Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Buddhist Geeks

Buddhist Geeks artwork

The Grammar of Social Metta

Sep 16, 20268 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Vince Fakhoury Horn on the grammar of social metta - why a metta phrase needs a wish and only optionally a subject, how Sharon Salzberg’s “pith metta” shortens the phrase once the wish starts coming true, and why open-heartedness is a byproduct of the practice rather than its purpose, so there is always more to aspire to. 💬 Transcript Vince Horn: Today as we continue to unfold the social metta instructions I wanted to talk a little bit about the grammar of social metta, meaning the linguistic structure of how this practice works at least as far as I understand, which is very much an emerging understanding. And I think talking about grammar with this stuff is really helpful, because as one of my mentors Ken Wilber often points out, you know, you can be a completely fluent speaker without having any understanding of the grammar of the language you’re speaking. In fact that’s how all of us learn language, unless you have like linguistic professor parents or something, who are teaching you grammar early. You know, we all learn to speak without knowing the rules of the language. And then later in school, you know, we go to school and still most of us don’t learn the grammar of the language we’re speaking. And so, to know the grammar, to know how something works is not required to do it. But it’s very much helpful if you’re going to try to help other people do it, or if you wanna have a deeper understanding of what you’re doing. So I wanted to just share a little bit of sort of the grammar here of what we’re working with. At the heart of how we’re working with social metta, and I think this is because it’s an out-loud practice, and out-loud practices seem to really be aided by words. We’re working with a phrase, this metta phrase, and we started with a very simple phrase: may it arise. May loving awareness arise. May compassionate presence arise. May happiness arise. Whatever the it is, working with a quality of presence or of a dimension of the open heart and inviting it to arise. That’s a simple phrase and it has in that phrase a wish. This is the kind of one of the key parts of the metta phrase, is there’s a wish embedded in the phrase. There’s something that we’re wishing for, in this case, compassionate presence. Now I’d say at the very minimum, a metta phrase has to have a wish. There has to be something that we’re wishing for. That’s kind of what makes it a metta phrase. It’s a well wish. It’s a prayer using other language. Metta is Buddhist prayer in a way. And the other thing that often can show up in the basic structure grammar of social metta, but it doesn’t have to, as you can see with the phrase “may it arise,” is that there can often and is often a subject as well in the phrase. That is a person or group of people or category of beings that we are sharing that wish with. So, instead of just “may it arise,” where there’s not a clear sense of the subject, it could be for everyone, it could just be for me. Who knows what is going on in the interiority of someone who’s saying that phrase. It’s kind of hard to tell. But when we actually include a subject, and we are using things like pronouns, or we’re coming up with particular categories. For instance, you know, with the situation, the political unfolding in Russia, we could - “May all Russian people be happy.” And really, you could call to mind a particular group or category of beings. “May all animals be happy and healthy.” There’s really no limit there in terms of how we parse out who it is that we’re wishing this for. But that’s the subject, the who, in this practice. And so I’d say that metta phrases have to at least have a wish in them, and then can also have a subject. In a sense, that’s the elementary grammar of a social metta practice that include that as a kind of minimum. Then you can build, you know, more complex structures and sentences and things. You can rotate through phrases. You can pick phrases. You can go through a sequence of different subjects with a particular intention in mind. You know, these practices are very versatile in terms of how you can apply them. So that’s why we’re focusing on the core grammar. If we understand the elemental aspect of this, it becomes easier to build. Once you understand how a sentence works, it’s much easier to write a paragraph and then a book, and so forth. So yeah, just a little bit about that. And this is important, too, for our practice today. We’re going to explore the practice of pith metta, which I first learned about this through Sharon Salzberg and working with her instructions on loving-kindness practice. And she would often share with people and suggest that say you’re on a deep metta retreat, and you’re doing a lot of metta practice. And here I’d say, or if you’re doing social metta and it starts to happen, because social metta in some ways maybe can be like the equivalent of being on a retreat. You start to notice that you are actually feeling it. The wish becomes reality. You know, your wish comes true, and you’re suddenly not just wishing for compassionate presence to arise, but you are feeling compassionate presence, or you are being compassionate presence. In that case, Sharon would suggest that having this whole phrase can become clunky and get in the way of the living experience of the practice. And in that case, she said, feel free to shorten the phrase down to its pith. What’s the essential wish, the one or two usually words that points to what you’re wishing for. And you could just shorten it down to the pith in those cases, and just say happy or compassionate presence or just compassion, whatever feels the most pithy. The most kind of simple. And so in this practice too, in social metta, we found it really helpful to introduce the pith phrase. And that is essentially just working with the wish, just being with the wish. Here what’s important, I think, to highlight is that sometimes metta practice, we are aspiring, you know, we’re wishing, and sometimes we are realizing. It moves from inclining the mind toward the open heart to being open-hearted. And important, I think, to recognize those two different possibilities because the purpose of the practice isn’t to be open-hearted. It is actually to incline toward open-heartedness. And if it arises, great. That’s beautiful, and it’s a byproduct of doing the practice. But it’s not the purpose of the practice. It’s a result that can happen from doing the practice. So, even if you’re using the full phrase or you’re just working with the pith, it’s always possible to share it in a way where it’s more of an aspiration. It’s like, may compassionate presence arise. I’m not feeling it. I don’t even know what it is. I sure wish it were here. That’s fine. Like, that’s actually totally legit to practice metta in that way, to wish for it to arise. It’s also totally legit if it arises to just say “compassionate presence.” Or even you can say, may compassionate presence arise, and you can feel it. It may have arisen here, but has it arisen everywhere for everyone throughout all space and time? Well, if not, there’s more. There’s more to aspire to. And I think that’s always the case with metta. Get full access to Buddhist Geeks at www.buddhistgeeks.org/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Today, as we continue to unfold the social meta instructions, I wanted to talk a little bit about the grammar of social meta, meaning the linguistic structure of how this practice works, at least as far as I understand, which is very much an emerging understanding. And I think talking about grammar with this stuff is really, it's really helpful because as one of my mentors, Ken Wilber often points out, You know, you can be a completely fluent speaker without having any understanding of

SPEAKER_00the grammar of the language you're speaking. In fact, that's how all of us learn language, unless you have like a linguistic professor, parents or something, or teaching your grammar early. You know, we all learn to speak without knowing the rules of the language. And then later in school, you know, we go to school and still, most of us don't learn. The grammar of the language we're speaking. And so to know the grammar, to know how something works is not required to do it, but it's very much helpful if you're going to try to help other people do it or

SPEAKER_00if you want to have a deeper understanding of what you're doing. So I wanted to just share a little bit of sort of the grammar here of what we're working with. At the heart of how we're working with social meta, and I think this is because it's an out loud practice and out loud practices seem to really be aided by words. We're working with a phrase, this meta phrase. And we started with a very simple phrase, may it arise, may loving awareness arise, may compassionate presence arise,

SPEAKER_00may happiness arise, whatever that it is working with a quality. Of presence or of a dimension of the open heart and inviting it to arise. That's a simple phrase. And it has in that phrase, a wish. This is the kind of one of the key parts of the meta phrases. There's a wish embedded in the phrase. There's something that we're wishing for in this case, compassionate presence. Now I'd say at the very minimum, a meta phrase has to have a wish.

SPEAKER_00There has to be something that we're wishing for. That's kind of what makes it a meta phrase. It's a well-wish. It's a prayer using other language. Metta is Buddhist prayer in a way. And the other... Thing that often can show up in the basic structure, grammar, or social metta, but it doesn't have to, as you can see with the phrase, may it arise, is that there can often, is often a subject As well in the phrase that is a person or group of people

SPEAKER_00or category of beings that we are sharing that wish with. So we're instead of just made arise where there's not a clear sense of the subject, it could be for everyone. It could just be for me, who knows what is going on in the interiority of someone who's saying that phrase, it's hard to tell, but when we actually Include a subject and we are using things like pronouns or we're coming up with particular categories.

SPEAKER_00For instance, you know, with the situation, the political unfolding in Russia, we could, may all Russian people be happy and really could fall to mind a particular group or category of beings. May all animals be happy and healthy. There's really no limit there in terms of how we parse out who it is that we're wishing this for, but that's the subject, the who in this practice. And so I'd say that metaphrases have to at least have a wish in them and

SPEAKER_00then can also have a subject. In a sense, that's the elementary grammar of the social meta practice that would include that as a kind of minimum. Then you can build, you know, more complex structures and sentences and things. You can rotate through phases. You can pick phrases. You can go through a sequence of different subjects with a particular intention in mind. You know, these practices are very versatile in terms of how you can apply them. So that's why we're focusing on the core grammar and we understand the elemental Aspect of this, it becomes easier to build.

SPEAKER_00Once you understand how a sentence works, it's much easier to write a paragraph and then a book and so forth. So yeah, just a little bit about that. And this is important too, for our practice today, we're going to explore the practice of Pith Mehta, which I first learned about this through Sharon Salzberg and working with her instructions on loving kindness practice. And she would often share with people and suggest that say you're on a deep Metta retreat and you're doing a lot of meta practice.

SPEAKER_00And here I'd say, or if you're doing social meta and it starts to happen because social meta in some ways maybe can be like the equivalent of being on a retreat. You start to notice that you are actually feeling it. The wish becomes a reality. You know, your wish comes true and you're suddenly not just wishing for compassionate presence to arise, but you are. Feeling compassionate presence, or you are being compassionate presence. In that case, Sharon would suggest that having this whole phrase can become clunky and get in

SPEAKER_00the way of the living experience of the practice. And in that case, she said, feel free to shorten the phrase down to its pith. What's the essential wish, the one or two usually words that points to what you're wishing for. And you could just Shorten it down to the pith in those cases and just say happy or compassionate presence or just compassion, whatever feels the most pity, the most kind of simple. And so in this practice too,

SPEAKER_00in social metta, we found it really helpful to introduce the pith phrase. And that is essentially just working with the wish, just being with the wish. And here, what's important, I think to, to highlight Is that sometimes in metta practice, we are aspiring, we're wishing, and sometimes we are realizing. It moves from inclining the mind toward the open heart to being open hearted. And it's important to, I think, to recognize those two different possibilities because the purpose of

SPEAKER_00the practice isn't to be open hearted. It is actually to incline toward open heartedness. And if it arises, Great. That's beautiful. And it's a byproduct of doing the practice, but it's not the purpose of the practice. It's a result that can happen from doing the practice. So even if you're working with the full phrase or you're just working with the pith, it's always possible to share it in a way where it's more of an aspiration. It's like, may compassionate presence arise. I'm not feeling it. I didn't even know what it is.

SPEAKER_00I sure wish it were here. That's fine. Like that's actually totally legit to practice menta in that way and to wish for it to arise. It's also totally legit if it arises to just say compassionate presence, or even you can say may compassionate presence arise and you can feel it. It may have arisen here, but has it arisen everywhere for everyone throughout all space and time? Well, if not, there's more, there's more to aspire to. And I think that's always the case. With META.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Framing the Unframable

    Nov 15, 202617 minAudio

    Vince Horn opens The 9th Jhāna by offering frames for what cannot be framed - the Sudden and Gradual approaches to awareness, the twin paths of Via Negativa and Via Positiva, and the Several Ways to Meditate with...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. No One Has Ever Got Jhāna

    Oct 29, 202652 minAudio

    Recorded on the first evening of a 2026 Pragmatic Dharma meditation retreat, this dharma talk from Brian Newman offers a wide-ranging exploration of jhāna practice, the Pa-Auk tradition, the jhānic factors, and the role...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Three Ways to Prepare a Dharma Talk

    Oct 14, 202614 minAudio

    Vince Fakhoury Horn lays out three ways to prepare a dharma talk for teachers-in-training, exploring how detailed notes can polish a talk into dead words, why speaking with no preparation depends on being prepared not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What are Buddhist Wisdom Chords?

    Oct 9, 20268 minAudio

    Vince Fakhoury Horn introduces the Buddhist Wisdom Chords, which is both a teaching model, and a live training in the Pragmatic Dharma app, that looks at each Buddhist lineage as a chord made up of seven meditative...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Insight Chord

    Sep 30, 202613 minAudio

    Vince Fakhoury Horn describes the insight meditation tradition as a chord in which concentration, mindfulness and heartfulness sound together, with concentration giving mindfulness its depth and heartfulness keeping the...

    Credit the people on this episode