Bob Crawford - John Quincy Adams is a Vehicle for Understanding Today
54 minAudio
You may know Bob Crawford as the bassist for the Avett Brothers, but while traveling in a van for years across the United States, Bob discovered he loved reading history. One thing led to another, and he’s now written his own book: a biography of John Quincy Adams. We talk about the process of writing his first book, how he came to understand Adams’ story, and how it helped him understand today’s political climate. America’s Founding Son releases next week; you can preorder a copy here. Hey friend, thank you so much for reading this piece. I’ve decided to keep all of my Substack writings public so they can be as accessible as possible. That said, I rely on paid subscribers to sustain this work as an independent creator. If my writing has been helpful and you’d like to help it reach more people, would you consider becoming a paid subscriber? I’d be so grateful. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit compendiumshow.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01I love research and writing. It's a place to go. No matter what else is going on, it's like somewhere I can get lost. Getting to a point where I've been doing music professionally for over 20 years, music is also what you do to make money. And it's work. And it's glorious work. It's amazing work. But it's really great, because I spent all this time working on this book, and it made me love playing music as well at the same time.
SPEAKER_01It just gave this weird flow of energy from one love to another love. Adams is the son of John Adams. Abigail takes him. They walk a mile up to a mountain ridge and watch the Battle of Bunker Hill. At eight years old, he's the eyewitness to Battle of Bunker Hill. A few years later, he goes to France with his father. There he's educated while his father is negotiating France into the war. Then he becomes a diplomat. Washington appoints him to his first diplomatic post.
SPEAKER_01He's off and running, right? His parents raised him to be the preserver, of the nation they sacrificed all to establish. In the best movie, the best book, you see a character make a turn in their life. It's how these characters, they change over time, how we all change over time. And Adam's change over time is very dramatic, and it's beautiful.
SPEAKER_00What is the thing that now that you're on the other side of it, you've written the book, you've done the research, what is the thing that you've come away with from this project and how it's sort of impacted you personally and maybe impacted how you potentially see the world?
SPEAKER_01Democracy's always in crisis.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Today, I'm so excited to welcome an amazing guest on the show. You may know Bob Crawford as the bassist for the band, the Avett Brothers, where he's been touring with them for 20 years. And now he's got a new book out about John Quincy Adams. So today we're going to talk about that intersection of music and writing history, what it was like for him to write his first history book and sort of what he's learned about himself in the process. We're also going to dive into what made John Quincy Adams so
worthy of a new book, why Bob decided to write the book that he hoped would be the beach read for so many
SPEAKER_00people. We're going to talk about how John Quincy Adams's career in politics can sort of be reflected in today's politics and why it's so important to keep going back to history and trying to educate ourselves about American history and trying to understand who we are and where we come from. This was such a fantastic conversation. I'm so thankful to Bob for coming on the show. So without any further ado, let's hop into the conversation with Bob Crawford. Bob Crawford, thank you so much for coming on the show.
SPEAKER_00Josh, it's an honor to be invited. Well, I brought you on because you've got a book coming out here soon about John Quincy Adams. Now, many folks may know you from the Avett Brothers. But this is a little bit of a different thing, and it's very exciting. So tell me a little bit about this relationship with touring and music and then now getting into history, and how did all that happen? So, yeah, okay. How did I get to be such a big fan of history to the point of
going back to school
SPEAKER_01while I'm on the road touring with a band, starting a history podcast 10 years ago, and ultimately writing a book? You know, I think that that's kind of your question. And I always felt connected to history. I've always, my whole life, since I was a young boy, we would go on, and I'm 54, so we're talking about the 1970s here, but we would go on family vacations and we would stop at the rest stops and there would be these little kiosks with pamphlets for local historic
sites and I would
SPEAKER_01collect them. And we would go back home and I would lay them out on the floor and just look at them and whatever. It was just kind of weird. And my mother would take me to some, in South Jersey, my mother would take me to some local historic sites from time to time. And I just always felt connected to it, but I didn't have an outlet for it or a direction for it. I wasn't a great student. But I always did good in history classes and was always just – the knowledge just kind of absorbed into me somehow for that particular subject.
SPEAKER_01So when we started going on the road in the early 2000s, here we are, three guys originally in a conversion van and we are – in that van eight, nine hours a day, sometimes longer. And we talked a little bit. We didn't listen to a lot of music, ironically, which is kind of funny driving around. But we did a lot of talking. And I started to read. We're talking about 2003 and 2004. And it was a period of American...
SPEAKER_01history that was very like always in crisis. We were involved in these wars in Iraq and Afghanistan and horrible things were coming out about what was happening in Abu Ghraib, which was like this prison in Iraq where American soldiers had been just like taking horrible photos of these prisoners and really just kind of abusing them and
I remember reaching this moment where I was like, wow, gee, how do we get here?
SPEAKER_01How did it start 1776, if that's your starting point, and how did we get to what is happening today here in this far off land and involved in this war? Of course, it was all connected to 2001 and September 11th and all that. So at the same time, David McCullough had either put out John Adams or 1776. And he was on all the, I mean, every time I turn on the TV,
he was on some show.
SPEAKER_01And the way he spoke about history just mesmerized me and captivated me. And so I started reading his books. I started with, I think I did 1776 first, and then I did John Adams. And that set me off. Here I was... in an environment conducive to reading, being in a van for many hours a day. And it just captivated me. And I wanted to see this, like,
I imagine straight line from back from 2004 to 1776 or whatever that starting is.
SPEAKER_01But I quickly realized that That that American history is not a straight line and maybe it's not a road, even though we have the road to now. Maybe it's an ocean. Maybe it's in its deep and it's vast and it's mysterious. And and in that in that ocean, in that road, whatever analogy you want, you want to use. there are these characters. And these characters are every bit as rich and as compelling as
any character you
SPEAKER_01will read in fiction. And they really lived and they really existed. And they were good, bad, ugly. Some found redemption. Some went the opposite way in their life. And I just was hooked. I was just really hooked.
SPEAKER_00You know, I had a similar experience as well. Dave McCullough seems like just a great window in for so many different people. Isn't he? He's the gateway drug. He is. He is. And it's funny because 1776, I was actually this morning, I was just flipping through it. and he, it's so funny. He finds a way to write a really accessible history, but it's rigorous. And, and he includes a lot of quotes, uh, from primary sources, which I think, you know, the,
SPEAKER_00the, the thing we're always told is, you know, summarize things. Right. And he, he does that, but I just noticed he wants you to see what people were saying in their own words about what was happening early on. And, um, In that way, he tended to humanize a lot of these people that he's writing about. And that was just like this morning. I was like, man, he does such a good job of three-dimensionalizing some of these people that as time moves on, right, they get very two-dimensional. They turn into whatever you want them to be.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. the history is funny like that, especially American history. Um, so you're coming at this outside of academia and I'm really curious, what is that experience like, like coming at it sort of outside of the academic space, but like you, you obviously got to do academic work in order to write a book like this. What has that experience been like for you? Is there like archival work happening? What's what, what was that experience like for you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So just to be clear on this, my historiography learning, like, right. My, my, my master, I got my master's. I went to Arizona state online and I started in like 2018. I finished in 2020. And so that was my, like, I did, I did ultimately go through, you know, the academia, but I come at this.
like you said earlier about McCullough and trying to make something accessible.
SPEAKER_01So the goal here was not, and I have this amazing 700 page John Quincy Adams book right here, but it's at the bottom of the pile. So I'm afraid to pull it out, but it's Randall Woods and it's, it's like, it's like 800 pages and it's created a grave and it's amazing and everyone should read it. But my book is like 300 pages and it's, I want you to read it on your beach week. Like I want you to be able to consume this book and in two or three weeks and I want you to be after the goal here
is after you consume this book to be so excited you want to read another history book like that is I want like I want you to read this book and go oh my god I didn't know that happened and then I want to learn more about this character in this book or this character
SPEAKER_01in this book or another time period like that is the goal so How did I, source-wise, okay, so the one thing that people need to understand about John Quincy Adams is he kept a diary from when he was, I don't know, like 14 years old in like 1779 or something like that until his death in 1848. So he has left behind this massive account of,
SPEAKER_01first-person telling of the first half of the 19th century, political history of the first half, and other things, and some very personal things. You will find, if you read a book about American history, the first half of the 19th century, you look in the sources, whether your book's about John Quincy Adams or not, his diary is probably a source. His diary is probably a source. Now, the amazing and there's many different editions of his diary
you can get.
SPEAKER_01You can go out and get you can find it for free online. In fact, what I wound up using, I have a few different editions. And then I learned about through the Massachusetts Historical Society, which has the Adams Papers. They have primarysourcecoop.org. I'm pretty sure it's .org. Primary Source Co-op. And his whole diary is there. And it is searchable through date, through name.
SPEAKER_01It became an incredible... And to this day, I'm still reading it. I'm still reading it. And so... That, I would say, was my main primary source. My other source were the congressional journals going back from that time period. And they are also available for everyone to – and I encourage – and these are in the notes of the book. I encourage everyone to go read these actual debates on the floor of the House and the Senate. And they are all – they had different –
SPEAKER_01It's like you have the Congressional Record, and then you have the Gales and Seton version of the journals, but they're all available to us online. And the University of North Texas, I went through a couple different portals to get to them, but the University of North Texas had, for me, the most accessible way to access them. So... Check out the congressional record. You can do it, I think, from the first Congress to the current Congress.
SPEAKER_01It's all there. That's amazing. And then what I would do is... We were in Boston for a few days with the band and I went to the Massachusetts Historical Society and I did some, looked at letters and some other documents. I went to the Library of Congress, which we are all, everybody, historian or no matter what you do for a living, American, you have, they are our documents. Those are our documents. And you go to the Library of Congress,
you get a Library of Congress card.
SPEAKER_01Which I have, which we all, again, we're all entitled to. You go into the archive, you fill out a sheet, what you want to see. You go to a table. They say go to a table. And then they wheel out on a cart the folders for what you want to see. But that was an incredible experience, that first experience in that archive. And then when I couldn't get somewhere, you know, because I'm on tour with the band and I've got, you know, a family and we have a really complicated home life.
SPEAKER_01And I would find out where some documents I wanted, like Benjamin Lundy. He's a Quaker abolitionist, big character and very important in this book. He had a newspaper called The Genius of Universal Emancipation. And so I found out that most of those are in Columbus, Ohio, in an archive in Columbus or in a library in Columbus, Ohio. So I hired... someone to go and make copies of all that and send that to me.
SPEAKER_01And I also did that for the Pennsylvania Historic Society. You can go on there and you could pay a small fee and they'll send you documents and copies of documents. So, and then of course, secondary sources, like massive stack of books. And again, in the notes section, I lay all this out for everybody can see where all the information came from. So it's funny because I'm working on a proposal right now for a history book,
SPEAKER_00and this part of it, the research part of it, you know, I find that research and writing are braided together. They're all kind of one long thing, and the research never really stops. The writing also never really stops. You just sort of, at least— my process has been so far. Like you write a little bit and then you're like, Oh, I need to go do more. And then you go do more and you're like, Oh, I want to write a little bit here. But it's this, it's a really fun sort of herky jerky kind of a, kind of a process. My favorite part of the process. It's, it's so much fun. And also, um, the,
SPEAKER_00that feeling that you get when you find something. You don't know what you're really looking for, but when you find it, it's that eureka, aha, kind of a, oh, this is absolutely going in the book. It's going to be great. You know, it's amazing. Um, were you pursuing a theme when you were, when you were doing this book? Cause you're not doing a cradle to grave biography. Thank the Lord, by the way, hot take. Thank the Lord. Yeah. Biographies. Sure. We need more 300 page biographies. I think that's, that's maybe the new wave. Um, were you pursuing like a theme or,
or were you trying to study political power or are you trying to study maybe some
SPEAKER_00views that he had? What was your approach to this book?
SPEAKER_01I wanted to, um, bring to life the 1830s and 1840s. Like I wanted people to get a sense of what was it like in the halls of power? What was it like out in the country? Like, like here we're, we're in a moment now where you have politicians and you have activists and And we had that then. And Adams is kind of like this kind of connection. In an odd way, he was the establishment for most of his life. Like, he's the establishment. Like... And in fact,
SPEAKER_01that's why he was a one-term president, because he was the old way and people wanted a new way, right? But he becomes this pipeline for what is happening in the country, like this anti-slavery movement that's happening in the country. And he kind of gets tapped into that in a way. And in fact... He does it in a way where he can be critical of the activists, and then he'll turn around and do something that completely supports and benefits them. He's this crazy character. But I knew,
so reading about him in that time period, these two names would come up.
SPEAKER_01But it would always be a paragraph or a couple sentences. Benjamin Lundy and Theodore Weld. And they're both abolitionists from different generations of the movement. Lundy's like the old school abolitionist and here Weld is the new, the new, like the second, second great awakening inspired, uh, you know, uh, abolitionist. And they both have these connections to Adams.
SPEAKER_01And I wanted to tell the story of the three. Like that was like what made this like different. And I didn't know, I didn't know when I was like writing the proposal and I was mapping this out and like, how do you do this? Like, how do I go from here's Adams in Washington, here's Lundy in Ohio, here's Weld, you know, in, in, in New York. How do I, how am I going to do this? Like no one's going to buy, like no one, I mean like no one's going to buy it, but like no,
SPEAKER_01no publisher's going to buy it. Like, you know, this is completely wacky, but that's what I wanted to, the story I wanted to tell. And it's the story I ultimately got to tell.
SPEAKER_00How'd you figure that out, those relationship between the three of them?
SPEAKER_01Timeline, chronology. You know, somebody told me that their mentor told them, abandon chronology at your own peril. And I stuck to it pretty well. Like I stuck to it. Pretty, pretty well. Like there, there were times I had to kind of start back again and then work back up.
But I, I, you know, finding those like chronological connections is how I ultimately did it. And then you realize like when you're going through the, like the editing process,
SPEAKER_01Like someone will say, well, what happened to Lundy? Where'd he go? I'm reading this thing and you haven't talked about him in a while. And so then you have to go and find like, okay, where was he at this moment? How can I bring him back in for a minute to remind everybody he's here, you know? And then, and I also had to keep the camera on Adams. Like the focus always had to be on Adams, even when I'm with these other guys who are like supporting characters.
SPEAKER_00What'd you learn about yourself when you were doing all this? Because this is a multi-year process. It is, and I'm projecting a little bit on you just from my own experience with trying to do a similar thing, but you're almost like grasping at it and you're trying to figure it out. And there's a lot of time spent Just try to figure out what do you have? Is the story you're trying to tell actually the story you're going to tell? And, you know, you can't really shape it. You're subjected to the facts for good or ill. And,
SPEAKER_00you know, it's a moving, breathing, organic process that takes a while to kind of come in fully formed. What did you learn about yourself in that long process? I love research and writing.
SPEAKER_01Like I love, I just, it's, it's a place to go, right? It's just like a place to go. And it's a, I don't know. It just, no matter what else is going on, it's like somewhere I can get lost. Right. Like it's almost like, yeah, somewhere to go to get lost. And I really, I really enjoy that. And it's nice. Like people have hobbies and things they do that bring them great peace. And music is that for me as well. But I, you know,
getting to a point where I've been doing music professionally for over 20 years,
SPEAKER_01you know, Music is also what you do to make money and it's work and it's a glorious work. It's amazing work, but it's really great. Cause I spent all this time working on this book and it made me love playing music as well. Same time. Like it, it just gave, it's just this weird flow of energy from, you know, one, one love to another love. And you know, it's so that that's what I learned about myself that I also learned that like, um,
SPEAKER_01The process of, like, I love talking about the book. Mm-hmm. I don't love the idea of sitting down with a group of people who have, have paid me to do the book and then say like, and then mapping out how to sell the book. Like I don't like it. And this is all parallels what we do with records, with albums, like the, you know, the, the part in everybody, like, thankfully everybody I've worked with on this book on every side of it has, has been amazing. And they're all very excited about it.
SPEAKER_01And, There's a lot of enthusiasm. And so that makes it easier. But just the idea of like trying to convince people to buy your thing. Right. That's kind of like that can be there's a line there. And I want to stay on the good side of that line, the positive side of that line. But that's like the least like we've sat like with the band. I've sat in meetings over the years with record labels and like that can just be. you know, just can kind of be a bummer sometime. It just can kind of kills the whole beauty of,
SPEAKER_01of what you, what you've trying to create, what you've created, but it's necessary. And so, you know, this is what I've learned about myself. I love making and creating and not always don't always love selling, but if I can, if I can sell from my heart genuinely, uh, that's, that'll be the most positive, positive way to do it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I have, I have noticed just through social media and kind of approaching this, you know, from, from a far off place, but there is like an excitement about it. You know, the way you talk about it, you can tell there's, there's a passion there and it comes through. Adams is yet, I think he's the most powerful and consequential American public servant in
SPEAKER_01between Washington and Lincoln. We're in a time now where a lot of people would say there are no heroes in politics. We don't have a Washington or a Lincoln who's going to save us from the crisis that we're in. As far as we know right now, that person is not around. And And putting all that weight on one person is kind of ridiculous.
SPEAKER_01But Adams, by sheer force of his... Yielding to adherence to the ideas of the Constitution and, more importantly, the Declaration of Independence was kind of the man standing in the breach at a time when... And in the best fiction, in the best movie,
SPEAKER_01the best book, you see a character make a turn in their life. Right. It's how we, how these characters, they make turn, they change over time, how we all change over time. And Adams is change over time is, it's very dramatic and it's, it's, it's beautiful. And, and so, right. I'll never find a subject like him again, right. To, to spend time with and work on. And, and the, the, you talk about the years.
SPEAKER_01Well, the years were, discovering him and then pitching a podcast. So I did a six part America's founding son, John Quincy Adams series for I heart going back to, we started that in 2022, I guess. And then that led to this book. And when I signed the contract for the book, I had one year to deliver the book. which having never done this before, that's no joke.
SPEAKER_01It's no joke. And it kind of sucks, you know? And so the good news was I had so much experience with him and so much research already in the tank. And I had the, the, the series to draw upon, right. To kind of, we tell a bigger story. We tell a lot, a lot more that we couldn't tell. You know, the series was like six half hour episodes. I think it's like 13 pages, a script per episode. So, you know, starting with that,
SPEAKER_01you know, and then being like, well, where do I want to start this? Missouri Compromise is essentially where we start this 1820 and we're going to 1848. So whereas the, the podcast series kind of like, you know, hit highlights and, and, and told a narrative. And I think it really came out amazing. And we had amazing actors read the, We had Nick Offerman as Andrew Jackson and Patrick Warburton was an incredible John Quincy Adams. So anyway,
that's kind of what went into this and how much time it took to do it.
SPEAKER_00Dig a little bit deeper into John Quincy Adams standing in the breach, because you do have, you've got your Henry Clay's, your Calhoun's, your Andrew Jackson's. What makes John Quincy Adams different from those? Because those are like the establishment figures, right? Those are the main guys that shape American politics. How does he sort of differ from those?
SPEAKER_01Andrew Jackson, here's an interesting, Andrew Jackson was the populist who the guy rose to fame. He rises to national fame after the Battle of New Orleans. It was 1815. So funny. See, Adams and Jackson were both born in 1767. And they have these incredibly different life experiences.
SPEAKER_01Adams is the son of John Adams. Abigail takes him... They walk a mile up to a mountain ridge and watch the Battle of Bunker Hill, like eyewitness at eight years old. He's the eyewitness to Battle of Bunker Hill. He goes, a few years later, he goes to France with his father. There he's educated while his father is negotiating France into the war. Then he becomes a diplomat. First, he's like a diplomatic assistant. And then Washington appoints him to his first diplomatic post.
SPEAKER_01And he's off and running, right? His parents raised him to be the preserver of the nation they sacrificed all to establish. So public service is what is ingrained. I know his parents thought like, he will be president one day like that was like the big dream he goes on to be this two-term secretary of state with monroe he's the author of the
monroe doctrine on paper 1824 presidential election he's got it right he's got it and you can like
SPEAKER_01draw like a not a perfect parallel but like 2016, on paper, Hillary Clinton. She's first lady, senator, blah, blah, blah. Secretary of State, no-brainer. She's presidential timber. Jackson, he's born in the Waxhalls of North Carolina, which is like this border region between North and South Carolina. Very poor. His father dies before he actually is actually,
SPEAKER_01while his mother's pregnant with him, his father dies. When the war comes, he is like a messenger for, you know, the rebels. You know, in the South, we would think of them as rebels there, you know, for the Americans, right? And he is like, at one point, a British soldier tells him to shine his boots, and he refuses, and knocks him over the head with the back of a sword and he's got the scar for life
and this hatred for the bridges he loses his brothers and his mothers all to the war he's orphaned after the revolutionary war he's orphaned he he uh he gets his law degree in salisbury north carolina he's wild he's a wild man he goes out west goes tennessee makes his money comes a slave holder and you know all this stuff
SPEAKER_01ultimately goes in into the the what we think of as the national guard, the militia in Tennessee. And he becomes the hero of the battle of new Orleans and he's a folk hero. And he represents, um, the rising wave of populism because here we are at this moment in the 1820s where the revolutionary, the founding generation are passing from the scene and And what do you always think of your father's generation?
You know, the next generation is always going to do it better in their mind.
SPEAKER_01They're going to do it different. And at the same time, the suffrage is being extended not only to landholders, but to white men. These white farmers and tradesmen, they're getting the right to vote. And so in 1824, and this is the best way I can kind of articulate this moment and who these characters are. Adams is the establishment running for president, and Jackson is the populist, if you want to think of him.
SPEAKER_01I mean, we can think of somewhat of a parallel. It's not, believe me, it's not a perfect parallel. But there is a parallel to like 2016, 2020 with the rise of Jackson. And so... When I compare Adams to the thing that, so Jackson's the populist leader, Adams is the establishment. Clay and Calhoun and all these guys, Adams in his diary,
he called out all the politicians. He was not only a great public servant and had a great handle on American history and the founding documents and the rules of parliamentary procedure and all that,
SPEAKER_01but he was an observer of human nature. So if Daniel Webster is promoting himself in a certain way or says something, or if Henry Clay does it, He's like, they are egotistical. They are just trying to get votes. They have no soul. He basically calls everybody out. He calls everybody out for who they are. And he had his faults as well. Believe me, he was obviously very egotistical. He was a curmudgeon and he didn't have a lot of close relationships.
SPEAKER_01But he called everybody out. So where does Adams stand? Adams was... And he thought of himself as the representative for the whole union, and he was a party of one. Even when he was a member of the Whig party, he was always independent. He had criticism for William Henry Harrison or U. Lawson White or whoever was standing for the Whig ticket, as much as he had criticism for Van Buren or Jackson,
SPEAKER_01whoever was standing for the Democratic ticket.
SPEAKER_00Fascinating. Yeah, so... I think with, with Adams, I think the broad strokes of the story are you have a guy who, if you look at him as just a president, you're sort of selling the story way, way short because there's so much. Right. There's, there's so much more to him. The highlight is not presidency, but what is the highlight? If it's not the presidency, you would think that would be the highlight, right? But, but it's not. What is it?
SPEAKER_01It's the seventh. So he is, and we haven't even said this up to this, however long we've been speaking. 35 minutes. So Adams was a failed one-term president. He wins in 1824 in a really controversial election, and then he loses in 1828. To Andrew Jackson. Finally, he loses to Andrew Jackson. Outright. Outright loses. And he goes, from there, he goes into Congress. He's the only president to go into Congress after his presidency.
SPEAKER_01And there he serves for 18 years before he dies. And it's his time in Congress that I think his legacy is cemented as being the man standing in the breach. Because it's in Congress that he slowly becomes anti-slavery, staunchly anti-slavery. But he comes to it through being a defender of freedom of speech.
SPEAKER_01That's how he becomes this anti-slavery activist is because the Southern slaveholders in Congress and their Northern allies passed what is known as the gag rule. And the gag rule meant that you couldn't mention slavery on the floor of the house. They weren't allowed to do it. And this is at a time when all these abolitionists and people were sending petitions. So the First Amendment, one of the clauses is you can petition your government for a redress of grievances. And in the 19th century,
SPEAKER_01that was like literally, like there was time set aside in the House calendar and the Senate calendar where people Congressmen and senators would read petitions from their constituents, and then they would decide what to do with them. Would you table it? Which means just kind of goes away. Would you send it to a committee? Would you act on it? Would you print it and publish it? And so, but anti-slavery petitions as of 1836,
SPEAKER_01May of 1836, were no longer allowed to be acknowledged at all. And that kind of like was the switch for Adams because he's like, well, you're talking about freedom to petition. Yeah. What happens next to freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom to peaceably assemble? Now you are damning the Constitution of the United States, the First Amendment, on behalf of slavery,
SPEAKER_01in defense of slavery. You are weaponizing the Constitution against the people. And that's essentially what was happening. And that's part of why the story is so relevant.
SPEAKER_00I think when we think about John Quincy Adams collectively, we think about him as being unbelievably intelligent. It's famous now. You can go back and read the letters he's writing to his father where he's talking about the schoolwork that he's doing. I think it's when they're in France. And the stuff he's doing is just unbelievable. And you're not going to find any other 8, 9, 10, 11-year-olds, however old he was when he wrote the letters, doing the stuff he's doing. Like, he's just fabulously intelligent. How does that sort of shape his political career,
but also his convictions and sort of how he comes to arrive at a lot of these
SPEAKER_00convictions?
SPEAKER_01Annoyingly intelligent, right? Imagine knowing someone like him. Like, we've all known someone like him. This person. And how do those people who are gifted that way, how do they interact with others? It's hard for them. It's hard for them, right? Yeah. So the thing with Adams is that he had what we would say, my dad would say, that person's got book smarts, but they don't have street smarts. Yeah. And that's Adams' president.
He can't connect with the American people because he doesn't know how to connect with people.
SPEAKER_01And so he's quoting Cicero and Tacitus, and it's like you're a farmer in Virginia or a farmer out in Tennessee or something, and that doesn't – Kentucky, you don't – how do you connect with that guy? You don't connect with that guy. But that common man, Jackson, is you know, who's rough, Old Hickory. Now that's a guy who gets me. And so Adams didn't get the American people.
SPEAKER_01And while he was president, And it took him a while, but eventually he gets there. Eventually he connects. But that is the biggest thing about him. He says this thing in his first annual message to Congress, which we would think of that as when the president speaks in front of the State of the Union. Yeah. Right? Yeah. He says, back then it was a letter to Congress, and then it's published in the newspapers.
SPEAKER_01He says, he's laying out how we need to invest in a naval academy. We need to invest in universities, in scientific technology, in lighthouses of the sky, which are telescopes. We need to build roads, federally funded roads and bridges, infrastructure. He says, we can't be palsied by the will of our constituents into not doing this. What does that mean?
SPEAKER_01Well, he essentially says, congressmen, senators, your people don't want to spend the tax dollars on this, but they don't know what's best for them. We can't let them hold us back. We're in competition with Europe. And that, pausied by the will of our constituents, was basically him saying, basket of deplorables. And it had the same effect. It was tone deaf, right? And Andrew Jackson, who's just lost 1824 election, picks right up on it.
SPEAKER_01And Jackson's supporters pick right up on it. And it becomes the rallying cry. Like, Adams, he doesn't get it. You don't need a professor as president. We don't need a professor. We need a... strong man, you know, to be president. So it reminds, there's a moment when Thomas Jefferson does the Louisiana Purchase.
SPEAKER_00And strictly speaking, at the time, it's not something you're like, technically allowed to do like it's a gray area it's like can I even do this and the thing that he uses as a justification essentially is he says I'm doing it for the nation's good they don't really know how good this is going to be for them whether or not I can technically like this is I promise you this is going to be great In fact, Abraham Lincoln—I was reading a book by John Meacham, and he basically says when Abraham Lincoln suspends the writ of habeas corpus in
SPEAKER_001861, he's thinking a very similar thing. It's for the nation's good. It's for your good. It'll be just fine. And it's so fascinating to find that with Adams because that seems to be a thing that when you're reading about presidents, there are moments where—maybe it's a big thing or a very small thing, but there are moments where they go, This is for your good, whether you know it or not, whether it's strictly within the within the realm of what's possible or not. Does is there like a.
SPEAKER_00Is that symptomatic, I guess, of how he tends to approach politics? Like, I just need to do things for the good of the people. And it's, you know, is there a time when maybe he is doing things for the good of people and maybe they come to recognize it? Or is he not really appreciated in that way until maybe after he passes away?
SPEAKER_01He is appreciated. He is... The deeper he dives into the anti-slavery fight, and he was never an abolitionist, but he becomes a fellow traveler with the abolitionists. At the same time, he's being very critical of them. He was definitely a man alone, but then he had a couple of victories against the forces of slavery. And that's when he becomes beloved and appreciated by his people.
SPEAKER_01So he experiences it in his lifetime. It comes late, but he gets that victory lap. Uh, and yeah, so the, yes, when he later in his life, and this is part of that great turn he makes in his life, but later in his life, he becomes very appreciated for fighting against slavery, for taking a stand against slavery. What do you think Adam's career would suggest about the nature of democratic politics?
SPEAKER_00Because It's a very up-and-down, convoluted sort of a thing. And I've heard it said that the best part about democratic politics is that there's a feedback loop. Something you don't get in autocratic systems is you don't have a feedback loop. And at times, that feedback loop can be really chaotic or can feel really chaotic, but that's the beauty of it, that there is sort of this self-correcting nature to it. Is there a way to sort of read into his career and come away
thinking certain
SPEAKER_00things about the nature of democratic politics and how they work?
SPEAKER_01Adams knew that men are corrupted. You know, he recognized that. He recognized that, you know, as much of a defender of the Constitution as he was, One of the things that he writes about, like, so he'll write about against slavery in his diary, you know, a long time before he begins to speak out about it. And so he's predicting the Civil War in 1820 in his diary to himself. And...
SPEAKER_01He knows that politics is a very corruptible kind of a thing, but the ideals... It's like the Declaration of Independence kind of comes up in this book repeatedly, and it was actually used by... those who were against slavery. It was held up by them as well. And so it's funny because Adams grows to hate Jefferson.
SPEAKER_01He grows to be a great critic of Thomas Jefferson. but yet he always holds up the Declaration of Independence. And so what he knew about politics was people are corruptible and are greedy and are out for themselves, but we need to stick to these ideals. We need to hold these ideals sacred.
SPEAKER_00Is his relationship with Jefferson sort of an offshoot of his father's relationship, or is it something that he kind of comes to himself?
SPEAKER_02Both. both.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I could see how that would be like a really awkward kind of a, kind of a relationship for him. Well,
SPEAKER_01in fact, like while his father's repairing his relationship with Jefferson, you know, Adams is kind of being critical, critical of Jefferson. So John Quincy is being more, more critical, but, but even as John Adams, to the best of my knowledge of, and this side of it, I don't, I can't be an expert, but, but to my knowledge, uh, Adams, John Adams was still critical of Jefferson while they were repairing their friendship into his face. Like literally would call him out in his letters while they
were, you know, which is great.
SPEAKER_01That's a, you need your friend. That's how we need to be as friends. We need to be able to call each other out and, and, and not, you know, but somebody asked me recently, what would John Quincy Adams think of what's happening today? And other than like the, the stuff he couldn't understand with technology and all that, he would not be surprised. He would have seen it coming. He would have written in his diary 20, 30 years ago that this was going to happen. Because it's about people.
And something I learned and discovered writing this book was the molds of the
SPEAKER_01people, the John C. Calhouns and the And all the politicians, they're the same people that we have today. They're the same characters. If you read this book, you will think of contemporary people as these characters in this book. The issues change, but the characters don't. Yeah. Think about it like this, Josh. In the 1830s and 1840s, there was no
conception that slavery would ever end yeah it was big business it was big business and it was deeply entrenched in in the in washington and it was deeply entrenched in the manufacturers of the north and of course in the south and there was no way out you could not think your way out of slate of like well how's this going to end
SPEAKER_01And there are things like that that we experience today, and we have no conception of how the history could turn. Adams in some ways saw his own times clearest by seeing the Civil War coming decades ahead of time, repeatedly seeing it and commenting, this is the only way this ends. But we can't conceive for ourselves So Adams would be here, and he would not be surprised by Trump.
SPEAKER_01He would not be surprised by the parties, the party system. He would not be surprised by Epstein files. None of it would surprise him. None of it would surprise him. He would be aghast by it, but he would not be surprised by it.
SPEAKER_00He strikes me, the more you're talking about him, he strikes me as somewhat of a political moderate in some ways. And yet he is, I think, remembered in a lot of ways as a defender of abolition, even though, like you said, he would push back against some of the more radical abolitionists. What... What's his approach to slavery, I think, in a vacuum? If you were to kind of characterize it in a vacuum sort of a way,
SPEAKER_00what is his approach to slavery and his legacy?
SPEAKER_01He aborted it. He claims it was never in his family. I'll point out in the book where that's not 100% true. He... He was reconciled to it when he was a diplomat and secretary of state. He was... challenging Britain and trying to get recompensation for American farmers or people who lost slaves in the War of 1812.
SPEAKER_01He wanted to get compensation for that. He fought for that. But there are times when he'll argue with Quakers and he'll say, oh, well, slavery isn't that bad on the slave. They're not treated that bad. There's a lot of... he, he couldn't conceive, um, blacks and whites living together. Very few could. Yeah. Even, even a lot of abolitionists couldn't conceive that. Uh, but some could, uh, so,
so he, you know, he's, he, he's not perfect, right?
SPEAKER_01He's, he's, he's flawed and he's also a creature of his times. Um, But he was reconciled to slavery was embedded in the Constitution and that Congress had no right to interfere with slavery in the states where it exists. And he gets to a point where he rethinks that. And that's an important point, part of the book. But it's the Three-Fifths Compromise, which he thought was a terrible bargain. He wouldn't make that bargain again if it was up to him.
But that bargain was made, and that bargain needed to be honored until a time which it couldn't.
SPEAKER_01And eventually, he gets to the point where slavery's got to end. But it's a road. It's a road.
SPEAKER_00So the book is America's founding son. Obviously, he is sort of that second generation of the founding era. What would be, if you were to put it in like a sentence, what is the thing that now that you're on the other side of it, you've written the book, you've done the research, it's an evergreen process, but you've done the work. What is the thing that you come away with from this project and how it's sort of impacted you personally and maybe impacted how you potentially see the world?
SPEAKER_01democracy is always in crisis.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01You know, you know, and we, we are the same people. We are, we are the same people like you and I are, I don't know how many miles away we are. Um, But here we are, like we're in the same room. We're talking to each other in the same room. And this will be shared with thousands of people. And that is a technological advance that could not have been conceived in 1830 and 1840.
SPEAKER_01However, the human heart has not changed a bit. Not one iota has the human heart and a human being's capability to do great good or great evil. It's still the same as it ever was, as David Byrne would say, talking heads would say. So some things change, some things never change, and people do not change, have not changed.
SPEAKER_00The book comes out, if I've got my dates right, it's March 10th. That's correct. Very excited about it. Thank you so much for coming on the show and teaching us a little bit about John Quincy Adams, about the 1830s and 40s. It's one of my favorite periods in American history. So thank you so much for coming on. Thank you, Josh. And I love what you do and best of luck with your book. America's Founding Son comes out March 10th, so go pre-order a copy. If you haven't already, I'll have a link below where you can do that. And while you're there,
hit the subscribe button if you're watching this and you're not subscribed. Or if you're listening on audio, leave a rating and a review wherever you're listening.
SPEAKER_00It helps so much with the podcast algorithms, whatever the heck they are. But it helps. Thanks so much for hanging out, for listening, for supporting the show and telling a friend about it. It really does mean the world to me. And I'll see you again very, very soon in the next episode.
Earlier this year, a little book from Coffee House Press blew me away. It was absurdism at its very best. So naturally, I read all the author’s other books, too. Today, I get to interview Mark Haber. He’s the author of...
Fredericksburg, Chancellorsville, and Gettysburg are three of the most famous battles in the Civil War. Casualties are immense, and public opinion begins to sour. It all builds toward a muggy Friday morning in July,...
Many in both the North and the South believe the American Civil War is God's punishment for America's sins. By the end of 1862, the casualty lists had become impossible to ignore, and both sides began to realize that in...
Denis Johnson has quickly become one of my favorite authors. Train Dreams blew me away, then I read Angels with you all, and I finished Jesus’ Son about a week ago. I’m nearly done with Tree of Smoke as I post this,...
Jeff O’Neal and Rebecca Schinsky from BookRiot join me to talk about books, the different avenues a reading journey can take, their favorite “bridge books”, and what they can’t wait to read next! This is a public...