Prime Minister Mark Carney revealed this week that he has studied the possibility of U.S.-led military action in Canada. In a lengthy New York Times interview published Wednesday, Carney said it would be irresponsible not to prepare for what he called an “extreme tail risk.” “That’s just risk management,” he said. “That’s not a base case, but it would be irresponsible not to [prepare].” How realistic is a Trump-ordered military invasion? Considering the U.S. President's musings about a 51st state, how seriously should our government be taking such a threat? On this week’s episode of Village Media’s Closer Look podcast, we revisit our recent conversation with Adam Gordon, a former senior legal and policy adviser to Canada’s Minister of Foreign Affairs who is now an affiliated researcher at the Cascade Institute. Reach out to Frisco and Scott
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01What we want to do is convince them that it's really not worth it to start using or even threatening to use force against Canada, that the cost would just not not make it a good uh uh a good policy.
SPEAKER_03It's a scenario that would have seemed almost unthinkable not long ago. Canada preparing for the possibility of military action by its closest ally. But Prime Minister Mark Carney says his government has studied exactly that, calling it an unlikely extreme tail risk, but one Canada would be irresponsible not to prepare for. Welcome back into the Closer Look Studio. Ding, alongside Editor-in-Chief Michael Friscolanti. I'm Scott Sexmith. It is Sunday, the uh 27th day of September.
SPEAKER_03Uh okay, Frisco, let's uh dig into this uh a little bit and maybe provide a bit of context here. So all of this stems from a recent interview uh with the Prime Minister that he did with the New York Times.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, he spoke to the New York Times uh while he was in New York uh with the United Nations, and he did acknowledge that they have studied the possibility. They've looked at it. He called it risk management, which I guess is not surprising considering his background in economics. Um what's fascinating about this is just you know, we it's been talked about. I mean, this idea, especially when the tariff war first started, that you know, is there any possibility for that we'd that the U.S. could attack Canada or have a military action against Canada? And others talked about it, but definitely not the Prime Minister. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_03It seems extreme, but let me ask you this what is the significance of a sitting Canadian Prime Minister publicly acknowledging this? Aaron Ross Powell, Jr. It makes you wonder the way the world has gone right now.
SPEAKER_02Maybe it's not surprising at all, but it is it is shocking. These are supposed to be our best friends, and they were for so long. And uh to think that it's gotten to that point. Um but uh you know, you wonder - Kearney's a very strategic person. Trevor Burrus, Jr. Yes. And you wonder how much of this was part of the strategy of because he knows Donald Trump will read those comments and he knows that there's that there's stalled negotiations going on right now. Who knows what's going on behind the scenes? But you know, it's shocking, but not shocking, right, Scott? It's shocking because you'd never like ten years ago, you wouldn't have seen the Canadian Prime Minister ever say anything like that.
SPEAKER_02But in the in the world we live in now, it's really not that shocking. Trevor Burrus, Jr.
SPEAKER_03Well, and it's a great point. I mean, tariffs are one thing, but what does this say about the current state of the relationship between Canada and the US. Aaron Powell, Jr.
SPEAKER_02It's awful. But it's interesting because you still see, especially in the northern states, you see they're having rallies for Canada. You saw uh was it the bare-naked ladies sing the national anthem at the Buffalo Bills game, right? So there's still a lot of love along the border for the Canada-U.S. relationship, right? I think it's when you get away from those regions, it's maybe not the same. But this is an hour-by-hour situation. And we've been watching it unfold for you know long months and months now, and it's who knows?
SPEAKER_03Okay. Uh today on the program, we're gonna revisit a conversation that uh we had a few months back with uh Adam Gordon. Uh, Adam is a uh former senior legal and policy advisor uh to two uh of Canada's uh former foreign uh affairs ministers, uh Melanie Jolie and Anita Anand. Yeah, and he spoke about this.
SPEAKER_02He was but he was one of the first experts to come out and talk about how this is not likely, but not something we can ignore. So we're gonna revisit that conversation and dig deep into this topic.
SPEAKER_03When Donald Trump started musing about Canada becoming the 51st U.S. state, it was easy at first to think it was all bluster, but what's happening in Greenland right now has a lot of people worried about what Trump might have in store for us. In fact, a recent poll found that nearly one-third of Canadians believe the United States might attempt direct action against our country. Joining us to talk about where things stand and what our country should be doing to prepare is Adam Gordon, a former advisor to Canada's Minister of Foreign Affairs and now an affiliated researcher at the uh Cascade Institute.
SPEAKER_03Adam, uh thank you for your time tonight. Uh welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for having me. Pleasure to be here.
SPEAKER_03All right, Adam. Before we uh dive in, can you uh tell our viewers and listeners maybe a bit about yourself and what your role was in the office of the uh Minister of Foreign Affairs?
SPEAKER_01Sure. Uh I was the Minister's senior legal and policy advisor. Uh I led on a number of files, one being international law. Uh on top of that, I uh I led on all things to do with the Ukraine and uh and and Russia war. So um relations with uh with those countries with that uh issue, as well as uh um was help helped um helped on the Middle East issue, uh specifically the uh the war in Gaza.
SPEAKER_03A busy man. Yeah, no kidding. Okay, Adam, you recently uh co-authored a column in the Globe and Mail under the headline we need to prepare for the possibility that the U.S. uses military coercion against Canada. Let's start with the obvious question here, Adam. Why do we need to prepare for this possibility, which once seemed unthinkable?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it did seem unthinkable. Um, there's there's three things we've seen that uh that led us to want to write this piece. The first is a pattern of behavior from the United States and from the president of the United States, where he's essentially treating sovereignty as optional. Um, this is a man who has has openly discussed the idea of wanting to acquire Canada. Um, and we're seeing actions uh regarding other areas that he's he's um commented on, either wanting to have U.S.
SPEAKER_01ownership of or other comments he's made um that uh that they're following through on. The second is a few weeks ago, the United States released a new uh national security strategy. In that strategy, they promised the revival of the Monroe Doctrine. And the Monroe Doctrine is a uh is an old US policy, which has two sides. First is essentially telling the European powers at the time, but any other powers, hands off the Western Hemisphere, this is our zone. Uh, stay away, don't come here, don't interfere.
SPEAKER_01But the flip side of that coin is that it was essentially saying, hey, Western Hemisphere, you're our backyard. And we kind of get to do what we want here. Now, during the Cold War, which was the last time we kind of saw this really play out, this style of US US um action, Canada seemed to be exempted from from the things that were going on, whether you think of uh um uh Panama, Nicaragua, Latin America, we we got a special ex exemption from that.
SPEAKER_01We tended to sort of uh uh be treated a little differently. This US administration does not seem to have any special feelings for Canada. And so the statement that they are reviving this doctrine means that essentially we can't count on being exempted. And then the third piece is international law. And international law, we'd like to think when it comes to someone like Maduro, look, terrible human rights record, all all kinds of reasons why this is why this is an individual who it's quite frankly, you know, Venezuela can do without.
SPEAKER_01But from an international law perspective, that's not actually relevant. Um, that's not relevant to whether the United States unilaterally had the right to go in and impose their will on Venezuela. The same laws that should have and were supposed to protect Venezuela are the ones that would protect Canada. Um, and so there's no difference. So when you add that all up, it at least becomes plausible that that something could be could happen vis-a-vis Canada.
SPEAKER_01And if that's the case, then we need to be ready.
SPEAKER_02It's a great point. And we talk about international law. It just maybe I'm I'm not a lawyer, obviously, like you are, but it feels like that's all been thrown out the window. Like international law has kind of been, yeah, that's gone. Doesn't mean it's does it does it feel that way to you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, frankly, this is a very open question at the moment. This is something we're we're all grappling with in the international law world. International law has more power than just when people follow it or not. International law sets the sets the boundaries for what is considered acceptable on the international stage. You go back to the 1800s, European powers didn't even frankly, I mean, in the way that we do now, it wasn't considered unacceptable to invade your neighbors. Now it is, and we see that the response is part of what the power of international law is.
SPEAKER_01You look at what's happened to Russia, Russia thought they could invade their neighbor, thought that they could just make that happen. We've all responded. And they've paid a massive reputational cost uh price for that. Um, and and so these are the kinds of things that uh that international law still has some power to do. Um, whether it's the international reputation, uh government's reputation with its own people, um, there is still some power, but very much it uh it we're in a we're in a real nerve uh nerve-wracking time, uh, and it's unclear where international law is going to go.
SPEAKER_03Uh Adam, in terms of uh preparation and and us actually preparing for the potential of this, what do we have to do?
SPEAKER_01Right. So I think the question that I've seen from some people over the past couple weeks is well, I guess the assertion I should say is if the US invades, then Canada can't do anything anyways. I don't think that's true. Um now, look, if a superpower decides to invade a country, that's that's a dicey situation, to be sure. Um, however, you look at the history of superpowers invading other countries in recent years, whether or in the past hundred years, whether that's Russia in Ukraine, whether that's the United States uh not invading, but but using military action in Vietnam, doesn't always go as as they plan.
SPEAKER_01US in uh uh in Afghanistan. And the key is to make it costly. And there's two elements to making it costly. The first is the actual more tangible side of that, which looks like building up our military capacity, um, building up our military resources. That includes everything from hard material to expanding, uh, you know, uh amplifying our our um uh the the scope of our forces. I'm not a military planner, so I won't uh presume to know the specifics of what uh our our government should do.
SPEAKER_01And to be clear, we're already engaging in this. The Cardi administration is is working hard to expand our military capacity. Um, but this is more of a uh you know one more element of impetus to really uh um have urgency on that. And then the second side of cost is is reputational cost. Uh again, whether that's with the international community, um if if the US government faces significant backlash, that's really the key. And and we want that to be international, but we want that to also be at home from Americans.
SPEAKER_01Um and the two are linked, of course. If if the international community is unhappy and and considers something to be an unacceptable action, that doesn't that doesn't play well with Americans. Now the the government can always uh you know use justifications, uh, all kinds of things, try and convince people uh of anything, but um, but uh by and large that's uh that's a side of the cost. So if they do something it'll be really difficult. What we want to do is convince them that it's really not worth it to start using or even threatening to use force against Canada, that the cost would just not not make it a good uh uh a good policy.
SPEAKER_02So you've been behind the scenes of power, you've been you've advised the Minister of Foreign Affairs. What's going on back there? I don't mean people must be feeling pretty nervous these days.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, people are feeling nervous. Um look, uh, I think we we said it in our in our uh piece in our op-ed. We're in a we're in a truly nonlinear world. Um all the all the rules, all the predictability that we used to be able to count on. Um it's uh it it's it's much harder to know what's gonna happen. And that makes it harder to plan for things. Um it makes it harder to know what to do. Everything's multifaceted. Uh when whenever we make a decision, um, we can no longer count on our overall geostrategic understanding and go, okay, we're just gonna deal with this incident, with this isolated uh uh issue and have it not spill over.
SPEAKER_01I'll give an example, which is uh when when there was uh pressure from the United States for Canada to join the war in Iraq, we got to make that decision, yes, knowing that it was gonna have some impact on Canada's relationship. Everything you do with another country is is gonna have some impact. But we didn't start to question whether this was going to lead to the downfall of our economy or cause this country to uh you know consider us uh not a friend.
SPEAKER_01And that was an issue that directly involved the US. Now we're seeing issues that don't even directly involve the US, and we need to be much more aware that if our our positions are out of line with theirs, uh that's gonna possibly lead to con uh complications. But the good news is uh there is a growing recognition uh both in the Canadian government. I mean, I think Canadians, Canadians have always been well aware. I think we have a very good idea, we've got our finger on the pulse of the United States.
SPEAKER_01We live right next to them, we consume their media. We're so connected that we really, really do understand the Americans, I think, in a in a way that is uh that comes from that uh incredible closeness and and uh level of ties. I think elsewhere, including in Europe, there's a growing recognition of the need to recognize that we're in a new world, that that everything needs to change and figure out ways to confront that reality. Um But as you say, so I mean the the the long and short of it is it's a really difficult time uh behind the scenes.
SPEAKER_01Uh we're we're we're trying to break new ground and come up with solutions to problems we've never had. We haven't had in 100 years.
SPEAKER_02You're right. And you and you said it best the stakes just feel so high. The stakes are always high. If you're the federal government, if you're the PMO or you're the Minister of Foreign Affairs, stakes are always high. There's always big decisions to make, but it feels like they're as high as they've ever been, at least in my lifetime.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so. Um look, the I I had a friend uh who who works in uh in uh in business, in in commodity trading, who said, you know, a number of months back, uh jokingly said, Well, I don't, you know, Crystal Ball, tell me, are we gonna have tariffs? Uh what's this, what's gonna happen? And I I kind of half jokingly said back, if tariffs are the worst thing that we're talking about, then all told that's that's not that bad.
SPEAKER_01And yet, tariffs we know could be debilitating for the Canadian economy. So there's there's all sorts of levels of this, uh, economic, um, our ability to to uh live our lives as Canadians, to travel, to to enjoy all the the prosperity that we have, um, geopolitical, uh we need to can think about our relationships, not just us and the the Americans, but as well if if we're gonna have a new relationship with them, what that means for all of our other relationships, uh, whether with traditional partners.
SPEAKER_01Um, one of the big things that I've been advocating, and and we have again have this in the in the op-ed, is that we need to really be looking at non-traditional partners, especially those facing similar issues to us, whether that's uh those that live next to to a superpower and are dealing with that. Um essentially find friends everywhere on earth because we're gonna need to be much more um much more diversified in in how we uh approach all of world affairs.
SPEAKER_03Adam, let's uh talk about the Greenland situation uh for a second. What are you watching for specifically?
SPEAKER_01I'm watching I uh again, my strongest interest is in seeing how Europeans respond, um as well as how Canada responds. Uh I think that we're we're what comes next, not just in Greenland, but in other issues, will really be dictated by the response here. I think that people perhaps uh underplay how much these situations have to do with each other. I think, for instance, uh uh when when Putin looked to invade uh Ukraine, he was looking at a what he saw as a pattern of of non-follow through from the West.
SPEAKER_01And I think he was actually quite surprised to find how much we really came in, showed unity, um, showed resolve in confronting him. Because I think that that maybe from his perspective had not been demonstrated in whether it was in Afghanistan, in in other scenarios, um, to where he thought that, you know, I'll push, they'll they'll say some words, but then really they'll just kind of let it go at the end of the day. Um so similarly, I think what's really needed here is is is a unity of purpose, is an understanding of the stakes and and that this is really like this is it.
SPEAKER_01This is the moment um that we need to show uh how how we're gonna how we're gonna respond. The other side I'm looking for, and we're already seeing some signs of this, is how the United States responds, not the not the executive, not Donald Trump's administration, but everyone from the American public to uh to to the Senate and Congress. Um especially Republicans. I think, you know, we'll seeing how Donald Trump's own party reacts and responds to this, um, because this is very different.
SPEAKER_01I think, like I said earlier, from an international law perspective, Venezuela is identical to not identical to Canada, but very similarly situated. It's not really relevant what kind of government. But in the minds and hearts of people, it's obviously very different. Venezuela was a regime that that has had done, you know, terrible human rights abuses, oppression, all kinds of things. And so I think the idea that the United States uh went in and and uh confronted this government, uh you know, no one's gonna shed a tear for the Maduro regime.
SPEAKER_01Uh conversely, uh you know, you you you have you have Denmark and you have the you know NATO ally and and friend, and and so uh I think the more that we see reactions from the Americans of well, no, no, no, we we we can't do this, we shouldn't do this, we wouldn't do this. Hopefully that's enough that uh that we'll see uh a change in behavior.
SPEAKER_02For sure. It's a very difficult choice for the Canadian government. As we record this, there's reports about the fact that Canada may send some troops there because we know some some NATO allies are also sending troops over there. At the same time, Mark Kearney's been appointed to this new um group that's gonna help with peace in Gaza, with it, which is Donald Trump's creation. I just can't imagine being in the PMO right now or being in your old shoes trying to advise on what's the right move. What's the right move here, Adam?
SPEAKER_01Right, right. Uh, you know, it gets even more complicated. Uh our force capacity is uh is you know, there are there are limits to what we what we can do. Um that includes needing to continue demonstrating our support in Eastern Europe, uh, Canadian contingent in the in um Latvia, I believe. Um that includes our own Arctic. Uh we've heard, I I've heard an NBC segment that uh behind closed doors, while Greenland's getting all the attention, Donald Trump is expressing uh a lot of displeasure with Canada's own management of our Arctic.
SPEAKER_01Again, I can't uh confirm whether that's true or not. Um NBC reporting that those close to the president are saying this. So if we're sending people to to Greenland, those those that that capacity has to come from somewhere, um, whether it's our own Arctic, our own, our own uh national bases or or deployment. So real difficult. Uh the other thing, uh similarly, Mark, uh Prime Minister Carney was in uh was in China recently. Um again, that's a relationship where you go back 10 years and Canada's relationship with China was was kind of our own issue.
SPEAKER_01It was between us and China. Now, how we interact with China and the closeness of that relationship is something that the Americans are are watching or going to notice. Now, luckily, Trump so far has come out saying, you know, good for Canada, they should absolutely go do that. But everything beyond that comes unclear. Um, as far as responding to Greenland, on the force side, I I really can't comment. I I don't have the out that expertise or that understanding of our forces.
SPEAKER_01But I'd love to see us continue to stand up for the norms and the notion that this should not be on the table, that the people of Greenland, the people of of of Denmark, uh complex relationship internally between the two. But regardless, this is a decision that um is is within the right of of that nation or those nations to to decide and an issue for them to figure out um when it comes to their sovereignty.
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. Absolutely. If it's a it's hard to even put into words, but this is NATO countries versus NATO countries, is kind of what's happening in Greenland right now. Where do you see NATO in a year from now? Is it just a total gas?
SPEAKER_01I think so. Um Truly, truly hard to predict. Um yeah, honestly, I I wish I wish I knew. Even uh as you say, there's there's obviously the the US on the one side, other NATO countries on the other. But even where the NATO countries that are not the US go with each other is something that's very that's very much um we'll we'll see how that plays out.
SPEAKER_02Just a couple more questions. Thank you again, Adam. Is this this worry that we all we all feel this worry? We're talking about it with family and friends, this concern that this could actually possibly happen, some kind of military um force coming to coming to Canada from the United States. But could there be some smaller steps first? Would they maybe break up NORAD or would they more economic sanctions or or tariffs, things like that? Well, would you could there be a progression here?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I would argue that that progression has already started. Yes, for sure. I would I would say that I'm helping to start it, quite frankly, which is that the comments themselves um are bringing us into a pattern of behavior that responds to even the risk of the threat of force. That can escalate to being an actual threat of force, even if it's an offhand comment. If Trump says, well, the Canadians are, you know, we don't like what they're doing up there, so maybe we should move some troops further north, uh, up to our northern border.
SPEAKER_01That alone is enough to start to to impact Canada's sovereignty and our ability to make decisions on our own terms. Um, but there's everything then, you know, one step up from there is actually sending uh troops to the northern border. There's a lot that can be done to bring a country in line that is short of actually marching troops across a border.
SPEAKER_03Adam, let's talk about average citizens uh for a sec. Uh like those of us in this room and and yours how do how do we begin to prepare? What should we be doing?
SPEAKER_01Well, that's a great question. Um I think first and foremost, um you know, look, I'm uh I I've worked for for politicians and uh and I'm not gonna sit here and claim that they should uh always get uh well I'll I'll say that the the the criticizing our politicians is a long tradition and uh and I I I think that they deserve more uh uh slack and credit and make difficult decisions um at all times, but especially right now, I think we really need to show a uh unity as a country.
SPEAKER_01Um these are as as we have been discussing incredibly difficult times. I think there's gonna be um a lot that happens for reasons that people don't necessarily see on the surface, either because we're playing to considerations that are that are you know trying to play the chess game, um, as well as looking forward um a few moves, uh, some of the things we do uh there. The other thing as far as preparing, I think uh the elbows up movement is great.
SPEAKER_01Um, you know, let's let's keep on demonstrating our our our unhappiness with the situation, um avoiding trips to the United States where we can, um uh buying Canadian is is fantastic. And then yeah, really, really that's that's about it. Um it's it's hard, you know, these are things that can't really they they need to happen at an in at an organizational level, more than more than one individual to the next.
SPEAKER_01But I think showing those signs that you know we're we're unified and that uh that we're all on board with uh with uh with the plan.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, sorry to keep asking you questions, Adam, but I could keep going all day. This is a fascinating and it's an important conversation, right? But I do wonder, have you in all your discussions, is there a bit of a pro-American sentiment out there in some pockets of Canada? There's some people in Canada saying, you know what, maybe being the 51st state would be a good idea.
SPEAKER_01I I don't have any particular insight on this. I haven't uh I haven't conversed with anyone who said that. Um I'm seeing, you know, we're all seeing this play out possibly in in uh I think the spotlight is on Alberta, given the talk of referendum. And we're seeing some polling that shows this. What we are also seeing, as we actually someone mentioned in our scenario there in the piece, um there is some indication uh of of meetings between those leading the separatist movement and and elements in the United States, including in the US government.
SPEAKER_01Um so there's definitely an interest there uh from those individuals, but uh but yeah, beyond that I'm not sure.
SPEAKER_02Here's the here's the most unfair question I'm gonna ask you. Would we have any hope if America came across the border? What do you think? How do you think Canadians would respond to that?
SPEAKER_01Like I said, it's on the one hand, superpowers can bring an immense amount of uh of force. On the other hand, um uh, you know, I'll I'll again point back to the history in the past hundred years of of how well that's gone. I think it goes especially poorly when a country doesn't believe in the the actions they're taking. Um, you know, for for all the difficulties, all of the challenges, all of the the casualties that the United States suffered in uh in Afghanistan, there was at least some recognition that there was, you know, that there that that they had a reason to be there, I think, among the American population.
SPEAKER_01Much less so in Iraq. There would be much less so in Canada. Now, the Trump administration has been incredible at convincing at least elements of their base, you know, uh uh having a particular narrative, and then months later that's that's the narrative that uh that they're that a certain segment of the US population is is really believes in. Um, but American population at large, I think and I hope would be quite appalled at the notion of of a use of force against Canada.
SPEAKER_01And so if it especially if it started to cost them, if there were casualties and and you know body bags coming home to the United States, um, I think that could get pretty unpopular pretty quick when they really don't believe in it. Uh, so you know, you have to hope that that's enough. You have to hope that the domestic pressure, international pressure, um, you know, from my perspective, just because uh, you know, the how Article 5 of the um uh of NATO, which is the one that says that countries are supposed to come to each other's defense, that uh uh I can't remember the exact wording, but uh essentially an attack on one is an attack on all.
SPEAKER_01Um we've never had to confront the question of what happens when it's one member of NATO using force against another member of NATO. Um, but I would hope and think that uh other NATO members would treat this as uh uh as something that that did engage that obligation that that did uh bring them into the question. Um, again, raise the costs, make it make it incredibly unpleasant to be in Canada.
SPEAKER_02This is my last question for you, Adam. It really hit home what you just said. The idea that there could be a conflict and body bags would be going back to the United States from a war or a conflict with Canada is just unthinkable, as we said at the top of the show. And we're all mourning something, too, because this friendship, this neighborly relationship we've had with America is real. We were very close. We have family and friends on both sides of the border. We've had so many decades of prosperity together and and fighting alongside each other in certain, you know, we lost lots of soldiers in Afghanistan, friends who we we lost there, for example, not to mention the world wars.
SPEAKER_02And so we're we're all kind of mourning this change. This is this this still feels so unbelievable. Is there any scenario where in 10 years things will get back to normal and we'll look back and say, or are we, or is this forever changed?
SPEAKER_01I think, and and to I I want to clarify something, because I I don't want the the sort of story out of this saying that uh former former staffers said body bags won't go back to the United States. Look, we're talking this is this is hypothetical, worst case scenario, active conflict that uh, you know, by no means in in always we want to avoid any military confrontation, even if there is the threat of use of force, uh de-escalate, de-escalate, de-escalate. Like I I went to um uh law school in the United States.
SPEAKER_01I have an unbelievable number of friends, like all Canadians, massive number of connections. Uh this is these are terrible scenarios we're talking about. Like we don't want to be talking about these. Um, as far as things getting back to normal, I think that uh what we saw with the United States after the first Trump administration when Biden came in, they tried to do a bit of a we're back. Um and to a degree it kind of worked because the first Trump administration was actually quite different than than this administration.
SPEAKER_01And it worked somewhat. Uh we weren't, you know, there was some skepticism of like, well, you know, are you you're back in the Paris Agreement for now? And uh, you know, all all the all these things where they tried to come in and and take up their leadership ship position that they had, and there was some skepticism. At this point, Canada's changed, Europe has changed. So even if the Americans were to snap back to where they were 10 years ago, 20 years ago, uh develop that that sort of renewed approach, renewed commitment to international law, I think that Canada will it'll take a long, long, long time before we're ready to go.
SPEAKER_01You know, we're actually willing to really trust you and put our economy uh in your hands in a certain way, put put our defense. Like uh I I think that um whether they've changed, we've changed.
SPEAKER_03Uh Adam, last question before we let you go. Could you ever have imagined in your wildest dreams having a conversation like this one tonight, uh, where Canada-US relations are concerned?
SPEAKER_01Yes, and no. The no is that I mean, look, we've had 70 years where we live we've lived in a world where uh rule of law has predominated, yes, with exceptions clearly, but overall the thrust has been in that that direction. We're Canada and the US uh gripe at each other in a big brother, little brother kind of way, but you know, we we we share a hockey league and a basketball league and uh and professional associations and uh uh you know, I think what um uh a transmission, uh I remember learning about 15 years ago that a single Ford transmission from a parts from from raw material to a complete transmission crossed the bridge from Windsor into Detroit and back uh 40 times or something like that.
SPEAKER_01Like we're so integrated with them. So it seems it seems unbelievable. But on the flip side, there's a there's a great analogy, which is uh, you know, if you jump out of 11 store an 11-story building and 10 stories down go, well, this whole myth of the ground thing, like you know, things this this worked out pretty well so far. Things are unbelievable until they're not. And history has shown time and again that uh a thing, a a certain uh action, a certain global context predominates for a long time, and we just get used to it, and it seems implausible that that would ever change.
SPEAKER_01Uh but time and again things have changed, uh, whether it's the Roman Empire falling, or uh the the the you know Tsar Nicholas II falling, or the then then the the Soviet Union falling, like things uh will suddenly be different in a w and and be completely changed forever. And we see this time and again, and I think that's the real lesson here is is that just because it's felt impossible for the past era, there's a real feeling out there that we're in a new era.
SPEAKER_03That we are. Uh okay, let's uh leave it there. There's Adam Gordon, a researcher at the Cascade Institute and a former senior legal and policy advisor to uh the Minister of Uh Foreign Affairs. Uh Adam, uh great insight tonight. We appreciate your time.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for having me. Pleasure to be here.
SPEAKER_03Uh the point that you made uh earlier, uh, and it's a good one, uh, this situation is changing and unfolding um at an alarming pace.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell, Jr. Yes. And like the shock of hearing the Prime Minister talk about this, uh it does make it feel more real because before it was just experts and analysts saying, you know, this is a possibility, this is why it could be a possibility. But knowing that the Prime Minister at some moment in his day in recent memory has spent some time looking over the possibility of this and studying it, doing some risk management, as he says, uh let's hope we don't get to that point where we're talking about that reality.
SPEAKER_03It's staggering to think about that. Yeah, let's hope we don't get there. Let's hope. Okay, that's it for uh Closer Look uh this week. You can uh check us out at closerlookpodcast.ca and of course uh reach out by email anytime 24-7 at closerlook at villagemedia.ca for Zach Trunso, executive producer of the program, and Michael Friscolenti, our editor in chief here at Village Media. I'm Scott Sexmith. Thanks for watching. Enjoy what's left of your weekend. We'll see you next time right here on Closer Look.
SPEAKER_00Frisco and Scott's wardrobe, provided in part by Morris Clothing for Men.
Season after season, Hazel Mae has been a familiar face to Toronto Blue Jays fans, bringing viewers closer to the game and the players they cheer for. But after telling so many other people’s stories, the veteran...
For a generation of Canadians, Rick Campanelli has been one of the most recognizable faces on television - the energetic, always-grinning “Rick the Temp” who turned a MuchMusic contest into a remarkable career in...
Matthew Schaefer was the first overall pick in the 2025 NHL draft - and he definitely lived up to the hype. In his first season, the talented defenceman put up Bobby Orr-esque numbers, tallying 23 goals and 36 assists...
In November, the Ontario Liberals will elect a new leader - the party’s third in six years. Five candidates are on the ballot to replace Bonnie Crombie: Navdeep Bains, Stephanie Bowman, Lee Fairclough, Eric Lombardi and...
At last count, nearly 200,000 people have signed an online petition demanding the expulsion of Donald Trump's ambassador to Canada. The petition - which will be presented in the House of Commons this fall - calls on the...