Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Buddhist Geeks

Buddhist Geeks artwork

Framing the Unframable

Nov 15, 202617 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Vince Horn opens The 9th Jhāna by offering frames for what cannot be framed - the Sudden and Gradual approaches to awareness, the twin paths of Via Negativa and Via Positiva, and the Several Ways to Meditate with Awareness at its apex. 💬 Transcript Vince: I was thinking about where to start with the 9th Jhāna, and I think the first thing to say is that the 9th Jhāna is not a state. Let me share a little bit where this term came from. So I’m borrowing this term from a researcher who I spoke to some months ago. This is a researcher working on a project studying advanced meditation. And they were asking me about my experience with jhānas and then asked, do you have any experience with anything that would be considered like a 9th Jhāna or anything beyond the eight jhānas. And I had to think about that because I’d never heard the term, the 9th Jhāna. I’d heard other things, weird things, but I hadn’t heard that one before, so I thought about it and I was like, well, I guess the only thing I would describe as the 9th Jhāna is just sort of resting in awareness, or just being open, and not doing anything. Just being. What I would normally in my own models call Awareness Meditation. And so that is the spirit of this exploration here. The 9th Jhāna is an exploration of how to explore these states of consciousness that arise in meditation naturally and organically when the mind and body are settled, through the doorway of a very different kind of meditation object, which is not an object at all. We take awareness as our quote unquote object. Of course, you can’t, awareness can’t take itself as an object, right? If you could take awareness as an object, that wouldn’t be awareness. It’d be some experience. With the 9th Jhāna we’re learning how to rest in awareness, to be aware of awareness. And there are lots of ways to do that, and there’s lots of ways to think about that. So today I wanted to kind of just share a few different frames with you, as an attempt to frame the unframeable. Awareness isn’t something which we can frame properly, because it’s not an experience, or it’s not a thing, or state. But we still have to talk about it, because it’s like the whole point of the Buddhist meditative tradition in a certain way. So how can we talk about something that doesn’t fit into the normal categories of how we think about reality? One way I think we have to talk about this, and this is a longstanding conversation in the Buddhist contemplative tradition, is we have to talk about how we enter into this awareness of awareness. And there’s a longstanding debate here between what in the Buddhist tradition they call the Sudden and Gradual schools. They’re not actual real schools. Okay, and in fact, they’re probably not really actual people who really believe either one of these extreme positions anymore. But, over thousands of years, you could say a dialogue has been happening across these different lines. Looking at how the path unfolds. And one of the schools so-called says that the path is a gradual process, it’s something that you develop through time and, in a book called One Dharma by a teacher named Joseph Goldstein he does his best to try to make sense of these different approaches and he describes this kind of approach where you’re gradually developing stage-by-stage or step-by-step, he calls this the Building From Below orientation. But there’s also, as he describes it, a way to Swoop From Above with awareness. You don’t necessarily have to spend 20 years and you know, five Goenka retreats or whatever. Whatever the amount of stuff that you did before you realized the basic truth about awareness, which is that, good luck trying to not be aware. Ken Wilber, one of my early mentors, he used to always point to awareness, he’d say, “Try to stop being aware of my voice.” You know, and he talks a lot and he’d just keep talking, talking, talking about how you can’t not be aware. And it’s true, like you, it’s hard to shut awareness off. So here, how do we actually suddenly realize that we’re already aware? This is the Sudden School. And Joseph described this as sweeping from above. You could just realize it’s already done. You know, you’re already aware, you’re already awake. Sri Nisargadatta Maharaj, in a book called I Am That, he said, “To be aware is to be awake. Unaware means asleep. You’re aware anyhow, you need not try to be. What you need to be is aware of being aware. Be aware, deliberately and consciously broaden and deepen the field of awareness. You’re always conscious of the mind, but you’re not aware of yourself as being conscious.” I like this way of describing awareness practice, because in a way, he’s integrating these two, the sudden and gradual approaches. He’s not prioritizing one or the other, he’s saying both are true. You’re always conscious, right? Consciousness is always present, but you’re not always aware that you’re aware. You’re not always conscious of your consciousness. That’s the practice is being aware of being aware. That’s it. That’s what we’re doing here. B. Alan Wallace in The Attention Revolution, another awesome book, Dharma book that touches on awareness as a doorway into jhāna. He says, “In awareness of awareness, there is no intentional directing of attention. You simply rest in that flow of knowing, and from time to time gently recognize that you are aware.” I wish it were more complicated than that, sometimes, you know, sometimes I wish I could just lay it out like kind of like Daniel Ingram did in his book, and just lay it out, give you the full, 400 page diagram detail of how to get into awareness. And I’m sure that book exists, and that might be a useful, actually exercise, but for me, the practice is quite simple. And, unfortunately, the thinking mind will tend to make this more complex than it is, and that tends to be one of the biggest obstacles that I’ve noticed in using awareness as a tool for entering into jhāna. So this is one way to look at what we’re doing here with the 9th Jhāna. How is it that we’re coming into this awareness? Gradually, or all of a sudden? Another way of looking at awareness practice, I think that’s very important, is that if you are taking a gradual approach, if you feel like there’s some kind of movement or development or progression through time, what I’ve noticed is that that progression often takes one of two forms, and this seems to largely depend on the person and the tradition that they’re practicing in. One of the ways, in the Christian contemplative tradition, they call this Via Negativa. In the Hindu tradition, they call this Advaita, which is you take all of the experiences that are arising and you recognize that you are not any of those, because they’re objects, because they’re rising, because you can know them. That means they arise in time that they’re changing and they will vanish. This is the basic truth of vipassana, right? Mindfulness. Yeah. So we can recognize that and we recognize anything that we can be aware of is not ultimately who we are. This is the process of Neti Neti. You’re backing away from the untruth. You’re backing away from everything that is not you. You’re letting go of all those objects and just resting in awareness that’s devoid of any characteristics. Devoid. That’s important. This is the path of the void. Not this. Via negativa. Then on the other side though, you have the opposite path, Via Positiva. This too. This too. This too. This too. Nothing is excluded. Anything that arises that appears to be apart from you, you include it in awareness. You fold it back into awareness and see, “Ah, yeah, that thing that I thought was out there over here, this too.” Shunryu Suzuki Roshi in Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind, he said, “That everything is included within your mind is the essence of mind.” So here we’re recognizing that everything that arises in the mind is the essence of mind. Another quote from Sri Nisargadatta Maharaj, in I Am That, he said, “The mind produces thoughts, ceasele… Get full access to Buddhist Geeks at www.buddhistgeeks.org/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00I was thinking about where to start with the ninth jhana. And I think the first thing to say is that the ninth jhana is not a state. Let me share a little bit where this term came from. So I'm borrowing this term from a researcher who I spoke to some months ago. This is a researcher working on a project studying advanced meditation. And they were asking me about my experience with jhanas and then asked, do you have any experience with anything That would be considered like a ninth jhana or anything beyond the eight jhanas.

SPEAKER_00And I had to think about that because I'd never heard the term the ninth jhana. I'd heard other things, weird things, but hadn't heard that one before. So I thought about it and I was like, well, I guess the only thing I would describe as the ninth jhana is sort of resting in awareness or just being open and not doing anything, just being what I would normally in my own models call awareness meditation meditation. And so that is the spirit of this exploration here. The ninth jhana is an exploration of how to explore these states of consciousness

SPEAKER_00that arise in meditation naturally and organically when the mind and body are settled through the doorway of a very different kind of meditation object, which is not an object at all. We take awareness as our quote unquote object. Of course, awareness can't take itself as an object, right? If you could take awareness as an object, that wouldn't be awareness. That would be some experience. With the ninth genre, we're learning how to rest in awareness, to be aware of awareness.

SPEAKER_00And there are lots of ways to do that. And there's lots of ways to think about that. So today I wanted to kind of just share a few different frames with you. As an attempt to frame the unframable, awareness isn't something which we can frame properly because it's not an experience or it's not a thing or state, but we still have to talk about it because it's like the whole point of the Buddhist meditative tradition in a certain way. So how can we talk about something that doesn't fit into the normal categories

SPEAKER_00of how we think about reality? One way I think we have to talk about this, and this is a longstanding conversation in the Buddhist contemplative tradition, is we have to talk about how we enter into this awareness of awareness. And there's a longstanding debate here. Between what in the Buddhist tradition they call the sudden and gradual schools. They're not actual real schools, okay? And in fact, they're probably not really actual people who really believe either one

SPEAKER_00of these extreme positions anymore. But over thousands of years, You could say that a dialogue has been happening across these different lines, looking at how the path unfolds. And one of the schools, so-called, says that the path is a gradual process. It's something that you develop through time. And in a book called One Dharma by a teacher named Joseph Goldstein, he does his best to try to make sense of these different approaches. And he describes this kind of approach where you're gradually developing stage

SPEAKER_00by stage or step by step. He calls this the building from below orientation. But there's also, as he describes it, a way to swoop from above with awareness. You don't necessarily have to spend 20 years and five going retreats or whatever the amount of stuff that you did before you realize the basic approach. Truth about awareness, which is that good luck trying to not be aware. Ken Wilber, one of my early mentors, used to always point to awareness.

SPEAKER_00He'd say, try to stop being aware of my voice. And he talks a lot and he just keep talking, talking, talking about how you can't not be aware. And it's true. It's hard to shut awareness off. So here, how do we actually suddenly realize that we're already aware? This is the sudden school of Joseph described this as swooping from above. You could just realize it's already done. You're already aware. You're already awake. Sri Nisargadatta Maharaj in a book called I Am That, he said, to be aware is to be awake.

SPEAKER_00Unaware means asleep. You're aware anyhow. You need not try to be. What you need to be is aware of being aware. Be aware deliberately and consciously. Broaden and deepen the field of awareness. You are always conscious of the mind, but you are not aware of yourself as being conscious. I like this way of describing awareness practice because in a way he's integrating these two, the sudden and gradual approaches.

SPEAKER_00He's not prioritizing one or the other. He's saying both are true. You're always conscious, right? Consciousness is always present, but you're not always aware that you're aware. You're not always conscious of your consciousness. That's the practice is being aware of being aware. That's it. That's what we're doing here. B. Alan Wallace in The Attention Revolution, another awesome book, Dharma book that touches on awareness as a doorway into jhana. He says, in awareness of awareness, there is no intentional directing of attention.

SPEAKER_00You simply rest in that flow of knowing. And from time to time, gently recognize that you are aware. I wish it were more complicated than that. Sometimes, you know, sometimes I wish I could just lay it out, like kind of like Daniel Ingram did in his book and just lay it out, give you the full 400 page diagram detail of how to get into awareness.

SPEAKER_00And I'm sure that book exists and that might be a useful actually exercise. But for me, the practice is quite simple. And unfortunately, the thinking mind will tend to make this more complex than it is. And that tends to be one of the biggest obstacles that I've noticed is In using awareness as a tool for entering into jhana. So this is one way to look at what we're doing here with the ninth jhana. How is it that we're coming into this awareness gradually or all of a sudden?

SPEAKER_00Another way of looking at awareness practice, I think that's very important. Is that if you are taking a gradual approach, if you feel like there's some kind of movement or development or progression through time, what I've noticed is that that progression often takes one of two forms. And this seems to largely depend on the person and the tradition that they're practicing in. One of the ways in the Christian contemplative tradition,

SPEAKER_00they call this via negativa in the Hindu tradition. They call this Advaita, which is you take all of the experiences that are arising and you recognize that you are not any of those because they're objects, because they're arising, because you can know them. That means they arise in time, that they're changing and they will vanish. This is the basic truth of Vipassana, right? Mindfulness. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So we can recognize that. We recognize anything that we can be aware of is not ultimately who we are. This is the Process of neti neti. You're backing away from the untruth. You're backing away from everything that is not you. You're letting go of all those objects and just resting in awareness. That's devoid of any characteristics. Devoid. That's important. This is the path of the void. Not this. Via negativa.

SPEAKER_00Then on the other side, though, you have the opposite path. Via positiva. This too, this too, this too, this too. Nothing is excluded. Anything that arises that appears to be apart from you, you include it in awareness. You fold it back into awareness and see, ah, yeah, that thing that I thought was out there over here, this too. Shunri Suzuki Roshi in Zen Mind, Beginner's Mind, he said that everything is included within your mind is the essence of mind.

SPEAKER_00So here we're recognizing that everything that arises in the mind is the essence of mind. Another quote from Srini Sagadatta Maharaj in I Am That, he said, the mind produces thoughts ceaselessly, even when you do not look at them. When you know what is going on in your mind, you call it consciousness. That is your waking state. Your consciousness shifts from sensation to sensation,

SPEAKER_00from perception to perception, from idea to idea in endless succession. Then comes awareness, the direct insight into the whole of consciousness, the totality of the mind. The mind is like a river flowing ceaselessly in the bed of the body. You identify yourself for a moment with some particular ripple and call it my thought. All you're conscious of is your mind. Awareness is the cognizance of consciousness as a whole.

SPEAKER_00Awareness is the cognizance of consciousness as a whole. Again, we'll use this as our kind of broad definition for what it is that we're meditating on. And of course, we don't meditate on awareness. We meditate as awareness. There's no way to take awareness as an object. You can only be that awareness. So how do you be aware? Well, you're already aware. How do you not be aware? That might be a more interesting question.

SPEAKER_00How do we not be aware? How do we avoid this moment? So these are two approaches, not this too, this too, this too. Both are valid ways to realize awareness. I remember the first time I really heard this spoken by someone I respected. I was a teacher at Naropa University. I was in this class called Contemplative Hinduism and learning about the different contemplative approaches in the Hindu tradition.

SPEAKER_00My teacher was a woman named Sri Devi Bringi. And she grew up in India and her family, this was very interesting. Her family were close friends with JD Krishnamurti. And so she grew up hanging out with Krishnamurti in her family house. Okay. I'll give you any sense of her background. She said in India, there are two basic approaches and she described these two approaches and she described it pretty much the same way I just described them to you, except she said the neti neti approach. She said in India, you know, we call this Advaita Vedanta.

SPEAKER_00Radical non-duality. And the other approach, this two, this two, too, we call that tantra. We have Vedanta and tantra. And she said, both of these are valid approaches. And at the time when I heard that, it was really useful to hear that because I'd taken the via negativa approach. And I thought, well, this must be the only way. I noticed in the beginning when everyone was sharing about your background, I should have probably asked when your first Goenka retreat was because almost everyone here seems to have experienced that. And that very much is the via negative approach where you're just breaking down,

SPEAKER_00deconstructing your experience, disidentifying, you could say dissociating from whatever arises. So this is also, I think, an important frame for understanding the ninth jhana, that there's different ways in that are either about backing away from identification with anything or moving toward identification with everything. Ultimately, I would suggest these lead to the same realizations.

SPEAKER_00And then finally, I want to throw this last frame out to you, which is the several ways to meditate framework. This is a framework that my wife, Emily, and I developed over many years now to kind of describe the various approaches to meditation that we have practiced and we teach to kind of provide a schema for understanding all the different possible ways there are to do this and how they connect and relate to each other. And if you think for a moment of a hexagram, okay?

SPEAKER_00Start off with a very simple six-sided object. If you look at that hexagram, you can see that there's six points in the hexagram. And each of those points is a style of meditation or a way to meditate. You have concentration meditation, bringing attention to a single point, mindfulness, noticing sensations as they change. Heartfulness, inclining the mind toward opening the heart. Inquiry meditation, where we're using a question as a prompt for discovery,

SPEAKER_00like what is awareness or who is aware? Then you have imaginal meditation, where you're using internal imagery or other internal senses to kind of put yourself in a position that you can only imagine, where you're more whole and integrated. And then finally we have embodiment meditation where you're working on inhabiting the body. Now, obviously there's a lot of overlaps between these styles. It's not that they're completely separate.

SPEAKER_00In fact, they do connect. And if you imagine this hexagram, every point connecting up to a single point, like a pyramid, except this is a hexagramic pyramid, single point, that single point at the top, the apex is awareness. Awareness is the only way of meditating that doesn't have a focus. It's the only style of meditation where there's nothing to do. And awareness doesn't contradict any of these other styles of practice.

SPEAKER_00You might be missing that you're aware while you're furiously meditating on your breath or something. You might actually miss that, really. It's true. But you can be aware and breathe at the same time. Awareness is compatible with everything. And it's the common denominator of all these styles. It's the point that transcends and includes all these different ways to meditate. So in that sense, it's a kind of special approach. And because of that, you can use any of those other styles of meditation

SPEAKER_00in combination with the intention to be aware of awareness. And you can practice that as a doorway into the ninth jhana. So you can practice mindful awareness. You can use techniques that intentionally bring in mindfulness and also point toward awareness. Or you could do a kind of inquiry into awareness. You could use inquiry meditation to hone in on the nature of awareness through asking questions. What is aware of this experience right now?

SPEAKER_00Can you find that? You can just sit and be in your body. Embodied awareness. You can take awareness as your concentration object, shamatha without a sign, just mentioned earlier, and you could move through the jhanas naturally and organically as you just rest in awareness, concentrated awareness. So I mentioned this model because I'm going to be pulling from a lot

SPEAKER_00of these different techniques. And my hope is that by exploring this from different angles, you can find the approaches to awareness that work for you to let you in, that are access points for you that are reliable, which you can deepen through. My experience is sometimes people will find that access point in one place and it might not be a go anchor retreat. It might be somewhere else. And so here I want to provide as many access points as possible while also continuing to keep the focus centered on the ninth jhana.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. No One Has Ever Got Jhāna

    Oct 29, 202652 minAudio

    Recorded on the first evening of a 2026 Pragmatic Dharma meditation retreat, this dharma talk from Brian Newman offers a wide-ranging exploration of jhāna practice, the Pa-Auk tradition, the jhānic factors, and the role...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Three Ways to Prepare a Dharma Talk

    Oct 14, 202614 minAudio

    Vince Fakhoury Horn lays out three ways to prepare a dharma talk for teachers-in-training, exploring how detailed notes can polish a talk into dead words, why speaking with no preparation depends on being prepared not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. What are Buddhist Wisdom Chords?

    Oct 9, 20268 minAudio

    Vince Fakhoury Horn introduces the Buddhist Wisdom Chords, which is both a teaching model, and a live training in the Pragmatic Dharma app, that looks at each Buddhist lineage as a chord made up of seven meditative...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Insight Chord

    Sep 30, 202613 minAudio

    Vince Fakhoury Horn describes the insight meditation tradition as a chord in which concentration, mindfulness and heartfulness sound together, with concentration giving mindfulness its depth and heartfulness keeping the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Imaginal Meditation

    Sep 22, 202624 minAudio

    In “Imaginal Meditation,” Emily West Horn introduces an approach to imaginal practice - drawing on Vajrayana deity yoga, Jack Kornfield, Chögyam Trungpa, and Dzongsar Khyentse Rinpoche - to show how invoking,...

    Credit the people on this episode