Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Compound Growth

Compound Growth artwork

The Golden Handcuffs: Navigating RSUs and Stock Comp Packages

Mar 16, 202642 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Have you ever looked at a job offer and felt overwhelmed by the alphabet soup of RSUs, ESPPs, and vesting schedules? In this episode of Compound Growth, Colin and Wheeler break down the complex world of equity compensation - moving beyond the raw numbers to explore how these benefits actually impact your long-term financial freedom. Using real-world examples from Google and Amazon, they pull back the curtain on how golden handcuffs are designed and how you can negotiate a package that aligns with your life goals. They dive into the mechanics of RSUs and the crucial differences between front-loaded and back-loaded vesting schedules - because understanding that timeline is the difference between building real wealth and leaving money on the table when your career path changes. They also get into the psychological side of equity: how to avoid the trap of mentally spending deferred compensation before it vests, and why diversification matters so much when your company also pays your mortgage. Whether you're an L9 software engineer or just starting to see stock options in your benefits package, this episode gives you a grounded framework for making intentional decisions - and a reminder that your job offer is an investment decision, not just a paycheck. Follow Us: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/compoundgrowthpod YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@CompoundGrowthPodcast TikTok: http://www.tiktok.com/@compoundgrowthpod Wheeler’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/wheeler-crowley-0a63933b/ Colin’s LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colin-walker-mba-6099a038/ Credits: Created By: Wheeler Crowley and Colin Walker Production, Editing and Post-Production: Tori Rothwell

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_04Um all right. So the difference between community and a scene. And as we were just discussing, so community is what you said like basically people who cohabitate together.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_04People who cohabitate together. Right. And a scene is more of a aesthetic functionality within that community.

SPEAKER_02So the picture frame within the the picture.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. No, it's not a picture frame, actually. It has nothing to do with think about before movies, people did plays. They still do plays. What about setting? Setting would be a like background, like with this studio is a setting, and the scene is the thing that happens inside the setting. That's what, like in a play or in a movie or whatever. Right. So in the movie All Almost Famous. Yes. You know, the when yeah, when the kid gets brought into the rock and roll scene, it's filled with people who know each other.

SPEAKER_04There's a community element to it, but they're also defined by like the art that's happening or your relationship to the art. And it's like a it's it's kind of a movement, right? So typical scenes you might think of, it could be an art scene. It could be like the Renaissance was a scene. It could be music, it could be skateboarding, but it's something that is like there's an aesthetic element to it.

SPEAKER_02I always think of like the hippie scene.

SPEAKER_04Sure. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And like what is that, the 60s, 70s?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's late 60s. Yeah. Yeah. And I is what's funny about that is like Woodstock is kind of like the pinnacle of like the hippie scene or whatever. Right. That was like it was a really short scene when you look at historically. It really wasn't that long. It was a very short scene. Anyways, so the scene is what kind of draws people in. So you could have like a skateboarding scene, and that's just filled with people who like to skateboard and there's certain music that they listen to or movies that they listen to. There's like a vernacular, a dialogue that they have they all share, and then they get to know each other, and then they have a community.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_04Right. So what I've always been interested in is community. Yeah. Something that we've talked about a lot. And sometimes you start at a place because you're drawn into it by the scene. And then you get in there and you're like, wait, is this the community that I was looking for? Or is it kind of like a transient scene? And the reason I'm bringing this up today is because when we left our prior firm, I looked at it as an opportunity to establish a scene, quote unquote, within our little firm.

SPEAKER_04And then like helping build that community with our clients and prospects and colleagues, et cetera. And I think the way I think about things is I craft, I'm like crafting that in my mind as a storyteller, right? Does that make sense? It does.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I I vibe with that because we've gone back and forth on this, and I've always been kind of lost on whether or not the community is the clients or the other firms that we're friendly with, or like the COIs that we've become friends with, or whoever it all is, or just even our own employees and you and I and all that kind of stuff. So I guess the way that I would probably frame it is to imagine the perfect scene and then build a community around it.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, exactly. Design your scene, then find that finds that brings the people in that are they find that scene attractive, and then you can establish community and relationships with them. And sometimes brands will establish a scene, quote unquote, in the you know, the most marketing horrible way that you could describe it. And then they lose the through line, they lose the narrative, they lose the story. And what I've realized is that I have such a like um, it's such an emphasis, it's such a priority to me that even though it sucked, I was willing to give up my equity ownership and that other firm.

SPEAKER_00Look at that.

SPEAKER_01I was trying to think how you're gonna transition into this conversation today, based off of that. But I have to give it to you. That was a good one.

SPEAKER_03Welcome to the compound growth podcast with Colin and Wheeler, where we talk all things growth, from financial growth to career growth, personal development to societal progress, we explore how each layer builds on the next, compounding over time to shape who we become. Each week, we break down complex ideas and emerging trends into clear, actionable insights. Because growth isn't just about numbers, it's about understanding the world and our place in it. The information in this material is for general information only, and is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual.

SPEAKER_03Investment advice offered through Integrated Partners doing Business as Co-Fi Advisors LLC, a registered investment advisor. Integrated Partners does not provide legal, tax, mortgage advice or services. Please consult your legal tax advisor regarding your specific situation. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. All investing involves risk, including loss of principle. No strategy assures success or protects against loss. The economic forecasts set forth in this material may not develop as predicted, and there can be no guarantee that the strategies promoted will be successful.

SPEAKER_01So talk to me through, talk me through what that means giving up your equity.

SPEAKER_04You and I had equity compensation that we received from our previous employer as employees at that company. And I received some equity compensation to join the company. It was a part of like my sign-on bonus. And then each year we would have more equity accrue, either through just kind of like our production, like our achievements, or some sort of company benefit. Right. Right. Becomes over time kind of like a golden handcuffs situation.

SPEAKER_02Yes. And I broke free. We had a lot of conversations about separating from the firm and leaving that benefit behind. Yeah.

SPEAKER_04There's so many people who can't do that.

SPEAKER_02There are so many people that can't do it. And I'm not saying that everybody should, but it's something that we talked about a lot. And it is a conversation that we're constantly having with clients. Yeah. And it's a conversation that always comes up in regards to planning and benefit packages is stock options. Yes.

SPEAKER_04Equity ownership, equity compensation.

SPEAKER_02Yes, very much so. And actually, I think one of the um reasons that I, you know, I really wanted to talk about this today is because we had a prospect come in a few weeks ago that worked for um a tech company. And she had all of these grants and vesting schedules and, you know, employee stock purchase plans and RSUs, all these different things that she had going on. And she did not know how to navigate it. And we talked to people all the time about this. And as we were having those conversations, I saw something that was pretty crazy, which was on TikTok.

SPEAKER_02And there's this guy on TikTok that reviews benefit packages. So it's total compensation benefit package. Total comp. So basically, someone from Meta or Facebook or name the company, the same company. Same company, uh, Meta or Google or Apple or whoever will submit their job offer. Yeah. And he will review it. Wow. Which is bold. Kind of cool. Yeah. And one of the ones that was submitted, I thought was pretty crazy.

SPEAKER_02I'm going to read it to you.

SPEAKER_04Okay, please share.

SPEAKER_02Okay. And we're going to get into other examples of stock options and RSUs later on in the episode. Yeah. But there are different levels when you join a tech company. And it's the same way with many other firms as well, where basically you're ranked on levels from like one through nine as the most entry level to more senior being level nine. Okay. And your comp goes up with them.

SPEAKER_04One through nine. Why is there no 10?

SPEAKER_02There might be a 10. It's probably C-suite at that point.

SPEAKER_04It's just like it's a random place to stop in. Sorry.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, no, no. It's all good. I don't know why they rank them that way. But anyway, so one of the ones that was submitted was for a Google L9 software engineer. High, high, high up there. So you're talking like 10 to 15 years of very specific industry experience, leadership, all of that kind of other stuff. The base salary package was$480,000. Okay. Base salary. Pretty good start. Annual bonus of right around$130,000 of cash bonus.

SPEAKER_02Cash bonus. Cash bonus. Stock RSU bonus of$1.375 million annualized. Yeah. And that's a four-year situation. Okay. So basically you're talking roughly a five point two five million dollar stock package with vesting rules. Okay. And he was comparing that against some of the other packages out there, and it was mid-level. It was mid-tier. That's a mid-tier for a level nine software engineer.

SPEAKER_02Correct. Like if you go to Meta, their stock RSU bonus package is far superior. But there are different ways to evaluate this. I was watching this the other day, and that's how this all came up. Is because we've had multiple conversations with clients about this recently. Yeah. I saw this online, and then it made me think how can someone easily identify if A, a package is good, what the difference is between RSUs, employee stock purchase plans, all of those types of things.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And just how to go about thinking about this because it's such a huge wealth builder for people that I want to make sure people get it right.

SPEAKER_04Yes, I mean it's really important, especially in that situation where the compensation is more equity than salary. Right. So it's that's I mean, that's a heavy evaluation. And it can go the other way, obviously, where you know the equity compensation is a really small part of the total compensation package. And at the same time, you know, we we've worked with clients that have been able to achieve some of their financial dreams because they had that equity compensation element to it. And some of the choices that they made along the way helped them either retire early or just find financial success.

SPEAKER_04And it's it's really, really important to be actively engaged in those decisions because if you have some missed opportunities, you can really miss out on some long-term options.

SPEAKER_02Oh, 100%. The other thing, too, to keep in mind is as you become more senior in these roles and as you become more valuable to the company, your compensation goes from being probably 68 to 60 to 80% salary based to actually flipping the other way. Like if you looked at this offer, it's 60 to 70% stock based. Yeah. Because they want to keep you there longer. So you really have to understand these things as you become more senior and you move up the ranks, that the stock conversation is going to be an even bigger thing for you moving forward in the future.

SPEAKER_04All right. So we're talking RSUs, eesops, stock and equity options. Where do you want to start, Colin? Let's start with RSUs. Okay.

SPEAKER_02RSU is an RSU. So restricted stock unit. So basically what it is is it's awarded to you from the company. You did not purchase it. It is a part of your benefits package. So what that means is oftentimes when you sign on with a company, just like how I read with that offer from Google, you are awarded stock from a company in the form of grants, basically, is the way that that's set up. And you have a vesting schedule, which means that let's just say that there's a four-year vest and it's an equal amount every year.

SPEAKER_02Let's say your total package over a four-year period is a million dollars. What it's going to do is it's going to divide up that million dollar grant at the date of grant over a four-year period. So in theory, it would be 250, 250, 250, 250. Got it.

unknownYep.

SPEAKER_02So that's the setup of it, but we know that it might not actually be 250.

SPEAKER_04Right, because the stock value can change. Very much so. It's based on the value at the time of the award, not the time that it bests.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And that was the conversation I had with a client the other day is they received in their welcome offer, you know, a healthy stock package in the form of grants when they signed on. And the value of them dropped significantly over the last few months, as tech companies have. We know tech sold off, and some of the big ones have come down pretty dramatically. So what would have been, you know, a pretty healthy six-figure stock package ended up being much less than that on her first VEST schedule.

SPEAKER_04And there's so many things that just come to mind right then, right? Like, what do you do? What do you like? What happens if the company you're working for, the stock loses 30 or 40% of its value at the time that that equity's vesting for you and you finally have access to it?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, 100%. Well, I think that's like the big question. And we'll talk through this as well when we like talk about evaluating certain things. But when it comes to these schedules and these RSU packages, if you're leaning into a company that's very equity-based in your compensation package, you have to have a lot of faith in that company that they're going to continue to perform if you're going to tie your compensation and future well-being to it financially. Let's let's walk through that scenario.

SPEAKER_04Right. So let's say that you received a million dollars in RSUs in Salesforce when you signed on four years ago. And now all your shares have vested, but Salesforce is worth 40% less. So you have a$600,000 value in those shares instead of a million. How are you taxed on those shares?

SPEAKER_02So the way that you're taxed on those shares is let's use the example of a four-year vest before. And we'll just keep it easy. Companies have different vesting schedules. Some of them are front loaded, some of them are backloaded. But in this example, just to keep it easy, we'll say it's 25% a year over a four-year period. Yep. And um, we'll say it's annualized. So if that's the case, then if it's a million dollars, what it would do is it would basically look at the value of those shares at the vest date and you would be taxed on it as income when it vests.

SPEAKER_04Right at besting.

SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, but if it's a four-year vest, it would be 250. Okay. Right. The first year. But if the company went down in value, then it might be a lower tax burden. If it went up, then it's a higher tax burden.

SPEAKER_04You could look at it and say, if the company loses value, like let's say that I want, you know, I'm gonna own this stock for a while. You almost want to lose value when it vests.

SPEAKER_02So it can recover.

SPEAKER_04Then let's so let's say that you hold on to those shares. You say, I really believe in the future of Salesforce and Hentic AI and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And so now I'm gonna wait for my$600,000 to go back up to a million. And let's say over the next year that's what happens. Then I want to cash out. What, what, what do I pay? Then your tax at capital gains. Okay.

SPEAKER_02And if you hold it for more than a year, then it's long-term capital gains, which is a much favorable tax rate, usually, than your income tax. Yeah. So I can't remember the exact number, but I think the 10% capital gains bracket, if you're married filing jointly, goes up to, you know, in the like right around 500,000. It's low. Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. It's 15%. And then Yeah, 15%. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So so okay. So that that's one of those scenarios where you could bet on the future success of the company, you're working for it, you're like, I think the stocks can go back up. But then what if it goes down? Well, then that's the other thing.

SPEAKER_02So if it goes down in value, then A, the value of those benefits has gone down. So in theory, your total comp package at that point is kind of less than what you had originally anticipated. So that would mean that let's just say you had a thousand shares at, you know,$250. So$250,000 is what the original grant was supposed to be and it vests in that first year.

SPEAKER_04Yeah.

SPEAKER_02If that's the case, and if the value of those shares have gone from$250 to$200, then that's a$200,000 grant that would vest after that first year and you would be taxed on the$200, not the$250. Yeah. So you paid less in tax, but the value of it is less. Right. But you have to pay taxes on that. Companies do tend to withhold when the RSUs vest. And, you know, you take those and sell them and do whatever you want to do with them. Yeah.

SPEAKER_04But you don't have so like the difference, if you were just like a guy on the street, like we don't work for Salesforce. So let's say we want to go buy Salesforce stock, not an investment recommendation, and you say, well, I'm going to ride this out and I'm going to, you know, let it grow for four or five years. I'm going to be taxed capital gains tax on it. And I have control over that situation. Whereas when it's a company benefit, you have limited control. Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_02So if you were to just buy the stock outright, you know, you have control over that. When you have an RSU, that's restricted, hence the name. Um with that being said, if if you're really negative about that company, and let's just say you have all this money invest or vesting over a four-year period, there's nothing you can do about it. Yeah. You know, that's your bonus. That's what you're going to get. That's what you signed on for. That was your comp package. But if you just own it outright in your brokerage account, then you have total flexibility. And in the same way that after it vests, if you hold on to the stock, then you have more flexibility on what to do with it too.

SPEAKER_02And you can use tax losses to help reduce your future burden as well.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. So that becomes kind of like a just everybody's experience. Once you own the stock, it's fully vested. You're the same as any other investor.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. So you're basically the same as any other investor at that point. But, you know, with that being said, you do have other tools to be able to acquire the stock when you're at some of these companies, such as an employee stock purchase plan. Right. Which usually allows you to go in and buy the shares, oftentimes at a discount, but those are your shares. You put your own after-tax dollars into it. And then if you hold those for a year, you sell them. That's capital gains. What does that discount tend to look like?

SPEAKER_04I mean, what are some examples of some discounts that you've seen?

SPEAKER_02So an example that I saw recently for a healthcare company was a 10% discount on their stock price. So if it was trading at$200, you know, you would buy for$180 at that point. Um and it incentivizes employees to purchase the stock and kind of, you know, I'll say benefit from that discount. So we do see a lot of taking advantage of that where it becomes kind of tricky. And this was a client conversation, uh, same client that I was talking about, was they had huge RSU compensation, then they also were contributing pretty dramatically to the employee stock purchase plan.

SPEAKER_02So they had even more of their net worth tied up in the company's stock, which, hey, if the company's stock goes up, that's great. But it's very little diversification. Like there are other ways to get more diversification with maybe some of your other benefits through, say, a 401k or a mega backdoor conversion in plan. There's a bunch of different ways to get it done. Just keep that in mind.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. I mean, if you are fortunate enough to work for a company in which the stock really and you own stock right in the company and it massively appreciates, then you're in a good situation because you increased your wealth, but you concentrated all your wealth in one company. Right. And that one company also pays your bills on it. It does.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, it's very risky to have so much of your net worth tied up into a single company. Yeah. We all know horror stories of companies that, you know, were shining beacons of the future that completely fell apart. Yeah. And that's why, you know, diversification is such a strong thing that we talk about. But certainly a lot of people have gotten very wealthy over concentration as well.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. And you know, we have a lot of clients that work at a beverage company that has a really good employee stock option plan, a purchase plan. Some of the employees that work there have a 40% discount on the stock. That's huge. So it's a great, and it's a four-year Cliff Vesting. So it might be five, but it's a Cliff Vesting, and they're buying at such a discount that it's really hard to argue against that purchase option. We have clients, though, that we've worked with for, you know, well over a decade, and that price has been really volatile.

SPEAKER_04So a 40% discount is a really great buffer. It kind of like buffers out some of the volatility of the stock as it goes up and down. You don't have to worry about the decline as much because getting down to that 40% discount, you know, that's a really aggressive decline. It is. To get worse than that is not more, not all that likely. Right. But we have clients that because they build up so much wealth in that company, they have a really hard time selling the stock. And I've worked with clients that I couldn't convince to diversify, uh, or that diversification was in their best interest and their wealth has dropped precipitously as the stock is underperformed.

SPEAKER_04And I have had other clients that listened or maybe didn't listen right away, but when the stock went down, they started to listen and they diversified their risk. They got off that plunging roller coaster and they were able to retire early. It's the risk aspect of this is always what I'm kind of drawn to. And it makes it hard for me sometimes because I know that there's an opportunity that I'm almost like just vibrating away from like that's a massive opportunity, but it's also a massive risk.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I totally get that. You mentioned something that I want to unpack. Unpack something. Cliff vesting. Yes, what is cliff vesting? I was just gonna ask you that. You brought it up first. About a four-year cliff.

SPEAKER_04So there's as you just said, there's the different vesting processes, right? That gets either it could be annually vesting or it can invest all after like this one four-year or five-year period. Yep. And how much you this this compensation package that you were talking about, that you know, the L9 compensation package, what happens if they you know sever employment along the way? If it's if it's vesting all at the same time five years down the road, and you only make it two or three years, you're missing out on that equity compensation.

SPEAKER_04And I don't want to say that people gamify that, but it could be a factor in whether you are still employed when they're doing a headcount.

SPEAKER_02I was uh reading last night, just as I was prepping for this, what the average tenure is for a software engineer at a tech company. Well it is the average tenure. Two years.

SPEAKER_04Well, that's not great.

SPEAKER_02So something that becomes like a big factor when it comes to these packages is the vesting schedule. Oftentimes, depending on what it is you're trying to achieve and how mobile you are and your goals and how quickly you want to advance, it's possible you might not be with a company for very long, or it's possible you might be with a company for very long. And that changes the value of certain packages. Because in your example, the cliff vest at the end, if someone's looking to just get into a company, get great exposure, and then use that to advance to another company, that's not a great package to necessarily go with because you're missing out on total comp versus other packages might have a more front-loaded comp package in the beginning, where it's more like a 30 or 40% upfront vest for the first two years and then either 10 or some lower amount in the later years.

SPEAKER_02And that's a very important caveat that people don't often consider with these comp packages because life does change.

SPEAKER_04And you know what also people need to consider is their ability to negotiate, right? Like if you're if you're leaving Meta to go to Google, you can say, you know, I have$2 million in unvested shares. Can you match that? Can you give me some sort of besting schedule in 100%? Like I think the importance of focusing on the value of your, of your work, of you as an employee or a member of the team, it's really easy to get like stuck in this kind of idea that you you get what you get and you're just fortunate to have it.

SPEAKER_04And it's historically speaking, wem women have done a they've had a harder time advocating for themselves. And that is one of the ways in which they miss out or fall behind in wealth accumulation in these industries. If they're both L9 techs or L9 software engineers or whatever, and there's that gender diversity, if women don't really advocate for themselves, like men, I guess, feel born to do.

SPEAKER_04Like you have to be able to negotiate, you have to be able to negotiate and have inflated senses of value. I've seen Survivor. You have to negotiate. Yeah. Um, and you have to negotiate no matter who you are. The the first offer should not be the final offer.

SPEAKER_02One thing that I think is pretty powerful is looking back through history and seeing the evolution of the RSU benefits package conversation change so much. Because I remember when I started in this industry back in the day, RSUs were a topic of conversation, but certainly not as heavy as they are now. And I was just curious about this. I was looking back and I said, How much of the RSU's grown? And this is a Chat GPT exercise.

SPEAKER_02And 94% of public companies offer an RSU benefit to their employees. But if you were to go back to 2000, it was less than 20% for US publicly traded companies. And then if you think about it, think about the fall of the pension. Yep. I'm not saying RSUs have replaced the pension, but if you think about incentives for these major companies to offer stock options and employee stock purchase plans, it's benefiting them because their stock price is going up.

SPEAKER_02It's like gets everybody a seat at the table versus, you know, a pension before was an expense for the company that they would have to pay out to all of their employees. So I think we're gonna continue to see the RSU conversation evolve and become a bigger conversation moving forward. It's certainly here to stay.

SPEAKER_04Well, equity compensation is a line item in an every earnings report. And it is, to your point, something that is a little bit more fungible. Like they can manipulate that by shrinking headcount. 100%. And with a pension, you're kind of stuck with what you are, right? So that's that's a really good point. It's also, gosh, it it ties into so many of the conversations we've just had about deferred gratification, right? Getting a seat at the table, getting a seat of the American dream, the Trump accounts, et cetera. Yeah. And it's it's just it's really exemplary of the evolution of how we look at equity and stock and ownership and finance and just everything inside this country.

SPEAKER_04It just goes more and more and more towards capitalism. 100%. And ideally, more and more and more towards individualization within capitalism because you know, you get to control that to a degree. Um, but yeah, it it is it's a really interesting trend. That's a good point.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, it's almost like your community becomes that company that you're within if you're so heavily invested in it, going back to your community, same thing before. Yeah, it's a rah-rah, let's go. The rah-rah. Because if your net worth is really tied to that company, you want it to do well. Yeah. I have um two examples of comp packages that are currently available. Were these user plus six were they reviewed on on Twitter or whatever it was? No, I actually found these. And something that I think is a useful thing to think through is not just total comp.

SPEAKER_02And we touched on this briefly.

SPEAKER_00Yep.

SPEAKER_02But the amount of cash you're receiving versus the amount of stock you're receiving versus the vesting schedule you're receiving and how much that matters. And I think we can talk through these two examples and maybe stack rank them and talk through some of the differences and similarities. Do we get to pick? Like we do. Can I choose one of these? Of course you can. Sweet. Yes. All right. Uh so get your resume ready. Okay. I have not had a resume in two decades. Uh, probably about the same for me. Full of dust right now.

SPEAKER_02All right. So the first one is uh software engineer L5 level. Okay, at Google. Yep. Base salary,$195,000. Target bonus of 15%. Call it as near as makes no difference,$30,000 of cash bonus a year. Let's use$320,000 over a four-year period with a front-loaded vest. Okay. 33%, 33%, 22, and 12, and a one-time sign-on bonus in the first year of$40,000 with a subsequent sign-on bonus of$30,000 in the second year.

SPEAKER_02Do I have to live in California? You do. Mountain View, California. All right. So talking through this, summarizing, front-loaded vest,$320,000 in RSUs spread out over a four-year period, but mostly upfront, 66% in the first two years, and$195,000 base salary with a$30,000 upfront target bonus and a$40,000 sign-on bonus. So your total year one comp uh for this particular situation is$369,850.

SPEAKER_02Option two. Amazon. Okay. You're familiar with the company. I've heard of it. Yep. Okay. Sounds good. Senior software engineer. L6 level. Okay, better, better title. Better title. Similar, similar base comp$190,000. Target bonus first year of$38,000. Then you have RSUs of$400,000 over a four-year period.

SPEAKER_02However, they backload the vest. 5% first year, 15% second, 40% third, 40% fourth. You already have an opinion. However, your sign-on bonus in year one is$80,000. So you have a target bonus first year of$38,000 a sign-on bonus of$80,000 and a base salary of$190 with a 5% best. So what that means is your year one total comp is$328,000, but the latter half of your comp in years three and four is$388,000.

SPEAKER_02But year two is much smaller, right? Because you don't have that sign-on bonus. Correct. Yeah. So your year two sign-on bonus drops from$80 to 60. So very similar in terms of total comp amongst both packages, but it's amazing how different the structure is. And they sound similar. Like if someone was to be presented with those two things, you would be like, oh, well, I'm basically just choosing between the two companies. But that's not true. There's huge differences between them.

SPEAKER_04Well, you know what's also interesting? I mean, the average person might receive that and not even pay attention to the vesting schedule. Totally. Right. And you're really, you're drawing a line and focusing on it. And that's very helpful. Yeah. Um, because otherwise you're just you're focusing on the frontline numbers, especially an$80,000 sign-on bonus. Right. Does this seem a little arbitrary that there's these tiny, tiny other bonuses of$30,000? Like compared to all the rest of the income, your annual bonus is like nothing.

SPEAKER_04And it requires you hitting certain metrics in order to get it, whereas the other ones are just kind of like a given. Fair.

SPEAKER_02The one you have to work the hardest for is the smallest form of compensation. That's true. I think one thing that really sticks out to me, and the reason why I'm highlighting the vesting schedule so much is because you better be committing to being at Amazon for four years, or else you are leaving serious equity on the table. And this is assuming the stock price remains flat. You know, like the thing with the Amazon package is we're talking about that in year three or four. We know a lot can happen in the market in three and four years. It can go up, it can go left, right, sideways, wherever you need it to go, it can go.

SPEAKER_02But the fact of the matter is that you're committing to this company in terms of your total comp for those years three and four. And if you were to leave in year two, just like what we were saying before, you're leaving a ton of money on the tape.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, and you'd have to negotiate again, like I was saying. But you know what? I think I would pick option A, but it's not just because of the better vesting schedule. It's because of my thoughts on the company as well. Totally. So you have to kind of like you have to have a thesis, like an assumption on what the company is going to do, what both of these companies are going to do, and how they're going to be rewarded for that and their compensation and the equity growth.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, totally. Because when your comp is tied so much to the actual stock of the company, that makes a huge difference. Now, granted, too, we talked about it, you know, you can kind of play the game where, well, maybe if the stock's down, you hold it and you know, you let it recover if you have, you know, confidence in the company long term. Yeah. And on top of that, if you delay selling it, if you don't need the money right away, then ultimately you can play games with tax losses. And there's a bunch of different strategies that you can use to help diversify and mitigate your taxes.

SPEAKER_02But when evaluating these things, I think it's really important to keep the vest schedule in mind, keep, you know, the idea of what it is that you're looking to achieve long term, whether or not you see yourself long term with this company or how long you see yourself with this company. And then ultimately kind of evaluating the upfront versus the back end will make a huge difference in your financial plan long term as well.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Well, speaking of financial planning, I do think that when you're looking at this, either of these situations from a near-term financial planning perspective, you have to think about all of this deferred compensation as deferred. Like it's not there for you to plan to live off of, even if it's investing quarterly, or I mean not quarterly, but annually, like you have that additional compensation. It shouldn't be part of your assumed living expenses. And you shouldn't, I don't think, even tie them to.

SPEAKER_04I made this mistake. When we were at said former employer, and I had a schedule of when different shares were going to best and different income was coming my way. Right. I tied it to certain goals. I said, when this vest, I'll pay off this student loan. And when this vest, I'll pay off this student loan. And that was perfect on paper. And then we left. And then I said, Well, I guess I need a new plan. And uh I think one of the reasons it was hard for me, even though I valued what we were building more than just paying getting paid this deferred compensation at that company, was realizing that I had already mentally accounted for paying off something with that money.

SPEAKER_02Right. Well, I mean, ultimately, whenever you make these decisions and select a company and go through this, it's an investment decision. Yeah. You know, like by signing on to one of these packages and thinking through your RSUs and even at the top level ISOs and things like that, you know, you are making a personal investment decision. And you really need to evaluate your faith in that company because if you're going to tie your net worth to it, you have to have that confidence because it makes a huge difference.

SPEAKER_02And certainly a lot of people will get their stock options and just sell them right away, but other people have a ton of faith in the company and they hold them, and that's sometimes how real wealth is built. And we've seen that even with a lot of our own clients who have, you know, legacy stock positions from companies that they were at that have just appreciated like crazy. And um, you know, now we're coming up with strategies to trim them over time and make it tax efficient and manage them. But uh, it's it's a pretty big thing to think through.

SPEAKER_04It is. And the fact that we're thinking about your income, it's not salary, but your income and an investment, like the way that to your point earlier, the way we've had to evolve and change and evaluate income and how it's just creeped into evaluating investment is really kind of mind-blowing to me. And it's, you know, again, it doesn't have to be million-dollar packages. You know, that you there could be a 30 or 50 or$100,000 benefit that could be really meaningful to some people, but it's still tied to the success of the company.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. And it can never be presumed.

SPEAKER_02Comp packages are becoming more complex. Yeah. And when complexity steps in, it's really important that you do your research to figure out what it is that you're signing on for, understanding all of these things. And if you don't, and if you want a second opinion, it's important to reach out to someone like a financial planner who can help you with something like that. Because we could be talking, like you said, a smaller number that's still very impactful for someone, or a very big number that's going to be a multi-generational planning opportunity.

SPEAKER_02And you don't want to make the wrong decision when it comes to those types of things.

SPEAKER_04Do you want to get into anything that you can do to sort of offset some of the risk in that that in that equity that we receive?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, there's certainly things that some brief strategies I think that we can touch on. I think tax loss harvesting is probably one of the big ones. You want to talk through that?

SPEAKER_04Yeah. I mean, I I think the idea of if you let's just keep using Google because it's just a name we can use. You know, Google is a stock in the SP 500. There are a lot of companies that or index funds out there that will have a Google investment as a part of it. It might be a five or six or seven percent weighting, depending on how the company performs in any given year. But that's only like, let's call it 70,000 out of a million. Um, if you've done the other and you you have like, let's say you have$100,000 in index fund and a million dollars in Google, you are 93% invested in Google.

SPEAKER_04So what we want to try to do is diversify that risk across all the rest of those 500 names. And if we can start to build up in an individual account a fund that or a strategy that owns individual stocks and not just the index fund, we can first of all exclude Google because you shouldn't own it over here if you own so much of it over there. Yeah, you don't want that overlap. Right. And then you want to start to lost harvest along the way when the market goes down, right? Sell coke, buy Pepsi, et cetera, is the old adage.

SPEAKER_04I think that's a really good way to do it, but it's also just being really intentional. You shouldn't own Google anywhere else if it's 93% of your portfolio in one place.

SPEAKER_02Right. Exactly. Yeah, you don't want to have too much overlap in your portfolio in general. Now, this isn't investment advice. But with that being said, I think anybody that has one of these big packages understands that, you know, it's a meaningful amount of stock in one particular company. And certainly that's how net worths and I'll say wealth can be created and destroyed simultaneously. Coming up with a good strategy to help you offset the taxes from it that you're going to be paying in the form of capital gains and maybe even some other strategies along the way.

SPEAKER_02Diversification and figuring out how to manage these vesting schedules along the way and what to do with them is such like a crucial thing that you need to have a plan for.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. I mean, if you can use some losses that you harvest and realize in some other place to chip away at that iceberg of Google stock that you own in this other place, I think that's just a it's a really valuable approach. And there are ways to kind of accelerate that strategy. They're a little bit overly complex for us to get into.

SPEAKER_02Right. Yeah. But know that you have options and know that, you know, when it comes to these types of packages, evaluating every aspect of it is important. Yeah. Cool. I think that's a great place to leave it.

SPEAKER_04Agreed. Great job today, Colin. Oh, likewise. I do want to encourage our listeners to start to reach out and share their thoughts with us. We should ask people to like and subscribe. We should. We never do. We never do. And we're going to do a better job of asking for that, like referrals. Exactly. Yeah. You don't get it. You don't miss 100% of the shots you don't take cut. But also, what I find more often than not is when I am getting ready for one of our mailbags, it's not a question, but it's a correction that's coming in from one person or another.

SPEAKER_04Feel free to correct us or share your critiques. Yeah. Or just tell us we're doing a great job.

SPEAKER_02If if you're a listener and you want to either leave a comment or reach out with also suggestions on future episodes, might be a good thing. Reach out to Tori, yes, T-O-R-I, at KofiAdvisors.com. Now that's not there.

SPEAKER_04I feel like info at KofiAdvisors.com might be a better place.

SPEAKER_02You can just this episode goes viral. I'll feel bad for your inbox, Tori. It's my fault.

SPEAKER_01All right. Thanks. Compound growth with Wheeler and Colin, sponsored by Cobby Advisors. Reach out today. Yay!

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. With Nvidia Down 30%, What Should Investors Actually Worry About Before Year End?

    Nov 16, 202650 minAudio

    Nvidia is down roughly 30% from its highs after the Jensen Huang headlines, the market has swung hard since the midterms, and year end is bringing a tax bill some investors won't see coming. It's hard to tell which of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The K-Shaped Economy, Bitcoin's Rough 18th Birthday, and the Slow-Go Years That Never Come

    Nov 9, 202645 minAudio

    The headlines say the economy is strong and the market is near its highs, but for a lot of people it doesn’t feel that way. Wheeler and Colin are joined by Dan to look at who this economy is actually working for....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Property Taxes on the Ballot, Visa and Mastercard Under Pressure, and a Bubble on Watch

    Nov 2, 202646 minAudio

    Property tax bills keep climbing, a bill in Congress promises lower card fees while card companies warn that rewards could shrink, and everyone seems to be waiting for the AI bubble to burst. It’s hard to tell where the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. A Call From Inside the House, the Fall of FICO, and a Retirement Plan AI Couldn't Finish

    Oct 26, 202647 minAudio

    Homes cost about five times the typical household income, the average car payment has climbed by about a third in five years, and letters from the Treasury keep arriving with help that rarely adds up to much. It can...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mailbag: Is AI Truly Being Adopted or Just Distributed?

    Oct 23, 202619 minAudio

    In the race of technology, is AI truly the fastest adopted innovation in history, or is it just a case of mass distribution? If you’ve been questioning the impact of AI on the economy, your portfolio, or even just your...

    Credit the people on this episode