Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Closer Look

Closer Look artwork

Fantasy island? We fill you in on Doug Ford’s grand vision for new convention centre

Mar 9, 202620 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Tonight on Village Media's 'Closer Look' podcast: Premier Ford says he is considering filling in part of Lake Ontario to make room for a multi-billion-dollar 'shock and awe' convention centre in Toronto. Hosted by Village Media’s Michael Friscolanti and Scott Sexsmith, and produced by Derek Turner, Closer Look is a new daily podcast that goes way beyond the headlines with insightful, in-depth conversations featuring our reporters and editors, leading experts, key stakeholders and big newsmakers. Fresh episodes drop every Monday to Friday at 7 p.m. right in your local news feed - and on the show’s dedicated website: closerlookpodcast.ca. Of course, you can also find us wherever you get your favourite podcasts. Want to be the first to know when a new episode lands? Sign up for our free nightly newsletter, which delivers the latest Closer Look straight to your email inbox. You can also subscribe to our YouTube channel or follow us on X, Instagram, Facebook and TikTok. Have something to say? Please reach out. Our email address is closerlook@villagemedia.ca Reach out to Frisco and Scott

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00He did confirm that yes, he is absolutely looking at uh filling in part of Lake Ontario uh in downtown Toronto to build a two million square foot convention center.

SPEAKER_02Welcome back to Closer Look on this uh Monday, the ninth day of March. Michael Friscalandi, our editor in chief, is here. I'm Scott Sexmith. Uh Zach Trunzo uh in for uh Derek Turner today. Uh time change. Uh how are you feeling? Did Derek not survive the time change?

SPEAKER_01Is that what happened? Having a Derek turned the clock ahead an hour, and that was it? He's had a good run.

SPEAKER_02He's had a good stuff to deal with. You know what?

SPEAKER_01Like I said on our show Friday, we had uh an expert from York University on that. She was excellent. I never gave more than five seconds of thought to daylights. I never thought I did what I was told. I turned my turned my clock back when they said, turned it forward when they said. I never really thought about it. I assumed, of course, I assumed it had to do with farmers. That's what everybody thought was the old wives tale of the farmers. So okay, yeah, whatever. Obviously that's not the case, that's a total myth. And I learned a lot from that conversation, and it really had me thinking about just how stupid daylight savings time is, to be honest, right?

SPEAKER_01It really is. Uh and if and this whole idea that BC has has adopted this as full time, but that in the winter they're not going to have sunlight till 9 a.m. It's crazy.

SPEAKER_02I thought about that this morning driving in because I get here a little bit earlier than you do. Yes. And uh it was dark, like headlights on. Was it really? Yeah. Did you have your headlights on? I I absolutely did. And I'm I'm I wasn't a fan.

SPEAKER_01Well, the good professor on Friday talked about how, like, you know, the first couple days after turn your clock said that there's increase in traffic accidents, stroke judges are angry, so they're giving harsher sentences, and people are just feeling kind of groggy and tired. It's true, you lose that one hour and it doesn't really you don't think about it, but it does make a big difference.

SPEAKER_02I don't know how one hour can have the impact uh that it does. First of all, yesterday I found just dragged on like crazy, which which is weird. Yeah. Uh and then this morning, you know, around quarter to seven, I was like, oh my god, I don't want to get out of bed.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I just felt like I could have slept another two.

SPEAKER_01So just so everyone knows Scott's taking the rest of the week off. He's put in for some uh vacation or maybe sick days. I don't know what it is, you put in.

SPEAKER_02I haven't figured it out yet, but we'll we'll manipulate the paperwork. All right. Uh yeah, anyway, that was uh Patricia uh Lake and Thomas uh sorry. All good. She's a wonderful guest. And and she you can tell clearly that she is uh the uh you know the the brains behind all of this because every media outlets.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and if you and if you don't if you didn't watch the show, I'd recommend going back to see, even though you've already changed your clocks at you turned your clocks ahead because there's kind of like an inner circle of these experts who've been talking and strategized. Remember we said like she expected to get a lot of media calls, her and her colleagues who are in this world, right? She operates what's called the clock lab at York University, which is an amazing name for your research laboratory. So check it out, the clock lab. Yeah, that that that that and they study how are there are our kind of our biological clocks, how we tick, how our bodies work, and how it correlates to time and sunlight and and moonlight and all kinds of crazy things.

SPEAKER_01It's fascinating. It's amazing. You learn people do all kinds of different things, Scott. All right. Maybe they can help with the construction of this new convention center if we get in on time.

SPEAKER_02I I read uh Jack Howans' story over the weekend about the premier. Uh now he says, look, I I don't want to build an island, but I want to throw a bunch of dirt into Lake Ontario so that I can eventually build a new convention center. So it's like an island. It's like an island.

SPEAKER_01I mean it's not an island, but I had to refresh my memories that Jack's story was great, and and when I went back and read from a couple weeks earlier, so he but the premier's kind of been on this kick about we need a new convention center in downtown Toronto. The other one's way too small, we're not attracting enough events. So there were a lot of reports from various news elements about how we're looking at exhib they they're looking at exhibition plates, they're looking at some other pieces of land. And then on Thursday, the Globe Mail exclusively reported that he's the quoting unnamed sources that the Premier is really looking into this idea of dumping a bunch of fill into part of Lake Ontario and building it uh on top of that.

SPEAKER_01Um and then the premier kind of didn't shy away from that on Friday during a press conference. So it's kind of evolved into this like so. We're gonna talk to Jack about, you know, sort of what's the big deal, why the Premier is so fixated right now with the convention center, whether he's right, and whether this plan to uh fill up the lake has any reality in it. We'll put it right beside the 401 tunnel.

SPEAKER_02But his latest idea might be one of the biggest yet, literally. The premier says he's exploring a plan to fill in part of Lake Ontario along Toronto's waterfront to create new land for a massive convention center. Something he says the city desperately needs because the existing Metro Toronto Convention Center simply can't compete for the world's largest events. The proposal is still just an idea, but it raises some big questions. Jack Howen from our Queen's Park team at the Trillium has been reporting on this story and joins us from Toronto tonight.

SPEAKER_02Jack, welcome to the show. Good to see you as always. You too. All right, uh, let's start from the beginning here. Uh, Jack, all this talk about a new convention center uh began last week uh when the premier promised some shock and awe architecture for a new space that would be five times bigger than the current convention center. Uh what triggered all this talk about a new facility and and why is Ford so keen on this?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, like many proposals from this government, it it comes during a press conference, and um this is this is how these things start. The the premier mentions it and outlines the problem at every opportunity. And uh as far as he's he's concerned, I mean you you covered it in the in the intro. We're missing out on conventions to the states, to other bigger convention centers. And uh certainly the premier has made no secret of being pro-business um and you know having the ear of the business community and and vice versa.

SPEAKER_00So um, you know, I don't know who who he's been talking to behind the scenes, but uh that would certainly seem to be behind the push.

SPEAKER_01Am I right that he mentioned this first at the mining conference that was going on? Is that right? That one?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I believe that's right. I think that was the first time. That makes sense. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Is he right, Jack, that the convention center there in Toronto isn't living up to its potential? That did the numbers back him up on that?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, he is right. Um, and this is something we can say because the the auditor general reported on it in 2023. Um no longer had enough space to to host the biggest conventions. And uh something the premier has repeated is that uh we're among the you know the worst major cities, and that was also found in the HE's report. We were 18th out of 21 uh among a sample of North American convention centers. Um so yeah, it's it's not as big uh as it needs to be to host the biggest conventions.

SPEAKER_02Okay, Jack, we'll get into the uh Ontario Place uh location because that's what everyone's uh been talking about. But before we do, what are some of the other locations being tossed around?

SPEAKER_00Uh so yeah, the the Globe was the first to report on the the island plan, um, which the premier, I should note, um, disputes that it would be an island um drilling in the lake. But uh in their story, they uh they mentioned that sources had had told them that um the province is considering the East Harbor uh development site, uh just east of the Don River. Um that would be on the future Ontario Line subway. Um, and there's, you know, there's a bunch of plans around that area. Also in the Portlands area, again, a ton of plans uh for housing and employment space there.

SPEAKER_00Um and then also uh exhibition place, which is owned by the city, but would also be on the Ontario line. And it also, that last one also has uh existing convention facilities that uh that can beef up.

SPEAKER_01All right, so let's talk about the reaction of the globe story. Obviously, I think on Friday there was a press conference where the premier addressed it. What was what was he asked and how did he respond?

SPEAKER_00Um yeah, he was the it was a scrum, I believe, and and they asked, uh, you know, are you considering building an island? And he said, Well, I wouldn't call it an island. Um so he did confirm that yes, he is absolutely looking at uh filling in part of Lake Ontario uh in downtown Toronto to build a two million square foot convention center. Um, as you said, it would be shock and awe. And uh yeah, like you said, it's it's still just an idea. Um, you know, there haven't been any environmental scans the Premier says so far.

SPEAKER_00Um, but seems to be something he's taking seriously.

SPEAKER_02Jack, so what exactly is uh Premier Ford envisioning here? Are we talking about a small extension of land or something that would dramatically reshape the uh the waterfront?

SPEAKER_00Um so shock and awe, I mean, implies something pretty big, I guess. Uh, but they you know, he has attached the number to it, which is two million, two million square feet, um, which is quite large. Um, so I mean it you know, it it depends on how high it is, what it'll look like, uh, whether we're going for a you know, Dubai Palm Island sort of thing, or just an extension uh to the existing land. Um, obviously everything depends on on the plan, but it will be big if indeed it is built and built there.

SPEAKER_00And uh and yeah, would definitely change how that spot looks.

SPEAKER_01Here's my dumb question for the day, Jack. The premier uh said that we already have or the province already has, quote, a tremendous amount of fill. Where is that material coming from? Do you like where where do they have all this fill?

SPEAKER_00So that would be from I don't know, I don't know where it is currently. That's a great question, but it that would be from all the tunneled transit projects. They've been digging up so much earth to build um the Ontario line and the Eglinton LRT kilometers of tunneling. Um so he's right, yeah, they they must have that must be somewhere. And um, the other thing he said is that we need more land, we need more land. Um so whether he means specifically for the convention center or just in general, um we have the fill, presumably, to do it.

SPEAKER_02So here's an idea when he starts digging the tunnel for the 401, he could take that fill and use it to build his non-island. That could work. That could work.

SPEAKER_01I don't know if he built the timing uh goes down, but that that probably wouldn't work.

SPEAKER_00Could build another Toronto with that film.

SPEAKER_01That'd be that'd be a lot of film for sure. All right, here's the real question too: the cost, right, Jack? Who foots the bill for a mega? We're talking about, okay, we're gonna build a wherever they build it, whether it be they fill the lake or not, they're gonna build a two million square foot convention center the premier wants to. Who foots the bill for that? Is that all the province?

SPEAKER_00Well, this is the fun part of making announcements in press conferences and through anonymous sources that who knows where the where the bill is coming from. You know, Ford is uh the premier's positioned himself as the cheerleader and the guy who wants this done. So uh presumably that would put the province on the hook for at least most of it. But um, you know, he says he's talked to the mayor's office and um potentially he's talked to the feds as well. I don't know. But uh yeah, we don't have any details about how much it would cost, but it would be a lot.

SPEAKER_00Uh it would be billions of dollars for sure to build a gigantic convention center of this scale.

SPEAKER_02Well, you mentioned the uh the mayor's office, uh, Jack, and the premier is saying that they've shown some support, yet the mayor's office is saying they haven't even seen a proposal yet. So what's uh what's what's really going on?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so they both chose their words carefully there. Um the premier said that uh the mayor, Olivia Chow, is uh he said she's endorsing it. Um obviously she hasn't uh formally endorsed anything. Uh and as the premier's office or as the mayor's office has said, they haven't received uh an actual proposal. What they didn't say was whether uh the mayor and the premier have chatted about it and what the mayor's reaction was in that theoretical uh informal chat. So, you know, maybe like they could both be right uh if a situation took place where the premier was like, Hey, what do you think about this?

SPEAKER_00And the mayor said, Yeah, sounds good. But we don't know.

SPEAKER_01I know it's the opposition's job to have a field day with government announcements. Clearly they've done that in this one, too. I think it was the liberal leaders calling it Ford's Fantasy Island, I think. What has the reaction been from the opposition, Jack, and from others?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's um it's more of the same for um the reaction to the Ford government's um major project that the opposition doesn't agree with, which is that uh it will be insanely expensive, it will be billions of dollars uh that the government would be spending uh when you know hospitals are falling apart and we need more nurses and the cost of everything is skyrocketing and et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. The government's response would be you need to attract business and make business happy to have a tax base to fund all those things, but um, surely the opposition would say that spending billions of dollars not on necessities is uh not the right thing to do in current economic climbs.

SPEAKER_01It's a great segue to the next question. I know one professor in some of the coverage called the island proposal insane, but I think that was from an engineering perspective. I think. But there's also the question of whether there's actually a market for these big convention centers, that there's that there's enough demand to fill them. What do you know about that? What are you hearing?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's um I that that professor's quote uh reminded me of a quote uh that uh my editor Jessica Smith Cross got when when the premier first floated the 401 tunnel uh where she talked to a tunneling expert and he just went, wow, that would be a big tunnel. And that's a tunneling expert. That's crazy. Astounded at the the size of this tunnel. I don't it's hard to tell whether it was like wistful or self-dame. Anyway. Um yeah, uh I haven't seen many super pro convention center takes.

SPEAKER_00Um I mentioned uh, you know, at the outset of this podcast that the premier is right that the current convention center is too small to host the biggest conventions, but uh the demand for big conventions has been falling for years. And uh, you know, it's it's definitely a question of whether Toronto should be even competing for those conventions, especially if it comes at the cost of billions and billions of dollars to build uh a convention center for it. Um John Michael McGrath, a very smart writer for TVO, uh compared building convention centers to uh sports stadiums as two things that make governments sort of lose their minds when it comes to uh funding major projects for you know minimal gain.

SPEAKER_00Um I don't know how accurate that is, but it rang true certainly, um, especially with how the premier's been positioning it.

SPEAKER_01It's a great point. Just remind me, it's been a while since I've been to the Metro Toronto Convention Center. I mean, is it as bad as everyone's saying it is?

SPEAKER_00Uh I certainly am not uh a convention aficionado, but you know, the premier does have a point that you do need to go up and down and up and down to get to certain places, and it is small if you're comparing it to the biggest convention centers in North America. Sorry, you know, it's not like it's not like it smells. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Sorry, you're it's not like this basement that we're sitting in right now. Any other reaction at all, Jack, that we didn't touch on the what people are saying about this? Obviously, I mean, because it's the talk everywhere, seeing it on social media, hearing it on talk radio. Yeah. What other what other things are people saying about it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think we've covered it. The the reaction that I've seen from experts is that it would be um uh you know insane to put it bluntly and a big, big project to put it mildly. Um, and uh people who follow conventions and these sorts of things uh definitely wonder whether we need it. And uh, you know, there have been plenty of of tweets from Joe Schmoe that are similar to uh you know the 401 tunnel that's like this would be billions of dollars and for what?

SPEAKER_00Um, you know, certainly uh if and when it's completed, it would attract likely the uh some of these gigantic conventions. But you know, the question is obviously the cost to get there.

SPEAKER_01Last question for me, and I think it might be unfair, and I'm sorry about that, Jack. But obviously, this announcement, this kind of announcement comes on the heels of other announcements like OSAP funding cuts, for example, right, which are triggering protests at Queen's Park, which are obviously impacting a lot of Ontarians in a in a negative way. How does Ford uh answer those questions when asked about, well, how can you do this when you're seeing you're cutting over here?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and basically it's um well, he said think of the OSAP cuts as or think of think of paying for education as an investment in your future. Um, you know, the the lack of grants, you you can't get a free ride, do you need to be choosing the right courses? You can't be just suckling on the government's teeth and taking basket weaving courses. Uh and one might quibble, obviously, with that uh interpretation of things and you know, whether we want uh an educated populace who can write essays or whether we only want construction workers, which we certainly need.

SPEAKER_00Um but yeah, he's framed it as a as a business decision, essentially, right? Like you have to make the business uh community happy in order to get the generate the taxes to pay for all the nice things. Um but in doing so, he's um certainly positioned the government as less of an active participant in funding those things, uh, like hospitals, like education, um, in order to facilitate uh things that would make the business community happier, like highways and uh a potential convention center.

SPEAKER_02All right, good stuff. Jack, anything else on this issue before we let you go? I think that's all from me. All right, good stuff. From the Trillium, there is reporter Jack Howant joining us from Toronto tonight. Thanks, Jack. Thanks for having me. I'm not gonna lie here. When I heard Ford Fantasy Island, I pictured Tattoo on the edge of the edge of the dock, boss the plane. Do you remember that show?

SPEAKER_01I'm a little younger than you, but I do remember the show. I don't think I ever watched it.

SPEAKER_02Or Zach Shay. What are you talking about? Fantasy Island. What is that?

SPEAKER_01I just you know what Google it Google it, Zach.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I I feel like Convention Center falls into that category of things we may or may not need in the next five years. The way the world is changing is like people need like I guess they can have a conference on how I pay my OSAP loan back. That could be a conference. You know, read the room. Well, this is I I I I mean I'm not an expert on any of this, but I just who's getting the we're doing we're less social than ever. And I'm not saying that's a good thing, but we are. And I don't know, like are people and maybe there are numbers out there. Is the Chicago Convention Center, for example, still filling up every week with massive I don't know.

SPEAKER_01Massive conferences? What's the time you've been doing a conference?

SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell, but do you do you wake up in the middle of the night and say, I've got it? We'll build a new convention center. Yeah. The doctors, the schools, the highways. Let's just put a pin in that stuff. I get what you're saying. But a new convention center.

SPEAKER_01Well, I think Jack nailed it on the head as he always does, is that you know, there's these competing interests, right? There is value in and you want your local businesses to do well. So there's value if you can bring people in that for sure there's value in that. But he also mentioned the the sporting uh arena now. That has always been the most controversial issue. People think it makes huge money. It doesn't. It's always a dud. And there's all there's all kinds of good research on that. So you have this these competing entities that are looking for funding, right? I've I I'm always interested in federal and provincial budgets, but I'm I'm as interested as ever in when the next provincial budget comes out.

SPEAKER_01There's definitely I think it's partially because we've talked to so many people on this show about competing interests, right? About what they're looking for funding for, and all making a great case for why it's important. I'll be anxious to see the uh convention center lobbyists come on next.

SPEAKER_02And uh budget we understand is towards the end of this month. The end of this month, I believe.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02So we'll uh we'll break that down as well. We absolutely will. Closerlook at villagemedia.ca. Reach out anytime, and of course, uh, you can sign up for our nightly newsletter, closerlookpodcast.ca. For Michael Friscolanti, our editor in chief here at Village Media. I'm Scott Sexmith. Uh, thanks for your time. Uh we'll see you tomorrow night, seven o'clock, right here on Closer Look. Frisco and Scott's wardrobe, provided in part by Moore's Sault Ste. Marie.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Hazel Mae steps up to the plate in new memoir

    Nov 15, 202642 minAudio

    Season after season, Hazel Mae has been a familiar face to Toronto Blue Jays fans, bringing viewers closer to the game and the players they cheer for. But after telling so many other people’s stories, the veteran...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Away from the cameras, 'Rick the Temp' hid a dark secret

    Oct 11, 202629 minAudio

    For a generation of Canadians, Rick Campanelli has been one of the most recognizable faces on television - the energetic, always-grinning “Rick the Temp” who turned a MuchMusic contest into a remarkable career in...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. NHL's rookie of the year takes a shot at joining our podcast

    Oct 4, 202626 minAudio

    Matthew Schaefer was the first overall pick in the 2025 NHL draft - and he definitely lived up to the hype. In his first season, the talented defenceman put up Bobby Orr-esque numbers, tallying 23 goals and 36 assists...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Far-fetched or not, Carney is right to prepare for U.S. military action

    Sep 27, 202636 minAudio

    Prime Minister Mark Carney revealed this week that he has studied the possibility of U.S.-led military action in Canada. In a lengthy New York Times interview published Wednesday, Carney said it would be irresponsible...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Navdeep Bains has some things to say about Doug Ford

    Sep 6, 202624 minAudio

    In November, the Ontario Liberals will elect a new leader - the party’s third in six years. Five candidates are on the ballot to replace Bonnie Crombie: Navdeep Bains, Stephanie Bowman, Lee Fairclough, Eric Lombardi and...

    Credit the people on this episode