72. Getting There – How Transportation Shapes Opportunity
40 minAudio
Transportation affects nearly every part of daily life, but for many people, getting where they need to go isn't simple. In this episode of Community Difference Makers, we explore the transportation challenges facing central Iowa and the impact they have on employment, education, healthcare, childcare, and other essential services. Featuring: •Brooke Ramsey, Heart of Iowa Regional Transit Agency (HIRTA) •Erin Hockman, Des Moines Area Regional Transit Authority (DART) •Luke Lynch, United Way of Central Iowa •Emily Abbas, Bankers Trust Hosted by: Bankers Trust and United Way of Central Iowa Production: Snaadt Media Group
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Think about all the places you need to go and get to in a typical week. Work, school, childcare, the grocery store, a doctor's appointment. For many of us, getting there is something we barely think about until we can't. Today I'm joined by three people who see every day just how much transportation can shape someone's opportunities. Luke Lynch with United Way of Central Iowa, Brooke Ramsey, COO of the Heart of Iowa Regional Transit Agency, also known as HERTA, and Aaron Hoffman, CEO of the Des Moines Area Regional Transit Authority, better known as DART.
SPEAKER_02Welcome. Thank you for being here. Transportation, as we know, is not just about getting from point A to point B. It can determine whether someone can get to work, receive healthcare, continue their education, or access the services throughout this community that they need. Hi, I'm Emily Abbas, and this is the Community Difference Makers podcast brought to you by United Way of Central Iowa and Bankers Trust. Welcome to all of our guests. And Luke, we're going to start with you. We like to start with the big picture. Transportation isn't one of the five United to Thrive elements, yet it seems to affect almost every one of them.
SPEAKER_02It's come up in every podcast we've recorded this year. Why is transportation such an important issue for United Way?
SPEAKER_00It does cut across every element of United to Thrive. When we look at essential needs, folks need transportation to access food or housing and other services. Early childhood education or success. Parents need transportation to get kids to daycare or to appointments. Education success. Students need transportation to get to school or after school or enrichment activities. Economic opportunity, it's important. It's essential to have transportation to get to a job and to keep a job. Health and well-being, we need transportation to get to medical and behavioral health appointments.
SPEAKER_00So it it's a resource that is necessary, and those other resources don't exist if people can't access them.
SPEAKER_02Right. So an interesting way to put it. Who is most affected by transportation barriers here in central Iowa?
SPEAKER_00Aaron Powell The Alice population that we've talked about so often on this podcast. Households without reliable access to vehicles, lower income households where vehicle maintenance and upkeep is an expense and a barrier, older adults, folks with disabilities, young folks, people who can't drive, workers with non-traditional hours, so second and third shift workers, rural, suburban areas where transportation may not be as prevalent or as available. And then families that are just juggling schedules that have to get everywhere at once.
SPEAKER_00It's a barrier for a lot of folks.
SPEAKER_02Brooke, when we say central Iowa, we're talking about a pretty diverse region. Herda provides transportation across seven counties. What makes providing public transportation in communities outside of the urban core different from operating a traditional city bus system?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so uh seven counties, which if you're not from Iowa, would not uh mean a lot, right? But for us, just to put some um, you know, uh statistics to that, it's 4,100 square service miles in 87 different cities. And they're all so vastly different. Um, you know, looking at a place like Madison County, who is so rural, the largest town only having 5,000 people, um, you know, in contrast to let's say Knoxville, um, and looking at how Knoxville has a larger veteran population than other communities and no longer has the VA clinics and hospital um in their community.
SPEAKER_03And then, you know, Warren County being very different as well. No hospital, only county in the state that doesn't have a hospital or a dialysis clinic. So their needs are very unique to each different community and each county. Um, you know, the the need to get between communities for things like healthcare are more prevalent, um, especially in those communities that are smaller because they don't have uh as many providers and they don't have specialty clinics available to them.
SPEAKER_03Um, one thing that we do see though is that there's a misnomer in these smaller communities that there is no public transportation. And so I feel like we're constantly doing that educational component that Herta is that public transportation. Um, but they feel that way because they don't have fixed route service. So when people think about public transportation, they're often relating that directly back to fixed drought.
SPEAKER_02So you've talked about the diversity maybe in the cities and the counties that you provide or that you support. What does a typical Herta rider look like? Or is there really no such thing?
SPEAKER_03Um, so that's an interesting question because I think we tend to see people getting on the bus, and that's who you then identify as the rider. So if you see your neighbor who maybe is an older adult versus you see someone with a disability or somebody who's maybe lower income, um, then you're going to think of that as what the typical rider looks like. But in reality, with public transportation, anybody can ride for any reason. So the service is available to everyone.
SPEAKER_02Please share an example of a trip that illustrates maybe some of the challenges and what might someone need to do to get from a smaller central Iowa community to a medical appointment or to their job.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so that really truly depends on, you know, where they are, because for us, um, you know, service in the communities is kind of tailored to that community. So for example, in Perry, they no longer have a dialysis clinic in Perry any longer. So those individuals need longer distance trips and chronic care three times a week coming into the Des Moines Metro versus someone um, let's say in Pella, who they do have a lot of those specialty clinics and and are getting more.
SPEAKER_03Um, we were just told that they're bringing in oncology services, so that's amazing for them. Um, but you know, there are people who, even with our low-cost fares, which public transit is known for, um, they still can't afford that. And so we still run into um a gap in service, which is why Herta created a volunteer program. People can ride to medical appointments um on a donation basis. Um, but to schedule a ride, whether it's using our service or leveraging the volunteer program, they can email us, they can call us, and we even have an app that they can use called HERTA on demand.
SPEAKER_03So we try to make it um as easy as possible, I'm sure as Dart does.
SPEAKER_02Erin, congratulations. Dart has gone through a major transformation this year with the launch of a redesigned bus network. Uh, why was it necessary to rethink the system rather than simply continuing with the routes that Dart had been providing?
SPEAKER_01Well, thank you. It was really exciting to launch a whole new bus network just in June. And we really did that because as you look over the last 10 to 15 years, the region has changed significantly. How we've grown has changed, where jobs are located have changed, where housing is located. And that means travel patterns have changed. And so it just didn't make sense to modify what was in place. It was really a unique opportunity to say, let's start with a clean slate. And if we were going to, you know, allocate the resources that we have to align with how travel patterns have changed and with what our community's priorities for transit are, what would that look like?
SPEAKER_01And that's what we really tried to do.
SPEAKER_02What specifically changed for bus riders?
SPEAKER_01A lot. Um, and it varies from one rider to the next. But when you think about the changes that we made, you know, we went from a system that had about 27 routes to 11. Um and we had a very robust public input process that helped inform those changes. Um really what we heard from the community is the majority of people wanted us to focus on more frequent service in the busiest areas of the region where there are the most people and activities. And so we did reduce service hours by 10%.
SPEAKER_01So it was a service cut. Um, but one of the things I'm really proud of is despite the fact that it was a service cut, we actually expanded access to transit. So the average resident can reach 15% more jobs on this new network. And that's really the power of investing in more frequent service on those key corridors because uh the how often the bus comes really dictates how far people can get.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's an important point because improving public transportation doesn't always mean simply adding more routes everywhere. How do you balance that frequency and having a bus coming more often with coverage, which is more referring to having service reach as many places as possible?
SPEAKER_01That really is the fundamental uh fixed route transit planning trade-off. Um, and there is no right or wrong answer to that question. It really comes down to what a community's values are. And, you know, at Dart, we are just stewards of our community's resources. We don't decide what the community's priorities are. So we went out to our community and we said, if we were to design a transit system that took the resources we had and designed a coverage network where we spread our resources out to put bus routes in lots of different places.
SPEAKER_01They didn't come very often because you can't afford to when you put that service a little bit of everywhere. Um and so not a lot of people use it, but a lot of it's near more people. That's what a coverage network is. And then we brought a concept out that also showed what does a ridership network look like? Um so people could really visualize, you know, we're we're having this conversation around ridership versus coverage, but if we were to completely lean into one or the other, what does that look like? And that ridership network, again, has fewer routes, more frequent service.
SPEAKER_01Um, and we heard that most uh majority of people preferred that ridership uh network where you can just travel farther faster because the bus is coming more often. But that does mean there are lower density areas of the region that just don't have any transit access, and that is one of the trade-offs.
SPEAKER_02One of the things I appreciate that you took into consideration is time. Um, when someone works an eight-hour shift, they also might spend an hour on either side of that shift getting to and from work, uh making their workday much longer. So I I just appreciate that you helped to incorporate travel time into designing that system as well.
SPEAKER_01Thank you.
SPEAKER_02Um, Brooke, in Herta's service area, you have a different version of this time problem I'm explaining because the distances are so much greater, as you've as you've explained. How difficult is it to match riders, vehicles, and schedules efficient efficiently over such a large region?
SPEAKER_03Well, it can be um it can be a challenge. Um so we try as best as we can to create the schedules uh in advance so we then can build in um same-day requests and changes onto what's already happening for efficiency. Um one example is uh the need to get between, let's say, Nevada and Ames. So Nevada is only about 10 minutes away from Ames. However, um, you know, it doesn't make sense for us to have a vehicle constantly running between those two two communities.
SPEAKER_03So, kind of like what Aaron said, there's more of a shuttle service that we do. We go at specified times and we try to um get as many folks into those existing services that we can. Um, you know, grouping people together to be more efficient with our resources, both human resources and our fleet. Um, and then, you know, longer distance rides are obviously more costly. So um I talked earlier about the Knoxville area having that veteran population and them needing to get into the Des Moines area for care at the VA.
SPEAKER_03So that's 55 miles each way, um, typically for most people. And uh, you know, so that service is more costly. It does take more time to provide, and and we try to um group those folks together in order to do the best we can with our resources. So we still have um, you know, as you referenced, we still have similar needs, and um the need remains, whether you're in an urban area or in a rural area, to have that access.
SPEAKER_02Well, and some needs don't happen conveniently between nine and five, right? Um, nothing happens at the time that you, you know, would anticipate it. How do evening shifts, weekends, or an unexpectedly sick child complicate transportation? And on both of you jump in. Maybe we'll start with you, Brooke.
SPEAKER_03Um, so I think we probably both do our best. I think transit is an industry, uh, it's not as well known how much we have to pivot in the work that we do. Seems like there's always something that comes up that you couldn't have predicted. I've been at her to 16 years and I still feel like there's always something you've never seen before. Um, but I guess I would like to say credit to Dart for bringing awareness to some of the challenges that we've had. And I know that um you've been speaking for years about knowing that this fiscal cliff was coming, but it's not just Dart, right?
SPEAKER_03It's everywhere. And it's a national issue that we're facing as an industry. So unfortunately, we don't have enough funding to be able to provide services later in the evening and the amount of service hours that Dart offers. Um, some of that comes with the population, too, that the demand isn't as great on the weekend or in the evenings. So we really look at where that demand is and tailor the service hours around it.
SPEAKER_01Um you know, uh, when we were designing our new bus network, the consultants who are phenomenal talked about how uh frequency is freedom. Um, because the more frequent the bus comes, the more opportunities you have, the more places you can get to. I think the same concept really applies to what we call span of service, which is the hours the buses operate. Um I mentioned we had to reduce our service hours by 10%. The one of the ways that we did that was we reduced our span of service.
SPEAKER_01So we now operate two less hours on the weekdays, one less hour on Saturday. So our buses operate between 6 a.m. and 10 p.m. Monday through Saturday, 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. on Sunday. Um and we try to provide the best service we can within those span of hours. But what that really means, and I just received an email this week from a writer who cannot, she doesn't have a car, she relies on Dart, she's has to get to work by 7 a.m. And we can't do that for her.
SPEAKER_01Um, and I want to just read uh she actually moved to Des Moines from Charlotte. So she's accustomed to a larger city whose buses run 5 a.m. to midnight. And you can work second shifts and third shifts. And um, you know, the the um span of service does impact the jobs that people can get and keep. And in her email, something she shared was hospitality, healthcare, and retail workers keep this city running every single day. And we need transit that actually supports us instead of holding us back.
SPEAKER_01And that's that's the impact of you know, the funding and the hours of service that we're able to provide.
SPEAKER_02Thank you for sharing those stories, really helped bring this to life. Let's let's turn our conversation to employers and and Luke, let's connect this directly to economic opportunity. We talk a lot about workforce shortages, and um the letter you received just ties to that. Employers are trying to find workers. Can transportation determine the size of the workforce available to an employer?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. And you know, we heard from Brooke and Aaron about a lot of these circumstances. But to my earlier point that a resource isn't available if you can't access it, jobs not available if you can't get there. And so it really is a conversation that employers should be a part of. Again, those second and third shift employees, hard to get there. Um, suburban growth, all you know, all the things we've talked about. One one important thing that maybe we haven't talked about from the employer standpoint and employee standpoint is that lack of transportation can lead to missed shifts, which can lead to lost jobs or upward mobility within an organization because they're not able to reliably get to work.
SPEAKER_00Uh, and so um that's a negative for employers who are looking to grow their workforce and grow internally uh for them. So, yes, absolutely, employers should be a part of the conversation.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell And Dart has said that getting to and from work is one of the primary reasons people use transit. Um, what are employers telling you about transportation? We heard what a rider or potential rider is telling you. What are employers telling you?
SPEAKER_01You know, I'm gonna be honest. I think we've improved, but I think we have more improvement to go when we think about how employers view um really transportation as workforce infrastructure. That's what it is. Uh to Luke's point, um, if a job, you know, if somebody can't get to a job, or you know, we talk a lot about as we think about workforce, affordable housing, and childcare. Um, if you can't get to those things, they're not available to you. Um but because so many decision makers um don't rely on public transit, it's often an afterthought.
SPEAKER_01And in Iowa, you know, we are a car-centric culture. Um, and so that is a sort of a challenge that we have battled and we're trying to continue to educate and raise that awareness. It's not uncommon for an employer to um build a new facility. Um, and maybe it's a service, you know, they're primarily employing service workers. And this is, you know, about five years ago, a major large employer in Des Moines did this. And it wasn't until they started hiring that they realized their employees needed transit to be able to get to work.
SPEAKER_01And they didn't locate that facility on a bus route. Um, and so fortunately we were able to work with them. They weren't too far off of a bus route. Um, but it's really thinking about where do we locate housing jobs that are on transit that already exists because that maximizes our region's investment in transit. Um, and we are seeing positive uh progress on this from uh housing developers. Uh, the Annex group uh just opened the Union at River's Edge affordable housing complex here in Des Moines earlier this week.
SPEAKER_01And they were very intentional about ensuring that they located that property on a bus route. And they also provide uh free transit access to all of their residents. So that's really one of my hopes, I guess, for our community is to continue to think about transit as a workforce infrastructure and really thinking early on with new projects and how do we ensure that, you know, that access is there so that everyone can access, you know, your business and your jobs that you're offering.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, part of the plan, not an afterthought. Um, Brooke, is this all true outside of the metro as well?
SPEAKER_03Well, because we don't offer fixed route service, uh, I think the the community, when they're looking at developing and um and bringing in new employers, it's probably not as prevalent for them because they're used to our service being more door-to-door. Um, what I would say though is that both Dart and Herta provide van pool services. So even if you're an employer that's in an area that maybe doesn't sit along a fixed route service, I would encourage you to look into those opportunities and make those opportunities available for people, especially second and third shift workers tend to benefit the most from van pools.
SPEAKER_03Um, and I don't know if you want to say anything about that, Erin. You guys have had van pools for many years.
SPEAKER_01So uh just that it's, you know, I appreciate that you brought it up. It is a um a transportation option that not a lot of people think about. And it is a way to expand um, you know, the jobs that someone could consider. Because uh, and we see this, you know, there's a lot of rural parts of the state that have large manufacturing centers and they don't have the workforce within that town. Um, and so you know, that's where the van pools can come in. They can bring uh groups of people in from a nearby town that's maybe 30 miles away.
SPEAKER_01Um and it's a really affordable way for that um, those individuals to to access those jobs, even though it's a longer commute.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I know even at Bigger Stress, we have an employee who does a van pool in from Pella. Yeah, yeah. It's great. Um, so we've talked about employment as um, you know, one of the main reasons of and needs for public transportation. Healthcare also is a clear example of why transportation matters. What happens when someone has a medical appointment but has no way to get there? You've mentioned um less access to certain services in rural communities. Um, what what happens?
SPEAKER_03Well, uh I know we started working several years ago now with the United Way of Central Iowa, and healthcare was a focal point for us. Um, we've done a lot of work with the public health offices, uh, looking at social determinants of health, looking at their community health needs assessments and their health improvement plans. Um, and what we found is if you don't have transportation, you have delayed care. And what that equates to is more serious chronic health conditions, you're missing preventative appointments, um, you're going into specialty care when it could have been something that maybe you could have uh diagnosed earlier.
SPEAKER_03Um so overall, we loot we become a less healthy community because we aren't accessing the resources and the things that we need. Um, so I would say, you know, definitely something to consider as we're making decisions.
SPEAKER_01Um, but I think I would add that the care also becomes more expensive. Yes, it does. Um, and then sometimes it can drive up utilization of more expensive emergency services as well. Um, so lots of impacts to that.
SPEAKER_03We actually a few years ago uh started working with um the American Cancer Society specifically because they had a patient outside of Winterset that declined care because they didn't have transportation and it was a treatable, curable case. So I think it's so important that people realize that.
SPEAKER_02Well, and and healthcare transportation isn't necessarily one trip. Right. So someone going through cancer treatment, dialysis, physical therapy, or another ongoing treatment made me transportation again and again and again. I think of radiation that is often five days a week for three to four weeks or more. And personally driving half a mile from work to a hospital was an inconvenience every day. I can't imagine um not having transportation, having to schedule that and having to travel for um, you know, longer each way.
SPEAKER_02Um it's a lot.
SPEAKER_03It's a lot. Yeah. I'm worrying about if it's going to show up on time. Ah, I haven't even thought of it from that point. And that's one thing I say about our industry is we have amazing on-time performances. You know, ours is usually anywhere from 95 to 98%. I'm not sure what Dart's is.
SPEAKER_01Not quite that high, but we're yeah, we're around 85. Yeah. 85 or so percent.
SPEAKER_03You have a little more traffic than we do.
SPEAKER_02Uh, this seems like a good example of why United Way sees transportation as more than a logistical problem. United Way uh got directly involved in transportation through Ride United, um, which was a pilot program that provided rides for people trying to reach things like medical appointments, like job interviews, food pantries, and housing services. Um, the pilot concluded earlier this year. Luke, what did United Way learn from this pilot?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so Ride United was designed to be a short-term uh intervention for specific transportation gaps. We saw strong demand. We know that transportation remains a barrier. One thing to note is that most people use Ride United for services rather than convenience. They were going to doctor's appointments to hospitals uh to get to the food pantry uh for housing. Um, so it's not just a luxury, it was really a need for folks. Um we also know that that flexible point-to-point transportation can solve some transportation issues, but fixed route transit is expensive.
SPEAKER_00Uh, it's maybe not possible everywhere all the time. So um we you know, keep that in mind. I think the data that we got from this Ride United pilot uh will help us inform future partnerships and solutions, but it's all important to know that you know there's not a single solution out there. Um so it's gonna take everyone.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So it sounds like one of the lessons is that we shouldn't necessarily be looking for the one transportation solution. It's gonna take all of us, it's gonna take the whole community, it's gonna take diverse services like your teams are providing. Um Brooke, we can't talk about public transportation without talking about how it's funded. Oh. You knew I was gonna go there topic. Um Gerta had to make some difficult decisions um when it came to service changes this summer, including reducing service hours similarly to what Aaron's explained with Dart, also more limited services in some communities.
SPEAKER_02What pressures are transit systems facing right now, and what does it mean for a community when transit services are reduced?
SPEAKER_03Well, uh, Aaron and I were actually talking as we walked here in the building. And we know, unfortunately, with the work that we do, anytime that you reduce or change the service, there are going to be people who can't access things that they need in their life. And as Aaron mentioned earlier, you know, an example of someone getting to work. Um, and you know that does not that weighs heavily on us when we make those choices.
SPEAKER_03Um, but ultimately people are going to be impacted. And that's that's just the unfortunate part. Um, but in talking about funding, I would say uh, at least in rural systems, we probably have the most um diversified funding mechanism because we work with partners like United Way um for grants for funding, and it is one of the most complicated things we talk about. Uh so I would say, you know, things that people are experiencing at home, we're experiencing in transit rising costs, the cost of fuel, the cost of maintenance, um, employee wages, benefits, auto insurance, they're all skyrocketing.
SPEAKER_03Um, across the board, our insurance was up over 30% last year for auto. Um, we had our renewal with our health insurance earlier this year in May, um, 22% increases. So unfortunately, we had to reduce how lucrative those employee benefit packages were in order to make it affordable for her to as an employer and for the employees. Um, and so there's, you know, there's negative consequences to those decisions as well. It's not something we had to do, but it's something, or it's not something we wanted to do, it's something we had to do.
SPEAKER_03We didn't have a choice. Um, but you know, ultimately the funding that we get, federal sources, really haven't increased, yet all of the costs are going up. Um, and in some cases, we've seen decreases. And I think you've Dart have probably experienced this as well with um changes to the Medicaid program as an example. People were um able to leverage access to care through um, you know, Medicaid services would cover some of their transportation. And we're seeing that decrease year over year over year, yet the people still need their health care and they're still riding.
SPEAKER_03It's just it's not being funded. So what we end up with is more people, less funding, and more cost. And, you know, that's where I think we probably both had a bit of a breaking point and had to make those service reductions.
SPEAKER_02Well, and it really ties to the recent survey data that United Way has shared that across our nonprofits in our community, there's a high increased demand for service. Um, but those services are costing you all more to provide. Yeah. Um, but that funding isn't going up to match those increased costs, um, even to maintain current levels of service. Aaron Dart has faced similar questions about how much transit the region can afford. Why is sustainable funding such a difficult issue?
SPEAKER_01I could talk about funding for a while, so I'll try to keep this short. Transit funding in general is complex. Um, you know, for an urban system, the majority of our federal funding funds our capital costs. And then our operating budget that provides the services is really local taxes. But it's the state legislature that determines what that local taxing mechanism is. Um, and decades ago in Iowa, the legislature decided we would fund public transit through property taxes for urban systems.
SPEAKER_01And um, and then it's our local elected officials that set the rate within those perimeters. Um, we fund a lot of services in Iowa with property taxes, a lot of really important services. Um, and property taxes are really unpopular. I have yet to meet anyone who says, I love paying my property tax bill. Um, and what we see around the country is that, you know, there are some states that use property taxes to fund transit, but it's not the most common. Um, and so sustainable funding, um, we really need another funding mechanism.
SPEAKER_01I think part of the challenge in getting that done is how do we change, you know, the way we think about public transit in Iowa? Um, that it's not, it doesn't only benefit the people who use the service, it really benefits the entire community because just for the same reason that we invest in public schools, in public libraries, it's a public good when more people can get to work and pay their bills and earn a living. We are a stronger community, our economy is stronger, we are a healthier community, um, and that has just ripple effects.
SPEAKER_01Um, and so we we really need to um view transit as a public good, as a critical infrastructure that is truly an investment in our region's health and competitiveness in order to get that done.
SPEAKER_02So, as you're consistently asked, you know, the question I'm sure you hear most often is well, why can't the bus just go there? Um, it sounds like that you always have to think through what resources are available to provide that service. So let's turn towards solutions. Um, we've mentioned on-demand transit and microtransit several times. For listeners who aren't familiar with those terms, how are they different from a traditional bus route? And how are you both incorporating on-demand service into the areas that you serve? Um, how are you testing this?
SPEAKER_02What are you hoping to learn?
SPEAKER_01Microtransit is uh a flexible, just like it sounds, on-demand type of service. So if you've ever used Uber or Lyft, it operates a lot like that. Um, but we can put different parameters around it because, of course, it's public and it's subsidized. Uh so we've had an on-demand service in the city of Ankany for about the last five years. We create a zone. Um, and so anywhere within that zone, someone can download our on-demand app, book a ride, um, and it's been a door-to-door service.
SPEAKER_01Uh, it was incredibly popular. So uh the biggest challenge we've had is actually meeting demand for the service. And we've just launched new on-demand zones this week, and we are expanding that to some other communities. So it's a great way to serve lower dense areas where a fixed route bus does not make sense. Really looking forward to seeing how, you know, areas of Altoona, Clive, and Urbendale that have not had access to transit, what that demand there may be. But we have redesigned our service model again to try and serve as many people as possible with the resources that we have.
SPEAKER_01So rather than being a door-to-door service, um, someone will be asked to walk a couple blocks to meet the bus at a main street corner, and then it will take them to one of pre-selected major destinations within the zone because that just allows us to serve more trips uh more efficiently. Um so there's different ways to provide that on-demand service. But again, it is just a more flexible service than a fixed route that's really operating just on a set street at a set time within a certain area.
SPEAKER_01One of the differences, though, that I think is important to mention, because I've gotten the question, why not just uh replace all of your fixed routes with on-demand? Our budget would have to be probably four times what it is to be able to just maintain all the rides that we have by the nature of the service. So our fixed routes provide about 18 passengers per hour, whereas the most passengers per hour we can operate on a fully well-utilized on-demand zone is about four. Um that's just because of the way the services are designed.
SPEAKER_01Uh, fixed route by nature is just so much more efficient. And the cost isn't that different because the cost driver is the operator. Um, and so it, but there's a there's a place for both. And I think that's really what we're looking at trying to find for our region is where do we, where can we maximize the investment in fixed route? And then how do we supplement that with this like on-demand model?
SPEAKER_02So, what does that look like? I just want to that's it's conceptual and so everyone understands what's that look like for a writer if that might use on-demand? How do they request this service? Then where do they go? And where what are one of some of those select places they could choose to go to?
SPEAKER_01You can download the Dart on Demand app. If you're not tech savvy, you can also call customer service. There is a website where you can go and book a trip. Um, but if you've ever used Uber or Lyft, it's very similar. Like within those apps, you put in where you're starting, where you're going to. Um, the app has our preloaded destinations. So because we're public transit, we've really focused on grocery stores, medical facilities, um, major job centers, those destinations that, you know, we want to prioritize serving with transit. And that's what we call hubs.
SPEAKER_01Um, so someone could go from their house to the grocery store. They might be asked to walk a couple blocks, meet the bus, and then the bus will take them to the grocery store.
SPEAKER_02Got it. That helps me understand what those destinations are.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02What would you like to add?
SPEAKER_03Um, just her to service, I think, looks a lot like uh what Aaron's described with microtransit a few years ago. We actually uh switched to the same vendor that you're using for that and um for our scheduling software. And so our app works just the same. You download the HEDA on-demand app and you can schedule a ride. Um, talk about payment methods, super convenient because you can choose to store your credit card on file like you do with the Uber or Lyft app and um easily, you know, pay as you use the service, which is great and convenient.
SPEAKER_03Um, but not everyone has a smartphone, not everyone has a data plan, not everyone uh has a credit card. So uh similarly, you can call us, you can email us. We try to make that as convenient as possible. Um, although we do have demand response, so we still do advanced reservations. Uh, changing software platforms gave us the ability to be more spontaneous in the services that we provide because not everyone can plan their life in advance. Um, and sometimes your doctor's appointment uh gets rescheduled and things happen.
SPEAKER_03Um, or sometimes you wake up and you just don't feel good. Um, sometimes you don't realize that you ran out of an ingredient for your dinner tonight and your kid gets sick at school. So, you know, life happens. And I think as an industry, microtransit was kind of spawned out of the need to evolve into helping people in a different way because we can't continue to do something the way we did it 40 years ago.
SPEAKER_02So, Luke, when you look at all of these different approaches, what would a strong regional transportation system ultimately look like?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think it's all of these different systems functioning together as a network rather than in isolation. Um, it's something that's understandable for the riders, for the individuals who are accessing services that they understand their options. It's cross-jurisdictional, so it's not one city or another city or county or another county. Everybody's working together to that earlier point, functioning as a network. Um and that we consider transportation when we're our cities are growing, uh, when employers are coming to town, uh, that that's a consideration for for folks around healthcare as well and other services.
SPEAKER_00Uh really important that we have that public, private, nonprofit, and employers at the table having the conversation. It's everybody uh at the table, everyone has a stake in this. Um and then we focus on out access and outcomes rather than one particular mode of transportation.
SPEAKER_02I love how you pull out those key themes and kind of take us up a level to look at things. Thank you. I appreciate that about you, Luke. Thanks. So, all of you, I want to end with the same question. Imagine we're having this conversation five years from now, and Central Iowa has made meaningful progress on topic on this topic of transportation. What's one thing you hope is different than today? Erin, would you like to start? Sure.
SPEAKER_01Uh I really hope that Central Iowa sees transit as a strategic investment, uh, one that strengthens our economy, helps us attract and retain workers, and supports growth across the entire region. I think too often today, transit gets framed as something we provide only for people who can't or don't drive. And in cities that we compete with for talent and economic development, transit is viewed as essential infrastructure. And many communities are increasing, not decreasing, their investment in transit, which does mean we are falling behind.
SPEAKER_01Um I think if we don't shift this mindset soon, um, it will have long-term consequences because businesses, talent, workers, they have options and they're increasingly choosing places where it's easy, reliable, and connected. And so five years from now, I hope that we recognize transit as a foundation for our region's competitiveness and are really making meaningful investments that reflect that.
SPEAKER_03Well said, Brooke? I would agree. Um, we once had a writer tell us that transit is like a utility and everyone deserves to have access to it. So I think it's important that, you know, as we continue these conversations, um, and for people who are decision makers, that they really look at transportation, um, especially passenger transportation, the way that you would look at other forms like bridges and roads, and that you start to fund it in the same way, in a way that we can expand and grow and meet the needs of our communities, so that we're not talking about service reductions, because ultimately what we're talking about is the people.
SPEAKER_00I don't think I can say it any better. I guess I'll just repeat myself a little bit. It that we're bringing more awareness to the need for those partners, nonprofit, nonprofit, public, private employers, to come together to continue the conversation, uh, to raise awareness on this is bigger than transportation. This is our community thriving. Um, and that's what's important.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And that's our goal. Let's make sure this community continues to thrive. Thank you all for the part that you play in that. Um, well, I hope that five years from now we can look back and see just how much progress we've made. Um, because as we've heard today, when people can get to where they need to go, so many other opportunities open up. Luke, Brooke, and Aaron, uh, thank you. I really appreciated the perspectives each of you brought to this conversation and the work you're doing to better connect people and communities. And thank you to our listeners. If you've enjoyed this conversation, please share our podcast with others.
Mental health is part of every young person's health. In this episode of Community Difference Makers, we discuss what young people and families are experiencing in Central Iowa, the services available to support them,...
A raise, promotion, or additional work hours should help a family get ahead. But for some, earning more can mean losing access to critical public benefits like childcare assistance, food support, or healthcare coverage....
For today’s students, success doesn’t follow a single path. While some may choose a four-year university, others may find their future through community college, registered apprenticeships, industry credentials,...
What does it take to build a community where everyone has the opportunity to thrive? In this episode of Community Difference Makers, we explore the intersection of disability services, health, education, and equity in...
Graduating from high school is an important milestone. But what happens the morning after graduation? For more than one in five Central Iowa graduates - 22% - there isn't yet a clear plan that includes education or...