Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Community Difference Makers

Community Difference Makers artwork

73. When A Raise Costs You Money – Understanding Benefits Cliffs

Nov 10, 202641 minAudio

A raise, promotion, or additional work hours should help a family get ahead. But for some, earning more can mean losing access to critical public benefits like childcare assistance, food support, or healthcare coverage. In this episode of Community Difference Makers, we explore a challenge that many working families face but few people talk about - the benefits cliff. Featuring: Sue Wilson, WeLIFT Karla Evans, Iowa Center for Economic Success Dave Stone, United Way of Central Iowa • Emily Abbas, Bankers Trust Hosted by: Bankers Trust and United Way of Central Iowa Production: Snaadt Media Group

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Imagine your supervisor calls you into their office with good news. You're getting a raise. It should mean your family is getting ahead. But then you do the math and discover that earning more could actually leave you with less money at the end of the month. It's called a benefits cliff. For some families, accepting a raise, a promotion, or additional hours can mean losing assistance they rely on for things like childcare, food, or health care. That can create an incredibly difficult question. Can I afford to earn more?

SPEAKER_03I'm Emily Abbas, and this is Community Difference Makers. Our podcast is brought to you by Bakers Trust and United Way of Central Iowa. Today I'm joined by three people who can help us understand why it happens and why it matters. Dave Stone, Advocacy Officer at United Way, welcome back.

SPEAKER_04Thank you for having me again.

SPEAKER_03Thanks for joining. Oh, thanks so much for including us. And we also have Carla Evans with the Iowa Center for Economic Success. Thanks for having me as well. Wonderful. I look forward to our conversation. Dave, let's start with the basics. I just described a hypothetical example. What else should we know about a benefits cliff?

SPEAKER_04Sure. Well, all public assistance programs are income-based on your household's income. And they're all different as well. And so what happens as a family proceeds in their career, earns more income, they start hitting these cutoffs where they no longer qualify for certain benefits. And one thing, you know, we've talked about the Alice households before, these are all typically the same individuals. They may be requiring food assistance, childcare assistance, Medicaid, health insurance.

SPEAKER_04As they approach these eligibility thresholds, they hit what we refer to as a cliff, where suddenly, because they earn a little bit more money, they had a few more hours this month, they no longer qualify for those public assistance benefits and suddenly lose a good portion of their budget from no longer being able to access that program. There's lots of examples of it, and each one is different. So families can hit that cliff multiple times, even though they're doing what we all want them to do, earn more money and stabilize the family.

SPEAKER_03So childcare seems to be a great example. Why is that? And maybe share with us a specific example of a benefits cliff in the childcare realm.

SPEAKER_04United Way of Central Iowa has been working on child care assistance for 20 years plus. Childcare assistance is incredibly important because it is a necessity for our parents to go to work. Iowa typically ties or is in the top three of all states where the most caregivers are in the workforce. 75% of our caregivers of young children, both guardians, parents are working. So it's a requirement for them to show up.

SPEAKER_04We also know that on average for a family with two kiddos, childcare can cost up to$1,450 per month. Right. That's an average, too. There's much higher, there's much lower. And that price doesn't change depending on whether you're making lower income or higher income. And anybody who has young kiddos out there, regardless of your income, know the expensive cost of childcare. So let's say your supervisor does come to you and offers you a slight raise.

SPEAKER_04Maybe you're going to be making an additional$200 that month and moving forward. However, you're going to lose access to child care assistance, which means you'll get next to nothing towards that$1,450 bill each month. So yes, you made it ahead. You're getting, uh you're advancing in your career, you're helping out your organization, your business, uh, because you're, you know, a skilled, valued employee, but you just took a huge hit to the family budget because you're no longer eligible for that assistance and benefit.

SPEAKER_03So it's not really about someone saying I'd rather receive assistance than work. It's it's a rational household budget decision. Um, and I think that's an important distinction. Um, that there's a space between qualifying for assistance and being able to afford everything on your own. Sue, your organization works directly with people who are trying to build greater stability in their lives. When we talk about a benefits cliff, that's policy language. What does it look like from the perspective of a family that you've encountered?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, it's interesting. I've been in this work um for a long time now, and I didn't really understand benefit cliff and and what what that really was until we kind of made um some changes within WeLift and we said, every person that comes in, we really need to look at their financials, where where are we at with things? And it wasn't till that point that we were looking at just strict income coming in and expenses going out and realizing that um some of some of the highlighted numbers and at the total were plus six dollars.

SPEAKER_00So I had six dollars left in that month. Um or or working with families, single parents, maybe, maybe with two incomes also in these families. And um, we hadn't even gotten to car insurance yet or gas yet, and we had already hit the income and expense balance. Um, and so that's when I started to dig into this a little bit more as to um this is a decision that our families have to make all the time is what part of the budget is more important than the other, right?

SPEAKER_00So transportation, car insurance, food, shelter, utilities, all of that goes into their budget. And um, 68% of the people we serve have incomes. And so I think that uh this is a very valid discussion we're having today because there is a narrative around public assistance use. And some of that narrative is very much that the people we serve aren't working and they don't have income coming in. And uh, and so I think that uh the more we can talk about this and the real life situations that we see every day with it, um, it helps us better really start figuring out those foundational issues in our systems.

SPEAKER_03Without identifying anyone, can you give us an example of someone who's faced this kind of a decision? I think stories are powerful.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um unfortunately, I have a lot to choose from. But the one that that really um rings out is a single mom and her daughter. Um daughter was four years old, and um the mom was like, she just wants to work. She wants to work. She was in our housing where it was$25 a month because it's income-based. Um, but she's a hard worker. So we found her a great job at our local childcare facility. And so she was working full-time at child care, and then her four-year-old daughter could attend, and she could attend for free, right?

SPEAKER_00So now we have a child that is around people in structure, and we have a mom that is starting to feel really good about herself, a lot of self-worth, building it all up. Um, so she started about in July, August, and then she she had her annual um re-evaluation, reinstatement of her housing application with her landlord. And she was making$17 an hour, um, the kitchen manager at this child care facility. And um, she sat down with her landlord, and her landlord calculated right her new income.

SPEAKER_00And she first looked at the number and she's like, this can't be right, I'm gonna recalculate it. And her rent went from$25 a month to$800. Wow.

SPEAKER_03Not a small jump. Not a small jump jump.

SPEAKER_00And no, no, no little cheer steps up to this. Um, and it was immediate. So she came over to our office in tears, and the landlord had called me too and said, Sue, I'm I'm sorry, I my hands are tied, this is what it is. And so we went back to her financial budget sheet and um calculated it, went back to her employer and actually asked, can she go part-time? Can you decrease what she's making hourly? Um, and so after conversations that went back and forth, we tried to make some things happen.

SPEAKER_00Um, the employer needed a full-time position. They needed somebody there full-time. Um, and so she left the workforce back into um her daughter not being socialized, not being around, because now she's not in the workforce and doesn't have child care. Right. And so she's staying at home. Um, and unfortunately, that really transpired into a mental health situation for the mom, which transpired into some really poor decision-making skills. Um, and so we've had to really work through this with her.

SPEAKER_00Um, but it's it's that like success story where we had her employed and she loved what she was doing. And it so quickly kind of crumbled.

SPEAKER_03And I imagine it's important not to judge that decision from the outside, right? If losing a benefit means you suddenly can't afford childcare, um, telling someone to think long term doesn't really solve the bill that's due next month. And that's just a dramatic example. Wow. Thank you for sharing. Yeah. Carla, the Iowa Center for Economic Success helps people build financial stability and pursue economic opportunities. I know Bankers Trust, we've partnered with you many times. Um, there's an interesting financial planning problem here. Um, we often tell people that earning more is one of the most important ways they can improve their financial position.

SPEAKER_03But in this situation, the path upward isn't necessarily a straight line. How do you help someone plan for that?

SPEAKER_01So, our mission at the Iowa Center is to bring financial well-being to Iowans. And the way we help them achieve that is through the pathway of small business ownership. So it's a little bit different. Um, it does allow them to maybe take a passion that they have or a product that they make and turn it into an income, but a lot of times they don't have the resources to do that. So at the Iowa Center, what we do is we provide, help them achieve that financial wellness. And we have the financial wellness piece, the personal piece, we have the classes and coaching, and then we also have our credit and lending.

SPEAKER_01So what we see clients come in is they come in with their ideas and we help them create a plan. So they might go to a class or talk with a coach about how they could achieve their goals, and all of that is free. So we give that to them. We also help them achieve that personal financial well-being through our tax program. We have the volunteer income tax assistance program, which is really critical when you talk about the Alice population. There's a great overlap between the Alice population and the Vita population.

SPEAKER_01So we can provide free tax preparation for those clients. And then along with that, we can provide some of those personal financial skills that that maybe they need help. It sounds like you do some things with budgeting as well and that sort of thing. But we can provide resources that they can help get some of the things that they need without losing other benefits.

SPEAKER_03That that's important. We we don't want to frame a benefits cliff as a budgeting failure. Um any of you jump in. What does genuine financial stability look like?

SPEAKER_04I can take this one. Uh, you know, when we're talking about these public assistance benefits, it's best to ground ourselves and understand that these are for families that are really low income. Um, in the housing example, typical family of four, that benefit cuts out shortly after what we consider the federal poverty level. So for a family of four, a little over$31,000 a year, which is really hard to make it in central Iowa when you're talking about housing, childcare, food, medical care.

SPEAKER_04Um those benefits stack up. Um, but again, even at the last benefit program, we're not talking about folks who make a ton of money. Um and so it's some it was intended to be a bridge out of poverty, a bridge to better uh better incomes for the families and better outcomes. But unfortunately, what we see is folks hit that cliff and it destabilizes them. Um and really, this is a design problem of our public assistance programs.

SPEAKER_04This is not something we can fix this. We have fixed this in some areas, child care assistance in our state is one. Um but it you're not gonna get that rate, you're not gonna go into your supervisor's office and your raise is gonna be we're doubling your salary. Because in many instances, that's what we're talking about, the gap between where families are currently earning and having to double their salary, household income, to actually be able to pay for all these expenses out of pocket, out of their own budget without support.

SPEAKER_04So the only way for us to get folks to grow out of poverty is to have well-designed public assistance programs that don't all kick in and kick out at certain points. Really, we should be aligning them more towards what a realistic, thriving family budget should be that's part federal government, part state government. There's a lot of work to be done in that space.

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. A lot of what we found was uh the families that would come to us that would need assistance qualify for very little too sometimes. And so we have a uh a working population as well that is struggling to uh to just make ends meet across the board. And uh we have worked with them on how do you have these conversations with the employers. You know, how do you how do you uh approach it?

SPEAKER_00Um, do you trust your employer enough to say, thank you for seeing me as a value? Thank you for offering me this, but can I be really transparent and say no, thank you, because this is going to put my family in a really hard spot. And that that could ultimately make my productivity at work worse, right? If I lose my transportation, if I can't pay car insurance. And so um really working with them on you know what is the communication that can be had with business owners or HR directors when when these offers kind of come forward too.

SPEAKER_00And it's oh, go ahead.

SPEAKER_04To build on that, a lot of these folks either have full-time jobs where they aren't offered benefits. So could you imagine working a full-time job and not having access to health insurance? That's why you would need Medicaid support, which is a public assistance program that's income-bound. Another good portion of these population that we're talking about are also working multiple part-time jobs, um, two, three part-time jobs to try and earn the income, but at the same time, they're not qualifying for those other ancillary benefits.

SPEAKER_04Almost all of these programs, with the exception of maybe Section 8 housing vouchers at the very early limit, require you to have some work to prove that you are working. So the the idea that folks are not working and sitting on benefits is really not true.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And you bring up a really valid point because um one of the pillars of WeLift is like job um sustainment and and job applications and search. And it has been um a really long time that we have been able to place people in jobs that are offering full insurance, full benefits. They just don't exist. Um, we have people that uh will say, Will you help me manage my schedule because I'm working three jobs and show me how I can do it? And a lot of times I'm like, You you can't.

SPEAKER_00When are you sleeping? When are you taking care of your family? Um, and so it's a really valid point. Our opportunities in workforce uh right now that provide all the benefits and the insurance and the wages that are needed to be sustainable aren't available right now.

SPEAKER_04And like you said, when are they sleeping? When are they taking care of their kiddos? When do they have the time to further their education or training to get that better job? If you're juggling two or three part-time jobs, there's no time left in the day, and you're exhausted. Um planning for your future uh is just not possible. These folks are planning for next week and next payday.

SPEAKER_01Carla, what's the other thing? I think in addition to that, one of the things we have found, and I know you've talked about this at United Way, and we've heard from the Federal Reserve, is that a third of adults do not have the capability of handling a$400 sudden expense. So if they have an emergency, a medical emergency, they have to pay for, if they need a car repair, if something breaks down in their house, they don't have that, and that causes a lot of anxiety in people. And so we use our tax time as a way to kind of address that. So a lot of this population we're talking about will get a tax refund.

SPEAKER_01Some of it obviously goes to paying bills because a lot of it, a lot of people just say, I've got to pay my bills. But if they come to us and um, for example, in this last tax season, quite a few people got a bigger refund because all of a sudden they weren't getting um taxed on overtime or tips. And so we would encourage them to say, take some of that and can you save some of that so that you can relieve your anxiety in the future and have a little bit saved? And we actually had a a great example from the last last couple years. We had a woman come in and she got help on a few years of tax returns.

SPEAKER_01They had made a mistake where she'd gone before, and we had a Vita volunteer do her taxes for three years, and so she got a bigger than normal refund. And she was able to, we said, Well, we'd encourage you to save some. And we know that we uh tell everyone that, but we know that a lot of people don't. She came back the next year and said, I was able to save a lot. And I had my refrigerator break down and I could go get a new one. Yeah. And then she said, and then a few months later, I had my stove break down, and without that, I mean it was three years of tax refund basically. Yeah, she was able to take care of those and she said it was so much less stressful for me.

SPEAKER_01And that's part of achieving that financial stability.

SPEAKER_00Can we help people just save a little bit so that they can get when when um WeLift was kind of looking just at the landscape of the people we serve, um, we are we are running into just small barriers that nobody would cover, right? So um a tire goes out and they can't replace it, uh, the car is in the shop for a week, they still have to get to work, uh, a cell phone that was going to be turned off, but that's how your employer gets a hold of you, that's how the schools get a hold of you, right? So um our compassion fund has been one that uh there's no real eligibility requirements because these are the working population.

SPEAKER_00And so being able to step into that space to take away a barrier for them has been really, really um important to watch our families try to push through that obstacle and push ahead. But the the savings, right? The the the savings in case of something were to happen. And it's not, you know, if it's gonna happen, when the car goes out or when something needs to be changed. You're right, that's a huge, huge part of it. Um, and how and how do we get the families financially ready to start being able to save a little bit?

SPEAKER_03So we've talked a lot about families. Um, let's turn our attention to employers. What happens when an employer offers someone a raise or promotion and the employee does say, I can't afford it? And to your point earlier, do workers feel comfortable telling an employer, do they have that trust that you mentioned to explain why they're declining an opportunity?

SPEAKER_04I'll go with that one. Um, you know, this ends up being a workforce issue for the employer. Um, you've got a good employee that you're obviously promoting or providing more hours or higher wage to. Uh if they end up losing those benefits, they're gonna have that hard household decision of should I continue working? Uh it's a chicken and egg problem. Let me go back to child care again. But if no one's taking care of the kiddo during the day, how can you go to work?

SPEAKER_04Uh so that would take half the household out of the out of workforce. Um, you'll have retention issues, you'll have turnover issues, you won't be able to elevate and um promote good, skilled, knowledgeable employees. It's kind of like they're stuck where they're at until they make that huge jump. And so for employers, you know, considering flexibility um on scheduling, um, considering what benefits packages you can offer, uh also in in when it comes to down to it, wages.

SPEAKER_04Um, you know, and this shouldn't be a surprise to a lot of employee employers out there. They, I'm sure they've heard this when uh a uh new development manufacturing business wants to come to a community, they look at these things. How much childcare is available, um, what is the uh healthcare situation in this community? Because you you know, you can't just open up a new business, put out a help wanted sign these days, and expect to have the workforce that you need. You kind of have to provide those workforce supports and wraparound supports in order to make your employees thrive, which in turn help your business or organization thrive.

SPEAKER_04So it's a challenge on both sides. Um but there's things that we can all do from a systemic level as well to really address these. Issues.

SPEAKER_01And Dave, you talked about business opening up. And that's one thing we talk about with our small business owners is first, what do you do to get your business to the point where you can support your family? And how do you prepare for yourself for the future? Are you setting aside a little bit for retirement because you're eventually going to be there? And then we always talk with them when they start hiring employers because people think of small businesses are just one or two people, but they're not. A lot of times they have employees. And what do you want to offer your employees? And a lot of these small business owners want to offer them what they didn't have.

SPEAKER_01So consider offering some help for childcare. Consider offering a match for a 401k, those sorts of things. And the Iowa Center is there to help them navigate those things that they don't know about. They just know they've got something great that they want to sell. But that is something that we definitely encourage our small business clients to do.

SPEAKER_00We um we actually had an employer reach back out to us and say, Will you explain to me why this employee came in and denied the raise? Um and so it was a really precious moment to educate them on the system and and the system flaws. And the employer was um basically stunned at the conversation, right? Like I had no idea, like I'm just over here wanting to to to give somebody um the credit they deserve by by increasing their wages.

SPEAKER_00I had no idea it would negatively affect this family so much. And and um their response was, what can we as employers do, right, to help with this? Um and you know, we have a lot of housing issues, right? We we don't have affordable housing, we don't have child care. You know, it's it's a bigger, it's the big picture. But I I do believe the more um business owners and employers understand um the benefits, Clift, it maybe will help them make make um clearer decisions, especially at starting wages and kind of go from there.

SPEAKER_04And and to be clear, you know, when you have some of these public assistance benefits, you don't have much. You you are not receiving thousands and thousands of dollars in a month. You're basically just getting it by uh housing vouchers, you know, you're in very low cost apartments, rentals. Um child care assistance is a copay model where the provider gets paid SNAP benefits or food assistance, you may only get a couple hundred dollars to feed your family of four in a month.

SPEAKER_04Try to do that now in the current environment.

SPEAKER_00And if if you get a job and you reapply for SNAP six months later, you could go from$400 down to$14.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_00So that's another one that that our single mom ran into too, is like when she had to reevaluate for SNAP when she was working.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. So as we talk with employers, creative benefits are something to consider. Um because yes, we all talk about public assistance and the government benefits, but they're really not as much as you think. Then there's the input of the family themselves. What are the turnover costs that an employer faces if they lose that employee? Would child care subsidies or we would call them dependent care benefits, because you may have an aging parent that you're taking care of or other dependents that you're also taking care of, not just little kiddos.

SPEAKER_04Uh, housing, um, you know, these are things that the business community maybe has not thought about. There are plenty of businesses that do this, I should say. There are plenty of businesses in central Iowa that do offer some of these kind of ancillary benefits. But think of it from the business sense of a little bit of investment in my employees outside of the government public assistance benefit system will actually save us money in the turnover costs, retention, keeping that good employee productivity. Because when the childcare provider doesn't show up or they can't take them, that employee is calling in sick that day because you just can't leave your kiddos at home alone.

SPEAKER_01So one thing I would like to see employers do as well is make more use of Vita because we're talking about low-income wage earners here and a lot of single parents. And if if employers would be willing to promote VIDA, you know, get a hold of us, contact us, and we could do that. So one of the things we see in Iowa is we know that about 20% of people that qualify for the earned income tax credit don't claim it. A lot of them don't have to file. So if you don't make enough, you don't actually have to file your taxes.

SPEAKER_01But if they got if they were able to educate their employees and say, go get your taxes done, because even though you aren't going to owe any tax, if you've got these kids, you might qualify for the earned income tax credit, which is a totally refundable credit. It's not your taxes going back. It's money you can get in your pocket if you don't even have to pay taxes.

SPEAKER_04The EITC, the earned income tax credit, is the single best anti-poverty program we have in America. Simple as that. Uh it rewards people for working. Um it comes back to them on their taxes, and as you said, it really is beneficial for them. But I do have to credit VIDA as well. And I used to be a Vita volunteer, I should say that.

SPEAKER_01You can be one again. Uh I can. Yeah.

SPEAKER_04The tax becomes a little more complicated now. Uh you know, I remember clients coming in, they are not financially savvy at all. They don't know the first thing about completing a tax form, let alone what tax credits are or what this means, or what is a 401k or saving an IRA. That the hour you spend with them doing their taxes is probably the most beneficial financial education they've ever received. And they're getting it for free. And I don't know what is the limitation on the income.

SPEAKER_01Because next year it's gonna be$70,000 a year.

SPEAKER_04$70,000 a year. The IRS considers you are low enough income to have your taxes completed for free. That's kind of a mind-blowing number to me.

SPEAKER_03Well, Carly, I'm glad you encouraged people to use this service, and it sounds like it's maybe accessible to more people than we would have originally thought. I'm gonna encourage uh members of our community to volunteer for Vita. Please do. Sounds like you could use more. I know um we have shout out several of our bankers' trust team members volunteer for Vita, and I'm sure we can help come up with a few more as well. But what an important service. And also good to hear that employees are concerned, like the example you shared about this, and have asked, what can they do? And some of them, it sounds like are coming up with some creative solutions.

SPEAKER_03I guess my assumption was that they would have thought if someone turns down a race or a promotion or more hours that it was a lack of ambition. So I'm glad that that that's not necessarily the case, but you just never know. All employers might react a little bit differently. Um, so we've talked about a cliff. So the phrase we keep using is cliff. I wonder if instead we need a ramp. Um, and so what does that mean from a policy perspective, Dave?

SPEAKER_04Sure. Again, all of these public assistance programs are flawed by design, and we can change these, whether it be Medicaid, SNAP, child care assistance, Section A housing vouchers, Lie Heap, Low-income heating energy assistance program. I always almost get that one. Uh instead of a hard cutoff, we can make a more graduated exit. And we have been successful with that with childcare assistance, particularly here in Iowa, a lot of the work from United Way and our coalition partners.

SPEAKER_04But instead of, oh, you earned an extra$100 this month, you no longer qualify, we cut you off. It can be a slower, gradual reduction. Um, in terms of childcare assistance, as family income went up, what we did was we started increasing the weekly co-pays that they pay to gradually get them ready for market rate. Um, that went from 145% of the poverty level, now all the way up to 225% of the poverty level. And of course, I would always argue we can go a little bit higher than that.

SPEAKER_04But um, you know, the idea that these percentages of federal poverty suddenly you can afford living in America these days is just not practical. Uh in terms of the FPL, it was designed in the 60s based off of two times what the average grocery bill was in 1960s. That isn't practical in 2026 anymore.

SPEAKER_03Because grocery prices are the same as they were. Right, right. And gas prices.

SPEAKER_04Gas and you could buy a car or a house for nothing. Uh it's just it has not kept pace. Now they do uh uh adjust that number on an annual basis, but it is not actually keeping up with the cost of living now. So, how can we smooth these exits? How can we make these bridges instead of cliffs? The goal is to help families move up and out of poverty. But if suddenly they get their knees cut out from under them by losing these types of benefits, they're just stuck. They're stuck.

SPEAKER_04And it's our system's design that kind of keeps them stuck there because again, you're not going to be offered a double salary overnight. Uh, and that's what we really would take. Um, so there's some things we can do. Gradually lower benefits, increase the share of the family's costs, uh, slowly, you know, going from that$25 a month to$100.

SPEAKER_00And even emotionally, yeah, she would be like, I can do that. Yeah, right. Emotionally. Even I think if we probably would have showed$200 and then up to$350 and then up to$500, like she would have been, but when you put$800 in her face just like that, it it was like, no, there's no way I can do that. It's not possible. And it didn't even give us a chance to budget what the next year could look like at 200, then 350, then 575, right? And slowly moving up because she's gonna have to save some part of that.

SPEAKER_00You you do 800 right off like this. There's no chance of her saving anything.

SPEAKER_04You cannot budget your way out of poverty. You just cannot. And that's the simple, sad truth. And an$800 bill may sound like a lot to some of the viewers, maybe not a lot to others, but when you're at the lowest end of the income spectrum, that's an insurmountable bill. And so how can we climb it?

SPEAKER_00You know, the 50% house burden, right? That's a dangerous statistic if 50% of your paycheck is going towards housing because there's a lot of other essential needs that need to be covered in that.

SPEAKER_03So United Ways worked on the child care cliff for well over a decade. Where have we made progress?

SPEAKER_04We've made a lot of progress. Uh as I said, we have moved to a graduated exit. Uh that was a big win with United Way of Central Iowa, our United Ways across the state, and our coalition partners. Um all CCA childcare assistance participants always had a small income-based copay, and it could have been as low as 20 bucks a week for childcare, which is a deal. We moved that to slowly ratchet up as they got closer to the exit. We extended the exit to where it was, but there's still a lot to be done.

SPEAKER_04Um, because you know, just because you've magically hit 225% of the federal poverty level does not mean you can afford living in central Iowa or America in 2026. It's just not possible. Um so we could be working on things like reimbursement rates for the providers so that they actually get paid for the costs that it cost of care. Um our child care providers who accept child care assistance are basically taking a hit every single time they take one of those kids on. It's it's charity.

SPEAKER_04Um in fact, you know, if you're calling the kid down the street so you can have a movie night and getting them to take care of your kiddo, you probably pay that kiddo just to watch your kid for movie night more than a licensed childcare center receives for taking care of your kid for eight hours a day. It's shocking, but that's what we're at. So um child care assistance, we can definitely improve still. Um and then thinking about what uh getting away from this percentage of income, household income, and really going to what point does that family thrive?

SPEAKER_04Right. What point are they stable? And that number can be different for every family. You know, one thing that we don't talk about, or we haven't talked about yet, is there's a lot of stressors in this space right now. We've had the impacts of HR one or the one big beautiful bill. Some of those are going into effect. Um whole household income is is counted. So if your teenager has a summer part-time job, their income counts against you for all of these things. The value of your house if you own one, if you're lucky enough to own one and be able to do this, the value of your used car.

SPEAKER_04Um, what's your bank account looks like? Also, I want to say like benefits are difficult. It is a part-time job just to sign up for them.

SPEAKER_00Yes, sir. Or to assist them in signing up. And so uh our staff gets extremely frustrated. And uh because it's sometimes we're just running in a circle and they'll say, Well, you just paid me to run in a circle for eight hours, right? Because no one's answering their phone, or they can't find the the the it's not being submitted online correctly, or we're missing a birth certificate, a social security card, and it won't scan correctly. And so now you you ask people to do this on their own in their home on maybe a phone or maybe a government-issued phone that then takes all their minutes to submit all of this information and stuff.

SPEAKER_00So it it really is an extremely frustrating system to navigate.

SPEAKER_04And getting that birth certificate costs$30,$40 and that social security costs this much. And that's you know, having the documentation sounds like easy, but if you've ever lost your birth certificate and have to go back to your literal county of where you were born, it could be another state, it could be another country. Uh, you know, it's difficult for you to get all these things together and then fill out all the paperwork. And the thing is, when you hit a cliff or you lose your benefits, it's instant. Getting reinstated can take months, months to get back on benefits.

SPEAKER_04And that's months without food assistance, that's maybe months without medical insurance, like Medicaid. And that's just it it makes my skin crawl, thinking of what if that family truly needs ongoing medical care, prescription drugs, and from a paperwork snapo or a slight raise, they lose access to these things, but then you know, go to the pharmacy and that prescription has quadrupled in price for them and they have to start making those tough choices.

SPEAKER_03So let's end with um maybe some some reminders and some hope. If someone's listening who's never heard of a benefit cliff, I'm sure they've learned a lot today because I know I sure have. What's one thing you'd like them to really take away from today's conversation?

SPEAKER_01And Carla, let's start with you. Sure. Um, I think we work with our clients on building their financial well-being. And that means not spending more than you take in. It means setting aside a little savings and planning for the future. And that's the same whether you're a small business owner or uh a family. And so if if we can help people figure out those things, we do it through small businesses. There's a lot of other things that have been discussed here today, but that's that's what we want for the people in Iowa. Thank you.

SPEAKER_00You know, I think um I'll go back to to what I said a little bit before, but um I think it's we have to do our due diligence to change the narrative for the people that are um running the bills through. Um we have a large working population in Iowa um that are really struggling to put everything together. And it's not because of their um lack of will, in a sense, to go to work and get up and and do the hard stuff every day.

SPEAKER_00But um, you know, getting maybe certain organizations to also understand how can we all work together to decrease some of these barriers that help push them along, pay for the social security cards, pay for the new birth certificates, pay for the housing application fee, because some of those are up to$200 just to apply for housing. You know, so look outside that box. You know, what does the state and and the federal government provide as assistance? And where can we put our other um resources to use to try to help them overcome this benefit cliffs?

SPEAKER_00And maybe that is cell phone support, transportation support, um, some of those things outside the box. But I think we're we're at a time where we really have to lean in on organizations like United Way, um, Vita, you know, the the faith-based organizations, nonprofits, to really come together and work through a system because we know it can be improved and we need it to be improved.

SPEAKER_04I would say the viewers have compassion. Um, you know, these are safety net programs. And regardless of where you are in life or station, you may find yourself needing these programs at some days. I think most recently the pandemic cut across income and status lines, and people needed assistance that just wasn't available to them. And if we could rethink uh how these programs help support families up and out of poverty, because really what these cliff effects are are traps to keeping them there.

SPEAKER_04Um so if we can get away from this, um I I want accountability and of course, uh, you know, tracking and making sure the right people receive benefits, but there's no magic number. There's no magic number that says, oh, you make this enough now, you can make it. Um, it's just not practical and feasible. So consider that, you know, anyone can have uh a similar crisis in their family that makes them fall into homelessness or needing food assistance or things like that.

SPEAKER_04Um, and that's sort of the the safety net that we have in our country, but we can do better and we as a nation can design these systems better to support families instead of keeping them where they are.

SPEAKER_03I think all three of those answers bring us back to something that sounds so simple. When somebody earns more money, they should be able to move forward, not fall farther behind. Dave, Sue, and Carla, thank you for helping us better understand why that doesn't always happen and what can be done about it. And I think there's some just great discussion, so much good education, but also some great solutions that we can work toward if we all continue to work together. And thank you for listening to Community Difference Makers, because when we come together around a shared purpose, we don't just talk about change, we make a meaningful difference together.

SPEAKER_03Please join us next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 74. Helping Young People Get the Mental Health Support They Need

    Nov 17, 202644 minAudio

    Mental health is part of every young person's health. In this episode of Community Difference Makers, we discuss what young people and families are experiencing in Central Iowa, the services available to support them,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 72. Getting There – How Transportation Shapes Opportunity

    Nov 4, 202640 minAudio

    Transportation affects nearly every part of daily life, but for many people, getting where they need to go isn't simple. In this episode of Community Difference Makers, we explore the transportation challenges facing...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 71. Helping Students Discover Their Future

    Oct 27, 202640 minAudio

    For today’s students, success doesn’t follow a single path. While some may choose a four-year university, others may find their future through community college, registered apprenticeships, industry credentials,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 70. Creating a Community Where Everyone Belongs

    Oct 20, 202635 minAudio

    What does it take to build a community where everyone has the opportunity to thrive? In this episode of Community Difference Makers, we explore the intersection of disability services, health, education, and equity in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 69. A Diploma and a Plan – Preparing Students for What Comes Next

    Oct 19, 202643 minAudio

    Graduating from high school is an important milestone. But what happens the morning after graduation? For more than one in five Central Iowa graduates - 22% - there isn't yet a clear plan that includes education or...

    Credit the people on this episode