Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! The Cyber AB’s October town hall had a lot for defense contractors, and most of it didn’t make headlines. Stacey and Brooke recap what matters: where the pause really stands, why certifications are still happening, a new association built for manufacturers, and practical advice on telling a real compliance partner from a scare-tactic seller. In this episode: Why “CMMC is paused” and “CMMC is not paused” are both true, and what it means for the certification requirement that was set to start November 10 Why the Pentagon’s decision is taking longer than the timeline it signaled, and what rumors about November are worth Why shops that already scheduled assessments are still going through them What the DIB Collective is, who it’s for, and why it’s a peer resource for manufacturers (dibcollective.org) How to vet a compliance provider: the ESP Collective, the MSP Collective, and why a provider that has been through certification is worth more than one that hasn’t How the code of professional conduct addresses conflicts of interest for assessors and consultants Why two assessment companies can reach different conclusions on the same shop Why CCP and CCA credentials expire, what the continuing education requirement is now (120 credits over three years, minimum 20 per year), and how to check that a consultant is current Whether overseas vendors can be part of the defense supply chain, including the first foreign C3PAO Three questions the panel couldn’t fully answer: how long an SSP should be, whether assessor cloud tools that feed AI training create a conduct issue, and what happens to consultants if the certification requirement goes away Links mentioned: DIB Collective & MSP Collective
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
StaceyHey there, welcome to the CMMC Compliance Guide Podcast. I'm Stacy and I'm Brooke from Justice IT Consulting, where we help businesses like yours navigate CMMC and NIST 800 171 compliance. We're hired guns getting companies fast track to compliance, but today we're here to give you all the secrets for free. So if you want to tackle it yourself, you're equipped to do so. Let's dive into today's episode and keep your business on track. Today we're recapping the Cyber A B's October Town Hall held on October 27th.
StaceyAnd it's packed with things that affect your shop, even if you've never sat through one. There are now 2,551 companies with a level two certification and 120 assessment companies you can hire. There could be an announcement from the Pentagon as soon as this month. Two brand new groups have formed, one for manufacturers and one for outside IT providers. And one of them was built to push back on scare tactic sales. And we heard some surprisingly practical advice on how to tell whether the company assessing you has a hidden conflict of interest.
StaceySo let's go ahead and dive into today's episode. So, Brooke, it seems like there's still talk about that pause with CMMC, but the Cyber A B says it isn't paused. So which is it and what should our contractors out there be doing about that?
BrookeSure. It's uh it's both things, really. So uh, you know, we sit through uh meetings with our clients, uh we call them technical business reviews quarterly, and um sit through those quarterly. And uh so they all have heard it multiple times by now, but I would say, look, it's it's not the whole CMMC program is paused. What's paused is actually just the certification requirement on new contracts that is not going to begin on November 10th. That's been paused. Uh they announced it. So they sent out that uh memo, which directs their program management officers and I and I think the uh contract officers to not include uh the CMMC certification requirements in the contract for the foreseeable future.
BrookeSo though that's what's paused, but they also made specifically clear, uh explicitly clear, that uh everyone if you have a contract, uh they're not revoking the requirements that you actually be compliant, which I might add is the actual more expensive part of it. Uh, but you know, we won't go into the whole reason for the pause right now. But nevertheless, uh you still have to be compliant, um, you still have to implement everything. There's still a uh uh a POAM uh limitation and everything.
BrookeSo uh so yes, both are true. Uh there is a pause, but it's only the pause for uh for certifications on new contracts, for the certification requirements on new contracts. And uh CMMC is still in effect and you still have to be compliant. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
StaceyIt looks like there was talk about the Pentagon saying it would take about 75 days to decide what happens next from the pause. Um, and it's been well past that. So can you go into why it's taking so long and when do we hear something about it?
BrookeWell, uh yeah, they did say uh it'd be much sooner. And then you look at uh you know things they were saying, you know, should be, and uh you know, express extrapolating timelines from there, and you'd think maybe sometime between the middle and end of October, and uh we're we've blown past that. Uh there have been some rumors, and I and Matt Travis on the call uh on the uh webinar did say these are just rumors. Don't take them at face value, but uh that they um are expecting uh possibly something to come out in November.
BrookeSo we were expecting it in October. Now we're expecting it maybe in uh November, so who knows? So you know the the previous the previous updated version of CMMC came out in November of uh like 2021. Uh so who knows? November's a big month. Uh new budgeting and all that kind of fun stuff, I guess. Uh so uh there may be something come out in November, but that's just a guess. It's a roll of the dice. Maybe we can find this on what's that uh what's that app, Calci or something like that? Oh, yes. Where you can uh bet on the all sorts of weird things, the outcome of all sorts of weird things.
BrookeSo uh but yeah, maybe that's something you can bet on and maybe make some money. Who knows?
StaceySo with all of this talk about the pause um here, are shops still getting certified or has everybody stopped because of the pause?
BrookeUh so yes, shops are still getting certified, absolutely. Uh mostly, mostly, not not uh not everyone, but uh people who already had their certifications and mock assessments uh scheduled and on the calendar, uh. Most of those are going ahead and moving forward with them because they see a business reason to do that. That's a I mean, it lowers the risk if you get certified, that's a third party saying this company's good, right? And uh so that lowers the risk for somebody that wants to hire for a prime or the government that wants to hire you to do something.
BrookeSo also uh the uh I don't remember exactly if it was Air Force or the Army, but uh somebody was trying to put incentives in to say, hey, if you already have your CMMC certification, we'll give you this bonus or this this much of a priority, excuse me, uh of you know being um of being picked for uh for this uh for this contract, right? So uh they were trying to reward it, slide it in another way, which is uh I think is is not a bad idea, you know?
BrookeBecause I said if you're if you've got a uh if you've just if you're just self-attested and say, hey, um, you know, I uh I I promise I meet all these controls, then you know your uh your risk is way up here, you know. And if you if a third party has come in and you've got a certification that another third party said, no, they they really do have all the controls in place, then your risk drops a lot. So that should be in you know they're they should be able to prioritize that, I would think.
BrookeBut that's that's just me thinking that. So uh but what we see again is is mostly uh people that already had their assessments or mocks on the calendar, they're gonna going ahead and moving forward with those. I know uh some of our clients that have those on the on the uh calendar, they're moving forward with them. We haven't had any new ones schedule any. Uh I've I've heard of companies that are, but I've none of our clients have uh that didn't already have it on the calendar scheduled any. Um but uh like you said, there's um at this point, there's 25 over 2,500 companies that have had that have gotten uh achieved a level two certification.
BrookeThat is well past what the deal the DOD at the time, the deal with W Now uh uh estimated uh before all this got started, right? They only I think between 500 and 700 they uh thought would be uh certified the first year, depending on where you look. Um they never expected a hundred thousand companies the first year, never ever uh uh expected that. And uh, you know, the other thing is uh that I've another thing that I've just jogged my memory here was uh that there's uh there's even more C3 PAOs out there.
BrookeUh that number has continued to climb. Uh there's more uh certified people uh to go through all this with you. There's more which would be a CMMC certified professional or a CMMC certified assessor. So anybody that has those designations uh would be great to help out. Uh there's even more of those, but the I think what I understood is that the training, people who've applied for training, has fallen off dramatically. So uh I wouldn't expect this was probably people that are already similar to the certification assessments, this is probably already people who had already paid for the training or had it scheduled or or something like that, or taken the training and just hadn't uh taken the exam.
BrookeUm so from what I understand that uh the training for that has dropped off uh sharply. Um but there are more CCPs and CCAs than there were before. So there we go.
StaceyAaron Ross Powell So for those listening out there that run a machine shop um and they're searching up CMMC compliance, a lot of what they see out there is very technical. Um is there anything uh other than our lovely podcast that they can go and look at to see their own like perspective and their own voice as manufacturers?
BrookeAbsolutely. And uh so they spooled up a a um an association, uh group, a collective anyway, called the Dib Collective. Dib is defense industrial base. So really it's more than just manufacturers, although we have a tendency to think manufacturers because a lot of our clients are manufacturers, and when you think of the defense industrial base, you think of people that that make things for the for the military, and it's not just people that make things. So um there's a there's a whole bunch of other work being done for the military that's not just making things, although that's a lot of it, right?
BrookeUm but the Dib Collective is a group for uh for defense industrial-based companies. Uh they won't even let companies like us be part of it. Uh I'd love to be part of it, not to sell anything, not just see what advice they're giving people and listen to it and then offer my own advice. Uh but um but that that collective is just for Dib companies. And and rightly so, and I completely understand that. Uh, you know, it's just the DIB companies getting together and saying, hey, this is the way we uh this is what the way we did this, this is the way we did that, this is what passed, this is what didn't work.
BrookeUh and it's so it's a great thing for Dib companies to be part of. Um I don't believe that there is a cost to that for Dib companies, or maybe if there is, there's that's not very much. I do know the other ESP collective they have, they want a pretty penny to be part of that. But uh but the DIB collective is a really uh really good thing. You really you ought to be able to get some good advice there from companies like you, right? Um They I really wish they talked about starting uh a couple of different organizations like or uh anyway, organizations like this from the get-go, and it just took a took a while to get off the ground.
StaceyAaron Powell If you guys are interested in that, I'll actually put it down in the link uh in the description below, but it's gonna be at dibcollective.org in case that sounds like something right up your alley.
BrookeAbsolutely.
StaceySo for those that are shopping around for a provider to help them with CMMC, um how do they know one who's just trying to scare them into signing a contract versus somebody that can actually help them?
BrookeWell, that's uh that's a good question. There's a couple of ways to look at that, a couple of organizations that can help out. Um the uh the Cyber AB has also spun up another uh organization called the ESP Collective. And that's the other organization I said they that they want a pretty penny to be part of. We looked at it and we're like, hey, we'll join that. And uh for the amount of money they want, I think we'll just uh be a non-paying member and and go enjoy the conferences. But um sorry, ESP collective, but you know.
BrookeUm so uh but yeah, that that'd be a good place to start. Uh I believe DIP companies can be part of that, but they encourage you to be part of the uh the DIB collective. Um in fact they were talked about that on the on the uh town hall. Uh they said, look, you know, that'd be great, but the first thing we're gonna do is say, hey, go be part of the DIMP collective, and because you can get really good tailored information for yourself there, right? Um but the ESP Collective is uh a bunch of it's ESPs, right? External service providers.
BrookeIt's MSPs, MSSPs, um training providers, it could be anybody else that's a that's an ESP, right? Um so uh but that'd be a good place to look. There's also another one uh called the MSP Collective. So ostensibly it's a a listing of uh MSPs and other related companies. They're not all MSPs on there, um uh but it's a listing of uh MSPs and other companies that have achieved level two uh certification status, and they verified that uh between you and uh between the MSP or between the ESP and um and whoever certified them.
BrookeSo you give the uh see-through PAO uh the the authorization to release your information to the MSP collective, and then they list that you've been certified and that they checked out your um they checked out your shared responsibility matrix uh along with that uh with that certification. So uh that's a really good place to look because they'll they'll list those companies out. Anybody that's been certified and gone through the process uh uh is uh would be someone to really uh really look at because those those people have the experience and have actually been through certifications uh and and know what it's like.
BrookeBecause if when you're getting ready for one, you have no idea what to expect, even though you know other people can explain it and tell you what to expect. It's not it's just a a big unknown for you, you know. So actually going through it, actually understanding what the assessor is looking for and all that kind of fun stuff uh is really very helpful. Even if you're not going to get certified somebody to help you uh help you get compliant, uh that would be a really good place to start at some point. I would, as I've said, I would imagine that they're going to require some sort of third-party validation, even if it's uh risk-based or you know uh prioritized somehow.
BrookeUh they'll they'll they'll require some sort of third-party validation at some point. And so if you're already there and you're already ready for it, that's a good place to go, uh good place to start. And to get there, you want somebody that's been through before. So that MSP Collective uh is a really good place to go. That's MSPcollective.com, I believe, is what it is.
StaceyAaron Powell We'll also link that below in case you want to look at it. Um it'll probably be very helpful if you're trying to vet some PSPs out. There was a couple of um interesting questions in the town hall. So one was in the perspective if a contractor or someone needing help um to have their company certified, um, how do they know that the person that they contracted is fair and not tied to someone with a stake in the results? So just overall not having a conflict of interest.
BrookeYou know, that's that was part of the whole uh thing about uh you know the Cyber A B coming up with an accreditation program to uh for C3 PAOs, um and to make sure that you know there's a there's a whole code of ethics, uh code of professional conduct uh that anybody that's part of the CMMC ecosystem, and be you know, people like us, anybody that's certified, anybody that's registered, anything like that, uh you have to sign a code of professional conduct, and they're very serious about it.
BrookeThey talk about it on every single cyber A B Town Hall, and any other time they get a chance, they're very serious about that uh code of professional conduct. Um so uh but they they do have, they work very hard to make sure uh that they're gonna be fair and honest and uh and all that. And I've the ever all the c all the C through POs I've run into doesn't mean there's not any bad ones out there, but all the ones that I've run into have been fair, have been honest, and wanted to do a good job and and uh and all that.
BrookeNow they may differ in how they do it, and they may differ in how strict they are in interpretation, you know. Uh but all of them have wanted to do a good job. All of them have been uh made sure that they uh don't have any conflicts of interest or do any consulting if they're doing certification and stuff like that.
StaceyAaron Ross Powell There was another question that kind of um touches on like what you just mentioned right now with the C through PAOs, but if two different assessment companies looked at a shop, would they reach the same answer?
BrookeAaron Powell If two different assessment companies, see through PAOs, looked at a, you know, did an assessment on a shop, you'd probably get three different answers. So within reason, they're gonna be they're gonna be similar, uh, but there are different interpretations. Uh I know uh my so my son showed uh cattle when he was younger uh through FFA and through 4-H and stuff like that. And you know, you can go you can go be winning uh, you know, first, second, or third place with this with this heifer or or steer, you know, in lots of different places, and then go get like fifteenth place at you know at a different show.
BrookeAnd it's like, well, it's it's one judge's opinion on one day, you know, or one judge's opinion on that day, you know. And so um, you know, another judge or the same judge on a different day, you know, they're gonna come up with something different. So uh same thing with these, uh, you know, people are people, there's no even though uh unless you have a cookie cutter um a cookie cutter enclave solution that you just go, here, this is yours, here this is yours, here this is yours. It's all the same uh except for the name on it, you know.
BrookeUm if you have that, that is the best way to get multiple uh multiple uh system multiple companies assessed the same and and have things go the same. But uh, you know, when you have company A, B, and C, what we specialize in is uh taking those companies who don't fit perfectly into that enclave and trying to help them figure out a solution. And even though we try to make everything's as standard as possible, there's still stuff that's different because one build-depart CNC place is gonna be a little bit different than another build-de-part CNC place.
BrookeYou know, it's it's uh they're just different, they run their business different, they have different kinds of contracts, they have different people, uh, different tolerances, different risk tolerances. So um it's just gonna it's gonna be a little bit different. So you're not gonna always get the exact same answer from different assessors. And I would say that uh that is our experience too.
StaceyIt's all up to interpretation and everyone's is a little different.
BrookeIt is, yep, absolutely.
StaceySo for those that have a hired consultant that say they're certified, why does it matter whether their certification is current and what exactly is changing there?
BrookeAaron Powell These are certifications. The certifications we're talking about really are uh for uh individuals. And those uh there there are some um uh registered uh you can be registered as a as a uh provider, um, as a person or uh an organization. Uh that is a lot lower bar, and uh registered uh practitioner, a registered uh practitioning organization, uh RP or RPO, though that's a lot lower bar. Uh so I would say also pair some uh certification experience and or uh uh uh certified individuals with that, right?
BrookeUh so the certification we're talking about is uh CMMC certified professional, CCP, or a CMMC certified assessor, CCA. Uh and then there's a lead CCA, and lead CCAs are just a uh uh CCA that has uh more qualifications and and has a lot more experience, right? Um but the um as far as the CCPs and CCAs go, uh those are good for a certain amount of time, uh good for three years, uh, and you have to retest.
BrookeUm they're coming up with a test now. They just actually transferred everything from the Cyber A B uh Keiko to uh the uh to ISOCA that does a whole bunch of other kinds of certifications. Um and we didn't have uh I got certified early and not early, early on, but somewhat early on uh as a CCP. Uh and so whenever they transferred everything over, they reset the dates and and so I basically got an an extra extra amount of time.
BrookeBut uh but there are uh with Isaac, um we didn't well before we didn't have any uh continuing uh CPE credits. Uh and we didn't have any continuing education we had to worry about. Uh however uh with uh Isaac, you do. And so uh with Isaac, you have to have uh a total after in three years you have to have a total of 120 hours of CPB CPE or 120 CPE credits, however they work out.
BrookeIt's usually well, I guess maybe it's not usually an hour, but anyway, it's uh CPE credits. Uh and so uh that breaks down to 40 a a year. However, the minimum that you have to cover in a year is 20 uh for a CCP or CCA. Um so if you if you only do the minimum the first two years, you've got 40 out of the way and you need 80 more the third the third year. Uh so it's uh I I don't know why you wouldn't try very hard to get uh you know close to 40 done.
BrookeUh but so you do have to do those that those continuing education credits, they can be in the form of you know conferences, they can be training, they could be uh related cybersecurity classes, they could be you know all sorts of fun stuff. But but that training helps make sure that those people are on those uh certified professionals are on top of uh their education, right? Um so uh making sure that those people are current and all that kind of fun stuff. Hey, you know, where's your can you show me your uh you know what?
BrookeThere's a uh I'm pretty sure they've released the new badge that shows if you're current or not. And if I think we've got I think I think you have attached my new one to uh uh to the website but in any case it's a uh uh there's a certification badge that's electronic and you click on it and it it shows yes this person. Yeah this person is certainly badgely if I does badgely absolutely uh so um you know look at that make sure that they're certified make sure they're still in good standing the whole nine yards uh that'll go a long way to helping make sure that you have somebody uh certified and is still current and and still understands to to be able to help you out.
StaceyAaron Ross Powell So for those that are thinking my vendors are overseas so maybe someone um a vendor from Taiwan or Korea can they handle our controlled defense information? Is that safe with CMMC?
BrookeAaron Ross Powell Well yeah you I mean there are all sorts of other extenuating circumstances there but simply being uh overseas uh uh does not prevent them from uh taking part in our dip our defense industrial base, right? They have there's lots of other countries that uh have uh that have worked with the Defense Department to be able to do work in their country. Um and uh we there is a in Taiwan uh there is a uh the first foreign uh C through pao has been uh authorized there.
BrookeAnd so um so if you want to get uh certified by by a uh Taiwanese company then you can you can do that as well. I'm sure that you know they're they'll have lots of Taiwanese business to to take care of. But uh yeah there's nothing that really prevents that except for your current contracts and what they say about you know about who you can work with.
StaceyAaron Ross Powell were there any questions that the panel just couldn't really give an answer to uh during the October town hall?
BrookeAaron Ross Powell Yeah there were uh there were um a few of them three of them or so uh and one of them was uh how long should your uh uh system security plan your SSP be? And uh you know somebody said somebody used a gauge of like 30 pages and or something like that. And uh or uh actually I think it's 15 to 20 pages. And I think the the basic form is longer than that. So I don't know how you would get shorter than that other than not using the you know the form they want.
BrookeBut the uh there's most SSPs are gonna probably be more than 100 pages. If you're closing in on 900 pages it's probably way too long. You probably have policies laid out in your uh in your SSP um there's no good um there's no good uh way to gauge that and tell you what too long or too short is uh exactly or even really close but somewhere between you know uh somewhere between uh a hundred and and I don't know three hundred pages something like that who knows uh but your your SSP should include you know um all of your all of the assessment objectives how you're addressing those assessment objectives it should include the uh the control summary statement uh whether things are inherited or not and if they're inherited how are they inherited um all that kind of fun stuff you don't really need to put policy language uh for instance in your uh in your SSP you can put a little snippet you know just to say hey this is what we say in the uh uh access control policy that addresses this but uh we we try very hard to keep that short and and make sure that it's concise and you have just the part you need in the SSP instead of putting a big long four or five paragraphs in for a for a uh assessment objective statement.
BrookeAnd uh you know there's no as far as I'm concerned there's no need for that because if you're you know you can say this is addressed in the uh access control policy with this statement and then if they want to know any more if the assessor wants to know any more they can look at your access control policy. But you should be able to include something in there in a pretty pretty short manner. And what I can tell you also is that we've been complimented two or three times by different assessors that are uh uh they liked our SSPs for our clients because they weren't gigantic you know they were they were short to the point had everything you need there referenced where you know where else you need to look in the access control policy or whatever.
BrookeSo I would say more more concise and to the point is is good. When you start putting too much fluff in there uh you open yourself up to you know all sorts of things too much interpretation taking too long to do the assessment um things that you don't need to put in there and getting mixed up you know so um but there's not a there's not a real good answer for that. One of the other questions was uh someone asked uh whether an assessor using cloud software that automatically feeds into data into AI training could break the assessor's code of professional conduct uh which includes keeping client information confidential and that's a that's a good question there's several things you have to think about there um is it an on-premise uh you know well this specifically says cloud so you know if it's in the cloud you know is it your own tenant is there any FCI or C UI involved you know uh do they disclose that you know what's what's going on there's a there's a million things to ask um about that AI is in use in a lot of places there are there's a a lot of platform AI platforms they're made for CMMC as well um uh some that are uh you know FedRamp uh uh FedRamp uh uh authorized uh so um you know it's uh it's not it's not a terrible thing it's another tool and you just gotta make sure that it's configured properly that it's used properly you know the whole nine yards uh you know where is the you know where is everything located at what systems is it going into?
BrookeUm is it connected to anything else that helps crunch data? Um you know it is there is uh some complicating factors to it uh probably a little more so or definitely a little more so than just a plain old cloud platform where you know well you know if it's a cloud platform and it's hosted in AWS, you know, where is it hosted in AWS? Where is it hosted in Azure? You know is it do you know for sure it's in the US? Is it overseas? Is it where is it at? You know? And so there's a lot of things that matter there.
BrookeSo it doesn't automatically uh break it, but uh it very well could. You know, for those kinds of things it might be safer to use on-premise uh you know an on-premise LLM or something. Another question was uh someone asked what happens to certified assessors and consultants if the certification requirement goes away and that's uh you know who knows answer. So I would suspect that there's still going to be call for um uh consultants and companies that are certified uh because they know uh you know they know this uh NISTA171 and CMMC uh so I would I wouldn't expect that to completely go away but who knows?
BrookeMaybe we'll find out later on in November. So we'll see. That's a good question.
StaceySo for those listening out there, if they only remember one thing from this town hall, what should it be? I know it's a loaded question. There's a lot of good stuff.
BrookeI can never have uh one uh an answer that is just one thing. So uh you know I would say that uh um even though the certification requirement on contracts is paused, that uh to remember that you still have to be compliant. They made that very clear that you still have to be compliant even though that's the more expensive side of the program. But you know, we won't we won't go there. And also that even if you are uh certified or looking to get certified uh uh then that still matters it still reduces the risk uh for whoever wants to contract you to do business whether it's a prime whether it's um another you know second or third tier sub or whether it's the government it lowers their risk to hire you and they can have uh they can sleep at night knowing that a third party has assessed you and said yes, these people are good.
BrookeSo that's that's what I would say.
StaceyAaron Ross Powell Well that wraps up today's episode. If you have questions about what we covered reach out to us. We're here to help fast track your compliance journey. Text, email, or call in your questions and we'll answer them for free here on the podcast. You can find our contact info at cmcompliance guide dot com. Stay tuned for our next episode. Until then stay compliant stay secure and make sure to subscribe
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! About half the companies we talk to either don’t know what an SSP is or have one that’s just a purchased template or an AI draft with their company name on...
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! If your CMMC project has been all firewalls and IT configurations, you may be missing half the program. Austin and Brooke walk through the controls that have...
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! You’ve done the work, the assessment is scheduled, and your stomach is in knots. What actually happens once the C3PAO shows up? Austin and Brooke walk through...
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! You have a $400,000 CNC machine running a Windows 7 controller that the manufacturer won’t update. Do you have to replace the machine to pass a CMMC...
Submit any questions you would like answered on the podcast! These are the 10 questions Stacey and Brooke hear more than any other from defense suppliers, and most companies get at least half of them wrong without...