things that we measure right now are pretty good. Like, we we're materially very wealthy in the United States. It's the things that we can't measure very well that have sort of been neglected, right?

SPEAKER_00Like community, young people being able to buy homes, uh, people having an investment in the consistent culture in the nation. Like all these sort of like intangible things just became less and less, I guess, important societally because they're hard to measure. We need to do a little bit better job, like trying to measure these things and investing in them, I think, in the US, if we want to continue to be a thing over here. There's so much talk about geopolitics, there's so much, so much talk about Russia, Ukraine, Israel, like Iran, all this stuff.

SPEAKER_00Honestly, like the biggest problem the United States has is just like internal division. So I hope, again, we can find some ways to just find common ground with each other. And I think we can. I travel all over this country, I talk to people in every state. Like, it's the digital world that divides us, in my opinion. When I meet Americans all over the country, like everybody's pretty cool and I get along well with pretty much everybody. So um, I think a lot of this is just like a fever dream from like integrating technology in our lives and not knowing how to deal with it yet.

SPEAKER_02We agree. I mean, we always talk about when we talked about this at the very beginning, being pulled down rabbit holes. And oftentimes you can get pulled down to rabbit holes that take you to places that aren't necessarily the happiest, whether you're looking at politics, something economic related, or whatever it might be. And I think that's definitely a fair point that building the community back up and having that camaraderie as a country is certainly something that I think we should all be striving for.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's the intangible thing that's like more powerful than anything else, right? It's what really made the United States into a superpower at the end of the day. So I think it's uh something pretty valuable to get back.

SPEAKER_01For sure. I like the uh the message of unity, Bryce. So thank you very much. Bryce Gill, everybody. Bryce, where's the best way for people to read and hear what you have to say? Where should they find you? Are you on LinkedIn? Where do we where do we get more Bryce Gill?

SPEAKER_00I mean, you the first thing you do is just Google First Trust, subscribe. We write all these pieces on the economy. Um, everything's one page or less. Easy to read, easy to share. It's all free. I'm never gonna send you a 10-page paper on the yield curve. If you're interested in this stuff, I think that's a good resource, right? I also have a LinkedIn, I post everything on. So um, that's a great place to find this stuff if you don't want it in your inbox.

SPEAKER_02Perfect. Awesome, Bryce. Well, thanks so much for joining us today. It was a great conversation. We'll have to have you back on again and uh enjoy the warm weather out in Austin. Absolutely, guys. All right, talk to you soon. Yep. Thanks.

SPEAKER_01The information in this material is for general information only and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. Investment advice offered through Integrated Partners, doing business as Ko-Fi Advisors LLC, a registered investment advisor. Integrated Partners does not provide legal, tax, mortgage advice or services. Please consult your legal tax advisor regarding your specific situation. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All investing involves risk, including loss of principle.

SPEAKER_01No strategy assures success or protects against loss. The economic forecasts set forth in this material may not develop as predicted, and there can be no guarantee that the strategies promoted will be successful.

SPEAKER_03Compound Growth with Wheeler and Colin, sponsored by Kobi Advisors. Reach out today. Yay!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. With Nvidia Down 30%, What Should Investors Actually Worry About Before Year End?

    Nov 16, 202650 minAudio

    Nvidia is down roughly 30% from its highs after the Jensen Huang headlines, the market has swung hard since the midterms, and year end is bringing a tax bill some investors won't see coming. It's hard to tell which of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The K-Shaped Economy, Bitcoin's Rough 18th Birthday, and the Slow-Go Years That Never Come

    Nov 9, 202645 minAudio

    The headlines say the economy is strong and the market is near its highs, but for a lot of people it doesn’t feel that way. Wheeler and Colin are joined by Dan to look at who this economy is actually working for....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Property Taxes on the Ballot, Visa and Mastercard Under Pressure, and a Bubble on Watch

    Nov 2, 202646 minAudio

    Property tax bills keep climbing, a bill in Congress promises lower card fees while card companies warn that rewards could shrink, and everyone seems to be waiting for the AI bubble to burst. It’s hard to tell where the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. A Call From Inside the House, the Fall of FICO, and a Retirement Plan AI Couldn't Finish

    Oct 26, 202647 minAudio

    Homes cost about five times the typical household income, the average car payment has climbed by about a third in five years, and letters from the Treasury keep arriving with help that rarely adds up to much. It can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mailbag: Is AI Truly Being Adopted or Just Distributed?

    Oct 23, 202619 minAudio

    In the race of technology, is AI truly the fastest adopted innovation in history, or is it just a case of mass distribution? If you’ve been questioning the impact of AI on the economy, your portfolio, or even just your...

    Credit the people on this episode