Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! About half the companies we talk to either don’t know what an SSP is or have one that’s just a purchased template or an AI draft with their company name on it. Austin and Brooke explain what a System Security Plan really has to say, how to structure it alongside your policies, what assessors check, and the one piece of incident reporting paperwork that can’t be rushed in a crisis. In this episode: Why a template or AI-generated SSP is fine as a starting point but fails if it doesn’t describe your actual environment Why you should map your CUI data flow before writing anything, and why it’s the highest-value task in compliance that costs nothing How to structure documentation: control summary statements and assessment objective statements in the SSP, with roughly one policy per control family Why policies should use roles and tool categories instead of names, so a tool change doesn’t force you to rewrite them What the assessor is really verifying: that your real environment matches your SSP, and your SSP matches your policies The physical gaps that undo a good SPRS score: open bay doors, unlocked screens, unattended drawings What you can outsource, what you can’t, and why decision makers must stay involved What a POA&M is for, why the 180-day clock and 88-point minimum limit it, and why the hardest controls can never go on one The incident reporting certificate: why you must have it installed before an incident, why the reporting window is 72 hours, and why you need it on more than one computer Why you should write your documentation before you buy any tools
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hey there and welcome to the CMMC Compliance Guide Podcast. I'm Austin.
BrookeAnd I'm Brooke
SPEAKER_00from Justice IT Consulting, where we help businesses like yours navigate CMMC and NIST 800-171 compliance. We're hired guns getting companies fast-tracked to compliance. But today, we're here to give you all the secrets for free. So if you want to tackle it yourself, you're equipped to do so. Let's dive into today's episode and keep your business on track. Today we're going to be talking about our most favorite part of CMMC. And I think everyone's favorite part.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Documentation. The documentation, the paperwork portion of compliance is uh, you know, again, I I think we always say this about everything is the one thing that people get wrong by compliance, or they always mess it up, right?
BrookeBut it is certainly the single most uh laborious part, all the paperwork, all the documentation that you have to do.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes, it is. And um it is uh often something that people get wrong, right? Yes. So we're gonna try and tackle the the paperwork portion of it today and um and tell you guys uh, you know, m why maybe uh a document that looks really nice, pretty, and impressive with a bunch of words and fluff and everything else in there is you know something that still can fail you, right?
BrookeAbsolutely.
SPEAKER_00So uh let's dive into it, Brooke, and talk a little bit about paperwork.
BrookeLet's do it.
SPEAKER_00So whenever we do uh our gaps analysis, um whenever we have new customers come in, or uh whenever we're just doing our discovery with prospective customers, one of the things we always ask about, of course, um uh foundational to the paperwork portion of compliance and documentation is do you have a system security plan, an SSP?
BrookeRight? Yep.
SPEAKER_00Um and about half the time they'll say, What's that?
BrookeYeah. Right. At least half the time, yes.
SPEAKER_00Yep. And then if they do say, oh yeah, absolutely, we've got an SSP, um whenever you dive into it a little further, um, you know, it can often just be uh template that they purchased or um a clot or chat GPT, you know, um output, which I'm not knocking, um with uh their company name on it and you know, a bunch of words that mean a lot of things. Uh so beyond just buying a template or hopping into you know the LLM or um AI of your choice and saying, you know, here's a system security plan, or you know, get me a template and me smack my company name, my LLC in there.
SPEAKER_00Um, you know, what actually do you need to see in it?
BrookeWell, your system security plan or SSP uh it really is a story, and we've gone over this. Really, I feel like we're like we're beating a dead horse, but uh so uh an SSP is a story of how you're implementing those controls and all those assessment objectives, right? And uh so you've got to put some detail in it. Um you don't really want to write, you know, two or three paragraphs for each assessment objective necessarily, unless it requires it. Some of them are you know pretty simple. Um some stuff requires you know more length to explain.
BrookeUh, but you want you want to put in there and explain in your SSP how you do things, right? You of course want to have your policies and everything else. Um but your as far as your SSP goes, uh uh starting with a template is fine to get an idea. Starting with a cloud or or uh Chat GPT assisted template is fine. Uh, but you've got to go through it and make sure it matches your your uh program, matches what uh your environment. Uh and of course, before that, what do you need to do?
SPEAKER_00I don't know.
BrookeOh, come on, man. I Austin just failed the test. I'm just kidding, he knows I'm
SPEAKER_00just a sales guy. What do you want me to do? Just
Brookekidding, he knows. But uh, you know, the first thing you need to do is is figure out your data flow, right?
SPEAKER_00Yep.
BrookeAnd figure out what kind of CUI you have, why you think you have it uh as part of that data flow or as a separate exercise. Uh usually if a lot of times we do we separate data out into a separate exercise where we say, what kind of CUI do you have? Well, how do you know it? Well, where do you get, you know, why are you think why do you think you need to be CMMC level two or level one maybe? Um so
SPEAKER_00you know it's it's funny. Um whenever I'm talking to customers, I'm sorry to interrupt you there, but um you talk about CUI data flow. Um often when we're talking to like a smaller organization, maybe owner-led uh machine shop or manufacturer or something like that, um, you know, he's able to get um you know himself, maybe business partner or something, and um and you know, some key people um in the room and and it with with a properly led interview, um, we can pretty much hone into what their COI data flow is relatively quickly.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's gonna need some more pen and paper, some more ink, uh and uh to really flesh it out, but we can really hone into that. Whenever um I'm talking to larger organizations that come to us, it's actually a much harder process. Um and I often ask like I'll just tell them like, look, let's pop top, you know, just hit the brakes here brakes here. Um uh because they'll maybe I'm talking to, you know, uh the IT department lead or or
Brookea
SPEAKER_00compliance person something, and you'll ask them. And and they'll have a very tangential understanding, um, but don't really know what their data flow is. And so I'll say, well, you know, you're gonna hate me saying this, um, because this is gonna slow, slow the train down here, but it's really foundational and important what we do. Like we need to pause this, and honestly, before you talk to any consultants either, because they're they're not gonna be able to invent the data flow for you.
BrookeRight.
SPEAKER_00Um Right. Uh and if anyway, they're not gonna be able to invent it for you. So before you go forward with anybody, even if you're just DOI it in-house, like you need to go to your team and go ask the salespeople that are getting these POs. You know, you need to go talk to the foreman and shop floor or whatever, and really interview everyone and and hone in on this data flow. And then let's let's add another meeting, you know, a week, two weeks, maybe a month, because that's how long it's gonna take you if you're you have to go talk to all those people and uh map that out.
SPEAKER_00Because what we're the foundation of what we're gonna build, and what I'm gonna quote for you, is gonna be completely misinformed if we haven't done this exercise.
BrookeIt absolutely will. Yeah, whenever we do our boot camps, and uh that is it's part of the boot camp, is figured out, and it's one of the first questions we ask is what kind of CUI do you have? You know, and uh a lot of them say, well, I don't know. You know, well, you kind of need to know, you know, there's because it matters, you know. It matters if you have basic or specified, if there's um if there's some sort of dissemination requirements, you know. Uh it matters what kind you have. If you have ITAR, uh then it's a decent bet, although not 100 percent.
BrookeIt's a decent bet that that you're gonna have uh con uh uh controlled technical information or CTI specified. With
SPEAKER_00just C UI.
BrookeC
SPEAKER_00I C UI. Yep.
BrookeAnd so that's gonna be a uh uh specified C UI, CTI uh with an export control, you know. Um anyway, that's not a it's not a uh definitive, but you know, it's likely. So you've got to figure out what kind of CUI you have and uh why you think you have that. Is just because you've been pulling out of your your rear end, is it because uh you know uh Lockheed Martin said, hey, we need to be level two compliant, and you say, okay, well I guess we must have uh CUI.
BrookeYou know, what kind of uh what kind of DFARS rules are in your contracts? You know, uh what is what are your contracts, your POs, what do they say about ITAR or ER or anything else, you know? Uh so you got to know those things. And uh before you before you can even really start a data flow diagram, or as part of the data flow diagram process. So that's one of the first questions we ask, and we and you know, we'd help folks do a data flow diagram, and we start out with a simple one and ask them about all the systems. We're talking about, you know, what kind of customer portals, emails, where where do you get this stuff from?
BrookeWhere do you get CUI from? Now that you understand what CUI you have, hopefully, uh, you know, where does it come from? Well, it comes from here, it comes from there, uh, it comes from DOD safe, uh, it comes from you know wherever it may come from. Um we get it through email, hopefully not. Uh so you mark those down as sources, and then in your system, where does it go? Does it go to servers? Does it go to a file share? Does it go to uh applications? Does it go to um uh enclave like Prevel?
BrookeUh does it go flow around to different computers? Um do you send it through email to other people, by the way? It's a no-no. Um I guess unless you have GCC or GCC high, but
SPEAKER_00proper handling.
BrookeYeah, proper handling. So uh and beyond
SPEAKER_00nothing's definitive in compliance. That's one thing that we know.
BrookeSo in other words, with uh I think we're gonna hit on this. I'm getting ahead of myself. But uh so you got to figure out where the data flows, and then what we usually do is we have the data flow up over here on one screen while we're talking to them and going through the whole SSP and helping them write out their SSP. So we can talk about it invariably though. What happens if you get to one of the controls and you say, well, what about this, that, and the other, and they say, Oh yeah, and they mention a system that they didn't mention before, and you're like, Oh, huh. Well, over here on my data flow diagram, I don't see that. So uh tell me more about that.
BrookeAnd so then you insert something in. So you gotta you gotta have that uh data flow understanding and how you want to build it out because it doesn't have to stay the same. You can you can tighten that flow up or you can make an enclave, whatever you whatever you think. You should tighten it up because generally it's coming in from every which way and going to every which direction.
SPEAKER_00So
Brookeum but in any case, uh that data flow diagram will help inform you as you as you go through and write your SSP and um it'll help you keep your mind around what all systems are in scope for CUI, SPA, uh special out specialized assets or out of scope, you know, it'll help you keep keep you informed as you go through making that SSP.
SPEAKER_00And that is one of the most high-leverage activities you can do in compliance that is free. Right? I don't I feel like I have to say that you know a lot, but it's really is important. Like it's the highest leverage thing you can do that costs no money, that requires no tools, that uh gets no buy-off from anyone in the organization, you know, no checks need to be remitted to do that thing, right? Um, unless
Brookeyou hire somebody to come in and help you make it.
SPEAKER_00Right, yeah. Which which there's value in. There is value in that. But you can 100% do that yourself without a consultant.
BrookeYou've got to you've got to keep your mind open and think about all the different systems, not just a server, but you know what what on that server is ingesting the CUI? Is it file shares? Uh is it an application, is it a SQL database, is it you know, what is it?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. So I think I might have got us a little off track there. We can blame that one on me. Yeah.
BrookeWe'll we'll go with that.
SPEAKER_00But the long and short on you know what needs to be in an SSP, um, if you want to wrap that up. Sorry.
BrookeSo to wrap that up, as far as an SSP goes, it's your story about how you are protecting CUI in your system. So uh it's a template is great to start with. Uh a cloud or a chat GPT-assisted template is great to start with, uh, but you've got to make sure it addresses your whole system. Having that good data flow diagram that you've drawn uh out here for you to reference is a great way to make sure that you have that accounted for. Um and uh make make sure you have all the systems accounted for as you're describing your SSP.
BrookeAnd if you have multiple places that they're CUI, you know, uh SharePoint on your server, uh on a workstation over here with uh you know a CAD workstation, you've got to all those are in scope and you've got to describe all them for all the all the controls uh that you you uh that apply to them, right? Uh so but you just gotta keep that in mind as you're writing your SSP.
SPEAKER_00So I want to caveat the you know this episode and this next statement, you know, with um with the context of there is no particularly prescriptive model um for how you have to write documentation exactly this way, right?
BrookeRight, not exactly, right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So but
Brookehowever, there's always a but.
SPEAKER_00There's expectations. You know, if you have assessors and you have, you know, an industry of people, you know, doing this, there's there's best practice, generally accepted like ways that um, you know, just work the best, right?
BrookeYep, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Um and so uh why I bring that up is because one mistake, uh and so it's it's hard for I guess for me to call it a mistake, you know, whenever there's not really a prescriptive model. So that's why I want to caveat the statement. But um it just doesn't work well to uh like for example, people often try to build their policies within the system security plan is like one humongous um you know document that is fully inclusive of a
Brookepage uh SSP, yes.
SPEAKER_00Right. Um and that is um just typically a mistake and not the best way to handle it. Um uh they are policies living within the SSP. Can you kind of explain that?
BrookeIf you do it that way and you love a 900 or a thousand page SSP, more power to you. But your
SPEAKER_00assessors must may hate you. Your
Brookeassessors may hate you, yes. Uh but generally what's expected is uh you know an SSP that has a control summary statement uh for each of the controls and then a statement for each of the assessment objectives and how you meet that objective. So um uh you know you'll have one summary statement and several one or several uh you know assessment objective statements, how you cover those assessment objectives. Um but the and then you'll reference uh you know you'll have a system description, you know, the it all it all lays out what you're supposed to document.
BrookeAnd so really putting that all together in the SSP uh is that's where all needs to go. But then you reference policies, and those policies is generally a lot you can write your policies however you want, right? But it's a whole lot easier if you have uh roughly uh a policy per family, you know, access control, um uh awareness and training, you know, and and so forth and so on. So one one policy per family uh is easy. I've seen people break out AC into uh access control.
BrookeDo we call
SPEAKER_00this the one family policy?
BrookeActually it'd be 14 family policy, but anyway, yeah. Um so uh but I've and I've seen people split out the uh access control family into several different policies because it's a hu it's a big one and touches on a lot of stuff. Uh and that's understandable, uh, you know. Um but we've we tried that and decided we didn't like it and went back to one access control policy. Um and it's also easier if you lay out a table of where uh you know uh 3.1.1 where in your document, where is that described at?
BrookeYou know,
SPEAKER_00easy map.
BrookeEasy easy map. You go, uh I can't remember where it is, rather than scrolling up and down and up and down trying to find it. Uh you go to that table, you go, yep, it's over here at uh 5.1. Also
SPEAKER_00it reminds you if you change something somewhere where you might want to look at where
Brookeabsolutely. It helps for a lot of reasons. Uh but generally acceptable, uh generally um not acceptable, but uh uh understood or or expected that you'll have a control or a policy per family. It's you don't have to do that. Like I said, there's different ways to do it. Uh but uh it's uh it's it makes it easier if you break it out that way. And so your SSP, when you're going through that, that'll reference uh wherever it wherever it needs to reference policy, it'll reference your AC policy, and that'll be your access control policy.
BrookeAnd that'll be one policy, and then inside that policy, what's helpful, you don't have to do this, but you know you can list you have a little table towards the top that says these are where these controls can be found in the document. And uh and then number your sections in your document. Uh it makes it really easy to go through those during assessment. Or, like you said, when uh you need to change something, you know where exactly where to go change it at. Uh your policies should be, you know, thou shalt and thou shalt nots, and generally describe things.
BrookeWe try really hard to keep uh product names, for instance, out of and people names, uh like Austin Justice is not gonna show up or Brook Justice is not gonna is not gonna show up in any of our uh policies, right? Uh there are gonna be roles, they're gonna be um you know types of tools like application whitelisting tool, for instance. Um or it'll reference the uh authorized user list, you know, some something like that. So um I guess that's not a tool really, but anyway, point is it doesn't reference brand names or anything like that.
BrookeThose are referenced elsewhere. So your policies, you can write them and and they can stay uh the they have less chance to change if you do that. And your SSP is we're gonna uh label uh list out those uh you still list out uh you'll still list out roles, uh possibly some tool names, but we also have a list of tools that we have that this tool is is uh this application whitelist is this tool, you know, and so on and so forth.
SPEAKER_00Like true IT guys, we like to try to make things make sure things are as dynamic as possible unless not statically referenced, you know, hard-coded
Brookeup.
SPEAKER_00If I change from
Brookethreat locker to app locker, I don't want to have to go change all the policy references to it, you know. I just want it to say application whitelisting, and then know that uh, you know, for application whitelisting over here we use Threat Locker. Now we're gonna change the app locker, so we're gonna use App Locker, make sure that nothing needs to change as far as documentation goes. Uh other documentation policies. Um, if they should work pretty much the same way, uh you should be in pretty good shape, be able to configure it similarly. There may be some things that, you know, permission levels that you need to reference that uh may be different, but uh that yes, that's why we do that.
BrookeAnd I think I went way into depth uh over what I should, but
SPEAKER_00I think you you hit on a good like philosophy point, if you will, because like you try to work on a car these days and you're like, how in the heck do I get to this stupid, you know, widget under the deal? Like the engineer didn't think one second about, you know, uh well maybe they did, so they can get the service rates up, but they didn't think one second about the guy that buys the car and has to go fix the dang thing, right? Um uh and so you know, you you kinda wanna you don't want to be that, you know, um automotive engineer that designs a 10-hour uh problem for what should be a 15-minute fix, you know.
SPEAKER_00You kinda wanna because it you know, once you've once you build this house of documentation, you're gonna have to live in it, right? Um
Brookedon't be like an auto manufacturer and design it to be rebuilt every time you need to do something.
SPEAKER_00Right. Exactly. Or
Brookedo a new one every time you need to, you know, need to change something.
SPEAKER_00Well, I think it's an important point to note because a lot of people are like trying to sprint through compliance with like the goal in mind of let's get compliant as quickly as possible and as cheap as possible, and you know, I need to get this done because I'm they're breathing down my neck and and then that's the end goal they have in mind, and they forget that they're gonna have to keep doing this after certification day. Oh yeah,
Brookeyeah. It's all built around management and ongoing process.
SPEAKER_00So don't hate your life afterwards, right? It's not gonna be hard enough to do this, you know.
BrookeSo
SPEAKER_00only point I want to make, we try and you know make sure that um you know we uh make those living with the documentation a little easier.
BrookeRight.
SPEAKER_00So
Brookeyeah, it's you know as far as the policies go, you know, to wrap that up, uh you know, uh you can do whatever you want with policies, but if you keep it simple, uh you know, the old phrase we try to live by, keep it simple, stupid. You know. Um Well,
SPEAKER_00you call me stupid a lot, but I was looking at
Brookeyou when I said that, so maybe I should have looked at the camera. Uh so uh but the uh you know one generally accepted is one policy per family. And again, some people break out access control into several policies, uh, but it's up to you. Um we also have, like for instance, uh we have all of our uh policies, all our procedures and plans, and then we have a a governance document that tells how they're all related, although it should be fairly understandable.
BrookeYou know, there's no prescriptive thing that says how you have to uh do policies, but there are places in the um several places uh all over the place uh in the controls that say you have to have things documented and you know, so th a lot of those things um really require policies. Just like audit and accountability family, AU, uh you know, it's not it doesn't tell you that you need a sim, but read that and tell me that you You it doesn't really need a SIM put in place. And a SIM is a uh SIM is a security, information, and event monitor or management.
BrookeAnd uh it monitors all your logs, uh it alerts for you, all that kind of fun stuff. A lot of times there's a SOC, uh security operations center team on the back end that you've also got to think about and make sure that they meet uh whatever requirements you may have. Um but that uh SIM uh uh is a really good way to cover the audit and accountability because it does your monitoring for you, alerts you when you need to be alerted and address things. Otherwise, uh to review those logs and monitor those logs, you have to go through and read those logs.
BrookeAnd you can't, I mean you can say you do that, but there's no way. Oh, I did a uh uh technical business review with a client the other day, and uh the logs they had for uh and it wasn't even that big of a client, uh logs uh the log entries that were reviewed in the SIM or put in the SIM uh were like 800,000. How can you really go through 800,000 logs?
SPEAKER_00What I do every morning
Brookelook for uh look for obvious stuff, look for obfuscated stuff, you know. Uh no, you can't you can't really do that and be secure, you know. So really it needs a sim. In any case, point is uh the AU family really is written to have a sim in place. Uh it doesn't say you need one, but the same thing with policies, right? There's all sorts of things that you need to document and specify, and uh you know a policy is a is an expected place for it to be.
SPEAKER_00Makes sense. Um so we talked about the SSP, we talked about the policies supporting the SSP. So if the SSP tells the story of everything you're doing and the policies are you know the more detailed version of you know the control families, right, then what's the assessor for? Right? If it if it my point is like all the documentation says this is all thing things you're doing, and assessor looks at it and goes, okay, it says you're doing everything. What's yeah,
Brookewhat
SPEAKER_00are the what's the assessor?
BrookeYou know, if an assessor uh what the assessor is there for to make sure real world matches what you've documented, right? Uh your SSP is what your data flow diagram says. It flows into your SSP, and this is what your SSP describes. Your SSP is that uh how is it you know in practice? What have you implemented? Does it match SSP? And does your SSP match what your policies say? Or do your policies match what your SSP says, however you want to phrase that? Uh do you have any mismatches?
BrookeYou know? Uh there are mismatches from time to time. You say, you know, the director of operations over here and the um COO over here, you know, something like that. And when you really meant the same person, uh but you know, one one family you reference one way, another family you reference another way, or something like that. Uh that's just a goofy example. Uh but uh you know, assessor is there to make sure the real world matches uh what you've documented and that it and that your documented your the documentation matches, right?
BrookeUh the good thing is if a uh if an assessor comes along and uh you know they request all your documents beforehand uh for phase one, they go through all those documents, they read all of them, everything looks really good, and then they go through and say, okay, show me this, show me that. Uh the more things you show them that are understandable and click right off and say, Yep, that matches, that matches, that's good, I understand. Guess what? So less questions they're gonna ask, or fewer questions they're gonna ask. You know, things start going wrong and they're gonna ask more questions, you know, and they're not gonna really trust that documentation.
BrookeAnd uh, but the more the more you show them that the documentation is correct and how it's implemented, uh the better it's gonna go for you.
SPEAKER_00Makes sense. So um the assessor checks um, you know, whether your documentation actually matches what you're really doing in reality, right?
BrookeYeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Um
Brookeand if you say that uh, you know, we we review um the website and uh we we review publicly accessible systems uh for CUI and FCI. Uh we do that on a uh you know monthly basis, you know. Uh yeah, I reviewed on a monthly basis. Well, well, how do you do that? Well, I just go look at it, you know. Well, did you document it? You know, so so then uh the one of the other things you have to have, you know, for a lot of these is a log. You know, yeah, I have a log. It's right here that I reviewed it. Here's all the times that I reviewed it, and they match what uh, you know uh what I'm telling you that we do, uh that matches, right?
BrookeAnd so uh they wanna and that's a the other things they'll ask for is you know, show me your Active Directory or your enter ID and show me the users and show me the admins and all that kind of fun stuff. But uh point is they'll ask you for for proof of that. And if you can generate proof uh show you and show them that you've been doing what you say you're doing, good. That's all good.
SPEAKER_00A lot of times you'll think uh, you know, IT, compliance, cybersecurity, CMMC, all you know, uh that's about where it stops, right? But um there's so many other like physical protections and things that and and business operations items that are just completely missed um whenever uh people think of CMMC. Um and even if they know they're in there, they just completely gloss over it. So like if we talk to somebody, uh says like, oh yeah, we Smit our SPERS score pretty good.
SPEAKER_00We know we need you know to improve or whatever. We put in like 107 or 110, you know. Um, but you know, we're we're pretty much there. And um, you know, uh we just need you're you're you know, talking to us and your help to get us just that little last mile, you know, and you know, all set up, right? And then you know, I may go on site and you park in the parking lot and you kind of check things out and you can, you know, walk to the you know the door that's open to the shop, bum a cigarette from the machinist.
BrookeSee if big doors open with somebody out there smoking a cigarette.
SPEAKER_00Walk through that that smoking door, you know, um right up to a machine milling out a defense park, take a pic uh picture of it, you know. Walk yeah
BrookeI'm
SPEAKER_00not saying I do these things, uh, but you know, walk right into, you know.
BrookeAll the time at least. You don't do them all the time.
SPEAKER_00Depends on how hard a day I'm having, you know. But uh point is, you know, uh a lot of times, um, you know, and and by the way, I forgot to mention in this example um that the computers are just logged in, right? So, because what's worse than you know um running a chaotic shop um you know is having to log into your computer whenever you're you know running a chaotic shop and having a busy day. I get it, right?
SPEAKER_00Um but the point is the doors are open, you know
Brookethe drawings are just sitting out there, you know, with nobody around them, you know.
SPEAKER_00Marked no foreign ITAR, you know, uh open parking lot, um, you know, computers just open and and everything else. And uh I'm not saying that's anybody that we have ever talked to. But um, you know, conceivably you could see a lot of um shops like that, right? Um anyway, but you know, on so my point here, uh what I'm trying to say is maybe they feel like they've done a lot of things from IT side of things, but you show up and you know, all the real world issues of having a shop floor that are producing defense parts um, you know, are not addressed at all, right?
SPEAKER_00Despite them maybe feeling like they've got a pretty good Spurs score or something. You know, so my point is how does how do those things show up in documentation? How do those need to be addressed?
BrookeSo yeah, I mean most of those things you described are are physical uh protections. Um and so uh they matter, and they matter just as much as the the digital uh protections, um uh because they are addressed. I mean, there's a there's a physical uh you know family, physical protection family, so um you do have to control access to your facility and uh only authorized people can see CUI and so uh you gotta control that somehow. And if somebody can, you know, drive back park and walk into an open bay door because it's hot in the shop, understandable,
SPEAKER_00but
Brookeif they can just walk into a shop through a bay door and uh walk around and say, Hey, you know, uh I'm here delivering, you know, XYZ, you know, and where is where's George, you know, and and if anybody can do that, then that's you've failed because they can get around and walk around and see CUI and whatnot,
SPEAKER_00right?
BrookeUm there's you know when CUI is not being not in use, you know, you're supposed to lock it up. At the end of the day, you know, uh is it stay in a protected area? Does it uh is it get locked up, you know? Uh do you have how does that happen? How does that uh transmission of that paper from uh I guess that's transmission, but how does the uh progression of that paper CUI uh go from employee-deploy or or um uh job spot to job spot, you know, from um whatever, milling to, you know, plating or whatever, you know, how does it well how does it go through there and where that CUI uh you know, how do you make sure that stays, you know, how do you make sure that gets controlled?
BrookeUh that all matters. Um it matters that you know who is coming in your facility and who's not. If it's not a protected area, you know, and you don't care who walks in, uh then that's up to you, I guess. I mean, I would I'd really want my facility to be protected, but um, you know, we're just not any uh Joe Blow can walk in. Um but if you don't if you don't care necessarily, you can you can fence off, wall off, segregate somehow, you know, uh where your COI is is uh located at uh and and b have that be your secure facility.
SPEAKER_00If
Brookeyou have open bay doors and uh it gets hotter than heck in the summertime,
SPEAKER_00we're in Texas, we get
Brookewe're in Texas. There's a lot of people that leave their bay doors wide open. You know,
SPEAKER_00a lot of people don't have you know uh uh climate-controlled shops.
BrookeAbsolutely not. They don't have any AC out there. So it gets hot, they leave all their bay doors open. Fine, understandable. Well, how about uh, you know, how about a uh Riley gate, uh, you know, an accordion.
SPEAKER_00Baby gay, whatever. Yeah, baby gay
Brookegay, yeah, a giant baby gay. Uh to keep the you know, six-foot babies out. But uh, you know, how about a accordion gate that you can lock, and then of course you've got to keep track of those keys and who has them and their inventory and all that. But yeah, the all that matters um just as much as the digital uh protecting the digital CUI does.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. Absolutely. You know, so a a common occurrence um, you know, is you run a uh a company um that does an or sort of defense work. You have a CMMC requirement
unknownor
SPEAKER_00deforest clause on your contract or something like that. Um and uh either, you know, uh you've tried to do this yourself and you don't want to do it no more, you
Brookeknow.
SPEAKER_00Um so you want to find someone um to do it for you. Uh like uh a common uh thing that we'll hear is like, you know, I don't want another consultant to come in um and just give me a template I have to fill in, you know, pay you a bunch of money to go fill in a template uh for you, right? Um super common occurrence that you know that we see. So um people are often looking for like, I just want to offload this and I don't want to have to do it, right?
SPEAKER_00Um fair
Brookeenough.
SPEAKER_00It's understandable. Um so you know the question is, you know, how much of that can you from you know a CMMC paperwork and like getting through to your assessment, how much of that can you reasonably um offload uh and it either, you know, and it still be illegal or like actually worth uh or actually being able to uh get certified, right? So how how much of that can you outsource?
BrookeWell you can you can outsource quite a bit of it. You still own it and you still need to be responsible for it and you still need to be part of it. Just like do you want to completely outsource your uh financials to some third-party company for that you that's the lowest bidder, you know? No, you probably don't want to outsource your financials, you know, to uh to the lowest bidder, just some company, and not not ever have anything to do with them. You probably still want to be involved, you want to uh make sure you understand, make sure they give you reports, make sure they work through with you on different things, uh, you know, all that kind of fun stuff.
BrookeIt's the same thing with uh CMMC. Roughly. Same rough thing as CMMC. Uh, you know, you can absolutely outsource uh, you know, a lot of this, not all of it, but a lot of it. Uh the the the uh line share of the work, you know, to um to a third party. Uh I would make sure you know who and that you trust them, but uh, you know, they can help you work through, you're gonna have to have decision makers part of this whole process. Whether it's you know the owner, whether it's uh you know the CEO, whether whoever it is, uh decision makers are gonna have to be part of this process because you're gonna run through things that say, look, um this is how your data flows right now, right?
BrookeAnd uh we think that you'd be better served if you have a you know reduce the footprint, create an enclave, whatever it may be, but that's gonna be another cost. That's gonna be a change of your business processes, you know, and an IT guy, uh a hired company, uh, you know, a lowly, you know, uh never mind, a uh uh quality guy, you know, whoever it may be that you've entrusted and and told to go run with this, you know, uh they're not gonna be able to make those decisions, right?
BrookeAnd and it's not gonna be their rear end on the line if a false false claims act comes knocking. So uh, you know, the decision makers really have to be part of this. Um and it can be, it doesn't have to be the owner, it doesn't have to be the CEO, but it has to have to be somebody with decision-making authority uh who is uh you know a substantial lead for the company, right? So so yeah, you can outsource a lot of that. Uh the a a good shop will work with you um and uh work with you through data flow diagram, work with you through designing the SSP, and work with you through customizing the policies, uh, and we'll hand over finished customized policies and SSP to you that that are tailored to your company.
BrookeThat they might start from templates, they not they might, they almost certainly start from the
SPEAKER_00own templates. Right.
BrookeShould start from templates, but uh those templates, you know, maybe one company has, you know, enter ID in place, maybe one company has Active Directory in place, maybe another company has both in place, maybe another company has a uh cloud ERP that's FedRamp in place or FedRamp equivalent. Maybe one has everything in on premise. You know, it's so those templates are good to start with, but they need to be just like any other company, you know, that would need to, if they're doing it on their own, would need to customize them. They need to be customized. You need to have a partner that will customize those for your company and not just say, yeah, here's some templates, we put your name on it, fill the rest in.
BrookeYou know, that's not how it works. You don't just fill in the templates, you know. You have to describe your system, you have to make it work for your environment. And likely you'll want to change your environment up a little bit because you'll run into things that you'll say it's gonna be really expensive or really difficult to do this, so we need to pivot and do this. And and so uh you're gonna run into a lot of those things. And again, somebody who has decision-making authority needs to make that decision. And if you have to go through, you know if the salesman has to go talk to the car, you know, the manager at the car dealership, every time you need to make a chain, you know, every time you know bad analogy, maybe it's a good analogy, uh it just draws out the process, makes it lengthy, makes it hard to deal with, you know, especially when the the executive that's in charge and making decisions, if they don't have insight and understand why you're wanting to make that, um, you know, through the two-hour session you just got sit through sitting through, uh just got finished sitting through, uh they're not gonna have they're not gonna understand that and they're gonna say, absolutely not, we're gonna spend we're not gonna spend that money, you
SPEAKER_00know.
BrookeUm or we're not gonna make that change, that'll make things harder, you know. But if they've sat through and they understand how everything's working, and they should uh understand that, then they'll they either may, you know, run with the proposal or propose something different, and you can all hammer it out right there, right? Uh point is you can outsource a whole bunch and line share of the work, but you have to be part of that process. Big part of the process.
SPEAKER_00You can outsource it, you can't advocate it.
BrookeRight.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So if you're familiar with compliance, CMMC, you know, NIST documentation, paperwork, at all, um, then then you know you've got your system security plan, you've got your sporting policies, right? Um, and then you've got your poem, your plan of action and milestones. Um, but what is the purpose of the poem if you have to do everything? Right? So like why can't, you know, you know, a poem can often be thought of as like, well, here's the things I'm gonna do whenever I get around to it, when, um, and the purpose of having the poem is so I don't have to do it now, right?
BrookeRight.
SPEAKER_00Um so speep people can often think of it that way. Um and so wh why is why are poems still around? Why are they still used? What's the utility of it?
BrookeWell the poem gives you a way to uh be eligible for contracts, but um uh not have to be a hundred percent there. Right. Um so a poem uh can be open for at this point, used to. There was no time requirement on a poem, and you could say, yeah, I'm working on these things here, you know, and uh uh working on these uh 40 things, and uh we're our poem says we'll be done by you know 2029.
SPEAKER_00And
Brookeuh December 31st, 2029. Well that's not good anymore. You can't just have a a long uh you know uh lead out there for a poem. You can't have an open-ended poem. You have to have uh your poem is gonna be six months, 180 days. Uh so uh you have 180 days to finish up your poem. So that gives you some it gives you a little bit of breathing room to be able to be uh eligible for some of those contracts and and uh but still have to get those done, right?
BrookeThe uh they're also uh they're the controls are uh either five points, three points, or one point. Uh so none of the five pointers or three-pointers can be poamed, and some of the one-pointers can't be poamed either. Plus, you have to have a minimum score of 88 uh to uh uh to qualify. So if you if you really go look at it, number one, some of those five-pointers really probably shouldn't be five-pointers, but uh if you go look at it, uh, you know, the five-pointers and the three-pointers, uh and the one-pointers that can't be poamed, guess what?
BrookeThey're the more difficult ones. Surprise, surprise, they're the more difficult ones. And which ones are you more likely to have to poam? A more difficult one. So you can only poam the easier ones, in large part, only the easier ones. And uh so that would be easy stuff that you you have left out, right? Um so uh you got to keep all that in mind, but it it's meant to give you a little bit of runway to to to be able to you know uh get there to uh not have to be a hundred percent right away.
SPEAKER_00Probably doesn't need to be said, but just for clarity's sake, I can't pass my CMMC level two certification assessment with the POAM, can I?
BrookeYou can get a conditional.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
BrookeYes, but a conditional is not uh a final. And so uh you can absolutely get a conditional and you can be okay for 180 days. At which point uh before which point you need to have the C three PO C three P AO come back out uh and verify that you've covered all those missing controls, all those POAM controls. Uh and then and then declare that yeah, you're good and you have a final uh they're recommending you for a final certification.
SPEAKER_00Which is functionally almost nothing, right?
BrookeRight.
SPEAKER_00So uh because the the bigger items, the the things that you're most likely to fail with are um not the poammable. Yeah, and I
Brookeyou know I I say that, and there are I mean there are things that are worth poaming that if you you can't figure them out. But again, most of the hard ones are you can't poam. So you gotta figure those out. And those are the they're just they're the hardest ones to figure out and hardest ones to get done. So
SPEAKER_00fair enough. So another topic I wanted to bring up that um is you know definitely part of the paperwork portion, um but also kind of not, you know, it's it's all related, right? Because it's compliance, but um, is instant response um and and the plan around that. Um that we often see um even if people have been maybe you know uh have used a consultant um to help them get um to to the point where they are now um or they um even have a pretty good like DIY you know um capability in-house um seems like I don't think that I've met a a company yet that's come through our discovery process um and has had um a certificate uh for their instant response.
SPEAKER_00So um can you kind of talk about um you know the the paperwork and reporting requirements and that um uh you know the the certificate required to be able to report properly?
BrookeYeah yeah uh so um uh you
SPEAKER_00which is not the same certificate as a CMMC level two certificate
Brookeno uh uh this is an actual or a digital I guess the other one's digital too but anyway. Nevertheless uh so uh for incident response you have to build a a capability you know you have to have a uh generally uh you'll probably have a a procedure uh a policy and a plan and a procedure in place for incident response. Um maybe list out you know the procedure may list out you know different scenarios possibly or something like that. But uh you also have to test it and make sure that it works.
BrookeSo you want to test the whole the whole system. Not necess you don't necessarily test every scenario, but you need to test the whole plan, the whole policy, make sure it works. And one of those things is what you're talking about, and this is the reason to go test it, make sure that you were able to report an incident. So if you have to report it to uh DC three uh the Defense Cybercrime Center I think it is uh anyway but DC three um and uh there's a little button that says report report an incident so you click that report an incident button and next page it comes up says unauthorized guess what you can't report an incident.
SPEAKER_00So you can click the button
Brookebut it won't work a button but it won't work. So uh you have to buy a uh certificate to install on your computer uh and for that certificate uh you have to um uh you have to go through an uh uh a process to prove you are who you are uh you know yes I am Brooke Justice here's the proof uh yes I've had a a uh uh notary sign it and all that stuff I've sent it off and the company said yes we we think you are who you are and now here's your certificate and it gets installed under your profile on that computer right and uh and so now when you go to that site uh you can click report an incident and it'll go to that page at after a couple more prompts but anyway uh to use that certificate usually uh but uh you'll get a pay to a page to be able to report an incident so that's important because I can guarantee you um if you haven't requested uh one of those certificates yet you will not get that certificate in the time frame that you're supposed to report the incident and for right now at least uh the and the timeline is 72 hours so you have 72 hours to report an incident even if it's still under investigation even if you're trying still trying to figure it out it's okay if it ends up being a false positive you just say oh hey my bad you know uh you know it's not that was a false positive you know we researched it and and all is good um which brings up we uh we had a false positive early on that uh all hands on deck we thought something really bad had gone wrong something on one on a computer reached out to a whole bunch of IP addresses and uh a bunch of them were on the uh you know bunch of the IP addresses were blacklisted we thought oh my god this is terrible this is horrible long story short ended up being a licensing program for for a piece of software that licensing program couldn't reach the initial server so it just fell back and just spammed out trying to reach all these other
SPEAKER_00spraying prey baby
Brookehungry some mod IP addresses and so surely that's you know that's malware. No it was just somebody's poor freaking design on a licensing program. So uh so that was a false positive thank goodness. Um but uh point is uh we were uh nearing 72 hours before we we suspected probably after uh a couple hours once we kind of researched it that it that's what it was but we had to prove that and and get some uh evidence and make sure that we have it all documented but uh it took us quite a while to get that and for sure and uh because we had to get with the vendor and of course you know this particular incident happened you know on a Friday afternoon.
SPEAKER_00Always does right
Brookeyou know and uh you know the vendor was uh really uh happy to uh respond quickly on a Friday afternoon. But anyway, they uh but that's what you have to be ready for and and uh so if you have 72 hours and that uh certificate that you have to go by to be able to report those in incidents at the best it'll take you a few days. At worst you may have to go back and forth and back and forth and it may take a couple of weeks something like that. So uh you will miss that timeline to report if you don't already have that certificate.
BrookeSo that's you got to have that in your uh incident response uh procedure plan something, right? Got to have that documented gotta have a document of where you go. It'd be good to document what computer that certificate is installed on and under whose profile because that is hard to find later, just so you know. So all that documented incident and response uh tested. So yeah it's you've got to have all that all that ready to go and you've got to test that uh process. And when you test it um you know you may discover that alerts didn't work like you thought they would or that uh you know an automated process to lock an account out or something like that didn't work like you thought it would.
BrookeYou've got to test these things and make sure that you actually can report and uh that you can uh that you know how to isolate the computer uh get you know get copies of the data without shutting it down you know all that kind of fun stuff you have to know how to do all that and so it has to be you need to have that written down and documented so everybody knows has something to follow.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. Yep. So not only do you have to do all the work to you know make sure all that stuff's in place, we have to document it.
BrookeAbsolutely.
SPEAKER_00And then it would really suck to have done all the right things, built the program, you know, built your plan, had it all the documentation and then you go to report and then you can't um and then you've just run a foul Uncle Sam and gotten in trouble because you didn't have that one little certificate installed on your computer to be able to report.
BrookeAbsolutely.
SPEAKER_00And it kind of works for someone not really understanding if you ever gun uh that certificate getting it kind of works like a passport. So if you ever gone on a like a family trip or or trip with a group of people with maybe uh uh some you know um less than sharp people and maybe they've uh I'm kidding of course when I say that but you know they've they've paid the deposit for their trip or paid for the whole trip at this point and gotten packed and everything else and then you you get to the cruise ship or you get to uh security or whatever and they don't have their passport or or it's like a week or two before and everyone's like all right you got your everything's paid up you got your passports and everyone and Bob's like Passport
BrookeYep.
SPEAKER_00You're like dude you can't get that in a frickin' week.
BrookeYep
SPEAKER_00like what did you no no one no one thought about this? You know um so you know you can't get your password or excuse me your your passport and um you know the nick of time for your for your trip um the the certificate from the government to be able to report works in a very similar way where you have to go through the entire government vetting process to get the you know the passport the certificate to be able to report those things um and not having that they ain't gonna let you go on the trip.
SPEAKER_00You can't hop on that cruise ship. You can't go on that plane same works the same way for that it does.
BrookeThe other thing I would that we always recommend and we try to put in place is more than one computer with that more than one person more than one computer with that certificate, right? And again document who has that on their computers um you know whether when can computers are upgraded and replaced you know uh it goes bye-bye. If you didn't think about that certificate, you know, it's gone and you have to work with the company hopefully to be able to get another one and uh and set it back up on your on your computer. You might have to buy a new one probably not but uh it is a process.
BrookeIt's a lot easier if you plan for it and just you know export that uh certificate and then uh get installed on the new one. But uh but it is a process you have to keep track of it you have to document it.
SPEAKER_00These are things that uh are very easy to handle if pre-planned well and very hard to handle if if not planned. So Brooke I think it's about time to wrap it up. So the question to you would be you know maybe you're a listener at home and you realize maybe we've convinced you like okay um I need to take a pause on all my technical implementations, the software I'm installing or the tools I'm buying and really take a look at paperwork, which is the keystone or foundation of my compliance program.
SPEAKER_00And you and you're like, okay, well I'm gonna start I'm gonna tackle it today, right? What would be your piece of advice to them if they were to start tackling that paperwork?
BrookeFirst of all I'll say that we uh you know maybe it's not a good phrase maybe it is but we eat our own dog food this is the way we do things right um probably why we recommend it but it really is the way you should start so again start with the paperwork start with designing the whole program uh start with uh you know the very first part you should start with which is you know what kind of CUI do you have and draw your data flow diagram and likely your data flow diagram needs to change and so change it up however you think you want to change it and then write your documentation accordingly you might come back and realize that oh this isn't going to work I need to change something else up but write that documentation prepare and then once you get done with that then you can think about tools that satisfy those requirements.
BrookeAnd I've I can't tell you how many people I've told you know don't no no don't buy any tools yet but when we're going through our we call it a boot camp. When we're going through our boot camp uh well should I buy this should I buy that? Just hold on. I realize I can give you all sorts of answers right now but let's get through this process and I can tell you the way it's likely going to be but wait till you get through the process and then you can buy some tools that fit your whole program right rather than buying stuff right now. Do you really need GCC high?
BrookeIt might might work for you and it might be too much, you know, for instance. So but start with the documentation make sure again that your SSP tells your story and tells how you implement all those controls and more importantly all the assessment objectives right because uh really the assessors only care about the assessment objectives because those assessment objectives uh describe how that control is met. Right uh if you miss out you know if you have six assessment objectives and you get five of them are met but one of them's not guess what that control is not met.
BrookeSo um address those assessment objectives put in a you know uh control statement summary control summary statement uh but uh but write that SSP it tells your story um write your policies for thou shalt thou shalt not and then your plans and everything else and then from there you can start implementing everything. So it's it's very important to you know Carpenter measure twice, cut once, right? And there's all sorts of other analogies that I'm sure we could use uh but uh plan well and uh and document well and then you can go in and start building your program out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You know I've I've realized and maybe this is just advice for life but um like if if you're dreading something that's usually the thing that you need to do. Right right this is like the thing that feels good usually is not the thing that's gonna help you out, right?
BrookeRight.
SPEAKER_00So it's like if you're if you're dreading the paperwork and which is you know news flash that's what everyone dreads doing right and it's probably the one that you need to attack first, right? So um and the rest will kind of fall into place. But that that dope being hit uh right in the check to you know software vendor number a or whatever um um isn't gonna solve your compliance problem you know um much like life's problems the the ones that take the you know most pain or um the ones that net the biggest you know result.
SPEAKER_00Like the C UI data flow um you know I'd mentioned earlier that's the highest leverage, freest thing you can do. And but it is it it takes some um pain and effort to sit down and and map that out. You
Brookedo need one more than one person doing that too because it helps to um to have more more brains in there, the more eyes on the problem to uh help you make sure you think of things. You know, get more bring in you know stakeholders in your business to help you think through all the processes and where digital CUI goes, where physical CUI goes and all that kind of fun stuff. Very important.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm absolutely so um but that's about it for today. So if you have any questions about what we covered please reach out to us. We're here to help fast track your compliance journey. Text, email, or call in your questions and we'll answer them for free here on the podcast. You can find our contact information at cmccomplianceguide.com. Stay tuned for our next episode. Until then stay compliant stay secure and make sure to subscribe
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! If your CMMC project has been all firewalls and IT configurations, you may be missing half the program. Austin and Brooke walk through the controls that have...
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! The Cyber AB’s October town hall had a lot for defense contractors, and most of it didn’t make headlines. Stacey and Brooke recap what matters: where the...
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! You’ve done the work, the assessment is scheduled, and your stomach is in knots. What actually happens once the C3PAO shows up? Austin and Brooke walk through...
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! You have a $400,000 CNC machine running a Windows 7 controller that the manufacturer won’t update. Do you have to replace the machine to pass a CMMC...
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! These are the 10 questions Stacey and Brooke hear more than any other from defense suppliers, and most companies get at least half of them wrong without...