Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Compound Growth

Compound Growth artwork

Who Really Owns the Debt, the Worst Trade of the Last Five Years, and Mark Cuban's Equity Tax Idea

Aug 31, 202647 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Wheeler opens this week's headline discussion after a conversation with his partner Jess, who came away from an NPR Up First segment thinking that countries lending the U.S. money are charging higher interest rates because the U.S. looks riskier - and that the resulting interest payments now exceed the national defense budget. The hosts use it as a jumping-off point to explain how U.S. debt actually works: the government issues new Treasury bonds and notes to the open global market, and the market, not a handshake with any one country, sets the rate. A chart breaking down ownership of the national debt shows foreign governments and investors hold about 24% (Japan, not China, is currently the largest single foreign holder), U.S. private retail investors and mutual funds hold 28.5%, intragovernmental accounts hold 20%, the Federal Reserve holds 11%, and other U.S. banks and state/local governments hold 8% each. The hosts push back hard on the idea, visible in social comments under a post about Japan's holdings, that a foreign country "owning" U.S. debt gives it leverage over the country: a Treasury bond is a contractual loan with a term, a rate, and an expiration date, not a geopolitical hold. What actually matters, they argue, is whether the U.S. ever defaults, not who's holding the paper. That leads into the bond market itself: the 30-year Treasury yield spiked to 5.53% last week, reportedly its highest level since 2007. The hosts connect it to a separate headline about total margin debt hitting an all-time high near $1.5 trillion, arguing neither figure is automatically bad - margin debt rises naturally when a rallying stock market inflates the value backing it, and a high yield mostly reflects what the market is pricing today rather than signaling a crisis on its own. They also point to a chart tracking the dollar against Bitcoin and gold: when the new 30-year issuance and yield spike hit last week, Bitcoin jumped roughly 20% (from about 64,000 to about 78,000) and gold rose 5-6%, while the dollar index slipped about 1%, with the hosts noting Bitcoin's chart currently tracks gold's pattern more closely than the Nasdaq's. From there, the conversation turns to a rough stretch for conservative portfolios: TLT, the 20-plus-year Treasury bond ETF that was a popular "safe" allocation heading into 2022, has returned roughly -7.68% annualized over the last five years, and even the broader Aggregate Bond Index is close to flat over the same stretch - meaning bond investors have effectively lost ground to inflation while the stock market kept climbing. The hosts use it to unpack what "risk-free rate" actually means: mortgage and auto loan rates track long-term Treasury yields, not the Fed's overnight rate, and with 30-year Treasuries near 5.5%, the bar for stock returns to be worth the added risk is that much higher. The back half turns to a Mark Cuban tweet arguing corporate tax rates should rise for companies that don't share equity with employees and hold steady for those that do, tying it to broader frustration with wealth disparity. The hosts are skeptical it would change much in practice, but agree the underlying wealth gap is real: a chart tracking indexed real wealth since 2019 shows higher, equity-heavy incomes pulling away from middle, real-estate-heavy incomes and lower, cash-heavy incomes, and the hosts cite reporting that roughly 4,400 SpaceX employees became millionaires off the company's valuation gains, with about 400 of them passing the $100 million mark. Cutting the other way, a Bank of America chart the hosts flag as a "narrative buster" shows after-tax wage growth for lower-income households at 4.1% year-over-year in June, actually outpacing the 3.4% rate for middle-income households, while higher-income wage growth dipped, even as a separate consumer sentiment reading cited on the show shows sentiment dropping sharply, with only about 8% of consumers surveyed expecting their wages to outpace inflation over the next year. Wheeler ties it together with a detour into the French Revolution's three-estate voting structure as a historical parallel for feeling unheard, and the two close on a lighter note, borrowing a bit from Ted Lasso about the unifying power of a common enemy (they land on AI, only half-joking). They land on the idea that the goal isn't erasing wealth inequality entirely, but making sure lower- and middle-income households have a genuinely good quality of life, while acknowledging that's a feeling the data alone won't fix anytime soon. Sources: NPR, Up First (referenced on the recording) National debt ownership breakdown chart (referenced on the recording; original source not specified - recommend confirming before publishing) Y Charts, dollar/Bitcoin/gold comparison (referenced on the recording) Bank of America, wage growth data, "Exhibit 4" (referenced on the recording; not independently verified this session) Mark Cuban, public post on corporate tax rates and equity sharing (referenced on the recording; recommend confirming exact wording before quoting publicly) Consumer sentiment index data (referenced on the recording; not independently verified this session) Follow Us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/compoundgrowthpod YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CompoundGrowthPodcast TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/@compoundgrowthpod Wheeler’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/wheeler-crowley-0a63933b/ Colin’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colin-walker-mba-6099a038/ Credits: Created By: Wheeler Crowley and Colin Walker Production, Editing and Post-Production: Tori Rothwell

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01The conservative investor continues to get hosed, I feel like. It's very true. I was thinking about this with TLT. So TLT is the 20 plus year treasury bond to ETF. And that was leading into 2022, like a really strong uh allocation in your portfolio. Yep. If we look at over the last five years, the annualized return of TLT is negative 7.68%.

SPEAKER_00So if you're a conservative investor, you want to hold on to your money. You walk in, you say to a financial advisor or Vanguard or whoever you talk to, you say, I am worried about the stock market. I want a conservative portfolio. They say, Great, you should check out bonds. And you invested in bonds in 2022. That was when the war in Ukraine became a thing. Stock market traded down. We also had interest rates spike up. But let's just say you were worried about it, you invested in bonds. You put a million bucks in, you know,$76,000 less if you were in TLT.

SPEAKER_00Yep. Yeah. Versus if you would have put your money in the stock market, you would have an extra$700,$769,000 to your name.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to the Compound Growth Podcast with Colin and Wheeler, where we talk all things growth from financial growth to career growth, personal development to societal progress. We explore how each layer builds on the next, compounding over time to shape who we become. Each week we break down complex ideas and emerging trends into clear, actionable insights. Because growth isn't just about numbers, it's about understanding the world and our place in it. I'm at a point now where I can't watch scary movies at home by myself because I get a little unsettled at night.

SPEAKER_01Because you don't watch a scary movie on a sunny afternoon. No, you don't. That would just be weird. It's always at night. And then Jess won't watch scary movies with me. So my scary movie diet has just gone down. And I like going to the theater, but I do the jump thing that Tori was talking about. And I'm actually at a point now where if I'm really uncomfortable with something, I will pull a blanket over my ass. I do that.

SPEAKER_00I do that too.

SPEAKER_01You cover your eyes too. Like I can't carefully if this is happening.

SPEAKER_00I look away like some of the scenes in the main scene in Alien. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I I like look like I can't. But there's a lot of things like that where I look away.

SPEAKER_01I feel like that type of scene, which was iconic at the time. Yes. We're gonna ruin this. It's it's the alien the alien bursts out of this guy's stomach. It was a classic thing. Now I shit like that happens in everything. It's like the the discomfort level has been ratcheted up. There's more gore, there's more awkward comedy. Like nothing used to be this uncomfortable to watch. And now it's like it's crazy.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it is crazy. I know. There's so much, so much gore. It's it's unsettling. It's unsettling. All these youngsters out there, you know.

SPEAKER_01Uh all right, Colin. Yes. Can I talk to you about some unsettling headlines, please? Let me set the stage. Okay. So we're in 2026. In 2026. August. Yes. Last season of the year. Um, so Jess and I were driving up to Vermont for my birthday weekend. And just like you and Kaylee talk about Colin, we were talking about the national debt levels. Yes.

SPEAKER_00Our typical uh conversations. Yeah. Um, so it is good you bring this up though, because I I have been hearing a lot about this recently. And I read some recent articles on it.

SPEAKER_01See, people have been talking about it a lot. Because we reached a new high. But it's like, it's like, okay, but again. It's like we reached a new high again. Like I get this keeps happening. This isn't like a new headline. It's just the number has changed. And some of the interest rates have changed. But Jess listens to the NPR up first podcast, which is where they'll go through like three headlines from the day before, news headlines from the day before, in a very quick fashion. And we were talking about the national debt and her understanding of it, and her understanding of it was informed by the uh podcast that she listened to that morning.

SPEAKER_01And the podcast said something that was factually accurate-ish, but not exactly fair in his description of what was happening. Okay. What is it? So the podcast, and we went and listened to it. The podcast basically suggested that the other countries borrowing our or like lending us money were charging us higher interest rates. And so then like we owe more debt to other countries, and they're charging us extra money or higher rates because we're like riskier or whatever.

SPEAKER_01It's like basically the takeaway from this podcast episode.

SPEAKER_00What they're saying is that we're borrowing from more countries at a higher rate than other countries are borrowing from us.

SPEAKER_01Not even comparing to other countries, just saying, like, hey, you know, the we we have more and more debt, and the countries lending us the the money are charging us more, like higher and higher interest rates. Sure. And so now we have like these the interest rate payments alone are like, you know, more than our natur our budget for national defense. Sure. Right. So that's that's kind of like where they left it for the most part. And then they talked about like how this impacts everyday Americans, how it impacts mortgage rates and car loans and things like that. And that's everything, yeah. That's all true. But I was like, well, that's not exactly how this works.

SPEAKER_01So I thought it would be really helpful to just like talk a little bit about what the national debt is, who's lending it, who's buying it, et cetera. I love this. I love macroeconomics. I don't. Okay. So I think just to just to clarify, when we when the government basically issues debt, right? They come to market and they say, here's what we are issuing today.

SPEAKER_00And when you hear debt, a lot of people don't know, but we should clarify what that means is selling treasury bonds.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, mostly treasury notes, like bonds, notes, et cetera. Yes. Um, so the government comes and says, here's here's what we're offering today. New issuance, exactly, and they put it out for bid to the market. And the market determines the interest rates. Yeah. Right. It's a global market. So it's not just the US. There are other countries in the world that are gobbling up our debt, is the way to think about that. Okay. It's that's what is happening. The country is not, we're not knocking on Canada's door or heading over to France and saying, hey, can you can you loan us some more money?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. That is kind of what used to happen many, many years ago, right? Like when you had uh when a country would borrow, they would borrow specifically from another country. Right. Right. That that was a very standard thing. But today we have new issuance where the government says, here's what we're looking for, who wants it, and then people go and buy it. Right. And what I think was confusing to, I don't know, maybe the reporter in the story, but certainly to Jess after, because like this is what they told her was who owns the debt.

SPEAKER_01So I've got a chart here, Khan. I shared it to you in Slack. It's gonna say ownership breakdown of total U.S. national debt. Okay. This is up to date. You can see that, yes, 24% of the national debt is owned by foreign investors and governments. I know Japan's our largest debt holder as a country. Japan is now. I mean, used to be China would be something like it's but the the concept that the government is borrowing money from all these other countries is a little bit misinformed.

SPEAKER_01In reality, 28.5% is with US private retail mutual funds. That's you, me, our clients, and everybody else here. Yep, right? Anybody who's invested in treasuries. 20% is literally still within the government, intergovernmental loans, trust funds, et cetera, that are still tied to the government. Yep. The Federal Reserve often owns treasuries. They own 11% of the treasuries. Other US banks and financial institutions own 8%, state and local governments own 8%.

SPEAKER_01The vast majority of the new issuance or of total issuance is not owned by foreign entities. I have a question. Yes. Why would it even matter if it did? Well, I think for what we're talking about, vibes or aura or whatever, the vibe shift here really matters. I'm going back to vibes. Because this isn't really, this doesn't feel like an aura thing to me, Torrin. I think this is a vibe. The concept, if if what would it matter if it did? It would perception is reality, right?

SPEAKER_01People would feel like the US is really struggling because China owns all of our debt. So China owns us, essentially.

SPEAKER_00You want to know what's so funny? Is I was on Instagram the other day and uh there was some news thing that was talking about how Japan is our biggest debt holder, which is why I do that fact. It was Japan, then it was UK, then it was China, I think. Okay. So what was funny is whenever I see these posts, I always go to the comment section because I'm fascinated to see what people actually think of this stuff. Yeah. And people were talking about the fact like this administration sucks because now Japan's just gonna call us on our debt, and it's we're gonna have to declare bankruptcy.

SPEAKER_00This is what I'm saying. And I'm like, you can't call debt. It is a loan, it is a bond with a rigid structure. It's just is no difference, right, in my mind, who owns it. The fact of the matter is that it is a contractual loan with a term, an interest rate, and an expiration date. Like, yes.

SPEAKER_01What matters is if we default on it or not.

SPEAKER_00Correct.

SPEAKER_01That's different.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um, but this is I think it's a common misconception that people have. And they think that we're bar the US is borrowing money from all these other countries. Right. And that then those countries have some sort of authority over us because they're borrowing this. But in reality, it's not some like geopolitical game. No. It's an investment. And you invest, you you people pay or they loan or they buy this issuance because they know that it's quote unquote money good.

SPEAKER_00Right. Well, I mean, you think about it, and let's look at Japan as a perfect example. Their currency is currently tanking, and you look at the interest rates like within their own country. If you have no stability in your own currency, you're going to probably want to go to the US dollar at that point. So you can buy and hold a higher interest rate loan and invest in a more safe currency. Yeah. That's what I would be doing if I was Japan too. I mean, it makes perfect sense, but that doesn't mean that they now control the United States.

SPEAKER_00Right. Well, it's just the same thing.

SPEAKER_01Like if you're an investor and you want to the the 30-year yield on treasuries last week spiked to 5.53, which is the highest since 2007. So it's it's certainly like it's a very high rate. And yes, you have to say that these the market determining that a 30-year loan with the US requires that type of interest, that's something to be aware of. And the fact that we are making these significant debt payments is something to be aware of.

SPEAKER_01Who we're making them to is interesting because a lot of that is going to individuals in the United States in the form of individual investments or pension funds or whatever. Well, we don't have a single client that doesn't hold US treasuries in one way or another. Right. I don't think we do.

SPEAKER_00No, I mean you would have to not have any cash in your account whatsoever. Right.

SPEAKER_01But I think the interest rate is what's different this this time, like the reason you brought up like people were talking about the national debt again. And I think I've been hearing about it, you know, a little bit more and more over the last couple of years, is because I think of the interest rates tied to it. Obviously, this country very rarely ever runs a surplus, right? We we frequently run a deficit. And what kind of bothers me is part of this NPR podcast episode, and again, they're really distilling down complicated stories into five-minute sound bites, and they're doing the best they can.

SPEAKER_01I'm not knocking NPR on this, but they'll talk about well, you know, in boom times, we don't have a deficit, we have a surplus. This country has been around for 250 years. The the modern economy's been around for like a hundred years. There's very little that you can go back to and say, well, you know, deficit, surplus, blah, blah, blah. Bad times we should have a uh deficit, good times we should have a surplus. There's like one time in modern economic history in the 90s where we had a surplus.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. You want to know what this reminds me of? Is there was an article um it was on Globe and Mail. Did you see this one? It was historically speaking, the stock market has argued and then it was talking about margin levels. And it was talking about let me uh actually quote this outstanding margin debt has gone parabolic. Oh, parabolic. Parabolic. That's a big word. That is a big word. Total margin debt hits one and a half trillion dollars, um, which is an all-time high. It's very high. We talked about this a few episodes back.

SPEAKER_00We did talk about it, but this is just like what you're kind of saying with the debt levels. Of course, margin is going to go up when you have a stock market that's rallying. Because if you're using margin to buy stocks and your stocks go up, your margin will go up because you use margin to buy the stocks. Is it necessarily a problem that margin debt is this high? No, it's not. I mean, there has been a pretty big surge over the last year, and that might not be great. But at the end of the day, just because margin levels were high when you go back to the dot-com era, yeah, doesn't mean margin debt now being high is the exact same thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think it's nothing is good and well, rare is something good or bad just in and of itself. Right. It's it's headlines try to simplify things and make it sound that way. But in reality, it's only bad if this, then that. Right. Right. And I don't I think the same thing with our national debt. It's not great that we have more and more national debt if we can't offset it with some sort of growth in GDP, et cetera.

SPEAKER_01But I think and the interest rates, like we don't want as a country to have to pay out more on interest. No, of course.

SPEAKER_00And it is a genuine problem what's going on with the bond market right now. Yeah. I mean, it doesn't seem like they can get a grasp on interest rates at the moment, and inflation is just um like it's anyway.

SPEAKER_01Well, that's that's one of the other charts I sent you. So if you pull up the the Y charts one, it's the last chart I sent you today. Yeah. This shows the relationship between the dollar right across the middle of the screen in orange and Bitcoin and gold. Yep. And last week when the new the latest issuance came out, we saw that interest rate spike in the 30 year and all these concerns kind of gathered up some steam. You saw Bitcoin and gold as alternative currencies jump back up.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, now Bitcoin, I think last I saw was like 78,000, somewhere around that. Which, you know, a week or two ago was at 64. So it was a pretty big jump very quickly. I mean, there were a lot of arguments talking about Bitcoin, whether or not it's actually a diversifier. Yeah. Because a lot of people track it against the NASDAQ. But when you look at this chart, it's almost the exact same as gold. Well, it's interesting to me, yeah, it's well, it was up. The correlation is similar to gold. Correlation, yeah, not the total return, but the charts are quite similar.

SPEAKER_01Right, yeah, exactly. Bitcoin went up 20% on this news. Yeah. Gold went up six percent, five to six percent, depending on how you measured it. Like, yeah, those are and the dollar index fell like one percent. Yeah. So in terms of volatility, that makes a lot of sense. Dollar's gonna have less volatility than gold, which is gonna have less volatility than Bitcoin. Right.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, at the end of the day, it's been you want to know what I was thinking about this morning when I was in the shower, is um I was thinking about our portfolios in general. And then I started to think about the bond market. And I've been kind of a naysayer on the bond market for like a very long time. And it's just once again, a frustrating year for diversified portfolios. You know, it really is. Like you look at what the bond market has done, and you look at interest rates in general, and stocks have continued to rip, which is a positive thing for people that own stocks.

SPEAKER_00But the conservative investor continues to get hosed, I feel like. It's very true.

SPEAKER_01Um, I was thinking about this with TLT. So TLT is the 20 plus year treasury bond, yeah. And that was leading into 2022, like a really strong uh allocation in your portfolio. Yep. Um, if we look at over the last five years, the annualized return of TLT is negative 7.68%.

SPEAKER_00So if you're a conservative investor, you want to hold on to your money, you walk in, you say to a financial advisor or Vanguard or whoever you talk to, you say, I am worried about the stock market. I want a conservative portfolio. They say, Great, you should check out bonds. And you invested in bonds in 2022. That was when the war in Ukraine became a thing, stock market traded down. We also had interest rates spike up. But let's just say you were worried about it, you invested in bonds. You put a million bucks in, you know,$76,000 less if you were in TLT.

SPEAKER_00Yep. Yep. Versus if you would have put your money in the stock market, you would have an extra$700,$769,000 to your name.

SPEAKER_01Right. And I mean, TLT in terms of conservative, it's probably the most more aggressive bonds, right? Yeah. Because of that duration. But yeah, like even the ag is still negative over the last five years in total return. Yeah, you look at the ag.

SPEAKER_00I mean, it's probably, I don't know it off the top of my head, but I would guess it's down two or three percent.

SPEAKER_01The total return annualized over the last five years for the ag is negative 0.11.

SPEAKER_00So So literally you've lost money to inflation.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh, yeah, to inflation? Absolutely. Yeah. But that's so that's what's interesting about this current yield. Like how does how does all this debt and yield or interest rate on the debt impact everybody is important because it does, you know, the Fed, when we were talking about the Fed raised raising or lowering rates, people like think, okay, well, that is going to change what I get my mortgage. It's not necessarily the case because the Fed is overnight rates and mortgages are often 30-year mortgages.

SPEAKER_01And as we just said, 30-year, you know, money good, the best quote unquote, best debt you can get out there is US Treasuries. And the cost of that is 5.33% on a 30-year. So you are not as money good as the government necessarily, although I think you're in great shape, Colin. Thank you. Um, but I I think that that's what you should expect to guide or direct your mortgage rates and your car loans, is what the global market is offering for things like treasuries.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, 100%. I mean, it's one of those situations where you have to ask yourself, what does conservative and aggressive actually mean? Yeah. You know, because I always go back, it's like, well, do you want to be conservative because you're afraid of just like loss of money? Or are you conservative because like you just don't feel like you need to make that much? Or do you just have an adverse opinion about the stock market, or maybe it's political? And it's amazing how many different responses we get to those questions.

SPEAKER_00Like so many people don't agree with the administration, which rightfully so, on a lot of things. So they just don't think they should be in the stock market. Or maybe they're like, you know, well, I just don't believe in this AI thing, so I don't want to be in the stock market, like whatever it might be. Um, so they go to bonds, thinking that that's totally safe and viable. But I mean, you look at like I was just pulling this up, you know, just performance in just 2022 in general. So the stock market at its peak was down 18%. And then if you look at the interest rate hike and all of that, um, inflation peaked at 9.1% in 2022, and the stock market was down 13 to 14 percent, depending on your term.

SPEAKER_00So even in bad environments, that doesn't necessarily mean your bonds are safe. So you said stock market, but you're saying the bonds were down.

SPEAKER_01Stock market was down 18%, bond market was down 14%. 14%. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think bonds, I mean, yeah, obviously we talked about this a lot. But um if you're I think if you're anti-administration, owning the stock market might make you uncomfortable. Owning treasuries might make you uncomfortable. Sitting in cash is losing out to inflation. Um, high yield treasury uh sorry, high yield market accounts, savings accounts are able to provide that yield to you because of their treasuries and their exposure.

SPEAKER_01So it's like, um where do you go? Right.

SPEAKER_00That's the question. And I think that's why a lot of people we've been seeing maybe more alts.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and more gold and crazy enough, more Bitcoin.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um, but what's interesting about and this I think why we might be seeing a little bit of a near term ceiling in the stock market is when you when you have risk free or less, risk free rates. Meaning treasuries. Meaning treasuries at five and a half percent, your hurdle as a stock market investor is higher. If you can essentially take a get a You know, issue a loan or receive the interest from a loan that's guaranteed by the government and get five and a half percent, then your long-term performance on the stock portfolio has to be, especially on a risk-adjusted basis.

SPEAKER_03Much than that. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean basically what we're saying is that we recognize that nothing is technically risk-free. The US government could technically default on it. Yeah. But that is what it's defined by as the risk-free rate is the U.S. Treasury bond. Um, that makes perfect sense because when you take into account the treasury bonds being 5%, though the only problem with that is that we have inflation now at, you know, whatever it is, 3.7 to 4% now. Yeah. So I mean, you're really only getting a 1% total return, but that's certainly a lot better than sitting in cash.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And actually, I think inflation, depending on how you measure it, is much, much lower than what it's published. Yeah. Yeah. Um, like Bank of America, for example, they have their own inflation estimates and then their inflation estimates are like 2%. Um and I think we've talked about like the the real-time inflation analysis. And and I think for a risk-free rate, like the the very lowest risk you can take is probably a high yield savings account, or like the overnight rate, I think is what you should. So whatever the Fed is has pegged the overnight rate to, yep.

SPEAKER_01I think that's really what you should think of as like risk free at that time. I like it. Three and a half percent, whatever.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um, anyways, that's the relationship with what's going on in the bond market, in the treasury market, et cetera. Um, can we talk about wage growth? Yes.

SPEAKER_00Is this the Mark Cuban thing? This is not Mark Cuban. What do Mark Cuban say? Well, that's great. Um Mark Cuban had a very, I'll say, I don't want to say it went viral because whatever he says tends to get picked up by something. Sure. But um he had a tweet that I thought was kind of interesting. And it was talking about wage disparity. Okay. In particular with business owners and employees. Okay. And it was talking about, I'll just read the quote from the Twitter post. Taxes serve a societal purpose.

SPEAKER_00If we continue to see growing disparity in income, you risk unrest and further division, which is the most expensive tax on every business. What I suggested was the corporate tax rates go up for companies that don't share equity and stays the same for those that do. They have a choice. Interesting. Okay. And what was the response to this? Uh a lot of different responses. Um, essentially, what he's saying is like if we go back to RSUs or just companies in general, let's we were just talking about an acquisition recently where someone made a billion dollars and their employees, you know, are still by the hour, even though the employees helped the business owner grow and get there.

SPEAKER_00Um so that is leading to a lot of wage disparity because you now you have many, many people who have had acquisitions over the last five to 10 years, especially. Um, but with that being said, I think some people are very up in arms about this, and some people very much agree with it. There's actually a pretty clear division on this, but I was curious to get your take on it.

SPEAKER_01First blush, I feel like there are a lot of games that can be played to qualify as a company that shares equity with its employees. Right. Right. And I think that that's, you know, there are grants and RSUs, et cetera. There's um, you know, the opportunity to offer your shares at discounted value to your uh employees. Yeah. Um you're seeing share buybacks are often a good way for you to, you know, offer to buyback shares from your employees or whatever.

SPEAKER_01You're seeing fewer of that. Um fewer of those. I think I don't think that this is necessarily a solution to anything.

SPEAKER_00That's what I was gonna say too. I really don't think that this is gonna change anything. You know, like if you were to offer employees more RSUs, I think that's great. You know, the employees would have more money, but at the end of the day, the owner is still gonna walk away a billionaire.

SPEAKER_01I think what you have to get I I was looking, we we were doing. And is that a problem? I don't know if it's well, I think the problem that currently people have with billionaires is that it just they don't like the billionaires. Like, you know, when we it used to be like Silicon Valley was some place where it was filled with like these really popular people that were very successful in a way that you could champion them. Like people loved Steve Jobs. There's no Steve Jobs out there. Sam Altman is not Steve Jobs, Mark Zuckerberg is not Steve Jobs.

SPEAKER_01Like people hate these people. Elon Musk, of course. People, people just vehemently just do not like them. And so to see people that you don't like succeed at a level that seems unfair is incredibly painful for a lot of people.

SPEAKER_00The question is, though, is um, would you not like them as much if they weren't as successful?

SPEAKER_01I think what's interesting is do you like them even less because they're successful? Sure.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01They would still not like them in the first place. I don't think their success is creating the dislike. I think the success is amplifying the dislike. Yep. But there's also a lot of billionaires out there that people don't either don't know about, right? They don't have opinions on. I think like when people think billionaires, they can list five and that's all the billionaires, and they're all the same.

SPEAKER_00Right. It's kind of like just associating an entire party negatively because of four or five people you can't stand.

SPEAKER_01I think that or don't agree with. Right. When people I think people wonder about like whether sh billionaires should exist or not. And I don't know what the answer is to that. I think that we definitely have a wealth disparity in this country. Actually, one of the charts I sent you, it says index real wealth accumulation trajectory. So this is, you know, going from 2019 to where we are today. And this, if you if you kind of connected these lines a little bit further over to the left, you'd see that this is kind of like the K-shaped economy that people are talking about.

SPEAKER_01You can see that the higher income, which is equity dominant, equity in companies, like Mark Cuban's talking about, has been skyrocketing. Lower income and middle income have also increased. They just aren't increasing at the same rate. And they're increasing in different ways. Middle income is real estate dominant, right? Yeah. Higher income is uh sorry, cat lower income is just like, what do I do with my cash?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I mean, it makes sense because look at the stock market over the last 10 years. Sure. Or more actually now. But yeah, it's if you've owned stocks, you're going to be wealthier. That's just the name of the game.

SPEAKER_01Or even like you haven't even needed to own publicly traded stocks. Think about SpaceX. Yeah, of course. Think about anthropic. Think about like these companies that have been private, that you're increasing, like that's that's a part of that higher income. The people who have access to those companies are seeing their wealth increase at a higher rate. And then those companies come to market, like SpaceX, for example, and they go down 16%.

SPEAKER_00Do you know how many millionaires were created by the IPO of SpaceX, specifically SpaceX employees that saw their net worth increase by over a million dollars? No. 4,400 people became millionaires by being employees of SpaceX. Right. You know? So when you look at that chart that you showed about the equity, it makes perfect sense. And that's one IPO.

SPEAKER_01Right. And think about the people who are had were already millionaires. Yeah. Right. And then they also increase their wealth. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So 400 out of those 4,400, 10% are now centrillionaires. 100 million or more. Yeah. And how do they how do they know that? Do you ever wonder like where how do they know how much money I don't know how much money you have?

SPEAKER_01And I work with you every day.

SPEAKER_00No, I know. But I think when you when it comes to like stock transactions, like you can probably track some of that, you know?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But it doesn't okay. So let's say that Tori worked at SpaceX instead of Ko Fi and she smartly invested in the company while she was there. And now she went and she had, you know, her SpaceX shares go public and she was able to sell them and she's got a million dollars. Or if she can see them on an account that says a million dollars, whatever, right? Yeah. But let's say it's a transaction. She sells them, she gets a million dollars, and that's how we track it. It doesn't say anything about Tori's real estate or the mortgage against that real estate or student loans or anything else.

SPEAKER_01Like, how do they know all of this information, all of this private information that we actually sometimes have difficulty collecting in financial planning software?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So um, great question. The answer to that is uh journalists interviewing workers, um, legal math tied to the company's historical IPO offerings. Uh, and then um it basically comes from independent financial research.

SPEAKER_01Hmm. Okay.

SPEAKER_00So whether or not it's reliable, uh, take a grain of salt. But I'll take a lot I'm not I'm not surprised by those numbers, though. That to me seems realistic given how massive a company it is that 4,400 people became millionaires off of it.

SPEAKER_01I yeah, or they just saw a million dollars and increased value. Exactly. Whatever it is, like trajectory was up and to the right. It backs up your chart. Sure.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01What doesn't back up my chart is the first chart that I sent you today that says exhibit four in June. This is coming from Bank of America in June, after tax wage growth among lower income households rose four rose to 4.1% year over year, surpassing 3.4% year-over-year growth rate for middle income households.

SPEAKER_00I saw this actually. Um, I saw that it was the highest wage growth in however many years uh for lower income households.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it what's interesting is that that was a comparison from lower to middle. On top of that, you have higher, which dipped. Yeah. Which I don't know necessarily what to make of this, except that it's a little bit of a narrative buster. You know?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I uh I would imagine that I don't know. I don't want to say something that might not be correct, but I do wonder if this has to do with I just look at our own clients and book of business. We have a lot of people who are high earners retiring right now. And that could be that gold bar.

SPEAKER_01I don't think that they're I'm not sure what qualifies as a high earner that would retire. And then you know what I mean? Like it's it's different than let's say that you have a you, you know, you earned$300,000 a year in salary. That's not going to fall into the high earners. Yeah, because it's done now. Right. Yeah. But um I think what's also interesting is if you let's say you make$50,000. Sure. And you get a$2,000 raise. Well, that's your 4%. Right. Right.

SPEAKER_01It's only$2,000. It's but it's still 4%. Right. So it's law of large numbers. I think that this shows that maybe the lower income is doing better, but it's easier to do better at that lower income, but just on a percentage level.

SPEAKER_00Maybe. But then if that's the case, then we you would have seen the same results over the last few years, which we didn't see for the lower income. That's true.

SPEAKER_01And it actually, yeah, it kind of bucking the trend and going back the other way.

SPEAKER_00Right. Which is good to see. It is good. It's a positive thing because in an ideal world there would be less disparity. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think this is what's really tough, is that you know, everybody loves to complain. And there are so many good reasons to complain. But if we are seeing more, more than less, just stops job stability. Like the job market is stable, right? Unemployment rate is still very low. People are seeing wage growth for the first time in a while. Stock markets up. Stock markets.

SPEAKER_00So anyone with a 401k is doing pretty well right now. Well if you are As long as you're not in TLT.

SPEAKER_01If you what but if you if you are owning treasuries or are participating in high yield savings accounts, then you're getting paid more for having your cash on the sidelines. 100%. There's a lot that's working right now, and people are really unhappy. And I think that I can obviously see, I can pick and choose. Like, I hate how much concert tickets are, for example. Sure. I don't have a combustible engine anymore, but I see gas prices are high, and that must be really annoying.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um it's not ideal. Like in I understand that things have gone up, inflation has gone up, but inflation has not gone up over the last like six to eight months of this year at the same rate that wage increase has gone up. And maybe we're turning a corner and going in the right direction.

SPEAKER_00I think we are. I mean, if you look back, um, really inflation started in 2022. Like if you look at inflation just in general, when interest rates started to change and um there was a lot of issues, I'll say, that's when inflation started to pick up. And we all know that inflation is sticky. It's not like you're gonna have super high inflation for like a few months and then it's just gonna go away. So if inflation went up a lot in 2022 and it's starting to kind of slow and things are starting to normalize now, we're starting to see unemployment come down, like all of those types of things, that would make sense.

SPEAKER_00And it's only been four years. Yeah. You know, if you look back, you know, this is gonna be potentially a blip that we'll look back on and say, do you remember when interest rates did what they did and when unemployment was what it was, and when people were unhappy with the way that things were.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I think that just if you look at like if you measure U.S. inflation rate, as we talked about, it's not necessarily measured in very useful ways. Like oil can really drive that, even though it's less of a piece of the pie most of the time.

SPEAKER_00Right. And it's like oil is going up because we have a war in Iran right now, not because of inflation. But if we took that oil out, but it is a factor that they're putting into the metric.

SPEAKER_01But if we took that oil out, we'd we'd be back to where we were in the 2018 era. Like it's pre-COVID. We're we were at pre-COVID levels on the U.S. inflation rate year over year before Iran. And I think that's probably a temporary situation. But either way, like that impact on the measurement of inflation that oil has is not as valid as it used to be. It's things are just not as bad in the data as they seem to be in real life. What's consumer sentiment like these days?

SPEAKER_01Uh I don't know. I don't want to wager a guess. I don't want to posit a theory on that, Colin. I'm nervous. You look it up. You look it up.

SPEAKER_00So here's what the consumer sentiment index currently says. Because I was just about to ask you, so if this is the deal and this is what we're saying, what's wrong? So um there has been uh significant drop in consumer sentiment, meaning Americans are feeling highly strained by the cost of living, growing increasingly pessimistic about the future economy, embracing for persistent inflation. Seventy percent of the US economy uh in general, uh people who s were surveyed feel this is downbeat and it is historically a negative change of behavior.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Only 8% of consumers expect their wage growth to outpace inflation over the next year. The rest feel their purchasing power is actively eroding.

SPEAKER_01I think you have to first and foremost say that the responses to that survey are valid responses. Like the people who answered that answered with validity, and we have to take that at at face value. I think that some of the data that we were looking at just now suggests that what they're feeling is in the past and maybe things are gonna get better. That's what I was gonna say.

SPEAKER_00I feel like they're feeling this based off of the last year. Yeah. You know, which is valid. Things did go up a lot really over the last three to four years. But maybe they feel as if they did not receive the wage growth that they needed to combat the inflation over the last three to four years.

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, that's definitely the case. Like you saw wage and wage growth in increase like COVID, post-COVID, right? Um, and then it kind of like leveled off, and maybe we're starting to see it. It was, I guess, decreasing before now. But it, you know, if you there are plenty of people who point to the 1970s and say that wages have just been decreasing versus inflation over the last 50 years. I think though it's it's possible that whenever you're looking at, and we've kind of talked about this before, but whenever you're looking at things on a macro level, you're doing yourself and the story a disservice.

SPEAKER_01And I think what what gets tough is that there's more and more macro. That's what we were just talking about. Right. It's you know, the meta just settled on the um the latest batch of of lawsuits about how they've uh negatively impacted children, like they've harmed children through Instagram and Facebook, and et cetera. And I think that they're focused on the children because you know, gotta say the kids. Yeah, of course. But it's I think that there's been lasting damage done by social media, and I've said that before, and I'll continue to say it because I see it every single day.

SPEAKER_01And people feel worse when they have so many reasons shoved in their face and down their throat to feel worse. Yeah. And it's just very different than when what people I think felt when I was young.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I was uh going back to Mark Eubin's uh quote and tweet and everything. He was talking about the division of the country and everything, and how you know the middle class and lower class are angry and everything. And I was watching a history thing the other day on the French Revolution, which is why I knew that fact earlier. Yep. Um, and it was uh fascinating to go back because basically what had happened is in the late 1700s, like France economically was basically in complete shambles. And the uh king at the time um basically called a meeting to vote on a few different things, and you had three houses, which were the commoners, the nobles, and the church.

SPEAKER_00And the commoners, who made up 99% of the population, got one vote. The nobles, which were 300 people, got one vote. And then the church, who I don't know how many people would call it 50 to 100 people, got one vote. So the commoners were very pissed off about the fact that their voices didn't really matter. So they famously left, and that ended up to the storming of the Bastille and overthrowing the government and eventually killing of the king down the road. And I don't think we're necessarily at that point.

SPEAKER_00But um, I guess what Mark Cuban is saying, like the division in society does feel kind of real, like at the moment. You know, there definitely feels like the average person is struggling while you know you have the wealthy people that may not. Whether or not that's the case long term remains to be seen. But the data that we've seen recently is showing that low income wages are starting to pick up, which is a positive thing.

SPEAKER_01We need to see more of it though. Yeah. We need to see more of people having what they need and some of the things they want, and less of people having more than they'll ever need or want, right? And just like have some sort of sense of normalcy where it's like it's it's not just so over the top. And if we can kind of shift not the vibes, but the aura, then I I I think that that's where we need to go.

SPEAKER_01And it's really we were watching um Ted Lasso, the new season last night. I'm not gonna spoil anything, Tori, but um they were talking about how having a common enemy is often the best way to like unite, right? I think right now, unfortunately, the common enemy is AI.

SPEAKER_00I was gonna say the government.

SPEAKER_01I don't think the government's a common enemy at this point because there's still people who feel that the government is doing what it's supposed to do. Like there are people who are supporting the government. Yeah, that's they're supporting whatever. Yeah. I I think AI right now is the common enemy. It's the common enemy. Nobody likes AI, nobody likes data centers, nobody wants to lose their job, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. Um I think that that needs to go the other way because you need to have, you can also have a common cause, like a common goal. And if we have a common goal and it's let's try to build a better world through AI type of thing, which I think sounds type sometimes ridiculous when some of the anthropic people say it.

SPEAKER_01Right. So maybe I don't sound as as annoying as them, hopefully. But I think we need to build towards something. We need to get everybody on the same page. And if people say, well, there's not wealth inequality or there's not wealth disparity, then that's not getting them on the same page.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I don't want to sound pessimistic, but I'm going to. I don't think this problem will be solved in our lifetime. Which problem? I don't think that there will be without some sort of like massive shakeup, I don't think there will ever be a world where just like everybody's on the same playing field. And that's okay. Like I don't feel as if there's going to be a massive change in wealth disparity from the top to the bottom necessarily. In my mind, though, that's okay so long as lower and middle income households have a fantastic quality of life.

SPEAKER_00Like for me, it's not about getting the person making 50,000 to getting to them to the point where they're making 5 million. But to me, it's about getting everybody on the same playing field where, you know, you can afford a great house, you can have good healthcare, you can send your kids to a good school. Like all of those things that make quality of life good is why I think ultimately people want to be wealthy, unless you're being pushed social media crap or socialism.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um, I think that you're right. I don't think there's ever in history history been like complete equality. I don't think that's what we're looking for. But I think that we are looking for a feeling, an aura of feeling good. Yeah. Um, and I think that we're just not there right now, which sucks.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I can't remember, well, maybe one or two times. I felt like COVID was maybe one of those times where people were like, everybody was on the same page. Everybody was on the same page. Yeah. Yeah. Short-lived.

SPEAKER_01But I'll tell you what, I know COVID was horrible. I really liked going for bike rides with my daughter during COVID. And there's always something that you can point to and say, this is good, and maybe we should just do more saying this is good. Yeah. And it's tough to do that without acknowledging the bad. It's tough to say that lower income is going up without acknowledging that it's just like a a penny versus a pound. Right. You know, and it's I don't want to be ignorant of the problems or just say they aren't there, but I do want to be able to focus on some progress that's being made.

SPEAKER_01I like it.

SPEAKER_00All right. Let's focus on that. Like, subscribe, share with a friend.

SPEAKER_01The information in this material is for general information only and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. Investment advice offered through Integrated Partners, doing business as Ko-Fi Advisors LLC, a registered investment advisor. Integrated Partners does not provide legal, tax, mortgage advice or services. Please consult your legal tax advisor regarding your specific situation. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All investing involves risk, including loss of principle.

SPEAKER_01No strategy assures success or protects against loss. The economic forecasts set forth in this material may not develop as predicted, and there can be no guarantee that the strategies promoted will be successful.

SPEAKER_03Compound Growth with Wheeler and Colin Sponsored by Kobi Advisors reach out today. Yay!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. With Nvidia Down 30%, What Should Investors Actually Worry About Before Year End?

    Nov 16, 202650 minAudio

    Nvidia is down roughly 30% from its highs after the Jensen Huang headlines, the market has swung hard since the midterms, and year end is bringing a tax bill some investors won't see coming. It's hard to tell which of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The K-Shaped Economy, Bitcoin's Rough 18th Birthday, and the Slow-Go Years That Never Come

    Nov 9, 202645 minAudio

    The headlines say the economy is strong and the market is near its highs, but for a lot of people it doesn’t feel that way. Wheeler and Colin are joined by Dan to look at who this economy is actually working for....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Property Taxes on the Ballot, Visa and Mastercard Under Pressure, and a Bubble on Watch

    Nov 2, 202646 minAudio

    Property tax bills keep climbing, a bill in Congress promises lower card fees while card companies warn that rewards could shrink, and everyone seems to be waiting for the AI bubble to burst. It’s hard to tell where the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. A Call From Inside the House, the Fall of FICO, and a Retirement Plan AI Couldn't Finish

    Oct 26, 202647 minAudio

    Homes cost about five times the typical household income, the average car payment has climbed by about a third in five years, and letters from the Treasury keep arriving with help that rarely adds up to much. It can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mailbag: Is AI Truly Being Adopted or Just Distributed?

    Oct 23, 202619 minAudio

    In the race of technology, is AI truly the fastest adopted innovation in history, or is it just a case of mass distribution? If you’ve been questioning the impact of AI on the economy, your portfolio, or even just your...

    Credit the people on this episode