Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Cast On

Cast On artwork

215 Ease

Oct 9, 202624 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The mirror didn’t care what I thought should be there. Steroids, weight, a body that changed without permission - none of that was the real difficulty. The difficulty was the gap: the distance between what the mirror showed and what I expected to see by now. That gap is where getting dressed stops being getting dressed and starts being negotiation. Lakyn Carlton calls it expertise - knowing to the millimetre what hides and what shows, and choosing. The fitted answer is the Leo from Bella Loves Patterns, cut in a red cross-grain pinstripe cotton lawn from SR Harris: stand collar, full placket, a shirt that reads as authority. Narrow shoulders shift the armscye out of place - Sandra Betzina’s Fast Fit fixes it at the shoulder line. One alteration. Everything else follows. The unfitted answer is the Jenna in autumn-coloured linen - volume as architecture, not surrender. Three trousers handle the lower half: the Mitchell for the long line, the Billy in grey crinkle linen from Misan for the days that want movement, the Pegs from episode two, nearly finished, for the proof of concept. On top, the Olya from Paper Theory in mustard geometric - the coordination layer. Big Love, the teal cardigan, tones with everything. The charcoal sweater’s replacement is coming; knitters do that. Knowing exactly what you need is not denial - it’s craft applied to the specific problem of getting dressed in a body that changed. MUSIC * Evergreen - Instrumental, by UPPLAND * Is What It Is, by Judah & the Lion Get full access to Brenda Dayne at brendadayne.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Knit, knit like the wind. This is Cast On with Brenda Dayne.

SPEAKER_00215. Ease. [music] In this episode, an Ikea mirror two meters high with one eyebrow raised, a wardrobe full of clothes that no longer fit the brief, and the shoulder fix that changed everything.

SPEAKER_00It's time to cast on. Greetings, Knitsib. How you doing? An ordinary Tuesday morning in spring. Just me and my closet and a big damned Ikea mirror purchased when we moved into the cottage. A statement mirror, two meters high, 1.2 meters wide, leaning against the wall with its arms folded and one eyebrow raised.

SPEAKER_00It did not feel friendly. Nothing fit. I'd been on steroids the whole of the previous winter. Weight had arrived without my permission and it would not leave on my terms. I tried calorie counting. Calories in, calories out. I know this works for me. I've done it. I'd lost three stones in 2018 just by making sure I used more calories than I ate. I did yoga every day. I felt fabulous. I kept the weight off all through lockdown and I was really bendy.

SPEAKER_00This time, tracking everything I ate for a month, religiously, no cheat days, the needle barely moved. The following month, I tried South Beach Phase 1, low-carb, three weeks of it. Tonya joined me in solidarity. We ate boiled eggs and counted almonds into tiny piles of 10 to be consumed throughout the day at regular intervals. I was, personally, very brave about the number of meals that began and ended with meat on lettuce.

SPEAKER_00The mirror remained completely unmoved. By the end of the process, Tanya had lost 10 pounds, and I was exactly the same weight that I'd been at the beginning. It wasn't the weight, though, that made Tuesday morning different, or not only the weight. It wasn't that very few of my clothes fit me anymore. The reason the mirror felt so unfriendly had to do with the gap between what it showed me and what I thought should be there.

SPEAKER_00And once I noticed that gap, I started seeing it everywhere. You're not looking at your body in the mirror. You're looking at the gap. The one between the body in the mirror and the body you expected to have by now. The body from before the illness, before the pregnancy, the decade of sitting at a desk. The body that was going to be the result of the diet you started in January. The yoga body that you promised yourself you'd have by now.

SPEAKER_00The body in the photograph from 10 years ago that you think of as the real one. That gap is where getting dressed gets hard. Because you're not dressing the body in the mirror. I don't think this is unusual. I think we've all been there in front of the mirror that doesn't care what you think, pretending the problem is the clothes. Everyone has something. It doesn't have to be visible scars or a dramatic medical history.

SPEAKER_00It can be as quiet as the way weight rearranged itself after menopause, or the upper arms that appeared one summer and didn't leave, or the stomach that no longer sits the way it once did. The specifics vary. The mechanism is the same. There is one feature, or several, that become the private rule behind every outfit without ever being named out loud. Body positivity as a concept is incomplete.

SPEAKER_00Body positivity says accept your body, and I do. My body allows me to do most of the things I want to do in my life. I can walk for two or three miles, climb several flights of stairs without getting winded, crouch on the floor and get back up again, pick up a grandchild, knit my way through a box set, and

SPEAKER_02sit at my desk for four hours every day to write. And I'm aware that the organizing principle of every outfit

SPEAKER_00I choose as I move through the world is hide the weight. Even at home, where the only person I'm hiding the weight from is me. Naming the thing you hide is difficult because naming it means acknowledging that it's there. That's the place where body positivity is incomplete. Acceptance is not wrong, but it's not the whole story. The whole story includes the moment you stand in front of your wardrobe and make a choice.

SPEAKER_00The drape over the skim. The drop shoulder over the fitted. Fabric with enough body to hold its shape without clinging. A garment that stands slightly away from the body instead of asking the body to explain itself. These choices don't hide the weight, but they change how I feel in what I'm wearing. That's not denial. That's craft, applied to the specific problem of feeling at ease in a body that changed.

SPEAKER_00Lakin Carlton is a stylist writing on Substack. I've been following her for a couple of years. I found her on Twitter. About a year ago, she wrote a piece that really stayed with me. Lakin had a childhood illness, an infection in her legs that left serious scarring. She wrote about knowing to the millimeter how tall the boots need to be, how long the skirt needs to be in order to hide those scars. The precision of that knowledge isn't shame.

SPEAKER_00It's expertise. She's an expert in her own body's relationship with clothing. What stayed with me was not that she knew how to hide the scars. It was that the hiding had become information, not failure. Sometimes Lakin wears the boots. Sometimes she lets the scars show. The choice is hers. And that's what ease actually means. Not the absence of things to hide. The freedom to choose what you show.

SPEAKER_00We all do this. We all have the thing. The arms, the belly, the scar, the skin condition, the asymmetry that only we can see. Accommodation covers the thing. Strategy The difference between the two is whether you feel like you're getting dressed or getting away with something.

SPEAKER_02I believe in using garments as strategies. Here's what that looks like in practice, because practice is where all of this either becomes useful or turns back into

SPEAKER_00a slogan. I've had a piece of cotton lawn shirting in deep stash since 2012. S.R. Harris, Minneapolis, a fabric warehouse that deserves its own

SPEAKER_02episode, possibly its own series.

SPEAKER_00This particular fabric has a red pinstripe running through,

SPEAKER_02fine as a hair, on a white background. 3.1 meters. Men's shirting weight, which means it's finer than most things I've sewn in cotton, and it wants a pattern that won't swallow it. The expected answer is a classic tailored shirt. The expected answer is also correct, which is mildly annoying. I've chosen the Leo from Bella Loves Patterns. Full placket on the sleeves, stand collar, the kind of shirt a man would wear to an

SPEAKER_00important meeting, and a woman wears to signal she's already run the meeting and left. It works with my aesthetic, femdandy, in a way that more obviously feminine options don't. Sometimes the expected answer is the right one. The thing about tailored shirts, if you have narrow shoulders, is that they never fit off the pattern. The shoulder seam sits way too far out. The armscye drops. The whole upper body of the garment reads as borrowed from someone larger.

SPEAKER_02You can redraft the armscye. That's one of the more difficult things to get right in pattern drafting.

SPEAKER_00Or you can do what Sandra Betsina taught me in Fast Fit. You don't redraft the arm side. You adjust the shoulder line and then the sleeve to fit the shoulder line and then everything else follows. It's a tricky little alteration that just involves rotating a sleeve slightly off axis. One alteration and the shirt stops reading as borrowed from someone larger.

SPEAKER_02It starts belonging to the person inside it. That's the whole argument of this episode in a single pattern hack. Fix the right thing, everything else follows. The Leo is the fitted answer.

SPEAKER_00Here's the opposite. 100% linen, white ground, widely spaced floral in autumnal colors. Ochre, rust, the particular green of things starting to turn. 2.7 meters, also from S.R. Harris, also 2012. This one is becoming a Jenna shirt from Closet Core. The Jenna is an oversized shirt that needs a fabric with some presents, and linen has presents.

SPEAKER_02This linen in particular has the colors to carry it through winter with a sweater over it, which puts it in service across at least three seasons.

SPEAKER_00Maximum deployment, minimum fuss. The Leo solves the shoulder. The Jenna solves the days when fitted isn't what you want. When ease means volume and presence rather than precision. Volume, when you choose it on purpose, is not giving up. It is architecture.

SPEAKER_02My version of Lakin's boots is a pair of trousers. Several pairs, actually. Not because trousers are magic, although if they fit properly,

SPEAKER_00they come close, but because the line from waist to shoe changes everything.

SPEAKER_02The Mitchell trousers from Closet Core in a heavyweight camel linen. Also S.R. Harris, 2012. Also clearly a very good shopping day. The Mitchell is exactly what it sounds like. A tribute to Joni Mitchell, which tells you everything you need to know about the silhouette. Pleated, but not in the way you might fear, the pleats sit closer to the hips than the center front, so the trouser reads as flat-fronted at first glance. Side tabs, small straps with buckles at the waist, let you cinch the waist in.

SPEAKER_02A wide-leg pleated trouser with side tabs in medium-weight linen is the kind of garment that looks like you made an effort without looking like you tried. Then the billy trousers from Bella Loves Patterns. In a gray crinkle linen from Meissen Fabrics in London. The color is cooler than I usually wear. A medium gray with a blue lean to it. But it tones with a pinstripe shirting in a way I didn't entirely plan and I'm not going to argue with.

SPEAKER_02Double pleats, slash pockets,

SPEAKER_00high waist, billy and crinkle linen will drape in a way that makes standing still look like movement.

SPEAKER_02The third pair is the pegs from Merchant & Mills, olive green cotton poplin. You may remember these from Episode 2, Top Down Center Outfitting. The pegs are very nearly finished. The fit is better than I expected, which means the proof of concept is almost confirmed. A trouser fits when you're wearing it, though, not while you're pinning the muslin, so I will keep you posted. Three trousers, three strategies. The camel for the long line, the gray for the movement, the olive for the proof of concept.

SPEAKER_02Not accommodation, strategy.

SPEAKER_00I know exactly what I need, and I've made it, or I'm about to. On top of those, a mustard geometric quilting cotton. The pattern is olia from Paper Theory, oversized with menswear details, front and back yoke, Inset pockets, in a stripe with the yoke cut on the cross grain, this shirt sings. Not loudly, more like it knows the harmony.

SPEAKER_02It's a shirt that wants to be worn untucked over wide trousers, which is exactly how I intend to wear it. Three tops, one fine and tailored, one relaxed and layerable, one oversized and graphic. They don't match, they coordinate. That's the distinction that makes a capsule work. Reality check. Podcasts don't make themselves.

SPEAKER_02Sometimes I wish they did. Cast On requires real resources to produce. If you're finding value here, you can support this work on Substack at £7 a month or £42 for the year, which works out at half price and is also the answer to life, the universe, and everything. No elaborate tier systems, no manufactured urgency, just steady support for steady work. Details at brendadayne.substack.com.

SPEAKER_02Getting dressed should feel like getting dressed. The point is not to own fewer clothes. The point is to have fewer arguments with them. Here's what I'm getting dressed in. The capsule collection I described in Episode 3 has 20 pieces. Today, I've pulled nine of them into a mini capsule. Three tops, three bottoms, three layers. You've heard about the tops and bottoms. The layers are where the logic gets complicated and the story gets personal.

SPEAKER_02The first layer is nearly finished. Big Love, a soft teal cardigan, just needs its tubular bind-off like it has since September. I will finish this. I will. It tones with everything in this mini capsule, from the mustard geometric to the camel linen, which is the kind of quiet miracle you don't plan for and should not argue with. It just needs finishing, which is not the same as needing to be solved. The second layer is the folkwear frock coat,

SPEAKER_02which I'll be talking about in detail in the next episode. I'll leave that story where it belongs and just say here that it's the most ambitious make in the collection, and it's waited almost 15 years for the right version of me to attempt it. For today, all it needs to do is hang there. Promising structure. The third layer is the one that required admitting I was wrong. Last June, I wrote for Substack about the gray sweater, the one that's been in rotation for 20 years and is nearing the end of its life.

SPEAKER_02I talked myself out of replacing it. I had a worsted weight in claret, in stash, and I will use it. I was going to design the sweater for this yarn. The gray sweater, I decided, wasn't actually what the capsule needed. Knitsib, it is precisely what the capsule needs. The charcoal gray sweater goes with everything in this collection. The pinstripe shirt, the camel trousers, the gray linen, the olive poplin. It goes with all of it. The gray sweater lasted 20 years in constant rotation,

SPEAKER_02and then it wore out, which is what well-made things do when they're loved enough. The right response to a well-made thing that wore out is to make another one. So, I'm buying yarn. I know. But every other make in this collection is from Stash. A single sweater's worth of new yarn, around a thousand yards, feels proportionate. Stash is a resource, not a prison sentence.

SPEAKER_02The pattern is Frigg by Anna Josvard. A top-down raglan with raglan increases worked around the circumference of the yoke, not gathered together in raglan faux seams. I know, right? Interesting architecture. The back of the sweater does some interesting things. There's volume back there that hangs in an interesting way. I'm looking forward to wearing this. It looks to me like the kind of sweater you reach for without thinking, which is exactly the kind of sweater that's worth replacing.

SPEAKER_02The yarn decision is still in progress. Probably something tweety. I don't have to choose yet. The capsule doesn't need it finished. It just needs to know it's coming. So here's what those nine pieces have in common. Every single one was chosen to solve a specific problem. The fine pinstripe shirting for the body that wants a fitted shoulder without a fitted waist. The camel linen for the legs that want a longer line. The gray crinkle for the days that want something that moves.

SPEAKER_02The olive poplin for the proof of concept. None of this is about hiding. It's about hiding strategically, which is a completely different thing. Lakin Carlson said she knows exactly where the boots need to reach. I know exactly where a fitted shoulder needs to sit. That knowledge didn't come from a magazine or a body type quiz.

SPEAKER_02It came from 20 years of making and wearing. Lakin ends her essay with a conditional. Sometimes, if the outfit's cute enough, you might stick a toe out of the comfort zone. That conditional is doing everything. It isn't a triumph narrative. It isn't a prescription. It's

SPEAKER_02What happens after ease arrives? The hiding becomes a choice rather than a reflex. And choices can go either way. You can choose to hide. You can choose not to. The outfit decides. The mirror in the bedroom has not become any kinder. It is still two meters high, judgmental as hell, leaning there with one eyebrow raised. But I am no longer asking it to show me a different body before I get dressed.

SPEAKER_02Getting dressed gets easy when you stop fighting the body in the mirror and start dressing the one you actually have. Thanks for listening. As always, thanks for choosing to squander a perfectly good half hour here with me. Support details, if you're looking for them, are at brendadayne.substack.com. To existing supporters, sincere and grateful thanks.

SPEAKER_02Talk to you soon. Until then, if you're cold, put on a sweater. That's what they're for.

SPEAKER_01I don't know what any of this means Why we go through so many things Scared to death and too afraid to live That's why me and my friends just talk about the aliens Breathe in Breathe out,

SPEAKER_01my two feet on the ground Breathe in, breathe out, my two feet on the ground It is what it is, wasn't meant to happen any other way Cause it did, doesn't really matter what you wanted in the end When it is what it is, what it is, what it is, what it is It is what it is, wasn't meant to happen any other day.

Cause it did, doesn't really matter what you wanted in the end.

SPEAKER_01It is what it is, what it is, what it is, what it is, what it is, love. One thing I know is I don't got any answers. Try to stay in the moment, I get lost in forever. I don't know if it ever gets better. So why old men just talk about the weather?

SPEAKER_01Breathe in, breathe out, my two feet on the ground. Breathe in, breathe out, my two feet on the ground.

SPEAKER_03It is what it is, wasn't meant to happen any other way, cause it did. Doesn't really matter what you wanted in the end, but it is what it is, what it is, what it is, what it is. It is what it is, wasn't meant to happen any other way, cause it did. Doesn't really matter what you wanted in the end, but it is what it is, what it is, what it is, what it is.

SPEAKER_03Begin by settling in to your body, just notice the sinking, the softening, into the nose, out to the mouth, and light it in. It is what it is, what's it meant to happen any other way? What's it did? Doesn't really matter what you wanted to be.

SPEAKER_03What it is, What it is, What it is, What it is, What it is, What it is, What it is, What it is, What it is,

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 217 Closer Than You Think

    Oct 23, 202627 minAudio

    A culture of one sounds grand until it becomes a spreadsheet. Twenty garments, five categories, six with a date or a next step, and a lot of honest blank space. That is not failure. It is the handmade wardrobe becoming...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 216 Making

    Oct 16, 202625 minAudio

    Everyone has worn something that felt like them. In this episode, that feeling starts with a teenage pantsuit made by Brenda’s mother, and widens into the question Claire McCardell asked in What Shall I Wear?: what...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 214 Enough

    Oct 2, 202628 minAudio

    Stash Acquired Beyond Life Expectancy. It’s a joke until you do the maths. Eight complete sweaters-worths of yarn in DK and fingering weight alone, not counting the oddballs, the luxury fibre, or the container of 2-ply...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 213 Fit

    Sep 25, 202626 minAudio

    The quest for trousers that actually fit involved eBay-stalking vintage pattern drafting books - Flat Pattern Cutting and Modelling for Fashion (Helen Stanley, 1972), Pattern Drafting and Dressmaking (Dorothy Moore,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 212 Low Impact

    Sep 21, 202627 minAudio

    Vinted used to feel like the internet version of a Naked Lady party: somebody else’s wrong thing becoming exactly what you needed, for a fiver and postage. Then the pro sellers arrived, the charity-shop stock moved...

    Credit the people on this episode