Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Cast On

Cast On artwork

211 Grace Notes

Apr 9, 202621 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Ghost in the Orchard. Four inches from done. I’d stare at the cable chart and the tiny squares would dance. Close my eyes. Open them. Over and over. The hands that made those cables could not remember how cables worked. Endel Tulving‘s encoding specificity principle. Godden and Baddeley’s divers learning words underwater. Jonathan Spence‘s memory palace. And 60% of the total surface of our brains committed to our hands. My second sweater - bricky red, carnelian buttons, the physical therapist who inadvertently retired it - became the Gaia Jacket from Jean Moss’s Sculptured Knits. Which became the red cabled vest I’m knitting now. Thirty years of memory in the same wool. Serotonin stripped the filters. Melatonin locked the repair. Dopamine lit the paths. Norepinephrine broke the bridge. Memory is where it all comes home. Music: Rore, Arrival; Waveshaper, Our Time (Instrumental) If you’d like to help support the podcast, you can do so via Ko-fi or Patreon, or by spreading the word to a fellow knitter. Get full access to Brenda Dayne at brendadayne.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

A common antibiotic dysregulated my brain chemistry and left me unable to knit for months.

SPEAKER_00I taught myself neuroscience to understand why. What I found surprised me. I'm Brenda Dane. You're listening to Cast On. This is your Brain on Knitting. Pablo Casal, the cellist, once remarked that in music, the notes not played are as important as the ones that are played.

These are the grace notes, the silent beats of space between audible tones of sound.

SPEAKER_00The project bag was a little dusty. Unsurprising, given that it had been sat in a corner for four months. The project inside, a beautifully cabled V-neck pullover vest, was four inches from completion. Just four inches, plus the neck and armhole ribbings. I had planned to finish last autumn. I knew it would be a wardrobe staple.

SPEAKER_00I had bought a new shirt to wear with it, but I could not finish. The project was good, the yarn choice sound, pattern well within my skill level. The fit was going to be perfect. I could not finish. The cable was charted, and I could no longer read the chart. I didn't understand why. I'd look at the chart, the tiny squares would begin to dance, I'd close my eyes, open them again,

SPEAKER_00over and over. I could see a vest at 95% done, recognize my own work, my design choices, remember the stretchy cast-on, and the decision to move some of the stitches from the center panels to the side panels to narrow the neck of the garment. But I could not remember how cables worked, how they happened. How does anyone manage to knit these? Never mind that, at one time, quite clearly I had.

Not long after my friend Jean taught me to knit, I noticed something peculiar.

SPEAKER_00Memories of things that were said, music that I listened to, conversations that happened around me as I knit would come bubbling up from the back of my mind the next time I picked up whatever project I had been working on. I noticed the memories were easy to access, how they stayed, even in the oldest projects. I wondered why. You can't step very far into the world of memory without

meeting the 5th century

SPEAKER_00Greek poet Simonides of Chios, sole survivor of a tragic accident. Having given a fine speech at a banquet to honor Scopus, a Thessalonian nobleman, Simonides was called from his place at the banquet by a messenger. Simonides left the banquet, and at the very moment his feet crossed the threshold of the building, it collapsed behind him, killing everyone inside. Word of the tragedy spread quickly and family members began

arriving on the scene.

SPEAKER_00Bodies extracted from the wreckage were beyond recognition, and no one could even truly say who had been inside. Then something remarkable happened that changed forever the way that humans would think about memory. Simonides closed his eyes, mentally removed himself from the chaos happening all around him, and he turned back time in his head. Before him, instead of dust and rubble, he saw pillars of marble and tables laden with food and wine,

SPEAKER_00his friend Scopus laughing at the head table, musicians playing in a corner, a fellow poet across the room, a nobleman smirking at a joke. He opened his eyes and one by one led each of the hysterical family members by the hand through the debris to where their loved ones had been sitting. At that moment, as the legend goes, the art of memory was born.

SPEAKER_00In his book, The Memory Palace of Matteo Ricci, Jonathan Spence writes about a 16th century Jesuit who brought to the people of China the memory system used by the ancient Greeks, born on that day, 11 centuries earlier, when a building collapsed in the middle of a banquet. Ricci taught people to build memory palaces, huge buildings of the imagination, with room upon room leading off countless corridors. What Ricci taught as a deliberate mnemonic device comes very

close to describing

SPEAKER_00what the brain does automatically. As we move through the world, experience is transformed into memories. Neuron by neuron, we snap together mental structures, constantly evolving palaces of memories that are ours alone, with us until we die. The second sweater I ever knit was a freeform affair. I did not use a pattern.

SPEAKER_00I knit a gauge swatch. I measured a sweater I liked, and Jean helped me design a not-too-complicated pattern for a second sweater. I finished knitting the garment in what seemed like days, but I'm sure it must have been at least a few weeks. It was mostly stockinette, and it was knit from an Aran yarn that Jean had given me from her stash, so it knit up fast. The color was a rich, bricky red. Entirely the wrong color for Jean's cool gray-blue eyes and pale skin.

SPEAKER_00The buttons I had chosen for this project were, I thought, very special. They were pewter with carnelian centers and they cost $4 each. There were five of them. It felt like a fortune to spend on buttons. I loved them in that way that little girls love the unremitting pinkness of their Barbie dream house, which is to say I loved these chunky, heavy pewter and carnelian buttons blindly and without the

benefit of taste.

SPEAKER_00Eventually, the garment was complete. Though the Buttons definitely wore the sweater in this instance, it was on the whole not a bad job. I wore that sweater to parent-teacher conferences and to work at my graphic design studio downtown and out for drinks. It was a good sweater. Not a great sweater, but a good one, and I loved it. It was one of the sweaters that came with me to Wales, and I wore my second sweater as long and as well in my new home as I had in my old sweater.

SPEAKER_00Eventually, I realized that the sweater was past its best. One day I wore it when I went to see my physical therapist who asked, did you knit your sweater? Let me be rightly understood. This is not a question asked from one knitter to another, did you knit that? Evoking the fraternal bond across a crowded ladies' dressing room. This was something else. When did you knit that is a question asked by your physical

therapist in a small

SPEAKER_00village in Wales, you know it's probably time to retire the sweater. When I realized it was time for my sweater's retirement, it seemed the most obvious thing in the world to me to simply pick the pieces apart, unravel the entire thing, and re-knit the wool into something new. It made complete sense. Finding enough real wool in rural Wales for an entire sweater was next to impossible, and I already loved the yarn—

I wasn't as crazy about the buttons as I'd once been, but they matched and were serviceable. The sweater had been a wardrobe staple forever, largely due to the color of the yarn.

SPEAKER_00There was good wool in that sweater, and I was determined to set it free to become something else. I had saved a sweater's worth of money by reusing the yarn, so I splurged on a brand new knitting book by Jean Moss called Sculptured Knits. I settled on the Gaia jacket, a boxy little crop number in a textured knit and purl pattern with a double moss stitch collar. It was perfect. I had just enough yarn.

SPEAKER_00I got to work, and I busted out a sweater. I wanted to like the Gaia jacket more than I did, and it languished at the bottom of my sweater drawer. I wore it for a little while, but it never became a favorite. Every autumn when I packed the summer clothes away, it surfaced with the rest of the sweaters and was folded neatly into the sweater drawer. Every spring, I packed it away again, unworn.

SPEAKER_00I suppose the real question is why couldn't I just let it go? Knit something else? A fair point and one I considered. Something stopped me from doing that, though. As I handled the Gaia jacket, so full of memories, deciding its fate, I realized that the most important part of the sweater were the grace notes, the memories held between the stitches, of the woman who taught me to knit,

SPEAKER_00the gift of the yarn, the wrong color for Jean, the right color for me, the ridiculously overpriced buttons, and the creation of every stitch in both garments. It was all of it. The most important aspect of this sweater was me.

SPEAKER_00There are many theories for why knitting is sticky. Why we remember the things that happened around us while knitting and recall them with perfect clarity the very next time we pick up the project. The encoding specificity principle, first postulated by Endel Tolving, a Canadian experimental psychologist and cognitive neuroscientist, states that memories are best retrieved when the conditions at retrieval match those present during encoding.

SPEAKER_00In 1975, researchers Godin and Baddeley took two groups of people and asked them to learn and remember new words. The twist in this study is that one of the groups was required to learn their new words underwater, while diving, while the other group learned the same words on dry land. Later testing revealed that recall was better when the groups were tested within the environment in which they learned the new words. Another theory,

SPEAKER_00theta wave activity, suggests that cyclic brainwaves are induced by the repetitive motion of our hands while we knit and serve as a timing mechanism to temporally organize memory encoding. We're not just passing time. We're creating the optimal encoding conditions. Alternating left and right hand movements, bilateral stimulation, facilitates memory consolidation and is linked to reduced

cortisol levels and an

SPEAKER_00increase in serotonin and dopamine. When knitting becomes automatic, when procedural memory takes over, we enter a flow state. Prefrontal cortex activity decreases along with working memory, but encoding continues through other pathways. Information retention can improve by up to 500% when learning in flow. This next one blows me away.

SPEAKER_0060% of the total surface of our brain is committed to our hands. Knitting lights up somatosensory cortex like a pinball machine, creating neural activity that interconnects with whatever is being processed simultaneously. Knitting creates the perfect storm for memory encoding. When you pick up the project again, you're not just touching yarn. You're recreating the encoding conditions. Like those divers learning words underwater.

The tactile cues trigger a cascade of memory retrieval of everything that was bound

SPEAKER_00to the fabric. The music, the conversation, the words used, the mood, the emotions, even the lighting. And that's why knitting is sticky. The Gaia jacket was unmade as easily as she was made. Though never as easily as one thinks it should be. The ball winder in its familiar place at the end of a dining room table.

Clouds of woolly dust and whatever the hell else that cloud contained that,

SPEAKER_00frankly, I'd rather not know the specifics of. The skeins tied and bound for the soak they desperately need. Kinks relaxing in the gentle bath of not-too-hot water and mild soap. The pewter buttons happily retired. Last winter, I cast on a red cabled vest. This autumn, I hoped I'd finish it in time to wear over the winter. As hand and brain begin again to remember how cables work,

SPEAKER_00I'm remembering everything bound up in the yarn, in the fabric, and in my memory. The firelight of last winter. the chair with its back to the window, the occasional shaft of sunlight entering the room in the late afternoon, Rachel and Phil Ray playing softly in the background, the pop and hiss of firewood burning, the ticking of a clock,

SPEAKER_00the taste of tea. Serotonin stripped the filters and let everything in, made everything meaningful. The lack of melatonin locked the repair system and wouldn't let me sleep so my brain could heal. Dopamine lit the desire paths and some of them stayed. Norepinephrine broke the bridge between knowing and doing. And underneath all of it, the neurochemistry of the shimmer and the sleepless nights and

the banana bread was

SPEAKER_00memory. The thing I lost for a while. The thing I missed most. Without memory, the yarn is just string. The cables just crossed stitches. The sweater just wool. Memory is what makes my knitting, mine. Knitting is us. Our personalities, our individuality, our experience,

SPEAKER_00our observation, our likes and dislikes, our taste, our thinking, all reflected in the fabric created by our hands. These are the grace notes held between the stitches. It's taken me over 30 years to realize that what's most important is not the business end of the knitting needles, but the hands that hold them. The vest is nearly finished now. Four inches became three, then two.

SPEAKER_00The cables make sense again. And everything I lost is held between the stitches, just waiting for me to find it. Trimethoprim broke me open in the worst possible way. It was hard and horrible and weird being inside a broken brain. And it was worth it.

SPEAKER_00Impossibly, it was worth it. For about four years before taking the drug, I'd been creatively flat. Not blocked. Flat. The difference matters. A block is something you can feel pressing against you. Flatness is the absence of pressing. I didn't know the voice had gone quiet because I'd forgotten what my voice sounded like. We were living in a toxic community,

trying to sell our house, and then focused on moving.

SPEAKER_00The podcast was on hiatus. The writing had stopped. I hadn't noticed because not noticing was the whole shape of it. Trimethoprim cracked my creative energy open along with everything else, allowed me to access it again. The shimmer, the sleepless nights, the research, the connections I built at 3 a.m. when I couldn't sleep, all of it arrived through the same broken door. The creative drive that's producing this series didn't exist six months ago.

Given the same set of circumstances, and knowing what I know now, I'd take the drug again.

SPEAKER_00Go through it all again. It was a stroke of very bad luck that turned into a stroke of insight. Music Thanks for listening to Grace Notes, the final episode of Your Brain on Knitting. Links to everything I've talked about in this series, including the research, are in the show notes at BrendaDane.Substack.com.

SPEAKER_00Quick word about how this podcast gets made. Cast On takes time, thought, and care to produce. If you value this work, you can support it at seven pounds a month on Patreon. That's the public radio model. No extras, no gimmicks, just thoughtful podcasts consistently made. Links in the show notes. A few years ago, I mentioned a series I'd been dreaming about, one based on the shipping forecast. Fourteen episodes,

SPEAKER_00one for each of the sea areas adjacent to Great Britain, taking me all the way around the coastline of the United Kingdom. At the time, it was just a dream. An enormous project requiring travel and resources I didn't have. I'm not sure I have them now, if I'm honest. But something has changed. After producing this series, after teaching myself neuroscience from inside a broken brain and coming out the other side with five episodes and my voice back,

a 14-part series about the sea feels less like a dream and more like something I

SPEAKER_00might actually do. I'll let you know. In the meantime, thank you for being here, for listening to all of it, the science, the sleepless nights, the banana bread, the buttons, for staying until the end. Thank you. And as always, if you're cold, put on a sweater. That's what they're for.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 217 Closer Than You Think

    Oct 23, 202627 minAudio

    A culture of one sounds grand until it becomes a spreadsheet. Twenty garments, five categories, six with a date or a next step, and a lot of honest blank space. That is not failure. It is the handmade wardrobe becoming...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 216 Making

    Oct 16, 202625 minAudio

    Everyone has worn something that felt like them. In this episode, that feeling starts with a teenage pantsuit made by Brenda’s mother, and widens into the question Claire McCardell asked in What Shall I Wear?: what...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 215 Ease

    Oct 9, 202624 minAudio

    The mirror didn’t care what I thought should be there. Steroids, weight, a body that changed without permission - none of that was the real difficulty. The difficulty was the gap: the distance between what the mirror...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 214 Enough

    Oct 2, 202628 minAudio

    Stash Acquired Beyond Life Expectancy. It’s a joke until you do the maths. Eight complete sweaters-worths of yarn in DK and fingering weight alone, not counting the oddballs, the luxury fibre, or the container of 2-ply...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 213 Fit

    Sep 25, 202626 minAudio

    The quest for trousers that actually fit involved eBay-stalking vintage pattern drafting books - Flat Pattern Cutting and Modelling for Fashion (Helen Stanley, 1972), Pattern Drafting and Dressmaking (Dorothy Moore,...

    Credit the people on this episode